All rights reserved. No part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or
transmitted in any form or by any means without the prior permission from the Publisher.
Richmond publications may contain links to third party websites or apps. We have no control over
the content of these websites or apps, which may change frequently, and we are not responsible
for the content or the way it may be used with our materials. Teachers and students are advised to
exercise discretion when accessing the links.
The publisher and authors have to the best of their knowledge, ascertained the intellectual
rights of the creators of all the works cited in this books. If, for any reason, they have omitted to
acknowledge a certain author, they are ready to make the necessary corrections, as they were not
aware of such authorship at the time of publication.
Gabriel would like to dedicate this book to all the teacher learners
who, over the years have inspired him to continue reflecting on
how to become a better teacher educator, and also to his teacher
education colleagues in the United States and Uruguay for being a
constant source of support, learning and encouragement.
5
TAbLE OF CONTENTS
PrEFACE .................................................................................................13
IntroduCtIon ......................................................................................15
How to usE tHIs book .......................................................................17
7
TA b L E O F C O N T E N T S
8
TA b L E O F C O N T E N T S
9
TA b L E O F C O N T E N T S
10
TA b L E O F C O N T E N T S
GLossArY............................................................................................. 417
11
PREFACE
13
P R E FA C E
own student teachers. This gives to the work a credibility and a breadth
of vision that I’m sure will make its reading relevant to a wide number
of professionals regardless of their particular contexts. It also helps the
book achieve its clever balancing of theoretical concerns and practical
classroom applications, as readers can engage in practicing the theory
it presents while, more importantly, theorizing their own practice.
This balance is clearly established at the start of each chapter
in which learning goals are divided into two key domains: “Learning
about…” (the theoretical) and “Learning how…” (the practical).
These then culminate in the “Learning to…” domain, which I see
as being intrinsically bound up with teacher and learner identity. By
adopting such a framework, the book explores the nature of “learning
communities” and “the small culture of the classroom” and ultimately
the key concern of learning how “to be oneself ” as a language teacher.
Finally, on a personal level, I’ve been lucky enough to be a colleague
of Gabriel and Lesley’s on the faculty of the New School’s MA in TESOL
program and, therefore, am convinced that their extensive professional
experience - both as teachers and teacher trainers – transpires clearly
through these pages. Such invaluable insights into both how teachers
develop as well as the “here and now” of the classroom can only be
gained from years of such hands-on experience.
For all the above reasons and many more, I have every confidence
that this book will become an invaluable companion to any language
teacher as well as an important addition to the field of teacher education
and development literature.
If truth be known, I wish I’d had a book like this thirty years ago
when I was taking my first steps to becoming a teacher. To all of you who
are now embarking on this journey for the first time, as well as those of
you keen to relearn the art of language teaching, I feel sure this primer
will make you reflect on the process in the best possible way.
Ben Goldstein
Barcelona, April 2016.
14
INTRODUCTION
15
INTRODUCTION
16
HOW TO USE THIS bOOK
17
HOW TO USE THIS bOOK
What follows is a mind map that lays out the content of the
chapter using key words and concepts and an anticipation chart. We
encourage readers to look at the mind maps, to complete the adjacent
anticipation chart and to share this anticipation with peers. The
anticipation chart is aimed at activating your existing knowledge of the
chapter contents thus making it easier to receive the new information
in the chapter.
We begin the chapter content by providing quotes from former
student teachers (teachers-in-training), our language-teaching colleagues,
and our language learners and invite you to think about your responses
to the quotes. It is our hope that you relate to these quotes and frame
them in your own context and experience.
What follows is the actual contents of the chapter, where we
explore, extrapolate, and analyze the core areas teaching a foreign
language.
Each chapter contains the following tasks and activities:
Pit stops – when learning, it is critical that we pause every so
often to take stock of what we have learned and review what we have
covered. In a way, this is a ‘stop and look at the view’ moment. We
rethink, reword and reconsider the new information that we have read
or studied before heading further into a text, book or lesson. At these
points, we begin to frame new information in our own realities and
understanding. Pausing allows us to move forwards. Our pit stops may
mean looking back to classroom experiences (either as a teacher or as
a learner), looking back at a section of the chapter and making sure
you understand key points, or looking back at former chapters so as to
establish connections between the ideas in each part of the book.
over to you – these are tasks or activities, which engage you, in a
practical sense, with the concepts in the chapters. We believe in Dewey’s
(1934) principle of the continuity of experience. By this, he meant that
every new experience significantly affects the way we perceive not
only the new experience, but our past and future experiences, also. Our
aim is to ensure you experience this when using this book.
18
HOW TO USE THIS bOOK
19
HOW TO USE THIS bOOK
Gabriel: gadiaz@anep.edu.uy
Lesley: painterl@newschool.edu
20
1.
X.
CHAPTER
LEARNING ABOUT OUR
XXXXXXX
STUDENTS
learning
learning about:
about:
• •
students’ needs.
classroom
• students’ motivations.
management
• •
students’ backgrounds.
learning communities
• •
the role of English in the
teachers’ roles
world.
• teachers’ use of L2 in
• the role of English in
class
your students’ lives.
learning how to:
• develop and value a
learning how to:
• get to know your
learning community
students.
• plan lessons to cater
• work with differing
for different energy
motivation.
levels and attention
• perform a needs
spans
analysis.
• use the white or
Why Xxxxx
am I learning English? blackboard
• use the classroom
When will I use English?
seating arrangements
Why do I have to study English? to optimize learning.
How can I learn English?
Where will I use English?
Who will teach me English?
How long will I have to study English?
Who will I use English with?
How often will I have to use English in daily life?
Shall I take classes or learn on my own?
How far do I want to get learning English?
Can I learn English?
I tried and failed; should I try to learn English again?
Why is English a subject in the school curriculum?
Why is English so popular?
What do I really need English for?
Who else studies English?
How much English do I need to learn?
Which areas of English do I need to study?
21 21
THE CHAPTER AT A GLANCE
what are
their needs?
how do we
what are their
know what
expectations?
they need?
what are their
prior learning
experiences?
What do you already know about the role of English in your life, your
students’ lives and their learning needs?
What issues about your students’ need for learning English have
you heard your colleagues/cooperating teacher discuss? Why are
they important/relevant?
22
CHAPTER 1
STARTING OUT
Students say…
23
CHAPTER 1
• I study English because I did not learn enough at school and now
I want to study abroad and I need the language for that.
• I have always wanted to study English. When I studied it at school,
I did not pay attention in class and did not learn much. Then, I got
married, had kids…you know…life, right? Now that I have time, I
want to enjoy learning it.
• My kids think I am stupid because I can’t speak English- I must
learn English.
• My boss has told me to learn English.
• It’s very useful when traveling. Not only useful, but also necessary.
It’s very nice to be able to talk to people of other cultures.
• I love the sound of the language. I think my mother gave me the
pleasure of learning my first English words.
• Since I was a little child, I have experienced pleasure in learning
languages, not only English.
24
CHAPTER 1
“In my view, the chief task facing ELT (English Language Teaching)
is how to devise pedagogical policies and practices in which the
need to maintain an international standard of intelligibility, in both
speech and writing, can comfortably exist alongside the need to
recognize the importance of international diversity, as a reflection
of identity, chiefly in speech and eventually perhaps also in writing.”
LEARNERS’ NEEDS
Let’s look a little more closely at our learners. Consider these students and their learning needs:
1. A student in a Latin American public education highschool.
2. An immigrant in the US who is trying to make the US his new home.
3. A businessperson working for an international company.
4. A student who wants to travel around Australia for a few months.
5. A refugee who has been displaced from his country and is now in the US.
In each activity, the students need a variety of teacher support and guidance.
• What attitude towards English do you think these learners would bring to class?
• What source of motivation do you think they all have?
• What challenges would both their attitude and motivation present to teachers?
• How do you think you might meet some of the challenges?
25
CHAPTER 1
LANGUAGE LEVELS
26
CHAPTER 1
C2 Mastery
B2 Vantage
A2 Waystage
27
CHAPTER 1
28
CHAPTER 1
Name: Age:
29
CHAPTER 1
1. Provide a clear picture of who our students are and why they come
to class.
2. Help generate the course goals. We may have a prescribed syllabus
to cover, but will still need to ensure that we can adapt it to meet
our students’ needs.
3. Illustrate to our students that they can and do contribute to the
syllabus thus providing them with an agentive role in what they
study.
4. Show teachers we respect the students’ learning process and the
outcomes they expect to get from our course.
30
CHAPTER 1
31
CHAPTER 1
Long (2015) makes the point that besides probing learners’ needs
we should also perform a means analysis. This implies finding out
students’ preferred teaching styles so that there are no conflicts between
the way they expect to be taught and the way you intend to teach them.
This prevents expectations being misunderstood. For example students
may want overt corrective feedback, regularly. However, the teacher
32
CHAPTER 1
Think back to your experience learning a foreign language. Were you ever involved in needs analyses?
What do you wish your teachers had asked you that would have made your learning more effective?
MOTIVATION
Knowing why students are learning and how they feel about
learning is the first step in ascertaining that they will come to class with
an open attitude towards learning and with the right motivation to learn.
The noted materials writer Victoria Kimbrough, once told Lesley
that students can learn anything if they are suitably motivated. Certainly
motivation is a vital part of learning. Students’ lack of motivation can
lead to boredom in class, behavioral problems, lack of progress and
attrition. Although there are many definitions and classifications of
motivation, a frequent distinction is made in language teaching between
intrinsic motivation and extrinsic motivation.
Intrinsic motivation comes from within the students. They want to
learn and gain pleasure from it and so they derive their will to learn
and their predisposition to it from their own internal drives. These drives
include their learning needs, a particular liking for the teacher, the class
or the language, or their will to succeed.
Extrinsically motivated students are motivated by outside forces:
parents, bosses, exam results and so forth. To these students success is
measured by the degree of compliance with rules that are imposed upon
them by others. In general, these students are harder to motivate than
intrinsically motivated students.
Although this distinction is useful, neither one is an absolute. We
are all motivated, at different times, by internal and external forces. The
sources of our motivation are influenced by everything we have explained
33
CHAPTER 1
so far: our learning needs and preferences, the learning context and our
current life situation. For example, a person who was a poor learner of
English during highschool may have failed because the person failed to
see the usefulness of the language (no intrinsic motivation) and because
the person did not care about grades (extrinsic motivation). Later on in
life, the person may be extrinsically motivated to learn English in order
to get a scholarship and would thus become a very effective learner
intrinsically motivated by a personal goal.
Reeve (1996) points out that motivation is a combination of both
internal and external factors. These factors are crucial as they can prompt,
maintain and enhance or diminish the levels of motivation students have.
The challenge for teachers is to sustain students’ motivation. This often
means realizing what the driving force behind students is and connecting
with that as much as possible. For example, a teacher may realize that a
student wants to learn English because they love American pop music,
in which case, it might be a good idea to play songs in class and create
activities around the song lyrics. Equally, a teacher may find out that a
student’s motivation is derived from the need to obtain a specific job, in
which case, the class content should address looking for a job, possibly
job interviews and so forth. In other words, relevant class content is an
important way to maintain students’ motivation.
In 1956, Shramm proposed that the definition of motivation can be
reduced to a simple equation:
Students’ expectation of success in a task
MOTIVATION=
Students’ expectations of the amount of effort involved
34
CHAPTER 1
• Creating the conditions for motivation to • Creating the conditions for motivation to
blossom. blossom.
» Focus on students’ needs. » Always explore your students’
» Help students set personal goals for background knowledge explicitly.
learning. » Make sure students are prepared for
» Make your planning explicit to the task at hand.
students. » Help students understand the criteria
» Share criteria for success with students for success.
before they engage in learning. • Generating opportunities for initial
» Share examples of successful motivation.
performance of former students with » Always contextualize language to the
your current class. learners’ background knowledge.
• Generating opportunities for initial » Focus on use and meaning more than
motivation. on form.
» Grade and sequence the activities you » Use all the information in your
use so that everyone can experience needs analysis to help students set
success. achievable goals.
» Go over the lesson’s agenda and help • Sustaining and shielding motivation.
learners identify what contributions » Offer students choices.
they can make to it. » Foster collaborative work.
» Communicate high expectations. » Focus on students’ preferences and
• Sustaining and shielding motivation. needs in terms of learning, topics,
» Engage students in self-monitoring. activities, etc.
» Help learners identify success. • Fostering opportunities for retrospective
» Provide positive feedback on success. self-assessment by learners.
» Teach learning strategies. » Incorporate peer-assessment.
» Use a variety of scaffolds. » Help students perceive the successful
• Fostering opportunities for retrospective learning strategies they have applied
self-assessment by learners. in order to succeed.
» Provide formative corrective feedback » Help students keep track of their
in a variety of ways. progress in explicit ways (e.g. using
» Help students self-assess. individual progress charts).
35
CHAPTER 1
36
CHAPTER 1
• What is it?
• Whose is it?
• Where is it from?
• Why do you think it is important to me?
• How is it used?
• Who uses it?
• Where is it kept?
• How is it cared for?
• What things go with it?
• What is its meaning?
37
CHAPTER 1
When I was a child, we used to use this red teapot to make a pot of tea
on Sunday nights. Looking at it reminds me of those days. We always had
tea with milk and a little sugar.
Many years later, my mother gave the teapot to me. I feel that it is a
little piece of my grandmother. I treasure this teapot because it connects
me to my childhood – my mother, my grandmother and all those Sunday
night suppers.
38
CHAPTER 1
The previous lesson illustrates a few things that should happen in class:
39
CHAPTER 1
40
CHAPTER 1
Table 1.3 – A typology of teacher roles – Adapted from Hadfield J. and Hadfield, C. (2008, p. 144).
CONCLUSION
41
CHAPTER 1
Chapter wrap-up
42
CHAPTER 1
Observation task
Observe one of the learners in your class for at least four consecutive lessons. Notice how the
learner interacts with his peers and the teacher. Notice whether the learner uses English or
makes any attempt at using English, and try to discover what this student likes about the English
class and about learning English.
Make a list of all the possible ways in which your students might use English in their daily lives
(now and in the future). Then reflect about what a curriculum for these learners should be like.
What should it include? What should it not include? What kinds of materials, activities, classroom
setup would you use? Why?
portfolio task
43
CHAPTER 1
44
2.
X.
CHAPTER
XXXXXXX
REFLECTIVE TEACHING
Xxxxx
learning
learningabout:about:
• • Reflective Practice.
classroom
• the fundamental role
management
• Reflective Practice
learning communities
• plays in teacher
teachers’ roles
• development.
teachers’ use of L2 in
• directed observation.
class
learning
learninghow howto:to:
• • direct your own
develop and value a
Imagine that there is a great field stretching before you of white, reflective feedback.
learning community
• • use evidence to
plan lessons to cater
untouched snow. You walk across it enjoying the apple-crunching
guide your reflective
for different energy
sound underneath your boots. Sometimes your boots dig further into feedback.
levels and attention
the snow than you expect, sometimes the snow is softer or harder • evaluate what
spans
than you anticipate; each time, you adjust your steps to account for • is understood
use the white or
the variations. You are now on the other side of the field, you turn as constructive,
blackboard
• productive feedback.
use the classroom
around to look at the footprints that you have made and the path
seating arrangements
you have taken. At first glance, your path appears straight and your to optimize learning.
footprints look similar. However, under further scrutiny, you notice that
some prints are deeper than others. Your path is not as straight as you
had first thought and the prints are not made of white snow but dark
and muddied. What happened here? Well, your observations of the
footprints changed, the longer that you looked at them.
At the beginning, you based your interpretations largely on
expectations and then slowly you recalibrated your thoughts as your
scrutiny intensified. Once you had noticed one deviation from an
expectation, you began to look more critically for other variations and
additionally began to hypothesize about what had caused them. This
thought process is similar to what occurs when we reflect on our lessons.
Initially, we make general observations based predominantly on
what our expectations of the lesson had been and the impression of the
lesson. We then look more closely and maybe see things more clearly,
we see or recall more details. We begin to consider why the things that
happened actually happened. Additionally, we try to consider how we
might do things differently. In short, we reflect, and as we do so, we grow.
45 45
THE CHAPTER AT A GLANCE
looking
back to move
forward
takeaways
evidence-
based
reflection
Reflective reflection on
Practice action
the reflective
learning cycle
reflection in
action
reflective
thinking
46
CHAPTER 2
STARTING OUT
• I don’t have time to reflect. I teach almost eight hours a day and and
then I have to plan and correct my students’ work.
• I take a few minutes at the end of every class to think about what
went well and what did not go as planned. I do this even if I don’t
have time, for example, while I walk from one classroom to the next.
• I used to reflect on teaching when I was doing my teacher training.
My instructor always insisted that I write a short reflection after each
lesson I taught. But I am experienced now and I do not need to reflect.
• I reflect systematically about my teaching. This is what helps
me grow. I am lucky to work in a school that values this kind of
practice, so I often talk to my colleagues about my teaching.
• I cannot conceive of teaching without reflection that is why, still
today, after so many years of teaching, I keep a journal where I
write my reflections.
UNDERSTANDING REFLECTION
47
CHAPTER 2
48
CHAPTER 2
usually more than a few words and often based on a feeling, as opposed
to fact or evidence.
The first question above is an obvious one to ask but not that
useful or insightful. It only helps us process a personal reaction, at the
level of feelings. However, we need to dig deeper into the actual lesson
events, hence the second question. This question requires that we trawl
over the events of the lesson and select one incident or critical incident
(Farrell, 2008) to examine. Farrell argues that it is often only one event
or ‘critical incident’ that provides the greatest insights into overall
lessons. At this point, a few things occur, we begin to objectify the
lesson and slightly disengage from the reflective process on a purely
personal level. It is no longer simply about how we felt the lesson
went, but about the evidence that we can gain from real classroom
occurrences. We begin to look at these events in terms of what we can
learn from them and prioritize those, which are the most important or
useful.
The next two questions, questions three and four, probe further
into this idea. The subtle shift in these questions is that the focus is
removed from solely teacher actions to integrating students’ behaviors
also. This forces us to look at the lesson through the students’ lens.
This is not a minor detail, on the contrary. The ultimate purpose of
teaching is to promote effective, quality learning for all students, and
putting them and their learning process at the center of our reflection
is a fundamental trait of a reflective practitioner.
The final questions frame reflection as a means for development,
growth, and change, which is why reflective practice is critical and
ultimately can be equated to learning. As Wallace (1991, p. 54) states
“fruitful change is extremely difficult without reflection.”
Growth means change and change means taking risks, stepping
from the known to the unknown. However, growth is not easy. We all
have to ask ourselves: Am I open-minded enough to reflect?
John Dewey posited that in order for teachers to reflect effectively,
they need to be openminded, have an open heart and take responsibility.
49
CHAPTER 2
50
CHAPTER 2
This may not be the only problem: we can also be too critical,
or hypercritical, of our own classroom. When this happens we are
not only undermining our teaching but also our confidence and self-
esteem. There has to be a middle ground in order for us to develop as
teachers and create a healthy practice of reflection.
Beginning by acknowledging that reflection is an integral part
of teaching and teacher learning is a fundamental first step. This
should validate the practice, ensure that it is an ongoing process, and
underscore the fact that teachers are constantly striving for genuine
understanding (Loughran, 2002) of the students, of themselves, of
the context and the material. Every lesson is an opportunity to learn
something. From every lesson the students and we can gain a useful
takeaway, or point of learning, which provides information for future
lessons. As Dewey told us, “reflection converts action that is merely
appetitive, blind, and impulsive into intelligent action” (1933, p. 17).
For this reason, reflection is a practice.
Look back at the text to see where these keywords were mentioned:
Review them and consider how they relate to your teaching and lessons
51
CHAPTER 2
DEFINE
identify a
problem within
a lesson
IMPLEMENT
HYPOTHESIZE
Consider what
what caused
solutions can now
the problem?
be systematically
what could
adopted Reflective resolve it?
in class. Practice
Cycle
REASON
TEST what additional
trying out factors may
the proposed impact the
solutions. problem and its
solution?
52
CHAPTER 2
Can you think of an issue or problem that occurred in a class that you recently taught or observed?
Possibly a student dominated the class, and you found it difficult to use the student’s energy
effectively, or maybe you had difficulty conveying the meaning of a language structure that had
appeared straightforward before the lesson but once in the lesson seemed to unravel. Try to follow
these steps in thinking about the problem. How do you feel following these steps?
6) Once you have experimented with a few solutions, consider how successful you were in tackling
the problem and which proposed solution was most effective.
53
CHAPTER 2
“The Wonder of Video: The good, the bad, the ugly and the ‘eh-
not so bad.’ It is invaluable to watch videos of others teaching but even
more so of ourselves. It really keeps you honest. Once over the initial
shock of our appearance, a visual record of a lesson provides insight
into our teaching techniques, our comportment and our behavior
towards students. By seeing myself in the first video, I realized my
lesson plans were not well sequenced and I needed to prepare myself
better for the class.”
54
CHAPTER 2
A teacher trainer once said that you could judge how clear or logical
a lesson has been by looking at the white or blackboard. This might be a
slight exaggeration but what we can do once we have finished teaching,
and the students have left the room, is ask ourselves the following
questions:
55
CHAPTER 2
56
CHAPTER 2
57
CHAPTER 2
You may want to do this at the end of every unit, or at the end
of each semester. Additionally, you can use proactive assessment for
learning tools (see Chapter 11) such as one-minute papers, or exit slips
to gather information about every lesson, at the point of need.
We should remember that students might feel slightly uncomfortable
about noting down things that they did not like. Because of this, you will
need to navigate how best to question your particular groups of students.
The question that is possibly the most useful is what the students learnt
during the lesson. This will give you the greatest insight into whether
you accomplished the learning objective for the lesson, or not, and what
options you have when planning lessons.
58
CHAPTER 2
to understand the reason for these differences, once the lesson is over,
take out your plan again and add the changes that you made including
changes to the timing, extended or dropped activities, and so forth. These
changes will give you insights into your planning and your execution.
Additionally, you will be getting insights into your planning, your
execution and the pace of the lesson as experienced by the students. In
rewriting your plan, you will be able to analyze why a particular activity
needed to be dropped which should in turn inform future lessons.
A note to end on
As vital as it is to make reflection a practice, we must not fall into
routinized reflection-in other words reflecting because we know we
should. True, purposeful reflection has to impact teachers´ actions and
result in change.
Zeichner and Liston (1990, p. 167), question whether “teachers’
actions are necessarily better just because they are more deliberate or “Not all thinking
intentional.” This is a useful consideration. Reflection cannot simply about teaching
constitutes reflective
be something that happens after a class and ends there. It needs to be
teaching”
utilized and should result in action.
Zeichner & Liston
Along the same lines, Fendler (2003, p. 6) provides this interesting (1990, p. 167)
observation:
59
CHAPTER 2
consider how useful the following reflection is. What evidence is there
that this teacher is analyzing her lesson productively?
Overall, I feel pretty good about this lesson— at least better than
my previous one. I felt that by planning out the rationale and really
breaking down each aspect of the lesson helped out, so it does speak
volumes to the importance of lesson planning. I chose to use technology
again (and a great excuse to use my brand spankin’ new computer).
The use of the presentation not only helped scaffold the entire lesson
for the student, but also helped me organize my thoughts and see how
each macro and micro skill was being assessed and focused on. I think
the most successful part was scaffolding the vocabulary the way I did.
The students had fewer questions about the article because I pre-taught
the vocabulary. That was a big improvement for my class and I will
continue to use this strategy in all of my Hot Topics courses. I really
enjoyed the use of the PowerPoint. The whole problem now is getting
all of my students on the same article each week so I can just create
one presentation — I don’t have time to create four or five different
PowerPoints.
One thing that the lesson did fall short on was the amount of
fluency practice the student received. We could have kept going
because I didn’t have a class afterwards, but since they are paying for
40-minutes, they get 40 minutes. So, I did run out of time.
60
CHAPTER 2
is reducing the number of choices, and hence, the number of things she
must attend to prior to and during the lesson. As we will keep reiterating
throughout this book, in teaching, less is usually much more.
Identifying one aspect of your teaching that you would like to
work on after a lesson is both manageable and more constructive than
presenting yourself with a shopping list of “TO DOs” which, as we have
alluded to previously, can be both unwieldy and demotivating.
CONCLUSION
Chapter wrap-up
What is the most important What lingering questions What steps will you take
learning you have derived about reflective teaching to find answers to these
from this chapter? do you still have? questions?
61
CHAPTER 2
Observation task
As you go about your daily teaching routine, note down in a special notebook or even in your
reflective journal, all those times when you catch yourself wondering and reflecting. Write down
the place, time and describe the situation so that you can remember it well. Also, it is important
to write down the questions you are asking yourself. Are they ‘good’ reflective questions? If you
have the chance, share your wonderings with your cooperating teacher, or a colleague and note
down their comments and reactions to your musings.
Think back to when you were a student at school, college or university. Can you remember any
specific lessons? This is not an easy task but it is useful. Lesley, for example, distinctly remembers
a lesson from her elementary school days. Read about her lesson on the following page and
pay close attention to the final questions in her recount. Then, In your journal, think back to
a learning experience that you have had which has impacted your teaching. Break down the
experience and reflect on why it was important to you.
A TIP:
We recommend that you make a few notes after all lessons, maybe only write down one or two
things that occurred in your classroom that changed the direction of your lesson, presented an
obstacle, or were unexpected. Note down how you reacted to the incidents; try to hypothesize
why they occurred and consider what you might do differently with hindsight. Make journaling
about your in class experiences a habit.
portfolio task
Here are some definitions of reflective practice made by teachers-in-training. Which definition
aligns most closely to your view of reflective practice?
62
CHAPTER 2
63
3.
X.
CHAPTER
OBSERVATION:
XXXXXXX
A LEARNING TOOL
Xxxxx
learning
learningabout:about:
• • classroom observation.
classroom
how to looK at • the key role of
management
a worK oF art • observation in teacher
learning communities
• education and teacher
teachers’ roles
“We all look at the • development.
teachers’ use of L2 in
same things, yet see • the value of pre and
class
different things.” post discussions with
the teacher who is
learning how to:
Claude Monet • being observed.
develop and value a
learning community
• plan lessons to cater
learning how to:
• recognize the
for different energy
We all have different ideas about art. These ideas can be the product usefulness of
levels and attention
of our own perspectives and our previous experiences with artistic observation tasks.
spans
expression, and others may have been the product of the opinions of • • design an appropriate
use the white or
our teachers and parents. When we go to museums or observe a work observation task in
blackboard
• order to aid a teacher’s
use the classroom
of art, we generally quickly dismiss it—if we don’t like it or understand
development.
seating arrangements
it—or spend a long time contemplating it. The longer we contemplate it, • use observation tasks
to optimize learning.
the more we enjoy it and, perhaps the better we understand it. However, to direct teacher
we seldom stop to think why we like a specific piece of art and why we development.
dismiss others.
In general, our attitudes towards those pieces of art that we do not
like begin to change when we have the chance of having them explained
to us. It is then that we begin to perceive the nuances of the various lines
and colors, the meaning behind the shapes. This is because learning to
look requires that we develop a specific set of skills and an awareness
of the elements that compose the work of art. In other words, we need
guidance and knowledge to do more than glance at a piece of art and
make quick judgments about it.
Just as it happens with art, learning to look at what happens
during a lesson requires the skills and knowledge to notice events, make
observations, understand the complex dynamics of the lesson, as well as
the ability to respond effectively to these various simultaneous occurrences.
Observation is thus a key professional skill that we need to develop from
the start of our careers and preferably, in the company of our peers.
65 65
THE CHAPTER AT A GLANCE
why?
when? who?
how?
66
CHAPTER 3
STARTING OUT
67
CHAPTER 3
WHAT IS OBSERVATION?
68
CHAPTER 3
69
CHAPTER 3
70
CHAPTER 3
himself teaching. He explains that students tend to “act” during the first
few classes, even turning around and looking at the camera. However,
after a few days, they stop doing so, as the camera becomes one more
normal element in the classroom.
Finally, a word of caution. Even when you are filming yourself,
make sure to request informed consent from the students (or the
students’ parents if they are minors). This is a fundamental ethical
requirement that cannot be overlooked. In order to obtain informed
consent, write down a short text where you explain:
Also, make sure that you give students the opportunity not to
appear on camera. Make arrangements for them to sit in a place out of
reach of the lens.
Throughout this book, we engage you in systematic observation of
teaching. Every chapter contains an observation task that helps ground
what we are discussing theoretically to the reality of the classroom.
Although in other chapters these observation tasks appear at the end,
since we are dealing with Observation here, we chose to include your
first observation task half way through the chapter. The idea is that you
carry out the task and then discuss it in class or in your reading group.
Observation task 1
Before we move on in this chapter, arrange to carry out two live observations.
• For the first observation, simply arrange with the teacher the time, the length of the
observation – we recommend roughly forty-five to sixty minutes of a lesson. Observe the
lesson and take notes on the lesson in general. For example:
- Did the students seem engaged?
- Did the teacher create a good rapport with students?
71
CHAPTER 3
• For the second observation, meet the teacher that you are going to observe ahead of time.
If you do not already know the teacher well, introduce yourself, get to know him or her, find
out how long he or she has been teaching, why he or she became a teacher and make the
objective of your observation clear, i.e. that you would like to learn more about teaching and
feel that being in a live class is one of the best ways to do that. Talk to the teacher about
areas that he or she feels are strong areas of his or her teaching. Discuss areas that he or
she would like to work on. Ask the teacher what he or she would like you to focus on during
the observation, for example, the quantity and quality of teacher talking time (TTT) or how
instructions are given. Create a specific task to help you observe this area or use the ones
in the PLUG IN. Once you have observed, meet the teacher again to discuss the lesson and
the observation task findings. Ask how he or she feels the lesson went, whether or not it
went as expected, and if he or she would do anything differently. Again, keep notes of your
observation and bring them to class or to your reading group.
72
CHAPTER 3
Read the following teacher’s observation report of her colleague. Is she going to adopt, adapt or
discard what she observed?
I knew that in my own lessons, I needed less material, with the goal of more learning and
fewer activities crammed into lessons. I was fortunate to observe a colleague, who embodies
this principle of less is more. There was part of me that thought “Less is More” is fine if you
are teaching in a program without grades, but impossible in an academic context with high
expectations from students and administrators. However, my colleague follows this philosophy
in her academic classes. Her teaching method is to focus on one or two sets of questions and
answers that she drills for accuracy and mastery before students move on to freer use. I saw
students allowed the time to absorb the language form, explore its meaning, and practice its use.
By the end of the class, I saw students using the language, and even catching and correcting their
own mistakes. In turn, I now use a similar technique when introducing a new grammar unit. I no
longer feel pressured to teach every example from the text or every exception to the rule.
Amy Tate
73
CHAPTER 3
Amy noticed a great deal that was aligned with an area that she felt
was her own area of weakness: cramming lessons with materials and
language.
Productive observation is often most useful when we are observing
one specific area. This could mean observing an area that you feel is a
weakness, it could mean observing something that you want to learn
more about, or it could mean observing specific issues that the teacher
would like to have observed. This means either using a predesigned
observation task or creating your own. For example, the observation
tasks that appear in the PLUG IN for this chapter are some of the tasks
that we have created to work with our teacher learners. We call this
kind of observation that is guided by a concrete task and focused on
a particular area a directed observation. Over the course of a learning
teaching program, each directed observation task can focus on a
specific area and, along a sequence of observations, each one will build
incrementally on the previous ones.
Observation task 2
Now that we have seen the impact that observing can have on our own teaching, let’s observe
another lesson. This time, arrange to observe a regular lesson taught by a colleague or
cooperating teacher with the objective of:
• witnessing something in the teacher’s lesson that you like and will use in your own teaching,
• witnessing something you will not use in your own teaching
• witnessing something that you like but need to adapt for your own teaching context.
In each case, consider your rationale behind each of your choices, and write up your answers. Re-
read your notes taken during the first observation task in this chapter, and reflect on the process
you needed to go through in order to make your choices.
74
CHAPTER 3
DIRECTED OBSERVATION
Contact a colleague and arrange to go into his/her classroom.
1. Meet the teacher prior to the lesson and discuss with him/her how he/she feels about her/his own
teaching. Ask him/her to identify something that she/he would like you, as an observer, to focus on.
Note that this is an extremely important part for ‘framing’ observation. Ensure that the conversation
is clearly directed and gives you a clear understanding of what the teacher would like you to ‘see’.
2. Based on the contents of the discussion, design an observation task, which focuses on the aspect
of teaching that the teacher talked about.
3. Observe the lesson and complete your task.
4. Organize a post-lesson feedback session with the teacher during which you provide feedback - use
your observation task as a guide for the discussion.
Before you continue reading think: How does this description of the cycle above reflect your own
experience of observation so far?
75
CHAPTER 3
1. Start with the end in mind – we always start by discussing what the
learning objectives for the lesson are. These learning objectives,
couched in terms of student outcomes, will be the ones we will
use to assess the effectiveness of the lesson.
2. Specify success indicators – discuss how you and/or the person
observed will know that the learning objectives have been attained.
3. Anticipate approaches – Ask the person to be observed to “walk”
you through their lesson. Ask questions if there are things you
76
CHAPTER 3
77
CHAPTER 3
78
CHAPTER 3
The issue of what we are looking for in a teacher and why we feel a
teacher is ‘good’ is similar to an iceberg: on the surface there is a possible
quick answer such as he or she had a good rapport with the class, and
we can conclude this because we saw it. However, the more we think
about it the more complicated and interconnected the answer grows.
The answer may be different for each one of us due to our own culture,
our own educational experiences, our learning preferences as well as
what we believe is effective (or “works”) in a classroom. For example,
if you have had a negative learning experience due to a harsh teacher,
you might look more closely at the rapport in the classroom than at
how effectively the teacher conveys meaning or, if you enjoy teaching
grammar, you might focus on the teacher’s language awareness during
observation. All of these issues are relevant to the establishment of a
good rapport with students. Now, a lot of emphasis in teacher training
courses is placed on teacher competencies. You may have already been
observed by a supervisor. Perhaps the supervisor had a check-off list
of competencies that he or she was looking for, such as how you give
instructions or how you provide feedback to learners. A competency is
synonymous with an ability or skill.
If you were observing a teacher, what competencies would you
be looking for? In other words, what abilities does a teacher need to
possess in order to be able to teach effectively? Brainstorm what a
teacher needs to know or be able to do and make a list. Then, compare
your list to our own:
79
CHAPTER 3
About teaching
• grade language, explain tasks, question students
• develop a learner centered class
• transition from one task to another
• maintain a well-paced lesson
About planning
• plan a lesson which facilitates learning
• construct a board plan that efficiently and exactly records vital parts of
the lesson that students need
• ensure that the rationale behind tasks is clear and logical
• be able to adapt the lesson plan to fit learners’ ability and needs
• plan a series of lessons that fit together coherently
One problem with competencies is that the list can grow to super
human lengths and cannot account for the immeasurable ‘je ne sais quoi’
– some teachers are simply ‘wonderful’ (for want of a more scientific
word) and it is not because of one single factor but multiple that are
interrelated and often rooted in the teacher’s innate ability to meet the
students not only on their level but as individuals.
Having the chance to observe others and to observe ourselves is
one way in which we can begin to understand the complexity of teaching
as it relates to learning. Above and beyond competencies, directed
observation opens us a door into professional thinking and decision-
making that, in turn helps us learn as we develop our own, engage
in substantive dialog about teaching and learning with colleagues and
reflect on how our actions impact our students’ learning as well as their
motivations and potential.
The following table inspired by the work of Richards and Farrell
(2011, p. 103) effectively summarizes the main points made in this chapter:
80
CHAPTER 3
CONCLUSION
81
CHAPTER 3
ChaPteR wRaP-uP
What is the most important What lingering questions What steps will you take
learning you have derived about observation do you to find answers to these
from this chapter? still have? questions?
how?
82
PLuG IN: CLASSROOM OBSERVATION TASKS
observing the teacher: task a observing learners: task 1
Before entering the classroom, ask the teacher Draw a layout plan of the classroom and indicate where
to tell you about the objectives for today’s class. learners are sitting. Stop to watch the interaction among
Write them down as literally as possible. Are they learners for five minutes of the class. Who speaks to
language objectives or content objectives? Watch whom? Who interacts with whom? What about?
the class. How truthfully were objectives met? Reflect
Reflect Were the interactions in your school classroom similar
What aspects of the language does this teacher to these when you were a learner? What has changed?
emphasize through his/her actual teaching? What has remained the same?
83
4.
X.
CHAPTER
managing our
XXXXXXX
cLassrooms
learning
learningabout:about:
• • classroom
classroom
management.
management
• • learning communities.
learning communities
• • teachers’ roles.
teachers’ roles
• • teachers’ use of L2 in
teachers’ use of L2 in
class.
class
learning
learninghow howto:to:
• • develop and value a
develop and value a
learning community.
learning community
• • plan lessons to cater
plan lessons to cater
for different energy
for different energy
levels and attention
levels and attention
spans.
spans
• • use the white or
use the white or
A teacher trainer once asked a group of teachers-in-training to
Xxxxx blackboard.
blackboard
• • use the classroom
use the classroom
keep ten balloons up in the air without letting any drop to the ground.
seating arrangements
seating arrangements
The group kept the balloons in the air, by hitting them high, watching to optimize learning.
to optimize learning.
them constantly to ensure balloons were not nearing the ground,
checking the action of the other members of the group and, all the
time, trying not to fall over each other. They continued until they were
exhausted. The teacher trainer then asked what they thought this
represented in teaching. It was not long before the group reached the
conclusion that the task was an analogy for the constant classroom
juggling that is classroom management.
In both cases, decisions have to be made rapidly, actions taken
swiftly and there are multiple variables, which impact the decision-
making process. Lampert and Ball described this as the ability to “make
reasoned judgments in the context of action” (Lampert & Ball,1998: 29)
Decisions include:
• Should I stop this activity or let it run longer?
• Should that student sit next to that student?
• What should the group that has finished the activity early do?
• This material is more difficult for the students than I thought,
what shall do?
85 85
THE cHaPTEr aT a gLancE
Sustaining
a learning
Community
establishing
Planning
and
for the
maintaining
unexpected
rapport
Classroom
Management
Managing teacher
discipline talk
establishing
giving
productive
instructions
routines
86
CHAPTER 4
sTarTing ouT
Teachers say…
Students say…
87
CHAPTER 4
88
CHAPTER 4
Teacher Language
Type, pitch, loudness, level, amount
A LEARNING COMMUNITY
89
CHAPTER 4
enjoys being a part of the group and realizes the benefit of his or
“Collaboration is her membership. The South African word: ‘Ubuntu’ (which roughly
the cornerstone of means, if one succeeds, we all succeed) is both a useful and powerful
the educational ideal to keep in mind when considering and facilitating the growth of
experience.”
any learning community. In many ways, fostering the development of
Palloff and Pratt and sustaining a learning community is like weaving each strand of
yarn that is drawn over and under other strands of yarn that in order
to create something beautiful and functional – more beautiful and
more functional than any one strand of yarn is on its own. It takes
time. The strands have to fit together. There has to be a sense of the
wholeness and not only recognition of each individual. But why is this
important?
Most vitally because union supports and encourages all the requisite
“What children can components of language learning: experimenting, communicating,
do with the assistance making mistakes, learning from mistakes, collaborating, co-constructing
of others might be knowledge and so forth. Entering a language learning environment is not
in some sense more easy, for many students it reminds them of previous failures, previous
indicative of their hours wasted sitting at an uncomfortable desk, or humiliations. The idea
mental development,
of a community is that these past memories are replaced with a shared
than what they can
do alone.” goal. This puts forward the construct of an enmeshed view of learning,
that is supported and co-constructed with peers and teachers together
Vygotsky or socially.
Many studies on learning communities and collaborative work,
including pair work, have shown that learners are able to provide each
other with foreign/second language input, as well as opportunities for
interaction. Because they work together, students do not necessarily
produce more errors than when they are interacting with the teacher,
and they can also provide each other with feedback on errors in the
form of clarification requests and negotiation for meaning. In short, it
appears that learners benefit from the opportunity of more one-to-one
conversation rather than when they work in a teacher-centered, whole
class environment (Gass and Varonis 1994; Long and Porter 1985; Pica
1987; Yule and MacDonald 1990, Lightbown 2000). In other words, we
should heed the old adage that “Two heads are better than one.”
The teacher’s role is thus pivotal as the initial model, facilitator
and guide for the students to follow and understand how the learning
community works. The teacher’s voice, attitude, and overall skill in
90
CHAPTER 4
OUR STUDENTS
91
CHAPTER 4
Birthday – for most of us, especially younger learners, this is our very own
special day. We want to have it recognized in some way. some teachers
have small paper crowns for the birthday boys and girls and other teachers
prepare a small card for each student to write a message in to deliver, even
if the day of classes is not the actual birthday. This is a wonderful way of
illustrating teacher and student investment in the community.
92
CHAPTER 4
Likes/dislikes – if you know that the students like movies, you may ask
them for a recommendation every so often or ask which movie theatre
is best to go to nearest the school. if they like certain events, you may
cut our stories from newspapers or print them off the internet to give to
the specific student to read. The key is not to give everyone the same
news articles because this negates the individual who you are trying to
recognize. You may also note down likes, dislikes in terms of English
study: for example, looked uncomfortable working with his partner during
a writing activity or did not like talking about families etc. maintaining
motivation is tough in a language class, knowing what makes students feel
uncomfortable is useful. it does not mean that you will entirely avoid the
areas but it may mean that you will discuss this with the student privately
in order to help or plan the activity differently for a better result.
Friendship Muffins
Procedure for the Activity:
1. Brainstorm with your class on a word map what friendship is and how we make friends.
2. Tell the class to think about what ingredients go into making friends and tell them that you are
going to make them into muffins: friendship muffins.
3. Put the students into groups of threes to create a friendship recipe.
4. Each group can share with their classmates the recipe. Possibly ask them to write their recipes
on large sheets of paper that they pin to the classroom walls.
ask all of the students to walk around the class reading each other’s recipes
93
CHAPTER 4
Consider what the benefits of this activity are and how you might
end it. What could the students do to build on the ‘friendship’ idea- what
theme could they continue to explore in another lesson?
Also, consider other traits that a community has: respect, kindness,
helpfulness and so forth. Not only is this a wonderfully rich lexical set to
introduce to a class but it also illustrates expected behaviors. We once
observed a teacher who felt that to encourage respect in the classroom
was the most important trait of her community. She created a routine
called ‘Catching Compliments.’ On the wall, she put a table with all of her
students’ names’ on it, when she heard or saw one student help another
without being asked to, she put a star next to the name. At the end of
every two weeks, she asked the students to help her count who had the
most stars. The ‘winner’ was given a round of applause and a small prize.
We will talk about routines a little later but for now, reflect on how useful
this routine is for younger learners.
In an adult classroom, the introduction of collegiality may be less
overt but of equal importance as in the younger learner classroom. Look
at the following activity for adult learners:
Again, consider what the rationale behind this activity is. How
might you build on this activity and possibly repeat this activity at a later
point in the term? We often observe teachers doing ‘getting to know
you’ activities at the beginning of the term only but in fact, these types
of activities are needed throughout the term. Sometimes because the
group begins to get tired or routinized with one another, for example
always working with the same person, or because a new student joins
the class, they need a refresher and, in the process, they can learn more
about one another.
94
CHAPTER 4
can you find an activity that you would like to adapt for your classroom? Try it out.
Here is an example to get you started: an old, faithful activity is ‘Find someone who…’.
This is a very traditional idea but it is also very effective.
Find someone who……
1. Likes chocolate.
2. Likes to cook.
3. …
usually this activity is conducted by giving students a copy of unfinished sentences and asking them to
mingle in class, asking each other whether they like different things. The rationale behind the activity is
for students to familiarize themselves with one another. However, there are a few other key elements to
ensuring this happens: Why do students need to mingle (walk around)? if you asked students do this task
in pairs, do you think it would be as effective as conducting it as a mingle activity? Where is the teacher
and what is the teacher doing during this activity? How would you extend this activity?
95
CHAPTER 4
consider for a moment the worst learning experience that you have ever had. What made it
difficult? note some of you thoughts down.
There is a strong possibility that you felt embarrassed or intimidated and isolated from the other
students in the class. Try to identify what contributed to your feelings and how the situation could
have been rectified. How did the teacher contribute to your feelings? as we mentioned in the
previous chapter: we learn an immense amount from observing other teachers – we can use good
and bad experiences for our own development.
96
CHAPTER 4
• Attention span
• Metacognitive engagement
• Activities and tasks
• Motivation
• Behavioral issues
• Teacher roles
Two concrete differences between the two age groups are that
young learners’ activities usually take a lot less time than activities in an
adult learners’ class; therefore, a lesson for young learners has to have
more planned activities per period. This in turn means more transitions
and more organization for the teacher. Additionally, young learners’
lessons themselves, in terms of time duration, are usually shorter that
lessons for adults (for example 40-45 minutes, as opposed to 90 or 120
minutes). In part, this is because young learners’ attention spans are
shorter than adults’ attention spans.
Trying to keep little ones at their desks for a full lesson is a trying
experience for all, not least for the teacher. To accommodate this
younger learner trait each lesson needs to incorporate a variety of task
types, from “sit-down” tasks, to “moving tasks;” from “quiet” tasks to
“make noise” tasks. In other words, the classroom needs to be fluid and
the space adaptable; for example, the seating area may need to turn
into a bus to allow students to ride along looking at amazing animals as
they travel through the African savannah.
Many teachers organize their classrooms into specific ‘areas’
such as reading spaces or areas for circle time so that each space is
appropriate for certain tasks or activities. This organization helps to
focus young learners and expend their energy as needed for each task.
Additionally, young learners tend to need more game-type activities
97
CHAPTER 4
Find these words in the text above and reflect on what they mean to you.
Think of concrete instances of these concepts in your own classes when teaching or as a student.
98
CHAPTER 4
TEACHERS’ ROLES
One can easily see this as wearing many hats in the classroom
at various points in the lesson to ensure that students are supported
when necessary. A traditional view of teaching would suppose that
the teacher is a teacher and knows more than the students therefore,
the teacher gives out information or downloads information into
students’ heads. Freire (1973) described this as the ‘banking concept’
Banking concept
of education, in which teachers deposit information into the passive of Education
students in front of them.
There are other metaphors that we use in our profession to describe
this situation: “mug and jug,” or “chalk and talk” type of teaching, for
example. In these metaphors, the students are the mugs waiting to
be filled and the teachers are the jugs. However, what we know is that
students do not enter our classrooms as a tabula rasa and do not or
rather should not passively receive information but rather have an
active engagement in the learning process, receiving and synthesizing
information using their own frames of reference. One teacher made the
following observation:
“Often students are able to draw on their past or present life
experiences to make connections to things we are studying in class.“
Therefore, the roles that a teacher takes are not only standing in front
of the class but walking around the classroom as students work,
supporting language experimentation, guiding students’ own discovery
and generally, empowering students.
99
CHAPTER 4
consider what the most appropriate teacher role is for each of the following activities. note that there
may be more than one role:
• role play
• Find someone who activity
• grammar explanation
• repetition activity (drill)
in each activity, the students need a variety of teacher supports and guidance.
What we say to the students and, more importantly, how we say it, is
critical for the self-evident reason that we are not mediating instruction
in the learners’ first language. We need to be very deliberate about our
instructional language and ensure that our students understand what
we are saying and not wasting valuable mental energy deciphering
instructional language.
Both teachers and students need to talk in class, but the correct
balance of both is vital, so it should be carefully and intentionally
planned. Students need to practice English, experiment and engage in
what Swain calls ‘Comprehensible output.’ In very simple terms we can
understand this as learning by using.
However, falling into the TTT (Teacher Talking Time) overload
Think about Freire’s
concept of the trap is easy. Sometimes, this is because the most direct route to
‘Banking System’. explaining something elludes us.
Why is this useful to Many times, as we try to describe something, we resort to
consider here? redundant, overcomplicated language and unnecessary repetition. For
example, we repeat our instructions or explanations saying the same
things, just in varying ways. We have already mentioned “mug and jug”
type teaching, which is a very traditional form of teaching and one that
100
CHAPTER 4
Language grading
Grading means adapting the way we speak so that our instructional
language meets the level of the students. For example, if you are
working with a group of intermediate students you probably will not
want to use long, infrequent words such as “convoluted.” Instead, you
will gear your vocabulary selection to terms that are used every day,
such as “difficult” or “complicated.”
101
CHAPTER 4
102
CHAPTER 4
consider how you could gesture, draw or mime the following without using any words:
“Pairs” “Open your book”
“Check the sentences true or false” “Mingle!”
“the past” “the future”
103
CHAPTER 4
The differences may appear subtle but they are fairly dramatic in
terms of the underlying messages that they convey. In the first group of
commands, the students are called upon to work together; in the second
exchange, they are called upon as individuals. This can be very divisive
and may create an environment of comparison. In other words, the
students can see who can answer questions and who cannot. We may
all know who the strongest student in class is and who the least strong
one is. However, this should not be seen as a hindrance to the group.
Instead, it should be an opportunity for the group to work together
and help one another. A teacher’s attitude can promote collegiality or
promote comparative learning. When students compare their own ability
with that of others in class they may become demotivated, as they
appear to see gaps between what they feel they know, and what they
feel their colleagues know. It is destructive to the whole group and goes
directly against the ideal of Ubuntu we have discussed previously. After
all, “Ubuntu” literally means, “I am because you are.” Recently, a student
told us that her teacher read out the test scores out loud in class. The
student was demoralized by how awfully she thought she was doing in
class. This type of teacher behavior sets each student apart from one
another rather than bringing them together as a community.
ELICITATION
One of the most important skills to have in your teacher tool kit
is the ability to elicit information from students rather than impose it,
or only ask questions that follow an Initiation Response Feedback
(IRF) pattern. It involves questions but it also combines the use of
unfinished sentences, cues, possibly visual and word prompts, use of
104
CHAPTER 4
the white or black board all tools that lead to a specific point or set of
points. Here is an example of eliciting:
Teacher: Did any one go out night last, i went to the …….. (T shows
Teacher: Did any one go out night last, i went to the …….. (T shows
a
a shopping bag)
shopping bag)
students: mall?
students: mall?
Teacher:
Teacher: Yes, i went to the mall last night, when class ended… what
Yes, i went to the mall last night, when class ended… what
time
time did class end?
did class end?
student: 6
student: 6
Teacher: Yes, i (gestures pointing back over her shoulder)…. went to
Teacher: Yes, i (gestures pointing back over her shoulder)…. went to
the mall at 6 pm.
the mall at 6 pm.
105
CHAPTER 4
QUESTION TYPES
Display questions
106
CHAPTER 4
Referential Questions
Unlike display questions, when asking referential questions we do
not assume that students know the answers. Also, referential questions
may lead to multiple, possible answers rather than a single, correct
answer. For example, look at these questions:
107
CHAPTER 4
open
open questions: require more elaborate answers.
questions: require more elaborate answers.
Teacher:
Teacher: What do you like doing when it rains?
What do you like doing when it rains?
student 1: i like to stay at home and watch TV.
student 1: i like to stay at home and watch TV.
108
CHAPTER 4
Wait time
Once we have become mindful of the type of questions that
we ask and their use, we need to consider how long we wait for our
students to respond to the questions. Our students usually need more
processing time when being asked questions. Tsui suggests that many
students are generally shy and reticent to speak; therefore, sufficient
wait time is essential (Tsui 2001) if we want all our students to succeed.
However, research has shown that the average time that teachers wait
for students to respond is only one second (Nunan and Lamb, 1996).
Why do you think this is the case? One teacher in training attributed it
to the fear of silence in class. This is possibly true. Other reasons may
include that the teacher is hurried because of the brevity of the class
session, the need to cover some particular content or certain textbook
109
CHAPTER 4
materials, or simply the fact that teachers allow the brightest students
to respond first.
Our advice is that you wait about 5 seconds before calling on any
students to answer the question, or even repeat the question yourself.
Because you will not be able to check your watch, count up to 5
Mississippi’s (that is, say the numbers followed by the word “Mississippi”
like this: 1 Mississippi, 2 Mississippi, 3 Mississippi, 4, Mississippi, 5
Mississippi) and then ask the question again or call on a student to
answer. This way, you will help all students by providing them ample
time to process the question and search for an answer. Using wait time
effectively has been proved to improve students’ chances to do well in
class, thus, bear our advice in mind.
110
CHAPTER 4
Consider teachers that you have had and reflect on your own
language and consider how Teacher Talk can impede learning rather than
facilitate it. Look at the issues below. Did you consider any of them?
Echo
In Beginner level classes, this might be seen as an aid for the students,
as it affirms that what they have said is correct and allows the other
students to hear also that it is correct. However, we should be mindful that,
if done too frequently, it can also lead to students’ loosing confidence in
their ability to communicate correctly because the teacher repeats what
they have just said thus interrupting the flow of communication in an
unnecessary manner. It is best to echo students’ expression only in those
occasions when teachers feel the rest of the class has been unable to hear
it. Even in those cases, it is best to ask the student to speak out loud and
get him or her to repeat what s/he has just said.
Confusing Instructions
Consider the following set of instructions:
111
CHAPTER 4
How would you feel if you were a student in that class? We bet that
you would feel confused, even anxious about not knowing what to do
first. Some classroom tasks or activities require that we give complex
instructions (for example, because there are various steps to the task or
activity). When this is the case, the best scenario involves the breaking
down of the instructions into steps and providing students with each
step in sequence. Next, ask students to remind you what needs to be
done. This way, you can check that they have really understood. While
they do so, even if you need to correct them, write the sequence of steps
on the board. By doing this, students will have something to go back to
while doing the activity or task, if they get lost.
What has happened here? Consider the roles of the teacher and
what the student has just shared. Many times, language teachers tend
to focus too much on responding to the learners’ “language” and not
to the “ideas expressed through that language.” In the case above, the
student is sharing something painful and the teacher does not respond
in an authentic manner to the students’ ideas. Instead, the teacher
chooses to focus on correcting the student. This is not only inauthentic,
but it also conveys the wrong message in terms of our idea of “Ubuntu.”
Teacher: Yes, good! Very good! Was that useful? Did you enjoy it? Do
you want to sit next to a new partner now? Are you comfortable or
112
CHAPTER 4
are you too close? Move your chair a little, please. Do you want me
to move the chair?
In this part of the lesson the teacher is not focusing on the class
but listening to one student only. Probably, in this instance, it is the
most able student, which sets the pace of the lesson, the pace of that
one student. The other students’ understanding is not checked. Always
make sure you call on various students to answer (after also making
sure to use wait time). One strategy we often use is the “lighthouse
light” strategy. We make sure we involve everyone by focusing on
different sections of the classroom from left to right, as if we were the
light of a lighthouse thus illuminating all students equally. This makes
sure that everyone has a fair chance of participating. We do this, even
when we request that students “Raise their hands” before speaking.
One key issue to effective classroom management is to make all efforts
to involve all learners at all times in the lesson, when you know that
they can be successful.
113
CHAPTER 4
Over Praising
Teacher: Good, good, great, good, lovely… that was really, really
good!
INTERACTION PATTERNS
114
CHAPTER 4
Interaction
Instructions Rationale
pattern
Pairs instruct students to work This is possibly the most useful interaction
with the person sitting next pattern in class and the most common. There
to him or her. are many uses for pair work, which we will
address in more detail in the next paragraph. in
s s many ways pairwork can be described almost
as a pedagogy in itself because of the various
reasons it is implemented in class.
Trios instruct students to work in The usefulness of this is that it changes the
groups of threes. groupings a little especially if students tend to
work in pairs and generally with the person next
ss ss to him or her.
Mingles in this interaction pattern, This works well when you want to change the
the whole class stands up dynamic in the room, for example if the students
and walks around the room have been seated for a long time during the
talking to as many of the lesson, they get to stretch, add movement to the
other students as possible. class along with talk to all of the students in class.
This helps strengthen the learning community
because students become familiar with one
another, get to know one another more.
115
CHAPTER 4
Interaction
Instructions Rationale
pattern
Class Divide the class into groups of up to six This is one of our favorite
Carousel students. Place large posters on each wall of the types of interaction pattern
classroom along with a task, for example each for multiple reasons: students
poster could have a question written on it, or a collaborate, it generates
text to read and answer a few questions about discussion because there
something, etc. is only one writer and so
one student in each group should be assigned everyone needs to speak up,
to be the writer. ask each group to go to a the teacher is able to monitor
poster and tell them that they will all have without being too imposing
an allotted amount of time to work together, and finally, each group is able
complete the task and write their answers on to read what other groups
the posters. once the time is up, ask all of the have written and can interact
groups to move clockwise around the room to with that information and
the next poster and to complete the task on build on it. This usually leads
that poster. The students should continue until to a very rich set of answers to
they have worked on every poster. any task.
Onion in this pattern, students begin by working This is a useful way of ensuring
Working in pairs, after a part of the task has been that lots of different students
completed; some pairs are broken up and get to work together. This
asked to join a pair. This then creates trios of means you are able to mix
students. again, once a part of the task has students up, continue to build
been completed, some of the trios are broken the class community and
up and join other trios to make groups of fours. change the dynamic of the
This is continued until eventually you have all community. again, the teacher
the class working together. it is called ‘onion’ is able to monitor during
because the students are in a way ‘layered’ this activity but not be too
during the activity. imposing.
Talking Divide the class into two groups each with the This is a useful activity if
Lines same amount of students. you have a little space in
Tell one half to stand in a line from the top of the your class, possibly chairs
class to the back of the class. Tell the other half and desks that do not
to line up, facing the first line. set a speaking task move because there is little
along with a set time limit and tell the students to movement and yet students
talk to the student opposite him or her. once the can still speak to different
time limit is up, ask one student standing at the people in class.
front of the class at the front of the line to walk to
the end of his or her line at the back of the class.
Tell all of the other students in this line to move
up and face the new student in the opposite line.
Keep doing this until the first student that you
moved is at the front of the class again.
116
CHAPTER 4
Interaction
Instructions Rationale
pattern
Swivel in this pattern, students remain seated while This is a useful activity if
Chairs doing an activity that you set. Put the students you have a static classroom
in pairs, after you have completed a part of design with very little room
the activity, ask the students to twist in their for either movement or
chairs either to the right or the left and talk to remodeling. it is also fun.
the students on the opposite side to the one
that they were just talking to. You may need to
manage this quite heavily in order to ensure that
all students have someone to speak to and there
are no students left without a partner.
117
CHAPTER 4
Board plan
Many teachers plan their board in an
“H” formation, thus: on the left side of the
board in the margin, the lesson objectives
are written. In the middle of the board is
the target language or a key piece of the
lesson objective. Below that, we use the
space to write down activities or exercises.
On the right side, corrective feedback
is written along with incidental lexical
items and below that, the homework
118
CHAPTER 4
assignment, if any. This has been a popular board plan for many years.
Actually, it was given to both of us when we first started teaching and
we have rarely strayed from this format because it helps us to organize
the content in the lesson, prioritize information and to support our
teaching and, in turn, our students’ learning.
How can we use the board? What would you use these for?
COLORS CARDS DRAWINGS ARTWORK
SYMBOLS MARKING THE WAY THINGS SOUND
✔ ✕ =
How could the above universal symbols be used to give instructions for a reading activity in which
students have to decide what is true or false? How could the other symbol be used? What could it show?
DISCIPLINE MANAGEMENT
119
CHAPTER 4
for students to complete as soon as they enter the classroom also helps
set the tone for the lesson. These activities need not be sophisticated.
They may include asking students to say something to a peer, sing
a song, make a list of words they now connected to the topic of the
lesson, and so forth.
As soon as attendance has been taken, a set up activity or a
warmer allows students to get started on work and adjust to the English
speaking only environment. Many teachers will have already written
the lesson’s agenda on the board before the students enter the class and
then explain it once the set up or warmer activity is over. This should
help to focus the students and also act as a reference throughout the
lesson that the teacher can refer to so as to keep the students on track
and bring the class back together at the end of the different activities.
Erasing the agenda items as they get completed gives students both a
sense of progress and a sense of fulfillment.
Transitions can be one of the most difficult things to accomplish
smoothly both with young learner and adult students alike. Teachers
can feel at these points in the lesson that they have lost control of the
students. There are many techniques to get students’ attention back
on the tasks at hand. Some teachers flick lights on and off, others hold
their hands up and encourage all of the students to do the same until
everyone is holding their hands up and focused, and some teachers
say: “One, two, three eyes on me!” while others say, in a normal tone
of voice, “If you can hear me, can you clap once?” In general, a few
students will clap at the beginning, the teacher can continue asking
them to clap twice, three times and so forth. In general, it only takes
five or six claps for all students to be paying attention. All of these
activities aim at focusing the students first before moving on to a new
activity or lesson stage for which instructions are going to be given
out. A pitfall to avoid is to begin to give out instructions for tasks
whilst trying to gain students’ attention. It is better to do one thing at a
time. Another idea is to use different classroom locations to reinforce
your verbal management. For example, you may choose to stand at
the front of the class only when explaining. Stand on one side of the
classroom to give feedback on tasks and maybe stand at the back of
the classroom when you want to give instructions, and stand in the
middle of the class to bring all students together. With consistency
120
CHAPTER 4
over time, students become used to what goes on in each zone, and
experience has shown that this reduces the need for the teacher to call
students’ attention orally.
Infraction Slips
In young learner classrooms, there can come a point when
students need to be reminded that their behavior is not acceptable in
the classroom. This is best done in steps. The first step is a warning.
The next step is to put the student into ‘time out’. In one school, we
observed a teacher who had a special table where she asked students
in “time out” to sit. Most students detest time out and the threat of it
alone is enough to ensure that their behavior improves. In Montessori
schools, time out is given to students who disrupt the flow of work by
having them sit in a corner facing the class. This is supposed to serve as
a model of correct interaction. After a few minutes, the student is asked
if he or she is ready to return to work and, if so, they are allowed to join
the activity once again. The final step is a slip of paper that will either
go to the parents or the Principal of the institution. This, however, will
depend on the institution’s discipline protocol. Some teachers give this
slip to the student to control. If he or she still has the slip by the end of
the lesson, the student can throw it away. If the teacher has had to take
it off the student, it will go into an addressed envelope to be delivered
to either the Principal or parents, and in some cases both. This should
be a last resort and not be treated lightly.
Other teachers find the “three strike” rule equally effective. During
lessons students are given strikes for inappropriate behavior. If they get
three strikes, they will be given a slip that goes home to parents, to the
Principal or results in sanctions in class such as exclusion from a game
or other enjoyable activities.
We must remember that dealing with discipline issues is difficult.
It is wise to consider what your strategies will be before the beginning
of term, laying them out carefully and considering what your limits
are in class. The most difficult piece is then to consistently adhere to
your own rules. If you have written out a contract with your class,
you can add your rules and simply remind students during lessons.
For example, gum should be removed before class starts. If a student
walks in chewing gum, point to the rule only but do not say anything.
121
CHAPTER 4
Often, saying little and simply looking at students who are not acting
appropriately may be enough deterrence. Raising your voice in class,
although it may be necessary, at times, usually leads to teacher
exhaustion and once used tends to be the default mechanism for class
control. Ideally, it should be the last resort. Every class of students
reacts differently to techniques used by teachers.
Routines
122
CHAPTER 4
Routine language
A large part of routines in class is not only activities or tasks,
but the routine instructional language used. As we mentioned earlier
in the chapter, this is language that the teacher uses in order to give
instructions, set up tasks, begin and end the lesson and manage the
class in general. Some typical teacher-set phrases are the following:
• Criss-cross, apple sauce – meaning “Cross your legs and sit down.”
• One, two, three: eyes on me! – meaning “Stop talking.”
• Stand like statues – meaning “Keep very still. Don’t move.”
• If you care, you share- Asking students to share their work
123
CHAPTER 4
assign tasks is by drawing the task on a piece of card and handing the
cards out to the assigned students at the beginning of the lesson. The
students should feel a sense of pride in what they do while also realizing
that they are a necessary part of the group.
Catching compliments
on a poster write the names of all of the students. When you see a student doing something nice
or helpful for another student without being prompted by another students or the teacher, such as
helping someone to find a page in a book or giving someone help, reward this behavior by putting a
star next to his or her name. Whenever it seems appropriate (at the end of the week, once a month or
maybe midway through the term), tally the number of stars and give the student with the most stars a
prize.
Homework Rewards
in a similar way as it was the case with the previous idea, create a poster containing all of the
students’ names, and give out stars to students who regularly hand in homework on time. at certain
points in the semester tally the stars and give the students with the most stars small prizes.
124
CHAPTER 4
This brings the lesson to a close and refers the learning back to
the lesson objectives.
“Can do” activities can be introduced throughout a lesson to
help maintain motivation. They are always simple activities, which
all students are able to complete. When planning, as well as when
managing a class, consider all of the options that you have available to
you to help move through the contours of learning and working with
people. Both these aspects present challenges that require engagement
not only with the content but also among the learners as people, and
the class and its resources as support.
CONCLUSION
125
CHAPTER 4
CHaPTeR wRaP-uP
Observation task
observe a lesson taught by a colleague or a peer and note down how the teacher:
• utilizes the space and resources he or she has used including the white board.
• organizes the various interaction patterns.
• takes on various teacher’s roles.
• takes on various teacher’s roles.
• plans cooler, warmer or “can do” activities.
Portfolio task
Write your “classroom management Platform.” What are your beliefs about classroom discipline?
What are your preferred teacher’s roles? What kind of instructional language, instructional
activities and instructional strategies do you use that foster learning for all your students?
126
5.
X.
CHAPTER
XXXXXXX
LESSON PLANNING
Xxxxx
learning
learningabout:about:
• • lesson planning as a
classroom
process.
management
• • why planning is
learning communities
• important.
teachers’ roles
• • stages of lesson plans
teachers’ use of L2 in
and of planning.
class
• key traits of a good
lesson plan.how to:
learning
• • the value of
develop and value a
anticipating a plan.
learning community
• plan lessons to cater
for different energy
learning how to:
Berry (2013) uses dribbling as a metaphor for business planning. • write learning.
levels and attention
We consider this metaphor could also apply to the planning that objectives.
spans
teachers do. Dribbling, as it happens in the football court, is not the • • plan lessons.
use the white or
goal but a means to an end. In the same way, planning is not the goal • sequence activities.
blackboard
• use the classroom
of the teaching activity, but a means to helping teachers organize their
seating arrangements
instruction so that all students can learn. to optimize learning.
One often cited constraint of lesson plans is that many times
they become a straightjacket for the teacher. However, plans can, and
should, be made flexible so as to respond to the unanticipated events
that will definitely happen in class. This is similar to what happens
when a player gets the ball in the wrong end of the court or when he
misses a goal. Even in those moments, a plan is in place and all the
players know what the plan is. So, for example, when the goalie gets
the ball and passes it to the defender, the whole team responds to that
action. However, if the other team players do something unexpected,
the player has the freedom to change his strategy and, because a plan is
in place, all the other players in his team will be able to understand the
logic of that move and continue playing towards the same goal.
Finally, dribbling involves paying attention simultaneously to the
overall field and also to what is happening in the immediate surroundings
of the player who has the ball. In the same way, a good lesson plan allows
the teacher to keep an eye on the horizon while also attending to the
details of the here-and-now.
127127
THE CHAPTER AT A GLANCE
bloom’s
anticipation
taxonomy
Practice Scaffolding
Pace
What issues about lesson planning have you heard your colleagues/
cooperating teacher discuss? Why are they important/relevant?
128
CHAPTER 5
STARTING OUT
Gelsomina Chionio
Roshii Jolly
129
CHAPTER 5
130
CHAPTER 5
131
CHAPTER 5
132
CHAPTER 5
WHERE TO BEGIN
133
CHAPTER 5
134
CHAPTER 5
• the students,
• the materials,
• the length and structure of lesson times,
• the classroom and its resources including whiteboard/
blackboard size position, teacher’s desk and students’ desks
135
CHAPTER 5
SPACE
• How big is your classroom? Where is the black/whiteboard?
• What is the seating arrangement?
• Is it easy for students to move around the classroom?
• Is there enough space to carry out whole class role-plays or are the
desks in rows with little room for full class movement?
• Is there anything you could do to the classroom to optimize its use?
For example: If you have little whiteboard space, could you use a
flip chart to give you more board space?
• Do you need to put posters up to make the space look more inviting?
Remember: every little change you make to the classroom environment is dynamic and may have a big
impact on both your learners and your lessons. Experiment organizing the classroom in various ways.
STUDENTS
• Who works best with whom?
• What type of activities do the students appear to like?
• How soon is it into a lesson before you start to see their attention
wander and their concentration wane?
• What do they need to work on?
TIME
• How long are lessons?
• When are the breaks?
• How long do certain activities usually take?
• Do students arrive on time?
• Who are the usual latecomers?
• Who are the early finishers?
• Who takes the longest amount of time to finish tasks and who
takes the least amount of time?
MATERIALS
• What is the course syllabus?
• Do you have set materials to cover?
• How much material do you have to cover per lesson?
• Are the materials interesting, useful, relevant?
• Do they match your students’ needs?
• What do you need to do to make them relevant for your students?
• Do you feel the curriculum is attainable?
• How can you ensure that each lesson aim is manageable?
136
CHAPTER 5
SPACE TIME
LEARNING
OUTCOMES
MATERIALS PEOPLE
STAGES IN PLANNING
Both Hunter’s and Gagné’s steps were based on the most recognized
model for both curriculum and lesson planning: Tyler’s Rational-Linear
approach (1949), which involves the following prescriptive steps that
must be taken in this particular order:
137
CHAPTER 5
138
CHAPTER 5
Stage Two: Anticipation of how the lesson objectives will play out
during the actual lesson
This includes considering the difficulty or the challenges that the
lesson objectives will present to students as well as what you, as a
teacher, will need to do in order to help students meet the challenges
that the objectives might present them. This stage is about planning
those scaffolds (temporary support that we give students so that
they move along the learning process) that will ascertain that students
actually achieve the lesson objectives.
139
CHAPTER 5
Stage 1
Selection Stage 2
of learning Stage 3
Anticipation of
objectives and
the difficulties or Stage 4
observable Selection and
challenges that
evidence that the
the objectives will ordering of Anticipation of
objectives have learning tasks and
present. challenges to the
been achieved. activities.
procedural plan
and decisions
about the
execution of the
plan.
140
CHAPTER 5
141
CHAPTER 5
“By the end of the lesson, all students should be able to use the colloquial
A B
expressions taught in class in short dialogs during pair work.”
C C
142
CHAPTER 5
143
CHAPTER 5
Let’s take a pit stop and look at the following key words:
Motivating, anticipation, lesson objectives, realistic, erudite, clear, logical, teachable moment
Look at each word and consider where and why it was mentioned in the text.
144
CHAPTER 5
From what has been mentioned so far, as well as from your own thoughts about what we have
written, take a minute to note down what the traits of effective and efficient learning objectives
should be.
Now read the following and check to see if your list matches ours.
You may have more than this, in which case email us!
• Relevant
Learning objectives should be relevant to the students’ needs and
their use of English. For example, if the students use English in their
workplace, which is a bank, should some of the class content include
banking terms?
• Useful
This trait takes into account the students’ context, for example if the
students live in New York, would it be useful to teach them colloquialisms
such as ‘What’s up?’ because they will hear them frequently?
• Realistic
As we have already mentioned, the desire to plan every aspect of
a piece of language or a mountainous list of lexical items often leads
to a cumbersome and unrealistic amount of information for students
to try to scale.
• Authentic
In one of the descriptors of a lesson plan at the beginning of
the unit, a teacher-in-training stated that a lesson should contain
‘prototypical examples.’ She was referring to examples of target language
and the need for them to be examples that are used in authentic
communication. Authentic also refers to the actual language students
should be able to use in communication as a result of our teaching.
• Teachable/learnable
It is easier to consider the concepts of teachability and learnability
through examples. Consider the ease of conveying the meaning of
145
CHAPTER 5
ANTICIPATION
By the end of the lesson, students should be able to understand and use
the function “Speculating about unreal situations” by using the second
conditional, example: “If I were rich, I would buy a new house.”
146
CHAPTER 5
This stage allows you to walk in the students’ shoes and see the
language from their point of view. It also helps you appreciate what
the students really need to cover in a language lesson. Engaging in this
questioning arms you with methods to resolve the problems because,
for every challenge we forecast, we need to consider how we will deal
with it if and when in corps up in class. Our anticipation must cover
all our fronts, and we should consider even how we might circumvent
the problem. Many certificate-level teaching courses break potential
problems down into four broad areas:
Appropriate use - Why is the register of the language
important? In the case above we might want to highlight to
students that ‘was’ as in “If I was rich…” is permissible in spoken
American English even though this would be seen as colloquial.
Meaning - how and where the language realistically
lives (what functions are achieved by the use of this particular
language). This information stems from the pragmatic level of
language and must be made clear to students so that they do not
incur in sociolinguistic mistakes.
Pronunciation – are there tricky sounds in the sentence?
How does the sentence sound when spoken at natural speed?
Remember that pronunciation is not simply about the students
being able to be understood when using the language, but also
being able to understand the language when they hear it.
Form - the construction of structure may pose difficulties
to students if it requires syntactic moves that are not present in
the students’ L1. For example, Spanish speakers tend to omit the
subject when speaking or writing in English because they transfer
that practice from their L1. Students need to understand that the
omission of the subject is possible in Spanish because the verbs
one declination per person, which is not the case in English.
These areas will help you to focus on, and break down, what may
cause problems for the students; they provide you with a framework
for analyzing language as well as for prioritizing what needs to be dealt
with in class and what might not. It also informs the procedural plan
147
CHAPTER 5
PROCEDURAL PLAN
148
CHAPTER 5
Creating
Evaluating
Analyzing
Applying
Understanding
Remebering
Figure 5.3 – Anderson, Krathwhol, et.al. (2001) Taxonomy of the Cognitive Domain
149
CHAPTER 5
trusted lesson planning pattern that countless teachers use around the
world on a daily basis.
While a P P P planning sequence appears logical for teaching
or reviewing language, other planning patterns are also popular for
dealing with lessons that involve developing the language skills (reading,
listening, writing, speaking). The chart below illustrates the differences:
In later units we will see that there are various alternatives to these
planning patterns. However, for the time being, let us consider these
as the “default” settings for planning language and skills lessons. Not
only are these patterns systematically taught in initial teacher education
courses around the world, they also figure prominently in most language
teaching textbooks. Perhaps they are so popular because they give
teachers a sense of security and predictability in terms of their students’
learning. This fact notwithstanding, we must acknowledge that they also
pose limitations on that learning. We will see how to counteract these
limitations further on in the book.
Each stage in our lessons also has an explicit objective. These
objectives build incrementally to ensure that the students’ learning is
supported. For example, before students practice language, they should
have at least some idea of its use and meaning; therefore, the students’
understanding should have been checked.
A useful analogy when planning lesson procedures is to consider
the process as if you were walking. This idea came from the observation
150
CHAPTER 5
151
CHAPTER 5
152
CHAPTER 5
Beginners’ class
Monday 2-4pm (120 mins)
Class Description: This class is made answer the questions or express what they
up of 8 students (one woman the rest are like.
men – this is not tough on her as she is Solution: Cut initial pair work short and omit
outgoing and full of fun- she can hold her ‘like’ in the initial part of the lesson.
own with any of them!) – they all work in the
restaurant business: waiters, busboys, pasta Problem: Is Obama memorable?
chefs, pastry chefs) The age range is 18-25 Solution: Will ask sts. to introduce their own
– fairly young. All students work long hours. famous character during the game. Obama
Two start at 3 am daily. All are extrinsically is memorable but is he relevant to them?
and intrinsically motivated. Many have They are interested in current events so will
described learning English as difficult. They try.
frequently use L1 I class.
Problem: Second part of question forms
Objectives: By the end of the lesson, adds a lot of language
students should have practiced the present Solution: Allow for plenty of pair work
simple for habitual actions (live, work, like) activities to provide ‘space’ for the students
and reviewed the use of the auxiliary do for to use/practice the language. This will
question and negative forms after which provide me with the time to keep running
they should be able to describe a famous diagnostics to see when the camel’s back
person of their choice to a peer when breaks. I will be able to teach 1:1 during pair
working orally in pairs. work.
Timetable fit: followed on from Thursday’s Problem: Students may want to use adverbs
lesson re: daily routines and a review of of frequency or may need them
the auxiliary ‘do.’ The evidence at the end Solution: Will not overtly teach them unless
of that lesson indicated that they needed necessary, allow students to use them if they
more repetition of the structure with special know them.
attention on the third person ‘s’.
Problem: Students may forget the third
Anticipated problems and possible person ‘s’ when talking about actions about
solutions other people
Problem: Initial test may be overloaded i.e. Solution: Will diagram the language on
students may not be able to ask questions the board and use flashcards to show
correctly or have enough language to conjugation of the verb and highlight the
153
CHAPTER 5
form again during a pronunciation activity. Problem: Students may omit auxiliary ‘do’ in
Will use different colored markers on the the question form or add it to the response
board ad point to the ‘snake’ on the wall. sentence.
Solution: Will do a lot of repetition, count
Problem: Student may confuse meaning of form off on fingers highlighting how many
habitual action words are in each sentence and show
Solution: Use timeline and show repetitive structures on board
activity in the past, present and future. Will
review my routine. Problem: Energy may drop
Solution: Will watch the attention levels and
Problem: Students may omit third person ‘s’ change to game at end if necessary. Will
ending acknowledge how hard they are working
Solution: Use phonemes to show sound and give out candy.
differences and show snake.
BOARD PLAN:
I live He lives
Work works
Like likes
Am is
I DO NOT LIKE
154
CHAPTER 5
10 -15 T<>Ss Introductions – allow time for sts to Review previous lesson and continue
mins arrive to focus on scaffolding language
Introduce myself: I am…I work in…I
live in…. I like…..I don’t like hot
weather with visuals.
5 mins T<>Ss Focus on verbs: live, work, and like. This is language that the students
Use flashcards to show work, like etc. will need in the following activity-
Contrast pronunciation of live vs. like scaffolding.
10-15 mins S<>S Pairs to discuss job, live, likes Test how much the sts already know
10 -15mins
T<>Ss Each pair feedback to the class Focus on language needed for
correct question form- scaffolding to
the next activity
Show answer on the board and show Review language and allow student
that auxiliary is absent to experiment with new structures.
Commit structures to memory
Repetition of question form, and allow students to practice
highlight pronunciation and aspects anonymously – this should build
of connected speech motivation.
155
CHAPTER 5
156
CHAPTER 5
Would you change anything about the plan? If so, what would you
change? Why?
TRANSITIONS
157
CHAPTER 5
metacognitive level that not only helps them to learn but to understand
how to learn. This can be done by explaining the objectives at the
beginning of the class and planning your own language in class so that
you incorporate instructions and the rationale for activities.
Many teachers write the lesson objectives on the board at the
beginning of the lesson; some teachers hesitate to do this because they
feel it takes away from the surprise of the lesson. However, consider
the lesson from the students’ points of view. Given that our students
are usually not teachers or educators and, therefore, do not have a
strong sense of learning pedagogy or the course curriculum, they
need support to concentrate on the lesson objectives rather than try to
decipher them. Writing out an outline of the plan (or, if you are teaching
very young learners drawing it – for example use a clef to mean “song,”
two heads to mean “pair work,” a pencil to mean “drawing,” etc.) or the
objectives helps learners engage in the lesson as a learning process.
We must remember that learning a new language can be
intimidating and having access to the plan on the board gives students
both, a sense of security and also a sense of progress, if you tick the
various activities as you cover them. The plan can also be used as an
effective closure.
One of us likes to devote 5 minutes of each lesson to asking
students questions about what was learned and they have to indicate
where in the plan they did so. This technique acts as a revision as
well as closure, it helps the teacher and students assess the degree
of attainment of the lesson objectives and finally, it provides students
with a takeaway, as they are able to reflect on what they have actually
learned. This is a particularly effective way of making sure that young
learners have something to tell their parents when they ask “What did
you learn today in English class?” As many of you may know from
experience, in general, younger learners tend to say what they “did” but
not what they “learned,” whereas the default answer a teenage student
often gives is “Nothing.” So, making them aware of the takeaways from
our lessons also helps build community and understanding of why we
are together. In short, it is not enough for teachers to recognize how to
achieve lesson objectives; the students also need to know them so that
they become aware of their own learning process.
158
CHAPTER 5
1. Okay have you finished exercise one? Let’s go over the answers and
do the next activity.
2. Okay, have you finished exercise one? Did it help you to remember
the new grammar forms? Let’s do the next activity, which should help
us to use the language a little more but this time in conversation.
159
CHAPTER 5
at the lower levels and with very young learners you can use words
such as “remember,” “write,” “read,” or “use” to help illustrate the aim
of each task. Even though this could be categorized under classroom
management, as opposed to lesson planning, it is a vital part of our
lesson design. Thinking through what we are going to say helps take
the plan off the page, and provides rehearsal time. One teacher-in-
training told us:
“I am able to ensure that I have covered all of the bases that need
to be covered and ensured that there is a balance of skills in my classes
between listening, reading, writing and speaking and how much I am
speaking and how much the students are speaking.”
160
CHAPTER 5
161
CHAPTER 5
162
CHAPTER 5
• Mood – vary the mood in your lesson. Include light and fun
activities along serious and profound activities in every lesson. Do
not let one mood monopolize the whole lesson.
163
CHAPTER 5
These are comments made by a teacher after a class that did not
go as planned. Many of the problems could have been prevented if the
teacher had planned the lesson in a slightly different way. As you read
the teacher’s self-assessment, consider why they may have occurred:
1. The students were lively at the beginning of the class but their energy
levels waned in the middle and the end.
2. I ran out of time, I didn’t get to my practice activities!
3. The students got frustrated with the content. They couldn’t
understand.
164
CHAPTER 5
There are many more things which may go wrong in a class and
that force us to stray away from our plan. Alternatively, things may
have gone wrong because we stuck to the plan too strictly. This is
one of the main challenges of teaching, but it is an exciting (albeit
frustrating at times) one. Reflecting on each lesson and as we have said
before, keeping a journal, help you to navigate your own successes
and failures, although, the word failure is not a word we subscribe to, a
better way of looking at failures is ‘opportunities to learn.’
165
CHAPTER 5
There are probably more but these are generally the main issues
we think about when we plan.
CONCLUSION
166
CHAPTER 5
Chapter wrap-up
What is the most important What lingering questions What steps will you take
learning you have derived about lesson planning do to find answers to these
from this chapter? you still have? questions?
Observation task
Arrange to observe a colleague; explain that you are going to observe the various components
of a lesson mentioned in this chapter and how they impact a lesson plan. Ask the teacher to
provide you with a lesson plan before the observation. This does not have to be a formal plan;
a simple outline of the tasks will suffice. As you are observing, note down the changes made to
the plan during the lesson. For example, see if an activity was added, if an activity took longer
than the teacher had expected, if an activity was removed and so forth. Along with the change,
note down what was the catalyst for the change. Consider the four areas below and how they
contributed the plan adjustments
Students Space/classroom
Materials Time/pace
167
CHAPTER 5
Think about a specific lesson that you have recently taught which went well. Reflect on:
• Why it went well
• How each of the components mentioned above impacted the lesson plan’s execution
• How big a part of the success was the actual paper plan
portfolio task
168
pLuG IN: ALTERNATIvE LESSON PLAN TEMPLATES
We present below two different templates that can be used to plan lessons. The first one is a linear one
that organizes the lesson in a sequential manner. In this sense, it is easy to read and follow. However, there
are critics to this kind of plan, as it fails to capture the actual “messiness” of the teaching and learning
processes by presenting a lesson as a linear series of activities.
Aims
Objectives:
Materials:
B) PROCEDURE
Closure
169
CHAPTER 5
Hook / Motivation
Learning Schema
Outcomes Building
Assessment
Input
Input
extension
Construction / Reconstruction
Differentiation
(Process, Product or Content)
170
6.
X.
CHAPTER
ORGANIZING LANGUAGE
XXXXXXX
LESSONS
Xxxxx
learning
learningabout:about:
• • different
classroom
understandings of
management
• language lessons.
learning communities
• • ways of organizing
teachers’ roles
• lessons.
teachers’ use of L2 in
• purposes of lessons.
class
171171
THE CHAPTER AT A GLANCE
Collection engage
of activities Study
Schema building
activate
Pre-presenting
Developing metacognition
Contextualizing opening
bridging Sequencing
Modeling transitions
recast Pacing
Closin
Focused
instruction
Presentation guided
Practice lesson a flexible instruction
Skill-based types model Collaborative
review/reteaching learning
independent
learning
172
CHAPTER 6
STARTING OUT
Teachers say…
Students say…
173
CHAPTER 6
• I need the teacher to teach me! I hate it when lessons are all about
“talk among yourselves.”
174
CHAPTER 6
As you read about the different lesson formats, think back to your times as a language learner. What
was the most frequent kind of lesson organization?
175
CHAPTER 6
E→S→A
This kind of lesson has proved useful for beginning level students
because individual items can be presented in a carefully dosed way
that may lead to students’ being able to use them right away (Ur, 2012).
Finally, straight arrow lessons are easy to plan and implement which
is perhaps why they are popular with aspiring and novice teachers, as
well as with materials developers.
176
CHAPTER 6
E→A→S→A→E→S
177
CHAPTER 6
and whether they would expect to find these facts in another kind of
text (maybe a song). The teacher then plays the song (E) for students
to check their predictions (S).
We prefer to look at individual lessons as stories collectively woven
by teachers and learners working together, where the protagonists are the
latter and not the former. While useful at beginning stages, a framework
such as the one presented by Harmer can help you organize the activities
teachers choose to do in class. However, we should acknowledge that
this framework fails to account for the “story” embedded in every lesson
by focusing mostly on the actions of the teacher and still responding to
a traditional view where the teacher decides what language to teach and
practice, without much student input.
In our view, each lesson has a particular purpose that stems
from the students’ communicative needs. It is this purpose that will
determine how the lesson will evolve and what structure it will have.
All these considerations put the students, and not the language, at the
center of teaching process.
Having said this, we should also recognize that lessons do tend to
progress through some predictable “moments,” which need to be taken
into consideration as they impact students’ opportunities for success
by helping the teacher structure and sequence teaching and learning
activities.
As you read about the different lesson blocks below, think back to your times as a language learner.
Do you remember how your teachers implemented transitions? How about closure?
178
CHAPTER 6
179
CHAPTER 6
making clear how the contents are sequenced), showing how this
specific lesson connects to future ones or making explicit how students
can use the contents learned in this lesson in real life. Also, the closure
moment provides a great opportunity for assessment for learning
activities (these are discussed in Chapter 11).
Again, this depiction of the components of a language lesson
provides useful information as to what the overall structuring blocks of
a lesson are, but it does not explicitly show you how lessons pursuing
different purposes can be organized. In our opinion, the deciding factor
in shaping a lesson is its purpose. A language presentation lesson
will have a particular organization, which is different from that of a
reading lesson or a fluency lesson. Lesson organization is a matter of
teachers’ decision making in light of students’ learning needs. It is also
a consideration made in light of broader course goals, as the teacher
will decide when to present language inductively and deductively,
when to practice it, and when to engage students in free expression.
We can conclude that because, as we have said before, lessons are
“stories” told by the teacher and the learners, they require the active
participation of both parties.
One key idea behind our view about language teaching and learning
is that teachers and students should engage in meaningful and active
co-construction of their knowledge where the teacher’s main task is to
organize for learning to happen, as well as to mediate learners’ efforts
by providing the necessary scaffolds (Diaz Maggioli, 2013). Along the
same lines, Fisher and Frey (2014) suggest that effective instruction
leading to student learning is a matter of structuring teaching so that
responsibility for learning is gradually released towards the students.
In other words, these authors advocate for the provision of scaffolds
as the teacher’s main task where the ultimate aim of the teacher’s
intervention is to bestow control over the communicative activity
on the students themselves. In order to do this, the teacher will use
different mediational moves that seek to extend the students’ current
grasp of the language.
180
CHAPTER 6
As you read the following section, think of concrete examples of the various scaffolds that you have
used or seen used in language classes. Which is the most common scaffold you have seen? Can you
think why this is so?
• Modeling
Learners are able to see or hear what a demonstration of the
expected performance looks like. They are also given clear
examples of what is required of them. Teachers can provide
modeling by demonstrating procedures, showing their thinking in
action by verbalizing decisions they make, and also by exhibiting
their use of knowledge in action.
• Bridging
When you use this scaffold you make sure that new understandings
are firmly built upon students’ previous understandings. You can
model both at the cognitive level (e.g. activating the learners’
prior knowledge by providing anticipatory guides or graphic
organizers) as well as the metacognitive level (e.g. by coaching
learners’ thinking targeting their prior experience and helping
them self-monitor and evaluate performance).
181
CHAPTER 6
• Contextualizing
This scaffold involves you in “fleshing out” new concepts by
making explicit connections between these and the learners’
current understandings. You can do this through analogies and
metaphors based on the learners’ prior experiences (“This is
similar to…” or “An auxiliary verb is like a crutch that helps you
ask a question”).
• Schema building
We organize knowledge and understanding around schemata
(singular: schema), or clusters of meaning that are interconnected.
Understanding is then a process of weaving new information
into pre-existing structures. Hence, you can scaffold evolving
understandings by helping learners see connections between what
they already know and the new understandings. One effective way
of fostering schema building is Socratic questioning (lead students
to discover new facts about the language by asking them questions
to help clarify their thinking, challenge their assumptions, asking
them to provide evidence, etc.) and also by providing advanced
organizers (for example, a short semantic map of the topic they
will work on), explicit summaries or allowing for “previews” of
the content to be learnt.
• Re-presenting
To implement this form of scaffolding you resort to alternating
among different genres in order to help learners make sense of
events or information. For example, you may choose to use a
narrative to illustrate the process of deriving a conclusion from
a text used for reading, which is not self-evident at first. Walqui
(2006, p. 174) suggests that an effective sequence for scaffolding
understanding through representation “starts with asking students
to say what is happening (as in drama or dialogue), then what
has happened (narratives, reports) and, finally, what may happen
(tautologic transformations, theorizing).”
182
CHAPTER 6
• Developing metacognition
Metacognition refers to the ability to plan, monitor and evaluate
one’s own understanding, so that one is aware of how adequate
that understanding is. Walqui (op.cit: p. 176) indicates that this
kind of scaffolding comprises four aspects:
a) “consciously applying learned strategies while engaging in
activity;
b) knowledge and awareness of strategic options a learner has
and the ability to choose the most effective one for the particular
activity at hand;
c) monitoring, evaluating and adjusting performance during
activity; and
d) planning for future performance based on evaluation of past
performance.”
These scaffolds are a toolkit for you to interact with students during
a lesson and respond to their evolving understanding and emergent
language capacity. As to how the lesson should be structured, we refer
once again to the learners’ communicative needs. The purpose of any
lesson is to help learners make headway in their language development.
If the lesson is teacher-centered, then students have few opportunities
to gain control over their language. If, on the other hand, the lesson
has no structure, students may feel lost because they do not have the
necessary resources to use the language to fulfill their communicative
intent. What is needed, then, is a framework for lesson development
that is responsive to students’ evolving needs and language proficiency,
while helping the teacher manage the learning process.
Fisher and Frey (2014) provide one such framework for teaching
and learning activities organized around four key forms of interaction.
They propose a “gradual release of control over understanding” model
that comprises four kinds of interaction: one where you interact with
the class as a whole, another one in which students interact with one
another and with you in small groups, a further one in which students
interact with one another in groups, and finally, one where students
individually interact with the content and the learning tasks built
around it. The model can be graphically depicted as follows:
183
CHAPTER 6
“i do it”
Focused instruction
As you read this section, think back to your language lessons. How do they compare to Fisher and
Frey’s model? If you are currently teaching, how would you describe a typical class taught by you?
184
CHAPTER 6
185
CHAPTER 6
186
CHAPTER 6
Purpose:
To raise students’ awareness about how language works, while
helping them notice relevant features of the input so they can engage in
grammaring and language use.
Can you explain the meaning of the different pyramid diagrams before reading each of the next
sections? How can you connect them to the notion of scaffolding we saw before?
187
CHAPTER 6
188
CHAPTER 6
which are very close to real life encounters where they would need to
use the language learned.
The following is the description of a sample lesson for elementary
students.:
As the students come into the classroom, the teacher has written a “DO NOW” activity
that reads: “Welcome to today’s lesson! While we are waiting for everyone to arrive,
please take your notebook and write two or three ideas you associate with the word
“CRIME.” Once all students have arrived, the teacher informs the class that they are
going to learn how to ask for and give information about safety in the neighborhoods
they live in. He invites students to come to the board and write the ideas they came up
with during the DO NOW activity. Once this is complete, the teacher uses the words
students have suggested in a brief description of the neighborhood where he lives.
Focused Additionally, he adds as many words as necessary to make the text comprehensible for
instruction students. Next, he checks students’ understanding by asking them YES/NO questions
and also asks students if they remember any part of the description. He elicits one or
two sentences such as “It is safe to walk in the streets during the day, but you must
be careful after dark” or “If you come to my neighborhood at night, you should try to
either come in groups or come by cab.” He uses these sentences to teach students
how to give advice, using modals. He then involves students in chorally repeating some
of the sentences and for this, he uses substitution drills. Finally, he elicits an explanation
from students, which he writes on the board, making sure information about use,
meaning, function, form and pronunciation is included.
The teacher engages students in taking turns repeating some of the sample sentences
Guided by cueing one another in open and closed pairs. Next, the teacher produces a series of
instruction exercises where students work together to practice syntactic and semantic aspects of
the uses of modals, to discuss safety in various neighborhoods in the city.
Students work in groups performing a role-play. They are a family and they must decide
where to buy their first house. The teacher gives each student a role card that describes
Collaborative what family member they are and their specific needs. Of course, each individual’s
learning needs are somehow at odds with those of the other members of the family, thus
creating both an information gap and an opinion gap. Once they have finished, groups
present their work to the rest of the class.
Students are asked to go home and find safety statistics about the neighborhood
where they live. They use that information to create a blog page providing information
Independent to neighbors, classmates and friends. The teacher may choose to provide a skeleton
learning text (just providing the beginning of sentences) for students to follow. Every student
must read and comment on at least three of their classmates’ blogs or there could be a
class discussion about safety in the various neighborhoods in the city.
189
CHAPTER 6
Why is this diagram different if the purpose of the lesson is the same?
As the students come into the classroom, the teacher has written a “DO NOW” activity
that reads: “Welcome to today’s lesson! While we are waiting for everyone to arrive,
please take your notebook and write two or three ideas you associate with the word
Focused
“CRIME.” When everyone has arrived, the teacher tells students that today they will
instruction
discuss safety in their neighborhoods. He asks students what other language they
might need and provides it. He also reminds students of strategies for turn taking and
other communicative strategies.
Students work in groups performing a role-play. They are a family and they must
decide where to buy their first house. The teacher gives each student a role card
that describes what family member they are and their specific needs. Again, each
Collaborative
individual’s needs are somehow at odds with those of the other members of the family,
learning
thus creating both an information gap and an opinion gap. Once they have finished,
the teacher gives groups some time to prepare how they are going to report their
findings to the rest of the class. Groups present their decision to the rest of the class.
The teacher plays a recording of either native speakers of the language or more
proficient students performing the same task and asks students to compare their
Guided role-play to the one on the audio. Once students have become aware of the language
instruction gaps, the teacher provides an explanation of the language needed (if necessary) and
has students practice the new language via various exercises and activities ranging
from controlled to semi-controlled ones.
Students work together again, but this time they are given a map of a different
neighborhood with crime statistics and other information. They must decide what part
Independent
of the neighborhood would be a good place to establish a Youth Center. Students are
learning
reminded to use the language they have just learned. The teacher follows the same
stages as before for the report and the noticing stages (see Guided Instruction).
190
CHAPTER 6
Purpose:
To provide clarification and further practice of the language.
What is the main difference in scaffolding opportunities in this diagram compared to the others?
191
CHAPTER 6
CONCLUSION
192
CHAPTER 6
ChapteR wRap-up
What is the most important What lingering questions What steps will you take
learning you have derived about different kinds to find answers to these
from this chapter? of lessons do you still have? questions?
Observation task
What the teacher does. What students do. What kind of interaction?
Think about your experience learning a foreign language. Can you identify different kinds of
lessons that your language teachers used to implement? Think back to one of your language
teachers in particular (either recent or from a long time ago), how would you categorize that
teacher in terms of Kumaravadivelu’s ideas on page 174 of this unit.
193
CHAPTER 6
portfolio task
194
pLuG IN 1:
ADAPTING COURSEBOOKS & OTHER MATERIALS
Textbook goals. Before starting to work with the book, ask students what they want to achieve in the
course. Then ask them to leaf through the book and spot what might help them achieve their goals.
Share the goals with peers.
Personalized gaps. Students make their own sentences using the words they filled blanks with. They
find someone who has written a similar sentence.
Instant word search. Ask students to choose 5 random letters in a word search and ask them to write
a word they know (you may ask them to use a certain category, e.g. “animals”) starting with that letter.
Then they create their own word searches. Also good for crosswords.
Changing characters. Ask students to change characters in a dialog and to either rewrite the dialog for
the new characters or to role-play it (e.g. dialog between two friends changes to an old lady and a young
rock fan).
Questions first! Cover the reading text in the unit but let students see the questions. They read the
questions and try to answer them using what they know about the topic. Then, they predict what the text
will be about and check with the text.
Jigsaw reading. If there is more than one reading or writing text in the lesson, split students in groups
so as to turn it into a Jigsaw reading or writing activity.
Numbered questions together. Assign one question from a reading text to various students. Number
students in the class according to the number of questions in the activity. They answer the question for
their number. Then, they stand up and share answers with other students with the same number. Finally,
they share with the class.
Dictogloss. Choose an activity that is mechanical and turn it into a Dictogloss: 1. Read the activity out
loud at normal speed. Students listen. 2. Read again, students take notes. 3. Read again while students
complete their notes. 4. Students share notes and do the activity. 5. Have students change groups and
compare answers. 6. Refer them to the actual activity.
Skeleton dialogs. Use blank dialogs for students to create their own versions. Use the dialog in the
book as a template. Example:
A: How was your _________?
B: It was ___________!
Flip it! Assign the Grammar discovery activity or the reading texts as homework. Provide students with a
key. Flip the class by having students do other things in class using what they have learned (e.g. write a
summary of the text; do practice activities on the grammar, etc.).
Take a fill in the blanks text and turn it around! Instead of the original words, provide students with
blanks and just include the words that should go in the blanks in the original exercise. Establish the
context of the text (e.g. provide a title or mention to students what the text is about) and have students
complete the text.
195
VTS (Visual Thinking Strategies).
Give students some time to look at a picture in their textbook. Ask: “What is going on in this picture?”
As students contribute ideas, point to what they are saying in the picture. Rephrase what they say in
correct English (but do not praise students) and try to weave every student’s contribution into your
rephrasing. Next, ask learners “What do you see that makes you say that?” As different students
contribute answers weave information from various students together. When ideas stop coming ask:
“What more can we learn from this picture?” Refrain from explicit correction or praise. Thank students
for their contributions.
Points of view. Ask students to describe the picture in the textbook using conflicting points of view.
For example, for a picture of a tropical island ask one student to describe it from the point of view of
someone who hates hot weather. Turn this into pair work by giving students role cards.
Guess the teacher’s ideas. If students have to complete sentences with their own ideas, create your
own version ahead of time and ask students to try and guess what your version is.
Odd one out. Use the vocabulary in the lesson to create “odd word out” activities with no correct
answer. For example, in a lesson on animals give students these words and ask them to tell you which
one does not belong in the group and why: DOG – CAT – RABBIT – GOLDFISH – BUDGIE
Disappearing texts or dialogs. Take a text or dialog from the book and write it on the board (or create
a PowerPoint presentation). Ask students to read it aloud as you point to the various words. Then ask
them to close their eyes and delete some of the words. They open their eyes and have to read all the
text including the missing words. Continue until there are no words. Works well also with flashcards and
dialog lines.
Personalized dictation. Take a reading text and turn it into a dictation. Students listen and they have to
make the text true about themselves (i.e. they are not copying literally).
Liar, liar, pants on fire! Have students write three sentences about themselves using a new grammatical
item. One of the sentences has to be FALSE. They read their sentences out loud to other students who
have to guess the FALSE sentence.
Diaries. Ask students to keep a vocabulary and/or grammar diary. In the last few minutes of the lesson,
after they have learned something new, they write sentences about themselves using the newly learned
language. They then use these sentences to generate activities and exchange them with other students.
Everything is kept in the diary.
Role-play it! Turn any text or dialog into a new role-play by changing one element (setting, characters,
topic, etc.). Give students time to plan and then get them to perform.
196
Dialog starters. Write the first two lines of dialogs about various everyday situations on slips of paper.
Mix them up and give them out to students. They memorize the line and return it to you. They then go
around the class saying their line and trying to find their partner. Once they meet, they complete the
dialog. For example:
1) A: How much is this magazine?
B: One thousand pesos.
2) A: I’m Kevin and I’m going to be your server. Can I get you started with something to drink?
B: Yes, please. I’d like a diet soda.
Make it stick! Give students a sticky note. Ask them to place it next to an activity or text in the
textbook unit that they would like to be in control of (they can read the text out loud, ask other students
questions, give correct answers for an exercise, etc.). They reuse the sticky note as they move along the
textbook.
Use learning circles to differentiate learning. Organize coursebook activities in a sequence and, if
necessary, design a new sequence. Divide students in groups according to their level and have them
complete a “circle” by spending 10 minutes on each activity (they start at the activity that best matches
their level or needs).
Make it digital! If you have access to computers, students can make free videos of dialogs using the
free trial versions of various software platforms that allow them to create short cartoons and videos.
Turn it into a board game. When learning new language item or information about a new topic, have
students create activities and design a board game. Brainstorm language associated with board games
(e.g. “Miss a turn”). Give students various pieces of color paper. They write a different activity for each
color (e.g. fill in blanks on the red papers, give a synonym on the yellow, etc.). They also create the rules
for the game.
197
pLuG IN 2: TECHNOLOGY-MEDIATED
TEACHING AND LEARNING
Using technology to teach English does not guarantee success in language learning, even if students
are motivated. In general, the applications that have become popular (with some distinguished
exceptions) do not promote communicative use of the language.
Diaz Maggioli and Painter Farrell (2013) make a distinction between acquisitional and transactional
use of technology. Technology is used in acquisitional ways with activities that present language
as linear; where the student has little say (as everything is pre-designed and responds to an
Initiation→Response→Feedback logic). The students only “drag and drop” items. These activities are
built with a traditional transmission model tied to the binary codes of the computer. In short, they are
computer-centered or “machine-deep.” We know, from experience that, in order for learning to happen
through the use of technology, we need activities that favor a transactional use of technology (i.e. activities
that are responsive to learners’ evolving mastery of the language; they favor interaction; make language
come alive by involving students in actual language use; in short, activities that are “people-deep”).
198
7.
X.
CHAPTER
UNDERSTANDING
XXXXXXX
AND TEACHING LANGUAGE
Xxxxx
learning
learningabout:about:
• • lexis, syntax and
classroom
phonology.
management
• • register and genre.
learning communities
• • techniques for
teachers’ roles
• teaching lexis, syntax
teachers’ use of L2 in
and phonology.
class
learning
learninghow howto:to:
• •
use basic instructional
develop and value a
techniques.
learning community
• •
organize instruction to
plan lessons to cater
teach lexis, syntax and
for different energy
Look at the picture above. Do you know what this is? It’s called a phonology.
levels and attention
fractal. Fractals are defined by the fractalfoundation.org as never-ending • design practice
spans
patterns that are very complex but self-similar across different scales. activities.
• use the white or
Fractals are created by repeating a simple pattern or process over and blackboard
• use the classroom
over again. However, with each repetition, the fractal picture changes
seating arrangements
shape and becomes both deeper and more beautiful. One interesting to optimize learning.
thing about fractals is that the patterns are extremely familiar as they
are found in nature: in rivers, coastlines, mountains, trees, clouds,
seashells, etc. Language, as a human capacity, is also found in nature and
all languages are made up of the same components. Traditional views
of language define it as a “system of systems” made up of phonology,
syntax and semantics, among others. However, these systems on their
own fail to account for both the beauty and the depth of meanings we
can produce by combining the patterns found in them. We have chosen
the metaphor of fractals to stand for how we see language at work. First
of all, language surfaces in social interaction, and is not a product of
grammar rules. The same grammar rule, the same sound or the same
word, uttered in different social settings will have different meanings and
different connotations. That is why, we see language as a semiotic system
humans use to express and negotiate meanings. Each sub-system may
be there, but without the social dimension, they are just one line in the
drawing. We need all the lines, that is to say, the use of all the resources
that language affords us, to be able to create beauty.
199199
THE CHAPTER AT A GLANCE
Synonyms
antonyms
hyponyms
Collocations
Connected speech lexis
idioms
Prominence
Chunks
intonation units
Formulaic language
thought groups
understanding and
Consonants Sounds
remembering lexis
Vowels
Pronunciation Understanding
& Teaching grammar
Language
What do you already know about teaching lexis, syntax and phonology?
What issues about teaching lexis, syntax and phonology have you
heard your colleagues/cooperating teacher discuss? Why are they
important/relevant?
200
CHAPTER 7
STARTING OUT
Teachers say…
Students say…
201
CHAPTER 7
WHAT IS LANGUAGE?
202
CHAPTER 7
Table 7.1 - A sample scope and sequence section from a Beginners’ level book
203
CHAPTER 7
204
CHAPTER 7
205
CHAPTER 7
Sit on the bus and listen to two people talking. Then, go to a bank and do the same. Think about
how the two situations compare and how registers and genres vary. What is similar in both situations?
What is different?
interpersonal
textual
discourse
semantics
sequence
clause
figure lexicogrammar
group
etc.
etc.
word
syllable graph/
etc. phonology
phoneme
ideational
206
CHAPTER 7
WHAT IS LEXIS?
207
CHAPTER 7
respect, Cook (2008) posits that the most frequent words in English are
all function words (prepositions, articles, conjunctions, etc.) and not
content words (nouns, verbs, adjectives and adverbs). He emphasizes
that, while frequency can be an important factor in determining what
lexis to teach, we should also take into consideration the ease with which
meaning can be demonstrated and also, the availability of a particular
lexeme (word) to students’ needs. These reasons are mostly practical
but very important. Particularly at beginning levels, our selection of
words to teach should be based on how easy it is to present them to
students. Additionally, even if a word appears late in the frequency
count, but students need it to satisfy communicative needs, we should
teach it.
According to O’Keefe (2012) what gives core words such potency
are two factors:
208
CHAPTER 7
in relation to other words. The word “girl” has a distinct meaning from
the word “boy” but also from the word “child” and the word “woman.”
Put in another way, words exist in lexical relations to one another.
The most common lexical relationship is synonymy. Many
words have synonyms (e.g.: start, begin, commence, initiate, etc.).
Though these words mean approximately the same, there is not
100% synonymy and this can sometimes lead students to errors.
Of course, what will determine the degree of synonymy will be the
register features we discussed in the previous section. For example, in a
situation where the learner is interacting with other learners explaining
an experiment in class, they can say “First, you start by…” However, if
they were defending a doctoral thesis, they would be expected to use
clauses like “You initiate the experiment by…” There is one case in
which there is 100% synonymy, and that is in the naming of the same
object in different varieties of the language. For example, the words
“lift” (in British English) and “elevator” (in American English) are 100%
synonymous. In any case, it would be risky to teach lexis only through
synonymy. That is why we need to look at other lexical relations in
order to provide fruitful encounters with new words.
The meaning of words can also be accessed via opposite meanings.
This is known as antonymy. Again, because the meaning will derive
from the specific context of use of the word, these will not have just
one antonym for every word. The context will determine the proximity
between two antonyms. Consider, for example, two potential antonyms
for the word “special”: “ordinary” and “general.” When would you use
each? As you can see, the choice of antonym will necessarily depend
on the context of use.
As it is clear from the two examples above, if we want students to
have “increasing contextual encounters” (O’Keefe, 2012, p. 240) with
lexis so that they can remember the words, then these words need to
be taught in their context of use. This is because isolated explanations
of individual words, contribute little to vocabulary learning.
One last semantic relationship (or way of organizing lexis
according to meaning) is hyponymy. Hyponymy helps us organize
words in hierarchical categories so students can say “X” is a type of
“Y” (for example, motorcycle is a kind of vehicle). The advantage of
using hyponymy as a lexical teaching strategy is that, in general, the
209
CHAPTER 7
main category word is a core word. O’Keefe (2012) gives the example
of the word “shoe” (a core word) and the related lexical items “pump,”
“stiletto,” “sandal” and “moccasin.”
Expanding on the concept of lexical relations, Cook (2008)
cites the work of Rosch’s who created a theory to account for those
instances in which it is not possible to break down the meaning of a
word. This author posited that either in L1 or L2 we all learn what he
calls the “basic” or central concept of a word. For example, we first
learn the word “table” to stand for a four-legged piece of furniture. In
this sense, we acquire a central form of a concept and the things we see
and talk about correspond to that prototype. Through lexical relations,
we then learn that the basic concept also forms part of a superordinate
category (e.g. “furniture”) and that there are subordinate categories for
it, as well (e.g. “night table,” “coffee table”). Cook (op.cit) is critical of
materials that impose the superordinate before the basic, as it has been
found that the first approach to a new lexeme is at the basic level.
He recommends that we teach the basic meaning of words in context
and, as students accumulate knowledge about a word through iterative
approximations to it, then we may begin to include the superordinate
and subordinate (e.g. through classifying words, asking students to
categorize them, or through mind maps).
Lexis is also organized syntactically. In this sense, students need
to be familiar with features such as:
210
CHAPTER 7
lexis operates in real life. Tools such as “The Compleat Lexical Tutor”
(http://www.lextutor.ca) can help teachers analyze texts in terms of
word frequency, collocation and meaning.
So, what does “knowing a word” entail? First of all, all aspects
of a word cannot be learned in one single teaching session. Learners
will access the richness of vocabulary by progressively encountering
the word in meaningful contexts that demand that they use it. In this
recurring process students will progressively learn the:
Look at the following list of words for one minute. Then, close the book and try to remember as
many as you can. How many were you able to recall? How did you recall them
Think back to when you were learning a language. What strategies did you use to try and
understand new words?
211
CHAPTER 7
Understanding lexis
We use a variety of strategies to understand words. Some of these
strategies include guessing, using dictionaries, deducing the meaning
from the form of the word and relating words to similar words in
another language.
Guessing from context is perhaps the most natural process in
attempting to understand the meaning of unknown words. However, it
is also a strategy that is limited by the students’ own language resources
and also their experience with using this strategy in other contexts or
subjects. If we choose to use it in class, we must remember that it also
has some dangers. First, we should bear in mind that guessing from
context requires that students have extensive access to the text (in
written or oral form) so that they can check and modify their guesses.
These guesses can go wrong sometimes because the language can be
unpredictable from the situation. Lastly, guessing takes time, so it is not
an adequate strategy to use unless students have ample time to come
up with and modify their guesses.
The use of dictionaries is a widespread practice in language
teaching but it is not devoid of problems, either. Would you use a
monolingual or bilingual dictionary? Bilingual dictionaries focus on
the discrete meaning of a word by providing a synonym in another
language. We have seen already that one-to-one synonymy between
languages seldom occurs. It would appear that the better choice is to
use a monolingual dictionary. Again, there can be debate as to whether
we use a dictionary which is based on a corpus of the language or
one which is example-based and provides a mere list of meanings. In
general, it is recommended that corpus-based monolingual dictionaries
be chosen, as they are more representative of the actual use of the
language in a particular social context.
Many students choose to deduce the meaning of a word by
breaking it down into its component parts (e.g. base + suffix). Again
this is a valid and productive process but it is not safe proof. Just as
it was the case with guessing, this process can take a long time and
students would need sustained and extended access to the context
in which the word is used, as well as experience of successful prior
applications of the strategy.
212
CHAPTER 7
Think back to when you were learning a language. What strategies did you use to remember new words?
Remembering lexis
We also use a variety of strategies to remember new words. The
most commonly used in classrooms is repetition. In this sense, if we look
at many popular materials, students are encouraged to listen and repeat
new words, match the words to pictures, complete the word or even
reorder the letters to make up the word. All these involve some degree of
repetition (both at the orthographical or phonological levels). However,
research has disqualified this approach to learning. In particular, there is
one theory that stresses that the first encounter with a word is what makes
it memorable. So, our advice is that we should concentrate on “making
a good impression” when introducing new words. This can be done by
properly contextualizing its meaning and use, and also by making sure
that it makes an impact on students (by exaggerating, including a funny
or interesting fact about the word, eliciting the meaning from students, or
by using pictures that are truly memorable).
Another useful strategy we use to remember new words involves
organizing them in our minds in meaningful groups. Here we should
refer back to prototype theory and remember that the starting point
should be the basic concept of a word.
Finally, we use our different memory systems to remember
new vocabulary. Because learning a new lexeme in isolation can be
extremely hard, we should contextualize our presentation as much
as possible and then, offer students ways to cling to that meaning by
helping them make connections between the new lexeme and their
background knowledge. One popular way of doing this is to use a
procedure called “loci” in which you store information you want to
remember in a carefully visualized location (e.g. Visualize how you make
213
CHAPTER 7
your way back home and associate a new word to each stage of your
journey. Then, practice remembering the meaning of the words as you
“go back home”). A similar technique is to use mental imagery in which
you associate the meaning of a new word to an exaggerated or very
clear illustration of the word. For example, when Gabriel first learned
the word “awesome” in English he pictured himself on a new bike and
his friends looking at him with their mouths open in admiration.
Also, using acrostics and other mnemonics to remember the
meaning of words can be very effective.
Think back to when you were learning a language. How did your teachers teach new vocabulary?
Which of those approaches did you find useful?
Teaching lexis
Given all the above information, here are some recommendations
(loosely adapted from Cook, 2008) for teaching vocabulary:
214
CHAPTER 7
WHAT IS GRAMMAR?
215
CHAPTER 7
there are other possible views, such as those that advocate for a more
holistic approach to grammar development. For example, in his 2001
book, Uncovering Grammar, Thornbury invites us to think of grammar
as a process, and not as a product.
Views on Grammar
Simply put, Grammar refers to the study of the structures that
are possible in a language. Those structures are made up of words and
their order within a sentence. Syntax gives us rules for how words are
ordered within a sentence, and morphology allows us to study how
those words are formed. Given this, a frequent definition of grammar
is: “the way that words are put together to make correct sentences” (Ur,
2012, p. 76).
Some authors (Thornbury, 2001; Scrivener, 2011; Ur, 2012) point
to the fallacy of such a simplistic definition. To Ur (2012) issues of
grammar are not merely issues of order or correctness. She makes the
point that grammar carries meaning since it establishes time (verbs,
adverbs), place (prepositions), and a multitude of functions (e.g.
“possibility,” through modals and conditionals) and it is not so much
the order of the words but the lack of understanding of these meanings
that causes problems to students learning grammar.
Thornbury provides us with this example of language in use to
illustrate the complexity of grammar:
“‘This is
“‘This is 2680239.
2680239. We
We are
are not
not at
at home
home right
right now.
now. Please,
Please, leave
leave a
a
message after the beep.’
message after the beep.’
You will recognise it as an answerphone message. That is the kind of
You will recognise it as an answerphone message. That is the kind of
text it is. It consists of three sentences, which themselves consist of
text it is. It consists of three sentences, which themselves consist of
words, and the words (when spoken) consist of sounds. All language
words, and the words (when spoken) consist of sounds. All language
in use can be analysed at each of these four levels: text, sentence,
in use can be analysed at each of these four levels: text, sentence,
word, and sounds. These are the forms that the language takes. The
word, and sounds. These are the forms that the language takes. The
study of grammar consists, in part, of looking at the way these forms
study of grammar consists, in part, of looking at the way these forms
are arranged and patterned.” (Thornbury, 1999, p. 1)
are arranged and patterned.” (Thornbury, 1999, p. 1)
216
CHAPTER 7
217
CHAPTER 7
Grammar as a process
If we adhere to a view of grammar as a process, then we should
first understand how that process evolves. Various researchers have
drawn parallels between the genesis of grammar in L1 and that of L2,
so we will attempt to describe grammar as a process by analyzing how
grammaticality surfaces in children’s speech.
Children’s speech, at around the age of one, is mostly low on
grammar and relies heavily on lexis. Individual words, or attempts at
218
CHAPTER 7
Before reading on, think back to a moment in your language learning career when you became
aware that you were experiencing success. How did you feel? What did you do next?
219
CHAPTER 7
“the ability
“the ability to
to use
use grammar
grammar structures
structures accurately,
accurately, meaningfully,
meaningfully,
and
and appropriately
appropriately as
as the
the proper
proper goal
goal of
of grammar
grammar instruction.
instruction. The
The
addition
addition of ‘-ing’ to grammar is meant to suggest a dynamic process
of ‘-ing’ to grammar is meant to suggest a dynamic process
of
of grammar
grammar using.
using. In
In order
order to
to realize
realize this
this goal,
goal, it
it is
is not
not sufficient
sufficient
for
for students
students toto notice
notice oror comprehend
comprehend grammatical
grammatical structures.
structures.
Students
Students must
must also
also practice
practice meaningful use of grammar grammar … … This
This
means
means that in order for students to overcome the inert knowledge
that in order for students to overcome the inert knowledge
problem
problem and
and transfer
transfer what
what they
they do
do in
in communicative
communicative practice
practice to
to
real
real communication
communication outside
outside of
of the
the classroom,
classroom, there
there must
must bebe a
a
psychological
psychological similarity between the conditions of learning and the
similarity between the conditions of learning and the
conditions
conditions of use” (Larsen-Freeman, 2009, p. 526).
of use” (Larsen-Freeman, 2009, p. 526).
If this were not so, then children would be given ready-made rules
by their caretakers that they would imitate in order to communicate.
This is definitely not what happens in real life. In real life, I do not speak
to a child only in the present for a year or so, and then only in the past,
and so on. I use complex language (which is adapted to the child’s
actual level of comprehension, so the focus is always on meaning, not
form) to interact with the child and, in the process, I am transferring
control over language from myself to the child.
This is a process that can be replicated in the foreign language
classroom, if certain conditions are met. First and foremost, we must
recognize that in the foreign language classroom we are not generally
dealing with babies, but with children, teenagers or adults who have
already developed an L1. This has provided them with resources that
can be transferred to their L2 learning experience. Secondly, in real
life we use language by interacting with significant others. Hence, the
220
CHAPTER 7
221
CHAPTER 7
For example, when Lesley was learning Polish, she once had
difficulty trying to express the conditional. She attempted a conditional
sentence in a conversation with her boss who stopped her and told
her “This is how you say it...” It was at that point that she noticed
the language, and she became aware of how that particular language
feature worked in real life. Once she was conscious of how to say it, she
went on to apply it in real life by purposefully seeking opportunities to
use that particular form.
This example, as well as research, helps us conclude that in short,
both formal instruction and real-life interaction are necessary in order
for students to be able to make use of their noticing as a contribution
to their grammaring. In reviewing research on noticing carried out
by Schmidt, Thornbury (op.cit., p. 36) explains “Without the formal
instruction, specific features of naturally-occurring language use
might have washed right over...But without the real-life interaction, the
outcomes of formal instruction may have simply sat on a shelf in the
brain and gathered dust… both kinds of learning required a degree
of attention. In other words, language learning involves conscious
processes.” And he adds, “Fluency activities are necessary in order to
help make language production fluid and automatic. But they need to
be balanced with other activities that encourage learners to develop
their grammaring skills--that is, to increase the complexity, not just the
automaticity, of their developing language system.” (op.cit., p. 21).
In short, the process of grammaring starts with consciousness-
raising activities that promote noticing by students. It ideally progresses
through a series of grammar-focused activities that will eventually
yield the necessary grammatical complexity for students to be able
to engage in real-life interaction through fluency activities. Taking this
process as our starting point, we will now turn to other more practical
considerations regarding what grammar to teach, when, and how.
222
CHAPTER 7
223
CHAPTER 7
• Identify the target item to teach. This selection can be the result of you having noticed that students
need a particular grammatical item in order to communicate, or simply your selection may derive from
the syllabus or textbook you are using.
• Fine-tune the selection. Once you know what item to teach, make a decision regarding what exactly
needs to be learned. Do students need to master mostly the interrogative form or all forms of the
item? Will you attempt to teach everything in one session? Two? Three?
• Carefully reflect on the context of use of the item. List situations, places and relationships in which
the language is typically used. Think in terms of the components of register explained earlier in this
chapter and also consider the kind of text/s that you will need in order to teach this item.
• Brainstorm five to ten everyday sentences that use the item in a natural way and which are connected
to the context of use you have selected.
• Select two or three ‘target sentences’ from the list above that clearly and unambiguously can be used
to help students notice the grammatical item and which make its use, meaning and form salient.
• Analyze and note down all the aspects of the use of the grammatical item you intend to have students
notice.
• Analyze the meaning of the grammatical item and create concept questions or other forms of
elicitation that you will use to help raise students’ awareness of the grammar item.
• Analyze the form (to include spelling and pronunciation) of the grammatical item. Develop charts,
timelines or other forms of mediation you will use to get learners to learn the form.
• Decide what you hope learners should be able to achieve during a lesson on this item. You may think
of what a typical student in your class should be able to say and do as a result of your teaching. Use
this information to write your lesson’s objectives.
224
CHAPTER 7
Teaching grammar
In general terms, we can say that the teaching of grammar needs
to be both efficient and appropriate. An efficient presentation is short.
This means that it does not consist of numerous exceptions or lengthy
explanations, but provides only the necessary information for students
to be able to move on from where they are now to the level in which they
can use the grammar item productively in communication. An efficient
presentation is also thorough in the sense that it unambiguously allows
students access to how the grammar is used in real life contexts, what
it means and how it is formed. Lastly, a grammar presentation should
be easy to implement, requiring little or no set up, and being delivered
with the most efficient tools (chalkboard, diagrams, visuals etc.). One
key element that favors these three criteria for efficiency is the need
to present grammar in meaningful contexts or texts and not just as
isolated examples. The context and/or text will allow the teacher to
highlight use, meaning and form adequately. However, if there is no
context present, the understanding of both use and meaning may be
jeopardized and we have already seen that form alone is not enough.
In terms of appropriacy, we can say that a grammar presentation
is so if it correlates to the students’ communicative needs, but also, if it
takes into account learners’ interests and motivations. A presentation
that overlooks students’ needs is pointless, as is one that overlooks
what motivates students to communicate. Lastly, appropriacy also
refers to fulfilling students’ expectations about the learning of a
foreign language. For example, if students’ goals are to simply develop
fluency, an unnecessary focus on accuracy will not cater for students’
expectations, needs or motivations.
Ellis provides a list of suggestions for when and how to teach
grammar:
• “Both form and meaning should be emphasized; learners need to have the opportunity to practice
forms in communicative tasks.
• Focus more strongly on forms that are problematic for learners.
• Explicit grammar teaching is more effective at the intermediate to advanced levels than beginning
classes.
• Attend to both input-based (comprehension) and output-based (production) grammar.
• Both deductive and inductive approaches can be useful, depending on the context and purpose of
instruction.
225
CHAPTER 7
• Incidental focus on form is valuable in that it treats errors that occur while learners are engaged in
meaningful communication.
• Corrective feedback can facilitate acquisition if it involves a mixture of implicit and explicit feedback.
• Separate grammar lessons (“focus on forms”) and grammar integrated into communicative activities
(“focus on form”) are both viable, depending on the context.”
(Ellis, 2006, pp. 102—103)
• Providing clear and unambiguous examples of the grammar item in meaningful, relevant contexts of
use before explaining it.
• Making sure students have access to both the written and oral versions of the grammar item.
Teachers need to both say and write the selected examples.
• Teaching the use, meaning and form, in this particular order.
• If the chance arises, help students compare the grammatical item to their L1 during awareness-
raising activities.
• Providing explicit rules (of use and of form) is generally useful.
• Balance inductive (students “discover” the use, meaning and form of the grammar item from the
examples without an explicit explanation) and deductive (the students are explicitly taught the use,
meaning and form and then work out their own examples) approaches.
226
CHAPTER 7
master one item and then move on to another. In fact, the learning
curve for a single item is not linear either. The curve is filled with peaks
and valleys, progress and backsliding.”
Re-read the quote by Diane Larsen-Freeman above and think back to your language learning
experience. Can you recall moments when your learning curve fluctuated in the way she describes it?
227
CHAPTER 7
228
CHAPTER 7
Personalization
communication
communication
completion
Guided
substitution
Imitation &
Sentence
Structured
responses
discourse
Awareness
Free
Brief
While in some cases you will need to use the whole gamut of
practice activities described here, many times, after assessing your
students’ current communicative needs, you may choose to skip some
of the activity types. Using the whole gamut of activities appropriately
is a matter of teacher judgment. Sometimes, you may want to follow
the sequence to the letter. At other times, you may want to skip steps or
reverse them. It will all depend on your students’ level of English, their
learning needs and their awareness of the language.
The table on the following page describes the different types of
activities and addresses how controlled they are.
229
CHAPTER 7
230
CHAPTER 7
Choose an activity from a language learning textbook you are familiar with. Assess the activity in
terms of the criteria we discussed above:
Try to modify the activity so that it fulfills all the criteria. Share it with colleagues.
WHAT IS PRONUNCIATION?
231
CHAPTER 7
232
CHAPTER 7
• Thought groups
Thought groups generally represent a meaningful grammatical
unit. In that sense, they have boundaries that are generally
signaled by pauses. Some students think that if they pause, then
they are not fluent, and tend to talk in extremely long sequences
without even breathing. It is important that we help students
identify logical breaks in spoken texts used for fluency practice.
• Prominence
Within thought groups, there is one element that is more prominent
than the rest and this is called the sentence focus or tonic
syllable. This focus allows the listener to get the exact meaning
that the speaker is intending to convey. It is not the same to say:
I LOve you. (I don’t just like you).
I love YOU. (I don’t love anyone else).
I love you. (It is I, not him or her, who loves you, it’s I).
Each focus syllable conveys a radically different meaning. Note
that the particular meanings are derived from context so we need
to explicitly draw students’ attention to this feature so as to raise
their awareness of how the sound--meaning relationship operates.
233
CHAPTER 7
• Intonation
Focus, or tonic, syllables that are made prominent are in general
accompanied by a rise or fall of the pitch forming a melodic
pattern that we call intonation. In English there are two distinctive
intonation patterns: rise and fall. Whether we use one or the other
will also depend on the contextual meaning of the utterance. For
example, we may use a fall pattern when we ask for information
(e.g. Why are you HERE? but a rise intonation when we just want
to clarify a mishearing or misunderstanding, on when just checking
(e.g. WHY are you here?).
• Rhythm
In English, rhythm is created by a combination of stressed
(prominent) and unstressed (non prominent) syllables. We generally
make prominent: nouns, main verbs, adverbs and adjectives (also
known as content words) and tend not to stress function words
(articles, prepositions, pronouns). Goodwin (op. cit., p. 138) reminds
us that “Rhythm, also called sentence stress, refers to all the syllables
that receive stress in a thought group, while prominence refers to one
of those stressed elements (the one that receives the most emphasis.”
• Word stress
Individual words composed of more than one syllable also exhibit
stress patterns (also called lexical stress). In these multi-syllable
words, one syllable receives the most prominent stress (primary
stress) while the others receive very weak stress (secondary stress).
Lexical stress is important in that a change in stress can determine
a change in the meaning of the word (e.g. ADDress= the location of
a building; addRESS = to make a speech to a group).
• Connected speech
In fluent English connected speech, a variety of modifications
occur that make the boundaries between words appear blurred.
Some of the features of connected speech are:
- Assimilation
The influence of one sound on another to become more like itself /t/
“in that man” /ðæpmæn/ or “How d’you do?” /ha du:/
234
CHAPTER 7
- Elision
The complete disappearance of a sound in a word or phrase. For
example: /t/ in “Next, please!” /nekspli:z/ or in “I don’t know”
/a d n /
- Liaison
This is the insertion of a sound between two others so as to keep
the flow. For example: “Get to it!” inserts a /w/ in between / / and
/ / /get w t/
- Reduction
This refers to the substitution of the weak central vowel in
unstressed syllables. If there is no elision of that sound, the weak
central vowel is substituted by / / (called schwa). For example, “a
bit of time” / ’b t v’ta m/.
These features of connected speech help speakers to squeeze
unstressed syllables in between stressed syllables. Because stress
is what determines the rhythm in English, this language is said to
be stressed-timed, in contrast with syllable-timed languages such
as Spanish or Korean. Students may experience difficulty both
identifying and producing these features.
• Consonants
Consonant sounds in English are characterized by movement of the
organs of speech and different blockages to the flow of air. Because
of this, consonant sounds can be described in terms of their place
of articulation (the organs of speech that are needed to make the
sound), the manner of articulation (the way the organs of speech
interact), and voicing (whether or not the vocal cords vibrate).
235
CHAPTER 7
Nose
Alveolar Ridge
Hard Palate Soft Palate (Velum)
Upper Teeth
Upper Lip
Uvula
Lower Lip
Tongue
Pharynx
Lower Teeth
Vocal Chords
• Vowels
Producing English vowels involves a movement of the tongue and
jaw, a certain degree of lip rounding and a degree of tension of the
muscles involved. Hence, vowels in English can be described as
frontal, central, or back according to the position of the tongue; as
high, mid, or low in terms of the movement of the jaw; as rounding
or spreading according to the rounding of the lips; and as tense or
lax according to the tension in the muscles involved. Students may
experience difficulty perceiving the different vowel sounds as well as
producing them. In this respect, sagittal diagrams that show where
each vowel is produced can be a helpful teaching aid. An interactive
tool that students can consult on their own can be found at: http://
smu-facweb.smu.ca/~s0949176/sammy/
236
CHAPTER 7
Factor Suggestions
237
CHAPTER 7
AWARENESS OF
KNOWLEDGE OF THE
POTENTIAL STUDENT PEDAGOGICAL
PRONUNCIATION
PROBLEMS (e.g., PRIORITIES (i.e., which
FEATURES (e.g., rules,
stemming from features should be
occurrences in discourse,
students’ L1 or taught and when).
etc.)
diagnostic work
238
CHAPTER 7
Model intonation
• When teaching grammar have students listen to some typical examples
of natural uses of the language and have them imitate stress and
intonation.
239
CHAPTER 7
Use dialogs
• Engage learners in thinking how the dialog may sound before exposing
students to an audio version. You can ask them to refer to the printed
version and predict which syllables may be stressed and then listen and
confirm predictions.
Shadow reading
• Students read at the same time with a competent reader. Once you
have gone over a text and ascertained that students understand it, you
can read it out loud (or play the audio) and have students read aloud
along. It is more useful if this is done more than once. You can then pair
students up to do the same.
240
CHAPTER 7
241
CHAPTER 7
second language instruction that departs from the traditions that are
popular—though not always effective—in the field. In the remainder
of this chapter, we will look at some basic instructional techniques that
can be used to promote this kind of pedagogy.
Clarifying use
We have seen above that the context of use is what determines the
grammatical, lexical and phonological realizations of the meaning we
intend to communicate and, because of this, it should be fore fronted at
the time of clarifying the meaning of new phonological features, lexis
or grammar.
The main tool for conveying use is a good situational context
from which the new grammatical, phonological or lexical item can be
clearly elicited and that provides information about the topic and the
participants in the conversation.
Before engaging in disclosing the meaning or the form of a new
item, teachers need to establish the context of use. In order to do that,
the teacher can use questions such as:
242
CHAPTER 7
243
CHAPTER 7
244
CHAPTER 7
read
a
She novel
245
CHAPTER 7
Timelines
When clarifying the meaning of tenses, timelines can help by
providing a graphic representation of a concept. In general, we would
advise to draw the timeline after having established meaning via
concept questions. Look at this example of a timeline for the target
sentence: “I have been to Paris three times in my life.”
present
I have been to Paris three times
in my life
past future
tree times
246
CHAPTER 7
Photo 1
Photo 2
Photo 3
247
CHAPTER 7
If students have difficulty stressing a word, you can also use the
rods to mark stress. Photo 3 shows the stress pattern for the word “PAris.”
Photo 4
Also, as you can see in picture 4, you can use the rods to mark
stressed and unstressed syllables in a sentence thus marking its rhythm,
e.g. “SHE has NEVER BEEN to FRANCE.”
Additionally, you can create situations with the rods and thus help
learners discover the meaning of new language. Each rod can stand
for a person in the situation and, since they can be moved around, you
can develop a context for students to notice the new language in a
non-written way.
Rods are a flexible tool that can help you highlight use, meaning
and form of grammar and pronunciation. They engage students
because of their color as well as the chance to manipulate them. Thus,
they are a wonderful and economical teaching resource.
248
CHAPTER 7
249
CHAPTER 7
250
CHAPTER 7
Types of drills
251
CHAPTER 7
CONCLUSION
In this chapter we have analyzed the three main systems that make
up the resource we call language. We concluded that phonology, lexis
and syntax can be taught inductively or deductively and proposed a
framework for their teaching that starts by providing students with rich
and varied input of real language in use. This input is used for students
to notice features of the target language so as to raise their awareness
of how they can best enhance their expression in the foreign language.
Hence, phonology, lexis and syntax are best taught through rich contexts
that make their use, meaning and form salient for students. We can the
conclude that, without knowing why people use a particular item in a
specific situation, students will be unable to make sense of language.
CHAPTER WRAP UP
What is the most important What lingering questions What steps will you take
learning you have derived about teaching the language to find answers to these
from this chapter? systems do you still have? questions?
252
CHAPTER 7
Observation task
Arrange with your cooperating teacher or a colleague to observe a lesson where the language
systems are being taught. During that lesson pay attention to how the instructor teaches lexis,
grammar and phonology. Note down techniques, materials and procedures used for teaching
these systems.
Reflect on how closely the principles discussed in this chapter were taken into account in the
teaching of this lesson.
Portfolio task
1) Design a lesson in which you typically teach language to your students.Arrange to have the
class videotaped or observed by a more experienced peer/ cooperating teacher. Make sure
you follow the guidelines and frameworks that are given in the chapter for the teaching of the
language systems.
2) At the end of the lesson ask your students these questions and have them write their answers
and give them back to you:
• What did you learn today that you did not know?
• What did you do today that you already knew?
• What can you do in English now that you could not do before this lesson?
• What did the teacher do that helped you learn?
• What did the teacher do that prevented you from learning?
• How do you compare this lesson to other English lessons?
253
CHAPTER 7
Candidates games
Prepare a list of four or five fictitious characters together with a description for each of them. Include
for each: age, occupation, hobbies, personality, likes/dislikes, etc. Make them as different as possible.
Then set up a situation where students would need help accomplishing something and have them
match the right person to the need.
bingo
Prepare a bingo boards with words showing differences in one sound (e.g. ship - sheep). Give out
one bingo boards to each student. Start saying sentences using the words. Students cross out the
words on their board. If they get three in a row, they must shout BINGO! Then they come to the
front and say sentences with the rest of the words on their board. You can also use these boards to
practice grammar and vocabulary.
tic-tac-toe
Draw a three-by-three squares board and fill it with verb forms (infinitive, past form, and past
participle). Students take turns selecting a verb and saying a correct sentence with it. If their sentence
is correct, they can claim the square. Play until someone gets Tic-Tac-Toe. This game can be adapted
for phonology and vocabulary.
Fill in the....
To practice vocabulary sets, put students in pairs and give each pair a dice. Students label themselves
‘A’ and ‘B’. ‘A’ students must try to roll only odd numbers, ‘B’ students must try to roll even numbers.
The task is to fill in something (e.g. a fridge). Students roll the dice and when they roll a suitable
number they must name an item to go in the fridge and write it to show their score. Use this game for
clothes, stores, items of furniture, positive/negative adjectives, etc.
254
8.
X.
CHAPTER
DEVELOPING
XXXXXXX
LITERACY SKILLS
Xxxxx
learning
learningabout: about:
• • reading, writing and
classroom
other literacy practices
management
• in the twenty-first
learning communities
• century.
teachers’ roles
• • schemata and schema
teachers’ use of L2 in
theory.
class
• top-down and bottom-
up processing.
learning how to:
• • genres and registers.
develop and value a
learning community
• plan lessons to cater
for different energy
levels and attention
learning how to:
• design effective
spans
The development of writing marked an important signpost in human • reading and writing
use the white or
evolution. It is with writing that history began to be recorded and has been sequences.
blackboard
• • develop students’
use the classroom
made accessible to us. However, the original purpose for the creation of
language through
seating arrangements
written records was not educational, but mostly commercial. Writing was reading and writing.
to optimize learning.
the product of agrarian societies that had abandoned their migrant hunter- • respond to students’
gatherer traditions and opted out to develop settlements where they could writing.
plant and harvest food and live in the company of other individuals. It was • assess reading and
writing.
the need to keep a record of their animals, and measures of grain or parcels
of land that prompted the development of writing as a form of record
keeping. There are as many systems of writing as there are languages in
the world. This is because, with time, writing became a practice strongly
tied to the cultural contexts and purposes for which texts were created.
Because of these facts, reading and writing practices vary across the world
and language teachers need to pay attention to those variations when
helping students understand or express themselves through the written
word.
255255
THE CHAPTER AT A GLANCE
Developing
reading writing
Literacy Skills
What issues about reading and/or writing have you heard your
colleagues or cooperating teacher discuss? Why are they important/
relevant?
256
CHAPTER 8
STARTING OUT
Teachers say…
Students say…
257
CHAPTER 8
LITERACY
In foreign language education the written word has been long used
and abused. For most of the twentieth century, the notion of Literacy
revolved around the ability to express oneself through writing, which
implied the ability to read as well. It was not until the emergence of
the Communicative Approach that reading and writing ceased to be
alternative ways to practice grammar and were recognized as skills in
their own right.
Nowadays, with the influx of technologies and the phenomenon
of globalization, literacy has come to mean more than being able to
read and write. Other forms of literacy have become important, such
as information literacy (the ability to select information that is relevant
by knowing how to search, tag, filter, and critically evaluate information
258
CHAPTER 8
259
CHAPTER 8
in real life, skills are actually integrated (see Chapter 9 for more on
integrated skills). This means that in everyday communication various
skills are put at play simultaneously, or sequentially, so that the
individuals interacting can achieve particular communicative goals.
For example, we may be in class, listening to the teacher and
taking notes (that would be listening comprehension) and at the same
time we may be writing comments to our notes (that would be writing)
and perhaps asking the professor or a colleague for clarification (this
would be speaking and listening). Hence, we must understand that the
separation of skills into individual units is done solely for the purpose
of improving your understanding of how they evolve and can be
developed.
260
CHAPTER 8
Think back to the times when you were learning how to write in a foreign/second language. How did
your teachers teach you to write? What were some of the typical activities you did? Did you write in class
or for homework? How would you describe your experience learning how to write in that language?
261
CHAPTER 8
262
CHAPTER 8
to the social situation for which the text is being created); interpersonal
meaning (related to the social relationship of the people who are involved
in negotiating meaning); and textual meaning (related to the spatial or
temporal distance between the people using the language). A second
layer of language is comprised of words and structures, also called
lexicogrammar. It is through this lexicogrammar that the three kinds of
meaning above are coded for communication, imbuing language of its
creative power and complexity. The last layer of language - that makes
the second layer concrete so that it can be perceived in the physical
world - is that of phonology and/or graphology. Sounds and letters
allow us to express the meanings we are negotiating as either speech
or writing through a limited set of symbols or sounds that are mutually
comprehensible to the participants in the communication situation.
By placing interaction at the front and center of the process of
communication, and by categorizing communicative events according
to the texts (oral or written) used by participants in order to create
meaning, this systemic-functional view of language opens up the
possibility of attending to language in use in real contexts. In this sense,
it is particularly suited to the development of writing skills as it allows
you to attend to both process and product while engaging learners in
understanding and producing different genres.
To review some of these ideas that we saw in previous chapters, in
the immediate social context, we can say that language is characterized
by a particular register that is the product of the combination of three
variables. First, there is the field, or the actual social situation that
will determine what kind of text is needed. Then, there is the tenor
that makes reference to the proximity or distance in status between
those who communicate. Finally, there is the mode, which refers to the
temporal or spatial distance between people communicating. Hence,
specific activations of the different language layers are characteristic
of particular situations and the people interacting in them. There is one
register that is adequate for communications in business and another
one, which is adequate for communication in the home, for example.
We said above that the social context shapes the language and that
at the same time the social context is shaped by the people engaged
in communication. In the broader cultural context, we can recognize
263
CHAPTER 8
patterns and structures in the texts that have been put in place in order
to achieve particular purposes. These patterns that characterize the
cultural and social function of texts are called genres.
The following table (adapted from Gibbons, 2002), summarizes
the main genres typically explored in schools, together with their
characteristics:
Discussion (one
Procedure
Recount Narrative Report side) Argument
(How to upload
(What I did at (“The tortoise (Life cycle of a (Two sided)
Type of text a video to the
the weekend) and the hare”) plant) Should smoking
Internet)
be made
illegal?
To persuade
To tell what To entertain, to To give To tell how to others, to take
Purpose
happened teach information do something a position and
justify it
Personal state-
ment of position
Orientation General
Orientation (tell Argument(s)
(tells who, statement
who, where, and supporting
where, when) Characteristics Goal
when) evidence
Organization Series of events (parts, Steps in
Series of events. Possible coun-
Personal processes, etc.) sequence
Problem terarguments
comment/ May have
Resolution and supporting
conclusion subheadings
evidence
Conclusion
Table 8.1 – Most frequent school genres. (Adapted from Gibbons, 2002).
264
CHAPTER 8
The table on the previous page shows how the various genres are
realized through different registers and how these, in turn are made
possible through the three layers of language. By using this framework,
it is possible for the teacher to help students develop their writing skills
while focusing on the process without losing sight of the product. Initial
applications of a particular framework for implementing text-based
skills instruction seem to indicate that students become stronger users
of more realistic language than when taught via the product approach
or the process approach alone.
This approach was popular over half a century ago, but it is still
used in many examination preparation courses, as well as in many
contemporary language-teaching textbooks. The main concern of this
approach is with the product (an essay, a report, a narrative) but little
attention was paid to the actual composing process. Instead teachers
tended to focus on whether students were able to meet the requirements
of certain rhetorical styles, using accurate grammar and vocabulary
and organizing their texts in accordance with the requirements of the
particular text type.
In general, teachers followed two bottom-up parallel processes
to reach the final product. A bottom-up approach focuses on accuracy
through analysis and/or practice of discrete components of language
(grammar, vocabulary, spelling, correct use of connectors, etc.). The
center of the class was a model text, which students were supposed
to imitate. In order to facilitate that imitation, teachers would create
a motivating skills activity to elicit ideas and at the same time, look
for clues about deficits in students’ language production. This was
followed by an analysis of the grammar, vocabulary and organizational
characteristic of the model text and, in parallel by the provision of
exercises aimed at reinforcing students’ command of those features.
The final stage would involve students in writing the text on their
265
CHAPTER 8
own. This writing was little more than a written substitution drill. For
example, if the model text were a letter of complaint, students would
have received a text that read:
266
CHAPTER 8
Publishing
Editing
Redrafting
Conferencing
Drafting
Figure 8.2 – The process
Prewriting approach to teaching writing
267
CHAPTER 8
268
CHAPTER 8
the use of the language. The editing stage may involve students
in further rewrites and feedback conferences as they prepare to
make their text public.
• The final stage of the process is publishing. Here the teacher
becomes the student’s audience and will provide corrective
feedback on both language and meaning, as well as provide
learners with an assessment of the effectiveness of their text.
269
CHAPTER 8
Stage 1: Building the Field. In this stage the aim is to make sure
that your students have enough background knowledge of the topic
to be able to write about it. The focus here is primarily on the content
or information of the text. At this stage, students are a long way from
writing a text themselves, and activities will involve speaking, listening,
reading, information gathering, note taking, and reading.
Stage 2: Modeling the text type. In this stage the aim is for students
to become familiar with the purpose, overall structure, and linguistic
features of the type of text they are going to write. The focus here is
therefore on the form and function of the particular text type that the
students are going to write.
Stage 5: Linking related texts. Here students search for and work
on understanding or crafting other texts within the genre.
270
CHAPTER 8
building Modeling
the field the text type
independent
writing
WHO A researcher
WHAT discovered a new definition for a technical term
WHERE in a little-referenced paper
WHEN written in 1976
HOW by using Discourse Analysis as a research method
WHY because he believed the popular definition was wrong
271
CHAPTER 8
• Use tasks that require students to fill a gap (information gap, opinion gap or reasoning gap). For
example, you can ask students to “Find ‘x’ differences between two pictures.”
• Get the students to interview students in other classes about their knowledge of the topic at
hand. Alternatively, invite an “expert” to class and help students prepare questions to ask that
person about the topic. Also, make sure to provide support for note taking by providing graphic
organizers such as T-lists, Venn diagrams, etc.
• Build up an information grid on a piece of construction paper and display it in the classroom. As
students contribute or discover different pieces of information, enter these in the grid. Categories
in the grid could include: text type, purpose of the text, participants, organization, cohesive
devices, key vocabulary, key language, etc.
• Use the topic to practice or introduce language structures that are characteristic of the text
type or the topic. For example, introduce different ways of talking about the past to teach how
narratives are structured. Make sure you keep the focus on form grounded in actual language use.
272
CHAPTER 8
• Use a running dictation as a way of providing a model text. The running dictation is a fun activity
that helps students integrate important macroskills while collectively working towards building a
model text. The procedure is a follows:
- The teacher displays the model text prominently in a place far from where the students currently
are (e.g. you can put the text on the wall outside the classroom, or on the back wall.
- Students work in groups. They take turns running to the spot where the text is displayed,
memorizing chunks of it, and returning to their groups to dictate the text.
- It is important that you give clear rules and make sure these are respected at all times or else
the activity can become chaotic. Here are the rules: students must individually go to the text and
memorize as much of it as possible. They then come back to their groups where they first write
what they remember and only then do they dictate it to their peers. Once all their peers have
taken the dictation, another student leaves the group and does the same.
- Once all groups have finished, the teacher distributes or displays the original version of the text
for students to compare and contrast with their own.
- Note that running dictation texts need not be extremely long. In general, a paragraph or two
should suffice.
• Use cloze activities to help students access the model. Cloze procedures are reading techniques in
which certain words in a text are deleted for students to complete while reading the text. Originally
intended as a test of reading comprehension, cloze procedures have taken many different forms:
- Regular cloze: the rule for creating a regular cloze test is to delete every 7th (or 11th) word. If
the word to be deleted is a proper noun or a word with heavy content (i.e. the word cannot be
deduced from the context) then you may skip to the next word.
- Selective cloze: here the teacher selects which words or grammatical features to delete.
- Vanishing cloze: the teacher writes a short text on the board. Student read the text out loud.
Then, the teacher asks students to close their eyes, and s/he erases one word. Students open
their eyes and attempt to read the text including the missing word. The procedure is repeated
(with the teacher erasing one or more words at a time) until all the text has been erased. Students,
working individually, attempt to reconstruct the text. The compare their version with those of their
peers and agree on a final version. Finally, the teacher displays the complete text for students to
compare to their own version.
- Total cloze: this is another class activity in which the teacher provides only the title of the text,
followed by a series of blanks (each blank representing a word). Students suggest words that can
go in the blanks and the teacher writes the correct ones in the right space. The activity becomes
progressively easier as the students help flesh out the text.
- Partial cloze: in this activity, the teacher provides students with a text but covers part of it. Students
have to work together to reconstruct the parts of the text that are missing. The teacher then
provides the complete text for students to compare. Here are some possibilities:
273
CHAPTER 8
274
CHAPTER 8
ASSESSING WRITING
275
CHAPTER 8
5 3 1
IDEAS This paper is clear The writer is beginning As yet, the paper
and focused. It holds to define the topic, even has no clear sense of
the reader’s attention. though development is purpose or central
Relevant details and still basic or general. theme. To extract
quotes enrich the central meaning from the
theme. text, the reader must
make inferences
based on sketchy or
missing details.
276
CHAPTER 8
5 3 1
WORD CHOICE Words convey the The language is The writer struggles
intended message in functional, even if it lacks with a limited
a precise, interesting, much energy. It is easy vocabulary, searching
and natural way. The to figure out the writer’s for words to convey
words are powerful and meaning on a general meaning.
engaging. level.
SENTENCE The writing has an The text hums along The reader has to
FLUENCY easy flow, rhythm, and with a steady beat, practice quite a
cadence. Sentences are but tends to be more bit in order to give
well built, with strong pleasant or businesslike this paper a fair
and varied structure that than musical, more interpretive reading.
invites expressive oral mechanical than fluid.
reading.
Table 8.2 – 6+1 Traits Rubric adapted from Utah Education Network.
277
CHAPTER 8
278
CHAPTER 8
279
CHAPTER 8
PROMOTE
• comprehension
• motivation
Figure 8.4 – A possible model • communication
of the reading process
a- Pre-Reading stage
All encounters between students and texts should start with a pre-
reading stage. The purpose of the pre-reading stage is to help learners
prepare to understand the text. Hence, it relies mostly on top-down
processing, as the emphasis will be on generating meaning. During this
stage you will guide learners by helping them activate their background
knowledge (specific knowledge about the topic and text type) and make
predictions about the text. We suggest that you follow the phases in this
stage in the specific order in which we present them. This will help you
make sure that students are suitably scaffolded in their approach to the text.
Our pre-reading stage starts with an exploration of students’
background knowledge about the text and its contents. Here you can
use a variety of activities, such as:
280
CHAPTER 8
281
CHAPTER 8
Would you favor reading aloud to develop reading skills? What was your experience as a student?
Do you agree with the following ideas?
b. While-reading stage
The second stage also has three phases, each concerned with
enhancing comprehension while developing interactive reading
strategies and skills. While the pre-reading stage favored mostly top-
down processing, the while-reading stage will foster mostly bottom-
up processing, thus allowing learners to apply their knowledge of the
language to the process of comprehension. Because students will have
direct access to the text, this particular stage will take longer than the
other two.
The first phase of the while-reading stage involves students in
working on vocabulary in context. Many published materials and also
some methodology books, recommend pre-teaching new vocabulary
prior to having students read the text. In our opinion, this does not lead
to productive vocabulary learning or even use. It makes more sense
to have students work out the meaning of new words in the context
in which they are used while providing them tools (such as learning
strategies) so they can activate that knowledge. Having said this, we
282
CHAPTER 8
Vocabulary Activities
• Asking students to find synonyms or antonyms in the text.
• Providing students with definitions of certain key words and asking them to locate those words in
the text.
• Multiple choice activities.
• “Cloze” activities where keywords are deleted from the text and students have to fill them in, if they
have encountered these words before.
• Word analysis activities such as working with literal and implied meaning of some key words or
substituting words in the text for phrases or expressions that have the same meaning.
283
CHAPTER 8
One framework that can help you organize questions is the taxonomy,
which we have already seen. In it, Bloom (1956) offered six levels of
cognitive complexity ranging from lower-order thinking (knowledge,
comprehension, and application) to higher-order thinking (analysis,
synthesis and evaluation). Later on, Krathwohl (2002) modified the
original taxonomy by distinguishing six levels, as well, but with certain
changes that reflect creativity. You can use the terms and prompts in
the taxonomy to create your own questions that progress from the
simplest to the most complex. This has a number of advantages. For
example, varying question types allows you to provide differentiated
opportunities for all students to participate. Also, when you build up
questions from the lower-order to the higher-order categories, you
are contributing to the development of students’ critical thinking.
Finally, varying questions using this taxonomy affords students various
opportunities to actually use the language, as they will be given the
chance not only to repeat, but also to defend, elaborate, question and
express their own opinions.
The following table summarizes the revised taxonomy and offers
key words and prompts that can help you formulate a multitude of
questions that target various thinking processes.
284
CHAPTER 8
285
CHAPTER 8
286
CHAPTER 8
Table 8.3 – Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy of the Cognitive Domain (adapted from Krathwol, 2002)
287
CHAPTER 8
c - Post-reading stage
The goal of the post-reading stage is to help students integrate
the new learning with what they already know. The phases in this stage
encourage students to organize their prior and current knowledge, and
put both to use.
The first phase within this stage engages students in an oral
summary of the text. The purpose of this phase is to recall new
information obtained through reading. You can use any new vocabulary,
textual feature or information from the text for this summary, in line
with the goals of the text you have selected. This summary can take
various forms, for example:
Summary Forms
• Ask learners to draw their favorite part of the text (character, plot point, piece of information,
moment in a story, etc.) and give reasons for their selection.
• Put students in groups and ask them to take turns saying what they remember about the text.
• Ask students to write one question about the text. Collect all questions and have students take
turns answering them.
• Ask each student to say something they remember about the text and then invite students to stand
up and organize themselves in the order in which these ideas are presented in the text.
• Play “20 questions.” Tell students you are thinking of a moment in or fact from the text and they
have to ask you Yes/No questions to discover what it is you are thinking. Get students to take your
place and continue the game.
• Play “Find the fib.” Say three statements about the text: two are false and one is true. Students
have to discover which one is true. The student who discovers the true statement takes your place.
288
CHAPTER 8
289
CHAPTER 8
ASSESSING READING
290
CHAPTER 8
CONCLUSION
ChAPTeR WRAP-uP
What is the most important What lingering questions What steps will you take
learning you have derived about teaching reading to find answers to these
from this chapter? and writing do you still have? questions?
291
CHAPTER 8
Observation task
Arrange to observe a reading or writing lesson taught by your cooperating teacher or a colleague.
While observing, complete the first two columns in this chart:
Teacher Students
Select three contemporary coursebooks targeting the same language level and:
• select a genre they teach (e.g. narratives, discursive essays, etc.).
• analyze the kind of approach to the development of reading and writing they advocate for.
• choose one of the sequences of reading and a writing tasks and provide concrete ways in
which it can be improved.
• share your work in your journal.
Portfolio task
1. Write the “literacy skills development platform” to be included in your portfolio. Explain:
• what the purposes of teaching writing to your students are.
• what approach/es and tasks you consider should be used and why.
• the impact that the use of those approaches and tasks may have on yourself, your students
and the course you are teaching.
2. Design a text-based sequence of tasks to teach a particular genre and teach it to your practice
group. Make sure to involve students in assessing your class.
3. Reflect about the advantages and disadvantages of using that approach with your learners.
292
PLuG IN 1: USING GRADED READERS
Graded readers are collections of books whose language has been adapted so that it is
comprehensible for students at different levels of proficiency. Most publishers offer these collections at
beginning, lower-intermediate, intermediate and higher-intermediate levels and incorporate both original
titles and adapted versions of literature classics.
These readers are an ideal bridge between reading skills development and motivation, as they usually
present high-interest topics (both fiction and nonfiction) at language appropriate levels that make reading
pleasurable. Because of this, they are an ideal resource for extensive reading programs. Extensive reading
is an alternative to the intensive format we have presented in this unit in that students select what they
want to read and do not have to perform tasks around the text. The benefits of extensive reading have
been documented in the research literature and include, among others, enhanced levels of vocabulary
development; better language monitoring skills; enhanced motivation to learn the language; and
greater independence in language use by students. Setups for extensive reading include D.E.A.R. (Drop
Everything And Read) time, where the teachers devotes a segment of the class to have students read in
silence, and Sustained Silent Reading, where for a fixed block of time, teachers and students engage in
silently reading texts of their choice.
Teachers may also choose to use readers intensively in class by choosing a book that all students will
read. In this scenario, it is advisable to devote specific blocks of time in the weekly schedule to work with
the reader in class. If the reader is to be used intensively, the three-step approach to the development of
reading skills we presented in this unit is advisable. Here are a few ideas for reading activities involving
graded readers:
PRe-ReADING IDeAS
Chapter headings
Give learners the chapter headings and suggest three or four possible titles for the book. They have
to decide which would make the most suitable title and explain why. Alternatively, you can provide the
chapter headings but not the possible titles, and ask students to name the book from what they can
infer. A further alternative is to provide a collection of information about the book (some illustrations,
chapter headings, information about the author, etc.) and have students come up with a possible title
giving reasons for their choice.
Sequencing before reading
Give learners the chapter titles in random order and ask them to suggest a possible order and explain
why they have arranged chapters that way. Alternatively, you may want to share illustrations taken from
different chapters, or even “documents” that may appear in the book (for example, for the graded
reader “Dracula” you may provide a copy of a blood test, a shopping list where “garlic” is underlined, a
train ticket, etc.) and have the students sequence them.
Cover story
Photocopy the cover of the book and create as many questions as possible about it. Learners work
in groups to answer the questions. As they progress through the book, they check their answers.
Alternatively, learners can give the picture a title, or compare versions of the cover from different
editions of the same book. You can also give students sentence stems such as “I like the way,” “I
think,…/ I think…/ I am happy…/etc.” and encourage learners to complete the unfinished sentences
with some of that information derived from the cover of the book while giving reasons for their choice.
293
WhILe-ReADING IDeAS
Whatever next
Read part of the chapter aloud (or play the accompanying audio if available) and stop occasionally. Ask
learners to predict what comes next as suggested in the DRTA Plug In below. Record predictions on the
board and check by reading on.
What was it about?
Ask learners to read a certain part of the book and then quickly summarize it orally. Alternatively, select
five key words from the section of the book students have just read and ask them to use those words to
write a 5-sentence paragraph summarizing the section.
Find the fib
Prepare a summary of the chapter learners have read and make sure to include some mistakes in it.
Learners read the chapter and, as they read along, try to correct the mistakes. You can extend this
activity by redacting the summary text so that there are missing parts that learners have to complete.
Personality poster
Learners produce a poster about one of the characters in the book using only pictures (no words).
Alternatively, they can use any of the poem formats in Plug In 3 to write a poem about a character.
Plot lines
Most stories follow the usual sequence of introduction-->conflict-->climax-->resolution. To make this
pattern evident to students, select key sentences from a chapter and ask learners to rank them from
the one which shows the greatest tension in the chapter to the least tense. They then create a graph to
depict the tension in the chapter.
Ordering puzzle
Give facts from the story in disorder and ask learners to order them as they read.
Dear Abby,
Have learners write a diary entry as if they were a certain character in the book or ask them to write a
letter asking for advice. Alternatively, they could write the letter or diary entry from the point of view of
a secondary character, an object an animal.
POST-ReADING IDeAS
Change one
Ask learners to decide on what they would change about the plot if they could change only one thing.
Have them retell the story taking that change into consideration.
Book metaphors
Ask learners to suggest different things that could represent this book (e.g. a song, a place, a work of
art, a smell, etc. Get them to explain why.
Reconstructing
Prepare a set of true sentences about different characters, facts and settings in the story. Give these
to learners in groups and ask them to match events, people and places. Once they have matched the
information, they can write a summary of the book or even a book review using it as notes.
294
PLuG IN 2: DIRECTED READING AND THINKING
ACTIVITIES (DRTA)
Directed Reading and Thinking Activities are reading tasks that encourage learners to be more
thoughtful readers by keeping them actively involved in questioning and/or responding to the text at hand,
thus targeting higher order thinking. These activities teach students how to monitor their understanding as
they are reading the text while strengthening their critical thinking skills.
Boundaries - the teacher Selective substitution - the teacher Prediction - the teacher se-
prepares a version of the text modifies some of the words in the lects stopping points within
that runs continuously and text so that students can change the text and inserts predic-
asks students to divide it into them. The teacher then shows the ori- tion questions for students
paragraphs addressing what ginal text and discusses with students to answer giving evidence
purpose each of the paragra- their choice of words. from what they have read
phs has. so far.
295
PLuG IN 3: CREATIVE WRITING: POEMS
Poems are a useful form of writing in that they afford students the possibility to become really creative
in generating ideas. In writing poems, students will be using metaphors to express their meaning clearly
and they will be connecting with language at an affective level.
While much poetry makes use of rhyme, the collection of poems we offer in this section, do not
explicitly require it. We have found that, while students may want to use rhyme, not requiring it make the
composing process easier. The poems below offer ample opportunities for language practice and true
expression and can be adapted to any topic at any level.
Types of poems
Acrostic Concrete poem
Take a word and write it vertically. Write a poem Choose an object, person, topic or issue. Brainstorm
in which each line starts with each of the letters. words associated with it. Write the words one after the
other creating the shape of the object, person or animal.
Alphabet poems
Choose a sequence of five letters from the alphabet Haiku
and write them vertically. Have students write a poem Haikus are three-line poems in which each line has a
about the topic of the class in which each line starts with different number of syllables.
one of the letters. They can write just one word per line Line 1 - 5 syllables
or write full sentences. Make it more fun by choosing Line 2 - 7 syllables
sequences of letters from the beginning, middle or end Line 3 - 5 syllables
of the alphabet.
Diamond poem
Cinquain Diamond poems are about a topic, person or issue and
A cinquain is a 5-line poem made up mostly of individual use increasing and decreasing number of words per line
words. to form the shape of a diamond
Line 1: Topic (always use a noun) 1 word Line 1 - Noun (subject) 1 word
Line 2: A description of the topic in 2 words (adjectives) Line 2 - 2 words that describe line 1
Line 3: Three ‘action” words (verbs) related to the topic Line 3 - 3 “ing” words that describe line 1
Line 4: Four ‘feeling’ words about the topic. Line 4 - 4 nouns (2 connected to line 1 and 2 connected
Line 5: A synonym for the word in line 1. to line 7)
Line 5 - 3 “ing” words that describe line 7
Sense poem
Line 6 - 2 words that describe line 7
Sense poems consist of six lines in which students
Line 7 - Noun (subject) from the same word family as
describe a person, topic or issue by comparing it to the
line 1
five senses
Line 1: Name the topic, person, issue (1 word) WH poem
Line 2: X looks like__ Students use the usual five Wh- questions words to write
Line 3: X sounds like__ a poem.
Line 4: X smells like__ Who?
Line 5: X tastes like__ What?
Line 6: X feels like__ When?
Where?
Bio poem
Why?
Students are given these instructions to write a poem
about themselves. Alternatively, they can write the poem Shadow poem
about a character they have studied in class. Take a well-known poem, and ask students to change
Your name some of the words in it. For example, instead of
Four words that describe you “Stopping by woods on a snowy evening” by Robert
One person you are related to Frost, students could change the poem to fit the title
Your favorite food “Stopping by the beach on a sunny morning.”
Something important to you
Your favorite color
296
X.
9.
CHAPTER
DEVELOPING
ORACY SKILLS
learning about:
• the necessary
classroom
management
knowledge and skills
• for students to master
learning communities
• speaking and listening.
teachers’ roles
• effective ways of
teachers’ use of L2 in
class
promoting interaction
in oral language
development.
learning how to:
• develop and value a
effective tasks and
learning community
activities for the
• plan lessons to cater
development of
for different energy
speaking and listening.
levels and attention
spans
An old man went to the doctor complaining that his wife could barely • use the white or
learning how to:
hear. The doctor suggested a test to find out the extent of the problem: • set up, monitor and
blackboard
• bring to a closure
use the classroom
“Stand far behind her and ask her a question, and then slowly move up and
interactive activities.
seating arrangements
see how far away you are when she first responds”. The old man, excited • implement pair and
to optimize learning.
to finally be working on a solution for the problem, runs home and sees group work.
his wife preparing supper. “Honey”, the man asks standing around 20 feet • balance process and
away, “What’s for supper?”. After receiving no response he tried it again 15 product in listening
and speaking.
feet away, and again no response. Then again at 10 feet away and again no
• assess listening and
response. Finally he was 5 feet away: speaking.
“Honey what’s for supper?”
She replies: “For the fourth time, it’s lasagna!”. 1
1 Great Clean Jokes (2013). Jokes of the day: Can you hear me? Retrieved from http://www.greatclean-
jokes.com/jokes/other-joke-types/funny-speech-openers/
297
THE CHAPTER AT A GLANCE
Developing
Speaking listening
Oracy Skills
What issues about listening and/or speaking have you heard your
colleagues/cooperating teacher discuss? Why are they important/
relevant?
298
CHAPTER 9
STARTING OUT
Teachers say…
Students say…
299
CHAPTER 9
• I can’t understand the English in the audio because they speak too
quickly.
• My pronunciation is always bad and my teacher constantly
interrupts when I am speaking in order to correct me.
ORACY
Listening and Speaking are Oracy skills since they rely heavily on
the use of verbal language. However, it should be noted that in oral
communication, meaning is also conveyed via non-verbal language
(paralinguistic features such as gestures, haptics, etc.). In order to
effectively use these skills, students need a thorough grounding not just
on language, but also on strategies that help them keep the conversation
going. Hence, the development of listening and speaking skills cannot
be taken for granted, since it requires extensive planning, monitoring
and feedback by the teacher.
Oral communication is, in general, a highly interactive process
involving two or more speakers who respond to one another in order
to exchange and negotiate meanings. Even on those occasions where
one speaker dominates communication (such as
in the case of presentations), that speaker will
modify his or her delivery based on the reaction
of the listeners. Therefore, we will approach the
development of listening and speaking skills from
the premise that one cannot develop properly in
the absence of the other.
The development of listening and speaking
skills has been the focus of much controversy
over the years. During Audiolingual times, these
skills were thought of as the two main skills that
300
CHAPTER 9
provided access to the language. In that sense, all lessons used to start
with the students listening to the teacher and then speaking. However,
the speaking taught in those times was mostly imitative consisting of
repetition drills, dialogs and memorized role-plays. We can say that
these classroom activities did not involve real communication. Even
today, most textbooks follow the same sequence in their introduction
of new language features and the techniques mentioned above are
quite ubiquitous.
Furthermore, the language contained in some popular textbooks
—which are the source for much of the L2 input students receive—
is selected, not necessarily for its communicative value, but for its
syntactic, semantic or phonological relevance to the pre-established
scope and sequence of the book. This causes dialogs and other texts
used for the presentation of new language, to sound constrained and
artificial. In this sense, these texts provide over simplified language
samples that are more characteristic of written language than oral
expression.
301
CHAPTER 9
For many years, the teaching of listening as a skill was taken for
granted and not really focused on. This fact has led some researchers
to claim that the history of the teaching of listening comprehension
is relatively recent (Field, 2012). In fact, prior to the advent of
comprehension-based approaches such as The Total Physical Response
or the Natural Approach, listening was conceived of as a mere means to
present new language, be it grammar or vocabulary, and not developed
as a skill in itself.
302
CHAPTER 9
• A pre-listening stage - during this stage the teacher would set the
scene by introducing the topic, pre-teaching key vocabulary and
organize activities oriented towards motivating students to listen
to the text. Texts were in general contrived in that they were not
generally authentic and were created in order to exemplify the use
of a particular language item.
• Extensive listening stage - this was the first listening of the text
by students and it was followed by the teacher asking general
303
CHAPTER 9
304
CHAPTER 9
305
CHAPTER 9
306
CHAPTER 9
MICROSKILLS
1. Retain chunks of language of different lengths in short-term memory.
2. Discriminate among the distinctive sounds of English.
3. Recognize English stress patterns, words in stressed positions,
rhythmic structure, intonational contours, and their role in signaling
information.
4. Recognize reduced forms of words.
5. Distinguish word boundaries, recognize a core of words, and interpret
word order patterns and their significance.
6. Process speech at different rates.
7. Process speech containing pauses, errors, corrections, and other
performance variables.
8. Recognize grammatical word classes (nouns, verbs, etc.), systems (e.g.
tense, agreement, pluralization), patterns, rules, and elliptical forms.
9. Detect sentence constituents and distinguish between major and
minor constituents.
10. Recognize that a particular meaning may be expressed in different
grammatical forms.
MACROSKILLS
1. Recognize cohesive devices in spoken discourse.
2. Recognize the communicative functions of utterances, according to
situations, participants, goals.
3. Infer situations, participants, goals, using real-world knowledge.
4. From events, ideas, etc., described, predict outcomes, infer links and
connections between events, deduce causes and effects, and detect
such relations as main idea, supporting idea, new information, given
information, generalization, and exemplification.
5. Distinguish between literal and implied meanings.
6. Use facial, kinesic, body language, and other nonverbal clues to
decipher meanings.
7. Develop and use a battery of listening strategies, such as detecting
key words, guessing the meaning of words from context, appealing
for help, and signaling comprehension or lack thereof.
307
CHAPTER 9
Pre-listening stage
To start with, teachers will select a suitable audio text for students’
level and the curriculum topic under discussion. The suitability of the
text will be determined not solely by the grammar it contains, but by
how closely it relates to the thematic content under discussion in class.
Also, while students will benefit from exposure to authentic audio texts,
teachers should bear in mind students’ level and assess whether the
text selected will pose additional hurdles to students on top of the
difficulties that oral language generally presents. Finally, in recent
times, there has been an emphasis on the use of video clips as texts for
listening comprehension, which we wholeheartedly adhere to as they
are more representative of real-life communication than an audiotext.
Thereof, the same advice we just outlined for the selection of audio
texts applies to the selection of videotexts.
During the pre-listening stage, the teacher will seek to activate
students’ schemata for them to be able to make connections between
their prior knowledge and the audio text theme, but also so that
they can be prepared to make predictions. Another important action
teachers have to take at this stage is to establish a purpose for listening.
To do so, they can resort to engaging students in making predictions.
Some activities that can be used at this stage are:
308
CHAPTER 9
While-listening stage
The pre-listening stage will be followed by a task or series of tasks that
require students to process the audiotext using both top-down and bottom-
up approaches. We should remember that one of the modes of listening
that needs to be developed is interactive (and not just reactive) listening.
Hence, during the while-listening stage, teachers will provide opportunities
for students to provide intermittent responses to the listening text.
These responses will vary according to the micro and macroskills
selected for focus in the particular listening lesson in question and may
include responding by:
309
CHAPTER 9
down processing will be given by the different tasks that you set around
the selected listening text.
Post-listening stage
The final stage engages learners in blending their prior knowledge
with the new information derived from the audiotext. In order to foster
more interaction, the teacher can engage students in extended speaking
tasks that use both the language and the content that were the focus
of the while-listening stage. Alternatively, the teacher may choose to
incorporate other skills at this stage, too. Some post-listening activities
may include:
PROMOTE
• comprehension
• motivation
Figure 9.1 – A possible model
• communication
of the listening process
310
CHAPTER 9
311
CHAPTER 9
312
CHAPTER 9
313
CHAPTER 9
314
CHAPTER 9
Knowledge of systems
In order to master speaking, students should possess a working
knowledge of phonology, lexicogrammar, as well as of the different
genres and sociocultural conventions of the target language. However
commonsensical as this may seem, the fact remains that other
developments in the field, such as the move towards validating the
different varieties of English as an International Language (EIL) bring
to bear interesting issues at the time of deciding which “norm” of these
systems to favor.
In terms of phonology, there has been consensus for quite some
time already, that the achievement of native-like pronunciation is
no longer the aim. The English as a Lingua Franca (ELF) movement
advocates for the teaching of those segmental features needed for
mutual intelligibility so comprehensibility, and not native-like mastery,
should be the goal. However, we should stress the need to develop
strong suprasegmental awareness and proficiency, as it is these
features of connected speech that generally impinge upon mutual
understanding more than the mispronunciation of individual sounds.
As far as knowledge of grammar is concerned, there have been calls
to also do away with what was generally known as “standard English” in
favor of a “conversational grammar” derived from corpora. This would
mean equipping students with an awareness of the characteristics of
spoken language such as the frequent use of clause-like chunks that
make language less complex, the existence of hesitations, false starts,
repeats, incomplete utterances and syntactic blends. Again, the aim has
shifted from a concern with native-like competence, to the promotion
of intelligible, fluent language.
In what respects lexis, McCarthy (cited in Thornbury, 2012)
advocates for the teaching of only high-frequency nouns, adjectives,
adverbs and verbs, together with discourse markers and deictic
expressions that allow cohesion and fluency in expression. This is
315
CHAPTER 9
proposed in the belief that students will be able to recombine these few
elements into longer stretches of oral language. In order to achieve this
aim, students should also be taught language for expressing attitude and
appraisal as well as fixed and semi-fixed multiword phrases also known
as formulaic language. These account for 60% of spoken English and
are a valuable resource for the development of fluency.
We saw in the previous chapter that language users dwell on the
preceding three systems simultaneously at the time of communicating
and that they do so through texts that are shaped by the sociocultural
environment in which they are created. In this sense, the knowledge
base of speaking should also include an awareness of a range of
discourse markers, connectives and speech events that characterize
these different genres, together with sociolinguistic and pragmatic
knowledge of how these contribute to expression.
While it makes a lot of sense to bear in mind the contributions
of the ELF movement (after all, most students will interact in English
with other non-native speakers) and we now have access to a thorough
corpus of oral language, the fact remains that most teachers will be
working from materials that still make reference to the systems of
standard English. Teachers can adapt these materials to include
elements of ELF that will best serve students.
Knowledge of skills
Douglas Brown (2007) explains that a conversation generally
consists of five basic moves. There is first of all a nomination of the
topic of the conversation. Next, speakers strive to keep the conversation
going by actively responding to what the other is saying (either
verbally or non-verbally). They take turns and interrupt one another
and eventually, they use socially established routines to terminate the
conversation.
In order to achieve this dynamic in real-time, students need to
learn and systematically apply a range of skills that would allow them
to master three main forms of speaking:
316
CHAPTER 9
317
CHAPTER 9
MICROSKILLS
1. Produce chunks of language of different length.
2. Orally produce differences among the English phonemes and
allophonic variants.
3. Produce English stress patterns, words in stressed and unstressed
positions, rhythmic structure and intonational contours.
4. Produce reduced forms of words and phrases.
318
CHAPTER 9
MACROSKILLS
1. Use cohesive devices in spoken discourse.
2. Accomplish appropriately communicative functions according to
situations, participants and goals.
3. Use appropriate registers, implicature, pragmatic conventions, and
other sociolinguistic features in face-to-face conversations.
4. Convey links and connections between events and communicate
such relations as main idea, supporting idea, new information, given
information, generalization, and exemplification.
5. Use facial features, kinesics, body language, and other nonverbal
clues along with verbal language to convey meaning.
6. Develop and use a battery of speaking strategies, such as emphasizing
key words, rephrasing, providing a context for interpreting the
meaning of words, appealing for help, and accurately assessing how
well your interlocutor is understanding you.
319
CHAPTER 9
320
CHAPTER 9
321
CHAPTER 9
information gap activities. All these allow students to gain control over
the target language and its particular needed for expressing particular
functions. The last tier of the model is the autonomous stage where
speakers engage independently in a range of different spoken genres.
Seen in the light of the bottom-up and top-down dichotomy
discussed in our previous chapter, we could say this is an example of
a bottom-up approach. It is also an example of the direct approach
referred to by Brown (2007).
Other approaches, such as the “fluency first approach” engage
learners in fluency activities, which “are not just a means of practicing
a skill, but are a platform for language acquisition itself ” (Thornbury,
2012, p. 202). One current example of a fluency first approach is Task
Based Learning. In this approach, the teacher sets the stage for students’
engagement in communication by first providing an orientation to the
task and the topic thus activating students’ background knowledge.
This is followed by a “task” stage, during which students solve a
task, plan how to report their findings to the rest of the class and finally
carry out the report. During this stage, the teacher monitors students’
work—generally done in pairs or groups—so as to gather information
about their language needs.
After all groups or pairs have reported, students are given the
chance to listen to an audio sample of fluent speakers performing
the same task. Here, their attention is drawn to the similarities and
differences between their own expression and that of the fluent
speakers’.
Next, the teacher intentionally and explicitly reviews or teaches
those language features needed to solve the task, keeping in mind how
these features are used in real life by fluent speakers. This will include
explicit presentation and practice of the language features needed.
322
CHAPTER 9
323
CHAPTER 9
324
CHAPTER 9
“the word ‘task’ has been used as a label for various activities
including grammar exercises, practice activities and role plays…
these are not tasks in the sense the word is used here… tasks are
always activities where the target language is used by the learner for
a communicative purpose (goal) in order to achieve an outcome.”
325
CHAPTER 9
Classroom Activities
Tasks Exercises
• Focus on meaning. • Focus on form.
• Concrete negotiated outcome. • Single, correct response.
• Language use. • Grammar practice.
• Students use any language at • Students use pre-specified lan-
their disposal. guage selected by the teacher.
• Emulate real-life communication. • Reinforce particular language
• Derived from a topic of interest or features.
relevance to students. • Derived from grammatical or
• Promote student interaction. functional syllabus contents.
326
CHAPTER 9
327
CHAPTER 9
328
CHAPTER 9
Sharing personal - Casual, social Students work together to share their own
experiences conversation experiences. These are recorded and similarities and/
or differences among the experiences are specified.
Creative tasks - Projects, creative Students work together through a series of tasks
writing, poetry, etc. in order to create a novel product (poem, poster,
model, presentation, etc.).
329
CHAPTER 9
330
CHAPTER 9
do so, remember that just verbal instructions are not always effective.
The best scenario involves learners in reading the instructions (from
the board or a handout), followed by the teacher asking students what
they have to do and then possibly demonstrating with a good student.
Another alternative could be to show students what previous students
have achieved in the same task. While this could be a rich source of
feedback, make sure that the nature of the task allows for this kind
of exemplification. For example, this strategy would not be useful if
students are working on a problem-solving task, as the example could
very well give out the answer.
Having ascertained students have understood what they are
expected to do, the teacher moves on to electing functionaries, that is,
generating the need for students to work together. Whenever students
are working in groups, it is advisable that each group member be
responsible for some aspect of the task. For example, one student
could become the “monitor” and make sure that every member of the
group participates (and does so in English); another student could be
the “recorder” in charge of taking down notes, drawing or recording
necessary information; another student could be appointed “time
keeper” in order to maximize students’ time on task; finally, groups
will need a “reporter” who will share the outcome of the task with the
rest of the class.
Once everyone knows what they have to do, the teacher should
set out the rules for the task. These may include the requirement for
“English only” while doing the task, a pre-specified time limit and the
nature of the desired outcome (will students read something they wrote
or present and explain a drawing to the class?). This is also the time
to remind students of potentially beneficial language they can use in
order to keep the conversation going (e.g. expressions for agreeing and
disagreeing, for making suggestions, etc.). Lastly, the teacher should
make explicit how and when the report is going to take place.
331
CHAPTER 9
d. Providing feedback
The provision of feedback is another important consideration to
bear in mind, as it adds to the potential success (or failure) of the task
at hand. Once students have completed the task and have reported
on its outcome, it is the teacher’s time to provide feedback. This
feedback should be all encompassing and focus not just on the product
(e.g. Did the students achieve the expected outcome?) but also on the
process and the language used. In what respects the process, given
that students had specific roles to perform while also working on the
task, it is important to check that the roles were performed adequately.
As a rule, the teacher should encourage self- and peer-assessment of
student performance in their role. This need not be too complicated. A
few simple questions such as “Did the monitor engage all participants?”
or “Did he request that participants speak English only?” should suffice.
However, the questions in themselves are not enough. They should
also be followed by some sort of target setting for the next time that
students work in groups. You can do this by asking students how they
can improve their performance in the different roles the next time they
332
CHAPTER 9
work in groups. Because roles will rotate each time that students work
in groups, this kind of assessment is intended to provide everyone with
concrete ideas on how to enhance their participations.
Finally, having listened to each group’s report, the teacher can
show students an example of fluent speakers performing the same
task. Even though this looks difficult in some situations, it need not be
so. The teacher can write or transcribe an example or, if technology is
available, play an audio or video recording of former students doing the
same task fluently. This model is an optimal opportunity for students
to do self-assessment of their performance, as well as a chance for the
teacher to point out areas for development.
One last issue to discuss is when the teacher can actually correct
students’ performance. A rule of thumb in the profession is that teachers
should refrain from interrupting students with corrections whenever
they are communicating. The teacher should wait until students have
finished communicating the outcomes of their task and she has actually
ascertained those areas of language that need particular work on in
order to provide corrective feedback. In this respect, having listened
to the students’ private and public language use, the teacher will get
a good idea of those areas of language that require further work. She
will then organize activities to present or review particular language
areas, while offering extensive practice opportunities, as well. Ideally,
this last stage should be followed by the students engaging in a similar
task where they can activate the new language learned, or by providing
the students with the same task but mixing the groups so that students
work with new classmates this time.
As we have said before, success in the development of the
speaking skill is a complex matter. It requires motivation (provided by
the topic or the task), careful preparation (task design and sequencing
by the teacher), student involvement (provided by skillful management)
and opportunities for students to notice how they are progressing (for
more on effective, corrective feedback see Chapter 12). When all these
areas converge, success in speaking development is more attainable.
333
CHAPTER 9
ASSESSING SPEAKING
334
CHAPTER 9
335
CHAPTER 9
CONCLUSION
Oracy skills have long been taken for granted in English language
teaching, since most classroom activity is dependent on speaking and
listening. However, as we have seen, specific measures must be taken
in order to provide students with suitable strategies and knowledge so
that they can communicate freely and efficiently.
As was the case with reading and writing, students need instruction
in both the different language systems and a repertoire of strategies to
help them put this knowledge into action. This requires a careful selection
of tasks and topics that foster the use of both. In order to achieve
the aim of successful communication, teachers need to carefully plan,
monitor and assess students’ evolving mastery of oracy skills. More
importantly, the teacher’s instructional design should provide students
with enough opportunities to put their evolving mastery at play with
the teacher acting mostly as a manager and feedback provider. In this
respect, the evolution of the oracy skills will follow an upward spiral
movement if and when an interactive approach to skills development
is implemented. This requires the constant interplay of both bottom-up
and top-down approaches, a focus on both systems and strategies, and
enough opportunities for students to engage in real-life communication.
ChAPter WrAP-UP
336
CHAPTER 9
Observation task
Arrange to observe a class where the teacher is developing both speaking and listening skills.
While observing, complete the first column in the chart. After the lesson, go over the chapter
once again and find connections between the teacher’s actions and the theory and note them
down. Finally, complete the third column of the chart with your own recommendations to improve
this lesson.
TASK
• Select three contemporary course books targeting the same language level and:
- select the speaking section of a unit in each
- analyze the kind of approach to the development of listening and speaking they advocate for
- choose one of the sequences of listening or speaking tasks in one of the three textbooks
and provide concrete ways in which it can be improved
- share your work with a peer through journal exchange
Portfolio task
1. Write the “oracy skills development platform” to be included in your portfolio. Explain:
• what the purposes of teaching listening and speaking to your students are
• what approach/es and tasks you consider should be used and why
• the impact that the use of those approaches and tasks may have on yourself, your students
and the course you are teaching
2. Design a sequence of oral tasks and teach it to your practice group. Make sure to involve
students in assessing your class.
3. Reflect about the advantages and disadvantages of using tasks for oral language development
with your learners.
337
PLUG IN 1: STORYTELLING
why use stories in the classroom? becoming a storyteller
338
PLUG IN 2: COOPERATIVE LEARNING
Cooperative learning is a framework for classroom interaction based on the creation,
analysis, and systematic application of structures or content-free ways of organizing social
interaction in the classroom.
An important cornerstone of the approach is the distinction between “structures” and
“activities.” To illustrate, teachers can design many excellent cooperative activities, such as
making a team mural or a quilt. Such activities almost always have a specific content-bound
objective and, thus, cannot be used to deliver a range of academic content. In contrast,
structures may be used repeatedly with almost any subject matter, at a wide range of grade
levels, and at various points in a lesson plan.
The structural approach to cooperative learning was first introduced by Spencer and Miguel
Kagan and their colleagues. Kagan and Kagan (1994) describe four principles which are key to
their structural approach:
1. Simultaneous interaction
2. Equal participation
3. Positive interdependence
4. Individual accountability
Another approach to cooperative learning that may shed light into its nature is Neil
Davidson’s. His definition shows the diversity that exists among views of cooperative learning.
However, most authors agree that, at least, it should incorporate:
While most experts on cooperative learning would agree on these first four points, others
would include some or all of the following points:
5. Heterogeneous grouping;
6. Explicit teaching of collaborative skills;
7. Structured mutual interdependence.
In short, one could say that truly cooperative structures are based on four core principles:
• Positive interdependence occurs when gains of individuals or teams are positively
correlated. If a gain for one student is associated with gains for other students, the
individuals are positively interdependent.
• Individual accountability can take different forms, depending on the content of
the cooperative learning model. This principle refers to the fact that even though
interdependent, each group member’s contribution is vital to the success of the group.
• Equal participation is an integral part of the learning process since students learn by
interacting with the content and with fellow students. Hence, everyone in the group
should have the chance to participate and contribute to the group’s process.
• Simultaneous interaction is one more essential component of cooperative learning.
When all students are involved in the same task at the same time, their chances of
interaction are maximized and thus they have more learning opportunities.
339
Some Cooperative Learning Structures
The following are some frequently used cooperative structures. These can be adapted to any grade,
proficiency level or content.
Roundrobin. Students work in groups of 4 to 6. Each student in turn shares some kind of information
with his or her teammates.
Corners. Each student moves to a corner of the room representing a teacher-determined alternative.
Students discuss within corners, then listen to and paraphrase ideas from other corners.
Paraphrase Passport Students correctly paraphrase the ideas of the person who has just spoken and
then contribute their own ideas.
Discussion tokens. Each student is given four tickets (or four votes) and must make a decision about
what to “spend” them on or use them for in a particular situation. The team tallies the results to
determine its decision.
Group Processing. Students evaluate their ability to work together as a group and each member’s
participation, with an aim to improve how the group works together.
Numbered Heads Together. Students work in groups of 4 to 6. Each student in the group receives a
number. The teacher asks a question; students consult to make sure everyone knows the answer. The
teacher calls out a number and only the students with that number can raise their hand to answer the
question.
Send-a-Problem. Each student writes a review problem on a flash card and asks teammates to answer
or solve it. Review questions are passed to another group.
Cooperative Review. Students engage in a variety of games to review the week’s material.
Three-Step Interview. Students work in groups of 4. Students interview each other in pairs, first one
way, then the other. Students share with the group information they learned in the interview.
Group Discussion. The teacher asks a low-consensus question. Students talk it over in groups and
share their ideas.
Roundtable. Students pass a paper and pencil around the group. The paper may contain several
choices for ways of doing something (e.g., different research strategies). Each student in turn writes his
name by his preferred strategy. Teams then agree on which strategies to use.
Partners. Students work in pairs to create or master content. They consult with partners from other
teams. They then share their products or understanding with the other partner pair in their team.
Co-Op Co-Op. Students work in groups to produce a particular group product to share with the whole
class; each student makes a particular contribution to the group.
Group Investigation. Students identify a topic and organize into research groups to plan learning
tasks or sub-topics for investigation. Individual students gather and evaluate data and synthesize
findings in a group report.
340
PLUG IN 3: SONGS
why use songs in language teaching?
• Music is one of the basic expressions of the human spirit, and it has become an important part of
foreign language teaching.
• Learners are encouraged to express their feelings, emotions, ideas, images and thoughts.
• Songs provide a fun and relaxing break from the usual routine of classroom activity.
• Songs provide optimal language practice, as they are both a pleasant relaxation after intensive
language work and provide great ways of working on rhythm, stress and pronunciation in general.
• They provide instant motivation for most learners.
• Songs reflect a variety of interests and cultures.
• Singing generates enthusiasm and helps convey the culture and values of the country where the
song was composed.
• Songs provide memorable and long-lasting practice opportunities as students will go on singing the
song outside the classroom.
341
CHAPTER 9
Preparation of students for listening / viewing • Understanding: compare, contrast with other
• Supply essential cultural information. cultures.
• Review/introduce essential vocabulary/structures. • Integration: justify, explain, imitate in role-plays.
• Preview (overviews of contents and C. Script-oriented tasks
characteristics). • Find examples of redundancy.
• Motivate/ arouse interest. • Underline certain structures/vocabulary items.
• Always provide pre-listening or pre-viewing. • Identify words/phrases used to express emotion,
tasks (brainstorming, guessing from clues, etc.). to persuade, etc.
• Read aloud portions of the script.
Listening / viewing tasks
• Rewrite portions of the script.
A. Skills-oriented tasks • Cross out extra words in “doctored” version of
• Comprehension (listening, reading): yes/no the script.
questions, true-false, multiple choice, physical • Fill-in words omitted from script.
response, checklists, fill-ins.
• Comprehension plus production: open- Expansion activities
ended questions, role-play, brainstorming, • Play games and puzzles based on the plot.
debate, discussions, note-taking, summaries, • Build or make something that appears in the
continuations. video.
B. Culture-oriented tasks • Read related material.
• Awareness: notice, identify similarities and • Learn songs or dance sequence from the video
differences between the foreign culture and and perform them.
one’s own. • Create own audio or video broadcast.
342
X.
10.
CHAPTER
INTEGRATING
XXXXXXX
LANGUAGE SKILLS
Xxxxx
learning
learning about:
about:
• •
communicative
classroom
Competence.
management
• •
“forced” vs “natural”
learning communities
skills integration.
• teachers’ roles
• •
approaches that help
teachers’ use of L2 in
integrate skills.
class
343343
THE CHAPTER AT A GLANCE
DogMe t.b.l.
What issues about skills integration have you heard your colleagues/
cooperating teacher discuss? Why are they important/relevant?
344
CHAPTER 10
STARTING OUT
Teachers say…
Students say…
345
CHAPTER 10
346
CHAPTER 10
347
CHAPTER 10
348
CHAPTER 10
PRINCIPLED INTEGRATION
As you read the situation, make a note of the skills being used
Imagine the following situation:
You are attending a language teaching conference. You get to the conference site and receive a
program, which you read in order to decide which presentation to attend. You arrive in the room,
see the presentation, take notes and, at one point, take out your cellphone and tweet a quotation
that impressed you. After the talk is over you approach the presenter and ask questions. You go
back home and write a summary of the presentation in your blog. You also search for material by the
presenter online and incorporate some of his/her ideas into your teaching.
349
CHAPTER 10
350
CHAPTER 10
Task-based learning
The most frequently cited approach that promotes naturalistic
language use is Task-based Learning (TBL). Developed first in India by
Prabhu, and extended in its application through the work of Willis (1996),
Nunan (2004), Ellis (2008), and Long (2015), this approach focuses on
engaging students in solving tasks that imitate what they will have to
deal with outside the classroom in order to promote language learning.
A task is any language learning activity in which students use
language in order to achieve a concrete, communicative outcome.
Examples of tasks are: listing; comparing & contrasting; prioritizing;
classifying; categorizing; doing a project; or problem-solving. Tasks
present students with a gap they need to bridge by using the language.
The gap can be related to information (some students have information
that other do not and they work together in order to share what is
needed to complete the task), reasoning (students work together in
order to solve a real or imaginary problem) or opinion (students share
personal experiences in order to exchange opinions about a topic).
While each of the authors mentioned above specifies a particular
way of doing task-based learning, the most popular model is the
framework developed by Jane Willis (1996). Borrowing the idea of
flowcharts to exemplify teaching procedures from the work of Wright
and Rebuffet-Broadus (2013) we will now present a diagram that
makes explicit how a typical task-based sequence can be enacted in
351
CHAPTER 10
the classroom. While you follow the sequence pay attention to how
different skills are introduced and implemented.
As you read, make a note of the skills being used and consider how they are being integrated. Can
you think of a similar adaptation you can make to one of the last classes you have taught or seen?
1. Pre-class preparation:
2. T designs a sequence 3. T opens lesson by briefly
T chooses a topic that is
of tasks that would allow introducing the topic,
interesting and/or relevant to
students to communicate potentially presenting key
students. T analyzes the topic
about the topic, while new vocabulary and asking
in terms of what communicative
also integrating the four students to tell what they
functions students would need
macroskills. know about the topic.
to develop.
11. T rounds off the lesson by involving students in self- 10. Ss finish this second task
evaluating what they have achieved in this lesson and by and are given time to plan how
asking them to set goals in order to improve their current level they are going to report it to
of expression. Homework that extend the language and the the rest of the class.
topic is assigned.
352
CHAPTER 10
353
CHAPTER 10
As you read, make a note of the skills being used and consider how they are being integrated. Can
you think of a similar adaptation you can make to one of the last classes you have taught or seen?
354
CHAPTER 10
355
CHAPTER 10
356
CHAPTER 10
As you read, make a note of the skills being used and consider how they are being integrated. Can you
think of a similar adaptation you can make to one of the last classes you have taught or seen?
357
CHAPTER 10
2. T opens lesson by
3. T. elicits information and
1. Pre-class preparation: explaining aims and
ideas from students while
T chooses theme/content, introducing theme/content to
noticing the language, which
and analyzes it in terms students (using visuals, charts,
arises out of that interaction.
of content obligatory and tables, figures, etc.). T. activates
The teacher will use the
content compatible language students’ schemata by having
content obligatory and
and finds suitable materials. them discuss what they know
compatible analysis
about the theme/content.
11. T rounds off the lesson by: recycling vocabulary; 10. Ss, in groups, design something
asking students to reflect on what they have learned; using the new information (e.g.
asking students to write “can do” statements in their poster; magazine article; powerpoint
notebooks, etc. Homework is given to encourage further presentation, etc.) and present it to
investigation. the rest of the class.
358
CHAPTER 10
In dealing with the various concepts that make up the core of the
theme or topic, students will be engaged in a series of tasks that engage
them in negotiating meaning as well as co-constructing knowledge
among themselves and with the teacher.
Notice that in this sense, the learning of the content manages to
bring together essential features of both TBL and TBT. The scaffolding
role of the teacher is present not only in the selection of the language,
but also in the selection or design and sequencing of the tasks that will
result in the students’ mastering both the content and the language.
Dogme
Dogme is a philosophy of teaching, which seeks to promote
interactivity between teachers and learners as co-constructors
of knowledge, by engaging learners in student-centered learning
experiences from which language is supposed to emerge. Dogme
was developed originally by Scott Thornbury who, in 2001 made a
call to simplify the way we teach English and focus on how language
is supposed to evolve. The inspiration for Dogme came from the
work of cinema director Lars von Trier and his movement to make
filmmaking more authentic. Dogme, as a teaching approach, stemmed
from Thornbury’s fruitful collaboration with Luke Meddings. Dogme
has had a great impact in ELT mostly in Europe and has helped revive
359
CHAPTER 10
360
CHAPTER 10
As you read, make a note of the skills being used and consider how they are being integrated. Can you
think of a similar adaptation you can make to one of the last classes you have taught or seen?
2. If Ss have something
1. T starts the lesson by interesting to share, T
3. T. looks for errors to
interacting with Ss. T encourages Ss to ask question
correct and opportunities to
can choose to talk about and converse. If Ss do not
extend language expression.
a relevant topic, ask a elaborate, T provides further
T posts language on
question, show an object, or input (photos, a story, etc).
the board and discusses
allow an ongoing discussion/ Ss brainstorm notes/prepare
corrections and language
topic to continue among something to say and then
with Ss.
students. exchange ideas in pairs/
groups.
7. T introduces oral or written 8 T rounds off the lesson by 9. T and Ss discuss where to
text on the topic and uses engaging Ss in reflecting on go next. T invites Ss to bring
it to draw Ss’ attention to what has happened and what ideas, objects, photos, etc. to
how the language they have has been learned. the next lesson.
learned is used in the text.
361
CHAPTER 10
CONCLUSION
362
CHAPTER 10
Chapter wrap-up
What is the most important What lingering questions What steps will you take
learning you have derived about integrating skills to find answers to these
from this chapter? do you still have? questions?
Observation task
Arrange to observe a skills lesson. As you observe complete the following table:
363
CHA
CPHTAEPRT E
1 0R 1 0
Look at three to five current English coursebooks. In your reflective journal discuss how they treat
the different language skills and how they attempt to integrate them. Provide links between what
you have found in these coursebooks and make explicit the connections to the ideas discussed in
this chapter.
portfolio task
1. Now that you have researched current practices in current coursebooks, and having read the
chapter and discussed the various implications it raises, write your “Skills Integration Platform”
to be included in your portfolio.
2. Next, select one of the units from the coursebooks you reviewed in your Reflective Journal and
redesign it so that skills are integrated in a natural way.
3. Write a caption to this Portfolio entry where you reflect on how this unit captures the essence
of the topic discussed in the chapter.
364
CHAPTER 10
IN:1:LEARNING STRATEGIES
pLuG IN LEARNING STRATEGIES
Knowledge can be described in terms of both concepts and procedures. Knowledge that
we know about is called “declarative” and knowledge that we know how to do (skills) is called
“procedural.” In cognitive psychology, these two kinds of knowledge are not only learned but
also recalled in different ways. While declarative knowledge is learned through associations of
new concepts into a complex web of previous knowledge, procedural knowledge is learned
through three stages that help finely tune it and make performance autonomous. Anna Uhl
Chamot (2009) makes a case for proceduralizing declarative knowledge. To her, if we teach
students how to apply learning strategies, then learning can progress at a faster and more solid
pace. Learning strategies are defined as thoughts of actions that we systematically apply and
that help us learn. Strategies cannot just be taught, they should also be practiced. Whenever
we teach content or develop the four language skills, learning strategies can help us make that
learning “stick.” Here is a list of three kinds of strategies
1. Name the strategy: giving the strategy a name makes it more memorable.
3. practice it: involve students in applying the strategy (e.g. if they are going to write, ask them to
plan; if you are teaching vocabulary ask them to group similar words, etc.).
4. recall it: remind students of opportunities to use the strategies you have taught and help them
recall how to use them,
5. evaluate it: always ask students to evaluate the usefulness of a strategy by helping them see how
it has helped them learn.
365
1X.
1.
CHAPTER
ASSESSMENT AND
XXXXXXX
EVALUATION
Xxxxx
learning
learning about:
about:
• •
assessment.
classroom
• evaluation.
management
• •
washback effect.
learning communities
• •
assessment of and for
teachers’ roles
learning.
• teachers’ use of L2 in
class
learning how to:
• learning
use assessment
how to:
information to direct
• develop and value a
your teaching.
learning community
• •
design assessment
plan lessons to cater
instruments.
for different energy
• reflect on assessment
levels and attention
Imagine you are setting out on a road trip to the destination of data.
spans
your dreams. All you have to direct you is a map. However, you do • use the white or
not care because you know that along the way, you will find road signs blackboard
• use the classroom
leading the way.
seating arrangements
Yet, as you start traveling you find that all road signs look like the to optimize learning.
one in the picture on the left. You do have milestones here and there
that indicate the number of miles you need to cover, but the direction
you take will be mostly dependent on your intuition.
In the same way, many teachers and educational institutions tend
to rely heavily on the results of standardized tests—the milestones—
rather than on information that can help them steer their course towards
the intended outcomes. Instead, they end up with a collection of
numbers, which very seldom reflect actual student language learning.
For a journey to be successful, that is to say, in order to reach your
destination, you need both the road signs (assessment information
to guide your teaching) and the milestones (various grades students
achieve in summative tasks).
In this chapter, we will explore ways in which teachers can use
both sources of information in order to make informed instructional
decisions in light of students’ progress towards course goals.
367367
THE CHAPTER AT A GLANCE
aSSeSSMent
For Definitions
learning
advantages assessment
limitations evaluation
examples
Assessment
and
Evaluation
SuMMatiVe
aSSeSSMent
vs
oF learning
ForMatiVe
What issues about assessment and evaluation have you heard your
colleagues/cooperating teacher discuss? Why are they important/
relevant?
368
CHAPTER 11
STARTING OUT
Teachers say…
Students say…
369
CHAPTER 11
WHAT IS ASSESSMENT?
Many teachers readily associate the term “assessment” with different standardized tests. While the
terms have been used indistinctly in the general education field, in ELT we draw a difference between
testing (aimed at grading students) and assessment (aimed at informing teaching and learning). Can
you think of an example of each?
370
CHAPTER 11
371
CHAPTER 11
Summative Formative
• Final • Process-oriented
• Evaluative • Informative
• Graded • Ungraded
• Authority-driven • Growth-driven
• Controlling • Empowering
• Teacher-directed • Student-directed
• Traditional • Alternative
372
CHAPTER 11
ASSESSMENT OF LEARNING
373
CHAPTER 11
proctor and also grade the tests of students taught by another teacher.
This happens because assessment of learning generally has important
consequences for students: they may fail or pass a course, be transferred
to a higher level or the test may even determine whether they graduate
or not. In these scenarios, and because these test results are used to make
important decisions about the students’ future, assessment of learning is
considered to be high stakes.
But assessment of learning can also be low stakes, in that its results
may not necessarily have a major impact on students’ lives. In general,
this occurs at the classroom and school levels in the form of progress
tests (for example, at the end of a unit or sequence of units in the
textbook students are using), culminating projects and tasks, and also
through the grades regularly sent to students’ homes via report cards.
However, it should be noted that the low or high stakes characteristic
of assessment is very contextual. What is high stakes in one school
may be low stakes in another.
Proponents of assessment of learning claim that it constitutes
a useful, valid and objective way of providing accountability for
learning. In other words, it is assumed that the evaluation of students’
language performance via standardized and scientifically constructed
instruments can yield an objective picture of those students’ progress
towards the desired level. Within this perspective, it is assumed that
assessment of learning results can help make decisions about what
needs to be reformulated (for example, a change in the syllabus
or the curriculum, the need for teacher training in a particular area,
or the suitability of different materials such as textbooks and their
components). So, in this sense, assessment of learning is intended as
a decision-making tool. However, we should note that, because of its
final nature, the decisions, which will eventually be made, are not going
to affect the students who were tested, but future generations. In this
sense, assessment of learning is reactive and not proactive.
Detractors of the assessment of learning movement disagree with
its supposed benefits. They claim that it does not maximize students’
achievement, but rather minimizes learning potential. In a high stakes
situation it is not unusual for the whole curriculum process to be
built around the test. For example, materials are created that teach
exclusively the contents expected to be tested, or courses are designed
374
CHAPTER 11
that specifically prepare students for the test. This is generally called
frontloading or “teaching to the test” and it refers to a phenomenon
called washback or backwash effect. This phenomenon can be both
negative (for example, when useful and valuable contents are not taught
because they are not included in the test), or positive (for example,
when the grading criteria for the test is known by teachers and students
and used systematically to guide learning activities during the course).
In terms of teaching, a high stakes emphasis on assessment of
learning also has the potential of limiting teachers’ creativity and
freedom to teach, in that teachers will teach to the test and will thus
adopt a teaching style which does not favor learning, necessarily, but
which only prepares students to succeed in the test. Finally, tests and
other forms of assessment of learning impinge on the learning process
via adaptations of the teaching process to align learning goals and test
outcomes.
375
CHAPTER 11
376
CHAPTER 11
student learning, and help the teacher plan the next steps in
instruction. However, AfL is oftentimes resisted by teachers and
administrators because of different reasons. Some of these reasons
include the fear that AfL may take time away from teaching, and in
high stakes situations, the need to cover content to be tested seems
to take priority over helping students learn. Likewise, teachers often
report that students are interested only in grades. However, research
has shown that embedding assessment in the teaching and learning
processes, that is to say, making it a part of the various learning tasks
students engage in, leads to improved learning for all. Hence, it is a
matter of changing perspectives and encouraging the use of this form
of assessment starting with individual classrooms and schools.
The advantages of using AfL are many:
• When we systematically apply AfL in our classes we open
up an ongoing dialog with our students that can help them
perceive ways of improving their performance.
• Because in AfL we rely on data about learning in real time,
it helps clarify our teaching goals and establishes clear
evidences for students’ learning. In other words, AfL helps
make learning visible.
• In this sense, it provides credible evidence about students’
learning.
• It also provides increased understanding about the processes
of teaching and learning and this understanding allows
us, and our students, to take the necessary steps towards
improvement in a timely manner.
377
CHAPTER 11
b. Minute papers
Another popular AfL tool is the minute paper. This can be given
at the beginning or end of class and, as the name indicates, it
consists of giving students one minute to answer questions such
as “Which aspects of today’s topic do you think you will find
difficult?” (at the beginning of the class) or “What was the most
important thing you learned in class today?” Again, answers are
collected and used by the teacher to help learners either prepare
for the new contents or review what has not been learned.
c. Rubrics
Rubrics are instruments, which break down the requirements
of a task and provide a description of different levels of
378
CHAPTER 11
Other popular tools used in AfL are rubrics. The following practical
advice can help you design and create useful rubrics
What is a rubric?
A rubric is an assessment instrument that clearly outlines for
students the criteria that are required to complete a learning product
or performance. These criteria can be used to plan, develop, revise and
evaluate students’ work (self- and peer assessment).
Frequently Asked
Possible answers
Question
What kind of rubrics There are four kinds of rubrics. Holistic rubrics provide a single score
are there? based on an overall impression of a students’ performance. Analytic
rubrics provide specific feedback along several criteria. General rubrics
contain criteria that are general across tasks. Task-specific rubrics are
unique to a specific task.
379
CHAPTER 11
Frequently Asked
Possible answers
Question
How are rubrics Holistic and General rubrics are generally used for summative
used? assessment. Analytic and Task-specific rubrics are generally used for
formative assessment.
What is included in Rubrics should contain two main elements: a description of the
an analytic rubric? product or performance and an explicitation of levels of performance.
An analytic rubric lists in detail the criteria that make up the final
performance or product. It also contains a breakdown of levels of that
performance or product on a continuum of quality. The criteria are
conditions that define what meeting the task requirements means. It
may also describe the consequences of performing at each level of
quality along the continuum.
How do I select First establish what the end performance or product should look like.
criteria to include? List all the requirements for it, making sure all areas are covered. Then
revise your list and create categories using the task requirements.
How do I write the It is best to start with a description of what an average student in the
level descriptors? class would show as evidence of attaining the product or performance.
This will include the basic level of attainment. Next, create a description
that is below this level of performance and finally think about how the
basic performance level could be made outstanding.
How do I add clarity Use concrete evidence of performance. Avoid general verbs (e.g.
to the rubric? understand) and use performative verbs (e.g. name, sequence, organize
in groups, etc.). Also, detail what consequences attaining this particular
level would have on the overall performance (e.g. “The learner provides
a list of five to seven animals that share the same characteristics. The
list contains enough examples to make the characteristics clear” as
opposed to “The learner provides a list of two or three animals that
share the same characteristics. From the examples included, it is not
clear what the characteristics are.”
How do I use the First, share it with a colleague who teaches the same grade level and
rubric? content. Make sure both of you set the same task to your students and
use the rubric to assess it. Meet and discuss what needs to be changed
or modified. Every time you use the rubric, assess how it is working and
make changes as needed.
What happens if Make all the necessary changes that add clarity to the rubric. Think
the rubric needs about what rubrics are designed for: to make evident and accessible
reformulation? what a good learning performance or product looks like.
Table 11.4 – An explanation of rubrics
380
CHAPTER 11
To sum up, we would like to refer once again to Huba and Freed
(2000) who list the following as the most salient characteristics of AfL:
Authentic Addresses the here and now with a view on the final performance. Acts as
a guide
381
CHAPTER 11
As you read this section, make notes on the margin on your experience taking tests as a student.
What test types did you experience as a learner?
It is fair to admit that not all tests have a negative effect on teaching
and learning. In fact, there are forms of tests that help students and
teachers make important instructional and learning decisions. For
example, when decisions have to be made at the macro level (e.g. at the
time of creating a new statewide or national curriculum), assessment
of learning information can help indicate those areas where the
change is most urgently needed. Likewise, the rigorous nature of most
standardized tests (test items are not just created, they are also piloted,
reconstructed and analyzed in terms of their validity and reliability
using rigorous statistical methods) can yield a very accurate picture
about the learning results of large populations.
There is a variety of test types, each one fulfilling a different (and
often complementary) purpose. The table below lists and explains the
most frequent test types in ELT.
382
CHAPTER 11
Aptitude This kind of test was popular in the mid twentieth century and it was used
to measure students’ ability to learn a language and also to predict their
potential success or failure in that endeavor. Aptitude tests are no longer
popular, although they are still used in certain contexts.
Progress Progress tests are given along a course and they measure students’ mastery
of contents in a certain unit. They are very popular in language textbooks
and their format tends to replicate that found in the main body of the unit
(same contents, same kind of exercises, etc.)
Proficiency Proficiency tests measure global competence in the language. In this sense,
they are not limited to a particular course or program but test overall ability
in the language. These tests are generally given to large audiences at the
end of a series of courses and help ascertain mastery of the language.
383
CHAPTER 11
Practicality
Practical classroom tests are economical in every sense. They do
not require extensive time to prepare; neither do they demand that
special costs be taken into consideration. A good test can be easily
and cheaply reproduced and is practical in that it does not require
sophisticated equipment (be it hardware or software).
Reliability
Reliability is concerned with consistency and dependability. A
reliable classroom test, when applied to different groups that have
similar characteristics, independent of who teaches those groups, will
yield similar results. Reliability also refers to test administration (Is it
administered under the same conditions?) and correction (Do different
scorers agree on the scores they give?)
Validity
Grounlund (1998, cited in Brown and Abeywickrama, 2010, p. 29)
defines validity as “the extent to which inferences made from assessment
results are appropriate, meaningful, and useful in terms of the purpose of the
assessment.” In other words, does the test evaluate what was taught and
in the way in which it was taught? When you look at test design you can
probe for validity by comparing its contents with what was taught. If
384
CHAPTER 11
you look at the results then you question whether the criteria of the test
(e.g. the test was intended to teach all four skills) have been reached.
Lastly, validity refers to the consequences the test may have and which
include its accuracy in measuring the criteria, the demands in terms of
student preparation and the eventual impact that taking the test may
have on students’ lives.
Authenticity
This principle refers to how faithfully the test captures the
dynamics of real language in use. In other words, if students read a
text, is this text similar to the one they would find in a newspaper, book,
webpage or magazine in those places where the target language is
spoken? Many times, classroom tests make use of heavily edited texts
to present students with samples of the language they have studied. A
good classroom test, uses texts that are natural and as authentic as the
level of the students permits them to be.
Positive Washback
Finally, and as we have said before, the effect that tests can have on
teaching in particular, as well as on curriculum development in general,
is worth mentioning. The influence that a test has on teaching and
curriculum development is referred to as “washback” or “backwash.”
There can be two scenarios in this influence. Negative washback is
when teachers teach to the test, that is, they do not actually teach
the language to the students, but they teach them exclusively what is
evaluated in the test together with strategies to take the test. Obviously,
this negative effect limits the learning of the language and severely
narrows down the curriculum. On the other hand, washback can have
a positive effect, as when students develop test taking strategies that
they can then transfer to other subjects and contexts or when they
learn something during the preparation for the test that they can
readily apply to communicating in real life. Evidently, a good test would
promote positive washback.
385
CHAPTER 11
Testing theory was developed mostly during the first half of the
20 century, and it borrowed heavily from the field of psychometrics in
th
terms of design and analysis. The main aim of testing, even nowadays,
is to produce accurate standardized results across vast populations. Test
scores can help paint a picture of reality and are generally assumed to
inform whether or not students have registered gains in their learning.
In that quest for objectivity, test designers usually try to minimize
the influence that the test scorers could potentially have on test scores.
Because of this, a number of reliable and valid testing techniques were
developed, which can be found in most tests.
While different educational systems and institutions will have
specific guidelines on how to write tests, in all likelihood, they will
make use of all or some of the following test items. The following table
summarizes the most frequent test items and provides examples and
advice and how to construct them.
Example/
Test Item Advantages Disadvantages Advice
Description
Q: Where did » High level of » Difficult to write » Make sure the
Peter go? reliability (if well good items. distractor is a suitable
A: Peter ____ written). » Only useful for one.
to the club. » Useful at many receptive skills. » Check for grammatical
a. go different levels. » Encourages consistency.
b. went » Does not guessing if » Do not provide obvious
overtax other students do clues.
c. goes
language skills. not know the » All options should
Multiple d. gone correct answer.
» Cost-effective be similar in terms of
choice
(in that they can length and difficulty.
formats
be scored by » Make sure only ONE
computers) option is correct.
» Check for sensitivity
issues (gender, religion,
etc.).
» Take into account what
background knowledge
students would need
386
CHAPTER 11
Example/
Test Item Advantages Disadvantages Advice
Description
Indicate true- » Are good to » They » Focus on meaning and
false or not test many encourage not trivial details.
stated different kinds guessing (50% » Consider background
1. This type of of conceptual chances of knowledge.
scoring rests and factual getting it right).
» Use simpler language
on one clear content. » A sufficient in the questions than
criterion. » They require number of that which appears in
2. Criteria are little time to items is needed the text.
True/ respond. to make the
contextual. » Keep the questions in
False » Marking is test valid and
3. It takes the same order as the
formats quick and very reliable.
a global information in the text.
approach reliable.
» Include enough questions.
to the
» Avoid the 50/50 guess
assessment
by including a third
of writing.
category (e.g. “Does
not say”) or by asking
students to correct the
false statements.
Match the » Same as for » Same as for » Provide more options
situations to Multiple Choice Multiple than beginnings so as
these useful formats. Choice formats. to keep the items valid.
expressions. » Easier to write » Use numbers in one
___ 1. When than Multiple column and letters in
checking in. Choice the other.
___ 2. When Formats. » Make the options
requesting » There are more shorter than the
room service. distractors per beginnings.
___ 3. When question. » Keep all beginnings
Matching
asking for and options
formats wake-up contextualized to the
service. same theme.
A. Hello! » Make sure all
B. I need a call beginnings and options
at 7:00 am. appear on the same
page.
C. How much is
it with taxes?
D. I’d like a
burger and a
coke, please.
387
CHAPTER 11
Example/
Test Item Advantages Disadvantages Advice
Description
Cloze tests - » Easy to prepare. » More than » Make sure answers are
words in a text » Easy to score. one correct short.
are removed answer may » Provide enough
Cloze/ at regular be possible. context.
Gap-fill intervals (e.g. Difficult to
» Keep the same length
items (see every 7th or provide
in the gap for all items.
chapter 11th word). support for
8, page learners (there » Do not put blanks in
Gap fill -
273 for is a need in the first sentence or
phrases or
more gap fills to paragraph.
sentences are
informa- purposefully include key
tion) removed to words—such
test specific as adverbs—
language to prompt
areas. students to the
correct answer).
Students » Require more » Responding · There must be just ONE
provide production than can take a long short, concise answer.
answers to a other items. time. · Allow for partial credit
prompt in a » There is less » Students are if students make
Short few words or guessing. likely to make mistakes.
answer/ sentences. more mistakes.
» Easy to prepare.
Com-
Can be used » Scoring is more
pletion
to test higher- subjective than
items
order thinking in previous
skills. items.
» Scoring may
take longer.
388
CHAPTER 11
Example/
Test Item Advantages Disadvantages Advice
Description
Students » The student » Time » Write prompts that
respond to decides how to consuming encourage higher-
a prompt by approach the for students order thinking
writing an question. (writing) and skills (summarizing,
extended text. teachers evaluating, creating).
» There are more
TYPES OF opportunities (marking). » Be specific about
SCORING
for students to » Subjective the task (audience,
Holistic scoring express their scoring even purpose, length,
uses a variety
ideas. when detailed format, etc.)
of criteria to
» Ideal for criteria are » Develop scoring rubrics
produce a
single score. assessing used. for the task, share them
Analytic scoring higher-order » Best graded with students ahead of
uses detailed thinking skills. through time and use them to
Essay
calibration grade the task.
questions step-by-step
criteria and level sessions (see » If you give choices
indicators thus Plug in: Writing of prompts, make all
recognizing calibration in choices similar in terms
that different this chapter) of difficulty.
students will
perform at
different levels
in various
criteria.
See ideas for
the calibration
of writing in
the Plug-In for
this chapter.
Table 11.3 - Test items (adapted from O’Malley and Chamot,1996 and Coombe, Folse and Hubley, 2010)
389
CHAPTER 11
“A student might read an authentic text on the importance of maintaining good health (interpretive
communication), interview classmates on their views about good health (interpersonal communication),
and create an oral public service announcement with tips on ways to stay healthy (presentational
communication).”
Notice how in this example, each task focuses on one of the three modes of communication and
how each task provides input for and leads naturally into the next task, with the final performance task
acting as a summary of the whole process. Because IPAs are performative in that they require students
to do things with language that they would be expected to do in real life, they have the potential to
better account for students’ learning than a regular test.
Each IPA is built around a relevant theme that has been worked on in class and it is good practice to
390
CHAPTER 11
present the IPA to students at the beginning of the teaching sequence so that they know exactly what
they will be assessed on. In order to do this, IPAs are constructed following a set of steps:
1. The teacher selects a topic around which to develop a thematic unit. The topic gives rise to one,
two or three “essential questions” that the learning activities are supposed to help students answer.
2. Next, the teacher clearly specifies the language functions (tasks that the learner should be able
to handle in a consistently spontaneous manner), text types (what genres and registers will help
learners master functions, strategies, etc.), communication strategies (the amount of negotiations
of meaning), level of comprehensibility needed (can speakers/writers at this level be understood?
By whom?) and degree of language control (grammatical accuracy, vocabulary, degree of fluency)
that will form the core of the teaching during the unit. With all this information the teacher creates
rubrics to assess all the elements above.
3. Once the end-result of the unit has been made clear, the teacher designs an overview of the IPA
that unambiguously describes the context and purposes of the various authentic tasks. During
the development of the unit, the teacher refers students back to the overview of IPA, shares and
uses the assessment instruments (rubrics, checklists, etc.) that will be used to grade the IPA. It is
recommended that the introduction of the overview to the students also include illustrations of the
IPA involving students in previous years that have successfully completed it.
4. The teacher clearly designs the sequence of tasks addressing the three modes of communication:
Adair-Hauk, et al. (2013, p. 10) suggest the following cyclical approach to the design of IPAs
391
CHAPTER 11
In the following example of an I.P.A. for beginning students of English, identify: the stages of the
overview, the Interpretive, Interpersonal and Presentational tasks and the topic of the unit this IPA
evaluates:
392
CHAPTER 11
CONCLUSION
393
CHAPTER 11
ChaPteR wRaP-uP
What is the most important What lingering questions What steps will you take to
learning you have derived about assessment do you find answers to these
from this chapter? still have? questions?
Observation task
Arrange with your cooperating teacher or a colleague to meet at a time convenient to both of you
and close to an Assessment of Learning event (e.g. progress test). During that meeting discuss:
• what the purposes of the assessment are.
• what the specifications for the assessment are.
• what format the assessment will take.
• how the teacher will use the results of the assessment.
Portfolio task
394
PLuG IN: WRITING CALIBRATION CHAPTER 11
There is a frequent concern when assessing writing about how valid and reliable the scores that different
teachers give to the same sample of writing are. In order to enhance what has been called inter-rater reliability
(the degree of agreement on the score given to an artifact or performance by two different assessors),
schools and districts have turned to a process called Writing Calibration. This consists of a focused meeting
involving all the teachers who will have to grade the same writing tasks (for example, in a final test). During
the meeting, participants follow a protocol that helps them agree on criteria and grades. The following is a
typical protocol:
Preparation - All the teachers that will give the same test agree on the writing prompt
I) Before giving and collectively build an analytic rubric to assess it. They also appoint a facilitator for the
the test to calibration session. The facilitator will book a room, select examples of students’ work
students after the test (12 to 15 examples including students in the low, middle and high ranges),
writes the timing for the protocol and makes sure each participant will have a copy of all
the materials.
II) On the day of Orientation - The facilitator reviews the protocol with the group and distributes
the calibration the materials (writing samples together with rubrics, a scoring sheet and all other
session necessary materials).
Familiarization - Participants read all the materials in silence and prepare questions to
ask if there is something they do not understand.
Clarification - Participants ask questions about what is not clear. The facilitator’s task is
to keep the group on task and contribute clarifications, if needed.
Scoring - Participants work individually and in silence grading all the writing samples.
They enter their grades and make comments why they assign a particular grade in
their copy of the scoring sheet.
Sharing - Participants take turns sharing their grades only. No discussion is allowed
at this time. The facilitator copies the grades of all participants in his/her score sheet,
and identifies those writing samples where there have been the greatest discrepancies
among raters.
Consensus - Participants focus on each of the writing samples selected above, and
give their reasons for their scores. They analyze the rubric and the samples and reach a
consensus on how to interpret these to assess the samples. After a consensus has been
reached, participants collectively review all other samples and make adjustments to their
grades, if necessary. While this happens, the facilitator makes sure to take copious notes
of the agreements.
Next steps - The work done can become a rating manual for other faculty in the
school. The facilitator compiles all the writing samples and adds the agreed grade and
the comments that raters made on each piece. This material is compiled in a packet
that is distributed to all teachers who will grade the same writing prompt school-wide.
395
X.
12.
CHAPTER
MINDFUL, CORRECTIVE
XXXXXXX
FEEDBACK
Xxxxx
learning
learning about:
about:
In Lewis Carroll’s “Alice’s Adventures in
• •
mindful, corrective
classroom
Wonderland” there comes a moment when
feedback.
management
Alice gets lost and asks for directions from
• •
different learner error
learning communities
the Cheshire Cat. Here is their exchange: types.
• teachers’ roles
• •
distinction between
teachers’ use of L2 in
“Would you tell me, please, which way I ought to go from here?” and error and a
class
“That depends a good deal on where you want to get to,” said the Cat. mistake.
“I don’t much care where—“ said Alice. • learning
Interlanguage.how to:
“Then it doesn’t matter which way you go,” said the Cat. • develop and value a
“—so long as I get somewhere,” Alice added as an explanation. learning community
learning how to:
“Oh, you’re sure to do that,” said the Cat, “if you only walk long • provide constructive,
• plan lessons to cater
enough.” mindful corrective
for different energy
Alice felt that this could not be denied… feedback.
levels and attention
• implement a variety
spans
of corrective feedback
• use the white or
Let’s think for a few minutes about this situation. Alice does not know strategies.
blackboard
• promote student
• use the classroom
where she is going, and the Cheshire Cat gives her advice. The advice;
uptake of teacher
seating arrangements
however, is not of much use, is it? When you do not have a destination feedback.
to optimize learning.
(or goal) you do not know where you are going, any advice is not helpful.
Without a destination, you will never be able to arrive anywhere. You need
to know where you are going so as to plot a course to get there and know
when you have arrived.
Notice that many times, our students are in a position very similar to
Alice’s. When they do not have any clear awareness of the destination or
goal, the teacher has to explicitly help the students to become aware of that
goal. Hence, one of the most crucial forms of scaffolding that teachers can
give is advice on where to go to next, what is needed and how to arrive.
We call this information: mindful, corrective feedback. Mindful because it
takes into account not just the language performance of the student, but
his or her whole learning persona; and corrective, because it informs the
students of what concrete steps they can take in order to successfully get
where they are going: proficiency in the second or foreign language.
397397
THE CHAPTER AT A GLANCE
Slips, errors,
mistakes and
experimentation
goals of
who should
corrective
correct?
feedback
Mindful,
corrective
feedback
how should it
get corrected?
What issues about mindful, corrective feedback have you heard your
colleagues/cooperating teacher discuss? Why are they important/
relevant?
398
CHAPTER 12
STARTING OUT
Teachers say…
• I don’t like interrupting my students when they make mistakes; it’s it’s
rude.
• I don’t think correction helps students.
• I provide indirect correction because, with time, students will “get it”.
• I use a marking code (e.g. WW: wrong word) to provide feedback to
my students’ writing because I want them to become independent
learners.
Students say…
399
CHAPTER 12
400
CHAPTER 12
401
CHAPTER 12
• what to correct.
Are the students showing evidence of attempting new language?
Is it an error or a slip of the tongue?
Is it a global error?
• when to correct.
Is it during a focus on fluency activity or a focus on accuracy
activity?
• who corrects.
Should the correction be made by the teacher or offered up to other
students to help repair?
• how to correct.
Should the teacher stop the activity and use the board to
correct or should the teacher prompt the other students orally
to correct?
402
CHAPTER 12
ERRORS OR MISTAKES?
403
CHAPTER 12
of the tongue and, as such, they are not really relevant to the language
learning process as students are able to self-correct them and generally
do so on the spot. He calls these non-systematic errors “mistakes” to
differentiate them from more significant and proper “errors” which
are part of the process of language development but which may be
indicative of more pervasive underlying comprehension or expression
problems. Hence, we will call “errors” to those instances of students
expressions that evidence a recurring pattern of incorrectness and
which may be indicative of fossilization. In general, students are not
aware they are making these errors and cannot even self-correct them.
On the other hand, mistakes are temporary slips that students are
readily able to self-repair. However, as we have seen before, students
often experiment with the language, testing out hypothesis they make
about how language works and these do not fall in either of the two
categories explained above. These experimentations are hypotheses
that students construct on their own by noticing incomplete aspects
of the input they receive, and which they might consciously or
unconsciously use in order to receive feedback as to whether they
are on the right track. In general, once the feedback is received, the
hypothesis is either confirmed (if it led to correct use of the language)
or discarded (if it led to a mistake). What is importance to notice here
is that all these different attempts that students make are very useful
information for the teacher and that they are all indicative that students
are, in fact, actually learning.
Marks and Bowen (1994) point out that the etymology of the
word “error” takes us back all the way to the concept of original sin
and falling from grace and they advance the idea that, if we substituted
the use of that word for “learning step,” we could all develop a more
positive attitude to how we perceive these attempts that students make
at mastering the language. Compare these two sentences:
and
404
CHAPTER 12
Look back at the transcript from the class session above and identify instances of implicit and explicit
correction.
405
CHAPTER 12
So, you WENT to the cinema yesterday! What did you see?
406
CHAPTER 12
Implicit Explicit
Error type
For example, phonological, syntactical, written or oral etc. An oral
recast may be a good method of correcting a phonological issue but
will be of less use for a complicated syntactic error.
Learner Confidence
For example, a good learner perceives that making mistakes is
a necessary part of the learning process and embraces correction as
407
CHAPTER 12
v
How would you correct the following utterances?
408
CHAPTER 12
sp spelling mistake
p punctuation mistake
^ something is missing (a word, a preposition, etc.).
π new paragraph needed
ns new sentence needed
c misuse of capital letter
^c missing capital letter
gr grammar mistake
ww wrong word
wo word order problem
/ (placed over a word) delete
reverse
409
CHAPTER 12
Rationale (+)
Rationale (-)
410
CHAPTER 12
411
CHAPTER 12
Feedback DO’s
• Focus feedback on the task/response process/goals (not the learner).
• Present feedback in manageable units (concentrate on two or three areas at the most).
• Be specific and clear with feedback messages (provide concrete suggestion of what students could
do in order to improve).
• Keep feedback as simple as possible (make sure students understand what is required of them next).
• Reduce uncertainty between performance and goals by giving examples or requesting them from
students.
• Give unbiased, objective feedback.
• Promote a learning goal orientation (emphasize that effort increases learning and that mistakes are
an important part of the learning process).
• Provide feedback after learners have provided a possible solution.
Feedback DON’Ts
• Do not compare a student to their peers, but rather to the student himself or herself now, in the
past or in the future.
• Do not forget to highlight students’ strengths when giving feedback. It is not all about
improvement. It is also about achievement.
• Do not be tempted to exemplify performance in terms of potential grades.
• Do not present feedback that discourages the learner or threatens the learner’s self - esteem.
• Use praise sparingly (focus on effort/progress).
• Do not interrupt the learner with feedback if the learner is actively engaged in a task.
• Avoid using progressive hints that always terminate with the correct answer.
412
CHAPTER 12
413
CHAPTER 12
assessment prior to the students engaging with the task, the teacher
will be scaffolding students’ expression since they will be able to use
the criteria as a guide for completing the task. Secondly, and most
importantly, students will have a tool to self-monitor and self-assess
as the criteria will turn any task into a criterion-referenced task, where
the underlying supposition is that all students, and not just a few, can
achieve excellence.
In sum, feedback should serve the purpose of reducing the
gap between current and desired performance by either providing
information for improving inappropriate knowledge (level explicitness)
or skills or by reducing the cognitive load presented by a task or
content (amount of rationale provided). If feedback serves either of
these purposes, then it can be called mindful and corrective, in that it
does not evaluate, but rather redirects learning efforts.
In this sense, it can both direct and facilitate learning. Feedback
can be directive when it is used to tell students exactly what needs to be
fixed or revised, or it can be facilitative when it provides comments or
suggestions to help guide learners in their own revision. Either form of
feedback is grounded on the idea that the learner needs to be informed
about their areas for improvement, and be given concrete steps they
can take in order to achieve that.
However, informing or telling is one part of the equation. The other
variable is the requirement that the students be able to take action on
the feedback provided to modify their performance or understanding.
So feedback giving and feedback uptake are both a pre-requisite for
high quality learning.
CONCLUSION
414
CHAPTER 12
ChapTeR wRap-up
Observation task
Observe a class and note down the various techniques the teacher uses in class to provide
students with mindful, corrective feedback. Note down also the students’ responses. Is uptake
evident?
• Think back to a time when you received feedback from your teachers. How effective was that
feedback? Why was it effective or ineffective? What would you have needed more of? Less of?
How has that experience receiving feedback influenced the way you give feedback to your
students?
415
CHAPTER 12
portfolio task
1. Write down the “Mindful, corrective feedback” platform for your portfolio.
2. Select a sample of written mindful, corrective feedback you have given your students and
reflect on how effective that feedback has been.
3. Also include a recording of yourself giving mindful, corrective feedback to your students and
reflect on how effective it was.
416
GLOSSARY
417
GLOSSARY
418
GLOSSARY
419
GLOSSARY
Fluency. Ease and flow of speech similar to the speed with which a
native speaker communicates.
420
GLOSSARY
Low-stakes testing. The potential minor effects that a test may have
on learners’ futures as compared to situations when test results may
significantly affect these.
421
GLOSSARY
422
GLOSSARY
Scanning. A reading strategy in which the reader looks for and finds
specific information. This is a more detailed form of reading.
423
GLOSSARY
424
GLOSSARY
425
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Brown, H.D. (2015). Teaching by principles. (5th Ed). New York: Longman.
Brown, H.D. and Abeywickrama, P. (2010). Language Assessment:
Principles and Classroom Practices. (2nd Edition). White Plains:
Pearson Longman.
Bruner, J., & Sherwoord, V. (1976). Peekaboo and the learning of rule
structures. In J. Bruner, J., Jolly, A. & Sylva, K. (Eds.). Play: Its
role in development and evolution. (pp 277-287). Harmondsworth:
Penguin Books.
427
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Case, A. (2008). Criteria for a good needs analysis. Retrieved November 23,
2014 from http://edition.tefl.net/articles/teacher-technique/
needs-analysis-criteria/
Case, A. (n/d). Needs analysis: Part 1. Retrieved, November 23, 2014 from
http://www.onestopenglish.com/business/teaching-approaches/
needs-analysis/needs-analysis-part-1/144573.article
Coyle, D., Hood, P., and Marsh, D. (2010). CLIL: Content and Language
Integrated Learning. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
428
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Dale, L. and Tanner, R. (2012). CLIL Activities: A resource for subject and
language teachers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
429
BIBLIOGRAPHY
431
BIBLIOGRAPHY
432
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Masuhara, H., Hann, M., Yi, Y. and Tomlinson, B. (2008). Adult EFL
Courses. ELT Journal, 62, (3), 294--312.
433
BIBLIOGRAPHY
434
BIBLIOGRAPHY
435
BIBLIOGRAPHY Ur, P. (1981). Discussions that work: Task-centred fluency practice.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Utah Education Network (n/d). The 6+1 Trait ® Rubric. Retrieved, June
6, 2012 from http://www.uen.org/Rubric/rubric.cgi?rubric_
id=1082
Wood, D., Bruner, J., & Ross, G. (1976). The role of tutoring in problem
solving. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 17, 89-100.
436
BIBLIOGRAPHY
OnLIne LInks
CHAPTER 1
CHAPTER 2
A conceptual framework
deepening the reflection.
CHAPTER 3
Observation technique.
437
OnLIne LInks
CHAPTER 4
CHAPTER 5
Ideas on planning.
CHAPTER 6
Impact.
CHAPTER 7
Teaching lexis.
Making Crosswords.
438
OnLIne LInks
CHAPTER 8
CHAPTERT 9
Speaking strategies.
Listening strategies.
Speaking techniques.
Speaking ideas.
Digital Storytelling.
CHAPTER 10
Dogme.
CLIL.
Text-based teaching.
Task-based learning.
439
OnLIne LInks
CHAPTER 11
CHAPTER 12
440