Anda di halaman 1dari 2

Advantage: Cat

Cat 336E L Excavator vs.


®

John Deere 350G LC


PERFORMANCE/ Caterpillar: John Deere:
OPERATOR
EFFICIENCY • Max digging forces available full time in all modes • Max digging forces only available with Power Dig
with no additional operator input required. button, limited to 8 seconds per push.
• Cat® emissions solution works with no operator • Fuel dosing may require operator intervention and
intervention. possible stationary regeneration (downtime).
• Fully integrated auxiliary hydraulics ease work • Auxiliary and coupler circuits not fully integrated,
tool changes and maximize performance. often require manual hydraulic adjustment.
• Time delay lighting for nighttime safety and MP3 • Does not have time delay lighting or MP3 capable
capable radio for enhanced operator comfort. radio.

RELIABILITY/ Caterpillar: John Deere:


DURABILITY
• High-pressure hydraulic hose for max uptime, no • Lower pressure hydraulic hose.
recommended replacement interval. • Shorter bolts without spacers in the swing bearing
• One-piece forged swing bearing flange and long joint lessen clamping load.
bolts with spacers maximize clamping load. • Single-walled sheet metal doors more susceptible
• Heavy-duty service doors with auto-catch hinges to damage, need manually installed door catches.
ease maintenance access. • Thinner bottom guards not as effective against
• Heavy-duty bottom guards protect components track debris and site material.
from track debris and site material. • Lighter gauge electrical wiring.
• Industrial-grade electrical wiring with diagnostic
coding eases service and minimizes downtime.

SERVICEABILITY/ Caterpillar: John Deere:


SAFETY
• Key-turn electronic fuel priming pump for ease of • Manual fuel priming pump may result in
service and low risk of pre-fill contamination. technicians pre-filling filters during service.
• Full firewall separates engine and pump • A partial firewall allows open access between
compartments. engine and pump compartments.
• Top platform, ample handrails, wide anti-skid • Narrow platform in front of the engine, raised bolt
punched plating, and recessed bolt heads. heads, sandpaper-type traction material.
• Standard case drain hydraulic filter provides • No case drain filter provided.
added protection against system contamination. • Aftermarket quick coupler with controller
• Integrated quick coupler controller in the console mounted against glass in sight line.
with audible alarm to guide operator.

336E Advantage: Fuel Efficiency


The Deere 350G LC increased fuel consumption by 1 gph over the prior Deere D series due to fuel dosing for emissions. The Cat 336E L
300 hp engine consumes the same amount of fuel per hour as the Deere 350G LC @ 271 hp engine, which translates into the 336E L
delivering more production using the same amount of fuel.
This document is intended as a reference for internal use by Caterpillar and Cat dealer personnel only. Some statements may be subjective based on operator observation or customer
feedback. Please do not distribute, reproduce or copy.
Advantage: Cat
Cat 336E L Excavator vs. John Deere 350G LC

Fuel Efficiency Comparison


APPLICATION: PRODUCTION (ton/hr) FUEL CONSUMPTION (gal/hr) FUEL EFFICIENCY (ton/gal)
Truck Loading Cat 336E L vs.
Deere 350G LC 10% CAT ADVANTAGE COMPARABLE 10% CAT ADVANTAGE
Source: Production Study, Tinaja Hills, 2013

Specifications

Cat 336E L Deere 350G LC


OPERATING WEIGHT – lbs (kg) 79,600 (36,100) 76,557 (34,726)
Cat C9.3 ACERT™ John Deere PowerTech PSX
ENGINE MODEL
U.S. EPA Tier 4 Interim U.S. EPA Tier 4 Interim
ENGINE DISPLACEMENT – in3 (L) 568 (9.3) 549 (9.0)
ENGINE NET POWER – hp (kW) 300 (224) 271 (202)
ENGINE MAXIMUM – rpm 1800 1900
MAIN PUMPS MAX FLOW – gal/min (L/min) 153 (578) 152 (576)
MAXIMUM HYDRAULIC PRESSURE – psi (Bar) 5,366 (380) 4,974 (373)
TAIL SWING RADIUS – ft.-in. (m) 11'5" (3.49 m) 11'10" (3.6 m)
MAXIMUM DIGGING DEPTH – ft.-in. (m) 26'10" (8.19 m) 26'10" (8.19 m)
MAXIMUM GROUND LEVEL REACH – ft.-in. (m) 38'5" (11.7 m) 38'6" (11.73 m)

Customer Advantage Demo Tips


• The Cat 336E L has faster cycle times than the Deere in high- • Highlight smooth multi-function control with varying amounts
power mode for better productivity. of bucket payload through a wide range of motion.
• Even with a higher hp engine, Cat 336E L fuel consumption is • Show the machine at greater dig depths to highlight superior
similar to Deere in high-power and ECO modes. Advantage is in speed under load (hydraulic horsepower advantage).
standard mode – Cat 336E L burned 1.5 gal. less than the Deere. • Begin with machine in maximum power (HP+), then
• The 336E L delivers more productivity using the same or less demonstrate STD and ECO modes to stress fuel savings with
fuel (depending on mode) than the Deere. no loss of breakout force.
• Caterpillar integrated solutions including work tools, auxiliary • Maximum breakout is always available with no added
circuits, quick couplers, Product Link™, Cat Grade Control. complexity of a time-limited Power Dig button.
• Tier 4 Interim emissions solution is transparent to the • Explain and demonstrate the versatility and integration of the
operator, takes care of itself, and requires no maintenance. tool control auxiliary system by showing the work tools listed
• Strong focus on key safety features throughout the machine. in the machine monitor, resulting in automatic reconfiguration
• Better resale value – higher auction value estimates for a of flow and pressure settings from inside the cab.
5-year ownership period. (Source: VET Auction Value Estimator). • Use the quick coupler to showcase the versatility, integration,
• Lower estimated parts prices. (Source: Price Comparison, 8/2012). and speed of safe work tool changes.

Materials and specifications are subject to change without notice. Featured machines in photos may include additional equipment.
See your Cat dealer for available options. CAT, CATERPILLAR, BUILT FOR IT, SAFETY.CAT.COM, their respective logos, ACERT, AEXQ1247-00
Product Link, “Caterpillar Yellow” and the “Power Edge” trade dress, as well as corporate and product identity used herein, are ©2014 Caterpillar
trademarks of Caterpillar and may not be used without permission. All rights reserved.

Anda mungkin juga menyukai