deposits
Robert J Scott David Selley Stuart Bull
Centre for Ore Deposit Research Centre for Ore Deposit Research Centre for Ore Deposit Research
University of Tasmania, Hobart University of Tasmania, Hobart University of Tasmania, Hobart
robert.scott@utas.edu.au d.selley@utas.edu.au s.bull@utas.edu.au]
INTRODUCTION
SUMMARY
A systematic relationship between the distribution Known copper deposits in the Zambian Copperbelt (ZCB)
grossly stratiform Cu-deposits, basin architecture, and account for 46% (~90 Mt Cu) of the total production and
facies associations in the Zambian Copperbelt (ZCB) reserves of the Central African Copperbelt, the largest and
suggests the deposits formed at sites of former significant highest grade known sediment-hosted copper province on
accumulations of both mobile and/or in situ Earth. The ZCB deposits are hosted by the Neoproterozoic
hydrocarbons. Deposits occur within a 200 m Katangan Supergroup, a relatively thin, moderately to highly
stratigraphic window containing the first laterally- deformed succession of marginal marine and terrestrial meta-
extensive, fine-grained, originally organic-rich strata sedimentary rocks, deposited in an intra-continental rift or
within the host Katangan Supergroup. Arenite-hosted passive margin setting between ~877 and ~600 Ma (Selley et
deposits occur within, or immediately overlie confined or al. 2005). The Katangan Supergroup consists of the Lower
peripheral portions of sub-basins formed during the and Upper Roan Groups, Mwashia Group and the Lower and
initial stages of sedimentation and are overlain by Upper Kundelungu Groups, and has an entire preserved
relatively impermeable strata; sites with classical thickness of less than 5 km in the ZCB. The majority of the
hydrocarbon trap geometries. Direct evidence for the ZCB deposits are broadly stratiform and hosted by either
former presence of hydrocarbons (e.g. pyrobitumen) is argillites (70% of ore) or arenites (30% of ore) of the Lower
lacking in the ZCB, however anomalously light carbon Roan Group.
isotopic signatures for both vein and matrix carbonate,
spatially associated with the ores, are interpreted to The origin of the ZCB deposits has been the subject of
record the oxidation of organic matter synchronous with conjecture for over 70 years. Syn-orogenic and shear zone-
ore formation. hosted models for at least some deposits have recently been
proposed (Molak, 1995; McGowan et al., 2003). However,
Antithetic distributions of (early diagenetic) wall-rock
the gross geometry of the deposits indicates most clearly
anhydrite and sulfides at many ZCB deposits suggest
formed prior to significant folding of the host successions
sulfur in the deposits was largely sourced and reduced in
during the ~590–500 Ma Lufilian Orogeny. Accordingly
situ. A local source for migrated hydrocarbons and
syngenetic to early diagenetic models have dominated
evidence that extensive in situ thermochemical sulfate
published work on the ZCB deposits since the 1950s.
reduction accompanied or preceded ore formation
requires pre-mineralisation burial of the host rocks to
Our petrographic and geochemical studies in the ZCB suggest
depths approaching or exceeding the maximum preserved
copper deposition was synchronous with intense potassium
thickness of the Katangan succession in the ZCB. This
metasomatism of argillaceous rocks (e.g. Selley et al., 2005).
indicates Cu-mineralisation occurred late in the
However, while potassium metasomatism affected almost the
depositional history, perhaps during initial stages of basin
entire Lower Roan throughout much of the ZCB (including
inversion at the onset of onset of Lufilian orogenesis after
rocks at stratigraphic levels well above the copper deposits),
~600 Ma, but prior to significant folding of the host
the major copper deposits all occur at or close to the level of
succession.
the Copperbelt Orebody. Member of the Lower Roan Group
(and correlates east of the Kafue Anticline). Although the
Key words: Zambian Copperbelt, sediment-hosted dolomitic shale and siltstone facies of the Copperbelt Orebody
stratiform copper deposits, hydrocarbons, Member forms the major ore host, all major lithofacies in the
thermochemical sulfate reduction. Lower Roan (i.e. clean to argillaceous sandstone and
conglomerate, siltstone, shale and even massive carbonates)
(a) 10
10 organic matter originally (e.g. Annels, 1979). Thus the
Neopr oterozoic
marine carbon ate presence of highly depleted carbon isotopic values for
55
interstitial carbonate cements in these units is best explained
00 by accumulation of migrated hydrocarbons. In this regard, it
is particularly noteworthy that the most depleted carbon
-5
-5 isotopic values within the Mindola Clastics Formation come
δ C (‰, P DB)
Figure 2. Carbon and oxygen isotope data from Roan and Sulfur isotope data from the ZCB, particularly for the arenite-
Mwashia Group carbonates from the Zambian hosted deposits, can also be interpreted in terms of a
Copperbelt. (a) Coupled depletion in both δ13C and δ18O hydrocarbon-replacement model for the copper deposits.
relative to Neoproterozoic marine carbonate is best Seawater sulfate or (evaporitic) anhydrite formed during early
explained by the oxidation of organic carbon. (b) diagenesis are the most likely sulfur sources for the ZCB
histogram showing the range in carbonate δ13C values for deposits. Partial to complete replacement of early diagenetic
samples containing greater and less than 100 ppm Cu. Cu anhydrite by carbonate and sulfides at several deposits, and
mineralised samples show a clear bias towards low δ13C the grossly antithetic distributions of anhydrite and sulfide at
values, suggesting the oxidation of organic carbon (e.g. many ZCB deposits (e.g. Garlick and Fleischer, 1972;
through reaction with anhydrite to produce H2S) Fleischer et al., 1976; Annels, 1974; 1989; Sweeny and Binda,
accompanied copper mineralisation. From Selley et al. 1989) suggest in situ reduction of wall-rock sulfate, provided
(2005). a major source of reduced sulfur for many of the copper
deposits (Annels, 1974; 1989; Sweeny and Binda, 1989).
Although metamorphic volatilisation and decarbonation can
produce coupled δ13C and δ18O depletions in carbonates, this Sulfur isotope values for anhydrite from the lower Katangan
does not explain the trend to very low δ13C values observed in Supergroup typically lie in the range 14–19‰, compatible
the ZCB. Isotopic depletions related to metamorphism should with Neoproterozoic seawater. Assuming an average
be similar for all carbonate in a given area. However, reservoir δ34Ssulfate value of 17‰, arenite-hosted deposits have
unmineralized massive to microbially-laminated dolomites in ∆SO4-sulfides values 5 to 17‰ while fractionations for argillite-
both the Copperbelt Orebody Member and the Upper Roan hosted deposits range from 11 to 30‰ (Figure 3). The
Group retain typical Neoproterozoic marine carbonate contrasting sulfur isotope systematics suggest different
signatures (δ13C = +10 to –5 ‰ and δ18O = 19 to 26‰; processes or sulfur sources were involved in the formation of
Jacobsen and Kaufman, 1999; Figure 2). Interaction with a the argillite- and arenite-hosted deposits.
moderate to high temperature (e.g. 150 to 350°C) fluid can
also decrease δ13C and δ18O values for sedimentary carbonate δ34S values for H2S produced by closed-system
(e.g. Hitzman and Beatty, 1996). However such depletions thermochemical sulfate reduction due to interaction with
rarely exceed 5 to 8 ‰ for δ13C and 10 ‰ for δ18O. hydrocarbons should approach δ34Sreservoir sulfate where
Interaction with hydrothermal fluids is thus unlikely to thermochemical sulfate reduction proceeds to completion
explain trends in the ZCB isotopic data, where depletions of (Orr, 1974). The generation of mature H2S-rich hydrocarbon
up to 30‰ in δ13C and 20‰ in δ18O occur (Figure 2). reservoirs prior to copper introduction may account for the
ZCB arenite-hosted systems with anomalously low degrees of
Fluviatile arenaceous units of the Mindola Clastics Formation sulfur isotopic fractionation (e.g. ∆SO4-sulfides values of 5 to
as well as those hosting the Mufulira orebodies east of the 6‰, Figure 3). Arenite-hosted deposits showing greater
Kafue Anticline, are unlikely to have contained significant excursions from Proterozoic seawater δ34S values are
interpreted to record either open system behaviour or
AESC2006, Melbourne, Australia. 3
Hydrocarbon replacement model for the ZCB deposits Scott, Selley, Bull, Broughton, Hitzman,
Cooke, Large & McGoldrick
incomplete reduction of wall-rock sulfur. Mineralogical Mineralogical evidence for the nature of reductants
evidence (discussed below) supports the former presence of
Most alteration styles in the ZCB, including those coeval with
H2S reservoirs at the giant Mufulira system. However, the
copper mineralization, are regional in extent and are not
relatively large average ∆SO4-sulfides value of 16.6‰ and
indicative of either proximity to ore, or ore forming processes.
particularly large range of δ34Ssulfide values (21.4‰) at this
In contrast, sericite development at the expense of detrital ±
deposit suggests that either thermochemical sulfate reduction
secondary K-feldspar (and to a variable extent Ca- and Mg-
was incomplete (due either to sluggish reaction kinetics or the
bearing phases) at several arenite-hosted deposits (most
large volume of in situ sulfate present), or that additional
notably Mufulira, Chibuluma, and Chibuluma West) is largely
sulfur was introduced at the time of sulfide precipitation.
restricted to, or centered on, the highest grade portions of
these systems (Darnley, 1960; Annels, 1979). These spatial
associations suggest that K-feldspar destruction was
intimately related to copper deposition at these deposits; in
stark contrast to the marked K-feldspar enrichment evident in
Cu-mineralized argillaceous rocks elsewhere the ZCB.
CONCLUSIONS
Geological Engineering at the Colorado School of Mines Gustafson, L.B. and Williams, N., 1981, Sediment-hosted
(CSM). We acknowledge the financial support provided by stratiform deposits of copper, lead, and zinc, in Skinner, B.J.,
the Australian Research Council, financial and logistic support ed., Economic Geology, 75th Anniversary Volume, 139-178.
provided by the 12 industry sponsors and Alan Goode
(AMIRA International) for his key role in project Hitzman, M.W., and Beaty, D.W., 1996, The Irish Zn-Pb-(Ba)
management. In addition we thank CODES PhD students Orefield, in Sangster, D.F., ed., Carbonate-Hosted Lead-Zinc
Mawson Croaker and Nicky Pollington for their valuable Deposits: Society of Economic Geologists Special Publication
contributions to this study. 4, 112-143.
Annels, A.E., 1989, Ore genesis in the Zambian Copperbelt, Ohmoto, H. and Goldhaber, M.B., 1997, Sulfur and carbon
with particular reference to the northern sector of the isotopes, in Barnes, H.L., ed., Geochemistry of Hydrothermal
Chambishi Basin, in Boyle, R. W., Brown, A. C., Jefferson, Deposits, 3rd Edition, New York, Wiley, 517-612.
C.W., Jowett, E.C. and Kirkham, R.V., eds., Sediment-hosted
Stratiform Copper Deposits: Geological Association of Orr, W.L., 1974, Changes in sulfur content and sulfur isotope
Canada, Special Paper 36, 427–452. ratios during petroleum maturation - study of Big Horn basin
Paleozoic oils: AAPG Bulletin, 50, 2295-2318.
Darnley, A.G., 1960, Petrology of some Rhodesian
Copperbelt orebodies and associated rocks: Institute of Selley, D., Broughton, D., Scott, R., Hitzman, M., Bull, S.,
Mining and Metallurgy Transactions, 69, 137-173. Large, R., McGoldrick, P., Croaker, M. Pollington, N. and
Barra, F., 2005, A new look at the Zambian Copperbelt,
Dechow, E. and Jensen, M.L., 1965, Sulfur isotopes of some Economic Geology 100th Anniversary Volume, 965–1000.
central African sulfide deposits: Economic Geology, 60, 894-
941. Sweeney, M.A. and Binda, P.L., 1989, The role of diagenesis
in the formation of the Konkola Cu-Co orebody of the
Fleischer, V.D., Garlick, W.G., and Haldane, R., 1976, Zambian Copperbelt, in Boyle, R. W., Brown, A. C.,
Geology of the Zambian Copperbelt, in Wolf, K.H., ed., Jefferson, C.W., Jowett, E. C. and Kirkham, R.V., eds.,
Handbook of Strata-bound and Stratiform Ore deposits, 6, Sediment-hosted Stratiform Copper Deposits: Geological
223-352. Association of Canada, Special Paper 36, 499-518.
Garlick, W.G. and Fleischer, V.D., 1972, Sedimentary Worden, R.H., Smalley, P.C. and Oxtoby, N.H., 1995, Gas
environment of Zambian copper deposition: Geologie en souring by thermochemical sulfate reduction at 140C: AAPG
Minbouw, 51, 277-298. Bulletin, 79, 854-863.