On
By
At
Mr. CT Sunilkumar
DECLARATION
Title of project report: Financial Statements & Ratio Analysis of Tata Consultancy Services
I declare,
a) That the work presented for assessment in this Company Report project is my own,
and that it has not previously been presented for another assessment and that my debts
(words, data findings, arguments and ideas) have been appropriately acknowledged.
b) That the work in this report adheres to all the guidelines for presentation and style set
out in the relevant document for company report guidelines.
Date:
It is with deep gratitude and immense pleasure that I, Anaika Bonita Rodrigues; present this
project on the financial statements and ratio analysis of TCS. I am indebted to each and every
person for his/her cooperation to me, without which this project would not have been
accomplished. I take this opportunity to thank my program leader CA Mukund Jakiya and
also, Mr. CT Sunilkumar, faculty guide for his valuable guidance and support, which has
helped me a lot in the completion of this project.
NEED AND OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
To understand and analyse the financial statements of Tata Consultancy Services.
To evaluate the liquidity, solvency and profitability position of TCS.
To assess TCS’s financial strengths, weaknesses, threats and areas of financial
opportunity.
Research Methodology
Methods of Data collection - For collecting secondary data, annual reports of companies
will be used as well as financial reports available on various stock market websites are also
used. No field work has been done in order to collect primary data for the study and the study
is entirely descriptive and analytical.
Data Analysis & Interpretation - Collected data is analysed and interpreted with the help of
accounting and statistical tools and techniques which are as follows:
The financial ratio analysis has been done using the financial data of TCS for the last five
financial years i.e March 2013 – March 2017.
Introduction
Type of Activity: Information Technology services and IT business consulting services and
outsourcing services
Key people: Nataraj Chandrasekaran (Chairman); Rajesh Gopinathan (CEO and MD)
TCS is under one of Asia’s largest conglomerates- Tata Group of companies-which with its
diversified interests in areas of Telecommunications, Energy, Chemicals, Finance,
Engineering, provides the subsidiary with a solid understanding of various business
challenges facing global companies.
TCS and its 67 subsidiaries deliver a range of IT-related products and services including
business process outsourcing, application development, consultancy services, capacity
planning, enterprise software, software management, payment processing and technology
education services. The firm’s most renowned software products are TCS BaNCS and TCS
MasterCraft. TCS helps clients to identify opportunities and build the roadmap to getting
there and leverage technology to make it possible, by providing world class services and
solutions such as consulting, IT services, application development, application development
and maintenance, asset leverage solutions and enterprise solutions.
Data Analysis & Interpretation
Absolute Change
Fiscal year ends in March. 2017-03 2016-03 Increase/Decrease %Change
Assets
Current assets
Cash
Cash and cash equivalents 35970 67848 -31878 -46.984
Short-term investments 431100 223592 207508 92.807
Total cash 467070 291439 175631 60.263
Receivables 0 240697 -240697 -100.000
Inventories 210 163 47 28.834
Other current assets 337980 98375 239605 243.563
Total current assets 805260 630674 174586 27.682
Non-current assets
Property, plant and equipment
Gross property, plant and equipment 15410 212048 -196638 -92.733
Accumulated Depreciation -89270 89270 -100.000
Net property, plant and equipment 115980 122778 -6798 -5.537
Intangible assets 16440 20199 -3759 -18.610
Deferred income taxes 28280 8229 20051 243.663
Other long-term assets 66560 111963 -45403 -40.552
Total non-current assets 227260 263170 -35910 -13.645
Total assets 1032520 893844 138676 15.515
Preferred dividend
Net income
available t... 262890 242918 19,972 8.222
Common size Balance Sheet
Preferred dividend
Net income available t... 262890 242918 22.285 22.359
Ratio Analysis
Liquidity Ratios
Liquidity ratios indicate the capacity of a business to meet its short-term liabilities. It is
important to study the liquidity position of a business so as to know whether the company has
sufficient liquidity to pay off short-term debts and also to survive in tough financial times.
Lack of liquidity may result in a firm having to take decisions such as selling of assets for
low price, borrowings with high interest rates and also selling off a part of the company to
vulture investors.
Current Ratio
Current ratio indicates the amount of current assets that a company has in order to meet short
term liabilities.
The ideal current ratio is 2:1 which signifies that the company’s current assets are sufficient
to meet twice the amount of short term liabilities.
(In millions) March 2017 March 2016 March 2015 March 2014 March 2013
TCS’s Current Ratio for the year ended March 2017 is 5.55 and for the year ended March
2016 it was 2.87. The company’s average current ratio over the past five years is 3.24 which
show that TCS is not facing any liquidity problems and is able to meet its short term
obligations. However, the company had a high current ratio of 5.55 for the year ended 2017
which indicates inadequate investment.
Quick Ratio
Quick ratio, also known as Acid test ratio, shows the ratio of cash and other liquid resources
in a firm in comparison to the short term liabilities. The ideal QR is 0.5 which is indicative of
a company’s ability to settle half of its current liabilities without any difficulties.
(In millions) March 2017 March 2016 March 2015 March 2014 March 2013
77.99 – 0.02 70.56- 0.02 66.27-0.02 63.90-0.02 60.41- 0.04
Quick Assets
= 77.97 = 70.54 =66.25 = 63.88 = 60.37
Current
= 14.05 =24.59 =27.58 =23.34 =22.66
Liabilities
Quick Ratio
= 3.79 = 2.86 =2.39 =2.69 =2.59
(QA/CL)
TCS’s Quick Ratio for the year ended March 2017 is 2.59 and for the year ended March 2016
it was 2.69. The company’s quick ratio indicates that the firm’s capacity to pay out its quick
liabilities is strong. Considering the quick ratio value for the past five financial years, TCS
has a strong average quick ratio value of 2.85. A high quick ratio means that TCS’s liquidity
position is strong and they are able to meet commitments without delay.
Solvency Ratios
Solvency ratios, also referred to as leverage ratios, determine a company’s ability to keep the
operations on going by comparing debt levels with equity, assets and earnings. This ratio
focuses on the long term sustainability of the business instead of short-term liabilities.
Debt-Equity Ratio
Debt-Equity ratio indicates proportion of debt fund in relation to owner’s fund. It reflects the
capital structure, financial and solvency position of the company.
(In millions) March 2017 March 2016 March 2015 March 2014 March 2013
Total debt
25,260 20,483 27,079 22,727 17,787
(Long + Short)
Total stock-
862,140 653,606 506,348 491,948 386,457
holders equity
TCS’s debt-equity ratio is in the range of 0.01-0.05 over the last five years. The value is
nearly negligible which is considered highly favourable from long term creditors’ point of
view. There is a high margin of safety for the creditors. The ratio is below the norm of 1:1.
Debt-equity ratio is important because if a firm has a higher debt-equity ratio, it means that
there is high level of risk indicating potential to be forced into bankruptcy. TCS has a
minimal debt-equity ratio for the past 5 financial years which shows that the company is not
relying heavily on debt as a source of financing.
Interest coverage ratio measures the company’s ability to make interest payments on long-
term debts taken by the company. This is a very significant ratio for creditors and investors to
determine the profitability and risk of the business. Investors will use Interest coverage ratio
to find out the ability of the company to settle its payments on time without having to
compromise its profits and operations.
Interest Coverage ratio = EBIT (Earnings before Interest and Taxes)/ Interest Expense
(In millions) March 2017 March 2016 March 2015 March 2014 March 2013
TCS’s interest coverage ratio is 1141.62 for the year ended March 2017 and it was 1699.17
for the year ended March 2016. If the computation is less than 1, it means the company isn’t
making enough money to pay its interest payments. If the coverage equation equals 1, it
means the company makes just enough money to pay its interest. The company’s average
ICR over the last 5 financial years has been 840.7. The ratio is very high for the study period
reflecting that TCS may have undesirable lack of debt or is paying too much debt with
earnings.
Capital gearing ratio is a tool used to analyse the capital structure of a company and is
calculated by dividing common stock-holders equity by fixed interest or dividend bearing
funds. The ratio involves measuring the relationship between funds provided by the common
stockholders and the funds provided by those who receive periodic interest or dividend at
fixed rates. Capital gearing ratio is also known as “Financial leverage”.
A company is said to be low geared if the larger portion of the capital is composed of
common stockholders’ equity. On the other hand, the company is said to be highly geared if
the larger portion of the capital is composed of fixed interest/dividend bearing funds.
Capital Gearing Ratio = Common stock-holders equity/ Fixed cost bearing funds
(In millions) March 2017 March 2016 March 2015 March 2014 March 2013
Common
stock-holders 8,62,140 6,53,606 5,06,348 4,91,948 3,86,457
equity
Fixed cost
7,18,450 4,77,084.67 3,49,205.51 3,61,726.47 2,86,264.44
bearing funds
CGR 1.20 1.37 1.45 1.36 1.35
From the above table, it is observed that there has been an upward trend in the CGR of the
company, but March 2017 witnessed a fall in the CGR. TCS has a low geared capital
structure which means that there is more common stockholders equity. This ratio is very
important to investors because it represents the capital structure and financial strength of the
company. It is considered risky to invest in a firm with high gear because it indicates that the
company has to pay more interest on loans and dividends on preference shares, and therefore
has less level of dividend for common stockholders during times of low profits.
Efficiency Ratios
Efficiency ratios give investors insight into the efficiency levels of a business in employing
resources invested in fixed assets and working capital.
The asset turnover ratio measures the company’s ability to generate sales from its assets by
comparing Net sales with Average total assets. The ratio calculates net sales as a percentage
to indicate the quantity of sales generated from each dollar of company’ assets.
This ratio measures how efficiently a firm uses its assets to generate sales, so a higher ratio is
always more favourable. Higher turnover ratios mean the company is using its assets more
efficiently. Lower ratios mean that the company isn't using its assets efficiently and most
likely have management or production problems.
(In millions) March 2017 March 2016 March 2015 March 2014 March 2013
Net Sales 1,179,660 1,086,462 946,484 818,094 629,895
TCS has a strong and high asset turnover ratio for the last 5 financial years. The ATR has
been greater than 2 in all the five years, which indicates that the company is using its assets
efficiently and is able to quickly generate sales from total assets.
The ratio is important because it gives creditors and investors an overall view of how the
company is managing and using its assets to generate sales.
The inventory turnover ratio shows how companies are able to manage their inventories and
this can be done by comparing Cost of goods sold with Average inventory. Therefore, it will
measure the times average inventory is turned into sales during the period. Through this
ratio, interested parties are able to study how well the company is able to sell its inventory
ensuring minimum stock levels. If the company cannot sell these greater amounts of
inventory, it will incur storage costs and other holding costs.
(In millions) March 2017 March 2016 March 2015 March 2014 March 2013
COGS/COS 616,210 691,709 621,211 495,235 391,581
Average
186.35 161.700 156.399 181.800 194.599
Inventory
ITR 3306.73 4277.73 3971.94 2724.06 2012.24
From the data in the above table, it can be concluded that the company’s inventory turnover
ratio has a mixed trend of increase and decrease. The turnover levels of stock were very high
in the last three years which reflects financial threat of inefficient stock management.
Day sales outstanding measures the average number of days that a company takes to collect
revenue after sales has been made.
Days Sales Outstanding = Accounts receivable / Total credit sales x Number of days
Year March 2017 March 2016 March 2015 March 2014 March 2013
DSO 50.02 74.76 74.56 72.07 74.16
A low DSO value means that it takes a company fewer days to collect its accounts receivable.
A high DSO number shows that a company is selling its product to customers on credit and
the time period to collect dues is large. Therefore, TCS’s days receivable has decreased over
the last 5 years indicating that the company is taking lesser days to collect revenues after its
sales.
Profitability Ratios
Profitability ratios tell you how good a company is at converting business operations into
profits. Profit is a key driver of stock price, and it is undoubtedly one of the most closely
followed metrics in business, finance and investing.
The return on assets ratio measures the net income produced by total assets during a period
by comparing net income to the average total assets. The ratio shows how the company is
able to manage assets to produce profits during the relevant year. Some investors see ROA as
a return on investment for the company since capital assets are the biggest investments.
(In millions) March 2017 March 2016 March 2015 March 2014 March 2013
Average total
963,182 815226.5 703993.5 597025 469069.7
assets
ROA shows how efficiently a company can convert the money used to purchase assets into
net income or profits. TCS has a positively consistent ROA with slight ups and downs in the
ROA value over the last 5 years. A positive ROA ratio usually indicates an upward profit
trend as well. In the case of TCS, their assets would mainly be computers and softwares, and
a healthy ROA is indicative of efficiencies in management of assets to produce greater
amounts of net income. The ratio was very high from standard of 10%.
The return on equity ratio measures the ability of a firm to generate profits from its
shareholders investments in the company. It shows how much profit each rupee of common
stockholder’s equity generates.
(In millions) March 2017 March 2016 March 2015 March 2014 March 2013
191,639 139,173
Net Income 262,890 242,700 198,521
Average
stock-holders 7,57,873 5,79,977 4,99,148 4,39,202.5 3,41,696.53
equity
TCS’s Return on equity ratio is significant to the investors because it computes the amount of
money based on the investors’ investment in the company. The average ROE of Tata
Consultancy is between 39-44% and fluctuates depending on market conditions. Investors
will be interested in seeing a high ROE because it shows effective use of investors’ funds.
Company growth or a higher ROE doesn't necessarily get passed onto the investors however.
If the company retains these profits, the common shareholders will only realize this gain by
having an appreciated stock.
Gross Profit Margin measures the efficiency of a company in using its materials and labour to
produce and sell products profitably. GP ratio is an important indicator of the profitability of
the core business activities without considering indirect costs. This gives investors a key
insight into how healthy the company actually is.
Gross Profit Percentage = {Gross Profit (Total sales – Cost of Revenue)}/ Net Sales x 100
Here, Gross Profit = Total Sales – Cost of Revenue and Net sales means Sales – Sales Return
(In millions) March 2017 March 2016 March 2015 March 2014 March 2013
322,859
Gross Profit 563,450 394,753 325,273 238,313
A low GP margin indicates under-pricing while a high GP margin indicates that a company is
making reasonable profit on sales. Investors are interested in this ratio because they will only
choose to invest in a firm that earns higher gross profits. They are typically interested in GP
as a percentage because this allows them to compare margins between companies no matter
their size or sales volume.
TCS has a healthy gross profit ratio, and the company’s GP margin has been increasing since
2013. The year 2016-17 witnessed an increase in the company’s GP which shows that costs
are kept under control and TCS is able to earn more with the sale of every Rs 100.
The net profit margin, also known as net margin, indicates how much net income a company
makes with total sales achieved. A higher net profit margin means that a company is more
efficient at converting sales into actual profit.
(In millions) March 2017 March 2016 March 2015 March 2014 March 2013
262,890 242,918 139,173
Net Income 198,522 191,639
1,179,660 1,086,462 946,484 818,094
Sales 629,895
The above table indicates that the company is having a stable net profit margin since 2013.
There has been no sudden increase in net profit to elevate the net profit margin. A higher
NPR attracts investors because it highlights the effectiveness of the company in turning
revenues to actual profit. Therefore, it can be said that TCS has positively consistent and
progressive net profit ratio.
The net profit margin is likely to be affected by internal and external factors such as
industries & segments, selling price, cost of factors of production, efficiency of operations,
debt-equity ratio, taxation and variations in accounting policies.
Earnings per share, is a market prospect ratio that measures the net income earned per share
of stock outstanding. These earnings are the amount of money each share of stock would
receive if the profits were distributed to the outstanding shares at the end of the year.
This is a very important ratio from lenders and investors point of view as it shows the
profitability of the company on a shareholder basis. Higher the EPS, greater amount of the
company’s earnings will be divided amongst the shares of stock.
Earnings per share = (Net Income – Preferred dividends)/ Weighted average common shares
outstanding
In millions March 2017 March 2016 March 2015 March 2014 March 2013
Net income 262,890 242,918
198,522 191,639 139,173
Preferred
-
Dividends - - 337 222
Earnings per share ratio has the same significance as any profitability or market ratio. Higher
EPS signifies that the company is able to make higher profits and hence distribute higher
dividends to its shareholders. A higher EPS forms the stock price of a company.
From the above table, it can be inferred that TCS has a very strong EPS in the financial year
ended March 2017. There has been an increasing trend in the EPS for this company and this
reflects a positive image about the company’s position in the market.
The operating margin ratio demonstrates how much revenues are left over after all the
variable or operating costs have been paid. This ratio is important to both creditors and
investors because it helps show how strong and profitable a company's operations are.
(In million) March 2017 March 2016 March 2015 March 2014 March 2013
Operating
302,920 290,988 233,988 233,042 239,428
Income
Net Sales
1,179,660 1,086,462 946,484 818,094 629,895
OMR
= 25.678% = 26.783% = 24.721% = 28.485% = 38.01%
From the above table, it can be deduced that TCS had a very strong operating margin ratio in
2013, and ever since the ratio has decreased and now comes between the range of 20-25%.
TCS will only be considered stable if it can make enough money from its operations to keep
the business going. A high Operating margin is more favourable as compared with a lower
ratio because this shows that the company is making enough money from its on -going
operations to pay for its variable costs as well as its fixed costs.
Price Ratios
Price ratios are used to get an idea of whether a stock's price is reasonable or not. Price ratios
are "relative" metrics, meaning they are useful only when comparing one company's ratio to
another company's ratio, a company's ratio to itself over time, or a company's ratio to
a benchmark.
The price earnings ratio is a market ratio that calculates the market value of stock relative to
its earnings by dividing market price by earnings per share. The ratio determines what the
market is willing to pay for stock based on current earnings.
Investors often use this ratio to evaluate what a stock's fair market value should be by
predicting future earnings per share. Companies with higher future earnings are usually
expected to issue higher dividends or have appreciating stock in the future.
EPS aggregated 133.41 in the year ended March 2017; 123.28 in fiscal 2016 (` 101.35 in
fiscal 2015, ex rewards) – a growth of 21.63%.
A company with a lower P/E ratio indicates poor present and future performance. A higher
ratio attracts investors because of anticipated higher growth, performance and profitability.
Expressed in M INR
Fiscal Period March
March 2017 March 2016 March 2015 March 2013
March 2014
P/E Ratio 18.2 20.5 25.3 21.9 22.20
P/E ratio shows the desirability of the company’s shares compared to other companies. This
is a very crucial ratio for equity investors as it helps them decide whether the company’s
shares are overpriced or under-priced compared with its real value and with the other shares
in the same sector. P/E ratios lower than 15 indicate that a company’s shares are undervalued
and a P/E ratio above 20 indicates overvaluation of shares.
TCS has an average price to earnings ratio of 21.62 over the last 5 years. The company’s P/E
ratio was overvalued in 2013, 2014 and 2015 which indicates that the shares were overpriced
and the ratio fell to the stable level in the year ended March 2016 and March 2017.
Considering that TCS is a technology based company, it is normal for them to have higher
P/E ratios than other sectors because of their rapid growth rate that in turn gives investors a
higher return on equity.
Brief Analysis of TCS Annual Report (Year 2015-2016)
From the annual report, it can be concluded that TCS prepares its reports in accordance with
the Companies Act, 2013 and follows all the standards of generally accepted accounting
principles (GAAP). The company has decided to follow the Indian Accounting Standards for
preparation of its financial statements from the financial year beginning April 2016. As stated
in the annual report, TCS has developed an IFRS 9 Compliance Services that mainly equip
financial institutions with cost-efficient methods to address compliance needs. The IFRS 9
service is a broad program that covers all spheres of compliance i.e Classification,
Measurement, Hedge Accounting, Impairment and Disclosures.
Revenues
TCS’s revenues aggregated at Rs 108,646.21 cr in fiscal 2016 and Rs 94, 648.41 in fiscal
2015, indicating a growth of 14.79%. The revenue growth rate in fiscal 2016 was lower than
that of fiscal; 2016 because of low business growth rate. The year 2016 witnessed substantial
movement in exchange rates particularly affecting USD, AUD, CAD and EUR.
The EBITDA aggregated ` 30,589.79 crores in fiscal 2016 (` 27,109.62 crores in fiscal 2015)
– a growth of 12.84%.
PBT aggregated ` 31,675.87 crores in fiscal 2016 (` 28,926.40 crores in fiscal 2015, ex
rewards) – a growth of 9.51%.
PAT aggregated ` 24,291.82 crores in fiscal 2016 (` 21,911.85 crores in fiscal 2015, ex
rewards) – a growth of 10.86%.
TCS’s earnings per share aggregated at 132.28 in the fiscal year 2016 as compared to 101.35
for the year ended March 2015.
Acquisition / amalgamation (Note 29)
April 1, 2015 - CMC Limited, a subsidiary, amalgamated with the Company in accordance
with the terms of the Scheme of amalgamation sanctioned by the High Court of Judicature at
Bombay vide its Order dated August 14, 2015 and the High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad
vide its Order dated July 20,2015.
July 2, 2015- The Company through its wholly owned subsidiary, Tata Consultancy Services
Netherlands BV subscribed to 76% share capital of Tata Consultancy Services Saudi Arabia.
October 30, 2015- TCS through its wholly owned subsidiaries TCS Inversiones Chile
Limitada and Tata Consultancy Services Chile S.A. subscribed to 100% share capital of
Technology Outsourcing S.A.C, an information technology services provider in Peru.
Basis of Preparation - Financial statements are prepared under Historical cost on accrual
basis, except for certain financial instruments which are measured at fair value.
Use of Estimates – The management is required to make estimates and assumptions that
affect the reported balances of assets and liabilities and disclosures relating to the contingent
liabilities as at the date of the financial statements and reported amounts of income and
expense during the year.
Example – Employee benefits, provision for doubtful debts, provision for income taxes
Recording of Fixed Assets – Fixed assets are recorded at cost less accumulated depreciation/
amortisation.
Method adopted for depreciation – For fixed assets, straight line method of depreciation is
used to write off the costs of the assets over the useful lives and for assets acquired prior to
April 1, 2014, the carrying amount as on April 1, 2014 is depreciated over the remaining
useful life based on an evaluation.
Looking at the company’s current ratio, it can be said that the current ratio is more than the
ideal ratio; however the ratio should not be as high as 5.5:1 because it indicates inefficient
usage of short term assets. The satisfactory current ratio (Av5: 3.24 times) and quick ratio
(Av5= 2.85 times) reflects good liquidity and good working capital management. The gross
profit margin (AV5= 39.15%) and net profit margin (AV5= 21.61%) indicates cost
effectiveness. The debt-equity ratio has been in the range of 0.01-0.05 in the last five years
which indicates that TCS is not relying heavily on debt as source of finance.
The interest coverage ratio has an average of 840.7 which poses a financial threat that TCS
might be unable to pay fixed charges. TCS’s capital gearing ratio is healthy, indicating a low
geared structure which is highly favourable from investors’ point of view. Total assets
turnover ratio has an average of 1.32 times showing possibility that there is less frequency
with which assets are realized.
The company’s inventory turnover ratio reflects very high levels of inefficiency in inventory
management (Av5 = 3258.54). Although return on assets seems to be consistent, it is still very
low when compared to the standard. TCS has average earnings per share of 105.34 which
can also prove to be a financial opportunity of the firm to make their capital structure more
optimal.
Conclusion
The financial ratio analysis helped us to understand the liquidity, solvency, capital structure
and profitability position of TCS. The liquidity ratios have shown that the liquidity is sound
for the company. Trends of sales, PBIT, PAT and EPS reflected financial strength of
satisfactory probability. In terms of solvency ratios, it can be concluded that TCS has lesser
amount of debt as compared to own funds. The company can try to employ more borrowed
funds as compared to own funds, keeping the financial expenses under control. Overall
profitability of TCS measured with the help of different ratios is satisfactory and they should
use this opportunity to raise their profit margins which will attract investors and also increase
economic prosperity. Certain ratios that highlighted weaknesses and threats include asset
turnover, inventory turnover, and price to earnings ratio. In conclusion, TCS has a healthy
average growth rate and there are financial opportunities for the firm to improve its debt-
equity mix and dividend payout.