Policy Studies Review, Spring 1999 16:1
MANAGING
IN NETWORK
SETTINGS
L8
Robert Agranoff
Michael McGuire
School of Pablic and Environmental
Affairs Department of Public
Administration
Indiana University
University af North TexasAgranof/McGuire: Managing in Network Settings
The focus of this article ts on managing networks, A network knowledge
pase is developed fram the authors” studies of ity government involvement in
economic development, management within rural enterprises and the
evaluation of a rural strexegic planning project. Other public management
nepvork analyses are also incorporated. Management in network settings
iy not based on central authority and cannot be guided by a single
organizational goal ay is the case in the classical management approach
Management involves managing flexible structures toward collective
efficiency. The ability 19 manage is related to the mternal condition of the
manager's primary arganization. It involves technical, legal, political and
cost dimensions It requires different capacities, skills and knowledge frum
that of single organization management. The next steps in the research
wondd inchide the development of the skills needed, an analysis of the role of
organizational power and the operational variables of neaworks, the issue of
network cohesion, and the question af loss of contrad or difficulty in assessing
network accountability
MANAGI
2 IN NETWORK
“TTIN
Itis time to focus attention on managing within networks. The
significance of these actions is clear. now the details need to be filled
in. Kettl (1996) maintains that the most important change in
administrative functions over the last century. in both the public and
private sectors. is the dramatic rise in organizational interdependence.
As he points out, a core task of managers is to build critical linkages
while simultaneously managing the intemal functions of their agencies.
However, network analysis has lagged behind other types of
interorganizational analysis. Milward (1994), for example. observes
that researchers in public management seem to display an
overdeveloped capacity for policy analysis and an underdeveloped
capacity for administrative analysis. Examination of the
managerial aspects of networks and networking holds the prospect
of altering this imbalance.
Since networks are great laboratories of contemporary
management. empirical research on network process can make
important contributions to management theory. Empirical research on
19?
0
Policy Studies Review, Spring 1999 16:1
public management networking thus forms the basis of the analysis.
in this article. we develop a network management knowledge base,
relying on our own and other empirical studies. The authors’ major
networking study isa multi-phase study of city government involvement
in economic development policy networks in 237 Midwestern cities,
along with six field-based case studies conducted among the more
active of these cities. The study examines the multiple actors involved
in these networks, the structures and purposes of the networks, multiple
networking strategies, and the varying levels of networking activity
across the cities (Agranoff and McGuire, 1998a: 1998b: 1998¢;
1998d: McGuire. 1998). Another important study involves
management within rural enterprise alliances. which are formal
networks of producers, distributors, labor unions. employer institutions,
and government agencies (Agranoff, 1998). The other body of
research with a strong bearing on our understanding of networks
involves an evaluation of a rural strategic planning project, where
community leaders were expected to create networks and engave in
intergovernmental linkages (McGuire, etal. 1994), Many other pubtie
management network analyses help frame our thinking, including those
of Bardach (1998). Milward (1994), O" Toole (1993: 1996: 1997},
and Hull with Hiern (1987). We present these findings initially by
differentiating networks from other managerial contexts and
perspectives. The nature of management within networks is then
explored. followed by a section on the skiils needed to manage
effectively. Finaliy, an agenda for future research in network
management is developed.
THE EMERGENCE OF NETWORKS
When we refer to networks, we are speaking of social
structures that permit interorganizational interactions of exchange,
concerted action and joint production (Alter and Hage. 1993}. Quite
simply. networks are “structures of interdependence involving multiple
organizations or parts thereof, where one unit is not merely the formal
subordinate of the others in some larger hierarchical arrangement”
(O'Toole. 1997: 45). For the public manager, such network structures
can be formal or informal, and they are typically imtersectoral,