GROUP LEADERS - Please print this one for purposes of your FS defense. Thanks, and good luck!
Attendance will be strictly checked before the start of your presentations. Anyone who misses this final activity shall get zero for four (4) course requirements.
SCORING RUBRICS FOR FEASIBILITY GROUP PRESENTATION AND PAPER 3
Designed by Prof. GAB Orcena
A. PRESENTATION
CRITERION DESCRIPTION MAXIMUM POINTS ACTUAL POINTS
Concept Originality Feasibility concept is 4 relatively original, unique, or extra-ordinary; otherwise, interestingly adapted (cite original source), and as much as possible, is aligned to technical disciplines Innovativeness / Creativity Feasibility introduces 4 interesting innovative features in terms of the product itself, service delivery, physical setting, etc. Implementation Feasibility implementation 4 Feasibility/ Procedural procedures are Clarity convenient, well-defined and logical. Accuracy of Financial Financial projections 4 Projections which include the project cost, revenues, production costs and profits are accurate, clear, complete and trustworthy with assumptions properly laid down. Environmental Foresight Feasibility incorporates 4 principles of environmental awareness, stewardship, care and protection Oral Presentation Skills Presenter has excellent 4 communication skills, competent, and exudes positive aura Responsiveness & Feasibility proponents 4 Aggressiveness provide sensible answers to questions, and are modestly persuasive Group Personality Group solidarity or 4 teamwork is evident - prior to, during, and after the presentation; Members are as well accommodating and respectful of the client Group Preparedness Physical setting is properly 4 set-up equipped with appropriate and interesting technology, materials, resources, etc.; Recommended dress code is properly observed Time Management Presentation starts and 4 ends promptly. Group is ready ahead of time. No delays. No extensions. No excuses. TOTAL POINTS 40
B. FEASIBILITY PAPER
CRITERION DESCRIPTION MAXIMUM POINTS ACTUAL POINTS
Concept Originality Feasibility concept is 4 relatively original, unique, or extra-ordinary; otherwise, interestingly adapted (cite original source), and as much as possible aligned to technical disciplines Innovativeness / Feasibility introduces 4 Creativity interesting innovative features in terms of the product itself, service delivery, physical setting, etc. Implementation Feasibility implementation 4 Feasibility/ Procedural procedures are Clarity convenient, well-defined and logical. Accuracy of Financial Financial projections 4 Projections which include the project cost, revenues, production costs and profits are accurate, clear, complete and trustworthy with assumptions properly laid down. Environmental Foresight Feasibility incorporates 4 principles of environmental awareness, stewardship, care and protection Content Quality & Feasibility format is 4 Adequacy properly observed; otherwise interestingly modified; Various aspects of feasibility are highly evident and sufficient. Discussions are succinct and yet comprehensive. Language Quality Language structures and 4 semantics adhere to standards of effective writing styles Logic and Coherence Discussions are clearly 4 logical, and portions of feasibility are interestingly interwoven. Correct Grammar and Rules of correct and good 4 Documentation grammar are properly observed. Paper is also well-documented with references cited. Adequacy of Figures, Appendices contain 4 Instruments & necessary figures, Illustrations instruments, illustrations, etc. TOTAL 40