Kylie Gempler
CIG: 660
I was born and raised in a quaint mountain town in rural Northern, California. Growing up in
a small town, I can personally relate and understand the life of small town individual and
community as a whole. I saw firsthand the constant and consistent negative pattern of a never
ending vicious cycle. A majority of the individuals of this community, and communities similar
to mine, become stagnant and stuck because of the lack of resources available. Unfortunately,
with the lack of resources and opportunities, there are not many motivators in getting people out
of this town and onto bigger and better things. The general public are consumed by negative
behaviors including crime and excessive use of selling and using of drugs. Luckily for me, I had
parents who motivated me to get out of this small town and venture out to become the best
person I could be. Now with becoming a teacher and understanding the power of education and
believing that ALL students deserve the chance to do big and positive things in the world, I
wanted to study the pattern and understand why there is such marginalization in my hometown,
specifically with children, and why there is an alarming increase in kids being expelled from
school and thrown into our new juvenile hall facility. I wanted to take a look for myself and see
how and if this juvenile hall is advocating for social justice and, hopefully, rehabilitating and
About two years ago, a juvenile hall opened up in my small town. I was surprised by this
because the only major building we have here in this little town of Sonora is a Super Walmart.
This intrigued and peaked my interest in why there even needed to be a brand new juvenile hall
built. I wanted to see and find out why the epidemic of increase juvenile halls have now
somehow landed into my community. Before going to the new juvenile hall, I did research on
this brand new juvenile hall. According to their mission statement on the Tuolumne County
website, “The mission of the Mother Lode Regional Juvenile Detention Facility is to provide for
the safe and supportive detention of youth requiring secure rehabilitative services. It is guided by
the belief high risk youth are capable of changing negative patterns of conduct through active
participation in evidenced based and best practices programs empirically proven to promote
positive change” (Mother Lode Regional Juvenile Detention Facility, 2017). There mission
statement illuminates that their ultimate goal is to not punish, but rehabilitate in a positive
manner in order to truly promote positive change for these kids. The website also stated various
positive and proven evidence based practices they use to promote positive change in these kids.
There are four categories in which they focus on: Core Programs, Education, Health Services,
and various Evidence Based Activities/Programs. For the Core Programs, this includes: a
Religious Program, Life and Vocation Skills, Truth about Drugs Education, Sex and Parenting
Education, and a Work Program. For the Education Services, this includes: English/Language
Arts and Social Sciences, Math, Science, Health, Fine Arts/Foreign Language, Electives,
Specialized educational services, Credit recovery services, and Emphasis on project based
learning. The Health Services include: dental, mental health, behavioral health, and medical.
Gempler 3
Lastly, the Evidence-Based Programs t hat are offered include: Boy’s Council, Girl’s Circle,
Interviewing, Interactive Journaling, Seeking Safety (treatment for youth with PTSD and
co-occurring substance use disorder), and Dialectical Behavior Therapy (Mother Lode Regional
Juvenile Detention Facility, 2017). After doing research and seeing all of the resources provided,
It made me truly hopeful that this juvenile detention center was truly advocating for these kids
3) Review of the Literature Bases Concerning Juvenile Hall Systems in the United State
Juvenile hall detention centers are a growing and increasing at a startling rate.
Incarceration in general, whether it be juvenile hall, county jail, or the prison systems, are ALL
escalating and increasing in both size and population at an alarming rate. Unfortunately, the
problem of incarceration is only getting worse and worse especially in the United states for it
“ has the highest rate of incarceration in the world. Our country has only 5% of the world’s
population, yet we incarcerate 25% of the world’s prisoners. In real numbers, that statistic
translates into 2.3 million people behind bars” (de Bladio & Hall, 2015). These staggering
statistics prove that there is a major issue and epidemic in the way in which incarceration is
handled in the U.S. Yes, it is good we have a justice system that protects society from violent
criminals, but it has“unfortunately, become the default remedy for a host of non-violent offenses
in instances where other more effective remedies are available” (2015). There needs to be an
alternative method then just throwing an individual in jail. There is no reason why some of these
Gempler 4
individuals should be ut in juvenile hall, jail, or prison. There has to be another cost effective and
ethical way.
Not only are the numbers of how many individuals are getting incarcerated is astounding,
but so is the marginalized demographic that is being incarcerated. Unfortunately, there are
certain races that are targeted and more likely to be incarcerated just because of their cultural
background,
“ Our country’s massive and reflexive use of incarceration as the solution to all criminal
Latino young men. African-Americans and Latinos collectively account for 30% of our
population, but they represent 60% of our current inmates...Approximately one in every
35 African-American men, and one in 88 Latino men is presently serving time behind
Once again, these statistics prove that there is a detrimental and unfair systemic pattern that is
occuring in our justice system. There needs to be preventative measures put into place instead of
specifically why their is such an increase and failure to prevent th kids from not only being
thrown into juvenile hall, but becoming repeated offenders that eventually end up in the adult
system. I found that one of the reasons is because, “there is “slippage” in the system that reduces
practitioners’ ability to effectively address needs. Even in domains where interventions are
available, many youth are not receiving services matched to their needs” (Peterson-Badali,
Gempler 5
Skilling, & Haqanee, 2015, p. 305). Like with teaching, if the individualized needs are not met
for each and every student, those students are more likely going to struggle and sometimes even
give up all together. The research article also illuminated the positive outcome that occurs when
the individualized needs are met, “meeting individual needs in treatment was associated with
decreased offending” (2015). This proves how it is imperative to make it a priority to really treat
these kids on an individualized basis and take the time to make sure ALL needs (socially,
behaviorally, emotionally, and academically) are being met . These findings prove when it comes
to educating and trying to reform these students, the system needs to truly take the time to
understand each and every kids individualized needs in order to get them back on the positive
track.
Below were my four set interview questions I asked one of the teachers at the Juvenile
detention facility. The interview was recorded in order to get accurate and specific answers
(Anonymous, 2018)
“As the teacher, I try to make up credits for students who need to graduate. I have a special
program where kids who are deficient in credits so I would give them a weeks worth of work for
a quarter credit. It is almost like independent study, but I would work with the students hand
on”.
“We recently got a juvenile hall because we were sending kids to Nevada City and it was a little
rough out there. So instead, out county wanted something for our community to help with not
only credit recovery, but counseling. We have volunteers and licensed professionals that help
Gempler 6
with various activities such as helping in library and job opportunities. We have a whole lot of
programs for kids including college while they’re at this facility”.
● What negative patterns do you see in regards to the continuous and vicious cycle in these
kids being “stuck in the system?:
“Right now we have a cycle where the kids get in trouble at school and then their next step is a
community day school. Then the next step after that is a credit recovery with the Gold Rush Day
School a nd finally after that, it’s juvenile hall. Most of these kids have gone to all four different
systems. I personally believe we need to do something first hand with teachers for when these
kids were younger. We have to make sure and see if they they need an IEP or if they have a
learning disability. Most of the time,that’s probably why the kids are having behavior problems
because once they have behavior problems, it's hard to fix. Then these kids get stuck in the
system of behavior problems and it just goes from there. Once they go to juvenile hall, then the
next step for them is going to Jade County Jail and then they may even end up in prison if they
do not follow through with all the programs that they have for the kids”.
● What kind of kids come to this juvenile hall? Do they all have similar backgrounds or
different? Do you see a consistent pattern?:
“Most students do not have a support system at home. They have one or more parents who were
on drugs. I’ve had a few that had parents that sold drugs and they actually participated in as well.
I’ve had students that were victims of sex trafficking too.I’ve had students who have just been
pushed through the education system and nobody really cared so the next step was breaking the
law”.
Overall, the agency as a whole seemed effective in the sense that I truly believe this
juvenile hall has the best intentions for rehabilitating these kids and helping them with getting
back on the positive path. When I interviewed the teacher, she seemed really passionate about
trying to help these kids and give them the best education possible. The educator even told me at
Gempler 7
the interview she helped one student graduate with their high school credits and helped another
student complete 15 units of college classes! When I heard this I truly had chills on my arms. It
is wonderful to see and know there are teachers like her trying to make sure these kids are taken
care of and succeed. This juvenile hall teacher is giving her all in believing in these kids and
knowing they are capable of change and reform. I thought this facility is truly trying to make a
positive influence and impact on these kids lives. You can also tell the community as a whole
wants to help too (I could tell with all the volunteers that were helping out that day).
The only negative evaluation regarding the agency is the cost. The cost of the building
was around two million dollars to build! Plus, there only seemed to be a handful of kids at this
detention facility too. This made me think about that two million dollars and how that money
could have been used to prevent kids from going into a juvenile detention facility in the first
place. What if that two million dollars was used to have access to more SPED classes or
programs for at risk youth? All the workers at the facility truly seemed to honestly try their
hardest. I tell the workers their are passionate individuals working hard to truly make a positive
impact in making sure these kids have a fair chance at a good life.
When looking around in the detention facility, I felt very badly for these marginalized
kids. It truly broke my heart seeing these kids in here, knowing that there life had come to this. It
made me wonder what other options, if put into place, would have prevented this? Luckily for
me, I lived a life of privilege. My father is a cop and my mother is a teacher, therefore, I was not
Gempler 8
exposed to any negative behaviors that many of my classmates growing up had to deal with.
Taking a look inside this facility, in my hometown with my own eyes, truly made me want to
help these kids. It made me feel sad, but also upset and angry that this was happening in my town
I grew up in. It seems like a never ending cycle, full of the same things happening over and over
again.
Being a teacher, I really feel it is my duty to not give up on any of my kids! Before taking
this class, I understood the importance of taking the time to make sure the needs of ALL my
students are met, but I never realized how truly imperative it is. I truly realize now that
differentiated and one-on-one instruction is vital in making sure all students are enaged in the
content. This will lead to less behavioral issue and hopefully motivate and show students that
they are smart and can succeed! I also realize after doing the readings and research from this
class that I need to be an advocate for my students! Au not only teaches and writes books about
multicultural education, but also takes action in social justice! I believe that I need to more than
ever speak up for my students, especially the students who are marginalized, and give them a
voice. It is my duty as an educator to make sure students are given all the resources available and
Not only do I vow to make it my mission to make sure all the needs of my students are
met and advocated for, but also the system needs to make change too. There needs to be a
coherent and positive system that works together, “Most juvenile justice systems, in reality, do
(Guarino-Ghezzi,2017, p.1). This proves that juvenile halls are ran like big business. Instead of
doing what is right, money is the contributing factor to why the expansion of incarceration
systems are expanding. Money should not be the priority, but instead giving these kids a chance
and asking “what is best for them?”. The only way to make true change is to make positive
that policymakers should use in striking a balance between holding youths accountable for their
past behavior, and providing services and opportunities to change their environments so that
future behaviors will be guided by constructive, rather than destructive, forces” (Guarino-Ghezzi,
2017, p. 5). This proves that positive action must take place and we must come together as a
whole to truly rehabilitate these kids instead of just keeping them in the system for the rest of
their lives.
I truly believe real and true positive change only takes one person. I vow to be that
person. Even though I may not have the power to reform the entire juvenile hall system as a
whole, I do have the power to make sure my students do not fall into the never ending vicious
cycle of the system. I believe that I can make a true difference by making sure the individualized
needs of ALL my students are met. It is time to make positive change, one student at a time.
Even though I may be one person, I realized that my students depend on me to be their advocate.
Gempler 10
Sources
de Blasio, H. B., & Hall, C. (2015). Re: Mass Incarceration: Seizing the Moment for Reform.
Retrieved from:
https://www.tuolumnecounty.ca.gov/910/Mother-Lode-Regional-Juvenile-Detention