net/publication/275406655
CITATIONS READS
0 8,290
1 author:
Aditya Tom
Deakin University
3 PUBLICATIONS 0 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Encouraging growth of sustainable buildings in Indian commercial sector using Energy Performance Contracting View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Aditya Tom on 25 April 2015.
submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the award of the degree of
BACHELOR OF TECHNOLOGY
IN
CIVIL ENGINEERING
Submitted by
BONAFIDE CERTIFICATE
Certified that this project work entitled “Coconut Fibre Reinforced Concrete” is an
authentic record of project work done by Aditya Tom (Reg.No. 10001911), Anushree
S (Reg.No. 10001929), Diya Maria Varghese (Reg.No. 10001942) and Jerin Antony
(Reg.No. 1000194), towards the partial fulfillment of requirements for the award of
degree Bachelor Of Technology degree in Civil Engineering, MG University,
Kottayam, Kerala
We take this opportunity to express our deep sense of gratitude to each and every one
who lend us a helping hand in our research. First and foremost we thank God
Almighty for showering his immense blessings upon us throughout this venture.
We owe a lot to Sr. Claramma Rosary (Head of the department), for her keen
interest and support whenever in need. We are overwhelmed by the sincerity and
concern of our guides Ms. Jiss Abraham (Asst. Professor, Department of Civil
Engineering) and Ms. Cini Philip (Asst. Professor, Department of Civil Engineering).
Their valuable inputs, constant encouragement and constructive feedback kept us in
the right track and motivated, which helped us in timely completion of this work. We
also thank Dr. Mini Mathew (Assoc. Professor, Department of Civil Engineering) for
her guidance. This project would have been nothing if it wasn’t for Mrs. Sheena P
Abraham, Mrs. Mini Jacob and Mr. V T Thomas who were there to help us in the
laboratory. Special appreciation goes to our classmates Joseph G Tom, Charls K
John and Gino George who helped us overcome the difficulties of lack of manpower.
We also express our sincere gratitude to other staff members, Department of Civil
Engineering and our parents for their encouragement and support.
ADITYA TOM
ANUSHREE S
DIYA MARIA VARGHESE
JERIN ANTONY
i
ABSTRACT
Coconut fibre is available in abundance at the test site, which makes it quite viable as
a reinforcement material in concrete. Further, it acts as a new source of income for the
coconut producer who gets the benefits of the new demand generated by the
construction industry. In addition to this, it is an effective method for the disposal of
coir mattress waste which will reduce the demand for additional waste disposal
infrastructure and decrease the load on existing landfills and incinerators.The problem
of high rate of water absorption of the fibre could be reduced by coating the fibres
with oil. Moreover the fibres being natural in origin is ecologically sustainable and
can bring down the global carbon footprint quite effectively.
This study aimed at analyzing the variation in strength of coconut fiber (oil coated
raw and oil coated processed fibres) reinforced concrete at varying fibre contents and
to compare it with that of conventional concrete. The various strength aspects
analyzed are the flexural, compressive and tensile strength of the coconut fiber
reinforced concrete at varying percentages (4%,5%,6% by the weight of cement) of
fibre. The influence of shape of fibre on strength is also studied by testing on coconut
fibre mesh of predetermined dimensions. The optimal percentage of both the
processed fibre strands and raw fibre meshes were found out by trial and error and the
optimum percentage of superplasticizerneeded for the required workability was also
determined.
ii
CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT ........................................................................................................ i
ABSTRACT ..............................................................................................................................ii
1. INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................ 1
2.1 OVERVIEW................................................................................................................ 4
3. METHODOLOGY ........................................................................................................... 7
iii
3.6.1 CASTING OF RAW AND PROCESSED COIR FIBRE REINFORCED
CONCRETE .....................................................................................................................14
4.1 OVERVIEW.............................................................................................................. 16
4.5 WATER..................................................................................................................... 18
iv
5.3 EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE ........................................................................... 33
6. CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................... 60
7. REFERENCES ............................................................................................................... 63
v
LIST OF TABLES
Table 5.7 : Split tensile strength for processed Plain Concrete cylinders .................... 50
Table 5.8 : Split tensile strength for processed CFRC cylinders ................................. 50
Table 5.9 : Split tensile strength for raw CFRC cylinders ........................................... 52
Table 5.10 : Comparison of post peak load failure in raw and processed CFRC ........ 54
vi
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 4.3 : Raw coconut fibre obtained from mattress waste .................................... 19
vii
Figure 5.9 : Finished fibre reinforced concrete cubes.................................................. 45
Figure 5.14 : Graph showing variation of split tensile strength at varying percentages
Figure 5.15 : Graph showing variation of split tensile strength at varying percentages
Figure 5.16 : Graph showing variation of split tensile strength at varying percentages
Figure 5.17 : Graph showing variation of split tensile strength at varying percentages
Figure 5.18 : Cracking pattern of Conventional concrete and coconut fibre reinforced
concrete ........................................................................................................................ 53
fibre (processed)........................................................................................................... 56
fibre (processed)........................................................................................................... 57
viii
Figure 5.23 : Graph showing variation of Flexural strength at varying percentages of
Figure 5.24 : Cracking pattern coconut fibre reinforced concrete beam .................... 59
ix
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
x
Department Of Civil Engineering 2014
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 BACKGROUND
The construction industry is revolutionizing in two major ways. One way is the
development of construction techniques, such as using automated tools in
construction. The other is the advancement in high-performance construction
materials, such as the introduction of high strength concrete. Among these high-
performance materials, fibre reinforced concrete (FRC) is gradually gaining
acceptance from civil engineers. In recent years, research and development of fibres
and matrix materials and fabrication process related to construction industry have
grown rapidly. Their advantages over other construction materials are their high
tensile strength to weight ratio, ability to be moulded into various shapes and potential
resistance to environmental conditions, resulting in potentially low maintenance cost.
These properties make FRC composite a good alternative for innovative construction.
Their application in construction includes both upgrading existing structures and
building new ones, which can apply to various types of structure, for example
offshore platforms, buildings and bridges (Thou, 2005).
The aim of this study was to identify the improvement in strength characteristics of
concrete with the addition of oil coated coconut fibre. In the study, coconut fibre is
added to concrete and Plain Cement Concrete (PCC) is used as reference to study its
effect on flexural, compressive and tensile strength properties and also drying
shrinkage. Fibre is coated with oil so as to decrease the water absorption. Some of the
advantages being observed are low-cost, low density, reasonable specific strength,
good thermal insulation, reduced wear and ability to be recycled with minimal impact
on environment (Majid Ali et al.,2011). Thus in addition to the enhancement in the
physical properties of concrete, it turns out to be a sustainable waste management
technique
Coconut fibre with a tensile strength of 21.5 MPa is the toughest among all natural
fibres (Munawar et al., 2003). They are capable of taking strains4–6 times higher than
other fibres (Munawar et al., 2003).Although it is a cheap and efficient a major
hindrance towards its wide scale use is the high rate of water absorption, which can
be reduced by coating it with oil.
The advantages of coconut fibre are :low cost, reasonable specific strength, low
density, ease of availability, enhanced energy recovery, biodegradability, ability to be
recycled in nature in a carbon neutral manner, resistance to fungi moth and rot,
excellent insulation to sound, flame, moisture and dampness, toughness, durability,
resilience.
The aim of this study is to investigate the effect of oil coated coir fibre on physical
properties of concrete
1.4 METHODOLOGY
Chapter 4 gives an overview of various materials used in the test and the material tests
associated with them to determine its suitability in this research
Chapter 6 summarizes the study, presents the salient conclusions from the study and
its limitations, and discusses scope for future
2. LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 OVERVIEW
This chapter deals with various research works done on fibre reinforced concrete
including CFRC. The properties of various fibres were studied and the advantages of
coconut fibre over other fibres were highlighted to justify its selection in this research
work.
(Bhatia, 2001) studied the usefulness of fibre reinforced concrete in various civil
engineering applications. Fibres include steel fibre, natural fibres and synthetic fibres-
each of which lends varying properties to the concrete. The study revealed that the
fibrous material increases the structural integrity. These studies made us adopt natural
fibres which are abundantly available and cheap.
(Chouw et al., 2012) studied the viability of using coconut-fibre ropes as vertical
reinforcement in mortar-free low cost housing in earth quake prone regions. The rope
anchorage is achieved by embedding it in the foundation and top tie-beams. The bond
between the rope and the concrete plays an important role in the stability of the
structure and the rope tensile strength is also found to be fairly high. The rope tension
generated due to earthquake loading should be less than both the pull out force and
the rope tensile load to avoid the structure collapse. The study concluded that the pull
out energy increases with an increase in embedment length, rope diameter, cement
and fibre content in the matrix.
(Li et al., 2007) studied fibre volume fraction by surface treatment with a wetting
agent for coir mesh reinforced mortar using non-woven coir mesh matting. They
performed a four-point bending test and concluded that cementitious composites,
reinforced by three layers of coir mesh with a low fibre content of 1.8%, resulted in
40% improvement in flexural strength compared to conventional concrete. The
composites were found to be 25 times stronger in flexural toughness and about 20
times higher in flexural ductility. To the best knowledge of authors the only research
work on static CFRC properties is the test done on concrete reinforced with coir fibre
of length 4 cm. With regard to dynamic properties of CFRC, no study has been
reported yet. Dynamic tests had been performed only for concrete reinforced by other
fibres, e.g. polyolefin fibres or rubber scrap. To reveal the consequence of fibre length
for CFRC properties, thorough investigations involving more fibre lengths and other
parameters are required in order to arrive at reliable conclusions. The knowledge of
static and dynamic properties of CFRC is essential to understand the potential of such
concrete in cheap housing in earth quake prone regions. But the scope of which
requires stringent investigations CFRC blocks are used as pavement materials in
parking areas to avoid shrinkage crack. The high crack resistance offered by coconut
fibre made us adopt coconut fibre reinforced concrete.
(Reis, 2006) performed third-point loading tests on concrete reinforced with coconut,
sugarcane bagasse and banana fibres to investigate the flexural strength, fracture
toughness and fracture energy. The study revealed that fracture, toughness and energy
of coconut fibre reinforced concrete were the highest compared to other natural fibres
with an increase in flexural strength of up to 25%.The advantages of coconut fibre
over other natural fibres made us conclude to use coconut fibre as the reinforcement
material in our project.
(Asasutjarit et al., (2006) determined the physical (density, moisture content, water
absorption and thickness swelling), mechanical (modulus of elasticity, modulus of
rupture and internal bond) and thermal properties of coir-based light weight cement
board after 28 days of hydration. The physical and mechanical properties were
measured by Japanese Industrial Standard JIS A 5908-1994 and the thermal properties
using JIS R 2618. The parameters studied were fibre length, coir pre-treatment and
mixture ratio. 5 cm long boiled and washed fibres with the optimum cement: fibre:
water weight ratio of 2:1:2 gave the highest modulus of rupture and internal bond
amongst the tested specimens. The board also had a thermal conductivity lower than
other commercial flake board composite. These paper made us choose 5cm fibre
length after proper treatment of the fibre for the removal of the coir dust.
(Liu et al., 2011) studied the influence of 1%, 2%, 3% and 5% at fibre lengths of 2.5,
5 and 7.5 cm on properties of concrete. For a proper analysis the properties of plain
cement concrete was used as reference. It was seen that damping of CFRC beams
increases with the increase in fibre content. It was observed that CFRC with a fibre
length of 5 cm and fibre content of 5% produced the best results. In this study the
optimum percent of coconut fibre added was 5%,which made us to adopt addition of
4%,5% and 6% coconut fibre by weight of cement in our research work.
(Kelleret al., 2005) investigated the shear behaviour of reinforced concrete beams
strengthened by the attachment of different configurations and quantities of carbon
fibres. The study revealed that the strengthening by using carbon fibres increased the
resistance to shear and also spalling of concrete.
The next chapter is methodology which gives a brief idea about the overall aspects of
this research.
3. METHODOLOGY
1. Standard Consistency
2. Initial Setting Time
3. Final Setting Time
4. Fineness of Cement
5. Density of Cement
6. Soundness of Cement
The standard consistency of a cement paste is defined as that consistency which will
permit the Vicat plunger of 10 mm diameter and 50 mm length to penetrate to a point
5 to 7 mm from the bottom of the Vicat mould Figure 3.1. The experiment was done
as per IS 4031-Part IV.
Initial setting time is regarded as the time elapsed between the moment that the water
is added to the cement to the time that the paste starts losing its plasticity. Experiment
was done as per IS -269:1989, clause 6.3.
Final setting time is the time elapsed between the moment that the water is added to
the cement and when the paste has completely lost its plasticity. Experiment was done
as per IS -269:1989, clause 6.3.
Fineness is a measure of total surface area of cement. For finer cements surface area
will be more. Fineness influences the rate of hydration, rate of strength development,
shrinkage and rate of evolution of heat. Experiment was done as per IS 4031-Part I-
1996.
The testing of soundness of cement is to ensure that the cement does not show any
applicable subsequent expansion. Unsoundness in cement is due to excess of lime,
magnesia or excessive proportion of sulphates. Experiment is done by Le Chatelier
method. And the value of soundness is 1mm.
Aggregates are important constituents in concrete. They give body to the concrete,
reduce shrinkage and effect economy. The aggregates occupy 70-80 percent of the
volume of concrete; their impact on various characteristics and properties of concrete
is considerable. To determine the various properties of aggregates different tests are
done.
The bulk density is the weight of material in a given volume and it is measured in
kilograms per litre. The bulk density of an aggregate is affected by several factors,
including the amount of moisture present and the amount of effort introduced in
filling the measure. Bulk density shows how densely the aggregate is packed, when
filled in a standard manner. It depends on the particle size distribution and shape of
the particle. The experiment was carried out as per the procedure in IS 383.
The bulk density is the weight of material in a given volume and it is measured in
kilograms per litre. The bulk density of an aggregate is affected by several factors,
including the amount of moisture present and the amount of effort introduced in
filling the measure. Bulk density shows how densely the aggregate is packed, when
filled in a standard manner. It depends on the particle size distribution and shape of
the particle. The experiment was carried out as per the procedure in IS 383
Mix design is defined as the process of selecting suitable ingredients of concrete and
determining their relative proportions with the object of producing concrete of certain
minimum strength and durability as economically as possible.
A Mix design was conducted as per IS 10262-1982 to arrive at M 20 mix concrete.
The coarse aggregate and fine aggregate were weighed and the concrete mixture was
prepared by hand mixing on a water tight platform. On the water tight platform
cement and fine aggregates are mixed thoroughly until a uniform colour is obtained,
to this mixture coarse aggregate was added and mixed thoroughly. Then water is
added carefully making sure no water is lost during mixing. While adding water care
should be taken to add it in stages so as to prevent bleeding which may affect the
strength formation of concrete rising of water required for hydration to the surface.
Clean and oiled mould for each category was then placed on the vibrating table
respectively and filled in three layers. Vibrations were stopped as soon as the cement
slurry appeared on the top surface of the mould
These specimens were allowed to remain in the steel mould for the first 24 hours at
ambient condition. After that these were demoulded with care so that no edges were
broken and were placed in the tank at the ambient temperature for curing. After
demoulding the specimen by loosening the screws of the steel mould, the cubes were
placed in the water for 7 days and 28 days.
The calculated amount of cement and fine aggregate are mixed together until a
uniform mix is obtained. Fibres at varying amounts of 4%, 5% and 6% to that of
weight of cement are taken. Coir fibre strands are cut into a length of 5cm washed and
while the raw fibres are cut into square meshes of 5cm x 5 cm, coated with coconut
oil and dried in sunlight for 24 hours
It is then added to the mix until a uniform colour is obtained. Coarse aggregates are
then added to the same and mixed, followed by addition of water. Care should be
taken to add water slowly in stages so as to prevent bleeding which may affect the
strength formation of concrete. Admixture is added towards the end of mixing
procedure so as to avail sufficient time for mixing before the concrete hardens. It is
placed in the moulds of standard dimensions, compacted and finished
The remoulded specimens after being cured for sufficient time period are taken out
and dried in sunlight and tested under standard testing apparatus.
COLLECTION OF MATERIALS
TESTING OF MATERIALS
MIX DESIGN
MOULDING
TESTING OF SPECIMEN
The next chapter deals with the study of various materials used and the material tests.
4.1 OVERVIEW
Concrete is a freshly mixed material which can be moulded in to any shape. Concrete
is a site made material unlike other material of construction such as can vary to a
very great extent in its quality, properties and performance owing to the use of natural
material except cement. The properties of materials are important to make concrete
workable and durable.
Cement : PPC
Fine aggregate : M-sand
Coarse aggregate : Aggregates passing through 20mm is sieve
Coconut fibre : Washed fibres of length 5cm
Water : Potable water
Admixture : Rheobuild 918
4.2 CEMENT
IS 1489 1991 Part I defines PPC as “An intimately interground mixture of Portland
clinker and pozzolana with the possible addition of gypsum (natural or chemical) or
an intimate and uniform blending of Portland cement and fine pozzolana”. Portland-
pozzolana cement can be produced either by grinding together Portland cement
clinker and pozzolana with addition of gypsum or calcium sulphate, or by intimately
and uniformly blending Portland cement and fine pozzolana. The pozzolanic materials
generally used for manufacture of PPC are calcined clay or fly ash. Portland-
pozzolana cement produces less heat of hydration and offers greater resistance to the
attack of aggressive waters than normal Portland cement. Moreover, it reduces the
leaching of calcium hydroxide liberated during the setting and hydration of cement.
Aggregates are the important constituents in concrete. They give body to the concrete,
reduce shrinkage and effect economy. They occupy about 70-80 percent of the
volume of the concrete. Aggregates shall consist of naturally occurring (crushed or
uncrushed) stones, gravel and sand or combination thereof. They shall be hard, strong,
durable, clear and free from veins and adherent coating; and free from injurious
amounts of disintegrated pieces, alkali, vegetable matter and other deleterious
substances. As far as possible, flaky and elongated pieces should be avoided.
Aggregates can be mainly classified into fine aggregates and coarse aggregates.
IS 383- 1970 defines fine aggregates as “Aggregate most of which passes 4.75mm IS
sieve and contains only so much coarser material as permitted.” It may be:
i. Natural sand: Fine aggregate resulting from the natural disintegration of rock
and which has been deposited by streams or glacial agencies.
ii. Crushed stone sand: Fine aggregate produced by crushing hard stone.
iii. Crushed gravel sand: line aggregate produced by crushing natural gravel.
There are four grading zones for fine aggregates such as grading zone I, II, III, and
IV. It is recommended that fine aggregate conforming to Grading Zone IV should not
be used in reinforced concrete unless tests have been made to ascertain the suitability
of proposed mix proportions.
4.5 WATER
According to IS 456 : 2000, water used for mixing and curing shall be clean and free
from injurious amounts of oils, acids, alkalis, salts, sugar, organic materials or other
substances that may be deleterious to concrete or steel. Potable water is generally
considered satisfactory for mixing concrete. The pH value of water shall be not less
than 6
Coconut fibre both raw and processed are used in this research.
It is the waste material obtained from mattress manufacturing and possess high degree
of tensile strength of 21.5 MPa Figure 4.3. They are properly washed before use. This
will remove dust and other residual particles left on the fibre so as to augment the
surface of contact between the fibre and mix resulting in better binding between the
reinforcement and concrete and ultimately higher strength. The fibres are then cut into
square meshes of size 5cm x 5cm
They are properly washed and drawn into strands before use. Treatment of fibres
removes dust and other residual particles left on the fibre so as to augment the surface
of contact between the fibre and mix resulting in better binding between the
reinforcement and concrete and ultimately higher strength. The fibre is washed in tap
water for 30 minutes so as to loosen the fibres and to remove the coir dust. Fibres are
then washed and soaked again for 30 minutes. This process is to be repeated three
times The softened fibres are straightened manually and combed with a steel comb.
Figure 4.4.To accelerate the drying process, the wet long fibres will be then put in
oven at 30°C for 10–12 in which most of the moisture will be removed. The fibres are
then completely dried in the open air, combed again and finally cut into the required
length of 5cm and soaked in oil for 15-20 min and dried in sun for 24 hours.
1. Standard Consistency
2. Initial Setting Time
3. Final Setting Time
4. Fineness of Cement
5. Density of Cement
6. Soundness of Cement
The experiment was done as per IS 4031-Part IV and the obtained value of standard
consistency is 34 %.
Experiment was done as per IS -269:1989, clause 6.3 and the obtained value of initial
setting time is 70 min. According to IS code initial setting time of cement shall not be
less than 30 minutes.
Experiment was done as per IS -269:1989, clause 6.3 and the obtained value of final
setting time is 300 min. According to IS code initial setting time of cement should not
exceed 10 hours.
Experiment was done as per IS 4031-Part I-1996 and the obtained value of fineness of
cement is 7%.According to IS code the weight of residue should not exceed 10% for
ordinary cement.
Experiment was done in Le Chatelier’s flask and the obtained value of density of
cement is 3.09 g/ml. According to IS 4031-Part II-1988 density of cement is around
3.15 g/ml.
Experiment was done by Le Chatelier method and the obtained value of soundness of
cement is 1mm.According to IS 269:1989-Clause 6.2, the expansion of cement must
not exceed 10 mm for ordinary rapid hardening and low heating portland cement.
The experiment was carried out as per IS code 2386 part-III-1963 and IS 383.
INFERENCE
As per IS code 2386-part III -1963, the obtained value of bulk density of
aggregates lies within the range of 1.2-1.8kg/l.
The experiment was carried out as per IS code 2386 part-III-1963 and IS 383.
INFERENCE
As per IS code 2386-part III -1963, Average value of specific gravity should
lies between 2.6-2.8
Experiment was done as per IS 2386-Part I-1963,IS:383-1970 and the results are
tabulated in Table 4.1. The gradation curve is shown in Figure 4.5.
80 0 0 0 100
40 0 0 0 100
120
99.16 100
100 100
80
% Finer
60
% finer
40
20
4.74
5.06
0
1 10 100
IS Sieve Size (mm) in log scale
INFERENCE
Value of fineness modulus is 6.9. As per IS 2386 part-1, 1963 fineness modulus of
coarse aggregate is between 6.5 and 8. Obtained value lies within the range. hence it
can be used for making satisfactory concrete.
The experiment was carried out as per IS code 2386 part-III-1963 and IS 383.
INFERENCE
As per IS code 2386-part III -1963, the value of bulk density of aggregates lies within
the range of 1.2-1.8kg/l. The obtained value if bulk density is 1.78 kg/l which is
within this range and hence can provide sufficient rigidity to the concrete mix
The experiment was carried out as per IS code 2386 part-III-1963 and IS 383.
Specific gravity=2.706
INFERENCE
As per IS code 2386-Part III -1963 the specific gravity of fine aggregate ranges from
2.65 to 2.68. The obtained value is 2.706 is within the range.
Experiment was done as per IS 2386-Part I-1963,IS:383-1970 and the results are
tabulated in Table 4.2 and table 4.3 respectively. The gradation curve is shown in Fig
4.6 and Fig 4.7
Sample 1
Weight of sample taken, W = 500g
Percentage Cumulative %
Weight retained
I.S sieve size retained on retained on % finer
on each sieve(g)
each sieve each sieve
120
98.976 99.516 99.684 99.864
100
80
% Finer 72.976
60
40
20
12.976
0
0.1 1 10
IS Sieve Size (mm) in log scale
Sample 2
Weight of sample taken, W = 1000g
100 97.7
80
% finer (%) 77.16
60 58.62
44.09
40
27.96
20
13.03
0
0.1 1 10
IS Sieve Size (mm) in log scale
INFERENCE
The physical property of cement, fine aggregate, coarse aggregate and the
compressive strength test results of the concrete cube specimens are detailed below.
Fineness 7% <10%
INFERENCE
The values obtained for properties of cement are within the range specified by IS
code. So the given cement is suitable for construction.
Sieve analysis of fine aggregate is done using standard set of IS sieves. The results of
tests conducted on Sample are tabulated in Table 4.5
INFERENCE
The properties obtained for fine aggregates are within the range given by IS code. So
the fine aggregates are good for concreting.
INFERENCE
The properties of coarse aggregates are within the range given by IS code. So the
aggregates are good for concreting.
The next chapter titled casting and testing deals with the casting, curing and tests on
concrete specimen.
Slump test is the most commonly used method of measuring consistency of concrete.
It is used conveniently as a control test and gives an indication of the uniformity of
concrete. Additional information on workability and quality of concrete can be
obtained by observing the manner in which concrete slumps. The apparatus for
conducting the slump test essentially consists of a metallic mould in the form of
frustum of a cone having the internal dimensions of bottom diameter 20 cm, top
diameter 10 cm and a height of 30 cm as shown in Figure 5.1.
strength of concrete cubes for the plain concrete and fibre reinforced concrete are
found out using Compression testing machine. Three cubes were cast for each
percentage of fibres and the average of the two compressive strength values was
taken. A Compression testing machine is shown in Figure 5.2.
5.2.3 FLEXURALSTRENGTHTEST
Mix design is defined as the process of selecting suitable ingredients of concrete and
determining their relative proportions with the object of producing concrete of certain
minimum strength and durability as economically as possible. The mix design must
consider the environment that the concrete will be in exposure to sea water, trucks,
cars, forklifts, foot traffic or extremes of hot and cold. A Mix design was conducted as
per IS 10262-1982 to arrive at M 20 mix concrete.
Workability : 100mm(slump)
Specific gravity of
Water absorption of
2) Fine aggregate : 1%
Bulk density of
Sieve analysis
From Table 5 of IS 456, maximum water cement ratio for M20mix = 0.55
Entrapped Air, as
Maximum Size of
Percentage of Volume of
Aggregate(mm)
Concrete
10 3
20 2
40 1
The water content and percentage of sand in total aggregate by absolute volume
are determined from Table 2 of IS 10262 : 2009
Estimated water content for 100mm slump = 186 + (6/100*186) = 197 litres
The cement content per unit volume of concrete may be calculated from free
water cement ratio and the quantity of water per unit volume of concrete.
From Table 5 of IS 456, minimum cement content for severe exposure condition
= 320kg/m3
a. Volume of concrete = 1 m3
b. Volume of cement = (mass of cement / (specific gravity of cement
* 1000))
= (350 / (3.09 * 1000)) = 0.1275 m3
c. Volume of water = (mass of water / (specific gravity of water *
1000))
= (197 / (1 * 1000)) = 0.197 m3
d. Volume of chemical
admixture = NIL
e. Volume of all in aggregate = (a - (b + c + d)) = 1 – (0.1275 + 0.197 + 0) =
0.675 m3
f. Mass of coarse aggregate = e * volume of coarse aggregate * specific
gravity of
coarse aggregate * 1000
= 0.675 * 0.62 *2.72 * 1000 = 1138 kg
g. Mass of fine aggregate = e * volume of fine aggregate * specific gravity
Of fine aggregate * 1000=0.675 * 0.38 * 2.706
* 1000= 687 kg
Cement = 394kg/m3
Water = 197 kg/m3
Coarse aggregate = 1138 kg/m3
Fine aggregate = 687 kg/m3
Water cement ratio = 0.5
Coarse 27 27 27 27 27 27 27
Aggregate
(Kg)
Concrete is mixed either by hand Fig 5.4. In this casting process is used. Concrete is a
mixture of Cement, Water, Coarse and Fine Aggregates and Admixtures. The
proportion of each material in the mixture affects the properties of the final hardened
concrete. These proportions are best measured by weight. Measurement by volume is
not as accurate, but is suitable for minor projects. The dry ingredients are mixed and
water is added slowly until the concrete is workable. This mixture may need to be
modified depending on the aggregate used to provide a concrete of the right
workability. The mix should not be too stiff or too sloppy. It is difficult to form good
test specimens if it is too stiff. If it is too sloppy, water may separate (bleed) from the
mixture.
For casting, all the moulds were cleaned and oiled properly. There were securely
tightened to correct dimension before casting. Care was taken that there is no gaps
left, where there is any possibility of leakage of slurry. Careful procedure was adopted
in the batching, mixing and casting operation. The coarse aggregate and fine
aggregate were weighed first. The concrete mixture was prepared by hand mixing on
a water tight platform. On the water tight platform cement and fine aggregates are
mixed thoroughly until a uniform colour is obtained, to this mixture coarse aggregate
was added and mixed thoroughly. Then water is added carefully making sure no water
is lost during mixing. While adding water care should be taken to add it in stages so as
to prevent bleeding which may affect the strength formation of concrete rising of
water required for hydration to the surface. Clean and oiled mould for each category
was then placed on the vibrating table respectively and filled in three layers.
Vibrations were stopped as soon as the cement slurry appeared on the top surface of
the mould. Fig 5.5 shows cube specimen placed on table vibrator.
These specimens were allowed to remain in the steel mould for the first 24 hours at
ambient condition. After that these were demoulded with care so that no edges were
broken and were placed in the tank at the ambient temperature for curing. After
demoulding the specimen by loosening the screws of the steel mould, the cubes were
placed in the water for 7 days and 28 days.
The calculated amount of cement and fine aggregate are mixed together till a uniform
mix is obtained.. The amounts of fibre adopted are 4%, 5% and 6% of cement. Coir
fibre strands are cut into a length of 5cm washed, oil coated with coconut oil and
dried in sunlight for 24 hours Fig 5.7.
It is then added to the mix until a uniform colour is obtained. Coarse aggregates are
then added to the same and mixed followed by addition of water. Care should be
taken to add water slowly in stages so as to prevent bleeding which may affect the
strength formation of concrete rising of water required for hydration to the surface.
Admixture is added towards the last stage of addition of water so as to avail sufficient
time for mixing before the concrete hardens. It is placed in the mould, compacted and
finished is shown in Fig. 5.8. 6 cubes each of the same are prepared and cured. The
compressive strength for 7day and 28 day is determined.
The calculated amount of cement and fine aggregate are mixed together till a uniform
mix is obtained. The amounts of fibre adopted are 4%, 5% and 6% of cement. Raw
and non uniform coir fibres are cut into square chips of of 5cm x 5cm. They are then
washed, oil coated with coconut oil and dried in sunlight for 24 hours and added to
the mix until a uniform colour is obtained. Coarse aggregates are then added to the
same and mixed followed by addition of water. Care should be taken to add water
slowly in stages so as to prevent bleeding which may affect the strength formation of
concrete rising of water required for hydration to the surface. Admixture is added
towards the last stage of addition of water so as to avail sufficient time for mixing
before the concrete hardens It is placed in the mould and compacted. 6 cubes each of
the same are prepared and cured. The compressive strength for 7day and 28 day is
determined.
INFERENCE
From the table it is observed that the desired slump value is obtained for trial 3 at
water cement ratio = 0.5. Hence we fix it as the design ratio. Trial 1 and 2 yielded
very low slump values which may be either due to inadequate paste available for
binding the mix or due to improper mixing procedure
The compressive strength of ordinary concrete with different water cement ratio was
tested. The results are as shown in Table 5.4.
28 day
Slump Value 7day strength strength
Specimen w/c ratio 2
(mm) (N/mm ) (N/mm2)
24.88
1 14
25.1
2 0.5 120 14.4
25.1
3 14.2
25.03
Average 14.2
INFERENCE
For the table the average of value from the 3 observations is 25 N/mm2, is taken as
compressive strength of plain concrete cube
Coconut fibre reinforced concrete was added to concrete at varying proportions (4% ,
5%, 6% of that of weight of cement) at a water cement ratio of 0.5 The desired slump
value and compressive strength was obtained for conventional concrete at this ratio .
However, when fibre is added to the mix low workability was observed. Hence
superplasticizer was added at different proportions of cement to get a concrete mix of
suitable workability. The result of compressive strength of fibre reinforced concrete
and slump test results are shown in Table 5.5 and is shown graphically in Fig 5.9 and
Fig 5.10.
Compressive
Slump strength(N/mm2)
Percentage of
w/c Amount of Value
Specimen coconut fibre
ratio superplasticizer
added 28
(mm) 7 day
Used day
0.2 %
1 4% 110
14.6 25.7
0.4 %
2 0.5 5% 105
16.3 28.3
0.8%
3 6% 105
15.02 26.2
29.5 28.3
Compressive Strength (N/mm2)
27.5
26.2
25.5
25.7
23.5
21.5
7 day
19.5
28 day
17.5 16.3
15.5
15.02
13.5 14.6
3% 4% 5% 6% 7%
% of fiber added
30
25.03
20
15
10
0
0% 4% 5% 6%
% of fibre added (%)
INFERENCE
The value obtained for 5% addition of coconut fibre water cement ratio 0.5 yielded
highest results for compressive strength. However, the compressive strength
decreased on the increase in fibre addition. This may be due to the fact when fibres
are added initially the finer sized fine aggregates enter into the surface pores in the
fibre creating a better bonding between the fibre and mix, however further addition of
fibres causes formation of bulk fibre in the mix decreasing the bonding. Hence there
is an optimum value of fibre to cement ratio, beyond which the compressive strength
decreases. Hence 0.5 was taken as the optimum water cement ratio and optimum fibre
content was taken as 5%
Coconut fibre reinforced concrete was cast at a water cement ratio of 0.5 at which
desired slump values and compressive strength were obtained for conventional
concrete. However, when fibre is added the mix showed very low workability. Hence
Compressive
Slump strength(N/mm2)
Percentage
w/c Amount of Value
Specimen of coconut
ratio superplasticizer
fibre added (mm) 7 day 28 day
used
INFERENCE
From the table a decreasing trend in compressive strength is observed with a
maximum at 4% fibre addition. On further addition of fibres compressive strength
values way below that of conventional concrete is obtained. This is due to formation
of zone of transition, which creates a weak zone around the fibre making the entire
specimen weak. Moreover the thickness of the fibres can hinder better packing of the
constituents of concrete thus making it weak.
23.2
18.5
16.5 7 day
10.5
3% 4% 5% 6% 7%
% of fibre added (%)
30
25.03
Compressive Strength (N/mm2)
25 23.2
22.1 21.82
20
15
7 day
28 day
10
0
0% 4% 5% 6%
% of fibre added (%)
INFERENCE
Also, the compressive strength value is still less than that of plain concrete .This can
also be due to the presence of dust and other impurities on the surface of fibres which
may interefere with proper bonding of mix and subsequent strength formation.
Another important factor is the influence of shape of fibres. Only properly combed
fibre strands can be used for reinforcing concrete as presence of bulk fibres can result
in improper compaction
Split tensile strength tests were conducted on standard cylinders of dimension 15cm
diameter and 30cm depth Fig 5.13 specimens each for plain concrete, coconut fibre
reinforced concrete (both raw and processed fibre) were cast at varying percentages of
fibre (4%, 5%, 6%). For each case 28day strength values were obtained by loading
under a compression testing machine. The result of Split tensile strength of plain and
processed fibre reinforced concrete and slump test results are shown in Table 5.7 and
Table 5.8 respectively and is shown graphically in Fig 5.14 and Fig 5.15
Table 5.7 : Split tensile strength for processed Plain Concrete cylinders
28 day strength
Slump Value
Specimen w/c ratio (N/mm2)
(mm)
3.39
1
3.46
2 0.5 120
3.46
3
3.44
Average
Slump
Percentage
w/c Amount of Value Split Tensile
Specimen of coconut
ratio superplasticizer strength(N/mm2)
fibre added (mm)
Used
Average = 4.17
4.5
4.14
4
3.8
3.5
0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5% 6% 7%
% of fibre added (%)
5
Split tensile Strength
4.57
4.5
(N/mm2)
4.14
4
3.8
3.5
4% 5% 6%
% of fibre added (%)
INFERENCE
From the graph it is seen that when fibre content is increased there is an increase in
split tensile strength with a maximum at 5% of fibre. However when the fibre content
is increased beyond this value a downward slope of the graph is observed. This is due
to the fact that tensile failure occurs due to the dislocation of atoms and molecules
present in concrete. However when the fibre is added it acts as a binder holding them
together.
The results for Split tensile strength of raw fibre reinforced concrete and slump test
results are shown in Table 5.9 and is shown graphically in Fig 5.16 and Fig 5.17.
Table 5.9 : Split tensile strength for raw CFRC cylinders
Amount of Slump
Percentage of
w/c superplasticizer Value Split Tensile
Specimen coconut fibre
ratio strength(N/mm2)
added used (mm)
Average 4.33
5
Split Tensile strength (N/mm2)
4.86
4.5
4.15
4
3.98
3.5
0% 2% 4% 6% 8%
% of fibre added (%)
3.98 4.15
4
0
4% 5% 6%
% of fibre added (%)
Table 5.10 : Comparison of post peak load failure in raw and processed CFRC
INFERENCE
Fig 5.18 shows the variation in cracking pattern of conventional and fibre reinforced
concrete.It is seen that in conventional concrete abrupt failure occurred which is
represented by cracking of cylinder into two halves at maximum load,however for
CFRCthere is a time lag before the specimen actually fails.Cracks were found to be
held together after the initial cracking occured and even after the test was continued
up to360 sec post the failure.This is due to post peak load strength making it suitable
for earth quake prone regions so that sufficent warning period is available before the
disintegration of structure.The post peak load strengths of both processed fibre and
raw fibre mesh reinforced concrete are shown in table 5.10
Flexural strength tests were conducted on standard beams of dimension 15cm x 15cm
x 70cm Fig 5.19. 3 specimens each for plain concrete, coconut fibre reinforced
concrete were cast at varying percentages of fibre (4%,5%, 6%). For each case the
28day strength values were obtained by loading under a apparatus for flexural
strength. The result of Split tensile strength of plain and processed fibre reinforced
concrete and slump test results are shown in Table 5.11 and Table 5.12 respectively
and is shown graphically in Fig 5.20 and Fig 5.21.
28 day strength
Slump Value
Specimen w/c ratio (N/mm2)
(mm)
3.5
1
3.75
2 0.5 120
3.75
3
3.67
Average
Table 5.12 : Flexural strength for processed Coconut Fibre Reinforced Concrete
Beams
Slump
Percentage
w/c Amount of Value Flexural
Specimen of coconut
ratio superplasticizer strength(N/mm2)
fibre added (mm)
Used
Average 4.53
5
4.83
Flexural Strength (N/mm2)
4.5 4.6
Series1
4.16
4
3.5
0% 2% 4% 6% 8%
% of fibre added (%)
5
4.83
4.5
4.16
Series1
4
3.5
4% 5% 6%
% of fibre added (%)
INFERENCE
From the graph it is seen that when fibre content is increased there is an increase in
flexural strength with a maximum at 5% of fibre. However when the fibre content is
increased beyond this value a downward slope of the graph is observed
The results for Split tensile strength of raw fibre reinforced concrete and slump test
results are shown in Table 5.13 and is shown graphically in Fig 5.22 and Fig 5.23.The
cracking pattern of the beam is shown in Fig 5.24.
Table 5.13 : Flexural strength for raw Coconut Fibre Reinforced Concrete
Beams
Amount of Slump
Percentage of
w/c superplasticizer Value Flexural
Specimen coconut fibre
ratio strength(N/mm2)
added used (mm)
Average 4.38
5
Flexural strength (N/mm2)
4.73
4.5
4.4
4
4.02
3.5
0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5% 6% 7%
% of fibre added (%)
4.5 4.4
4.02
4
3.5
4% 5% 6%
% of fibre added (%)
INFERENCE
From the graph it is seen that when fibre content is increased there is an increase in
flexural strength with a maximum at 5% of fibre. However when the fibre content is
increased beyond this value a downward slope of the graph is observed. This must be
due to balling of fibres which can hamper the binding and strength formation in
concrete.
6. CONCLUSION
Coconut fibre is available in abundance at the test site, which makes it quite viable as
a reinforcement material in concrete. Further, it acts as a source of income for the
coconut producer who gets the benefits of the new demand generated by the
construction industry. In addition to this, it is an efficient method for the disposal of
coir mattress waste which will reduce the demand for additional waste disposal
infrastructure and decrease the load on existing landfills and incinerators. Coconut
fibres being natural in origin, is ecologically sustainable and can bring down the
global carbon footprint quite effectively.
2. When the fibre content is increased there is an increase in split tensile strength
with a maximum at 5%. However when the fibre content is increased beyond
this value a reduction in tensile strength is observed. This is due to the fact that
tensile failure occurs due to the dislocation of atoms and molecules present in
concrete. However when the fibre is added it acts as a binder holding them
together.
5. The tensile properties and cracking pattern of CFRC shows that it can be
particularly useful in construction activities in seismic zones due to its high
tensile strength and post peak load behaviour, which offers sufficient warning
to the inhabitants before complete collapse of the structure.
6. Due to its relatively higher strength and ductility, It can be a good replacement
for asbestos fibres in roofing sheets, which being natural in origin pose zero
threat to the environment
8. It can also be used as the reinforcement material in cement fibre boards which
can act as a good backing to tiles thereby improving its impact resistance and
also in faux ceilings. The advantage of cement fibre boards is its ability to
survive under moist environments unlike paper based gypsum boards
The effect of coconut fibres on high strength concrete should be studied and thus the
use of CFRC can be extended to industrial and commercial buildings. Since the
corrosion study is not done, the applicability of CFRC in reinforced constructions
could be tested.
Coconut fibre is a good insulator in itself and as such it can improve the thermal
properties of concrete. This is particularly useful in a tropical country like India where
the mercury levels are quite high for most part of the year, so as to maintain the room
temperatures within comfort levels of its inhabitants. It can also reduce the load on air
conditioning systems thus reducing the power consumption.
The acoustic properties of concrete reinforced with other natural fibres have been
studied in the past using an impedance tube apparatus and the results are fair enough
to justify the use of coconut fibres as an alternative which is a good absorbent due to
the presence of surface pores.
7. REFERENCES
1. Majid Ali, Nawawi Chouw (2012),“Experimental investigations on coconut-fibre
rope tensile strength and pullout from coconut fibre reinforced concrete”,
Construction and Building Materials, 41, 681–690
4. Noor Md. Sadiqul Hassan, Habibur Rahman Sobuz (2012),“Use of coconut fibre in
production of structural light weight concrete”, Journal of applied sciences 12(9) 831-
839, 2012
5. Vijay Chavada, A.A Parikh (2013), “An application review of coir fibre reinforced
concrete”, Vol. 2 Issue 4 ISSN: 2278-7844
8. Joanna M Ferraz, Sabrina A Martins, Claudio H.S Del Menezzi (2013), “Effect of
coir fibre treatment and coir-fibre ratio on properties of cement bonded composites”,
Bio Resources 6(3), 3481-3492
10. Izad Amir Bin Abdul Karim (2012),“Effect of coconut waste on concrete
structure component”ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences, 30(2012).
2538 – 2547.
11. Yalley, P. P. and Kwan, A.S K (2008), “Use of coconut fibre as an enhancement
of concrete”, International Journal of Sustainable Construction Engineering
&Technology, 27(5), 2008, pp. 575-582.
12. Kamel K.Alzboon and Khalid N.Mahasneh (2009), “Effect of Using Mattress
Waste on the Compression Strength and Slump Characteristics of Concrete”,
Construction and Building Materials 2009;23(2):865–71.
14. Bhowmick B.B. and Debnath C. R. (2007), “Properties of coir”, Indian coconut
journal, 15, (5), 2007. p.12