Anda di halaman 1dari 5

Surg Radiol Anat (2011) 33:53–57

DOI 10.1007/s00276-010-0697-2

ORIGINAL ARTICLE

Three nearly forgotten anatomical triangles of the neck: triangles


of Beclard, Lesser and Pirogoff and their potential applications
in surgical dissection of the neck
R. Shane Tubbs • Mark Rasmussen •
Marios Loukas • Mohammadali M. Shoja •

Aaron A. Cohen-Gadol

Received: 28 September 2009 / Accepted: 29 June 2010 / Published online: 10 July 2010
 Springer-Verlag 2010

Abstract The neck is an area that lends itself to ana- were found between the measurements of each leg of any
tomical geometry, such as triangles. Many triangles of the of the three triangles and gender, or between the mea-
neck have been described, and some are well known; surement of each leg of any of the three triangles and right
however, some have been nearly forgotten. The purposes of versus left sides. Beclard’s triangle, when present, was
this study were to review prior literature on the forgotten found to contain both the hypoglossal nerve and the lingual
triangles of the neck, to measure and document the artery. Pirogoff’s triangle always contained the lingual
occurrence of these triangles and the structures found artery, and Lesser’s triangle contained no major structures,
within them, and to discuss their surgical significance and but the lingual artery was deep to its floor. Knowledge of
relationships to the standard triangles of the neck. This these triangles, their contents, and relationships to other
study was carried out on 17 (34 sides) formaldehyde-fixed structures of the neck could be important for cranio-facial,
adult human cadavers (5 males and 12 females), the mean oral, general, and neurosurgeons who operate within the
age being 78 years. All triangles were found within the neck.
submandibular triangle of the anterior cervical triangle.
Beclard’s triangle was present on 28 sides and absent on 6 Keywords Neck  Anatomy  Surgery  Landmarks
sides because the posterior belly of the digastric muscle did
not touch the hyoid bone and because the posterior belly of
the digastric muscle was directly over the greater cornu of Introduction
the hyoid bone. Lesser’s triangle was present on 30 sides
and absent on 4 sides because the hypoglossal nerve Many anatomical triangles of the neck have been descri-
remained inferior to the digastric muscle. Pirogoff’s tri- bed, and some are well known; however, some have been
angle was also present on 30 sides and absent on 4 sides, nearly forgotten [16, 17]. The purposes of this study were
again because the hypoglossal nerve remained inferior to to review prior literature on three nearly forgotten triangles
the digastric muscle. No statistically significant differences of the neck, to measure and document the occurrence of
these triangles and the structures found within them, and to
discuss their surgical significance.
R. S. Tubbs (&)  M. Rasmussen
Department of Pediatric Neurosurgery, Children’s Hospital, On either side of the neck, the sternocleidomastoid
1600 7th Avenue South ACC 400, Birmingham, AL 35233, USA muscle can be used as a guide to divide the neck into an
e-mail: rstubbs@uab.edu anterior and a posterior triangle. The anterior border of
the anterior triangle is the midline; the posterior border is
M. Loukas
Department of Anatomical Sciences, St. George’s University, the anterior margin of the sternocleidomastoid, and the
Grenada, West Indies base is directed superiorly and is formed by the mandible
[12]. The anterior cervical triangle can be subdivided into
M. M. Shoja  A. A. Cohen-Gadol
three paired (bilateral) and one unpaired triangle. The three
Indianapolis Neurosurgical Group, Department of Neurosurgery,
Clarian Neuroscience Institute, Indiana University, Indianapolis, paired triangles include the carotid (superior carotid), the
IN, USA muscular (inferior carotid), and the submandibular

123
54 Surg Radiol Anat (2011) 33:53–57

(submaxillary or digastric) triangles [9, 16]. The single the other two sides are composed of the intermediate tendon
unpaired triangle is found immediately inferior to the chin of the digastric muscle (inferior border), and the posterior
and is the submental triangle. border of the mylohyoid muscle serving as the anterior
The final paired triangle, the submandibular triangle, is border. Pirogoff’s triangle is actually the posterior continu-
bound superiorly by the inferior border of the body of the ation of Lesser’s triangle. One source has referred to
mandible and lies between the anterior and posterior bellies Pirogoff’s triangle as both Pinaud’s and the hypoglossohy-
of the digastric muscle. The submandibular gland almost oid triangle [6].
completely fills this triangle [14]. Three smaller triangles
of the neck, rarely found in the literature, are housed within
the submandibular triangle; they are Beclard’s, Lesser’s, Materials and methods
and Pirogoff’s triangles (Fig. 1). The inferior leg of
Beclard’s triangle, named after the French anatomist Pierre This study was carried out on 17 (34 sides) formaldehyde-
A. Beclard (1785–1825) [2, 3, 12], is formed by the greater fixed adult human cadavers (5 males and 12 females), the
cornu of the hyoid bone, the superior leg by the posterior mean age being 78 years. The presence or absence, size,
belly of the digastric; the posterior border of the hyoglossus anatomical relationships, and accompanying structures
muscle serves as the posterior leg and base of the triangle. contained within Beclard’s, Lesser’s, and Pirogoff’s trian-
Beclard’s triangle is also known as the posterior triangle of gles were measured with a centimeter ruler and docu-
the lingual artery, and contains the lingual artery and the mented. All measurements were made twice and the mean
hypoglossal nerve. This triangle has also been used to aid taken. No specimen was found to have scars or evidence of
in ligating the external carotid artery. The superior border prior surgical procedures to the areas dissected. Statistical
of Lesser’s triangle (Fig. 1), named after the Polish born, analysis was performed using a Student’s T test (Microsoft
German surgeon Ladislaus Leo Lesser (1846–1925) [12], is Excel, Redmond, WA, USA), and statistical significance
created by the hypoglossal nerve as it courses deep to the was observed when P \ 0.05.
mylohyoid, the anterior and posterior bellies of the digas-
tric, and more specifically, the anterior belly and interme-
diate tendon of the digastric create the inferior leg. The Results
posterior leg of Lesser’s triangle is the posterior margin of
the mylohyoid muscle at the intermediate tendon of the Beclard’s triangle was present on 28 sides and absent on 6
digastric muscle. The hypoglossal nerve also forms the sides because the posterior belly of the digastric muscle did
superior border of Pirogoff’s triangle (Fig. 1), named after not touch the hyoid bone and because the posterior belly of
the Russian surgeon Nikolai I. Pirogoff (1810–1881) [6, 14]; the digastric muscle was directly over the greater cornu of

Fig. 1 Schematic drawing of


left side Beclard’s, Lesser’s, and
Pirogoff’s triangles

123
Surg Radiol Anat (2011) 33:53–57 55

Fig. 3 Adult male cadaver noting the submandibular region (area of


Pirogoff’s and Lesser’s triangles). Note the following: digastrics
Fig. 2 Infrahyoid view of the left neck (region of Beclard’s triangle) muscle (D), mandible (M), mylohyoid (MY), facial artery and vein
noting the hypoglossal nerve (XII), omoyhoid muscle, hyoid bone (F), and hypoglossal nerve (XII)
(H), and facial vein (F)

the hyoid bone (Fig. 2). Beclard’s triangle tended to be the


largest of the four triangles studied, ranging from
0.5 9 2.0 9 2.0 cm to 2.0 9 4.0 9 4.0 cm (for the pos-
terior, inferior, and superior legs, respectively). Beclard’s
triangle was found to contain both the hypoglossal nerve
and the lingual artery when it was present (24 of 24 sides).
The mean length and standard deviation for the posterior,
inferior, and superior legs were 1.23 ± 0.43, 3.05 ± 0.40,
and 3.22 ± 0.50 cm, respectively. No statistically signifi-
cant differences were found between the measurements of
each leg of Beclard’s triangle and gender, or between the
measurement of each leg of Beclard’s triangle and right
versus left sides.
Lesser’s triangle was present on 30 sides and absent on 4
sides because the hypoglossal nerve remained inferior to
the digastric muscle. Lesser’s triangle was found within the Fig. 4 Adult male cadaver noting the submandibular region (area of
Pirogoff’s and Lesser’s triangles) following the removal of the
submandibular triangle of the anterior cervical triangle on
mylohyoid in order to illustrate the continued course of the
all sides (Figs. 3, 4). The posterior border of Lesser’s tri- hypoglossal nerve (XII). Also note digastrics muscle (D), mandible
angle was also the anterior border of Pirogoff’s triangle and (M), mylohyoid (MY), facial artery and vein (F), and hypoglossal
was the smallest of the three legs, measuring from 0.5 to nerve (XII)
2.0 cm. The superior leg, the most difficult to measure due
to its course deep to the mylohyoid muscle, was between anterior cervical triangle, directly posterior to Lesser’s
1.0 and 3.0 cm. The inferior leg ranged from 1.0 to 3.5 cm. triangle. By strict definition, no structures were found
The mean length and standard deviation for the posterior, within the triangle, but Pirogoff’s triangle always contained
superior, and inferior legs were 0.73 ± 0.38, 2.08 ± 0.46, the lingual artery, found deep to the hyoglossus muscle, the
and 2.35 ± 0.51 cm, respectively. No statistically signifi- floor of the triangle. Pirogoff’s triangle was the smallest of
cant differences were found between the measurements of the three triangles, with measurements ranging from 0.5 to
each leg of Lesser’s triangle and gender, or between the 2.0 cm for the anterior border (also the posterior border of
measurement of each leg of Lesser’s triangle and right Lesser’s triangle), 0.5–2.0 cm for the superior border, and
versus left sides. 0.5–2.5 cm for the inferior border. The mean length and
Pirogoff’s triangle was also present on 30 sides and standard deviation for the anterior, superior, and inferior
absent on 4 sides, again because the hypoglossal nerve legs were 0.73 ± 0.38, 1.18 ± 0.38, and 1.29 ± 0.48 cm,
remained inferior to the digastric muscle. Pirogoff’s tri- respectively. No statistically significant differences were
angle was found within the submandibular triangle of the found between the measurements of each leg of Pirogoff’s

123
56 Surg Radiol Anat (2011) 33:53–57

triangle and gender, or between the measurement of each alternative site for microvascular anastomosis to the lingual
leg of Pirogoff’s triangle and right versus left sides. artery during free vascularised tissue transfer in recon-
structive head and neck surgery, especially in the maxil-
lofacial area. In their opinion, Pirogoff’s triangle is an ideal
Discussion location to gain access to the lingual artery because of the
ease of access. The authors summarized that not only is
While reference to the three forgotten cervical triangles Pirogoff’s triangle the ideal site for ligation of the lingual
described herein can be found in medical dictionaries and artery in the case of severe hemorrhage, it is also an
eponym books [7, 8, 13], most, if not all, recently published attractive option for the performance of a microvascular
anatomy books fail to mention of any of these triangles. anastomosis to the lingual artery [16]. The results for
For example, Deaver [6] is one of the few older books to Pirogoff’s triangle are somewhat in disagreement with
describe Lesser’s triangle, which is also referred to as the Homze et al. [11]. In their study, Pirogoff’s triangle was
lingual triangle. The roof of the triangle is the sub- only present in 58.2% of their dissections, while in the
mandibular gland, while the floor is formed by the hyo- present study it is was found in 88% [10]. The authors
glossus and middle pharyngeal constrictor muscle. The concluded that the lingual artery and hypoglossal artery
most important structure found within this triangle is the are located more inferiorly than has been classically
lingual artery. Deaver [6] stated that ligation of the lingual described [11].
artery is easily performed via access through Lesser’s tri- Homze et al. [11] described variations in the lingual
angle. van Es and Thuau [18] mentioned that Pirogoff’s artery position to review the anatomy of some of the
triangle is the ideal location for ligation of the lingual smaller/forgotten cervical triangles, with emphasis given to
artery. The borders of Lesser’s triangle as described by Pirogoff’s triangle, and to discuss management of intraoral
Deaver [6] were: superiorly, the hypoglossal nerve, pos- hemorrhage emanating from the lingual artery. The authors
teriorly by the posterior belly of the digastric muscle, and performed 91 extraoral dissections of the submandibular
anteriorly by the anterior belly of the digastric and the region in 54 adult cadavers [11]. For each, the presence or
mylohyoid muscles. As previously mentioned, Pirogoff’s absence of Pirogoff’s triangle and the positions of the
triangle is simply a continuation of Lesser’s triangle pos- hypoglossal nerve and lingual artery relative to the digas-
teriorly, past the posterior border of the mylohyoid muscle. tric tendon and hyoid bone were recorded. The lingual
The superior border of each triangle is the hypoglossal artery was found inferior to the superior border of the
nerve. At some point in history, Lesser’s triangle must have digastric tendon (within Pirogoff’s triangle) in 67% and
been divided into a new smaller, anterior Lesser’s triangle, superior to the superior border of the digastric tendon in
with the posterior border being the posterior margin of the 33%. This study demonstrated that the lingual artery and
mylohyoid muscle, and the posterior portion renamed hypoglossal nerve were found to be located more inferiorly
Pirogoff’s triangle. Deaver [4] also mentioned the fact that than is classically portrayed.
‘‘if the attachment of the digastric central tendon is long, Bademci and Yaşargil [1] investigated the microsurgical
the hypoglossal nerve may be below the muscle, so that in anatomy, including the course and the relationship to
reality no lingual triangle is present, the artery being found important landmarks of the hypoglossal nerve. In addition,
closer to the hyoid bone than the central tendon’’. the authors also described a new ‘hypoglossal’ triangle,
Campbell [5] also mentioned Lesser’s triangle and its bordered posteriorly by the descending portion of the
importance for in locating the lingual artery. The floor of hypoglossal nerve, inferiorly by the transverse portion of
the triangle is the hyoglossus muscle, beneath which is the hypoglossal nerve, and superiorly by the inferior border
found the lingual artery. Heisler [10] also made reference of the stylohyoid muscle [1]. Important structures found
to the triangle of Lesser and its favorable location as a site within the hypoglossal triangle were the occipital, and the
for ligating the lingual artery, but incorrectly gives its external and internal carotid arteries.
borders as Pirogoff’s triangle. ‘‘… this is the hypoglossal
nerve, this portion of which should now be cleaned, and
which forms the base of the triangle of Lesser, while the Conclusion
posterior belly of the digastric and the free border of the
mylohyoid form its sides’’. Additional anatomical landmarks during surgery of the
In an article by Burke and Masch [4], a case study was neck may be useful to the surgeon. Isolation of the hypo-
presented where lingual artery ligation, using Pirogoff’s glossal nerve for neurotization procedures and identifica-
triangle, was performed in order to control severe intraoral tion of the lingual artery for ligation are just two examples
hemorrhage. In 2000, van Es and Thuau [18] presented a of uses of the triangles described herein. These geometric
technical note examining Pirogoff’s triangle as an regions lie within the internationally accepted zones I and II

123
Surg Radiol Anat (2011) 33:53–57 57

of the neck [15]. Our hopes are that these data will help 9. Healey JE, Hodge J (1990) Surgical anatomy, 2nd edn. B.C.
minimize surgical morbidity and aid in the efficiency of Decker Inc., Toronto
10. Heisler JC (1912) Practical anatomy. J. B. Lippincott,
surgical dissections. Philadelphia
11. Homze EJ, Harn SD, Bavitz BJ (1997) Extraoral ligation of the
lingual artery: an anatomic study. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Path
Oral Rad Endo 83:321–324
References 12. Jamieson GG (2006) The anatomy of general surgical operations,
2nd edn. Elsevier, Edinburgh
13. Orly R (1995) Dictionary of anatomical eponyms. Gustav Fischer
1. Bademci G, Yaşargil MG (2006) Microsurgical anatomy of the Verlag, Stuttgart
hypoglossal nerve. J Clin Neurosci 13:841–847 14. Pirogoff NI (1852–1859) Anatome topographica sectionibus per
2. Béclard PA (1824) Extirpation de la parotide, pratiquée l’hôpital corpus humanum congelatum triplici directione ductis illustrate.
de la Pitié. Arch Gen Med 4:60–66 St. Petersburg
3. Béclard PA (1830) Elements of general anatomy. MacLachlan 15. Robbins KT, Clayman G, Levine PA, Medina J, Sessions R,
and Stewart, Edinburgh Shaha A, Some P, Wolf GT (2002) Neck dissection classification
4. Burke RH, Masch GL (1986) Lingual artery hemorrhage. Oral update. Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 128:751–758
Surg Oral Med Oral Path 62:258–261 16. Skandalakis JE (2004) Skandalakis’ surgical anatomy: the
5. Campbell WF (1922) A text-book of surgical anatomy, 3rd edn. embryologic and anatomic basis of modern surgery. Paschalidis
W. B. Saunders, Brooklyn Medical Publications, Athens
6. Deaver JB (1926) Surgical anatomy of the human body. Blakis- 17. Skandalakis JE, Gray SW, Rowe JS (1979) Surgical anatomy of
ton, Philadelphia the submandibular triangle. Am Surg 45:590–596
7. (2003) Dorland’s illustrated medical dictionary, 30th edn. Saun- 18. van Es RJJ, Thuau H (2000) Pirogoff’s triangle revisited: an
ders, Philadelphia alternative site for microvascular anastomosis to the lingual
8. Forbis P, Bartolucci SL (1998) Stedman’s medical eponyms. artery. Int J Oral Maxillofacial Surg 29:207–209
Williams and Wilkins, Baltimore

123

Anda mungkin juga menyukai