Φ
Abstract -- This paper presents no-load core loss analysis of 3- measurements were performed on toroidal core [5],[6]. The
phase energy-saving small size induction motor supplied by toroidal core was chosen because it better reflects the
sinusoidal voltage. In field-circuit part the distribution and phenomena of the machine core, also the cutting stress
changes of magnetic flux densities of the motor are computed effect, than an Epstein test frame. The samples of the non-
by using time-stepping FEM. Discrete Fourier Transform is
used to analyze the magnetic flux density waveforms in each oriented silicon steel M600-50A thickness 0.5 mm for tests
element of the motor model. Rotational aspect of the field is were cut in form of rings with width 10 mm and assembled
included by introducing correction to first harmonic of in toroidal form of height 10 mm, to approximate changes of
alternating losses. Core losses in each element are evaluated their parameters to these obtained as results of cutting sheets
using core loss curve measured on toroidal core at different at manufacture a magnetic core of an electrical motor. The
frequencies. In addition, rapid circuit method is presented. The measured specific core losses as a function of frequency for
results are compared with the measurements.
different values of peak magnetic flux density are presented
Index Terms — induction motors; magnetic losses; finite in Fig. 1 and as function of frequency and flux density in
element method; rotating machine transient analysis; rotating Fig. 2. This approach is an extension of ideas presented in
machine measurements; circuit modelling. [7] where a possible way to characterize the core losses is
the use of the ring-test data collected on the machine under
I. INTRODUCTION study.
Φ
The curves of the specific core loss versus peak flux
This work was supported by the Ministry of Science and Higher
Education (Project N N510 388235).
density for different frequencies were approximated by third
K. Komeza and M. Dems are with Institute of Mechatronics and order polynomials.
Information Systems, Technical University of Lodz, Stefanowskiego 18/22, Sample of that polynomial for 50 Hz have the form:
90-924 Lodz, Poland (e-mails: komeza@p.lodz.pl, mdems@p.lodz).
1.0 1.08 1.16 1.24 1.32 1.4 1.48 1.56 1.64 1.72 1.8
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0
Fig. 7. The equipotential lines of the vector potential correspond to time 0.2
s. One flux tube contains a flux per unit length of 0.001 Wb/m. (left)
Magnitude of magnetic flux density at time 0.2 s (right)
N −1
− i 2πkn / N
B pk = ∑ B (n )e p = x and y k = 0,.., N - 1 (6)
p
n=0
0.8 0.9 1.0 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8
for first harmonic. The ground for such procedure was that 18,00 with rotor movement
Stator core losses ( W )
is defined as the ratio between minor and major axis of the 0,00
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39
flux density loop. Harmonic order
Fig. 16. Core losses spectrum calculated with and without rotor movement.
λ=B /B (7) 2,20
min maj 2,00
1,80
where Bmaj and Bmin are the peak flux density values
Stator core losses ( W )
1,60
along major and minor axis of the field loop.
1,40
The rotational losses are calculated as [20]-[22] 1,20
with rotor movement
⎡ ( )⎤
1,00
12,00
10,00 where ρ is mass density of the core material, Dsi is
8,00 Fe
6,00 internal diameter of the stator core, Dre is external diameter
4,00
of the rotor core, lFe is length of stator core, kFe is packing
2,00
0,00
factor of the core, kts(r) defines the ratio of tooth width to
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 stator or rotor slot pitch, pscν is eddy current loss density in
Harmonic order
Fig. 18. Total core losses spectrum calculated with rotor movement.
the sheets for flux density Br(s)ν and frequency fν.
Total additional surface loss in the stator and rotor teeth we
6,00 can calculate from formula:
5,50
5,00
P = ∑P (10)
4,50 s0 s 0ν
4,00 ν
3,50
Additional pulsation losses in the stator teeth, caused by the
Core losses ( W )
3,00
2,50 flux of the harmonic rotor fields, were calculated from
2,00 formula in the form [25]:
1,50
1,00
2
0,50 P =m B p (11)
0,00 p0ν ds rν pcν
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39
Harmonic order
Fig. 19. Total core losses spectrum calculated with rotor movement. First and P = ∑P (12)
harmonic omitted. p0 p0ν
ν
4,50
where mds is weight of teeth, ppcν is specific pulsation core
4,00
loss for flux density Brν and frequency fν.
3,50
Additional pulsation losses in the rotor cage, caused by the
Rotor core losses ( W )
3,00
flux of the harmonic stator fields, were calculated from
2,50
formula in the form [25]:
2,00
1,50 πD
2 1.5 re (13)
P = 0.85e − 6( B k k ) f b l Q k
1,00
Alν sν cr s r1 Fe r cr 2 ν
0,50 sν s
0,00
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 where kcr is rotor Carter factor, Bsν and fni. are amplitude of
Harmonic order
Fig. 20. Rotor core losses spectrum. the flux density and frequency of the νs harmonic of the
stator field, br1 is a width of opening of the rotor slot, Qr is
From these results it is clear that including motion of the number of the rotor slots. Total no-load core losses
rotor is crucial for proper losses calculation. One can notice calculated are presented in the Table 1.
the significant contribution of slotting harmonics to the total
losses. Fundamental losses amount only about a half of total TABLE I
losses. The losses in the rotor are dominated by the losses in BASIC AND ADDITIONAL NO LOAD CORE LOSS CALCULATED WITH USE
FIELD CIRCUIT AND CIRCUIT METHOD AND MEASURED
the tooth-tips. The no-load core losses calculated by use of
the field-circuit method are presented in the Table 1. The no-load core loss [W]
Calculated by use Calculated by Measured
field circuit use circuit
V. THE CIRCUIT CALCULATIONS method method
In the circuit calculation of the basic core loss only first Total basic stator 22.5 23.9
harmonic of the field was taken into account. The calculation core loss for first
harmonic
of the basic core loss in the stator teeth was made including Stator core loss for 8.59 2.00
the division of the tooth into 6 parts, for value of the flux higher harmonics
density in each of these parts. For frequency 50 Hz the basic Rotor core loss for 5.14 9.52
no-load core losses of the motor were respectively: in the higher harmonic
stator teeth – 7.54 W, and in the stator yoke – 16.36 W Additional loss of 3.41 2.78
In the calculations of the additional no-load core loss the pulse in the rotor
higher harmonics of the magnetic fields in the air-gap were Total core loss 39.64 38.20 39.3
taken into account.
Additional surface loss Ps0ν in the stator and rotor teeth, The measured total no-load core loss was obtained from the
caused by the flux of the νr(s) order harmonic rotor and stator tests made with rotor movement. Mechanical no-load losses
fields, were calculated from formula proposed by F. Taegen were measured for the entire range of rotor speed [5], using
[26], in the form: accurate torque transducer placed between the measured
unsupplied driven motor and additional driving motor.
An error of total no-load core loss calculation in relation to [11] G. Diaz, P. Arboleya, C. Gonzalez-Moran, J. Gomez-Aleixandre,
“Revision of the hysteresis and excess loss computation method as a
the measurement results is: means of improving the rotational loss estimate in induction motors”,
• for the field –circuit method – 0.9 % IET Electric Power Applications, Vol. 1 , Issue: 1,pp. 75 – 81,2007.
• for the circuit method – 2.8% [12] L. Jeong-Jong, K. Soon-O, H. Jung-Pyo, K.Ji-Hyun; H. Kyung-Ho,
All circuit calculations were made with including 40 field “Core loss distribution of three-phase induction motor using numerical
method”, in Proc31st International Telecommunications Energy
harmonics. Conference INTELEC 2009, pp.1-4.
[13] N. Hyuk, H. Kyung-Ho, L. Jeong-Jong, H. Jung-Pyo, K. Gyu-Hong,
VI. CONCLUSIONS “A study on iron loss analysis method considering the harmonics of
the flux density waveform using iron loss curves tested on Epstein
This paper presents no-load core loss analysis of 3-phase samples”, IEEE Trans. on Mag., Vol. 39 , Issue 3 , Part 1, pp. 1472 –
energy-saving small size induction motor fed by sinusoidal 1475, 2003.
[14] F. Fiorillo, A. Novikov, “An improved approach to power losses in
voltage. In field-circuit part the distribution and changes in magnetic laminations under nonsinusoidal induction waveform”, IEEE
magnetic flux densities of the motor are computed by using a Trans. on Mag., Vol. 26 , Issue 5, pp. 2904 – 2910, 1990.
using time-stepping FEM. Discrete Fourier Transform has [15] A. Belahcen, A. Arkkio, “Comprehensive Dynamic Loss Model of
Electrical Steel Applied to FE Simulation of Electrical Machines”,
been used to analyze the magnetic flux density waveforms in IEEE Trans. on Mag., Vol.44 , Issue 6, pp. 886 - 889, 2008.
each element of the analyzed model. Rotational aspect of the [16] S.O.Kwon, J.J. Lee, B.H. Lee, J.H. Kim, K.H. Ha, J.P. Hong, “Loss
field was included by introducing correction to first Distribution of Three-Phase Induction Motor and BLDC Motor
According to Core Materials and Operating”, IEEE Trans. on Mag.,
harmonic of alternating losses. Core losses in each element Vol. 45 , Issue 10, pp. 4740 – 4743, 2009.
are evaluated using core loss curve measured on toroidal [17] F. Fiorillo, A. M. Rietto, “Rotational and alternating energy loss vs.
core at different frequencies. In addition, rapid circuit magnetizing frequency in SiFe laminations”, J. Magn. Magn. Mater.,
83, pp. 402–404, 1990.
method is presented. The results are compared with the [18] G. Bertotti, A. Boglietti, M. Chiampi, D. Chiarabaglio, F. Fiorillo, M.
measurements and good agreement was obtained for both Lazzari, “An improved estimation of iron losses in rotating electrical
methods. However, the field-circuit time-stepping method is machines”, IEEE Trans. Magn., 34, pp. 5007–5009, 1991.
[19] J. G. Zhu, V. S. Ramsden, “Improved formulations for rotational core
quite time consuming, so the choice for optimization losses in rotating electrical machines”, IEEE Trans. Magn., 34, pp.
methods is rather the rapid circuit method. 2234–2242, 1998.
[20] T. Kochmann, “Relationship between rotational and alternating losses
in electrical steel sheets”, Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic
VII. ACKNOWLEDGMENT Materials, 160, pp. 145-146, 1996.
The authors gratefully acknowledge the contributions of [21] C.A. Hernandez-Aramburo, T.C. Green, A.C. Smith, “Estimating
rotational iron losses in an induction machine”,, IEEE Trans. on Mag.,
J. Szulakowski from TU Lodz for his work on core losses Vol. 39 , Issue 6, pp. 3527 – 3533, 2003.
measurements and of A. Michaelides from Vector Fields [22] G.Youguang, Z. Jian Guo, Z. Jinjiang; L. Haiyan; J. Jian Xun,
Software Cobham Technical Services for valuable help. “Measurement and Modeling of Rotational Core Losses of Soft
Magnetic Materials Used in Electrical Machines: A Review”, IEEE
Trans. on Mag., Vol.44 , Issue 2, pp. 279 – 291, 2008.
VIII. REFERENCES [23] L. Yujing, S. K. Kashif, A. M. Sohail, “Engineering considerations on
[1] J. Lavers, P. Biringer, “Prediction of core losses for high flux densities additional iron losses”, Proc. 18th International Conference on
and distorted flux waveforms”, IEEE Trans. on Mag., Vol. 12 , Issue Electrical Machines ICEM 2008, pp. 1-4.
6,pp. 1053 - 1055, 1976. [24] O. Bottauscio, M. Chiampi, A. Manzin, and M. Zucca, ”Additional
[2] M. Amar, R. Kaczmarek, “Alternative method is presented in [A Losses in Induction Machines Under Synchronous No-Load
general formula for prediction of iron losses under nonsinusoidal Conditions”, IEEE Trans. on Mag., vol. 40, no. 5,pp. 3254-3261, Sep.
voltage waveform”, IEEE Trans. on Mag., Vol. 31 , Issue 5, pp. 2504 2004.
– 2509, 1995. [25] T. Śliwiński, “The methods of the induction motors calculation”,
[3] G. Bertotti, “General properties of power losses in soft ferromagnetic PWN, Warszawa, Poland, 2008, p.324 (in polish)
materials”, IEEE Trans. on Mag, vol. 24, no. 1, pp. 621–630, Jan. [26] B. Piepenbreier, F. Taegen,“Surface losses in cage induction motors”
1988 in Proc. Beijing International Conference on Electrical Machines,
[4] D. Ionel, M. Popescu, C. Cossar, M.I. McGilp, A. Boglietti, A. China Academic Publishers, Book I, pp. 326-329, 1987.
Cavagnino, “A General Model of the Laminated Steel Losses in
Electric Motors with PWM Voltage Supply”, in Industry Applications IX. BIOGRAPHIES
Society Annual Meeting 2008, pp. 1-7.
[5] M. Dems M., K. Komęza, J Szulakowski., “No-Load Curves of the Krzysztof Komeza is vice director of Institute of Mechatronics and
High-Speed Small Size Induction Motor”, ZP-ME, vol. 82, pp. 239- Information Systems at Technical University of Lodz, Poland. He obtained
245 Katowice, Poland, 2009, his Ph.D. in 1983 and D.Sc. in 1995 at the Technical University of Lodz.
[6] M. Dems M., K. Komęza, J Szulakowski., “Influence of different From 1998 he works as a professor at the Technical University of Lodz.
magnetic material of the high-speed induction motors cores on motors His research interests include computational electromagnetics, efficient
fields distribution and integral parameters”, Proc. of XIV International finite element computations and coupled field computations and design and
Symposium on Electromagnetic Fields in Mechatronics, Electrical and optimisation of electrical machines. He has done a number of consultancy
Electronic Engineering, ISEF 2009, Arras, France, September 10-12, works for electrical machines industry. He has published over 160 papers.
2009, pp. 295-296.
[7] A. Tessarolo, F. Luise, “A finite element approach to harmonic core
loss prediction in VSI-fed induction motor drives” in International Maria Dems Ph.D, D.Sc. obtained her Dipl.Ing. and M.Sc. in Electrical
Symposium on Power Electronics, Electrical Drives, Automation and Engineering at the Technical University of Lodz in 1970 and her Ph.D. in
Motion SPEEDAM 2008, pp. 1309 – 1314. 1978. The title D.Sc. she obtains in 1996. From 1998 she works as a
[8] E. Dlala, A. Belahcen, J. Pippuri, A. Arkkio, “Interdependence of professor at the Technical University of Lodz, Poland. She specializes in
Hysteresis and Eddy-Current Losses in Laminated Magnetic Cores of electrical engineering, especially in modelling, design and optimization of
Electrical Machines”, IEEE Trans. on Mag., Vol. 46 , Issue 2,pp. 306 electrical machines, applications of modern tools, databases and expert
– 309, 2010. systems. She has done a number of consultancy works for electrical
[9] E. Dlala, A. Belahcen, K. A. Fonteyn, M. Belkasim, Magnetics, machines industry. Author or joint author of over 150 publications.
“Improving Loss Properties of the Mayergoyz Vector Hysteresis
Model”, IEEE Trans. on Mag., Vol. 46 , Issue 3 , Part: 2, pp. 918 –
924, 2010.
[10] E. Dlala, “Comparison of Models for Estimating Magnetic Core
Losses in Electrical Machines Using the Finite-Element Method”,
IEEE Trans. on Mag., vol. 45, issue 2, part 1, pp. 716 – 725, Feb.
2009.