Anda di halaman 1dari 6

International Journal of Computer Science Trends and Technology (IJCST) – Volume 6 Issue 3, May - June 2018

RESEARCH ARTICLE OPEN ACCESS

A Literature Survey on Modified Iterative Channel


Estimation with Coded OFDM System
Ajay Kumar [1], Dr. Abhishek Sharma [2]
ME Student [1], Asst. Prof [2]
Department of ECE
J.E.C., Jabalpur
M.P, India

ABSTRACT
In this paper, we introduce a new Modified iterative channel estimation technique with coded-OFDM systems. The
demands for high bandwidth & high speed application are growing at a faster rate and with the minimum tolerance
of error. To enhance available bandwidth and improve the quality of transmission convolution codes are used on the
OFDM (Orthogonal frequency division multiplexing) communication system over AWGN channel. In OFDM
systems with channel estimation play a key role in overcoming distortions caused by phenomena like fading, delay
spread and multipath effects. A series of review papers were already available to provide a history of the
development of the field until the end of the last decade. During survey of work we have found that different authors
have developed different methods to solve the purpose. So from the study of various papers we can easily conclude
that there is not any unique method. Hence in this work we come across to develop a new modified iterative channel
estimation OFDM algorithm.
Keywords:- OFDM, IDD, Convolution coding, AWGN channel, channel estimation, modulation scheme.

I. INTRODUCTION with knowledge of the channel length. A problem


Orthogonal frequency division multiplexing with TD CE is to determine the proper channel
(OFDM) is an efficient multicarrier modulation length. The easiest solution is to set the estimated
scheme which is resilient to the effect of multipath channel length equal to the maximum value (say L)
fading channels. Although all the OFDM subcarriers that produces no Intra Carrier and Inter Symbol
are modulated by waveforms that are limited in the Interference, i.e. the OFDM cyclic prefix length plus
time-domain, in practice, there is unavoidable power one. This assumption simplifies the problem, but can
leakage in the frequency-domain and because of this, lead to performance degradation, in case of short
the guard band has to be placed so as to minimize channel impulse responses. To avoid this degradation
adjacent channel interference to other coexisting some CLE must be implemented. Also CLE can be
wireless systems [1]. performed in the frequency or time domain.
Focusing on OFDM systems, CE can be Frequency domain estimators look for some specific
performed both in the frequency or in the time behavior of the channel estimates, such as the zero-
domain. Frequency Domain (FD) CE is usually level crossing rate. They are simple, but do not
simpler, since it can be applied even independently exploit all the available information and typically
subcarrier by subcarrier: this is the case of Zero require several OFDM symbols to become reliable.
Forcing (ZF), that delivers a noisy CE. More refined Time domain CLE usually starts from the maximal
estimators exploit some additional information about length and then ignores taps with amplitudes below
the channel, to reject noise. Depending on the way some threshold [5].
this information is given, it could be convenient to
perform CE either in the FD or in the Time Domain II. LITERATURE REVIEW
(TD). E.g., if the channel Power Delay Profile (PDP)
is known, one can derive the channel covariance SU HU et.al: This paper is focused on
matrix in the FD and perform LMMSE estimation to training sequence design for efficient channel
reject more noise, or can even embed the PDP into a estimation in multiple input multiple-output
TD LMMSE estimator, focusing on the most relevant filterbank multicarrier (MIMO-FBMC)
channel taps. To reduce complexity, one can also also communications using offset quadrature amplitude
apply estimation to small groups of subcarriers, or modulation (OQAM). MIMO-FBMC is a promising
just exploit the largest eigenvalues of the channel technique to achieve high spectrum efficiency as well
covariance matrix. Reduced order models can also be as strong robustness against dispersive channels due
applied in the TD: the most popular is ML estimation to its feature of time-frequency localization. In this

ISSN: 2347-8578 www.ijcstjournal.org Page 194


International Journal of Computer Science Trends and Technology (IJCST) – Volume 6 Issue 3, May - June 2018

paper, authors proposes a new class of training these high speed and high quality applications.
sequences, which are formed by concatenation of two Worldwide Interoperability for Microwave Access
identical zero-correlation zone sequences whose (WiMax) is an IEEE 802.16 standard-based
auto-correlation and cross correlation are zero within broadband wireless access (BWA) technology which
a time-shift window around the in-phase position [1]. employs Coded orthogonal frequency division
The system model considers imperfect multiplexing access (COFDM). This paper analyses
channel estimation, pilot contamination (PC), and Bit Error Rate for WiMax based COFDM system
multicarrier and multipath channels. Analytical with QPSK modulation scheme under various
expressions are first presented on the mean square channel conditions like AWGN, Rayleigh, Rician and
error (MSE) of two classical channel estimation Nakagami-m. It has been observed that performance
algorithms [i.e., least squares (LS) and minimum of Nakagami fading channel is better than other
mean square error (MMSE)] in the presence of PC. fading channels [6].
Then, a simple H-infinity (H-inf) channel estimation Sanjana T et.al: In this paper channel
approach is proposed to have good suppression to PC estimation and equalization techniques are analyzed
[2]. to improve the performance of OFDM system. The
Yu Zhu et.al : In this paper, author channel estimation techniques considered here are
considers a robust SC-FDE design with imperfect estimation using wiener filter and frequency domain
channel knowledge at a receiver due to the channel approach. Prior Channel estimation leads to simple
estimation error. Based on a statistical model for equalization. The channel equalization techniques
channel estimation, the optimal equalization employed here are based on LMS algorithm and one
coefficients are derived under the criterion of tap frequency domain equalization, under different
minimizing the mean square error conditioned on a channels; AWGN, Rayleigh and Rician channels.
given channel estimate. The bit error rate is further Eye patterns for different channels are compared in
analyzed and a tight performance approximation is simulation. It is observed from simulation that wiener
proposed. Two robust FDE schemes in coded filter provides better estimation and OFDM
systems were also proposed, where feedback from performance is better under AWGN channel than
the channel decoder is utilized to improve the fading channels. SER curves shows 6dB
equalization and/or channel estimation performance improvement in AWGN performance than fading
[3]. channels to achieve 0.1 SER. In addition, MSE
Charles U. Ndujiuba et.al: Authors performance shows fast convergence for AWGN
proposed a Joint estimation of the channel length and channel [8].
of the impulse response for OFDM systems, Sunho Park et.al: Authors proposed a new
exploiting information criteria to find the best trade- decision-directed channel estimation technique
off, in terms of Kullback-Leibler divergence, dealing with pilot shortage in the MIMO-OFDM
between noise rejection and channel description systems. The proposed channel estimator uses soft
accuracy. So far, information criteria have not been symbol decisions obtained by iterative detection and
used for practical channel length estimation methods, decoding (IDD) scheme to enhance the quality of
due to their prohibitive complexity. Authors show channel estimate. Using the soft information from the
how to make them affordable, performing channel decoders, the proposed channel estimator selects
estimation in a recursive way that allows establishing reliable data tones, subtracts interferences, and
the optimal channel length with a moderate performs re-estimation of the channels. Authors
incremental cost & achieved performance and analyze the optimal data tone selection criterion,
robustness are very good [4]. which accounts for the reliability of symbol decisions
Alessandro Tomasoni et.al: In this paper and correlation of channels between the data tones
transmission scheme for OFDM have been and pilot tones. From numerical simulations, we
investigated. The advantage of employing adaptive show that the proposed channel estimator achieves
transmission scheme is described by comparing their considerable improvement in system performance
performance with fixed transmission system. A better over the conventional channel estimators in realistic
adaptation algorithm is used to improve the MIMO-OFDM scenarios [9].
throughput performance. This algorithm utilizes the Petros S. Bithas et.al: Authors proposed a
average value of the instantaneous SNR of the new threshold-based channel selection strategy,
subcarriers in the switching parameter. The results which decreases the system complexity, without
show an improved throughput performance with considerably affecting the system performance.
considerable BER performance [6]. Assuming independent but nonidentically distributed
Hardeep Kaur et.al: Authors proposed a channel conditions, a generic analytical framework is
COFDM based WiMax here,which promises to cater first presented, based on the Markov chain theory.

ISSN: 2347-8578 www.ijcstjournal.org Page 195


International Journal of Computer Science Trends and Technology (IJCST) – Volume 6 Issue 3, May - June 2018

Then, the proposed selection scheme is applied to modulation scheme size causes to improvement in
three specific communication scenarios, namely throughput along with BER value [13].
multichannel reception; transmit antenna selection Han Wang et.al: An Adaptive Regularized
with diversity reception, and cooperative relay Compressive Sampling Matching Pursuit
selection. In all three cases, closed-form results are (ARCoSaMP) algorithm is proposed here. Unlike
obtained and used to analyze the performance of the anterior greedy algorithms, the new algorithm can
systems under consideration. It is shown that based achieve the accuracy of reconstruction by choosing
on the proposed scheme, computational complexity is the support set adaptively, and exploiting the
reduced and thus important energy savings can be regularization process, which realizes the second
achieved, without a significant loss in performance selecting of atoms in the support set although the
[10]. sparsity of the channel is unknown. Simulation result
Dimitrios Katselis et.al : Authors proposed shows that CS-based methods obtain significant
preamble-based least squares (LS) channel estimation channel estimation performance improvement
in OFDM systems of the QAM and offset QAM compared to that of conventional preamble-based
(OQAM) types is considered. The construction of methods. The proposed ARCoSaMP algorithm
optimal (in the mean squared error (MSE) sense) outperforms the conventional sparse adaptive
preambles is investigated, for sparse (a subset of pilot matching pursuit (SAMP) algorithm. ARCoSaMP
tones, surrounded by nulls) preambles. The two provides even more interesting results than the most
OFDM systems are compared for the same transmit advanced greedy compressive sampling matching
power, which, for cyclic prefix (CP) based pursuit (CoSaMP) algorithm without a prior sparse
OFDM/QAM, also includes the power spent for CP knowledge of the channel [14].
transmission. OFDM/OQAM, with a sparse preamble Shilpi Gupta et.al: This paper investigates
consisting of equipowered and equispaced pilots a new ICI self-cancellation technique to mitigate the
embedded in zeros, turns out to perform at least as effect of ICI in FFT-OFDM and compares it to DCT
well as CP-OFDM. Simulations results are presented based OFDM system in terms of bit error rate (BER)
that verify the analysis [11]. and carrier to interference ratio (CIR). The proposed
Yuan Ouyang et.al: Author presents the method for group size three results in a significant 20
performance analysis of the multiband orthogonal dB improved CIR in FFT-OFDM. In terms of BER,
frequency division multiplexing (MB-OFDM) ultra proposed ICI self-cancellation technique outperforms
wideband (UWB) systems for multipath fading and the other self-cancellation techniques in FFT-OFDM.
multiuser interference channels. A closed form Also, this paper investigates outperforming BER and
approximation of the BER performance of the MB- CIR improvement by using DCT-OFDM without
OFDM UWB system with multiple interferences is applying self-cancellation techniques, due to its
proposed. Based on the derived approximation, the energy compaction property [15].
effects on the BER performance for the choice of the Archana Jatav et.al: Author purposes the
codeword constraint lengths of the convolutional adaptive equalizer is to operate on the channel output
encoder, the length of the cyclic prefix, and the such that the cascade connection of the channel & the
multiuser environments of two or more interferers are equalizer provides an appropriate to an ideal
thoroughly discussed. The simulated results provide transmission medium. This paper presents the
us with useful information to appropriately choose performance of channel equalization based RLS &
the parameters of the MB-OFDM UWB system for LMS Adaptive equalizer. Author compares the
the sake of achieving the BER performance that proposed algorithm with other algorithm. Finally
conforms to requirement of the FCC standards [12]. concludes that RLS-LMS equalizer with QAM
B. Siva Kumar Reddy et.al : Author modulator gives better bit error rate than RLS &
presents The mobile-WiMAX offers a special feature LMS equalize [16].
that has adopted an adaptive modulation and coding Guan Gui et.al: Author proposes two stable
(AMC) in OFDM to provide higher data rates and sparse variable step-size NLMS (VSSNLMS)
error free transmission. AMC technique employs the algorithms to improve the accuracy of MIMO
channel state information (CSI) to efficiently utilize channel estimators. First, ASCE is formulated in
the channel and maximize the throughput with better MIMO-OFDM systems. Second, different sparse
spectral efficiency. In this paper, LSE, MMSE, penalties are introduced to VSS-NLMS algorithm for
LMMSE, Low rank (Lr)-LMMSE channel estimators ASCE. In addition, difference between sparse ISS
are integrated with the physical layer. The NLMS algorithms and sparse VSS-NLMS ones is
performance of estimation algorithms is analyzed in explained and their lower bounds are also derived. At
terms of BER, SNR, MSE and throughput. last, to verify the effectiveness of the proposed
Simulation results proved that increment in algorithms for ASCE, several selected simulation

ISSN: 2347-8578 www.ijcstjournal.org Page 196


International Journal of Computer Science Trends and Technology (IJCST) – Volume 6 Issue 3, May - June 2018

results are shown to prove that the proposed sparse mitigated in order to remove or reduce considerably
VSS-NLMS algorithms can achieve better estimation the guard interval and to gain some spectral
performance than the conventional methods via mean efficiency. The adaptive algorithm is based on
square error (MSE) and bit error rate (BER) metrics adaptive filtering with averaging (AFA) for
[17]. parameter update. Based on the development of a
Thamer M. Jamel et.al : “Author’s model of the OFDM system, through extensive
proposes new two smart antennas algorithms based computer simulations, author investigates the
on a combined method for performance enhancement performance of the channel equalized system. The
of mobile communications systems. The first results show much higher convergence and
proposal combination method includes merging pure adaptation rate compared to one of the most
Conjugate Gradient Method (CGM) with pure frequently used algorithms - Least Mean Squares
Normalized Least Mean Square (NLMS) algorithms, (LMS)[21].
so that the new algorithm is called as CGM-NLMS. B. Siva Kumar Reddy et.al: Authors
While the second proposed algorithm will merge pure presents the OFDM technique is predominantly used
CGM with modified NLMS algorithm so that this during the implementation of WiMAX Physical
algorithm is called as CGMMNLMS algorithm. The layer. This paper focuses on the PHY-layer design
MNLMS algorithm is regarded as variable aspects, namely, modulation and coding techniques
regularization parameter that is fixed in the associated. OFDMA, an extension of OFDM, makes
conventional NLMS algorithm. The two new use of Adaptive Modulation and Coding techniques
proposed algorithms provides fast convergence time, to improve efficiency, fairness, and throughput in
higher interference suppression capability and low WiMAX. To achieve higher data rates and smaller
level of Mean Square Coefficients Deviation (MSD) BER's channel coding can be carried out in OFDM,
and minimum Mean Square Error (MSE) at the called COFDM. The channel state information is fed
steady state compared with the pure CGM and pure back to the transmitter by the channel estimator. The
NLMS algorithms [18]. simulation analysis presented includes comparison of
Bharti Kaushal et.al : In this paper BER vs. SNR for different modulation schemes.
Authors presented a channel Equalizer based on Here, LMS channel estimator is used [22].
Adaptive Kalman Filter. The performance indexes Marwa Abdelfatah Abdeltwab et.al:
used for measurement are mean square error (MSE), Author discusses the performance improvement of
Rate of convergence and signal to noise ratio (SNR). OFDM communication system using different
This analysis is compared with some other Adaptive channel coding techniques through AWGN channel
Equalizer like recursive least square (RLS) and model. These coding techniques include Reed
experimental results shows that this approach gives a Solomon coding, Convolutional coding,
less mean square error which is better than other Concatenated coding (by combining Reed Solomon
equalizer with fast rate of convergence. Also with Convolutional), and Interleaved concatenated
experimented for different communication system coding techniques. Besides, a new algorithm
like QAM (64 QAM, 16 QAM, 4QAM), QPSK and produced to choose a good convolutional encoder
BPSK, results shows that this equalizer is quite design for a certain rate and memory registers [23].
compatible with different digital modulator [19]. Irfan Y. Khan et.al: Authors investigated
Shadma Pragi et.al: Author proposes the the OFDM system performance of uncoded adaptive
Long Term Evolution (LTE) is an area of research modulation using quadrature amplitude modulation
interest for next generation of wireless (QAM) and phase shift keying (PSK). To further
communication. OFDM is selected as the basis of enhance the system, authors employed convolutional
LTE physical layer. Author presents the performance coding to OFDM system. In OFDM system, the
of OFDM UMTS based LTE system where minimum Signal to noise ratio is estimated at receiver and then
BER is measured for different modulators. The transmitted to the transmitter through feedback
proposed model is compared with OFDMIDMA channel, the transmitter according to the estimated
system in terms of BER. This paper concludes that it SNR select appropriate modulation scheme and
is quiet efficient and is applicable for next generation coding rate which maintain constant bit error rate
wireless communication system [20]. lower than the requested BER. The obtained result
Farhana Enam et.al : Author proposes a shows that a significant improvements in terms of bit
specific approach to channel equalization for error rate (BER) and throughput can be achieved
Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplex (OFDM) demonstrating the Superiority of the adaptive
systems. Inserting an equalizer realized as an modulation schemes compared to fixed transmission
adaptive system before the FFT processing, the schemes [25].
influence of variable delay and multi path could be

ISSN: 2347-8578 www.ijcstjournal.org Page 197


International Journal of Computer Science Trends and Technology (IJCST) – Volume 6 Issue 3, May - June 2018

Hamza Khan et.al: Authors proposed a [1] Su Hu et.al : “Training Sequence Design for
dynamic interference control method using the Efficient Channel Estimation in MIMO-
additive signal side lobe reduction technique and FBMC Systems” IEEE access Vol 5 2017.
genetic algorithm(GA) in CR-OFDM systems. [2] Peng Xu et.al : “Analysis and Design of
Additive signal side lobe reduction technique is based Channel Estimation in Multicell Multiuser
on adding a complex array to modulated data MIMO OFDM Systems” IEEE transactions
symbols in the constellation plane for side lobe on vehicular technology, vol. 64, no. 2,
reduction in OFDM system. In the proposed method, february 2015 page no. 610-620.
GA generates optimum additive signal which can [3] Yu Zhu et.al : “Robust Single Carrier
effectively reduce the OOB signal interference to the Frequency Domain Equalization With
primary system. The results show that the side lobes Imperfect Channel Knowledge” IEEE
of the OFDM-based secondary user signal can be transactions on wireless communications,
reduced by up to 38 dB and the PU interference vol. 15, no. 9, september 2016.
tolerable limit can be satisfied at the cost of a minor [4] Charles U. Ndujiuba et.al : “Dynamic
addition in bit error rate (BER). The results further Differential Modulation of Sub-Carriers in
show that the proposed method delivers better OFDM” Journal of Wireless Networking
performance as compared to non-GA additive signal and Communications 2016, 6(1): 21-28.
method in terms of side lobe reduction as well as [5] Pallavi Suryawanshi et.al : “Underwater
BER [26]. communication by using OFDM system”
International Journal of Scientific and
III. PROBLEM FORMULATION Research Publications, Volume 3, Issue 12,
After studying different approaches we December 2013.
observe that some of the algorithms provide low [6] Alessandro Tomasoni, Member et.al:
BER, higher interference suppression capability and “Efficient OFDM Channel Estimation via an
minimum Mean Square Error (MSE), but still there is Information Criterion” IEEE transactions on
need of an approach which may provide better result wireless communications, vol. 12, no. 3,
i.e. reduces the mean square error (MSE) and low march 2013.
BER as compared to the other conventional [7] Hardeep Kaur et.al : “ Analyzing the
algorithms. Performance of Coded OFDM based
WiMax System with different Fading
IV. PROPOSED WORK Conditions” International Journal of
Advanced Science and Technology Vol.68
After analyzing several techniques we (2014), pp.01-10.
proposed a new modified iterative channel estimation [8] Sanjana T et.al : “comparison of channel
algorithm technique along with coded convolution estimation and equalization techniques for
coding OFDM system to reduce the mean square ofdm systems” Circuits and Systems: An
error (MSE), BER & higher interference suppression International Journal (CSIJ), Vol. 1, No. 1,
capability. January 2014.
[9] Sunho Park : “”Iterative Channel Estimation
V. CONCLUSION Using Virtual Pilot Signals for MIMO-
In this paper, we present a survey on OFDM Systems” IEEE transactions on
channel Estimation for coded OFDM communication signal processing, vol. 63, no. 12, june 15,
system concentrating on different techniques and 2015.
emphasize on the problems, we also suggest an [10] Petros S. Bithas et.al : “An Improved
efficient solution to solve the above problem. Threshold-Based Channel Selection Scheme
Concatenation of the convolutional codes (CC) in for Wireless Communication Systems”
OFDM system and proposes a new modified iterative IEEE transactions on wireless
LMMSE channel estimation algorithm. The main communications, vol. 15, no. 2, february
objective is to transmit the data with low bit error rate 2016.
& low MSE in the noisy environment. Convolution [11] Dimitrios Katselis et.al: “Preamble-Based
coding will be employed to minimize the bit error Channel Estimation for CP-OFDM and
rate (BER) of the received signal. OFDM/OQAM Systems: A Comparative
Study” IEEE transactions on signal
REFERENCES processing, vol. 58, no. 5, may 2010.
[12] Yuan Ouyang et.al : “Performance Analysis
of the Multiband Orthogonal Frequency

ISSN: 2347-8578 www.ijcstjournal.org Page 198


International Journal of Computer Science Trends and Technology (IJCST) – Volume 6 Issue 3, May - June 2018

Division Multiplexing Ultra-Wideband [20] Shadma Pragi et.al : “OFDM UMTS Based
Systems for Multipath Fading and Multiuser LTE System” International Journal of
Interference Channels” Hindawi Publishing Emerging Technology and Advanced
Corporation Mathematical Problems in Engineering, Volume 3, Issue 7, July 2013.
Engineering Volume 2015, Article ID [21] Farhana Enam et.al : “Performance
190809, 9 pages. Evaluation of Orthogonal Frequency
[13] B. Siva Kumar Reddy et.al: “Adaptive Division Multiplexing (OFDM) based
Modulation and Coding with Channel State Wireless Communication System with
Information in OFDM for WiMAX” I.J. implementation of Least Mean Square
Image, Graphics and Signal Processing, Equalization technique” (IJCSIS)
2015, 1, 61-69. International Journal of Computer Science
[14] Han Wang et.al: “A New Sparse Adaptive and Information Security, Vol. 10, No. 11,
Channel Estimation Method Based on November 2012.
Compressive Sensing for FBMC/OQAM [22] B. Siva Kumar Reddy et.al : “Adaptive
Transmission Network” MDPI, sensors Modulation and Coding in COFDM for
2016 page no. 2-12. WiMAX Using LMS Channel Estimator”
[15] Shilpi Gupta et.al: “Performance on ICI Conference on Advances in Communication
Self-Cancellation in FFT-OFDM and DCT- and Control Systems 2013 (CAC2S 2013).
OFDM System” Hindawi Publishing [23] Marwa Abdelfatah Abdeltwab et.al : “
Corporation Journal of Function Spaces Performance Improvement of Coded OFDM
Volume 2015, Article ID 854753, 7 pages. Communication System in AWGN
[16] Archana Jatav, Agya Mishra: “channel Channel” International Journal of Computer
equalization & BER analysis based on Applications (0975 – 8887) Volume 110 –
combination of RLS & LMS adaptive filter No. 11, January 2015.
for communication system” : GJCAT, Vol 2 [24] Jayprakash Upadhyay et.al: “Ber
(4), 2012. performance of cc-ofdm system with nnlms
[17] Guan Gui et.al: “Variable Is Better Than equalization technique” IEEE International
Invariable: Sparse VSS-NLMS Algorithms Conference on Computer, Communication
with Application to Adaptive MIMO and Control, MGI Indore, INDIA.
Channel Estimation” :Hindawi Publishing September 10 -12, 2015.
Corporation, Scientific World Journal [25] Irfan Y. Khan et.al : “To Improve
Volume 2014, Article ID 274897, 10 pages. Performance of OFDM System Using
[18] Thamer M. Jamel: “Performance Optimize Adaptive Coding Technique with
Enhancement of Smart Antennas Algorithms Convolutional and BCH Coding”
for Mobile Communications International Journal of Application or
System”:international journal of circuits, Innovation in Engineering & Management
systems and signal processing Volume 8, (IJAIEM) Volume 3, Issue 5, May 2014.
2014. [26] Hamza Khan et.al : “Dynamic Interference
[19] Bharti Kaushal et.al : “ Adaptive Kalman Control in OFDM-Based Cognitive Radio
Filter based Channel Equalizer” (IJCSIT) Network Using Genetic Algorithm”
International Journal of Computer Science Hindawi Publishing Corporation
and Information Technologies, Vol. 3 (5) , International Journal of Distributed Sensor
2012,page no. 5195 – 5199. Networks Volume 2015, Article ID 870607,
10 pages.

ISSN: 2347-8578 www.ijcstjournal.org Page 199

Anda mungkin juga menyukai