Energy
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/energy
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Chillers consume more than 40% of the total energy used in the commercial and industrial buildings for
Received 20 August 2010 space conditioning. In this paper, energy consumption by chillers and chilled water pumps, condenser
Received in revised form pumps and fan motors has been estimated using data collected by a walkthrough energy audit for the 16
17 May 2011
faculties of the University of Malaya. It has been estimated that chillers and motors and pumps used in
Accepted 15 June 2011
Available online 20 July 2011
chillers consume 10,737 MWh (i.e. 51% of total energy consumption) of electric energy for different
percentage of loadings. As chillers are major energy users, variable speed drives are applied in chillers to
reduce their energy consumption. It has been estimated that about 8368 MWh annual energy can be
Keywords:
Chiller
saved by using efficient chillers at different loadings. It has also been found that about 23,532 MWh
Energy saving annual energy can be saved for chilled water supply pumps, condenser pumps and cooling tower fan
Variable speed drive motors by matching required speeds using variable speed drives for 60% of speed reduction. About
Emission reductions 1,274,692 kg of CO2 emission could be avoided for using energy efficient chillers at 50% load. It has been
also found that about 2,426,769 kg CO2 emission can be reduced by using variable speed drives for 60%
speed reductions. Payback periods found to be only few months for using variable speed drives in chilled
water pumps, condensers and fan motors.
Ó 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction of current interest because this usually presents the greatest energy
saving opportunity for air conditioning systems in buildings.
Chillers are the major energy consumers in central air condi- Advances in variable frequency drives for energy efficiency evolve
tioning systems. In commercial buildings, where air-conditioning use of variable speed control for chiller compressors, chilled water
systems account for almost half of the total electricity consump- pumps, condenser pumps and cooling tower fans [6]. Electric
tion, chillers end up being the single biggest consumers. Therefore, motors are over 90% efficient when running at their rated loads.
their efficiencies has a significant effect on the overall energy However, they are very inefficient at part loads. Normally, motors
performance of these buildings [1]. The chillers are major energy operate more efficiently at 75% of rated load and above. However,
users (i.e. 42% of total end use consumption) for a typical end use motors are very inefficient when they are operated lower than 50%
consumption [1,2]. It is also found that chillers consume about 40% of rated load. Due to the reactive current increase at low loads,
of total air conditioning energy use [3,4]. It was also reported that power factors are also decreased [7,8]. In such cases, VSDs can be
21% of total operating costs are spent for chillers and pumps as can used to match load requirements so that energy consumption can
be seen in Fig. 1. be reduced. From the study carried out by Saidur et al. [9], found
Water-cooled chillers having efficiency of 0.9 kW/RT were that variable speed drives are good candidates to match the load
common in the 1970s. Efficiencies of these chillers have improved requirements and consequently will save huge amount of energy,
over the last 30 years and the average chiller efficiency is about lower utility bills and protect the environment from harmful
0.50 kW/RT [5]. Improving energy performance of chiller plants is pollutants.
Since cooling load of a building is changed throughout its
occupied period, chillers tend to operate frequently at part load.
* Corresponding author. Tel.: þ603 79674462; fax: þ603 79675317. This kind of operation will cause chiller efficiency to drop, and the
E-mail addresses: saidur@um.edu.my, saidur912@yahoo.com (R. Saidur). drop becomes considerable when the set point of condensing
0360-5442/$ e see front matter Ó 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.energy.2011.06.027
5234 R. Saidur et al. / Energy 36 (2011) 5233e5238
temperature is fixed at a high level while outdoor temperature is Before conducting a walkthrough energy audit in the 16 facul-
low. It is therefore accepted that improving the part-load efficiency ties/academic institutes, the following preparations had been
of chillers is the cornerstone for building energy effectiveness made. A meeting was held with the appropriate technician who is
[6,10,11]. familiar with the physical conditions and day-to-day operation of
It is worth widening the use of variable speed drives (VSD) for the air-conditioning system in a faculty. The purpose of the meeting
chiller systems and their components to operate as efficiently as was to identify areas where auditors’ attention should be focused
possible [12]. Applying VSDs to cooling tower fans with optimized during the walkthrough audit. The well-prepared questionnaire
control could make a 5e8% improvement in energy performance and checklist were made for the walkthrough energy audit and met
[13,14]. Qureshi and Tassou [15] and Tassou and Qureshi [16] made with the technician to get the important data about the air-
a review on the use of VSDs for chiller systems. They confirmed that conditioning system in a faculty.
Nitrogen plant 5%
Fans 6%
Support
Process water pumps
DI water
Nitrogen plant
Fans
Recire and make-up
Fans
Fig. 1. Magnitude of operating cost of end uses equipment in a semi-conductor industry [3].
R. Saidur et al. / Energy 36 (2011) 5233e5238 5235
Table 1
Energy consumption in different faculty and chiller of University of Malaya.
Total energy Number of Number of Chiller energy Chilled water, Total chiller
consumption RT 14 Chiller RT 25 Chiller consumption condenser pumps systemenergy
(MWh/year) and cooling tower consumption (%)
fan motorsenergy
consumption
MWh/year % MWh/year %
Academy of Islamic Studies 2901 23 6 593 20 911 31 51
Academy of Malay Studies 613 4 2 133 22 192 31 53
Faculty of Built Environment 885 5 4 214 24 292 33 57
Faculty of Languages and Linguistics 716 6 1 137 19 218 30 49
Faculty of Economic and Administration 1080 11 1 225 21 370 34 55
Faculty of Engineering 10381 68 35 2297 22 3295 32 54
Faculty of Education 1520 10 3 270 18 410 27 45
Faculty of Dentistry 1594 10 5 333 21 479 30 51
Faculty of Business and Accountancy 3033 21 8 621 20 920 30 51
Faculty of Medicine 7924 52 21 1575 20 2319 29 49
Faculty of Culture Centre 165 2 0 35 21 61 37 58
Faculty of Sports Centre 884 6 2 168 19 253 29 48
Faculty of Science 11289 78 30 2316 21 3426 30 51
Faculty of Computer Science and 5011 37 10 966 19 1477 29 49
Information Technology
Faculty of Arts and Social Science 3551 22 8 639 18 950 27 45
Faculty of Law 859 5 4 214 25 292 34 59
Total 52406 360 140 10737 20 15865 30 51
2.2. Energy audit data As all these are variable torque applications, the power required
(to drive the pumps or fans) varies to the cube of the speed and,
All the faculties in University of Malaya use central air condi- therefore, large power reductions result from small reductions in
tioning systems for space conditioning for lecture halls, labora- speed. The most common method is to modulate the speed of the
tories, offices, and lecturers’ rooms. It has been found that central motors of pumps and fans to vary their capacities using VSDs [19].
air conditioners are operated with 14 RT and 25 RT chillers. As Variable-frequency drives provide continuous control, matching
chilled water supply pumps, condenser pumps, and cooling tower motor speed to the specific demands of the work being performed.
fan motors are the components of chillers systems, their specifi- Variable-frequency drives are an excellent choice for adjustable-
cations have also been collected. The most important data that speed drive users, because they allow operators to fine-tune
have been collected during the walkthrough energy audit are: processes while reducing costs for energy and equipment mainte-
number of chillers, chilled water pumps, cooling tower fan motors, nance in heating, ventilating and air conditioning of buildings
their cooling capacity, power rating, monthly energy billing data [5,20].
and operation time. In this study, the average usage and electricity VSD installations can increase energy efficiency (in some cases
bill are considered as 3632 h/year and 0.064 US$/kWh respec- energy savings can exceed 50 percent), improve power factor and
tively. From the survey data, it is found that chillers are operated process precision, and provide other performance benefits such as
about 18 h/year at 25% load, 1570 h/year at 50% load, 1278 h/year soft starting and over-speed capability. They also can eliminate the
at 75% load and 767 h/year at 100% load, respectively. Using this need for expensive and energy-wasting throttling mechanisms
data, an analysis has been carried out to estimate energy such as control valves and outlet dampers [19].
consumption, energy savings, cost-benefit analysis and emission
reductions associated with the energy savings. The most pertinent 2.3.1. Mathematical formula
data that have been collected through this walkthrough audit are Energy used by chillers can be estimated using Eq. (1) [5]:
presented in Table 1. Moreover, chillers efficiency and operating
hours at different loads and some other related data have been AECchillers ¼ N UH C LF h (1)
collected from other sources [18] as this data is necessary for an Similarly, energy consumption by pumps and motors can be
analysis. expressed as [21]:
AECpumpsCT ¼ N UH P LF (2)
2.3. Pumps and motors energy savings using variable speed drives Table 2 shows the number of pumps and cooling tower fan
(VSDs) motors with their power ratings to estimate their energy
consumption.
Many building systems are designed to operate at a maximum
load. However, most building systems are operated at full load only
for short periods of time. This often results in inefficient operation Table 2
Number of pumps and motors for chilled water supply and cooling tower.
of many systems over long periods of time. Most such inefficient
operations are encountered in air-conditioning systems in build- Type of motors Total number Power rating (kW)
ings that are normally sized to meet peak load conditions that occur Chilled water supply 360 5.5
only for short periods during the normal day. The efficiency of such 140 7.5
systems can be improved by varying their capacities to match Cooling tower 500 5.5
Condenser water pumps 500 3
actual load requirements.
5236 R. Saidur et al. / Energy 36 (2011) 5233e5238
Table 3
Chillers energy consumption and energy savings analysis at different loadings.
Energy use (MWh) without VSD Energy use (MWh) with VSD Energy savings (MWh)
Chiller capacity, RT Load 25% Load 50% Load 75% Load 100% Load 25% Load 50% Load 75% Load 100% Load 25% Load 50% Load 75% Load 100%
14 64 4273 3156 1817 10 1385 1546 1430 54 2888 1610 387
25 44 2967 2192 1262 7 962 1074 993 37 2006 1118 268
2.3.2. Mathematical formulations to estimate energy savings using the chillers energy savings has been estimated and presented in
VSDs Table 4. From the table, it has been observed that more utility bills
There are many ways of estimating the energy savings associ- can be saved for chillers loading at 50% and 75% as chillers are
ated with the use of VSDs for industrial motors for a range of operated longer at these loadings. Table 4 shows the payback
applications. This paper used the method found in [22]. period for using VSDs to reduce chillers energy consumption. It has
Annual energy savings for chillers with VSD in reducing cooling been observed that payback periods at 50%e100% loadings are
load requirements can be expressed as [23]: economically very viable as payback period is very short (i.e. only
few months).
AESchillerVSD ¼ ðAECchillerwithout VSD AECchillerwithVSD Þ Using Eqns. (2) and (4) and data from Table 2, energy savings,
(3) bill savings and payback periods for different percentage of speed
reduction using VSDs for pumps and cooling tower fan motors
Energy use in fans and pumps varies according to the speed have been estimated and presented in Tables 5e7. It has been
raised to the third power, so small changes in speed can result in observed that more energy and bills can be saved at higher
very large changes in energy use. Chilled water supply pumps and percentage of speed reduction using VSDs in pumps and cooling
cooling tower fan motors energy savings using a VSD can be esti- tower fan motors. It was also found that use of VSDs in energy
mated as [24,25]: savings for pumps and fan motors is economically very viable as
payback periods are very short. It also may be mentioned that
AESVSD ¼ N P UH SSR (4)
use of VSDs in reducing energy consumption is economically
SSR- Percentage energy savings associated certain percentage of viable if payback period of an implementation strategy is lower
speed reduction. The potential energy savings associated with the than the life span of the system as has been found in literatures
speed reduction using VSDs for pumps and motors which is taken [27,28]. They reported that the payback period of using VSDs
from Ref. [22]. The data was then used to estimate pumps and for different sizes and categories of motors ranges from 0.4 to
motors energy savings using VSDs. 1.5 years.
The bill savings (US$) associated with the energy savings can be Using Eq. (6) and data from Tables 3 and 5, emissions reduc-
estimated as [24]: tions associated with energy savings for chillers pumps and fan
motors have been estimated and presented in Tables 8e9. It may
BS ¼ AES UEP (5) be mentioned that these savings has been estimated for only one
higher learning institute in Malaysia. There are about 70 higher
learning institutes in Malaysia and there is huge potential for
energy savings in chillers and their components. Moreover,
2.3.3. Formulations of emission reductions associated with the
energy use of chillers can be saved by other energy savings
energy savings
options such as use of absorption chillers and thermal ice storage
It is known that CO2, SO2, NOx and CO are generated when fossil
to shift peak time energy consumption to night time thermal
fuels are burned to produce power. The amount of emission that
energy storage.
can be reduced associated with the energy savings can be estimated
Based on results presented in Table 8, it has been estimated that
using the Equation [26]:
about 1,274,692 kg of CO2 can be reduced for 50% load for using
efficient chillers. This is the maximum amount that can be reduced
ER ¼ AES PE1 Em1p þ PE2 Em2p
as efficiency is low at this part load operation. Similarly, 928,368 kg
þPE3 Em3p þ . þ PEn Emnp (6) of CO2emission can be avoided for 75% load for using efficient
chillers.
The percentage of electricity generation based on fuel types are It has been estimated that about 11,777,380 kg of CO2 can be
16.76% from coal, 2.4% from petroleum, 53.2% from gas and 27.6% reduced when 60% of the motor speed can be reduced using VSDs.
from hydro. Emission factor for per unit electricity generation are As higher speed reductions results in more energy savings, this
taken from ref. [26]. Based on the given data, the emission reduc- amount is the highest savings that can be made for motors and
tions can be calculated as function of energy savings. pumps used in chilled water systems.
Table 5
Savings (MWh) with VSD for chilled water, condenser pumps and cooling tower fan motors.
Quantity Motor power (kW) 10% speed reduction 20% speed reduction 30% speed reduction 40% speed reduction 50% speed reduction 60% speed reduction
360 5.5 1582 3164 4387 5250 5969 6400
140 7.5 839 1678 2326 2784 3165 3394
500 5.5 2197 4395 6093 7291 8290 8889
500 3 1199 2397 3323 3977 4522 4849
Table 6
Bill savings for pumps and cooling tower fan motors using VSDs.
Power rating (kW) 10% speed reduction 20% speed reduction 30% speed reduction 40% speed reduction 50% speed reduction 60% speed reduction
5.5 100,485 200,969 278,617 333,426 379,101 406,506
7.5 53,287 106,575 147,751 176,817 201,039 215,571
5.5 139,562 279,124 386,968 463,092 526,530 564,592
3 76,125 152,250 211,073 252,596 287,198 307,959
Table 7
Payback periods for pumps and cooling tower fan motors using VSDs.
Power rating (kW) 10% speed reduction 20% speed reduction 30% speed reduction 40% speed reduction 50% speed reduction 60% speed reduction
5.5 0.18 0.09 0.07 0.06 0.05 0.05
7.5 0.47 0.24 0.17 0.14 0.12 0.12
5.5 0.13 0.07 0.05 0.04 0.04 0.03
3 0.11 0.06 0.04 0.03 0.03 0.03
Table 8
Amount of emission reduction at different % of chiller loadings using efficient chiller.
Chiller capacity (RT) Emission, kg For 50% Load Emission, kg For 75% Load Emission, kg For 100% Load
Table 9
Emission reductions associated with energy savings by using VSD.
Motor Emission reductions (kg) for 20% speed Emission reductions (kg) for 40% speed Emission reductions (kg) for 60% speed
power (kW) reduction reduction reduction
Acknowledgement [12] Abbott, L., Power quality and cost analysis of industrial electrical distribution
systems with adjustable speed drives, MS thesis, California State University,
USA. 2006.
This research was carried under the High Impact Research Grant [13] Yin J, Wu Z. Corrosion behavior of TP316L of superheater in biomass boiler
(HIRG) scheme. The authors would like to acknowledge the Vice with simulated atmosphere and deposit. Chinese Journal of Chemical Engi-
Chancellor, University of Malaya for providing the financial support neering 2009;17(5):849e53.
[14] Crowther H, Furlong J. Optimizing chillers and towers. ASHRAE Journal 2004;
under the HIRG scheme. 46(7):34e40.
[15] Qureshi TQ, Tassou SA. Variable-speed capacity control in refrigeration
systems. Applied Thermal Engineering 1996;16(2):103e13.
[16] Tassou SA, Qureshi TQ. Comparative performance evaluation of positive
References displacement compressors in variable-speed refrigeration applications.
International Journal of Refrigeration 1998;21(1):29e41.
[1] Jayamaha L. Energy effficiency building systems: green strategies for opera- [17] Flake, B.A., Parameter estimation and optimal supervisory control of chilled
tion and maintenance. 7th ed. McGraw-Hill; 2007. plants. PhD thesis, Department of mechanical Engineering, University of
[2] Capehart BL, Turner WC, Kennedy WJ. Guide to energy management. 5th ed. Wisconsin-Madison. 1988.
The Fairmont Press; 2005. [18] DG, www, http://ateam.lbl.gov/Design-Guide/DGHtm/chillers.htm, Access
[3] Mardikar, Y.M., Energy analysis, Diagnostics, and Conservation in Semi- date: 01.05.09.
conductor Manufacturing. MSc thesis, Department of Industrial and [19] Beggs DC. Energy efficient heating, in energy management and conservation.
Management SystemsEngineering, College of Engineering and Mineral Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann; 2002. pp. 117e147.
Resources at West Virginia University. 2004. [20] Teitel M, Levi A, Zhao Y, Barak M, Bar-lev E, Shmuel D. Energy saving in
[4] Saidur R. Energy consumption, energy savings, and emission analysis in agricultural buildings through fan motor control by variable frequency drives.
Malaysian office buildings. Energy Policy 2009;37(10):4104e13. Energy and Buildings 2008;40(6):953e60.
[5] Jayamaha L. Energy efficient building systems. McGraw Hill Publisher; [21] Hasanuzzaman M, Rahim NA, Saidur R, Kazi SN. Energy savings and emissions
2008. reductions for rewinding and replacement of industrial motor. Energy 2011;
[6] Yu FW, Chan KT. Improved energy performance of air cooled centrifugal 36(1):233e40.
chillers with variable chilled water flow. Energy Conversion and Management [22] Saidur R. A review on electrical motors energy use and energy savings.
2008;49(6):1595e611. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2010;14(3):877e98.
[7] Kaya D, Yagmur EA, Yigit KS, Kilic FC, Eren AS, Celik C. Energy efficiency in [23] Saidur R, Mahlia TMI, Hasanuzzaman M. Developing energy performance
pumps. Energy Conversion and Management 2008;49(6):1662e73. standard, label and test procedures and impacts analysis for commercial
[8] Thirugnanasambandam M, Hasanuzzaman M, Saidur R, Ali MB, chillers. Energy Education Science and Technology Part A: Energy Science and
Rajakarunakaran S, Devaraj D, Rahim NA. Analysis of electrical motors load Research 2011;27(1):175e90.
factors and energy savings in an Indian cement industry. Energy 2011;36(7): [24] Saidur R, Hasanuzzaman M, Yogeswaran S, Mohammed HA, Hossain MS. An end-
4307e14. use energy analysis in a Malaysian public hospital. Energy 2010;35(12):4780e5.
[9] Saidur R, Rahim NA, Ping HW, Jahirul MI, Mekhilef S, Masjuki HH. Energy and [25] Saidur R, Rahim NA, Hasanuzzaman M. A review on compressed-air energy
emission analysis for industrial motors in Malaysia. Energy Policy 2009;37(9): use and energy savings. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2010;
3650e8. 14(4):1135e53.
[10] Yu FW, Chan KT. Environmental performance and economic analysis of all- [26] Mahlia TMI. Emissions from electricity generation in Malaysia. Renewable
variable speed chiller systems with load-based speed control. Applied Energy 2002;27(2):293e300.
Thermal Engineering 2009;29(8e9):1721e9. [27] Tolvanen J. Saving energy with variable speed drives. World Pumps;
[11] Yu FW, Chan KT. Part load performance of air-cooled centrifugal chillers with 2008:32e3.
variable speed condenser fan control. Building and Environment 2007;42(11): [28] Tolvanen J. LCC approach for big motor-driven systems savings. World
3816e29. Pumps; November, 2008:24e7.