Demonstrations
Barcelona (ES)
DESCRIPTION
The ZeEUS Demonstration in Barcelona is investigating
the feasibility of two opportunity-charged 18m articulat-
ed buses and two overnight-charged 12m buses. Solaris E18
The 18m buses are charged at the depot for 2-6 hours
and run under normal Barcelona conditions for 16 hours.
The opportunity–charged buses recharge their batteries DEMO IN BRIEF
each 12km (half of the route) to up to 80% of total ca-
Vehicle technology:
pacity. This allows the buses to run all day.
2 x Full Electric
The test in hilly routes shows than consumption is similar Brand and model:
to that on flat routes. The energy consumed ascending Solaris E18
is almost completely recouped when descending.
Bus length: 18m
Capacity: 115 passengers
100 Charging technology:
80 Opportunity
Duration:
Height in m
60
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Vehicle technology:
Distance in km 2 x Full Electric
Elevation map of the line route L34 Brand and model:
Irizar i2e
Bus length: 12m
100
80
Capacity: 75 passengers
Charging technology:
Height in m
60
40 Overnight
20 Duration:
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
From Sept 2014 and ongoing
Distance in km
FIGURES FOR THE BARCELONA DEMO FROM AUGUST 2014 TO AUGUST 2017
62,039 litres 1
163,260km
The distance travelled by ZeEUS buses
The amount of diesel fuel saved by running in pure electric mode
the ZeEUS bus project
1
Assuming 38l/100 km
89,441kg
The amount of carbon dioxide emissions
2
RESULTS AND LESSONS LEARNED “Opportunity charging is the best solution for
TMB. Urban route conditions offer the ideal
• Currently, opportunity charging is the best option for
environment to realise the advantages of
TMB operations. However, the costs and delays of in-
electric buses.”
frastructure installation are the next challenge. Working
hand-in-hand with city council is essential. Mario Canet, Engineering New Development
Responsible, Transports Metropolitans de
• Powertrain, batteries and motors technologies are suffi-
Barcelona
ciently mature to allow implementation.
• Batteries lose power at the predicted rate; LTO batteries
provide the optimum solution for opportunity charging FUTURE PLANS
application Electrify new lines with opportunity charging;
• ‘Zebra’ (Sodium Nickel Chloride) batteries lack reliability. ‘wait and see’ for overnight charging.
In July 2018, TMB will receive seven 18m articu-
lated e-buses from Irizar and Solaris with oppor-
tunity charging.
In 2019, line H16 will be fully electric (with 22 bus-
es) and TMB will begin electrifying another line.
www.zeeus.eu
The ZeEUS project is coordinated by UITP. ZeEUS is co-funded by the European Commission
under the 7th Research & Innovation Framework Programme, Mobility & Transport Directorate
General under grant agreement n° 605485. The ZeEUS project has been launched by the European
Commission in the frame of the European Green Vehicle and Smart Cities & Communities.
Bonn (DE)
DESCRIPTION
Stadtwerke Bonn (SWB Bus und Bahn), the local trans-
port operator, plans to convert its bus fleet from diesel
E-Bus in Bonn, connecting Central Station with
to electric propulsion. The ZeEUS Demonstration, using Headquater of DHL an UNFCCC
six electric buses, is viewed as a first step towards this
ambitious goal.
The 12m battery buses operate on all lines, providing a
comprehensive overview on the opportunities and chal-
lenges of operating buses using an overnight charging DEMO IN BRIEF
approach.
Vehicle technology:
6 x Full Electric
Brand and model:
160 Sileo S12 (Bozankaya)
Bus length: 12m
140
Capacity: 80 passengers
120
Charging technology:
Height in m
40
0 3 6 9 12 15 18
Distance in km
KEY TOPIC
Elevation map of the line route 606
From the outset, any considerations about operating
electric buses SWB Bus und Bahn had to meet three
essential preconditions before any project launch:
OPERATIONAL CONDITIONS • Full integration of electric buses into the existing fleet
Line number: mainly 606/607, also other lines • One-for-one replacement of diesel buses
Typology: City centre and suburban areas • No adaptations to lines and service schedules
Topography: mostly flat with moderate hills The major challenge was to identify the most suita-
ble electric bus for these parameters.
Length: 17km
During the demonstration period, the focus was on
Average commercial speed: 16.6km/h proving the operational suitability during daily ser-
Total daily hours of operation: 13.5h vice while monitoring the development of range, reli-
ability and frequency of repairs.
Total km driven/vehicle/day: 200km
Av. no. of passengers/day: 7,250 passengers
(Mon-Fri)
SORT type: N/A
DEMO TIMELINE
• Apr 2016 - Start of operations
• Nov 2015 - Beginning of training
• Nov 2015 - Preparation of depot/garage
• Jul 2015 - Procurement
• Feb 2015 - Start of tender process
• Jan 2014 - Feasibility study report
• Feb 2012 - Project launch
Six electric Sileo buses in Bonn
FIGURES FOR THE BONN DEMO FROM MARCH 2016 TO DECEMBER 2017
93,736 litres 1
246,674km
The distance travelled by ZeEUS buses
The amount of diesel fuel saved by running in pure electric mode
the ZeEUS bus project
1
Assuming 38l/100 km
99,809kg
The amount of carbon dioxide emissions
2
RESULTS AND LESSONS LEARNED “Bonn is home to UNFCCC and is the German
Capital of Sustainibility. Zero emissions in
• The ZeEUS-Project has provided valuable experience
public transport are our aim and ambition.”
for shaping our future approach
Anja Wenmakers, CEO SWB Bus und Bahn
• From an ecological perspective, we would prefer to con-
vert to electric propulsion as soon as possible. However,
from an economic perspective, we need to be patient
• The reliability and range of the vehicles has to be im-
proved, particularly for low-temperature operations
FUTURE PLANS
• A key challenge in the depot is to ensure effective inter-
action between vehicle and charging infrastructure We will persist with the chosen approach, with
the aim of finding the optimum technical solu-
Conclusion: Currently, it is not feasible to replace diesel tion for balancing economic efficiency with en-
buses with electric buses on a one-to-one basis vironmental sustainability.
www.zeeus.eu
The ZeEUS project is coordinated by UITP. ZeEUS is co-funded by the European Commission
under the 7th Research & Innovation Framework Programme, Mobility & Transport Directorate
General under grant agreement n° 605485. The ZeEUS project has been launched by the European
Commission in the frame of the European Green Vehicle and Smart Cities & Communities.
Cagliari (IT)
DESCRIPTION
CTM evaluated the performance (efficiency, reliability,
etc.) of six battery trolleybuses against both tradition-
Kiepe Van Hool A330T while running the Line
al trolleybuses of the same brand and model equipped 5-ZeEUS by batteries
with a diesel auxiliary power unit (APU) and diesel buses.
The demo was undertaken during normal service (line
5-ZeEUS) using all vehicles simultaneously. A section of
the route was driven using the trolleybuses with the aux-
iliary system only (batteries, diesel APU). DEMO IN BRIEF
Vehicle technology:
100 6 x Battery Trolleybuses
80 Brand and model:
2 x Solaris Trollino T12,
Height in m
60
60
40
20
0
0 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 24
Distance in km
KEY TOPIC
OPERATIONAL CONDITIONS The core of the Cagliari Demo test was to assess the
Line number: Line 5 ZeEUS technical-economic feasibility of trolleybuses. Equip-
ping these vehicles with traction batteries provides all
Typology: City centre – suburban (seafront road) the advantages of trolleybuses - less noise, no local
Topography: Moderate pollution, lower energy costs, etc. - with the flexibility
of traditional buses.
Length: 17.1km (winter configuration),
25.6km (summer configuration) With a properly-designed system of vehicle and
charging infrastructure, battery trolleybuses make
Average commercial speed: 13.3km/h it possible to extend the full-electric public transport
Total daily hours of operation: 15 - 18h service without the need to install new infrastructure
such as overhead lines. This brings environmental
Total km driven/vehicle/day: 180 - 220km
benefits, with significant savings in investment costs
Av. no. of passengers/day: 8,000 passengers and implementation times.
SORT type: N/A
DEMO TIMELINE
• Sept 2017 - end of Cagliari Demo test
• April 2017 -Demo test extension
• August 2016 - charging station completed,
start of service of four Kiepe-Van Hool A330T
• March 2016 - start of the Cagliari Demo Test
with entry into service of two Solaris Trollino T12
FIGURES FOR THE CAGLIARI DEMO FROM MARCH 2016 TO SEPTEMBER 2017
131,837 litres 1
346,940 km
The distance travelled by ZeEUS buses
The amount of diesel fuel saved by running in pure electric mode
the ZeEUS bus project
1
Assuming 38l/100 km
105,100kg
The amount of carbon dioxide emissions
2
The ZeEUS project is coordinated by UITP. ZeEUS is co-funded by the European Commission
under the 7th Research & Innovation Framework Programme, Mobility & Transport Directorate
General under grant agreement n° 605485. The ZeEUS project has been launched by the European
Commission in the frame of the European Green Vehicle and Smart Cities & Communities.
Eindhoven (NL)
DESCRIPTION
The Zuid-Oost-Brabant concession covers a region with
750,000 inhabitants. Its main cities are Eindhoven and
The electric bus in the centre of Eindhoven
Helmond.
The 43 electric buses of Transdev fleet form part of a
fleet of 215 in this concession. All 43 electric buses were
included in the ZeEUS demo in order to test different
pre-heating strategies as from December 2016.
DEMO IN BRIEF
Vehicle technology:
43 x Full Electric
Brand and model:
VDL Citea SLFA-E181
Bus length: 18.15m
80 Capacity: 136 passengers
60 Charging technology:
Combination of opportunity
Height in m
0 Duration:
Dec 2016 – Sept 2017
-20
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Distance in km
KEY TOPIC
OPERATIONAL CONDITIONS Eindhoven is the ZeEUS demo for smart pre-heating
of electric bus interiors and batteries.
Line number: 400, 401, 402, 403, 404, 405, 406
and 407 The e-buses are scheduled to drive 71,000 km per
vehicle per year.
Typology: City centre and suburban
Opportunity charging is through roof-mounted pan-
Topography: Flat tographs and fast chargers within the bus depot dur-
Length: 4.4 - 12.3km ing the day. There are 22 slow chargers of 30kW and
10 fast chargers of 300kW available at the bus depot
Average commercial speed: 18.5 – 27.5km/h
in Eindhoven, situated only 1km from the bus transit
Total daily hours of operation: 20h station.
Total km driven/vehicle/day: During the contract period (2016-2026), the remain-
av. 200km - max 300km ing diesel buses will be replaced with electric buses
Av. no. of passengers/day: (12m - 13m and midis).
11.500 passengers per line
SORT type: E-SORT
DEMO TIMELINE
• Dec 2017 – 3,000,000km driven
• April 2017 – 1,000,000km driven
• Dec 2016 – start of operations
• Nov 2016 – training of 560 drivers
FIGURES FOR THE EINDHOVEN DEMO FROM DECEMBER 2016 TO JANUARY 2018
1,167,054kg
The amount of carbon dioxide emissions
2
www.zeeus.eu
The ZeEUS project is coordinated by UITP. ZeEUS is co-funded by the European Commission
under the 7th Research & Innovation Framework Programme, Mobility & Transport Directorate
General under grant agreement n° 605485. The ZeEUS project has been launched by the European
Commission in the frame of the European Green Vehicle and Smart Cities & Communities.
London (UK)
DESCRIPTION
As part of the ZeEUS project, the London demo trialled
three plug-in electric-diesel hybrid double-decker buses
on route 69. These ran between two major city trans- Bus positioning for charging
port hubs, Canning Town Bus Station and Walthamstow
Central Bus Station.
The buses charged wirelessly at either end of the route,
where they were parked over a 100kW charging plate. In
DEMO IN BRIEF
addition, the batteries were fully charged by overnight
plug-in charging at the bus station. Vehicle technology:
3 x Plug-in Hybrid-drive
electric range extender
Brand and model:
Alexander Dennis, E400 VE
Bus length: 10.3m
Capacity: 83 passengers
Charging technology:
Overnight plug-in charging,
and route termini inductive
wireless charging
Duration:
Nov 2015 - April 2017
KEY TOPIC
OPERATIONAL CONDITIONS Approximately two-thirds of the London bus fleet is
in double deck configuration. This poses a technical
Line number: 69 challenge for pure electric vehicles, given the current
Typology: City Urban state of battery technological maturity. Although
permissible maximum gross vehicle weight has now
Topography: Flat
been increased to 19,500kg, this still presents signifi-
Length: 11km cant challenges in maintaining passenger capacities
Average commercial speed: 12km/h while carrying sufficient battery capacity to achieve
and maintain route schedules.
Total daily hours of operation: 16h
Total km driven/vehicle/day: 160km
Av. no. of passengers/day: 26,966 passengers
SORT type: N/A
DEMO TIMELINE
• April 2017 - buses transition from demonstration trial
status and into normal operation
• April 2016 - Entry into service
• April 2016 - Acceptance testing
• Jan 2016 - First reporting
• Dec 2015 - Official launch
• Nov 2015 - All buses delivered
Official Launch of the London Demo
• Oct 2015 - ADL delivery, driver and engineering training
FIGURES FOR THE LONDON DEMO FROM APRIL 2016 TO DECEMBER 2016
33,582kg
The amount of carbon dioxide emissions
2
The ZeEUS project is coordinated by UITP. ZeEUS is co-funded by the European Commission
under the 7th Research & Innovation Framework Programme, Mobility & Transport Directorate
General under grant agreement n° 605485. The ZeEUS project has been launched by the European
Commission in the frame of the European Green Vehicle and Smart Cities & Communities.
Münster (DE)
DESCRIPTION
The Münster demo consists of five full-battery electric
buses built by manufacturer VDL. These use an op-
The electric buses pass through Münster’s
portunity fast-charging system at terminal stops and historic city centre
slow charging at the depot. With a battery capacity of
62.5kWh, the buses run as a full-day service on an ur-
ban line, serving the city centre and central railway sta-
tion with the zoo and suburban districts.
Zero-emission vehicles, funded by the ZeEUS project, DEMO IN BRIEF
support the Münster clean air plan.
Vehicle technology:
5 x Full Electric
Brand and model:
VDL Citea SLF-120 electric
100
Bus length: 12m
80 Capacity: 80 passengers
Height in m
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Distance in km
KEY TOPIC
Clean air is a key component of healthy living. How-
OPERATIONAL CONDITIONS
ever, many German towns face high nitrogen oxide
Line number: 14 levels from road vehicles emissions. Although each
diesel bus efficiently reduces air pollution by replac-
Typology: City centre and suburban
ing up to 100 cars during rush hour, high demand
Topography: Flat remains for zero-emission public transport.
Length: 11km ZeEUS enabled local energy supplier and trans-
portation company Stadtwerke Münster to operate
Average commercial speed: 14km/h
electric buses at an early stage. This has provided a
Total daily hours of operation: 16h great deal of insight into bus, battery and charging
Total km driven/vehicle/day: 150km infrastructure technologies. This expertise will help
manage the transition from diesel to electric opera-
Av. no. of passengers/day: 5,000 passengers tions within the next years.
SORT type: 2
DEMO TIMELINE
• Since Sept 2016 – continuous operation
• Sept 2016 – change of charging solution from side
coupling to overhead pantograph system
• Sept 2015 – extended operation with fast-charging
side-coupling system at the terminal stations and
slow charging at the depot
• May 2015 – start of short-range operation until com-
pletion of fast charging stations Charging by pantograph. The substation imitates an
electric bus
FIGURES FOR THE MÜNSTER DEMO FROM NOVEMBER 2016 TO AUGUST 2017
44,844litres 1
118,012km
The distance travelled by ZeEUS buses
The amount of diesel fuel saved by running in pure electric mode
the ZeEUS bus project
1
Assuming 38l/100 km
49,047kg
The amount of carbon dioxide emissions
2
RESULTS AND LESSONS LEARNED “Electric buses represent the future of pub-
lic transport. The ZeEUS projects gave us a
• Electric buses are perceived positively by passengers,
head start, enabling us to support cities from
residents and bus drivers
near and far.”
• The charging infrastructure is key to the reliability of
Eckhard Schläfke, Public Transport Manager,
the buses
Stadtwerke Münster
• Many of the frequent technical failures related to oper-
ating errors or vehicle malfunctions rather than to the
electrical propulsion technology
FUTURE PLANS
• On-board support from a trainer during real-world op-
eration helps instil driver confidence in the vehicle tech- Stadtwerke Münster will continue on the “zero
nology emissions” path started with ZeEUS. Two hy-
drogen fuel cell and five additional VDL electric
• Integrating e-buses into a diesel fleet takes time buses will operate in Münster from 2018. The
latter will use the same charging infrastructure
but their larger batteries offer greater flexibility,
whilst the former have 400+ km range.
www.zeeus.eu
The ZeEUS project is coordinated by UITP. ZeEUS is co-funded by the European Commission
under the 7th Research & Innovation Framework Programme, Mobility & Transport Directorate
General under grant agreement n° 605485. The ZeEUS project has been launched by the European
Commission in the frame of the European Green Vehicle and Smart Cities & Communities.
PILSEN (CZ)
DESCRIPTION
The project was designed to test full-electric buses in
combination with rapid-charging infrastructure in re-
Battery Bus SKODA PERUN
al-time operations. The objective was to assess the po-
tential for replacing diesel buses. This is considered a
landmark in Pilsen´s and Skoda´s history of cooperation
with PMDP (Plzeňské městské dopravní podniky/Pilsen
City Transport Company) as a bus, tram and trolleybus
operator, Plzenska Teplarenska as an energy provider DEMO IN BRIEF
and West Bohemian University as an academic and re-
search partner. Vehicle technology:
2 x Full Electric
Brand and model:
ŠKODA PERUN E-BUS
450 Bus length: 12m
Capacity: 82 passengers
400
Charging technology:
Height in m
KEY TOPIC
OPERATIONAL CONDITIONS The goal of the project was to test pure-electric vehi-
cle operations on the most frequently-used bus line
Line number: 27, 33 to compare the environmental and financial perfor-
Typology: City centre, suburban area mance of electric buses in public transport. The ŠKO-
DA vehicles were pure-electric, 12m-length full low-
Topography: Hilly floor city buses with an advanced battery system
Length: 6km allows rapid charging at one terminal station. The
rapid-charging solution selected was the most effec-
Average commercial speed: 25km/h tive given the combination of the length of the bus
Total daily hours of operation: 7.5-18.5h line, the time needed for charging and the required
vehicle parameters such as passenger capacity.
Total km driven/vehicle/day: 80 - 200km
Av. no. of passengers/day: 1258
SORT type: SORT1, SORT2
DEMO TIMELINE
• April 2017 - end of e-bus demo operation
• May 2015 - e-buses enter service
• Sept 2014 - start of e-bus testing
• March 2014 - installation of the charging infrastructure
• March 2014 - detailed e-bus and charging station-
technical specifications
FIGURES FOR THE PILSEN DEMO FROM MAY 2015 TO APRIL 2017
17,852 litres 1
46,980km
The distance travelled by ZeEUS buses
The amount of diesel fuel saved by running in pure electric mode
the ZeEUS bus project
1
Assuming 38l/100 km
6,149kg
The amount of carbon dioxide emissions
2
The ZeEUS project is coordinated by UITP. ZeEUS is co-funded by the European Commission
under the 7th Research & Innovation Framework Programme, Mobility & Transport Directorate
General under grant agreement n° 605485. The ZeEUS project has been launched by the European
Commission in the frame of the European Green Vehicle and Smart Cities & Communities.
STOCKHOLM (SE)
DESCRIPTION
This was part of the EU-funded ZeEUS project led by
UITP. Volvo, Vattenfall, Viktoria ICT and Stockholm
Two Volvo Electric hybrid buses driving in
County cooperated to demonstrate eight opportuni- Stockholm
ty-charged electric hybrid buses.
The demonstration was in standard traffic conditions,
replacing existing Keolis-operated buses on route 73 in
central Stockholm.
DEMO IN BRIEF
The objective was to demonstrate these buses in public
transport operations with low emissions, energy con- Vehicle technology:
sumption and noise levels while maintaining high per- 8 x Plug-in Hybrid Electric
formance and cost efficiency. Brand and model:
Volvo 7900 Electric Hybrid
25 Length: 12.13m
Capacity: 71 passengers
20
Charging technology: Two
opportunity fast chargers with
Height in m
15
descending arm pantograph
10 Duration:
March 2015-Dec 2016
5
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Distance in km
KEY TOPIC
OPERATIONAL CONDITIONS The demonstration in Stockholm focused on testing
an automatic fast-charging bus with a pantograph
Line number: 73 on a charging pole at each end of the route com-
Typology: City centre bined with overnight charging at the depot.
FIGURES FOR THE STOCKHOLM DEMO FROM MARCH 2015 TO DECEMBER 2016
170,163kg
The theoretical amount of carbon dioxide emissions
3
2
The ZeEUS project is coordinated by UITP. ZeEUS is co-funded by the European Commission
under the 7th Research & Innovation Framework Programme, Mobility & Transport Directorate
General under grant agreement n° 605485. The ZeEUS project has been launched by the European
Commission in the frame of the European Green Vehicle and Smart Cities & Communities.
WARSAW (PL)
DESCRIPTION
MZA purchased 10 Solaris Urbino U12 e-buses as the
first phase in electrifying city centre transport. Current-
ly, the buses operate on line 222, which passes through
the congested centre as well as the historic part of the Solaris Urbino 12 electric in service
city. The entire line is operated solely with e-buses. Pas-
sengers appreciate the comfort and driving dynamics,
despite the fact it can sometimes be crowded (for ob-
vious reasons). An efficient HVAC system completes the
positive overall opinion of the vehicle.
DEMO IN BRIEF
300 Vehicle technology:
10 x Full Electric
250
Brand and model:
Solaris Urbino 12 electric
Height in m
200
Bus length: 12m
150 Capacity: 70 passengers
50 Charging technology:
0 2 4 6 8 10 Plug in at depot, pantograph at
0 Distance in km terminal
Duration:
Elevation map of the line route
Since June 2015 to present
OPERATIONAL CONDITIONS
Line number: 222
Typology: City centre
Topography: flat
Length: 13.75km
Average commercial speed: 12km/h
Total daily hours of operation: 16h
Total km driven/vehicle/day: 160km
Av. no. of passengers/day: 581
SORT type: SORT 1
DEMO TIMELINE
• Dec 2016 - Pantograph charger was built on the
terminus of line 222 (fed from commercial energy
provider)
• Dec 2016 - All e-buses equipped with roof panto-
graphs
• June 2015 - Start of operations begun
• Dec 2014 - first bus operational
• Nov 2013 - start of project
KEY TOPIC
The objective of the Warsaw project has been to demon- Opportunity charging at the end of the line
strate that electric buses are fully substitutable for their
diesel counterparts on the same route. The environmen-
tal benefits have been be realised through using electric
buses with the ability to charging either in the depot or at
FUTURE PLANS
the end of the line (terminus).
In 2018 MZA will operate a total of thirty
The MZA Warszawa has an impact on the environment
12-meter electric buses.
through diesel fuel savings and reducing CO2 emissions,
GHG emissions, SO2 emissions as well as other pollut- Between 2019 and 2020, MZA intends to pur-
ants. Noise pollution is also reduced. chase further 130 articulated e-buses.
www.zeeus.eu
The ZeEUS project is coordinated by UITP. ZeEUS is co-funded by the European Commission
under the 7th Research & Innovation Framework Programme, Mobility & Transport Directorate
General under grant agreement n° 605485. The ZeEUS project has been launched by the European
Commission in the frame of the European Green Vehicle and Smart Cities & Communities.
ZeEUS in brief
Scope Testing electrification solutions at the heart of the urban bus system
network through live urban demonstrations and facilitating the market
uptake of electric buses in Europe.
Partners
Stockholm
Public Transport