• Introduction
• Interdependence of engineering,
engineering operation
and maintenance
• Management of Change (MOC)
Risk Integrity
Management Management
Technology
Value
Cost Reliability
y
Stakeholders
St k h ld
Benefit
Engineered Safety - 1
• Engineered safety is a core technology and is a
corner stone of technical integrity.
integrity
It includes the following major components:
1. Safety in Design
- Quality Control in Design
- Inherent Safety
2. Safeguarding
3. Technical Safety Audits and Reviews
4. Pre-Startup Audits and Reviews
5. Procedures And Controls
Mechanical Integrity
• The mechanical integrity of pressure equipment
and piping systems can only be achieved when the
following three inter-dependent criteria are
satisfied:
– The pressure vessels/piping systems are designed
correctly for the specified service conditions,
– They are operated within the design envelope
– They are maintained within the design envelope,
• The degradation processes the pressure system is
subject to are understood, monitored, and trended
and the piping system is fit for continued service
Design
Mechanical
Integrity
O
Operation
i M i
Maintenance
Design
Maintenance
Operation Mechanical Integrity
Mechanical Integrity
Operational Risk
The most effective way
People
to reduce operational
risk is by identifying
specific areas that need
Operational
improvement based on
Risk
their contributions to
the overall risk
Equipment Production
Susceptibility Severity
factor factor
Internal corrosion
Risk to life
External corrosion
Damage to asset
Fatigue
Loss of production
Stress Corrosion Cracking
Cost of failure
Third party damage
Environmental effects
Sabotage/pilferage
Public image
Loss of ground support
Inspection
i POF Consequences
RISK
Knowledge of materials and service conditions tells us what failure
mode to expect
Safety Management
Acceptable Risk
Risk Management
Safety in Design
Reliable Operation
Risk-Based Maintenance
PREMATURE FRACTURE
BRITTLE
FRACTURE
KI = σ Y√(π
Y√( a))
Y is a geometry factor
Asset Utilization
We make money only when the equipment is running
Equipment
Planned Unscheduled
fully functional
Maintenance Maintenance
Making $
50
Equipment Failures
Equipment Equipment Failure Failure Detection
Category Types Mode Cause Method
Pumps, Premature Excessive Force Vibration and Lube
Bearing Loss Analysis
Rotating Motors,
Machinery Compressors, Over/Under or Spectrographic &
Blowers Lubrication Improper Lube. Ferrographic
Failure Heat & Moisture analysis
Motors, Time/Resistance
Insulation Failure Heat, Moisture Tests, I/R Scans,
Electrical Cable,
Oil Analysis
Equipment Starters,
Corona Discharge
g Moisture, Splice
p Ultrasound
Transformers Methods
Heat Transfer Exchangers, Sediment/ Heat Transfer
Equipment Condensers Fouling Material Buildup Calculations
EQUIP
Column 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0
Compr 1 1 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 4 1
Heater 29 20 8 0 4 2 0 0 0 16 79 1
25
H.Exch 8 22 0 0 0 5 0 0 0 0 35
Pipeline 12 5 0 0 1 5 0 0 0 0 26 4
Piping 102 67 5 0 26 26 1 1 0 7 235 36
Pump 3 477 1 0 1 1 0 0 0 3 56 9
Tank 32 9 6 0 2 4 0 9 0 12 74 11
Transp 12 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 15 2
Vessel 47 16 6 2 11 4 0 0 0 5 91 14
Other 12 3 0 2 4 0 0 1 0 4 26 4
U/K 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 10 10 2
TOTAL 258 193 27 4 49 48 2 11 1 60 653
PERCENT 39 30 4 1 8 7 0 2 0 9
The origin of the initiating defect (115mm long crack at the fillet weld)
was thought to be hydrogen cracking in the HAZ of the fillet weld.
Risk-Based Inspection
Rigorous system for managing pressure equipment risks
- Anticipate future problems -
Identify Future risks and opportunities
Knowledge & Understanding
• Design (& Change) envelope
Probability
• Service conditions
• Damage mechanisms of Failure
• Inspection / maintenance history RISK
• Failure mechanisms / rates Consequence
• Defects types & characteristics
of Failure
• Criticality
• Probability of Detection Optimum Inspection
• Impacts of failure
Plan
Analysis
Preparation High-Risk
RISK Scenarios
Fault
Mechanism Consequence
Assessment Assessment Inspection
Checklist
Retire/
Not Replace
Tolerable
Risk Levels Economic
Determination
asing risk
Determination
Continue
Generally Tolerable to
or Run
Negligible Risk
NDT Reliability
• Repeat inspections of the same flaw size or the same
yp will not necessarily
flaw type y result in consistent hit
or miss indications. Hence there is a spread of
detection results for each flaw size and flaw type and
this is precisely why the detection capability is
expressed in statistical terms such as the PoD.
• In order to ensure the structural integrity of critical
components it was becoming more evident that
instead of asking the question ‘…what
what is the smallest
flaw that can be detected by an NDT method?’ it was
more appropriate, from a fracture mechanics point of
view, to ask ‘…what is the largest flaw that can be
missed?’
Management of Change
• Continued plant integrity needs to be upheld by
adequate maintenance,
maintenance inspection and avoidance of
unauthorised design or operational changes.
• To avoid hazards caused by modifications, any
proposal for change must be identified, technically
investigated by competent personnel, and formally
authorised.
• Modifications
difi i should
h ld be b designed,
d i d constructed, d
inspected, tested to verify compliance with design
intent and should be maintained at least to the standard
of the design criteria required by the process.
Definition of Change
Change may be defined as:
– A modification
difi ti made d tot an existing
i ti unit
it off plant,
l t
system, organization or entity from its current
design or state.
– A change may be permanent or temporary, cost
nothing or cost millions.
– It would normally exclude normal repairs or other
activities
ti iti to
t restore
t the
th original
i i l functionality
f ti lit andd
the replacement of like with like. In some cases,
however, repair in kind may constitute a change, or
it may result in the loss of an opportunity for
improvement.
Engineering Safety
approval approval
Final approval
Update
database
Permit to work
1. Introduction 2. Employee
p y 3. Process 4. Process
to PSM involvement Safety Hazard
in PSM Information Analysis
5. Operating 6. Employee 7. Contractors 8. Pre-startup
procedures training Safety
and practices
9. Mechanical 10. Non-routine 11. Managing 12. Investigation
integrity work Change of incidents
authorization
13. Emergency 14. Compliance
preparedness audits
Possible
Questions
Score
Total Points 80