Anda di halaman 1dari 5

NOTES

Whatever Happened brings in discomfort in the spaces of


many academic institutions. It is not

to Women’s Studies merely the academic and political


debates raised by scholars in women’s
studies that bring in this discomfort. The
presence of the discipline is further
M S Sreerekha linked to the epistemological question of
who can speak for whom; as in, women

T
More and more women’s studies he historical journey of women’s should speak/think/study only about
centres and courses in gender literacy and women’s education women (one can replace women with
in India has gone through many Dalits or any other marginalised sec-
studies are being introduced in
phases—from the danger of the possibi- tions). This is more relevant especially in
India but the academic relevance, lity of “good girls from good families” a context when conventional disciplines
recognition and role for women’s/ writing love letters, of making women still try to maintain their academic bound-
gender issues within the broader literate or educating them “just enough” aries within their specific epistemologi-
to be “good wives or mothers,” to the cal paradigms. Thus, these marginalised
space for social sciences are
journey to streams like home science or disciplines in the academia have to
still very marginalised. One the never-ending promotion of voca- struggle to prove their credibility to
major challenge is posed by the tional trainings for women. All these speak or listen to beyond the conven-
dominant patriarchal thinking phases were steps which women and tional disciplinary boundaries. It is also
feminists in India have climbed in order certain that as an academic discipline,
within academic institutions
to reach where we are today with women’s/gender studies would chal-
and their administrative wings, women’s/gender studies. lenge the epistemological base of many
which interfere or control the However, “what do you do/teach disciplines and it will further challenge
functioning of these centres there?” is not just a common question other disciplines on their capability to
asked by the ignorant, but even by many break the barriers, to question the exist-
while being mostly unaware of
who are members of academic institu- ing social hierarchies and marginalisa-
the thoughts and developments tions. One is not or should not be sur- tion, and contribute to bring in social
within the discipline. prised with the question at all, though change. Furthermore, women’s/gender
sometimes the question comes not just studies scholars are entitled to speak
from mere ignorance but more from a from a location of advantage, gendering
politically motivated intentional igno- each discipline while raising many fun-
rance. This is not just the case of women’s damental epistemological challenges to
studies centres but of other relatively conventional social science disciplines,
new disciplines like Dalit studies (which even more than Dalit studies.
is a part of the programme for the study Women’s studies in India as an aca-
of social exclusion and inclusive policies) demic discipline has a history of more
too—though many in this case are clearer than four decades. Other than the wom-
about what is being taught. As an integral en’s studies centres, we also have vari-
part of society, what happens in society ous non-academic forums for addressing
and its power structures will certainly women’s rights/issues in academic insti-
reflect in academic institutions too. tutions, and there has been a gradual
Interestingly, just as a reflection of this, process and change among these for-
disciplines like women’s studies/gender ums—from ladies’ forums or women’s
studies/sexuality studies or Dalit studies cells to gender studies forums—address-
in most of the academic institutions ing non-academic, academic or political
are also marginalised in a similar way issues related to women’s/gender/sexu-
within its internal structures. This is ality issues. There are women’s studies
reflected in the resources provided to centres initiated and funded by state
them or the positions or power shared governments, independent, autonomous
by them within academic institutions academic institutions and government
M S Sreerekha (sree.sathi@gmail.com) is at the which are comparable. institutions under the guidance of the
Sarojini Naidu Centre for Women’s Studies, Whether women’s or gender studies, University Grants Commission (UGC).
Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi.
the very introduction of the subject still There are around 160 women’s studies
64 APRIL 9, 2016 vol lI no 15 EPW Economic & Political Weekly
NOTES

centres in the country today under the Desai et al 1984; Khullar 2000; Poonacha dilemmas and challenges it faces today.
UGC, divided into different phases 2003; Anandhi and Swaminathan 2006; As shown by many scholars, women’s
(phases I, II, III and advanced studies John 2008; Patel 2010; Rege 2011, among studies in India is certainly an outcome
centres) running different academic others). In a conference paper, “Whose and contribution of the women’s move-
programmes in women’s/gender studies. Past, Whose History and Whose Tradi- ment in India; however, it is important
The discipline is in an important phase tion? Indigenizing Women’s Studies in to note that both women’s studies and
in its history where it is shaping itself India,” Vina Mazumdar (2000) presented the women’s movement in India have
while facing many challenges internally a biographical note on her life and her re- gone through major changes in the past
and externally, and these are epistemo- lationship with the women’s movement three decades. The change in the termi-
logical, methodological and institutional. and women’s studies in India, her jour- nology from the monolithic “women’s
There are ongoing deliberations around ney with the Committee on the Status of movement” to “women’s movements,” the
its practice of multidisciplinarity, its Women in India (CSWI 1974) and the emergence of Dalit women’s movements
choices from being a discipline to being challenges she faced in working for the and the other, not-so-visible, real chal-
a perspective, its relationship with the discipline in the 1970s. Here, Mazumdar lenges posed by Adivasi women, Muslim
women’s movement, its curriculum devel- rejected the notion of a value-neutral so- women, transgender women and women
opment and its institutional structures; cial science, and argued for an activist, from other marginalised sections are
and as far as the discipline is concerned, interventionist role as a social responsi- extremely important in this context.
each of these are extremely relevant bility. For her, scholars within institu- The challenges from postmodern
issues of debate. tions had to be involved in understand- debates towards the very existence of the
Though there are more and more ing and eliminating the obstacles, inher- subject and the category of woman and on
women’s studies centres, and courses in ited from the past and flowing from the construction of the woman/gender/
women’s/gender studies are being intro- the present. The need of the time was to sex and sexuality also brought forth more
duced in the country, the academic focus on issues like producing data on epistemological and methodological ques-
relevance, recognition and the role for women or to generally bring women’s tions to address. Along with the mono-
women’s/gender issues within the issues into the centre of social sciences. lithic subject “woman,” the earlier focus
broader space for social sciences are still Discussing the role of Centre for Women’s on the working class woman also had to be
very marginalised. One major challenge is Development Studies (CWDS) and the problematised, and here the postmodern
certainly the dominant patriarchal think- twin movements of women and women’s debates and the plurality of the patriar-
ing rampant within the academic insti- studies in India, Mazumdar explained chies it brought in were a real challenge.
tutions, including within their adminis- how the CWDS, CSWI and the Indian Coun- An important task in the contemporary
trative set-up. In some ways, the admini- cil for Social Science Research (ICSSR) times thus remains the ability to under-
strative set-up in many academic institu- worked together towards organising the stand the extent of its failure in recog-
tions interfere or control the functioning Asian Workshop on Women’s Studies nising, addressing or constructively re-
of these centres while being mostly in 1982. flecting upon the challenges raised by
unaware of the thoughts and develop- The struggle for a space of its own for these Other women’s movements.
ments within the discipline. Further, the women’s studies in the academia and in In the present context, the thrust on the
history and growth of the discipline in social science in India goes back to those history of the relationship of the women’s
India also brings in some other relevant years; in her words, “We drew our expe- movement with women’s studies should
issues which, as far as the discipline is riences and pleaded for an acceptance of be seen more as a reflection of the politi-
concerned, is more self-infused or self- women’s studies as a method to indi- cal commitment of those who nurtured
reflective in nature. A critical rethinking of genise social sciences in Asian countries the discipline earlier. The changes in the
whatever happened to “women’s studies,” with a major focus on exploring and women’s movement through NGOisation
especially with regard to its relationship grappling with the realities in the or the engagement of women’s studies
with the women’s movement, is signifi- lives of the majority of our women.” For centres with non-governmental organi-
cant in this context. Mazumdar, the relationship between sations (NGOs) through many “extension”
women’s movement and women’s studies activities are relevant today for a critical
Extension and Action will be an ongoing and complex process, analysis and a rethinking towards the
Much has been written by Indian scholars reflected in the turbulence and creativity trends in the discipline. The impact of
on the history of women’s studies, on displayed by the women’s studies move- NGOisation on movements, especially the
the challenges it faced and the contri- ment. While challenging the role of value- women’s movement, has been studied in
butions it has made. From its pioneer neutral social science was extremely depth by scholars in the field (Biswas
Vina Mazumdar to Sharmila Rege, many relevant for a feminist standpoint in 2006). The later developments in women’s
have contributed to the debates around women’s studies, the argument towards studies centres in many cases show a
the discipline (Mazumdar and Sharma an activist and interventionist role gave direct nexus with funded NGOs. However,
1979; Ganesh 1985; Krishnaraj 1988a, a different direction to the discipline, while the women’s studies centres got
1988b, 2005; Balasubrahmanyan 1993; which I feel has had an impact on the themselves to working with NGOs through
Economic & Political Weekly EPW APRIL 9, 2016 vol lI no 15 65
NOTES

activities of empowering women in the connected directly with the movement. access to resources, which is otherwise
field, this did not necessarily mean a link However, many women’s studies centres available for a permanent faculty.
with the important debates raised by the continued or still continue to function The ignorance of the authorities or the
women’s movement in the past. There only within this “extension activity” administration on “what do you do there”
continued to be invisibility and discon- framework (considering the fact that can thus actually have a direct impact
nect between many important debates there are less than 20 centres which are on the faculty too where the absence of a
in the history of autonomous women’s in Phase III or advanced stage today in a permanency to their position will deter
movements/groups and the discipline. total of around 160), though this phase them from taking any strong step to
The NGOisation of the discipline took of a limited focus on academic activities overcome the obstacles from within.
place more clearly in those women’s has come under severe criticism, more so However, it is always possible to find
studies centres which involved them- in contemporary times. In the process of space to struggle against such situations;
selves only with action-oriented projects their extension activities and NGOisation, as an example of such a situation, the
or research (those centres which were/ these centres left out any clear agenda author would like to narrate briefly her
are in phases I and II as per UGC norms either in academics or in activism. The personal experience. Under the tenure of
or have/had no academic programmes). very word extension itself is problematic Najeeb Jung, the previous Vice Chancellor
Further, in this context, many academic and apolitical in nature, but “extension of Jamia Millia Islamia (the present Lt
institutions and their administrative set- activity” became the only activity for many Governor of Delhi), the centre for women’s
up intentionally made it a point that centres. This is discussed by Anandhi studies at Jamia Millia Islamia was com-
women’s studies programmes were to and Swaminathan (2006) on the question pletely NGOised. Not only that, it went
focus only on extension activities, train- of disciplining women’s studies. They through the cutting down of access to
ings, networking, advocacy, capacity build- point out how the UGC failed to spell out teaching papers for students to less than
ing and community work in partnership the linkages between research, teaching half from the earlier days; then, with the
with NGOs, and not to stress on research or and extension work, and further how implementation of the sixth central pay
teaching. This was happening even though this diluted the earlier conceptualisation commission, the university decided that
they were clearly part of established aca- of women’s studies as a critique of the staff of the women’s studies centre
demic institutions that were otherwise knowledge production itself. Neverthe- (who were appointed on grade pay as
into serious academic work in other dis- less, taking a cue from the thrust given per the fifth pay commission) will not be
ciplines. It is important to notice that by the UGC to extension activities, many given the benefits of the pay commission
such an environment also brought forth institutions which were uncomfortable since their appointments were tempo-
existential dilemmas to the members of with the political and academic relevance rary in nature. There was no explanation
these centres; as to whether they are of women’s studies used this situation to given on how this could be valid. After a
even part of an academic institution or further prevent any meaningful academic two-year-long attempt at a dialogue with
working in an NGO. The ghettoisation of intervention by these centres. This became the university, this author was orally
women’s studies centres thus happened the de facto rationale for these institu- told by the then vice chancellor to either
this way where centres were dominated tions to sideline women’s studies centres quit or go to court. The non-implementa-
and controlled by the patriarchal elements and keep them in their place. tion of the sixth pay commission in only
in academic institutions, including both one centre was totally illegal and against
men and women, who used this space to Forever Temporary the Equal Remuneration Act, 1976. The
superficially convince the academic Other than the imposition of extension author had to fight a case in the Delhi
world of “doing something for women.” activities, keeping these centres forever High Court against the university, UGC and
Those who have studied the history of temporary in nature has remained ano- the Ministry of Human Resource Devel-
the discipline must be familiar with words ther way of ensuring its marginalisation opment. The high court gave a favourable
like “extension” and “action” through (unlike other disciplines or centres, UGC- judgment to the petitioner though it
UGC’s earlier documents and reports in sponsored centres are renewed on a plan took three years, while three contempt
which these activities were given extreme basis in every five years and the staff then of court strictures were issued against
importance. Though Mazumdar’s position will remain temporary till the scheme/ the main respondent, the university.
on the activist and interventionist role of plan lasts, and though the UGC guide- It is not easy to fight a court case while
the discipline was relevant, this is then lines clarify that these centres should continuing to work at the same institu-
later interpreted as if the main responsi- gradually be taken over by the institution, tion; however, it was the struggle for rights
bility of the discipline was only to act and many do not consider this possibility or and justice, and many years of activism
intervene which led or actually misled delay it endlessly). Not only does the tem- in Delhi and the precious support from
the discipline from its earlier times. Per- porariness of the centres have an impact friends that helped to battle it out.
haps, the intention behind the extension on running regular academic courses, it However a ray of hope that came in its
activities was to keep reminding one of renders the staff of these centres ex- wake was the further support from the
the history and politics of the discipline; tremely vulnerable, affecting their intel- UGC towards women’s studies and also
to make sure that the discipline remains lectual ability and contribution and their the support from the new administration
66 APRIL 9, 2016 vol lI no 15 EPW Economic & Political Weekly
NOTES

at the university towards new academic consistent samples of research. Women’s/ in the academic world, hopefully the dis-
programmes in women’s/gender studies. gender studies have made major contri- cipline will no more see initiating courses
While the temporariness of an academic butions to the methodological debates in like computer applications/NGO Manage-
centre will certainly have an impact on research about the power hierarchies ment and Women. However, strangely, the
the development and expansion of the between the researcher and the re- UGC in its present guidelines for women’s
discipline, it is not just women’s studies, searched. However, instead of further studies is still giving priority to capacity
Dalit studies too is in the same state, both enriching the debates in the existing building for women managers, consider-
victims of marginalisation in the aca- feminist research methods, such inter- ing women’s studies centres as the right
demic set-up for reasons mentioned ventions run the risk of taking feminist place for these. Obviously, the challenges
above. The sword of temporariness is still research praxis two steps back in beco- for the discipline and its practitioners
hanging on the heads of these centres in ming tokenistic. While the challenge of and believers are enormous.
many academic institutions. NGOisation or a balanced thread between There has been a thought for some time
In addition to this, while issues like its activism and research continues, the now, sometimes bordering on sarcasm,
sexual harassment continue to be an discipline is certainly accorded a much that anything related to women or gender
important challenge within academic higher status as far as the question of is easy to be published or sold. With a
institutions where they are still struggling ethics and responsibility is concerned in massive increase in the number of publi-
with measures towards curtailing it, comparison with many other academic cations, there is also a dilution of the
women’s studies centres in many institu- disciplines. It is relevant to see that a political agendas of the women’s move-
tions are burdened with this job as good academic and political under- ment, contributing towards its further
another extension activity, as if the issue standing of an issue is a must before depoliticisation. Incidentally, the com-
of sexual harassment is just their responsi- entering into research in the field. mercialisation and corporatisation of
bility, and not of the entire institution. higher education is also happening, along
Further, academicians involved with Enormous Challenges with the need for women’s studies centres
the women’s studies centres were/are At present the UGC’s attempt is to make in this atmosphere to struggle to prove the
expected to be in the field, helping the women’s studies centres more aca- employability of the subject. Rege (2011)
empower women. Unlike any other social demic oriented, to initiate more academic has addressed the question of employ-
science discipline, from sociology to programmes, along with teaching and ability in detail and argued around the
social work or even Dalit studies, women’s research, and a focus on the development new teaching experiments in women’s
studies centres are expected to prove their of a new teaching curriculum (as shown studies with a better and holistic under-
social commitment by directly being in in the Twelfth Five Year Plan). Towards standing of the crisis in practices of
the field. There has been no debate or this, the UGC in 2009, with the help of its higher education, especially in social
understanding on this—about how or why Standing Committee in Women’s Studies, sciences in India. However, in fact, it has
these centres, especially in the absence initiated a Curriculum Development Com- become easier to prove that the discipline
of academic programmes, should directly mittee at the national level which worked has more market than any other social
engage with the field without any histori- towards a common model curriculum in science discipline and so the need for
cal, conceptual, theoretical or academic women’s/gender studies for the whole expansion. Few scholars in the discipline
understanding or knowledge of the country. Research in women’s/gender understand the relevance of the relation-
struggles and issues. In fact, on many studies has come a long way from the ship between an academic, political and
occasions such engagements have been or 1970s to now, debating feminist research epistemological feminist discourse and
can be more damaging rather than pro- methodologies and its epistemological the history of the relationship between
ductive. There are two relevant issues standpoints. Both Rege (2011) and Anandhi autonomous women’s movements and
here worth mentioning. One is the fact and Swaminathan (2006) have analysed women’s studies in this country. And these
that in an academic context, the involve- the developments in women’s studies in scholars have to struggle now to fight
ment of a student or a staff in fieldwork depth, contributing to bringing out the the NGOisation of the women’s studies
or related research activities should be challenges in teaching women’s studies programmes and also to create more space
supported by academic (both epistemo- in India. Rege (2011) discussed in detail the for the Other(s) movements into women’s
logical and methodological) learning, in challenges within its interdisciplinarity, studies academia, without which the dis-
the absence of which the very act of such its intellectual and institutional expansion, cipline and its relevance is bound to fail.
an engagement is meaningless. its practices in higher education, its A major increase in academic publish-
Further, many a time (this is applica- employability and its pedagogical growth ing on gender, sexuality, and the grow-
ble not only to women’s studies centres) and practices. Anandhi and Swaminathan ing scholarship in Dalit women’s studies
the subjects of such temporary activist (2006), while addressing the pedagogical as well as in identity struggles and
interventions from academic institutions development, also analysed the institu- movements is certainly a silver line to-
have turned hostile against their re- tionalisation, its patterns and initiatives in wards the growth of the discipline. Thus,
searchers in the absence of any change different contexts. As they reflect upon it is not necessary to emphasise that
in their real life other than just being how to make women’s studies relevant whatever has happened to the so-called
Economic & Political Weekly EPW APRIL 9, 2016 vol lI no 15 67
NOTES

upper-caste/upper-class monolithic/singu- or women with anything under the sun. intellectually engaged with and taught
lar women’s movement in the past is det- Though this trend is changing, it is cer- just the way Marxism, Socialism or any
rimental to women’s studies. It is also tainly a challenge to encourage serious other ‘isms’ are dealt with as a stream of
not necessary then to fear that an end of scholarship in the discipline. political thought. However, an impor-
extension activities will be detrimental The patriarchal masters of conven- tant challenge for women’s studies as a
to the link between the women’s move- tional disciplines have used this tricky discipline in India is still to survive in
ment and women’s studies. Moreover, it conundrum many a times—the problem academia without getting NGOised or
should not be religiously argued that with you feminists is that you are ques- otherwise marginalised and thus failed
teaching in women’s studies in every tioning without reading the originals! by the patriarchies within the academia
way should always have a direct link to And feminists worked on these for long, and its institutions. While the historical
the women’s movement in terms of ac- long enough till they realised that there journey is taking it closer to its destina-
tion. Instead, a focus on academics is no end to the so-called originals, un- tion, it helps (just like in any other disci-
should be primary for academic institu- less and until they themselves start pro- pline) if women’s studies scholars too
tions. There is a need to recognise and ducing some. The institutionalisation of are good academicians who can bring in
accept that the danger of NGOisation of women’s studies also led to questioning a balance between activism and acade-
women’s studies is more hazardous than of its members, the women’s studies mics which is close to feminist politics.
it becoming more academic or convert- scholars, dragging them towards a guilt
ing itself into an examination or re- trip about making it a profession and References
search subject. Certainly it is a complex making a living in the name of women. Anandhi, S and Padmini Swaminathan (2006):
“Making It Relevant: Mapping the Meaning of
process. Further, it is detrimental for However, it is necessary to recognise Women’s Studies in Tamil Nadu,” Economic &
the discipline to go with those who ar- and assert that the academic work done Political Weekly, 21 October, p 4444.
gue against academic intervention; that in many of the women’s studies centres Balasubrahmanyan, Vimal (1993): “Teaching Women’s
Studies: The Problems,” Economic & Political
women’s studies should take place only are more meaningful than in many oth- Weekly, 31 July, p 1572.
in the field and that its agenda is to em- er disciplines. In fact, those who are con- Biswas, Nilanjana (2006): “On Funding and the
NGO Sector,” Economic & Political Weekly,
power women. Especially those who cerned with whatever is happening in 21 October.
have been part of the autonomous wom- the sector of higher education in India Chakravarti, Uma (2003): “Oppositional Imagina-
tions,” Narratives from the Women’s Studies
en’s movement in India will be more today should certainly rethink the rele- Family, Devaki Jain and Pam Rajput (eds), New
wary of such terminologies like empow- vance of many conventional academic Delhi: Sage, pp 355–71.
erment, knowing its history of appro- disciplines in its present structure. It is CSWI (1974): “Towards Equality,” Report of the Com-
mittee on the Status of Women in India, GOI.
priation in the world of development. also important along with this to ad- Desai, Neera et al (1984): “Women’s Studies and
dress the question of marketisation of the Social Sciences, a Report from India,” The
Anything under the Sun Feminist Press, Women’s Studies Inter national,
higher education to see actually what is No 3, 2–6 April.
Women’s studies has a long and stable being given back to the society. Ganesh, Kamala (1985): “State of the Art in Women’s
Studies,” Economic & Political Weekly, 20 April,
history and is no more a new discipline. It is true that a shift from the term p 683.
However, when it comes to addressing “women” to “gender” has helped a bit in John, Mary E (2008): Women’s Studies in India: A
women’s or gender issues many prefer to the academic space; so far as the doubting Reader, India: Penguin.
Khullar, Mala (2000): “The Siamese Twins: Wom-
stick to their parent discipline with a minds are concerned, it now is not merely en’s Movement and Women’s Studies in India,”
gender perspective. To extend this trend talking about women. This shift along with Seminar, Women’s Studies in Asia, Volume V.
Krishnaraj, Maithreyi (1988a): “Perspectives for
and its contribution, there is even the the missing subject—the woman—the Women’s Studies,” Economic & Political Weekly,
argument that some of the most interest- allegation of depoliticisation of the move- 13 August.
ing work in women’s studies is being pro- ment and along with this, new studies on — (1988b) “Women’s Studies: Case for a New Par-
adigm,” Economic & Political Weekly, 30 April.
duced independent of women’s studies the plurality of patriarchies, masculinity — (2005): “Research in Women Studies,” Economic
centres (Chakravarti 2003). However, studies, etc, all have been relevant issues & Political Weekly, 9 July.
Mazumdar, Vina (2000): “Whose Past, Whose His-
while this trend can be welcomed, it is of debate. However, I believe it is time to tory, Whose Tradition? Indigenizing Women’s
still extremely important to see the end the debate of choosing between Studies in India,” Centre for Women’s Develop-
ment Studies, New Delhi.
trends within the discipline and its future women and gender in academics, con- Mazumdar, Vina and Kumud Sharma (1979):
directions. Moreover, the challenge of the sidering the increasing relevance of men “Women’s Studies: New Perceptions and the
Challenges,” Economic & Political Weekly,
impact of a value-neutral social science and masculinity studies both in a very 20 January, p 113.
and the dominance of conventional dis- academic and political sense. The depo- Patel, Vibhuti (2010): “Dynamics of Women’s Stud-
ciplines and its burdening with a tradi- liticisation of the subject women through ies and Women’s Movement,” Economic & Poli-
tical Weekly, 14 August, p 35.
tion still continue. Further, while many the introduction of the concept of gender Poonacha, Veena (2003): “Women’s Studies in
consider that only issues around/of can be addressed through intentional ini- Indian Universities; Current Concerns,” Eco-
nomic & Political Weekly, 28 June, p 2653.
women should be taken up by women’s tiatives towards a politicisation or re- Rege, Sharmila (2011): “Women’s Studies since the
studies centres, the other extreme is to politicisation of the vast framework of 1990s: Mapping New Conjuncture, Challenges
and Strategies,” Insights and Interventions:
expect scholars in women’s or gender gender and sexuality studies. And the Essays in Honour of Uma Chakravarti, Kumkum
studies to be experts in linking gender history and politics of feminism can be Roy (ed), Primus Books.

68 APRIL 9, 2016 vol lI no 15 EPW Economic & Political Weekly

Anda mungkin juga menyukai