Anda di halaman 1dari 1

Heriot-Watt University

EPS Chemical Engineering B47AD-2016_2017: Foundation Engineering B Assignment 2

B47AD-2016_2017: Foundation Engineering B


Assignment 2 – Newspaper Article – Peer Review

Student

Title of Article

Reviewer Date

Topics to Mark
ARTICLE OVERALL:

HEADLINE:

Did the headline summarise the story in one sentence?

Content:

Did the content catch your attention - what is interesting/useful?


Did the “journalists” convince you that their story was important – did it have impact?
Did the article give you the basic facts - who, what, when, why?

FORMAT:

Did each paragraph stand alone - stories are cut from the bottom up by editor.
Did the article highlight strengths and limitations of the technology under discussion

UNDERSTANDABILITY:

Did the “journalists” use easily understandable comparisons?


Could the article have been understood by a person aged 12 to 15?

Reviewers should add comments on individual sections above for feedback purposes.

Overall Grade

Please return this sheet to Assistant Professor Collie