Anda di halaman 1dari 10

T H E AMERICAN JOURNAL OF CLINICAL PATHOLOGY

Vol. 35, No. 5, pp. 393-402 May, 1961


Copyright © 1961 by The Williams & Wilkins Co.
Printed in U.S.A.

A MICROSCOPIC STUDY OF DERMAL GUNSHOT WOUNDS


LESTER ADELSON, M.D.
Laboratory, Cuyahoga County Coroner's Office, and the Institute of Pathology, Western Reserve University
School of Medicine, Cleveland, Ohio

The medicolegal importance of evidence fatal episode and discloses the finer details
that may be obtained by careful examination of this unique variety of injury.
of wounds produced by bullets has long Rationale of the study. The firing of a
been recognized. In view of this, it is sur- bullet involves a chain of explosive chemical
prising that virtually nothing with regard reactions. Flame, hot gases, fragments of
to the microscopic characteristics of bullet burned, burning, and unburned powder,
wounds is to be observed in the English or and perhaps small particles of metal shaved
American literature. This paper deals with off of the bullet, precede and follow the
descriptions of the histologic features of rapidly moving pellet (ball, missile) from
entrance and exit wounds produced by a the muzzle. Any or all of these substances
variety of weapons at different ranges of may be present in or on the target, human
fire. or otherwise, depending on the distance
An autopsy is the most reliable key to the between target and muzzle, type of am-
correct solution in fatal gunshot incidents munition, variety of weapon, and so on.
in which the sole witnesses were the assailant It may be accepted as a truism that all
and the (dead) victim, or where several cartridges of modern firearms are loaded
witnesses offer conflicting and contra- with some type of smokeless powder.
dictory information. The classic anatomic The products of the muzzle blast are
approach to the gunshot fatality involves responsible for the zone of charring and the
meticulous description and accurate localiza- fouling and stippling ("soiling"), popularly
tion of the external wound or wounds, miscalled "powder burns," which are
followed by complete autopsy with explora- invariably present on the skin, or clothing,
tion of the entire bullet tract, visualization or both, of the victim with contact or near
of all injuries, and recovery of all bullets wounds. The flame of the muzzle blast
and bullet fragments in the body. Pains- produces surface burns if the skin is within
taking study of the victim's clothing, range. The bullet, heated by the friction
together with such ancillary technics as resulting from its passage through a tightly
photography, x-ray, and chemical studies fitting barrel and the explosion within the
(Walker test), is an essential corollary of the chamber, creates thermal injury in the
anatomic examination. deeper areas, as well. The blast may become
Bullet injuries are among the most a factor in the production of skin damage
complex lesions encountered in forensic with contact and close wounds.
pathologic practice. Careful scrutiny of the
wounds is essential for correct reconstruction METHOD
of the shooting incident. Microscopic
study of surface and deeper gunshot wounds Microscopic sections stained with hema-
provides yet an additional avenue for toxylin and eosin were made from entrance
exploration to aid in the recreation of the and exit gunshot wounds excised from
victims of fatal shootings as part of routine
anatomic examination. Police reports were
Received, July 22, 1960; revision received, Aug- consulted for the circumstances surrounding
ust 12; accepted for publication January 13, 1961.
the fatal episode, including facts revealed
Dr. Adelson is Pathologist and Chief Deputy
Coroner, Cuyahoga County Coroner's Office, and by investigation of the scene, interrogation
Assistant Professor of Forensic Pathology, De- of witnesses and suspects (when available),
partment of Pathology, Western Reserve Uni- type of weapon, and other pertinent data.
versity School of Medicine, Cleveland, Ohio. Inasmuch as the presence of clothing (light
393

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ajcp/article-abstract/35/5/393/1768356


by Airlangga University user
on 23 February 2018
394 ADELSON Vol. 35

or heavy, single or multiple layers, type of visible soiling of the intact skin. Powder
fabric) at the site of bullet entry may residue is always present in the subcutaneous
significantly alter the dermal characteristics and deeper areas.
of an entrance gunshot wound, special 2. Close or near. The skin adjacent to the
attention was directed to the effects pro- bullet perforation and its areola of abrasion
duced by the victim's garments. is fouled and sometimes stippled ("soiled").
Powder residue is almost always present on
W O U N D S OF ENTRANCE the surface and within the defect, in the
Entrance gunshot wounds are usually subdermal areas, and occasionally in the
round or elliptical perforations with an more deeply situated regions.
areola of abrasion where the pellet has 3. Distant. All tissue damage results
rubbed off the epithelium. When the pellet solely from the missile.
strikes the skin, it first indents and then
stretches the surface so that perforation Observations
occurs through a taut area. After the pellet
has completed its passage through the skin, The histologic findings will be grouped
the resiliency of the tissues restores the according to the type of wound, i.e., contact,
previous state of turgor, and the defect near or close, and distant, and the changes
contracts. As the skin is being stretched classified as epithelial, collagenous, and
over the nose of the missile, it is burned, powder residue.
abraded, and soiled over an area larger
than the opening itself. Marginal abrasion Contact Type
and soiling are the hallmarks of entrance 1. Epithelial changes. Epithelial damage
of gunshot wounds and are observed at all in tight contact and loose contact wounds
ranges.1-3 results from a combination of mechanical
Thus, an entrance wound is usually and thermal trauma, the former produced
smaller in diameter than the bullet which by the impact of the rapidly moving pellet,
made it, and one can not establish with any and the latter from a combination of muzzle
degree of accuracy the caliber (diameter) flame and hot missile. A distinctive feature
of the bullet from the dimensions of the of all entrance wounds, regardless of the
skin perforation. Moreover, the missile may range of fire, is a more or less orderly series
"tumble" and strike the target in profile of changes in the epidermis, ranging from
or at some irregular angle ("key hole"). little or no alteration at the periphery,
This is likely to happen if the victim is through varying degrees of cellular dis-
struck by a ricochet. In such instances the tortion and disruption, to total epithelial
skin perforation may be greater than the destruction and absence at the center
diameter of the bullet. (Fig. 1). As the perforation is approached,
A halo of oil or grease is occasionally the first significant cytologic evidence of
present at the edges of the perforation, injury is provided by a region of compressed
representing material wiped from the and distorted epithelial cells, many revealing
bullet during its passage through the skin. "streaming" of the nuclei (Fig. 2). This
The amount of this type of marginal soiling area is succeeded by a region in which the
varies with the nature of the projectile. more superficial epithelial layers are absent.
Lubricated lead bullets cause more soiling Only the deeper extensions of the rete pegs
than nonlubricated jacketed missiles. remain in situ at the edge of the perforation
(Fig. 3). In the defect, all epithelial elements
For purposes of the present discussion
are absent. If contact between muzzle and
and descriptions, entrance wounds were
skin was not tight (especially when one or
classified on the basis of naked eye appear-
more layers of clothing are interposed),
ances into the following 3 types:
there may be scattered foci of epithelial
1. Contact. The margins of the perforation damage surrounded by essentially normal
are charred with occasional fouling of the tissue. This pattern probably results from
abraded border, and there is no grossly

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ajcp/article-abstract/35/5/393/1768356


by Airlangga University user
on 23 February 2018
May 1961 GUNSHOT WOUNDS 395

PIG. 1 (upper). Entrance wound at contact range. Intact skin at left (periphery)
with compression, distortion, and loss of epithelium at right (perforation). Promi-
nent collagenous changes in dermis. Minimal powder residue (PR). Weapon was a
23-20 Marlin rifle. Hematoxylin and eosin. X 35.
FIG. 2 (lower). Elongation and "streaming" of epithelial nuclei on surface of
entrance wound. Prominent perinuclear halos. Focus of PR on surface. Weapon was
a P 38 automatic. Hematoxylin and eosin. X 440.

deflection and spread of the muzzle blast muzzle. The latter may be sufficiently hot
by the clothing (Fig. 4). to carbonize the epidermis. This is partic-
A distinction should be made between 2 ularly true in the case of muzzle blast from
varieties of heat injury which may be shotguns and large-caliber or high-velocity
present in the epithelium. One is produced sporting rifles with their relatively massive
by the hot missile, and the other results heat production. The hot bullet is more
from the burning gases expelled from the likely to produce a coagulative type of

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ajcp/article-abstract/35/5/393/1768356


by Airlangga University user
on 23 February 2018
396 ADELSON Vol. 85

necrosis rather than carbonization.4 The scattered collections of brown-yellow


basal epithelial cells frequently manifest needles. Abundant PR is usually seen on
nuclear swelling and vacuolization, indicat- the surface of the epithelial defect (Fig. 3)
ing this latter type of thermal injury (Fig. and in the subcutaneous tissue of a contact
2). Blast may partially separate the entire entrance wound. PR is frequently observed
thickness of the epithelium from the corium. grossly and microscopically in the deeper
2. Collagenous changes. Thermally induced areas (muscle and bone) and even in the
changes in the dermal collagen are observed underlying viscera, having been carried to
in all entrance wounds. In sections stained these relatively remote sites through several
with hematoxylin and eosin 2 striking layers of soft and osseous tissues by a
collagenous characteristics are present. The combination of blast and bullet soiling. It is
first one involves the tinctorial properties not unusual to find PR in the brain beneath
and is manifested by amphophilia, basophilia, contact or near wounds of the head or in
or chromophobia. With the first 2 types of the thoracic organs with similar wounds of
changes, the affected fibers stain variously the chest (Fig. 5).
from a deep blue-red through a variety of Relatively little PR is observed on the
colors to a mottled gray-blue. These changes skin surface immediately adjacent to the
result from heat coagulation. If the temper- defect if contact was tight between muzzle
ature has been sufficiently high to car- and skin. With loose contact there may be
bonize the tissue, chromophobia ensues. moderate quantities on the abraded border
The spectrum of staining of the altered and even inside the epithelial cells as well
collagen stands in sharp contrast to the as scattered collections on the neighboring
usual uniform, rather soft pastel, orchid- undamaged skin (Fig. 6). This is particularly
pink fibers seen in undamaged skin. Con- true in shotgun wounds, especially if a
comitant with the color change is fusion and layer or two of clothing was present between
homogenization (coagulation) of the collagen muzzle and skin.
fibers so that the damaged site may present
itself as an almost solid sheet of rather Near Wounds
hyaline material (Fig. 1). Occasionally the When the weapon is sufficiently close to
collagen may swell to the extent that it the human target to produce grossly visible
protrudes through the skin defect above the fouling and stippling, the microscopic
level of the adjacent epithelium. features are in some respects similar to
That the collagen changes are caused by those previously noted, with the differences
heat and not merely by perforation or being quantitative rather than qualitative.
drying is established by the absence of these The pattern of epithelial cellular damage
findings in perforating injuries produced by and alteration is essentially the same as
cold objects such as knives, ice picks, or that observed in contact wounds, i.e.,
scissors. In this respect it is also significant gradually increasing damage as one passes
that such coagulative change is usually from outer edge to center. However, there
much less pronounced at the site of exit is usually a heavy deposit of PR on the
if the bullet tract is entirely through soft intact skin surface, frequently mingled with
tissue (see below). the overlying keratin. The deposit is spotty
Skin appendages and cellular elements in rather than uniform with areas of relatively
the corium also reveal evidence of thermal heavy soiling alternating with zones of
trauma as indicated by nuclear pyknosis comparatively sparse or no fouling. Intra-
and vacuolization and cellular shrinkage. epithelial PR is abundant. The amount of
The alterations in the epithelium and foreign material on the epithelial defect and
dermal collagen brought about by the heat in the subcutaneous tract varies but is
which the products of discharge of firearms often abundant. It is noteworthy that PR
and pellet have created are comparable to may be observed within viscera located at
those in other types of thermal injury.6 considerable distances from near entrance
3. Powder residue. Powder residue (PR) wounds, having been deposited in these
occurs as black amorphous clumps or as sites by a combination of blast and bullet

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ajcp/article-abstract/35/5/393/1768356


by Airlangga University user
on 23 February 2018
May 1961 GUNSHOT WOUNDS 397

I"'M...'•$^upper). Close-up of edge of entrance wound. Progressively increasing


damage and distortion from periphery (left) to perforation (right). Rete pegs
preserved. Moderate quantity of PR present. Collagenous changes slight in this
area. Grossly skin perforation was surrounded by area of soiling 1}4 in. by % in.
Weapon was a .32 caliber revolver. Hematoxylin and eosin. X 120.
FIG. 4 (lower). Area adjacent to loose contact entrance wound. Solitary focus of
epithelial destruction with abundant intra-epithelial PR. Neighboring skin intact.
Edges of perforation were blackened and adjacent surface fouled. Victim was shot
through underwear which revealed perforation surrounded by zone of soiling and
burning. Weapon was a .22 caliber rifle. Hematoxylin and eosin. X 120.

soiling. Figure 7 reveals large quantities of Hair at the target site will be singed if
characteristic black material in the cere- it is within range of muzzle flame (Fig. 6).
bellum resulting from a near entrance wound Thermal collagenous injury is comparable to
on the side of the nose. that seen in contact wounds, indicating

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ajcp/article-abstract/35/5/393/1768356


by Airlangga University user
on 23 February 2018
398 ADELSON Vol. 35

rft£ t*

Jliti.«*P''.

F I G . 5 (upper). P R in myocardium. Deceased was wearing woolen sweater and


heavy winter underwear when shot a t contact range through precordium. Skin
perforation bordered by areola of black abrasion % t o Vg in. No gross fouling or
stippling of intact skin or clothing. Weapon was a .22 caliber Springfield rifle.
Hematoxylin and eosin. X 120.
F I G . 6 (lower). Contact wound with abundant P R on abraded epithelium, in
corium and extending laterally over undamaged skin. Grossly t h e skin perforation
was surrounded by a rim of charring measuring up to Ys in. without peripheral
soiling. Hair singed. Weapon was a .22 caliber target pistol. Hematoxylin and eosin.
X 35.

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ajcp/article-abstract/35/5/393/1768356


by Airlangga University user
on 23 February 2018
May 1961 GUNSHOT WOUNDS 399

FIG. 7 (upper). PR in right cerebellar hemisphere. Entrance wound on left side


of nose surrounded by area of soiling measuring up to % in. in diameter. Bullet
perforated nose, sphenoid sinus, dorsum sellae, pons, and cerebellum. Weapon was
a .32 caliber automatic. Hematoxylin and eosin. X 120.
FIG. 8 (lower). Exit wound with essentially intact epithelium extending to
margin of defect. Cellular distortion and compression absent. PR absent. Minimal
thermal collagenous changes. Bullet passed through trunk. Weapon was a .45 caliber
automatic. Hematoxylin and eosin. X 35.

that this portion of injury probably results to that noted in the contact and near
from heat imparted by the bullet as well as varieties. Dermal collagenous polychromato-
from direct muzzle flame. philia and fusion are consistently present,
comparable to that previously described.
Distant Wounds T h e m a j o r di ff er ences between this group
The pattern of epithelial damage and of gunshot injuries and the other 2 reside
defect in distant gunshot wounds is similar mainly in the quantity of and distribution

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ajcp/article-abstract/35/5/393/1768356


by Airlangga University user
on 23 February 2018
400 ADELSON Vol. 85

of the PR. The foreign material derived from the site of entry. PR is either sparse or
the muzzle blast is sparse or absent in absent.
distant gunshot entry wounds. The only The intervention of one or several thick-
exception is the shotgun injury in which nesses of clothing between muzzle and skin,
wads may constitute secondary missiles. even when the muzzle is pressed firmly
Inasmuch as a distant gunshot wound is against the outer fabric, converts the wound
denned as one in which the target is beyond from "contact" to "near," and tends to
the range of flash and smoke of the muzzle impart the characteristics of the latter type
blast, any PR on the surface or in the to the dermal injury.
tract of such an injury must originate from
surface debris on the missile. The small W O U N D S OF E X I T
quantities of residue wiped off of the pellet Exit wounds result from a stretching
as it penetrates the skin and subcutaneous force applied to the skin from its under-
tissues are usually located in the epithelium surface with perforation as the limits of
and superficial zone of the corium. PR is skin elasticity are exceeded. They vary in
rarely, if ever, observed in the viscera in size, shape, and configuration and may be
distant gunshot wounds. stellate, cruciate, triangular, or crescentic.
The skin changes in re-entrance wounds They may even resemble stab wounds. The
are similar to those of a distant wound, skin edges are frequently everted, and the
regardless of the nature of the original characteristic collar of abrasion, fouling,
wound. Little or no PR is present, the stippling, and burning is never seen.
bullet having cleansed itself during its initial Exit wounds are usually larger than the
passage through the body, and the muzzle corresponding entrance wound if the latter
blast, if any, having been absorbed at the has not been affected by expanding muzzle
primary site. The dermal collagen reveals blast, or if the missile did not strike the
the tinctorial changes and fusion previously skin in profile or at an angle.
described.
Effect of clothing on entrance wounds. The Observations
patterns of epithelial damage and col- The major difference between exit wound
lagenous amphophilia and fusion are not and entrance wound is the nature of the
significantly altered by the interposition of epithelial damage and defect. The epithelial
one or several layers of cloth or fabric defect of an exit wound is almost always
between muzzle and skin; however, the sharply demarcated from the adjoining
deposition and introduction of PR may be surface covering with the latter demon-
seriously altered in such instances. The strating relatively little or no evidence of
extent of the alteration produced by the damage except immediately adjacent to
clothing depends on the number of layers the edge of the perforation (Fig. 8). This
of fabric, the type of fabric, and whether contrasts conspicuously with the transi-
it is tightly woven or loose-mesh. Frag- tional changes and progressive increase in
ments of fabric may be seen occasionally damage observed as one approaches an
in the subcutaneous area, blown in by entrance defect. The epithelium may be
muzzle blast, or carried in by the missile. partially stripped from the underlying
Contact or near gunshot wounds sus- tissue as seen in contact entrance wounds.
tained through loosely woven clothing, even The marginal zone of epithelial abrasion, so
when several layers are present, can result characteristic of entrance wounds, is con-
in the deposition of PR on and in the skin, stantly absent (Fig. 9).
and in the deeper areas in quantities com- Powder residue in exit wounds is usually
parable to those seen with similar wounds sparse or absent. PR may be abundant in
received in an unclothed area (Figs. 4 and an exit wound only when entrance and exit
5). Distant gunshot wounds sustained are quite close to each other, and when the
through clothed areas are essentially similar entrance wound is of such nature as to
to those in which no clothing is present at result in the abundant deposition of PR

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ajcp/article-abstract/35/5/393/1768356


by Airlangga University user
on 23 February 2018
May 1961 GUNSHOT WOUNDS 401

FIG. 9 (upper). Edge of exit wound. Epithelium essentially undamaged except


immediately adjacent to defect. The keratin has been elevated by the departing
bullet. Weapon was a .25 caliber Colt automatic. Hematoxylin and eosin. X 120.
FIG. 10 (lower). Overall appearance of exit wound. Skin edges sharply margi-
nated. Adjacent epithelium reveals no distortion. PR absent. Conspicuous
collagenous heat changes. Bullet entered posterior wall of thorax, traversed thorax,
and perforated sternum. Exit wound in presternal area. Weapon was a P 38 auto-
matic. Hematoxylin and eosin. X 25.

in the skin and subcutaneous tissues. When responding entrance injury is the deposition
PR is present, it tends to localize in the in this site of surface debris carried by the
deeper regions, and is less conspicuous in pellet.
the more superficial areas, a distribution Dermal collagenous changes are frequent
opposite to that seen in entrance wounds. in exit wounds, indicating the presence of
The best explanation for the presence of residual heat in the missile to which heat
PR in the depths of an exit wound located created by friction may have been added
at a considerable distance from the cor- as the missile passed through the tissues.

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ajcp/article-abstract/35/5/393/1768356


by Airlangga University user
on 23 February 2018
402 ADELSON Vol. 36

This is likely to be prominent if it has Le examine histologic del vulneres de


passed through bone (Fig. 10). Occasionally entrata e de exito facite per ballas de fusil
the dermis of the exit wound may reveal revelava plure aspectos histologic le quales
little or no evidence of thermal injury. (1) establi le nette differentiation inter iste
Histologic evidence of hemorrhage and duo typos de injuria e (2) es frequentemente
acute inflammatory response are observed de valor in determinar le distantia del foco.
both in entrance and exit wounds and serve Ballas produce plus o minus specific typos
no useful purpose in distinguishing between
de lesion epithelial e de disrangiamento al
the two. Granulocytic infiltration and
sito de lor entrata e al sito de lor exito.
fibroblastic proliferation are indications of
vital response to trauma and furnish valu- Le quantitate e le distribution del residuo
able concrete evidence of survival for shorter de pulvere super e in le epithelio e in le areas
or longer intervals after injury. plus profunde es importante aspectos diag-
nostic.
SUMMARY
Alterationes thermic in le collageno dermal
Bullet wounds represent a unique combi- es presente in omne typos de vulnere de
nation of mechanical, thermal, and blast entrata e in certe vulneres de exito. Le grado
injury. de alteration tende a esser plus conspicue in
Microscopic examination of entrance and le caso del vulnere de entrata, sed occasional-
exit gunshot wounds disclosed several mente illo es equalmente prominente in le un
histologic features (1) that clearly dis-
e le altere sito.
tinguish these 2 types of injury and (2)
that are often useful in establishing the Omne le alterationes histologic deberea
range of fire. esser prendite in consideration in le studio del
Bullets produce more or less specific natura de tal vulneres, e le apparentia micro-
types of epithelial damage and derangement scopic debe esser correlationate con le
at the sites of entry and exit. character macroscopic del injuria.
The quantity and distribution of powder
Acknowledgments. T h e author acknowledges
residue on and in the epithelium and in the
with deep gratitude t h e valuable advice and sug-
deeper areas are important diagnostic gestions of D r . Alan R. Moritz, Director of the
features. I n s t i t u t e of Pathology, in t h e preparation of this
Thermal changes in the dermal collagen manuscript. The photomicrographs were made by
are present in all types of entrance wounds Mr. Sid Pancner, Chief Photographer of t h e
and in some exit wounds. The degree of Cuyahoga County Coroner's Office.
change tends to be more conspicuous in
the entrance injury, but occasionally it may REFERENCES
be equally prominent in both sites.
1. ADELSON, L.: Medical evidence in fatal gunshot
All of the histologic changes should be injuries. Am. J . Clin. P a t h . , 23: 758-767,
taken into consideration in the study of 1953.
the nature of the wound, and the micro- 2. F I S H E R , R. S., AND F R E I M U T H , H . C : Gunshot
wounds. Postgrad. Med., 16: A 68-72,1954.
scopic appearance should be correlated with 3. M O R I T Z , A. R., AND D U T R A , F . R . : Scientific
the gross character of the injury. evidence in cases of injury b y gunfire. A.
M. A. Arch. P a t h . , 37: 340-349, 1944.
SUMMARIO I N I N T E R L I N G U A 4. MORITZ, A. R.: Personal communication.
5. MORITZ, A. R . : Studies of thermal injury. I I I .
Vulneres de balla representa un combina- Pathology and pathogenesis of cutaneous
tion unic de injuria mechanic, thermic, e burns. An experimental study. Am. J .
explosive. P a t h . , 23: 915-941, 1947.

Downloaded from https://academic.oup.com/ajcp/article-abstract/35/5/393/1768356


by Airlangga University user
on 23 February 2018

Anda mungkin juga menyukai