Anda di halaman 1dari 7

Investigative Ophthalmology & Visual Science, Vol. 31, No.

9, September 1990
Copyright © Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology

Pepfidergic Innervafion of the Retinal Vasculature


and Optic Nerve Head
Xioodan Ye, Alon M. Lories, and Richard A. Srone

Using immunocytochemistry, the authors studied the peptidergic innervation to the vasculature of the
optic nerve and retina in the rhesus monkey and rat. In the monkey, beaded nerve fibers immunoreac-
tive to the vasoactive peptides, calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP), neuropeptide Y (NPY), sub-
stance P (SP), and vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP), are present in the adventitia and perivascular
space along the course of the central retinal artery within the optic nerve. The CGRP and SP
immunoreactivities fully co-localize. Perivascular peptidergic nerve fibers terminate as the blood
vessel enters the globe and do not follow the branches of the central retinal artery inside the eye.
Within the substance of the optic nerve behind the lamina cribrosa, small blood vessels occasionally
are supplied with CGRP-, SP-, and sometimes NPY- or VIP-immunoreactive nerve fibers. Of special
note, fine nerve fibers not clearly related to blood vessels are seen within the lamina cribrosa; their
simultaneous immunoreactivity to CGRP and SP suggests a sensory function. In the rat as in the
monkey, the retinal arterioles beyond the surface of the optic disc lack evident peptidergic innervation.
Perhaps an explanation for the known physiologic reactivity of the retinal circulation to neurohumors
in the absence of recognizable peripheral innervation can be based on comparison to the brain where
intraparenchymai blood vessels may be regulated by local neurons. Since the inner piexiform layer has
abundant amacrine-derived nerve processes containing classical neurotransmitters and/or neuropep-
tides, a local mechanism coupled to intrinsic retinal activity might contribute to the regulation of the
circulation. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 31:1731-1737,1990

Whether or not peripheral nerve fibers innervate occur in peripheral nerves supplying both the eye14
the intraocular branches of the central retinal artery and blood vessels to the brain.15 In peripheral ocular
(CRA) remains controversial. Claims for such inner- nerves, CGRP and SP nerve fibers are sensory, and
vation originally made on the basis of silver stains' VIP nerve fibers are parasympathetic. Generally as-
have not been supported by electron microscopic2"4 sociated with the sympathetics, the assignment of
or histochemical studies,5"7 except in the rabbit.8"10 NPY is problematic; it also is found in some para-
As a result, the retinal vascular tree in most species is sympathetic neurons supplying the eye, indicating a
now considered devoid of extrinsic nerve fibers. Yet a mixed autonomic derivation.14
paradox exists: evidence is mounting that the retinal
blood vessels have receptors for and sensitivity to Materials and Methods
neurotransmitters and neurohormones, including bi-
ologically active peptides.""13 In an attempt to clarify Eight rhesus monkey eyes were obtained immedi-
matters, we extended recent work on peripheral ately after death from animals killed under deep pen-
neuropeptidergic innervation, examining the inner- tobarbital anesthesia as part of the polio-vaccine test-
vation of the CRA and its intraocular branches in the ing program of the Bureau of Biologies of the Food
monkey and rat for four neuropeptides, calcitonin and Drug Administration; the eyes were fixed by im-
gene-related peptide (CGRP), neuropeptide Y mersion in Zamboni's solution16 at 4°C for 48 hr.
(NPY), substance P (SP), and vasoactive intestinal Twelve male Wistar rats also under deep pentobarbi-
peptide (VIP). All four peptides are vasoactive and tal anesthesia were perfused through the left ventricle
first with 0.85% NaCl and then with Zamboni's solu-
From the Department of Ophthalmology, University of Penn- tion. The enucleated eyes were postfixed at 4°C for
sylvania School of Medicine, Scheie Eye Institute, Philadelphia, 48 hr. All tissues were washed overnight at 4°C in 0.1
Pennsylvania. M phosphate-buffered saline (PBS), pH 7.4, with 30%
Supported by NIH grant EY05454 and the Harry and Edith H. sucrose. Then 16-20 /im thick cryostat tissue sections
Hubschman Research Fund of the Scheie Eye Institute.
Reprint requests: Dr. Richard A. Stone, D-603 Richards Build- were cut in a horizontal plane to include the optic
ing, University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Philadelphia, nerve head. Tissue sections were thaw mounted on
Pennsylvania 19104-6075. gelatin-coated slides, dried at room temperature, and

1731

Downloaded From: https://iovs.arvojournals.org/ on 10/06/2018


1732 INVESTIGATIVE OPHTHALMOLOGY b VISUAL SCIENCE / September 1990 Vol. 31

stored at -20°C until stained with the indirect im- were reacted with the anti-rabbit secondary anti-
munohistochemical technique. serum. All control studies demonstrated appropriate
For primary antisera, we used polyclonal antisera immunohistochemical specificities.
generated in rabbits against CGRP (Lot # For the histologic sections of rat CRA, enucleated
V054/5517; Cambridge Research Biochemical, Val- rat eyes were dehydrated and embedded in Historesin
ley Stream, NY), NPY (Lot # 00317/1098; Cam- (Microscopic Optical Consulting, Valley Cottage,
bridge), SP (Lot # 8706025; INCStar, Stillwater, NY). Then 4-ixm tissue sections were stained with a
MN), VIP (Lot # 8726017; INCStar), and monoclo- 0.5% azure II, 0.5% methylene blue, 1% sodium bo-
nal antibodies raised in the rat against SP (Lot # rate solution. All studies conformed with the ARVO
B3K35; Pel-Freez, Rogers, AR). All primary and sec- Resolution on the Use of Animals in Research.
ondary antisera were diluted in 0.05 M PBS, pH 7.2,
containing 0.3% Triton X-100, and all rinses were Results
done with 0.05 M PBS, pH 7.2, containing 0.2% Tri-
ton X-100. Peptidergic Innervation of Central Retinal Artery
and Optic Disc
Tissue sections from both species were incubated
overnight at room temperature with the primary an- In the monkey orbit, the CRA and central retinal
tibody (anti-VIP diluted 1:500; anti-SP, 1:500; anti- vein together enter the optic nerve some 3-8 mm
NPY, 1:800; and anti-CGRP, 1:800). After rinsing, behind the lamina cribrosa, surrounded by a sheath
the tissue sections were incubated for 1 hr at 37°C of glia and connective tissue. They rapidly gain a
with the biotinylated F(ab')2 fragment of donkey central position, travel forward, and finally pass
anti-rabbit IgG diluted 1:300, followed by a 15-min through the lamina cribrosa to divide at the face of
incubation at 37°C with fluorescein-labeled avidin the optic nerve head. Immunoreactive nervefibersof
diluted 1:300 (Amersham International, Arlington beaded appearance and meandering course, typical of
Heights, IL). The stained tissue sections were peripheral nerve fibers, were seen in the vascular ad-
mounted in a TRIS-glycerin mixture and were exam- ventitia of the artery during its intraorbital course.
ined with an epi-illumination system. Frequently they extended inwards to the adventitia-
For the co-localization of CGRP and SP in the media border. In separate preparations, nerve fibers
monkey eye, tissue sections were incubated overnight immunoreactive for each of the four neuropeptides
at room temperature with a mixture of rabbit CGRP under study were visualized (Fig. 1). The NPY-like
antiserum and rat SP monoclonal antibodies, each immunoreactive (-LI) nerve fibers were consistently
diluted 1:300, and then for 1 hr at 37°C with a mix- more numerous than those of CGRP, SP, or VIP. As
ture of goat anti-rabbit IgG conjugated to rhodamine nervefiberstraveled forward with the blood vessels in
isothiocyanate (RITC; Cappel Laboratories, West the optic nerve, no significant change of innervation
Chester, PA) and goat anti-rat IgG conjugated to fluo- density was detectable behind the lamina cribrosa.
rescein isothiocyanate (FITC; Cappel), respectively Between the lamina cribrosa and the optic disc sur-
diluted 1:400 and 1:300. The microscope illumina- face, a rapid and profound attenuation occurred: no
tion system allowed for rapid alteration of optimum CRA branches emanating from the optic disc had an
filter combinations for visualization of RITC observable peptidergic nerve supply (Fig. 2). When
(510-560 nm exciter; 580 nm dichromatic beam specifically studied, CGRP and SP fully co-localized
splitter; 590 nm barrier filter) or FITC (450-490 nm (Fig. 1). In comparison with the artery, the nerve
exciter; 510 nm dichromatic beam splitter; 520 nm supply to the central retinal vein was consistently far
barrier filter) fluorescence. lower in density and less predictable; in many in-
For controls, the primary antisera were preab- stances, it was absent.
sorbed by overnight incubation at 4°C of each diluted In the intracanalicular segment of the monkey
primary antiserum with 1.0 /xM of the respective optic nerve, individual fine CGRP- and SP-LI nerve
peptide (Peninsula Laboratories, San Carlos, CA); the fibers also were seen in the posterior part of lamina
preabsorbed antisera then were substituted in the im- cribrosa (Fig. 3). They were immediately adjacent to
munohistochemical procedure. As another control, laminar beams oriented perpendicular to the optic
the primary antiserum was omitted entirely. To eval- nerve axons. CGRP and SP co-localized fully in these
uate specificity for the co-localization studies, the nerve fibers as in other locations. Even though small
primary antibody mixture was preabsorbed with 1.0 intrascleral blood vessels adjacent to the optic nerve
nM CGRP or SP. For additional specificity controls, head in the circle of Zinn-Haller and others passing
tissue sections stained with rabbit primary antiserum between the sclera and lamina cribrosa were occa-
were reacted with the anti-rat secondary antiserum; sionally surrounded by nerve fibers similarly immu-
those stained with the rat monoclonal antibodies noreactive to CGRP and SP, we could not identify

Downloaded From: https://iovs.arvojournals.org/ on 10/06/2018


No. 9 PEPTI.DERGIC INNERVATION / Ye er ol 1733

Fig. 1. Calcitonin gene-


related peptide and sub-
stance P-like immunoreac-
tive nerves associated with
the centra) retinal artery
of the rhesus monkey.
In a longitudinal section
through the optic nerve al-
ternatively viewed for
CGRPin(A)andSPin(B),
fibers immunoreactive to
each peptide innervate the
central retinal artery {CRA)
throughout most of its
length. Arrows point out the
precise registration of the
immunoreactivity to each
peptide, indicating co-local-
ization. An arrowhead indi-
cates the vitreal surface of
the optic nerve head. Mag-
nification bar, 50 jiiti.

clear vascular associations of the fine nerve fibers in enters the optic nerve head obliquely between the
the lamina cribrosa. No NPY- or VIP-LI nerve fibers sclera and optic nerve. CGRP-, NPY-, SP-, and VIP-
of similar distribution were observed within the lami- LI nerve fibers were present in the adventitia of the
nar region. CRA. The CGRP-LI fibers terminated just before the
In contrast to its course in the monkey, the CRA in CRA entered the globe. The other three types of pep-
the rat passes inferolaterally to the optic nerve and tidergic nerve fibers underwent a small decrease in

Downloaded From: https://iovs.arvojournals.org/ on 10/06/2018


1734 INVESTIGATIVE OPHTHALMOLOGY 6 VISUAL SCIENCE / September 1990 Vol. 31

Fig. 2. Absence of peptid-


ergic innervation to the su-
perficial retinal blood ves-
sels. Near the monkey optic
disc, a superficial retinal
blood vessel (asterisk) is de-
void of innervation. Va-
soactive intestinal peptide-
like immunoreactive nerve
fibers are visible within the
inner plexiform layer
(arrows) of the retina and
surround choroidal blood
vessels of differing sizes (ar-
rowheads). Magnification
bar, 50 fim.

density as the blood vessel passed forward to the optic were observed to surround the branch retinal blood
disc and then also ended abruptly (Figs. 4, 5). As in vessels at the optic nerve head, and none served the
the monkey, very few peptidergic nerve fibers were retinal blood vessels.6'7'9
observed around the central retinal vein. In this report, we extended prior histochemical re-
sults on adrenergic and cholinergic innervation to
Neurovascular Relationships Within the Retina neuropeptides and found that peptidergic nerve fibers
disappear as the CRA passes forward into the globe.
The arteriolar branches of the CRA repeatedly bi- The attenuation is such that, although a few peptid-
furcate in the superficial nervefiberlayer to distribute ergic nerve fibers can be traced as far forward as the
into layered capillary beds, the deepest of which reach vitreal surface of the optic nerve head, none follow
the outer plexiform layer. As capillaries penetrate the the blood vessels in their course over the retina. The
inner plexiform layer, they are in immediate proxim- entire series of histochemical and immunocytochem-
ity to amacrine cell processes. The monkey and rat ical observations is supported by electron micro-
retina contained VIP- and SP-LI amacrine cell bodies scopic findings which also demonstrate no nerve ter-
with inner plexiform layer processes.17 In both spe- minals on branch retinal blood vessels in rats, mon-
cies, alternating-phase and fluorescence microscopy keys, and humans.2"4 The rabbit is a limited
clearly demonstrated that capillaries penetrate the exception to this generalization. Although SP-LI
inner plexiform layer in close proximity to peptider- nerve fibers surrounding its CRA do not extend into
gic nerve fibers (Fig. 6). the globe,19 a definite adrenergic innervation to reti-
nal blood vessels has been observed on several occa-
Discussion sions.8"10 In this respect, however, the rabbit and hare
The existence of a rich and complex nerve fiber are distinct among mammals: their retinal blood ves-
plexus to the CRA in its course through the optic sels are restricted in distribution to the horizontal
nerve has been well known for many years. In fact, region of the vascular stripe, an area more or less
the sympathetic contribution was described by Tie- coextensive with myelinated ganglion cell axons.20
demann and others in the early 19th century.18 As An observation that retinal blood vessels in the dog
specific histochemical methods for the identification and in pathologic human eyes are innervated has not
of neurotransmitters and/or their enzyme systems been replicated.21
supplemented nonspecific silver staining, a choliner- Based on these considerations, the regulatory po-
gic component was ascribed to parasympathetic tential for the vascular innervation would seem to
sources. In the rat and monkey, the two species we depend on the location of blood vessels in relation to
studied, only a few adrenergic or cholinergic fibers the optic nerve head. Regarding the extraocular com-

Downloaded From: https://iovs.arvojournals.org/ on 10/06/2018


No. 9 PEPTIDERGIC INNEfWATION / Ye er ol 1735

Fig. 3. Presumed sensory nerve fibers at the lamina cribrosa of Fig. 4. Vasoactive intestinal peptide and innervation of the rat
the monkey. (A, B) A small nerve fiber (arrow) at the lamina central retinal artery. (A) The central retinal artery (CRA) enters
cribrosa stains simultaneously for CGRP in (A) and SP in (B) the eye inferior to the optic nerve. Its course through the optic
evidence for a sensory origin. (C) The location of this nervefiberis nerve is oblique and short. (B) Vasoactive intestinal peptide-likc
indicated on the phase micrograph of the identical field (arrow) immunoreactive (VIP-LI) nerve fibers (arrow) accompany the ar-
seen in (A) and (B), Magnification bar, 50 nm. tery as it enters the eye. Note that branch blood vessels (asterisks)
within eye are devoid of VIP nerves. A few VIP-LI nervefibersare
visible in the inner plexiform layer (arrowhead). Magnification bar,
50jum.

Downloaded From: https://iovs.arvojournals.org/ on 10/06/2018


1736 INVESTIGATIVE OPHTHALMOLOGY b VISUAL SCIENCE / September 1990 Vol. 01

the cat is followed by a widespread drop in retinal


oxygen tension independent of the choroidal circula-
tion.22 More directly, the isolated perfused ophthal-
mic artery of the Japanese monkey demonstrates
graded reactivity to vasoactive amines, such as nor-
epinephrine and tyramine.23
Less certain is what occurs to the blood vessels in
the retina. Although such blood vessels lack extrinsic
innervation, autonomic receptors are present on their
walls.1213 Also altered vascular diameter and/or reti-
nal blood flow in response to change in the partial
pressure of blood gases indicates control of vessel cali-
ber.24 In most vascular beds such functions are attrib-
uted to precapillary arteriotes,25 but in the retina a site
for regulatory control remains uncertain. Although
precapillary endothelial specializations have been
observed in several species,26'27 there are none in
monkeys or humans, and thus there is no accepted
locus of control for circulation through the retinal
Fig. 5. Neuropeptide Y and the innervation of the rat central microvascular bed. In this respect, direct innervation
retinal artery. Neuropeptide Y-like immunoreactive (NPY-LI)
nerve fibers (arrow) supply the central retinal artery (CRA) as it
of capillaries by retinal neurons can be proposed as a
travels to the surface of the optic nerve (ON). Note also the NPY-LI candidate mechanism for local circulatory control. In
nerve fibers in the choroid (arrowheads). R = retina; magnification anatomic support of this hypothesis, we repeatedly
bar, 50 ^m. visualized neuropeptide-containing amacrine pro-
cesses immediately adjacent to retinal capillaries in
ponent, an active innervation probably influences the the inner plexiform layer both in the monkey and rat
head of pressure reaching the retina at the optic disc. retina. Our observations complement the recent find-
Evidence for this comes from several sources. For ing in the same species of dopamine-containing ama-
example, superior cervical ganglion stimulation in crine processes to retinal capillaries.28 In fact, we

Fig. 6. Relation of retinal


blood vessels to peptidergic
nerve fibers in the inner
plexiform layer of the rat
retina. (A) A phase micro-
graph shows a small blood
vessel (arrow) passing
through the inner plexiform
layer (IPL). (B) A fluores-
cence micrograph of the
identical field illustrates va-
soactive intestinal peptide-
like immunoreactive ama-
crine cells (arrowheads) and
fluorescent dendrites in the
IPL. Dashed line indicates
position of the blood vessel
shown in (A). Magnification
bar,

Downloaded From: https://iovs.arvojournals.org/ on 10/06/2018


No. 9 PEPTIDERGIC INNEfWATION / Ye er ol 1737

found dopamine-containing amacrine processes im- rabbit and guinea-pig. Acta Univ Lundensis Section II. No.
mediately adjacent to capillaries as far sclerad as the 20:1, 1964.
9. Ehinger B and Falck B: Morphological and pharmacohisto-
outer plexiform layer in the spider monkey retina chemical characteristics of adrenergic retinal neurons of some
(data not shown). Support for local neural control mammals. Graefes Arch Clin Exp Ophthalmol 178:295, 1969.
also comes by comparison with the brain, where neu- 10. Furukawa H: Autonomic innervation of preretinal blood ves-
ronal processes associated with intraparenchymal sels of the rabbit. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 28:1752, 1987.
blood vessels are suggested to regulate blood flow at 11. Ferrari-Dileo G, Davis EB, and Anderson DR: Angiotensin
the capillary level.29 Unfortunately, confirmation of a binding sites in bovine and human retinal blood vessels. Invest
Ophthalmol Vis Sci 28:1747, 1987.
hypothesis of intrinsic neuronal regulation of retinal 12. Ferrari-Dileo G: Betai and beta2 adrenergic binding sites in
blood flow requires a physiologic understanding of its bovine retina and retinal blood vessels. Invest Ophthalmol Vis
microcirculation that at present is lacking. Clearly for Sci 29:695, 1988.
retinal amacrine cell processes to alter retinal blood 13. Hoste AM, Boels PJ, Brutsaert DL, and De Laey JJ: Eftect of
flow, retinal capillaries would need to contract, a alpha-1 and beta agonists on contraction of bovine retinal re-
sistance arteries in vitro. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 30:44,
function that remains to be established. 1989.
Regarding the fine nerve fibers in the lamina cri- 14. Stone RA, Kuwayama Y, and Laties AM: Neuropeptides and
brosa, the coexistence of CGRP and SP immunor- the ocular innervation. In Regulatory Peptides, Polak JM, edi-
eactivities leads at once to speculation of a specialized tor. Basel, Birkhauser Verlag, 1989, pp. 266-291.
15. Edvinsson L: Functional role of perivascular peptides in the
sensory function. Possibly relevant to intraocular control of cerebral circulation. Trends Neurosci 8:126, 1985.
pressure regulation, this presumption is reinforced by 16. Stefanini M, De Martino C, and Zamboni L: Fixation of ejacu-
the lack of visceral motor fibers in the same location. lated spermatozoa for electron microscopy. Nature 216:173,
However, the difficulty of discriminating a free-run- 1967.
ning nerve fiber from one serving a small but unseen 17. Brecha NC, Eldred W, Kuljis RO, and Karten HJ: Identifica-
tion and localization of biologically active peptides in the ver-
blood vessel by light microscopy makes it impossible tebrate retina. In Progress in Retinal Research, Vol 3, Osborne
to state firmly that these nerves truly serve the lamina NN, Chader GJ, editors. New York, Pergammon Press, 1984,
cribrosa and not the local circulation. Yet, the obser- pp. 185-226.
vation is sufficiently provocative to justify further in- 18. Duke-Elder S and Wybar K.C: The anatomy of the visual sys-
quiry by methods better suited to define local tissue tem. In System of Ophthalmology, Vol 14, Duke-Elder S, edi-
tor. St. Louis, CV Mosby, 1961, p. 366.
relationships, such as electron microscopy. 19. Kumagai N, Yuda K, Kadota T, Goris RC, and ICishida R:
Substance P-like immunoreactivity in the central retinal artery
Key words: central retinal artery, innervation, neuropep- of the rabbit. Exp Eye Res 46:591, 1988.
tides, monkey, rat 20. Duke-Elder S: The eye in evolution. In System of Ophthalmol-
ogy, Vol 1, Duke-Elder S, editor. St. Louis, CV Mosby, 1958,
p. 479.
Acknowledgment 21. Fukuda M: Presence of adrenergic innervation to the retinal
vessels: A histochemical study. Jap J Ophthalmol 14:1, 1970.
The authors thank Dr. Patricia A. Grimes and Ms. Alice 22. Aim A and Bill A: The eftect of stimulation of the cervical
McGlinn for valuable advice and assistance. sympathetic chain on retinal oxygen tension and on uveal reti-
nal and cerebral blood flow in cats. Acta Physiol Scand 88:84,
1973.
References
23. Ohkubo K and Chiba S: Vascular reactivities of simian oph-
1. Duke-Elder S: System of Ophthalmology, Vol 2. London, thalmic ciliary arteries. Curr Eye Res 6:1197, 1987.
Henry KJmpton, 1961, pp. 380-381. 24. Riva EC, Grunwald JE, and Sinclair SH: Laser doppler velo-
2. Hogan MJ and Feeney L: The ultrastructure of the retinal cimetry study of the effect of pure oxygen breathing on retinal
blood vessels: I. The large vessels. J Ultrastruct Res 9:10, 1963. blood flow. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 24:47, 1983.
3. Cohen A: Ultrastructural aspects of the human optic nerve. 25. Wiedeman MP, Tuma RF, and Mayrovitz HN: General ana-
Invest Ophthalmol 6:294, 1967. tomical comparisons. In An Introduction to Microcirculation,
4. Ruskell GL: Dual innervation of the central artery of the retina New York, Academic Press, 1981, pp. 12-20.
in monkeys. In The Optic Nerve, Cant JS, editor. London, 26. Henkind P and De Oliveira L: Retinal arteriolar annuli. Invest
KJmpton, 1972, pp. 48-58. Ophthalmol 7:584, 1968.
5. Ehinger B: Adrenergic nerves to the eye and to related struc- 27. Biissow H: Ultrastructure of the terminal vascular bed in the
tures in man and in the cynomolgus monkey (Macaco irus). retina of mammals. Bibl Anat 20:94, 1981.
Invest Ophthalmology 5:42, 1966. 28. Favard K, Simon A, and Nguyen-Legros J: Relationships be-
6. Laties A: Central retinal artery innervation: Absence of adren- tween dopaminergic processes and blood capillary walls in rat
ergic innervation to the intraocular branches. Arch Ophthal- and monkey retinas: An electron microscope immunocyto-
mol 77:405, 1967. chemical study. ARVO Abstracts. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci
7. Laties A and Nichols CW: Demonstration of a non-specific 30(Suppl):20, 1989.
cholinesterase in retinal Miiller cell. Am J Ophthalmol 29. Lou HC, Edvinsson L, and Mac Kenzie ET: The concept of
71:1093, 1971. coupling blood flow to brain function: Revision required? Ann
8. Ehinger B: Adrenergic nerves to the eye and its adnexa in Neurol 22:289, 1987.

Downloaded From: https://iovs.arvojournals.org/ on 10/06/2018

Anda mungkin juga menyukai