fischerwerke Artur Fischer GmbH & Co.

KG, Weinhalde 14 – 18, D - 72178 Waldachtal Page 1

System comparison of the features of ‘fischer FIRE STOP’ with competitor systems

Features of the systems fischer FIRE STOP Hilti Würth BC

C1/T1
Product with name Fire protection mass foaming CP 611A Fire protection putty Fire protection paint viscous,
(FDB) (intumescent) intumescent

Application pursuant to MLAR Yes Yes Yes Yes

(gap width > 15 mm)
Ageing-resistance Yes Yes Yes N.a.
Applicator gun Commercially available Special gun Commercially available Commercially available
Non-toxic, water-based Yes Yes N.a. Yes

Features of the systems fischer FIRE STOP Hilti Würth BC

C2/T2/V2
Product with name Fire protection mortar FM3 CP 632 Fire protection cement MGIII Fire protection mortar M30 -
Opti

Application pursuant to MLAR Yes Yes Yes Yes

(Gap width < 15mm)
Weather- and ageing-resistant Yes Yes Yes N.a.
Coatable Yes N.a. N.a. N.a.
fischerwerke Artur Fischer GmbH & Co. KG, Weinhalde 14 – 18, D - 72178 Waldachtal Page 2
System comparison of the features of ‘fischer FIRE STOP’ with competitor systems

Features of the systems fischer FIRE STOP Hilti Würth BC

Product with name FAB/FAS/ FASK (ablative) CP 673 (ablative) Fire protection coating / fire BC fire protection colour, fire
protection filler / fire protection putty
protection putty (intumescent)
(intumescent)

Non-toxic, water-based Yes Yes N.a. Yes

Asbestos and solvent-free Yes Yes N.a. Solvent-free

Chemical behaviour to the Neutral N.a. N.a. pH-neutral; metals must be

subsurface protected against corrosion!
In the event of fire, no toxic or Yes N.a. N.a. N.a.
corrosive gases
Permanently flexible (after Yes N.a. N.a. N.a.
drying)

Water-insensitive (can be used Yes No No and can also not be used in Can be used with BC fire
outdoors) wet rooms! protection ceiling paint for
indoors and outdoors!
Coatability Yes – with water-based with Exposy No – may not be coated No – may not be coated, apart
dispersion paint from see below
Resistant to radioactive and UV Yes N.a. N.a. N.a.
radiation
Own heat behaviour of the cables Yes N.a. N.a. N.a.

Rotting and age-resistant Yes Age-resistant Age-resistant N.a.

Mould-resistant Yes N.a. N.a. N.a.
fischerwerke Artur Fischer GmbH & Co. KG, Weinhalde 14 – 18, D - 72178 Waldachtal Page 3
System comparison of the features of ‘fischer FIRE STOP’ with competitor systems

Features of the systems fischer FIRE STOP Hilti Würth BC

C10/M10/T10
System with name Combined Board Firestop CP 673 Fire firestop W Combined BC fire protection firestop
S90 S90/Combi

Other suppliers of the system - - bio Brandschutz -

Coating properties See FAB/FAS/ FASK (ablative) See CP 673 (ablative) Fire protection coating / fire BC fire protection colour, fire
protection filler / fire protection protection putty (intumescent)
putty (intumescent)
Light partition walls (GK) Yes Yes Yes Yes

Minimum firestop thickness 120 mm 100 mm / 120 mm 100 mm 100 mm

Pipes in the firestop (wall/ceiling) Yes Yes Yes Yes

Coating length from firestop 100 mm 150 mm 200 mm 200 mm

Gas tightness check Civil defence test up to 100 Gas permeability check Tight against smoke gases Tight against smoke gases
mbar! (Fire fighting with according to DIN 1026
extinguishing gases)
fischerwerke Artur Fischer GmbH & Co. KG, Weinhalde 14 – 18, D - 72178 Waldachtal Page 4
System comparison of the features of ‘fischer FIRE STOP’ with competitor systems

Features of the systems fischer FIRE STOP Hilti Würth BC

C11
System with name Board firestop S30/S60 CP 673 No S30 firestop! BC fire protection firestop
S60

Other suppliers of the system - - - -

Coating properties See FAB/FAS/ FASK (ablative) See CP 673 (ablative) BC fire protection colour, fire
protection putty (intumescent)
Light partition walls (GK) Yes Yes Yes

Minimum firestop thickness 60 mm 60 mm 60 mm

Coating length from firestop 100 mm 100 mm 200 mm

Installation only possible from Yes – as no coating beyond N.a. N.a.

one side the board
fischerwerke Artur Fischer GmbH & Co. KG, Weinhalde 14 – 18, D - 72178 Waldachtal Page 5
System comparison of the features of ‘fischer FIRE STOP’ with competitor systems

Features of the systems fischer FIRE STOP Hilti Würth BC

C20, M20, T20
System with name Combined Mortar Firestop CP 636 Combined firestop BC mortar firestop S120
S90
(FMO)

Other suppliers of the system - - bio Brandschutz Rex

Light partition walls (GK) No permitted! Not permitted! Not permitted! Not permitted!

Minimum firestop thickness Wall 240 mm, ceiling 200 mm 150 mm 150 mm 180 mm
(incl. 40 mm mineral fibre
board)
Pipes in the firestop (wall/ceiling) Wall Wall and ceiling Wall and ceiling Not permitted!

Yield 1 kg of dry mortar yields 2.4 – 20 kg yields around 20.6 kg of 20 kg yields around 20 kg of 20 kg yields 23 litres of wet
2.7 litres – with 20 kg up to 54 fresh mortar, or approx. 17.2 fresh mortar, or approx. 19.1 mass
litres litres litres
Density 500-600 kg/m³ 1200 kg/m³, corresponds to MG approx. 1050 kg/m³ 1200 kg/m³
IIa
Additional cable coating Not necessary Not necessary Not necessary Not necessary

Option of subsequent installation Subsequent installation wedges Subsequent installation wedges Subsequent installation wedges Subsequent installation wedges
possible, opening without drill necessary necessary necessary
possible
Sound-damping quality proved by a test, Proof for solid wall, with N.a. N.a.
measurements without interpretation in interpretation of the results
installation
Distances for component May adjoin and be mounted at Min. 30 mm distance Min. 20 mm distance Below and at the side 0 mm, at
embrasure the side and below (0 mm) the top 30 mm!
Cable and cable support
fischerwerke Artur Fischer GmbH & Co. KG, Weinhalde 14 – 18, D - 72178 Waldachtal Page 6
System comparison of the features of ‘fischer FIRE STOP’ with competitor systems
constructions
Coatability With aqueous with Expoxy N.a. N.a.
floor dispersions
Temperature change resistance Checked N.a. N.a. N.a.
Expansion and shrinking Purely hydraulic hardening N.a. N.a. N.a.
behaviour (no tension cracks)
fischerwerke Artur Fischer GmbH & Co. KG, Weinhalde 14 – 18, D - 72178 Waldachtal Page 7
System comparison of the features of ‘fischer FIRE STOP’ with competitor systems

Features of the systems fischer FIRE STOP Hilti Würth BC

C30
System with name Cushion firestop S90 (FBK) CP 651 Fire protection cushion 90 BC fire protection cushion
S90
corresponds to fischer FIRE
STOP!

Other suppliers of the system BC Minimax, OBO Bio Brandschutz fischerwerke

Light partition walls (GK) Not possible Possible Possible Not possible

Minimum firestop thickness 240 mm 340 mm 300 mm 240 mm

Cushion – standard sizes 4 sizes 3 sizes 2 sizes 4 sizes

Moisture sensitive No N.a. No No

Additional materials necessary None None Fire protection putty with cable None
bundles and subsequent
installation necessary
Inflationary effect in a fire Yes Yes No. as mineral fibre filling Yes
fischerwerke Artur Fischer GmbH & Co. KG, Weinhalde 14 – 18, D - 72178 Waldachtal Page 8
System comparison of the features of ‘fischer FIRE STOP’ with competitor systems

Features of the systems fischer FIRE STOP Hilti Würth BC

C40/C41
System with name Stone firestop S30 – S120 CP 657-M, CP 657-L Fire protection stone / plugs No stone / plug in range!
(FBB)

Manufacturer of the product - ZZ Brandschutztechnik MEBA GmbH, Bio Brandschutz

Other suppliers of the system - Promat, OBO -

(with different dimensions)
Light partition walls (GK) Yes Yes Yes

Minimum firestop thickness 130 mm / 230 mm 120 mm/ 170 mm / 200 mm 220 mm

Pipes in the firestop (wall/ceiling) No Yes No

Ageing-resistance Yes Yes N.a.

Additional materials necessary No – Foam FBS possible as Yes – Fire protection mass at Yes – Fire protection putty
combination least 20 mm deep at all line continuous with ducts
joints
Applicator gun for additional With commercially available Special applicator gun Special applicator gun
materials applicator gun necessary necessary
Expanding effect in a fire Yes Yes Yes
Coatability Yes - with plastic dispersion, No – being clarified! N.a.
epoxy resins, PU acryl, etc.
Mechanically durable Yes N.a. N.a.
fischerwerke Artur Fischer GmbH & Co. KG, Weinhalde 14 – 18, D - 72178 Waldachtal Page 9
System comparison of the features of ‘fischer FIRE STOP’ with competitor systems

Features of the systems fischer FIRE STOP Hilti Würth Henkel

C50/C51
System with name Foam firestop S30 - S90 CP 620 Fire protection foam 2K FP 500
(FBS) intumescent

Manufacturer of the product - ZZ Brandschutztechnik bio Brandschutz?

Other suppliers of the system - Promat bio Brandschutz OBO

Light partition walls (GK) Yes Yes Yes No

Minimum firestop thickness 75 mm / 200 mm 200 mm (S90) 150 mm wall / 200 mm ceiling 150 mm
Pipes in the firestop (wall/ceiling) no Yes – as combined firestop Yes – according to MLAR According to MLAR or with
additional measures!
Yield At 23°C, 1 litre with cartridge Up to 2.2 litres with 300 ml Up to 2 litres with 20°C With 300 ml cartridge up to 4
with 180 g (approx. 150 ml) cartridge cartridge 380 ml litres
Additional cable coating No No No Yes! – Tangit FP801
Ageing-resistance Yes Yes N.a. N.a.
Processing without flow and Yes Depending on application N.a. N.a.
without dripping speed!
Assembly time / processing time Reaction time 15 secs Depending on application Reaction time 10 secs Reaction time 6 mins
speed!
Applicator gun With commercially available Special applicator gun Special applicator gun Special applicator gun
applicator gun necessary necessary necessary
Expanding effect in a fire Without approval Without approval With approval Without approval
Waste-free processing Foam that has oozed out can Foam that has oozed out can Foam that has oozed out can Foam that has oozed out can
be reused be reused be reused be reused
Fibre-free material Free from fibres containing N.a. Free from fibres containing N.a.
minerals and asbestos minerals and even asbestos
fischerwerke Artur Fischer GmbH & Co. KG, Weinhalde 14 – 18, D - 72178 Waldachtal Page 10
System comparison of the features of ‘fischer FIRE STOP’ with competitor systems

Features of the systems fischer FIRE STOP Hilti Würth BC

T60
System with name
Fire protection sleeve R90 CP 644 Pipe partition M No own make! – 1. like
(FBM) Fischer, 2. like Würth!

Other suppliers of the system BC - Kuhn fischerwerke

Light partition walls (GK) Yes Yes Yes Yes

Assembly types (flush/surface mounted) surface mounted surface mounted (flush/surface mounted)
(inserted/mounted)
Closure of the sleeve Tension lock With fixation hook Fixation straps Tension lock

Pipe diameter from/to 32 - 200 mm 32 - 250 mm 32 - 200 mm 32 - 200 mm

Sound-damping inlay possible 4 mm soft foam strip supplied With Armaflex damping <=26 Synthetic rubber insulation can 4 mm soft foam strip supplied
mm possible as a damping be included
inlay