13:00:00
The current time is:
13:01:13
Central Daylight Time
UTC-5
• Stacey Blodgett
stacey.blodgett@bayesia.us
BayesiaLab.com 2
Today’s Objectives
Methodological Objective
• Bayesian networks as a framework for reasoning about health policies
under uncertainty.
stefan.conrady@bayesia.us 3
Today’s Agenda
Motivation & Background
• Over- and Undertreatment Malaria and Pneumonia
• Testing Innovations & WHO Guidelines
30 min.
Methodology
• Knowledge Modeling & Reasoning with Bayesian Networks
Research Workflow
• Encode Domain Knowledge in Bayesian Network
• Elicit Probabilities 30 min.
• Assess Costs and Utilities
• Search for Optimal Policies
stefan.conrady@bayesia.us 4
Teaching Edition
Academic Edition
Desktop BayesiaLab 6
Bayesia Market
Simulator
Code Export Module
Software
Professional
BayesiaLab
WebSimulator
Web
Application Bayesia Expert
Knowledge Elicitation
Environment
(BEKEE)
BayesiaLab.com 5
Webinar Slides & Recording Available
stefan.conrady@bayesia.us 6
Motivation & Background
Malaria Testing
?
BayesiaLab.com 7
Optimizing Health Policies
Caveat
• The medical subject matter presented in this webinar is
strictly for methodological illustration purposes.
• Today’s particular problem domain of infectious disease
diagnosis is merely a prototypical example diagnostic
inference.
• Also, the subject matter is presented in a highly
simplified format. This is by no means an exhaustive
treatment of the topic.
• No part of this webinar should be interpreted as medical
research or a health policy recommendation.
stefan.conrady@bayesia.us 8
Motivation & Background
Infectious Diseases in Sub-Saharan Africa
BayesiaLab.com 10
Malaria Diagnosis in the Developed World
Microscopic Diagnosis
BayesiaLab.com 11
Past Practice in Developing Nations
Diagnostic Approach:
• Fever " Malaria
“Presumptive Treatment”
• Result:
• Overtreatment of
malaria
• Undertreatment of
bacterial infections,
e.g. pneumonia
BayesiaLab.com 12
Rapid Diagnostic Test for Malaria
• “…in all settings, clinical suspicion
of malaria should be confirmed with
a parasitological diagnosis“
Source: WHO: Guidelines for the treatment of
malaria (2e). Geneva: World Health
Organisation, 2010.
• Result:
• 200,000 Rapid Diagnostic Tests
(RDT) distributed in 2005
• 50 million in 2010
BayesiaLab.com 13
BayesiaLab.com 14
Unintended Consequences
• “The researchers found that after the rapid diagnostic test ruled out malaria,
many patients were prescribed antibiotics — in effect, trading the overuse of
anti-malarial drugs for the overuse of antibiotics.”
• “‘If you’re in a remote area and you don’t have a lot of other options — you’ve
got a sick child or a sick patient in front of you, that person may have come
from even up to 20 kilometers away with expensive transport or even walking
— you want to do something,’ Hopkins says. ‘And if you don’t feel like you
should give an anti-malarial — the test is negative — your alternative, in some
cases, is an antibiotic.’”
Source: PRI Interview, October 15, 2017, https://www.pri.org/stories/2017-10-15/quick-and-easy-
malaria-tests-some-unexpected-drawbacks
BayesiaLab.com 15
Probabilistic Reasoning
Human
reasoning
is flawed!
BayesiaLab.com 16
Probabilistic Reasoning
Human Cognitive Limitations and Biases Under Uncertainty
Remember?
Disease Test
FALLACIES
Webinar on March 2
Human Reasoning ≠ Normative Reasoning
BayesiaLab.com 17
Probabilistic Reasoning
“Treat for pneumonia” “Don’t treat for malaria”
Reasoning about an individual case:
“Explaining
Away”
= True = Negative
BayesiaLab.com 18
Probabilistic Reasoning
Why Not?
• The probability of pneumonia
given a negative malaria test 50% Probability of Pneumonia
result depends on:
• Prevalence of pneumonia
• Sensitivity & Specificity
of RDT
• Prevalence of malaria Malaria Test = Negative
Prevalence of Malaria
BayesiaLab.com 19
New Health Policy? Hypothetical Example
&
Rapid Diagnosis Test C-reactive protein (CRP) Test
for Malaria for Pneumonia
BayesiaLab.com 20
New Health Policy? Hypothetical Example
Policy Questions
?
• For Malaria
• Test & Treat or Presumptive Treatment
BayesiaLab.com 21
New Health Policy? Hypothetical Example
BayesiaLab.com 22
stefan.conrady@bayesia.us 23
Big Data?
No Data!
24
Map of Analytic Modeling & Reasoning
Data
Model Source
Theory
BayesiaLab.com 25
Map of Analytic Modeling & Reasoning
Data
Model Source
BayesiaLab.com 26
Data
Model Source
YELLOW CAB CO. ?
Map of Analytic Modeling & Reasoning
BayesiaLab.com 27
New Health Policy?
Proposed Policy Development Approach
• Domain Knowledge Encoding
• Probability Elicitation
• Cost/Utility Assessment
• Optimization
BayesiaLab.com 28
Building a Bayesian Network Model
29
1. Brainstorming & Model Construction
• Variables of interest
• Causal relationships
Facilitator Qualitative
Network
Experts
stefan.conrady@bayesia.us 30
Qualitative Bayesian Network
Structure from Brainstorming
BayesiaLab.com 31
2. Knowledge Elicitation Web Client
BAYESIALAB
?
BEKEE Server
Facilitator
Quantitative ?
Elicitation
Experts
stefan.conrady@bayesia.us 32
“Parameters” from BEKEE
BayesiaLab.com 33
3. Inference, Analysis, and Optimization
Final Network
BAYESIALAB
stefan.conrady@bayesia.us 34
Inference & Optimization
BayesiaLab.com 35
BayesiaLab.com 36
Previous Examples
Sounds Familiar?
• It’s all about encoding a qualitative structure and
eliciting probabilities.
BayesiaLab.com 37
VR
In Conclusion…
38
User Forum: bayesia.com/community
BayesiaLab.com 39
bayesia.com/pricing-2018
BayesiaLab.com 40
BayesiaLab Trial
Try BayesiaLab Today!
• Download Demo Version:
www.bayesialab.com/trial-download
• Apply for Unrestricted Evaluation Version:
www.bayesialab.com/evaluation
BayesiaLab.com 41
Webinar Series: Friday at 1 p.m. (Central)
Upcoming Webinars:
• March 23 Quantifying Product Cannibalization — A Case Study in
Marketing Science
• March 30 t.b.d.
stefan.conrady@bayesia.us 42
BayesiaLab Courses Around the World in 2018
• April 11–13 • August 29–31
Sydney, Australia London, UK
• May 16–18 • September 26–28
Seattle, WA New Delhi, India
• June 26–28 • October 29–31
Boston, MA Chicago, IL
• July 23–25 • December 4–6
San Francisco, CA New York, NY
stefan.conrady@bayesia.us 43
San Francisco
BayesiaLab.com 45
Thank You!
stefan.conrady@bayesia.us BayesianNetwork
linkedin.com/in/stefanconrady facebook.com/bayesia
BayesiaLab.com 46