Library
Recent Titles in
Bibliographies and Indexes in World Literature
William Baker
Greenwood Press
Westport, Connecticut • London
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Copyright Acknowledgment
The author and publisher gratefully acknowledge permission to quote extracts from published and
unpublished letters of Wilkie Collins and to cite from the marked-up copy of the Puttick and
Simpson auction catalogue of the sale of Wilkie Collins's library, dated January 20, 1890. With per-
mission of Faith Clarke, great-granddaughter of Wilkie Collins.
For Faith and William M. Clarke
with affection and thanks
This page intentionally left blank
Contents
PREFACE IX
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS xi
ABBREVIATIONS xiii
INTRODUCTION
Presentation/Association Copies 15
Imprint Analysis 32
Place of Publication Analysis 36
Language Analysis 42
Subject Analysis 43
Conclusion 65
Reconstruction 73
Vlll
Contents
Addenda 164
APPENDIX 165
INDEX 177
Preface
those who purchased lots. Additionally, the catalogue indicates whether or not
copies of books owned by Wilkie Collins are association copies.
The marked copy of the Puttick and Simpson sale catalogue, and the existence
of a catalogue containing books purchased at this auction by the London
booksellers M. L. Bennett, produced barely a month after the Puttick and
Simpson sale, make it possible to reconstruct Wilkie Collins's library. This
reconstruction combines information found in the Puttick and Simpson and M.
L. Bennett 1890 catalogues. Such a reconstruction creates the opportunity for a
fuller understanding of Collins's source materials. It is useful not only to those
interested in Wilkie Collins. Of value to all students of the nineteenth century,
the reconstruction provides detailed annotations to the abbreviated and
sometimes cryptic entries in the 1890 catalogues, of Collins's unusually rich
collection of literature, language, history, biographies, law, and other subjects of
general interest. Drawing upon published and unpublished Collins letters, there
are detailed listings of Collins's references to authors and editors. His
association copies led to fresh biographical revelations concerning his
friendships, professional and personal associations. The copious subject-based
index provides a key to the purchasers of this work, the late nineteenth-century
book trade, the subjects that interested Collins, the previous owners of his
books, and a myriad of other details. An appendix, again drawing upon hitherto
unavailable materials, provides a listing of artwork in Wilkie Collins's
possession at the time of his death. This book is then one for students of
nineteenth-century literature, history, art, the booktrade, and culture.
The "Introduction" discusses in some detail Wilkie Collins and his relationships
to books, including the use of books in his writing. There is an extensive
discussion of "the 1890 dispersion of his library" and of the two catalogues:
Puttick and Simpson's and M. L. Bennett's. This is followed by extensive
analysis, places of book publication, languages and subjects. Next is a
description of the organization, alphabetical arrangement, entry numbering and
information provided in each entry in the reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's
library. Such information includes, if a book or an author is mentioned, citation
from the pertinent published or unpublished Wilkie Collins letter. Such data in
the reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's library enriches its overall object: to gain
a fuller understanding of Wilkie Collins as a reader and of the sources he
transformed in his magnificent creative fictional worlds.
William Baker
Northern Illinois University
Acknowledgments
This work could not have been undertaken without help and assistance from
various sources and individuals. William Clarke, Andrew Gasson, Professor
Donald Hawes, Professor Kenneth Womack, and Henry Terwedow went
through the manuscript of this book with critical acumen and a fine eye for
detail, looking for inconsistencies and errors. The faults that remain are mine
alone. Paul Lewis, of the Wilkie Collins Society, kindly shared his extensive
knowledge of Victorian art, and Wilkie Collins, with me. Others who have
helped and to whom thanks are due include: John Collins of Maggs Bros. Ltd.,
London; Sara Dodgson, Librarian of The Athenaeum, London; Mark Irvine;
Alan Jutzi, Rare Book Curator, Huntington Library, San Marino, California;
Professor Graham Law of Waseda University, Tokyo, Japan; Dr. K. A. Manley
of the Institute of Historical Research, University of London; David Quentin of
Bernard Quaritch, Ltd., London; Petra Soderlund, Department of Literature,
University of Uppsala, Sweden; Sue Usher, Librarian, English Faculty Library,
Oxford University; the late Alexander Wainwright, of the Parrish Collection,
Princeton University Library; Ian Willson of the Centre for English Studies,
University London; Adriaan van der Weel, Chairman, Leiden Centre for the
Book, University of Leiden, Netherlands.
Thanks are due to the dedicatees of the book Faith and William Clarke (author
of The Secret Life of Wilkie Collins [1988, 1996] and co-editor of The Letters of
Wilkie Collins [1999]) for help in all kinds of ways, and for sending me their
marked-up copy of the Puttick and Simpson auction catalogue of the sale of
Wilkie Collins's library dated January 20, 1890. Thanks are also due to Faith
Clarke for permission to quote extracts from the published and unpublished
Xll Acknowledgments
letters of her great-grandfather, Wilkie Collins, and to cite from her copy of the
Puttick and Simpson auction catalogue. Similarly thanks must go to Andrew
Gasson of the Wilkie Collins Society, author of the richly informative Wilkie
Collins: An Illustrated Guide (1998), for his generosity and many kindnesses.
Catherine Peters, author of The King of Inventors: A Life of Wilkie Collins
(1991, 1993), generously sent me a copy of M. L. Bennett's "Caxton Head
Catalogue 198: Books from the Library of the late Wilkie Collins, London
February 1890" and answered many questions.
Special thanks must go to Gina Unger, Daniel McMahon, and Henry Terwedow
for their assistance in preparing and typesetting portions of the book during its
various stages of production. Thanks also go to George Butler, Senior Editor of
Academic and Trade Publishing, the volume's production editor, and the
editorial staff of Greenwood Press, for their guidance and encouragement.
At Northern Illinois University, thanks are due to Ron Burshinger and his
colleagues in the Information Delivery Services Department of the University
Libraries, Arthur P. Young, Dean of the University Libraries, Mary Munroe,
Associate Dean, University Libraries, Heather Hardy, Chair, English
Department. Other colleagues in the University Libraries and English
Department are to be thanked for their encouragement and for granting the
author release time from teaching and other duties.
Abbreviations
{ } - indicates a number in Puttick and Simpson's catalogue
[ ] - indicates a number in Bennett's catalogue
4 to. - quarto
8 vo. - octavo
12 mo. -duodecimo
bd./bds. - board/boards
Bennett - entry in Bennett's catalogue
Boase - Frederic Boase, Modern English Biography: Containing Many
Thousand Concise Memoirs of Persons Who Have Died between the
Years 1851-1900. 6 vols. Truro: Netherton, 1892-1921
British Library Catalogue - The British Library General Catalogue of Printed
Books to 1975 (BLC). Managing Ed. Jim Emmett. London: Clive
Bingley and K. G. Saur, 1979-1987
cf. - calf
cl. - cloth
Clarke - William M. Clarke, The Secret Life of Wilkie Collins. Far Thrupp,
Stroud, Gloucestershire: Alan Sutton Publishing, 1996
cr. - crown
Dickens, Letters - The Letters of Charles Dickens. [The Pilgrim Edition]. Ed.
Madeline House, Graham Storey, Kathleen Tillotson, and others.
Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1965-
DNB - The Dictionary of National Biography (DNB). Ed. Leslie Stephen and
Sidney Lee. 1885-1900, rpt. 21 vols., London: Oxford UP, 1967-1968
Dolbow - Sandra W. Dolbow, Dictionary of Modern French Literature from the
Age of Reason through Realism. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press,
1986
ex. - extra
fl.-floruit
fol. - folio
XIV Abbreviations
France - The New Oxford Companion to French Literature. Ed. Peter France.
Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1995
front/fronts - frontispiece
Gasson - Andrew Gasson, Wilkie Collins - An Illustrated Guide. Oxford:
Oxford UP, 1997
g. e. - gilt edges
gt. - gilt
Hart - James D. Hart, with revisions by Phillip W. Leininger, The Oxford
Companion to American Literature. 6th ed. New York: Oxford UP,
1995
Harvey - The Oxford Companion to English Literature. 3 rd ed. Ed. Paul Harvey.
Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1958
Harvey and Heseltine - The Oxford Companion to French Literature. Ed. Paul
Harvey and J. E. Heseltine. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1959
hf.-half
illus. - illustration
imp. - imprint
impft. - imperfect
impl. - imperial
item - entry in present catalogue (unless "Bennett's item" or "Puttick and
Simpson's item")
Letters - The Letters of Wilkie Collins. Ed. William Baker and William M.
Clarke. 2 vols. London: Macmillan, 1999
lot - entry in Puttick and Simpson's catalogue
mor. - morocco
Nadel - Ioldni; or Tahiti as It Was. A Romance. Ed. Ira B. Nadel. Princeton:
Princeton UP, 1999
n. d. - no date
Peters - Catherine Peters, The King of Inventors: A Life of Wilkie Collins.
Princeton: Princeton UP, 1993
port./ports. - portrait/portraits
post - large
Raimes - Ann Raimes, Keys for Writers. 2nd ed. Boston: Houghton Mifflin
Company, 1999
Robinson - Kenneth Robinson, Wilkie Collins: A Biography. New York:
Macmillan, 1952
roy. - royal
sm. - small
Smith and Terry - N. Smith, R. C. Terry, eds., Wilkie Collins to the Forefront:
Some Reassessments. New York: AMS Press, 1995
Stephens - John Russell Stephens, The Profession of the Playwright: British
Theatre 1800-1900. Cambridge: Cambridge UP, 1992
Sutherland - John Sutherland, The Stanford Companion to Victorian Fiction.
Stanford, CA: Stanford UP, 1989
swd. - sewed
t. e. g. - top edge gilt
Abbreviations xv
Todd and Bowden - Tauchnitz International Editions in English, 1841-1955. A
Bibliographical History. New York: Bibliographical Society of
America, 1988
vig. - vignette(s)
v. y. - various years
WC - Wilkie Collins
Wing - precedes entry number of the item as it is listed in Donald Wing, Short-
Title Catalogue of Books Printed in England, Scotland, Wales, and
British America And of English Books Printed in Other Countries
1641-1700, 2nd ed., rev. and enl. 4 vols. New York: MLA, 1982-98.
Wolff - Robert Lee Wolff, Nineteenth-Century Fiction: A Bibliographical
Catalogue Based on the Collection Formed by Robert Lee Wolff 5
vols. in 2. New York: Garland Publishing, 1981
This page intentionally left blank
Introduction
Books and Libraries play a crucial role in WC's early novel Basil; A Story of
Modern Life. First published in 1852, the novel expresses its author's sense of
class and family conflict played out amongst the tapestry of a contemporary mid-
Victorian setting. Autobiographical, the novel draws upon its author's
differences with his father's attitudes to politics, religion, and his son's choice of
the career of a professional writer. The main plot of Basil focuses upon a
younger son who makes a secret marriage, which isn't consummated for a year.
The delay is in order that the son can reveal to his father his marriage to the
daughter of a wealthy but vulgar linen draper. In the third section of the third
part of the novel, Basil travels to his family home to tell his father, from whom
he is estranged, of the marriage. The lack of communication between son and
father is depicted through setting. Basil, the narrator of the story, describes how,
to avoid human contact, his father retreated into his library and his books. At the
point of revealing his marriage to his father, Basil describes how his father "was
2 Wilkie Collins's Library
sitting at his table, cutting the leaves of some new books that lay on it." The
father's library is a place of retreat, of escape from family commitments. Basil
reflects: "As children, how often" he and his brother Ralph "had peeped
curiously through that very door, to see what my father was about in his study, to
wonder why he has so many books to write, and so many books to read. How
frightened we both were, when he discovered us one day, and reproved us
severely!" The father's sanctuary contains a "high, old-fashioned, mahogany
press before the window, with [a] large illustrated folio about Jewish antiquities
lying on it."2 After Basil has made his confession, his father, physically
transformed with emotional shock, uses his bookshelves as a physical prop. He
prefers to lean upon the inanimate bookcases rather than upon his animate son.
WC reveals the deep associations and meanings books as objects, and books as
contents, have for humans. The fictional father reacts to his son's revelation by
choosing "a biographical history of his family, from the time of his earliest
ancestors down to the date of the births of his own children. The thick quarto
pages were beautifully illuminated in the manner of the ancient manuscripts."
Basil describes how "Slowly and in silence, my father turned over the leaves of
the book which, next to the Bible, I believe he most reverenced in the world,
until he came to the last-written page but one - the page which I knew . . . to be
occupied by my name." His father tears the page from the sacred family object
and disinherits the son (201).
The Library is then in WC's fictional world a place for retreat and collapse, a
place where human action, reaction, or lack of action, are part of a chain of
revelations and consequences. In The Law and the Lady, serialized in the
Graphic, September 1874 through March 1875, the plot revolves around the
slow emergence of a series of secrets, each of which leads to additional problems
and questions. Valeria, the heroine of the novel, discovers the crucial secret,
which has haunted her, and influenced her life, and that of others, through
searching through the Library of her husband Eustace's close friend, Major Fitz-
David. Her Library search is not an easy one: "I saw Voltaire in red morocco;
Shakespeare in blue; Walter Scott in green; the History of England in brown; the
Annual Register in yellow calf. There I paused, wearied and discouraged already
by the long rows of volumes. How (I thought to myself) am I to examine all
these books? And what am I to look for, even if I do examine them all?" On the
top shelves are smaller volumes "not so careftilly arranged as on the lower
shelves. Some were bound in cloth; some were only protected by paper covers."4
Her attention is drawn by "a gorgeously-bound book" standing "in solitary
grandeur" on an upper shelf. In this book Valeria finds a dated inscription in
French and a "lock of red hair." Falling out of the book is "a small photograph"
(87-88).
The position of books on shelves, and their bindings, lead to the volumes inside,
which provide clues to provenance, to past human associations, and possibly
significant revelations. However, Valeria doesn't herself find what she is
searching for. WC presents Valeria as middle-class: the voyeuristic element
implied by her library search doesn't accord with her class. The revelation comes
through her counterpart, the working-class Miss Hoighty acting as a detective.
The major's mistress interrupts Valeria's library searching with "coarse
questions" and "uncultivated manners." Miss Hoighty is for Valeria a "welcome
intruder on my solitude: she offered me a refuge from myself " (91). Valeria
"waited without moving a muscle, without uttering a word . . . helpless as a
baby" as Miss Hoighty finds and opens volumes of trials. Valeria has already
gone "twice over" the volumes (93). Valeria's reaction to the contents is "the
black blank of a swoon" (94). Miss Hoighty keeps her composure and shoulders
"the blame for procuring this forbidden knowledge. "Not one of the fainting
sort", she connects her powers of detection with her situation as the Major's
kept-woman: "Didn't you tell me that you were looking for a book?" she asks
Valeria: "And didn't I present it to you promiscuously with the best intentions?"
(97).
Libraries, books, evoke past deeds and memories. They are used by WC for plot
revelations, to depict class differences, human difference, and as sexual props.
WC drew upon his own experiences in his fiction. In The Law and the Lady, the
major's mistress Miss Hoighty goes to volumes of Trials which she likes
reading. WC, a trained lawyer, too was fascinated by old trials. Jenny Bourne
4 Wilkie Collins's Library
Taylor writes in her "Introduction" to the World's Classics edition of The Law of
the Lady that WC "exploits widely in his work both this fascination and his own
knowledge of the law; here he may well have drawn in part on a case in J. H.
Burton's Narratives from Criminal Trials in Scotland (1852) (he owned a copy
of this, and other accounts of trials)" (xix). In The Woman in White WC draws
upon Maurice Mejan's compilation of eighteenth-century trials, Recueil des
Causes Celebres (1807-1814). Copies of Burton and Mejan are both found in
WC's Library (see items 60 and 349). Volumes by Voltaire, Shakespeare, Walter
Scott and the Annual Register, in Major Fitz-David's Library, are found in
WC's, too (see for instance items 505, 441, 432-435, 165).
Books are not the only objects in Libraries. In Major Fitz-David's Library there
are, on top of bookcases, "vases, candelabra and statuettes" and "fragments" of
broken vases (81). Reaching for the volume of trials, Miss Hoighty destroys yet
another vase. WC's anti-Jesuit novel, The Black Robe, was serialized in The
Sheffield and Rotherham Independent Supplement, October 1880 through March
1881 and published in 1881 in three volumes. In this novel, the Library of Lord
Loring's spacious residence is a place where attempted religious conversions
occur. It is a place where Father Benwell, the Jesuit spiritual advisor to the
Loring family, can be employed. Status, position, and ownership are closely
linked in WC's fiction and life. Adjoining the fictional aristocratic Loring
Library is a picture gallery. Noticeable among the paintings is a Linnell. John
Linnell (1792-1882), a landscape and portrait painter, was a close friend of
WC's father. Clearly his work has sentimental associations for the novelist,
whose own library was adorned with paintings, especially those by his father.
In a letter to his mother, Harriet Collins, dated 11 May 1867, WC tells his
mother how he and his brother Charles "tossed for" his father's pictures. A
listing of paintings left by his father to the family is included as an appendix in
the present volume. WC's letters contain frequent references to his reading, to
his search for books, and in his later years, reminiscences of his favorite authors.
Books are clearly important for WC when writing his fictions. For instance, his
notes for The Moonstone, now at the Parrish Collection at Princeton University,
contain lists of books to consult on India, on Indian customs, and on gems and
their mystical properties. Characters in his novels have similar tastes to those of
their creator. The hero Amelius Goldenheart of The Fallen Leaves, serialized in
The World, January to July 1879, and published in three volumes in the same
year, has the works of Sir Walter Scott in his library: "the writings of the one
supreme genius who soars above all other novelists as Shakespeare soars above
all other dramatists - the writings of Walter Scott - had their place of honour in
his library"5 as in WC's own library. His letters attest to his great admiration for
Sir Walter Scott as a person and as a writer (see items 432-35).
Introduction 5
A facet of WC's life which has been relatively neglected is his intellectualism.
Biographies have tended to focus upon his mysterious relationships with women.
He never married and had two common law wives. By one he had children. He
brought up the other's daughter as his own. In 1885, when he was over sixty,
WC began a correspondence with an eleven-year-old girl, Nannie Wynne. Using
Nannie's mother as an intermediary, he wrote in most intimate detail enacting a
fantasy marriage with the young girl. As fascinating as this element of WC's life
may be, an emphasis on his complicated relationships with women of all ages
tends to downplay his life as a professional writer, as an intellectual, and as a
person who needed books to exist. WC wrote for a living: he also depended
upon books as a basic resource for his creativity.
The Puttick and Simpson "Conditions of Sale" printed at the beginning of the
auction catalogue contain nothing that was not standard London auction house
practice. Seven conditions are specified. Firstly, "The highest Bidder to be the
Buyer." If there is a dispute "the Lot so disputed to be immediately put up again
and resold." Secondly, in monetary terms, no bidder is "to advance less than"
one shilling. If bidding goes above pounds no bidder is to advance less than two
shillings and sixpence "and so on in proportion." Thirdly "The Purchasers to
give in their Names and Places of Abode, and to pay down 10 s in the Pound, if
required, in Part Payment of the Purchase-money; in Default of which the Lot or
Lots so purchased shall be immediately put up again and resold."
In actual fact few lots attracted prices above three pounds, and a large number
went for below a pound. Of the volumes commanding higher prices, George
Henry Borrow's [Craik's] six-volume Celebrated Trials (item 43) realized £8 -7
s- 6 d (eight pounds seven shillings and sixpence). The London booksellers
Francis Edwards paid nineteen pounds for lot twenty-seven. This consists of
6 Wilkie Collins's Library
three items by John Forster, the friend of WC, Dickens and other Victorian
writers. The lot includes a presentation copy to WC of his Debates on the Grand
Remonstrance (item 204). There is Forster's biography of Sir John Eliot (item
207), and a copy of his two-volume biography of Walter Savage Landor (item
208). No single lot fetched the sum of twenty pounds. Indeed nineteen pounds
appears to be the highest price recorded at the auction. Maggs Brothers, the
London booksellers, paid that amount for lot 90. This consists of two unspecified
presentation copies, and two presentation copies. Of these specified presentation
copies, Joseph Ritson's Robin Hood: A Collection of All the Ancient Poems,
Songs, and Ballads, Now Extant, Relative to That Celebrated English Outlaw,
published in 1820, is described in the auction catalogue as having a "woodcut on
title painted, with signature 'William Collins aged 8 years 1832'" (item 420). It
is one of the earliest books of WC to have survived. The other lot item was an
inscribed copy from the translator, Sir John Kingston James (1815-1893), to WC
dated 1865, of his translation of Tasso's Jerusalem Delivered (item 475).
amongst the London dealers7, buying under his own name, is surprisingly the
purchaser of only two lots: Forster's Life of Dickens, with WC's marginalia {lot
63}(item 206), and a twenty-three-volume new edition of WC's Works with two
letters inserted {lot 219}(item 123).The Dickens item, lot 63, was bought by
Quaritch on commission for William Barclay Squire of 14 Albert Place, Victoria
Road, Kensington. Lot 219 was bought by Quaritch for a great WC admirer and
associate, Harry Quilter (1851-1907).8
Other lots from the Puttick and Simpson sale were well distributed amongst the
buyers in the auction room. "Nugent" and "Withers" purchased fourteen lots
each: "Nugent" acquired lots three through six at the opening of the auction and
then picking up various items as the auction proceeded {lots 3, 4, 5, 6, 73, 115,
132, 164, 165, 171, 199, 200, 211, 233}. "Withers," on the other hand, seems to
have been looking for books with prints in them. This would associate the name
with the provincial firm of Withers of Leicester who specialized in prints {lots 7,
13, 19, 28, 31, 42, 43, 53, 90, 91, 93, 108, 150, 232}. The names of "Hartley"
and "Suckling" appear by twelve lots. The pattern of "Hartley's" acquisition
seems to be that of miscellaneous literary items {lots 16, 21, 76, 85, 99, 114,
117, 124, 139, 141, 147, 172}. The other buyer is probably identified with
"George Suckling, then of Garrick Street, W C 2 and subsequently of Cecil
Court . . . a firm known to many latter-day visitors for their enormous stock of
engraved portraits, but the George Sucklings, father and son, ranged about pretty
freely in books."9 They also acted for Quaritch, purchasing lot 161. This consists
of eleven volumes including two by Jean Baptiste Louvet de Couvray (1760-
1797), a revolutionary and member of the Convention nationale (see item 320).
Another identifiable item in the lot is the memoirs of Jean-Henri Masers de
Latude (1725-1805), imprisoned in the Bastille for thirty-five years for
apparently plotting against Mme de Pompadour (item 299). These volumes were
also bought on commission for William Barclay Squire.10
Others active at the auction, who acquired more than five lots, range from the
names of "Oliver," "Parsons," and "Roche" to that of "Smith." "Oliver"
demonstrates a clear interest in illustrated materials including newspapers, serial
runs and popular novels in bulk. Amongst the items knocked down to "Oliver"
are a run of Dickens's Household Words, with one missing number, bound in ten
volumes {lot 62}, an eighteen-volume run of "popular novels" {lot 157}, thirty-
eight volumes of miscellaneous French plays and comedies {lot 174}, twenty-
seven volumes of French novels {lot 179}, and a parcel of magazines including
an unbound Notes & Queries for 1872 {lot 186}. The final acquisition knocked
down to "Oliver" {lot 189}, includes various numbers of the illustrated LArt
and the American Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper. This New York
periodical serialized Collins's The Fallen Leaves (1879), The Black Robe (1880-
1881) and Heart and Science (1882-1883).n
8 Wilkie Collins's Library
Another purchaser is "Parsons." Lots knocked down to this name include the
writings of Bryan Waller Procter (Barry Cornwall) {lot 26}, a broken run of the
Theatrical Observer {lot 105}, a copy of the theatrical manager and dramatist
Alfred Bunn's three-volume work on The Stage {lot 116}, a parcel of illustrated
works in Italian {lot 181}, William Collins's Memoir of the painter George
Morland {lot 218}, and a parcel of WC's scrap books containing press reviews
of his books {lot 231}. "Parsons" also acquired some Folio volumes, a copy of
Edward Young's Night Thoughts with William Blake's designs {lot 239}, and
the lavishly illustrated John Frederick Lewis's Alhambra Sketches and Drawings
{lot 242}. The presence of so much illustrative material suggests that "Parsons"
refers to Edwin Parsons & Sons, booksellers, of 45 Brompton Road, London, S.
W. 3. They were "specialises] in illustration . . . whose 'beautifully produced'
catalogue of engravings was enthusiastically reviewed in the The Bookman's
Journal for 24 December 1920."12
Less readily identifiable is "Roche" to whom eight lots were knocked down.
These items include a six-volume Aldine Poets {lot 29}, a presentation copy of
William Ketchum's History of Buffalo {lot 38}, William Hazlitt's four-volume
Life of Napoleon {lot 74}, a thirty-one-volume set of one of WC's favorite
novelists, James Fenimore Cooper {lot 83}, a twenty-eight-volume copy of
another favorite of WC, Sir Walter Scott's Prose Works with Turner's
frontispiece and vignettes {lot 87}, a twenty-six-volume record of French crimes
compiled by Maurice Mejan {lot 192}, a forty-five-volume Balzac {lot 194},
and WC's signed copy of Jacques Peuchet's Parisian police memoirs {lot 209}.
The last two lots were bought by Roche acting for Quaritch who in turn were
acting for the book collector William Barclay Squire.13
On the other hand, more recognizable are the names of two well-known London
dealers, Walter T. Spencer and Sotheran. It is surprising that they didn't
purchase more. Spencer's name may be found by three lots: Dickens's Plays and
Poems and the three-volume Dickens Letters {lots 59, 60} and a presentation
copy from the prolific dramatist Edward Ball, later Fitzball, to Charles Dickens
of a copy of his own book of poems {lot 121}. Such purchases reflect the
interest of the firm of Walter T. Spencer, "a deliberately literary dealer, with a
strong line in nineteenth-century English fiction, poetry, book-illustration, and
separate plates" (Freeman, 93). Somewhat surprising in the listing of successful
bidders is that the name of the bookselling firm of Henry Sotheran appears only
once. Sotheran specialized in areas similar to those dealt in by Spencer. Their
name may be found by a presentation copy of Harry Quilter's criticism,
Sentential Artis, to WC {lot 45}.
King's Theatre and Theatre Royal Drury Lane, published in 1826, was acquired
by Bain, a London bookseller at Puttick and Simpson's auction. According to the
minutes of the Library Committee of the Athenaeum, WC's old London club, of
which he had been a member since 1861, the volumes were a suggestion for
purchase made to the committee in January 1890. The two volumes of Kelly
were ordered after the meeting of 24 January 1890, just four days after they were
purchased by Bain at auction. They are now at the Athenaeum.
Three lots {191, 197, 206} were purchased by St. Martin's Public Library.
These lots consist of a twenty-two-volume set of Diderot's Oeuvres avec
Memoires (Paris, 1821), a six-volume set of Casanova's Memoires (Bruxelles,
1860), and a seventy-volume set of Voltaire's Oeuvres Completes ([Kehl],
1784). St. Martin's Public Library was the local rate-supported public library in
St. Martin's Lane, a stone's throw away from Puttick and Simpson's auction
rooms in Leicester Square. In the late twentieth century, St. Martin's Public
Library became part of the Westminster City Libraries, which in the last decade
of the nineteenth century had, according to Keith Manley, the historian of the
Library, "ambitions to be really serious and comprehensive libraries, and
probably those items were not too expensive, considering. That sort of thing
obviously looks good in annual reports."14 Unfortunately these purchased
volumes are no longer traceable at St. Martin's Public Library or in other
Westminster City Libraries in London.
Easier to identify today is lot 173, described in the Puttick and Simpson auction
catalogue as a "beautifully clean copy," with a presentation on the fly leaf from
the editor and translator Robert du Pontavice de Heussey (1850-1893), of his
L'Inimitable Boz: Sur la Vie et VOeuvre de C Dickens (Paris, 1889). Given to
WC by de Heussey on 17 January 1889, the copy is today at the Parrish
Collection, Princeton University. Two other items from WC's library are, in the
last year of the twentieth century, not in institutional collections, such as
Princeton University Libraries, but in the possession of his descendants. Faith
Clarke, WC's great-granddaughter, and her husband William M. Clarke, WC's
biographer, own WC's copy of Edward Holmes's The Life of Mozart (1845). On
the fly-leaf of the volume, which is in its original brown cloth, is the note in
pencil, "Purchased at the Sale of Wilkie Collins Library at Puttick & Simpson"
and the auction date "Jany. 20th 1890" with the note "Lot 7." Purchased by
Withers (probably of Leicester), this lot consists of books relating to music.
After the catalogue describes three titles - '''Beethoven's Life," "Bass' Street
Music in the Metropolis, " and uCallcott's Musical Grammar" - it has an "etc."
This probably refers to Holmes's biography of Mozart. In 1999, also in the
possession of Faith and William Clarke, is WC's four-volume copy of a
translation from the French, The Works of Francis Rabelais (1844). The first two
volumes contain WC's signature and the date "June 1844." The first volume has
the note in pencil on the fly-leaf "Lot 93. Purchased at the Sale of the Library...
10 Wilkie Collins's Library
of the late Wilkie Collins Esq at Puttick and Simpson's. Jany. 20th 1890." The
buyer was also Withers.
The descriptions in the auctioneers Puttick and Simpson's catalogue and details
in Bennett's catalogue reveal the provenance of books in WC's library. Many are
presentation copies either from authors or from publishers. Some have very close
personal associations. For instance, lot 90, purchased by Withers at the Puttick
and Simpson auction, is a two-volume copy of Robert Southey's Essays, Moral
and Political (1832). The volume is a presentation copy to "Master Collins 1st
Prize Maida Hill Academy Xmas 1835." WC was just eleven years old. Another
book, the six-volume Jacques Peuchet's Memoires Tirees des Archives de la
Police de Paris (Paris, 1838), is fortunate to remain amongst its owner's books.
It was borrowed by a friend and then returned to WC. The lender wrote to
Frederick Lehmann that his friend and fellow author Charles "Reade has been
here, and has carried off my book about the French Police (Memoires tirees des
Archives, &c &c)" (25 October 1869: Letters, II, 326). Evidently, Charles Reade
returned the volumes to WC.
The relatively low prices paid overall and the dominance of one purchaser,
Bennett, or his representatives bidding in other names on his behalf, suggests the
operation at the auction of the classic "ring." In other words, an agreement
amongst established dealers and booksellers to allow the prices to be kept down,
and most of the lots to realize a small amount. Of the two hundred forty-six lots
only thirty-three reached a hammer price above one pound sterling. Only one lot
fetched over ten pounds. This was a twenty-two-volume library edition of
Dickens's Works, a presentation copy from the author with "interesting
autograph letter inserted." Lot 55 was bought by someone using the name of
"Stirling". The only other price to come close to that was also for a Dickens
item. A three-volume first edition of Great Expectations in the original blue
cloth was knocked down to "Robson" {lot 57} for nine pounds and five
shillings.
The "Conditions of Sale" laid down by William Simpson and printed at the front
of Puttick and Simpson's catalogue appear to be standard for book auctions at
the time. The first three are straightforward. The fourth condition stipulates:
The Lots to be taken away at the Buyers' Expense and Risk within one
week from the conclusion of the Sale, and the remainder of the
Purchase-money to be absolutely paid, or otherwise settled for to the
satisfaction of the Venders, on or before delivery: in default of which
Messrs. PUTTICK AND SIMPSON will not hold themselves
responsible, if the Lots be lost, stolen, or damaged, or destroyed, but
they will be left at the sole risk of the Purchaser.
Introduction 11
This may explain why certain books known to be part of WC's Library do not
appear in the Puttick and Simpson Catalogue, or reappear in Bennett's
subsequent Catalogue of the Library. Of course their absence, as in the case of
Holmes's Life of Mozart, may fall under what in Puttick and Simpson's
catalogue is referred to as the "etc" category. Barry Cornwall's English Songs
and Other Small Poems does not appear in their 20 January 1890 listing or in
Bennett. It is not found, either, under Bryan Waller Procter, the real name of
"Barry Cornwall." WC's copy, inscribed on the front fly-leaf "Wilkie Collins
Esq with the Authors' [sic] Kind regards," and marginal lining throughout, was
in the year 2000 owned by the eminent WC collector and bibliographer, Andrew
Gasson.
There are items purchased by Bennett at the Puttick and Simpson auction which
do not reappear in the Bennett Catalogue. Puttick and Simpson lot 12 consists of
at least three items constituting six volumes in all. The first two, copies of Henry
Joseph Ruggles's The Method ofShakspeare as an Artist (New York: 1870), and
the second edition, published in 1840, of Sir George Stephen's Adventures of an
Attorney in Search of Practice, are marked down to Bennett as the purchaser.
Both of these volumes appear in Bennett's Catalogue [Bennett 119, 122]. The
third item in Puttick and Simpson's lot 12, a copy of James Miller's single
volume, Alcohol; Its Place and Power (Glasgow: 1860), also purchased by
Bennett at auction, disappears from view. It is not in his Catalogue. There are
three other volumes in the Puttick and Simpson Catalogue lot 12, purchased by
Bennett. These other volumes are in the "etc" category in the auction Catalogue.
They too have vanished.
The fifth sale condition states that "The Books are presumed to be perfect, unless
otherwise expressed in the Catalogue, or at the time of the Sale; but if upon
collating within one week of the Sale they should prove defective, the Purchaser
will be at liberty to take or reject them." Puttick and Simpson's catalogue
descriptions appear to be fairly thorough in order to cover themselves. Lot 124
consists of the plays of the Restoration dramatists Vanbrugh, Farquhar and
Otway. Of these, the second volume of the 1712 copy of Sir Thomas Otway's
Works lacks its cover. Lot 127, a twenty-one-volume Jonathan Swift Works with
Life and Notes by Hawkesworth, has a "small hole in title of vol.17," and the
final two leaves of the last volume are damaged.
The penultimate sale condition essentially amplifies at some length the fifth
condition, and covers the auctioneers for legal claims against them. "The sale of
any Book or Books is not to be set aside on account of any Stained or Short
leaves of text or Plates, want of List of Plates, or on account of the Publication of
any subsequent Volume, Supplement, Appendix, or Plates. All the Manuscripts,
all Magazines, and Reviews, all Books in Lots, and all Tracts in Lots, or
Volumes will be sold with all Faults, Imperfections, and Errors of Description."
12 Wilkie Collins's Library
The final sale condition relates to payment, settlement and the wish of the
auctioneers Puttick and Simpson, to clear their rooms of materials from a
specific sale - in this instance, the auction of WC's books - and to move onto
their next auction. The seventh and final sale condition reads: "Upon failure of
complying with the above Conditions, the money deposited in part payment shall
be forfeited; and all Lots left uncleared in conformity with these Conditions may
be resold by public or private Sale without further notice; and the Deficiency (if
any) arising from such re-sale shall be made good by the defaulters at this sale,
together with all charges attending the same." They add that "This Condition is
without prejudice to the right of the Auctioneers to enforce the contract made at
this sale, without such re-sale, if they think fit."
The first two items in Bennett's Catalogue are not books at all but two household
decorative items. These, it may be assumed, came from an auction of WC's
effects. The first consists of a "Candelabra" described by Bennett as "A Pair of
metal, for four lights each - namely, one in the centre and three around - \VA
inches high; a circular base, with three branches, supporting an amphora-shaped
shaft (on which are three medallions), above which are the before named triple
branches, price £2 10s. the pair." The second item in the Bennett catalogue
consists of "Indian Bronze Vases standing 11 inches high, 20 inches
circumference in the widest part, with covers having a grotesque animal on the
top, the whole of very fine antique workmanship, deeply engraved, and with
elephants' heads in high relief at the four corners, price £5 10s."
The books themselves begin with the third item in the "Caxton Head" catalogue
of M. L. Bennett. This is a copy of George Thomas Keppel, the Earl of
Introduction 13
6] for two shillings and six pence. His item seven, "Dot it Down," has the same
price. However, there is a note in Bennett's catalogue to the effect that with
Begg's Creation of Manitoba it may be purchased for four shillings. In other
words, by acquiring both Begg titles the purchaser obtains them at half their total
price, four shillings rather than eight shillings.
Two other illustrations will be sufficient to illustrate the nature of the mark-up
Bennett thought that he could command. He purchased at auction three folio-
sized items. These were the final two lots in the Puttick and Simpson auction of
WC's Library. Lot 245 consists of a copy of J. J. Johns's (not "J. W. Johns" as
printed in the Puttick and Simpson Catalogue) Anglican Cathedral Church of
Saint James, Mount Zion, Jerusalem, and Claude Warren's Celebrated Hands:
The Life-Size Outlines of the Hands of Twenty-Two Celebrated Hands.
Published in 1882, Warren's volume contains an illustration, amongst those of
other celebrities, of WC's hands. Bennett paid six shillings at auction for the
copies of Johns and Warren. He subsequently prices the former at seven shillings
and sixpence. Warren's Celebrated Hands is offered at ten shillings and
sixpence.
The final lot {246} in the Puttick and Simpson auction of WC's Library held on
Monday 20 January 1890, knocked down to Bennett, also appears in their
February 1890 Catalogue. The lot is described in their Catalogue as an "Atlas -
Black's General. 61 Maps by Hall Hughes &c, and Index of 57, 500 names,
folio, half morocco." Bennett item 18 a, published in Edinburgh in 1847, was
purchased at the auction for one shilling. It is offered in their catalogue for four
shillings.
Introduction 15
Presentation/Association Copies
[5 volumes.,
presented 1883-
1887]
38 344 S.C. Massett Drifting 1863 Author (1820-1898)
American
lyricist
39 353 E. Meryon Huguenot 1876 Author (1809-1880)
medical author
40 356 N.C. Moak Billings 1879 Author (1833-1892)
[trial] American
attorney
41 365 E. Nesbit Legends 1887 Publisher Longmans
copy dated 1824 is in his Library: the copy was presented to his mother a year
later (item 482).
Books with inscriptions to other people rather than to WC are revealing. To take
one instance, Forbes Winslow (1810-1874) was a physician and member of the
Royal College of Surgeons. The Dictionary of National Biography notes that in
1847 he "opened two private lunatic asylums in Hammersmith, where he
employed the humane method of treating lunatics. . . . The frequent
establishment of the plea of insanity in criminal cases was largely due to his
influence." Winslow presented a copy of his 1854 Lettsomian Lectures on
Insanity (item 519) to the Editor of The Leader, WC's close friend Edward
Pigott. The 1861 second edition of Winslow's On Obscure Diseases of the Brain
(item 520) has a presentation inscription to WC. Certainly both works relate to
WC's own fictional exploration of the world of insanity and lunatic asylums in
22 Wilkie Collins's Library
The Woman in White, serialized in All the Year Round from 23 November 1859
until 22 August 1860.
There are some surprising omissions from the inscribed copies in the Library.
There are copies which probably are presentation copies but lack inscriptions.
For instance in a letter dated 17 June 1869 WC writes to Joseph Ellis, "Pray
accept my best thanks for the copy of your poems which you have kindly sent
me." He comments upon the poems, demonstrating that he has actually read
some of them: "I may instance 'The dirge of man' as being, to my mind, one of
the most successful among your more ambitious efforts - and 'Try Again' as
offering a lively and pleasant essay in poetry of the more homely and practical
sort" (Ms: Bodleian). There is no indication that the copy of Joseph Ellis's
Meletic: Poems (1869) sold at Puttick and Simpson's auction, bought by
Bennett, and recorded in his catalogue, is an inscribed or presentation copy {lot
92}[Bennett 62]. Its presence is another illustration of WC's influence and the
high esteem in which he was held by many of his now largely forgotten
contemporaries.
Curious omissions from the record of WC's Library include works dedicated to
him. There are no works by James Payn (1830-1898), a prolific writer close to
WC who worked with him on Household Words. Payn dedicated his
Gwendoline's Harvest (1870) to WC. Blanche Roosevelt's (1853-1898) The
Copper Queen: A Romance of To-day and Yesterday (1886) was in WC's
collection at the time of his death (item 421). No copy of her Verdi, Milan and
Othello, published a year later, is present. Her account of the Italian opera is
dedicated to WC, and in her preface dated "Paris, June 1887", she writes, "My
dear Friend, | When I left England for Italy, you said 'Do write me all about
Verdi, Milan, and the new opera Othello'. . . . I hope also that it [the book] may
recall to your mind not alone a composer, a country, and a people whom you
have long so professedly admired." Her dedication reads "To Wilkie Collins. My
dear friend . . . knowing that the work never would have been written without
you, I dedicate it to you."
Introduction 23
WC's agent and confidant during his last years, Alexander Pollock Watt (1834-
1914), was in the habit of sending him books. Fine examples may be found in
two of the copies of Rider Haggard in WC's Library (items 242, 243). The
books elicited lengthy verbal and epistolary responses from the recipient. Of
She, WC wrote to Watt: "I must talk to you about 'She' the next time you give
me a look-in . . . 'She' is better written than 'Mines' - but it has not got the
movement of the story and the variety of situations . . . And I doubt the effect on
the stupid reader (a most important person, unhappily, to please) of the lady who
is 2000 years old" {Letters, II, 531:25 January 1887). A few weeks earlier he had
written a lengthy letter to Watt concerning the strengths and weaknesses of King
Solomon's Mines {Letters, II, 529-530: 4 January 1887). Published in 1885,
Haggard's novel was frequently re-printed. The copy in WC's Library is the red
cloth "28th Thousand" impression published in 1889. This suggests that an
earlier copy of the novel WC may have had disappeared. There is no evidence,
either in Puttick and Simpson's Auction Catalogue, or in Bennett's Catalogue,
that any of the copies of Rider Haggard's novels in WC's Library are
presentation copies from Watt.
Another copy, which more than likely is inscribed, but no association is recorded
in the Puttick and Simpson or Bennett sources, is that of the French dramatic
translation by Robert du Pontavice de Heussey of WC's The New Magdalen.
This was the stage version of his novel first published in 1873. The play was
successful in London and the provinces, and also was performed in Paris, Rome,
Berlin and Vienna. Produced by Augustin Daly on Broadway in November
1873, it was revived in London as late as 1906 (Gasson 113). De Heussey (1850-
1893), Breton author, translated WC's work into French and represented his
interests in France. He was the recipient of long intimate letters from WC (see
for instance Letters, II, 449-50; 482-83; 484-85; 559-60). Three of de Heussey's
books are found in WC's Library. A copy of de Heussey's biography of Dickens
24 Wilkie Collins's Library
Four copies of works by Victor Hugo are noted in WC's Library (items 267-
270). None give an indication of their provenance. One of these is a three-
volume Hugo's [Le Theatre] published in Paris in 1850. In an undated letter
written to the publisher Richard Bentley, WC thanks him for a copy of a Hugo
play and adds that he doesn't mind waiting for "Charpentier's edition of Victor
Hugo's Plays" (MS: University of Illinois, Urbana). According to Kenneth
Robinson's Wilkie Collins, A Biography (New York: Macmillan, 1952) Edward
Lear was "a lifelong friend" of WC. Robinson adds, "It is however a friendship
of which hardly a trace remains" (93).15 WC's Library contains one Lear item, a
copy of his Journal of a Landscape Painter in Corsica (1870) (item 302), but no
inscription is recorded. During the writing of Man and Wife (1868-1869), WC
sought the advice of the journalist, civil servant and social reformer, Joseph
Charles Parkinson (1833-1908). A copy of Parkinson's Places and People
(1869) is in WC's Library (item 382). It again is an example of a volume which
might well have contained an inscription but apparently does not.
On the other hand, there are presentation copies in his Library with no inscriber
recorded. There is a "presentation copy" of a pamphlet agitating against the
Proposed Destruction of the Well Walk Hampstead. This is a pamphlet by Sir
Gilbert Scott. There is no evidence that Scott presented it personally to WC
(item 398). A copy of The Public Ledger Building, Philadelphia: With an
Account of the Proceedings Connected with Its Opening June 20, 1867,
published a year later, is however more revealing as to its provenance. It was
published by George W. Childs (1829-1894), whom WC had met and formed a
friendship with during his 1873-1874 American visit. The copy contains a
"Dedication of Printer's Cemetery, Woodlands." The uninscribed copy (item
399) is probably a gift from its publisher, Childs.
There are, as we have seen, inscriptions which reveal the extent of the esteem in
which WC was held as a man of letters. There are inscriptions which reveal
friendships and hitherto ignored biographical, literary and social connections.
Theodore William Alois Buckley's (1825-1856) presentation copy of his
translation of Aeschylus's Tragedies (item 5), was published by Bohn in their
classics series in 1849. The presence of the presentation inscription reveals a
previously neglected connection between WC and the classical scholar who
contributed to Household Words and died in tragic circumstances, a victim of
Introduction 25
Some annotated copies are a guide to WC's sources used whilst writing his
novels. In some cases they illuminate the presence of other non-inscribed
volumes in WC's collection. There is for instance a presentation copy from the
author of the 1861 edition of [A Guide to] Aldeburgh and Adjacent Places (item
8). The Suffolk coastal town is used in No Name, which WC was writing in
1861-1862. He visited the resort with Caroline Graves in 1861 and the novel
contains powerfully evocative descriptions of the coastland. WC "admired
Crabbe's poetry, and he reminded his readers that Aldeburgh was the poet's
birthplace. His description of the town, gradually being reclaimed by the sea, and
the surrounding country are deliberately modelled on Crabbe's evocative
backgrounds to his tales of rural violence and poverty" (Peters 238). There is the
eight-volume 1834 edition of Crabbe's Poetical Works . . . With His Letters and
Journals, and His Life amongst WC books (item 141).
It is surprising that there are not more presentation copies or works by WC's
friend Charles Kent (1832-1902) (Dickens, Letters, II, 609). Kent, author and
26 Wilkie Collins's Library
Other volumes extant in WC's Library were probably drawn upon whilst writing
novels such as The Black Robe, which develops themes used in his "Yellow
Mask." This earlier tale, published in Household Words 7-28 July 1855, contains
a plot in which "a high-ranking Catholic priest schemes to recover property he
considers to belong rightfully to the Church" (Gasson 19). Volumes in WC's
library providing him with background information for such a plot include
Leopold von Ranke's History of the Popes. WC possessed the three-volume
translation by E. Foster published in 1847 (item 407). Also in the library is a
copy of Andrew Steinmetz's three-volume History of the Jesuits, published a
year later. The volumes contain "numerous pencil marks by Wilkie Collins"
(item 458). There is in addition a copy of Cardinal Wiseman's Recollections of
the Last Four Popes and of Rome in Their Times, published in 1858 (item 530).
Mejan is not the only volume of criminal trials found in the library providing its
owner with materials for his fiction. There is present the six-volume 1825
[Craik's] Celebrated Trials and Remarkable Cases of Criminal Jurisprudence
edited by the young George Borrow (item 43). Unfortunately there is no record
of how or when WC obtained the volumes. There is no record either of how a
copy of David Jardine's Celebrated Criminal Trials, published in two volumes
by the Society for the Diffusion of Useful Knowledge in 1825 (item 277), came
into its owner's possession. Neither is there a record of how Francois Richer's
eighteen-volume record of French criminal trials, Causes Celebres, published in
Amsterdam between 1772 and 1881 (item 418), came into WC's hands.
WC drew upon French police records and criminal trials for many of his finest
plots. In addition to Mejan he would have used Louis Canler's Memoirs . . .
Ancien Chef du Service de Surete, published in Brussels in 1862. An edition in
French is in WC's Library (item 73). Ward and Lock, the London publishers,
published in the same year an English translation. The 1881 two-volume
Memoires de Mr. Claude, Chef de la Police de Surete sous le Second Empire
amongst WC's books (item 89) reveals WC's continuing interest in French
detective work and criminal investigations. The other eight volumes of this ten-
volume work published between 1881 and 1883 are not present. A source he
would have drawn upon for his short stories, and novels such as The Woman in
White and The Moonstone, is Jacques Peuchet's Memoires Tirees des Archives
de la Police de Paris pour Servir a I 'Histoire de la Morale et de la Police Louis
XIV jusqu' a nos Jours. Six volumes published in Paris in 1838 are in his
Library with his signature (item 384).
In his "Introduction" to his edition of WC's first novel Ioldni: or, Tahiti As It
Was, Ira B. Nadel draws attention to WC's use of "the source text for Ioldni"
(xxii). This is the second edition in four volumes of William Ellis's Polynesian
Researches: During a Residence of Nearly Eight Years in the Society and
Sandwich Islands. Published in 1831, a copy is in WC's Library (item 187). No
annotations or marginalia are recorded in the work from which WC "borrowed
the names of the four principal characters Iolani, Aimati, Idia and Mahine, citing
Tahitian pronunciation, marriage customs, scenic descriptions and the practice of
infanticide which provides a key issue for the novel" (Gasson 85).
WC's detailed response in a letter to Hayne dated 16 July 1884 goes far beyond
WC's usual conviviality and politeness. There is no evidence that Hayne and
WC met. In one of the many lengthy personal letters to Hayne, whom WC
clearly recognized as a kindred spirit, WC opens with an acknowledgment of
personal problems, yet "I was utterly unworthy of your poems, until my mind
had rested a little." WC has "only at the beginning of this week .. . begun to read
[Hayne] confining myself at first to the shorter poems." He then picks out his
favourites so far in his reading. Three poems are named which "represent many
others in which I find true poetical feeling, expressed delightfully in truly
poetical language" which "is a very rare quality in the present time." Amongst
his contemporaries WC finds "affectation of language, and obscurity of
meaning." he formulates what he desires in poetry: "what I insist on is, a
favourable impression at starting. Excepting Tennyson (in his shorter poems),181
read hardly any modern poetry with pleasure." Hayne's work is an exception:
"What I like in your poetry (so far as I yet know it) is - that it makes me feel,
and that it has not stopped me" (Letters, II, 469-470). The presence of an
inscribed copy from a relatively obscure South Carolina poet reveals the extent
of WC's influence. The recipient's extensive response to the poems tells us much
about WC's poetic values, and the impact the book of poetry had upon him.
Another response to what may have been an unsolicited presentation copy shows
WC going beyond mere civility and politeness. In what must have been a
difficult letter to write, WC, in a letter date 15 January 1876, responds to a copy
he has received of the two-volume William Michael Rossetti and Philip Bourke
Introduction 29
Marston edition of Oliver Madox Brown's The Dwale Bluth, Hebditch 's Legacy,
and Other Remains (1876) (item 54). The volume contains "the literary remains
o f the son of Ford Madox Brown (1821-1893), the painter, whose connections
with the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood must have reminded WC of his own
brother Charles Allston Collins, and his sad and disappointing connections with
the Brotherhood. Charles died in 1873, three years before his brother received
the volumes from Ford Madox Brown. The young Oliver Madox Brown died at
the age of 19 on 5 November 1874. His death produced a sonnet of
remembrance from Dante Gabriel Rossetti, published in The Athenaeum, 14
November 1874. In his letter to Ford Madox Brown, the recipient of the volumes
is not uncritical of them. In the story "The Black Swan," WC sees "the inevitable
defects of youth and inexperience." Yet he agrees that "the untimely death o f
Ford Madox Brown's "son is a loss to literature which all friends of Art have
true reason to regret" (Ms: John Rylands, Manchester).
WC formed many lasting friendships during the visit. For instance he first met
Sebastian Benzon Schlesinger, the employer of his godson Frank Ward, in
Boston during his reading tour. Schlesinger and his wife were the dedicatees of
WC's novella The Haunted Hotel (1879). A record of their relationship and
other friendships made in America survives in WC's correspondence {Letters, II,
613). There are no books with Schlesinger's inscription, however the legacy of
his American tour is found in the many inscribed presentation copies from
Americans from all walks of life in his library. There is, for instance, a
translation of Adelbert von Chamisso's (1781-1838) Faust: A Dramatic Sketch.
The translation, published in Philadelphia in 1881 in a limited edition of one
hundred copies only for private circulation, is by Henry Phillips Jr. (1838-1895)
(item 83). A translator and numismatist, Phillips devoted his time to learned
30 Wilkie Collins's Library
WC met many publishers during his tour. A testimony to these meetings is seen
in a presentation copy of the French philosopher Victor Cousin's The Philosophy
of the Beautiful from its New York publisher Daniel Bixby (item 139). A
translator, who also presented her efforts to WC, was Mary French Sheldon
(1847-1936). A presentation copy of her translation of Gustav Flaubert's
Salammbo, published in 1886 (item 201), elicited an interesting response from
WC in a letter dated 11 April 1886 {Letters, II, 520-521).
WC assisted the American actress, journalist, lecturer and feminist, Kate Field
(1838-1896) with her Charles Albert Fechter, published in Boston in 1882. It is
hardly surprising that Field, who had corresponded with WC and met him,
should present him with a copy of the memoir of a mutual friend (item 196). It
was Fechter (1824-1879) who greeted WC when he disembarked in America.
WC stayed with him in Pennsylvania and saw him again in New York, for what
was to be the last time, before leaving for England. WC's "Recollections of
Charles Fechter" are candid and found in Kate Field's 1882 volume.
Other inscribed copies testify to WC's meetings with or the impact he had upon
Americans, such as Henry Phillips, now largely forgotten. These range from
presentation copies from the author Edgar Fawcett (1847-1904) (item 192), the
journalist William Fearing Gill (1844-1917) (item 228), the American natural
historian George W. Holley (1810-1897) (item 260), the historian of Buffalo,
New York, William Ketchum (1798-1876) (item 287), the diplomat and
journalist Edward De Leon (1828-1891) (item 305), the lyricist Stephen C.
Massert (1820-1898) (item 344), the Attorney Nathaniel Cleveland Moak (1833-
1892) (item 356), the abolitionist Alexander Milton Ross (1832-1897) (item
424) and the Boston-based novelist and short story writer John Townsend
Trowbridge (1827-1916) (item 497).
Copies from more well known figures include John Bigelow (1817-1911), Oliver
Wendell Holmes (1809-1894), and William Winter (1836-1917). John Bigelow
was the associate editor and owner from 1848 to 1861 of the leading New York
Republican evening newspaper, the New York Evening Post. "As consul general
at Paris (1861-65) and minister to France (1865-66), he helped swing sympathy
away from the Confederacy." An inscribed copy of his edition "based on the
manuscript he discovered in France" (Hart 67) of the Autobiography of
Benjamin Franklin, published in Philadelphia in 1868, is amongst WC's books
(item 210). A testimony also to the friendship formed between Bigelow, his wife
and WC is seen in the intimate letter WC wrote to Mrs. Bigelow on the final day
Introduction 31
of the year he had returned from America. WC observes to Mrs. Bigelow: "In
your country, I felt five and twenty years old. In my country I (not infrequently)
feel five and ninety" {Letters, II, 388: 31 December 1874).
Another of the friendships formed by WC on his American tour was with Oliver
Wendell Holmes. A man of diverse talents, Holmes was a leading contributor to
the influential Atlantic Monthly, which he helped found in 1857. A lecturer and
medical doctor, he was Parkman Professor of Anatomy and Physiology at
Harvard, and Dean of the Harvard Medical School. An accomplished poet, he
composed a "verse tribute" entitled "A Toast to Wilkie Collins," read at a 22
October 1873 breakfast party to honor WC. Upon his return to England, WC
wrote Holmes "I shall prize as long as I live the charming little poem which
speaks to me of your genius and your kindness whenever I look at it. Farewell,
dear Doctor Holmes, for the present. I have few dearer hopes than the hope of
my return to America" (Ms: Library of Congress: 7 March 1874).
Oliver Wendell Holmes sent his friend WC a presentation copy of his Songs of
Many Seasons: 1862-1874, published in Boston in 1875 (item 263). In a lengthy
reply to Holmes, WC comments in detail upon the poems: "Your last Poems
have been - in bed and out of bed - my always welcome companions," He
instances several poems including "the Organ Blower," "At the Pantomime," the
"War Songs," "Never or Now," "Class Meeting" and naturally Holmes's "A
Toast to Wilkie Collins" for commendation. He concludes his 17 May 1875
letter, "I am still looking forward to my return to the States, and to a renewal of
our brief intercourse at Boston - and still unable to fix a date for my departure"
{Letters, II, 394).
William Winter became a regular correspondent of WC. Nine of his works are
found in WC's library (items 521-529). One of them, a copy of Winter's English
Rambles and Other Fugitive Pieces, in Prose and Verse, published in Boston in
1884 (item 522), is a presentation copy. For more than forty years, from 1865
until 1909, Winter was the influential dramatic critic of the New York Tribune.
"Although during the first twenty five years he was respected as the Great Cham
of the New York theater, he was later considered a relic of the Victorian era
because of his romanticism, sentimentalism, insistence upon morality, and hatred
of the rising realism." Also, he wrote "a great many occasional poems . . .
funeral verse on the deaths of actors, which, because of his longevity, were so
frequent, that he came to be known as 'Weeping Willie'" (Hart 730).
personality was even more interesting than his authorship. To be in his company
was to be charmed, delighted stimulated and refreshed." Winters adds that WC's
"intellectual energy communicated itself to all around him, but his manner was
so exquisitely refined and gentle that, while he prompted extreme mental
activity, he also diffused a lovely influence of repose. The hours that I passed in
the company of Collins are remembered as among the happiest of my life" (203-
04). WC reciprocated such sentiments. His letters to Winter are affectionate,
personal, detailed, and look back with affection upon his visit to New York.
They are especially revealing concerning WC's views on literature and his
fellow authors, living and dead. Particularly noteworthy is his letter of 14
January 1883 with its views on "glorious Walter Scott (King, Emperor,
President, and God Almighty of. . . novelists)" {Letters, II, 453).
WC met Longfellow and Mark Twain in America. A copy of Twain's The Prince
and the Pauper, published in Toronto in 1882, is amongst WC's books (item
499). Surprisingly, no correspondence between Twain (1835-1910) and WC has
emerged. Absent from WC's Library are works by Longfellow (1807-1882),
with whom WC corresponded. In fact, whilst he was waiting at Boston to sail to
Liverpool, WC wrote to the great poet regretting that he was unable "to get to
Cambridge and to take your hand at parting." He hopes to return to America and
then visit Longfellow and his family at Harvard {Letters, II, 382: 6 March 1874).
Amongst the most poignant of the inscribed copies in the Library is that recalling
WC's old friendship with Charles Dickens. This is an inscribed copy of The
Letters of Charles Dickens, edited by his sister-in-law, Georgina Hogarth (1827-
1917) and Dickens's eldest daughter Mary Dickens (1836-1896). The copy,
published in two volumes in 1882, is inscribed on the fly-leaf, "with love from
the editors" (item 160). Both Georgina and Mary knew WC from the years when
WC and Dickens were close professionally and personally. In the aftermath of
Charles Collins's marriage to Dickens's daughter Kate, Georgina's friendship
with WC cooled. They "continued to be friends, if not intimates, and she and
Mamie [Mary Dickens] were very grateful for his help and professional advice
when they were preparing their edition of Dickens's letters" (Peters 347). WC's
letters to Georginia concerning the preparation of the edition are detailed and
practical. They also reflects past emotions. WC writes to her concerning a
forgery: "It is an outrage offered to Dickens's reputation to associate his great
name with rubbish which is utterly unworthy of if {Letters, II, 421: 18 March
1879).
Imprint Analysis
Both the Puttick and Simpson auction and the Bennett catalogues indicate
publication dates in addition to author's names, the title and the number of
volumes, in some instances places of publication, and the edition of a work. It is
Introduction 33
1700-1799 33 (26, 32, 36,44, 78, 86, 87, 130, 143, 6.15
151, 152, 165*, 191, 197, 232,280*, 286,
308, 339, 381, 395, 397, 403,417, 418,
443,448, 464, 474, 489, 500, 505, 537)
1800-1810 13 (79, 97, 147, 233, 238,272, 275, 281, 2.42
303,349,361,404,492)
1811-1820 19 (14, 18, 42, 45, 46, 71, 90, 94, 190, 3.54
225, 257, 307, 387, 400, 415, 420,433,
476, 535)
1821-1830 29(4, 11,41,43,85,96,131, 163,229, 5.40
236, 251, 252, 265, 283, 318, 320, 347,
357, 379, 386, 406, 412, 416,465,482,
488*, 509, 532, 534)
1831-1840 34 (2, 30, 49, 56, 62, 66, 68, 80, 141, 156, 6.33
167, 168, 173, 186, 221, 231, 244, 245,
269, 273, 277, 292, 299, 314, 340, 384,
419, 432,437 *, 449 *, [451], [452], 454,
459)
1841-1850 51 (5, [6]*, 25, 39, 50, 55, [65], 93, 99, 9.50
139, 145, 161*, 193,246,261,266,270,
279, 298,300, 301, 313, 317, 351, 358,
372, 390, 396, 402, 407,414, 422,426,
[427], [428], 431, [449], [450], 458,460,
461,462, 463,466, 472,478, 490*, 491*,
498,512,514)
1851-1860 53 (1*, [10], 13, 19*, 20*, 21, 34, 40,47, 9.87
51, 53, [57], 60, 67, 76, 95, [98], 104, 120,
136, 137, 161*, 162*, 194, 198, 199,203,
204, 220, 226, 249, 256, 267,274, 295,
[322], 326, 369, 370, 405,435,
441, 442, 445, 446,447, 471, 479,484,
34 Wilkie Collins's Library
1861-1870 71 (3, 8, 17, 24, 33, 72, 73, [74], 82, 84, 13.22
100, 114, 117, 119, 135, 148, 153*, 155,
157, [164], 169*, 185, 195, 207, 204, 208,
210, [216], [217], [218], [219], 223, 230,
258, 259, 285, 287, 289,294, 302, 304,
305, 316, 335, 344, 346, 355, 378, 382,
389, 393, 399, 408, 409,425, 440, 456,
467*, 468*, 469*, 470*, 475, 481, 486,
493, [501], [503], [504], 508, 520, 536)
1871-1880 95 (7, 12*, 28, 29, 31, 48, 52, 54, 58, 63, 17.69
[64], 81, 88, 103, 105, 107, 108, 109, 111,
115, 116, 118, 121, 122, 125*, 126*, 127*,
128*, 129, 132, 133, 134, 138, 140, 146,
149, 150*, 159*, 166, 171, 177, 178, 182,
183, 192, 206, 211, 224, 227, 228, 234,
235, 239, 260, 263, 264, 268, 282*, 284,
288, 291, 310, 312, 321, 323, 325, 327,
[331], [332], [333], 336, [341], 353, 354*,
356, 366, 371, 373, 385, [392], 398,423,
424, 430, 444, 480, 485, 486, 487,497,
[502],506,518,527,528)
1881-1889 84 (27, 35, 37, 69, 70, 83, 89, 91, 92, 101, 15.64
106, 110, 112, 113, 124, 134, 142, 144,
154, 158, 160, 179, 180, 181, 184, 189,
196, 201, 222, 240, 241, [242], 243, 248,
250, 253, 254, 255, 262, 271, 276, 278,
293, [319], 328, [329], 330, 342, 343, 352,
359, 362, 365, 374, 375*, 376*, 377*, 380,
383, 388, 401, 410, 411, 421, 434,473,
477, 483, [494], 499, 507, 510, 511, 513,
515, 521, 522, 523, 524, 525, 526, 529,
531,533)
Unestablished 53 (9**, 15, 16, 22, 23, 38, 59, 75, 77, 9.87
Dates 102**, 123, 170, 172, 174, 175, 176, 178,
187, 188, 205, 209**, 212, 213, 214, 215,
237, 247**, 290, 296, 297**, 309**, 311,
315, 324, 338**, 345, 348, 350, 360, 363,
364, 367 **, 368**, 391, 394, 413, 429,
436, 438**, 439, 455, 457, 495)
TOTAL 537 100.00
Introduction 35
[ ] items with approximate dating; * items published in more than one year; **
items not in book format: item 102 consists of Criticisms of the Press "in three
scrap books"; item 367 consists of two "scrap-books and [a] small parcel" of
"Newspaper Cuttings"; item 368 consists of a parcel of "Newspapers."
Not all the books then are from the later period of WC's life. Some, for instance
his school prize from 1835 (item 454), and his mother's copy of Jeremy Taylor's
Holy Living with her 1825 dating (item 482), survived the two major moves of
his late years. WC moved to 90 Gloucester Place in September 1867. Owing to
high rent demands he was then forced to move to 82 Wimpole Street in February
1888. As his letters reveal, the move was traumatic. He seems to have lost a
number of books in the process. He writes to Harry Quilter, the art critic, on 11
April 1888, imitating the pleas of his movers who are attempting to set up his
new home: "I am sorry to trouble you, but I miss three books out of the library
catalogue - Forster's Life of Goldsmith, and Lamb's Essays and Leigh Hunt's
Essays. Do you think they have been stolen?" . . . "I say, Wilkie! when you told
Marian and Harriet that they might help to put the books in their places, did you
know that Faublas and Casanova's Memoirs were left out on the drawing-room
table?" {Letters, II, 555). Neither John Forster's biography of Goldsmith,
published in 1848, nor any Leigh Hunt, are found in Puttick and Simpson's
auction, or Bennett's Catalogue. The copy of Lamb is one edited by Charles
Kent in 1889 (item 293). There is a six-volume Memoires de Jacques Casanova
published in Bruxelles in 1860 (item 76).
3.6 Wilkie Collins's Library
LOCATION TITLES %
1. Britain & Ireland 363 68.12
London, (329): (London & Dublin 1; London &
Edinburgh 1)
Elsewhere (32): Aldeburgh (1); Bath (1);
Bristol (1); Bury (1); Cambridge (1);
Douglas, Isle of Man (1); Dublin (2);
Edinburgh (11); Edinburgh & London (6);
Glasgow (1); Leicester (1); Louth (1);
Northampton (1); Oxford (2); Wakefield (1)
2. France: 95 17.93
Paris (95)
3. United States: 51 9.62
Albany, N.Y. (1); Boston (19); Boston & New
York (1); Brooklyn, N.Y. (1); Buffalo, N.Y.
(1); Cambridge, Mass. (1); Hartford, Conn. (1);
New York, (20); Philadelphia (6)
4. Canada: 8 1.51
Brockville, Ontario (1); Quebec (1);
Toronto (6)
5. Australia: 3 0.57
Melbourne (2); Sydney (1)
6. Belgium: 2 0.38
Brussels (2)
7. Germany: 5 0.94
Berlin (2); Leipzig (2); [Kehl] (1)
8. Italy: 6 1.13
Milan (2); Venezia (1); Rome (3)
9. Netherlands: 2 0.38
Amsterdam (1); Gravenhage (1)
10. Russia: 1 0.19
St. Petersbourg(l)
11. Sweden: 1 0.19
Goteborg(l)
TOTAL 537 100%*
Another writer, Henry Fielding, whose comic satire might have appealed to WC,
receives rather short shrift in his letters. In a letter to his friend Edward Pigott
written in 1855, WC quipped, "one of the most tedious books (to me) that I ever
read in my life was Tom Jones. This is wrong, I know, but all men have their
'cracked' points - and these are some of mine" {Letters, I, 146). One of the few
non-nineteenth-century works published in Edinburgh found amongst WC's
books is the twelve-volume fourth edition of The Works of Henry Fielding
printed by Martin and Wotherspoon in 1767 (item 197).
There are surprisingly few imprints from Oxford or Cambridge. From Oxford
there are two imprints: a four-volume Miscellaneous Works of Joseph Addison,
published in 1830 (item 4), and Pusey's edition of the Meditations and Prayers
of Saint Anselm, published by Parker's in 1865 (item 13). From the Cambridge
publisher, Deighton Bell, there is the Verses and Translations of Charles Stuart
Calverley (1831-1884) (item 72). WC may have been acquainted with the minor
poet and parodist, who also became a barrister of the Inner Temple but settled at
Christ's College, Cambridge. These imprints are not editions of the ancient
classical authors. Indeed there is a dearth of such editions and classical work in
WC's library. Of the editions printed elsewhere in the United Kingdom and
Ireland, there are presentation copies from provincial writers (see for instance
items 132, 258), and guide books which WC used on his travels whilst gathering
fictional materials (items 8, 202).
Even though editions published on the European Continent make up just under
20% of all the imprints found in the Library, nearly 18% of these, or ninety-five
items, have a Parisian imprint. Paris was WC's favorite city, which he first
visited with his parents in September 1836. He returned to the city frequently
and "developed a lifelong taste for French art, theatre and food" (Gasson 120).
Book hunting and buying were amongst his activities in Paris. There is, perhaps
not unexpectedly, a copy in WC's Library, of Horace Raison's classic Le
Manuel du Gastronomie, published in Paris in 1830. WC's copy has its "cover
loose" (item 406). Collins purchased in Paris his twenty-six volumes of Maurice
Mejan's Recueil des Causes Celebres, published in 1808 (item 349). His
enthusiasm for French Literature, and especially French drama and fiction, is
reflected in the volumes in his library, which teems with the works of often-
obscure eighteenth- and nineteenth-century French dramatists, novelists and
poets.
Neither the auctioneers Puttick and Simpson nor the booksellers, M. L. Bennett,
in their descriptions of WC's collection, did much service to his books published
in Paris. These tend to be lumped togther in multi-volume lots. Puttick and
Simpson lot 180 consists of "French Plays, original editions . . . a parcel" (item
214): these are assumed to have been published in Paris. The description of
auction lot 165 is more helpful: "Repertoire du Theatre Fran9ais 67 vols. cf 12
Introduction 39
mo. Paris 1813." This lot seems to be the sixty-seven-volume set of seventeenth-
and eighteenth-century French drama published in Paris in 1813 (item 415). In
spite of identification difficulties, the Parisian imprints present in the Library
reveal at least four pre-nineteenth-century books. There is a copy of the complete
works of the pornographer Pierre- Joseph Bernard (1710-1775), published in
Paris in 1794 (item 36). The compiler of Bennett's Catalogue places these under
the "Amatory" and somewhat euphemistically refers to them as "several
extremely pretty etchings" [Bennett 4]. There is a two-volume copy of Alain-
Rene Lesage's Le Bachelier de Salamanque published in Paris in 1767 (item
306). A difficult-to-identify title of which only the first volume in "(broken) calf
is present, is Les Nuits Anglaises with the 1770 Paris imprint (item 308).
Another eighteenth-century Parisian imprint is an incomplete copy of the friend
and disciple of Voltaire, Jean-Francis MarmontePs (1723-1799) "slight tales
with a moral intention, agreeably told" (Harvey and Heseltine, 456), Contes
Moraux, published in 1766 (item 339). There is also an undated copy of the
classic work of physiology by Xavier Bichat (1771-1802): his frequently
reprinted Recherches Physiologiques (item 38), first published in Paris in 1800.
Of the ninety-five Parisian imprints in the collection there are a high number of
novels and dramas. Forty are novels and twenty-nine plays. The vast majority of
these are nineteenth-century imprints. Of the major writers, Beaumarchais's
dramas are found in a 1846 edition (item 25). There is a twenty-two-volume
Paris edition, published in 1821, of Denis Diderot's works (item 163). There are
collections of the Dumas' (items 169-172), and a copy of Gustav Flaubert's
Madame Bovary (item 200). There are four separate Victor Hugo titles including
a copy of his three-volume [Le Theatre] published in 1850 (items 267-270). In a
letter written to Pigott, WC observes: "Excepting Falstaff and Dogberry, I think
Moliere a greater humourist than Shakespeare" {Letters, I, 146). A seven-volume
edition of Moliere's CEuvres Completes, published in Paris in 1824, is in the
Library (item 357). There are two George Sand novels (items 427-428), and four
Jules Verne (items 501-504).
There are volumes of French novelists and dramatists who have in the early
twenty-first century fallen into neglect. Some no doubt provided WC and his
contemporaries with creative fodder: "the works of dramatists such as Augier
[(item 15)], Sardou [(item 429)] and Scribe [(items 436-437)] could be picked
off at will by British adapters at no cost to themselves, because for most of the
time theatre managers had their spies out in Paris with instructions to send home
texts of all the latest novelties for instant translation" (Stephens 130). This may
explain the presence of so many popular French best-selling novelists and
theatrical successes in the collection. There are for instance in the collection, the
Scenes et Comedies, published in Paris in 1854 (item 194), of the very popular
Octave Feuillet (1821-1890) whose "blend of gentility and sentimentality
secured for him a large public under the Second Empire" (France 311-12). WC
40 Wilkie Collins's Library
Other works by popular writers include the drama of Henri Meilhac (1831-1897)
(item 348), who collaborated with the librettist and comic dramatist Ludovic
Halevy in smash hits such as Frou-frou (1869). Meilhac and Halevy wrote the
libretto for Bizet's Carmen. There are also copies of the dramas of Anne Honore
Joseph Melesville (1787-1865) (item 350), whose work was adapted for the
London stage by Planche and other dramatists. WC's collection of theatrical
plays published in Paris includes the theatrical pieces of the librettist for the
Comedie Fransais, Pierre Julien Nargeot (b.l799)(item 363). There are four
volumes (item 390) of the plays of the prolific popular dramatist Rene-Charles
Guilbert de Pixerecourt (1773-1844). Less forgotten today is the work of the
prolific dramatist, author of vaudeville, comedies of intrigue and opera libretti,
Eugene Scribe (1791-1861). Two editions of his work are found in WC's
collection. There are his plays, part of six volumes bound up with no titles (item
436), and the second edition, in twenty-four volumes, of his Theatre Completes,
published in Paris between 1834 and 1842 (item 437). According to a 15 March
1886 letter WC wrote to his French collaborator and translator de Heussey:
"Some of my earlier stories had been translated into French . . . and some
illustrious French authors had read them - notably Scribe who charmed me by
his kind encouragement" {Letters, II, 520).
Strange Bed" (1852), and "The Diary of Anne Rodway" (1856), finding its most
famous expression in his Sergeant Richard Cuff of The Moonstone (1868)
(Gasson 48, 44).
Amongst the non-fictional and dramatic volumes with Parisian imprints are two
items containing police memoirs, which WC no doubt drew upon for fictional
use. These consist of two volumes of the ten-volume Memoires de Mr. Claude,
Chef de la Police de Surete sous le Second Empire published 1881-1883 (item
89). There are also six volumes of Jacques Peuchet's Memoires Tirees des
Archives de la Police de Paris pour Servir a I 'Historie de la Morale et de la
Police, depuis Louis XIVjusqu'a nos Jours published in 1838 (item 384). The
volumes were considered so useful for fictional source material that, as WC
wrote to his friend Frederick Lehmann on 25 October 1869 {Letters, II, 326)
"Reade has been here, and has carried off my book about the French Police."
Other works of a similar nature with Parisian imprints, include J. B. B. Eyries
exploration into parapsychology in his two-volume Fantasmagoriana (1812)
(item 190). Also present is a copy (item 203) of the critical writings of Emile
Forgues (1813-1883), the French critic and translator to whom WC dedicated his
Queen of Hearts (1859). This was WC's way of acknowledging his gratitude for
Forgues's sympathetic defense of WC's work published in the La Revue des
Deux Mondes of 1859 (Gasson 62). French editions and translations of WC are
also found amongst Parisian imprints (items 126, 254).
Language Analysis
* Cf. Table III. In fact due to "rounding up" the percentage comes to 100.13%).
Eighty percent of the items in the collection are in English. Of those items in
other languages, two are in German (items 127, 531), and two in Italian (items
42, 128). One each are in Dutch (item 125) and Swedish (item 124). Both
German items, one of the Italian volumes (item 128), and the Dutch and Swedish
imprints are translations of WC's works or a book in German about him (item
531). The other item in Italian is a five-volume edition of Boccaccio's //
Decameron published in Venezia in 1813 (item 42). Another item (item 284) is
in many languages. The presentation copy of Charles Kent's Corona Catholica
"supplied translations of an English epigram into fifty languages; among the
many eminent scholars who supplied the translations were Max Mtiller, who
turned the translation into Sanskrit, Prof. Sayce, who turned it into Assyrian, and
Prince Lucien Bonaparte who rendered it in Basque" {DNB). WC tells his friend
Sebastian Schlesinger in a letter dated 29 December 1883: "My novels are so
popular among the native races of India (who can read English) that they are to
be translated into the Bengali language for the native inhabitants who want to
read me. The Series is to begin with The Woman in White'" {Letters, II, 464).
WC was "always extremely popular" in Russia "and almost all of his works were
translated" (Gasson 149). None of these translations are to be found in the
collection.
are a presentation copy of Goethe's Faust (item 83), and a translation of Lessing
published by Bohn in 1878 (item 310). There are three translations from the
Spanish into English. Two of these are translations of Cervantes's Don Quixote
(items 78,79). The third is William Walton's two-volume translation from the
Spanish documents of Antonio Puigblanch's The Inquisition Unmasked: Being a
Historical Account of that Tremendous Tribunal Founded on Authentic
Documents published in 1816 (item 400). Translations from classical languages
include a presentation copy from the translator, the classical scholar Theodore
William Alois Buckley (1825-1856), of Aeschylus's Tragedies published by
Bohn in 1849 (item 5). There is a two-volume translation in English verse by A.
Hawkins of Claudian (item 90) published in 1817. Sir John Kingston James
(1815-1893), who lived in Tunbridge Wells, the same town as Harriet Collins,
WC's mother, presented him with a copy of his translation of Tasso's Jerusalem
Delivered published in 1865 (item 475).
Subject Analysis
SUBJECT TITLES %
1. English Literature (including Drama) 263 35.0
2. French Literature 146 19.0
3. History 75 10.0
4. Biography/Autobiography/Memoirs 43 6.0
5. Adventures/Travel 42 6.0
6. American Literature 39 5.0
7. Art/Artists/Architecture/Sculpture 25 3.0
8. Religion 18 2.4
9. Music 11 1.5
10. Dictionaries and Reference 10 1.5
11. German Literature 10 1.5
12. Politics 10 1.5
13. Trials 10 1.5
14. All other subjects* 60 8.0
TOTAL 762 101.9%
Knowles, or to take but one other example, James Robinson Planche. Edward
Fitzball (1792-1873) is present through his two-volume theatrical memoirs
published in 1859 and a presentation copy to Charles Dickens of his poetry
published in 1857 (items 199,198). None of his over one hundred fifty dramas,
are in the Library (see Stephens). WC's theatrical contemporaries are
represented by Bulwer-Lytton's Dramatic Works (items 323-324). There is a
personally inscribed association copy of a drama by Thomas Brigstocke, who
was primarily an artist (item 52).
There are three dramatic histories. These include the 1812 edition of David
Erskine Baker's classic Biographica Dramatica (item 18). The dramatist and
manager Alfred Bunn's three-volume The Stage, published in 1840, is a record
of the early- and mid-nineteenth-century theater (item 56). There is also the poet
Robert Southey's copy of John Geneste's Some Account of the English Stage . . .
(item 221). Collections of plays range from Elizabeth Inchbald's two-volume
compendium of British theatrical dramas (item 272), a four-volume London
Stage; A Collection of the Most Reputed Tragedies, Comedies, Operas,
Melodramas, Farces, and Interludes, published in 1824 (item 318), to Isaac
Reed's six-volume 1825 A Select Collection of Old Plays (item 412). There is
also Sir Walter Scott's five-volume selection of tragic, farcical and comic drama
published in 1811, The Modern British Drama (item 433).
By far the largest number of theatrical works in WC's library are primary works.
Copies of English dramatists reveal considerable interest in the drama of the
Restoration and post-Restoration theater. The presence of volumes by women
dramatists complements memoirs and recollections of great actresses. In 1872-
1874 the Edinburgh publishing firm of William Paterson, in collaboration with
the well known London publishing house of H. Sotheran, produced the
Dramatists of the Restoration. Such a publication is indicative of an interest in
the late-seventeenth-century theater in late Victorian England. Volumes in WC's
library from this series include the first (item 146) of four volumes of plays by
John Crowne (1640-1712). There are four of the five volumes of the dramatic
works of Sir William D'Avenant (item 150). Also published by Patterson and
Sotheran, and present in the collection (item 518), are the dramatic works of
John Wilson (1626-1696). Some of the earliest dated copies in the collection are
those of dramatists. These include two eighteenth-century editions of the works
of George Farquhar (1678-1707), one dated 1728 and the other dated 1760 (item
191). A two-volume Works of Mr. Thomas Otway, the Restoration dramatist
(1652-1685) is dated 1712 (item 381). Thomas Southerne's comedy Sir Antony
Love or, The Rambling Lady is present in its first edition, published in 1698
(item 453).
These include copies of four novels: The Book of Snobs, The History of
Pendennis, The Newcomes, and Vanity Fair (items 484-487). Another surprising
absence are copies of the novels of Bulwer-Lytton, who was not adverse from
writing to WC for advice.22 There is one George Eliot work present, an undated
copy of her first published fiction, Scenes of Clerical Life, published by
Blackwood's in two volumes in 1858 (item 179). There is also a copy of WC's
old friend George Henry Lewes's first venture into fictional form, Ranthorpe,
published in 1847 (item 313). On the other hand, there are fourteen volumes of
the works of William Harrison Ainsworth (item 6), an unspecified run of the
novels of Charles Lever (item 311), and sixteen volumes of the works of
Frederick Marryat (item 341). This is accompanied by a copy of his The Pirate
and the Three Cutters (1836) containing Clarkson Stanfield's plates (item 340).
The presence in the collection of two novels by the Manx novelist Sir Thomas
Henry Hall Caine (1853-1931) (items 69-70), reflect his friendship with WC.
This is a product of the last years of WC's life, and is reflected in a lengthy letter
WC wrote Caine upon reading Caine's three-volume The Shadow of a Crime
{Letters, II, 553-554) (item 68). Another contemporary and friend of WC, the
prolific novelist Walter Besant (1836-1901), is represented in the collection by a
single novel, the three-volume Herr Paulus, published in 1888 (item 37). Both
Besant and WC were active in protecting authors' rights, and both had
connections with A. P. Watt. It was at WC's suggestion that Watt approached
Besant with the suggestion that Besant should complete the novel WC was too ill
to complete, the posthumously published Blind Love (1889-1890) (Gasson 18).
Already noted is the remarkable run of the works of the author WC revered
above all others, Sir Walter Scott. The four Scott items encompass his
Miscellaneous Prose Works (item 432), Scott's five-volume edition of The
Modern British Drama (item 433), twelve volumes of his poetry (item 434), and
the forty-eight-volume 1859 edition of the Waverley Novels (item 435). There
are ten volumes of Lockhart's life of his father-in-law, published in 1848 (item
317). Of other nineteenth-century poets and non-fiction prose writers, there is a
single work by Tennyson, a copy of Locksley Hall Sixty Years After (item 483).
There are no Thomas Carlyle, John Ruskin, William Morris, or Dante Gabriel
Rossetti volumes in the collection. There are three volumes only of the sixteen-
volume works of Thomas De Quincey (1785-1859), published in Edinburgh
from 1862-1871 (item 153). Thomas Babington Macaulay is found in a copy of
his Critical and Historical Essays (item 326). William Hazlitt is present in a
four-volume edition of his biography of Napoleon (item 251). There is, however,
an eight-volume edition of one of WC's favorite poets, George Crabbe (item
141). In a 5 August 1878 letter to William Winter, Collins writes of his "delight
in Byron and Scott - and more extraordinarily still, that I am a frequent reader
even of Crabbe!" {Letters, II, 413). There are three Byron items in his collection.
There is an [1842] Complete Works with Life, a single-volume Life, Letters and
Journals published in 1838 and an eight-volume Poetical Works published in
1857 (items 65-67). In addition, WC possessed a copy of Thomas Medwin's
memoirs of Byron published in 1824, his Journal of the Conversations of Lord
Byron Noted during a Residence with His Lordship at Pisa, in the Years 1821
and 1822 (item 347).
No volumes of Marvell are present, but there is Dryden. He is found in the four-
volume Poetical Works, with Life of the Author, published in 1832-1833 as part
of the Aldine edition of the British poets by Pickering (item 168). There is a
copy of a three-volume undated Poetical Works of Alexander Pope, and the
nine-volume Warton edition of Pope's Works published in 1797 (items 394-
395). The Pickering fifty-volume Aldine edition of the British poets is further
represented by its first volume, a copy of the poetry of WC's namesake, the
eighteenth-century poet William Collins (1721-1759) (item 96). Thomas Gray is
present in an 1821 edition of his poetry with plates by Richard Westall (1765-
1836), the historical and genre painter, etcher and mezzotint engraver (item
236). There are three Goldsmith items: a four-volume Miscellaneous Works
published in 1837, edited by Sir James Prior (item 231); a two-volume 1786
copy of his Poetical and Dramatic Works (item 232); and an 1803 copy of The
Vicar ofWakefield (item 233). Perhaps a surprising presence in the collection is
that of the ballad writer and satirist, Matthew Prior (1664-1721). A copy of his
two-volume Poems on Several Occasions, published in 1766, is found in the
collection (item 397). Prior imitated Samuel Butler's satirical Hudibras, found in
WC's library in an 1836 edition (item 62). There is also the eighth edition
published in 1676 of Robert Burton's The Anatomy of Melancholy (item 61).
Somewhat less of a surprise is the presence of the twenty-one-volume 1766-1767
edition of The Works of Jonathan Swift, with Life and Notes by John
Hawkesworth (item 474). In a 16 October 1853 letter to his mother, WC shows
his familiarity with Swift by commenting on the St. Peters mechanical cock in
Rome and its "Brobdingnag" propensities {Letters, I, 99).
50 Wilkie Collins's Library
French Literature
One hundred forty-six titles, 19% of the titles, belong to this subject
categorization. Sixty-three of these titles are associated with the French theater.
Most of these are primary texts of plays from the nineteenth-century French
theater or earlier. Publication place and date analysis reveal that most of these
are Parisian nineteenth-century imprints. They range from the dramas and
comedies of Alexandre Dumas fils (items 169-170) and the dramas of Victor
Hugo (item 270) to the prolific dramatic output of Eugene Scribe (1791-1861)
producer of vaudeville comedies, opera libretti and comedies of intrigue (items
436-437). Less well-known dramatists are represented, for instance, by the
presence of the works of the Guilbert de Pixerecourt (1773-1844). Known as the
"Corneille of the Boulevards", he was prolific, producing more than a hundred
dramas "where genres were mixed and violence and the romanesque abounded."
Most of his plays (item 390) "were produced in the theatres des boulevards (the
secondary theatres) in Paris" (Dolbow 248; Harvey and Heseltine 558). These
were the theatres attended by WC during his frequent visits to Paris.
The range of French fiction, and to a lesser extent poetry, in the Library reveals
an interest in popular as opposed to classic and high-brow literature. There are,
as has been observed, very thorough runs of Balzac (item 19), Victor Hugo
(items 267-270), and Jules Verne (items 501-504). There are also writers who, at
the start of the twenty-first century, are no longer fashionable. The majority are
nineteenth-century writers. To take but two instances, WC has three novels in his
collection (items 375-377) by Georges Ohnet (1848-1918). His novels are
described in The Oxford Companion to French Literature "as snobbishly
Introduction 51
sentimental . . . which made him the best seller of the 19 century and aroused
the disgusted wit of critics" (527). Charles Pigault-Lebrun (1753-1835) was the
author of popular and fashionable "lively, licentious novels." He was "the
favourite reading of old Miss Crawley in Thackeray's Vanity Fair" {Oxford
Companion, 557). WC's collection has a copy of his two-volume fictional
L 'Enfant du Carnival, published in Paris in 1815 (item 387).
French verse is less evident than theatrical and fictional work. There are a
greater number of popular low-brow works rather than serious poetry. An
example is the CEuvres Completes, published in two volumes in Paris in 1858
(item 34), of Pierre-Jean de Beranger (1780-1857). A "popular and national
songwriter who sang the praises of Napoleon and the common man," he "has
been called the greatest French songwriter ever" (Dolbow 26). It is hardly
surprising for a hedonist such as WC that his collection should contain erotic and
pornographic etchings and verse, found for instance in the works of Pierre-
Joseph Bernard (1710-1775) (item 36). However, there is not extant in his
collection poetry by Gerard de Nerval (1808-1855), Charles Nodier (1780-
1844), Alfred de Vigny (1797-1863) or, to take one other instance, Paul Verlaine
(1844-1896).
American Literature
Thirty-nine titles, five percent of the total collection, are represented by this
category. Many of the books are a legacy of WC's 1873-1874 North American
tour. The contacts he made during the tour are reflected, as has been noted, in
the presence of inscribed copies from, for instance, the diplomat John Bigelow
(item 210), the poet, physician and humourist, Oliver Wendell Holmes (item
263), the theater critic William Winter (item 522), and the South Carolina poet
Paul Hamilton Hayne (item 250). Other items of interest are a thirty-one-volume
set of the New York Household edition of the novels of James Fenimore Cooper
(1789-1851) (item 133). The American novelist is included in a 3 May 1884
letter to Paul Hamilton Hayne, with Scott and Balzac, as amongst WC's "three
Kings of Fiction" {Letters, II, 467). According to Gasson, "Cooper is a likely
influence on the character of Old Mat" in WC's early novel Hide and Seek
(Gasson, 42). Mat Marksman is an eccentric wandering character scalped by the
native Americans.
There is an 1877 copy of his best selling novel Two Years before the Mast (item
149), first published in 1840. WC, in the last of three known surviving lengthy
letters of his to Dana, a friend of his father, dated 17 June 1850, observes: "I
have read 'Two Years before the Mast', and read it with great delight - it is a
most entertaining and most original book; and is deservedly popular in England,
among all classes of readers" {Letters, I, 62).
Affinities between WC's works and the stories of Edgar Allen Poe (1809-1849)
have not gone unnoticed. Catherine Peters observes that in the fourth tale in the
extra Christmas number of Charles Dickens's Household Words, supplied by
WC, '"The Lawyer's story of A Stolen Letter' was perhaps suggested by Poe's
story 'The Purloined Letter.' The stories have similar titles, and both have a self-
satisfied narrator, an obvious hiding place and a clever boy" (145). Only one Poe
title has survived in WC's library, a copy of Baudelaire's [1872] edition of Poe's
Works (item 392). A note in the copy in WC's hand - "Stories by Poe not
included in the 'Complete collection'" - suggests that he possessed other
editions of Poe.
With the exception of foreign language translations into Danish, Dutch, French,
German, and Italian of WC's own works (items 124-128), and his collection of
French fiction and drama, there is a lack of materials not in English. This is in
contrast with items in the libraries of contemporaries of WC, such as George
Eliot and George Henry Lewes. In their collection, now at Dr. Williams's
Library, London, 24.5% of the titles are in German, nearly 5% in French, just
under 5% in Latin, and nearly 4% in Italian. There are also items in Greek,
Spanish, and Hebrew.23
This is not the pattern in WC's Library. There are only ten titles representing
German literature in the collection. None are in German. All are translations into
English. The one item in German is a copy of Ernst von Wolzogen's study of
WC's life and critical assessment of his writings, Wilkie Collins, ein
Biographisch-Kritischer Versuch, published in Leipzig in 1885 (item 531).
There is no evidence that this is a presentation copy from the author to the
Introduction 53
The riches of classical literature are scantily represented in the collection. The
presence of a translation of Aeschylus's Tragedies, published by Bohn in 1849
(item 5), is probably due to the fact that it is a presentation copy. The translator,
the classical scholar Theodore William Alois Buckley (1825-1856), was also a
contributor to Household Words and other journals. A. Hawkins's translation of
the political satirical poems of Claudian, published in 1817 (item 90), is likely to
have been drawn upon by WC for background material for his first published
novel, Antonina; or The Fall of Rome. A Romance of the Fifth Century,
published in 1850.
WC met the great Danish writer Hans Christian Andersen at Gad's Hill during
his 11 June to 15 July 1857 stay with Charles Dickens (Dickens, Letters, VIII,
426 and n. 2). Anna S. Bushby's translation of Anderson's To Be, Or Not to Bel
was published by the firm of Bentley in early June 1857 and dedicated to
Dickens. A copy is now in the collection (item 10). From Puttick and Simpson's
Catalogue description - "trans, by Bushby presentation copy from the author to
Wilkie Collins" - it is not entirely clear whether the book (lot 149), is from the
translator Bushby or its Danish author.
Literature written in English, published in what were then colonies, receive some
representation. There is a copy of the first book edition published in Melbourne
in 1874 of Marcus Clarke's (1846-1881) novel concerning transportation,
inheritance, convict life and murder. His Natural Life (item 88) was
subsequently published in London in three volumes by Bentley in 1875. WC
owned an author's presentation copy of Robert Dudley Adams (1829-1912), the
Australian lawyer and poet's, Song of the Stars and Other Poems, published in
Sydney in 1882 under the pseudonym of "Alpha Crucis" (item 144). There are
two other Melbourne imprints. Both are by Garnet Walch (1843-1913). One is a
copy of his Head over Heels. A Christmas Book of Fun and Fancy, published in
1874. The other is a presentation copy to WC from Walch of his A Little Tin
Plate, published in Melbourne in 1881 (items 506, 507). Another emerging
literature in English is represented by the presence of Nell Gwynne's Acorn
Leaves: A Series of Canadian Tales, published in Toronto in 1873 (item 239).
beauty of virtue and deformity of vice" and in its depiction of the complexity of
human psychology in its "mixture . . . of good and evil in the same character",
except in extreme instances.24 Titles in WC's collection range in period, subject
and national focus. There are books on French history, Irish life, Scottish history,
English political and court history, and works recounting North American
frontier history.
French history focuses upon Napoleon and the French Revolutionary period.
Translations into English are prominent. They range from Laure Junot duchesse
d'Abrantes's Memoirs of [Napoleon] and His Court and Family, published by
Bentley in 1836 (item 2), to William Hazlitt's detailed four-volume biography of
Napoleon published in 1830 (item 251). Hazlitt's Life of Napoleon praises
Napoleon, and condemns England's role in destroying liberty in France. Hazlitt
is critical of the national hero - Wellington. There are two other biographies of
Napoleon in WC's collection. One is a translation into English of Louis Antoine
Fauvelet Bourrienne's three-volume Life, published in 1831 (item 49). The other
is the four-volume French Pierre Lanfrey biography, published in Paris in 1869
(item 294). Two Napoleonic items of interest are the French memoirs by Las
Cases, focusing upon Napoleon's imprisonment on St. Helena (item 298), and an
English translation of Laurent's History of Napoleon (item 300). Both items are
replete with illustrations. Especially interesting is Laurent's volume, described in
M.L. Bennett's Catalogue as "from the French of l'Ardeche with 500
illustrations after Horace Vernet and original portraits" (Bennett 107). In a
lengthy letter to his mother dated 6 October 1845, WC praised Horace Vernet's
work {Letters, I, 35). Also present in the collection is a copy of the seventh
edition of the two-volume account of Napoleon's life in exile, published in 1827
(item 379), by Barry Edward O' Meara (1786-1836), who was close to the fallen
Emperor on St. Helena. In addition, there is a copy of the frequently reprinted
Sir William Francis Patrick Napier's (1785-1860), History of the War in the
Peninsula and in the South of France, from the Year 1807 to the Year 1814. The
collection has the three-volume 1882 edition (item 362) of this classic account of
the Peninsula wars, first published in six volumes between 1828 and 1840.
Pre-revolutionary France finds its place amongst the books with a copy of
Latude's French memoirs of his thirty-five year incarceration (1749-1784) for
56 Wilkie Collins's Library
English historical memoirs, biography and autobiography are not confined to one
historical period or historical personality. There is little on Cromwell or the
period of the English Civil Wars. The exceptions are copies of John Forster's
The Debates on the Grand Remonstrance, November and December, 1641. With
an Introductory Essay on English Freedom under Plantagenet and Tudor
Sovereigns (item 204), and his two-volume biography of Sir John Eliot (item
207). The former is a presentation copy from the author to WC. The latter is a
biography of the Parliamentarian Sir John Eliot (1592-1632), who defied Charles
I, and opposed Royal excesses against Parliamentary privileges.
There are three basic historical reference tools present. The first of these is the
ninth revised edition of Haydn's A Dictionary of Dates Relating to All Ages and
Nations (item 249), which is not confined to British history. The second is a
copy of Hatherly's A New Genealogical Scale of the Sovereigns of England with
Copious Tables and Explanatory Remarks (item 248). Its 1889 publication date
suggests that WC's copy was received from the publishers or the author, and was
not a reference book he used over a period of time. The third reference work
consists of ninety-five volumes of Dodsley's Annual Register (item 165). This is
a run from the first volume published in 1758 through to 1851, and was useful
for basic factual information on politics, literature, biography, statistics and
commerce.
Other materials range from books on social life and customs, poor laws, labor
history and local history. There are copies of William Grant Sewell's analysis of
labor in the West Indies, published in 1862 (item 440), and the account by
Thomas Wright, a journeyman engineer, of working-class habits and customs,
published in 1867 (item 536). Wright's work was praised by Dickens's All the
Year Round, which observed that "the working man remains a study - in some
respects, too, a problem - in great part a difficulty - in much a contradiction -
but, on the whole, a national hope and a national pride."26 There are studies of
the poor laws and their operation (item 383), and the autobiography of the
Chartist working-class leader William Lovett (1800-1877) (item 321). In his
great Progress and Poverty (item 222), first published in 1884, Henry George
(1839-1897) attributes poverty to rent and puts forward a land tax as the solution
to social ills. George's strictures on rent and its ills might well have struck a
sympathetic chord with WC. In the autumn of his life, in February 1888, he was
forced to move house owing to a rapacious landlord, "an enormously rich
Introduction 57
nobleman named Lord Portman" (WC to de Heussey, 12 July 1888: Letters, II,
559).
Works which have taken on a status as historical classics are not under-
represented. There is a twelve-volume Gibbon, Decline and Fall of the Roman
Empire, published in 1813. This is probably a re-issue of the twelve-volume
edition published by Strahan in London, 1791-1792 (item 225). Henry Hallam's
account of the middle ages, View of the State of Europe during the Middle Ages,
published in 1841, is present (item 246). There is an undated single-volume
edition of the American historian John Lothrop Motley's (1814-1877) The Rise
of the Dutch Republic (item 360). Another American historian, William Hickling
Prescott (1796-1859), is found in a three-volume 1849 edition of his classic
History of the Reign of Ferdinand and Isabella, the Catholic (item 396). Other
classic nineteenth-century histories are E. Foster's English translation in three
volumes of Leopold von Ranke's History of the Popes, published in 1847 (item
407), and Andrew Steinmetz's three-volume History of the Jesuits, published a
year later (item 458).
Other volumes in the collection attest to a fascination with adventure and travel
ranging from the Americas to the Orient. There are three works on Mexico. Two
of these focus on the Yucatan region. Both are written by John Lloyd Stephens
(1805-1852), born in New Jersey, who left his legal practice to travel. He was
sent by President Van Buren on intelligence missions to Central America. These
missions formed the foundation for his accounts of the jungle, and the remnants
Introduction 59
Other copies attest to WC's interest in the opening up of the Northern Canadian
territories. There is a copy, replete with illustrations and maps, of Sir William
Francis Butler's account, published by Sampson Low, Marston, Low and Searle
- the publishers of WC's The Woman in White - in [1872], of his adventures and
travels in the American North West, under the title The Great Lone Land (item
64). In this work, published in 1872 and reaching a fourth edition but a year
later, Butler relates his special mission. This was, in the words of the DNB
obituary of Butler, "to investigate the situation in Saskatchewan and report on
the need for troops, the Indians, and the fur trade. Striking the north
Saskatchewan at Carlton, he followed it up to the base of the Rocky Mountains,
and then descended it, reaching Fort Garry on 20 Feb. 1871, after a winter
journey of 2,700 miles."29 To take but one other example of their owner's
interests, WC possessed the six-volume-in-three facsimile reprint, published in
Quebec in 1870, of Charles Honore Laverdiere's (1826-1873) edition, published
under the title CEuvres de Champlain, of the Jesuit explorer Samuel de
60 Wilkie Collins's Library
Exploration and adventures in other parts of the world are reflected in books on
the Antipodes and the Orient. Present is the account by John Lort Stokes (1812-
1885) of his discovery and exploration of the Australian hinterland and coast,
found in his two-volume, Discoveries in Australia, with an Account of the
Coasts and Rivers Explored and Surveyed During the Voyage of the Beagle,
1837-1843, published in 1846 and illustrated with maps and plates (item 466).
Stokes sailed with the Beagle during the period Darwin was on board. He served
on the ship for a period of eighteen years and commanded it from March 1841.
His two volumes are a record of his Beagle voyages {DNB, 28. 1287). Darwin's
writings are not found in WC's library. There is a copy of the pseudonymous
volume published under the name "Topchi" in St. Petersbourg in the year before
WC's death, A Trovers L'Orient et L'Occident. The title page has the subtitle
"Recit de Huit Annees de Voyages en Espagne, Portugal, Grece, Montenegro,
Turquie," and other areas (item 494).
Given WC's family connections with art and artists, it is perhaps surprising that
only twenty-five titles, 3% of his collection, represent these subject areas.
Perhaps there were more books relating to art and artists, architecture and
sculpture in his collection. It is tempting to speculate that his mother retained
books which had personal associations with WC's father, William Collins (1788-
1847), member of the Royal Academy and friend of many fellow artists. Further,
WC's brother, the painter Charles Allston Collins (1818-1873), would have had
as equal a claim as his brother to possess books once owned by their father.
Indeed, in an 11 May 1867 letter to his mother, WC related how he and his
brother Charles "have tossed" for his father's pictures {Letters, II, 285).
Of the books remaining in his collection at the time of his death, there are
biographies, plate books, and lithographs. There are two prominent biographies
of artists known to WC's father. There is Anna Elizabeth Bray's Life of Thomas
Stothard: With Personal Reminiscences, published in 1851 (item 51). Thomas
Stothard, R.A. (1755-1834), was a popular illustrator, historical and portrait
painter.30 The other biography is by his grandfather William Collins Senior
(1740-1812), his three-volume Memoirs of a Picture (item 97). This semi-
fictional, partly-biographical depiction of his friend George Morland (1763-
1804) became the source for WC's early novel A Rogue's Life. According to
Gasson, William Collins's Memoirs of a Painter gives an "account of faking and
shady dealings in the art world together with the improvident and scandalous life
of Morland" (32).31 In his two-volume The Life of William Collins, Esq. RA. By
His Son, published in 1848, WC refers to his grandfather's Poem on the Slave
Introduction 61
Other Subjects
Massett (1820-1898), the American lyricist and composer of popular songs (item
344).
Amongst WC's childhood books may have been the two-volume Wonders of the
Universe with its subtitle Curiosities of Nature and Art: Including Memoirs and
Anecdotes of Wonderful and Eccentric Characters of Every Age and Nation,
published in 1827 (item 532). Other encyclopedias, dictionaries and reference
works he probably obtained for writing purposes. There is a ten-volume
Chambers' Encyclopedia, published in 1876 (item 81), the 1860 ninth revised
edition by Benjamin Vincent of Haydn's classic Dictionary of Dates (item 249),
and an 1849 Webster's American Dictionary of the English Language (item
512).
The six guide books in the Library focus upon areas of the United Kingdom and
were used by WC whilst writing his novels. For instance, he visited, with his
companion Caroline Graves, in August 1863, the Isle of Man in order to gain
material for his novel Armadale. This visit explains the presence in his Library
of a copy of Edward Forbes's Illustrated Guide and Visitor's Companion
through the Isle of Wight (item 202). Crucial passages of No Name (1862) are
set around Aldborough on the East Anglia coast. This probably explains the
presence in WC's Library of a copy of Mackenzie Edward Charles Walcott's
The East Coast of England from the Thames to the Tweed, Descriptive of
Natural Scenery, Historical, Archaeological, and Legendary (1861) (item 508).
In WC's Library there are eighteen religious titles. In a series of letters to Pigott,
stimulated by a controversy in The Leader, WC defended the declaration of the
64 Wilkie Collins's Library
Harriet Collins's copy of Jeremy Taylor's Holy Living and Dying, in an 1824
edition (item 482), reflects his parents' Protestant Tractarianism. There is a copy
of James Kershaw's The Grand Extensive Plan of Human Redemption published
in Louth in Scotland in 1797 (item 286). There is a curious absence of the family
Bible and books indicating that they belonged to WC's religious father William
Collins. Devotional works include a copy of Edward Bouverie Pusey's edition of
the eleventh-century Saint Anselm, Archbishop of Canterbury's Meditations and
Prayers to the Trinity, published in Oxford in 1856 (item 13). There is a third
edition of James A. Begg's Scriptural Evidence of the Redeemer's Speedy
Personal Return, 1831, with Harriet Collins's signature on the fly-leaf (item 30).
A copy of Walter Farquhar Hook's Church Dictionary, 1843, also contains
Harriet Collins's signature, this time on the title page (item 266). There are
copies, too, of Thomas Nolan's six-penny The Vicarious Sacrifice of Christ,
published in 1860 (item 370), and of the late-sixteenth- and early-seventeenth-
century Christian divine Christopher Sutton's Disce Vivere: Learn to Live with
Memoir of the Author in an 1847 edition (item 472).
Magnetism (item 414) was probably used for his letters on "experiments in
hypnotism and clairvoyance" published in The Leader (Peters 109-110).
CONCLUSION
The books belonging to WC listed in the Puttick and Simpson January 20, 1890
auction sale catalogue, and in the "Caxton Head" M. L. Bennett Bookseller's
catalogue from the same year, reveal eclectic taste. They contain books used for
research for WC's creative endeavors, but are by no means the only sources of
information for his work. As his notes for The Moonstone, now at Princeton
University Library, reveal, he took notes from various books. He noted from, for
instance, the amateur gem collector Charles William King's The Natural History
of Precious Stones and Gems (1865).38 At his London club, the Athenaeum, WC
took notes from the eighth edition of the Encyclopedia Britannica. He read the
two-volume edition of Theodore Hook's The Life of General Sir David Baird,
published in 1832, and he read J. Talboys Wheeler's The History of India from
the Earliest Ages (1867). None of these items are recorded in either the Puttick
and Simpson or Bennett catalogues. WC also consulted articles in Notes and
Queries. An unbound volume ten of this journal is recorded as being amongst his
books after his death. However the issue (item 373) dates from 1872 - four years
after the publication of The Moonstone.
WC's library contains a singular lack of antiquarian, rare items, finely printed
books or manuscripts. There is an overwhelming preponderance of nineteenth-
century materials, and a good many inscribed presentation copies attesting to
66 Wilkie Collins's Library
their owner's social affability. WC was not, if the evidence presented here is
reliable, a bibliomaniac. He did haunt the Parisian bookstalls and used the books
he owned for creative purposes. Some books he inherited from his family. Some
he received as copies from publishers. He was, after all, a publisher's reader -
hence the presence of books by Rider Haggard. These were gifts from his agent
Watt. His collection of works by Sir Walter Scott, Balzac, and James Fenimore
Cooper provide an insight into his tastes and inspiration. WC was a book man.
He lived amongst books, and he wrote to maintain himself and more than one
family. The surviving volumes in his collection reveal much about the man, the
writer, his friendships, his associations, and the sources for his creative
inspiration. They also provide an insight into a now-vanished world of book-
collecting and the late Victorian dispersing of the books of a writer regarded
amongst the pantheon of nineteenth-century English writers.
9
Arthur and Janet Ing Freeman, Anatomy of an Auction. London: The Collector
Limited, 1990. 82.
10
Information from David Quentin. For William Barclay Squire, book collector
and music librarian at the British Museum, see A. Hyatt King, "William Barclay
Squire, 1855-1927," The Library, Fifth Series, 12 (March 1957), 1-10. I have
been unable to locate the whereabouts of Squire's library. His books don't
appear to be in the British Library collections.
Introduction 67
11
See Gasson, 63, and Graham Law, Serializing Fiction in the Victorian Press.
Basingstoke, Hampshire: Palgrave, 2000. 104, 260.
12
A. and J. I. Freeman, Anatomy of an Auction, 91.
13
Information from David Quentin of Bernard Quaritch.
14
Personal communication, 5 November 1999.
15
See also S. Lonoff, "Sex, Sense, and Nonsense: The Story of the Collins-Lear
Friendship," in Nelson Smith and R. C. Terry, ed. Wilkie Collins to the
Forefront: Some Reassessments. New York: AMS Press, 1995. 37-51.
16
See C.K. Hyder, "Wilkie Collins and The Woman in White," PMLA, 54
(1939), 297-303, Appendix C: "The Main Source of The Woman in White," in
The Woman in White, ed., H. P. Sucksmith. Oxford: Oxford University Press,
1971. 599-600, and L. Nayder, Wilkie Collins. New York: Twayne, 1997. 74-75.
17
A Collection of Hayne Letters, ed. D. M. McKeithan. Austin, Texas:
University of Texas Press, 1944: reprinted Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press,
1944. xv-xvi.
18
An 1886 copy of Tennyson's Locksley Hall Sixty Years After is the only
Tennyson present amongst WC's books (item 483).
19
See John M. Kleeberg, "Phillips, Henry, Jr." American National Biography.
Vol. 17. Ed., John A. Garraty and Mark C. Carnes. New York: Oxford
University Press, 1999. 446-47.
20
For an account of Wilkie Collins's relationship with Watt see G. Law,
Serializing Fiction. 103-09.
21
See The Moonstone, ed. J. Sutherland. Oxford: World's Classics, 1999. 386-
87. For Collins's reading of De Quincey and Elliotson, see 497-98.
22
See Bulwer's letter of 22 October 1870, now at the Hertfordshire Record
Office.
23
See William Baker, The George Eliot-George Henry Lewes Library: An
Annotated Catalogue of Their Books at Dr. Williams's Library. London:
Garland Publishing, 1977. xxviii.
68 Wilkie Collins's Library
24
Frederick G. Ribble and Anne G. Ribble, Fielding's Library: An Annotated
Catalogue. Charlottesville: Bibliographical Society of the University of Virginia,
1996. xx.
25
For Louvret de Couvray, see Dolbow, 182.
26
8 June 1867: cited Asa Briggs, The Age of Improvement. London: Longmans,
1963. 522.
27
Collins to Mary Anderson, 14 April 1885: Anderson, A Few Memoirs. New
York: Harper and Brothers, 1896. 144-45.
28
The Dictionary of Art. Vol 6. London: Macmillan, 1996. 87.
29
DNB Supplement 1901-1911. London: Oxford University Press, 1912. 287.
30
See Dictionary of Art, 29. 732-33.
31
For Morland, see ibid., 22. 122-124; DNB, XIII. 961-64.
32
See DNB, XIX. 769-770, and Dickens, Letters, vol. IX. 61, n. 3.
33
See Julie F. Codell, "Serialized Artists' Biographies: A Culture Industry in
Late Victorian Britain," in Book History, 3 (2000), 94-124. For Redford, see The
George Eliot Letters. Vol. 3. Ed. Gordon S. Haight. New Haven: Yale
University Press, 1954. 178, n. 7.
34
For Cooke, see Ian Mackenzie, British Prints Dictionary and Price Guide.
Woodbridge: Suffolk: Antique Collectors' Club, 1998. 126. For Stanfield, see
Dictionary of Art, 29. 535-36.
35
For Lewis, see Mackenzie, 233-34.
36
Unpublished manuscript now at the Armstrong Browning Library, Baylor
University: cited Allan W. Atlas, "Wilkie Collins on Music and Musicians,"
Journal of the Royal Musical Association, 124 (1999). 255.
37
See Letters, I, xxix, 130-131, and cf. K. Lawrence, "The Religion of Wilkie
Collins: Three Unpublished Documents," Huntington Library Quarterly, 52
(1989). 389-402.
38
See J. Sutherland, "Explanatory Notes" to The Moonstone. Oxford: Oxford
University Press, 1999. 468-69, [xxx]-xxxi, and William M. Burgan, "Masonic
Symbolism," in Smith Terry, 101-48.
Reconstruction of
Wilkie Collins's Library
WC died on 23 September 1889. There were four main subsequent auctions of
his possessions:
1. Catalogue of the Sale of the Furniture of the Late Wilkie Collins, Walter
Holcombe, 24 October 1889.
Puttick and Simpson's 20 January 1890 auction of the "Library of the Late
Wilkie Collins, Esq." is arranged by lots and sizes. Lots one to two hundred
thirty-one are "Octavo et infra." Lots two hundred thirty-two to thirty-eight are
"Quarto," and lots two hundred thirty-nine to two hundred forty-six, are "Foli."
The lots contain either individual or mixed volumes. Authors, titles, number of
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 71
volumes, and dates of publication are given. Sometimes binding details and other
details are given. For instance lot one reads:
"1 Annual Register from the commencement in 1758 to 1851 including Index
1758 to 1819, together 95 vols. hf cf {some broken) 1758-1851."
The marked-up copy, now in the possession of William and Faith Clarke, also
contains the price realized for the item at the auction and the name of the
purchaser. The first lot was bought for one shilling and six pence by "Bennett."
The seventh lot was purchased by "Withers" for fourteen shillings.
Puttick and Simpson auction lot one becomes in the M. L. Bennett Catalogue:
The entry begins with a serial number (e.g., 165), based on the alphabetical place
of entry in the reconstruction. This number is followed by the last name of the
author and first name. This is followed by a short-title description, in italics, with
capitalization retained where necessary. The number of volumes are followed by
the place and date of publication. Where this is not given in either the Puttick
and Simpson or Bennett data, or has not been ascertained from available
information, the date/s are placed in [ ] brackets. On a separate line following
the serial number assigned the entry, the author, title, number of volumes (if
more than one), place of publication and date of publication, and information
from either the Puttick and Simpson or Bennett sources relating to book size and
binding states, such as "8vo half calf, (some broken)", details of the original
auction lot number and purchaser, are found. Item 165 was lot one in Puttick and
Simpson's auction, so this becomes "{1}". Its purchaser was Bennett. This fact
is recorded by "[17]". This indicates that the item "17" in the Bennett Catalogue
is the Annual Register. Information underneath such basic data contains
information of interest. In this instance the price Bennett purchased the book for,
and the price he attempted to sell it for, and a quotation from the Bennett
description. In other cases, where deemed relevant, there are dates and
information on the author of the item, citation from WC's letters if he refers to
the author or title, including whenever possible information on the present
location, or subsequent history of the ownership of WC's copy.
In instances where the purchaser is not Bennett, the name of the buyer appears in
brackets before Puttick and Simpson's auction lot number. Thus, to take one
instance, Puttick and Simpson lot 7 contains "Beethoven's Life, edited by
Moscheles port. 2 vols. 1841". The purchaser of the nine vols in this lot 7 was
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 73
RECONSTRUCTION
2. Abrantes, Laure Junot, duchesse d'. Memoirs of [Napoleon] and His Court
and Family. 2 vols. London, 1836.
Half morocco "gilt edges, 16 fine Portraits on steel"
{66} [108]
Aldine Poets.
See under Collins, William (item 96) and Dryden, John (item 168).
9. American Magazines.
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 75
"various nos. a parcel" See also The Forum (item 209), Harper's (item
247), and Scribner 's (item 438).
[Bennett] {185}
20. Bancroft, George. A History of the United States. 1 vols. Boston 1851-
1861.
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 77
hideous - and night too, up to 10 o'clock. Nobody complains but me" (24
June \SS5: Letters, 11, 4S0).
28. Begg, Alexander. Creation of Manitoba; or, A History of the Red River
Troubles. Toronto, 1871.
"ports."
{30} [7]
29. Begg, Alexander. i(Dot It Down ": A Story of Life in the North West.
Toronto, 1871.
"cr. 8 vo, cl."
[Bennett] [8]
Bennett offered [7] and [8] separately for "2/6 or with preceding 4/-".
Both works published by Hunter Rose, WC's Toronto publishers. See
Gasson 82.
31. Behn, Aphra (Mrs.). The Plays, Histories, and Novels of the Ingenious
Mrs. Aphra Behn with Life and Memoirs. Edited by R. H. Shepherd. 6
vols. 1871.
"Large Paper, bd uncut. Pearson." Reprinted from the plays of 1724 and
the novels of 1725.
[Maggs] {106}.
Mrs. Aphra Behn (1640-1689), regarded as the first professionally writing
English woman. She produced at least eighteen plays and fifteen "novels."
Forced to write for bread to survive, her themes are those of unwilling
marriages, "financial malpractice, and women (either victimized or
triumphantly reversing the sexual balance of power)" (V. Blain, P.
Clements, I. Grundy, The Feminist Companion to Literature in English,
1990,78).
32. Bellamy, George Anne. An Apology for the Life of George Anne Bellamy,
Late ofCovent-Garden Theatre. 3 vols. Dublin, 1785.
"Bellamy's Life vols. 1-3 (stained)"
[F. Hurt] {123}
George Anne Bellamy (1731-1788), actress: "her later years were
burdened with suffering and debt" {DNB).
33. Bentley Ballads: Containing the Choice Ballads, Songs & Poems
Contributed to "Bentley's Miscellany." 1861.
"engraved title by G. Cruikshank, signature of Wilkie Collins 1861, on
title cl."
[Woolley] {100}
34. Beranger, Pierre Jean de. CEuvres Completes. 2 vols. Paris, 1858.
"port. 2 vols. hf. cf."
[deCoverley] {198}
Pierre Jean de Beranger (1780-1857), songwriter who celebrated
Napoleon Bonaparte.
45. Boswell, James. Journal of a Tour to the Hebrides. 6th ed. 1813.
"enlarged, 8vo, half calf, gilt Portrait of Boswell after Reynolds and vig."
{51} [22]
46. Boswell, James. The Life of Samuel Johnson. 7th ed. 5 vols. 1811.
"sm. 8vo, hf. old calf. 'W. Collins' on fly leaf in pencil."
{168} [90]
In a letter to Robert du Pontavice de Heussey, WC writes: "I most
sincerely envy you a first reading of Boswell's wonderful book - the
greatest biographical work that has ever been written. I am constantly
dipping into it, to this day" (14 February 1887: Letters, II, 533).
See also under Croker, John Wilson (item 145), Johnson, Samuel (items
280-281).
52. Brigstocke, Thomas. The Mutual Scourges; or, France and Her
Neighbours. An Historical Drama in Four Acts. 1871.
"Thin cr. 8vo., cloth, Present, copy with Author's Inscription 1871, and
MS corrections by Collins, on back of title in pencil."
{98} [23]
Thomas Brigstocke (1809-1881), portrait painter. "He spent eight years in
Paris and Italy, and made some copies from pictures by the old masters,
among them one of Raphael's 'Transfiguration' in the Vatican, which, on
the recommendation of W. Collins, R.A., was purchased for Christ
Church, Albany Street, Regent's Park" {DNB).
54. Brown, Oliver Madox. The Dwale Bluth, Hebditch's Legacy, and Other
Literary Remains. Ed. William Michael Rossetti and Philip Bourke
Marston. 2 vols. 1876.
"ports, presentation copy."
[Bennett] {146}
William Michael Rossetti and Dante Gabriel Rossetti were greatly
attached to the promising artist and writer Oliver Madox Brown who died
aged 19 on 5 November 1874. Dante Gabriel Rossetti's "Oliver Madox
Brown" - a sonnet in remembrance - was published in The Athenaeum, 14
November 1874.
WC wrote to Oliver's father, Ford Madox Brown:
"I beg that you will accept my best thanks for the volumes containing
the literary remains of your son.
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 83
55. Bullar, Joseph. A Winter in the Azores; And a Summer at the Baths of the
Furnas. 2 vols. 1841.
"illustrated cl."
[Salisbury] {40}
Joseph Bullar, M.D., was a close friend of the Collins family.
56. Bunn, Alfred. The Stage: Both before and behind the Curtain from
"Observations Taken on the Spot". 3 vols. 1840.
[Parsons] {116}
Alfred Bunn (1798-1860), dramatist, manager, and member of the Garrick
(Stephens, 11).
57. Burke, Peter. The Romance of the Forum, or, Narratives, Scenes, and
Anecdotes from Courts of Justice. 2 vols. [1852-1853]
"fronts."
[George] {142}
Peter Burke (1811-1881: Boase), alternative title: Narratives, Scenes, and
Anecdotes from Courts of Justice: published in 4 vols. 1852-1861.
58. Burnaby, Fred. A Ride to Khiva: Travels and Adventures in Central Asia.
2nd ed. 1876.
"maps."
[Edwards] {103}
60. Burton, John Hill. Narratives from Criminal Trials in Scotland. 2 vols.
1852.
"cl"
84 Wilkie Collins's Library
[Nugent] {3}
WC drew upon the conflicts of Scottish and English marital law in "The
Parson's Scruple," originally published under the title "A New Mind,"
Household Words, 1 January 1859, and in his novel Man and Wife, 3 vols.
1870.
63. Butler, William Francis, Sir. Akim-foo: The History of a Failure. 1875.
"map"
[F. Hurt] {152}
An account of the disastrous Ashanti War 1873-1874.
64. Butler, William Francis, Sir. The Great Lone Land: A Narrative of Travel
and Adventure in the North-West of America [1873].
"map and illustrations."
[Maggs] {37}
First edition 1872. There were several editions: 2nd in 1872; 3 rd in 1873.
Both Butler titles were published by Sampson Low, Marston, Low &
Searle, with whom WC had dealings. Sampson Low published The
Woman in White, 1860-1863. See Gasson 136-7.
65. Byron, George Gordon, 6th Baron. Complete Works with Life. [1842].
"port, cf. gt.. . . roy. 8 vo."
[Storre] {128}
In a letter to Richard Edgcumbe, WC accepts with pleasure "the honour of
becoming a member of the Committee for The Byron Memorial - and . . .
will assist to the best of my ability in helping forward this object - the
excellent object as I think" (MS: Present whereabouts unknown: 27
March 1875). He writes to William Winter: "You will now not be
surprised to hear that I delight in Byron and Scott" (5 August 1878:
Letters, II, 413).
66. Byron, George Gordon, 6th Baron. Life, Letters and Journals of Lord
Byron: Complete in One Volume. 1838.
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 85
67. Byron, George Gordon, 6th Baron. The Poetical Works of Lord Byron. 8
vols., 1857.
"(impft.) hf. cf. 12 mo."
[Cogswell] {159}
See also Medwin, Thomas, item 347.
68. Byron, John. Byron's Narrative of the Loss of the Wager; With an
Account of the Great Distresses Suffered by Himself and His Companions
on the Coast of Patagonia from the Year 1740 till Their Arrival in
England 1746. 10 vols. 1832.
[Thistlewood] {148}
The narrative of John Byron (1723-1786).
have done here. I have read the chapters twice, and, if I know anything of
our art, I am sure of what I say.
Now let me think of the next book that you will write, and let me
own frankly where I see some form for improvement in what the painters
call 'treatment of the subject'.
When you next take up your pen, will you consider a little whether
your tendency to dwell on what is grotesque and violent in human
character does not require some discipline? Look again at the 'The
Deemster', and at some of the qualities and modes of thought attributed to
'Dan'.
Again, your power as a writer sometimes misleads you, as I think,
into forgetting the value of contrast. The grand picture which your story
presents of terror and grief wants relief. Individually and collectively,
there is variety in the human lot. We are no more continuously neglected
than we are continuously happy. Next time, I want more of the humour
which breaks out so delightfully in old 'Quilleash'. More breaks of
sunshine in your splendidly cloudy sky will be a truer picture of nature,
and will certainly enlarge the number of your admiring readers. Look at
two of the greatest of tragic stories - Hamlet and the Bride of
Lammermoor, and see how Shakespeare and Scott take every opportunity
of presenting contrasts, and brightening the picture at the right place" (15
March 1888: Letters, II, 553-54).
Sir Thomas Henry Hall Caine (1853-1931: DNB), Manx novelist and
friend of WC. The Deemster and The Shadow of a Crime were published
by Chatto and Windus, who from November 1874 had a seven-year lease
on WC's available copyrights. See Gasson 27, 25.
74. Caplin, Jean Francis Isidore. The Electro-Chemical Bath: For the
Extraction of Mercury, Lead and Other Metallic Poisonous and
Extraneous Substances from the Human Body; Which, by Their Presence
in the Organism. [1868].
"presentation copy from the author to Wilkie Collins 1868"
[Hartley] {16}
The first edition was published in 1856. In 1868 an edition "revised and
much enlarged; with plates, including a portrait" was published.
WC wrote to Charles Benham: "I have begun the electric baths. Rating the
pores of my skin at only 7 millions - 1 have had 7 million currents of
electricity running through me for 45 minutes. The result is great
cheerfulness and great disinclination to pay inland revenue" (25
September 1868: Letters, II, 313).
Jean Francis Isidore Caplin, French physician.
78. Cervantes Saavedra, Miguel de. The History of the Valorous and Witty
Knight-Errant Don Quixote of the Mancha. Translated by Thomas
Shelton. 4 vols. 1725.
"plates from the French of Coypel."
88 Wilkie Collins's Library
[Hartley] {172}
79. Cervantes Saavedra, Miguel de. The Life and Exploits of the Ingenious
Gentleman, Don Quixote de la Mancha. Translated by Charles Jarvis. 4
vols. 1801.
"port, map and plates . . . cf."
[Suckling] {50}
Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra (1547-1616).
WC writes in a letter to Mrs. Harriet Collins concerning Antwerp: "We
mixed with the crowd (who to use the words of Don Quixote - 'smelt of
anything rather than amber') and awaited the solitary advent of the sacred
box with considerable impatience." (6 August 1846: Letters, I, 38).
86. Cibber, Colley. An Apology for the Life of Mr. Colley Cibber: Comedian,
and Late Patentee of the Theatre-Royal: With an Historical View of the
Stage During His Own Time. 2nd edition, 1740.
"with signature of W. Wilkie Collins 1845 on fly-leaf
[name of buyer illegible] {170}
Colley Cibber (1671-1757): description of Restoration theatre. Cibber,
actor, theatre manager (Drury Lane), dramatist, adapted Moliere and other
French dramatists for the London stage. Ridiculed for snobbery by Pope,
Dr. Johnson, and Fielding in Joseph Andrews (Harvey).
88. Clarke, Marcus Andrew Hislop. His Natural Life. Melbourne, 1874.
[Suckling] {149}
Marcus Clarke [Andrew Hislop] (1846-1881), "author of the finest
Australian novel of the nineteenth century His Natural Life," serialized in
the Australian Journal, March 1870-June 1872, published in a single
volume in Melbourne, 1874 (Sadleir, 560), first English edition, 3 vols.
Bentley, 1875 (Sadleir, 560 A). Complicated plot concerning
transportation to Australia, inheritance dispute, convict life, discovery of
gold, murder, illegitimacy, with powerful prison scenes and descriptions
of the Australian landscape (Sutherland, 128, 297).
95. Coleridge, Samuel Taylor. The Poems of Samuel Taylor Coleridge. 1857.
"cf. 12 mo."
[Nugent] {171}
[Parsons] {218}
William Collins's (1788-1847: DNB) memoir of George Morland the
painter. Picture "so intrigued Wilkie Collins that he interrupted the
narrative of his life of his father to devote nine pages to unravelling the
complicated plot of a book which he compared, not absurdly, to Smollett,
Sterne and even Fielding" (Peters 11).
99. Collins, William Wilkie. Antonina; or The Fall of Rome. 3 vols. 1850.
"the Author's own copy with his autograph ' W. Wilkie Collins' on first
title."
{221} [42]
Bennett bought for 18/- and offered at 25/-.
107. Collins, William Wilkie. The Fallen Leaves: First Series. 3 vols. 1879
{224} {229} [40]
108. Collins, William Wilkie. The Frozen Deep and Other Stories. 2 vols.
1874.
[Sabin] {222}
See Gasson 66.
109. Collins, William Wilkie. The Haunted Hotel: A Mystery of Modern Venice
to which is Added My Lady's Money. 2 vols. 1879.
"WC has written 'Wilkie Collins, 90 Gloucester PL, Portman Square,
April 21 st 1883' on the fly-leaf in pencil."
[Sabin] {222}; {228} [38]
Author's copy is at the Huntington Library RB 120329.
111. Collins, William Wilkie. The Law and the Lady. 3 vols. 1875.
"cr. 8 vo."
{225} [33]; {229} [name of buyer illegible, not Bennett]
{223} [35]
115. Collins, William Wilkie. Miss or Mrs? and Other Stories in Outline. 1873.
"cr. 8vo., cloth."
{228} [45]
123. Collins, William Wilkie. Works. New edition, illustrated, 23 vols. various
years.
"hf. mor. (a few newspaper cuttings, and 2 letters relating to Works etc.
inserted)."
[Quaritch] {219}
126. Collins, William Wilkie. Works. Translated into French. 6 vols. Paris,
1875-1888.
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 95
127. Collins, William Wilkie. Works. Translated into German. 6 vols. 1871-
1882.
Comprises:
John J ago's Ghost. Berlin, 1875.
"sm., 12 mo., swd."
Mann und Weib. 6 vols. in 3. Leipzig, 1871.
"cr. 8vo., in hf. mor."
Der Schwarze Rock. 2 vol., [Berlin, 1882].
"cr. 8vo, swd. Present copy to Wilkie Collins from the Publisher
[Engelmann]. Berlin, 1882"
{230} [50]
128. Collins, William Wilkie. Works. Translated into Italian. 6 vols. 1876-
1884.
Comprises:
Cuore e Scienza. Milan, 1884.
Translated by Lida Cerracchini. "sm. 8vo, vellum gilt, red edges, very
[nice condition] . . . copy to W.C. with Autofgraph]."
/ due Destini, 2 vols. Roma, 1876.
"cr. 8vo. swd. port."
La Vita di un Marinolo[Mariolo]. [Roma] 2 vols. 1880.
"12 mo. swd. present copy to W.C. from the translator] Santarelli."
Le vesti Nere. [Roma], 1882.
"cr. 8 vo, neat leather, red edges."
{230} [51]
129. Commynes, Philippe de. Notes on Louis XI: With Some Short Extracts
from Commines' "'Memoirs. " 1878.
[Dobell] {236}
Extracts from Commines's Memoirs, with a short introduction by the
editor, "A.E." with his "Notes on Louis XI." privately printed by J. C.
Wilkins of London.
133. Cooper, James Fenimore. Novels. 31 vols. New York, Household Edition,
1872.
"fronts, and vignettes . . . cl."
[Roche] {83}
In a letter to Paul Hamilton Hayne, WC writes:
"It may be hundreds of years, before another Fenimore Cooper appears in
America, or another Walter Scott in England. I call these two and Balzac
- the three Kings of Fiction" (3 May 1884: Letters, II, 467).
135. Cornwall, Barry, pseud, [i.e., Bryan Waller Procter]. Charles Lamb: A
Memoir. 1866.
"portrait."
[Parsons] {26}
Bryan Waller Procter (1787-1874: DNB), poet, lawyer, and from 1832,
one of the metropolitan Commissioners in Lunacy. WC dedicated The
Woman in White"To Bryan Waller Procter; from one of his younger
brethren in literature, who sincerely values his friendship, and who
gratefully remembers many happy hours spent in his house."
See also under Lamb, Charles (item 293).
136. Cornwall, Barry, pseud. Dramatic Scenes: With Other Poems. 1857.
"illustrated."
[Parsons] {26}
137. Cornwall, Barry, pseud. English Songs and Other Small Poems. 1856.
The copy is inscribed on the front fly-leaf "Wilkie Collins Esq | with the
Authors' [sic] | Kind Regards". Marginal lining contains pencil markings
highlighting certain poems. Not in Puttick and Simpson 20 January 1890
Catalogue or in Bennett. Copy in the possession of Andrew Gasson in
1999.
139. Cousin, Victor. The Philosophy of the Beautiful. Trans. New York, 1849.
"presentation copies from Daniel Bixby to Wilkie Collins."
[Suckling] {20}
Daniel Bixby, New York publisher who met WC during his American
tour.
140. Cozzens, Samuel Woodworth. The Marvellous Country; or, Three Years
in Arizona and New Mexico, the Apaches' Home. Boston, 1873.
"illustrated cl."
[Vernon] {102}
141. Crabbe, George. The Poetical Works of the Rev. George Crabbe: With Hi
Letters and Journals, and His Life. 1834.
"fronts, and vignettes 8 vols. cl. 12 mo."
[Withers] {28}
WC writes to William Winter:
98 Wilkie Collins's Library
142. Craddock, Charles Egbert. The Prophet of the Great Smoky Mountains.
Boston; New York, 1886.
[Thistlewood] {148}
Fictional account of social life and customs in the Great Smoky Mountains
- North Carolina and Tennessee.
144. Crucis, Alpha. Song of the Stars and Other Poems. Sydney, 1882.
"8vo, bds. Present copy to Wilkie Collins with Author's Inscription."
{98} [19]
"Alpha Crucis," pseud, of Robert Dudley Adams (1829-1912), Australian
lawyer and poet.
146. Crowne, John. The Dramatic Works of John Crowne. Vol. I. Edinburgh,
1873.
[Dobell] {107}
Part of the Dramatists of the Restoration. Only the first volume of John
Crowne's (1640-1712) works was in WC's library. Vol. 1 contains
Juliana', The History of Charles the Eighth of France', Calisto.
149. Dana, Richard Henry. Two Years before the Mast. Boston, 1877.
[Thistlewood] {148}
WC writes to Dana: "I have read 'Two Years before the Mast', and read it
with great delight - it is a most entertaining and most original book; and is
deservedly popular in England, among all classes of readers" {Letters, I,
62: 17 June 1850).
150. D'Avenant, William, Sir. The Dramatic Works of Sir William D'Avenant.
Edinburgh, 1872-74.
[Dobell] {107}
Four of five volumes only recorded in WC's library. Part of the
Dramatists of the Restoration. William D'Avenant (1606-1668).
151. [Defoe, Daniel]. A General History of the Robberies and Murders of the
Most Notorious Pyrates . . . by Captain Charles Johnson. 1724.
"plates (impft.)."
[Nugent] {6}
154. Derby, James Cephas. Fifty Years among Authors, Books, and Publishers.
New York, 1884.
"ports cl."
[Suckling] {20}
156. Dickens, Charles. The Posthumous Papers of the Pickwick Club, first
edition. 1837.
"plates by Seymour and Phiz with the Buss plates (cut down) signature of
W. Wilkie Collins on fly-leaf, roan, gilt edged."
[Stirling] {57}
158. Dickens, Charles. Plays and Poems, edited by R.H. Shepherd. 2 vols.
1882.
"cl."
[Spencer] {59}
161. Dickens, Charles. Household Words. Vols. 1-19 (wanting vol. 15) in 10
vols. 1850-9.
[Oliver] {62}.
For WC's contribution to Household Words, see Gasson 81-82. Volume
15 (1857) contains WC's The Dead Secret.
163. Diderot, Denis. CEuvres avec Memoires par Naigeon. 22 vols. Paris, 1821.
"port, and plates . . . hf. cf."
[St. Martin's Public Library] {191}.
Denis Diderot (1713-1784).
166. Doran, John. A Lady of the Last Century: (Mrs. Elizabeth Montagu), 2nd
ed.4vols. 1873.
[F. Hurt] {152}
102 Wilkie Collins's Library
168. Dryden, John. Poetical Works, With Life of the Author. 4 vols. 1832-1833.
[Roche] {29}
Part of Pickering's Aldine edition of the British poets.
169. Dumas pare, Alexandre. La Dame de Monsoreau and other Plays and
Comedies. [Paris], v.y.
[Oliver] {174}
Part of 38-vol. collection.
171. Dumas pere, Alexandre. Vicomte de Bragelonne and other works. [Paris],
v.y.
[Oliver] {174}
Part of 38-vol. collection.
178. Egan, Pierce. Tom and Jerry, or, Life in London, n.d.
"coloured plates by G. Cruikshank."
[Oliver] {14}
First published in [1821].
181. Elliot, Frances. Diary of an Idle Woman in Sicily. New edition. 1884.
[F. Hurt] {151}
189. Ewald, Alexander, Charles. Stories from the State Papers. 1882.
[Hartley] {141}
191. Farquhar, George. The Works of the Late Ingenious Mr. George
Farquhar. 2 vols. 9th and 5th editions. 1728,1760.
[Hartley] {124}
George Farquhar (1678-1707), dramatist. WC owned two copies of
Farquhar's Works: according to the British Library Catalogue,the 5th
edition was published in 1728.
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 105
197. Fielding, Henry. The Works of Henry Fielding. 4th ed. 12 vols. Edinburgh,
1767.
"Calf."
[Hill] {126}
106 Wilkie Collins's Library
WC wrote to Charles Ward: "I have only two words to say about that ball
dress, and the charming person in it - they are the words of the immortal
Fielding: — 'My Arse in a Bandbox!'" (30 January 1861: Letters, I, 192).
WC also wrote to Edward Pigott: "one of the most tedious books (to me)
that I ever read in my life was Tom Jones. This is wrong, I know, but all
men have their 'cracked' points - and these are some of mine" ([October-
December 1855]: Letters, I, 146).
198. Fitzball, Edward. The House to Let, with Other Poems. 1857.
"presentation copy to Charles Dickens from the Author, cl."
[Spencer] {121}
Edward Ball, later Fitzball (1792-1873), author of over 150 plays, four
novels, and six volumes of verse, also adapter for the stage of many
novels and song writer. See J. R. Stephens The Profession of the
Playwright, 1992.
". . . discussing Oliver Twist, Mr. Forster remarks, 'Here was the
interest of a story simply but well constructed' (Life, 106). 'Nonsense',
writes William Collins, 'the one defect of that wonderful book is the
helplessly bad construction of the story. The character of "Nancy" is the
finest thing he ever did. He never afterwards saw all the sides of a
woman's character - saw all round her. That the same man who could
create "Nancy" created the second Mrs. Dombey is the most
incomprehensible anomaly that I know of in literature.'
The next note . . . relates to Barnaby Rudge [Forster notes that Dickens
had a 'fancy' to make the leaders of the Gordon riots 'three splendid
fellows . . . who should turn out, when all was over, to have broken out of
Bedlam'. With some difficulty, Forster made him see 'the unsoundness of
this' (Life, 168).] Concerning this Wilkie Collins writes, 'Where is the
unsoundness of it? I call it a fine idea. New, powerful, highly dramatic,
and well within the limits of truth to nature. It would have greatly
improved the weakest book that Dickens ever wrote' .. .
In a note in the second volume he describes Martin Chuzzlewit as in
some respects Dickens' finest novel, but severely criticises its successor.
'The latter half of Dombey no intelligent person can have read without
astonishment of the badness of it, and the disappointment that followed
lowered the sale of the next book Copperfield, incomparably superior to
Dombey as it certainly is."'
According to Robinson "Forster's assertion that there is scarcely a page
of Dickens which could not be placed in the hand of a child provokes the
explosion we might expect.
208. Forster, John. Walter Savage Landor, a Biography 1821-64. 2 vols. 1869.
"port."
[Edwards] {27}
WC wrote to Forster:
"My heartiest congratulations on the completion of 'Landor', and my best
thanks for the copy of the book which you have so kindly sent to me. I
shall read it with no common interest and attention - first as coming from
yow, secondly as saying, what no one else could have said so well, in
vindication of Landor's claims to a great place in English literature. You
taught me to understand 'Eliot' - and you will find me willing to learn (if
I can) to understand 'Landor'" (15 May 1869: Letters, II, 322-23).
110 Wilkie Collins's Library
[Smith] {217}
220. Gaultier, Bon [Aytoun, W.E. and Theodore Martin]. The Book of Ballads.
Edinburgh, 1859.
"illustrated by Doyle, Leech . . . (used copy)"
[Woolley] {100}
221. Geneste, John. Some Account of the English Stage from the Restoration in
1660 to 1830. 10 vols. Bath, 1832.
"hf. mor. (Robert Southey's copy Keswick 1834 and signature of Wilkie
Collins 31 st March 1881 both written on title of vol. 1)."
[Withers] {108}
223. George, Henry. Some Habits and Customs of the Working Classes. 1867.
[Hartley] {21}
224. Gibbon, Charles. For Lack of Gold: A Novel. 1st ed. 3 vols. 1871.
"cr. 8vo. cloth."
{146} [72]
Charles Gibbon (1843-1890), novelist. For Lack of Gold, first published
by Blackie & Sons in three-volume format in 1871. Reissued in other
formats in 1873, 1877, 1878 and in 1881 by Chatto & Windus (see
Chester W. Topp, Victorian Yellowbacks, & Paperbacks, 1849-1905, III,
Hermitage Antiquarian Bookshop: Denver, Colorado, 1997. 75).
225. Gibbon, Edward. The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. 12 vols.
1813.
"port, and maps . . . cf."
[Sabin] {77}
Possibly a re-issue of the 12-vol. new edition; London: W. Strahan, etc.,
1791-92.
A possible source for WC's Antonina; or The Fall of Rome. A Romance
of the Fifth Century (1850).
112 Wilkie Collins's Library
227. Giles, Chauncey. The Spiritual World and Our Children There. 1875.
"cloth," gilt edged.
[60]. Not recorded in Puttick and Simpson.
231. Goldsmith, Oliver. The Miscellaneous Works of Oliver Goldsmith. Ed. Sir
James Prior. 4 vols. 1837.
"vignettes on titles. . . cf."
[Gardner] {75}
John Forster's The Life and Times of Oliver Goldsmith, published in 1848;
James Northcote's (1746-1831), anecdotes of Goldsmith published in
Memoirs offG.J Joshua Reynolds, 2 vols., 1818.
WC also wrote to his mother, Mrs. Harriet Collins: "I walked yesterday to
the Serpentine - rested - and walked back again! An amazing
achievement for me. If I can keep it up 'Tony Lumpkin [A character in
Goldsmith's She Stoops to Conquer] will soon be his own man again.'" (2
July \863: Letters, I, 227).
238. Guyon, Jeanne Marie Bouvier de La Motte. The Exemplary Life of the
Pious Lady Guion. Trans. Thomas Digby Brooke. Bristol, 1806.
"8vo, hf. old cf."
{133} [25]
239. Gwynne, Nell. Acorn Leaves: A Series of Canadian Tales. Toronto, 1873.
"sm. 4to., cloth."
{30} [6]
with you, sir, heart and soul, when you say "alien to man"! That's a cut at
the Hottentots and they richly deserve it'.
The defect which I have tried to indicate is the only obstacle that I can
now see in Mr. Haggard's way. If he will be on his guard against this -
and if he will not let publishers tempt him to lead his readers too often
over the same ground - 1 believe he has the ball at his foot, and I shall be
rejoiced to see him kicking it to good purpose" (4 January 1887: Letters,
II, 529-30).
245. Hall, Basil. Schloss Hainfeld, or, A Winter in Lower Styria. 1836.
[name of buyer illegible] {170}
246. Hallam, Henry. View of the State of Europe during the Middle Ages. 2
vols. 1841.
"8vo. hf. grey calf, W. Collins' Autofgraph] in volume I Good Library
Edition."
{133} [81]
[Withers] {150}
249. Haydn, Joseph. A Dictionary of Dates Relating to All Ages and Nations.
9th ed, revised and greatly enlarged, by Benjamin Vincent. 1860.
"(with signature of Wilkie Collins 1860) cf. gt."
[Packer] {70}
252. Heber, Reginald, ed. Hymns, Written and Adapted to the Weekly Church
Service of the Year. 1827.
"with signature of H. Collins."
[Suckling] {135}
253. Heussey, Robert du Pontavice de. L'Inimitable Boz: Sur la Vie et TOeuvre
de C Dickens. 2 vols. Paris, 1889.
"thin 8 vo., swd, vig. port, on title and front, by Courboin . . . beautifully
clean copy. On fly leaf is written, 'A mon cher Maitre W. Wilkie Collins
hommage d'admiration et d'affectueux respect Robert du Pontavice de
Heussey 17. Janvier. 1889."
{173} [58]
Robert du Pontavice de Heussey (1850-1893), Breton author who
translated WC's work into French and represented his interests in Paris
and elsewhere.
Copy now at Princeton, Parrish collection.
254. Heussey, Robert du Pontavice de. Madeline; Piece en Quatre Actes, dont
un Prologue d'apres Wilkie Collins par R. du P. de Heussey. Paris, 1887.
"cr, 8 vo."
{173} [49]
WC wrote to de Heussey: "I leave the proof of 'Magdalen' in perfect
confidence to you - and I look forward with true interest to receiving a
copy of the play when it has received your last correction and has become
a published work" (14 February 1887: Letters, II, 533).
255. Heussey, Robert du Pontavice de. CEuvres Completes. 2 vols. Paris, 1887.
"2 roy 8vo. vols, swd. 2 finely etched portraits, clean as new."
{173} [83]
WC wrote to de Heussey: "You are the only French Man of Letters -
mind, I say this seriously - who understands England and the English.
And, because I mean this, you will find on the next morsel of paper, some
corrections of trifling slips - to be noted before you republish your
contributions to 'Le Livre'" (4 February 1887: Letters, II, 532).
256. Hogarth, George. Memoirs of the Opera in Italy, France, Germany, and
England. 2 vols. 1851.
"ports cl."
[Suckling] {120}
For a discussion of WC's operatic interests, see Allan W. Atlas, "Wilkie
Collins on Music and Musicians," Journal of the Royal Musical
Association, 124 (1999), 264-65. George Hogarth was Charles Dickens's
father-in-law.
118 Wilkie Collins's Library
257. Holcroft, Thomas. Memoirs of the Late Thomas Holcroft. 3 vols. 1816.
"port, bds."
[Maggs] {22}
Thomas Holcroft (1745-1809), friend of Thomas Paine and William
Godwin. His Memoirs, posthumously edited and completed by William
Hazlitt.
260. Holley, George W. Niagara: Its History and Geology, Incidents and
Poetry, with Illustrations. NewYork, 1872.
"presentation copy to W. Collins."
[Bennett] {32}
Purchased by Bennett but not in his sale.
George Washington Holley (1810-1897), American natural historian. WC
wrote to G. Maclean Rose of Hunter Rose & Co (Holley's Canadian
publishers): "Reverting to personal matters, my Godson and I have to
thank you for more than your kindness and Mr. Rose's kindness to us in
Toronto. Your friendly consideration followed us to Niagara - Saw us
through the Custom House . . . and showed us the Falls under the best
possible guidance. No words can tell how these wonderful Falls
astonished and impressed me. It is well worth the voyage from England
to see Niagara alone" (2 January 1874: Letters, II, 371).
264. Hone, William. The Every Day Book, or, A Guide to the Year: Describing
the Popular Amusements, Sports, Ceremonies, Manners, Customs, and
Events, Incident to the Three Hundred and Sixty-Five Days, in Past and
Present Times. 4 vols. 1878.
"numerous woodcuts hf. bd."
[Smith] {46}
William Hone (1780-1842), pseudonym John Cecil, appears on title page.
265. [Hone, William]. Sixty Curious and Authentic Narratives and Anecdotes.
1822.
"bds uncut"
[Nugent] {5}
271. Hunt, Robert. Popular Romances of the West of England; or, The Drolls,
Traditions, and Superstitions of Old Cornwall. 1881.
"illustrated by G. Cruikshank"
[Oliver] {14}
275. Jackson, William. The New and Complete Newgate Calendar: or,
Malefactor's Universal Register. Vols. 1-3. 1800-[1803].
Plates.
122 Wilkie Collins's Library
[Nugent] {6}
276. Jahn, Otto. Life of Mozart, trans, by Pauline D. Townsend. 3 vols. 1882.
"ports, cl."
[Smith] {8}
279. Johns, J. J., Anglican Cathedral Church of Saint James, Mount Zion,
Jerusalem. 1842.
"thin folio, cloth, 6 pages of coloured plates, containing 11 Illustrations,
loose in case, List of Subscribers"
{245} [18]
281. Johnson, Samuel. The Works of Samuel Johnson, with Life by Murphy. 12
vols. 1806.
"8vo, diamond calf, gilt, marbled edges. Portrait after Reynolds, M. A.
Beloe on title and Wm. Beloe's bookplate . . . Trade Edition."
Bennett's catalogue notes "Some of the covers are loose but could be put
in Library condition for a trifle. The price is very moderate." Bennett
purchased for 2s 6d and offered for sale at 15/-. See also Fleeman, II,
1661-1669.
{137} [88]
WC wrote to Paul Hamilton Hayne,
'"What must be done, sir, w|li be done,' old Doctor Johnson said, and
said truly, in the last century. I hope you like Doctor Johnson. He is one
of my heroes - Boswell's Life of him is my favourite book - and (to the
astonishment of some of the shallow literary men of the present time in
England) I persist in thinking his 'Vanity of Human Wishes,' and his
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 123
'lines on the death of Robert Levett' two of the grandest poems ever
written." (27 December 1885: Letters, II, 490).
See also under Boswell, James (items 44-47), Croker, John Wilson (item
145), and Piozzi, Hester Lynch (item 389).
282. Kane, Elisha Kent. Arctic Explorations in 1853-54-55. . . The Second and
Last United States Grinnell Expedition in Search of Sir John Franklin. 2
vols. Hartford, Conn. 1871-72.
"numerous illustrations hf. cf."
[May] {71}
283. Kelly, Michael. Reminiscences of Michael Kelly of the King's Theatre and
Theatre Royal Drury Lane, Including a Period of Nearly Haifa Century
with Original Anecdotes of Many Distinguished Persons, Political,
Literary and Musical. 2 vols. 1826.
"port. . . . hf. cf."
[Bain] {111}
The Athenaeum, WC's London club, purchased this copy with WC's
annotations in 1890.
At the foot of p. 154 (volume 2), WC notes "This is a mistake. The play
had proceeded beyond the Act in which these words occur, when Palmer
dropped dead on the stage (see the notice of John Palmer in Geneste's
'English Stage'.)" WC is reacting to Kelly's "On the 2nd of August [1798]
the stage had an irreparable loss, by the death of that excellent actor, John
Palmer [1742?-1798], who expired on the stage, while acting in 'The
Stranger,' just as he uttered - 'There is another, and a better world!'" (II,
154). The DNB entry on Michael Kelly (1764?-1826), actor, vocalist and
composer, attributes his Reminiscences to "Theodore Hook from
materials furnished by Kelly" (X, 1245).
291. Labiche, Eugene. Theatre Complet avec une Preface, par E. Augier. 8
vols. Paris. 1879.
"sewed"
[purchaser indecipherable] {178}
Eugene Labiche (1815-1888) wrote more than 160 farcical comedies.
292. Lamb, Charles. Specimens of English Dramatic Poets, Who Lived about
the Time of Shakespeare. 2 vols. 1835.
[Hartley] {85}
293. Lamb, Charles. Works: Poetical and Dramatic Tales, Essays and
Criticisms, with Biographical Introduction, Notes by Charles Kent. 1889.
"thick cr. 8vo, cloth,. . . Routledge"
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 125
299. Latude, Jean Henri Masers de. Memoires de Henri Masers de Latude.
2 vols. in 1. Paris, 1835.
[Suckling] {161}.
Suckling was acting for Quaritch who were purchasing on commission for
William Barclay Squire.
Jean-Henri Masers de Latude (1725-1805), imprisoned for thirty-five
years (1749-1784) for inventing a plot against Mme de Pompadour.
126 Wilkie Collins's Library
305. Leon, Edwin De. Askaros Kassis, the Copt. A Romance of Modern Egypt.
Philadelphia, 1870.
"presentation copy from the author to Wilkie Collins"
[Withers] {31}
Edwin De Leon (1828-1891), American diplomat and journalist. WC
wrote to 7 May 1874 and 1 June 1877.
Miriam F. Leslie (1836-1914). [Hart, 6th ed.]. WC sold the serial rights of
The Fallen Leaves, The Black Robe, and Heart and Science to Frank
Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper. See G. Law, Serializing Fiction in the
Victorian Press (2000), 104, 260, and also WC to William Seaver 12
January 1881 (MS: Princeton).
310. Lessing, Gotthold Ephraim. The Dramatic Works ofG E. Lessing, edited
by Bell, 2 vols. Bohn, 1878.
[Nugent] {115}
312. Lewes, George Henry. The Life and Works of Goethe. 1875.
[Lupton] {25}
314. Lewis, John Frederick. Sketches and Drawings of the Alhambra, Made
during a Residence in Granada, in the Years 1833-4. 1835.
"Folio . . . lithograph plates by Harding"
[Heald | Parsons] {242}
John Frederick Lewis, R.A. (1805-1876), Orientalist painter, draughtsman,
etcher, and mezzotint engraver. Colleague of William Collins. James
Duffield Harding (1797-1863), watercolorist, engraver and lithographer,
specializing in landscapes and topographical views.
Eliza Lynn Linton, nee Lynn (1822-1898), novelist. In 1856 she sold
Gad's Hill to Dickens.
317. Lockhart, John Gibson. Memoirs of the Life of Sir Walter Scott. 10 vols.
Edinburgh, 1848.
"hf. mor."
[Graham] {89}
See also under Scott, Sir Walter.
321. Lovett, William. The Life and Struggles of William Lovett, in His Pursuit
of Bread, Knowledge, and Freedom. 1876.
"cl."
[Lupton] {25}
William Lovett (1800-1877), Chartist.
323. Lytton, Edward George Lytton Bulwer. First Baron. Dramatic Works. 2
vols. 1876.
[Suckling] {140}
324. Lytton, Edward George Lytton Bulwer. First Baron. Dramatic Works, n.d.
"thick cr 8vo, cloth . .. Red Line Poets, Routledge"
{84} [96]
325. Lytton, Edward George Lytton Bulwer. First Baron. King Arthur, a Poem.
Toronto, 1871.
"cloth"
{84} [95]
WC wrote to his friend, the artist Edward Matthew Ward "I met Bulwer at
a party on Monday night. He is looking bright and plump. Now is the
time to take his portrait." (28 June 1849 Letters, I, 56). WC gave advice
to Lytton (1803-1873) on Canadian copyrights (MS: Herts Record Office:
22 October 1870).
333. MacDonald, George. St. George and St. Michael. [3 vols. 1876].
[Edwards] {143}
"5 vols. presentation copies to Wilkie Collins 1883-1887." Macdonald's
London publishers were Kegan, Paul and Trench. No correspondence
between WC and George MacDonald (1824-1905) has yet come to light.
335. MacMullen, John Mercier. The History of Canada, from Its First
Discovery to the Present Time. Ontario, 1868.
"mor."
[Maggs] {129}
337. M'Crie, Thomas. History of the Progress and the Suppression of the
Reformation in Italy in the 16th Century Including a Sketch of the History
of the Reformation in the Grisons. Edinburgh, 1833.
[name of buyer illegible] {170}
340. Marryat, Frederick. The Pirate and the Three Cutters. 1836.
"8vo, hf. brown, morocco gilt, gilt edges, with Portraits and 20 exquisite
plates by Clarkson Stanfield, brilliant impressions and spotless of the
original edition"
{72} [121]
Frederick Marryat (1792-1848), highly-paid, prolific novelist.
342. Marston, Edward. The Articles of the International Copyright Union: With
the Act and Order in Council Giving Effect to Them in the British
Dominions. 1887.
{15} [54]
Edward Marston (1825-1914), publisher, and partner in Sampson Low
who published The Woman in White and other WC novels. For Marston's
reminiscences of WC, see his After Work: Fragments from the Workshop
of an Old Publisher (1904), 86-87. Cf. WC to Marston (31 October 1860:
Letters, I, 191).
See also items 12, 134, 278, 319.
344. Massett, Stephen C. (iDrifting About, " or, What (<Jeems Pipes, of
Pipesville" Saw-and-Did. New York, 1863.
"illustrated, presentation copy from the author to Wilkie Collins"
{30} Item purchased by Bennett, not listed by him.
Stephen C. Massett (1820-1898), American lyricist, composer of popular
songs.
Part of 6 vols. bound with "no titles," also includes Melesvile and Scribe.
[Jones] {202}
Edouard Mazeres (1796-1866) collaborated with Scribe and others, wrote
theatrical vaudevilles.
346. Medbery, James Knowles. Men and Mysteries of Wall Street. Boston,
1870.
[Reya] {36}
349. Mejan, Maurice. Recueil des Causes Celebres, et des Arrets qui les Ont
Decidees. 2nd ed. 26 vols. Paris, 1808.
"hf. bd. with signature of Wilkie Collins in vol. 1"
[Roche] {192}
WC purchased this in a Paris bookstore in 1856: "T was in Paris
wandering about the streets with Charles Dickens .. . amusing ourselves
by looking into the shops. We came to an old bookstall - half shop and
half store and I found some dilapidated volumes of records of French
crimes, a sort of French Newgate Calendar. I said to Dickens 'Here is a
prize'. So it turned out to be. In them I found some of my best plots. 'The
Woman in White was one'" (Clarke 100, citing Wybert Reeve,
"Recollections of Wilkie Collins," Chambers's Journal, June 1906).
354. Miles, Henry Downes. Pugilistica; Being One Hundred and Forty-Four
Years of the History of British Boxing. 3 vols. 1880-1881.
"plates . . . cl."
[Thompson] {2}
355. Miller, James. Alcohol; Its Place and Power. Glasgow, 1861.
{12} Purchased by Bennett, but not listed in his catalogue.
358. Moore, Thomas. The Poetical Works of Thomas Moore. Paris, 1842.
"port. hf. cf. gilt, royal"
[Storre] {128}
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 135
360. Motley, John Lothrop. The Rise of the Dutch Republic, n.d.
"cl."
[Thistlewood] {104}
First published by Harper, New York in 3 vols. (1856). There were
various subsequent single volume editions.
361. Murphy, Arthur. The Life of David Garrick, Esq. 2 vols. 1801.
"port. .. bds. uncut."
[Suckling] (118)
362. Napier, William Francis Patrick, Sir. History of the War in the Peninsula
and in the South of France, from the Year 1807 to the Year 1814. 3 vols.
1882.
"plans cl."
[Broadhurst] {101}
366. Newman, John Henry. Apologia Pro Vita Sua: Being a History of His
Religious Opinions. 1879.
[Coverley] {52}
Published by Longmans. For the complex history of publication see The
Cambridge Bibliography of English Literature, III (1999), 2254.
367. Newspaper Cuttings Relating to Our Civilization, Hints for Scenes and
Incidents, etc.
"in 2 scrap-books and small parcel, with a few notes by Wilkie Collins"
[Edwards] {188}
371. Nordhoff, Charles. The Communistic Societies of the United States; From
Personal Visit and Observation: Including Detailed Accounts of the
Economists, Zoarites, Shakers, the Am ana, One i da, Bethel, Aurora,
Icarian and Other Existing Societies; Their Religious Creeds, Social
Practices, Numbers, Industries, and Present Condition. 1875.
[Maggs] {34}
WC used this as a source for The Fallen Leaves (1879) in which the hero
Amelius Goldenheart "has been brought up in a Utopian community in
America. .. . Wilkie took the details of the community from a description
of the Oneida communities in a book he owned, The Communistic
Societies of the United States by Charles Nordhoff (Peters 386).
380. Opening Ceremonies of the New York and Brooklyn Bridge. Brooklyn,
New York, 1883.
[Money] {238}
Published by the Press of Brooklyn Eagle Job Printing Department.
381. Otway, Thomas. The Works of Mr. Thomas Otway, in Two Volumes.
Consisting of His Plays, Poems and Love-Letters. 2 vols. 1712.
"vol. 2 wants a cover"
[Hartley] {124}
138 Wilkie Collins's Library
382. Parkinson, Joseph Charles. Places and People: Being Studies from the
Life. 1869.
{154} [113]
Joseph Charles Parkinson (1833-1908: DNB), journalist, civil servant,
social reformer. Contributed to the Daily News, All the Year Round,
Temple Bar, among other periodicals. Married in 1867 the daughter of
George Elliot - the industrialist. Friend of W. P. Frith, Edmund Yates,
and others: advocate for Poor Law Reform.
WC sought Parkinson's advice during the writing of Man and Wife', see
for instance WC to Parkinson (17 July 1869: Letters, II, 323-24).
383. Peek, Francis. Social Wreckage: A Review of the Laws of England as They
Affect the Poor. 1883.
[Hartley] {21}
384. Peuchet, Jacques. Memoires Tirees des Archives de la Police de Paris por
Servir a I 'Histoire de la Morale et de la Police, Depuis Louis XIVjusqu 'a
Nos Jours. 6 vols. Paris 1838.
"hf. cf. with signature of Wilkie Collins"
[Roche] {209}. Roche were acting for Quaritch who were buying on
commission for William Barclay Squire, 14 Albert Place, Victoria Road,
Kensington.
WC wrote to Frederick Lehmann, "Reade has been here, and has carried
off my book about the French Police (Memoires tirees des Archives, &c
&c)." (25 October 1869: Letters, II, 326).
388. Pini, G. La Cremation en Italie et al 'Etr anger de 1774 jusqu 'a Nos
Jours. Milan, 1885.
"illustrated"
[Parsons] {181}
391. Plouvier, Edouard. Le Pays des Amours: Comedie en Cinq Actes, Melee
de Chant. Paris, n.d.
[Jones] {205}
Edouard Plouvier (1821-1876), author of dramatic comedies.
392. Poe, Edgar Allan. The Works of Edgar Allan Poe, Including the Choicest
of His Critical Essays. With a Study of His Life and Writings from the
French of Charles Baudelaire. [1872].
"thick, cr. cl. WC has written in pencil 'Stories by Poe not included in the
'Complete collection' on first page."
{84} [114]
See Gasson 124.
394. Pope, Alexander. The Poetical Works of Alexander Pope. 3 vols. n.d.
"cl."
[Hartley] {85}
For WC's use of Pope in No Name, see Caracciolo in Smith and Terry
174-176.
395. Pope, Alexander. The Works ofAlexander Pope, Esq. with Notes and
Illustrations by Warton. 9 vols. 1797.
"cf."
140 Wilkie Collins's Library
[Nugent] {73}
WC quotes Pope in a letter to Frank Ward: "Well might Pope say 'The
life of a writer is warfare on earth.'" (MS: Princeton: 8 April 1886).
401. Quilter, Harry. Sententice Artis, First Principles of Art for Painters and
Picture Lovers. 1886.
"Author's edition plates presentation copy from the author to Wilkie
Collins, crimson mor. extra t.e.g. impl. 8 vo."
[Sotheran] {45}
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 141
402. Rabelais, Francis. The Works of Francis Rabelais, trans, from the French
with explanatory notes. 4 vols. 1844.
"vols. 1 and 2 with signature of Wilkie Collins, June 1844 cl."
[Withers] {93}
Vol. 1 (rebound) with WC's signature on the fly-leaf "Wilkie Collins,
June 1844" in 1999 in the possession of Faith and William Clarke. On the
fly-leaf in pencil is the note "Lot 93, Purchased at the sale of the Library
of the late Wilkie Collins Esq at Puttick & Simpson's. Jany. 20th 1890."
403. Radcliffe, Anne. The Italian, or, The Confession of the Black Penitents a
Romance. 3 vols. 1797.
[Thistlewood] {167}
"Collins's mother, Harriet, was a fan of [Radcliffe's] work" (Nadel, xxxi).
Radcliffe (1764-1823), "gothic" novelist.
407. Ranke, Leopold von. History of the Popes, trans, by E. Foster. 3 vols.
1847.
[Farren]{160}
WC probably consulted during the writing of The Black Robe.
408. Reade, John Edmund. The Laureate Wreath and Other Poems. 1863.
[Withers] {91}
409. Reade, John Edmund. The Poetical Works of John Edmund Reade. New
edition. 3 vols. 1865.
[Withers] {91}
142 Wilkie Collins's Library
410. Redford, George. Art Sales. A History of Sales of Pictures and Other
Works of Art. 2 vote. 1888.
Quarto "roy"
[Withers] {232}
416. Reynolds, Frederick. The Life and Times of Frederick Reynolds. 2nd ed. 2
vols. in 1. 1827.
"cl."
[Hartley] {117}
Frederick Reynolds (1764-1841), dramatist.
418. Richer, Frangois. Causes Celebres et Inter ess antes, avec les Jugements
qui les Ont Decidees. 18 vols. Amsterdam, 1772-1781.
"cf. 12mo."
[Bennett] {193}
French criminal trials: possibly used as a plot source for The Woman in
White and elsewhere.
420. Ritson, Joseph. Robin Hood: A Collection of All the Ancient Poems,
Songs, and Ballads, Now Extant, Relative to That Celebrated English
Outlaw. 1820.
"woodcut on title painted, with signature 'William Collins aged 8 years
1832'"
[Maggs] {96}
422. Roscoe, William. The Life of Lorenzo de 'Medici: Called the Magnificent.
1846.
"signature of W.W. Collins 1846"
[Farren] {160}
First edition [1822].
426. Ruxton, George Frederick Augustus. Adventures in Mexico and the Rocky
Mountains. 1849.
[Thistlewood] {104}
Puttick and Simpson Auction Catalogue misprints the author as "Buxton"
for "Ruxton." Ruxton (1820-1848), Sandhurst-educated adventurer (Hart,
579).
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 145
432. Scott, Walter Sir. The Miscellaneous Prose Works. 28 vols. Edinburgh
and London, 1834-1836.
"ports, fronts, and vignettes after Turner . . . red cl."
[Roche] {87}
See William B. Todd, Ann Bowden. Sir Walter Scott: A Bibliographical
History 1796-1832 [1998] 921-31 [350 A].
433. Scott, Walter Sir. The Modern British Drama, ed. by Sir Walter Scott. 5
vols. Edinburgh and London, 1811.
"five large thick imp. 8vo. volumes, half old calf, fine vignette on each
title by Smirke. Bookplates, 'The Harte.' Tragedies (2 vols.), Comedies (2
vols.), Operas and Farces (1 vol.), from 1598 to 1788 by the best writers
of both centuries."
{110} [61]
Bennett purchased for 10 s and priced in his catalogue for 28 s.
In fact, Smirke only drew the title vignette - in this instance of a Giant
Jester for the fifth volume. The other title vignettes were drawn by H.
Howard and M. W. Sharp (William B. Todd, Ann Bowden, 238-41 [54
A]).
434. Scott, Walter Sir. Poetical Works. 12 vols. Edinburgh and London, 1888.
"fronts, and vignettes after Turner . . . hf. bd."
[Graham] {88}
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 147
WC wrote to his mother from Whitby: "On the other side of the room, two
more windows look out over the town, and the ruins of Whitby Abbey
(celebrated in 'Marmion') on the cliff above" (7 August 1861: Letters, I,
198). WC wrote to William Winter: "I positively decline to let the poet
preach to me or puzzle me. He is to express passions and sentiment in
language which is essentially intelligible as well as essentially noble and
musical - or I will have nothing to do with him. You will now not be
surprised to hear that I delight in Byron and Scott - and, more
extraordinary still, that I am a frequent reader even of Crabbe!" (5 August
1878: Letters, II, 413). WC wrote to Paul Hamilton Hayne: "Shall I
astonish you if I confess that I read Walter Scott's poetry with admiration
and delight - and shall I add that I believe Byron to be beyond
comparison the greatest poet that has sung since Milton? Now you know
what my criticism is worth?"
(16 July ISS4: Letters, II, 470).
435. Scott, Walter Sir. Waverley Novels. 48 vols. Edinburgh and London, 1859.
"Illustrated edition, numerous illustrations, cl."
[Maggs] {86}
literary man has been ennobled in this country" (14 January 1883: Letters,
II, 464).
To J.A. Stewart, he wrote "After more than thirty years' study of the Art, I
consider Walter Scott to be the greatest of all novelists, and 'The
Antiquary' is, as I think, the most perfect of all novels" (9 January 1888:
Letters, II, 552). Similarly, he wrote to Hall Caine: "Look at two of the
greatest of tragic stories - Hamlet and the Bride of Lammermoor, and see
how Shakespeare and Scott take every opportunity of presenting contrasts,
and brightening the picture at the right place" (15 March 1888: Letters, II,
554).
The hero Amelius Goldenheart of The Fallen Leaves has Scott's works in
his library: "The writings of the one supreme genius who soars above all
other novelists as Shakespeare soars above all other dramatists - the
writings of Walter Scott - had their place of honour in his library"
(Stroud: Sutton, 1994; 186).
437. Scribe, Eugene. Theatre Complete. 2nd ed. 24 vols. Paris 1834- 42.
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 149
440. Sewell, William Grant. The Ordeal of Free Labor in the British West
Indies. 1862.
[Vernon] {102}
444. Siebe, Henry. The Conquest of the Sea; With Numerous Illustrations: A
Book about Divers and Diving. 1874.
[Woollett]{153}
446. Smedley, Edward. The Occult Sciences: Sketches of the Traditions and
Superstitions of Past Times, and the Marvels of the Present Day. 1855.
[Woollett] {153}
447. Smith, Sydney. The Works of the Rev. Sydney Smith. 3 vols. 1854.
"with autograph of Wilkie Collins on title of vol. 1"
[Withers] {53}
453. Southerne, Thomas. Sir Antony Love or, The Rambling Lady: A Comedy.
1698.
[Money] {238}
Thomas Southerne (1659-1746), Anglo-Irish dramatist.
Wing S 4767
454. Southey, Robert. Essays, Moral and Political. Now First Collected. 2
vols. 1832.
"presentation copy to 'Master Collins 1st Prize Maida Hill Academy
Xmas 1835'"
[Withers] {90}
[Jones] {195}
Emile Souvestre (1806-1854), French dramatist.
461. Stephen, Henry John. New Commentaries on the Laws of England Partly
Founded on Blackstone. 4 vols. 1841.
"cl."
[Woollett] {18}
465. Sterne, Laurence. The Works of Laurence Sterne; With a Life of the
Author. 5 vols. 1823.
"cl."
[Withers] {90}
466. Stokes, John Lort. Discoveries in Australia, with an Account of the Coasts
and Rivers Explored and Surveyed during the Voyage of the Beagle,
1837-1843. 2 vols. 1846.
"plates cl."
[Maggs] {41}
"4 vols. uniform, but in hf. dark green morocco" Part of 13 vols. "Works"
of Sue.
{214} [123]
474. Swift, Jonathan. The Works of Jonathan Swift, with Life and Notes by
John Hawkesworth. 1166-1161.
"copper-plates 21 vols. (small hole in title of vol. 17 and last 2 11. of vol.
21 damaged) cf."
{127} [124]
WC writes to Mrs. Harriet Collins from Rome: "St. Peters cock (big
enough to eat-up fifty St. Peters) flaps his wings, and crows mechanically
three times, during the ceremony - the machinery in the inside of this
Brobdingnag bird creaking and rattling audibly while the automation goes
through its performance" (16 October 1853: Letters, I, 99).
480. Taylor, Bayard. The National Ode, the Memorial Freedom Poem. Boston,
1877.
"sm. 4to finely bound in brown morocco, antique, gilt edges, 78 pretty
illustrations by leading American artists"
{72} [125]
483. Tennyson, Alfred Lord. Locksley Hall Sixty Years After. 1886.
"green cl."
{92} [128]
WC wrote to Mrs. Harriet Collins: "As they all like Tennyson at Oxford,
they may like to hear what he said about himself to a friend of mine, who
repeated it to me. 'My misfortune is,' said the great T. - 'that I have not
got anything in me. If I had only got something in me, I could write as
well as Shakespeare'" (26 July 1859: Letters, I, 169-70).
488. The Theatrical Observer and Daily Bills of the Play. 1821 -1832.
"some nos. wanting, bound in 12 vols. bds."
[Parsons] {105}
Topics; With the Names of the Plays, and Their Authors, Referr 'd to in the
Margin. 2 vote. 1724.
"cf."
[F.Hutt] {123}
493. Thornbury, Walter. British Artists from Hogarth to Turner. 2 vote. 1861.
"cl. presentation copy with interesting autograph letter from the author
inserted in vol. 1"
[Withers] {13}
Walter George Thornbury (1828-1876), miscellaneous writer, prolific
contributor to Household Words and All the Year Round. The Athenaeum
art critic.
497. Trowbridge, John Townsend. Coupon Bonds, and other stories. Boston,
1873.
"plates, presentation copy to Wilkie Collins from the author"
[Hartley] {141}
John Townsend Trowbridge (1827-1916), Boston-based novelist and
short story writer.
499. Twain, Mark. The Prince and the Pauper. Toronto, 1882.
[Withers] {150}
503. Verne, Jules. Vingt Mille Lieues sous les Mers. 2 vote. [Paris, 1870].
[Dobell] {213}
506. Walch, Garnet. Head over Heels. A Christmas Book of Fun and Fancy.
Melbourne, 1874.
"cr. 8vo. cl., many comical cuts"
{97?}[129]
508. Walcott, Mackenzie Edward Charles. The East Coast of Englandfrom the
Thames to the Tweed, Descriptive of Natural Scenery, Historical,
Archaeological, and Legendary. 1861.
[Black] {155}
509. Walton, Izaak. The Complete Angler oflzaak Walton and Charles Cotton.
2 vote. Chiswick, 1824.
"orig. bds., uncut fronts, and vigs. Finely printed"
{154} [16]
511. Warren, Claud. Celebrated Hands: The Life-Size Outlines of the Hands of
Twenty-Two Celebrated Hands. 1882.
Folio, "plates"
{245} [82]
Contains "The hands of Wilkie Collins": illustrated Gasson 37.
515. Whitman, Sidney. Conventional Cant, Its Results and Remedy. 1887.
[Hartley] {147}
517. Wilson, James. Autobiography of the Blind, with Essay on the State of the
Blind by John Bird. [1856].
"sm. 8vo, cloth, front."
[Bennett] [21]
Bennett Catalogue gives the date as "1859."
WC probably consulted during the writing of Poor Miss Finch (1872).
518. Wilson, John. The Dramatic Works of John Wilson. Edinburgh, 1874.
[Dobell] {107}
John Wilson (1626-1696), comic dramatist.
520. Winslow, Forbes. On Obscure Diseases of the Brain. 2nd ed. 1861.
"cl. with present. Inscription from the Author to Wilkie Collins"
{17} [102]
Forbes Winslow (1810-1874), physician, member of the Royal College of
Surgeons: "regarded by the public as an authority in cases of insanity, and
in 1847 opened two private lunatic asylums at Hammersmith, where he
employed the humane method of treating lunatics. . . . The frequent
establishment of the plea of insanity in criminal cases was largely due to
his influence" (DNB). WC may well have consulted whilst writing The
Woman in White.
Reconstruction of Wilkie Collins's Library 161
522. Winter, William. English Rambles and Other Fugitive Pieces, in Prose
and Verse. Boston, 1884.
"presentation copy from the author to Wilkie Collins"
[Bennett] {11}
525. Winter, William. The Press and the Stage, an oration. New York, 1889.
"only 250 copies printed cl."
[Dobell] {33}
529. Winter, William. The Trip to England. 2nd ed. Boston, 1881.
162 Wilkie Collins's Library
530. Wiseman, Nicholas Patrick. Recollections of the Last Four Popes and of
Rome in Their Times. 1858.
"ports, hf. cf. gt."
[Packer] {70}
Possibly a source for The Black Robe. Cardinal Wiseman (1802-1865),
Archbishop of Westminster.
534. Woodrooffe, Anne Cox. The History of Michael Kemp: The Happy
Farmer's Lad. 4th ed. 1830.
[name of buyer illegible] {170}
536. Wright, Thomas. Some Habits and Customs of the Working Classes. By a
Journeyman Engineer. 1867.
[Hartley] {21}
537. Young, Edward. The Complaint, and the Consolation; or, Night Thoughts.
With Marginal Designs by W. Blake. 1797.
Folio "hf. bd., edges uncut."
[Parsons] {239}
164 Wilkie Collins's Library
ADDENDA
Addition:
1
Sotheby's 18 June 1891 Sale containing WC's books is recorded in Index of
English Literary Manuscripts, Vol IV1800-1900 Part I Arnold-Gissing,
Compiled by Barbara Rosenbaum and Pamela White. London and New York,
Mansell, 1982. She also records a Sotheby's 3-4 June 1891 Sale containing
WC's "printed work" (665).
2
Cited Frederick G. Ribble and Anne G. Ribble. xliii.
3
ELS Monograph Series 24. Victoria, British Columbia: English Literary
Studies, University of Victoria, 1981.
Appendix
WC's first published book, his two-volume biography of his father, Memoirs of
The Life of William Collins, Esq., RA. With Selections from His Journals and
Correspondence published by the London publishers Longman, Brown, Green,
and Longmans in 1848, contains as an "Appendix," to the second volume, an
"enumeration" of his father's paintings (II, 341-352). The date of the painting is
followed by the title of the work, details of where exhibited, information on "for
whom painted, or by whom purchased" and then the sum received for the work.
Collins's biography of his father concludes with a two-page listing of
"Engravings from the Work of William Collins, R.A." (353-54).
Two years before her death, Harriet Collins agreed to the division of her
husband's paintings between her two sons. WC wrote to his mother on 11 May
1867: "Charley and I have tossed for the pictures, and Frith is coming today to
value Charley's half. Charley won the toss and chose first (to my astonishment!)
the upright Sorrento - (with the chestnut tree) - leaving the sea-Sorrento
(afterwards repainted large for Gibbons) to fall to me. We then went on
alternating. Charles chose next, the small park-[raling] landscape went with the
shadows on the road (near Hendon I think). I followed, and took the Roman
boy's heads! Charley followed . . . and took the green pool & weeds. I took next
the Devonshire stream. Charley took the (upright) Bembridge Sands. I took the
trees at Pond St. Charley took the copy from De Hoog. I took the portrait of my
Grand Mother, and there it ended." WC added, "I am quite content, and so is he.
You must certainly come to town - and see my Sorrento in its new and
beautiful, frame!" (Letters, II, 286).
166 Appendix
The evaluation by William Powell Frith (1819-1909), the Victorian painter and
close friend of both WC and Charles Collins, of the latter's share of his father's
paintings is unavailable. In the second volume of his biography of his father,
WC gives a description of the paintings realized at Sorrento. The painting of the
sea "possessed all the attractive simplicity of subject and purity of tone . . . a
view of the Mediterranean, with Vesuvius in the horizon, and a strip of beach
and promontory in the right-hand foreground - the whole being treated with
remarkable airiness and transparency of effect" (II, 191).
WC gave a copy of his Memoirs of his father to his literary agent and friend A.
P. Watt. The first of the two volumes, now in private possession, contains on its
front papers the inscription, "To A. P. Watt from | Wilkie Collins | April 21
1885". WC has annotated his "enumeration" of his father's paintings. The
undated annotations contain prices and purchasers. Tipped into the first volume
is a note in WC's hand, headed "Vol. I. Page 69":
Collins refers to the second chapter of his Life of his father, which covers the
years 1807-1816. He writes, "In the year 1815, my father exhibited at the Royal
Academy, - 'The Reluctant Departure,' (sold to Mr. Carpenter;) 'Half-holiday
Muster,' (sold to Lady Lucas;) and 'A Harvest Shower,' (sold to Mr. Currie)".
There follows a detailed description of "The Reluctant Departure" (I, 69-70).
Appendix 167
Christie, Manson & Woods auction sale at 8 King Street, St. James's Square, on
Saturday, February 22, 1890 contains "The Collection of Modern Pictures,
Water-Colour Drawings & Engravings of Wilkie Collins, Deceased." There are
sixty-six lots in all divided into twenty-six lots consisting of "Engravings and
Photographs - Framed." These are followed by a single lot consisting of "Sir
David Wilkie's palette" (lot 27) and by thirteen lots of "Water-Colour
Drawings" underneath which is the name of "W. Collins, R. A." - WC's father.
The remaining lots of "Pictures" are identified by the artist and then the title.
The following transcription follows the auctioneer's lot numbering. Whenever
any light can be thrown on a lot item, this is placed underneath the transcription
of the lot. The auctioneer's description is in italics. My annotation is not.
2. Portraits, &c.
11. Rubens' Son, and a Landscape after Rubens; and one after Rembrandt; &c.
18. The Fisherman's Home, after W. Collins, R. A. byJ. Phelps - artist's proof
WC's Appendix "Pictures Painted by William Collins, Esq., R.A." at the end of
the second volume of his Memoirs of the Life of William Collins, Esq., RA.
identifies a 1826 painting under the title "Fishermen Leaving Home for the
Night" - (afterwards entitled "The Fisherman's Departure"). The purchaser is
given as "J. Morrison, Esq" and the sum received as "350 gs." (346).
27. Sir David Wilkie's Palette Taken with him to Syria, and presented to William
Collins, R.A., by Wilkie's Sister
There is a detailed account of Sir David Wilkie's (1785-1841) close relationship
with William Collins, in WC's Memoirs, see especially I, 235.
Water-Colour Drawings
W. Collins, R.A.
29. A Common
31. At Sorrento
See Letters II, 286.
Pictures
38. A. W. Fowles.
The Yacht "Coquette" (in four views); and a photograph 2
In late June 1856 WC "went sailing with Pigott and Pigott's brother . . . . They
hired a boat of the Royal Yacht Squadron, the Coquette" (Peters 166): WC
describes, in a letter of 2 July 1856, his experiences on board whilst crossing the
Channel and entering the Bristol Channel (Letters, I, 156). A. W. Fowles of
Ryde (fl. 1840-1860), a maritime painter.
40. W. Gill.
Children, with a dog and mouse-trap
William Gill, fl. 1826-1869, exhibited at the Royal Academy: a follower of
David Wilkie.
41. C Collins
Portrait of a Lady, after Sir J. Reynolds
42. C Collins
The Empty Purse
43. C Collins
Nine Studies for Pictures
J. A. Gere observes in Pre-Raphaelite Drawings in the British Museum (1994)
that "the group of eighteen [Charles Collins] drawings in the Museum collection
was bought in 1891, for only £6 - 6 -, from Charles Fairfax Murray.. .. The
drawings by Collins had previously belonged to his brother Wilkie, who had
died in 1889" (101).
47. H Gray
Portrait of Wilkie Collins
Probably WC's "cousin, Henry Gray, who kept a picture dealer's shop in Old
Cavendish Street" Peters 269).
his Memoir of his father, WC recalls two of his father's sketches which "bear
the appearance of finished pictures." Of these, "the first is coloured with
surpassing brilliancy and vigour. Its foreground is a strip of cornfield, over-hung
by the branches of a large chesnut-tree; its distance, the olive-gardens of
Sorrento, the coast of Vico, the bright Mediterranean, and Vesuvius beyond."
The second also "looks towards Vesuvius . . . but from a different point. Here
the smooth limpid sea, with gay market-boats floating idly on its surface, ripples
into the foreground, tinged with the clear Italian reflections of the hour and
scene. A strip of beach, an extremity of rocky cliff, and the point of Vico,
presented the rest of the composition in Nature, and supply it in the sketch." WC
adds that "the airy delicacy and day-light of the effect thus produced proved so
popular in England, that the painter was commissioned to paint two pictures
from it. The original study, (for which many offers have been made,) remains as
well as the landscape first mentioned, a treasured heirloom in the family of the
painter" (II, 108-09). WC's Appendix listing his father's paintings contains
various paintings of Sorrento, Ischia and the Bay of Naples (II, 349, 51-52).
49. W. Collins, R. A.
Two Studies of the Head of a Roman Youth
50. W. Collins, R. A.
A Devonshire River Scene
Paintings by William Collins listed by his son include "Buckland on the River
Dart" exhibited in 1824 at the Royal Academy and purchased by E. P. Bastard,
Esq., M.P. for 120 gns. (II, 346).
51. W. Collins, R. A.
The Withered Tree
52. W. Collins, R. A.
Trees at Hampstead
53. W. Collins, R. A.
Portrait of Mr. Collins, father of the artist
William Collins (1740-1812), settled in London from County Wicklow and eked
out a living from picture dealing and restoring. He died a bankrupt. See Gasson
32.
54. A. Geddes
Portraits of Wilkie Collins and Charles Collins, when they were boys
Reproduced as Plate 3 in Letters, I, between [xlii-1]. Acquired at this auction by
WC's friend Horace Pym (1844-1896), and in possession of the Pym family until
174 Appendix
sold in the Pym auction, June 2001. Also reproduced as Illustration 5 in Peters
between 240-41.
55. C. Collins
Portrait of William Collins, R. A. - chalk
Probably "William Collins, 1846, from a drawing by Charles Allston Collins
National Portrait Gallery, London" reproduced as Illustration 3 in Peters
between 240-41.
61. W. Collins, R. A.
Portrait of the Artist's Mother
62. W. Collins, R. A.
Portrait of the Artist's Father: Studies of heads of children on the back
63. W. Collins, R. A.
A Landscape, with figures, after J. Ruysdael
Appendix 175
64. W. Collins, R. A.
The Virgin and Child
Exhibited at the Royal Academy 1843
65. W. Collins, R. A.
Antonio, from the "Merchant of Venice "
Exhibited at the Royal Academy, 1845
66. W. Collins, R. A.
A Patriarch
Exhibited at the Royal Academy, 1844
This page intentionally left blank
Index
All references to the Introduction and the Addenda are in bold and to page
numbers. References to the Reconstruction are to item numbers, not page, and
are not in bold.
Man, Isle of, 25, 36, 63; 148, 202 Moore, Thomas, 358
Manitoba, 13-14; 28 Moreau, J. M., 505
Marmontel, Jean Francois, 339 Morland, George, 8, 21, 60-61; 97
Marryat, Frederick, 6, 47, 61; 340- Morley (publisher), 510
341 Moscheles, Ignace, 62; 431
Marston, Edward, 342 Motte Fouque, Caroline, Baroness
Martin, Sir Theodore, see 'Gaultier De La, 229
Bon'. Mowbray, Walter Morris, 359
Mary, Queen of Scots, 27 Moxon, Edward, 316
Massett, Stephen C , 19, 30, 63; Mozart, Wolfgang, Amadeus, 261,
344 276
May (buyer at Puttick and Murphy, Arthur, 43, 45; 281
Simpson), 17,282,313, Music, 9, 25, 44, 62; 24, 33-35, 71,
316,419,458,496 252,256,261,276,318,
Mazeres, Edouard Joseph 322,344,431
Ennemond, 345, 350, 436
Medical testimony, 63; 356 Nadel, Ira B., 187,244,403
Medicine, 44, 62; 74, 478-479, Naigeon, Jaques Andre, 163
519-520 Nargeot, Pierre Julien, 40, 50; 363
Medwin, Thomas, 48; 347 Narrey, Charles, 364
Meilhac, Henri, 40, 50; 348 Netherlands, The, 360
Mejan, Maurice, 4, 8, 26, 38, 63; New America, 164
349 New Mexico, 140
Melbourne (Australia), 36, 54; 507 New York, 7,11, 15,17, 24, 29-32,
Melesville, Anne Honore Joseph, 36, 51, 65; 273, 380
40; 345, 350 New York (State), Ballston Spa,
Memoirs, 7-8,13, 21-22, 35, 41, 356
43-46, 48, 54-57, 60, 62- New York Tribune, The, 527
63; 35, 41, 73, 76, 89,93, New York (Wall Street), 57; 346
97, 129, 147, 154, 163, Newgate Calendar, 26; 275, 349
199,256-257,283,295, Newspapers, 2, 7, 35; 309, 367-368
298-299,317,320,336, Niagara, 29, 57; 260
347,384,416,424,472, Noise, 25, 62; 24
532-535 North America, 29, 42, 51, 55, 59;
Meryon, Edward, 353 84
Mexico, 58-59; 372, 426, 462-463 North Carolina, 142
Milton, John, 434 North West, The, 29
Moak, Nathaniel Cleveland, 19, 30, Northampton, 36; 514
63;356 Northcote, James, 232
Moliere, Jean Baptiste Poquelinde, Notes and Queries, 65; 338, 373
357 Nugent (buyer at Puttick and
Money (buyers at Puttick and Simpson), 7; 20, 43, 60,
Simpson), 26, 37, 91-92, 77,95,143,193,233,236,
259,380,390,453 265, 267-270, 272, 275,
Montagu, Elizabeth, 166 277,307,310,356,359,
Montenegro, 494 386,395,415,481,502
188 Index