STRATEGIC RESERVOIRS AT MAKKAH PHASE II & TAIF PHASE I

REVISION SHEET

DOC. TITLE: DESIGN CALCULATIONS FOR TANK

FROM REV : A FROM REV : B

DOC. NO : 7 6 - Q C 2 0 - J - 0 0

REV. DATE : 5/23/2018

CHANGES TO THE DOCUMENT :

ENGINEER'S NOTE NO CONTRACTOR'S ACTI

The following comments shall be considered for above mentioned documents as following:

As per QP10-G-5281_G02_Description of Pr
1. Site seismic data should be taken from final approved Geotechnical Works_Rev_2 section 4.3.2 : states that “ Wi
Investigation Report (e.g. site class, seismic zone, PGA …etc.) which has not loads shall be determined according to Saudi B
submitted yet by AICC. Also as per API 650 section 5.2.1 k) : States th
standard for specific conditions for the tank be

2. Occupancy category should be changed to be IV according to SBC 301

table 1.6-1, since this tank is a strategic tank. So, importance factor for wind Noted and implemented in the revised calcula
I=1.15, and earthquake I=1.5.

3. Site class in earthquake data should be changed to class D instead of class

Noted and implemented in the revised calcula
B.

4. The effect of all loads from the aluminum dome roof should be considered All loads from the aluminum dome roof in the
and verified in shell design calculations (gravity loads, wind load and considered. Please refer our document numbe
earthquake load). Moreover, the effect of dome roof in tank stability should be Rev. A) for Aluminum Dome Roof Design Lo
considered Summary.

Software used are as follows.

1) Metscco’s In-Built Excel Calculations
5. Description of software used should be mentioned in the reference
2) COADE TANK 2014 SP1
documents list.
and the same mentioned in revised calculation

Refer GA Drawing of Tank #1 (75-QP10-S-00

6. Tank drawing should be attached for review of tank data used.
along with this report
 STRATEGIC RESERVOIRS AT MAKKAH PHASE II & TAIF PHASE I

REVISION SHEET

DOC. TITLE: DESIGN CALCULATIONS FOR TANK

FROM REV : A FROM REV : B

DOC. NO : 7 6 - Q C 2 0 - J - 0 0

REV. DATE : 5/23/2018

CHANGES TO THE DOCUMENT :

ENGINEER'S NOTE NO CONTRACTOR'S ACTI

All loads from the aluminum dome roof in the

7. Aluminum Dome Roof weight to be used in design load after data available considered. Please refer our document numbe
from dome roof supplier. Rev. A) for Aluminum Dome Roof Design Lo
Summary.

Please note that, when the plates to be procure

manufacturer directly i.e from the mill (and no
the plate thicknesses shall be ordered as per th
thickness values since the Mills are capable of
8. Plates thickness to be used in round number (not in decimal value) to next plates with the thicknesses in decimal values &
higher value of thickness, to allow measurement / dimensional / rust cleaning measured easily with calibrated gauges/ instru
tolerances
All our thickness calculations are in complian
The thickness values cannot be rounded to nex
thickness since the plates tonnage/ weight wil
significantly.

Metscco is procuring the plates from Plates M

Mill. The mill tolerance is already considered
Plates manufacturer has already acknowledge
Metscco Purchase Order with all the technical
has further complied to Metscco’s clause whic
‘Negative tolerance in the thickness is not acc
For your reference, please find attached atatc
Manufacturers Purchase Order Acknowledgem
technical compliances.

9. Tanks location name to be changed to Al-Mughammas site. Noted and implemented in the revised calcula

OTHER CHANGES (REASONS FOR CHANGES) :

None
 STRATEGIC RESERVOIRS AT MAKKAH PHASE II & TAIF PHASE I

REVISION SHEET

DOC. TITLE: DESIGN CALCULATIONS FOR TANK

FROM REV : A FROM REV : B

DOC. NO : 7 6 - Q C 2 0 - J - 0 0

REV. DATE : 5/23/2018

CHANGES TO THE DOCUMENT :

ENGINEER'S NOTE NO CONTRACTOR'S ACTI

OTHER DOCUMENTS AFFECTED :
None

Submitted :

Yahya Mustata Date

Distributed : SR (PED) SR (S&R) SF EH
AT MAKKAH PHASE II & TAIF PHASE I

EVISION SHEET

ES TO THE DOCUMENT :

CONTRACTOR'S ACTION

oned documents as following:

As per QP10-G-5281_G02_Description of Project and

Works_Rev_2 section 4.3.2 : states that “ Wind loads and seismic
loads shall be determined according to Saudi Building Code (SBC)”
Also as per API 650 section 5.2.1 k) : States that “ Refer national
standard for specific conditions for the tank being designed”.

Noted and implemented in the revised calculation.

Noted and implemented in the revised calculation.

All loads from the aluminum dome roof in the tank shell are
considered. Please refer our document number (75-QC20-J-008
Rev. A) for Aluminum Dome Roof Design Load & Reactions
Summary.

Software used are as follows.

1) Metscco’s In-Built Excel Calculations
2) COADE TANK 2014 SP1
and the same mentioned in revised calculation report.

Refer GA Drawing of Tank #1 (75-QP10-S-001, Rev. B) is attached

along with this report
AT MAKKAH PHASE II & TAIF PHASE I

EVISION SHEET

ES TO THE DOCUMENT :

CONTRACTOR'S ACTION

All loads from the aluminum dome roof in the tank shell are
considered. Please refer our document number (75-QC20-J-008
Rev. A) for Aluminum Dome Roof Design Load & Reactions
Summary.

Please note that, when the plates to be procured from the plates
manufacturer directly i.e from the mill (and not from the stockiest),
the plate thicknesses shall be ordered as per the desired designed
thickness values since the Mills are capable of manufacturing the
plates with the thicknesses in decimal values & those can be
measured easily with calibrated gauges/ instruments.

All our thickness calculations are in compliance with API 650.

The thickness values cannot be rounded to next higher value of
thickness since the plates tonnage/ weight will increase
significantly.

Metscco is procuring the plates from Plates Manufacturer i.e from a

Mill. The mill tolerance is already considered in the thicknesses.
Plates manufacturer has already acknowledged the receipt of
Metscco Purchase Order with all the technical compliances. Mill
has further complied to Metscco’s clause which states that
‘Negative tolerance in the thickness is not acceptable’.
For your reference, please find attached atatchement#1 (Plate
Manufacturers Purchase Order Acknowledgement) with all the
technical compliances.

Noted and implemented in the revised calculation.

AT MAKKAH PHASE II & TAIF PHASE I

EVISION SHEET

ES TO THE DOCUMENT :

CONTRACTOR'S ACTION

Date
EH