Anda di halaman 1dari 2

BASIS QUALITATIVE RESEARCH BOTH QUANTITATIVE RESEARCH

Belief Belief that the world is not Belief that we inhabit a


stable, coherent and uniform. relatively stable, uniform, and
Rather, meaning is situated in coherent world (single reality)
a particular perspective or what we can measure,
context, and thus, there are understand, and generalize. The
multiple realities, none of purpose is to explain, predict,
which is more valid or true and/or control phenomena
than another. The purpose is through focused collection of
to explain and gain insight and numerical data.
understanding of phenomena Test hypotheses, deductive.
through intensive collection of
narrative data. Generate
hypotheses to be tested,
inductive
Approach to Inductive, value-laden Deductive, value-free
Inquiry (subjective), holistic, process (objective), focused, outcome
oriented oriented

Hypothesis Tentative, evolving, based on Specific, testable, stated prior to


particular study particular study

Review of Limited Extensive Does significantly


Related Does not significantly affect affect particular study
literature particular study

Research Naturalistic (as is) to the Controlled to the degree


Setting degree possible possible

Sampling Purposive: Intent to select Random: Intent to select


“small,” not necessarily “large,” representative sample
representative, sample in order in order to generalize results to
to acquire in-depth a population
understanding

Measurements Non-standardized, narrative, Standardized, numerical, at the


ongoing end

Tools of Both
Measurements qualitative and
quantitative
research are
used to
measure the
results of
data.

Design and Flexible, specified only in Structured, inflexible, specified


Methods general terms in advance of in detail in advance of study
study Nonintervention, minimal
disturbance Intervention, manipulation, and
All Descriptive— History, control Descriptive Correlation
Biography, Ethnography, Causal-Comparative
Phenomenology, Grounded Experimental Consider few
Theory, Case Study, (hybrids variables, large group
of these) Consider many
variable, small group
Both seek to
relate data
analysis to
research
already
published

Data Document and Artifact Observation (non-participant)


Collection Collection Observation Interviews and Focus Groups
Strategies (participant, non-participant) (semi-structured, formal)
Interviews/Focus Groups (un- Administration of tests and
/structured, in-/formal) questionnaires
Administration of
questionnaires (open ended)
Taking of extensive, detailed
field notes

Both are
concerned
about data
reduction

Data Analysis Raw data are in words Raw data are numbers
Essentially ongoing, involves Performed at end of study,
synthesis involves statistics

Data Conclusions tentative, reviewed Conclusions and generalizations


Interpretation on an ongoing basis, formulated at end of study,
generalizations speculative or stated with predetermined
nonexistent degree of certainty
Inferences/generalizations are Inferences/generalizations are
the reader’s or consumer’s the researcher’s responsibility
responsibility. Never 100% certain of our
findings.

Both argue for


the importance
of
transparency.
Both are
concerned with
the variation.
Both treat
frequencies as
a springboard
for analysis
Both seek to
ensure that
deliberate
distortions do
not occur

Anda mungkin juga menyukai