Mr. Pace
DC English IV
10 Oct. 2018
America prides itself on protecting religious freedom, but as Jon Krakauer says in his
book Under the Banner of Heaven, “How can a society actively promote religious faith on one
hand and condemn a man for zealously adhering to his faith on the other”(297)? rakauer remains
objective in the telling of how two Mormon Fundamentalists killed a mother and her infant
daughter after receiving a revelation from God telling them to do so, but there is a hidden
message underneath his objective front. Horrendous acts committed by those following their
faith are acts not justified by God, but by humans, as illustrated by Jon Krakauer in Under the
rhetorical questions. He uses these in a way that questions both extremes of the problem. He says
“If Ron Lafferty were deemed mentally ill because he obeyed the voice of God, isn’t everyone
who believes in God and seeks guidance through prayer mentally ill”(297)? This idea comes out
as crazy and convoluted to the vast majority of the audience, even though it is logically based on
how Ron’s lawyers argued his case. He did this in a way which allows readers to reach the
conclusion themselves that faith is not crazy because the generality of humans follow a religion
and very few of those are deranged. This shows that, yes, religion is justified and people are not
crazy to follow it. Krakauer also questions the other extreme of faith “How can a society actively
promote religious faith on one hand and condemn a man for zealously adhering to his faith on
the other”(297)? After seeing this, the reader understands that there must be a line drawn
between promoting religious freedom and giving free reign to horrible activities done in the
Lord’s name. Without this line, people realize that more instances similar to those which Under
the Banner of Heaven introduces and references will happen. Anything crossing this line must be
all Americans take to heart. This is an extremely powerful statement seeing that Krakauer’s
intended audience is Americans. To incite such emotion he says; “Does he think the sincerity of
their belief justified the act? And if not, how can Dan know that what he did isn’t every bit as
misguided as what bin Laden’s followers did on September 11, despite the obvious sincerity of
his own faith”(320-21)? By making this comparison, Krakauer shows readers the severity of this
situation by making a strong connection between 9/11 and in comparison to this, rather mild
crime committed by two American men. Realizing that the same motivation drives these very
different people, readers take a mental step back, thinking that these acts cannot be justified by
Acts of rape and murder are all logical fallacies if done in the name of God. Humans are
not perfect as Krakauer shows here; “He kept falling rapturously in love with women not his
wife. And because that rapture was so wholly consuming, and felt so good, it struck him as
impossible that God might frown on such a thing”(120). Joseph Smith is advocating cheating
with God because he wants it, not because God approves it. This is undeniably a human fault.
Logos shows that God has never been preached to support sin, unholy ways and any human
faults, therefore any acts of rape, murder, or even drugs are human fallacies, justified by the
human and not God. This makes the human directly responsible for the acts he or she has
committed.
He pushes the readers to understand that the fervid upholding of faith that includes rape
and killing, crosses a line, turning it so religious belief does not justify the misguided actions
committed. Rhetorical questions are used find the limit at which religious freedom turns into
criminal acts, never condoned by God. He compares following faith to murder with 9/11 in a
way to show that in no way is doing evil in the Lord’s name justifiable or forgivable. Krakauer
also shows that all evil done is not from God, but from the faults in human character, no evil
action can be logically commanded by God. This book demonstrates to readers that religion can
be put to horrible uses, uses that God never intends. People need to make sure they aren’t