Anda di halaman 1dari 33

What is SSVEP?

Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Enhancement of SSVEP-Based BCI Systems via a


Steady-State Motion Visual Stimulus Modality
Yunyong Punsawad, Yodchanan Wongsawata

Youmna Ismaeil1

1 Computer Science

June 7, 2018

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 1 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Overview
1 What is SSVEP?
2 Types of Stimuli
3 SSVEP applications
4 Problem
5 Solution
Change of Stimuli
Visual Motion Stimulus
6 Example
7 Stimuli in action
EEG
Algorithm
SSVEP Results
Motion Results
8 Hybrid System
Hybrid System Results
9 Summary
10 Reference
11 extra

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 2 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

What is SSVEP?

Brain signal
Flickering stimuli at constant rate
stable over time
Trigger harmonics

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 3 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Types of Stimuli

Figure: A Stimuli with flickering light as depicted by [Walters, 2018]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 4 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Types of Stimuli

Figure: A Stimuli with flickering pattern as designed by [mrbobowen, 2018]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 4 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Figure: A music player controller with flickering light as proposed by [Zerafa et al., 2018]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 5 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Problem ?

Figure: A Stimuli with flickering pattern as designed by [mrbobowen, 2018]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 6 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Solution

Proposed Solutions

Change flickering rate


Change color of the stimuli
Or Just flicker but without anyone noticing

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 7 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Visual Motion Stimulus

Visual Motion Stimulus

Figure: Motion stimuli as proposed in [Yunyong and Yodchanan, ]

Text
Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 8 / 25
What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Visual Motion Stimulus

Visual Motion Stimulus

Text

Figure: Motion stimuli as proposed in [Yunyong and Yodchanan, ]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 8 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Visual Motion Stimulus

Visual Motion Stimulus

Figure: Motion stimuli as proposed in [Yunyong and Yodchanan, ]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 8 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Visual Motion Stimulus

Visual Motion Stimulus

Figure: Motion stimuli as proposed in [Yunyong and Yodchanan, ]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 8 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Visual Motion Stimulus

Visual Motion Stimulus

Figure: Motion stimuli as proposed in [Yunyong and Yodchanan, ]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 8 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Visual Motion Stimulus

Expectations vs Realty

Text

Figure: motion stimuli simulated as motion to the right Figure: motion stimuli is in reality flickering with 7 Hz

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 9 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Working example

Two moving stimuli, both with


flickering rate of 7 Hz
Commands left and right
measure SSVEP using EEG

Figure: Motion stimuli as depicted in


[Yunyong and Yodchanan, ]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 10 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

EEG

How to obtain a signal?

EEG
recording brain signals
location of importance

Figure: A model of EEG hats as found in


[Issa, 2018]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 11 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

EEG

Electrode Locations

Naming convention (O, T, F, C, ...)


Ground Connections (Fz)
Reference Connections (C3, C4)
EGG signal to contributions

Figure: Locations of the electrodes


as in [Asanagi, 2018]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 12 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

EEG

Power Spectrum Density (PSD)

contribution of f
Welch PSD
Fourier transform

Figure: Power spectrum density of Noise as depicted in


[Lopes et al., 2007]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 13 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

EEG

Power Spectrum Density (PSD)

Figure: Summary of signal extraction as depicted in


Figure: Power spectrum density of Noise as depicted in [Chumerin et al., ]
[Lopes et al., 2007]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 13 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Algorithm

SSVEP Algorithm

Start

EEG signal
processing Baseline
(PSD)

Extract features
PSD - baseline

Normalize
remove -ve
features

yes
right left > Right

No

yes No
Nothing left = Right left

Figure: Diagram showing the SSVEP Algorithm for both O1 and O2 signals

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 14 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

SSVEP Results

Experiment and Results

SSVEP
Subject accuracy(%)
1 92.5
7 healthy subjects 2 82.5
No prior experience 3 80.0
40 trials 4 85.0
20 right 5 85.0
20 left 6 77.5
7 82.5
mean 83.57±4.76

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 15 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

SSVEP Results

Different Notations

flickering -> SSVEP


No flickering
Alpha band, 10-12 Hz
Beta band, 14-25 Hz
Motion and Alpha & beta band signals
Assumptions: PSDO1α ≈ PSDO1β , => right Vice versa

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 16 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Motion Results

Motion Visual Stimuli Algorithm

Start

EEG signal
processing
(PSD)

Attention indices
ratio => PSD_alpha/
PSD_(alpah, beta)

Difference
alpah - beta

Normalize
remove -ve
& >0.25 

yes
right Ndiff_1< Ndiff2

No

yes No
Nothing Ndiff_1= Ndiff2 left

Figure: Diagram showing the motion stimuli Algorithm for both O1 and O2 signals

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 17 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Motion Results

Experiment and Results

SSVEP vs Motion
Subject SSVEP(%) motion(%)

7 healthy subjects 1 92.5 87.5


2 82.5 70.0
No prior experience
3 80.0 80.0
focus on the cross
4 85.0 75.0
40 trials 5 85.0 85.0
20 right
20 left 6 77.5 75.0
7 82.5 77.5
mean 83.57±4.76 78.57±6.10

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 18 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Hybrid System and Application

SSVEP
13 HZ option
Forward option

Figure: Extended SSVEP stimuli as depicted in


[Yunyong and Yodchanan, ]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 19 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Hybrid System and Application

Motion Stimuli
13 HZ option
Forward option
stop command

Figure: Extended motion stimuli as depicted in


[Yunyong and Yodchanan, ]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 20 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Hybrid System Results

Experiment and Results

Hybrid system
Subject Hybrid(%)
1 85.83
2 89.18
10 healthy subjects 3 82.93
3 no prior experience 4 86.68
5 83.35
15 mins training
6 85.75
30 mins SSVEP
7 86.68
30 motion stimuli 8 82.5
-trials/command
9 83.33
10 90.0
mean 85.62±2.48
meantime/command 4.14

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 21 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Hybrid System Results

Summary

SSVEP signals are triggered by flickering stimuli


Application of SSVEP systems
Problems with flickering Stimuli
Possible solution
Introduction of motion stimuli
From Stimuli to action
SSVEP Algorithm experiments and results
motion detection stimuli experiments and results
Hybrid systems in Wheelchairs
Results

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 22 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Reference I

Asanagi (2018).
cerebral cortex.
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:
21_electrodes_of_International_10-20_system_for_EEG.svg.
Chumerin, N., Manyakov, N. V., van Vliet, M., Robben, A., Combaz, A., and Hulle,
M. M. V.
Processing and decoding steady-state visual evoked potentials for brain-computer
interfaces.
Laboratorium voor Neuro- en Psychofysiologie, KU Leuven, Campus
Gasthuisberg, O&N 2, Herestraat 49, 3000 Leuven, Belgium.
Issa, N. P. (2018).
cerebral cortex.
https://www.docneuro.com/cerebral-cortex.html.
Lopes, P. A. C., Germano, J., Almeida, T. M., Sousa, L., Piedade, M. S., Cardoso,
F., Ferreira, H. A., and Freitas, P. P. (2007).
A new handheld biochip-based microsystem.
In 2007 IEEE International Symposium on Circuits and Systems, pages
2379–2382.

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 23 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

Reference II

mrbobowen (2018).
Visual evoked potential (vep) - can also uncover scotomas.wmv.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xEd1h_lz4rA.
Walters, J. (2018).
A quick intro to ssvep: Steady state visually evoked potential.
http://synaptitude.me/blog/
a-quick-intro-to-ssvep-steady-state-visually-evoked-potential/.
Yunyong, P. and Yodchanan, W.
Enhancement of steady-state visual evoked potential-based brain–computer
interface systems via a steady-state motion visual stimulus modality.
IEEE Transactions on Electrical and Electronic Engineering, 12(S1):S89–S94.
Zerafa, R., Camilleri, T., and Falzon, O. (2018).
Ssvep-based brain-computer interface (bci) system for real-time application.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uekFQ6X5Gg0.

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 24 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

extra

motion visual stimuli


Simulation

Figure: Brain topographic mapping of Occipital lobe


with motion visual stimuli as depicted in
[Yunyong and Yodchanan, ]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 25 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

extra

Motor Cortex
central area
C2, C4
Motion Visual
stimuli
Simulation

Figure: Brain topographic mapping of central


area with motion stimuli as depicted in
[Yunyong and Yodchanan, ]

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 25 / 25


What is SSVEP? Types of Stimuli SSVEP applications Problem Solution Example Stimuli in action Hybrid System Summary Reference extra

extra

Occipital lobe and motion detection


Akinetopsia: Motion blindness
precise, symmetric damage to small
part in the occipital lobe

Youmna Ismaeil Saarland University SSVEP June 7, 2018 25 / 25

Anda mungkin juga menyukai