SUMMARY
New WESTRACE Solid State Interlocking systems utilise powerful, industry-standard, Information Technology
networks for most of its vital and non-vital communications. Standard protocols, through off the shelf communica-
tions hardware, provide unprecedented flexibility in designing large, complex, interconnected vital interlocking
systems. Serial communications paths, previously the most vulnerable parts of a system can be integrated into a
simple, redundant network. These networked connections open up new possibilities for hierarchical interlocking
systems while simultaneously giving flexible control powerful diagnostics.
This paper overviews the basic WESTRACE solid state interlocking and explains how railways can benefit from
transferring the vital data over networked communications to provide the maximum total system availability.
executed in vital logic ease the design. Any logic state Each and every railway feels the need to conduct its
can be transferred between the vital and non vital own safety assurance of the system. Some of these
logic. have been extremely rigorous and onerous. Inde-
pendent safety assurance consultants, recognised
Comprehensive diagnostics timestamp and record
industry safety experts and railway staff have audited
every vital and non-vital change of logic state.
and reviewed the thorough in-house safety assurance
All WESTRACE vital, non vital and diagnostic com- program that has always been integrated throughout
munications are by default routed using industry each phase of the development lifecycle.
standard UDP/IP (a subset of TCP/IP) over an
WESTRACE safety architecture is based on
industry standard 10 BaseT Ethernet port. Serial links
can also be used where Ethernet is not practical. • appropriate development environment
These features are described in more detail later in • appropriate development processes and tools
this paper.
• comprehensive diversity (and where possible, di-
WESTRACE’s inherent power and flexibility has versity between hardware and software)
allowed it to be applied in several related applications.
• demonstratable fault negation (and anti-de-nega-
The WESTECT Automatic Train Protection (ATP)
tion) systems
system uses the standard WESTRACE platform as its
heart. A trackside Encoder that transmits data to the • comprehensive testing of memory, hardware and
train informing it of signal states is simply a stored data
WESTRACE with an additional module. The WESTRACE either uses inherently vital hardware or
WESTECT ATP On Board Computer is also at least two diverse processes to ensure the system
WESTRACE based. integrity. Different software programs using diverse
WESTRACE’s inherent vital telemetery has been code independently evaluate the logic and compare
used without the associated logic to safely communi- the result. All system data is both stored and commu-
cate relay states over both radio and PCM channels, nicated in diverse forms—all the way from the input
including as a vital Token Block interface system. modules, through processing, to the output modules
and the results are compared at each phase. All vital
Some railways, such as in the UK, have particularly modules continually check themselves, cross check
complex requirements of level crossing control. each other and the VLM (including the correct opera-
WESTRACE has been configured as a flexible level tion of the processors) to ensure error free and totally
crossing controller, with many standard crossing con- safe operation.
figurations built in.
It is particularly interesting to note that WESTRACE
WESTRACE forms a key part of Invensys Rail’s pilot has passed some of the most demanding safety
line ERTMS systems. approval processes in the world, such as those of BR-
3. WIDELY ACCEPTED AND PROVEN IN SERVICE RailTrack-Network Rail, London Underground and
the EBA in Germany.
WESTRACE has become one of the worlds most
popular solid state interlockings since its introduction It has been assessed as compliant with RIA23,
in 1990. Over 1,000 installations are now in operation CENELEC EN50128, EN5029 and other recognised
including several very large installations with multiple safety standards.
WESTRACEs. Invensys Rail member company Westinghouse Rail
It has been applied to almost every conceivable type Systems of the UK has just been awarded a £850M
of railway; on mainline and subway systems, in freight contract for the resignalling of approximately two
and passenger service as well as in both dc and ac thirds of the whole of the London Underground
(up to 25 kVac) electrified territory. network using WESTRACE. London Underground is
one of the world’s busiest metro systems. They
It has gained safety approval, and is in use, in the fol- already have extensive experience of this system as
lowing countries; it is in use on the Central and Jubilee Lines and is cur-
rently the only solid state interlocking of its type
approved by London Underground.
• Australia • Germany
• Indonesia • Ireland WESTRACE also fully complies with the RDSO
• Malaysia • New Zealand standard for solid state interlockings for use on Indian
• Norway • Philippines
Railways
• Portugal • Romania
• Spain • Thailand WESTRACE continues to undergo continual improve-
• United Kingdom
ment and evolution since its introduction to increase
its capacity, do more and be easier to use. This evo-
lution rather then revolution approach maintains the checking. This enables it to check lamp circuits, re-
basic system architecture and therefore the maximum gardless of whether the aspect is currently energised.
backward compatibility to preserve a railway’s invest- The cold filament checking pulse is so short that it
ment in the large installed base. The evolution won’t produce a visible output from a de-energised
includes aspect.
• major increases in logic capacity The VROM and VLOM outputs incorporate a Graceful
• specialist input and output modules to interface with Degradation feature. If a fault is detected in an output
coded track circuits, WESTECT, etc circuit it is safely disabled but the remainder of the in-
terlocking continues operating normally. A fault bit is
• enhanced diagnostics cleared and this may be used in the logic. Graceful
• addition of non vital logic processing degradation limits the impact of any failure to the
• communications, especially the IP based network directly affected area—most of the railway continues
communications operation until the fault is repaired.
• design, testing and maintenance tools Each WESTRACE uses between one and four, 6RU
high 19 inch housings that are normally installed into
Unchanged modules can continue to be used with the
a 19 inch rack. The VLM and NCDM must be installed
new modules. A relevant case occurred in mid 2002
at the right side of the top housing but other modules
when the first ever WESTRACE, installed at Dry
can be installed anywhere. Only the number of
Creek in South Australia in 1990, was significantly
housings required to contain the modules required for
expanded to meet new operational requirements. In
an installation need be provided.
the process, the size of the installation approximately
doubled. All the existing input and output modules The WESTRACE design has paid particular attention
from the original installation were re-used in the new to immunity to both conducted and induced electro-
application. We were also able to transfer the original magnetic interference. The housing itself is fully
application logic for use as the starting point for the shielded and all circuits entering or leaving the enclo-
upgraded system. sure pass through carefully designed isolation filters.
High immunity to interference is not just a matter of
4. THE MODULAR INTERLOCKING
shielding and filtering. It is a system issue that
WESTRACE is a modular interlocking. Every installa- involves many disciplines. Therefore the WESTRACE
tion requires the Vital Logic Module (VLM) and the system documentation includes the appropriate rec-
non-vital logic, communication and diagnostic module ommendations on primary protection, earthing and
(NCDM), as well as a power supply module. Other cabling that ensure it is always applied in ways that
modules are added as necessary to provide the maintain this high inherent immunity.
required quantity and type of inputs or outputs.
WESTRACE is successfully operating in many areas
Most systems need only one type of input module and of extremely high incidence of lightning, such as
one or two types of output module. central Java in Indonesia and Northern Queensland
in Australia. These installations demonstrate the ex-
The Vital Parallel Input Module (VPIM) is the general
purpose input module. It detects the presence of 50 tremely reliable operation of a correctly installed
Vdc from external detection circuits or existing relays system. Recently there have been several cases
(eg track relays). Twelve fully isolated input circuits where lightning has struck near a location where a
are provided per VPIM module. Two inputs may be WESTRACE has been installed alongside other solid
combined in anti-parallel to detect polarised inputs. state interlocking technologies. The high immunity of
the WESTRACE was then impressively demonstrat-
The Vital Relay Output Module (VROM) is the general ed as it was the only unit to continue operation unaf-
purpose output module, sourcing 50 Vdc outputs to fected.
drive point contactors, Q relays or similar. Eight
isolated outputs are provided per VROM module. The system has been designed for use over an
They can be wired in anti-parallel to drive polar cir- extended temperature range of up to 70 °C ambient.
Air conditioning of the equipment room or location
cuits.
case is not a requirement. For example, in Indonesia
Signals may be directly driven by the Vital Lamp and Malaysia we have successfully provided a total of
Output Module (VLOM). This module can directly 123 WESTRACE installations and none of the equip-
drive 110 Vac LED or transformer coupled incandes- ment is in an air-conditioned environment.
cent signals (including those with filament changeo-
Overall, this extensive in service experience has
ver relays). The module has an integral steady or
resulted in an exceptionally reliable design. For
flashing aspect control with all flashing outputs from
example, as of the date of this paper all of the 60
an interlocking synchronised. The VLOM incorpo-
WESTRACE systems installed in Malaysia have been
rates both hot filament proving and cold filament
continuously operated for over 18 months without a powerful and flexible feature that opens up many pos-
single failure of WESTRACE equipment of any kind. sibilities and some of these are discussed below.
5. WESTRACE SYSTEM CAPACITY The network is based on the industry standard UDP/
IP protocol (a subset of TCP/IP selected used to
A common question is, “How powerful is
comply with safety restrictions), over 10 BaseT
WESTRACE, how much railway can it control?”.
Ethernet with a RJ45 connection. All data is coded
That is often a difficult question to answer because it and fully protected against all forms of corruption,
depends on a local signalling practice. For example, delay or transformation during transmission. The vital
it depends upon the complexity of the signalling prin- data messages containing the true and complement
ciples of the railway and whether the tracks are bi-di- data and CRCs are assembled and checked in the
rectional. However, a general sense of its capacity VLM and simply encapsulated in an IP packet by the
can be gained from the following vital statistics. NCDM for transport. Non vital data and diagnostic IP
packets are assembled in the NCDM. All data can
A single VLM can handle;
transferred over industry standard networks using
• 3,357 Internal Vital Latches (relay equivalents) industry standard IT hardware. Good network design
• 300 Internal Vital Timers will usually include network segmentation and redun-
dant routing paths and can utilise existing infrastruc-
• around 1,800-2,600 rungs of vital logic, with up to ture. High bandwidth links is generally not required
50 relay equivalent ‘contacts’ in each rung. outside a local area and typically a 64 kb/s circuit is
The non-vital logic has about 10 times this capacity. adequate for multiple interlockings along a railway.
This is typically sufficient processing capacity for 175- Proper separation should be maintained for vital data
200 Routes. and we recommend physically restricting the access
from an organisation’s general network. Some data
Processing capacity is only part of the answer and
may be made more widely available via an appropri-
there is a physical limitation in the 4 available
ately safety rated firewall that can also prevent
housings for input and output modules. Up to 28 input
network congestion from external sources.
and output modules can be used across 4 housings.
Each WESTRACE can simultaneously run 16 vital
Larger systems may use multiple racks of
and 16 non vital communication sessions.
WESTRACE, often with all the processing executing
in a single VLM. This keeps all the interlocking logic in 6.2 Stand-alone interlockings
one processor and eliminates the ‘cross-boundary’
issues that would complicate the design if the logic The most basic WESTRACE configuration is a stand-
were distributed across several processors. It simpli- alone interlocking as shown in Figure 2:
fies design and maintenance, and minimises
response time. It may also be used, as described
later, to segment the railway for availability.
WESTRACE has features that makes it particularly
simple to link multiple systems together. To under- (via WAN)
6. INTERLOCKING CONFIGURATIONS
VPIMs VROMs VLOMs
Many of the interlocking configurations rely on the ef- Adjacent
VPIMs VROMs VLOMs
WESTRACE
fective network communication architecture that (via WAN)
allows multiple vital and non-vital, high capacity, com- Railway Signalling Equipment
munications sessions to be established between in-
terlockings and the associated control and diagnostic Figure 2: Standalone Ineterlocking showing network
systems. A subset of the configurations is possible connections to the signalling environment
using serial point to point or point to multi-point com- Remote or local controls and indications are ex-
munications although these are mostly retained for in- changed over a serial link with external non-vital I/O
terface to legacy or hard wired systems. to interface a push button local panel (not shown) or
6.1 Communication Network over the network with a PC based control panel or a
remote (CTC) control centre. Logic can be configured
WESTRACE uses the network to exchange most of in the NCDM to handle all local and remote control, so
the vital and non-vital data in the system. This is a that control authority can be passed between the
systems as required or under fault conditions. Indica-
tions are sent to all control points but the logic the associated trenching costs. As the interlocking
ensures that control is only accepted from one. logic is all located centrally, this approach doesn’t
increase the complexity of the logic design.
The network is used to interface local and remote di-
agnostic systems. Although other solid state interlocking technologies
can appear to approximate to this approach, the flex-
Vital data (eg block information) may be exchanged
ibility of WESTRACE makes it so much easier. The
with adjacent interlockings over the network.
unusually large processing capacity ensures that the
6.3 Linked WESTRACE systems central WESTRACE can handle more Object Control-
lers before having to resort to splitting the logic across
The vital communications over the network become
additional interlockings and introducing boundaries.
particularly powerful, yet simple, where multiple
The networked architecture permits a particularly
WESTRACEs need to be connected for capacity or
simple single point interconnection approach over
distributed input and output purposes.
industry standard media rather than using multiple,
The most common application is within a single proprietary, point to point links with associated line in-
station area to link a master WESTRACE containing terfaces.
interlocking logic to one or more ‘dumb’ WESTRACEs
This Object controller approach can also be
that don’t contain active logic. These are then called
combined with another outstanding WESTRACE
Object Controllers and only the central WESTRACE
feature to provide an even more cost effective
with the logic is referred to as an Interlocking. There
solution as described below.
may also be links to adjacent interlockings for block
working. Figure 3:shows an example of a master 6.4 WESTRACE Hot standby Systems
WESTRACE and 4 object controllers. Only the prime
Hot standby is an integral feature of WESTRACE. It is
sources of control and diagnosis are not shown for
not an application engineered feature and no location
simplicity.
specific logic design is required. The Hot Standby
option only needs to be selected in the configuration
and the configuration logic prepared as normal.
Hot Standby, as an integral feature, has been subject-
WESTRACE
ed to the same rigorous design and safety approval
VLM6 NCDM
process as the rest of the design. This is important as
bolt-on hot standby can introduce a safety risks.
The WESTRACE hot standby system connects two
WAN to
Optional Hot Standby
other WESTRACEs separate, identical, standard WESTRACE systems
by high speed fibre optic links. The VLM and NCDM
each have separate fibre optic connections. The off-
VLM6 NCDM VLM6 NCDM VLM6 NCDM VLM6 NCDM
line system is completely updated with an identical
VPIMs VROMs
VROMs VLOMs VPIMs VROMs
VROMs VLOMs VPIMs VROMs VPIMs VROMs
VROMs VLOMs
VROMs VLOMs
VPIMs VLOMs VPIMs VLOMs VPIMs VLOMs VPIMs VLOMs
image of every internal logic state once every
Railway Signalling Equipment processing cycle. Even the software version in use
and the interlocking unique address is checked during
Figure 3: A WESTRACE Central + Object Controller the update. There is no possibility of the two available
system systems being out of correspondence at any time.
This technique may be used to expand input and There is no possibility of both interlockings have safe
output capacity but it is a powerful cost saving feature but different logic states due to slight differences in
as well. The central WESTRACE can now be located timing for reading inputs (this situation that could give
conveniently, perhaps in existing accommodation or an unsafe result on changeover cannot occur with
where maintenance access is best. The Object Con- WESTRACE)
trollers can be in the same place. However, they can
also be fitted closer to the equipment under control, Figure 4:shows a typical connection of a hot-stand-by
such as in trackside location cases or other conven- WESTRACE. The remote or local control do not have
iently located accommodation. By putting the Object to be duplicated and are omitted from this drawing for
Controllers close to the relevant equipment, consider- simplicity. Typically, they would connect to the switch
able savings can be realised by reducing cabling and shown.
ports.) Each interlocking change of state is stored as The underlying database is in standard Microsoft
it is received. A new file is created every few days Access format and can be separately analysed if re-
(user configured). Files older that 30 days are deleted quired.
or separately archived.
The graphical view coupled with the advanced
Users can configure the PC displays to show: logging and replay features has made MoviolaW a
useful tool for investigating incidents such as Driver
• track diagrams with signal, point and track occu-
passes a signal at Danger. The relationship between
pancy status shown by colour and shape;
the track circuit and the signal aspect can be clearly
• state of any nominated latches or inputs in the seen and understood by all. Even the simple exercise
system in a separate window of showing this to just a few drivers can create a no-
• status of selected (DOS wildcards are supported) ticeable improvement in driving practices and culture
mnemonics (eg all points) in a separate window across the whole fleet.
• all or selected mnemonic changes of state on a MoviolaW can be accessed remotely via the network,
cycle by cycle basis in a separate window dedicated serial port or dial in to view or replay and
• Reports on selected mnemonics (eg the number of has become a very important diagnostic tool. Logged
changes for a set of points) in the logged period data may be extracted over this connection for local
replay
• A diagram of the housing showing each of the
modules—the module will be shown in red if it is 8. DESIGN & TEST TOOLS
faulty. WESTRACE has been developed so that signal engi-
• english text messages describing any configured, neers, who are competent to design relay based cir-
external failures (eg, lamp fail, loss of detection) cuits, can apply the system with the minimum of
additional training. Our customers have confirmed
MoviolaW can also execute logic to generate alarms.
that typically only 5 days of system design training is
required for such staff. Additional training is only
required to fully use some of the more advanced pro-
ductivity and test tools. However the standard system
design training is entirely sufficient for a signal
engineer to design and test a WESTRACE interlock-
ing. Figure 6: overviews the design and test tools
available and the design and test process.
• select and place modules 8.2 Installation Check Sub System (ICS)
• define each input or output for a module It is vitally important that the right version of the
• define the data carried over any of the serial links or correct data is installed error free in the intended
network sessions and to define the sessions system. WESTRACE inherently checks the version
and ICS confirms what is actually in the target
• Design the signalling logic
WESTRACE by uploading, decompiling and validat-
• Manage the design through input, check, test, ing against the source data.
approve and maintenance phases
8.3 Graphical Simulator (GSIM)
It uses relay equivalent design concepts including a
graphical drag and drag approach from a palette of WESTRACE interlockings can be tested in the tradi-
standard icons. This is equivalent to drawing relay tional manner, using the control panel a custom
circuits using the familiar relay contact notation. PLC switch panel to simulate field equipment. MoviolaW
style ladder logic notation is also available, the user must be used to view the internal states and assists
can switch freely between the two. Figure 7: is an by giving a railway view of the testing. However, this
example of familiar signalling logic. approach requires the actual interlocking, completed
control panel (or even CTC) and expensive, custom
made field simulation. It is relatively inconvenient and
time consuming.
GSIM is a windows based software tool that provides
• a control centre mimic diagram for controlling the
simulated railway
• a track based mimic diagram and underlying logic
to simulate field equipment (points, signals, etc)
• one or many instances of the same logic evaluation
engine as is used in WESTRACE
• optional interfaces to a WESTCAD control system
and a MoviolaW system to enable all components
to be tested together
• logging and script generation (for repeated test
Figure 7: GCSS Logic Design Screen setups) facilities
GCSS also performs consistency checks to ensure
that syntactical and semantic errors such as unused
or duplicated mnemonics and configuration rule viola-
WESTRACE
tion are detected. Full version control ensures Ladder Logic
changes are properly authorised and controlled. Dif- Simulator
structed making the majority of testing and test record Overview and competency based training courses
keeping automated. available (often delivered to site staff) include
GSIM is suitable for safety proof testing of the inter- • Appreciation Course (half day)
lockings when used as specified. Once tested, only • First Line Maintenance Course (5 days)
correspondence (or connectivity) testing, is required
on site. • System Design Course (5-7 days)
• Set to Work Course
The combination of GCSS and GSIM means that the
required construction and testing time on site is very • Graphical Simulator Design
short and new installations can be commissioned in a • MoviolaW Design
matter of hours. Similarly stage-works can be intro-
Design and maintenance courses are competency
duced quickly and smoothly.
based with a significant hands-on component. The
Modifications to an interlocking can be executed with training materials are of a high quality and profession-
minimum down time because the modification can be al training specialists are used to deliver the courses.
fully tested in the office. A ‘Train Your Trainer’ service is also available so that
customers can subsequently deliver training courses
Apart from potential cost savings, this also helps
to their own staff independently. Invensys Rail recom-
maintain safety. This is because all the time the inter-
mends a 1 day refresher version of the maintenance
locking is unavailable during a commissioning or
courses is because the system is so reliable that staff
stage-works the railway is likely to continue to operate
do not have the need to practice their skills.
using emergency procedures. This can introduce
many safety risks as the railway is not enjoying the full The whole aim of the tools, training and support
protection of the signalling. Keeping this time as short model is to enable customers to competently imple-
as possible reduces the risk of related safety inci- ment WESTRACE based systems without direct
dents to a minimum. support from the supplier. Of course, such support is
available if required but the customer can have a high
8.4 Training, Manuals & Support
degree of independence if desired.
WESTRACE is supported by a comprehensive set of
Part of the support available includes the provision of
user documentation that is sufficient for the design
maintenance services, and module repairs as a
and maintenance of the system. The main documents
minimum. A wide range of services can be made
include;
available as required;
• WESTRACE System overview manual
• Repair or Exchange—From a local base
• WESTRACE Application manual
• Spares on Consignment
• Graphical Configuration Sub-System manual • Guaranteed stock holdings
• Installation Check Sub-System manual
• Extended Warranties
• First line maintenance manual • Long term pricing agreements
and are supplemented by manuals for GSIM and
• Full on-site maintenance services
MoviolaW
• Any combination of the above
Describes the System
9. SUMMARY
How to
Design a WESTRACE
System Overview Manual
The interlocking is the heart of the railway. Its per-
System
formance and safety are critical to the performance
WESTRACE WESTRACE and safety of the railway as a whole. The modern
First Line Maintenance
Application Manual
Manual railway is also a business and requires cost effective-
WESTRACE WESTRACE WESTRACE
ness in everything.
WESTRACE
Installation Check Graphical Configuration Template
TemplateTool
Tool
Sub System Manual System Manual Manual
Manual How to Maintain
a System
Figure 9: Documentation