Advanced Applications in
Power System Protection
Topics
• Radial versus non-radial lines.
• Worked Examples
1
Radial versus Nonradial Lines – Terminals and Sources
• Terminal
– A terminal is a connection point that is a source of current to the line.
In general, current flowing from all terminals must be interrupted to
clear a fault.
– Lines can have one, two, three or even more terminals
• Ground Sources
– Tapped load-serving transformers are not generally considered positive-
sequence sources.
• Negligible fault current would be supplied from the radial feeders supplied by
the transformer.
2
Zones of Protection and Device Coordination
• Objective of coordination is to
assure that primary protections
assigned to an element (or terminal)
operate first to clear a fault before
other backup protections operate.
OVERCURRENT
• On network systems, coordination RELAY
• For a given relay pickup setting, the distance along the line for which an
overcurrent relay will detect a fault is reduced as the source is weakened,
such as removing one transformer.
OVERCURRENT RELAY “REACH” WITH TWO
TRANSFORMERS IN SERVICE
OVERCURRENT
RELAY
3
End of Zone Uncertainty of Operation
OVERCURRENT
• A common end-of-zone reach criterion RELAY
4
Coordinating Time Interval (CTI)
5
Device Application and Setting Considerations
Application of Fuses
• Fuses often used where the cost of a circuit breaker or
circuit switcher plus associated battery, relaying,
enclosures, etc. is not justifiable.
– Small power transformers
– Small capacitor banks
– Distribution circuit side taps
maximum voltage. 15 23
20 30
• The maximum voltage is
25 38
typically from 5 to 14% above
30 45
the nominal voltage.
40 60*
• Continuous current ratings for 50 75*
EEI-NEMA fuse links are 65 95
given to the right. 80 120**
100 150**
* Only when used in a 100 or 200 A cutout 140 190
** Only when used in a 200 A cutout
200 200
ECE-5522 Distribution Line/Feeder Prot. 12
6
Device Application and Setting Considerations
Application of Fuses 15K (fast) Fuse MMT and TCT Curves
Fuse Characteristics
• Fuses have a maximum melt characteristic
(MMT) defined by a current vs. time curve
above which the fuse element may be
damaged, permanently altering its
characteristic.
7
ECE-5522 Distribution Line/Feeder Prot. 15
8
Setting Considerations for Phase Relays
Highest Short-Time or Transient Load Current
• Current pickup must be greater
than the maximum phase (load) Must carry the load.
current during normal or
contingency conditions.
9
Setting Considerations for Ground Relays
Maximum Load Unbalance
• Current pickup must be greater than Must carry expected
the maximum expected unbalance in
the system. unbalance.
10
Setting and Coordination Criteria
Phase Inverse-Time Overcurrent Relays (51, 67)
Following are general criteria applicable to
most situations.
11
Coordination Examples
12
Overcurrent Schemes – Coordination
Coordination
Example 1
Relay A Pickup:
CTI = 0.4
Relay B Pickup
CTI = 0.4
Relay C Pickup
13
HV BUS A HV BUS B
Coordination Example 2
Time 51B/A
8500 A
NO
LV BUS A
51B/A 51/F1
8500 A
51/F2
FEEDERS
CTI
Bus Relay
Operate Time
Feeder Relay
Operate Time
0
0 8500A Current
ECE-5522 Distribution Line/Feeder Prot. 27
14
Coordination Example 2 with Double Circuit Fault
Assume there is a downstream HV BUS A HV BUS B
6000 A
51B/A LV BUS A
NO
LV BUS B
51/F1 51/F2
Feeder Relay 3000 A 3000 A
Operate Time 51/F1
FEEDERS
Bus Relay
Operate Time
MISCOORDINATION FOR
DOUBLE-CIRCUIT
FEEDER FAULT
0
0 3000A 6000A 8500A Current
Time
51B/A
CTI 51B/A
6000 A
NO
LV BUS A LV BUS B
Bus Relay
Operate Time 51/F1 51/F2
51/F1 3000 A 3000 A
FEEDERS
Feeder Relay
Operate Time
Miscoordination resolved by
coordinating bus relay with
slower feeder relay OT.
0
0 3000A 6000A Current
15
Example 2 Double Circuit Fault with
Creative Relay Logic Solution
DO
XMTR2
TRIP
50/F2 PU FEEDER 2
DO
16
Coordination Example 2 with Sequential Circuit Fault
HV BUS A HV BUS B
51/F1
Time
51B/A
51B/A
8500 A
NO
LV BUS A
51/F1 51/F2
6000
8500 A
A
Bus Relay Op Time 6000 A
FEEDERS
F2 Relay Op Time
CTI
F1 Relay Op Time Miscoordination resolved by
coordinating bus relay with
the sum of F1 and F2 feeder
relay OTs.
0
0 6000A Current
17
Additional Topics
• DG/DR Considerations
• Load Encroachment
• In a fuse-saving scheme,
breakers or reclosers are set
fast to trip before the fuse
operates and then
automatically reclose.
18
Distribution Line Protection – Reclosing
Fuse Blowing Schemes
• Where feeders loads are
sensitive to momentary outages
and significant disruption occurs
if the line is momentarily
deenergized, a fuse blowing
scheme limits the number of
main feeder trip/reclose cycles.
DG/DR Considerations
19
DG/DR Considerations – Faults at F1
• For protective devices beyond the DR, the available current for faults at F1
will be greater than without the DR.
• Results in more circuit coverage from the protective device, which may or
may not be desirable. Device coverage may extend through additional
lateral circuits and possibly require greater operating times to coordinate.
• Coordinating devices on
the upstream side of the
DR will be subject to infeed
effects, resulting in a larger
coordination interval.
20
DG/DR Considerations – Faults at F3
• Faults on adjacent
feeders (location F3)
show effects similar to
both of the previous
faults.
• Backup protection from the substation breaker may have trouble with
coverage of circuit 1 due to infeed from circuit 2.
21
Load Encroachment Torque Control Using a
Mho Circle Characteristic Element
50/51
51 Relay Trip Region
(Assuming tripping at
50MVA)
LE Restrain
51 Relay No Trip Region (No Trip) Region
LE Restrain (Assuming tripping at
(No Trip) Region 50MVA)
22
Load Encroachment Torque Control Using a
Numerical Load Encroachment Element (R-X Plane View)
50/51
Transformer
LE Restrain impedance LE Restrain
(No Trip) Region (No Trip) Region
23
Voltage Applications
Voltage Applications
VT Connections – 3PH, 4-Wire Systems
24
Voltage Applications
VT Connections – 3PH, 3-Wire Systems Using 2 VTs
Voltage Applications
Zero Sequence Voltage Filter for Ground OV Sensing.
25
Questions?
26