Anda di halaman 1dari 8

Practice n

Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder


in a Nursing Context by Marissa L. Bowsfield and Joti Samra

Introduction Being aware of the causes and Criterion B: Intrusion Symptoms


symptoms of PTSD will enhance The traumatic event is persistently
Post-traumatic stress disorder
the degree to which Occupational re-experienced in the following
(PTSD) is a mental health disorder
Health nurses are able to contrib- way(s): (one required)
that is classified as a trauma-and
ute to the psychological health of 1. Recurrent, involuntary, and
stressor-related disorder by the
affected employees. intrusive memories. Traumatic
American Psychiatric Association’s
Diagnostic and Statistical Manual nightmares.
Diagnostic Criteria 2. Dissociative reactions (e.g.,
of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition
(DSM-V). The twelve-month prev- Post-traumatic stress disorder flashbacks) which may occur
alence rate among adults is results from exposure to a trau- on a continuum from brief epi-
estimated at 3.5%, and lifetime risk matic event, with symptoms that sodes to complete loss of con-
is estimated at 8.7% (APA, 2013). fall in four clusters: sciousness.
PTSD can occur at any age after • intrusion 3. Intense or prolonged distress
the first year of life, and symptoms • avoidance after exposure to traumatic
are typically evident within the • negative alterations in cogni- reminders.
first three months after exposure tion and mood; and, 4. Marked physiologic reactivity
to the traumatic event. Howev- • alternations in arousal and reac- after exposure to trauma-relat-
er, it is possible for the onset of tivity. ed stimuli.
PTSD symptoms to emerge sev-
The American Psychiatric Associa- Criterion C: Avoidance
eral months or even years after
tion (APA, 2013) criteria for PTSD
the event; this is referred to as include the following: Persistent effortful avoidance of
“delayed expression” (APA, 2013). distressing trauma-related stimuli
Criterion A: Stressor after the event: (one required)
Workplace Incidence and Impact 1. Trauma-related thoughts or
The person was exposed to:
Occupational Health nurses may feelings.
death, threatened death, actual or
encounter PTSD or PTSD-related 2. Trauma-related external remind-
threatened serious injury, or actual
symptoms in employees as the or threatened sexual violence, as ers (e.g., people, places, con-
result of critical incidents or emer- follows: (one required) versations, activities, objects, or
gencies in the workplace. The 1. Direct exposure. situations).
International Labour Organization 2. Witnessing, in person.
identifies a range of situations that Criterion D: Negative Alterations
3. Indirectly, by learning that a
in Cognition and Mood
may occur in the workplace that close relative or close friend
have the potential to put employ- was exposed to trauma. If the Negative alterations in cognition
ees at risk for PTSD, including event involved actual or threat- and mood that began or wors-
violence or threat of violence, sui- ened death, it must have been ened after the traumatic event:
cide, inter-employee violence and violent or accidental. (two required)
crime, fatal or severe injury, and 4. Repeated or extreme indirect 1. Inability to recall key features of
sudden death or medical incident exposure to aversive details of the traumatic event (usually dis-
(Braverman, 2011). the event(s), usually in the course sociative amnesia; not due to
Although psychological symp- of professional duties (e.g., first head injury, alcohol, or drugs).
toms related to PTSD are generally responders, collecting body 2. Persistent (and often distorted)
closely associated with the traumat- parts; professionals repeated- negative beliefs and expecta-
ic event, response factors relating ly exposed to details of child tions about oneself or the world
to environment and care after the abuse). This does not include (e.g., “I am bad,” “The world is
incident can work to exacerbate indirect non-professional expo- completely dangerous”).
or attenuate negative psychologi- sure through electronic media, 3. Persistent distorted blame of
cal outcomes (Braverman, 2011). television, movies, or pictures. self or others for causing the

26 OOHNA JOURNAL n Fall/winter 2015


Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder in a Nursing Context n Practice

traumatic event or for resulting the most effective treatment around problems and coping
consequences. approach involves a combination methods.
4. Persistent negative trauma- of psychological treatment and psy- • Although PD has good face
related emotions (e.g., fear, chopharmacological intervention. validity, it is not considered a
horror, anger, guilt, or shame). The International Society for psychological treatment nor
5. Markedly diminished interest in Traumatic Stress Studies (ISST) pro- should it be used as a substitute
(pre-traumatic) significant activ- vides Treatment Guidelines that are for psychological treatment;
ities. available at: http://www.istss.org/ randomized control trials have
6. Feeling alienated from others treating-trauma/effective-treat- not found PD to be effective in
(e.g., detachment or estrange- ments-for-ptsd,-2nd-edition.aspx. significantly reducing trauma-
ment). The individual Treatment Guide- related distress or preventing
7. Constricted affect: persistent lines address 18 specific areas, long-term psychopathology. PD
inability to experience positive and were developed in 2005 was widely advocated for use
emotions. under the auspices of the Post- as a group and individual inter-
traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) vention in the 1980s and 1990s.
Criterion E: Alterations in Treatment Guidelines Task Force Overall, the quality of studies
Arousal and Reactivity established by the Board of Direc- that examine the efficacy of
Trauma-related alterations in tors of the International Society for debriefing is poor.
arousal and reactivity that began Traumatic Stress Studies (ISTSS). “Studies included since the first
or worsened after the traumatic [Editor’s note: In 2015, the ISST edition’s guidelines support and
event: (two required) initiated the process of updating strengthen the original conclusion
1. Irritable or aggressive behaviour the ISTSS Treatment Guidelines that there is no evidence to suggest
2. Self-destructive or reckless and Complex Trauma Treatment that single-session individual PD is
behaviour Guidelines.] effective in the prevention of post-
3. Hypervigilance The following is a summary of traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)
4. Exaggerated startle response the level of evidence for those 18 symptoms shortly after a traumatic
5. Problems in concentration areas applicable to adults (Foa, event or in the prevention of longer-
6. Sleep disturbance Keane, Friedman & Cohen, 2009) term psychological sequelae (Level
Criteria F, G, and H require that [note: for the purpose of this arti- A). There remains an absence of
the symptoms persist for greater cle, the areas applicable to chil- evidence with regard to group PD.”
than one month; they result in dren and teens are not included.]: (p.539-540)
significant symptom-related dis- Guideline 1: Psychological Debrief- Guideline 3: Early Cognitive-Behav-
tress or functional impairment in ing (PD) for Adults ioural Interventions for Adults
important areas of function (e.g., • PD (or critical incident stress • Early cognitive-behavioural inter-
social functioning, occupational debriefing) is typically a single- ventions utilize strategies includ-
functioning); and, the symptoms session, semi-structured group ing psychoeducation, stress
are not the result of medications, intervention method that takes management skills training, cog-
substance use or other illness. place following a traumatic nitive therapy, and exposure
Symptoms may also include event; it is designed to reduce therapy to prevent the develop-
dissociative symptoms in reaction and prevent negative and ment of PTSD in the time imme-
to trauma-related stimuli. Deper- unwanted psychological conse- diately following (weeks, months)
sonalization is the experience of quences of involvement in or involvement in or exposure to a
being an outside observer of or exposure to a traumatic event by traumatic event.
detached from oneself (e.g., feel- encouraging emotional process- • These early interventions
ing as if “this is not happening to ing through the normalization should continue for 5-12 weeks
me”, or, as if one were in a dream)
of reactions and preparation for following the event, with ses-
and derealisation is the experi-
future experiences. sions ranging from 60-90 min-
ence of unreality, distance, or dis-
• PD should take place shortly utes each.
tortion (e.g., “things are not real”).
after the traumatic event and • Evidence from several ran-
be based on an accurate and domized control trials study-
Effective Treatments
current evaluation of the need ing a variety of traumatic events
Effective, evidence-based treat- of those affected; interventions (e.g., motor vehicle accidents,
ments exist for PTSD. For most should consider culture, devel- industrial accidents, nonsexu-
individuals suffering from PTSD, opmental level, and local norms al assaults) among men and

OOHNA JOURNAL n Fall/winter 2015 27


Practice n Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder in a Nursing Context

women found early cognitive- self-dialogue, and thought has received support as treatments
behavioural interventions to be stopping. SIT may also utilize for PTSD.... neither Dialectical
robust in reducing PTSD symp- exposure techniques. Behaviour Therapy nor Acceptance
toms and preventing chronic n Cognitive therapy (CT) is and Commitment Therapy has
PTSD. However, among female based on the premise that received support as an effective
nonsexual assault victims, these it is an individual’s interpre- treatment for PTSD.“ (P.551-554)
interventions hastened recov- tation of an event, not the
Guideline 6: Psycho-pharmacother-
ery but did not provide lasting event itself, that predicts
apy for Adults 
advantages over an assess- emotional reactions; CT
ment-only condition. • A range of pharmacotherapy treat-
involves the identification
ments exists for PTSD that target
“CBT is recommended as an early of erroneous or problemat-
different neurobiological mecha-
intervention for survivors of relative- ic thoughts, the evaluation
nisms, including the adrenergic,
ly discrete accidents who endorse of evidence for and against
hypothalamic-pituitary-adreno-
significant, enduring posttraumat- these thoughts, and the con-
cortical (HPA), serotonergic, glu-
ic difficulties in the aftermath of sideration of whether they
tamatergic, gamma-aminobutyric
trauma. It is more difficult to draw are the product of biases or
acid (GABA)-ergic, and dopami-
definitive recommendations from errors in an effort to develop
nergic systems. Serotonergic
studies that include both physical more useful and/or realistic
drugs that are used as antide-
and sexual assault survivors because thoughts.
pressants are commonly used
the efficacy data from these are • CBT interventions are typically
with PTSD patients (e.g., selec-
less compelling at this time. In the short-term individual programs
tive serotonin reuptake inhibi-
early aftermath of trauma (days lasting for 8-12 sessions, at 60-90
tors (SSRIs), monoamine oxidase
and weeks), treatment with CBT minutes each. CBT often involves
inhibitors (MAOIs), and tricyclic
should only be provided to sexual the completion of homework
antidepressants (TCAs).
assault and nonsexual assault survi- tasks between sessions.
• Pharmacotherapy treatments
vors following a period of sustained • The evidence supporting the
for PTSD should last for at
monitoring and support.” (p.547) effectiveness of CBT in treating
least 8-12 weeks; recent studies
and preventing PTSD is robust.
Guideline 4: Cognitive-Behavioural involving SSRIs indicate that the
Randomized control trials have
Therapy for Adults maximum benefit of drug treat-
found exposure therapy to be
• Cognitive-behavioural thera- ments may not be achieved
particularly effective across
pies (CBT) encompass a range until the 36th week.
numerous studies with a wide
of different treatments, includ- • The strongest evidence for the
range of affected samples.
ing exposure therapy, sys- use of pharmacotherapy for
tematic desensitization, stress “There is strong support for the PTSD exists for different classes
inoculation training (SIT), cog- efficacy of individual exposure of antidepressants.
nitive therapy, and combination therapy administered to a range
“The strength of the evidence is
treatments. of trauma populations (men and
best for the different classes of
n Exposure therapy involves a women; survivors of military trauma,
antidepressant agents tested in
series of procedures aimed physical and sexual assault, child-
most of the randomized clinical
at helping individuals con- hood sexual abuse, motor vehicle
trials (RCTs) on pharmacotherapy.
front negative or harmful accidents, political violence....there
There is also good evidence from
thoughts or stimuli that are is consistent support for cognitive
augmentation trials with atypical
feared and/or avoided. processing therapy... Support for
antipsychotic agents. Finally, there
n Systematic desensitiza- the efficacy of SIT is mixed but
are encouraging results with the
tion involves the pairing of generally supportive, particularly
antiadrenergic agent, prazosin,
trauma-related memories among female sexual assault vic-
the antidepressant, mirtazapine,
and thoughts with muscle tims.... CT was found to be effective
and older antidepressants, such as
relaxation with the goal of in reducing posttrauma symptoms
MAOIs and TCAs.” (p.564)
inhibiting fear. and received support from two con-
n SIT is an anxiety manage- trolled studies of civilian traumas.... Guideline 8: Eye Movement Desen-
ment treatment that includes systematic desensitization has sitization and Reprocessing 
education, muscle relaxation, not received strong support from • Eye movement desensitiza-
breathing retraining, role well-controlled studies.... neither tion and reprocessing (EMDR)
playing, modeling, guided relaxation training nor biofeedback is an eight-stage treatment that

28 OOHNA JOURNAL n Fall/winter 2015


Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder in a Nursing Context n Practice

includes history gathering, treat- ment, with effect sizes ranging “Case reports and tightly rea-
ment planning, patient prepa- from small to large. soned scholarly works comprise
ration, systematic assessment the bulk of the psychodynamic
“The empirical support for group
of trauma-relevant target(s), literature (Level D). These can
therapy as a modality for treating
desensitization and reprocess- neither provide ultimate tests
PTSD is largely based on pre-
ing, installation of alternative for psychodynamic hypotheses
to-post treatment change. There
positive cognitions, body scan nor define the limits of psycho-
are promising findings from a few
for persistent discomfort spots, pathology, theory, or technique.”
AHCPR Level A studies and sever-
and closure to address coping (p.583-584)
al Level B studies for superiority of
needs for future use.
specific groups relative to wait-list Guideline 13: Psychosocial Reha-
• The length and course of EMDR
controls. At present, there is not bilitation
treatment depends on the num-
sufficient evidence to warrant rec- • Many individuals with trauma
ber of traumatic events identi-
ommendation of a specific type histories demonstrate signif-
fied and the individual patient’s
of group therapy, to recommend icant disruptions in multiple
response throughout the stages.
group therapy in favour of individ- areas of life functioning, such
• Randomized control trials have
ual therapy, or to predict for whom as: family relationships; roman-
found EMDR to be comparable
group therapy might be more or tic relationships; employment;
to other frontline PTSD treat-
less effective.” (p.578)1 and friendships. Psychosocial
ments, including psycho-phar-
macotherapy. Guideline 11: Psychodynamic rehabilitation techniques target
Therapy for Adults  difficulties in these areas. Rath-
“EMDR is rated as a Level A treat- er than focusing on the internal
• Psychodynamic treatment
ment for its use with adults. Quality life of the individual, psychoso-
approaches have the goal of
clinical trials support its use for cial rehabilitation operates at
re-engaging normal mecha-
patients with PTSD. More stud- the union of the individual and
nisms of adaptation and coping
ies need to be completed with the broader community. Psy-
by addressing the unconscious
EMDR adapted for use with chil- chosocial rehabilitation may be
and making it conscious. This
dren and adolescents. It currently particularly relevant for individ-
process typically involves col-
has a Level B rating for treatment uals who have been multiply
laborative (patient-therapist)
with this population.” (p.576-576) traumatized or whose PTSD is
sorting and organizing of the
Guideline 9: Group Therapy patient’s wishes, fantasies, chronic in nature.
• Group therapy approaches vary fears, and defenses that are • Psychosocial rehabilitation
in terms of theoretical orienta- affected by the event. recommendations vary con-
tion, degree of trauma focus, • Psychodynamic therapy usu- siderably as a function of the
and group composition. Regard- ally involves 1-2 sessions per individual and the traumat-
less, group therapies capitalize week of about 45-50 minutes in ic event they experienced or
on efficiency, inclusion, social length and can be short term (a were exposed to. For example,
support and social contact, and few months) to long term (sev- employment/occupational pro-
the availability of social learning eral years). Session frequency grams may benefit an individu-
through modeling. and duration of therapy is large- al who was assaulted on the job
• Typical group therapy approach- ly dependent on the needs and and wishes to find a new place
es to PTSD treatment last for tolerance of the patient. of employment, but they would
10-25 weekly sessions of about • There exist few randomized likely not benefit an individual
1.5-2 hours each. Studied group control trials that investigate who has turned to substance
therapies tend to be comprised the validity of psychodynam- use to cope with witnessing a
of a single cohort of people. ic therapies. The complex and traumatic accident at work.
• Few well designed random- interactive nature of psychody- • Some controlled studies indi-
ized control trials have been namic therapies make it diffi- cate that educational inter-
run assessing group therapy for cult to test effectiveness; it may ventions for PTSD improve
PTSD; however, the evidence be the case that psychodynam- outcomes; however, no such
that does exist indicates that ic methods can be effective in support has been found for
group therapy shows positive very controlled settings but less family treatments. Unfortu-
change from pre-to-post treat- so in real-world settings. nately, the bulk of research on

1. (Agency for Health Care Policy and Research, US)

OOHNA JOURNAL n Fall/winter 2015 29


Practice n Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder in a Nursing Context

psychosocial rehabilitation has alone at the end of treatment, samples and did not include a
taken the form of case reports, although at a 3-year follow-up control or comparison group.”
naturalistic studies, and clinical the effects of CBT and CBT plus (P.596-597)
observations. hypnosis were equivalent. Thus,
Guideline 16: Creative Therapies
early treatment including hypno-
“With rare exception, psycho- for Adults
sis produced greater symptom
social rehabilitation techniques • Creative arts therapies involve
reduction.” (p.592-593)
have been evaluated primarily the intentional use, by a trained
in persons with serious psychiat- Guideline 15: Couple and Family therapist, of art, music, dance/
ric illnesses. Although it is fair to Therapy for Adults  movement, drama, or poetry in
assume that many participants in • There are two primary approach- the therapeutic process. These
existing studies have co-occurring es to couple and family therapy therapies utilize techniques that
(and often undiagnosed) PTSD, for PTSD: the first addresses have elements in common with
results from randomized trials the effects of trauma on families imaginal exposure. Imaginal
targeting persons with PTSD are and the relationships of trauma- exposure involves the represen-
sorely lacking.” (p.589) tized individuals and focuses tation of the traumatic expe-
on relieving overall family dis- rience in the creative art, in
Guideline 14: Hypnosis  tress; the second addresses the whatever form it takes.
• Hypnosis is a procedure that is role of the partner and family • Creative arts therapies vary
typically carried out via induc- members in assisting the indi- widely in their treatment for-
tion; this entails instructions to vidual who was involved in or mat, length, structure, and
disregard outside concerns and exposed to the traumatic event degree of integration with
to focus on the experiences in their recovery and focuses on other approaches.
and behaviors indicated by the enhancing the efficacy of social • Creative arts therapies have not
therapist, or those that arise support. been tested via randomized
more spontaneously. Hypnosis • Although programs for couples control trials and therefore are
can stimulate a narrow focus of and family therapy vary in their not empirically supported as a
attention, enhanced suggest- structure and application, many treatment approach for PTSD.
ibility, and alterations in con- are incorporated into larger However, clinical case studies
sciousness. treatment programs that target have noted progress in the pri-
• Hypnosis is often integrated the psychological consequenc- mary symptoms of PTSD and
with other approaches for treat- es of trauma. The number of in global clinical improvement
ing PTSD, including exposure sessions differ from program among patients.
techniques, cognitive restruc- to program; however, they are
turing, and coping skills training typically structured with early “Specific creative arts therapy
in an effort to manage trauma- sessions focusing on education treatments for trauma have not
related hyper-arousal. about the treatment program, yet been empirically tested. Evi-
• The number of randomized trauma, and PTSD in general, dence for the effectiveness of the
control trials assessing hypno- and later sessions focusing on creative arts therapies is based on
sis for PTSD is limited, however, specific skills, including com- numerous clinical case studies....
the results are promising. munication, problem solving, Despite relatively widespread use
coping, and mutual support. and application over a substantial
“The literature contains two ran-
• The existing body of research time period, the efficacy of the
domized, controlled clinical trials
on couple and family therapies creative arts therapies has not yet
of hypnosis for various types of
for PTSD is extremely small and been established through empiri-
posttraumatic symptomatology.
tends to focus on combat vet- cal research.” (p.600-602)
The older study showed that
erans and their partners. As
hypnosis significantly decreased Guideline 18: Treatment of PTSD
such, it is premature to rec-
intrusion and avoidance symp- and Comorbid Disorders
ommend these approaches for
toms, and seemed to do it in • There are three primary
PTSD patients.
fewer sessions than the compari- approaches for treating PTSD
son treatments. The newer study “The literature on couple and and comorbid disorders: the
found that hypnosis plus cogni- family therapies with trauma sur- first is an integrated approach
tive-behavioural therapy (CBT) vivors is severely limited. The few where disorders are treated at
had a larger therapeutic effect empirical studies have significant the same time by the same pro-
for reexperiencing than did CBT limitations. Most utilized small vider; the second is a sequen-

30 OOHNA JOURNAL n Fall/winter 2015


Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder in a Nursing Context n Practice

tial approach where disorders cal workplace incidents (Baxter, Dr. Joti Samra pursues a full spectrum of
are treated one after the other; 2004). Occupational Health nurses research, consulting and educational activi-
the third is a single diagnosis should be involved in debriefings ties in the field of workplace health. She
approach where just one disor- and/or interventions soon after a is the lead developer of Guarding Minds
der is treated. @ Work (GM@W): A Workplace Guide to
critical workplace incident, with Psychological Safety and Health, an inno-
• The integrated approach to the the focus being on education and vative online resource used by employers
treatment of PTSD and comor- prevention (Braverman, 2011). to address psychosocial threats in the
bid disorders is the most highly work environment and was a member
As PTSD is closely linked to a spe-
recommended. of the Technical Committee that devel-
cific event, the first step in successful oped Canada’s first National Standard
• About 4/5 of individuals with
PTSD have a lifetime rate of a prevention is to allow victims and/or on Psychological Health & Safety in the
witnesses to identify the connection Workplace (CSA Z1003/BNQ9700).
co-occurring psychiatric disor-
der; surprisingly, however, treat- between the event and his or her Marissa Bowsfield is a graduate student
symptoms (Braverman, 2011). This in Clinical Psychology at Simon Fraser
ments to address comorbid
University (email: mlb9@sfu.ca).
conditions have only become identification of the stress response
the focus of development and allows those affected to recognize
References:
study in recent years. The only that their reactions, although fright-
model that has been estab- ening and oftentimes confusing, Abbey, G., Thompson, S. B. N., Hickish,
lished as effective through T., & Heathcote, D. (2014). A meta-
are normal (Braverman, 2011). Fol-
randomized control trials is analysis of prevalence rates and
lowing “normalization”, affected moderating factors for cancer-related
Seeking Safety (SS) for comor- employees may need to go through post-traumatic stress disorder. Psycho-
bid substance use disorder.
controlled processing of their reac- Oncology, 24, 3171-381.
This model involves present-
tions, guided by a mental health
focused coping skills for PTSD American Psychiatric Association. (2013).
professional (Braverman, 2011). Diagnostic and statistical manual of
and substance use disorder.
Using knowledge of PTSD and its mental disorders (5th ed.). Arlington,
“Treatment models for PTSD comor- symptoms, the Occupational Health VA: American Psychiatric Publishing.
bidity offer a wide range of features, nurse should identify those affected Baxter, A. (2004). Posttraumatic stress
including the types of trauma for employees who may benefit from disorder and the intensive care unit
which they are designed, the use
employee assistance programs or a patient: Implications for staff and
of group versus individual modal-
referral to community mental health advanced practice critical care nurses.
ity, and the variety of techniques Clinical Dimension, 23(4), 145-152.
resources. An employee that is
offered. Some models are designed
from the start for comorbidity, assessed and diagnosed with PTSD Braverman, M. (2011). Post-traumatic stress
whereas others are a combination of by a mental health professional will disorder and its relation to occupational
likely be treated with a combination health and injury prevention. In Hurrel
existing approaches already found
Jr., J. Joseph, Levi, Lennart, Murphy,
effective for each separate disorder. of psychotherapy and pharmaco-
R. Lawrence, Sauter, L. Steven (Eds.),
Some studies address models that, therapy (Mohta et al., 2003). Mood and affect. Geneva: International
designed for only one diagnosis, Labor Organization.
also showed impact on comorbid Conclusion
conditions.” (p.607) Foa, E. B., Keane, T. M., Friedman, M. J.,
Although PTSD is a preventable & Cohen, J. A. (Eds., 2009). Effective

Recommendations for condition, its triggers and course treatments for PTSD: Practice guidelines
are variable and complex. This is from the International Society for
Implementation Traumatic Stress Studies (2nd Edition).
evidenced in the variety of afore-
Management of clinical PTSD New York: The Guilford Press.
mentioned interventions available
requires assessment and inter- Forbes, D., Creamer, M., Bisson, J. L.,
to PTSD patients. The application
vention by a psychiatrist or Cohen, J. A., Crow, B. E., Foa, E. b.,
of these therapies is beyond the
psychologist (Mohta, Sethi, Tyahi, Friedman, M. J., Keane, T. M., Kudler,
scope of the responsibilities of
& Mohta, 2003). However, the H. S., & Ursano, R. J. (2010). A guide
Occupational Health nurse’s abil- the Occupational Health nurse; to the guidelines for the treatment of
ity to recognize and differentiate however an awareness of their PTSD and related conditions. Journal
PTSD symptoms, as well as to take existence and evidence-based of Traumatic Stress, 23(5), 537-552.
the necessary actions to mitigate efficacy will allow for a more Mohta, M., Sethi, A. K., Tyahi, A., & Mohta,
pathological responses to trauma complete understanding of the A. (2003). Psychological care in trauma
is key in the management of criti- disorder. patients. Injury, 34(1), 17-25.

OOHNA JOURNAL n Fall/winter 2015 31


Practice n Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder in a Nursing Context

Appendix: ISTSS Levels of Evidence (Forbes et al., 2010)

Level A Evidence for treatment is based on randomized control trials (RCTs) for individuals with PTSD.

Evidence is based on well-designed clinical studies but without randomization or placebo


Level B
comparison groups for individuals with PTSD.

Evidence is based on service and naturalistic clinical studies, together with clinical obser-
Level C vations that are sufficiently compelling to justify use of the treatment or to follow the
recommendation.

Evidence is based on long-standing and widespread clinical practice that has not been
Level D
empirically tested in the context of PTSD.

Evidence is based on long-standing practice by circumscribed groups of clinicians that has not
Level E
been empirically tested in the context of PTSD.

Evidence is based on recently developed treatment that has not been clinically or empirically
Level F
tested in the context of PTSD.

32 OOHNA JOURNAL n Fall/winter 2015


Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without
permission.

Anda mungkin juga menyukai