INTRODUCTION
medium in different ways. Except for the series 6, (11) and 15, the amount
of amine used was close to the lower boundary for maximum corrosion
inhibition under the present experimental conditions (Fajers C Holmlund,
1966,1967). Each series comprised 10 autoclave tests (8 in a few exceptional
cases).
Series 1-7: In each test, three freely exposed samples - which had just
been cleaned ultrasonically - were exposed simultaneously to one of the
After each experiment, the corrosion products formed were collected from:
1) the test sample by subjecting it to the same ultrasonic treatment as that
employed before the autoclave test, i.e. post-cleaning,
2) the U-shaped support on which the sample was placed during the test,
3) the shallow pyrex dish and
4) the envelope material by wet-combusting it (Holmlund, 1963 d, e, f;
Fajers & Holmlund, 1967).
The Fe in the corrosion products collected was ionized by acidification
and taken as a quantitative measure of the corrosion. Fe in the envelope
material itself was also determined (blank). From previous investigations,
it is known that the Fe amount dissolved from the autoclave chamber is SO
small that it can be neglected (Holmlund, 1963 d, e). This was verified once
again in series 15 (c). Fe was determined spectrophotometrically and in
duplicate according to a modified orthophenanthroline method (Holmlund,
1963a).
The quantitative measure of the corrosion, expressed as pg Fe dissolved
out/cm2 sample surface area, was obtained for each sample by adding the
Fe amounts in the post-cleaning liquids (see Holmlund 1963 C) to the Fe
amounts from the support, dish and envelope. Correction was made for
the Fe in the envelope blank.
R a s h i n g procedure
The gla>a\\are and plastic-covered pincers used for transferring the test
CORROSION DURING AUTOCLAVE STERILIZATION 27
Table 11.
Amount of Fe dissolved (pg/cma sample surface area) from each sample during autoclaving
Type A . Samples exposed freely in the autoclave on a U-shaped support in a low pyrex dish
~ ~
Series 18 Steam alone 10 151.81 49.70 186.25 49.94 (Blank for 10, 12 and 14-17)
Series 19 Steam alone 10 - 186.93 47.69 (Blank for 11 and 13)
*) This value was obtained when the autoclave chamber was not sufficiently rinsed after the alco-
holacetic acid cleansing. The next value was found after further rinsings - the pH was also shown to
be natural and no smell of acetic acid could be detected.
**) The Fe inside the envelopes originating from corrosion products from the test samples was not
determined here. This was negligible in all experiments in which the sample was sealed together with
amine in its envelope but could not be neglected when the sample was sealed without amine.
28 C-M. FAJERS, L. G . IIOLMLUND A N D E. STENMAN
RESULTS
DISCUSSION
This procedure eliminates primarily the corroding effect of the steam and
condensate inside the envelope. It is becoming increasingly common now-
adays to autoclave instruments packed in bacteria-tight envelopes so that
they can be easily stored subsequently under sterile conditions (Wallen-
berg & Jarnhall, 1956; Savas, 1958; Brigden, 1960; Prince & Mogg, 1960;
Fajers & Holmlund, 1966).
The results for, for example, Series 10 and 15 (Table 11) show that a con-
Acta Odontol Scand Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Chulalongkorn University on 12/25/14
siderable reduction in the corrosion also occurs for the freely exposed sam-
ples. This indicates that a certain amount of the amine diffuses out through
the envelopes. This is particularly conspicuous in Series 10 in which the
amine was introduced into the envelope by impregnating its paper section
with cyclohexylamine. This amine is very volatile and thus quickly diffuses
out through the envelope and hence the amine concentration inside the
envelope becomes too low for complete corrosion inhibition. However, by
impregnating the paper section with a less volatile amine (Series 13), it was
found that the inhibition was nearly complete even if a certain amount of
the amine diffused out and inhibited the corrosion of the freely exposed
For personal use only.
samples.
This method in which one introduces into the envelope a quantity of
amine, chosen whh regard to the amount of corrosive medium in it, means
both that the total quantity of amine required is greatly reduced and also
that the highest amine concentration is obtained very close to the corrosion-
sensitive surface (See also Fajers & Holmlund, 1967). One should aim at
using the smallest possible amount of amine for complete inhibition since
most amines in high concentrations are toxic. Traces of amines and/or their
salts may remain on the instrument surface after autoclaving and, when the
instrument is used, these substances may be transferred to the body or into
the tissues and there produce toxic reactions. However, the surface products
obtained from carbon steel samples after corrosion inhibition using cyclo-
hexylarnine, decylamine and morpholine did not produce any cytotoxic
effects (Holmlund & Tarnvik, 1963; Holmlund & Tarnvik, 1967). No toxic
or undesirable dermal effect could moreover be found with octadecylamine
(Maguire, 1954).
SUMMARY
amine concentration employed was usually close to the lower boundary for
maximum corrosion inhibition.
The investigation showed that
1) these amines effectively inhibited the corrosion of carbon steels both
when the sample was freely exposed in the autoclave and the inhibitor added
to the feed water and also when the sample and inhibitor are sealed together
in an envelope and then autoclaved,
2) morpholine, cyclohexylamine and decylamine were somewhat more ef-
fective than octadecylamine when the amine was added to the autoclave feed
water,
For personal use only.
R~SUM$
CORROSION AU COUHS DE LA ST~RILISATIONd L’AUTOCLAVE
11. ESSAIS CONCERNANT L’EMPLOI DE DIFFCRENTS TYPES D’AMINES
ORGANIQUES VOLATILES COMME INHIBITEURS D E CORROSION
Quelle que fut la mCthode utilisCe, les amines ont CtC employees en con-
centration voisine de la limite inferieure donnant un inhibition maximum
de la corrosion.
Cette Ctiide a mis en Cvidence que:
1) les amines inhibent efficacement la corrosion des aciers au carbone, tant
lorsque 1’Cprouvette est librement exposCe dans l’autoclave et l’inhibiteur
Acta Odontol Scand Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Chulalongkorn University on 12/25/14
ZL‘SAMMENFASSUNG
KORROSION BE1 AUTOKLAVSTERILISIERUNG
11. FLUCHTIGE ORGANISCHE AMINE ALS KORROSIONSHEMMER
REFERENCES
Berger U..1954: Sterilization, Desinfektion und Hygiene in der Zahnarztlichen praxis.
Urban & Schwarzenberg, Miinchen, Berlin.
Berk A.A. & J . Nigon, 1948: Amine volatility and alkalinity in relation to corrosion control
in steam heating systems. Bureau of Mines, Technical Paper 714.
Brigden R. J., 1960: Nylon packet system for sterilization. Nursing Mirror 8: 1.
For personal use only.
-a- 1963 e: On steam corrosion and steam corrosion inhibition. 111. Corrosion experiments
in an autoclave using small carbon steel test samples at 1M0C for 25 min. including
bacteriological sterility tests. Odont. Revy 14: 310.
-H- 1963 f: On steam corrosion and steam corrosion inhibition. IV. Corrosion experiments
in an autoclave on round dental burrs at 135-l4O0C for 25 min. A clinical investiga-
tion. Odont. Revy 14:201.
-0- 1%5: Steam corrosion and steam corrosion inhibition in autoclave sterilization of
dental and surgical steel material. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 7: 177.
Acta Odontol Scand Downloaded from informahealthcare.com by Chulalongkorn University on 12/25/14
Maguire J . J., 1954: After Boiler corrosion. Industr. Engin. Chem. %: 994.
Obrecht, M . F., 1959: Filming amine inhibitors control corrosion, improve heat transfer ...
in steam heating systems. Heating, Piping and Conditioning 31: 121.
Perkins J. I.,1960: Principles and Methods of Sterilization. Publ. Charles C. Thomas, Spring
field, Illinois.
Prince A. & R. C. Mogg, 1%0: *Portex* Nylon Film for sterilizing and storing surgical
equipments. J. Med. H b . Techn. 17: 180.
Suuds I., 1958: Centralsterilisering - ett debattinligg. Sv. Liikartidn. 55: 976.
Uhlig H. H., 1948: The corrosion Handbook. New York. John Willey & Sons Inc.
Wallenberg E. & B. Jarnhall, 1956: Sterilisering av instrument och forbandsmaterial i pisar
av steriliseringsbar plastfilm. Sv. Liikartidn. 53: 2578.
Walter C. W.,1948: Aseptic treatment of wounds. The MacMillan Co., New York.
Addresses:
C-M. Fajers, L. G. Holmlund,
Department of Pathology I Department of Dental Technology,
University of Umed University of Umed
E. Stenman,
Department of Oral Diagnosis,
University of Ume6