Modes of asphyxia
Nose and mouth Neck Suffocation
Smothering Hanging Smothering
Gagging Strangulation Choking
o Manual/throttling Gagging
o Ligature
Overlying
o Mugging
Traumatic asphyxia
o Garroting
Burking
Air passage Others
Choking Traumatic
Drowning Postural
Burking
Sexual
Pathophysiology
mechanical interference to respiration causes anoxia and
cyanosis. Cyanosis is seen under nails, lips, ears, tongue,
lungs, meninges
Petechiae are found in lax, unsupported tissue – pleura (esp. on interlobular fissures & hilum),
pericardium, conjunctiva, around eyes, behind ears, undersurface of scalp, larynx, thymus
Tardieu spots: petechiae on the surface of viscera. Nonspecific feature. Also, in anaphylaxis, snake bites,
viral fevers, IHD, other congestive deaths
Postmortem features:
1. General features – common for all modes of asphyxia. Also, in electrocution, OP poisoning, CN
poisoning
2. Specific features – depend on mode of asphyxia
General features
External
Petechial hemorrhages in conjunctiva, inner aspects of lips and other areas of the skin
Conjunctiva injected
Bleeding from the nose and ears
Froth in the nose and mouth
Cyanosis is marked
Passage of stool & urine
Ejaculation
Internal
Anterior neck structures are examined at the end of autopsy—following removal of tissues and organs,
and collection of toxicology samples—to allow drainage of blood and reduce the possibility of artifactual
hemorrhage.
Incision "U" or "V" shaped made from sternal notch to the back of
each ear (also, called modified Y incision)
Darkened blood and profuse bleeding may be noted while making
the skin incision.
Chest cavity
Subcapsular hemorrhage in thymus of children
Pleural effusion (put hand into pleural cavity to check for fluid
before evisceration)
RS:
Blood tinged pleural fluid
Congested mucosa with petechiae
Froth in trachea and bronchi (due to hyperfunctioning bronchial glands)
pleura glistening due to oedema
Petechiae in pleura (interlobar fissures)
Lungs congested
Excess fluid squeezed out of lungs (pleural oedema)
CVS:
Pericardial effusion (may be blood tinged)
R heart – enlarged, fluid blood
L heart – contracted, comparatively empty
Visceral pericardium may have petechiae (on post surface of AV groove)
(subendocardial hemorrhages not usu. seen)
Abdomen:
Peritoneal effusion & congestion
Internal organs – congested (of stomach may be mistaken for irritant poisoning), edematous, petechiae,
bladder & rectum may be empty
CNS:
Cerebral oedema
Petechiae in white matter
Subarachnoid pooling of blood
Near-hanging: Patients who survive a hanging injury long enough to reach the hospital.
Classification
1. Position of knot
a. Typical: knot at occiput in the midline of the back
of the neck
b. Atypical: knot placed elsewhere
2. Degree of suspension
a. Complete: feet off the ground (constricting force = whole weight)
b. Incomplete/partial: Lower part of the body is touching the ground (constricting force =
weight of head)
Circumstances
Suicidal
Point of suspension remains approachable to the person.
Partial hanging is almost always suicidal in nature
more common in males
A history of a previous attempt may be present, and
generally committed in a secluded place (victim’s
home is the most frequent site). Suicidal note may be left behind.
Accidental
Infants and children
Hanging deaths in children < 6 years
while ‘playing hanging’ (e.g. pretending to be a cowboy) or playing ‘Lasso’ or getting suspended from
playground equipment (swings), getting entangled in cradles
Sexual asphyxia in adults (usu. males)
Rarely occupational
Homicide:
Very rare. Not ordinarily possible in an adult victim, unless aged, intoxicated or made unconscious or the
victim is either a child or a debilitated person.
Homicide should be suspected where:
Signs of violence/disorder of furniture
Clothes torn or disarranged
offensive or defensive injuries
Postmortem hanging/suspension
Person may be murdered, and body suspended to simulate
suicide.
Usu. follow homicide by manual/ligature strangulation;
death in police custody due to battery
Cause of death
1. Asphyxia:
a. Floor of the mouth is pushed up and backwards.
b. Tongue is pressed against the pharynx, obstructing the airway.
2. Cerebral ischemia:
a. Compression of the arteries supplying the brain.
b. Survivors may be in a permanent vegetative state.
3. Cerebral congestion:
a. compression of the veins and blocking the venous drainage of the brain.
b. Veins, capillaries and arteries get congested. Death is due to stagnant hypoxia.
4. Vagal inhibition:
a. Carotid bodies are compressed/stimulated
b. carotid vessels are pulled up suddenly stretching the aorta and its baroreceptors.
c. stimulation of the vagus INHIBITS the heart.
d. At PM, even a ligature mark may be absent (negative post mortem).
5. Fracture dislocation of upper cervical vertebral column:
a. occurs when the drop is great such as in judicial hanging.
b. Death is caused by damage to the upper cervical spinal cord.
Medicolegal investigation of a case of hanging
Visit site – house, building, locked room, garden, forest, prison
Photograph, sketch, describe
History – eye witness, P/H of mental or physical illness, previous suicidal attempts, social history (living
alone, sexual relationships)
Identify
Total/partial hanging
Point of suspension and its accessibility
Supports used to reach site of suspension
Distances: ground to point of suspension, ground to feet, neck to point of suspension, highest height the
person could have reached
Disturbance at the scene - footprints
Evidence of struggle, blood stains
Suicide note
Evidence of sexual asphyxia: naked body, female clothing on male, pornographic material, evidence of
masturbation
External examination
General features
Ligature: in situ/removed
Intense congestion and signs of asphyxia (oedema,
petechiae, eyes bulging out, tongue swollen and
protruding between clenched teeth, face swollen,
cyanosis)
Dilated pupils - ligature compresses on cervical
sympathetic chain (Antemortem hanging)
Subconjunctival hemorrhage
Froth in nose & mouth
Dribbling of saliva due to pressure on salivary glands Conjunctival petechiae
(Surest sign of antemortem hanging)
Bleeding form nose, urine, feces
Engorgement of penis and seminal discharge
Hypostasis – lower limbs, pelvis
Any other injuries – suspect struggle, may occur due to convulsions
Look for causes of PM injuries – rats, red ants
Clothing – nature, trace material (semen, feces)
Hand restraints (usu. suicide)
At mortuary
Preliminary procedure – photograph, X-ray, trace material, blood for toxicology if indicated
Ligature description
Material: coir rope, nylon, saree, sarong, bed sheet
Circumference of noose
Width
Nature of knot: slip-knot or fixed (granny/reef knot). Sometimes it is a running noose without a
knot.
o If, in situ, it should be cut away from knot and reconstructed by joining cut ends with a
string
o Slip knot & running noose – faster tightening, ligature mark at a lower level
o Fixed knot – slow tightening
Ligature mark/furrow
Number of ligature marks
Course (angled or straight)
Width
Skin changes – Usually depressed/grooved, pale in color,
but later becomes yellowish brown, dry, hard and
parchment-like with small abrasions at its edges,
corresponding to the thickness and edges of the rope.
These abrasions, known as rope burns, are due to
frictional force. Ligature mark is a perimortem injury;
Peri-ligature injuries - blisters, bruise, abrasion (in therefore, it is pale brown and
antemortem hanging) parchment-like.
o abraded area below the furrow may indicate
upward slippage of the ligature, usually seen when suspension is complete
Relation to thyroid cartilage
Pattern if imprint abrasion (agrees with pattern of ligature)
Neck circumference at level of furrow (to determine degree
of neck constriction) Knot may leave separate imprint
Neck veins above the furrow may be distended
Mark may be absent if wide piece of cloth is used (E.g. saree)
or if ligature has been removed soon after death
Internal findings
The neck is dissected layer by layer with fine instruments looking for hemorrhage and injures.
Neck
Subcutaneous tissue underneath the ligature mark is dry, white, firm and glistening.
Platysma and sternomastoid may show hemorrhages and are sometimes ruptured.
Amussat’s sign: Transverse carotid intimal tears may be seen in obese victims, long drops,
atheromatous arteries and posteriorly placed knots.
Vertebral artery injuries—rupture, intimal tear and subintimal hemorrhage (most frequent)
Yoshikawa lines
Ligature strangulation
pressure on the neck is applied by a constricting band that is tightened by a force other than the body
weight
F>M
Motive – rape
Incomplete occlusion of arteries – vertebral arteries are patent and supply the head with blood while
other vessels are obstructed (↑intravascular pressure → congestion & rupture of vessels → more
petechiae and subconjunctival hemorrhage)
Circumstances
Virtually all cases are homicides - most common method of homicidal asphyxia. In infanticide, a cord
around the neck is utilised
Suicides and accidents are rare
Accident
tie/scarf/cloth caught in a moving machine (e.g. fan, automobile wheel, motorcycle,
snowmobile, ski lifts, massage devices),
children may get entangled in ropes when playing,
nuchal cord in utero
Suicidal
Some individuals remain conscious for 10-15s after complete occlusion of carotid arteries giving
them time to tie at least one (if not more) knots
some individuals tightly wrap a ligature several times around the neck, securing it in place by the
overlapping loops.
tourniquet method: a ligature is loosely wrapped around the neck, knotted, and then tightened
by a stick inserted beneath the ligature and twisted multiple times. Clothing or the individual’s
own weight on the stick holds it in place, maintaining the “tourniquet.
Pseudo ligature marks
skin folds of neck skin in infants; more confusing in neonates as petechiae are found naturally if
delivered vaginally due to compression of the chest
Elderly - pale crease marks caused by overlapping rolls of skin, petechiae of the sclerae and
conjunctivae (caused by cardiac failure/acute heart failure is an uncommon cause of death in
the elderly) — with the addition of retropharyngeal hemorrhage.
tight collar/buttoned up shirt/neck tie/necklace around neck of decomposing body
Cause of death
Asphyxia
Occlusion of carotid arteries/venous congestion causing cerebral anoxia (LOC in 10-15s)
Vagal inhibition
Fracture dislocation is rare
Ligature material: electrical cords, neck ties, ropes, telephone cords, hose, towel,
Autopsy findings
External features
Face
Marked congestion, swollen, cyanosed
Fine petechiae on the face, esp. in the periorbital region (more abundant than in hnging)
Eyes: prominent, wide open, conjunctiva congested, pupils dilated, Confluent scleral hemorrhage &
conjunctival petechiae
Hypostasis prominent above ligature
Tongue: swollen, dark, protruding, bitten
Ear and nose bleed common
Blood stained froth in mouth and nostrils
Ligature mark
Transverse/horizontal plane, circular, continuous
At or below thyroid cartilage
Base is red, surrounding ecchymosis and congestion, imprint of ligature material
Indistinct or absent
o in young children or incapacitated adults
o if ligature is soft and broad or removed soon after death (need to examine under UV
light)
Cheese cutter method: narrow ligature material (narrow cord or electric wire), ligature is deeply
embedded and upon removal leaves a deep groove. Initially, it has a yellow parchment-like
appearance that turns dark brown.
Nail marks around ligature mark
Internal findings
Neck
Contusion of SC tissue and muscles
Fracture of thyroid cartilage (superior horn and wings)
Fracture of cricoid cartilage (less common)
Fracture of hyoid (rare)
Fracture of tracheal rings if great force is applied
Subcapsular and interstitial thyroid hemorrhage
Bruising of root of tongue and floor of mouth
Hemorrhagic infiltration of mucous membranes of larynx and pharynx
Blood stained froth in larynx, trachea and bronchi
Fracture/dislocation of cervical vertebrae not common – occur in infants if associated with twisting of
the neck
Strangulation by towel.
Ligature mark is barely visible.
Trace evidence
In victims of homicidal ligature strangulation, hair is often found clutched in the hands. This should be
recovered and retained. A control sample of the victim’s hair should be obtained for comparison,
because the hair found in the hands almost invariably turns out to be that of the victim.
Fingernail scrapings or cuttings (the latter are preferred) should be taken to look for tissue of the
perpetrator under the nails. Unfortunately, such scrapings or cuttings have traditionally been of little
help, with foreign tissue rarely identified.
Manual strangulation/Throttling
Strangulation is produced by pressure of the hand, forearm, or other limb against the neck, compressing
the internal structures of the neck.
Cause of death
Vaso-vagal inhibition from pressure on carotid nerve plexus consisting of fibers of vagus nerve,
sympathetic and glossopharyngeal nerves (50% cases)
Cerebral anoxia from occlusion of blood vessels
Asphyxia (probably plays a minor role)
Compression of carotid sinuses → ↑BP in sinus → bradycardia and vasodilation → hypotension (most
cases)
Compression below carotid sinuses → ↓BP in sinus → tachycardia and vasoconstriction → hypertension
Postmortem features
Nail marks
Impression Regularly curved, comma-like, exclamation mark-like, like, or oval, triangular,
rectangular epidermal injuries measuring 10–15 mm
Fingertip digs into the skin at a right angle to it with the fingernails penetrating
through the epidermis to the dermis.
Claw marks U-shaped injuries of both the epidermis and dermis, variable length (3-4 mm)
Fingernails dig into the skin at a tangential angle, cutting the epidermis and dermis
tangentially and undermining it.
Scratch Parallel linear abrasions or erythematous bands in the epidermis up to 1.0 cm wide
marks Fingernails dig into the epidermis at a vertical angle and then are drawn across the
skin, producing an elongated injury.
abrasions and bruises on the front and sides of the neck and are commonly at each side of the laryngeal
prominence and just below the jaw-line. The injuries may extend onto the upper part of the sternal
area.
Because of struggle and resistance, bruising and abrasions may be found over the face of the victim.
These can also be caused to stop the victim from shouting or crying for help.
Trace evidence
examine the nails of the victim and fingernail scrapings of the alleged assailant when possible, so that
these can be compared with tissue type of the victim.
Internal findings
Extravasation of blood in subcutaneous tissues underneath the external marks of bruising and
abrasions - most significant internal sign
Tear/laceration of platysma or SCM
Tongue - bruised/lacerated, may protrude out and bitten by teeth.
Hemorrhages (pinpoint to extensive extravasation) inn mucous membrane of larynx, epiglottis, pharynx
and peritonsillar region.
Inward compression fracture of hyoid bone (most diagnostic finding of throttling)
Fracture of superior horns of thyroid cartilage is common, though both horns do not get fractured
simultaneously.
Laceration of carotid sheath and tear of inner coat of carotid artery.
Cricoid is usually not fractured (if #, almost pathognomic of throttling)
Hyoid
Calcifies with aging, so more prone for #
Movement of the noncalcified portion resemble a fracture
Fracture can easily occur postmortem if calcified
AM # - spec of blood at # site
Take X-rays of neck before autopsy to visualize cartilages when minimal strangulation is suspected
The U shape of the hyoid does make it susceptible to fracture by compression. Thus, fractures of the
hyoid are, as a rule, seen only in strangulation. Whether the fractured ends of the hyoid bone are driven
inward or outward is immaterial.
Suffocation
Smothering
mechanical occlusion of nose and mouth by hand, cloth, plastic bag, pillow or other material.
Mechanism of death – asphyxia
Circumstances
Homicide - pillows, bedding, and the hands (nose pinched off and mouth closed); victims tend to be very
young, very old, debilitated, or incapacitated by restraints, disease or drugs.
Suicide – plastic bag over the head, commonly employ the thin, filmy plastic bag used by dry cleaners
which clings to the face easily
Accidental - occur with defective cribs.
Infant is trapped either between a too-small mattress and the frame of the crib, or between a defective
crib and mattress, with the face wedged against the mattress (Figure 8.2). The child is unable to move
and smothers.
Pathophysiology
Initially, there is stridor, respiratory distress, coughing and the inability of the victim to speak.
This is followed by a rapid, deep inhalation, which causes the foreign object to pass further down the
airway.
Laryngospasm occurs, followed by vagal stimulation, leading to arrhythmia, apnea and death.
Signs:
Stridor Risk factors for choking in adults
Respiratory distress Alcohol/drug intoxication
Coughing Bad fitting dentures
Choking Neurological injury
Inability to speak Senility
Mental retardation
Circumstances
Anaesthesia/unconscious
Accidental – commonest
Children – small toys, balls, seeds, stones, button
Adults – almost always involve food, vomitus (during anesthesia or if unconscious)
Homicidal – robbery; gags sometimes are used to mute the victim can travel posteriorly to the pharynx
and occlude the airway
PM findings