SSEM COMMENT RAM REPLY

Fence & Gate Details (Architectural & Structural):

columns and footing arangment for fence and other building al

1. For the Fence, Please prepare the layout showing the arrangement of columns. provided ,see DWG. No RH1414-S-ML-FN-300

columns and footing arangment for fence ad other building alr

2. Also show the other structures near to the fence. existing ,see DWG. No RH1414-S-MLl-FN-301

3. For all Pump Stations, Use the same Type of Fence instead of using different type for each pump station. The fence agreement greed priviously with Eng.Kinawi
General Notes (Structural):

Soil investigatoin report for shafts not for the building ,design
1. For Concrete Construction, Concrete compressive strength should be 300KG/cm2 as per the Soil Investigation procced on compressive strength in tender docoments refer
report. attachment.

Fence & Gate Details (Structural):

columns and footing arangment for fence and other building al

1. For the Fence, Please prepare the layout showing the arrangement of foundatoins provided ,see DWG. No RH1414-S-MLl-FN-300

columns and footing arangment for fence and other building al

2. Also show the other structures near to the fence. provided ,see DWG. No RH1414-S-MLl-FN-300

3. Please clarify the use of two types of fence. Single type can be used or not as per Tender. The fence agreement greed priviously with Eng.Kinawi
 SSEM COMMENT RAM REPLY

Refer to see DWG. No RH1414-S-MLl-FN-300 that clearly show t

4. Please check the conflict b/w the underground tanks & fence foundations no conflict

columns and footing arangment for fence , sec and guard ro

provided
5. Please provide the details for the foundation near to Guard House & SEC room. See DWG. No RH1414-S-ML-FN-300 ,
DWG. No RH1414-S-ML-GH-300
DWG. No RH1414-S-ML-SEC-300
Guard House (Structural):

columns and footing arangment for fence and guard room pro
1. Please provide a layout showing the location of Guard House & other foundation for fence near to the Guard SEE DWG. NO RH1414-S-ML-FN-300 ,
House. RH1414-S-ML-GH-300,

2. Please also show the orientation of the Guard House by putting the North arrow. north direction alraeady provided for all building

3. Same size of fence columns is shown up the foundation while the up to Ground the size is OK. Below Ground for size of pedestal see see DWG. NO RH1414-S-ML-FN-300, the
level, was done based on details structural calculations, if you have
the column size should be bigger with a pocket at top to fix the precast fence column. Sample drawing is amendment calculation please provide us
attached.

provided ,mechanical pad already monolithic with roof slab f

4. For the Mechanical Pad at roof, it should be monolithic with the roof slab instead of isolated pad. building, see typical detail in DWG RH1414-s-ML-GH-303

SEC Room (Structural):

 SSEM COMMENT RAM REPLY

columns and footing arangment for fence and sec room prov
1. Please provide a layout showing the location of SEC Room & other foundation for fence near to the SEC SEE DWG. NO RH1414-S-ML-FN-300 ,
Room. RH1414-S-ML-SEC-300

for size of pedestal se RH1414-S-ML-FN-300,he sizing was done b

2. Please show the actual pedestal size for the fence as per the comments mentioned for fence. details structural calculations, if you have any amendment calcu
please provide us

3. Please mark the north arrow to show the orientation of the room. north direction alraeady provided for all building

columns and footing arangment for fence and sec room prov
4. Please show the fence foundations near to the SEC room. SEE DWG. NO RH1414-S-ML-FN-300 ,
RH1414-S-ML-SEC-300

Power House (Structural):

1. For the pads at roof, Please make it a part of roof slab instead of providing isolation joint b/w the pad & roof provided ,mechanical pad already monolithic with roof slab f
slab. building, see typical detail in DWG RH1414-s-ML-PH-304,

2. Title Block is not correct, Please correct it. Noted

Fuel Tank & Fuel Pump Pit (Structural):

1. Please provide a layout showing the location of Tanks along with the Fence Foundations & check if there is Columns and footing arangment for fence ad other building alr
any conflict b/w foundations & tanks. provided ,see DWG. NO RH1414-S-ML-FN-300

2. Please provide the reinforcement details for the top slab as it will be casted at site. Noted
 SSEM COMMENT
3. Section – B, Provided reinforcement & dimensions are not correct. Please update as per plan & section – A.
4. Details for protection below base slab, 100mm blinding concrete & 4mm thick waterproofing membrane is
required while in the details, one additional layer of blinding concrete is provided above the waterproofing
membrane. Please update.
5. Top slab of Fuel Pump Pit, is it concrete slab or checkered plate. Please mention it & provide the details.
Pump Room & Attenuation Tank (Structural):
1. For the Pump House, monorail arrangement should be b/w Grid A&C instead of B&C as per Tender Document
Page # 1184.
2. Please provide the complete connection details for the steel structure.
3. Section – 1, mentioned wall reinforcement @ Grid – B, T25@150, Please check as there is a conflict.
4. Please provide the fixing details of steel column to the concrete column.
5. Please provide the details of concrete columns at Grid – B.
6. Water stopper for the internal walls is not required, Please update the sections.
7. In sections the Reinforcement for the Base Slab is different (e.g. Section 4 & 10). Please check & correct.
8. Please reduce the reinforcement as much possible. Check for attenuation tank section – A (T32@150).
9. Please check the reinforcement provided in all sections i.e. T32@150.
RAM REPLY
Noted
the layers agreed with Eng.Kinawi and we followed the layers pr
by whom in date 27-1-2019
Noted ,it will be checkered plate.
already modeifed see DWG No.DWg. No.RH1414-S-ML-PS-3
already modeifed see DWg. No.RH1414-S-ML-PS-305
All reinforcment in the said sectoin is T32 not T25 ,please clari
Provided, See DWg. No.RH1414-S-ML-PS-305 -Steel Connections
Provided, See DWg. No.RH1414-S-ML-PS-305 -Planted column
the height of the internal walls exceeds than 3 meters, so from
technical point of view ,water stop must be used if you insiste
remove it please confirm this issue to be under your responsib
we don't have section 4 of section 10, please clarify ??
the design is optimized for durability and safty ,see calculation r
and models , let us know if you have any justification
the design is optimized for durability and safty ,see calculation r
and models , let us know if you have any justification
 RAM REPLY
tural):

columns and footing arangment for fence and other building alraeady
provided ,see DWG. No RH1414-S-ML-FN-300

columns and footing arangment for fence ad other building alraeady

existing ,see DWG. No RH1414-S-MLl-FN-301

The fence agreement greed priviously with Eng.Kinawi

Soil investigatoin report for shafts not for the building ,design was
procced on compressive strength in tender docoments refer to
attachment.

columns and footing arangment for fence and other building alraeady
provided ,see DWG. No RH1414-S-MLl-FN-300

columns and footing arangment for fence and other building alraeady
provided ,see DWG. No RH1414-S-MLl-FN-300

The fence agreement greed priviously with Eng.Kinawi

 RAM REPLY

Refer to see DWG. No RH1414-S-MLl-FN-300 that clearly show there is

no conflict

columns and footing arangment for fence , sec and guard rooms
provided
See DWG. No RH1414-S-ML-FN-300 ,
DWG. No RH1414-S-ML-GH-300
DWG. No RH1414-S-ML-SEC-300

columns and footing arangment for fence and guard room provided
SEE DWG. NO RH1414-S-ML-FN-300 ,
RH1414-S-ML-GH-300,

north direction alraeady provided for all building

for size of pedestal see see DWG. NO RH1414-S-ML-FN-300, the sizing

was done based on details structural calculations, if you have any
amendment calculation please provide us

provided ,mechanical pad already monolithic with roof slab for all
building, see typical detail in DWG RH1414-s-ML-GH-303,
 RAM REPLY

columns and footing arangment for fence and sec room provided
SEE DWG. NO RH1414-S-ML-FN-300 ,
RH1414-S-ML-SEC-300

for size of pedestal se RH1414-S-ML-FN-300,he sizing was done based on

details structural calculations, if you have any amendment calculation
please provide us

north direction alraeady provided for all building

columns and footing arangment for fence and sec room provided
SEE DWG. NO RH1414-S-ML-FN-300 ,
RH1414-S-ML-SEC-300

provided ,mechanical pad already monolithic with roof slab for all
building, see typical detail in DWG RH1414-s-ML-PH-304,

Noted
:

Columns and footing arangment for fence ad other building alraeady

provided ,see DWG. NO RH1414-S-ML-FN-300

Noted
 RAM REPLY
Noted

the layers agreed with Eng.Kinawi and we followed the layers provided
by whom in date 27-1-2019

Noted ,it will be checkered plate.

ral):

already modeifed see DWG No.DWg. No.RH1414-S-ML-PS-302

already modeifed see DWg. No.RH1414-S-ML-PS-305

All reinforcment in the said sectoin is T32 not T25 ,please clarify ??
Provided, See DWg. No.RH1414-S-ML-PS-305 -Steel Connections Details
Provided, See DWg. No.RH1414-S-ML-PS-305 -Planted column detail
the height of the internal walls exceeds than 3 meters, so from our
technical point of view ,water stop must be used if you insisted to
remove it please confirm this issue to be under your responsibility
we don't have section 4 of section 10, please clarify ??

the design is optimized for durability and safty ,see calculation reports
and models , let us know if you have any justification

the design is optimized for durability and safty ,see calculation reports
and models , let us know if you have any justification