RE: Case Number 15-F-0327 Application of Galloo Island Wind, LLC for a Certificate
of Environmental Compatibility and Public Need to Construct an Approximately
108.9-Megawatt Wind Electric Generating Facility in the Town of Hounsfield,
Jefferson County, New York
This is in response to the letter submitted by Mr. Timothy Scee, Supervisor in the Town of Hounsfield, on
June 14, 2018.
Mr. Scee complains that nine months have elapsed and Galloo Island Wind LLC's application has yet to be
deemed complete. In reviewing the numerous filings since their initial application last September, it appears
that the cause of the delay lies with the Applicant, and not with DPS, for not fully complying with requests
for additional information. Additionally, Mr. Scee infers that a prior, completely different project review
completed in 2009 under SEQ RA would have relevance to the current Galloo Island project. Mr. Scee goes
so far as to state " ... in fact that pe1mit may still be valid." We certainly hope that is not the case.
The approval of a prior project should have no merit or bearing in this Article 10 proceeding. A close review
of the Examiners' transcripts from the July 2016 Pre-application conference seems to confirm that findings
from the prior project were not applicable to the current Applicant's project. Among other issues, Mr. Scee
neglects to note that the new project proposes turbines nearly twice as tall as the prior proposal and, as such,
would render the two projects dissimilar enough to merit a brand new and independent project review.
In a separate issue, we note that the Town of Hounsfield 's Zoning Laws were rewritten three times since
2009 (2012, 2014, 2016) and yet not a single revision provides an allowable use of wind turbines on Galloo
Island. In fact, Hounsfield's current law effectively bans wind turbines on Galloo Island.
The Applicant states in their application that they comply with all Town Zoning Laws. They are misleading
in their suggestion that their project constitutes "Essential Services" on Galloo Island. The definition of
"Essential Services", as taken from the Town of Hounsfield Zoning Law, is "The erection, construction,
alteration, operation or maintenance by municipal agencies or publicly regulated utilities of telephone dial
equipment centers, electrical or gas substations, water or sewer treatment or storage structures, pumping
stations and similar structures related to public service." Emphasis is added that only "municipal agencies
Sincerely yours,