M40 Gateway
Daws Hill
Abbey Barn
Planning and Infrastrucure Framework
Volume 1 - Main Report
In association with Drivers Jonas and Ech2o
August 2009
M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area
Planning and Infrastrucure Framework
VOLUME 1: Main Report
Project No: 150831
August 2009
10 Eastbourne Terrace
London, W2 6LG
T: 020 7053 1300
F: 020 7053 1301
E: london@cbuchanan.co.uk
____________________________________________ ____________________________________________
(C) Copyright Colin Buchanan and Partners Limited. All rights reserved.
This report has been prepared for the exclusive use of the commissioning party and unless otherwise agreed in writing by Colin
Buchanan and Partners Limited, no other party may copy, reproduce, distribute, make use of, or rely on the contents of the report.
No liability is accepted by Colin Buchanan and Partners Limited for any use of this report, other than for the purposes for which it
was originally prepared and provided.
Opinions and information provided in this report are on the basis of Colin Buchanan and Partners Limited using due skill, care and
diligence in the preparation of the same and no explicit warranty is provided as to their accuracy. It should be noted and is expressly
stated that no independent verification of any of the documents or information supplied to Colin Buchanan and Partners Limited has
been made.
VOLUME 1 - MAIN REPORT
Contents
1 Introduction
Other documents:
VOLUME 2 - EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
VOLUME 3 - APPENDICES
Appendix 1 - Consultation
Appendix 2 - Transport infrastructure schedules
Appendix 3 - Cost Assumptions
Appendix 4 - Sustainability Appraisal
Appendix 5 - Business land use competing locations
1.Introduction
1.1 The appointment
1.1.1 In June 2008, Wycombe District Council (WDC) timescale and contribution to wider investment needs
appointed Colin Buchanan (CB) in association with for the town.
Drivers Jonas (DJ) and Ech2o to prepare a planning 1.1.4 During the course of the study (May 2008 to
and infrastructure framework for three sites part of July 2009), we have engaged with a wide number of
the M40 Gateway area of High Wycombe. The client stakeholders and incorporated their aspirations and
steering group also included Buckinghamshire County requirements into the development of the final master
Council (BCC) transport department. plan proposals. District and County Councillors have
1.1.2 Colin Buchanan is responsible for planning, been briefed at all key stages of the project. Key
infrastructure, master planning and transport. DJ stakeholders include:
support and assess the master plan in terms of • Transport: Buckinghamshire County Council;
property viability, while Ech2o assist in the identification Highway Agency, bus operators;
of sustainable energy measures for the area.
• Education: Buckinghamshire County Council; St
1.1.3 The objective of the study is to inform the Delivery Bernard’s School; St Augustine’s School; Wycombe
and Site Allocation Development Plan Document Abbey School;
(SADPD) to be finalised for submission to Government
in 2010 and to guide development in terms of quality • Landowners/ Developers: Defence Estates;
and quantity. The study will influence the development Carington Estates; Berkeley Strategic; Wycombe
potential of these areas in terms of land use, character, Abbey School;
M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Introduction
• Residents and local pressure groups in three 12th century. It is also, however, a sizeable employment
meetings and workshops in October and November centre, gradually moving away from traditional sectors
2008; towards the knowledge economy.
• Service providers, through telephone interviews. 1.2.3 It provides spacious and green residential
neighbourhoods dispersed on the hills, proximity to
1.2 Background and overview attractive landscape and the countryside, which is in
large part recognised and protected by policy: Chilterns
1.2.1 High Wycombe is located in South Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty or Green Belt, as
Buckinghamshire approximately 45 km north west well as local designations. Recreational open space,
of London. Situated approximately half way between however, is somewhat limited as much of the open
London and Oxford, High Wycombe is the second space is privately owned and inaccessible.
largest town in Buckinghamshire. It is adjacent to
junctions 3 and 4 of the M40 and is well served by the 1.2.4 The town centre displays an attractive mix of
strategic road network. historic buildings, a new retail shopping centre, and a
small range of cultural facilities. It has, by and large,
1.2.2 The town is located along a river valley and an attractive public realm and it is well served by
between the steep Chiltern Hills. It is a lively and leafy numerous multi-storey parking. The recently opened
market town, with the stalls crowding the high street Eden shopping centre, which incorporates the former
three days a week – a tradition stretching back to the Octagon, provides 79,000sqm of retail and leisure,
1.3 The study area • The exploration of synergies between the three
sites and within the context of other M40 Gateway
1.3.1 The study focused on the role and synergies in allocations.
the M40 Gateway, particularly to the east of Marlow
Hill, where significant change is already pursued at the • The economic role of the study area.
Sport Centre site, with the proposal of a mixed area • Comprehensive measures to provide highways and
including a regional coachway, park and ride, sport public transport infrastructure.
centre and 25,000sq m of office development. The rest
• The minimisation of impacts (and reliance) onto the
of the area is essentially residential, with the exception
M40 and Handy Cross Junction.
of the two Roman Catholic Schools of St Augustine’s
(Primary) and St Bernard’s (Secondary). The residential • The identification and provision of social and
development form is in prevalence large detached community infrastructure needs of the sites and the
houses with large front and back gardens. wider areas.
The area also includes three potential development • The scope for highly sustainable development.
sites (see Figure 1.1), which are the focus for this
• Exemplar design solutions.
study:
• Daws Hill, a large windfall brownfield site formerly
occupied by US Forces and currently partially
occupied by 63 UK Army personnel families on a
temporary basis;
M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Figure 1.1: Study area
Introduction
1.3.3 These issues present a particular challenge,
as the sites themselves are isolated by landscape,
topography, road barriers and the local street pattern.
There will be a need to address local connectivity to
the town centre, to key employment sites and social
infrastructure, as well as, but not only to, the M40.
1.3.4 Phasing and sequential development of the sites,
within a coherent and comprehensive master plan, is
discussed in Part Four of the report.
M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
PART ONE:
Setting the Background
2.Strategic objectives:
the future of High Wycombe
2.1 Strategic issues
includes a wide area focused on the Thames Valley
Strategic planning
between London and Swindon, with Basingstoke
2.1.1 High Wycombe is a relatively large service at its southern boundary and High Wycombe at its
centre which acts as a focus for economic activity northernmost. High Wycombe is one of four Regional
for surrounding areas. High Wycombe is one of 22 Hubs within the WCBV sub region which faces
Regional Hubs identified in the South East Plan. significant pressures for economic and housing growth
These are a network of cities and towns where most whilst experiencing some of the highest levels of
employment, retail, leisure and cultural activity will transport congestion and house price inflation in the
gravitate. Greater South East.
2.1.2. The Plan supports the ongoing development and 2.1.4 The Core Strategy for WCBV (Policy WCBV1)
growth of Regional Hubs by affording them priority in reinforces the priority afforded to infrastructure
terms of new transport investment but in turn focuses investment and development in the Regional Hubs.
new housing development and economic activity in It also allows for greenfield urban extensions to be
locations close to or accessible by public transport to brought forward where they minimise incursions into
these hubs. It also encourages higher density and/or Green Belt or protected areas. The focus for these
mixed uses in Regional Hubs to create ‘living centres’. extensions will be on the less constrained hubs of
2.1.3 High Wycombe lies within the Western Corridor Basingstoke, Reading, Bracknell and Newbury, but the
and Blackwater Valley (WCBV) sub-region which plan indicates that smaller allocations may be brought
M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Strategic Objectives: the future of High Wycombe
View from Crendon Street
forward at other settlements, subject to meeting and strategic demand for employment space, and the
sustainability considerations. It goes on to state that balance between labour supply and demand. The aim
‘while the use of previously developed land and/or to secure a balance between homes and jobs at the
urban regeneration will be priorities, minimising the take local level should not override the need for the sub-
up of greenfield land will not be a factor that overrides region to continue to contribute to regional and national
all others’. economic prosperity. If employment land is judged
insufficient, new areas of employment land will be
Economic potential identified in development plan documents.
2.1.5 High Wycombe has a successful economy which 2.1.7 Within the sub-region, Reading clearly has the
has been growing faster than the regional average. It largest office market with Wycombe District, Slough
is a balanced economy with high levels of employment District and Oxford having similar levels of stock.
and a highly skilled workforce, mainly in managerial and However, should the office stock in other locations
professional occupations. However, unlike Reading and within the district, such as Marlow and Stokenchurch,
Basingstoke, Wycombe is not identified as a ‘Diamond’ not be accounted for, High Wycombe would have the
for investment and growth in the Regional Economic smallest office market by some margin.
Strategy.
21.8 Office take up figures for 2007 clearly indicate the
2.1.6 The WCBV strategy requires local authorities to static nature of the market in Wycombe District. This
work in partnership to assess the evidence of local can be attributed to lack of new office space in recent
10 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Strategic Objectives: the future of High Wycombe
2.2 Drivers for change Transport
2.2.1 High Wycombe is a well managed and successful 2.2.4 High Wycombe suffers from high levels of
town. As a Regional Hub, Wycombe will continue to be congestion which have been partially addressed
a focus for growth and development. The challenge for through enhancement to Handy Cross Junction and
the town is how best to manage that growth so that it the proposed Inter-Urban Coachway, improved Park
provides economic, social and environmental benefits. and Ride and redevelopment of the railway station. The
climate change agenda and national transport policy
Housing will reinforce the need to provide a range of modes of
transport through the town to address congestion and
2.2.2. Housing affordability and supply is one of the
environmental quality.
Government’s highest priorities for the domestic
economy. Over recent years affordability has been at its
Development principles
lowest and levels of demand at their highest (outside
London) in the Western Corridor / Thames Valley area. 2.2.5 The Wycombe Development Framework (WDF)
Meeting the Government’s housing targets for the town Core Strategy indicates a set of aspirations and
will be a critical driver of infrastructure, employment objectives for transforming the image of the town and
and environmental investment and will need to be strengthening its role as the cultural, economic and
effectively harnessed to maintain a sustainable balance social hub of the wider district. These are set out in
between these objectives. The Council has also Policy CS3 of the adopted WDF Core Strategy (July
recently published the results for their SHLAA (March 2008).
2009) which will inform the Delivery and Site Allocations
DPD.
The role of the project area
2.2.6 The project area is located within the M40
Economy Gateway, one of three key areas of change within
2.2.3 In economic terms, whilst successful within a Wycombe that are identified in the WDF Core Strategy
national and regional context, High Wycombe is not a (July 2008). The objectives to which development
major employment centre on the scale of some of its should contribute in this area are set out in Policy CS4
neighbouring centres including Reading, Slough and (Table 2.2).
Milton Keynes, nor will it grow to the same extent as its
northern neighbour Aylesbury. The Wycombe Economy
Study (2004) highlights the need for qualitative
improvement in the employment land/property offer,
and highlights the Gateway area as a possible location,
although improvements to Handy Cross Junction are
also necessary. The High Wycombe Property Market
Analysis and Sequential Test (January 2007) propose
preferred uses for the Cressex (Handy Cross), Cressex
Island and Compair sites. The analysis in this document
also highlighted the current qualitative supply of
employment land is insufficient to achieve the emerging
economic vision for Wycombe.
New development should contribute towards meeting the following objectives for High Wycombe:
1. Image – To transform people’s perceptions of the town, creating a diversity and richness of uses that satisfies community
needs and enhances the natural and built environment
2. Focus – To strengthen the role of High Wycombe as a regional hub and act as a focus to provide facilities to meet the
needs of the District, including:
a) New housing development
b) Economic regeneration and growth
c) Retail and leisure development
d) New development to support the higher and further education including development of Bucks New University and
relocation of Amersham and Wycombe College to a central location;
e) A new Sports Centre
3. Movement – To re-establish High Wycombe as a ‘People Place’, where people on foot, cycle and using public transport
enjoy a street network designed with their needs in mind, reducing the impact of roads and traffic, whilst ensuring satisfactory
operation of the highway network
4. Inheritance – To respect, preserve and use existing natural, historical and cultural assets as catalysts for further
regeneration across the town
5. Structure - To give the town a clear spatial structure for future growth and change that positively exploits existing axes of
activity, improves the relationship and connections between town and country (including opportunities created by the River
Wye and Hughenden Stream), and safeguards the setting of the town
6. Communities – To ensure local communities and neighbourhoods have access to a good range of local facilities, benefit
from “tranquil” streets away from main routes, and see the specific issues in our communities of greatest need addressed.
7. Sense of Place – Ensure new development achieves positive “place-making” and has a clearly identifiable character,
including
a) recognising the unique role of the Chilterns valley landscape
b) reducing the visual divide between the surrounding landscape and the townscape of High Wycombe through positive
integrated structural planting
c) conserving trees and woodlands, particularly on prominent hillsides and in key corridors.
Table 2.2: Wycombe Core Strategy (July 2008) – Role of local area
POLICY CS4 – HIGH WYCOMBE AREAS OF CHANGE – M40 GATEWAY
a. Gateway to the town - establishing the Handy Cross junction and its environs as a celebrated entrance to the town with
high quality new buildings heralding a sense of arrival
b. Improved highway network - in particular addressing the problems of the Handy Cross junction and enabling the
optimum use of potential development/redevelopment sites
c. Better access to public transport - providing new and improved facilities to remedy existing deficiencies and to improve
the sustainability of new developments
d. Coachway and Park and Ride - providing facilities to tap into the potential of the regional coach network, support the
town centre and M40 gateway area development/redevelopment proposals and the role of the town as a proposed regional
hub
e. Access to Public Open Space - remedying existing deficiencies and ensuring new development makes appropriate
provision
f. Renewables - take the opportunity of the development of major sites in this corridor to provide renewable energy
generation installations to serve the new developments and where possible the wider area
g. Cressex Business Park – concentrate business use, along with other non-B uses which are ancillary to the business
uses. In the longer term, facilitate redevelopment of parts of the business area to produce higher quality accommodation for
businesses
h. Synergies between major development sites – considering the potential for major development sites in the gateway to
play complementary and mutually-supporting roles and ensuring that all such opportunities are seized
12 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
2.4 A strategic opportunity • The scope for creation of a local centre or hub of
community and proximity retail facilities to serve
2.4.1 Together the three sites which are the subject of the new development and the existing residential
this study have the potential to present a significant neighbourhoods.
opportunity to address some of the strategic issues
identified, including:
• The need to improve and intensify this gateway
location to the town from the M40 to help transform
its image to visitors and potential investors.
• The provision, in the medium term of an increase
in the supply of high quality office space within
Wycombe to meet anticipated demand from
key growth sectors and maintain an sustainable
employment and housing balance.
• The potential to provide for longer term (post 2016)
demand for high quality business space to meet
wider sub-regional requirements to accommodate
levels of growth anticipated in the Western Corridor
and Blackwater Valley.
• A significant contribution to the overall delivery
of the required number, type and mix of housing
to support the sustainable growth of the town in
accordance with regional and local objectives.
• The need to address traffic congestion in and
around the town as part of a town-wide transport
strategy and through local enhanced provision by
a range of modes of transport, capitalising on the
proposed new Regional Coachway/improved Park
and Ride at Handy Cross.
• Enhanced bus services to the M40 Gateway area,
driven by high quality infrastructure and increased
patronage.
• The provision of formal and informal open space to
address existing deficiencies and provide publicly
accessible leisure opportunities.
14 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Context Baseline
High Wycombe Town Centre
3.1.7 The Core Strategy does not contain a policy 3.1.22 In terms of design, all proposals for new
on the percentage of energy from decentralised and development should deliver:
renewable or low carbon sources. However, Policy 1. High standards of design and layout to be achieved
NRM11 within the South East Plan states that in including the creation of positive, attractive and safe
advance of local standards, the following standard public and private environment
should be used:
18 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Context Baseline
2. Locally distinctive qualities of place to be reinforced 3.1.25 The former John North Student Hall of
Residence site has recently been refused permission
3. New buildings to be flexible for future use
for 106 new dwellings, associated car and cycle
4. Appropriate open space parking, landscaping and infrastructure. The site is
5. Efficient use of land proposed as a housing allocation in the Preferred
Options Site Allocations document. Reasons for refusal
6. Highway design to respond to the positive include, failure to achieve a high quality of design,
characteristics of the area and deliver high quality failure to secure developer contributions towards
public realm for all users. infrastructure to mitigate against impacts and the failure
to provide adequate affordable housing provision. The
Recent Planning Applications appeal was dismissed.
3.1.23 There are a number of planning applications
and pipeline developments that have a bearing on the 3.1.26 Wycombe District Council have also produced
development of the sites. This includes the following: concept statements for Cressex Island and Handy
Cross development areas in November 2008, following
• Construction of new 1,100 placed secondary school on from proposed allocations in the Preferred Options
to replace existing School on Cressex Road. Site Allocations document. The Council supports the
• Reservation of health/community facility land within redevelopment of Cressex Island for a mix/cluster, and
the employment land for a specified period at include those uses for which there is a demonstrated
Wycombe Marsh (Phase 2) – approx 700 sq m. need and cannot be accommodated in the town centre
or edge of town centre sites. The Council will support
• The outline application for Wycombe Marsh includes proposals for the Handy Cross site that includes a
a condition to safeguarded land to facilitate a future new leisure centre, headquarters office development
possible access to Abbey Barn South. (25,000sqm), Coachway/ Park & Ride, parking, and
3.1.24 Wycombe Summit, located along Abbey Barn open space, with scope for additional office, residential,
Lane proposed a real snow covered ski-slope, retail hotel or other use(s) yet to be determined.
and meeting rooms. It was recently refused permission
(April 2009) on the following grounds: 3.2 Employment sector
• The proposal would result in a reduction in the size 3.2.1 High Wycombe is the principal commercial
of ancient woodland. centre in the Wycombe District. The Wycombe
area experienced a significant expansion of its
• The proposal would fail to preserve the individual
business service and high-tech computing and
landscape qualities of an Area of Attractive
telecommunications industries in the 1990s, however,
Landscape and would have an adverse impact upon
in line with the more recent global downturn in these
its recognised character and appearance.
industries, the local office market suffered accordingly.
• The proposal fails to secure a mechanism for
3.2.2 The Financial and Business Services sectors
restoration in the event of the business being
represent a greater than normal proportion of the
unsuccessful and would therefore have a long
total employment in High Wycombe, accounting for
term adverse impact upon the Area of Attractive
approximately a third of all jobs. This is greater than the
Landscape.
national and sub regional averages. Of the Financial
• The proposal fails to secure planning obligations and Business Services sector the largest sub-sector is
within a legal agreement to provide a travel plan, Professional & Business Services.
financial contributions towards the Wycombe
Transport Strategy, a Woodland Management Plan
and public access to the development.
Colin Buchanan Wycombe District Council August 2009 19
Figure 3.1: High Wycombe Central Area
20 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Context Baseline
3.2.3 Public sector bodies represent some of the • Slough has a total approximate office stock of
largest office occupiers in the Wycombe area with 425,000 sqm (4,600,000 sq.ft) within the Borough
Buckinghamshire County Council and Wycombe of Slough and the main office locations are:
District Council among the largest occupiers of office - Slough Trading Estate
space in the town centre. - Axis Park
3.2.4 Information and Communication Technologies are • Oxford has a total approximate office stock of
important office occupiers in Wycombe. Although most 390,000sqm (4,200,000 sq.ft) (390,200 sq.m) within
of this sector tend to be small to medium sized firms, the Oxford District and the main office locations are
there are a number of significant businesses in the - Oxford Science Park
town, including Maritz Wolff & Co, Insignia Solutions, - Oxford Business Park
JD Edwards, Lysander Systems and Maindec. As - Oxford Spires Business Park
with the IT sector, most of the professional service
3.2.7 These three centres represent more established
sector tend to be small to medium sized firms although
and larger office markets and have historically been
there are large professional services, such as Dun &
considered as better office locations when compared
Bradstreet, which is the second largest occupier in the
to High Wycombe which has a total approximate office
district.
stock of 410,000sqm (4,400,000 sq.ft) within the wider
3.2.5 Manufacturing firms are also important in Wycombe District, but very limited recent development
Wycombe, particularly the pharmaceutical and car of Category A office stock, particularly within High
manufacturing sectors, including Johnson & Johnson Wycombe itself.
and Saab, Volvo and others.
3.2.8 Lack of new, high quality stock and market
perception have affected High Wycombe’s office
Competing locations
market, and its position as an economic centre within
3.2.6 High Wycombe competes with the nearby the sub-region. In order to increase the attractiveness
established office markets of Reading, Maidenhead, of High Wycombe as an office location in the medium
Slough and Oxford. Some of the competitive schemes to long term, a significant step change in the quality
in each location are as follows; and, more importantly, the quantity of the office offer
• Reading has a total approximate office stock of would be needed. The development of a sufficient
approximately 1 million sqm (10,900,000 sq.ft). critical mass of office product is key to this, which,
Eithin the Reading and Wokingham Districts, the subject to future demand, could be accommodated at
main office locations are: sites within close proximity to the M40.
- Green Park
- Winnersh Triangle Business Park 3.3 Socio-economic trends
- Reading International Business Park
3.3.1 Buckinghamshire is a highly prosperous county
- Arlington Business Park
with a skilled workforce, high activity rates, low
• Maidenhead has a total approximate office stock unemployment and a relatively stable population. High
of 450,000sqm (4,900,000 sq.ft) within the Wycombe, while less prosperous than other parts of
Maidenhead District. The main office locations are: Buckinghamshire, is still in a wider regional context a
- Vauxhall Business Park very successful town.
- Foundation Park
Employment
3.3.7 Employment change in High Wycombe has
broadly been in line with the wider region during this
decade. Manufacturing employment continues to
decline leading to a steady number of sites/buildings
coming available for redevelopment. Office employment
has increased due to growth in business services
while employment in the leisure, health and education
1
The High Wycombe Fact File 39, published by Wycombe District Council in 2003 estimates High Wycombe’s population at 92,000, using
Census 2001 data and the area defined by Wycombe District Council and the Buckinghamshire Structure Plan as: Downley, Hazlemere, Tylers
Green, Loudwater, Woodburn Green and High Wycombe Town Centre. We have adopted the more recent population estimate as stated above.
22 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Context Baseline
Figure 3.2: Employment by Occupation
3.4.6 The graph (Figure 3.3) below shows the house • Residential land values in the High Wycombe area
prices and office rental values between 2003 and 2008. moved from £1.65m-£2.4m per acre (£4.1-£6m per
hectare) in January 2008 to £1.25-£1.5m per acre in
24 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Context Baseline
the autumn. Furthermore, very few transactions took • A Minimal Impact Strategy which assumes the
place in the first half of 2009, and primarily for small LDF allocation but located in sites to the north of
sites. Wycombe.
• At the end of 2007 top office rents were reported to • An Emerging Core Strategy which assumes
stand at £24.75 per sq.ft (266 per sq.m), with the the preferred LDF allocation, which included
majority of the good quality office stock letting in the development on the sites under consideration within
region of £19-£21 per sq.ft (£205-224 per sq.m). In this report:
autumn 2008 top rents were at around £22 per sq.ft - RAF Daws Hill – 550 residential units
(£236 per sq.m). - Abbey Barn South – 500 residential units,
4000sqm
• In terms of second hand/poorer quality stock rents
B1, 2500sqm community use.
are in the region of £10- £15 per sq.ft (£108-161
- Abbey Barn North – 100 residential units.
per sq.m).
3.5.3 The model indicated that:
• One deal that shows property market deterioration
is the acquisition by McKay Securities plc of the • The Emerging LDF Strategy with the same level of
freehold interest in 37,900 sq.ft (3,520 sq.m) of road infrastructure actually performs better than the
office space within The Switchback development Minimal Impact Scenario across the whole network.
in March 2008. The property consists of six office
• With a lower level of highway infrastructure
buildings and was acquired for £9.05 million,
improvements (same as the Do Nothing Scenario)
reflecting a yield of 8.6%, compared to typical yields
the Emerging LDF Strategy performs slightly worse
of 5-6% in 2007.
than the Minimal Impact Strategy.
3.5 Strategic access and transport • Under both future scenarios there are a number of
junctions that are exhibiting congestion problems at
3.5.1 This section of the report provides a brief 2026 with development traffic flows.
descriptive review of the transport network in High
Wycombe, summarises the capacity modelling work • The model showed that in none of the peak hours
that has been undertaken between October 2008 and is there queuing on the M40 slips back onto the
April 2009 and identifies transport issues that will need motorway, although there is an increase in the
to be considered as the development of the sites is length of the queue on the westbound off slip under
progressed. the Emerging LDF Strategy scenario. The model
also found that there was no difference in queues on
Strategic highway network and highway the internal links within the junction.
modelling • Whilst queuing was found at the Marlow Hill /
3.5.2 Halcrow Group Limited produced in 2007 Marlow Road junction under no scenarios did this
a Highway Model for BCC, which was used to queue block back to Handy Cross.
assess the transport impacts of the Wycombe Local
• The report indicated that the overall increase
Development Framework proposals. Their Highway
in traffic levels at Handy Cross in the Emerging
Model Development Report (October 2007) tested
Strategy compared to the Do Nothing situation is
three different development scenarios under 2026
very modest and additional delays at the junction
traffic flows:
are not great enough to cause queuing onto the
• A Do Nothing Scenario where growth in housing is M40 motorway.
assumed to be development which is committed
and windfall development only.
26 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Context Baseline
Walking and cycling 3.5.17 Abbey Barn Lane has issues regarding width
3.5.13 Although central High Wycombe is only a and alignment in places, particularly at its northern end
short distance from the study area (a maximum where the alignment of the road crossing the disused
of 2 kilometres) there are a number of obstacles railway is significantly substandard. Road safety
to overcome if the development proposals are to improvements will need to be explored. Moreover, there
effectively promote walking and cycling: are wider issues of how traffic past Abbey Barn Lane
then accesses onto London Road.
• The topography is challenging, as the sites are
located beyond a ridge and significant gradients 3.5.18 The key transport issues that will need to be
separate them from the town centre. considered in taking forward development on the Daws
Hill and Abbey Barn sites are therefore:
• Private grounds (Wycombe Abbey School and
Carington Estates owning the woodland) prevent • The capacity of the Daws Hill Road / A404 junction
access along the shortest routes to the centre. • The alignment / carriageway width on Abbey Barn
There is scope, however, to negotiate new rights Lane and the need for improvement at its northern
of way for walking and cycling as part of the end
development.
• The capacity of the Handy Cross junction
• Footway and cycle provision along Daws Hill Lane
• Wider road network capacity
and Abbey Barn Lane is poor and improvements will
be required. • Public transport accessibility and bus access
3.5.14 The main east-west cycle route in High • Topography and land ownership effect on
Wycombe runs along Kingsmead Road and pedestrian and cycle access.
Bassetsbury Lane, north of the study area. Levels and
access permitting, there will be a number of options to 3.6 Social and engineering infrastructure
tap into this facility from both the RAF Daws Hill and
Abbey Barn sites. New north-south routes should also
baseline
be explored to ensure the town centre and rail station 3.6.1 The baseline work has been based on the
are accessible by bike, where feasible. following evidence base documents and investigation:
• the Michael Ling Report (February 2008)
Local access issues
3.5.15 The study area is located to the south east • the subsequent Buckinghamshire Infrastructure
of the town, immediately to the north of the M40 Study (April 2008) undertaken by Colin Buchanan
motorway, close to the Handy Cross junction. Direct • the Wycombe Open Space Study
vehicular access to the sites is limited to B-class roads
• Wycombe District Developer Contributions (SPD)
in residential areas, namely Daws Hill Lane and Abbey
- 2007
Barn Lane.
• Wycombe District Developer Contributions -
3.5.16 Significant peak time delays are experienced
Developers Guide - 2009
on Daws Hill Lane and at its junction with Marlow Hill.
In the morning peak, this is exacerbated by delays The information in these reports has been expanded
related to schools traffic associated St Bernard’s and through liaison with the relevant service providers.
St Augustine’s Roman Catholic Schools, situated just
off Daws Hill Lane.
Buckinghamshire Hospitals NHS trust has put in place a strategy that takes account of growth across its catchment area. The
services on offer at Stoke Mandeville and High Wycombe Hospitals are being rationalised so that they provide complementary
rather than competing services.
Hospital requirements will be determined by demographic structure and epidemiological issues.
Demand for hospital care is projected to decrease as service delivery is pushed to the primary sector and with shorter hospital
stays when they are required.
Buckinghamshire Primary Care Trust is seeking to rationalise GP services into well located health centres and to create primary
care hubs. There is an uneven distribution of GP services across the town with a lack of facilities at Cressex/Booker, Wycombe
Marsh, Micklefield, Castlefield and Downley.
The planning permission for Wycombe Marsh included space for a GP surgery / health centre but so far there has not been any
interest from the health providers.
The primary healthcare system is in a period of change and there are not currently population based standards for delivery of
services.
Pre-School Childcare
The 2006 Childcare Act requires local authorities to secure sufficient childcare places within their area to enable parents to
continue or take up employment, education or training opportunities. There is not a duty to provide facilities.
In accordance with the 2006 Act Bucks CC have undertaken a childcare sufficiency assessment for the county. The majority of
pre-school facilities (88 percent) are provided by the private and voluntary sectors. The sufficiency assessment indicates that
within High Wycombe there is a shortage of 585 pre-school places.
There assessment shows that there are few pre-school facilities within the Daws Hill area.
Primary Education
There are 29 primary schools within High Wycombe with a combined capacity of 8,252 pupils. BCC Education Department have
confirmed that the High Wycombe planning area is projected over the next five years to have a surplus of two percent of places
when all current planned housing is taken into account.
However, for schools in the vicinity of the site, there is projected to be a deficit of places as follows Marsh (-37%), Hannah Ball
(-7%), Beechview (-15%) and St Augustine’s RC (-11%). In addition, the Audit Commission recommends as best practice that ten
percent of capacity at individual schools should be retained to provide for parental choice.
Work is about to start on the Schools Area Plan for High Wycombe this term and should be ready for consultation by the end of
summer 2009. This plan is a high priority for the service due to the high levels of housing planned in the town.
Secondary Education
There are 11 secondary schools within Wycombe district, four of which are grammar schools. These have a combined capacity of
21,998 pupils, including the additional capacity being created through the rebuilding of Cressex Community School.
BCC project that there will be a two percent deficit in secondary school capacity across High Wycombe in 2012/13 when planned
housing growth is taken into account.
28 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Context Baseline
Post Sixteen EDUCATION
All secondary schools in Buckinghamshire provide sixth form facilities. We do not have figures for sixth form capacity.
Buckinghamshire has a very high level (72 percent) of students continuing in education post 16.
Amersham and Wycombe College provides further education services and also a number of higher education courses in
association with Bucks New University. There is a wide range of both vocational and academic courses on offer provided at sites
within High Wycombe and Amersham. The college’s facilities in High Wycombe are to be rationalised into a single town centre,
making access from all parts of the town easier.
The work undertaken for the Buckinghamshire Infrastructure study revealed that the college would not need to expand in
response to population growth across the district, thus, there will be no requirement to provide additional facilities in response to
development at Daws Hill.
Policing
Policing in High Wycombe is currently staffed from the police station in the town centre and Wycombe Council offices in Queen
Victoria Road. In addition there are schools officers based at Highcrest and Cressex schools.
There is a total of 175 police staff based in the town and the most recent survey indicates that both Wycombe police station and
the council offices site are rated by staff as being in a fair / satisfactory condition.
Thames Valley Police are considering relocating an additional unit to High Wycombe from within Buckinghamshire because of
pressures on existing resources.
Open Space
Wycombe’s Open Space Study identifies ten areas of open space within the study area. Two of the open spaces are school
playing fields and one is the Wycombe Sports Centre, part of which will be lost to the proposed Coachway.
Open spaces have been categorised as local (400m / 5 min walk time) and neighbourhood (800m / 10 min walk time). Some of
the smaller open spaces are considered to only have value to residents living close by and have thus not been categorised. Open
space includes playing pitches for team sports, and should be provided as an integral aspect of any residential development.
The existing Daws Hill residential area is considered to have an open space deficiency. If the school sites are excluded from the
open space provision (because they are not open access sites) then the open space deficiency for the Daws Hill area becomes
greater.
Using the Sports England Sports Facility Calculator (SFC), the Council estimates that High Wycombe requires additional
swimming pool space but has sufficient provision of other facilities.
Children’s play areas are provided to meet local needs and thus should be located as integral parts of any residential
developments.
Community Centres
There is a limited number of community meeting facilities within the Daws Hill area, and the majority are either schools or religious
buildings. Although schools and churches make an important contribution towards meeting community needs there are limitations,
namely that they are not available all the time, particularly schools.
Libraries
Water resource and sewage treatment capacity will be available to accommodate growth, however, there are issues relating to the
supply and waster water networks.
Thames Water (TW) have concerns regarding water and waste water services in relation to this site. Specifically, the network
capacity in the area is unlikely to be able to support the demand anticipated from new development. Further assessments will be
required at a more detailed design stage.
It should be noted that in the event of an upgrade being required, up to three years lead-in time will be necessary and may require
developer funding. Developers will be required to demonstrate that there is adequate waste water capacity both on and off the
site to serve the development and that development would not lead to problems for existing or new users. In some circumstances
it may be necessary for developers to fund studies, to ascertain whether the proposed development will lead to overloading of
existing waste water infrastructure and engineering solutions where upgrades in infrastructure are required.
Alternative technologies
Thames Water do not have a view on the use of alternative sewage disposal technologies. Such infrastructure would be outside
TW’s jurisdiction and would be regulated by the Environment Agency.
The Environment Agency have responded and state that alternatives to mains sewage treatment might be an option, but it should
be noted that the water environment in the areas is “relatively sensitive” and any alternative mechanism for sewage disposal
would have to be maintained and not result in any degradation to the aquatic environment in order to comply with the European
Water Framework Directive.
Flood Defence
The study area is outside the medium or high risk flood plain for the River Wye which passes through the eastern side of High
Wycombe.
30 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Context Baseline
Key infrastructure issues • Pre-school: space for a pre-schools facility
3.6.2 The review of the existing social infrastructure • Primary school: site for a school should be
reveals that the Daws Hill area is already deficient included as part of the master plan for the site.
in open space and community halls. Development
• Policing: it is possible that a police office as
at Daws Hill / Abbey Barn would only exacerbate
part of a policy of neighbourhood policing might
these deficiencies and thus will need to provide
be required. This could be a unit within the
sufficient capacity to meet its own needs and to help
neighbourhood centre or a small office within the
compensate for wider deficiencies.
community centre.
3.6.3 Preliminary investigations with the education
• Children’s play areas, sports pitches and open
authority have indicated that there is insufficient
space: these will have to be provided as integral
capacity within local primary schools to accommodate
parts of the development.
additional pupils in the locale. It might be possible that
existing schools can be expanded to meet demand, • Community centre: a community hall of adequate
but it is desirable that primary age pupils should size to include a badminton court and additional
not travel further than is necessary, and therefore a meeting space would be required for a site of this
site within Daws Hill / Abbey Barn South should be size.
reserved for a primary school. In addition, development
3.6.5 Full details of the community infrastructure to be
of the site will require the provision of localised facilities
provided as part of the development proposal are set
to meet resident’s needs.
out in Section 11.
3.6.4 In summary, the following facilities should be
provided on site as part of the development of the
Daws Hill and Abbey Barn area:
32 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Sites description
4.2 Site ownership
4.1.3 The three sites are located along Daws Hill 4.2.1 Daws Hill is owned by the Defence Estates, who
and Abbey Barn Lane, which can be accessed from intend to dispose of it with outline planning consent,
Marlow Hill a short distance away from Handy Cross to be applied for in the future.
junction. Their development is strongly correlated to the
M40 Gateway in a number of ways. Traffic generated
by the development is likely to trigger the need for
transport improvements, which could potentially
benefit the wider area and improve the access into
the town. Development could also strengthen the
role and performance of the Gateway, creating a local
destination within the town.
34 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Sites description
Figure 4.1: Daws Hill site
36 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Sites description
Figure 4.2: Daws Hill site
38 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Sites description
Figure 4.3: Abbey Barn South
40 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Sites description
Abbey Barn North 4.3.40 Views within the site are mostly open with
4.3.35 Abbey Barn North is a 11 ha farm located at only local containment afforded by the hedgerows
the bottom of the valley at the top of Abbey Barn and scrub. Outer views to the south, east and west
Lane towards Wycombe Marsh. It is bounded by the are contained by the rising ground, and trees and
Deangarden Rise housing development to the north, woodland on the ridgeline above.
Deangarden Wood to the west and the ski slope and 4.3.41 Despite the quality of its woodland setting,
Abbey Barn Lane to the south and east. the scrubby grassland, rough horse-grazed pastures,
4.3.36 The site is isolated: it has a narrow entry point neglected fencing and localised tipping all contribute to
and it is entirely concealed from view, as it is set within an impression of disrepair and neglect.
a bowl in the topography and it is screened by housing
and the former railway line.
Natural and historic environment
4.3.42 Abbey Barn North is classified as mainly Grade
4.3.37 Abbey Barn Lane has a dangerous bend in 4 agricultural land but with smaller amounts of higher
correspondence of the former railway bridge. Proposals grade land. Part of the site is also classified as a
to ease the road conditions would involve land take Biological Notification Site
from this site. Such a link could potentially provide
improved access to the site. 4.3.43 An ecological study has been carried out on
Abbey Barn North by consultants appointed by the
Landscape Local Authority in March 2000, which comprised of
4.3.38 Set within a natural bowl or amphitheatre, this a detailed and extended Phase 1 habitat survey. The
elevated site is strongly enclosed on three sides by survey provides an indication of the sensitive ecological
steeply rising, scrub-lined slopes and is dominated by nature of the site.
expansive elevated views out across the Wycombe 4.3.44 A number of habitats of high ecological value
Valley and open countryside to the north. The high were found on the site, as well as scrub, calcareous
cover of surrounding trees and woodlands give an grassland and tall herbs, including
overall wooded appearance to the hillside especially
• Unimproved calcareous grassland
when viewed from the opposite side of the valley.
• Broadleaved woodland
4.3.39 The site comprises predominantly rough
grassland with regenerating woodland scrub on the • Species-rich hedgerows
higher slopes and an area of abandoned allotments
4.3.45 The survey identified the preferred development
and rough pastures on the lower-lying land. It contains
area which would have least ecological impact. The
a number of sensitive habitats. Of these, the basic
developable area that was identified amounted to 3.42
grassland which covers much of the western part of
ha and located to the south east of the site. However,
the site is the most valuable and merits designation
it excludes the broadleaved woodland located at the
as a Biological Notification Site. However, in the
junction at Wycombe Marsh.
absence of appropriate management, its existence is
under threat from the processes of natural woodland
succession. In addition to its intrinsic value, this site
is also part of the green corridor linking Deangarden
Wood to the abandoned railway corridor, woods and
farmland to the east.
42 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
PART TWO:
Option Development
5.Option development
and assessment
5.1 Process and method
5.1.1 Option development started by exploring site • Emerging Options – designed in autumn 2008
capacity and identifying land uses on the basis of as a response to the selection of the initial stage.
strategic policies and criteria for the M40 Gateway as a These options where assessed against strategic
whole and the M40 Gateway Vision and Options Paper and sustainability objectives (although a fresh SA
(David Lock Associates, 2005), followed by successive was considered unnecessary), public consultation
refinements, assessment and consultation before response and implications for transport.
consolidating in a preferred option.
• Preferred Option – developed in Spring 2009 and
5.1.2 In summary, options were considered in the resulting in the refinement of previous options
following key stages: in consultation with planning, urban design,
transport, landscape, community infrastructure and
• Initial Options – identified in summer 2008 on the
conservation officers at WDC and transport officers
basis of identified strategic objectives (see Section
at BCC. A Sustainability Appraisal has been carried
2) and the M40 Gateway Vision and Options Paper.
out to inform the final design.
These proposals were discussed with officers
and members at Wycombe District Council, and
considered in light of the identified strategic criteria
and assessed via the Sustainability Appraisal (SA,
see Appendix 4).
44 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Option development and assessment
Abbey Barn South: The Ride
5.1.3 The site landowners and prospective developers • On site transport requirements;
have been involved at all key design stages and have
• Sustainable transport solutions (on and off site)
been offered the opportunity to comment and help
consisting of extensive investment in public
refine the final proposals. Other key stakeholders,
transport, and walking and cycling connections
such as the Roman Catholic Schools of St Bernard’s
to the town centre and the M40 Gateway Area
and St Augustine’s in Daws Hill Lane, the Wycombe
(including future Park and Ride and Coachway);
Abbey independent school and the Highway Agency,
have been contacted at all key stages of the study and • Alternative off-site highway solutions, to be finalised
their recommendations and inputs addressed before as part of the study of strategic transport for High
finalising the framework. Wycombe as a whole.
5.1.4 Particular attention has been paid to the
investigation of transport solutions for the site.
However, no final package of transport measures has
been identified as the transport demands of the site
merge with pre-existing road network constraints and
with general growth in strategic transport requirements,
which are independent of the demand of the site itself.
For this reason, transport solutions are identified as
follows (and described more fully in Section 13):
46 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Option development and assessment
The options were tested against 20 sustainability objectives as follows:
1 To provide the residents of Wycombe District 10 To protect & enhance the landscape & townscape
Council with the opportunity to live in a quality character of the District & in particular, those areas
home of designated importance
2 To reduce crime, fear of crime & antisocial activity 11 To conserve & where appropriate enhance the
through the creation of safer places to live & work historic environment
3 To improve accessibility to essential services & 12 Minimise waste & then re-use it through recycling or
facilities & to provide opportunities to obtain good composting or recovering energy from waste that
access to high quality health, education, recreation has not been recycled or composted
& other community facilities & services
13 To conserve soil resources & quality
4 Encourage a sense of community identity & welfare
14 To improve the efficiency of land use through the re-
5 Improve & maintain health & well-being of the use of previously developed land
population & reduce inequalities in health
15 To minimise the risk of flooding (in relation to both
6 To reduce contributions to climate change through: new & existing development)
• Sustainable building practices 16 To encourage economic growth & competitiveness
• Maximising the potential for renewable energy & 17 To achieve a broad balance in the growth of
energy conservation housing, population & employment
7 To encourage the use of sustainable methods 18 To encourage a diverse economy including a
of transport to reduce negative effects on the vibrant & sustainable tourism sector
environment
19 To develop & maintain a skilled workforce to
8 To provide for sustainable levels of water use, support long-term competitiveness of the District
supply & management, including quality of water
20 To reduce levels of social polarisation & levels of
sources
deprivation
9 To maintain & enhance biodiversity, flora & fauna &
avoid irreversible losses
48 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Initial options
The Rye
the M40; with a stadium and sport centre on the take forward the initial Vision and with the purpose of
Abbey Barn South site and employment uses in the exploring the development potential of the three sites.
sites adjacent to Handy Cross; potential long term Particular attention was paid to the scope for synergies
development of the Air Park site. in terms of land use, landscape and accessibility.
Significantly, the options have also been generated
6.1.2 The Vision and Option Paper’s four options
with the aim to identify ways by which development
linked highway development and a range of land uses.
can strengthen High Wycombe’s position as a Regional
Delivery and balance between infrastructure costs
Hub and a focus for the District.
and development scale were not considered at that
stage. A subsequent investigation of infrastructure 6.1.5 The six options set out below are as follows:
options (Peter Brett Associates, 2006) consolidated the
1. Brownfield housing-led development
highway options in local improvements and southern
link road. These were taken forward and further studied 2. Housing-led development
as part of this report. 3. Business Campus development
6.1.3 The Initial Options of this study considered all 4. Housing/employment/education mixed-use
land use options put forward by the Vision and Options development (A)
Paper.
5. Housing/employment/education mixed use
Initial Options development (B)
6.1.4 Six strategic options were initially prepared to 6. Leisure-led development
M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Low density residential Employment - Office quarter
Medium density residential Employment - Business campus
High density residential Community uses
Mixed use residential Park/open space
Leisure Public transport route
School Landmark
Note: Sq m are intended as GFA unless specified
Initial options
6.2 Option 1: Brownfield housing-led development
Description
Medium density development concentrated on the brownfield site of Daws Hill and Eaker Estate. Development to comprise
primarily housing, but ideally including a primary school, doctor’s surgery, local shops, recreational facilities and play space at
Daws Hill.
Small scale and complementary development in Abbey Barn South.
Two access points on Daws Hill Lane.
Potential link to Abbey Barn South safeguarded.
Development quantities
• 500 - 800 residential units (with up to 120 flats in mixed use area)
• 6,000 - 8,000 sq m GFA mixed use non-residential space (1,000 sq m retail, 2,000 sq m social facilities, 5,000 sq m small
business units)
• Primary school
• Tennis courts retained and new recreational facilities.
• Open space and sport requirements in adjoining sites.
Economic
6.2.5 This option provides the least employment
development of all the options and therefore it has
limited positive effects on economic objectives. There
is a limited contribution to adding to the labour force
during construction.
52 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Initial options
Other considerations
6.2.6 This option has the clear benefit of limiting
development to brownfield sites only and providing
a development form which is consistent with the
surrounding area. However, should the greenfield sites
be required at any time in the future, the development
of Daws Hill in isolation will fail to consider wider
synergies and potentially result in an isolated residential
neighbourhood, which is necessarily reliant on the
surrounding area for basic services, rather than
providing support and benefits to its surroundings.
6.2.7 The reduced scale, in particular, will result in
limited contribution towards sustainable transport
solutions; patronage to public transport; potential
community and recreational facilities. Moreover, it will
be necessary to establish a secondary access point
on Daws Hill Lane and safeguard an access point to
Abbey Barn South, should this site be reconsidered in
the future.
6.2.8 Open space provision will be small scale and only
locally significant, if off-site provision is not secured. ,
and whilst still feasible on a site of this scale, provision
of CHP would not benefit from efficiencies related to a
more extensive network and range of uses potentially
arising from the development of a wider area.
M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Low density residential Employment - Office quarter
Medium density residential Employment - Business campus
High density residential Community uses
Mixed use residential Park/open space
Leisure Public transport route
School Landmark
Note: Sq m are intended as GFA unless specified
Initial options
6.3 Option 2: Housing-led development
Option 2 – Housing-led development
Creation of a new neighbourhood arranged around a mixed use heart and a public transport spine.
Description
Medium density development of Daws Hill and Abbey Barn South and North primarily for housing, including a primary school,
doctor’s surgery, local shops, park. Mixed use and employment provision on Daws Hill and Abbey Barn South.
Dual access from Daws Hill Lane and Abbey Barn Lane.
Development quantities
• 1,200 - 1,500 residential units (including 200 flats in mixed use area)
• 22,500 sq m GFA mixed use non-residential space (3,000 sq m retail, 5,000 sq m social facilities, 20,000 sq m mixed
business units)
• Primary school
• Tennis courts, baseball pitch retained and new recreational facilities.
• 150,000 sq m open space/ nature reserve
Economic
6.3.6 This option creates some employment and
therefore it will have positive effects on economic
objectives. It also contributes significantly to the labour
force during construction.
56 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Initial options
Other considerations
6.3.7 This form of development is likely to generate
the highest returns and therefore it is more likely to
generate support and financial contributions towards
social infrastructure and public transport. It also has
the potential to deliver energy efficiency measures,
although a CHP solution will need more diversity of
uses to maximise efficiency.
M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Low density residential Employment - Office quarter
Medium density residential Employment - Business campus
High density residential Community uses
Mixed use residential Park/open space
Leisure Public transport route
School Landmark
Note: Sq m are intended as GFA unless specified
Initial options
6.4 Option 3: Business campus development
Option 3 – Business campus
Creation of a new district centre and a significant number and range of jobs.
Description
Medium density development of Daws Hill primarily for housing, including a primary school, doctor’s surgery and play space.
Abbey Barn South redeveloped with a mixed use focus and business campus use on a pre-let arrangement. Associated medium-high density
residential, local shops, park.
High frequency public transport. Main access from Abbey Barn Lane.
Residential development in Abbey Barn North.
Development quantities
• 900 -1,200 residential units (350 flats in mixed use area)
• 60,000 - 80,000 sq m GFA prime business uses (few single occupiers).
• 10,000 - 20,000 sq m GFA mixed use non-residential space (6,000 sq m retail, 3,000 sq m social facilities, mixed business
units)
• Primary school
• Tennis courts & baseball pitch retained and new recreational facilities.
• 150,000 sq m open space / nature reserve
Economic
6.4.7 This option provides for substantial employment
development and therefore it has a major positive
effect on economic objectives as compared to all other
options. Should it be possible to include education and
skill training as part of the business campus, this would
provide a major positive contribution to the quality of
employment opportunities and social development.
60 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Initial options
Other considerations
6.4.8 This option proposes the creation of a new
destination/ district centre, which will generate activity
on site throughout the day, thus maximising efficiency
of public transport and CHP energy generation.
However, the amount and type of mixed use facilities
may have a detrimental effect on other centres and
attract more traffic to the area.
6.4.9 The concept of a large scale business campus
is likely to require a pre-let arrangement with major
inward investors. This will leave the site vulnerable to
an uncertain property market, with the risk that failure
to identify and attract suitable large scale occupiers
would lead the site being vacant for a considerable
time. Moreover, this development is likely to require
significant pump priming and marketing of the town as
a office destination.
Traffic impact and major highway infrastructure
investment and the potential requirement of a new
access road directly linked to motorway may affect the
deliverability of this option in the current format.
M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Low density residential Employment - Office quarter
Medium density residential Employment - Business campus
High density residential Community uses
Mixed use residential Park/open space
Leisure Public transport route
School Landmark
Note: Sq m are intended as GFA unless specified
Initial options
6.5 Option 4: Housing, employment and education mixed use development (A)
Relocation of John Hampden School and redevelopment of their site for offices. Creation of a new destination around the
access on Daws Hill Lane, with a smaller cluster of office uses, a mixed area and education all within walking distance.
Description
Medium density development of Daws Hill primarily for housing, including a primary school, doctor’s surgery, local shops and play
space. Abbey Barn South redeveloped to incorporate a relocated John Hampden Grammar School, relocated from Marlow Hill .
Wycombe Marsh redeveloped for medium-high density housing with affordable component.
Major leisure sport facility and associated enabling residential and retail development to the west of the Gateway.
Park and Ride and Coach Interchange at Sports Centre site.
Mixed commercial development on Cressex Island.
64 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Initial options
Economic
6.5.7 This option suggests to develop sites along
Marlow Hill for employment uses, creating an
employment gateway into High Wycombe from
the Handy Cross Junction, thus strengthening the
economic role of the town. It also generates additional
employment directly linked to the relocation of John
Hampden School and has major positive effect on
economic objectives. New school facilities combined
with other community venues (i.e. hall, open space/
sports pitches etc) maximise the usage and outreach of
the provision.
Other considerations
6.5.8 The development is uncertain, due to the likely
difficulties of relocating John Hampden School. It is
likely to require significant infrastructure investment
and land equalisation agreements between the land
owners, as well as public funding towards the school
development.
6.5.9 Moreover, the large scale business campus on
Marlow Hill, although more resilient because of its
prime location, is likely to require a pre-let arrangement
with major inward investors. This will leave the site
vulnerable to an uncertain property market, with the
risk that the site remains vacant for a considerable
time. Furthermore, this development is likely to require
significant pump priming and marketing of the town as
a office destination.
6.5.10 John Hampden School have not been
contacted to verify their intentions. However, the
education authority, BCC, have expressed reservations
regarding this option as recent investment in the school
means that there is no immediate advantage in the
relocation and provision of new buildings.
M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Low density residential Employment - Office quarter
Medium density residential Employment - Business campus
High density residential Community uses
Mixed use residential Park/open space
Leisure Public transport route
School Landmark
Note: Sq m are intended as GFA unless specified
Initial options
6.6 Option 5: Housing, employment and education mixed use development (B)
Option 5 – Housing, education and employment mixed use development (B)
Relocation of St Bernard’s and St Augustine’s Schools and redevelopment of their site for a variety of uses including
offices. Creation of a new destination around the access on Daws Hill Lane, with a smaller cluster of office uses, a mixed
area and education all within walking distance.
Description
Medium density development of Daws Hill primarily for housing, including a primary school, doctor’s surgery, local shops and play
space. Abbey Barn South redeveloped to incorporate the relocated Roman Catholic (RC) Schools currently off Daws Hill Lane (ie St Bernard’s and
St Augustine’s). Park and playing field comprehensively designed. Associated residential.
Major leisure sport facility and associated enabling residential and retail development to the west of the Gateway.
Park and Ride and Coach Interchange at Sport Centre site.
Mixed commercial development on Cressex Island.
Development quantities
• 800 -1,000 residential units (190 in mixed use area)
• Approximately 60,000sq m GFA mixed use campus on schools site, including prime business space
• Up to 25,000 sq m GFA of office space along Daws Hill Lane
• 10,000 - 15,000 sq m GFA mixed use non-residential space (5,000 sq m retail, 3,000 sq m social facilities, small business
units)
• Primary school and relocated RC Schools, with potential common facilities
• Tennis courts retained and new recreational facilities.
• 150,000 sq m park and pitches / nature reserve
68 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Initial options
Other considerations
6.6.9 The development is uncertain, due to the likely
difficulties of relocating the schools. It is likely to
require significant infrastructure investment and land
equalisation agreements between the land owners, as
well as public funding towards the school development.
6.6.10 Moreover, the business and residential
development replacing the schools, however more
resilient because of its prime location, is likely to require
a pre-let arrangement with major inward investors. This
will leave the site vulnerable to an uncertain property
market, potentially requiring significant pump priming
and marketing of the town as a office destination.
6.6.11 The financial position in relation to the relocation
of the schools is clearly a very important factor and
it will be necessary to explore this with the schools,
together with wider issues regarding the acceptability
of the proposal. However any relocation would provide
the schools with good quality premises, an accessible
location, also including adequate parking provision
and the opportunity to improve the efficiency of their
operations.
M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Low density residential Employment - Office quarter
Medium density residential Employment - Business campus
High density residential Community uses
Mixed use residential Park/open space
Leisure Public transport route
School Landmark
Note: Sq m are intended as GFA unless specified
Initial options
6.7 Option 6: Leisure-led development
Option 6 – Leisure-led development
Description
Major ‘gateway’ entrance on Abbey Barn Lane, potentially with a direct link to the motorway, thus extending the vision for an
image making, active gateway to High Wycombe.
Medium density development of Daws Hill for primarily housing, including a primary school, doctor’s surgery, local shops and play
space.
Abbey Barn South redeveloped to provide for a major sport related leisure development, with leisure hub and (small) retail and
parking in conjunction with Snowdome. Associated residential.
High frequency public transport. New road link and double access: from Daws Hill Lane for residents and day users, from Abbey
Barn Lane for visitors to the leisure complex.
Residential development in Abbey Barn North.
Development quantities
• 1,100-1,200 residential units (300 flats in mixed use area)
• 10,000 -15,000 sq m GFA business space
• 15,000- 20,000 sq m GFA mixed use non-residential space (8,000 sq m retail, 5,000 sq m social facilities, mixed business
units)
• 85,000 sq m plot for leisure uses
• Primary school
• Tennis courts retained and new recreational facilities.
• 150,000 sq m park and pitches / nature reserve
72 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Initial options
6.8 Summary assessment and
recommendations
Other considerations 6.8.1 All six options seek to enhance the M40
6.7.9 This option proposes the creation of a new leisure Gateway as an identified Area of Change in the LDF
destination, which may generate activity on site through Core Strategy. All six options also deliberately provide
most of the day, thus maximising efficiency of public a mix of land uses to ensure that the sites do not
transport and CHP energy generation. However, the become residential suburbs or employment sites poorly
amount and type of leisure uses necessary to achieve connected with their neighbouring areas and the rest of
a well used site may have a detrimental effect on the the town.
town centre and attract more traffic to the area. 6.8.2 The mix of uses varies considerably between
6.7.10 The concept of a large scale leisure venue is the different options, although all include a substantial
likely to require a pre-construction arrangement with element of residential use, which is essential both from
investors and significant enabling funds. This will leave a planning policy perspective and for economic viability.
the site vulnerable to an uncertain development, with 6.8.3 The key issues emerging from the Sustainability
the risk that the site remains vacant for a considerable Appraisal (see Appendix 4) and consideration of the
time. Moreover, this development is likely to reduce the strategic objectives have guided further elaboration of
opportunity for other community investment provision. the options prior to consultation. Key issues to inform
6.7.11 Traffic impact and major highway infrastructure further option refinement and testing include:
investment and the potential requirement of a new
access road directly linked to motorway may affect the Gateway
deliverability of this option. • All options, with the exception of Option 1 and to a
lesser extent Option 2, make a major contribution to
the enhancement of the M40 Gateway as a vibrant
area within High Wycombe.
• Option 6 raises significant deliverability and
transport issues, and potentially adverse impacts on
the town centre. It would require the identification of
a major operator and a detailed feasibility strategy.
Because of its major implications, it should be
discarded as part of this study.
• Option 4 does not have the support of the
education authority, raises potentially major highway
issues close to Handy Cross and it is unlikely to
be deliverable. It should not therefore be taken any
further.
74 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Initial options
76 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Further option development
High Wycombe Town Centre
1. Public transport, open space, community facilities 3. The leisure-led option (Option 6) and relocation of
and sustainable energy are all better enabled by a John Hampden School (Option 4) should not be
larger scale integrated development. Development taken forward because they are not likely to be
of Daws Hill only (Option 1) would only partially viable and raise other significant delivery issues.
contribute to the provision of facilities to the area
4. The exploration of opportunities to relocate the
and to an enhanced gateway. Therefore, it was
Catholic schools should continue in a private
agreed that for the purposes of this study the Daws
discussion with the schools and a viability test.
Hill site should be considered a part of a larger
Short term options to improve access to the schools
development, of which it constitutes the first phase.
should also be considered.
2. Abbey Barn North has a sensitive ecology and offers
5. Different combinations of highway infrastructure
limited potential for development. Its contribution
investment and land use should be proposed. At
is essentially limited to the opportunity to create a
least one option should not require the creation of a
safer road link and a limited amount of housing. An
new link road south of the M40.
option that does not include the development of
Abbey Barn North (but retains the improved road 6. Sustainable transport links to the town centre via
link) should be considered. Wycombe Abbey school should be investigated.
Description
Integrated medium-low density development of Daws Hill primarily for housing, including a primary school, doctor’s
surgery, local shops and play space and Abbey Barn South to provide low density residential and park and playing field
comprehensively designed.
High frequency public transport along a structuring central spine.
Primary access from Daws Hill Lane.
No development in Abbey Barn North.
Development quantities
• 450-500 dwellings in Daws Hill
• 750-800 dwellings in Abbey Barn South
• Mixed use centre including 200 flats, 10,000-15,000 sq m of offices, shops and community facilities
• Primary school
• Large informal park and small scale pitches within the Ride
78 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Further option development
Urban design Provision of primary health care, primary education
7.1.3 This option creates a new neighbourhood and leisure and community facilities will be essential to
arranged around a mixed use heart and a public support the new development and address deficiencies
transport spine. There will be the potential to create in the surrounding area which will be further impacted
a local destination as well as a distinctive living by this development.
environment with a variety of quality architecture. The
proposed public transport link will serve a much wider Economic
area which is currently underprovided, and reinforce the 7.1.9 This option will result in an increase in population
ties of the Gateway to the town centre. of some 3,000 residents and 5 - 700 additional
potential employees. This will provide a significant
7.1.4 The local park and recreational facilities will be
boost to the town’s retail and leisure economy.
of sufficient scale to encourage use and patronage by
The proposed employment on the site while not
nearby residents. The employment component is likely
matching the increase in residential, will nevertheless
to attract a range of local businesses, but will not be of
be significant, especially if a significant proportion of
a scale and format to draw inward investment.
occupiers were to be new to the town.
7.1.5 The range of land uses makes limited contribution
7.1.10 Given the shortage of high quality office space
to the establishment of the M40 Gateway area as
in the town it is envisaged that most if not all of the
a prime area within High Wycombe. It will provide,
10 - 15,000 sq m of employment space will be B1a.
however, a potentially highly sustainable pattern of
Given its location and size the development is again
residential accommodation. Densities will be more
likely to appeal to small and medium sized employers.
compact than existing development in the area, but still
Accessibility will be very important and it is likely that
low rise.
the imbalance of employment and potential employees
7.1.6 The potential to integrate Abbey Barn North will lead to a greater degree of out commuting from the
will be limited to improved road and public transport town.
access. The site should reinforce linkages with the
Wycombe Marsh development, if possible. Transport and access
7.1.11 Traffic flows associated with this option will
Planning trigger the need for a detailed transport assessment
7.1.7 This option would provide the highest level and infrastructure improvements. Flows are, however,
of residential development, effectively providing for significantly lower than the business campus option
a major urban extension to the South of the town. (Option B).
It could also significantly contribute to any shortfall
7.1.12 There may be potential to serve the level of
(qualitative or quantitative) in employment land
traffic envisaged without the need to create new
provision in the town, primarily catering for growth of
access routes into the site, although this will be
existing businesses.
dependent on a more detailed study of multi-modal
7.1.8 In planning terms, the key considerations are trips. Early LDF modelling work undertaken by
likely to be related to the scale of development; the Halcrow assumed around 1,150 residential units on
access to the site by sustainable modes – particularly the three sites. The residential provision in Option A
how attractive connections to the town centre can is greater than this, and the need for off-site highway
be delivered by public transport, walking and cycling. improvements is therefore likely to be greater than
identified in the Halcrow study.
Property
7.1.14 In general terms, the high proportion of
residential is likely to make this option the most viable,
assuming that the phasing is controlled appropriately
to avoid over supply to the market (as the Wycombe
Marsh scheme may reactivate within a similar timescale
once the market improves). Additionally, there may
be potential to cross-fund the less value generating
elements of the scheme, in particular, the leisure and
social infrastructure.
7.1.15 The total area of mixed employment space
is probably most viable as B1a offices, for which
Wycombe currently has a limited supply of Grade A
space. The actual mix and viability of this scale of
business development will need careful consideration:
the scale of provision is such to exceed local demand
and may need to come on-stream in phases over
at least a 10 year period to maximise its chances of
securing pre-lets.
Sustainable energy
7.1.16 This option allows for the installation of CHP
(heat or power led), however it does not maximise
efficiency as there will be a reduced requirement
for heat and electricity throughout the day. Gas or
biomass operation should be considered. In case of
gas operation, the 15% on site generation component
would require 4 large wind turbines on the south side
of the site or a 1kWp PV array on 50 -70% of the
dwellings.
80 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Further option development
Figure 7.2: Options: B – Business Campus
A new medium-high density urban neighbourhood, incorporating a business campus and significant mixed use
development arranged around a new district centre and public transport spine.
Description
Integrated medium density development of Daws Hill primarily for housing, but also including a mixed use centre with offices,
a primary school, doctor’s surgery, local shops and play space. Abbey Barn South to provide a mix of residential (including
flats), a large business campus with a mix of large and small units, and park and playing field comprehensively designed.
High frequency public transport along a structuring central spine.
Primary residential access from Daws Hill Lane. Business access from Abbey Barn Lane/ Southern Link.
Small scale residential development in Abbey Barn North. Associated managed Nature Reserve.
Development quantities
• 450-500 dwellings in Daws Hill
• 600-700 dwellings in Abbey Barn South, including 300 flats
• Business campus of 60,000 sq m
• Mixed use centre including apartments, shops and community facilities, 8,000-10,000 sq m offices.
• Primary school
• Large informal park within the Ride
7.1.19 This option creates a new district centre and 7.1.24 This type of campus development targeted at
a significant number and range of jobs. It will have large single occupiers, is a relatively inflexible form of
a major ‘gateway’ entrance on Abbey Barn Lane, space and its viability entirely dependent upon securing
potentially requiring a direct link to the strategic road a major occupier. It is impossible to assess how strong
network, thus extending the vision for an image the market for such a campus will be in 5-10 years
making, active gateway to High Wycombe. The time.
development itself will be arranged around a business– 7.1.25 This type of employment offer may draw
led mixed use spine, with sufficient critical mass to employees from a very wide catchment area. As a
draw inward investment or a major business cluster. In hub Wycombe is the preferred location for this type of
turn this will attract a variety of convenience shopping, economic activity, however this will place a premium on
some comparison niche shops and a range of cafes the need to provide sustainable access to the railway
and restaurants, which will serve the businesses and station and the proposed Coachway. The transport
the residents at different times of the day. impacts associated with such a development will be
7.1.20 Synergies with the potential snowdome will be largest of any of the options and the implications for
maximised, in terms of common retail, public transport investment in new infrastructure would be significant,
provision and possibly parking. and potentially adversely impact upon the AONB and
Green Belt land to the South of the M40.
7.1.21 The business and mixed use component will
establish the area as an attractive, well served part of Economic
town, encouraging the creation of a distinctive living 7.1.26 This is the highest risk option which also
environment with a variety of quality architecture. The offers the highest rewards. A high quality, high profile
park and recreational facilities, part of a well served employment site anchored by a prestigious national or
and attractive district, could provide a destination for a international occupier would provide a massive uplift to
much wider area. the economy. To make it work would require a pre-let
7.1.22 The potential to integrate Abbey Barn North and with any major new employer moving in there is
will be limited to improved access and shared public also the risk that one day they could easily move out
transport. The site should reinforce linkages with the or significantly down size. However, the prestige and
Wycombe Marsh Development, if possible. location of the site reduces the risk of re-letting and
or redeveloping it in the future. Such a development
Planning would support the creation of a knowledge based
7.1.23 This option implies the highest level of economy, help to reduce out-commuting by the highest
development overall and involves the development of educated and qualified in the area, provide work
all three sites. The scale of non-residential development across a wider range of skill levels and help to bring
proposed is considerable and in employment terms in other related activities further raising employment
would add an entirely new strategic offer to the opportunities in the area all in line with the area’s
Wycombe market. The scale of the business campus aspirations. It would have a major significant positive
is such that it could be seen as a sub-regional impact on the town’s economy.
employment site, and should probably be viewed in
82 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Further option development
7.1.27 However, an inability to identify and attract a 7.1.32 Although the proportion of residential has
suitable occupier would result in the site being vacant the potential to be viable, the quantity of offices is
for a considerable time and the need to agree an end high, therefore this option is likely to be one of the
date when the site would be released for a different least viable (even in a post credit crunch market
use. At present Wycombe is not viewed by the market environment) unless a significant proportion of pre-lets
as an office HQ location to rival nearby centres at could be secured. There is little in the way of market
Reading and Slough. Major marketing and promotion evidence at present to support this level of provision in
of the town and the site as a prime location will have to a single campus in this location.
be done. This work should take account of the relative
attractiveness of the M40 Gateway with competing Sustainable energy
locations elsewhere within the Western Corridor sub- 7.1.33 This option offers a good match for CHP
region. (whether heat or power led) as there is a requirement
for heat and electricity throughout the day. Gas or
Transport and access biomass operation should be considered. In case
7.1.28 This option would generate the most number of of gas operation, the 15% on-site power generation
trips in the AM and PM peaks. requirement is likely to demand at least 5 - 6 large
wind turbines on the south side of the site or by a
7.1.29 Daws Hill Lane as a single carriageway route
1kWp PV array on most of the dwellings and additional
is likely to be insufficient to deal with this level of flow
installations for the offices. There will be a large energy
and alternative route(s) into the area may be needed.
requirement for the offices and resulting CO2 emissions
This could take the form of a new southern link road
are likely to be higher than a site with predominately
from Heath End Road across the motorway to the
dwellings due to the requirement of air conditioning for
A404 south of Handy Cross and/or could be a shorter
the commercial units. Alternatives to air conditioning
link from Heath End Road, over the motorway and
should be considered.
joining the access to the Sport Centre site and/or
improvements to Abbey Barn Lane and Abbey Barn
Other environmental issues
Road to give better access to the A40.
7.1.34 Abbey Barn North contains a designated
7.1.30 All of these options require further analysis Landscape Area and also ecological important areas
to confirm feasibility. Bus patronage for this option which should be proactively managed as a nature
is estimated to be 50% higher than for Option A reserve. Provision of open space within the developable
at around 600 trips per day, therefore offering the area and buffer zones to reduce pressure associated
potential to support a higher frequency bus route. with leisure activities on the retained calcareous
grassland will need to be incorporated into the overall
Property design. Buffer zones will also be required for Abbey
7.1.31 Although High Wycombe is a suitable office Barn South adjacent to Deangarden Wood. There
location, deliverability of this option is heavily reliant would also be negative impacts on the AONB and
on access/transport improvements. In order to Green Belt if road improvements are required South of
compete with surrounding and better established office the M40.
locations, this scheme would need to be of outstanding
quality and accompanied by infrastructure investment.
This would have an obvious bearing on development
costs and subsequent profitability.
84 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Further studies
Wycombe Abbey School Gates on Marlow Hill
8.1.3 The option involves the schools being relocated 8.1.5 Access for the offices will be directly from Handy
at the Abbey Barn Lane end of the site, to maximise Cross junction through the highway maintenance
efficiency of access from east and west, without depot. This new road link will also provide bus access
interfering with the residential development. This to the rest of the area and the Daws Hill and Abbey
location could provide shared access and parking with Barn sites.
a future recreational facility at the snowdome site and
8.1.6 An initial viability assessment of this option
be well served by public transport. Other sport facilities
was undertaken. This has indicated that, in current
and the park would be within a short and safe walking
market conditions, significant gap funding will have
distance. Moreover, this location would not prejudice
to be identified to enable the viability of this option.
coherent development of the residential component at
However this may change once the market recovers,
an earlier date. Other alternative locations within the
and assuming land is exchanged free of charge or part
sites may be equally acceptable, in due course, when
of a land equalisation agreement, and WDC supports
developers consider the detailed design and phasing of
or even promotes the arrangement, the option could
the sites.
become viable in the future.
8.1.4 It is assumed that the present school site would
be developed to provide a mix of low-medium rise
residential adjoining the existing neighbourhoods and
offices towards the motorway and Sport Centre site.
The exact mix of land uses will be established subject
to viability testing.
Colin Buchanan Wycombe District Council August 2009 85
8.2 Business Development as Argent, Prudential and Arlington should be actively
sought or continued.
Requirements
8.2.6 The key issues and requirements involving
8.2.1 A report prepared by Drivers Jonas in support of
the development and delivery of either a large scale
this study provides baseline information to assess the
business campus or offices as part of a mixed use
relative attractiveness of High Wycombe as an office
scheme are summarised below.
location (against the existing and pipeline competition)
and informs the elaboration of appropriate land use Business campus – key issues
options. The report is included in Appendix 5.
8.2.7 Occupiers seeking accommodation for large
8.2.2 Two main scenarios are considered: HQ facilities would consider a fairly wide target area
• The development of a large scale business campus; – driven primarily by proximity to motorways, rail
and and airport connections as well as the quality of the
environment and its associated amenities.
• The provision of a significant quantity of employment
within a mixed use area. 8.2.8 In order to achieve a campus development of
comparable scale and quality to High Wycombe’s
8.2.3 A review of the property market indicates that competitors, the following requirements would need to
High Wycombe is not an established office location be addressed:
and has not been promoted as one over the past two
decades. It has not attracted the same level of quality • A solution to traffic congestion at Junction 4 of the
occupiers when compared to its competing towns and M40 would need to be vigorously pursued;
lacks the range of stock found elsewhere. In addition • Where land is available within close proximity to
to this, there has been little suitable office development Junction 4 (school relocation option described
land close to the High Wycombe and to the M40 and above), improvements to existing road access and
thus development has occurred further afield towards certainty regarding the timescale for infrastructure
Marlow. This has left High Wycombe with a lesser office improvements would have a significant impact on
market than comparable towns, despite its strong the marketability for office development;
transport and communication links.
• Additionally, dedicated access independent of
8.2.4 The M40 Gateway sites represent a virtually residential areas, strong public transport links (to
unique opportunity to consider a major business-led rail and bus links) are highly sought after and are
development, which may be deliverable in the medium often essential prerequisites to large occupier site
term. searches;
8.2.5 A step change in employment provision in the • In terms of actual layout and format, in order
town, however, will potentially require the support to compete, the style would need to be of well
of an inward investment agency championing High designed buildings, potentially arranged as blocks
Wycombe’s assets, aiming to increase both the town’s and squares set within an attractive landscaped
business profile and presence and promote short term environment. Adequate on site car parking is
and long term opportunities in the M40 Gateway and essential, as is the development of on site amenities
elsewhere. By way of example, inward investment (shops, cafes, gym, etc.).
promotion agencies such as the successful “Locate in
Kent” has created 20,000 new jobs for Kent, following
the promotion of employment led sites. A dialogue with
major commercial investors active in the area such
86 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Further studies
8.2.9 Occupiers within the business services sector, 8.2.12 We would anticipate that this accommodation
the telecoms sector, and the finance sector, who could take the form of pre-lets and flexible blocks,
already make up a significant proportion of the office potentially in the region of c. 2,787 sq m (c.30,000 sq
occupancy in the town, have potential for further ft) on a speculative basis, that could be subdivided to
expansion. There are some significant occupiers in the ensure maximum flexibility to meet specific occupier
area, notably, Dun & Bradstreet, Johnson & Johnson, requirements.
Maritz Wolff & Co, Capstone Mortgage Services and
8.2.13 A clear infrastructure improvement strategy
SAS Software, that could in the future, with more
would greatly enhance the marketability of this site for
favourable market conditions, require expansion
business space within a mixed use master plan option.
and therefore provide increased demand for office
accommodation. In addition to this, occupiers within
these sectors, who currently are not represented within
the town could be attracted to the area, particularly if
their business have any synergy with occupiers already
in the High Wycombe office market.
8.2.10 Taking into account existing stock, take up and
pipeline supply within High Wycombe and at competing
locations, and given the current and uncertain market
conditions, a large scale (c.50,000 sq m/538,200 sq
ft) HQ business campus option within a master plan
context could be a challenging scenario to pursue,
which will require a significant commitment on the
side of the Council in terms of infrastructure delivery,
marketing and facilitation of development.
88 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Transport and movement options
9.1.3 In parallel, all layout options incorporated the 9.1.4 CB worked closely with Buckinghamshire
features of a sustainable transport strategy: County Council in exploring solutions for this sector
of the town, and final recommendations for strategic
• Land use mix sufficient to support patronage for
improvements at this location will be agreed by the
public transport and to reduce the need to travel
District and County once the analysis is complete.
by providing well located schools, local shops and
As part of this study, a number of options and
employment;
highway solutions were designed and tested; these
• A parking strategy to maximise synergies between are summarised below. Further detail is provided in
different uses and to encourage modal shift; Appendix 2.
• Efficient and safe access for emergency and service
vehicles;
• A direct bus corridor to service the site and link up
with existing and future destinations, such as the
Park & Ride;
• Walkable neighbourhoods, and improved pedestrian
and cycle links to the town centre and other
destinations, including direct, safe and overlooked
routes;
• Opportunities for car share.
Colin Buchanan Wycombe District Council August 2009 89
9.2 Strategic transport assessments -
Traffic modelling
9.2.1 Buckinghamshire County Council and its 9.2.5 Specific tests were undertaken with particular
transport modelling consultants Halcrow have reference to this study: the impact of different
developed a series of modelling tools to represent combination of site development, mitigation measures
the Wycombe Transport Study Model (WTS). The and infrastructure improvements and the effect of
components of this model include: including the Southern Link road. This ensured that the
model adopted a consistent approach when comparing
• A regional model, which generates longer distance
with other Core Strategy sites and that the impact of
trip matrices to use in the local model:
traffic generated by the development is understood.
• A local multi-modal model to estimate demand on
9.2.6 The tests considered the traffic effect of:
the highway and public transport networks; and
• Development of Daws Hill only (brownfield
• A more detailed ‘Paramics’ model to assess the
development only)
impacts on the Handy Cross Junction.
• Development of Daws Hill and Abbey Barn (North
9.2.2 The purpose of the models is to assess the
and South)
impact of growth arising from growth and the major
developments proposed in the town and contained • No development in all three sites
within the Core Strategy and the Delivery and Site • With and without local highway improvements (see
Allocations document, to assess the transport Appendix 2 for details)
implications of developments and identify potential
mitigation measures. 9.2.7 The Southern Link road is a potential measure to
support the Core Strategy, which provides an additional
9.2.3 A technical report setting out the outcome of the access route to development sites in the Abbey Barn
modelling work and the assumptions used is available / Daws Hill area, as well as an outer orbital route in
from the Council (Technical Note 2, Individual Site Tests the South East quadrant of the study area. Certain
– M40 Gateway - 2009). Key findings related to the development scenarios with and without the Southern
Daws Hill and Abbey Barn sites are summarised below. Link were tested to determine its impact on the
strategic and local networks as well as measure direct
Method and options benefits to the sites themselves.
9.2.4 The model considered and compared the
following scenarios; 9.2.8 The conclusions of the work to-date are:
• An initial test (the Do-Minimum) in which growth is • In the Do-Minimum scenario, traffic growth in
based on current planning permissions and potential Wycombe is 11% compared with 20% in the Core
future windfall development. Strategy Scenario.
• A second test was then undertaken assuming the • There is increased congestion in all time periods
full Core Strategy development. with network conditions more difficult in the PM
peak across the whole network.
• A series of tests (Exclusion Tests) where individual
developments assumed in the Core Strategy were • When comparing with alternative sites in other
removed to assess their individual impact. parts of High Wycombe, the development of Daws
Hill and Abbey Barn (North and South) have the
• The remaining tests examined the inclusion of greatest impact on the network and Handy Cross
additional transport measures, such as a Southern junction, although they also involve the greatest
Link road, linking Heath End Road and Wycombe amount of development.
Road (south of Handy Cross) thus providing a
second strategic access to the study area sites via
Abbey Barn Lane
90 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Transport and movement options
• The impact of Abbey Barn North on its own is 9.2.12 Access to the Daws Hill and Abbey Barn sites
negligible. would be improved, but less than 15% of users of the
Southern Link will be related to these sites.
• The growth in public transport demand is equivalent
to 38% growth in trips with the Core Strategy. 9.2.13 Key beneficial impacts are:
9.2.9 The DfT Transport Analysis Guidance suggests • It provides network-wide benefits in terms of travel
that reliability of urban networks is to be measured times and congestion.
as daytime average travel time compared with free
• Congestion Index of 1.22 (compared with 1.24 for
flowing traffic. This is expressed as 12-hour Congestion
the Core Strategy). The increase in network travel
Index, where 1.00 represents free flowing traffic and,
time is 32% (compared with 35% for the Core
for example, 1.20 represents 20% more travel time
Strategy without the link).
required to do the same journeys throughout the
network. • The Southern Link creates significant re-routing
patterns across the town, but particularly in the
9.2.10 The modelling tests indicate that:
South and East. In many cases the changes are
• The baseline position has a Congestion Index (C.I.) small but there are some notable changes.
of 1.12 (i.e. an average of 12% more time than free
• Examination of potential demands on the Southern
flowing traffic for any given journey);
Link shows that a large volume of traffic is routing
• Growth including the development of all Core from via Loudwater and Flackwell Heath (or
Strategy sites will result in a further increase in time Kingsmead) to the A404 south, M40 or Cressex.
travel of 12% (C.I. of 1.24).
• There is a forecast reduction in traffic flow of 2%
• The development of Daws Hill only (Abbey Barn entering the town centre, mainly in the interpeak and
North and South undeveloped) and of other Core evening peak periods.
Strategy sites will improve average delays across
• There is an 8% reduction in traffic on the London
the network by 2% only (C.I. of 1.22)
Road corridor, again mainly in the interpeak and
• Delay reduction across the network attributable to evening peak periods.
the Southern Link, with development of all Core
• On Daws Hill Lane there is a reduction of traffic of
Strategy sites, including Daws Hill and Abbey Barn,
13% during the day although there is no reduction
of 2% (C.I. of 1.22).
during the AM peak hour.
Southern Link tests • Within Flackwell Heath traffic levels in the Core
9.2.11 The effects of the Southern Link have been Strategy are reduced on Treadaway Hill in the
studied in some detail. The main outcomes of the morning peak hour (by 11%) but are only reduced
various tests is that the link has a primarily strategic by 1 to 2% during the rest of the day. There is re-
function, as it improves the distribution of traffic routing away from Sheepridge Lane (40% reduction
between the motorway junction and the south-east daily with the higher reductions in the interpeak
of the town. In doing so, it relieves Marlow Hill and period) to Heath End Road (24% increase with
the town centre. However, it brings more traffic into higher increases in the interpeak) and the Southern
Flackwell Heath and Kinsgmead Road, areas not Link.
necessarily suited to carry significant additional traffic. • The proportion of traffic using the Southern Link
Further analysis of cost/ benefits related to the link will from the Abbey Barn and Daws Hill development
be required to make conclusive recommendations: sites is small (less than 15%)
for this reason the delivery of the link is retained as an
option in the final movement strategy.
Colin Buchanan Wycombe District Council August 2009 91
9.2.14 Adverse impacts: 9.2.17 The modelling indicates that, generally, local
improvements to the road network enhance the
• There is a 28% increase in traffic on Abbey Barn
performance on these routes/junctions relative to
Lane due to the Southern Link. This is in addition to
no improvements being undertaken, but they do
growth associated with the development sites.
not in all instances satisfactorily mitigate the impact
• The inclusion of the Southern Link increases traffic in of development. They also shift the pressure from
the Kingsmead Road area (23% increase during the access routes to and from the sites onto other routes
day with a greater increase of 38% in the AM peak through the network. Further investigation of traffic
and only 9% in the interpeak) as routing patterns management interventions will be required.
change.
9.2.18 Not withstanding this, some improvements
• There are increases in delay on Abbey Barn Lane would be required by the development of the site when
at Kingsmead Road and on Abbey Barn Road at investigating the impact of the proposed development
the London Road. These have been found to be onto the local network using the standard transport
ameliorated by possible junction improvements assessment methodology and road safety standards.
although these result in the patterns of delays
9.2.19 In addition, consideration has been given to
moving such that other areas are affected.
how traffic conditions might be improved on Daws Hill
• Traffic levels at Handy Cross with the Southern Link Lane by improvement of drop off/parking arrangements
are increased by 2% with reduction on Marlow Hill around the Catholic Schools, and by improved access
and an increase on Wycombe Road. arrangements into the school sites. This has been
• On Marlow Hill there is a 3% increase in traffic flows, identified as a key factor in causing congestion in the
mainly in the inbound direction. area, and would be exacerbated further by traffic from
new development if not satisfactorily addressed.
• There are still significant peak hour delays on Daws
Hill Lane at the Marlow Hill junction. These have Traffic modelling outcomes
been found to be ameliorated by possible junction 9.2.20 In conclusion, modelling shows that there is
improvement. a major increase in traffic and delays in an area that
already suffers poor traffic conditions. This is due
Local highway improvements tests
to overall growth in High Wycombe (Core Strategy
9.2.15 Modelling tests also considered junction and scenario) as well as development of the Daws Hill
link improvements, with a range of options at various and Abbey Barn sites. This justifies improvements
locations, including: to a number of junctions as well as consideration of
• Marlow Hill/Daws Hill Lane major strategic infrastructure. However, analysis of
those improvements highlights wider difficulties as
• Daws Hill Lane well, which needs to be addresses as part of ongoing
• Heath End Road/Abbey Barn Lane Junction. transport modelling for the Delivery and Site Allocations
document and development of the transport strategy
• Abbey Barn Lane
for the town.
• Abbey Barn Lane/Kingsmead Road
9.2.21 The Southern Link, in particular, provides some
• Abbey Barn Road/A40 London positive strategic benefits, but also some undesirable
9.2.16 Details of all options tested are provided in impacts, and does not appear to resolve all the more
Appendix 2. local impacts. Moreover, it appears that only 15% of its
users come from the study area sites.
92 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Transport and movement options
Figure 9.1: Improvement locations
Link improvement
9.2.22 Further work and consideration of the various Junction improvement
options and combinations of measures will be required Existing Link
before determining the optimal highway solution that M40
supports development in the study area.
9.2.23 BCC Transport Department, after consideration 9.2.24 Transport investment in the area needs to be
of the modelling results, concluded that, in order to substantial. However, the details of the requirements
support growth, improve the environment and achieve must be part of a wider set of improvements for the
greater equality of opportunity, the transport solutions town. Therefore, it was not possible, as part of this
should: study to determine the required infrastructure. This is
• Make best use of the network already available; described as options for further study in Section 13.
• Suggest the creation of new road links only when
there is a robust evidence base for delivery;
• Improve traffic management measures;
• Encourage change of behaviour;
• Focus investment on sustainable travel as a priority.
94 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Transport and movement options
and Railway Station. This service is likely to be self key element of highway infrastructure required. Initial
sustaining only once the development is fully occupied, discussions with the school have been favourable
and would require subsidy in the initial phases of the in principle to the provision, as long as it includes
scheme. improved pupil access. Further work is required to
secure the creation of this link. This includes:
Diversions
• Obtaining the formal support of St Bernard’s School
9.3.7 Another option is to divert and reinforce the and access through their land;
existing service 36 into the site. Initially the existing
service could divert into the Daws Hill site to provide • Securing part of the land currently occupied by
an additional hourly service to the Sport Centre, Town Bucks CC/ Highway Agency Highway Maintenance
Centre, Bus Station and Train Station. Once the site Depot;
on Abbey Barn South is opened up, the service could • Potential acquisition of a residential property to
then run through the site and be reinforced to create a route via Daws Lea (depending on the exact route
half hourly service. This could be in addition to the new favoured);
service described above.
• Further investigation in terms of environmental
Other options impacts and topography;
9.3.8 A demand responsive minibus service has been • Further investigation of traffic impact at Sports
considered along a route through Wycombe Abbey Centre Site / Marlow Hill junction.
school site. However it is not recommended for
taking forward at this point due to uncertainties over 9.4 Walking and Cycling
patronage and viability. The service was thought to
have the following characteristics: Options
• Most direct route to the town centre. 9.4.1 Walking and cycling are severely under-provided
in the wider study area, yet they have great potential
• Shared with pedestrians and cyclists. to contribute to a sustainable transport strategy for the
• Also available to residents of Daws Hill who cannot developments. Key objectives are:
use existing public transport because of a disability • Provide improved pedestrian footpaths and
or infirmity. crossings to Daws Hill Lane, Heath End Road,
• Membership Scheme. Abbey Barn Lane and Abbey Barn Road;
• Fares based on a system similar to local bus fares. • Provide a direct link and attractive link to town
centre, potentially through Wycombe Abbey School
Recommendations site;
9.3.9 Any of the above options would need to be • Provide connections to existing public rights of way
supported by residential, school and commercial travel and footpaths;
plans.
• Provide improved links to woods and countryside to
9.3.10 A variety of routeing options to provide high south;
quality public transport to the sites are available,
either as stand alone provision or in combination and • Provide safe, direct and overlooked routes, well lit
reinforcing each other. However, provision of a public where appropriate; and
transport link through the St Bernard’s School site is a • Integrate with green infrastructure small bus link as
discussed in this framework.
96 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Transport and movement options
98 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Public & stakeholders’ consultation
10.1.5 Additional written responses submitted to the 10.1.7 Each breakout considered the following issues:
Council as part of the consultation feedback have also
• Traffic and transport issues, and measures to reduce
been considered and included in the summary below.
congestion
Workshop format • Public transport, pedestrian and transport facilities
10.1.6 The resident consultation workshops followed • Open space and leisure facilities
the format below:
• Community facilities
• Presentation on the analysis of key issues, study
findings and development options • Scale and character of development
• Breakout groups to discuss the key issues, local 10.1.8 The breakout groups were run as interactive
needs and character, and development options discussions, using a structured, highly visual technique
to gather the views of all participants, identify common
• Summarising to review the results of each breakout themes and discuss issues, concerns and ideas.
group.
• What are the key features of local character that Open space facilities
need to be reflected in new development?
10.2.4 Key messages received were:
10.2 Workshop results • One large park is preferred to separate small green
spaces.
10.2.1 The text below summarises the comments
made by the participants to the consultation process. • Maintain open space and wooded character.
• Range of informal space and sports facilities.
Traffic and transport issues
• Facilities for young people and children needed
10.2.2 Key messages received were:
within the development.
• Current traffic issues need to be addressed
• Well-maintained parkland.
irrespective of development.
• Respect wildlife and bio-diversity.
• Development will make the existing traffic situation
worse.
Community facilities
• There is little confidence that junction improvements 10.2.5 Key messages received were:
will be sufficient to address the likely level of traffic
congestion. • Celebrate the military history of the site.
100 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Public & stakeholders’ consultation
Balance of uses and scale Landowners and potential developers
10.2.6 Key messages received were: 10.2.8 Landowners and potential developers
were also involved at various stages during the
• Mixed use is fine.
consultation period and provided input to the emerging
• No business park-type development – provide small preferred option. Discussions mainly focused on the
starter business units and homes for families with development of Daws Hill and Abbey Barn South only.
gardens (not flats). The main points raised were:
• Use eco-friendly design. • Broad support, in principle, for a common
master plan, which would result in a seamless
Feedback from Wycombe District Council neighbourhood when complete;
and other stakeholders
• Willingness to explore ways to deliver a
10.2.7 The options and further studies were presented
comprehensive development;
and discussed with Council members and officers. The
following priorities emerged from the discussions: • No objection, in principle, to consider ways to
deliver/ facilitate off-site development, for example
• Need to identify a set of appropriate highway
the relocation of the schools or the Southern Link,
improvement measures to reduce congestion in the
subject to viability, Council support and other
study area;
sources of funding;
• Support for provision of high quality sustainable
• Need to be mindful of phased delivery, retaining
transport facilities as a way to control congestion
the option of developing Daws Hill independently of
and promote behavioural change: buses, walking
Abbey Barn;
and cycling.
• Concerns about the cost and phasing implications
• Preference for a mixed use development, with a
of community infrastructure, such as on-site
substantial employment component to support the
education or CHP,
economy of High Wycombe in the longer term;
• Concerns about the marketability and scale of the
• Clear support for further exploration of the feasibility
proposed employment;
of relocating the Catholic schools to the Abbey Barn
site; • Concerns about low density and sustainability
aspirations.
• Support for pursuing a new public transport link and
school access through St Bernard’s School in the
short term;
• Need to provide excellent community and open
space infrastructure;
• Preference for low to medium rise development;
• Need to preserve the Woodland Ride in its entirety
as a landscape feature of historic significance;
• Need to retain the valley feature in the topography
of the Abbey Barn South site as open space and a
green corridor to the Green Belt;
• Importance of retaining buffer zones and protecting
the existing woodland.
Colin Buchanan Wycombe District Council August 2009 101
11.Towards a preferred
option
11.1.1 The final set of options were reviewed to inform The emerging master plan framework sets out to:
the preferred development approach, in the light of: • Create a new neighbourhood centre offering a
• Closer examination of the site attributes and range of small scale retail and community facilities
requirements following initial options appraisal; to become a local focal point for new and existing
communities, without threatening other centres and
• Transportation issues (taking account of the need
Flackwell Heath in particular;
for further work to determine the final requirements);
• Incorporate a deliverable element of quality
• Public consultation responses;
business development, in the form of a business-
• Viability and property advice – business led mixed area in a high quality setting, with access
development/market; independent of the residential area and potentially
• Input from Council members and officers; offering a range of business units, suitable for
pre-lets and a range of local new and expanding
• Input from other key stakeholders. companies; small scale business units to be
included in the neighbourhood centre;
• Contribute significantly to housing delivery, by
providing efficient use of land and supporting High
Wycombe’s housing requirements;
102 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Towards a preferred option
Daws Hill Lane
• Adopt a style of development and scale that is • Provide a range of high quality community facilities;
appropriate to the suburban/ fringe/ village context
• Provide flexibility for the relocation of the Roman
of the site: primarily low rise and low-medium
Catholic Schools in the longer term, though with the
density.
potential for some business development on the RC
• Deliver exceptional quality open space, including schools sites instead (as part of a possible mixed
an informal park, playspace for children of different use development);
ages, allotments, informal walks and senior sport
• Retain Abbey Barn North as a longer term reserve
pitches;
site, primarily on grounds of sensitive ecology and
• Significantly contribute to the provision of limited development capacity.
sustainable transport, with high quality bus routes to
the town centre from the outset;
• Contribute to highway improvements to be
determined;
106 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Mast plan framework
Strategic objectives
The proposed master plan satisfies the strategic objectives of the study by:
• Integrated development: the site layout is • A new neighbourhood centre, located on the
comprehensive and integrated. The Daws Hill and Daws Hill site, which offers community services and
Abbey Barn South site, at completion, will become facility to the development, but also appeals to all
a single new neighbourhood with joint facilities the surrounding communities. The neighbourhood
and legible layout. No boundary distinctions will centre is pivotal to the identity of the new
be apparent, even with progressive and phased communities. It will provide a village green with
implementation. The street pattern is regular and children play space (LEAP), a basket grocery store
broadly based on the existing network on Daws and a small number of shops, cafes, small and
Hill and a simple grid on Abbey Barn South. Plot medium sized office space, a primary school, and
sizes will allow continuous direct frontages onto the flatted accommodation (including retirement homes).
streets. • An eastern gateway/ campus, at the edge of
• Magnificent woodland aspect: the master plan is the Abbey Barn South side on Abbey Barn Lane.
designed to maximise the impact of its woodland This area has a formal layout and is designed
setting and create opportunities to enjoy a network to accommodate predominantly business uses,
of long walks at the edge of the woodland, thus creating a business campus with a unique
connecting into existing paths and into the town landscape setting in close proximity of the M40 and
centre. The curved woodland edge frontages reflect the A40 corridor. This area is to provide, together
the topography and the position of a dry valley. with the neighbourhood centre, an ‘anchor’ to the
site and a local destination. An alternative option
• Unique parkland: the existing avenue of trees for this area is also the potential relocation of the
and spinneys forming the Ride are recreated as Roman Catholic Schools from their site on Daws
a distinctive park, which preserves the historic Hill Lane and redevelopment of the school site for
formal structure, and at the same time provides offices and residential.
pockets of activity (play space, a bowling green
and other sports courts) in the ‘rooms’ created by • A well identified development spine, integrating
the existing vegetation. The western end of the the whole area and allowing an efficient provision
Ride accommodates a community centre/ sports of public transport. The spine provides effective
clubhouse and a small apartment building with a connections to the rest of the M40 Gateway and
restaurant/ café with open views of the Ride. the town centre. It links the site entrance on Daws
Hill, the sport facilities and community clubhouse,
the neighbourhood centre and primary school,
residential neighbourhoods, the woodland walks
and the eastern campus. Further along, it reaches
the Wycombe Marsh development and London
Road.
Green and
playground
School
Senior housing
Apartments with
active ground floor
112 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Mast plan framework
Figure 12.4: Office area
Courtyard parking
Courtyard parking
Cafe
Campus green
Frontage onto park
Landmark office
building
12.4.3 The buffer zones between the site and 12.4.7 The proposals will be able to sustain a high
environmentally sensitive areas such as Deangarden frequency/quality bus service. The level of traffic impact
Wood are used for a cycle/walking network and are will not be as significant as other mixed use options as
overlooked by active frontages, thus encouraging the development quantities are lower.
access and enjoyment of local landscape.
12.4.8 The proposals are also a good match for CHP
12.4.4 The proposals would consolidate and enhance as energy use is required throughout the day and night
the sense of community identify by providing a with either the business or education campus.
comprehensive master plan for the sites.
12.4.9 The master plan also provides a range of open
spaces and recreational facilities addressing open
Environment
space deficiency in the area.
12.4.5 Development at Abbey Barn North is subject
to environmental feasibility and is not identified for Economic
development as part of this master plan. However, part
12.4.10 The proposals provide a significant amount of
of the site will be required by the potential re-alignment
employment space although it is dependent on option
of Abbey Barn Lane. Buffer zones will also be required
chosen for the campus area - a business campus
for Abbey Barn South adjacent to Deangarden Wood
or relocation of the schools on site. Even with the
to mitigate against the minor adverse impact. This is to
relocation of the schools, the option would free-up land
be used as a cycle/walking network. A green corridor
for economic development.
between the woods and the countryside is retained.
12.4.6 Mature trees within Daws Hill are broadly
retained. The conversion of the Woodland Ride
into a park will ensure the required long term tree
maintenance and rejuvenation.
Figure 13.3: Option 2 Route via the existing school access road
118 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Transport Infrastructure Framework
13.4 Sustainable travel requirements:
public transport
13.4.1 The public transport strategy proposed draws Route options
on several of the options considered in Section 9.3. 13.4.4 A variety of routeing options to provide high
13.4.2 High quality public transport provision is quality public transport to the sites are available,
essential to securing a sustainable development of either as stand alone provision or in combination and
the area, and securing a direct link to the proposed reinforcing each other.
regional Coachway/local park and ride facility at Handy 13.4.5 The potential routes are shown on the illustrative
Cross is essential. The preferred strategy includes diagram for the Catholic schools area, which also
the provision of a public transport link through the St illustrates the potential for improved drop off facilities
Bernard’s School site to the Coachway/ Sports Centre and management of parking in the area which currently
Site, and therefore link the site to: creates congestions on Daws Hill Lane. The main pros
• The strategic coach services to Oxford and London and cons of these two options are summarised in the
table below. These issues should be explored in more
• The local Park & Ride
detail with the schools and the highway authority.
• Recreation facilities
Service provision
• Employment uses
13.4.6 A new dedicated service should be provided to
• Provide opportunities to improve school access ensure a high quality service from day one, including:
issues
• Modern, clean, distinctive and environmentally
• Integrate with Daws Hill/ Abbey Barn South site friendly vehicles.
13.4.3 The service should also connect the • Better facilities at stops.
development to High Wycombe town centre and the
railway station. It should be integrated with WDC/ • Real time passenger information.
Bucks CC public transport strategies. The proposed • 15min frequency from outset.
public transport corridor along Desborough Road
• Improved journey times to key destinations.
would be utilised, and the service integrated with town
centre bus services at the Eden bus station.
Pros Cons
Direct frontages
Woodland walk/
shared surface
Green corridor/
valley
120 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Transport Infrastructure Framework
Option 3 - Low
Option 2 - Strategic and
Option 1 – Local Measures Environmental Impact
Local Measures
Approach
122 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Transport Infrastructure Framework
Figure 13.5: Southern Link Options
124 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Social & Community infrastructure requirements
Table 14.1: Infrastructure requirements: Daws Hill
Primary Health Care
Buckinghamshire Primary Health Care Trust have confirmed that they would not seek to provide an additional facility within the
study area, but would request a financial contribution to enable existing facilities to accommodate the increase in demand. (At
present the Council’s Developer Contributions SPD Guide does not include any standard charges for primary healthcare).
Pre-School
Using the child yield multipliers in WDC’s developer’s contributions guidance, stage one would generate 24 pre-school age
children. A space should be provided within the development that could accommodate a nursery facility to meet demand form
both Daws Hill and Abbey Barn. We have assumed that this will be provided for within the proposed community centre.
Primary Education
Based on the pupil multipliers set out in the WDC developer contributions SPD the primary age yield of Daws Hill is 167 primary
age pupils. This number of pupils would be insufficient to require a primary school in the first phase, however the nearby schools
of Marsh, Hannah Ball, Beechview and St Augustine’s are all projected to have a deficit of places and therefore, in order to
accommodate the shortfall in existing schools and new pupils from Daws Hill and Abbey Barn South (projected to be 134) a new
primary school should be provided.
This is proposed to be located on the Daws Hill site, adjacent to the neighbourhood green and close to the neighbourhood
centre – which also serves the wider development area. It will be necessary for a developer to hold further discussions with the
education authority regarding the delivery, but in the first instance a one form of entry school (210) pupils might be appropriate
allowing for potential future expansion to when Abbey Barn South is developed or contribution towards expansion of other nearby
schools.
Secondary Education
Based on the pupil multipliers set out in the WDC developer contributions SPD the secondary age yield of the Daws Hill
development would be 116 pupils.
This would not require physical infrastructure on the site but financial contributions towards new school places would be
collected. Contributions towards secondary school places are set out in the Developers contributions – developers guide which is
updated annually. The January 2009 contributions are:
• 2 bed flats - £848
• 2 bed house - £3,052
• 3 bed - £3,052
• 4 & 4+ beds - £4,239
Based on the pupil multipliers set out in the WDC developer contributions SPD the post 16 yield of the Daws Hill development
would be 27 pupils.
This would not require physical infrastructure on the site but financial contributions towards new school places would be
collected. Contributions towards post 16 places are set out in the Developers contributions – developers guide which is updated
annually. The January 2009 contributions are:
• 2 bed flats - £182
• 2 bed house - £728
• 3 bed - £728
• 4 & 4+ beds - £1,092
Policing
Space should be provided within the neighbourhood centre that can be used as a police office if required. Part of the Community
Centre could possibly be used for this purpose.
At the time of writing WDC are not collecting contributions towards the police service but this situation is kept under review.
Fire and Rescue
High Wycombe fire station is due to be relocated, not for operational reasons, but as part of the wider town centre
redevelopment. Location of a new fire station will be determined by wider directions of growth because location of fire station is
governed by statutory response times.
Open Space
The standards for provision have been provided by WDC are based on ha per 1,000 population. The following open space will be
required:
• Amenity green space –
Planning standard 0.4ha/1,000 population
550 dwellings @ 2.5 average = 1,375 population
Minimum requirement 0.55ha (just met)
Parks –
Planning standard 1.71ha/1,000 population
550 dwellings @ 2.5 average = 1,375 population
Minimum requirement 2.35ha (not met on site to be compensated by contribution towards park within the Ride)
• Neighbourhood green
• Woodland walk
• Wooded open space
126 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Social & Community infrastructure requirements
Sports Facilities
• Sports pitches -
Planning standard 1.6ha/1000 population
550 dwellings @ 2.5 average = 1,375 population
Minimum requirement 2.2ha (slightly exceeded)
• 2 senior pitches for rugby or football, near north-south orientation; bund required to screen motorway noise.
• Associated parking
• 2 tennis courts (existing – refurbished)
Play Space
• Play space –
Planning standard 0.8ha/1000 population
450 dwellings @ 2.5 average = 1,375 population
Minimum requirement 1.1ha (not met on site to be compensated by contribution towards facilities in the Ride)
• LEAP within neighbourhood green
Allotments
No additional floor space required. No contribution towards library services from developments within High Wycombe
Community Centres
The Air Cadet Facility currently located on RAF Daws Hill would need to be either retained or reprovided, by incorporating it within
a new Community Centre.
Residential developments of more than four dwellings are expected to make a contribution towards community facilities (WDC
Developers contributions – developers guide 2009).
Community halls would need to meet the Sports England standard of enabling badminton to be played inside them (a minimum
foot print of approximately 24mx16m). WDC is in the process of formulating a new standard for the provision of community
centres based on site population. Although a definitive parameter is to be agreed at this date, it is expected that it would require a
larger gross floor area.
Moreover, the standard will require the location to be within maximum 15 minute walk (that equates to a 750m radius around the
hall, approximately 1,200m distance between hall and house). Using this threshold, one community hall would be sufficient for the
combined site. The most appropriate location would be near the neighbourhood centre and the pitches.
The master plan proposes this facility to be combined with the clubhouses and changing rooms required to support the open
space provision in a single building for both Daws Hill and Abbey Barn. The facility is proposed to be located within the Abbey
Barn development and it is expected to be a small building of architectural merit (see Part Five: Design Guidance).
The applicable standard will be defined at the time of the planning application.
Based on the pupil multipliers set out in the WDC developer contributions SPD the secondary age yield of stage two would be 92
pupils.
This would not require physical infrastructure on the site but financial contributions towards new school places would be
collected. Contributions towards secondary school places are set out in the Developers contributions – developers guide which is
updated annually. The January 2009 contributions are:
• 2 bed flats - £848
• 2 bed house - £3,052
• 3 bed - £3,052
• 4 & 4+ beds - £4,239
Post Sixteen
Based on the pupil multipliers set out in the WDC developer contributions SPD the post 16 yield of stage two would be 21
pupils. This would not require physical infrastructure on the site but financial contributions towards new school places would be
collected. Contributions towards post 16 places are set out in the Developers contributions – developers guide which is updated
annually. The January 2009 contributions are:
• 2 bed flats - £182
• 2 bed house - £728
• 3 bed - £728
• 4 & 4+ beds - £1,092
Policing
Space should be provided within the neighbourhood centre that can be used as a police office if required.
At the time of writing WDC are not collecting contributions towards the police service but this situation is kept under review.
Fire and Rescue
High Wycombe fire station is due to be relocated, not for operational reasons, but as part of the wider town centre
redevelopment. Location of new fire station will be determined by wider directions of growth because location of fire station is
governed by statutory response times.
128 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Social & Community infrastructure requirements
Open Space
The standards for provision have been provided by WDC. The following open space are to be provided in relation to the Abbey
Barn South Development:
• Informal open space –
Planning standard 0.4ha/1,000 population
450 dwellings @ 2.5 average = 1,125 population
Minimum requirement 0.45ha (vastly exceeded)
Parks –
Planning standard 1.71ha/1,000 population
450 dwellings @ 2.5 average = 1,125 population
Minimum requirement 1.92ha (additional to unmet 2.35ha required by Daws Hill development)
• Park within the Ride (approximately 7ha, excluding playspace)
• Green corridor
• Woodland walk
• Business green
Play Space
• Planning standard 0.8ha/1000 population
450 dwellings @ 2.5 average = 1,125 population
Minimum requirement 0.9ha (additional to unmet 1ha required by Daws Hill development)
• LEAP to be provided within green corridor
• NEAP to be provided within Ride
• MUGA to be provided within Ride
Sports Facilities
• Sports pitches -
Planning standard 1.6ha/1000 population
450 dwellings @ 2.5 average = 1,125 population
Minimum requirement 1.8ha (just met)
• Baseball pitch – refurbished to accommodate multiple use and potential STP
• Bowling green within Ride
• 2 tennis courts within Ride
• Sport club within community hall
Allotments
Planning standard 0.21ha/1000 population
450 dwellings @ 2.5 average = 1,125 population
Minimum requirement 0.24ha (additional to unmet 0.29ha required by Daws Hill development)
Allotments south of the ride
No additional floor space required. No contribution towards library services from developments within High Wycombe
Community Centres
The Air Cadet Facility currently located on RAF Daws Hill would need to be either retained or reprovided, by incorporating it within
a new Community Centre.
Residential developments of more than four dwellings are expected to make a contribution towards community facilities (WDC
Developers contributions – developers guide 2009).
Community halls would need to meet the Sports England standard of enabling badminton to be played inside them (a minimum
foot print of approximately 24mx16m). WDC is in the process of formulating a new standard for the provision of community
centres based on site population. Although a definitive parameter is to be agreed at this date, it is expected that it would require a
larger gross floor area.
Moreover, the standard will require the location to be within maximum 15 minute walk (that equates to a 750m radius around the
hall, approximately 1200m distance between hall and house). Using this threshold, one community hall would be sufficient for the
combined site. The most appropriate location would be near the neighbourhood centre and the pitches.
The master plan proposes this facility to be combined with the clubhouses and changing rooms required to support the open
space provision in a single building for both Daws Hill and Abbey Barn. The facility is proposed to be located within the Abbey
Barn development and it is expected to be a small building of architectural merit (see Part Five: Design Guidance).
The applicable standard will be defined at the time of the planning application. Currently a contribution is sought from developers
of £1,520 per sqm (2007 prices) based on 0.3sqm per person (facility provided by Daws Hill development but on land within
Abbey Barn South).
130 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Social & Community infrastructure requirements
132 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Sustainability
• Homes should be designed to the following - Free travel card on occupation of a property on
standards: site;
- Code for Sustainable Homes 5 (6 post 2016); - Information packs about available sustainable
travel;
• Non residential buildings should be designed to the
- Clear information about available routes and
following standards:
destinations at all bus stops;
- BREAAM Excellent;
- Cycling facilities in office buildings;
• Sustainable Drainage Systems, including: - Cycle parking in all public areas (neighbourhood
- Limiting impervious cover to 35% of site maximum; centre, school, sport pitches, for example).
- Porous pavements for all parking areas, driveways - Provision of cycle tracks along the Spine.
and squares;
- Use of green roofs on 80% of non residential Abbey Barn South
buildings and apartment buildings; 15.1.4 All the measures identified above for Daws
- Usage of infiltration techniques (swales, trenches, Hill, except for the CHP plant and network, should
detention basins, etc) associated with soak-aways be expanded to serve the Abbey Barn South site,
and filtration beds to control pollutants. and wood-chip conversion if and when this solution
• Green travel plan for the all land uses and provides a carbon saving. The switch to biomass
encouragement of use of public transport by would need to account for any implications in relation
initiatives such as: to access and parking for regular deliveries of fuel. The
design of the initial CHP plant need to factor this in
from the outset.
Colin Buchanan Wycombe District Council August 2009 133
16.Planning framework
16.1 Planning context
16.1.1 Annual monitoring of development and planning • Taking account of the potential timing of
permissions, together with the recently published development of previously developed sites, there
Strategic Housing Land Availability Assessment is sufficient supply to reach 2019 without any
(SHLAA – March 2009) provide an up to date greenfield release;
assessment of the housing land supply position in the • Additional previously developed sites within the
district. The position as set out in the SHLAA is as SHLAA where there is currently no information on
follows: delivery could result in not requiring any greenfield
• The housing target for the period 2008-26 is of development before at least 2021.
6,832 dwellings (380 dwellings per annum); 16.1.2 Market difficulties make it more difficult than
• The SHLAA identifies 4,688 dwellings on usual to establish a firm and robust position on housing
deliverable/ developable previously developed sites; supply. Moreover, housing targets are likely to be
this corresponds to around 12 years supply of sites, reviewed when the South East Plan is reviewed, but a
including Daws Hill; timetable for this has not been agreed. On this basis,
justification for the release of the Abbey Barn sites
• The SHLAA also identifies potential for 2,190
before 2019 at the earliest is unlikely to be on the basis
dwellings on deliverable/ developable peripheral
of housing land supply.
greenfield sites, including the Abbey Barn sites.
134 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Planning framework
Daws Hill Doolittle Estate
16.1.3 However, as set out in Part One of the study, comprehensive strategic approach to development
there is currently a shortage of quality office space of the M40 Gateway area, the critical mass of
in Wycombe relative to competing towns (Reading, development required to facilitate the delivery of
Slough and Oxford). The short term prospects for transport and social infrastructure, and provision
increasing supply are poor due to market conditions, of new business development, for which there is
although the Delivery and Site Allocations is identifying a strategic justification. If such a comprehensive
potential sites, including at the Sports Centre site. approach is adopted by the Council, the development
The Daws Hill and Abbey Barn site provides a longer of the sites will be expected to deliver the necessary
term opportunity for enhancing the Wycombe offer infrastructure and a high quality development.
on an attractive site in a strategic location. This would
necessitate a strategy for enhancing highway access to 16.2 Planning strategy
the site. The long lead times and high costs associated
with any highway interventions would provide further 16.2.1 The critical mass associated with the phased
justification for a comprehensive approach to the release of the two sites as part of a comprehensively
planning of the two sites. master planned development would deliver the
strategic planning objectives described in Section 12.
16.1.4 The strongest case for the allocation of In addition the development would provide:
the two sites in the Delivery and Site Allocations
• A new ‘neighbourhood’ centre on the Daws Hill
DPD fundamentally relates to the delivery of a
site serving the two developments and the wider
surrounding residential area;
136 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Planning framework
• Abbey Barn South may need to be phased for 16.3.2 Part of the required infrastructure provision
release earlier than evidenced by current housing would need to be provided directly rather than through
land supply, to ensure that the master plan can be a financial contribution.
delivered in a comprehensive way. Should the site
16.3.3 It is essential that key infrastructure is delivered
come forward at completion of Daws Hill, however,
in a timely manner and it is recognised that the
development would commence around 2020, a
justification for a comprehensive development of
similar time to what the current land supply situation
the sites is also justified by the greater potential to
indicates.
deliver infrastructure benefits. However, in the current
• The Council should prepare a Supplementary economic climate, financial contributions towards
Planning Document covering the entire master plan infrastructure provision may be challenging for some
area. The SPD would: developers. The Council may wish to consider applying
- Identify site boundaries; some flexibility towards the charging regime applied to
- Specify the mix of uses (and associated floorspace the early phases of development. For example, where
for non residential uses); possible the Council could request payment in kind or
- Apply the affordable housing and housing mix provision of land and premises for community facilities
policy to the sites; where cash payments may ordinarily be requested.
- Identify the specific infrastructure requirements Alternatively, if justified, the Council may allow some
and their relationship to the development in terms of deferral or phased payments of contributions towards
phasing, delivery and funding; infrastructure that is not required in advance of
- Set out the design principles for the development development.
including landscaping, accessibility, integration
16.3.4 Particular attention will need to be given to
and connectivity between the two sites and
the level of developer contribution sought from each
with surrounding areas, density and form of
of the developments to the provision of strategic
development;
off-site infrastructure. These impacts will need to be
- Provide further site specific guidance on
looked at in combination as the aggregate impacts of
developer contributions towards on-site and off site
a comprehensive development will result in a different
infrastructure.
package of proposed solutions for mitigation than
would be the outcome of assessing the impacts of
16.3 Developer contributions each site in isolation.
16.3.1 Wycombe District Council has an up to date
Developer Contributions SPD. The scope for collecting 16.4 Housing mix
developer contributions towards infrastructure
16.4.1 The Wycombe LDF Core Strategy Affordable
requirements generated by Daws Hill and Abbey Barn
Housing and Housing Mix Policy states that ‘New
(in accordance with the SPD) is summarised in Section
housing developments will be expected to provide for
18 of this report. Significantly, the Council is committed
a mix of dwelling size, type and tenure that meet the
to ensuring the SPD remains up to date so that
identified housing needs of the community, including a
contributions are collected and allocated in accordance
significant proportion of smaller dwellings’.
with identified need. Where this study has identified
infrastructure needs for which there may be no 16.4.2 The Buckinghamshire Strategic Housing Market
identified source of funding or mechanism for delivery, Assessment (SHMA) does not provide indications for
the Council may wish to consider a partial review of the mix of private dwellings by size or type. This will
the SPD on developer contributions to address this largely be determined by market demand. However,
deficiency.
• 1 bed/ 2 person flat - 35% 16.5.6 The master plan includes only around 70%
of the calculated retail projections set out in Table
• 2 bed/ 4 person flat - 35% 16.2. This is to ensure that the development does not
• 2 bed/ 4 person house - 15% compete with other sequentially preferable locations,
including High Wycombe Town Centre and Flackwell
• 3 bed/ 5 or 6 person house - 15%
Heath District Centre.. For this same reason, no large
• 4 or more bed/ 6-8 person house - 0% convenience shopping unit is to be provided on site,
with a grocery store limited to basket shopping.
16.5 Retail provision 16.5.7 In addition, recent up to date retail projection
16.5.1 PPS6 requires retail provision to be subject to for the town as a whole (Nathanial Lichfield and
a sequential test, with town centre and edge of town Partners, 2009), show that there is very limited scope
centre sites being the priority locations. However, for additional convenience and comparison retail
policies elsewhere on sustainable urban extensions floorspace provision across the town in the short to
require that they provide an appropriate level of retail, medium term, and limited scope right up to 2026 in
leisure, social, cultural, community and health facilities terms of convenience floorspace.
that meet local needs but do not compete with the 16.5.8 Floorspace requirements are calculated by
town centre. average annual spend by retail type subdivided by
sales values per square metre of sale area.
138 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Planning framework
Table 16.1: Residential population
DEVELOPMENT % BY SIZE BEDROOMS OCCUPANTS NUMBER OF PEOPLE
New
1,100 20 4 4 880
1,100 40 3 3.5 1,540
1,100 30 2 2.5 825
1,100 10 1 1.5 165
Existing
600 60 4 3 1,440
600 40 3 2.6 840
Total 5,690
Notes:
• Assumes 80% of Convenience, 15% of Comparison, 80% of Retail Services, 25% of Meals &
Drinks, 80% of Comparison of Convenience Nature is spent locally by residents.
• Assumes 10% of Convenience, 0% of Comparison, 10% of Retail Services, 25% of Meals & Drinks,
10% of Comparison of Convenience Nature is spent by workers.
• Assumes a convenience expenditure growth rate of 0.8%, a comparison expenditure growth rate of
4.5%, a retail services expenditure growth rate of 1.8%, a meals and drinks expenditure growth rate
of 1.8%, a comparison of convenience nature expenditure growth rate of 4.5%.
• Assumes a convenience productivity growth rate of 0.8%, a comparison productivity growth rate of
2%, a retail services productivity growth rate of 0.8%, a meals and drinks productivity growth rate of
0.8%, a comparison of convenience nature productivity growth rate of 0.8%.
142 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Phasing
Abbey Barn South
1 concludes to ensure that the continued viability however, that employment is not left as a later phase,
of the public transport, education, social and retail and the Council may wish to consider how to secure
infrastructure provided as part of the first phase of the delivery of employment in policy terms. It is also
development is not undermined. essential that the timing of the development of a
strategic employment (office) allocation is not prejudicial
17.1.4 The timing of Phase 2b is largely dependent
to the bringing forward of town centre office allocations
upon the viability and deliverability of the options. This
and office allocations on more sustainable sites.
will be related to the demand for office space within
the High Wycombe area. Current market conditions 17.1.5 The recovery of the housing market will be
would not suggest that there will be sufficient demand essential to underpin the school relocation option,
in the short to medium terms to warrant an early which is necessary to provide the required funding.
release. However in the longer term as the economy This option would also be determined by the school’s
recovers the town would benefit from a strategic ability to raise its own finance to enable to move. This
employment allocation to improve its offer to the is likely to take a number of years.
market. The phasing of this release is difficult to predict
17.1.6 Abbey Barn North should be treated as a
and will probably emerge from future employment land
reserve site in the Delivery and Site Allocations DPD,
reviews to be undertaken by the Council. However,
to be brought forward if and when required. Its
it is unlikely that a commercial development scheme
relationship – in terms of the timing of its release – is
would be a viable proposition in isolation from the
not strongly dependent on the other two sites, with the
wider housing development and so is unlikely to come
only direct impacts being in relation to potential off site
forward in advance of Phase 2a. It will be important,
highway works on Abbey Barn Lane.
Colin Buchanan Wycombe District Council August 2009 143
18.Infrastructure
phasing
18.1 Overview
18.1.1 The timing and phasing of infrastructure is undevelopable land on Abbey Barn South is utilised for
important to provide residents with the quality of life the provision of public open space to meet some of the
they expect, to help reduce unnecessary travel and to requirements associated with Daws Hill. Some open
build a community. space required to support development at Daws Hill
may need to be brought forward on Abbey Barn South
18.1.2 The infrastructure framework for the master plan
in advance of its release for development. Conversely,
is based on a shared provision of physical, social and
early provision of social and community infrastructure
green infrastructure across the Daws Hill and Abbey
including a primary school and community centre as
Barn Sites. This will be the most efficient and effective
part of the Daws Hill development will also meet the
way to provide high quality facilities to this area.
requirements associated with the Abbey Barn South
181.3 The alternative – a requirement for each site to development.
provide only for that infrastructure required to support
18.1.5 This complementarity and interdependency
the level of development it generates – fails to capitalise
between the two sites provides a strong argument
on the ability to secure added value from the synergies
for bringing forward the development of Abbey
between the two sites and the wider M40 Gateway
Barn South in advance of when its release may be
area, as outlined in Section 17.
triggered by housing land availability, provided all
18.1.4 The provision of green infrastructure is perhaps the necessary infrastructure is provided. Failure to
the most obvious example, whereby the large area of deliver the infrastructure undermines the case for
144 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Infrastructure phasing
Marlow Hill
Single form entry primary school. Possible expansion of school to 2 form entry or contribution to schools off site.
Parks: Parks:
• Neighbourhood Green (incl. LEAP). • Park within the Ride (7ha excluding playspace).
• Woodland Walk (partial). • Green Corridor.
• Wooded Open Space (incidental). • Woodland Walk.
Modular CHP plant and distribution system. Extension to CHP plant and possible conversion to woodchip biomass.
146 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Infrastructure phasing
18.2 Infrastructure delivery
18.2.1 The necessary infrastructure will need to be 18.2.2 It is important to emphasise that the
delivered through a combination of service providers infrastructure requirements (particularly in relation to
and the developer. The exact mechanism for certain transport and highways) would not necessarily be
facilities will have to be agreed at the planning based on the financial contributions indicated in the
application stage, but the table below sets out who we Developer Contribution SPD. They should be primarily
anticipate would deliver different facilities. based on providing what it is identified as necessary to
mitigate the development’s impacts and provide a high
quality sustainable neighbourhood.
148 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Viability
19.2.2 Where infrastructure is not to be provided 19.3.2 The land value of Daws Hill would need to take
directly, financial contributions have been calculated on account of the following issues:
the basis of the Developer Contributions SPD, or on
• The site is an identified brownfield site within
experience of similar contributions elsewhere.
the Delivery and Site Allocations DPD. The Core
19.2.3 On the basis of these assumptions, and using Strategy has a brownfield first approach. With
current market values for sale and current finance that in mind, a potential purchaser would see the
costs, both sites show positive residual values and a site as a potential short/medium term residential
medium level of surplus. development opportunity.
• Although the site is an identified brownfield site at
19.3 Land values the edge of the urban area with a strong likelihood
19.3.1 In this market condition and given the specific of achieving planning permission, there is no
nature and location of the sites, an estimation of the permission currently in place. There is always a risk,
level at which the sites might transact at in the open where planning permission has not been granted,
market is a highly subjective task, which is likely to that permission might not be granted, or might be
result in a broad range of possible values potentially granted for a lower value use/scheme. There will be
being negotiated between current use value and hope a time period before permission is granted.
value for the sites. The current freeholders will have
their own views as to the planning prospects and the
ultimate value of their land.
150 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Viability
19.4.2 The sensitivity analysis provides an 19.5 Conclusions
understanding of how changes in market conditions
and development characteristics could impact upon 19.5.1 The viability study highlights the following:
the scheme’s viability and the potential for the scheme • In current market condition it is difficult to ascertain
to deliver further infrastructure contributions through the value of both the land and of development, and
any potential surplus. market-standard methods of assessment (based on
19.4.3 By way of example a 20% increase in sales current costs and values) become subjective and
values combined with a 10% increase in construction unreliable. This is particularly the case for a major
costs could increase the appraisal outcomes by development phased over at least a 10 year period;
around 50%. A 20% increase in residential sales • Nevertheless both sites show a positive outcome,
values combined with a 20% increase in development based on the parameters of this framework;
density produces an appraisal outcome which is more
• Sensitivity testing of options and design/ value
than double. Grant funding of the affordable housing
variables indicate a great variation of appraisal
component could also increase the baseline appraisal
outcomes.
outcome by 40-50%.
19.5.2 In the current market, lower sales values, site
19.4.4 A variety of other external funding sources
specific constraints including proposed and potential
should also be investigated including funding
infrastructure and sustainability measures have a
for transport initiatives including national funding
significant impact on residual values. However, given
initiatives, Regional Funding Advice and local funding
the timescales involved in the development of these
programmes.
sites, expected market improvement within this time
19.4.5 Other additional costs (off-site infrastructure, period, and other potential means of improving the
CHP and higher Code Levels) have been assessed value of the development, delivery of these sites should
as a broad range because solutions are as yet be achievable in the medium to longer term.
undetermined. These are set out in Appendix 3. It is
19.5.3 This framework provides guidance and
recommended that, at the time of development, an
direction for future ‘open book’ discussions between
‘open book’ discussion is initiated between developers
the Council and developers.
and the Council, so that an appropriate scheme is
identified within the parameters of this framework, that
ensures that the necessary infrastructure is provided.
154 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Design guidance
156 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Design guidance
20.1.5 Apartment building included in the Ride to be of • Each apartment to have private amenity space and
exceptional quality. access to multi-functional communal amenity space.
158 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Design guidance
160 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Design guidance
162 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Design guidance
164 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Design guidance
166 M40 Gateway Daws Hill and Abbey Barn Area Planning and Infrastrucure Framework August 2009
Design guidance