11/16/12 "Architects in China are lost" - Neri&Hu

Home
About
Submit a story
Advertise
Contact
Newsletter
Cookies policy

Search Go

Dezeen
Digital publisher of the year 2012

Older story »
Upgrade to Google+ for free to publicly recommend this.

“Architects in China are lost”

– Neri&Hu

Share 0 Tw eet 21 Like 13 2 0

16 November 2012 | Leave a comment

More:

Interviews
News

News: Chinese architects need to develop their own design manifesto to stem the tide of “half-assed” building projects in the country, according to Lyndon Neri and Rossana
Hu of Shanghai studio Neri&Hu.

Speaking to Dezeen in Shanghai last week, the duo talked about “the absence of a modern Chinese architecture and design language” and added: “Architects feel lost”.

Neri and Hu made the comments at the opening of their Design Republic Design Commune in the city’s Jingan district, where they organised a series of discussions about the
need for a new design manifesto for China.

Hu said the loss of belief is common to architects around the world, but is particularly critical in China due to the frenetic pace of development in the country. “A lot of architects
in the US are lost, but there are no projects,” Hu said. “Here, we are lost and we are building cities.”

Neri added that Chinese developers often brief their construction teams by pointing to pictures in magazines: “It’s done in such a half-assed way that it becomes scary,” he said.

Last week Neri&Hu Design and Research Office invited international designers, architects and founders of design brands to Shanghai to discuss their own design manifestos at
the opening of the building, which will be used to introduce Chinese audiences to design.

At the launch they distributed a booklet resembling Chairman Mao’s Little Red Book containing a series of slogans such as “We seek beauty in the everyday” and “We
denounce design for the sake of design, “which intended to stimulate debate about the meaning of design.

“If you tell people this kind of stuff here, they don’t understand why you’re even doing it,” said Hu. “In the west, when you tell people about this, at least they understand why
you’re searching. They might be lost, but they know that they are lost. People are lost here, not knowing they’re lost. That’s a real danger.”

www.dezeen.com/2012/11/16/architects-feel-lost/ 1/15
11/16/12 "Architects in China are lost" - Neri&Hu
Last month Aric Chen, the creative director of Beijing Design Week, told Dezeen that China needs to “slow down” and pay more attention to issues of authenticity, process and
identity.

See all our stories about Neri&Hu | See all our stories about Shanghai

Top photograph of the Shanghai skyline is from Shutterstock.

Here’s an edited transcript of the interview with Lyndon Neri and Rossana Hu, conducted by Dezeen editor-in-chief Marcus Fairs:

Rossana Hu: Lyndon and I are both architects but after we started our architecture practice here in Shanghai we also started another company called Design Republic. Design
Republic is really a platform for design. We started with a retail concept but there are other things with regards to Design Republic that we’d like to incorporate into the retail
environment.

One of them is education: educating the public about design, to bring designers from different parts of the world to China, to speak, to show their work, to engage with dialogue
with the local designers here.

Lyndon Neri: The idea is to bring the best of what the world can offer to China. And hopefully, one day, our aspiration is to bring the best of what China can offer from a
design point of view back to the world.

Rossana Hu: This week at the Design Republic Design Commune we are opening the space to the public and we’re having a two-day symposium series called Manifesto.
We’ve invited a lot of guest speakers from all over the world to come and talk about design in different ways.

If we don’t do this, and we only show and sell products, it’s just meaningless. And vice-versa, if we only do the talks, and you read about these products but you don’t see
them, you don’t touch them, that’s also meaningless. And that was the case [in Shanghai] before Design Republic opened. You couldn’t see classic modern design anywhere.
There were no design museums, there were no shops that sell modern classics. People were just not interested.

Lyndon Neri: The idea of Manifesto started about actually seven years ago when Rossana and I edited a book called Persistence of Vision. We interviewed fifty architects
practicing in Shanghai. We asked them twelve questions.

At the back of our mind was the notion of trying to find a manifesto in a city that is so busy; a city that is just building like mad. We realised that it was important to make sure
that people are thinking, having a discourse.

Rosanna Hu: It all derived from when we first started working here. We were talking to both local and overseas Chinese who returned about working, the conditions of
working here, and everyone’s so busy and has no time to think, no time to talk to each other. And every time you do have time to talk, it’s five to ten minutes, and you can never
really engage in a meaningful way. And we thought, okay, if everyone feels that way, then that means everyone must welcome the chance to engage.

So we did the book as an effort to bring about community, and it did I think. It made all the people we interviewed rethink about why it is they’re here. We asked a lot of
questions about culture, space, location, your work; what your responsibility as an architect and designer is; are you happy with what you’re doing here; those types of
questions.

So we wanted Design Republic to be a platform, and the retail just became the easiest thing to start because the form of a shop is easy. It is something that people understand:
you sell products.

But there are other things that we wanted to do: create a brand that incorporates other designers in China to bring about a Chinese voice in modern design; to be able to bring it
to the world and to engage in the problems that exist here today.

Marcus Fairs: And how does that relate to what you’re doing here? A lot of the speakers you have for your Manifesto talks here are from the West.

Rosanna Hu: From the book project we realised a lot of people were asking what today’s manifesto in design is. And actually that’s not just a Chinese problem; it’s a global
problem. Architects feel lost, we’re no longer confined within architecture with the big A, the way I thought we were say fifteen years ago, twenty years ago. It was probably
easier to design because everyone shared certain beliefs. We believe in manifestos, we believe that you need to stake your belief. If you know your dream, then you can chase
after it.

Lyndon Neri: And be rigorous about it.

Rosanna Hu: And also we notice the absence of a collective voice. The absence of a modern Chinese architecture and design language.

Lyndon Neri: In China, the phenomenon of copying is very great. So people look at magazines and they go, “I could sort of do this minimalist thing, I’ll have the contractor do
something like this.” It’s done in such a mama huhu way; a half-assed, half-baked way that it becomes, you know, scary.

Marcus Fairs: Shanghai’s quite funny to that extent because you have these western-style skyscrapers with Chinese details bolted on the top. It’s quite surreal.

Rosanna Hu: Yes, and I mean it goes back to our thesis projects in graduate school. I remember having a discussion with my teacher at Princeton. I remember talking to him
about my thesis proposal, discussing the problem of modernism, and regionalism versus globalism. He thought that to modernise means basically what Rem [Koolhaas] believes:
the tabula rasa. There’s no history; that’s all baggage that you don’t need. But I still insist that you are who you are. None of us can erase our past, and you bring the baggage
www.dezeen.com/2012/11/16/architects-feel-lost/ 2/15
11/16/12 "Architects in China are lost" - Neri&Hu
with you and you’ve got to work with the baggage that you have.

And how do you then exist as a contemporary architect, working with a modern architectural language? How do you exist in this environment, what is it that we take with us?
Maybe it’s not our history from the Ming and Qing Dynasties or even earlier. Maybe it’s what we see today. Maybe it’s the toilet that’s across your nongtang [traditional
Shanghai lane-house] window that you can see from your neighbour’s bathroom, or it’s the broom that everyone hangs up. Maybe it’s those very kind of mundane things of the
everyday that gives you a clue to what to design.

But also, we recognise that we’re only one part of the world, and we’re only one very small part of the larger Chinese modern context. I like to learn from other disciplines, and
I think that to learn from, say, how Chinese modern literature, Chinese modern art, Chinese modern music, has evolved to where they are today.

The modern [Chinese] language, the writing system is actually influenced from English writing; the same with poetry. People have gone abroad, studied and brought things back.
You know if you look at the [Chinese architects] who are doing significant work here, very few of them have actually never done work abroad: Yung Ho [Chang] Ma
[Qingyun], Ma Qingyun, Ma Yansong. Most of use went abroad, and now we are all back here, taking what we’ve learned and creating something new.

Lyndon Neri: [Vancouver-based architect and designer] Omer Arbel said something very interesting today when he was asked what he would say to Chinese architecture
students. He says, growing up, it was easy to model his career on the protagonists of his time. In his case it was Rem Koolhaas. But then quickly he realised it was not just
unattainable, but it was so abstract that to people in Vancouver it was meaningless. So then he started finding meaning within the context that he was practising, and that became
interesting.

Marcus Fairs: You mentioned that these are global issues; to what extent are they issues in China too?

Rosanna Hu: It is even more of an issue here because more people are working here, and it’s at a faster pace.

Lyndon Neri: It’s amplified, exaggerated.

Rosanna Hu: So if you get lost, you get lost faster. And if you fall, you fall deeper.

Lyndon Neri: A lot of architects in the US are lost, but there are no projects. So they could be lost and not build. Here, we are lost and we are building cities. We’re building
cities, you know. For crying out loud!

Rosanna Hu: If you tell people this kind of stuff here, they don’t understand why you’re even doing it. They don’t understand the need to have a manifesto. In the west, when
you tell people about this, at least they understand why you’re searching. They may not have it, they might be lost, but they know that they are lost. People are lost here, not
knowing they’re lost. That’s a real danger.

Marcus Fairs: So the manifesto needs to be figured out pretty soon. And how are you going to do that?

Rosanna Hu: I don’t really see that there needs to be an end. I don’t think it’s like saying, “Okay, once we formulate our manifesto, then this is it.”

Marcus Fairs: You produced a little Manifesto booklet for the opening event [above and below].

www.dezeen.com/2012/11/16/architects-feel-lost/ 3/15
11/16/12 "Architects in China are lost" - Neri&Hu

Rosanna Hu: We really worked hard [on that]. We really thought about it and the reason why it’s mostly blank pages is so that you write your own. And then they’re offset
with quotes from both Chinese writers, poets and Western writers’ quotes about life, about ideals, about utopia. This helps you set the tone. It’s the beginning but the key is that
you’re searching for something, and that your work will hopefully stand for something.

See also:

Sotto Sotto by HRC Design Works

The Design Republic Commune by Neri&Hu

“China is a dream scenario for a desig…

www.dezeen.com/2012/11/16/architects-feel-lost/ 4/15
11/16/12 "Architects in China are lost" - Neri&Hu

Design Collective by Neri&Hu

Foster + Partners exhibition to open in …

Qingpu Youth Centre by Atelier Deshaus

Tea House by Archi-Union

Inside awards: the Waterhouse at South B…

Inside awards overall winner: The Waterh…

Older story »

Share 0 Tw eet 21 Like 13 2 0

16 November Leave a commentMore:

2012
Interviews
News
China
Neri&Hu
Shanghai

Posted on Friday, November 16th, 2012 at 12:04 pm by Marcus Fairs. See our copyright policy.

www.dezeen.com/2012/11/16/architects-feel-lost/ 5/15
11/16/12 "Architects in China are lost" - Neri&Hu

Comments
There are no comments posted yet. Be the first one!

Post a new comment

Enter text right here!

Comment as a Guest, or login: facebook

Name Email Website (optional)

Displayed next to your comments. Not displayed publicly. If you have a website, link to it here.

Subscribe to None Submit Comment

See our comments policy here.

Top 10 Shanghai Tours DRM Premade Houses

local travel agency, lowest price "Book C anadian Quality - C ost efficient-
Now ! " with a large choice C ustomizable - Transportable Homes
www.tour-be ijing.com www.DR MLTD.ca

Magazine
Movies
Jobs
News
Watch Store
Book of Ideas

Newsletter
www.dezeen.com/2012/11/16/architects-feel-lost/ 6/15
11/16/12 "Architects in China are lost" - Neri&Hu

Enter email Join

Magazine feed
Screen feed
Jobs feed
@Dezeen on Twitter
Dezeen on Facebook

Latest news

“Architects in China are lost” – Neri&Hu

Twenty-ton treehouse under construction in Sweden

Zaha Hadid to design Japan National Stadium

BD Barcelona Design celebrates 40th birthday with hand-painted vases by Jaime Hayon

www.dezeen.com/2012/11/16/architects-feel-lost/ 7/15
11/16/12 "Architects in China are lost" - Neri&Hu

“China is a dream scenario for a designer” – Michael Young

Latest products

Bottleware by Nendo for Coca-Cola

Trix chair by Schmidinger Möbelbau

Pheasant Light by Ed Carpenter for Theo

Claudio Chair by Arquitectura-G

107 Chair by Robert Stadler for Thonet

Ads by Google

www.dezeen.com/2012/11/16/architects-feel-lost/ 8/15
11/16/12 "Architects in China are lost" - Neri&Hu

House From China

Search Largest C hina
Supplier Base. Verified
Global Exporters-Join Free
www.Alibaba.com

Liberte@Sarkies
Condo
Fh, Loft 3.3m C eiling. 2
min Mrt. VVIP save 24%
Discount, 98511599
www.libe rte -condo.com

Architect
Residential
Narita Architects
contemporary residence
architecture
www.narch.ne t

Design Architect
Viewer
Download AutoVue: View
& Markup Mentor Design
Architect & more EDA.
www.oracle .com /autovue

Architectural
Projections
Five questions answered
in 3D Projection Mapping
www.3DProje ctionMapping…

Architecture
Interiors
Design

We’ve just been to:

Shanghai

www.dezeen.com/2012/11/16/architects-feel-lost/ 9/15
11/16/12 "Architects in China are lost" - Neri&Hu

This week we like:

sand

Reader comment: “A Marmite

piece of architecture”

Architecture categories
Skyscrapers
Residential
Public and leisure
Cultural
More »

Interiors categories
Retail
Residential
Office interiors
Restaurants and bars
More »

Design categories
Furniture
Products
Homeware
Fashion
More »

News: US military invests

in 3D printing

Follow us

www.dezeen.com/2012/11/16/architects-feel-lost/ 10/15
11/16/12 "Architects in China are lost" - Neri&Hu

Features
Slideshows
Interviews
Movies
Podcasts
More »

Events
2012 «
Beijing Design Week 2012
Clerkenwell Design Week 2012
Cologne 2012
DMY Berlin 2012
Dutch Design Week 2012
Interieur 2012
Istanbul Design Biennial 2012
London 2012
London Design Festival 2012
Milan 2012
Paris 2012
Stockholm 2012
Venice Arch Biennale 2012
Vienna Design Week 2012
WAF 2012
2011 »
2010 »
2009 »
More »

Archive
2012 «
January 2012
February 2012
March 2012
April 2012
May 2012
June 2012
July 2012
August 2012
September 2012
October 2012
November 2012
2011 »
2010 »
2009 »
More »

Dezeen Screen
Architecture movies
Design movies
Interiors movies
Interviews
More »

www.dezeen.com/2012/11/16/architects-feel-lost/ 11/15
11/16/12 "Architects in China are lost" - Neri&Hu

Dezeen Jobs
Architecture jobs (17)
Internships (11)
Interior design jobs (11)
Design jobs (9)
More »

Dezeen Watch Store

Shin Azumi
Yves Behar
Achille Castiglioni
David Ericsson/VOID
More »

Movie: Magnus Pettersen on

east London’s creative vibe

Movie: swings that

generate electricity

Recommended on Facebook

www.dezeen.com/2012/11/16/architects-feel-lost/ 12/15
11/16/12 "Architects in China are lost" - Neri&Hu

Create an account or log in to see w hat

Sign Up
your friends are recommending.

Bent perforated facade by Chris Kabel

35 people recommended this.

Cardboard Bicycle by Izhar Gafni

228 people recommended this.

US m ilitary invests in 3D printing on the

frontline
142 people recommended this.

A Sign in Space sand prints by Gunilla

Klingberg
578 people recommended this.

House in Yam asaki w ith rooftop sheds by

Tato Architects
128 people recommended this.

The Dynam ic D*Haus by The D*Haus

Com pany
296 people recommended this.

Tåkern Visitor Centre by Wingårdhs

112 people recommended this.

Los Soprano by Pedro Scattarella - Dezeen

21 people recommended this.

Donky Bike by Ben Wilson

197 people recommended this.

Facebook social plugin

What people are saying about

Dezeen
Polifactory @Dezeen Yes we agree, it is a
reality in terms of design quality!
27 minutes ago · reply · retw eet · fav orite

Dezeen "Architects in China are lost," say

Neri&Hu: dezeen.com/2012/11/16/arc…
52 minutes ago · reply · retw eet · fav orite

atlgreenpages Bottleware by Nendo for

Coca-Cola zite.to/TSDZPb via @zite
26 minutes ago · reply · retw eet · fav orite

Polifactory @Dezeen Yes we agree, most

architects from china are kind of lost in
terms of design quality! but others are yet
really good!
25 minutes ago · reply · retw eet · fav orite

mohow What I want for Christmas:

bit.ly/Swq9jO (via @Dezeen)
24 minutes ago · reply · retw eet · fav orite

we_love_ad #Dezeen: â​ A rchitects in China

​
are lostâ​
​â​
​Neri&Hu | News: Chinese
archite... Read more: twitpic.com/bdohjp
4 minutes ago · reply · retw eet · fav orite
Join the conversation

Follow @dezeen

Dezeen Music Project:

featured track

www.dezeen.com/2012/11/16/architects-feel-lost/ 13/15
11/16/12 "Architects in China are lost" - Neri&Hu

Like
Like Share
Share
Brian Lewis Smith
So It Go es
Like Download
Share

4.10

87 1 2

Listen to all the tracks here »

Dezeen Mail #127

The latest issue of Dezeen Mail includes the best stories and comments from readers plus new jobs, competitions, movies and more.

Enter email address Join

Try Dezeen’s new search

Dezeen on Facebook
Like

204,429 people like Dezeen.

E lsie 鷹 Iolanda N ov ianto A na

C alendA rq S ilv ia Iv a S eoungeun Rajeev

А наст асия A ndrea H arshita M atteo Tejas

S ilv io บอส F lorian Le H oang Bruno

F acebook social plugin

www.dezeen.com/2012/11/16/architects-feel-lost/ 14/15
11/16/12 "Architects in China are lost" - Neri&Hu

Home
About
Submit a story
Advertise
Contact
Newsletter
Twitter
Facebook
RSS
Data protection
Copyright info

Search Go

Are you looking for a job in architecture or design? Visit our recruitment site Dezeen Jobs
Dezeen Watch Store

Out now! Dezeen Book of Ideas

www.dezeen.com/2012/11/16/architects-feel-lost/ 15/15