Anda di halaman 1dari 13

See

discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228069798

Nursing children after a disaster: A qualitative


study of nurse volunteers and children after the
Haiti earthquake

Article in Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing · July 2012


DOI: 10.1111/j.1744-6155.2012.00338.x · Source: PubMed

CITATIONS READS

10 266

5 authors, including:

Elizabeth Sloand Rachel Walker


Johns Hopkins University University of Massachusetts Amherst
41 PUBLICATIONS 257 CITATIONS 17 PUBLICATIONS 83 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Anthony Pho Joan Kub


Weill Cornell Medical College University of Southern California
3 PUBLICATIONS 31 CITATIONS 128 PUBLICATIONS 2,638 CITATIONS

SEE PROFILE SEE PROFILE

Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:

Haiti IPV View project

Asthma Express View project

All content following this page was uploaded by Anthony Pho on 16 October 2015.

The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.


bs_bs_banner

Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Nursing children after a disaster: A qualitative study of nurse


volunteers and children after the Haiti earthquake jspn_338 242..253

Elizabeth Sloand, Grace Ho, Rachel Klimmek, Anthony Pho, and Joan Kub
Elizabeth Sloand, PhD, PNP-BC, is an Assistant Professor and Coordinator, Pediatric Nurse Practitioner Track; Grace Ho, RN, BSN, is a PhD Student; Rachel
Klimmek, RN, BSN, OCN, is a PhD Candidate, Johns Hopkins University, School of Nursing, Baltimore, Maryland; Anthony Pho, MSN, MPH, NP-C, is a Staff
Associate in Medicine, Weill Cornell Medical College, New York, New York; and Joan Kub, PhD, APHN, BC, is an Associate Professor, Johns Hopkins
University, Schools of Nursing, Medicine, and Public Health, Baltimore, Maryland, USA

Search terms Abstract


Children, disaster nursing, Haiti, pediatric
nursing, qualitative. Purpose. The purpose of this study was to explore the experiences of nurse
volunteers caring for children after the Haiti earthquake in January 2010.
Author contact Design and Methods. This descriptive qualitative study using in-depth
Esloand1@jhu.edu, with a copy to the Editor:
interviews focuses on the experiences of 10 nurse volunteers.
roxie.foster@UCDenver.edu
Results. Four themes emerged: hope amid devastation, professional com-
Disclosure: The authors report no actual or promises, universality of children, and emotional impact on nurses.
potential conflicts of interest. Practice Implications. Nurses who volunteer after natural disasters have
rich personal and professional experiences, including extremes of sadness
First Received November 15, 2011; Revision and joy. Nurse volunteers will likely need to care for children. Nurses and
received January 8, 2012; Accepted for humanitarian agencies should prepare for the unique challenges of
publication March 5, 2012.
pediatric care.
doi: 10.1111/j.1744-6155.2012.00338.x

On January 12, 2010, a 7.0-magnitude earthquake August 2011 revealed that all of the publications
struck Haiti with an epicenter 15 mi from the capital are anecdotal in nature. There was no original
of Port-au-Prince (PAP). An estimated 222,570 research using scientific methods that systematically
people were killed, 300,000 were injured, and 1.3 explored volunteers’ experiences. In addition, none
million displaced (U.S. Geological Survey, 2011). of the publications specifically addressed the issues
The baseline poverty in Haiti further exacerbated the faced by nurses caring for children.
situation. Haiti is the poorest country in the Western Research that focuses on the pediatric population
Hemisphere, with 80% of the population living in disasters is generally lacking (Fallat, 2009; La
below the poverty line and more than half living in Greca, Silverman, Vernberg, & Roberts, 2002). The
abject poverty (Central Intelligence Agency, 2011). importance of a child-oriented approach is high-
The magnitude of the disaster, exacerbated by lighted when we examine the statistics of the Haiti
poverty, culminated in one of the most tragic earthquake records. In one general field hospital in
humanitarian crises in recent history. PAP, the median age among all injured patients
In the wake of this disaster, thousands of nurses was 24 years, and approximately 30% of all those
and healthcare volunteers traveled to Haiti to assist seen were infants through 14 years old (Centers for
in humanitarian relief efforts, providing care that Disease Control and Prevention, 2010). Domesti-
ranged from emergency trauma to community cally and internationally, children comprise a vul-
primary care. Since then, many publications describ- nerable population that requires special attention
ing these individuals’ experiences have appeared in during a disaster situation. At the local level, Strat-
the literature (Burnweit & Stylianos, 2011; Deckel- ton (2010) discussed the vulnerability of children
baum, 2010; Goodman, 2010; Huffman, 2011; Lau, and pediatric capacity in Seattle, Washington.
2010). A search of peer-reviewed literature pub- Nationally, two organizations echoed the special
lished from the time of the earthquake through needs of children in disasters: the National

242 Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing 17 (2012) 242–253


© 2012, Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
E. Sloand et al. Nursing Children After a Disaster: A Qualitative Study of Nurse Volunteers and Children After the Haiti Earthquake

Commission on Children and Disasters (2010) in phenomenon we were studying: the experiences
their Report to the President and Congress, and the of nurse volunteers during a humanitarian crisis
National Association of Pediatric Nurse Practitioners (Patton, 1990). Informed consent was obtained
(2011) in their recent position statement. Interna- prior to each interview. No incentives or gifts were
tionally, Farfel and colleagues (2011) reported on a given for participation.
pediatric field hospital in PAP after the earthquake
and discussed the unique challenges of caring for
children in a disaster. Data collection and analysis
This study sought to fill part of the knowledge gap The data for this study are from a larger study that
about nurse volunteers who care for children in included 12 participants who were nurse volunteers
disaster situations. It aimed to answer the question: in Haiti. The purpose of the larger parent study was
What were the experiences of the nurse volunteers to explore the experiences of nurses who volun-
who cared for children after the 2010 Haiti earth- teered to serve in Haiti after the earthquake of
quake? This study illuminates the impact of the January 2010. Semi-structured interviews took
earthquake on children and their caregivers through place in-person whenever it was possible (n = 6).
the eyes of the nurses who cared for them. With its Some were conducted over the telephone (n = 4)
focus on nurses and their experiences with children when participants were not able to do the in-person
postdisaster, this research is important because it interviews. In-person interviews were conducted at
takes a scientific approach to nurses’ experiences the participants’ place of choice. The interviews
and will help inform nurses who consider volunteer- ranged from 60 to 90 min in length and were con-
ing in future humanitarian missions. The study also ducted by four interviewers. Interviews were con-
informs aid agencies on how to improve the disaster ducted after volunteers returned home; most were
response system for affected children. done 8–10 months after they returned, and one was
conducted 5 months after return.
DESIGN AND METHODS An interview guide was developed by three nurses
who served in Haiti as volunteers and a qualitative
This research project used an exploratory descriptive research expert. The interviewers were all members
study design because little is known about the topic of the research team so they were very familiar with
of study (Sandelowski, 2010). The Johns Hopkins the study overall and the sampling technique. Inter-
Medicine Institutional Review Board approved this viewers were trained by a qualitative research
research study. expert to ensure consistency in conducting inter-
views. The training included interview techniques,
Study participants strategies to avoid bias, and rehearsing with the
interview guide. A sample of interview questions
The nurse volunteers were purposively selected by and probes are listed in Table 1. Participants were
the research team. Nurse volunteers were invited to asked for their permission to audio-record the inter-
participate based on the following criteria: (a) being view; all agreed. The audio recordings were tran-
a licensed nurse who volunteered in PAP, Haiti, or on scribed verbatim by one member of the research
the U.S. Naval Ship Comfort, the American hospital team. The interview transcripts were verified for
ship that anchored off the coast of Haiti; (b) serving accuracy by the respective interviewers prior to
in Haiti between January and June of 2010; (c) pro- analysis. A qualitative data analysis computer
viding direct patient care for at least 1 week; and (d)
being willing to discuss his or her experience as a
volunteer nurse. Snowball sampling was used to
identify potential participants. With this purposive Table 1. Sample Interview Questions and Probes
sampling method, the researchers can find potential • When you think back on your time there, what thoughts, images,
participants by asking other participants. This or words come to mind?
method helped produce a maximum variation • Describe a typical day for you in Haiti.
sample for this study, one that was diverse with • What kinds of patients did you encounter, and what was that like
respect to nursing experience and type of clinical for you?
site. Clinical sites included hospital setting, commu- • Did you encounter any challenges during your time there?
• Is there anything else you would like to tell me about your
nity clinic, and the hospital ship. This diverse sam-
experience that we haven’t already talked about?
pling helped give us a deep understanding of the

Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing 17 (2012) 242–253 243


© 2012, Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
Nursing Children After a Disaster: A Qualitative Study of Nurse Volunteers and Children After the Haiti Earthquake E. Sloand et al.

system, NVivo9 (QSR International, 2011), was used firmability) described by Lincoln and Guba (1986) to
to assist with data management. ensure trustworthiness of this study. Prolonged
The investigators first worked with transcripts immersion, reading the data multiple times, vertical
from the parent study. After multiple readings and and horizontal comparisons, peer debriefing
coding, the investigators determined that most of between the investigators, and consulting with two
the nurses (10/12) made specific references to their experienced qualitative research experts supported
work with children that stood out from the main the credibility of study findings. A dense description
study and warranted special attention. This discov- of participant characteristics, as shown in Table 2,
ery led to the decision to conduct a subgroup analy- supported the results’ transferability. A clear audit
sis that was pediatric-specific and included 10 of the trail that outlined sampling, data collection, coding,
original 12 participating nurses. Two of the partici- and analytic strategies supported the dependability
pants were males and eight were females. Education of this study. Confirmability of results was supported
and experience varied widely. Four were registered by the investigators’ use of reflexivity (i.e., use of
nurses (RNs), six were nurse practitioners, and all memos and peer debriefing to uncover feelings,
earned academic degrees that ranged from an Asso- thoughts, and emotions during coding and analysis).
ciate’s Degree in Nursing to Doctor of Nursing Employing reflexivity was salient as one’s own pre-
Practice. Most (8/10) had prior humanitarian work conceptions may affect the results, and a self-critical
experience. A summary of the characteristics of attitude on the part of the researcher is required to
these 10 participants is presented in Table 2. uncover and acknowledge these preconceptions
The investigators (ES and GH) extracted all child- (Thomas & Magilvy, 2011).
specific data and analyzed it using strategies
described by Corbin and Strauss (2008). We began
by reading all of the data to gain a grand view. After RESULTS
several readings, we performed independent open The nurses spoke strongly and compellingly in the
coding with two transcripts, and compared and con- interviews, which was not surprising given the
verged codes to subsequently create a codebook. We severity of the earthquake conditions combined
then coded independently and discussed emerging with Haiti’s underlying poverty and sociopolitical
ideas while identifying recurring and predominant disarray. The nurses described experiences and feel-
concepts. In subsequent readings and many ings that were powerful and oftentimes difficult. It
in-depth discussions, the investigators searched for was hard for them to care for children in the harsh
underlying meanings within the data. Common conditions of post earthquake Haiti, and that diffi-
themes across interviews emerged as data were culty came through in the interviews. Four themes
compared vertically (within the transcript) and hori- emerged from the data: devastation was expected
zontally (across different transcripts). We carefully but rare glimmers of hope?, professional compro-
considered these themes and how they were related mises and unsettling results, universality of chil-
and interconnected. These relationships helped dren, and emotional impact on nurses.
suggest a common story embedded in the data.
The researchers confirmed themes through analy-
sis of memos and field notes to get the truest picture Theme 1: Devastation was expected but rare
of the experiences of the nurses. Throughout the glimmers of hope?
analysis, the investigators explored thoughts, feel-
The nurses saw firsthand how the earthquake had a
ings, and emotions that arose while working with
devastating impact on Haiti’s children. The country’s
the data and analysis. This was important because
baseline poverty, compounded by the disaster’s
the principal investigator has volunteered in Haiti
massive damage, left its children with few to no
on many occasions both before and after the earth-
resources and basic necessities. The nurses gave
quake. Thus, the researchers triangulated these
many descriptions of this impact. For example, one
multiple data sources to provide the most complete
nurse responded:
view of the nurses’ experiences in this context.
The destruction was mind-boggling. The poverty, there’s
Trustworthiness just no words for the poverty, you know, tents every-
where and mud everywhere and children everywhere
The investigators employed the four criteria (i.e., and barefoot, dirty children everywhere . . . It was just
credibility, transferability, dependability, and con- rubble . . . there wasn’t anything. There’s an orphanage

244 Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing 17 (2012) 242–253


© 2012, Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
E. Sloand et al.

© 2012, Wiley Periodicals, Inc.


Table 2. Participant Characteristics

Interview Certifications/ Experience as RN Prior humanitarian Work environment in Interview


ID Age Gender licensures (in years) work experience Haiti (type of site) Length of stay format

RN1 25 Female PNP, MPH First year as NP Yes Emergency room tents 16 days Phone
ICU tents

Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing 17 (2012) 242–253


Primary care clinic
RN2 54 Male MSN-PNP, CRNP 5 Yes Hospital—pediatrics 16 days Phone
RN3 37 Female ADN 6 No Hospital—pediatrics 14 days (2 trips of 7 days) Phone
Hospital—adult ICU
RN4 24 Female RN 2.5 Yes USNS Comfort 14 days Phone
RN5 30 Female MSN/MPH, FNP 2.5 Yes Primary care clinic; 16 days In person
Emergency room (1 day)
RN6 26 Female RN, CPEN, TNCC 3 Yes Hospital—emergency 16 days In person
Primary clinic (1 day)
RN7 26 Male CCRN 3 Yes Hospital—emergency 16 days In person
RN8 55 Female CNS, ANP, GNP 5 years Yes Primary care clinic 16 days In person
as NP Hospital—adult ICU
RN9 56 Female ANP, DNP 34 No Hospital—emergency 12 days In person
Primary care clinics
RN10 55 Female PNP, CRNP, DNP 34 Yes Hospital—emergency 10 days In person
Primary care clinic—peds

Note: Humanitarian work experience is defined as having worked in resource-poor countries (e.g., medical missions) or domestic/international disaster response. RN, registered nurse; ADN,
Associate Degree in Nursing; CPEN, certified pediatric emergency nurse; ANP, adult nurse practitioner; PNP, pediatric nurse practitioner; DNP, Doctor of Nursing Practice; CRNP, certified regis-
tered nurse practitioner; GNP, geriatric nurse practitioner; CNS, clinical nurse specialist; FNP, family nurse practitioner; MSN, Master’s in Nursing; MPH, Master’s in Public Health; TNCC, trauma
nursing course certified; CCRN, critical care registered nurse; ICU, intensive care unit; NP, nurse practitioner; USNS, U.S. Naval Ship.

245
Nursing Children After a Disaster: A Qualitative Study of Nurse Volunteers and Children After the Haiti Earthquake
Nursing Children After a Disaster: A Qualitative Study of Nurse Volunteers and Children After the Haiti Earthquake E. Sloand et al.

across the street that was collapsed and all the children It was kind of ironic because he was found, the earth-
were in tents, literally pitched on top of the rubble . . . a quake caused him to be found because he was just
lot of children who would really beg for food. (RN10) [living] in the streets, and he ended up being diagnosed
with a rare skin disorder—that he’d have so much
Many parents and caregivers reported various cancer all over him they had to remove his eye and he
physiologic stress responses in their children, such as was just really malnourished, but . . . it was a good story
bedwetting and nightmares. For some children, ‘cause . . . he was able to come to the States and he was
however, the impact of the earthquake was much adopted . . . He actually wasn’t injured by the earth-
more severe. The nurses noted conditions that quake at all. . . . because of the circumstances, he was
found. (RN4)
ranged from coughs, earaches, diarrheal illness,
feeding problems, and rashes, to severe dehydration
and malnutrition, malaria, asthma exacerbations, Due to the influx of medical assistance, children
and pneumonia. Physical traumas were also were also getting access to primary care. For
common and, as the nurses reported, ranged from example, one nurse practitioner saw a set of
minor scrapes and bruises to horrendous wounds, newborn twins who were not breastfeeding well.
debilitating injuries and burns, uni- or bilateral She asked the mother to return to the clinic multiple
amputations, and severe facial and skull fractures. times and initiated breastfeeding education and
These children’s health problems ranged from mild guidance while monitoring the infants’ growth. She
and chronic to acute and severe, but nonetheless explained:
required consistent and quality care from parents or
caregivers. Many Haitian children lost their health That was one of those cases where it had nothing to do
or their families, and some lost both. RN4 shared: with the earthquake at all. It was just babies being born
and they were small . . . I always think about those
A lot of them just didn’t have, they had nobody, and twins actually. I was thinking about them recently
then they were, they had what little they had—their hoping that they, you know, made it. (RN5)
own health—was just completely crushed, literally
. . . They had devastating, devastating physical injuries The earthquake’s impact on Haiti’s children
and, . . . in the pediatric ward, a lot of the kids there, cannot be overstated. Contrary to common expecta-
their parents were dead, or they didn’t know where tion, however, we learned through the nurse inter-
they were . . . a lot of them didn’t have anybody taking viewees that not all children shared negative
care of them . . . they’re in a strange environment. It’s a experiences. While the disaster imposed destructive
hospital . . . they were overwhelmed . . . scared. (RN4) and devastating consequences on most, for a select
few, the earthquake became an unexpected life-
Compounding the loss of their caregivers, a
changing event for the better.
chaotic and crime-rampant environment also jeop-
To further understand the earthquake’s impact on
ardized the children’s safety and well-being. One
Haiti’s children, we also analyzed how the earth-
nurse cared for a girl who exhibited signs of sexual
quake affected parents and child caregivers. In a
and physical abuse. The lack of infrastructure to
majority of the cases, parents and caregivers in Haiti
handle these types of abuse cases in Haiti made it all
exhibited attitudes and practices that one would
the more difficult for her to report and remediate the
expect to see anywhere else in the world—they
situation, as she recalled:
cared for and protected their children.
It was really, it was a really difficult experience because
of the child . . . just broke your heart . . . I think it’s I found . . . as I’ve experienced with parents in every
traumatic any time you see a child that’s been abused place where I’ve worked, the parents just want to take
like that. (RN9) good care of their kids. (RN5)

Most of the children were severely negatively Another nurse described how the parents were
impacted by the earthquake, but some nurses noted often at the hospital continually, taking care of the
that there were a few unexpected cases where the children, getting them up, bathing, and feeding
earthquake actually had a positive impact. In these them.
circumstances, children with illnesses prior and The Haitian’s love for children and their celebra-
unrelated to the earthquake were “found” or “dis- tion for life and family were paramount despite their
covered” because of the earthquake. One nurse difficult and unfortunate circumstance. One emer-
explains about a young boy: gency nurse observed:

246 Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing 17 (2012) 242–253


© 2012, Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
E. Sloand et al. Nursing Children After a Disaster: A Qualitative Study of Nurse Volunteers and Children After the Haiti Earthquake

We give them pregnancy tests and they’d [be told they came back and was completely altered . . . I was
will] have a baby and they’re all excited and they start working night shift that night and we had worked on
crying and they’re grateful and I’m like, you just lost her for about 8 hours and then she passed away. And to
everything you have and you’re happy that you’re see the mom running with her in the street and stuff was
having a baby and . . . it was hard for me to understand really sad, really challenging. (RN6)
but . . . family’s everything to them . . . (RN7)
Some nurses saw a paradoxical occurrence where
Many children were displaced and separated from select parents, particularly mothers, detached from
their loved ones. Parents or caregivers with children the child. For example, RN3 described her experi-
in intensive/hospital settings often served as proxy ence working with a set of newborn twins where the
caregivers to orphaned children. For example, one mother had difficulty feeding one of them and “just
nurse saw mothers gathering around and praying gave up on him” (RN3). As a result, the baby became
over an orphaned child. She explained, “They were severely malnourished. The mother later returned
acting as a mother for all the children, like beautiful to and “. . . basically the mom handed over the baby to
watch, and I’ll never forget” (RN4). Relatives often them” (RN3). In other cases, women attempted to
assumed the parenting role: “I saw a couple babies terminate their pregnancies via dangerous means.
whose mothers had died in the earthquake and now Being a mother in this time of chaos and uncertainty
have family members taking care of them” (RN1). was not easy. One nurse explained the experience of
But the future of these orphaned children remains a new mother:
uncertain. In such a poor environment so severely
lacking in most resources, adults could barely satisfy The baby was delivered and, they monitored them for
their own life-sustaining needs, let alone take care of an hour, maybe 2 hours, and they said okay, you can go
a child who is not their own, as one nurse recalled: home, and she got on the back of a motorcycle and
drove home, . . . with the bumpy road at the back of a
I do remember at one point, one mom, it wasn’t a mom, motorcycle holding the baby . . . (RN8)
it was an aunt or a cousin of a woman who died in the
earthquake had this newborn baby and she actually Another overwhelming consequence of the earth-
handed the baby to me and said, “Will you take her back quake was its impact on parents and children as a
with you to the United States because I can’t care for family unit. One particular woman’s family was
her, there’s nothing I can do for her.” (RN1) broken by the earthquake:

This nurse knew that the baby was sick and was We took care of another woman who was on our ward
not thriving, but she had to give the infant back. She because she, she had given birth . . . it’s a newborn baby
reports, “It was absolutely heartbreaking to have to and she was not bonding with the baby because what
give the baby back and say I can’t do that . . . so had happened was during . . . the quake . . . she was
9-months pregnant and . . . she had dug through the
those were, those were really tough times. . . .”
rubble to find her children and her husband. She
Death and loss were a common and persistent
came across each of her children, each of her dead chil-
occurrence in post-earthquake Haiti, and children dren, . . . she dug them out. (RN4)
and pregnant women were particularly vulnerable.
One nurse practitioner who arrived in Haiti 2
months after the earthquake described: Theme 2: Professional compromises and
unsettling results
I returned to the parents, I carried down a number of There were severe limitations of supplies and medi-
children who died . . . there were pregnant women
cations, personnel, referral sources, and a range of
who died, there were pregnant women whose babies
died right after they gave birth . . . (RN2)
other resources throughout the healthcare sites in
Haiti. For the nurses caring for children, there were
While parental death leaves an orphaned child additional child-specific needs that made the prob-
with an uncertain future, the death of a child is lems even more acute. Children need smaller sizes of
equally heartbreaking. An emergency room (ER) certain equipment, such as nebulizer masks and
nurse described one of her most memorable intubation materials. They often need liquid medi-
moments with a 14-year-old girl: cines and syringes or small cups to properly dispense
medications. Pediatric expertise that helps ensure
There was one girl that had actually came in the day optimum care to children was another area of unmet
before, they said it was like viral illness . . . and then she need. Infants and children are more fragile in

Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing 17 (2012) 242–253 247


© 2012, Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
Nursing Children After a Disaster: A Qualitative Study of Nurse Volunteers and Children After the Haiti Earthquake E. Sloand et al.

general, which made them more vulnerable to mal- try somehow or find somebody and tell them you’ve
nutrition and dehydration. Nurses reported that the got this medicine, we don’t have any more water, we
lack of proper pediatric resources oftentimes pushed don’t have any here now, so if there’s somewhere
them to find creative solutions to health manage- you can find some . . .” (RN2). Nurses developed
ment problems. treatment plans that parents were not likely to be
Pediatric nurses described how they were not able able to carry out, which was troubling because it is so
to use some of the available medicines confidently contradictory to nursing standards of practice. The
because many pills were not scored to be accurately same PNP needed to give antibiotics to a mother for
broken into child-size doses. They lacked small her three children. The only containers available in
syringes that could be used to effectively hydrate a clinic were small paper cups, but he knew that using
severely ill infant; they lacked IV fluids and lines. those cups was a totally flawed solution: “I’m trying
Limited supplies resulted in grim consequences for to figure out . . . how she’s gonna walk out of there
children and very unsettled nurses. One ER nurse carrying 4 or 5 Dixie cups with liquid medicine in
explained: “What bothered me a lot is knowing that them that she’s supposed to give to these kids 2 or 3
the little 6-month-old baby could’ve survived if we times a day for the next 10 days.” He explained that
just had suctioning . . . small things like that that she was likely returning to a home that consisted of
you can’t help but, what bothers me the most is you four branches stuck in dirt and propping up a tarp or
couldn’t do anything about it” (RN7). One nurse in old sheet; there are no chairs, counters, refrigera-
primary care explained the difficulties of caring for tors, or really anyplace to put the medicines. Time
a young boy who was wheezing and short of and again, the nurses explained that their best avail-
breath: “There weren’t spacers or anything like able solution was woefully inadequate and that
that . . . there was no electricity so we couldn’t set really bothered them.
up a nebulizer machine or anything like that” (RN1). Children are different; they need caretakers, and it
She cut a hole in the bottom of a plastic water bottle was often not obvious who those caretakers would
to make a spacer for a metered dose inhaler. Later, be. A hospital-ship nurse found that the lack of reli-
when the boy felt better, she was conflicted about his able rehabilitative care for these seriously injured
discharge medicines: “I felt really awful sending him children posed an ethical dilemma for her. At the
home . . . just knowing that he had such a terrible same time, she did not have the ability to improve
asthmatic exacerbation and I had no medication the situation. When she described discharging chil-
other than steroids so I decided to . . . send him dren from the hospital ship, she noted: “Some of the
home with an inhaler . . . [but] it’s the only one that ethical issues I think that arose were in relation
I had.” She worried about what to do when the next to . . . where they were going to go or how they
child arrived with wheezing and she had no more were going to be taken care of afterwards and I just
inhalers. She mused: “It was just tough sending kids felt very torn when they were taking some of these
home knowing they didn’t have the medication kids to land . . . but at the same time, I don’t know
they needed.” A community clinic pediatric nurse what else could have been done, it—was just a very
practitioner (PNP) discussed the serious limitation of difficult situation . . . you just wished you could give
medicines: “You had medicines that really weren’t them all the resources that they needed” (RN4).
what you would use or what you want to use, but if Professional pediatric nursing and medical exper-
they were close enough you would give it a shot tise were a critical resource that was lacking. Deci-
because it was that or nothing” (RN2). Substitutions sions about the care of individual children were
and trial and error were strategies that the nurses affected. A hospital-based RN remembered a difficult
used but were not completely comfortable with. situation where a girl had continuous seizures, and
Even more basic than the lack of medicines and the whole team deliberated about whether to intu-
supplies was the dramatic shortage of clean water bate her or not. Unfortunately, they did not have
needed to reconstitute pediatric suspensions and any pediatric nurses working in the intensive care
containers to put the medicine in. One PNP needed unit (ICU) that day and night, so they eventually
to dispense medications after the clinic ran out of decided that intubation was not a viable option
water for mixing them so he had to explain to the because there would be no one to care for her on the
parents how to go home and mix the medicines with ventilator. Making this decision greatly diminished
clean water. “They would look at me and say well, I the girl’s chance for survival. Later, the same nurse
don’t know where we can get any clean water. And reports being the only nurse working night shift in
I’d say I understand, all I can say is if you can possibly the neonatal ICU with six babies who needed feed-

248 Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing 17 (2012) 242–253


© 2012, Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
E. Sloand et al. Nursing Children After a Disaster: A Qualitative Study of Nurse Volunteers and Children After the Haiti Earthquake

ings every three hours, which was impossible for her the same, they bounce back, they love, . . . they
to do. Her best solution was creative: she recruited have so much life you know, [they] want to live and
other volunteer physicians and nurses who were not experience” (RN3).
scheduled to work that night and showed them When talking about the children, some nurses
what to do as she supervised. As a pediatric nurse, specifically used the word “love.” One nurse dis-
she was often moved to work during her time off: cussed the severely injured children she cared for on
“. . . we would wander around to the hospital tent the hospital ship, including those with multiple
side . . . to the pediatric tent . . . to see if they amputations and serious crush injuries to the face
needed any help because a lot . . . of the nurses and extremities, and said:
there had no peds experience . . . and then [I] just
waited for day shift to come” (RN3). Knowing there “I think what really, really touched me though is that
was a lack of pediatric proficiency, she helped out they were so loving still, and . . . we would reach out to
until her scheduled shift began. Lack of pediatric them and they were scared—but at the same time, it’s
expertise also affected the ethical decision-making of like love took a language all its own . . . they were able
the nurse who cared for a severely dehydrated to feel the love. . . .” (RN4)
infant; if there were more personnel to care for the
children at the clinic, he could have spent much The same nurse talked of love as a communication
more time with the infant and mother rehydrating. vehicle that broke the language barrier, which was
But instead he reluctantly chose to move on to critical because the children spoke Haitian Creole
the other children. Time and time again, nurses and translators were not always available. She was
described how the limited pediatric expertise caused describing the language barrier as one of her biggest
them to be creative and sometimes give more com- challenges given the importance of talking with chil-
promised care than they would have wanted. dren on their level to comfort them and calm them,
but added: “. . . just being able to hold them . . . I
was always walking around with a child in my
arms or a child holding onto me and . . . that com-
Theme 3: Universality of children fort, . . . that physical touch, just the love. . . . It has
Children have characteristics and behaviors that are a language that surpasses any other language, so we
universal. Regardless of the circumstances that they were able to communicate. . . .” (RN4)
find themselves in, children laugh, play, hug, give Children are ready to play if they have the oppor-
love, and seek security. Pediatric nurses expect tunity. They will play with toys or they will make up
these behaviors in hospital units and health centers games with or without toys. While this is not surpris-
in the United States. The nurse volunteers in Haiti, ing to anyone who interacts with children, it is stun-
however, seemed surprised that these same traits ning that these traits persist against the backdrop
and behaviors were true for the children in Haiti of devastation in post-earthquake Haiti. The
after the earthquake. Some nurses worked in out- community-based PNP who was caring for a child
patient clinics and cared for children who suffered suffering a severe asthma attack had very little treat-
the losses of parents, home, school, siblings, regular ment capacity, and the best she could do was give
routines, and a stable environment. Others worked two puffs of a beta-adrenergic inhaler every few
in acute hospital settings and cared for children minutes. She explained:
who suffered life-threatening injuries in addition to
the losses of parents, home, school, siblings, regular “I had him sitting in the corner of the clinic . . . and
between every patient I would go over there to give him
routines, and a stable environment. Time after
a couple more puffs. I gave him a piece of paper and a
time, the nurse volunteers found that the children
crayon and every time I went over there I would give
had a ready smile or a hug for them in spite of their him a different color crayon and I remember after about
circumstances. 30 minutes . . . he was standing right there next to me
Nurses commented on the resilience of the Haitian holding up this picture and gave it to me and I still have
people, but it seemed to be even more pronounced it so it was all the different colors you can see like where
with respect to children. One nurse, working the he added new colors in and it was just really cool.”
pediatric ward at PAP hospital, asserted: “. . . that’s (RN1)
why I like pediatrics because the kids . . . have such
resilience anyways anywhere . . . it doesn’t matter Scenes in Haiti were reminiscent of scenes in any
what country or . . . where they come from, kids are pediatric setting, including the way children run and

Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing 17 (2012) 242–253 249


© 2012, Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
Nursing Children After a Disaster: A Qualitative Study of Nurse Volunteers and Children After the Haiti Earthquake E. Sloand et al.

jump and climb around even if it is a small office or a difficult, heartbreaking, and frustrating. On one
hospital room. One nurse reported: “. . . there’s one hand, these emotions appeared to stem from these
little girl with . . . hepatitis A who had you know nurses’ uncertainty about whether they made the
eyeballs the color of this saucer and happy and right decisions and practiced to their fullest capabili-
playing and running around, climbing into my lap, ties despite the resource restraints. Many nurses
crawling on me” (RN10). reported that if only they had more resources, be it
In addition to love, play was another way that human capital, supplies, medications, or equipment,
nurses addressed the language barrier with the chil- many problems and deaths could have been resolved
dren. An acute care nurse was working with a girl or prevented. Even upon returning to the United
who put a battery in her nose, which is a universal States, many nurses said those were the moments
pediatric situation in itself. She explains: that they remember and think about, as one
explained:
“. . . we spent a lot of time with her, we had some ENT
nurse practitioners that were there to . . . help get that Most of the cases that stick in my mind are cases where
out . . . just being able to play with her even though you kind of say, “Did I do everything that I
there was the language barrier, and give her stickers and could’ve . . . ?” . . . that was part of taking care of
colors and stuff, . . . and seeing how much her mom was people in Haiti, was saying, “You know, this is not
enjoying spending time with her while she had all these ideal . . . am I making the right call?” (RN5)
toys and stuff . . . that was fun.” (RN6)
As a result, the resource restraints and uncertainty
Children in Haiti were like children encountered
in their practices fostered a sense of hopelessness
anywhere in the world, with a resilient fiber that is
among these nurses, as one PNP recalled, “You’re
part of them. One of the community-based nurses
almost helpless sometimes to help some of these
reflected: “Kids are incredibly resilient and I think
folks who have absolutely nothing” (RN2). Further,
it’s become such a cliché—they talk about resiliency
the nurses also showed a resigned attitude because
of the Haitian people but these kids were remark-
they were simply not in control, as RN2 continued:
able.” Later, she mused: “I don’t know that I saw a
little kid that didn’t crawl in my lap or give me a hug
You try to do anything you possibly can to provide some
or run around and play or beam when I gave them a
relief and such . . . I can tell you what, I just saw 2,000
sticker so, these kids just are remarkable” (RN10). kids in the last 16 days. I don’t think I hurt one of
them . . . maybe I helped some of them. (RN2)
Theme 4: The highs were higher and the lows were
lower: Emotional impact of disaster relief on On the other hand, the nurses’ emotions stemmed
nurse volunteers from the worry and uncertainty they had for Haiti’s
children, particularly those who were severely
When asked to describe their experience in Haiti, injured and/or orphaned. After the earthquake,
the nurses presented a wide range of emotional many children were displaced and their futures
responses. RN4 said, “We are all human. We all share were largely unknown, as a nurse who worked on
this common human experience.” Observing the the Navy ship described:
enormous loss and tragedy, the nurses were over-
whelmed with emotion. I was just so sad and scared because I didn’t know what
would happen to them and just knowing what was out
Those kids, I’ll never forget them, they just will always there . . . you see these kids with just broken limbs and
be on my, on my heart. (RN4) amputated, amputated their limbs and you wonder how
I mean it was so many just wonderful, beautiful kids. I they’re gonna survive in this environment. . . . where
don’t know that there was one more than any other that they were gonna go or how they were gonna be taken
grabbed your heart. There was one an hour that grabbed care of afterwards and I just felt, I felt very torn, when
your heart. (RN10) they were taking some of these kids to land. (RN4)

Because of their great affection for children, how- Seeing the dim and uncertain future that Haiti’s
ever, seeing disaster’s devastating impact on them children faced, many of the nurses also reported that
triggered and magnified emotional reactions related parting with them was one of the toughest experi-
to feelings of uncertainty. The nurse volunteers ences they have ever had. Some joked about wishing
labeled the reality of their work as mind-boggling, they could take the children home with them. RN7,

250 Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing 17 (2012) 242–253


© 2012, Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
E. Sloand et al. Nursing Children After a Disaster: A Qualitative Study of Nurse Volunteers and Children After the Haiti Earthquake

who worked in the ER for 16 days, had a particularly Army nurses because they were generally unpre-
heartfelt experience saying goodbye to a 12-year-old pared to care for children and did not have the proper
boy: supplies and medicines. Nurses reported creative
strategies they used when adapting equipment,
This little kid that I met there . . . he lost his family and similar to the nurses in our study. Interestingly, Farfel
he messed up his foot real bad and he came back and I and colleagues (2011) reported on the field hospital
hooked him up with some crutches and all that in PAP and noted the need for pediatricians with
stuff . . . The last words he said to me was like, “Can I go
intensive care and surgical skills, but they do not
with you?” I was like crying like a little baby and just go
mention the need for pediatric nurses, which seems a
get on that helicopter and it’s like, why can’t we stay
longer? Very mentally and emotionally [and] . . . physi- huge oversight given the essential contributions of
cally challenging. (RN7) nurses in a hospital setting.
Nurses in prior studies have also reported ethical
Despite the heavy emotional toll, the nurses dilemmas related to limited supplies. Agazio (2010)
asserted an overall positive outlook. In fact, many found that Army nurses had limited supplies and
reported that working in Haiti was a life-changing questioned themselves about how many supplies to
experience for the better. For one nurse in particular, use and reuse because they were not sure when the
it served as the motivation for her to return to school next shipment would be and what casualties they
and pursue a higher degree, as she recalled: might encounter before then. On the other hand,
Almonte (2009) found that nurses felt anguished
I remember this one little kid, we brought him up to the and ethically conflicted due to their limitations in
operating room and we put him under general sedation what they could do and how long they could stay at
to change all the dressings for all his amputations a site to help. They felt overwhelmed about giving
and . . . you know, that’s one of the reasons I wanted treatment to some knowing that there were so many
to become a nurse anesthetist . . . it was actually more who would not receive treatment, and they
that impetus that drove me to . . . apply to these pro-
had to consciously think about the good they were
grams . . . it was so powerful. (RN4)
able to accomplish in order to live with the memory
of the many they could not help. Similarly, the find-
In examining the themes overall, it was clear that
ings of this study are consistent with the many anec-
the nurses had a powerful experience professionally
dotal reports of nurses who volunteered in Haiti.
and personally. They were deeply touched by the
Nurses reported serious shortages of essential sup-
children they cared for. They sometimes felt very
plies, such as antibiotics, antiseptics, iodine, tetanus
unsettled by the compromised care that they often
vaccine, numbing agents, gauze, and fuel for gen-
had to give the children, but still recognized the
erators (Adams, 2010; Amundson et al., 2010;
common threads of caring for children regardless of
Etienne, Powell, & Faux, 2010; Lau, 2010; Merin,
circumstances.
Ash, Levy, Schwaber, & Kreiss, 2010; Pierre-Pierre,
2010; Vanholder, Gibney, Luyckx, & Sever, 2010).
Similar to our study, one report noted the ethical
DISCUSSION
challenges that arose from providing care under
The findings of this study are consistent with much of severe circumstances where it was impossible to
the literature, which details both a domestic and triage everyone seeking care (Merin et al., 2010).
international shortage of pediatric expertise during Due to a high demand and high patient turnover,
disasters and crises. One scientific study of military many in the steady stream of acutely ill patients
nurses explored the nursing practice challenges were admitted, treated, and discharged almost
encountered by Navy nurses responding to the immediately and well before complete recovery,
humanitarian crises after the Indian Ocean tsunami which was very difficult for many of the healthcare
in 2004 (Almonte, 2009). The nurses unanimously workers (Merin et al., 2010). Again, this is consis-
felt unprepared to care for children in the disaster and tent with our study findings.
particularly challenged in dealing with child and Reporting positive experiences of nurse volunteers
infant deaths. A similar study of military nurses is unusual in the scientific literature regarding
looked at nursing challenges in several worldwide humanitarian health workers. Researchers mostly
locations, including Afghanistan, Honduras, Iraq, report on the challenges and difficulties that nurses
and Bosnia (Agazio, 2010). The investigators found encounter (Agazio, 2010; Almonte, 2009). One
that children presented special challenges to the exception is the study of New Zealand nurses who

Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing 17 (2012) 242–253 251


© 2012, Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
Nursing Children After a Disaster: A Qualitative Study of Nurse Volunteers and Children After the Haiti Earthquake E. Sloand et al.

reported the overwhelming need they encountered of nurses caring for children in disasters. Systemic
in humanitarian work, and despite the minimalist documentation of nurse volunteer needs and condi-
treatment that they could provide, many children did tions could lead to the development of a preparation
heal (Zinsli & Smythe, 2009). They described emo- program or orientation for nurses who choose to
tional aspects of their service, and that pain and suf- respond to the call for volunteers in disasters. Such an
fering and love were all part of their experiences orientation should include a clear picture of the chil-
while volunteering (Zinsli & Smythe, 2009). They dren’s grim and difficult situations that will likely be
noted the joy they experienced when working with found, and the more limited capacity to help and “fix”
children in the midst of all the hardship, which was problems than most nurses would ordinarily have.
reflected in our study. In anecdotal accounts, some Humanitarian agencies ought to incorporate some
healthcare providers described the positive aspects of sort of support system for volunteer nurses when
their experiences. Nurses discussed developing cre- they return home.
ative solutions in a resource-poor environment,
including tying IV bags to trees, using branches as
splints, and creating traction using bricks from col-
lapsed buildings (Millender, 2010). One nurse hoped How might this information affect
to retain this creativity when she returned to her ER nursing practice?
job (Lau, 2010).
Skilled pediatric nurses will be needed in future
emergency humanitarian missions; the study
Limitations authors encourage them to respond when called
upon. Children will inadvertently be involved in
The nurses who participated in the study were not
disasters, and they are best cared for by those with
asked specific information about caring for infants
pediatric expertise. Nurses will likely find volun-
and children. Richer data might have been gener-
teering to be both professionally and personally
ated if such questions had been included in the inter-
rewarding. While some nurses may be concerned
view guide. Some of the interviews were conducted
about some of the difficulties and challenges of
by phone when an in-person interview was not pos-
working in a humanitarian crisis, they will also
sible, which may have affected the data collected.
encounter uplifting and joyful times when caring
Member checking, which is considered to be one of
for children. Some nurses may also feel uncertainty
the most robust ways to assure credibility, was not
about what they can contribute, but this study sug-
done. This may have strengthened the rigor of this
gests that the holistic, personalized care that is
study, although it is controversial and some experts
central to the nursing process will insure their
believe that the drawbacks of member checking
effectiveness and ability to make a difference for
limit its usefulness (Angen, 2010; McBrien, 2008).
the children and families they care for. Potential
Another limitation is the lack of transferability of
nurse volunteers, whether pediatric nurses or not,
results due to the small sample size and large varia-
should be prepared for ethical issues and related
tion in participant characteristics.
decision-making. They can also expect resources to
be limited and are advised to regularly schedule
PRACTICE AND RESEARCH IMPLICATIONS therapeutic debriefing during deployment and
upon return home. Nurses can also consider frame-
Because children require special care, they are one of
works for continuous quality improvement during
the most vulnerable groups in a crisis situation. There
deployment to facilitate the best care of children in
is a shortage of pediatric-experienced nurses serving
disasters. Nurse administrators and volunteers can
in postdisaster situations (Agazio, 2010; Almonte,
raise the awareness of humanitarian agencies
2009). As we plan for the next large-scale humanitar-
regarding child-specific needs, and such agencies
ian crisis, nurses must be prepared to address the
should be fully ready to care for children in a disas-
unique and specific needs of children. Humanitarian
ter situation. Further, humanitarian agencies
agencies must call upon nurses with pediatric exper-
should consider allocating or increasing the medi-
tise to improve the care that children receive in such
cations and supplies reserved for children so that
circumstances. Continued research on children and
nurses serving in crisis situations will have the
disasters would improve the outcomes of children
minimum necessary resources to care for their
suffering in humanitarian crises. A large quantitative
pediatric patients.
study would be helpful in further defining the needs

252 Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing 17 (2012) 242–253


© 2012, Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
E. Sloand et al. Nursing Children After a Disaster: A Qualitative Study of Nurse Volunteers and Children After the Haiti Earthquake

La Greca, A. M., Silverman, W. K., Vernberg, E. M., &


References Roberts, M. C. (2002). Helping children cope with disasters.
Adams, P. (2010). Relief agencies prepare for long haul Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
in Haiti. Lancet, 375, 539. doi:10.1016/S0140- Lau, D. (2010). Disaster relief: Helping the survivors of the
6736(10)60212-7 Haiti earthquake. Emergency Nurse, 17(10), 18–21.
Agazio, J. (2010). Army nursing practice challenges in Lincoln, Y. S., & Guba, E. G. (1986). But is it rigorous?
humanitarian and wartime missions. International Trustworthiness and authenticity in naturalistic
Journal of Nursing Practice, 16(2), 166–175. doi:10.1111/ evaluation. New Directions for Program Evaluation,
j.1440-172X.2010.01826.x 1986(30), 73–84.
Almonte, A. L. (2009). Humanitarian nursing challenges: McBrien, B. (2008). Evidence-based care: Enhancing the
A grounded theory study. Military Medicine, 174(5), rigour of a qualitative study. British Journal of Nursing
479–485. (Mark Allen Publishing), 17(20), 1286–1289.
Amundson, D., Dadekian, G., Gleeson, T., Hicks, T., Killian, Merin, O., Ash, N., Levy, G., Schwaber, M. J., & Kreiss, Y.
D., Kratovil, K., . . . Miller, E. J. (2010). Practicing (2010). The Israeli field hospital in Haiti—Ethical
internal medicine onboard the USNS comfort in the dilemmas in early disaster response. New England Journal
aftermath of the Haitian earthquake. Annals of Internal of Medicine, 362, e38(1–3). doi:10.1056/NEJMp1001693
Medicine, 152(11), 733–737. Millender, E. I. (2010). Haiti: A firsthand view. American
Angen, M. J. (2010). Evaluating interpretive inquiry: Journal of Nursing, 110(4), 22. doi:10.1097/01.NAJ.
Reviewing the validity debate and opening the dialogue. 0000370153.02729.29
Qualitative Health Research, 10(3), 378–395. doi:10.1177/ National Association of Pediatric Nurse Practitioners.
104973230001000308 (2011). Pediatric nurse practitioners’ role in disasters
Burnweit, C., & Stylianos, S. (2011). Disaster response in a involving children. Journal of Pediatric Health Care, 25,
pediatric field hospital: Lessons learned in Haiti. Journal 9A–10A.
of Pediatric Surgery, 46(6), 1131–1139. doi:10.1016/j. National Commission on Children and Disasters. (2010).
jpedsurg.2011.03.042 Report to the President and Congress. (AHRQ Publication No.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2010). Post- 10-M037). Retrieved from http://cybercemetery.unt.
earthquake injuries treated at a field hospital—Haiti, edu/archive/nccd/20110426214356/http://www.acf.
2010. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 59, 1673–1677. hhs.gov/ohsepr/nccdreport/index.html
Central Intelligence Agency. (2011). The world factbook: Patton, M. Q. (1990). Qualitative evaluation and research
Haiti. Retrieved September 12, 2011 from https://www. methods. London: Sage.
cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/ Pierre-Pierre, G. (2010). Going all out for Haiti. Nursing
ha.html Standard, 24(25), 18–19.
Corbin, J., & Strauss, A. (2008). Basics of qualitative research Sandelowski, M. (2010). What’s in a name? Qualitative
(3rd ed.). Los Angeles: Sage. description revisited. Research in Nursing and Health, 33,
Deckelbaum, D. L. (2010). The Haiti earthquake: A 77–84. doi:10.1002/nur.20362
personal perspective. Canadian Medical Association Stratton, S. J. (2010). Surge capacity implications and
Journal, 182(5), E241–E242. geographic maldistribution of pediatric medical
Etienne, M., Powell, C., & Faux, B. (2010). Disaster relief resources in Seattle-King County. Prehospital and Disaster
in Haiti: A perspective from neurologists on the USNS Medicine, 25(3), 333–334.
comfort. Lancet Neurology, 9(5), 461–463. doi:10.1016/ Thomas, E., & Magilvy, J. K. (2011). Qualitative rigor or
S1474-4422(10)70091-0 research validity in qualitative research. Journal for
Fallat, M. (2009). The impact of data on the pediatric Specialists in Pediatric Nursing, 16, 151–155. doi:10.1111/
trauma and critical care research agenda. Journal of j.1744-6155.2011.00283.x
Trauma, 67(2), S106–S107. U.S. Geological Survey. (2011). Magnitude 7.0—Haiti
Farfel, A., Assa, A., Amir, I., Bader, T., Bartel, C., Kreiss, Y., & region. Retrieved from http://earthquake.usgs.gov/
Saqi, R. (2011). Haiti earthquake 2010: A field hospital earthquakes/recenteqsww/Quakes/us2010rja6.
pediatric perspective. European Journal of Pediatrics, php#summary
170(4), 519–525. doi:10.1007/s00431-011-1423-8 Vanholder, R., Gibney, N., Luyckx, V. A., & Sever, M. S.
Goodman, A. (2010). Ministry of touch—Reflections on (2010). Renal disaster relief task force in Haiti
disaster work after the Haitian earthquake. New England earthquake. Lancet, 375, 1162–1163. doi:10.1016/
Journal of Medicine, 362(11), e37(1 –2). doi:10.1056/ S0140-6736(10)60513-2
NEJMp1002311 Zinsli, G., & Smythe, E. A. (2009). International
Huffman, J. (2011). Surgical palliative care in Haiti. Surgical humanitarian nursing work: Facing difference and
Clinics of North America, 91(2), 445–457. doi:10.1016/ embracing sameness. Journal of Transcultural Nursing, 20,
j.suc.2011.01.001 234–241. doi:10.1177/1043659608330351

Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing 17 (2012) 242–253 253


© 2012, Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

View publication stats

Anda mungkin juga menyukai