The aim of this investigation was to compare the masses of fuel used to the temperature rise of the
water to determine which fuel is the most efficient. The three fuels tested will be the alcohols
ethanol, propanol and methanol.
Raw Data
Observations
Before heating:
- The alcohol was colourless
- The alcohol maintained a constant temperature of 21°C
During heating:
- An alcohol flame of the colour blue
- Sometimes a tinge of yellow can be seen on the edges of the blue flame
After heating:
- The alcohol remain colourless
Data processing
Ethanol
Before heating:
Mass of water (m) = volume x density
= 50cm3 x 1g/cm3
= 50g
70°C - 21 °C
IB CHEMISTRY
Energetics (HL Only)
= 49°C
Enthalpy change during combustion = mass of water x specific heat capacity x temperature
rise of water
From the following experimental data, it can be calculated that the standard enthalpy of combustion
of ethanol (∆H˚comb) is 502 kJ/mol. Similar procedures are followed to determine the standard
enthalpy of combustion of the rest of the alcohols. The results are put into a table below. Thus, all
the 4 alcohols have been tested for their standard enthalpy of combustions. The overall results are
as shown in the table form below.
Error propagation
Ethanol:
Uncertainty in the mass balance = ±0.001 g
Mass of ethanol burnt = 0.94 g ± 0.002g (calculated twice and uncertainties are always added)
Percentage Uncertainty = ±0.002g / 0.94g x 100% = 0.21%
The following steps can be followed to determine the uncertainties in the data values of the other
two alcohols.
The standard enthalpy of combustion of propanol (with uncertainty) is -572 kJ/mol ± 15.044
kJ/mol.
The standard enthalpy of combustion of methanol (with uncertainty) is -167 kJ/mol ± 6.045
kJ/mol.
Conclusion
In this experiment, our goal was to compare the masses and temperature rise to determine the most
efficient fuel. From the experiment we can observe that the standard enthalpy change of
combustion has a direct link to the number of carbon atoms in an alcohol chain. Hence, propanol
releasing the most energy. As the number of carbon atoms in this alcohol chain increase, the values
of standard enthalpy combustion will also increase. When being burnt, each successive member of
the series contains one more (-CH2-) bond than the other, meaning there will be one extra C-C
bond and two extra C-H bonds to be broken. Therefore, more energy will be required for
combustion, explaining the results I have obtained in the table above.
Error analysis
However, the literature values for the combustion of these three alcohols are given as:
Alcohol kJ/mol-1
Compared to the theoretical values, the experimental values are drastically different. As a result of
the large error rate, the error percentage for each alcohol was found.
Ethanol
Standard enthalpy combustion (ΔHc ):
Literature value: -1371 kJ/mol
Experimental value: -502 kJ/mol
Error = 1371 - 502
= 869 kJ/mol (Eliminating negative signs for calculations)
Percentage error = (Error / Theoretical value) x 100%
= (869 kJ/mol /1371 kJ/mol) x 100%
= 63.4%
In this manner, the percentage errors for other alcohols were also found and the results are summed
up in the table below:
Methanol 76.8%
Propanol 71.7%
IB CHEMISTRY
Energetics (HL Only)
Although my percentage errors were relatively high, ranging from 63-76%, I can prove that
propanol is the best fuel as it produced the highest amount of energy. Despite, not losing the least
mass, according to the literature value, it produces the highest energy by far compared to the other
alcohols, which shows a similar trend to my experimental values. As the lid on top of my copper
beaker did not fit properly, my values were likely affected and inaccurate, so this would be
something I would like change in the future, if I were to do the experiment again.
Evaluation
As high error percentages were obtained, better results could have been yielded. Therefore the
sources and other list of errors have been listed in a table below.