Sub-Plot 2
for
8 March 2018
Notice
This document and its contents have been prepared and are intended solely for WS Atkins & Partners
Overseas information and use in relation to Sub-plot 2 of the Yas Zone 1B development.
WS Atkins International Ltd assumes no responsibility to any other party in respect of or arising out of or in
connection with this document and/or its contents.
Document history
Job number: 5145326 Document ref: YAS-IB-ATK-AC-REP-00047
Revision Purpose description Originated Checked Reviewed Authorised Date
Rev 0 Issue SM CM DB IE 17/07/17
Rev 1 Updated Architectural SM CM DB IE 05/02/18
Section
Rev 2 Updated Façade Section SM CM DB IE 01/03/18
Rev 3 Minor changes SM CM DB IE 08/03/18
Document information
Revision no. 3
Document
YAS-IB-ATK-AC-REP-00047
reference
1.2. The project, Yas Zone 1B Plot 1 Residential Development is divided into 4 Sub Plots as shown in
the figure above and includes the following:
• Residential apartments.
Sub Plot 3:
• Residential apartments.
Sub Plot 4
• Mosque.
1.3. The intent of this report is such that should all design guidance and recommendations be followed
in this report, the design criteria outlined in Section 2 will be achieved.
1.4. The information and recommendations in this report are to be provided for the project and
coordinated with other design and construction disciplines. Where other documents may indicate
different approaches or treatments, the acoustic items and treatments in this report are to be priced
and provided for the project. A coordinated project approach will be documented by other design
1.5. Tender drawings and specifications of the development have been provided by Atkins Dubai
offices. Our review has been based upon the information and layouts shown in these drawings
dated January 2018.
1.6. This report is divided into several sections. Firstly, we outline the acoustic design criteria for the
project; then review the structural and architectural designs; and then we provide a review of
mechanical systems.
1.7. Specifications provided in this report primarily address acoustic performance for specific acoustic
materials and treatments. The specifications do not necessarily include all project general
conditions and requirements, and must be reviewed and modified as necessary to include project
specific general conditions and requirements.
1.8. General acoustic advice pertaining to the optimisation of sound insulation performance and general
detailing considerations are provided within the report. The various acoustic indices referred to in
this report are described in Appendix A.
2.2. Aldar Properties PJSC Apartment Design Guidelines Part 2 – Layout Principles (Section 2.4.17)
define the acoustic requirements for new developments. The design criteria are stated below for
the targeted Bronze standard.
2.3. Please note that Estidama Pearl ratings are being targeted for the development however only
mandatory credits have been sought. Therefore, the design criteria stated within Estidama LBi-9
Indoor Noise Pollution are not compulsory, though certain elements of the LBi9 design criteria have
been targeted e.g. indoor ambient noise levels.
2.5. The noise levels in the table refer to repeatable maximum internal noise levels measured during
the nominated period of the day over a 1 hour measurement interval. Areas not listed in the table
below shall be designed to comply with the relevant recommended design sound level as detailed
International standard ISO 91.120.20: Acoustics in building: Sound insulation. Where Estidama
Credit LBi-9: Indoor Noise Pollution is not required the below standard shall be followed:
BRONZE
Space Maximum Internal Noise level
Bedroom 40 dB LAeq (9 hour)
Living, dining rooms 45 dB LAeq (9 hour)
Acoustic Separation
2.6. For airborne sound insulation (i.e. resistance to the transmission of speech, music noise, television
noise etc.) the minimum acceptable level of sound insulation performance required by Aldar is
quoted in terms of a laboratory rated performance criterion (Rw) plus spectrum adaptation term
(Ctr).
2.7. The partition constructions and surrounding details with which to achieve the above performance
requirements are discussed in upcoming sections of this report.
2.9. The Aldar requirements are stated using the LAeq descriptor, however background noise from
mechanical plant is usually stated as a Noise Rating (NR) level. As a guide, the equivalent NR
level can be obtained by the following equation: NR = LAeq – 6.
2.10. Unless stated otherwise, the noise level criteria shall not be exceeded with the plant operating
under normal operating conditions, and at start-up for intermittently operating plant items. Tactile
structural vibration levels produced by plant shall not exceed the criteria given in ASHRAE NRC
and ISO 140-3 standards.
Interior Acoustics
2.12. The Aldar Apartment Design Guidelines do not include design criteria for the control of
reverberation within public areas. However, given entrance lobbies will be transient spaces, we
only envisage control of reverberation to be required within apartment corridors and stairwells.
2.14. Note that internal acoustics within apartments will be under the remit of the owner/ occupier and
will depend on how they wish to furnish their apartment.
Apartment Ceilings
2.17. The following list describes the minimum sound insulation(Rw) ratings for the separation of
waste/supply/storm water pipework traversing across apartments.
2.18. All ceiling systems are to comply with the Aldar requirements unless higher standard of treatment
is defined within the Abu Dhabi Municipality, International Building Code or service provider
applicable regulation.
Note* This rating may be achieved by constructing bulk heads locally or externally lagging
waste/storm water/supply pipework within the ceiling.
2.19. Acoustically certified access panels to equal the acoustic performance of the element in which they
are installed must be used. Typically, this will require the use of 25 dB Rw + Ctr access panels.
Access panels for waste piping shall not be located on the sides of risers facing habitable rooms.
2.22. Noise generated by rainfall on lightweight elements of the façade (excluding glazing) should be
minimised by effective damping of the outer skin.
2.23. Air movement across the façade shall not cause audible rattling, whistling or other attention-
catching noise inside or outside the building.
3.2. Special care must be taken by the contractor in acoustically sensitive areas, that is, where a high
degree of sound insulation or a low background noise level is required, or where special acoustic
treatment is installed.
3.3. The correct acoustic performance of the various completed buildings is essential to the future
success of the development. If specified acoustic criteria are not achieved, remedial work would
be necessary.
3.4. The criteria are concerned mainly with sound insulation between rooms and sound absorption and
distribution within rooms. Notwithstanding the generality of the requirement for a high standard of
workmanship, particular reference is made to the following:
Sound Insulation
3.5. Sound insulation between rooms is dependent mainly on the weight of the separating floors,
ceilings, walls, windows and doors and the degree to which they are sealed airtight.
3.6. It is essential, therefore, that blockwork is of the specified weight per unit area, mortar is continuous
throughout the thickness of the walls and that no gaps occur where walls meet other walls, the
structural soffit, or joinery work at windows and doors.
3.7. Where a mastic seal is specified, this should be continuous and completely airtight.
3.8. The fitting of doors in frames must be carried out with care, in accordance with the specified
tolerances. Any acoustic seals will need to be carefully adjusted so that the door installation is
airtight.
3.9. Service penetrations (ducts, pipes, conduits and trunking) through walls, floors and ceilings of
acoustically sensitive areas, must be carefully sealed in accordance with the details. No other holes
or chases are permitted without permission from a WS Atkins or Client representative.
• The weights, thicknesses and homogeneity of mineral wool and other acoustically
absorbent materials.
• The dimensions and relative positions of air spaces, mineral wool and all other materials.
3.13. During construction, it shall be ensured that building debris does not cause bridging of the isolation
boundaries. Measures shall be taken to prevent building debris entering wall, floor and ceiling
cavities, and soft joints. If it occurs, the cavities shall be immediately and thoroughly cleared of
debris.
Services Penetrations
3.14. Penetrations through building elements shall be sealed to ensure that the sound insulation and
noise criteria performance requirements of this document are not compromised. Refer to Appendix
C for typical details for sealing services penetrations.
3.16. Holes made in building elements shall be made good. This shall be done by filling or covering the
hole with a material of the same mass per unit area as the building element through which the hole
has been made, using a method that ensures that no material can fall into cavities or bridge
isolation boundaries.
Access Panels
3.17. Where access needs to be provided through a building element (e.g. for servicing or maintenance
purposes) access panels shall be provided.
3.18. Access panels shall be constructed in such a way that the sound insulation performance and noise
criteria requirements listed within this document are not compromised when the access panel is
closed. This will generally be achieved by ensuring that the access panel is of the same mass per
unit area as the building element through which access is being provided and that the access panel
is properly sealed around its full perimeter when closed.
Noise Generation
3.19. Ensure that all building elements are designed, constructed and installed in such a way that they
do not generate audible noises including (but not limited to) rattles, hums, buzzes, or creaks, during
normal use of the building, including (but not limited to) the following circumstances:
• When the building element is exposed to airflow from ventilation systems or winds;
• When loads and forces (within design tolerances) are applied to the building element;
Design Life
3.20. All building elements shall be designed, constructed and installed such that they meet the acoustic
performance requirements for at least as long as the design life of the building.
COSHH Regulations
3.22. Provide evidence of compliance with the CONTROL OF SUBSTANCES HAZARDOUS TO
HEALTH Regulations 2002 on demand including evidence of assessment and competence of
assessor(s).
3.23. Directive 2003/ 10/EC on the minimum health and safety requirements regarding exposure of
workers to the risks arising from physical agents (noise) requires:
The maximum noise level in all spaces, including plant rooms, shall where possible be no more
than 80 dB(A). In locations where this is not possible, the contractor shall obtain approval from a
WS Atkins or Client representative.
Where the noise level in any space exceeds the first action level of Directive 2003/10/EC, the
contractor shall carry out all work (including noise assessments) and supply all equipment required
to comply with the Directive 2003/10/EC.
4.2. The data obtained from the baseline noise survey was then utilised to inform the acoustic design
of the building façades in the development, and in this case Sub Plot 2. From the obtained dataset,
representative noise levels likely to be incident upon the building façades have been derived and
are presented in the table below. The figures shown in the table below include a +3 dB façade
correction.
Glazing Requirements
4.3. To determine the minimum sound insulation performance required of glazed façade elements for
compliance with the design criteria, noise intrusion calculations were carried out in accordance with
BS EN 12354:2017 ‘Building acoustics - Estimation of acoustic performance of buildings from the
performance of elements’ within the frequency range of 125 Hz to 4000 Hz.
4.4. The assessment was undertaken based upon the proposed façade design, glazing extents and
internal layouts. A reverberation time of 0.5 seconds was assumed within all spaces. The
calculations undertaken expected the ventilation strategy in all habitable spaces to be fully
mechanical with no operable windows required for the provision of adequate ventilation, and with
no untreated penetrations in the building façade.
4.5. The Aldar standard requires the selected glazing system to reduce noise to the following internal
levels: Bedroom 40 dB LAeq (9 hour); Living/Dining Room 45 dB LAeq (9 hour). However due to the high
impulsive type noise levels experienced at the site (up to 89 dB L AFmax), our study showed that
should glazing be installed that would achieve the Aldar LAeq standards, this would allow
excessively high noise levels inside the apartments i.e. over 50 dB LAFmax.
4.6. Note that during the noise survey we observed aircraft passing overhead approximately every two
minutes between 02:00 and 04:00 hours. Noise levels this intense, and being so frequent, would
be expected to cause sleep disturbance to apartment occupants.
4.7. Therefore, to try and protect residential amenity it is recommended that the more onerous Estidama
LBi-9 Indoor Noise criteria be targeted. The Estidama LBi-9 criteria state that internal ambient noise
levels should not exceed 40 dB LAeq,T in all spaces, plus during the hours of 23:00 to 07:00 internal
ambient noise levels within bedrooms should be less than 35 dB LAeq (8 hour), and critically, that
discrete impulsive noise events not exceed of 45 dB L AFmax.
4.8. A number of glazing options have been assessed. To achieve the recommended indoor noise level
within bedrooms, glazed areas of the façade should achieve the following acoustic performance to
minimise the risk of sleep disturbance during discrete noise events:
Frequency (Hz)
dB Rw (C;Ctr)
125 250 500 1000 2000 4000
27 30 39 47 47 46 46 (-2;-5)
4.9. For all other living spaces, the following glazing specification has been proposed. This is likely to
achieve an indoor ambient level of less than 35 dB LAeq,T in all residential areas.
Frequency (Hz)
dB Rw (C;Ctr)
125 250 500 1000 2000 4000
27 24 31 39 43 42 40 (-3;-7)
4.10. Acoustic performance will be severely diminished when windows are open, therefore adequate
ventilation will be provided via mechanical means. No untreated openings for building services will
be present in the façade.
4.11. To meet the recommended internal noise level targets stated above, the 300mm thick Super Eco
Block façade construction will be required to achieve a minimum sound insulation performance of
45 dB Rw+Ctr. Prior to installation the acoustic performance of all façade elements should be
verified via laboratory test data acquired in accordance with international standards and guidance.
5.2. A heavy slab alone, however, is not necessarily sufficient to control impact noise and structure-
borne noise sources which travel easily through solid concrete. All rotating equipment in the
building will also require vibration isolation. These issues are discussed later in the report.
Core Walls
5.3. Core walls and elevator wall constructions will be poured-in-place concrete. Concrete core walls
are the best possible wall construction for sound separation and minimising vibration. This does
not preclude structure-borne noise from transmitting, however, so precautions against transmission
of elevator rail noise will still apply. This issue is discussed in more detail later in the report.
Expansion Joints
5.4. Expansion joints will be installed at regular intervals throughout the building to safely absorb the
heat-induced expansion and contraction of construction materials; to absorb vibration; to hold parts
together; or to allow movement due to ground settlement (and in some regions earthquakes).
5.5. We have reviewed the location of expansion joints and we do not expect any problems or concerns.
6.2. We have carried out a detailed review of the Tender Design drawings and discussed individual
instances with the design team. The following have been understood:
• An independent wall lining with single layer 15mm gypsum board has been incorporated in the
design of the partitions separating apartments elevator shafts on the habitable side of the
partition. This will aid in suitably mitigate against the majority of airborne noise events (i.e.
elevator pass-bys, garbage trolleys movements). The detail below shows the design intent of
wall Type WL-09.
6.4. Please note that all acoustically rated walls must be constructed full height to achieve the desired
acoustic ratings.
WL-02
200mm thick dense solid block (1840
kg/m3 minimum density), 15mm 50 dB Rw
Demising walls
cement/sand plaster on both sides
(10 kg/m2 minimum mass per unit
area)
Internal partitions
WL-03
Service Risers 36 dB Rw
100mm thick aerated concrete block
(for electrical
(minimum density 576 kg/m3)
equipment only)
WL-05
36 dB Rw
Unipod Walls 12.5mm plasterboard on each side of
a metal C stud.
WL-09
Corridor Walls 200mm thick hollow block (1,375 50 dB Rw
kg/m3 minimum density)
• All masonry blocks must extend to the full length and height of the wall;
• Ensure that all masonry joints are completely filled and sealed with mortar;
• Ensure block walls have narrow perpends;
• External cavity walls should be stopped with a flexible closer at the junction with a separating
wall, unless the cavity is fully filled with mineral wool/quilt;
• Electrical sockets for adjacent rooms are to be positioned minimum 60cm apart;
• Provide continuous acoustic (non-hardening) caulking beads on each side of the top of the
partition. Between the caulking on each side, pack space with fiberglass batt insulation;
• Acoustic caulking should be used to close gaps between service outlets (electrical, telephone,
data, etc.) and drywall;
• Penetrations through the partitions (ducts, pipes, conduit, cable trays, etc.) will be handled per
the typical details provided in the architectural package.
6.7. Block partition constructions must be acoustically sealed at the termination conditions (vertically
and horizontally). To maintain an acoustic seal, compressible filler or insulation and acoustic
sealant are to be provided at the termination condition. Sketch details illustrating this and other
conditions described above are provided in Appendix C.
6.9. The techniques available for increasing the airborne sound insulation performance of a wall or floor
typically obey a law of diminishing returns. For example, the performance of a plasterboard wall is
only improved by 3 dB to 5 dB for each doubling of mass or density. Employing double leaf
constructions (e.g. independent plasterboard linings on masonry walls) goes some way to alleviate
this issue although flanking sound transmission and build quality typically represent the limiting
factors when high levels of performance are required (i.e. > 55 dB Rw). Achieving an increase of
5 dB in the acoustic performance of a 35 dB Rw wall is therefore considerably more practicable
than realizing a 5 dB improvement for a wall that already exhibits a performance of 55 dB Rw, since
heavy wall and ceiling linings will be required for the latter.
6.12. At Yas Zone 1B there are no common mullions or transoms spanning between adjacent spaces,
hence flanking noise transmission via these junctions is not a cause for concern.
6.14. A floor underlayment typically sits between the structural slab and the levelling screed. Including
the resilient layer beneath all hard floor surfaces would provide a useful structural break within the
floor build-up, thereby reducing the effects of heel drop, chair scrapes etc. from the vertically
adjacent apartment above. Omission of the underlayment could lead to complaints from residents
due to structure borne sound travelling into apartments below.
Doors
6.15. The main factors determining the sound insulation of a door are the mass of the door and the gaps
around the edges, usually the latter are critical. For good sound insulation, the door should form
airtight joints with the frame when closed, and the joints between frame and wall should be sealed.
A threshold seal is essential and even keyhole covers should be specified in critical situations.
6.16. Single door sets providing a sound insulation value greater than 35 dB R w are specialist products
and would normally be shipped as a single complete unit.
6.17. To assist in reducing noise transmission from corridors (voices, heel drop etc.) through doors into
apartments, Aldar require a minimum 25 dB D nT,w + Ctr rating. A sample entrance door specification
to achieve this rating is provided in the table below.
Location Comment
Solid timber, 44mm thick, minimum mass per unit area
Door
27kg/m2
Jamb and Head Low profile neoprene bubble seal.
6.18. To help reduce the level of noise break-out from mechanical rooms Aldar require a minimum 30dB
Rw acoustic rating. A sample entrance door specification to achieve this rating is provided in the
table below.
Location Comment
Door & Frame (single unit) 16 gauge door & frame; Vertically stiffened with
insulation fill; welded construction.
Interior Finishes
6.19. Reverberation is the continuation of sound in an enclosed space after the initial sound source has
ended. Reverberation Time (RT60) is the time in seconds that sound takes to decay 60dB from its
original level and is typically stated for the 500Hz octave band frequency – where human speech
is concentrated. Decay times in other frequencies are important and should be considered as well.
6.20. Generally speaking, the larger the amount of hard and reflective surfaces within a space, the longer
a sound will reverberate. Longer reverberation times will interfere with speech intelligibility,
increase background noise and create a less comfortable aural environment.
6.21. The enclosed public spaces within Sub-Plot 2 will have mainly hard and acoustically reflective
finishes. The spaces will have a light and airy feel and so a degree of reverberation is to be
expected. Lobbies have been designed to be transient spaces hence we do not envisage any
acoustical concerns with the proposed selection of finishes.
6.22. Although the Aldar guidelines do not include requirements for reverberation control within public
areas, it has been recommended to include provision for acoustically absorptive treatment within
public corridors leading to apartments to prevent reverberant sound built-up.
6.23. We would recommend to install an area equal or greater than the floor area of the corridors with a
Class C absorber (as defined in BS EN ISO 11654:1997) 1. A suitable absorber would typically be
a standard lay-in grid suspended ceiling containing fibrous ‘acoustic’ tiles (e.g. Ecophon Focus).
1
As per Approved Document E of the UK Building Regulations 2010
7.2. At the time of report production many of the mechanical system designs were not in a suitable level
for our review. The drawings provided having a general lack of detail such as ‘floating’ ducts, units
sitting in isolation, rooms not being served, and equipment not being labelled.
7.3. The selected Contractor must complete an acoustic review of all systems (FCU’s are very
important) in accordance with the specifications so the appropriate attenuators are selected and
the stipulated internal noise design criteria will be achieved. A sample sound attenuator
specification has been provided in Appendix D.
7.4. Please note, during the final equipment selection process the stated manufacturer noise data for
all mechanical equipment must be verified by the contractor using independent laboratory test data.
7.6. The design target will be exceeded whenever an aircraft passes overhead, however there is
nothing we can do to reduce this exceedance during fly-bys.
7.7. The transfer of noise from basement building service rooms to nearby amenity areas e.g. balconies
via louvered shafts should be controlled through the provision appropriate attenuation to
atmospheric connections of all noisy plant terminating at air plenums. It is noted that in-duct
attenuators are proposed. For the purposes of engaging with manufacturers for selection of
suitable attenuators, a target of NR 71 should be applied at each louvre. Where multiple
connections terminate at the louvre, this target should be reduced logarithmically (i.e. NR Target -
10 x log10 (n); where n = number of terminations).
7.10. Fan and turbulence noise “breaking out” of sheet metal ductwork is the major noise control
challenge in most cases, and is usually heard as a low-frequency rumbling in the vicinity of the
noise sensitive space near the air handling unit or its associated return fan. The degree to which
sound “breaks out” of the sheet metal ductwork is governed primarily by:
7.11. Typically the quality and reliability of acoustic lining in shop fabricated or field fabricated ductwork
in the Middle East is questionable. It is also true that acoustically lined ductwork exposed to the
elements prior to installation may be ruined. As delamination of internal duct liner is extremely
disruptive and expensive to fix, this may well outweigh the acoustic benefit.
7.12. Furthermore, AHU/FAHU’s serving acoustically sensitive spaces are recommended to include the
following noise and vibration control considerations:
• Select the largest, lowest speed, "quietest" fans possible within mechanical and physical
constraints. A plug/plenum type fan selection is recommended if possible.
• Provide 50 to 100mm thick double-wall perforated casing panels to minimise radiated noise.
Plastic liner behind the perforated metal can be used if desired for reasons other than noise
control.
• Variable speed to ensure the lowest sound output at any given time.
7.13. All AHU/FAHU units must be fully vibration isolated for the structure. This can be achieved by:
• Either mounting the units on 100mm deep housekeeping pad supported by spring type
isolators (see vibration table for guideline static deflection). Should this option be selected, the
manufacturer provided internal deflection spring mounts must be locked down to prevent
oscillation effects.
• Or, mount the units on 100mm deep housekeeping pad supported by 20mm thick neoprene
isolation pads sized for 3mm static deflection. Unlock manufacturer provided internal 50mm
deflection spring mounts for fans. In our experience this is the most common vibration isolation
method for AHU/FAHU’s in the Middle East.
7.15. In our experience, the best option is to select these units to provide sufficient cooling load at
medium or low speed fan operation. We also recommend that each FCU have at least 3-4 metres
of acoustically lined ductwork on the intake and supply side of the units to allow the fan noise to be
attenuated before entering the living spaces. Once we receive manufacturer’s sound level
information, we will make a detailed review and provide further comments and recommendations.
7.16. Initial recommendations and allowances for the units shall include the following:
Access Panels
7.17. To minimize noise transmission through the access panel into the space below, a sealed access
panel with recessed gypsum board should be installed underneath e.g. fan coil units.
7.19. Discharge noise control for pressure reducing boxes/valves can be handled with:
7.20. Acoustic duct lining and/or minimum 1.5m of lightweight flex are typically the most cost effective
approaches. A typical approach is as follows:
7.22. Perforated and plaque faced diffusers are extremely sensitive to inlet air velocities profiles. A slight
increase in air flow on one side of the diffuser, due to an elbow at the inlet for example, can cause
the diffuser sound to be well above the published levels. Therefore, perforated and plaque faced
diffusers should be selected 10 NR points below room design goals.
7.24. We provide the following general guidance to minimise audible impact on adjacent spaces:
• Use utility set fans only (no mushroom fans). Select fans for low rpm operation (typically 800
rpm or lower).
• Provide the following minimum ductwork lengths above the roof for fans that penetrate the roof
above residential units, based on fan static pressures of under 2 inches e.g.:
• Under 58 m/s: 3 metres
• 58 m/s to 145 m/s: 4.5 metres
• 145 m/s to 290 m/s: 6 metres
7.26. The basement fan rooms will be connected to the external ground floor via a louvered shaft. The
intake and extract points on the ground floor will be integrated within the landscaping. Please refer
to the external amenity noise criteria section for further advice and recommended noise limits for
louvered shaft atmospheric connections.
7.28. Acoustic lining is the usual method for controlling cross-talk (such as an acoustically lined duct 1.5
metres long with 12mm thick acoustic lining, preferably with an elbow used at all taps off risers).
However as mentioned earlier, in the Middle East this method is sometimes deemed unacceptable.
The alternative would be to provide upturned sheet-metal boots in the riser as shown below.
Pumps
7.31. Primary and secondary pumps should have the following considerations for noise and vibration
control:
Plumbing
7.32. General noise control guidelines for plumbing are as follows:
• Resilient piping attachments are recommended to isolate supply plumbing from the structure
(refer to Vibration Isolation schedule later in this section). This is particularly important for
plumbing near noise-sensitive spaces.
• Limit pressure at fixtures to 380 kPa (55 psig) to reduce noise generation.
• Pipes and conduit should not pass through sensitive spaces to service other spaces.
• Toilet rooms should be away from sensitive spaces. Do not put plumbing in walls next to or
common with these spaces.
• Specify quiet devices such as quiet-type, flush valves and taps with full-ported nozzles and
non-splash aerators. If toilet rooms are unavoidably next to sensitive spaces, use siphon-jet,
tank-type water closets with adjustable flow valves.
• Install air chambers or shock-absorbing devices to prevent water hammer in lines subject to
abrupt shut-off.
• Sprinkler piping should be routed along corridors with a single airtight penetration into each
room.
Generators
7.35. The emergency generator for Sub-Plot 2 will be located in a separate building that will have natural
ventilation. The diesel generator will be used for emergency power / life safety purposes only,
therefore noise from regular generator testing is not anticipated to be a major issue with proper
scheduling.
7.36. To minimise noise impact within the building and nearby buildings during testing it is recommended
that the generators be tested during the daytime/weekday hours only (or times deemed appropriate
by building management). The following measures provide our guidance for generators:
• Each generator is to be fully vibration isolated from the structure by mounting on spring type
isolators sized for nominal 25mm static deflection;
• Provide sound attenuators within the generator rooms’ intake and discharge air paths. Sound
attenuators in the 1.5 +/- meter length are typically used in this application. Attenuators to be
sized for a maximum discharge velocity of 4 m/s. Mechanical engineer to review for static
pressure drop consideration;
• Provide a ‘Critical’ grade (25-35 dB(A) reduction) hot exhaust muffler to be connected into the
exhaust air transition duct. The muffler is to be standard barrel or ‘cigar-shaped’ type (space-
saving flat ‘pancake’ type mufflers are typically not effective and should be avoided). Note:
when ordering, these mufflers tend to have a very long lead-time.
• To minimize reverberant noise build-up in the Generator Room, all available/exposed room
walls should be lined with 50mm thick acoustic duct-liner.
7.37. The above must be reviewed and coordinated based on community noise requirements (including
any specific to generator testing or emergency noise requirements) and generator hot gas
discharge and air intake/discharge paths with consideration of potential exposures.
• Mount the main transformer cores on 50mm deflection spring mounts with double layer noise
isolation neoprene pads.
• If springs are to be provided for internal core, mount the entire transformer on uniformly loaded
2.5mm deflection waffle or ribbed neoprene pads.
• Provide transformers with special core metal for quieter operation. Transformers are to be
specified as 6 dB below National Electrical Manufacturers Association (NEMA) ratings.
• Resiliently suspend or mount conduits and/or bus-bar. Flexible and/or expansion sections
within the conduit and/or bus-bar must also be provided. The flexible connection and resilient
hanger application is to be as follows:
• Provide 600mm of flexible conduit connected to the switchgear, and/or provide a bus-bar
expansion coupling. A "rubberized" expansion coupling within the conduit is an acceptable
alternate.
• Suspend conduct and/or bus-bar within the electrical room, but not less than 15 metres
from the equipment, by double-deflection neoprene isolation hangers with a nominal 12mm
deflection.
7.39. Applicable codes and regulations for conduit and bus-bar suspension details are to be verified.
Seismic restrained shall also be reviewed and incorporated as necessary, though must be provided
as not to degrade the noise and vibration isolation of mounts and hangers.
7.40. The above acoustic performance should be added to the appropriate specifications section.
• Suspended units are to be hung from double deflection neoprene isolation hangers with 12mm
deflection;
• Floor mounted units are to be mounted on double deflection neoprene isolation mounts with
12mm deflection;
• Flexible conduit is to be minimum 450mm long.
Seismic Restraint
7.42. Seismic restraints for internal core and/or entire transformer are to be provided as necessary to
comply with local codes and/or project requirements. Restraints are to be separate of noise and
vibration isolation and shall not degrade isolation efficiency.
Vibration Isolation
7.43. Noise and vibration energy from mechanical equipment could carry through the building structure
and transmit into adjacent spaces. Therefore all vibration/rotating machinery should be isolated
from the structure with some type of a spring and/or neoprene isolators.
7.44. The table below illustrates the typical vibration isolation required for mechanical and electrical
equipment. This table is intended to act as a guide at this stage to assist with the appropriate
selection of isolators.
Static
Base Isolator
Deflection
Equipment Types Type Type
(mm)
Fans (including AHU, ERU & FCU)
Floor/Roof Supported Per Mfr (7) Spring
below - 300 rpm (or VFD) 100
301 - 450 rpm 75
451 - 600 rpm 85
601 - 750 rpm 50
751 - 850 rpm 35
851 - greater 25
Suspended Sprg/Neop (above+6)
Condensate Pumps Per Mfr Neoprene 3
Dry coolers, Air-Cooled Condenser, Air- Per Mfr Restrained. 50
Cooled Chillers, Air-Cooled Equipment Spring (1)
Mechanical and Domestic Pumps (8) 50
3HP - greater Conc. Iner. Spring
less than 3HP Steel Neoprene 12
Associated equipment per Mfr. (1) (1)
(assoc. w/ pumps & piping)
Cooling Towers
below - 300 rpm (or VFD) per Mfr. Restr. Spring 100
301 - 500 rpm 75
501 - 800 rpm 50
801 - -greater 25
Hot Water Generators, Boilers per Mfr. Restr. Spring 25
Mechanical and Domestic Piping (3) as req’d
Floor Supported Spring 25
Suspended Sprg/Neop 30
Steam Neoprene 8
Curb Mounted Roof Equip. Spring isolation curb per fans above
Generators(2) per Mfr. Restr. Spring 25
Transformers (Interior Dry Type)
Floor Mounted (4) per Mfr Neoprene 12
Suspended per Mfr Neoprene 12
(1) Double layer noise isolation pads to be provided within spring assembly.
(2) Manufacturer’s standard springs
(3) All water and steam piping within MER, but not less than 20 metres of equipment or pressure
reducing stations, and all piping 100mm and larger within and/or suspended from occupied floor.
(4) Internal isolation for transformer cores complying with the above tabulated isolation type and
ratings are acceptable.
(5) Seismic restraints as required for project are to be separate of vibration isolation devices, and
shall not degrade vibration isolation. Extent and type of seismic restraints by others.
(7) Vibration isolation scheme to consider fan operating force and provide thrust restraint and/or
concrete inertia base in order to limit movement of fan to 7mm at any operating point. Thrust
restraints to have the same deflection as vibration isolation devices.
(8) In-line pumps to be mounted per manufacturer’s recommendations.
8.2. When operating per plans and specifications, the Aldar standards state elevator equipment should
not generate noise levels in excess of NR 30 in bedrooms and NR 35 in living spaces. We
recommend that noise emissions do not include tonal elements. For the purpose of this report, a
pure tone shall be defined as a sound level in any one-third-octave band, which is greater than 5
dB above both adjacent one-third-octave bands, in the range 45 to 16,000 Hz.
8.3. All traction elevator equipment should conform to the following requirements for noise and vibration
control:
• The hoist and sheaves (primary and secondary/deflector) are to be mounted to a single unitized
structural base which is resiliently isolated from the building structure. The resilient mounts
supporting the base shall be the most effective isolation system provided by the elevator
manufacturer, but should typically not be less than 25mm effective thickness (either single
thickness or layered) neoprene or natural rubber pads and shall provide 2.5mm static
deflection (or 10% strain) under installed loading conditions. Final pad thickness decided by
the elevator manufacturer based on their type of machine, weight of machine, placing of
machine etc.
• Mount the motor generators on the most effective isolation system available from the elevator
manufacturer, but typically not less than neoprene-in-shear double deflection mounts with
minimum 13mm static deflection. Final pad thickness decided by the elevator manufacturer
based on their type of machine, weight of machine, placing of machine etc.
• Mount control unit(s) on the most effective isolation system available from the elevator
manufacturer, such as minimum 19mm thick ribbed or waffled neoprene pads uniformly loaded
to achieve 2.5mm deflection (e.g., Mason Industries type 'Super W', 50 durometer pads
uniformly loaded at 310 kPa). Provide a top bearing plate where necessary to uniformly
distribute load. Final type / size / material of isolation pads will be decided by the elevator
manufacturer based of the weight and size of controllers.
• Provide an electrical filter/reactor between electric controls and the hoist motor. Mount the
reactor on the most effective isolation provided by the manufacturer, but not less than 19mm
thick ribbed or waffled neoprene pads uniformly loaded to achieve 2.5mm deflection.
• All bolts through isolation pads shall use resilient washers and bushings, with a minimum wall
thickness of 6mm, such there is no rigid contact between the isolated base and the securing
bolt.
• Double-roped systems shall terminate ropes on the unitized resiliently mounted base of the
machine.
• Ropes shall in no case terminate at un-isolated connections to the building structure.
• The rollers which guide cars and counterweights along the guide rails shall have a minimum
diameter of 150mm and shall have solid neoprene or rubber tires. Tensioned steel springs
shall be incorporated to maintain a constant force between the rollers and the guide rails. No
part of the elevator mechanism shall have sliding contact with rails.
• Braking action at the hoist shall be gradual, using fluid damping, so that the application of the
brakes does not generate an impact when the brake shoes contact the drum. Set by local
design Code requirements.
• Guide rails and rollers are to be installed to the most exacting vertical alignment tolerances
possible, but no greater than 1.14mm per 30 meter distance. Set using local design Code
requirements.
• The maximum noise level within the lift car during operation shall be 55 dB(A). The Vertical
Transportation – Elevator Specifications document produced by RBA Consultants, dated
19/06/2017, states that the car interior noise levels during operation shall not exceed 52dBA
8.4. Furthermore, lift call bells and lobby noise levels shall be controlled so as not to be heard within
apartments. It is standard practice that when a lift arrives at a floor a bell or auditory call signal is
activated to let the waiting passenger know of the lifts arrival. This type of lift call system can be
highly annoying for apartments located near the lifts if audible, therefore auditory lift call systems
must be low in volume and dull in nature.
END OF REPORT
Decibel, dB
A sound wave is a small fluctuation of atmospheric pressure. The human ear responds to these variations in
pressure, producing the sensation of hearing. The ear can detect a very wide range of pressure variations.
In order to cope with this wide range of pressure variations, a logarithmic scale is used to convert the values
into manageable numbers. Although it might seem unusual to use a logarithmic scale to measure a physical
phenomenon, it has been found that human hearing also responds to sound in an approximately logarithmic
fashion. The dB (decibel) is the logarithmic unit used to describe sound (or noise) levels. The usual range
of sound pressure levels is from 0 dB (threshold of hearing) to 120 dB (threshold of pain).
Due to the logarithmic nature of decibels, when two noises of the same level are combined together, the total
noise level is (under normal circumstances) 3 dB(A) higher than each of the individual noise levels e.g. 60
dB(A) plus 60 dB(A) = 63dB(A). In terms of perceived 'loudness', a 3 dB(A) variation in noise level is a
relatively small (but nevertheless just noticeable) change. An increase in noise level of 10 dB(A) generally
corresponds to a doubling of perceived loudness. Likewise, a reduction in noise level of 10 dB(A) generally
corresponds to a halving of perceived loudness.
Noise Rating, NR
Noise Rating values refer to a set of pre-defined curves which specify noise levels in individual octave
bands. The NR value is a single figure descriptor that was developed to assess acoustic comfort in buildings
and is now commonly used to specify building services noise limits. The lower the NR rating, the lower the
noise levels from building services.
Reverberation Time, RT
The RT is defined as the time taken for an impulsive sound to die away to one thousandth of its original
sound pressure level - that is, to decrease by 60dB. The sound waves are reflected many times from each
surface in the room, and are partly reduced at each reflection, the amount of reduction depending on the
acoustic absorption of the surface. Acoustic absorption is measurable and is defined by a coefficient
between 0 (totally reflective) and 1 (totally absorbent) at each frequency. Although an anomaly in the
standard laboratory test procedure can lead to absorption coefficients higher than 1, this is not achievable in
real installations.
simon.moyes@atkinsglobal.com
+44 (0)1925 238000