School of Biological Sciences, Monash University, Clayton Campus, Victoria 3800, Australia
ABSTRACT The interaction between the two main com- Bryant and Russell, 1995). Certain geometric prin-
peting geometric determinants of teeth (the geometry of ciples were established in these articles, but several
function and the geometry of occlusion) were investigated of the predictions made appear to have remained
through the construction of three-dimensional spatial untested. Also, there does not seem to be a clear
models of several mammalian tooth forms (carnassial,
understanding of all geometric aspects of occlusion
insectivore premolar, zalambdodont, dilambdodont, and
tribosphenic). These models aim to emulate the shape and in many tooth forms. No comprehensive analysis of
function of mammalian teeth. The geometric principles of these principles has been carried out, nor any inves-
occlusion relating to single- and double-crested teeth are tigation of their implications. For example, we
reviewed. Function was considered using engineering would like to know what dental shapes are feasible
principles that relate tooth shape to function. Substantial given certain geometric constraints; i.e., what are
similarity between the models and mammalian teeth were the limits to possible occlusal morphologies?
achieved. Differences between the two indicate the influ- The tooth form of occluding “primitive” therian
ence of tooth strength, geometric relations between upper teeth has been considered as a set of “reversed tri-
and lower teeth (including the presence of the protocone), angles” (Fig. 1a; Crompton and Sita-Lumsden, 1970;
and wear on tooth morphology. The concept of “autocclu- Crompton et al., 1994). This notion formed part of
sion” is expanded to include any morphological features
that ensure proper alignment of cusps on the same tooth
the “trituberculy” theory of dental evolution (Os-
and other teeth in the tooth row. It is concluded that the born, 1888, 1897; Gregory, 1916), in which it was
tooth forms examined are auto-aligning, and do not re- hypothesized that the ancestral dental shape of the-
quire additional morphological guides for correct align- rians was of this form. However, many features of
ment. The model of therian molars constructed by Cromp- the geometry of occlusion and the full ramifications
ton and Sita-Lumsden ([1970] Nature 227:197–199) is of the “reversed triangle” design appear not to have
reconstructed in 3D space to show that their hypothesis of been evaluated. The study of Crompton and Sita-
crest geometry is erroneous, and that their model is a Lumsden (1970) modeled the two-bladed basic the-
special case of a more general class of models. J. Morphol. rian molar pattern as reversed triangles (each cusp
267:649 – 662, 2006. © 2004 Wiley-Liss, Inc. is basically triangular and has two blades, the diag-
onal and transverse shearing edges, leading down
KEY WORDS: modeling; functional morphology; dental;
dentition; autocclusion; mammal; VRML; 3D from it; Fig. 1b). It was concluded that it would be
impossible for both of the blades on such a molar to
be two-dimensional curves: a 2D curve is one that
lies within a plane and is curved in only two dimen-
Teeth are attractive as study subjects for many sions rather than three, such as the letter “S” and a
and varied reasons, including their substantial con- scimitar blade. If so, this would greatly limit the
tribution to the vertebrate fossil record and their possible tooth and crest shapes, but the hypothesis
intriguing developmental processes (Butler, 1981; has not been tested.
Fortelius, 1985; Jernvall, 1995). Another notable In order to deal with the complexity and diversity
reason is the four-dimensional puzzles they present. of mammalian tooth forms, it is necessary to eluci-
Teeth have complex three-dimensional geometries
that interlock with their occluding counterparts in a
temporal sequence. Perhaps more important, the
Supplementary material for this article is available from the first
purpose of the geometry of the dentition is to per- author or via the Internet at http://www.interscience.wiley.com/
form several functions, the most significant of which jpages/0362-2525/suppmat
is the efficient break-down of food (Lucas, 1979).
Various aspects of tooth geometry and occlusion *Correspondence to: Dr. Alistair Evans, Institute of Biotechnology,
have been investigated for tooth forms, including University of Helsinki, P.O. Box 56 (Viikinkaari 9), FIN-00014 Uni-
versity of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland. E-mail: arevans@fastmail.fm
tribosphenic-like (Crompton and Sita-Lumsden,
1970; Kay and Hiiemae, 1974; Crompton et al., Published online 29 November 2004 in
1994), herbivore (Greaves, 1972; Fortelius, 1985), Wiley InterScience (www.interscience.wiley.com)
and carnivore molariform teeth (Mellett, 1981, 1985; DOI: 10.1002/jmor.10285
Fig. 2. Simple single-bladed models used as starting points for modeling mammalian teeth, illustrating occlusal geometrical
principles: (a) symmetrical with vertical movement; (b) symmetrical with latero-vertical movement; (c) asymmetrical with latero-
vertical movement. The blade edge and rake and relief surfaces of the upper (U) and lower (L) models are indicated. The lower model
moves according to the occlusal vector (solid arrow), and occluding blade edges always lie in the plane of blade occlusion (transparent
gray plane). In all figures, upper model is dark, lower is light. Additional terms defined in text. Light source for all 3D models comes
directly from the viewer (like a headlight), so the more perpendicular to the viewer, the lighter the shading.
two occluding blades or teeth. This includes multiple points, and these are shown in Figures 2 and 3. These simple
planes, curves, and a combination of the two with shapes are excellent initial shapes for modeling teeth because
they have been explicitly derived: their shape and the reasoning
planes separated by curved joins (Fig. 4). behind their construction are precisely known. In Evans and
Sanson (2003), the simple shapes were made by starting with
regular geometrical shapes (cube and triangular prism) and in-
MATERIALS AND METHODS corporating functional criteria without reference to real tooth
Models of several mammalian tooth forms were constructed forms. There are many similarities between the simple shapes
according to the following procedure. For each tooth form, the and real tooth structures before additional modifications are
surfaces of cusps and crests (and basins when present) were made, but the objective of this study is to make models that
modeled as polygons in 3D space where the vertices of each specifically emulate mammalian teeth.
polygon were designated by x, y, z coordinates. The lower model The simple models may represent entire mammalian teeth, or
moves with respect to the upper model according to the “occlusal components of the teeth, so that each model tooth is constructed
vector,” the direction of lower tooth movement. Occluding crests from one or more duplicates of the starting models. Successive
were constructed according to the geometry described above to changes were made to the models in a step-by-step process in
ensure proper alignment in all models. The tooth structures were order to more closely emulate real tooth forms. For instance,
represented in Virtual Reality Modeling Language (VRML; relative positions of crests and cusps and the angles of certain
Evans et al., 2001; Evans and Sanson, 2003), which allows ani- surfaces may be changed in the model so they more accurately
mation of 3D structures to demonstrate occlusion. represent the shape of the real tooth. However, no major changes
The models of single- and double-bladed tools constructed in were made to features such as the number of blades, so a reason-
the study by Evans and Sanson (2003) were used as starting able degree of similarity is still apparent between the final models
Fig. 3. Simple double-bladed models used as starting points for modeling mammalian teeth, illustrating occlusal geometrical
principles: (a) protoconoid with latero-vertical movement; (b) showing planes of blade occlusion; (c) two lower and one upper
protoconoid in occlusion; (d) right-angled protoconoid. The intersection of planes of blade occlusion is indicated by a dashed line, which
is parallel to the occlusal vector. Other conventions follow Figure 2.
Fig. 5. Mammalian tooth forms modeled in this study. a– d: Carnassial, PM4 (a,b) and M1 (c,d) (Felis catus; Carnivora: Felidae).
e– h: Zalambdodont, M2 (e,f) and M2 (g,h) (Tenrec ecaudatus; Insectivora: Tenrecidae). i–l: Dilambdodont, M2 (i,j) and M2 (k,l) (Myotis
daubentoni; Chiroptera: Vespertilionidae). m–p: Tribosphenic, M2 (m,n) and M2 (o,p) (Didelphis virginiana; Didelphimorphia:
Didelphidae). Lower right-side teeth in lingual (a,e,i,m) and occlusal (b,f,j,n) views; upper right-side teeth in lingual (c,g,k,o) and
occlusal (d,h,l,p) views. Anterior to left. Scale bars ⫽ 1 mm.
a fundamental cusp-crest structure found in many tooth forms side of the upper model, and “en echelon shear” occurs, where
(Evans and Sanson, 2003). The base of the protoconoid is an a blade from the lower model sequentially occludes with two or
equilateral triangle, and two of the top edges form blades, each of more blades of the upper (Crompton and Sita-Lumsden, 1970),
which has a V-shaped notch (Fig. 3). There are three main points between the lower model and two protoconoids in the upper
on the protoconoid, which occur at the end of blades, and the point model.
at the junction of the two blades is the tallest point on the model. Tribosphenic molars. The tribosphenic molar model was
The lower model moves with a latero-vertical occlusal vector. The based on the basic dilambdodont model, the main difference
upper and lower zalambdodont molars were modeled as “right- being that the center cusp of the ectoloph does not reach the
angled” protoconoids, where the base of the protoconoid is a buccal edge. In addition, the crests of the centrocrista are not
right-angled triangle with one blade perpendicular to the side of concave in the same manner as the dilambdodont form (Butler,
the model and the other oblique (Fig. 3d). 1996).
Dilambdodont molars. Each of the upper and lower dil- Improved dilambdodont molars model. To illustrate how
ambdodont molars was modeled as two “right-angled” proto- some of the differences between the models and real teeth
conoids in series. A third protoconoid was added on the lateral influence the form of the models, a second model of the dil-
Fig. 6. Modified models of mammalian tooth forms: (a) carnassial; (b) insectivore premolar; (c) zalambdodont; (d) dilambdodont;
(e) tribosphenic. A single upper and lower model is shown for carnassial and insectivore premolar; two upper and two lower models
are shown for zalambdodont, dilambdodont and tribosphenic. Planes of blade occlusion are shown in d to illustrate en echelon shear.
The main difference in the dilambdodont and tribosphenic models is the distance of the mesostyle from the buccal edge of the model.
ant, anterior; buc, buccal; dors, dorsal. LAP, lower anterior protoconoid; LPP, lower posterior protoconoid; UAP, upper anterior
protoconoid; ULP, upper lateral protoconoid; UPP, upper posterior protoconoid. Light source from viewer.
Fig. 7. Improved model of dilambdodont molars incorporating an anterior component to the previously dorsolingual movement,
crescentic crests on the upper ectoloph crests and preprotocrista, and paracone smaller than the metacone, with consequently smaller
talonid basin and shorter hypoconid. a: Nomenclature of upper and lower dilambdodont molars, and separate views of the upper and
lower dilambdodont models. The centrocrista comprises the postparacrista and the premetacrista. Lingual (b), posterior (c), and
buccal-occlusal (d) views of two upper and two lower model molars just after occlusion has started (top) and at centric occlusion
(bottom), where the lower molar is at its dorsal maximum and the protocone is at the base of the talonid basin. Abbreviations and
conventions follow Figure 6.
ture (Fig. 6b). In the two upper and two lower through the blades that occlude. Another blade is
zalambdodont molars shown in Figure 6c, each added to the lateral edge of the lower posterior pro-
zalambdodont molar occludes with two opposing toconoid (the previously non-occluding third edge)
models. that occludes with the posterior blade of the upper
As well as the two protoconoids in serial arrange- lateral protoconoid.
ment, the model of the upper dilambdodont tooth The main modifications in creating the dilambd-
has a third protoconoid (with the protocone as the odont model result from the addition of protocone.
main cusp) in a lateral position (Fig. 6d). Two main These can be summarized as follows:
functional changes result: on each tooth, two addi-
tional occluding blades and a flat “crushing” basin 1. The lower posterior protoconoid main cusp (hypo-
are created. The crushing surfaces are the rake sur- conid) was reduced in height and/or moved buc-
faces of the lower posterior and upper lateral proto- cally to prevent it from colliding with the rake
conoids. These are the talonid and the trigon basins, surface of the upper lateral protoconoid.
respectively, and they meet at the end of the occlusal 2. Two crests were added to the lower models
stroke. The posterior blade of the lower anterior against which the crests of the upper lateral pro-
protoconoid occludes with two blades in the one toconoid main cusp (protocone) occlude: the crest
stroke: with the anterior blade of the upper lateral running from the posterior cusp of the lower an-
protoconoid and the anterior blade of the upper lat- terior protoconoid (postmetacristid) and the crest
eral protoconoid. This en echelon shear is shown in on the exit structure of the lower posterior proto-
Figure 6d, where the plane of blade occlusion passes conoid (entocristid).
3. The height of the anterior crest of the lower pos- molars is now further removed from the initial pro-
terior protoconoid (cristid obliqua) was reduced toconoid shape.
so that it no longer connected to the posterior Additional changes were made for the improved
cusp of the lower anterior protoconoid (metac- dilambdodont model to increase the similarity to
onid) and instead terminated near the base of the real dilambdodont teeth (Figs. 7, 8). Three different
lower anterior protoconoid main cusp (proto- views of the 3D reconstruction of Crompton and
conid). This allowed the anterior crest of the up- Sita-Lumsden’s (1970) model are shown in Figure 9.
per lateral protoconoid (preprotocrista) to shear The blades of the reconstructed model fit within
against the posterior crests of the lower anterior planes and are therefore 2D curves.
protoconoid (protocristid and postmetacristid). The supplementary material contains VRML files
4. The basin of the lower posterior protoconoid (tal- for all model teeth constructed here, showing the 3D
onid basin) was deepened to form relief behind shape and animated occlusion of the models, and is
the new crests (postmetacristid and entocristid). also available from the first author.
The main modification made in order to construct
the tribosphenic model was the movement of the DISCUSSION
mesostyle from the buccal edge of the tooth, requir-
ing lingual and dorsal movement of the hypoconid The models constructed above have significant
(Fig. 6e). The shape of the main cusps in the upper similarities to the tooth forms on which they were
Improvements to Models
The improved dilambdodont model has now a very
high level of similarity to the teeth on which it is
modeled, emulating both the shape and function of
these teeth (Figs. 7, 8). Additional modifications to
the improved dilambdodont model could be intro-
duced, such as movement of the lower teeth in an
arc-like fashion, simulating the closing of a jaw,
rather than the linear trajectory that was used. This
would affect the size and orientation of the tooth
components along the tooth row, depending on the
distance from the condyle and its height above the
Fig. 10. The effect of wear and crest shape on the alignment of tooth row, but is not likely to change the overall
occluding notches. Each sequence (a,b) illustrates a particular shape of the models to a great extent.
arrangement of crests (thick lines) and notches on upper (dark)
and lower (light) teeth in the unworn and worn states, and shows
the change in shape after the removal of dental material by wear Influence of Protocone on Tooth Shape
(horizontal hatching). a: Both the upper and lower crests are
notched. Following wear, which mostly occurs on the end of the The models give us the unprecedented ability to
crest with the higher cusp (metacone (me) for the upper and analyze the effect of the protocone on overall tooth
protoconid (prd) for the lower), the notches no longer align in shape. In effect, this identifies the changes that are
occlusion. However, when one of the crests is curved (b), the required to create the dilambdodont and tribos-
effects on the alignment of the notch are not as severe. Dashed
lines show points at which the ends of crests occlude, dotted lines phenic forms. In order to ensure proper functioning
show the location of the upper (U) and lower (L) notches. Anterior of the upper lateral protoconoid (protocone and as-
view, with occlusal vector vertical. sociated crests) added to the two-protoconoid serial
structure, several modifications were required.
These mostly relate to the addition of crests to the
tribosphenic teeth (e.g., microbats Rhinolophus lower posterior protoconoid that occlude with the
blasii and Plecotus townsendii; marsupial Didelphis newly added upper lateral protoconoid, and the
marsupialis). However, upper dilambdodont and tri- shifting of the main cusp of the lower posterior pro-
bosphenic teeth usually do not have notched ectol- toconoid and associated crests to prevent collision
oph crests. This may be because a pointed notch may with the new protoconoid.
increase stress concentrations in the tooth at the tip Increasing the number of blades in close proximity
of the notch, with a subsequent rise in the risk of the (e.g., through the addition of a protocone on the
tooth fracturing at that point. An alternative is that upper tooth) leads to modifications in the shape and
it is related to the depth of tooth underneath the function of the adjacent blades. Capture by several
ectoloph crests, such that a deep, V-shaped notch of the blades (e.g., cristid obliqua, postmetacristid) is
would not fit. reduced or removed. This is particularly true for the
Effects of wear on occlusion. An important centrocrista crests of the upper tribosphenic molar,
difference between real teeth and the models is that where food is captured by the combination of the two
the former must accommodate wear. This becomes crests (postparacrista and premetacrista making up
important when we consider how tooth shape and the centrocrista) rather than one. The rake angles of
occlusion may be affected by wear. The function of the crests associated with both the lower posterior
notched crests will be optimal when the notches of protoconoid (hypoconid) and the upper lateral proto-
opposing crests align in occlusion (Fig. 10a). If conoid (protocone) are decreased, and are therefore
notches do not align, such as when their relative not as efficient. Fragment clearance from the lower
positions along the crests alter after wear, there posterior protoconoid is impeded by the addition of a
may be regions in which the approach angles of blade on the internal surface of the exit structure.
opposing crests are close to parallel, thereby reduc- This shows the influence of geometrical constraints