Anda di halaman 1dari 6

Journal of Surgical Research 160, 184–189 (2010)

doi:10.1016/j.jss.2009.05.030

ASSOCIATION FOR ACADEMIC SURGERY


Pediatric Solid Tumors and Second Malignancies: Characteristics
and Survival Outcomes
Vanitha Vasudevan, M.D.,* Michael C. Cheung, M.D.,* Relin Yang, M.D.,* Ying Zhuge, M.D.,*
Anne C. Fischer, M.D., Ph.D.,† Leonidas G. Koniaris, M.D.,* and Juan E. Sola, M.D.*,1
*DeWitt Daughtry Family Department of Surgery, University of Miami Miller School of Medicine, Miami, Florida;
and †Department of Surgery, University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center, Dallas, Texas

Submitted for publication February 23, 2009

Key Words: pediatrics; multiple cancers; solid tumor;


Background. To examine the incidence, character- outcomes; SEER.
istics, and outcomes for second malignancies following
the diagnosis of a primary solid tumor in pediatric
patients.
INTRODUCTION
Methods. The Surveillance, Epidemiology, and End
Results (SEER) database was queried from 1973 to
2005, excluding recurrences, in patients <20 y. The treatment of pediatric cancer is becoming
Results. A total of 31,685 cases of pediatric solid increasingly successful with the aggressive use of mul-
malignancies were identified. Overall, 177 patients timodal therapy, yielding an overall 5-y survival of
were diagnosed with a unique second malignancy 78%. This has brought forward the emerging spectrum
before the age 20 (0.56%) The mean follow-up was for of long-term sequelae among cancer survivors, of which
8.5 y (2 mo–30.8 y). Mean age at diagnosis of the primary the most life threatening are subsequent second malig-
tumor was 7.7 y. The most common primary malignan- nancies, congestive cardiac failure, and pulmonary
cies were CNS tumors (22.5%), followed by soft tissue complications [1]. The development of a second malig-
sarcoma (15.8%), retinoblastoma (14.1%), and bone nancy in childhood has been shown to cause a signifi-
tumors (13%). Hematologic malignancies (35.5%) were
cant increase in excess mortality among cancer
the most common second malignancies noted in the
cohort, followed by bone tumors (18%) and soft tissue
survivors. Previous studies have indicated that the
sarcomas (15%). Hematologic malignancies had cumulative incidence of a second neoplasm is 3.2% at
a shorter latency (3.1 y) compared with solid second 20 y from the original diagnosis [2]. This low frequency
tumors (11.6 y). The overall 10-y survival for the entire necessitates the use of large, multicentric studies or
cohort was 41.5%. For most tumor categories, develop- population-based cancer registries to achieve adequate
ment of a secondary malignancy was associated with sample sizes and follow-up.
lower 5- and 10-y survival than expected. We utilized the SEER population based cancer regis-
Conclusions. CNS tumors, retinoblastoma, and soft try to examine the incidence, characteristics, and out-
tissue sarcomas in children are the most common solid comes of pediatric second malignancies following the
primary tumors, with an increased risk of a second diagnosis of a solid tumor.
malignancy. Leukemia is the most common second ma-
lignancy seen in pediatric solid tumors. Second malig-
nancies are associated with significantly reduced MATERIAL AND METHODS
survival rates compared with the general childhood
cancer population. Ó 2010 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. Case Selection

The surveillance, epidemiology, and end results (SEER) April 2008


release was used to identify all malignancies developing in patients
1
To whom correspondence and reprint requests should be under the age of 20 y. From this set of patients, ID numbers that
addressed at DeWitt Daughtry Family Department of Surgery, Uni- appeared more than once were selected. These ID numbers repre-
versity of Miami Miller School of Medicine, 1611 N.W. 12th Avenue, sented patients who were diagnosed with a primary malignancy,
East Tower 3019, Miami, FL 33136. E-mail: jsola@med.miami.edu. and then subsequently diagnosed with another, unique malignancy

0022-4804/09 $36.00 184


Ó 2010 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
VASUDEVAN ET AL.: PEDIATRIC SOLID TUMORS AND SECOND MALIGNANCIES 185

at a later time point before the age of 20 y. Primary and secondary The incidence of second malignancies was noted to
cases were identified using date of diagnosis provided in the SEER
increase temporally with increase in age; 44% of second
database. From this dataset, all primary hematologic malignancies
were removed, thus leaving only primary solid organ tumors. Second malignancies developed in the 15–19 y age group. Inter-
hematologic malignancies were kept in the analysis. This dataset was estingly, 9.2% of second tumors were seen in patient-
then reviewed, and patients with second tumors that were not unique s < 5years of age, most likely reflecting a genetic
from the primary tumors were removed, thus eliminating patients
with tumor recurrence from the dataset.
susceptibility to cancer or familial syndromes predis-
posing to multiple cancers in these patients.
Table 3 also shows the histologic subtypes of the sec-
Survival Calculations and Statistical Analysis
ond malignancies observed in the cohort. The most com-
Only the percentages based on available data for each individual mon histologic subtype in children was hematologic
variable are given. Patients with missing data were excluded from tumors (35.5%), most of which were leukemia, followed
each respective univariate and multivariate analysis. Statistical
by malignant bone tumors (18.6%), and sarcomas
analysis was performed with SPSS Statistical Package version 15.0
(SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL). A P value less than 0.05 was considered sig- (14.8%). Analysis of age distribution among patients
nificant. Correlations between categorical variables were made using with these tumors subtypes revealed that bone tumors
the c2 test. Survival was calculated by the Kaplan-Meier method, and were more common in the 5–15 y age group, while sarco-
was abstracted from the time of the initial diagnosis to the date of last
contact (or the date of death, if the patient was deceased). Observed
mas were more common in the 10–19 y age group. The
survival represents survival of patients from our dataset, while incidence of leukemia increased with the age of the child,
expected survival time represents that of patients under the age of suggesting the possible effects of chemotherapy, radio-
20 with the same tumors calculated from SEER. therapy, or both. The incidence of carcinomas as a group
was highest in the 15–19 y age group, corresponding to
RESULTS a background increase in the incidence of carcinoma in
this age group. The most common histology in children
A total of 31,685 children with solid malignancies less than 1 y of age was pineoblastoma (n ¼ 3), following
diagnosed before 20 y of age were identified from the a primary retinoblastoma, again indicating the genetic
SEER data and followed up for an average of 8.5 y predisposition to cancer as a possible association.
(range 2 mo to 30.8 y, mean 8.5 y). The age-adjusted An attempt was made to study the effect of the type of
to year 2000 annual incidence for nonhematologic primary solid malignancy and the risk of a subsequent
malignancies was 9.29 cases per 100,000 population, second malignancy (Table 4). CNS, bone tumors, and
with an annual percent change of 0.73 over the study sarcomas developed leukemia as the most common sec-
period (P < 0.05). A total of 177 patients (0.56%) were ond malignancy, while retinoblastoma and neuroblas-
noted to develop a second malignancy with a unique toma were typically associated with subsequent solid
histology before the age of 20 y. The demographics malignancies like malignant bone tumors and sarcomas.
and clinical characteristics of this cohort are described We studied the relation of time from the diagnosis of
in Table 1. The mean age at diagnosis of the primary primary tumor to the development of a second tumor (la-
malignancy was 7.7 y (range 0–18 y). The male to tent period) with the number and type of second tumors
female ratio was 1.2:1. The majority of the patients shown in Table 5. Overall, 13.6% of second malignancies
were non-Hispanic and white. The overall 10-y survival occurred within 1 y of the first tumor, and 48% devel-
of the cohort was 41.1%. oped within 1 to 4 y from diagnosis of primary tumor.
Table 2 shows the histologic characteristics of the pri- Table 5 also shows the histologic subtypes and their dis-
mary solid malignancy. The most common solid tumors tribution according to the latent period. Approximately
were central nervous system (CNS) tumors (22.6%), 85% of the hematologic second malignancies were seen
sarcomas (15.8%), and retinoblastoma (14.1%). Retino- within the first 5 y from the diagnosis of primary solid
blastoma was the most common solid tumor for patients tumor (mean latent period of 3.1 y). In contrast, solid
less than 1 y of age. Between 1 and 5 y of age, the major- second tumors had a mean latency of 11.6 y.
ity of tumors were CNS tumors, retinoblastoma, neuro- The association of the latent period and radiotherapy
blastoma, and Wilms tumor. Between the ages of 5 and as a treatment modality for the primary tumor was stud-
15 years, malignant bone tumors, including osteosar- ied using c2 analysis and revealed that radiotherapy was
coma and Ewing’s sarcoma were the most common solid seen to have a significant association with the develop-
malignancy. After 15 y of age, carcinomas were the pre- ment of a second malignancy after 5 y of the primary solid
dominant primary tumor type. tumor (60%) compared with within 5 y (38%), P < 0.005.
Overall, 183 second malignancies were observed in
this cohort of 177 patients before they attained the Survival Statistics
age of 20 y, including the six patients who developed
a third primary malignancy. Table 3 shows the age dis- Cumulative survival were calculated for the various
tribution at the time of diagnosis of secondary tumors. histologic subtypes of second malignancies using the
186 JOURNAL OF SURGICAL RESEARCH: VOL. 160, NO. 2, MAY 15, 2010

TABLE 1 TABLE 3
Demographics and Clinical Characteristics Histological Subtypes of Second
Malignancies by Age
Entire cohort
Histologic type 0–4 y 5–9 y 10–14 y 15–19 y Total (%)
n ¼ 177
Carcinoma 2 1 4 16 23 (12.6)
Mean age at diagnosis initial tumor (years) 7.7 Sarcoma 1 5 9 12 27 (14.8)
Mean follow-up (years) 8.5 Bone tumors 1 13 9 11 34 (18.6)
Cumulative 10-y survival (%) 41.1 CNS tumors 3 1 6 7 17 (9.3)
n % of total Hematologic 5 14 15 31 65 (35.5)
Gender Skin 1 2 3 1 7 (3.8)
Male 96 54.2 Other 4 1 2 3 10 (5.5)
Female 81 45.7 Total 17 37 48 81 183
Age
<5 y old 72 40.7
5–9 y old 30 16.9 mortality cancers when seen as second malignancies. A
10–14 y old 45 25.4 similar effect was also noted for CNS tumors. The only
15–19 y old 30 16.9 exception was malignant bone tumor, which has no dif-
Race ference in mortality whether presenting as a primary
White 143 80.8
African American 16 9.0 or second malignancy.
Other 18 10.2 Comparison of survival rates performed between
Ethnicity patients who developed a subsequent second malig-
Hispanic 30 16.9
nancy within 5 y of primary tumor and those after 5 y
non-Hispanic 147 83.1
Tumor Stage demonstrated that a latent period of less than 5 y was
Local 48 27.1 associated with significantly lower 5- and 10-y survival
Regional 35 19.8 rates (36% versus 100%, and 26% versus 86%, respec-
Distant 43 24.3
Unknown 51 28.8
tively, P ¼ 0.0001).
Survival
Alive 76 42.9 DISCUSSION
Deceased 101 57.1

With just over 6,100,000 incident cancer cases, the


Kaplan-Meier method (observed) and compared with the SEER Program of the National Cancer Institute (NCI)
survival of the similar histologic subtypes from the is the largest registry source of information on cancer
SEER database for all childhood cancers (expected) incidence and survival in the United States. SEER cur-
(Table 6). For most tumor subtypes, there was a statisti- rently collects and publishes cancer incidence and sur-
cally significant decrease in 5- and 10-y survival rates vival data from 17 population-based cancer registries
once the patient developed a second malignancy. An es- encompassing approximately 26% of the U.S. popula-
pecially significant drop in survival was noted for hema- tion. The SEER program is the only comprehensive
tologic malignancies (19.7% versus 74% at 5 y and 16.6% source of population-based information in the United
versus 69.3% at 10 y, P < 0.001), indicating that leuke- States that includes stage of cancer at the time of diag-
mia and lymphoma, which are potentially curable child- nosis and actively collected patient survival data. The
hood cancers with high survival rates, behave as high data collected provide insight into tumor behavior and
allows investigators to examine outcomes from current
TABLE 2 treatment strategies. In addition, SEER has been previ-
Histological Subtypes of Primary Solid
ously used to report outcomes for a wide variety of pedi-
Tumors by Age atric malignancies [3–6].
Pediatric solid malignancies represent about 60% of all
Histologic type >1 y 1–4 y 5–9 y 10–14 y 15–19 y Total (%) childhood malignancies. In the United States, second
malignancies account for 6% to 10% of all cancer diagno-
Carcinoma 1 1 3 5 7 17 (9.6)
Sarcoma 2 6 8 7 5 28 (15.8) sis [7]. We studied a cohort of 177 patients with solid
Bone tumors 0 2 5 12 4 23 (13.0) malignancies who went on to develop a subsequent new
CNS tumors 1 14 6 13 6 40 (22.6) malignancy before 20 y of age. Because of the popula-
Retinoblastoma 16 9 0 0 0 25 (14.1)
Neuroblastoma 6 5 1 0 0 12 (6.8)
tion-based design and large size of SEER, the results pre-
Wilms tumor 0 5 6 2 0 13 (7.3) sented here are presumed to be broadly representative of
Gonadal tumors 1 0 1 3 4 9 (5.1) the survivors of childhood cancer in the U.S. as a whole.
Other 0 3 0 3 4 10 (5.6) We specifically included children less than 20 y of age to
Total 27 45 30 45 30 177
study the pattern of second tumors during childhood.
VASUDEVAN ET AL.: PEDIATRIC SOLID TUMORS AND SECOND MALIGNANCIES 187

TABLE 4
Histology Subtypes of Primary and Second Malignancy

Primary tumor Histology of second malignancy

Histology Carcinoma Sarcoma Bone CNS Hematologic Skin Other

Carcinoma 0 3 6 3 3 0 2
Sarcoma 4 3 4 3 13 1 1
Bone tumor 1 1 2 1 16 1 1
CNS 9 5 5 3 16 3 2
Retinoblastoma 0 4 11 3 4 1 3
Neuroblastoma 5 3 1 1 2 0 0
Wilms tumor 2 4 3 1 4 0 0

Certain types of primary tumors are shown to have used is the main contributor [7]. Furthermore, genetic
a higher incidence of subsequent second tumors. In syndromes like NF-1 and Li-Fraumeni syndrome are
this study, CNS tumors were found to be the most com- known to play a prominent part in the development of
mon primary solid malignancy associated with the a second malignancy in patients with sarcoma [12].
development of a second malignancy (22.6%), followed Leukemia, both myeloid and lymphoid, formed the
by soft tissue sarcoma (16%), and retinoblastoma single largest histologic subtype of second malignancies
(14%). Although CNS tumors are the most common in this cohort, followed by bone and soft tissue sarcomas
solid malignancies in children, they have not been (18% and 15%, respectively). The 2007 report on the
noted in previous studies to be associated with a partic- SEER dataset reported an observed to expected (O/E)
ularly high risk for second tumors. A further detailed ratio of acute nonlymphocytic leukemia to be 17:1 in
analysis of pediatric brain tumors is warranted in order childhood cancer survivors [9]. In comparison, many
to study the risk of second malignancies with primary large studies report carcinomas of the breast and thy-
tumors at this site. A review of the literature reveals roid, bone sarcomas, and brain tumors to be the most
Hodgkin’s lymphoma, retinoblastoma, soft tissue common types of second malignancies [7–9, 13]. One pos-
sarcoma, and bone tumors are primary cancers associ- sible explanation for this difference could be that we only
ated with a significantly higher risk for second tumors included second malignancies in patients less than 20 y
[7–10]. Hereditary retinoblastoma has especially been of age in our analysis, suggesting leukemia to be the
associated with a higher cumulative incidence of second most common second malignancy encountered in the
tumors as opposed to patients with no hereditary pre- pediatric population, while on follow-up into adulthood,
disposition (36% at 50 y versus 5.7%) [11]. The high rel- other tumors like sarcoma and carcinoma become more
ative risk of a second cancer in patients with common. Also, many of these studies only concentrated
retinoblastoma reflects the combination of genetic pre- on radiation-associated solid malignancies, most com-
disposition to multiple cancers and sensitivity to radio- monly seen after treatment for Hodgkin’s lymphoma.
genic cancer in very young patients. In addition, soft Female gender is associated with increased risk of
tissue sarcomas are also associated with an increased second cancers, but this is primarily due to the excess
risk for second tumors. It is not completely clear if sar- numbers of breast cancers in adult female survivors,
coma is an independent risk factor for the development typically after chest irradiation for Hodgkin’s lym-
of a second cancer or whether the treatment modality phoma at a median age of about 35 y [7, 8, 11]. In the
pediatric population, both male and female patients
TABLE 5 had a similar incidence of second malignancies, further
Second Tumor Latency and Histological Subtypes supporting the above association.
The median interval from the diagnosis of primary to
Histologic type <1 y 1–4 y 5–9 y 10–17 y Mean LP
the development of a second malignancy was signifi-
Carcinoma 4 5 5 9 12.3 cantly different for solid versus non-solid tumors. About
Sarcoma 2 11 9 5 10.7 85% of the hematologic malignancies were seen within
Bone tumors 1 12 14 7 12.3 5 y of diagnosis of primary tumors, while bone and soft
CNS tumors 5 3 5 4 10.5
Hematologic 6 49 6 4 3.1
tissue sarcomas were seen on average 10–12 y after the
Skin 3 4 0 0 1.7 primary, and this finding is consistent with the results
Other 4 4 2 0 3.6 from most previous studies. Nonhematopoietic second
Total 25 88 41 29 malignancies seem to have a longer latency with the
LP ¼ latency period in years. risk continuing for two or more decades [7, 11].
188 JOURNAL OF SURGICAL RESEARCH: VOL. 160, NO. 2, MAY 15, 2010

TABLE 6
Observed versus Expected Second Malignancy Survival by Histology

5-y survival (%) 10-y survival (%)

Observed Expected P Observed Expected P

Carcinoma 67.4 82.2 <0.001 49 80.1 <0.001


Sarcoma 55.6 69.5 0.003 55.6 66.9 0.021
Bone tumors 53.3 59.8 NS 47.7 54.1 NS
CNS tumors 40.7 65.2 < 0.001 13.6 60.7 <0.001
Hematological tumors 19.7 74 <0.001 16.6 69.3 <0.001
Skin tumors 63.6 91.1 <0.001 63.6 88.2 <0.001

The above finding may be related to the treatment should be noted. Since the database provides passive
modality used for the primary tumors. Significantly follow-up for its registered cases, many new cancers
elevated risks for acute myelocytic leukemia have may have migrated outside of the SEER catchment
been noted in patients with childhood soft tissue sar- area, hence our numbers are likely to be conservative.
coma treated with chemotherapy, especially alkylating Furthermore, the data on family history and genetic
agents and topoisomerase II inhibitors (etoposide, or associations of cancer is unknown. This study is also
teniposide) [7, 14]. Solid tumors like breast, thyroid, limited by the lack of complete, detailed treatment in-
and brain tumors, on the other hand, are common after formation on individual patients. Also, as with all
local radiotherapy, and typically have a longer latency such studies, treatment strategies for childhood cancer
[8, 10, 11]. We found radiotherapy to have a signifi- have changed considerably over the last 30 y, which
cantly higher association with tumors developing after could affect the overall risk estimates.
5 y of the diagnosis of primary malignancy. Exposure to In conclusion, second malignancies are a devastating
radiation therapy has been noted to be the most impor- long-term complication of childhood solid cancer survi-
tant risk factor for the development of subsequent brain vors with significant morbidity and mortality. CNS
tumors [15]. A higher risk for glioma in children irradi- tumors, retinoblastoma, and soft tissue sarcomas in
ated at a very young age may reflect greater susceptibil- children are the most common solid primary tumors
ity of the developing brain to radiation [15]. In addition, with increased risk of second malignancy. Leukemia
the risk of osteosarcoma is reported to be a linear func- is the most common second malignancy seen in child-
tion of the cumulative absorbed dose of radiation with hood. Young children are particularly susceptible to
an excess relative risk per gray of 1.8%, although the mutagenic effects of both chemotherapy and radio-
a lower risk is noted with orthovoltage radiotherapy therapy, as proven by several studies. Although effec-
that delivers more superficial bone doses [16]. Simi- tive treatment for the initial cancer is of paramount
larly, soft tissue sarcomas have been shown to occur importance, future therapeutic strategies for childhood
after very high doses of radiation (>10 Gy exposure), cancer should continuously evolve to minimize this
suggesting a quadratic dose response relationship [17, potential problem in the long run.
18]. These results clearly should guide us towards
a more judicial use of radiotherapy in childhood cancer REFERENCES
in order to minimize the devastating long-term conse- 1. Mertens AC. Causes of mortality in survivors of childhood can-
quence of second malignancies. cer. Pediatr Blood Cancer 2007;48:723.
To our knowledge, very few studies have looked into 2. Neglia JP, Freiedman DL, Yasui Y, et al. Second malignant neo-
the actual survival data after the development of sec- plasms in five year survivors of childhood cancer: Childhood can-
ond malignancies. Overall, for all histologic tumor sub- cer survivor study. J Natl Cancer Inst 2001;93:618.
types, survival was significantly lower after the 3. Gutierrez JC, Fischer AC, Sola JE, et al. Markedly improving
survival of neuroblastoma: A 30-year analysis of 1646 patients.
development of a second malignancy compared with Pediatr Surg Int 2007;23:637. Epub May 3, 2007.
the general pediatric cancer population. In addition, 4. Gutierrez JC, Housri N, Koniaris LG, et al. Malignant breast
significantly lower survival was noted when second cancer in children: A review of 75 patients. J Surg Res 2008;
malignancies developed within 5 y of the primary 147:182. Epub Apr 14, 2008.
malignancy. This may be related to genetic susceptibil- 5. Perez EA, Gutierrez JC, Koniaris LG, et al. Malignant pancre-
ity to cancer or to mutagenic effects of therapy or both. atic tumors in children: Incidence and outcomes in 58 patients.
J Pediatr Surg 2009;44:197.
The SEER cancer registry is an excellent resource to
6. Yang R, Cheung MC, Zhuge Y, et al. Primary solid tumors of the
study large numbers of patients in a population based colon and rectum in the pediatric patient: A review of 270 cases.
setting; however several limitations of this study J Surg Res Epub Dec 30, 2008.
VASUDEVAN ET AL.: PEDIATRIC SOLID TUMORS AND SECOND MALIGNANCIES 189

7. Bhatia S, Sklar C. Second cancers in survivors of childhood can- hood and adolescence in British Columbia, Canada. Pediatr
cer. Nat Rev Cancer 2002;2:124. Blood Cancer 2007;48:453.
8. Robison LL. Treatment-associated subsequent neoplasms among 14. Hijaya N, Ness KK, Ribiero RC, et al. Acute leukemia as a sec-
long-term survivors of childhood cancer: The experience of the ondary malignancy in children and adolescents. Cancer 2009;
childhood cancer survivor study. Pediatr Radiol 2009;39:32. 115:23.
9. Inskip PD, Curtis RE. New malignancies following childhood can- 15. Neglia JP, Robison LL, Stovall M, et al. New primary neoplasms
cer in the United States, 1973-2002. Int J Cancer 2007;121:2233. of the central nervous system in survivors of childhood cancer:
10. Green DM, Zevon MA, Reese PA, et al. Second malignant tumors A report from the childhood cancer survivor study. J Natl Cancer
following treatment during childhood and adolescence for can- Inst 2006;98:1528.
cer. Med Pediatr Oncol 1994;22:1. 16. Vu BL, Vathaire FD, Shamsaldin A, et al. Radiation dose, che-
11. Guerin S, Hawkins M, Shamsaldin A, et al. Treatment–adjusted motherapy and risk of osteosarcoma after solid tumors during
predisposition to second malignant neoplasms after a solid can- childhood. Int J Cancer 1998;77:370.
cer in childhood: A case-control study. J Clin Oncol 2007;25:2833. 17. Menu-Branthomme A, Rubino C, Shamsaldin A, et al. Radiation
12. Cohen RJ, Curtis RE, Inskip PD, et al. The risk of developing sec- dose, chemotherapy and risk of soft tissue sarcoma after solid
ond cancers among survivors of childhood soft tissue sarcoma. tumors during childhood. Int J Cancer 2004;110:87.
Cancer 2005;103:2391. 18. Bisogno G, Sotti G, Nowicki Y, et al. Soft tissue sarcoma as a sec-
13. MacArthur AC, Spinelli JJ, Rogers PC, et al. Risk of a second ond malignant neoplasm in the pediatric age group. Cancer
malignant neoplasm among 5-year survivors of cancer in child- 2004;100:1758.

Anda mungkin juga menyukai