IN I'IIt.

, CIRCT]I't COT JRT' OF' S'T'AIIKIi COUNTY, INDIANA

FAMILY PTJPPII:S. et al. CAI,T',NDAIT TI|RM 20I8

I)lairrtill-s. cAsE NO. 75COt-l 704-CC-l4l

VS.

".lASON KAYI.OR". "KI:1.1.Y".

" I S'l lrlrl.l:lt(ilRL'". ancl "ANONYMOt rS"
(posting on nllnreroLls u'cbsitcs" irrcluciing
r i po 1'1ic pu 11. c r-n.r . o u t r,r b c c o nr . t o p i r c o n-r "
1,'
. .

anci conr pIai ntsboard.cc-rnr ).

I)cl-cncJants

ORDF] R G RANTI NG .I U I)G M F]NT AN D I.]NT RY OI. PF]ITMAN IiNl- I NJ UNCTTON

'l-his rnattcr having conrc bcfirrc thc Cor"rrt upor-t thc (lonrplaint lLlcd by Plaintiffs Family

Puppics and Davicl C'hLrpp ("Plairrti11.s'") ancl thc accolr;larrvirrg Motion. thc Court hcreby'llnds

that I'}lairrtills' IVlotion bc (iRAN I'l:l). and this ('ourt cntcrs .luc-lgrncnt and iniunctive relief in

lirvor of Plaintitl.s againsl l)c1'cndatrts. as spcciflccl hcrcin.

[)cl'enclarrts postcd nunrcrous l'alsc anc] cJcl-anraton' statcnrcnts (thc "False Slatements")

regarding Plaintill-s r,r,'ith thc purpose of harnring Plaintiffs'prol'cssional reputation and br-rsiness.

'['hc attacks lalscly'accusc Plaintiffs o1'nriscorrduct ancl violatiot-ts in their business practices. In

response. Plaintill's tilcci their Conrplaint fbr libcl anci libcl pcr sc rclatcd to the False Statcnrents

postcd olt ltLllleroLls w,cbsites. Ilaving rcricwccJ thc Motion. thc supporting bric1. affldavits. and

othcr cvidcntiarn subn-rissions. this Court tlnds Dcl.cndants \\'as propcrly'served and that

Plaintit'l.s arc cntitlecl to.iuclgnrcnt agairrst Dcl'cnclants ats at tlatttcr ol'law on thc cot-tt-tts allegcd irt

thc Cornplatint.
 .I LID(; M F]N't

Il' IS III:ltl:llY ORI)lrltlrl). r\[).lt rD(;t:l) r\NI) I)l:('l{trlrD that I)cl..:nclants published

c'lctantaton statelt.lcltts ol'ancl col.lccnting Plaintill.s on thc Irrtcl'lrct tliat arc f-alse and def-amatorv

(thc "[)cl-antatory' Statclncnts'") on tlrc u,'cbsitcs \\'\\'\\.ripotfi cport.corn. www.youtube.com.

ww\\r. ntce tup.cotl" rvw'n'.doggics.conr. u r,r, u,'.clkharthulnaltcsoccitl,.conr. w w.w.topix.com. and

\\'w.\\'.corrtplaintsboard.coll.'l'he Dcf'arlaton'Statcrncnts incluclc claims that Plairrtif-f-s are not a

licclrsccl Anrcrican Kcnncl (llub brccdcr. that Plaintiffh use 1-alse ltalles in their br-rsiness. that

Plaintifls kecp thcir puppics irr bartrs ancl tcrriblc conditions. arrcl othcr lalsc clairr-rs agairrst

Plailrtiffs.'l'hcsc statctlcnts publishccl arbout Plaintil'1.s. vrhich arc Lrrrlirundccl. tblse. incorrect. and

atrc causing danragc to Plaintill.s. inclr-rcic. but arc not linritcd to" thc litllow,ing tJRLs:

I . littp-(wrru.npq.1llgpq.L1.9auA /14!u"b:p!lp!_Lc.sda*:,uayi:c/u@
"{6-5-10-/-l-b::til::gupprqr:rja-ypt:wa-\-Lqts!:q:clupp-:-ddl_!:@
wc5tr cs-cor-Urna-chupp- t'- I 0893 34:

2. _eluppl'rappance-
{0"5_5_0/day'd:q}_upp*.rql_d:!ue'_p_LlpJy:!hd-drqd:u:4:!x_o4ltr:@
250000-bctu ccn-vct- 1 3 72528:
.)
.'). https : // vl'w'lv. )' o r"r t r"r b c . c o ll / vr'g1g!'l v,, 3 [J 3 c G W c C' 0 Y0

4. htlp.:,lltl-p-,rtrct-q[gp-,"9-q-u!p-upp-urri-Uaug[!]lc-$$/lur:q,1agqy-bggrdV-tluea@l-4i
08_1.10:

5 . http-ilull-u-.ilpggr-c:r,Jrer-u/bl-ed:-Q0-9-/-021-l-8h-.:u:ir-l.1s:!-Le:I-dqktqanr/ :

6. ht_tps;/lq1-L[art_luuarqqae]_qll:..]_ojdp_Lqts._c_!)u r/_?AaflqZ!&fbs-horn/:

7. http://w'r,r,r,r,'.topir.conr/forurnr/cit)'/nappancc-in/'l'PN35l:M.lCN.lS0KtJ-['9;

8. http://www.conrplaintsboard.corrl/cgnrplaints/I'amil)'-puppie s-puppy-mill-
c698839.htnrl:

PTi RM AN I.]NT I N.I TJ N C'TI ON

 a. l)ef-clldatrts and his or hcr agents and assigns errc prolribited tiorn anl,flrther acts

o1'dcl-anlatiolt or publishing ol'thc lalsc or nrislcaciins statcrncr-rts. contnrcnts. or irrfbrmatio'

regarding Plaintiffi:

b. Del'crldants. irrclLrdins his ascltls. scrvants. cnrplovecs" irrdependent contracts.

atlornevs" rcpresclttatiVcs. anci tltt-rsc pcrsons or cntitics in activc coltccrt or participation with

thctlt. is nlanclatccl to takc all action" irrclLrcling" but rrot lirritccl to. ru-noving the publications

Irladc about Plaintill-s fl'ortt tlicir t'cspcctivc n cbpagcs on r,i hich thci appcar. irrclr-rding

wwrv'ripolii'cport.ctltrt. w'w\\'.\'otttltbc.cor-n. \\'\\'\\'. nrcctup.con-r" wwu,.doggies.cor-n"

u Vn i'r ' clkhatrthlrrllzlllcsocc itr'. cotrt. \\'\\'\\'.titpix. cont. ancl ww.\\ conrplaintsboard.cont. ancl
.

reclttcsting rct"noval fl'om thc Intcrnct scarch cngincs inclr-rding Google via its court order

submission wcbpagc at

LutpVruppqr_Leo as lqsq u/leg l/corrtact/lr courlordcr?product, websearcl"r&colttact coLl

rtorclcr&rd ,l " ancl Yahoo! and I) ing r,'ia thcir rcr-no'u'aI rcclucst page at

lflp_,s_ ;1/ s UW_Q L U_r_r_!ltX O li.qq It / qt_l

rus/*ctsupport'loaspn ork Ilor,r start I .0.0.0&rvlliarlc cansub& rocluctkcv binscctntcntrclloval

&lo!^ltig-q!r:Lu&qq!4- Q000 11672283 15550" ancl that Plaintifl.s nrar, also do so olt Def'endant's

bchalt'as nccdcd. to retttor,'c and rcclttcst rcmor,'al or all delarlatory" disparaging" libelor-rs. apd

f-alsc statcmcnts abor.rt Plaintilh that l)ef-crrdants posted on thc Intclnct. incllclinH. but pot limited

ttl thc statcntcnts [)cf':ndarrts nradc on thc lbllonins [.]RL adclrcsscs:

t. ]:Up./Wy@icport.conr/r"/f-an-rily-puppics-dave-wa),ne/nappanee-indiana-
'16
55 0/ l'anr i l),-pu pp ic s -d a vc- vva)'n e -dar,,c -c h u p p -c1a'u'cs- p up s- rny- lovab le -
rvcst i es-cori rtna-chupp- I - 1 0[i 93 3il :

2. btp_./r1yll_u.L_ipq1l_epg4_!._c__qq1[-.JprtVditr i-d:c_l]!pp/niq2pance-ipdjana-
0/clavicl-chupp-sold-nrc-pupp)'-that-clicd-in--l-rronths-no-rcfilnd-cost-me-
'165-5
250000-bctwccn-vct- 1 3 72528:
a
_)
 -
.'). hltpVuuyf o u t u b c . c o nr A\, atc h/r i I J_]qQ_&gQy__Q

,1
T, httpSlUlu.nfgslup. c alvplpp)::1tt]leuarylsgslm c s sa gc s/bo ard s/thre adl9 7 1,1 3
68/30:

5. http_./luu$Jagsrts_,selr/blqg/20Q_9/_0:ll8lu,-:ru:illqtctlastee$/ :

6. htUsiiiqtl k hartlr snrancsltc_ic_!t.1s dprq,s!,qe!_r_e gq&O9l_0"&&g_!:qul:

7. httUllt_u__u.lopu=c_lurr/fu&uu/d1Vrcppau_qet:11ll_llN35l:M.lC_,N.rS0KtJ't'9;
fl. [!p://w'n'u.conrplaintsboard.conr/corlplaints/f'anril]'-pLrppies-pupp,v-mill-
c(rc)8839.htltrl:

Il' IS liUR'flttrR ORDITRITI). AD.lLJDcfrl) ANI) I)lrcRIrlrD that Def-endants is

nlandatcd. as it is fbrcseeablc that tlre above-ref-erenced tJRLs and the statements contained
thcrcott r,iill bc copiccl or rcl'crcnccd orr additional wcbpagcs in the firtr-rrc. including but not

lirrtitcd to irtdcr" clirectorl'. anci scarrch rcsults pagcs. to takc rcasonable actions. inclr-rding

rcclr"testing rclnoval 1l'onr thc Intcrrrct scarch urgincs Googlc" Yahoo!. and Bing" to ren-rove. all

such nchpagcs ll'ont thc Intcl'lrct.

l'l ll: COLjlt'l' RtrQtJlrS't'S (iooglc. Yahoo!. Ilirrg. Ripol'fReport.com.

(-'olrtplaintsboarc-l.cot-n"'l'opix.conr. Mcetup.conr. Youtr-rbc.conr. Worclprcss.corlt. Doggies.cont.

and otltcr w'chsitcs rvith sirlilar ciclanraton'contcnt about Plaintil'f. to relnove all associated

wcbpagcs and URLs listed hercitr cc-lrtaining the clel'arnatorv corrtcnt about Plaintills fiom their

respcctir,'e scarch indcxcs and rvcbsitcs.

AND COS'I'S

Il'IS IrLjlt.l'l IllR OIf DITRI:l). AI).ltJD(il:l) ANI) DI:CItl:l:l) that no danrases are
g

allardccl to artv partf in this rtrattcr.

I'l' IS IrtlR.l'l IlrR ORDI:RI:l). AD.ltlD(il:l) ANI) I)l:CRlrl:l) that all costs of C'ourt

crpendcd or itrcurrccl in this caLrsc arc tarecl against thc partv incr-rrriltg sarltc.
 I'l' IS FLllt'l'l IIrR ORDI:ltlrl). AI).ltrDGI:l) ANI) DtrC'Rlllrl) that this C'ourt retains

.jurisdiction to cnfbrce this .ludgnrcnt.

I'l' IS FLIR t'l IllR ORDI:RI:l). AD.lt ID(il:l) ANI) DI:C'ltlrlrl) that this Order is the Final

.ludgmcrtt ol'this Court" atrcJ iill rclicl-pravcd lbr b1 an1'part\ but not hcrcilt cxpresslv grar-rted be

ancl is hercb'n' denied.

)ntE)'.
July 10, 2018

Kim Hall, Judge

Starke Circuit Court
K;,,* l-\,1 [[, Tu{ln
ltfut*-Ke C',bc ,r,f C-axrt