CONSIDERATION
http://crisbertcualteros.page.tl
Legal Medicine -is a branch of medicine which deals with the application of
medical knowledge to the purposes of law and in the
administration of justice.
a) Injury/Disease
point of view - Treatment Cause
3. Rights may be waived, unless the waiver is contrary to law, public order,
public policy, morals or good customs, or prejudiced to a third person with a
right recognized by law.
4. Customs which are contrary to law, public order or public policy shall not be
countenanced.
MEDICAL EVIDENCE
- is the means sanctioned by the rules of court of ascertaining in a
judicial proceeding the truth respect! ng a matter of fact.
Types of evidence:
1. Autoptic or Real evidence - made known to the senses
2. Testimonial evidence - oral under oath
3. Experimental evidence
4. Documentary evidence
2
1. Photo, videotape,photocopy 4.Manikin method
2. Sketching 5.ln the mind of the witness
3.Description 6. Special methods: embalming
3. Hypnotism
4. By observation
5. Scientific Interrogation
6. Confession
= Supplemetary tests:
3
a. Peak of tension test - peak of tension on relevant questions
b. Guilt complex test - does not response to added relevant quest.
c. Silent answer test - subject verbal response creates distortion in
the tracing or clearing of the throat.
B. Narcoanalysis or Narcosynthesis
- Sodium amytal or sodium penthotal
Ill. HYPNOSIS
4
- alteration of consciousness, not all subjects can be hypnotized
IV. OBSERVATION
Physiological and psychological signs and symptoms of guilt:
a) Sweating, color change
b) Dryness of the mouth
c) Excessive activity of adams apple
d) Fidgetting
e) Peculiar feeling Inside
f) Swearing, spotless past record
g) Inability to look at the investigator
V. INTERROGATION
- emotional appeal, mutt and jeff technique
VI. CONFESSION
- expressed acknowledgement of his guilt.
TOKYO DECLARATION
- contains guidelines to be observed by physician concerning torture, inhuman
and degrading punishment.
5
MEDICO-LEGAL ASPECTS OF IDENTIFICATION
- determination of the individuality of a person
Methods of identification:
1. By comparison - Id found in the crime scene compared with the file.
2. By exclusion
IDENTIFICATION OF PERSONS
A. Ordinary methods of identification
6
1. 0 ccupational marks - painters have stains
2. Race: Malay:brown, flat nose round face, Round head, Wearing apparel
3. Stature: Tips of middle fingers of both hands extended laterally
4. Tatoo marks
5. Weight- not good point - changes from time to time
6. Deformities, injuries leaving permanent deformities
7. Birth marks moles, scar
Age of Scar:
Recently formed: Slightly elevated, reddish/bluish, tender to touch
Few week-.2 months: Inflammatory redness. soft, sensitive
2 - 6 months: brownish, free from contraction, soft
> 6 months: white, glistening, contracted, tough
Scar formation is delayed by: sepsis, age, depth of wound, mob ii ity
May not develop- mall, superficial, healed by first intention.
Basis:
1. Human skeleton is unchangeable after 20 years.
2. No two human beings have exactly the same bones.
3. Use of slmpl e instrument
Information:
1. Descriptive data - color of hair. eyes, shape of nose ...
2. Body marks
3. Anthropometric measurement - height
4. Measurement of the head, limbs
7
3. Flash of firearm
= 2 inches letters can be read with the aid of the flash of 22 caliber
at a distance of 2 feet.
4. Flash of lightning - sufficient light to identify
5. Artificial light - relative to the Intensity of light
1. FINGERPRINTING
= most valuable method of idenUfication.
a) No two identical fingerprints 1 : 64,000, 000, 000
b) Not changeable - 4'" month formed in the fetus
= Practical uses
a) Identity of dead bodies
b) Prints recovered at crime scene
c) Prints on file for comparison
d) Right thumb print is substitute for signature
2. DENTAL IDENTIFICATION
= possibility of 2 persons to have the same is remote
= enamel is the hardest substance of the body,
outlast other tissues In putrifaction
3. HANDWRITING
8
4. IDENTIFICATION OF THE SKELETON
human - shape, size, general nature
single individual -plurality or excess of bones
Humphrey's table
=Table of different height of bones for different ages and their
corresponding statures.
9
6) Superciliary ridges less sharp, more rounded sharper
7) Zygomatic arches more prominent less prominent
8) Lower jaw larger & wider narrower and lighter
9) Face larger in proportion to cranium smaller
5. IDENTIFICATION OF SEX
Evidences of sex:
1. Presumptive evidence
= General features, hair in some parts
= Transvestism - sexual deviation by desire to assume the attire and be
accepted as a member of the opposite sex.
2. Highly probabale
=vagina, large breast
6. DETERMINATION OF AGE
Legal importance
a) Aid to identification
b) Determination of criminal liability
c) Determination of right of suffrage
d) Determination whether a person can exercise civil rights
e) Determination of the capacity to marriage
f) Requisite to certain crimes
10
Determination of age of fetus:
Hess's rule or Haase's rule
a) Fetus of less than 25 cm long- get square root of length in cm, result in months
b) > 25 cm- divide the length of the fetus by 5 and the res ult is the age in month.
Legal importance :
a) Disputed parentage
b) Circumstantial evidence against perpetrator of a crime
c) Determination of the cause of death
d) Determination of the direction of the escape
e) Determination of the appropriate time crime was committed
f) Determination of the pl ace of the crime
g) Determination of the presence of certain diseases.
Physical examination
a) Solubility test
b) Heat test
c) Luminescence test: 3 amino-phtallc-acid-hydrazide-HCL,
Sodium peroxide • dis ti lied water
> Bluish-white in a dark room
Chemical examination:
a) Saline extract of the blood plus ammonia - brownish> alkaline hematin
b) Benzi dine test - blue color in white filter paper
c) Guaiacum test (Van Deen's Dyas or Schombeln's test)- blue
d) Phenolpthalein test ( Kastle-Meyer test) - pink
e) Leucomalachite Green test
Microscopic examination
- saline extract of stain
Micro-chemical tests:
1. Hemochromogen crystal or Takayama test:
2. Teichmann's blood crystals or Hemin crystal test-
= Sodium chloride- dark brown rhombic prisms of chloride, hematin formed
= best of the micro-chemical test.
3. Acetone-haemin or Wagenhaar test
11
Spectrospcopic examination
- blood pigments have the power to absorb light of certain length and produce the
characteristic absorption bands on the spectrum.
=Fresh blood - oxyhgb, Hgb, reduced hematin
= olders stains - methemoglobin, alkaline hematin
Biologic examinations
1. Precipiti n test - blood is human or not
2. Blood grouping
Medulla
1. Air network In fine grains large or small sacks
2. Cells Invisible w/out tx in H20 Easily visible
3. Fuzz w/out medulla Fuzz w/ medulla
Cortex
1. Looks like a thick muff Fairy thin hollow cylinder
2. Pigments in the form of fine grains lrregul ar grains
Cuticle
I. thin scales thick scale
12
defendant.
Signs of death:
1. Cessation of heart action and circulation .• Usually the auricle contract after
somatic death fro a longer period than the ventricle, last to stop so called
ULTIMEN MARIENS.
13
- The progressive fall of the body temp. is one of the most prominent signs.
- First two hours after death the cooling is rapid.
- Fal I of temp. of 15 to 20 degrees Fahrenheit is considered as a
certain sign of death.
Methods of estimating how long a person has been dead from the cooling
of the body:
14
2. Chemical Method ( Schourup's formula for the determination of the time of
death of any cadaver whose CSF is examined for the concentrations of L.A .•
NPN,A.A.
= L.A> 15 mg to 200 mg/1 OOcc rapid in 1st 5 hours.
= NPN inc. from 15 to 40 mg/100 cc in 1" 15 hours
= A.A. inc. from 1 mg lo 12 mg% 1" 15 hours.
15
18-36H summer
b) Age
= early onset - aged and newborn
=delayed - good health, good muscular development
c) Integrity of nerves
= section of the nerve will delay onset, paralyzed muscle
2. Cold stiffening
= due to solidification of fats when exposed to cold temp.
16
RIGOR MORTIS CADAVERIC SPASM
1. Time of appearance 3-6H after death Immediately after death
2. Muscles involved All muscles Certain group
3. Occurrence Natural phenomena May or may not appear
4. Medico-legal signif. Approximates ti me of death Determine nature of death
17
2. Determines the position of the body has been changed after it's
appearance in the body.
3. Color of lividity may indicate the cause of death.
a) asphyxia - llvidity is dark
b) CO poisoning - pink
c) Hemorrhage - less marked
d) Hydrocyanic acid - bright red
e) Phosphorus - dark brown
f) Potassium chlorate - coffee brown
4. Determines how long the person has been dead
5. Gives us an idea as to the time of death.
Points to be considered which may infer the position of the body at the
time of death:
1. Posture of the body when found.
2. Post-mortem hypostasis or lividity
3. Cadaveric spasm
5. Incision shows blood outside the b.v. Blood Inside the vessels
=most certain test of difference
18
2. Loops of intestine
3. Brain
4. PUTREFACTION OF THEBODY
- Is the breaking down of complex proteins into simpler components associated
with the evolution of foul smelling gasses and accompanied by the change of
color of the body.
19
2. Evolution of gasses in the tissues
C02, ammonia, H2, Suphurated hydrogen, methane.= offensive odor
2. EXTERNAL FACTORS
a) Free air
a.1 air: tree air hastens decomposition
a.2 moderate moisture - accelerates
a.3 loaded with septic bacteria- early aerobes. later anaerobic
- Clostridium welchi i= decomposition
b) Earth
b.1 dry absorbent soil - retards
b.2 moist fertile soil - accelerates
20
5. depth at which the body was buried - greater the I ater
6. condition and type of soil
7. inclusion of something in the grave which will hasten decomposition-food
8. access of air to the body after burial
9. mass grave - rapid
1 0. trauma to the body - violent death - slow
1-3 DAYS AFTER DEATH - greenish discoloration over iliac fos sa, soft eyeballs
3-5 DAYS - frothy blood from mouth, nostrils
8-10 DAYS - abdominal distention, nails firm
14-20 DAYS - blisters all over the body, maggots
2-5 MONTHS - skull exposed, orbits empty
IN TROPICAL REGION
21
SPECIAL MODIFICATION OF PUTREFACTION
1. Mummification
=is the dehydration of the whole body which results in the shivering
and preservation of the body.
=usually occurs when buries in a hot, dry with free access of hot air
3. Maceration
=softening of the tissues when in fluid medium in the absence of putrefactive
mircro-orq, seen in death in utero
- reddish or greenish color, skin peeling off and arms flaccid and frail.
PRESUMPTION OF DEA TH
Disputable presumption - not heard In 7 years
22
Presumption of death
Absence of 7 years except success ion 10 years
Vess el for 4 years
Armed forces 4 years
In danger of death 4 years
PRESUMPTION OF SURVIVORSHIP
1. under 15 y.o. - older survives
2. above 60 y.o.- younger
3. under 15, above 60 - former
4. over 15 and under 60 y.o. - male, older
5. under 15, or over 60 y .o. and the other in between - latter
Inquest Officer - is an official of the state charged with the duty of inquiring into
certain matters.
- in medico-legal examination: manner and cause of death
2. Autopsy
- comprehensive study of a dead body, in addition to the external examination
. Post-mortem examination- external exam without incision being made.
Purpose of autopsy:
1. Determine cause of death
2. Correlate clinical diagnosis and symptoms
3. Determine effectiveness of treatment
4. Study the natural course of the disease
23
5. Educate students and physicians
Dead body belongs to the state for cases that requires medico-legal autopsy.
Mistakes in autopsy:
1. Error or omission in the collection of evidence for identification
2. Errors or omission in the collection of evidence required fro establishing
the time of death
3. Errors or omission In the collection of evidence required fro the medico-
legal examination.
4. Errors or omission result in the production of undesirable artifacts or in
the destruction of val fd evidence.
Negative autopsies
- If after all efforts Including gross and microscopic studies and toxicological
analysis fall to reveal a cause of death.
Negligent autopsy
No cause of death is found due to Imprudence, negligence, lack of skill, lack of
foresight.
24
CAUSES OF DEATH
Cause of death: is the injury or disease or both which initiates the physiological
disturbance resulting to a fatal termination.
25
findings.
4. When neither history, laboratory and anatomic findings, taken individually or in
combination is sufficient to determine the cause of death but merely speculate
as to the cause of death. Ex. Crib death among Infants.
DO A - means actually dead or dying, provided the physician had not been given
ample opportunity to arrive at a working diagnosis as to the cause of death.
b. Violent death
1. Accidental death
2. Negligent death
3. lnfanticidal death
4. Parricidal death
5. Murder
6. Homicidal death
26
If signs of violence are associated with the natural cause of death:
• Did the person die of a natural cause and were the physical injuries
inflicted immediately after death?
- violence applied in a dead person: Impossible crime.
•Was the victim suffering from a natural disease and the violence only
accelerate the death?
= Offender responsible of the death of the victim.
=Criminal liability shall be incurred by any person committing a felony
although the wrongful act done be different from which he intended.
(Art.4 no. 1 RPC)
• Did the victim die of a natural cause independent of the violence inflicted?
- accused will not be responsible for the death but merely for the physical
injuries he had inflicted. Ex. Slapping a person with heart problem. only
slight physical injury.
- to make the offender liable for the death of the victim, it must be proven that
the death Is the natural consequence of the physical Injuries i nft icted.
27
4. Affections of the GIT
a. Ruptured PUD
b. Acute intestinal obstruction
B. Violent death
- are due to injuries inflicted In the body by some forms of outside force.
The physical injury must be the pro xi mate cause of death.
=That the victim at the time the physical injuries were Inflicted was
in normal health.
=That the death may be expected from the physical Injuries inflicted.
= That the death ensued wi thl n a reasonable time.
28
PENAL CLASSIFICATION OF VIOLENT DEATHS
1. Accidental deaths - due to misadventure or accident.
Art. 12 no. 4 RPC
Any person who while performing a lawful act with due care, causes an
injury by mere accident without fault or intention of causing it.
Ex. Patient died of ATS injection after proper skin test.
2. Negligent death - felonies may be committed when the wrongful act is due to
reckless imprudence, negligence, lack of skill or foresight.
Ex. Surgeon left a pack - Homicide through reckless imprudence
4. Parricidal deaths
Art. 246 father, mother. child, (leg/illeg) ascendant. descendant, spouse (leg.)
29
SPECIAL DEATHS
l . Judicial deaths -Art. Ill Sec.1 Par. 19 Phil. Const. "cruel and
unusual punishment shall not be inflicted. ; electrocution, hanging,
musketry, gas chamber.
2. Euthanasia or mercy killing
3. Suicide
Automatism - due to drug may be considered as accidental
rather than suicidal.
The human body without food losses 1/24'" of its weight daily.
And 40% loss>death
Factors that influence the length of survival: age, condition of the body, sex,
environment.
30
DISPOSAL OF THE DEAD BODY
Sec.1103 Revised Administrative Code : Persons charged with the duty of burial.
1. Deceased was married: the surviving spouse
2. If unmarried: the nearest of kin of the deceased; adults, within the Phil.
And in poss es sion of sufficient means to defray the necessary expenses.
3. If none of the above - municipal authorities.
Concept of possession - the right of custody over a dead body .. The right of
custody does not mean ownership of the dead body.
Executors right of custody superior to the right of spouse dead body. An executor
is the person mentioned in a will who will carry on the provision of the will. In the
absence of a testamentary disposition. the right of the surviving spouse is
paramount.
2. Burial or inhumation
a. Sec 1092 RAC buried within 48 hours if unembalmed.
Within 12 hours, if communicable.
3t
c. Permission from the Provincial fiscal or from the municipal mayor.
Is necessary if death is due to violence or crime.
=Sec. 91 (f) P.O. 856 Code of Sanitation
Sec. 1099 the placing of the body of any deceased person In an unsealed
overground tomb Is prohibited unless if permanently sealed.
Except: 1. Tombs and vaults which are strictly receiving vaults for bodies or
remains awaiting final disposition.
2. Embalmed bodies awaiting final disposition.
Sec. 2695 RAC Penalizes the desecration of burial premises; tombstone, plant,
tree, fence, post or wall. P200/ not greater than 6 months.
32
2. The burial or remains in city or municipal grounds shall not be pro hi bi ted
due to race, nationality, religious or political reasons.
3. Except when required by legal Investigation or when permitted by the local
health authority, no embalmed remains shall remain unburied longer than
48 hours.
FUNERALS
Art. 305 CC The duty and the right to make arrangements for the funeral of a
relative shall be in accordance with the order of support under Art. 294.
Descendants : Eldest
Ascendants : Paternal
Art. 306 CC; In keeping with the social position of the deceased.
Art. 309 CC: Showing of disrespect to the dead shall be liable to the family of
the deceased for damages. materials or moral.
Art. 2219 CC: Provides for the moral damages may be recovered for acts
mentioned in Art. 309 CC.
33
4. Cremation- is the pulverization of the body into ashes
by the application of heat.
First must be identified,
Permit and in a crematory made for the purpose.
NOT GRANTED:
a. If the deceased left a note.
b. Identity of the person is not definite.
c. Exact cause of death cannot be ascertained and the need for
further inquiry or examination.
34
Sec 92 Code of Sanitation
3 years if non-dangerous communicable disease.
Remains shall disinfected before burial.
2. Set the date and time of exhumation, if physician has a strong reason to
believe that for the justification and strong probability.
4. Grave must be properly identified by the person who was present when
the body was interred.
5. After opening the coffin. the body must be viewed by any person who can
identify the deceased.
7. Dis infection of the body and all areas Involved must be carried out with the
assistance of the local health officer and the return of the body to the
burial place.
MEDICO-LEGAL ASPECTS OF PHYSICAL INJURIES
1. Physical violence
2. Heat or cold
35
3. Electrical energy
4. Chemical energy
5. Radiation by radioactive substances
6. Change of atmospheric pressure
7. Infection
b. Time
= The shorter the period of time needed for the transfer of energy,
the greater the likelihood of producing damage.
= If a person is hit on the body and the body moves towards the
direction of the force applied, the Injury Is less as when the body
Is stationary.
= The longer the time of contact between the object or instrument
causing the injury, the greater will be the dissipation of energy.
c. Area of transfer
=The larger the area of contact between the force applied on the
body, the lesser the damage to the body.
= By applying an equal force, the damage caused by stabbing is
greater compared to a blunt instrument.
d. Other factors
= The less elastic and plastic the tissue > the greater that a
laceration wi II result.
= Elasticity :
Ability of the tissue to return to its normal sizes and shape after
being deformed by a pressure.
36
VITAL REACTION
EXCEPT: vital reactions not seen even if injury inflicted during life:
1. During agonal state of a living person were cells don't react to the
trauma.
2. Sudden death as in sudden coronary occlusion.
CLASSIFICATION OFWOUNDS:
1. AS TO SEVERITY
a. Mortal wound- caused immediately after Infliction that is capable of
death.
Parts of body that are mortal - heart, vessels, CNS, lungs, other organs.
37
b. Sharp instrument
= Sharp-edge instrument> incised wound
= Sharp pointed > punctured wound
= Sharp edge and sharp-pointed > stab
d. Locus minoris resistencia - Physical injury not located at the site nor
opposite the site of the application of force but In some areas
offering the least resistance to the force appll ed.
Example: Blow in fore head > contusion on the region of the eyeball.
38
Example: Fall or MVA
1. MUTILATION
=Art. 262 RPC Kinds of mutilation:
a. Intentionally depriving a person, totally or partially of some of
the essential organs for reproduction.
b. Intentionally depriving a person of any part or parts of the
human body other than the organs for reproduction.
Mutilation to be punishable It must be intentional or not physical Injury.
39
SERIOUS PHYSICAL INJURIES Art. 263 RPC
Any person who s hal I wound, beat or assault another Art. 263 and
administering injurious substance, without intent to kill Art. 264.
1. Prison mayor- because of the physical injuries Inflicted, the injured person
becomes insane, imbecile, impotent or blind.
Elements:
1. The offender inflicted upon another any serious physical injury,
40
2. There is knowledge that the substance or beverage administered is
injurious Or took advantage of the victims weakness of credulity.
3. There is no intent to kill in the part of the offender.
If intentional so> frustrated murder. Treachery is inherent in Art. 264 RPC
Any person who s hal I inflict upon another physical injuries not described in the
preceding articles,
= But which shall incapacitate the offended party for labor 10 days or more
The crime of less serious physical injuries may be qualified and a fine of a higher
penalty is imposed when:
1. Arresto me nor- when the offender has lnfl lcted physical injuries which
shall incapacitate the offended party for labor form 1 to 9 days or shall
require medical attendance of the same period
2. Aresto menor or fine not exceeding P200 and censure when the offender
has cause physical injuries which do not prevent the offended party
from engaging in his habitual work nor require medical attendance.
3. Arresto me nor in its minimum period or a fine not exceeding P50 when the
offender shall ill treat another by deed without causing any injury.
41
So a tender slap on the face, holding the arm tighdy, application of
pressure in some parts of the body or mild blow which show no sign of physical
violence may still be considered slight physical injuries or maltreatment.
( Parag 3)
Elements:
42
Age of Contusion: appreciated from its color change
The size tends to become smaller from the periphery to the center
and passes through a series of color changes as a result of the
> Disintegration of the RBC and liberation of hemoglobin.
Contusion
Below the epidermis in the true skin In small bruises or extravasations,
below this in larger ones and often much deeper still.
The epidermis has no blood vessels to be ruptured.
Contusion
Cuticle was probably abraded by the same violence that produced the
bruise. In small punctures such as fleas bites, this Is not observed.
Post-mortem hypostasis
Cuticle unabraded, because the hypostasis Is a mere sinking of the blood,
there is no trauma.
Contusion
A bruise appears at the seat of and surrounding the injury. This may or may
not be a dependent part.
Post-mortem hypostasis
Always in a part which for the ti me of information Is dependent.
43
Contusion
Often elevated because elevated blood and subsequent inflammation swell
the tissues.
Post-mortem hypostasis
Not elevated, because either the blood is still in the vessels or at most has
simply soaked into and stained the tissues.
Contusion
Incision shows blood outside the vessels. This is the most certain test of
difference and can be observed even in very small bruises.
Post-mortem hypostasis
Incision shows the blood is still In its vessels and if any oozing occurs drops
can be seen issuing from the cut mouths of the vessels.
Contusion
Color variegated. This is only true of bruises that are the same days old due
to the changes in the hemoglobin produced during life.
Post-mortem hypostasis
Color is uniform. The well known change in color produced in blood
Extravasated Into living tissues does not occur in dead tissues with the
same regularity.
Contusion
If the body happens to be constricted at or supported on a bruised pl ace,
the actual surface of contact may be a little lighter than the rest of the bruise
but will not be white.
Post-mortem hypostasis
In a place which would otherwise be the seat of hypostasis pressure of any
kind even simple support is sufficient to obliterate the lumen of the venules
and capillaries and so to prevent their filling with blood.
44
5. Age - Children and old age tend to bruise easily.
6. Sex - women, obese easily develops unlike boxers.
7. Application of heat and cold
a.3 HEMATOMA
is the extravasation or effusion of blood in a newly formed cavity
underneath the skin. When the blunt instrument hit a hard part of the body
like a bony part which is superficially located.
Force causes the subcutaneous tissue to rupture on account of the
presence of a hard structure underneath ..
MUSCULO·SKELETAL INJURIES
45
a. Close or Simple Fx - no break in continuity of the overlying skin.
b. Open or Compound Fx - Fx is complicated by an open wound
caused by the broken bone which protruded with other tissues of the
broken skin.
c. Comminuted Fx - Fractured bone is fragmented into several pieces.
d. Greenstick Fx - Fx wherein only one side of the bone is broken
while the other is merely bent.
e. Linear Fx - when the Fx forms a crack usually in flat bones.
f. Spiral F x - break in the bones forms a spiral manner as seen in long
bones.
g. Pathologic F x - F x caused by weakness of the bone due to disease.
- is more severe when the moving or mobile head struck a fixed hard object
as compared when the head Is fixed and struck by a hard moving object.
Loss of memory for events just before the injury is a constant effect of
cerebral concussion and is of medico-legal Importance.
2. OPEN WOUNDS
46
a. Abrasion (Scratch, graze, impression mark, friction mark )
- it is an Injury characterized by the removal of the superficial epithelial
layer of the skin caused by a rub r friction against a hard rough object.
- Contussion with abrasion = forcible contact before friction occurs.
- the shape varies and the raw surface exudes blood and lymph which later
dries and forms a protective covering as SCAB or CRUST.
Characteristics of abrasion:
1. It develops at the precise point of the force causing it.
2. Grossly or with the aid of a hand lens the injury consists of
parallel linear injuries which are in line with the direction of rub or
friction causing it.
3. It may exhibit the pattern of the wounding material.
4. Usually ignored by attending physician. Medico-legal viewpoint
= abrasions caused by fingernails may indicate struggle or assault
and are usually located in the face, neck, forearms and hands.
= abrasions resulting from friction on rough surfaces are located in
bony parts and are usually associated with contusion or
laceration.
= nature of the abrasion may infer degree of pressure, nature of
the rubbing object and the direction of movement.
Forms of abrasion
1. Linear abrasion - appears as a single line. straight or curve.
= pinching with fingernails = curve a.
=sliding the point of a needle= straight linear ab.
Types of abrasion
1. Scratch - caused by sharp pointed object which slides across the skin,
like pin, thorn or fingernail.
- Injury usually parallel to the direction of slide.
= Fingernail scratch > broad at point of commencement with
tailing at the end.
2. Graze - usually caused by forcible contact with rough, hard objects
47
resulting to irregular removal of the skin surface.
= course indicated by a clean commencement and tags on the end.
3. Impact or imprint abrasion ( patterned abrasion, stamping abrasion,
abrasion a la signature)
- those whose pattern and location provides objective evidence to
show cause, nature of the wounding instrument and !he manner
of assault or death.
= marks of grid of radiator, thread marks of wheel, teeth marks.
4. Pressure or friction abrasion - caused by pressure accompanied by
movement usually observed in hanging or strangulation.
= spiral strands of the rope as seen in the skin in hanging.
Differential diagnosis:
1. Dermal erosion - gradual breakdown or very shallow ulceration of the
skin which Involves only the epidermis and heals without scarring.
2. Marks of insects and fishes bites - skin injury is irregular with no vital
reaction and usually found on angles of the mouth, margins of
nose, eyelids and forehead.
48
= Impact cut> when there is forcible contact of the cutting instrument
with the body surface.
= Slice cut> when cutting injury is due to the pressure accompanied
with movement of the instrument
= Chopped or Hacked wound > when the wounding instrument is a
heavy cutting instrument like saber
> Injury is severe
Suicidal wounds - usually located In peculiar parts of the body, accessible to the
hand.
the most common site is the wrist, radial artery and the neck.
Homicidal wounds - usually deep, multiple and involves both accessible and
non-accessible parts.
clothing are usually Involved
Defense and other forms of wounds are present.
49
Accidental wounds - multiple incised wounds observed on the passenger and
driver of MVA due to broken windshields.
kitchen knives in the preparation of food.
SEVERITY Usually not so deep and Usually deep and may cause
may only involve trachea, involvement of the carti I age
carotid and esophagus and bones.
BLOOD Bid found in front part of body Bid found at the back of neck.
DISTRIBUTION Hand smeared with blood. Hands are clean.
50
= smaller when the wound is not so deep.
The extremities of stab wound may show the nature of the instrument used.
a doubled bladed weapon shows both extremities to be sharp.
A single bladed weapon - one of its extremities as rounded and contused,
not seen if instrument is quite thin.
The direction of the surface defect may be useful in the determination of the
possible relative position of the offender and the victim when the wound was
inflicted.
51
Stab wounds may be:
A.Suicidal
1. Located over vital parts of the body.
2. Usually solitary
3. Located over covered parts of the body, the clothing is not involved
4. Stab wound is accessible to the hand of the victim
5. Hand of victim is smeared with blood
6. Wounding weapon is firmly grasp by the hand of the victim.
7. If stabbing is accompanied with slashing movement
> the wound tailing a bras ion is seen towards the hand Intl icting
the injury.
8. Suicide not may be present
9. Presence of a motive for self destruction.
1 0. No disturbance in the death scene with wounding instrument found
near the victim.
Medical evidence showing the intent of the offender to kill the victim:
1. there are more than one stab wounds
2. stab wounds located in different parts of the body
3. stab wounds are deep
4. serrated stab wounds means thrust and withdrawal of the wounding
weapon to increase Internal damages.
5. irregular or stellate shape skin defects> due to changing direction of the
weapon with the portion of the Instrument at the level of the skin as the
lever.
52
4. PUNCTURED WOUND - is the result of a thrust of a sharp pointed
instrument.
= External injury is quite small but the depth is to a certain degree.; ice-pick, nail
- Nature of the external Injury depends on the sharpness of the end of the
wounding instrument:
= contusion of the edges> if end is not sharp
= opening may be> round, elliptical, diamond shaped or cruciate.
- Site of external wound can be easily sealed by dried bid, serum, or clotted bid.
- Punctured wounds are usually accidental
Characteristics:
1. The opening of the skin is very small, wound Is much deeper than it
ls wide.
2. External hemorrhage is limited than intemall y may be severe.
3. Sealing of external opening is favorable for the growth and
multiplication of anaerobic organism like bacillus tetani.
Homicidal -
1. multiple and usually located in different parts of the body.
2. wound are deep
3. there are defense wounds on the victim.
4. signs of struggle In the crime scene.
Suicidal -
1. located In areas of the body where the vital organs are located.
2. usually singular, if multiple located in one area.
3. parts of body involved is accessible by the hand of the victim.
4. clothing usually not Involved.
5. wounding is made while the victim is in sitting or standing position,
bleeding is towards the lower part of the body or clothing.
6. no disturbance in the crime scene.
7. wounding instrument found near the body.
53
5.LACERATED WOUNDS (TEAR, RUPTURE, STRETCH "PUTOK'/
is a tear of the skin and the underlying tis sues due to forcible contact with
a blunt instrument.
May be produced by a hit with a piece of wood, iron bar, fist, stone, butt.
If the force Is applied to a tissue is greater than its cohesive force and
elasficity> the tissue tears and a laceration is produced.
Characteristic:
1. shape and size of the Injury does not correspond to the wounding
instrument
2. tear on the skin is rugged with extremities irregular, ill-defined.
3. injury developed where the blunt force is applied.
4. borders of the wound are contused and swollen.
5. developed in areas where the bone Is superficially I ocated.l ike scalp.
6. examination with the aid of hand I ens shows bridging tissue joining
the edges and hairs bulbs are intact.
7. bleeding is not extensive due to blood vessels are not severed
evenly.
8. heal Ing process is delayed and has a tendency to develop a scar.
3. Grinding compression
the weight and the grlndl ng movement may cause separation of the skin
with the underlying tissues.
4. Tearing
this may be produced by a semi-sharped edged instrument which causes
irregular edges on the wound like hatchet and choppers.
54
Edges are clean cut, regular, well defined edges are roughly cut, irregular, ii I-
defined
Extremities of the wound are sharp, may be extremities are ill-defined and
irregular
Round, or contused
GAPING OF WOUND
- Separation of the edges especially in deep wound may be due to the
following:
1. mechanical stretching or dilatation
the presence of a mechanical device on the edges to prevent coaptation
will cause separation. Example: drain in an abscess, retractor during
operation.
55
Determination of how much skin is involved is important in lhe mode of
treatment and prognosis especially in burns, contusion ..
=burns of 70% in children and older age group are fatal.
Causes of hemorrhage:
a. trauma - destruction of its blood vessel wall
b. natural causes
- lntracerebral hemorrhage(apoplexy)> lenticulostraite br. MCA
- Spontaneous subarachnoid hemorrhage> saccular berry aneurysm
- rupture of arteriosclerotic aneurysm
56
- rupture of esophageal varices
- pulmonary hemorrhage due to PTB, lung abscess, bronchiectasis
- ruptured ectopic pregnancy
2. Size of injury - burns greater than 1/3"' of the body are fatal
5. Foreign body or substance introduced into the body - bacterial, viral, foreign
body, chemical,
TOXIN.
I. snake bites> 2 punctured wds at the center of the reddened affected area.
The venom is Injected through its fangs which is connected to the poison
gland.
57
2. Scorpion venom
- venom has toxic, hemolytic, hemorrhagic
- one punctured wound on the center of a reddened area
- pain, edema and reddening
58
HEALING OF WOUNDS
1. Power of the human tissue to regenerate - replaced the destroyed tissue
by newly formed similar tissue.
59
- reasons for the multiplicity of wounds
- determination if the wound is accidental, suicidal or homicidal
3. Examinations of wound
- character of wound : abrasion, hematoma, laceration etc
- location of wound : from some fixed area
> to determine trajectory/course
- depth of wound : not in the living , only if the outer and inner are fixed
- condi lions of the s urroundlngs of the wound -
= near GSW- burning, tattooing
= suicidal cuts - superficial tentative cuts or hesitation cuts
= lacerated wounds - contusion on neighboring skin
- extent of the wound
= extensive injury- marked degree of force applied in the
production of the wound.
= homicidal cutthroats are deeper, extensive, numerous than
suicide
- direction of the wound> lmpt. in the position of the victim to the offender
- number of wounds - several> homicidal
60
blood inside b.v.
Edges gape owing to the reaction Edges do not gape, but are
of the skin and muscle fibers closely approximated to
Each other unless if the
wound is 1 to 2 hrs
after death
61
1. external signs and circumstances related to the position and attitude of the
body when found.
2. location of the weapon or the manner in which it was held
3. the motive in the commission of the crime
4. the personal character of the deceased
5. the possibility for the offender to have purposely changed the truth of the
condition.
6. other information
a. signs of struggle
b. number and direction of wounds
c. direction of wound
d. nature and extent of the wound
e. slate of clothing
1. degree or healing> signs of repair of wound appear in less than a day after
the infliction of injury.
2. changes In the body in relation to the time of death >systematic changes
a
In the body = was ng, anemia, bed sore.
3. age of blood stain - not reliable
4. testimony of witness when the wound was inflicted.
1. contusion - blunt
2. lncls ed wound - sharp-edged instrument
3. lacerated wounds- blunt
4. punctured wounds - sharp pointed
5. abrasion - body surface is rubbed on a hard surface
6. GSW - the diameter of the wound of entrance may approximate the
caliber of the wounding Instrument.
62
If none- offenders are only responsible for their individual acts.
If death ensued even the wounds are minor, and death due to the negligence
or incompetence of the physician then !he offender cant be responsible.
If death occurred from oompl ications arising from a simple injury owing to the
negligence of the injured person In its proper care and treatment
= the offender is responsible for the death
= a person is not bound to submit himself to medical tx for the injuries
received during the assault.
=unless ir it is proven that the negligence of the victim is deliberate so
offender is not responsible but only for physical lnj uries.
Relative position of the victim and assailant when injury was inflicted:
1. location of the wound
2. direction of the wound
3. nature of Instrument used In infllcti ng the lnj ury
4. testimony of the witness
63
EXTRINSIC EVIDENCES OF THE WOUNDS
1. HEADANDNECK
= not be underestimated
= bleeding from ears, nose, mouth > basal fractures
= may have normal x-rays yet with severe head injury
64
1. Direct or Coup injuries
2. Indirect injuries
a. contr-coup injuries
b. remote Injuries - fall hitting buttocks> basal fx
c. locus minoris resistencia - injury in areas with less resistance
3. Coup-contra-coup Injuries (direct and indirect injuries)
GUNSHOT WOUNDS
I. FIREARM WOUND
= the barrel of any firearm shall be considered as a complete firearm for all
65
purposes thereof.
3. as to manner of firing
=pistol - fired with a single shot Ex. Revolver
= rifle - may be fired from the shoulder Ex. Shotgun
66
Types of small firearms which are of medico-legal interest:
1. revolver - usual muzzle velocity is 600 feet per second
2. automatic pistol - self-loading firearm, muzzle velocity of 1200 feet per
second
3. rifle - muzzle velocity of 2500 feet per second and a range of 3000 feet.
4. shotgun - projectile is a collection of pellets
Appears to be smaller than the missile Always bigger than the missile
Owing to the elasticity of the tissue
Usually oval or round depending upon Does not manifest any definite
the angle of approach of the bullet shape
67
INSTANCES WHEN THE SIZE OF THE WOUND OF ENTRANCE DO NOT
APPROXIMATE THE CALIBER OF THE FIREARM
In distant fire, the rule is that the diameter of the GSW of entrance is almost the
same as the caliber of the wounding firearm except:
1. Factors which make the wound of entrance bigger than the caliber:
a. In contact or near fire
b. deformity of the bullet which entered
c. bullet might have entered the skin sidewise
d. acute angular approach of the bullet
2. Factors which make the wound of entrance smaller than the caliber
a. fragmentation of the bull et before penetrating the skin
b. contraction of the elastic tis sues of the skin
Determination of the trajectory of the bullet inside the body of the victim
1. external examination
a. shape of wound of entrance
= when bullet is fired at right angle with the skin> the wound of entrance Is
circular except In case of near fire.
= if fired at another angle • it is oval
=when the bullet is deformed no such characteristics findings will be
observed.
68
2. internal examination
a. actual dissection and tracing the course of the wound at autopsy
b. fracture of bones and course In visceral organs
c. location of bone fragments and lead particle
d. x-ray exam
Does not show characteristic shape unlike the entrance wound due to the
absence of external support beyond the skin so the bullet tends to tear or shatter
the skin.
Shored GSW of exit: if pressed on a hard object like when victim is lying:
Wound of exit is circular or nearly circular with abrasion.
=If the number of entrance and exit wound is even so presumption that no
bullet is lodge in the body.
= verified by x-ray
Instances when the number of GSW of entrance is less than the number of
GSW of exit in the body of the victim:
69
1. a bullet might have entered the body but split into several fragments. each
of which made separate exit.
2. one of the bullets might have entered a natural orifice of the body. Ex.
nose
3. there might be two or more bullets which entered the body through a
common entrance and later making individual exit wounds .
4. in near shot with a shotgun, the pellets might have entered in a common
wound and later dispersed while inside the body and making separate
wounds of exit.
Instances when the number of GSW of entrance is more than the number of
GSW of exit in the body of the victim:
1. when one or more of the bullet is not through and through and the bullet is
lodged in the body.
2.when all of the bullets produce through and through wounds but one or
more made an exit in the natural orifices of the body.
3. when different shots produced different wounds of entrance but two or
more shots produced a common exit wound.
Instances when there is no GSW of exit but the bullet is not found in the
body of the victim:
1. when the bullet is lodged in the GIT and expel led through the bowel or
lodged in the pharynx and expelled through the mouth.
2. near fire with a blank cartridge produced a wound of entrance but no slug
may be recovered.
3. the bullet may enter the wound of entrance and upon hitting the bone the
course is deflected to have the wound of entrance as the wound of exit.
70
The effects of the clothing on the movement of the bullet depend on:
c. far fire
=there Is a hole tear with inward direction of the thread
7t
7. personal history may reveal social, economic, business or marital problem
which cannot be solve.
8. gunpowder presence in the hand of the victim
9. entrance wound usually does not contain clothing
1 0. fingerprints of victim on the butt
11.suicide note at the vicinity
12. no disturbance in the pl ace of death
72
5. ARE THERE SIGNS OF STRUGGLE?
6. DID THE VICTIM DIE INSTANTANEOUSLY?
7. IS IT POSSIBLE FOR THE VICTIM TO FIRE OR RESIST THE ATTACK
AFTE THE INJURY WAS SUSTAINED?
8. WHERE WAS THE POSTION OF THE ASSAILANT AND THE VICTIM
WHEN THE SHOT WAS FIRED?
The caliber may be inferred from the diameter of the wound of entrance.
Capacity of a victim to perform volitional acts - depends upon the area of the
body involved, involvement of vital organs and the resistance of the victim.
GSW may not be a near fire or may not appear to be near fire:
1. when a device Is set up to hold the firearm and to enable it to be
discharged at a long range by the victim.
2. when the GSW of entrance does not show characteristics of a near shot
because the clothing are interposed between the victim and the firearm.
73
3. when the examining physician failed to distinguish between a near or far
shot wound
4. when the product of a near shot has been washed out of the wound.
X-ray
1. facilitate the location and extraction of the wound
2. reveals fragmentation and its location
3. shows bone involvement like fracture
4. reveal trajectory of the bullet
5. shows effect of the bullet wound, like hemorrhage, escape of air,
laceration
SHOTGUN WOUNDS
Is a shoulder fired firearm having a barrel that is smooth-bored and is intended
for the firing of a changed compound of one or more bal Is or pellets.
Measure the distance between the two farthest shot(pellets) in inches and
subtract one, the number obtained will give the muzzle-target distance in
yards.
Importance:
1. Determination of the distance of the gun muzzle from the victim's body
when fired. Usually not more than 24 inches when fired.
2. Determining whether a person has fired a firearm. - dorsum of the hand
= metallic residues. burning and unburned gunpowder
= in suicide found in the palm
74
Tests for the Presence of Powder residues
J. On the skin - Dorsum of the hand or Wound of entrance
2. On clothings
Walker's test ( c-acld test, H-acid test)
= glossy photographic paper fixed in hyposolution for 20 min to
remove the silver salts and washed for 45 min. and dries.
Tests for the presence of Primer Components - metallic primer residues like
barium, antimony, and lead.
1. Harrison and Gilroy test :Cotton swab moistened with 0.1 molar HCI to
gather the primer component.
= Reagent sodium rhodisonate yields red color with the pri mer oomponents.
= Add 1.5 H Cl to the red area> blue-violet or pink in lead or barium
=lacks specificity, sensitivity
75
THERMAL INJURIES OR DEATHS
- are those caused by deviation from normal temperature, capable of producing
cellular or tissue changes in the body.
Effects of CO LO:
A. Local effect ( Frostbite, Immersion foot, Trench foot)
1~ -Blanching. paleness of the skin due to vascular spasm.
2"' - Erthyma, edema, swelling due to vascular dilatation, paralysis and
increased cap ii lary permeability.
3"' - Blister formation
4~ - Necrosis, vascular occlusion, thrombosis and gangrene.
B. Systemic effects:
- Reflex in nature due to the stimulation and paralysis of the nerves
- Pulmonary .Cardiac action is slowed down due to cerebral anoxia>
resulting to lethargy, delirium, convulsions. coma or death.
b) Local effects:
b.1 Scalding
b.2 Burns
=Thermal
=Chemical
= Electrical, lightning
=Radiation
GENERAL OR SYSTEMIC EFFECT: death usually accidental
1. Heat cramps( Miner's Camp, Firemans Camp, Stroker's camp)
76
- Involuntary spasmodic painful contraction of muscles due to dehydration and
excessive loss of chlorides by sweating
- Tx: Fluids with chlorides
2. Thermal burns: Caused by heat or chemical substances like fire, radiant heat,
friction, solid substances, electricity.
: Classification of burns/ DUPUYTREN'S CLASSIFCATION
1 ~ Degree -erythema
2°• - vesicle formation
3•• - destruction of the cuticle, part of true skin, painful
4" - whole skin is destroyed, ulceration, not painful
s~ - deep fascia, muscles
6" - charring of the Ii mbs
BURNS SCALDS
1. CAUSE Dry heat - flame. heated soBd Moist heat - /}quid. steam
radiant heat
77
3. Dermal erythema, edema and vesicle formation.
4. Subendocardial left ventricular hemorrhage.
3. Chemical bums
Characteristics of lesions:
a. Absence of vesication
b. Staining of the skin or clothing by the chemical
c. Presence of the chemical substance
d. Ulcerative patches of the skin
e. Inflammatory redness of the skin surface
f. Delayed healing
78
SUBSTANCE
4. LESION Borders are disti net Diffused
b. Nitric acid
=Clothing is destroyed, brown
=yellow or yellowish brown slough
c. Hydrocloric acid
= not so destructive
=intense irritation, localized ulceration red or reddish-gray.
79
1. Direct effect from the electrical charge.
2. Surface flash burns from the discharge - electrical into heat energy.
3. Mechanical effect - expansion of air > laceration
4. Compression effect - "sledgehammer blow"
80
= As he goes deeper there will be an increase in the amount
of gas dissolved in the blood and other body fluids.
= If ascent is made rapidly, the diver will suffer from the effects of the sudden
release of the gasses from the body fluids.
= released of air bubbles in the circulation and act as emboli in different parts of
the body causing interstitial emphysema, pulmonary embolism, in big joints
called bends.
DEATH BY ASPHYXIA
Asphyxia -Applied to all forms of violent death due to interference with process
of respiration
- Conditions in which the supply of 02 to the blood or tissues or both
has been reduced below normal level.
81
b) External obstruction of the air passage - traumatic crush asphyxia
c) Paralysis of the respiratory center - poisoning, injury, anesthesia
d) Mechanical interference of the passage of air- drowning, asthma
e) Shunting of blood
Classification of Asphyxia:
1. Hanging
2. Strangulations: by ligature, manual strangulation, spl forms -palmar
3. Suffocation: choking
4. Asphyxia by drowning
5. Asphyxia by pressure on the chest
6. Asphyxia by irrespirabl e gasses
A. ASPHYXIA BY HANGING
= Not necessary the whole body is suspended: Pressure at side of neck
= Mechanism of death: Air passage Is constricted by pressure of the rope
; Compression of carotids, jugs, Sup, Laryng nerve> Cereb. anoxia
82
Hanging is ante-mortem: Vital reaction= principal criterion
1. Redness or ecchymosi s at the si le of I igature.
2. Ecchymosis of the pharynx and epiglottis.
3. Line of redness or rupture of the inti ma of the carotid artery
4. Subpleural hges.
C. ASPHYXIA BY SUFFOCATION
- Occlusion of air from the lungs by closure of air openings
or obstruction of the air passageway from the external openings to the air
sacs.
Smothering:
- A form of asphyxia! death cause by closing the external respiratory orifices.
83
Choking- Form of suffocation by the impaction of F.B. in the respiratory
passage.
Post-mortem findings:
1. External findings
2. Internal findings
A. RESPIRATORY SYSTEM
2. "Edema aquosum"- Oue:Entrance of water Into air sacs, Lungs are doughy
84
B. HEART
1. Both sides of heart may be filled or emptied with blood.
2. Salt water drowning - Blood chloride content is greater than left side.
Fresh water- Blood chloride is more I the right side. FRESH- RIGHT
Gettler's Test
- Quantitative determination of the chloride content of the blood in the right and
left ventricle of the heart. : Difference of at least 25 mg.
C. STOMACH
- Presence food in the stomach but absence of water.> Death is rapid or
submersion made after death. Impossible for water to get into the stomach if
body is submerged after death.
Homicidal D. =struggle, motive, articles found near the place, phys. injuries
Suicidal D.= note, heavy objects, mentality, Hx of previous attempt
Accidental =Absence of violence in the body., exclusion of suicide, witnesses
Burking - invented by Burke and Hare= murder for the sale to medical schools
85
- Kneels or sits on the chest and the hands close the mouth and nostrils
86
- found in eruption of volcano
WAR GASES
Classification based on the physiological action
1. Lacrimator or Tear gas - causes irritation with copious flow of tears
a) Chloracetphene (C.A.P.)
b) Bromobenzyl cyanide (B.B.C.)
c) Ethyl lodoacetate ( K.S.K.)
2. Vesicant of Blistering Gas - contact with skin cause bleb or blister formation
a) Mustard gas ( Dlchlordiethyl sulfide, yellow cross, Yperite)
b) Lewisite ( Chlorovinyl-dichlorarsine)
87
2. Second collision: Impact of unrestrained occupants with the vehicle interior
=1st Col., Occupants move same direction/velocity towards point of impact
a) Front impact> Occupants move forward.
b) Side impact (severe)> moves to the side that was involved in the 1" Col.
>The passenger nearest to it will suffer the most.
c) Rear impact crash-Acceleration-deceleration injury or whiplash
d) Roll over crash (Turn turtle impact)
= If vehicle is not put into a stop after the 1" Col. > the unrestrained
occupants will continue to strike to some parts of the vehicle interior.
Pedestrian-Vehicle Collision:
Death or Physical Injuries to pedestrian
1.Primary impact - Contact with vehicle
2. Secondary impact - Subsequent impact of the pedestrian to the ground
- Accounts for the multiple injuries
3. Run over Injuries
4. Hit and run Injuries
88