..
ro 12
~
0~
·a 13
-
u..... ·-ro
.~ u 14 When answering the following questions and filling out this Verdict Form, please follow
!::J4-<
Vl 0
ou
·-
Vl
Q)
.....
ro .....
1-<
.....
Vl
15 the directions provided throughout the form. Your answer to each question must be unanimous.
..... 0 16 Some of the questions contain legal terms that are defined and explained in detail in the Jury
~Q) aQ)
:::: ...c: 17 Instructions. Please refer to the Jury Instructions if you are unsure about the meaning or usage of
r:: t
::::::> 0
z 18 any legal term that appears in the questions below.
20 I. DIRECT INFRINGEMENT
21 1. Has Opticurrent proven that it is more likely than not that Power Integrations literally
22 infringes claim 1 of the '623 patent? (A "YES" answer is a finding for Opticurrent. A "NO"
24
25 /
YES - - - NO - - -
26
lfyour answer to question 1 is "YES," go to Question 3. If your answer to question 1
27 is "NO," go to Question 2.
28
Case 3:17-cv-03597-EMC Document 285 Filed 02/25/19 Page 2 of 3
2 2. Has Opticurrent proven that it is more likely than not that the accused products infringe
3 under the Doctrine of Equivalents? (A "YES" answer is a finding for Opticurrent. A "NO" answer
4 is a finding for Power Integrations.) If you answered "YES" in Question 1, you may skip this
5 question.
7 YES _ __
/ NO - - -
10 3. Has Opticurrent proven that it is more likely than not that Power Integrations induces
11 infringement of claim 1 of the ' 623 patent? (A "YES" answer is a finding for Opticurrent. A
........
0
14 YES _ __ No_L_
i:St>
.......
Cl) 1-o
15
II) .....
..... Cl)
(lj .......
..... Cl
(/)
16 IV. FINDINGS ON DAMAGES (IF APPLICABLE)
"0
II)
E
II)
.~ ...t:: 17 If you answered "YES" to any of Questions 1-3, proceed to answer the remaining
s:: t:
::J 0
z 18 questions. If you answered "NO" to all Questions 1-3, then do not answer the remaining
21
22 (a) on-going royalty payment of (1) $ _ _ _ [per unit sold] or (2) 3 % of sales
26
27 You have now reached the end ofthe verdict form and should review it to ensure it
28 accurately reflects your unanimous determinations. Please have the jury foreperson sign and date
2
Case 3:17-cv-03597-EMC Document 285 Filed 02/25/19 Page 3 of 3
the verdict form below. The jury foreperson should then notify the Courtroom Deputy that you
2 have reached a verdict. The jury foreperson should retain possession of the verdict form and bring
4
5
6 Dated:
7
8
9
10
11
ell 12
§ ·a
o..s 13
U:..:::
...... ell
.~
,be.;...
u 14
Cll 0
Cit>
·t::
Cl)
15
(I) ......
...... Cll
ell ......
.... C) 16
~(I) E
(I)
·"'t::= ..c:: 17
t:
~ 0
z 18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
3