Anda di halaman 1dari 170

Education

$22.95 U.S.
2ND E DITION

M U LTI PLE I NTE LLIG E NC E S I N TH E C LAS S ROOM


Preface by Howard Gardner
2ND E DITION
MulipleIntelligences
“To respect the many differences between people”—this is what Howard Gardner
says is the purpose of learning about multiple intelligences (MI). Now, in the 2nd
edition of Multiple Intelligences in the Classroom, Thomas Armstrong has updated his
best-selling practical guide for educators, to incorporate new research from Gardner
and others. Gardner’s original studies suggested that the human mind is composed
of seven intelligences—linguistic, logical-mathematical, spatial, bodily-kinesthetic,
musical, interpersonal, and intrapersonal.

This new edition includes information on the eighth intelligence (the naturalist), a
chapter on a possible ninth intelligence (the existential), and updated information
and resources throughout the text to help educators at all levels apply MI theory to
curriculum development, lesson planning, assessment, special education, cognitive
skills, educational technology, career development, educational policy, and more. The
book includes dozens of practical tips, strategies, and examples from real schools and
districts. Armstrong provides tools, resources, and ideas that educators can immedi-

2N D E DITION
ately use to help students of all ages achieve their fullest potential in life.

Thomas Armstrong, an educator and psychologist from Sonoma County, California,


has more than 27 years of teaching experience, from the primary through the doctoral
level. He is the author of two other ASCD books, Awakening Genius in the Classroom
and ADD/ADHD Alternatives in the Classroom.

ARMSTRONG
VISIT US ON THE WORLD WIDE WEB
http://www.ascd.org

Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development


Alexandria, Virginia USA

T HOMAS A RM STRONG
2ND E DITION

T HOMAS A RM STRONG

Association for Supervision


and Curriculum Development
Alexandria, Virginia USA
Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development
1703 N. Beauregard St. • Alexandria, VA 22311-1714 USA
Telephone: 1-800-933-2723 or 703-578-9600 • Fax: 703-575-5400
Web site: http://www.ascd.org • E-mail: member@ascd.org

2000–01 ASCD Executive Council: LeRoy Hay (President), Kay A. Musgrove (President-Elect), Joanna Choi Kalbus
(Immediate Past President), Martha Bruckner, Richard L. Hanzelka, Douglas E. Harris, Mildred Huey, Sharon Lease, Leon
Levesque, Francine Mayfield, Andrew Tolbert, Sandra K. Wegner, Peyton Williams Jr., Jill Dorler Wilson, Donald B. Young.

Copyright © 2000 by Thomas Armstrong. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted
in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and re-
trieval system, without permission from ASCD. Readers who wish to duplicate material copyrighted by Thomas Armstrong or
ASCD may do so for a small fee by contacting the Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Dr., Danvers, MA 01923, USA
(telephone: 978-750-8400; fax: 978-750-4470). ASCD has authorized the CCC to collect such fees on its behalf. Requests to
reprint rather than photocopy should be directed to ASCD’s permissions office at 703-578-9600.

ASCD publications present a variety of viewpoints. The views expressed or implied in this book should not be interpreted as
official positions of the Association.

e-book ($22.95) ebrary ISBN 0-87120-926-8 •Retail PDF ISBN 1-4166-0109-0

Quality Paperback: ISBN 0-87120-376-6 ASCD product no. 100041 ASCD member price: $18.95 nonmember price: $22.95

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data (for paperback book)


Armstrong, Thomas.
Multiple intelligences in the classroom / Thomas Armstrong.—2nd ed.
p. cm.
Includes bibliographical references (p. ) and index.
“ASCD stock number 100041”—T.p. verso.
ISBN 0-87120-376-6 (pbk.)
1. Teaching. 2. Cognitive styles. 3. Learning. 4. Multiple
intelligences. I. Association for Supervision and Curriculum
Development. II. Title.
LB1025.2 .A76 2000
370.15’23—dc21
00-008421
Multiple Intelligences in the Classroom
2nd Edition

List of Figures ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ iv
Preface by Howard Gardner ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ v
Introduction to the 2nd Edition~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ vii

1 The Foundations of the Theory of Multiple Intelligences ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1


2 MI and Personal Development ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 12
3 Describing Intelligences in Students ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 21
4 Teaching Students About MI Theory ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 31
5 MI and Curriculum Development ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 38
6 MI and Teaching Strategies ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 51
7 MI and the Classroom Environment ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 67
8 MI and Classroom Management ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 75
9 The MI School ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 82
10 MI and Assessment ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 88
11 MI and Special Education ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 103
12 MI and Cognitive Skills ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 112
13 Other Applications of MI Theory ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 121
14 MI and Existential Intelligence ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 127

Appendixes
A: Resources on Multiple Intelligences~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 132
B: Related Books on MI Teaching ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 135
C: Examples of MI Lessons and Programs ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 137

References ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 141
Index ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 145
About the Author ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 155
List of Figures

1.1. MI Theory Summary Chart ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 4


2.1. An MI Inventory for Adults ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 13
3.1. Eight Ways of Learning ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 22
3.2. Checklist for Assessing Students’ Multiple Intelligences ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 24
4.1. MI Pizza ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 33
4.2. Human Intelligence Hunt ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 36
5.1. Summary of the Eight Ways of Teaching ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 41
5.2. MI Planning Questions ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 45
5.3. MI Planning Sheet ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 46
5.4. Completed MI Planning Sheet on Punctuation ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 47
5.5. Sample Eight-Day MI Lesson Plan ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 48
5.6. MI and Thematic Instruction ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 49
7.1. Types of Activity Centers ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 70
8.1. MI Strategies for Managing Individual Behaviors ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 80
9.1. MI in Traditional School Programs ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 84
10.1. Standardized Testing Versus Authentic Assessment ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 90
10.2. Examples of the Eight Ways Students Can Show
Their Knowledge About Specific Topics ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 94
10.3. “Celebration of Learning” Student Sign-up Sheet~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 95
10.4. 56 MI Assessment Contexts ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 96
10.5. What to Put in an MI Portfolio ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 99
10.6. MI Portfolio Checklist ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 100
11.1. The Deficit Paradigm Versus the Growth Paradigm in Special Education ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 104
11.2. High-Achieving People Facing Personal Challenges ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 106
11.3. Strategies and Tools for Empowering Intelligences in Areas of Difficulty ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 107
11.4. Examples of MI Remedial Strategies for Specific Topics ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 108
11.5. Sample MI Plans for Individualized Education Programs (IEPs)~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 110
12.1. MI Theory and Bloom’s Taxonomy ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 118
13.1. Software That Activates the Multiple Intelligences ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 122
13.2. Prominent Individuals from Minority Cultures ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 125
Preface
By Howard Gardner

In addition to my own writings, there are now suggestions about how to involve youngsters in
a number of guides to the theory of multiple in- an examination of their own intelligences and
telligences, written by my own associates at Har- how to manage one’s classroom in an MI way. He
vard Project Zero and by colleagues in other has included several rough-and-ready tools that
parts of the country. Coming from a background can allow one to assess one’s own intellectual
in special education, Thomas Armstrong was one profile, to get a handle on the strengths and pro-
of the first educators to write about the theory. clivities of youngsters under one’s charge, and to
He has always stood out in my mind because of involve youngsters in games built around MI
the accuracy of his accounts, the clarity of his ideas. He conveys a vivid idea of what MI
prose, the broad range of his references, and the classes, teaching moves, curricula, and assess-
teacher-friendliness of his tone. ments can be like. Each chapter concludes with a
Now he has prepared the book that you hold set of exercises to help one build on the ideas
in your hands for members of the Association for and practices that one has just read about.
Supervision and Curriculum Development. Dis- As Armstrong points out in his introduction,
playing the Armstrong virtues that I have come I do not believe that there is a single royal road
to expect, this volume is a reliable and readable to an implementation of MI ideas in the class-
account of my work, directed particularly to room. I have been encouraged and edified by the
teachers, administrators, and other educators. wide variety of ways in which educators around
Armstrong has also added some nice touches of the country have made use of my ideas, and I
his own: the notion of a “paralyzing experience,” have no problem in saying “Let 100 MI schools
to complement Joseph Walters’ and my concept bloom.” From my perspective, the essence of the
of a “crystallizing experience”; the suggestion to theory is to respect the many differences among
attend to the way that youngsters misbehave as a people, the multiple variations in the ways that
clue to their intelligences; some informal they learn, the several modes by which they can

Howard Gardner is Hobbs Professor of Cognition and Education and Co-Director of Project Zero at the Harvard Gradu-
ate School of Education, and adjunct professor of neurology at the Boston University School of Medicine. He is the author of
Frames of Mind: The Theory of Multiple Intelligences (Basic Books, 1983/1993), Multiple Intelligences: The Theory in Practice (Basic
Books, 1993), and Intelligence Reframed: Multiple Intelligences for the 21st Century (Basic Books, 1999).

v
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

be assessed, and the almost infinite number of opportunity to present these ideas to you; and I
ways in which they can leave a mark on the hope that you in turn will be stimulated to ex-
world. Because Thomas Armstrong shares this tend them in ways that bear your own particular
vision, I am pleased that he has had the stamp.

vi
Introduction to the 2nd Edition

This book emerged from my work over the marked the effective birthdate of “MI” theory.
past fourteen years in applying Howard Since that time, awareness among educators
Gardner’s theory of multiple intelligences to the about the theory of multiple intelligences has
nuts-and-bolts issues of classroom teaching continued to grow steadily. From a model that
(Armstrong, 1987b, 1988, 1993). I was initially was originally popular mostly in the field of
attracted to MI theory in 1985 when I saw that it gifted education and among isolated schools and
provided a language for talking about the inner teachers around the United States in the 1980s,
gifts of children, especially those students who MI theory during the 1990s expanded its reach
have accumulated labels such as “LD” and to include hundreds of school districts, thou-
“ADD” during their school careers (Armstrong, sands of schools, and tens of thousands of teach-
1987a). It was as a learning disabilities specialist ers in the United States and in numerous
during the late 1970s and early 1980s that I be- countries across the globe. Educators have ap-
gan to feel the need to depart from what I con- plied multiple intelligences concepts to a wide
sidered a deficit-oriented paradigm in special range of settings from early childhood programs
(Merrefield, 1997) to community colleges
education. I wanted to forge a new model based
(Diaz-Lefebvre & Finnegan, 1997) and centers
on what I plainly saw were the many gifts of
for homeless adults (Taylor-King, 1997).
these so-called “disabled” children.
In this book, I present my own particular
I didn’t have to create a new model. Howard
adaptation of Gardner’s model for teachers and
Gardner had already done it for me. In 1979, as
other educators. My hope is that people can use
a Harvard researcher, he was asked by a Dutch
the book in several ways to help stimulate con-
philanthropic group, the Bernard Van Leer Foun-
tinued reforms in education:
dation, to investigate human potential. This invi-
tation led to the founding of Harvard Project • as a practical introduction to the theory of
Zero, which has served as the institutional mid- multiple intelligences for individuals new to the
wife for the theory of multiple intelligences. Al- model;
though Gardner had been thinking about the • as a supplementary text for teachers in
notion of “many kinds of minds” since at least training in schools of education;
the mid-1970s (see Gardner, 1989, p. 96), the • as a study guide for groups of teachers and
publication in 1983 of his book Frames of Mind administrators working in schools that are

vii
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

implementing reforms; and Finally, there has been a dramatic increase in


• as a resource book for teachers and other the number of books, manuals, training pro-
educators looking for new ideas to enhance their grams, audio- and videotapes, CD-ROMs, and
teaching experience. other resources related to the theory of multiple
intelligences, and the expanded resources guide
Each chapter concludes with a section called (pp. 132–134 ) reflects this exponential growth.
“For Further Study” that can help readers inte- Increasingly, examples of schools that have
grate the material into their instructional prac- successfully followed these principles have been
tice. Several appendixes and a list of references appearing on the educational scene. Hoerr
alert readers to other materials related to MI the- (2000), for example, details in his ASCD book
ory that can enrich and extend their understand- Becoming a Multiple Intelligences School the process
ing of the model. he and his colleagues went through to imple-
Since the publication of the 1st edition of ment the principles of MI theory at the New City
Multiple Intelligences in the Classroom in 1994, School in St. Louis, Missouri, where he is head-
several new developments in MI theory have master. Similarly, Campbell and Campbell
warranted its revision and expansion in this 2nd (2000), in their ASCD book Multiple Intelligences
edition. First, and most important, is Howard and Student Achievement: Success Stories from Six
Gardner’s addition of an eighth intelligence to his Schools, chronicle the application of MI theory at
original list of seven intelligences: the naturalist several schools—both elementary and secon-
(Gardner, 1999b). The core of this intelligence dary—in Kentucky, Minnesota, Washington, In-
includes a capacity to discriminate or classify dif- diana, and California. Perhaps most significantly,
ferent kinds of fauna and flora or natural forma- Harvard Project Zero has been engaged in Project
tions such as mountains or clouds. Gardner SUMIT (Schools Using Multiple Intelligence
added it to the theory after concluding that it Theory), which is examining 41 schools nation-
met the same criteria for an intelligence as the wide that have been incorporating multiple intel-
original seven (see pages 3–8 of this text for a de- ligences into their curriculum. Outcomes thus
scription of the general criteria, and Gardner, far include improved test scores, improved disci-
1999b, pp. 48–52, for an application of the cri- pline, improved parent participation, and im-
teria to the naturalist intelligence). I have inte- provements for students with the “learning
grated the naturalist intelligence into all relevant disability” label (Kornhaber, 1999).
text, strategies, activities, figures, charts, re-
sources, and other aspects of this 2nd edition of
Multiple Intelligences in the Classroom.
❦ ❦ ❦
Second, Gardner has also begun speaking Many people have helped make this book possi-
about the possibility of a ninth intelligence—the ble. First, I thank Howard Gardner, whose sup-
existential—or the intelligence of concern with port of my work over the years has helped fuel
ultimate life issues (Gardner, 1999b, pp. 60–64). my continued involvement in MI theory. I also
I have not integrated the existential intelligence thank Mert Hanley, director of the Teach-
into the body of this revised text, but have writ- ing/Learning Center in the West Irondequoit
ten a special chapter for this 2nd edition (Chap- School District in upstate New York, for provid-
ter 14, pp. 127–131) that discusses this ing me with the opportunity to work with sev-
candidate for a ninth intelligence and its poten- eral school districts in the Rochester area. Over a
tial applications to the classroom. period of four years in those districts, I tried out

viii
Introduction

many of the ideas in this book. Thanks also to in the Classroom possible. Finally, my special ap-
the following individuals who helped in different preciation goes to the thousands of teachers, ad-
ways to give form to Multiple Intelligences in the ministrators, and students who responded to the
Classroom: Ron Brandt, Sue Teele, David Thorn- ideas and strategies presented in these pages:
berg, Jo Gusman, Jean Simeone, Pat Kyle, DeLee This book has been created in recognition of the
Lanz, Peggy Buzanski, Dee Dickinson, and my rich potential that exists in each of you.
wife, Barbara Turner. I also want to thank the
editors, designers, and other members of the THOMAS ARMSTRONG
program development work group of ASCD for Sonoma County, California
making this 2nd edition of Multiple Intelligences May 2000

ix
The Foundations of the Theory
of Multiple Intelligences 1
It is of the utmost importance that we recognize and nurture all of the varied human intelli-
gences, and all of the combinations of intelligences. We are all so different largely because we all
have different combinations of intelligences. If we recognize this, I think we will have at least a
better chance of dealing appropriately with the many problems that we face in the world.
—Howard Gardner (1987)

In 1904, the minister of public instruction in seriously questioned the validity of determining
Paris asked the French psychologist Alfred Binet an individual’s intelligence through the practice
and a group of colleagues to develop a means of of taking a person out of his natural learning en-
determining which primary grade students were vironment and asking him to do isolated tasks
“at risk” for failure so these students could re- he’d never done before—and probably would
ceive remedial attention. Out of their efforts never choose to do again. Instead, Gardner sug-
came the first intelligence tests. Imported to the gested that intelligence has more to do with the
United States several years later, intelligence test- capacity for (1) solving problems and (2) fash-
ing became widespread, as did the notion that ioning products in a context-rich and naturalistic
there was something called “intelligence” that setting.
could be objectively measured and reduced to a
single number or “IQ” score.
Almost eighty years after the first intelligence
tests were developed, a Harvard psychologist The Eight Intelligences
named Howard Gardner challenged this com- Described
monly held belief. Saying that our culture had Once this broader and more pragmatic perspec-
defined intelligence too narrowly, he proposed in tive was taken, the concept of intelligence began
the book Frames of Mind (Gardner, 1983) the ex- to lose its mystique and became a functional
istence of at least seven basic intelligences. More concept that could be seen working in people’s
recently, he has added an eighth, and discussed lives in a variety of ways. Gardner provided a
the possibility of a ninth (Gardner, 1999b). In means of mapping the broad range of abilities
his theory of multiple intelligences (MI theory), that humans possess by grouping their capabili-
Gardner sought to broaden the scope of human ties into eight comprehensive categories or
potential beyond the confines of the IQ score. He “intelligences”:

1
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

Linguistic Intelligence. The capacity to use produce or transform things (e.g., as a craftsper-
words effectively, whether orally (e.g., as a story- son, sculptor, mechanic, or surgeon). This
teller, orator, or politician) or in writing (e.g., as intelligence includes specific physical skills such
a poet, playwright, editor, or journalist). This in- as coordination, balance, dexterity, strength,
telligence includes the ability to manipulate the flexibility, and speed, as well as proprioceptive,
syntax or structure of language, the phonology tactile, and haptic capacities.
or sounds of language, the semantics or mean- Musical Intelligence. The capacity to per-
ings of language, and the pragmatic dimensions ceive (e.g., as a music aficionado), discriminate
or practical uses of language. Some of these uses (e.g., as a music critic), transform (e.g., as a com-
include rhetoric (using language to convince oth- poser), and express (e.g., as a performer) musical
ers to take a specific course of action), mnemon- forms. This intelligence includes sensitivity to
ics (using language to remember information), the rhythm, pitch or melody, and timbre or tone
explanation (using language to inform), and color of a musical piece. One can have a figural
metalanguage (using language to talk about it- or “top-down” understanding of music (global,
self). intuitive), a formal or “bottom-up” understand-
Logical-Mathematical Intelligence. The ca- ing (analytic, technical), or both.
pacity to use numbers effectively (e.g., as a Interpersonal Intelligence. The ability to
mathematician, tax accountant, or statistician) perceive and make distinctions in the moods, in-
and to reason well (e.g., as a scientist, computer tentions, motivations, and feelings of other peo-
programmer, or logician). This intelligence in- ple. This can include sensitivity to facial
cludes sensitivity to logical patterns and relation- expressions, voice, and gestures; the capacity for
ships, statements and propositions (if-then, discriminating among many different kinds of
cause-effect), functions, and other related ab- interpersonal cues; and the ability to respond ef-
stractions. The kinds of processes used in the fectively to those cues in some pragmatic way
service of logical-mathematical intelligence in- (e.g., to influence a group of people to follow a
clude: categorization, classification, inference, certain line of action).
generalization, calculation, and hypothesis Intrapersonal Intelligence. Self-knowledge
testing. and the ability to act adaptively on the basis of
Spatial Intelligence. The ability to perceive that knowledge. This intelligence includes hav-
the visual-spatial world accurately (e.g., as a ing an accurate picture of oneself (one’s strengths
hunter, scout, or guide) and to perform transfor- and limitations); awareness of inner moods, in-
mations on those perceptions (e.g., as an interior tentions, motivations, temperaments, and de-
decorator, architect, artist, or inventor). This in- sires; and the capacity for self-discipline,
telligence involves sensitivity to color, line, self-understanding, and self-esteem.
shape, form, space, and the relationships that ex- Naturalist Intelligence. Expertise in the rec-
ist between these elements. It includes the capac- ognition and classification of the numerous spe-
ity to visualize, to graphically represent visual or cies—the flora and fauna—of an individual’s
spatial ideas, and to orient oneself appropriately environment. This also includes sensitivity to
in a spatial matrix. other natural phenomena (e.g., cloud formations
Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence. Expertise and mountains) and, in the case of those grow-
in using one’s whole body to express ideas and ing up in an urban environment, the capacity to
feelings (e.g., as an actor, a mime, an athlete, or a discriminate among nonliving forms such as
dancer) and facility in using one’s hands to cars, sneakers, and music CD covers.

2
The Foundations of the Theory of Multiple Intelligences

The Theoretical Basis impaired, while frontal lobe lesions might pri-
marily affect the personal intelligences.
for MI Theory Gardner, then, is arguing for the existence of
Many people look at the eight categories— eight relatively autonomous brain systems—a
particularly musical, spatial, and bodily- more sophisticated and updated version of the
kinesthetic—and wonder why Howard Gardner “right-brain/left-brain” model of learning that
insists on calling them intelligences, and not tal- was popular in the 1970s. Figure 1.1 (see p. 5)
ents or aptitudes. Gardner realized that people are shows the brain structures for each intelligence.
used to hearing expressions like “He’s not very The Existence of Savants, Prodigies, and
intelligent, but he has a wonderful aptitude for Other Exceptional Individuals. Gardner sug-
music”; thus, he was quite conscious of his use gests that in some people we can see single intel-
of the word intelligence to describe each category. ligences operating at high levels, much like huge
He said in an interview, “I’m deliberately being mountains rising up against the backdrop of a
somewhat provocative. If I’d said that there’s flat horizon. Savants are individuals who demon-
seven kinds of competencies, people would strate superior abilities in part of one intelligence
yawn and say ‘Yeah, yeah.’ But by calling them while their other intelligences function at a low
‘intelligences,’ I’m saying that we’ve tended to level. They seem to exist for each of the eight in-
put on a pedestal one variety called intelligence, telligences. For instance, in the movie Rain Man
and there’s actually a plurality of them, and some (which is based on a true story), Dustin Hoffman
are things we’ve never thought about as being plays the role of Raymond, a logical-mathematical
‘intelligence’ at all” (Weinreich-Haste, 1985, savant. Raymond rapidly calculates multidigit
p. 48). To provide a sound theoretical founda- numbers in his head and does other amazing
tion for his claims, Gardner set up certain basic mathematical feats, yet he has poor peer relation-
“tests” that each intelligence had to meet to be ships, low language functioning, and a lack of in-
considered a full-fledged intelligence and not sight into his own life. There are also savants
simply a talent, skill, or aptitude. The criteria he who draw exceptionally well, savants who have
used include the following eight factors. amazing musical memories (e.g., playing a com-
Potential Isolation by Brain Damage. position after hearing it only one time), savants
Through his work at the Boston Veterans Admin- who read complex material yet don’t compre-
istration, Gardner worked with individuals who hend what they’re reading (hyperlexics), and sa-
had suffered accidents or illnesses that affected vants who have exceptional sensitivity to nature
specific areas of the brain. In several cases, brain or animals (see, e.g., Sacks, 1995).
lesions seemed to have selectively impaired one A Distinctive Developmental History and
intelligence while leaving all the other intelli- a Definable Set of Expert “End-State” Per-
gences intact. For example, a person with a le- formances. Gardner suggests that intelligences
sion in Broca’s area (left frontal lobe) might have are galvanized by participation in some kind of
a substantial portion of his linguistic intelligence culturally valued activity and that the individual’s
damaged, and thus experience great difficulty growth in such an activity follows a developmen-
speaking, reading, and writing. Yet he might still tal pattern. Each intelligence-based activity has
be able to sing, do math, dance, reflect on feel- its own developmental trajectory; that is, each
ings, and relate to others. A person with a lesion activity has its own time of arising in early child-
in the temporal lobe of the right hemisphere hood, its own time of peaking during one’s life-
might have her musical capacities selectively time, and its own pattern of either rapidly or

3
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 1.1
MI THEORY SUMMARY CHART
Intelligence Core Components Symbol Systems High End-States

Linguistic Sensitivity to the sounds, Phonetic languages Writer, orator (e.g., Virginia
structure, meanings, and (e.g., English) Woolf, Martin Luther King,
functions of words and Jr.)
language

Logical- Sensitivity to, and capacity Computer languages Scientist, mathematician


Mathematical to discern, logical or numeri- (e.g., Basic) (e.g., Madame Curie, Blaise
cal patterns; ability to han- Pascal)
dle long chains of reasoning

Spatial Capacity to perceive the Ideographic languages Artist, architect (e.g., Frida
visual-spatial world accu- (e.g., Chinese) Kahlo, I. M. Pei)
rately and to perform trans-
formations on one’s initial
perceptions

Bodily- Ability to control one’s body Sign languages, braille* Athlete-dancer, sculptor
Kinesthetic movements and to handle (e.g., Martha Graham,
objects skillfully Auguste Rodin)

Musical Ability to produce and ap- Musical notational systems, Composer, performer (e.g.,
preciate rhythm, pitch, and Morse Code Stevie Wonder, Midori)
timbre; appreciation of the
forms of musical
expressiveness

Interpersonal Capacity to discern and re- Social cues (e.g., Counselor, political leader
spond appropriately to the gestures and facial (e.g., Carl Rogers, Nelson
moods, temperaments, mo- expressions) Mandela)
tivations, and desires of
other people

Intrapersonal Access to one’s own “feel- Symbols of the self (e.g., in Psychotherapist, religious
ing” life and the ability to dis- dreams and artwork) leader (e.g., Sigmund
criminate among one’s Freud, the Buddha)
emotions; knowledge of
one’s own strengths and
weaknesses

Naturalist Expertise in distinguishing Species classification Naturalist, biologist, animal


among members of a spe- systems (e.g., Linnaeus); activist (e.g., Charles
cies; recognizing the exis- habitat maps Darwin, E. O. Wilson,
tence of other neighboring Jane Goodall)
species; and charting out
the relations, formally or in-
formally, among several
species

*Recent research suggests that many sign languages, such as American Sign Language, have a strongly linguistic basis as well (see, for ex-
ample, Sacks, 1990).

continued

4
The Foundations of the Theory of Multiple Intelligences

FIGURE 1.1— continued


MI THEORY SUMMARY CHART
Neurological Systems Developmental Ways That
Intelligence (Primary Areas) Factors Cultures Value

Linguistic Left temporal and frontal “Explodes” in early child- Oral histories, storytelling,
lobes (e.g., Broca’s/Wer- hood; remains robust until literature
nicke’s areas) old age

Logical- Left frontal and right Peaks in adolescence and Scientific discoveries,
Mathematical parietal lobes early adulthood; higher mathematical theories,
math insights decline after counting and classification
age 40 systems

Spatial Posterior regions of right Topological thinking in early Artistic works, navigational
hemisphere childhood gives way to systems, architectural de-
Euclidean paradigm around signs, inventions
age 9–10; artistic eye stays
robust into old age

Bodily- Cerebellum, basal ganglia, Varies depending upon Crafts, athletic perform-
Kinesthetic motor cortex component (strength, flexi- ances, dramatic works,
bility) or domain (gymnas- dance forms, sculpture
tics, baseball, mime)

Musical Right temporal lobe Earliest intelligence to de- Musical compositions, per-
velop; prodigies often go formances, recordings
through developmental
crisis

Interpersonal Frontal lobes, temporal lobe Attachment/bonding during Political documents, social
(especially right hemi- first 3 years critical institutions
sphere), limbic system

Intrapersonal Frontal lobes, parietal lobes, Formation of boundary be- Religious systems, psycho-
limbic system tween “self” and “other” dur- logical theories, rites of
ing first 3 years critical passage

Naturalist Areas of left parietal lobe Shows up dramatically in Folk taxonomies, herbal
important for discriminating some young children; lore, hunting rituals, animal
“living” from “nonliving” schooling or experience in- spirit mythologies
things creases formal or informal
expertise

continued

5
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 1.1— continued


MI THEORY SUMMARY CHART
Historical Factors
Evolutionary Presence in (Relative to Current
Intelligence Origins Other Species U.S. Status)

Linguistic Written notations found dat- Apes’ ability to name Oral transmission more im-
ing to 30,000 years ago portant before printing press

Logical- Early number systems and Bees calculate distances More important with influ-
Mathematical calendars found through their dances ence of computers

Spatial Cave drawings Territorial instinct of several More important with advent
species of video and other visual
technologies

Bodily- Evidence of early tool use Tool use of primates, anteat- Was more important in
Kinesthetic ers, and other species agrarian period

Musical Evidence of musical instru- Bird song Was more important during
ments back to Stone Age oral culture, when communi-
cation was more musical in
nature

Interpersonal Communal living groups re- Maternal bonding observed More important with in-
quired for hunting/gathering in primates and other crease in service economy
species

Intrapersonal Early evidence of religious Chimpanzees can locate Continues to be important


life self in mirror; apes experi- with increasingly complex
ence fear society requiring choice-
making

Naturalist Early hunting tools reveal Hunting instinct in innumer- Was more important during
understanding of other able species to discriminate agrarian period; then fell out
species between prey and nonprey of favor during industrial ex-
pansion; now “earth-smarts”
are more important than
ever to preserve endan-
gered ecosystems

gradually declining as one gets older. Musical Higher mathematical expertise, on the other
composition, for example, seems to be among hand, appears to have a somewhat different tra-
the earliest culturally valued activities to develop jectory. It doesn’t emerge as early as music com-
to a high level of proficiency: Mozart was only position ability (five-year-olds are still working
five when he began to compose. Numerous com- quite concretely with logical ideas), but it does
posers and performers have been active well into peak relatively early in life. Many great mathe-
their eighties and nineties, so expertise in musi- matical and scientific ideas were developed by
cal composition also seems to remain relatively teenagers such as Blaise Pascal and Karl Friedrich
robust into old age. Gauss. In fact, a review of the history of

6
The Foundations of the Theory of Multiple Intelligences

mathematical ideas suggests that few original instruments, as well as through the wide variety
mathematical insights come to people past of bird songs. Figure 1.1 (p. 6) includes notes on
the age of forty. Once people reach this age, the evolutionary origins of the intelligences.
they’re considered over-the-hill as higher mathe- MI theory also has a historical context. Cer-
maticians! Most of us can breathe a sigh tain intelligences seem to have been more
of relief, however, because this decline generally important in earlier times than they are today.
does not seem to affect more pragmatic skills Naturalist and bodily-kinesthetic intelligences,
such as balancing a checkbook. for example, were probably valued more a hun-
On the other hand, one can become a suc- dred years ago in the United States, when a
cessful novelist at age forty, fifty, or even later. majority of the population lived in rural settings
One can even be over seventy-five and choose to and the ability to hunt, harvest grain, and build
become a painter: Grandma Moses did. Gardner silos had strong social approbation. Similarly,
points out that we need to use several different certain intelligences may become more impor-
developmental maps in order to understand the tant in the future. As a greater percentage of the
eight intelligences. Piaget provides a comprehen- citizenry receive their information from films,
sive map for logical-mathematical intelligence, television, videotapes, and CD-ROM technology,
but we may need to go to Erik Erikson for a map the value placed on having a strong spatial intel-
of the development of the personal intelligences, ligence may increase. Similarly, there is now a
and to Noam Chomsky or Lev Vygotsky for de- growing need for individuals who have expertise
velopmental models of linguistic intelligence. in the naturalist intelligence to help protect en-
Figure 1.1 (p. 5) includes a summary of develop- dangered ecosystems. Figure 1.1 (p. 6) notes
mental trajectories for each intelligence. some of the historical factors that have influ-
Finally, Gardner (1994) points out that we enced the perceived value of each intelligence.
can best see the intelligences working at their ze- Support from Psychometric Findings.
nith by studying the “end-states” of intelligences Standardized measures of human ability provide
in the lives of truly exceptional individuals. We the “test” that most theories of intelligence (as
can see musical intelligence at work by studying well as many learning-style theories) use to as-
Beethoven’s 9th Symphony, the naturalist intelli- certain the validity of a model. Although Gard-
gence through Darwin’s theory of evolution, or ner is no champion of standardized tests and, in
spatial intelligence via Michelangelo’s Sistine fact, has been an ardent supporter of alternatives
Chapel paintings. Figure 1.1 (p. 4) includes to formal testing (see Chapter 10), he suggests
examples of end-states for each intelligence. that we can look at many existing standardized
An Evolutionary History and Evolutionary tests for support of the theory of multiple intelli-
Plausibility. Gardner concludes that each of the gences (although Gardner would point out that
eight intelligences meets the test of having its standardized tests assess multiple intelligences in
roots deeply embedded in the evolution of hu- a strikingly decontextualized fashion). For exam-
man beings and, even earlier, in the evolution of ple, the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children
other species. So, for example, spatial intelli- includes sub-tests that require linguistic intelli-
gence can be studied in the cave drawings of gence (e.g., information, vocabulary), logical-
Lascaux, as well as in the way certain insects ori- mathematical intelligence (e.g., arithmetic), spa-
ent themselves in space while tracking flowers. tial intelligence (e.g., picture arrangement), and
Similarly, musical intelligence can be traced back to a lesser extent bodily-kinesthetic intelligence
to archaeological evidence of early musical (e.g., object assembly). Still other assessments

7
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

tap personal intelligences (e.g., the Vineland So- Susceptibility to Encoding in a Symbol
ciety Maturity Scale and the Coopersmith Self- System. One of the best indicators of intelligent
Esteem Inventory). Chapter 3 includes a survey behavior, according to Gardner, is the capacity of
of the types of formal tests associated with each human beings to use symbols. The word “cat”
of the eight intelligences. that appears here on the page is simply a collec-
Support from Experimental Psychological tion of marks printed in a specific way. Yet it
Tasks. Gardner suggests that by looking at spe- probably conjures up for you an entire range
cific psychological studies, we can witness intel- of associations, images, and memories. What
ligences working in isolation from one another. has occurred is the bringing to the present
For example, in studies where subjects master a (“re-present-ation”) of something that is not
specific skill, such as reading, but fail to transfer actually here. Gardner suggests that the ability to
that ability to another area, such as mathematics, symbolize is one of the most important factors
we see the failure of linguistic ability to transfer separating humans from most other species. He
to logical-mathematical intelligence. Similarly, in notes that each of the eight intelligences in his
studies of cognitive abilities such as memory, theory meets the criterion of being able to be
perception, or attention, we can see evidence symbolized. Each intelligence, in fact, has its
that individuals possess selective abilities. Cer- own unique symbol or notational systems. For
tain individuals, for instance, may have a supe- linguistic intelligence, there are a number of
rior memory for words but not for faces; others spoken and written languages, such as English,
may have acute perception of musical sounds French, and Spanish. Spatial intelligence, on the
but not verbal sounds. Each of these cognitive other hand, includes a range of graphic lan-
faculties, then, is intelligence-specific; that is, guages used by architects, engineers, and design-
people can demonstrate different levels of profi- ers, as well as certain ideographic languages such
ciency across the eight intelligences in each cog- as Chinese. Figure 1.1 (p. 4) includes examples
nitive area. of symbol systems for all eight intelligences.
An Identifiable Core Operation or Set of
Operations. Gardner says that much as a com-
puter program requires a set of operations (e.g., Key Points in MI Theory
DOS) in order for it to function, each intelligence Beyond the descriptions of the eight intelligences
has a set of core operations that serve to drive and their theoretical underpinnings, certain
the various activities indigenous to that intelli- points of the model are important to remember:
gence. In musical intelligence, for example, those
components may include sensitivity to pitch or 1. Each person possesses all eight intelli-
the ability to discriminate among various rhyth- gences. MI theory is not a “type theory” for
mic structures. In bodily-kinesthetic intelligence, determining the one intelligence that fits. It is a
core operations may include the ability to imitate theory of cognitive functioning, and it proposes
the physical movements of others or the capacity that each person has capacities in all eight intelli-
to master established fine-motor routines for gences. Of course, the eight intelligences func-
building a structure. Gardner speculates that tion together in ways unique to each person.
these core operations may someday be identified Some people appear to possess extremely high
with such precision as to be simulated on a levels of functioning in all or most of the eight
computer. intelligences—for example, German poet-

8
The Foundations of the Theory of Multiple Intelligences

statesman-scientist-naturalist-philosopher kick, and catch), spatial intelligence (to orient


Johann Wolfgang von Goethe. Other people, himself to the playing field and to anticipate the
such as those in institutions for the developmen- trajectories of flying balls), and linguistic and in-
tally disabled, appear to lack all but the most ru- terpersonal intelligences (to successfully argue a
dimentary aspects of the intelligences. Most of us point during a dispute in the game). The intelli-
fall somewhere in between these two poles— gences have been taken out of context in MI the-
being highly developed in some intelligences, ory only for the purpose of examining their
modestly developed in others, and relatively essential features and learning how to use them
underdeveloped in the rest. effectively. We must always remember to put
2. Most people can develop each intelli- them back into their specific culturally valued
gence to an adequate level of competency. contexts when we are finished with their formal
Although an individual may bewail his deficien- study.
cies in a given area and consider his problems 4. There are many ways to be intelligent
innate and intractable, Gardner suggests that vir- within each category. There is no standard set
tually everyone has the capacity to develop all of attributes that one must have to be considered
eight intelligences to a reasonably high level of intelligent in a specific area. Consequently, a per-
performance if given the appropriate encourage- son may not be able to read, yet be highly lin-
ment, enrichment, and instruction. He points to guistic because he can tell a terrific story or has a
the Suzuki Talent Education Program as an ex- large oral vocabulary. Similarly, a person may be
ample of how individuals of relatively modest quite awkward on the playing field, yet possess
biological musical endowment can achieve a so- superior bodily-kinesthetic intelligence when she
phisticated level of proficiency in playing the weaves a carpet or creates an inlaid chess table.
violin or piano through a combination of the MI theory emphasizes the rich diversity of ways
in which people show their gifts within intelli-
right environmental influences (e.g., an involved
gences as well as between intelligences. (See
parent, exposure from infancy to classical music,
Chapter 3 for more information on the varieties
and early instruction). Such educational models
of attributes in each intelligence.)
can be found in other intelligences as well (see,
e.g., Edwards, 1979).
3. Intelligences usually work together in
complex ways. Gardner points out that each in- The Existence of Other
telligence as described above is actually a “fic- Intelligences
tion”; that is, no intelligence exists by itself in life Gardner points out that his model is a tentative
(except perhaps in very rare instances in savants formulation; after further research and investiga-
and brain-injured individuals). Intelligences are tion, some of the intelligences on his list may not
always interacting with each other. To cook a meet certain of the eight criteria described above,
meal, one must read the recipe (linguistic), pos- and therefore no longer qualify as intelligences.
sibly divide the recipe in half (logical- On the other hand, we may identify new intelli-
mathematical), develop a menu that satisfies all gences that do meet the various tests. In fact,
members of a family (interpersonal), and placate Gardner has acted on this belief by adding a new
one’s own appetite as well (intrapersonal). Simi- intelligence—the naturalist—after deciding that
larly, when a child plays a game of kickball, he it fits each of the eight criteria. His consideration
needs bodily-kinesthetic intelligence (to run, of a ninth intelligence—the existential—is also

9
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

based on its meeting most of the criteria (see spatial intelligence, for example, will show that
Chapter 14 for a detailed discussion of the exis- capacity in every aspect of her life (e.g., wash the
tential intelligence). Other writers and research- car spatially, reflect on ideas spatially, socialize
ers have proposed other intelligences, including spatially). He suggests that this task remains to
spirituality, moral sensibility, humor, intuition, be empirically investigated (for an example of an
creativity, culinary (cooking) ability, olfactory attempt in this direction, see Silver, Strong, and
perception (sense of smell), an ability to synthe- Perini, 1997).
size the other intelligences, and mechanical abil- At the same time, it is a tempting project to
ity. It remains to be seen, however, whether these want to relate MI theory to any of a number of
proposed intelligences can, in fact, meet each of learning style theories that have gained promi-
the eight tests described above. nence in the past two decades, because learners
expand their knowledge base by linking new in-
formation (in this case, MI theory) to existing
schemes or models (the learning-style model
The Relationship of MI Theory they’re most familiar with). This task is not so
to Other Intelligence Theories easy an undertaking, however, partly because of
Gardner’s theory of multiple intelligences is cer- what we’ve suggested above, and partly because
tainly not the first model to grapple with the no- MI theory has a different type of underlying
tion of intelligence. There have been theories of structure than many of the most current
learning-style theories. MI theory is a cognitive
intelligence since ancient times, when the mind
model that seeks to describe how individuals use
was considered to reside somewhere in the heart,
their intelligences to solve problems and fashion
the liver, or the kidneys. In more recent times,
products. Unlike other models that are primarily
theories of intelligence have emerged touting
process oriented, Gardner’s approach is particu-
anywhere from 1 (Spearman’s “g”) to 150 larly geared to how the human mind operates on
(Guilford’s Structure of the Intellect) types of the contents of the world (e.g., objects, persons,
intelligence. certain types of sounds). A seemingly related the-
A growing number of learning-style theories ory, the Visual-Auditory-Kinesthetic model, is ac-
also deserve to be mentioned here. Gardner has tually very different from MI theory, in that it is a
sought to differentiate the theory of multiple in- sensory-channel model (MI theory is not specifi-
telligences from the concept of “learning style.” cally tied to the senses; it is possible to be blind
He writes: and have spatial intelligence or to be deaf and be
The concept of style designates a general ap- quite musical). Another popular theory, the
proach that an individual can apply equally Myers-Briggs model, is actually a personality the-
to every conceivable content. In contrast, an ory based on Carl Jung’s theoretical formulation
intelligence is a capacity, with its component of different types of personalities. To attempt to
processes, that is geared to a specific content correlate MI theory with models like these is
in the world (such as musical sounds or spa- akin to comparing apples with oranges. Al-
tial patterns) (Gardner, 1995, pp. 202–203). though we can identify relationships and con-
nections, our efforts may resemble those of the
There is no clear evidence yet, according to Blind Men and the Elephant: each model touch-
Gardner, that a person highly developed in ing on a different aspect of the whole learner.

10
The Foundations of the Theory of Multiple Intelligences

FOR FURTHER STUDY


In this chapter, I have presented the basic the 21st Century (New York: Basic Books,
tenets of the theory of multiple intelligences 1999b) as a basis for reading more widely on
in a brief and concise way. MI theory has con- the model.
nections with a wide range of fields, includ- 3. Propose the existence of a new intelli-
ing anthropology, cognitive psychology, gence and apply Gardner’s eight criteria to see
developmental psychology, studies of excep- if it qualifies for inclusion in MI theory.
tional individuals, psychometrics, and neu- 4. Collect examples of symbol systems in
ropsychology. There is ample opportunity to each intelligence. For instance, see Robert
explore the theory in its own right, quite McKim’s book Experiences in Visual Thinking
apart from its specific educational uses. Such (Boston: PWS Engineering, 1980) for exam-
a preliminary study may actually help you ap- ples of several spatial “languages” used by de-
ply the theory in the classroom. Here are signers, architects, artists, and inventors; and
some suggestions for exploring more deeply books on musical history provide examples of
the foundations of MI theory. earlier systems of musical notation.
5. Read about savants in each intelligence.
1. Form a study group on MI theory using Some of the footnoted entries in Gardner’s
Howard Gardner’s seminal book Frames of (1993a) Frames of Mind identify sources of in-
Mind: The Theory of Multiple Intelligences/Tenth formation on savants in logical-mathematical,
Anniversary Edition (New York: Basic Books, spatial, musical, linguistic, and bodily-
1993a) as a text. Each member can be re- kinesthetic intelligences. In addition, the
sponsible for reading and reporting on a spe- work of Oliver Sacks provides engagingly
cific chapter. written case studies of savants and other indi-
2. Use Gardner’s exhaustive bibliography viduals with specific brain damage that has
on MI theory found in his book Multiple Intel- affected their intelligences in intriguing ways
ligences: The Theory in Practice (New York: Ba- (see Sacks, 1985, 1993, 1995).
sic Books, 1993b) or his more recent book 6. Relate MI theory to a current
Intelligence Reframed: Multiple Intelligences for learning-style model.

11
MI and Personal Development
2
What kind of school plan you make is neither here nor there; what matters is what sort
of a person you are.
—Rudolf Steiner (1964)

Before applying any model of learning in a the total spectrum of abilities. The best way to
classroom environment, we should first apply it assess your own multiple intelligences, therefore,
to ourselves as educators and adult learners, for is through a realistic appraisal of your perform-
unless we have an experiential understanding of ance in the many kinds of tasks, activities, and
the theory and have personalized its content, we experiences associated with each intelligence.
are unlikely to be committed to using it with stu- Rather than performing several artificial learning
dents. Consequently, an important step in using tasks, look back over the kinds of real-life expe-
the theory of multiple intelligences (after grasp- riences you’ve already had in these eight intelli-
ing the basic theoretical foundations presented in gences. The MI inventory in Figure 2.1 on pages
Chapter 1) is to determine the nature and quality 13–16 can assist you in doing this.
of our own multiple intelligences and seek ways It’s important to keep in mind that this inven-
to develop them in our lives. As we begin to do tory is not a test, and that quantitative informa-
this, it will become apparent how our particular tion (such as the number of checks for each
fluency (or lack of fluency) in each of the eight intelligence) has no bearing on determining your
intelligences affects our competence (or lack of intelligence or lack of intelligence in each cate-
competence) in the various roles we have as gory. The purpose of the inventory is to begin to
educators. connect you to your own life experiences with
the eight intelligences. What sorts of memories,
feelings, and ideas emerge from this process?
Identifying Your
Multiple Intelligences
As you will see in the later chapters on student Tapping MI Resources
assessment (Chapters 3 and 10), developing a The theory of multiple intelligences is an espe-
profile of a person’s multiple intelligences is not a cially good model for looking at teaching
simple matter. No test can accurately determine strengths as well as for examining areas needing
the nature or quality of a person’s intelligences. improvement. Perhaps you avoid drawing pic-
As Howard Gardner has repeatedly pointed out, tures on the blackboard or stay away from using
standardized tests measure only a small part of highly graphic materials in your presentations

12
MI and Personal Development

FIGURE 2.1
AN MI INVENTORY FOR ADULTS

Check those statements that apply in each intelligence category. Space has been provided at the end of
each intelligence for you to write additional information not specifically referred to in the inventory items.

Linguistic Intelligence
Books are very important to me.
I can hear words in my head before I read, speak, or write them down.
I get more out of listening to the radio or a spoken-word cassette than I do from television or films.
I enjoy word games like Scrabble, Anagrams, or Password.
I enjoy entertaining myself or others with tongue twisters, nonsense rhymes, or puns.
Other people sometimes have to stop and ask me to explain the meaning of the words I use in my
writing and speaking.
English, social studies, and history were easier for me in school than math and science.
Learning to speak or read another language (e.g., French, Spanish, German) has been relatively
easy for me.
My conversation includes frequent references to things that I’ve read or heard.
I’ve written something recently that I was particularly proud of or that earned me recognition from
others.

Other Linguistic Abilities:

Logical-Mathematical Intelligence
I can easily compute numbers in my head.
Math and/or science were among my favorite subjects in school.
I enjoy playing games or solving brainteasers that require logical thinking.
I like to set up little “what if” experiments (for example, “What if I double the amount of water I give to
my rosebush each week?”)
My mind searches for patterns, regularities, or logical sequences in things.
I’m interested in new developments in science.
I believe that almost everything has a rational explanation.
I sometimes think in clear, abstract, wordless, imageless concepts.
I like finding logical flaws in things that people say and do at home and work.
I feel more comfortable when something has been measured, categorized, analyzed,
or quantified in some way.

Other Logical-Mathematical Abilities:

continued

13
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 2.1— continued


AN MI INVENTORY FOR ADULTS

Spatial Intelligence
I often see clear visual images when I close my eyes.
I’m sensitive to color.
I frequently use a camera or camcorder to record what I see around me.
I enjoy doing jigsaw puzzles, mazes, and other visual puzzles.
I have vivid dreams at night.
I can generally find my way around unfamiliar territory.
I like to draw or doodle.
Geometry was easier for me than algebra in school.
I can comfortably imagine how something might appear if it were looked down on from directly above
in a bird’s-eye view.
I prefer looking at reading material that is heavily illustrated.

Other Spatial Abilities:

Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence
I engage in at least one sport or physical activity on a regular basis.
I find it difficult to sit still for long periods of time.
I like working with my hands at concrete activities such as sewing, weaving, carving, carpentry,
or model building.
My best ideas often come to me when I’m out for a long walk or a jog, or when I’m engaging in
some other kind of physical activity.
I often like to spend my free time outdoors.
I frequently use hand gestures or other forms of body language when conversing with someone.
I need to touch things in order to learn more about them.
I enjoy daredevil amusement rides or similar thrilling physical experiences.
I would describe myself as well coordinated.
I need to practice a new skill rather than simply reading about it or seeing a video that describes it.

Other Bodily-Kinesthetic Abilities:

continued

14
MI and Personal Development

FIGURE 2.1— continued


AN MI INVENTORY FOR ADULTS

Musical Intelligence
I have a pleasant singing voice.
I can tell when a musical note is off-key.
I frequently listen to music on radio, records, cassettes, or compact discs.
I play a musical instrument.
My life would be poorer if there were no music in it.
I sometimes catch myself walking down the street with a television jingle or other tune running
through my mind.
I can easily keep time to a piece of music with a simple percussion instrument.
I know the tunes to many different songs or musical pieces.
If I hear a musical selection once or twice, I am usually able to sing it back fairly accurately.
I often make tapping sounds or sing little melodies while working, studying, or learning
something new.

Other Musical Abilities:

Interpersonal Intelligence
I’m the sort of person that people come to for advice and counsel at work or in my neighborhood.
I prefer group sports like badminton, volleyball, or softball to solo sports such as swimming and
jogging.
When I have a problem, I’m more likely to seek out another person for help than attempt to work it
out on my own.
I have at least three close friends.
I favor social pastimes such as Monopoly or bridge over individual recreations such as video games
and solitaire.
I enjoy the challenge of teaching another person, or groups of people, what I know how to do.
I consider myself a leader (or others have called me that).
I feel comfortable in the midst of a crowd.
I like to get involved in social activities connected with my work, church, or community.
I would rather spend my evenings at a lively party than stay at home alone.

Other Interpersonal Abilities:

continued

15
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 2.1— continued


AN MI INVENTORY FOR ADULTS

Intrapersonal Intelligence
I regularly spend time alone meditating, reflecting, or thinking about important life questions.
I have attended counseling sessions or personal growth seminars to learn more about myself.
I am able to respond to setbacks with resilience.
I have a special hobby or interest that I keep pretty much to myself.
I have some important goals for my life that I think about on a regular basis.
I have a realistic view of my strengths and weaknesses (borne out by feedback from other sources).
I would prefer to spend a weekend alone in a cabin in the woods rather than at a fancy resort with
lots of people around.
I consider myself to be strong willed or independent minded.
I keep a personal diary or journal to record the events of my inner life.
I am self-employed or have at least thought seriously about starting my own business.

Other Intrapersonal Abilities:

Naturalist Intelligence

I like to spend time backpacking, hiking, or just walking in nature.


I belong to some kind of volunteer organization related to nature (e.g., Sierra Club), and I’m
concerned about helping to save nature from further destruction.
I thrive on having animals around the house.
I’m involved in a hobby that involves nature in some way (e.g., bird watching).
I’ve enrolled in courses relating to nature at community centers or colleges (e.g., botany, zoology).
I’m quite good at telling the difference between different kinds of trees, dogs, birds, or other types of
flora or fauna.
I like to read books and magazines, or watch television shows or movies that feature nature in some
way.
When on vacation, I prefer to go off to a natural setting (park, campground, hiking trail) rather than to
a hotel/resort or city/cultural location.
I love to visit zoos, aquariums, or other places where the natural world is studied.
I have a garden and enjoy working regularly in it.

Other Naturalist Abilities:

16
MI and Personal Development

because spatial intelligence is not particularly intelligences that seem to be “blind spots” in
well developed in your life. Or possibly you your life is through a process of careful cultiva-
gravitate toward cooperative learning strategies tion or personal development of your intelli-
or ecological activities because you are an inter- gences. MI theory provides a model through
personal or naturalist sort of learner/teacher which you can activate your neglected intelli-
yourself. Use MI theory to survey your teaching gences and balance your use of all the
style and see how it matches up with the eight intelligences.
intelligences. Although you don’t have to be a
master in all eight intelligences, you probably
should know how to tap resources in the intelli-
gences you typically shy away from in the class-
Developing Your
room. Some ways to do this include the following. Multiple Intelligences
Drawing on Colleagues’ Expertise. If you I’ve been careful not to use the terms “strong in-
don’t have ideas for bringing music into the telligence” and “weak intelligence” in describing
classroom because your musical intelligence is individual differences among a person’s intelli-
undeveloped, consider getting help from the gences, because a person’s “weak” intelligence
school’s music teacher or a musically inclined may actually turn out to be her strongest intelli-
colleague. The theory of multiple intelligences gence, once given the chance to develop. As
has broad implications for team teaching. In a mentioned in Chapter 1, a key point in MI the-
school committed to developing students’ multi- ory is that most people can develop all their intelli-
ple intelligences, the ideal teaching team or cur- gences to a relatively competent level of mastery.
riculum planning committee includes expertise Whether intelligences develop depends on three
in all eight intelligences; that is, each member main factors:
possesses a high level of development in a differ-
• Biological endowment, including hereditary
ent intelligence.
or genetic factors and insults or injuries to the
Asking Students to Help Out. Students can
brain before, during, and after birth;
often come up with strategies and demonstrate
• Personal life history, including experiences
expertise in areas where teachers may be defi-
with parents, teachers, peers, friends, and others
cient. For example, students may be able to do
who either awaken intelligences or keep them
some picture drawing on the board; provide mu-
from developing;
sical background for a learning activity; or share
• Cultural and historical background, including
knowledge about lizards, insects, flowers, or
the time and place in which you were born and
other fauna or flora, if you don’t feel comfortable
raised and the nature and state of cultural or his-
or competent doing these things yourself.
torical developments in different domains.
Using Available Technology. Tap your
school’s technical resources to convey informa- We can see the interaction of these factors in the
tion you might not be able to provide yourself. life of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. Mozart un-
For instance, you can use CD recordings of mu- doubtedly came into life already possessing a
sic if you’re not musical, videotapes if you’re not strong biological endowment (a healthy right
picture-oriented, calculators and self-paced com- temporal lobe perhaps). And he was born into a
puter software to supplement your shortcomings family of musical individuals; in fact, his father,
in logical-mathematical areas, and so on. Leopold, was a composer who gave up his own
The final way to come to grips with career to support his son’s musical development.

17
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

Finally, Mozart was born at a time in Europe experience activated his genius and started him
when the arts (including music) were flourish- on his journey toward discoveries that would
ing, and wealthy patrons supported composers make him one of the towering figures in 20th
and performers. Mozart’s genius, therefore, arose century thought. Similarly, when Yehudi
through a confluence of biological, personal, and Menuhin was almost four, his parents took him
cultural/historical factors. What would have hap- to a concert by the San Francisco Symphony Or-
pened, however, if Mozart had instead been born chestra. The experience so enthralled him that
to tone-deaf parents in Puritan England, where afterwards he asked his parents for a violin as a
most music was considered the devil’s work? His birthday present, and he said he wanted the vio-
musical gifts likely would never have developed lin soloist they heard that evening to teach him
to a high level because of the forces working to play it! Crystallizing experiences, then, are the
against his biological endowment. sparks that light an intelligence and start its de-
The interaction of the above factors is also velopment toward maturity.
evident in the musical proficiency of many of the Conversely, I use the term paralyzing experi-
children who have been enrolled in the Suzuki ences to refer to experiences that “shut down” in-
Talent Education Program. Although some telligences. Perhaps a teacher humiliated you in
Suzuki students may be born with a relatively front of your classmates when you showed your
modest genetic musical endowment, they are latest artistic creation during art period, and that
able to develop their musical intelligence to a event marked the end of a good part of your spa-
high level through experiences in the program. tial development. Possibly a parent yelled at you
MI theory is a model that values nurture as much to “stop making a racket” on the piano, and you
as, and probably more than, nature in accounting never went near a musical instrument after that.
for the development of intelligences. Or maybe you were punished for bringing your
“messy” leaf collection into the house, without
any acknowledgment of the spark of the natural-
Activators and Deactivators ist that you might have displayed. Paralyzing ex-
periences are often filled with shame, guilt, fear,
of Intelligences anger, and other negative emotions that prevent
Crystallizing experiences and paralyzing experi- our intelligences from growing and thriving (see
ences are two key processes in the development Miller, 1981).
of intelligences. Crystallizing experiences, a con- A number of other environmental influences
cept originating with David Feldman (1980) at also promote or retard the development of intel-
Tufts University and further developed by ligences. They include the following.
Howard Gardner and his colleagues (see Walters Access to Resources or Mentors. If your
& Gardner, 1986), are the “turning points” in the family was so poor that you couldn’t afford a vio-
development of a person’s talents and abilities. lin, piano, or other instrument, your musical in-
Often these events occur in early childhood, telligence might well have remained undeveloped.
although they can occur anytime during the life Historical-Cultural Factors. If you were a
span. For instance, when Albert Einstein was student who demonstrated “proclivities” in
four years old, his father showed him a magnetic mathematics at a time when math and science
compass. The adult Einstein later said this com- programs were highly funded, your logical-
pass filled him with a desire to figure out the mathematical intelligence would likely have
mysteries of the universe. Essentially, this developed.

18
MI and Personal Development

Geographic Factors. If you grew up on a may have had little time to develop in areas of
farm, you might well have had more opportunity promise—unless they were interpersonal in
to develop certain aspects of the naturalist or nature.
bodily-kinesthetic intelligences than if you were MI theory offers a model of personal develop-
raised on the 62nd floor of a Manhattan high- ment that can help educators understand how
rise apartment. their own profile of intelligences affects their
Familial Factors. If you wanted to be an art- teaching approaches in the classroom. Further, it
ist but your parents wanted you to be a lawyer, opens the gate to a broad range of activities that
their influence might well have promoted the de- can help us develop neglected intelligences, acti-
velopment of your linguistic intelligence at the vate underdeveloped or paralyzed intelligences,
expense of your spatial intelligence. and bring well-developed intelligences to even
Situational Factors. If you had to help take higher levels of proficiency.
care of a large family while you were growing up, See the next page for ways to explore your
and you now have a large family yourself, you own multiple intelligences.

19
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FOR FURTHER STUDY


1. Fill out the inventory in this chapter to an even higher level. Using a piece of mu-
(Figure 2.1). Talk with a friend or colleague ral paper perhaps five feet in length, create a
about the results of the inventory. Make sure time line showing the development of that in-
to share something about what you perceive telligence from early childhood to the pres-
as your most developed intelligences and ent. Note significant events along the way,
your least developed intelligences. Avoid talk- including crystallizing and paralyzing experi-
ing in terms of quantitative information (“I ences, people who helped you develop the
had only three checks in musical intelli- intelligence (or sought to suppress it), school
gence”). Speak instead in anecdotal terms: influences, what happened to the intelligence
“I’ve never felt very musical in my life; my as you became an adult, and so forth. Leave
classmates used to laugh at me when I had to space on the time line to include information
sing solo in music class.” about the future development of the intelli-
Also, begin to reflect on how your devel- gence (see Study Item 4).
oped and undeveloped intelligences affect 3. Create a curriculum planning team or
what you put into, or keep out of, your work other school group that consists of individu-
as an educator. What kinds of teaching meth- als representing each of the eight intelli-
ods or materials do you avoid because they gences. Before beginning the planning work,
involve using your underdeveloped intelli- take time to share your personal experiences
gences? What sorts of things are you espe- of your most highly developed intelligence.
cially good at doing because of one or more 4. Select an intelligence that is not very
highly developed intelligences? highly developed in your life and create a
2. Select an intelligence that you would plan for cultivating it. Look over suggestions
like to nurture. It may be an intelligence you for developing the intelligences in 7 Kinds of
showed particular promise in as a child but Smart (Armstrong, T., 1993, 1999b), or create
never had the opportunity to develop (the in- your own list of ways to nurture each
telligence may have gone “underground” as intelligence. As you begin personally
you grew up). Or perhaps it is an intelligence developing an intelligence, notice whether this
you have had great difficulty with and that process influences what you do in the
you want to experience more competence classroom. Are you bringing more aspects of
and confidence in. Or, possibly, it’s a highly that intelligence into your professional work?
developed intelligence that you want to take

20
Describing Intelligences in Students
3
Hide not your talents
For use they were made.
What’s a sundial in the shade!
—Ben Franklin

Although it’s true that each child possesses all students’ multiple intelligences. If anyone should
eight intelligences and can develop all eight to a tell you they have a computer-scored test that in
fairly high level of competence, children seem to fifteen minutes can provide a bar graph showing
begin showing what Howard Gardner calls “pro- the eight “peaks” and “valleys” of each student in
clivities” (or inclinations) in specific intelligences your class or school, I’d suggest that you be very
from a very early age. By the time children begin skeptical. This isn’t to say that formal testing
school, they have probably established ways of can’t provide some information about a student’s
learning that run more along the lines of some intelligences; as I discuss later, it can provide
intelligences than others. In this chapter, we will clues to various intelligences. The single best tool
examine how you can begin to describe students’ for assessing students’ multiple intelligences,
most developed intelligences so that more of however, is probably one readily available to all
their learning in school can take place through of us: simple observation.
their preferred intelligences. I’ve often humorously suggested to teachers
Figure 3.1 provides brief descriptions of the that one good way to identify students’ most
capacities of children who display proclivities in highly developed intelligences is to observe how
specific intelligences. Keep in mind, however, they misbehave in class. The strongly linguistic
that most students have strengths in several ar- student will be talking out of turn, the highly
eas, so you should avoid pigeonholing a child in spatial student will be doodling and daydream-
one intelligence. You will probably find each stu- ing, the interpersonally inclined student will be
dent pictured in at least two or three of these in- socializing, the bodily-kinesthetic student will be
telligence descriptions. fidgeting, and the naturalistically engaged stu-
dent might well bring an animal to class without
permission! These students are metaphorically
Assessing Students’ saying through their misbehavior: “This is how I
learn, teacher, and if you don’t teach me through
Multiple Intelligences my most natural learning channels, guess what?
There is no “mega-test” on the market that can I’m going to do it anyway.” These intelligence-
provide a comprehensive survey of your specific misbehaviors, then, are a sort of cry for

21
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 3.1
EIGHT WAYS OF LEARNING
Children who
are highly: THINK LOVE NEED

Linguistic in words reading, writing, telling stories, books, tapes, writing tools, paper,
playing word games diaries, dialogue, discussion, de-
bate, stories

Logical- by reasoning experimenting, questioning, figur- materials to experiment with,


Mathematical ing out logical puzzles, calculating science materials, manipulatives,
trips to the planetarium and sci-
ence museum

Spatial in images and designing, drawing, visualizing, art, LEGOs, video, movies, slides,
pictures doodling imagination games, mazes, puz-
zles, illustrated books, trips to art
museums

Bodily- through dancing, running, jumping, build- role play, drama, movement,
Kinesthetic somatic ing, touching, gesturing things to build, sports and physical
sensations games, tactile experiences,
hands-on learning

Musical via rhythms singing, whistling, humming, tap- sing-along time, trips to concerts,
and melodies ping feet and hands, listening music playing at home and school,
musical instruments

Interpersonal by bouncing leading, organizing, relating, ma- friends, group games, social gath-
ideas off other nipulating, mediating, partying erings, community events, clubs,
people mentors/apprenticeships

Intrapersonal in relation to setting goals, meditating, dream- secret places, time alone, self-
their needs, ing, planning, reflecting paced projects, choices
feelings, and
goals

Naturalist through nature playing with pets, gardening, in- access to nature, opportunities for
and natural vestigating nature, raising animals, interacting with animals, tools for
forms caring for planet earth investigating nature (e.g., magnify-
ing glass, binoculars)

help—a diagnostic indicator of how students might gravitate toward books, social students to-
need to be taught. ward group games and gossip, spatial students
Another good observational indicator of stu- toward drawing, bodily-kinesthetic students to-
dents’ proclivities is how they spend their free ward hands-on building activities, and naturalis-
time in school. In other words, what do they do tically inclined students toward the gerbil cage or
when nobody is telling them what to do? If you aquarium. Observing kids in these student-
have a “choice time” in class when students can initiated activities can tell a world about how
choose from a number of activities, what activi- they learn most effectively.
ties do students pick? Highly linguistic students Every teacher should consider keeping a

22
Describing Intelligences in Students

notebook, diary, or journal handy in a desk or on football game or through a hands-on demonstra-
a shelf for recording observations of this kind. Of tion of how to fix a machine or plant a flower,
course, if you’re working with 150 students a capture their performance on videotape. Ulti-
day at the middle school or high school level, mately, MI assessment data will consist of several
regular recording of observations for each stu- kinds of documents, including photos, sketches,
dent would hardly be possible. You might, samples of school work, audio cassettes, video-
however, single out the two or three most trou- tapes, color photocopies, and more. The use of
blesome or puzzling students in class, and focus CD-ROM technology can allow all of this infor-
your MI assessment on them. Even if you have a mation to be conveniently included on a single
class of 25 to 35 students, writing a couple of disc and reviewed by teachers, administrators,
lines about each student each week may pay off parents, and students themselves. (For more on
in the long run. Writing two lines a week for assessment through multiple intelligences, see
forty weeks yields eighty lines, or three to four Chapter 10.)
pages of solid observational data for each Look at School Records. Cumulative rec-
student. ords, as two-dimensional and lifeless as they
To help organize your observations of a stu- sometimes appear, can provide important infor-
dent’s multiple intelligences, you can use a mation about a student’s multiple intelligences.
checklist like the one in Figure 3.2. Keep in Look at the student’s grades over the years. Are
mind that this checklist is not a test (it has not grades in math and the hard sciences consis-
been subjected to any protocols necessary to tently higher than grades in literature and the so-
establish reliability and validity) and should only cial sciences? If so, this may be evidence of an
be used informally in conjunction with other inclination toward logical-mathematical over lin-
sources of assessment information when describ- guistic intelligence. High art and drafting grades
ing students’ multiple intelligences. may indicate well-developed spatial intelligence,
In addition to observations and checklists, while As and Bs in PE and shop class may point
there are several other excellent ways to get as- toward bodily-kinesthetic abilities. Similarly, test
sessment information about students’ multiple scores can sometimes provide differential infor-
intelligences. mation about a student’s intelligences. On intelli-
Collect Documents. Anecdotal records are gence tests, for example, there are often subtests
not the only way to document students’ strongest that tap linguistic intelligence (vocabulary and
intelligences. Teachers should consider having a “information” categories), logical-mathematical
Polaroid camera available to snap pictures of stu- intelligence (analogies, arithmetic), and spatial
dents’ displaying evidence of their multiple intel- intelligence (picture arrangement, block design,
ligences. Photographs are particularly useful for etc.). A number of other tests may point toward
documenting products that might be gone in an- specific intelligences. Here is a partial list of the
other ten minutes, like giant LEGO structures. kinds of tests that may relate to each intelligence:
If students show a particular capacity for telling • Linguistic. Reading tests, language tests, the
stories or singing songs, record them and keep verbal sections of intelligence and achievement
the cassette as a document. If students have tests
drawing or painting abilities, keep samples of • Logical-Mathematical. Piagetian assessments,
their work or take photographs or slides of it. math achievement tests, the reasoning sections of
If students show their greatest assets during a intelligence tests

23
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 3.2
CHECKLIST FOR ASSESSING STUDENTS’ MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES

Name of Student:

Check items that apply:

Linguistic Intelligence
writes better than average for age
spins tall tales or tells jokes and stories
has a good memory for names, places, dates, or trivia
enjoys word games
enjoys reading books
spells words accurately (or if preschool, does developmental spelling that is advanced for age)
appreciates nonsense rhymes, puns, tongue twisters
enjoys listening to the spoken word (stories, commentary on the radio, talking books)
has a good vocabulary for age
communicates to others in a highly verbal way

Other Linguistic Abilities:

Logical-Mathematical Intelligence
asks a lot of questions about how things work
enjoys working or playing with numbers
enjoys math class (or if preschool, enjoys counting and doing other things with numbers)
finds math and computer games interesting (or if no exposure to computers, enjoys other math or
science games)
enjoys playing chess, checkers, or other strategy games
enjoys working on logic puzzles or brainteasers (or if preschool, enjoys hearing logical nonsense)
enjoys putting things in categories, hierarchies, or other logical patterns
likes to do experiments in science class or in free play
shows interest in science-related subjects
does well on Piagetian-type assessments of logical thinking

Other Logical-Mathematical Abilities:

continued

24
Describing Intelligences in Students

FIGURE 3.2— continued


CHECKLIST FOR ASSESSING STUDENTS’ MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES

Spatial Intelligence
reports clear visual images
reads maps, charts, and diagrams more easily than text (or if preschool, enjoys looking at more
than text)
daydreams a lot
enjoys art activities
good at drawings
likes to view movies, slides, or other visual presentations
enjoys doing puzzles, mazes, or similar visual activities
builds interesting three-dimensional constructions (e.g., LEGO buildings)
gets more out of pictures than words while reading
doodles on workbooks, worksheets, or other materials

Other Spatial Abilities:

Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence
excels in one or more sports (or if preschool, shows physical prowess advanced for age)
moves, twitches, taps, or fidgets while seated for a long time in one spot
cleverly mimics other people’s gestures or mannerisms
loves to take things apart and put them back together again
puts his/her hands all over something he/she’s just seen
enjoys running, jumping, wrestling, or similar activities (or if older, will show these interests in a more
“restrained” way—e.g., running to class, jumping over a chair)
shows skill in a craft (e.g., woodworking, sewing, mechanics) or good fine-motor coordination in other
ways
has a dramatic way of expressing herself/himself
reports different physical sensations while thinking or working
enjoys working with clay or other tactile experiences (e.g., fingerpainting)

Other Bodily-Kinesthetic Abilities:

continued

25
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 3.2— continued


CHECKLIST FOR ASSESSING STUDENTS’ MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES

Musical Intelligence
tells you when music sounds off-key or disturbing in some other way
remembers melodies of songs
has a good singing voice
plays a musical instrument or sings in a choir or other group (or if preschool, enjoys playing
percussion instruments and/or singing in a group)
has a rhythmic way of speaking and/or moving
unconsciously hums to himself/herself
taps rhythmically on the table or desk as he/she works
sensitive to environmental noises (e.g., rain on the roof)
responds favorably when a piece of music is put on
sings songs that he/she has learned outside of the classroom

Other Musical Abilities:

Interpersonal Intelligence
enjoys socializing with peers
seems to be a natural leader
gives advice to friends who have problems
seems to be street-smart
belongs to clubs, committees, organizations, or informal peer groups
enjoys informally teaching other kids
likes to play games with other kids
has two or more close friends
has a good sense of empathy or concern for others
others seek out his/her company

Other Interpersonal Abilities:

continued

26
Describing Intelligences in Students

FIGURE 3.2— continued


CHECKLIST FOR ASSESSING STUDENTS’ MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES

Intrapersonal Intelligence

displays a sense of independence or a strong will


has a realistic sense of his/her abilities and weaknesses
does well when left alone to play or study
marches to the beat of a different drummer in his/her style of living and learning
has an interest or hobby that he/she doesn’t talk much about
has a good sense of self-direction
prefers working alone to working with others
accurately expresses how he/she is feeling
is able to learn from his/her failures and successes in life
has good self-esteem

Other Intrapersonal Abilities:

Naturalist Intelligence

talks a lot about favorite pets, or preferred spots in nature, during class sharing
likes field trips in nature, to the zoo, or to a natural history museum
shows sensitivity to natural formations (e.g., while walking outside with the class, will notice
mountains, clouds; or if in an urban environment, may show this ability in sensitivity to popular
culture “formations” such as sneakers or automobile styles)
likes to water and tend to the plants in the classroom
likes to hang around the gerbil cage, the aquarium, or the terrarium in class
gets excited when studying about ecology, nature, plants, or animals
speaks out in class for the rights of animals, or the preservation of planet earth
enjoys doing nature projects, such as bird watching, butterfly or insect collections, tree study,
or raising animals
brings to school bugs, flowers, leaves, or other natural things to share with classmates or teachers
does well in topics at school that involve living systems (e.g., biological topics in science,
environmental issues in social studies)

Other Naturalist Abilities:

27
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

• Spatial. Visual-memory and visual-motor displaying kinesthetic or musical gifts (unless, of


tests, art aptitude tests, some performance items course, you are regularly teaching through the
on intelligence tests multiple intelligences). Even if you work with
• Bodily-Kinesthetic. Sensorimotor tests, some students through all subject areas, you can often
motor subtests in neuropsychological batteries, get additional information by contacting special-
the President’s physical fitness test ists who are working more specifically with one
• Interpersonal. Social maturity scales, socio- or two of the intelligences. Hence, the art teacher
grams, interpersonal projective tests (e.g., Family might be the best person to talk with about a
Kinetic Drawing) student’s spatial intelligence, the PE teacher the
• Intrapersonal. Self-concept assessments, person to go to for information about some
projective tests bodily-kinesthetic abilities, and the counselor the
• Naturalist. Test items that include pictures person who could share information about the
of animals, plants, or natural settings personal intelligences (although the counselor’s
ability to share information may be limited due
School records may also contain valuable an- to issues of confidentiality). Regard your col-
ecdotal information about a student’s multiple leagues as important sources of assessment infor-
intelligences. One of the most valuable sources, mation about students’ multiple intelligences and
I’ve discovered, is the kindergarten teacher’s re- meet with them periodically to compare notes.
port. Often, the kindergarten teacher is the only You may find that a child who appears quite low
educator to see the child regularly functioning in functioning in one class will be one of the stars
all eight intelligences. Consequently, comments in a class that requires a different set of
like “loves finger painting,” “moves gracefully intelligences.
during music and dance time,” or “creates beau- Talk with Parents. Parents are true experts
tiful structures with blocks” can provide clues to of a child’s multiple intelligences. They’ve had
a student’s spatial, musical, or bodily-kinesthetic the opportunity to see the child learn and grow
proclivities. under a broad spectrum of circumstances en-
When reviewing a student’s cumulative rec- compassing all eight intelligences. Consequently,
ords, I’ve found it useful to photocopy the rec- they ought to be enlisted in the effort to identify
ords (with permission from the school and the child’s strongest intelligences. During back-
parents, of course) and then take a yellow high- to-school night, introduce parents to the concept
lighting pen and underline all the positive infor- of multiple intelligences and provide them with
mation about that student, including the highest specific ways through which they can observe
grades and test scores and the positive observa- and document their child’s strengths at home,
tions of others. Then I type up each piece of including the use of scrapbooks, audio cassettes,
highlighted information on a separate sheet of videotapes, photographs, and samples of stories,
paper and organize the sheets according to intel- sketches, and artifacts that emerged from a
ligences. This practice provides me with solid child’s special hobby or other interest. Then, par-
information about a student’s strongest intelli- ents can bring to future parent-teacher confer-
gences that I can then communicate to parents, ences any information that may help teachers
administrators, and the student’s teachers. develop a broader understanding of the child’s
Talk with Other Teachers. If you have stu- multiple intelligences.
dents only for English or math class, then you Many years ago, the phrase “the six-hour re-
are usually not in a position to observe them tarded child” emerged to describe a student who

28
Describing Intelligences in Students

showed little promise or potential in the class- assessment data about students’ multiple
room but was a real achiever outside of school, intelligences.
perhaps as the leader of a youth group, a jack- Set Up Special Activities. If you regularly
of-all-trades that neighbors came to for all kinds teach through the multiple intelligences, then
of repairs, or a fledgling entrepreneur with a you have frequent opportunities to assess
flourishing small business. Obtaining assessment through the multiple intelligences as well. So, for
information from the home is critical in discov- example, if you teach a lesson on fractions eight
ering ways to transplant such a child’s success different ways, you can note how different chil-
from the home to the school. dren respond to each activity. The child who is
Ask Students. Students are the ultimate ex- almost falling asleep during the logical presenta-
perts on the way they learn, because they’ve tion may come alive when the bodily-kinesthetic
lived with it twenty-four hours a day ever since approach begins, only to tune out again when a
they were born. After they have been introduced musical method is used. Seeing little light bulbs
to the idea of multiple intelligences (see Chapter go on and off during the course of a day is an
4), you can sit down with them and through an affirmation of the existence of these intelligences,
interview discover what they consider to be their as well as a record of the individual differences in
most highly developed intelligences. I’ve used your class. Similarly, setting up activity centers
the “MI Pizza” shown in Figure 4.1 on page 33 for each intelligence (see Chapter 7) provides
as a record-keeping form for making notes while opportunities for seeing how students function
I ask students individually about their abilities in in each area or which areas students naturally
each area. You can also have students draw pic- gravitate toward when they are free to choose.
tures of themselves doing things in their most Because the MI perspective on assessment (pre-
developed intelligences (a spatial approach), sented in Chapter 10) is based on a close con-
rank from 1 to 8 their most-developed to least- nection between instruction and assessment,
developed intelligence on the MI Pizza (a logical- many of the activities in Chapters 5 and 6 can be
mathematical approach), or pantomime their used as diagnostic indicators, as well as teaching
most developed intelligences (a bodily- activities.
kinesthetic approach). Some of the activities in See the next page for more ways to explore
Chapter 4 can also be helpful in getting students’ multiple intelligences.

29
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FOR FURTHER STUDY


1. Fill out the checklist in Figure 3.2 for 4. Have students “tell” you their preferred
each student in your classroom. Notice which intelligences through one or more of the fol-
items cannot be answered for lack of suffi- lowing media: writing, drawing, pantomime,
cient background information about the stu- group discussion, personal interview. Make
dent. Identify methods you can use to obtain sure they have first been introduced to the
information about these items (e.g., parent or theory through some of the activities de-
child interview, experiential activities), and scribed in Chapter 4.
then use them to help complete the checklist. 5. During parent-teacher conferences,
How does your view of individual children devote some time to acquiring information
remain the same or change as a result of about a student’s multiple intelligences at
framing their lives in terms of MI theory? home.
What implications do the checklist results 6. Review selected students’ cumulative
have for your teaching? files, focusing on data that suggest the pres-
2. Keep a journal to record observations ence of special proclivities in one or more of
of students’ multiple intelligences. If you ob- the eight intelligences. If possible, obtain cop-
serve students outside the classroom (e.g., as ies of the file material so you can underline
a recess or lunchroom monitor) notice how strengths with a yellow highlighter pen and
their behavior is the same as or different from then transcribe the highlighted items onto
their behavior in the classroom. What evi- separate sheets of paper. Distribute these
dence for each student’s multiple intelligences “strength profiles” at the next meeting called
emerges from the anecdotal data? to discuss students’ learning.
3. Select one form of documenting stu- 7. Conference with other teachers about
dents’ learning activities that you haven’t yet students’ multiple intelligences. Set aside
tried, such as audiotaping, videotaping, or special time so that teachers who are re-
photography. Experiment with its use and no- sponsible for different intelligences in school
tice how effective it may be in providing and (e.g., math, shop, art, literature, biology, and
communicating information about students’ music teachers) can reflect on students’ per-
multiple intelligences. formance in each learning context.

30
Teaching Students About MI Theory
4
Give me a fish and I eat for a day.
Teach me to fish and I eat for a lifetime.
—Proverb

One of the most useful features of MI theory A Five-Minute Introduction to


is that it can be explained to a group of children MI Theory
as young as 2nd grade in as little as five minutes How does a teacher present the theory of multi-
in such a way that they can then use the MI vo- ple intelligences to a group of students? Natu-
cabulary to talk about how they learn. Although rally, the answer to that question will depend in
many other theories of learning contain terms part on the size of the class, the developmental
and acronyms not easily understood by adults, level of students, their background, and the
let alone children (e.g., INFJ in the Myers-Briggs kinds of instructional resources available. The
typology refers to an “Introverted, Intuitive, Feel- most direct way to introduce MI theory to stu-
ing, Judging” person), the eight intelligences are dents is simply to explain it to them. When I go
linked to concrete antecedents that young and to a new classroom to demonstrate how to teach
old alike have had experience with: words, num- a multiple-intelligence lesson, I always begin
bers, pictures, the body, music, people, the self, with a five-minute explanation of the theory so
and nature. students have a context for understanding what I
Recent research in cognitive psychology ap- am doing there. I usually begin by asking, “How
plied to education has supported the notion that many of you think you’re intelligent?” I’ve dis-
children benefit from instructional approaches covered that there seems to be an inverse rela-
that help them reflect on their own learning pro- tionship between the number of hands that go
cesses (see Marzano et al., 1988). When children up and the grade level that I’m teaching—that is,
engage in this kind of metacognitive activity, they the lower the grade level, the more hands go up;
can select appropriate strategies for problem the higher the grade level, the fewer hands. This
solving. They can also serve as advocates for reminds me of New York University professor
themselves when placed in new learning Neil Postman’s remark that “children go into
environments. school as question marks and leave school as

31
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

periods.” What do we do in the intervening years • “How many people here can see pictures in
to convince children that they’re not intelligent? their head when they close their eyes?”
Regardless of the number of hands that go • “How many of you enjoy watching moving
up, I usually say, “All of you are intelligent—and pictures on television, in the movies, or in a Nin-
not just in one way. Each of you is intelligent in tendo game?”
eight different ways.” I draw an “MI Pizza” on the Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence. Body
blackboard (a circle divided into eight slices) and Smart, Sports Smart, or Hand Smart (I use sev-
then begin to explain the model. “First, there is eral terms here to get at different aspects of this
something called word smart.” I use simple terms intelligence.)
to describe the intelligences, because words like • “How many people here like sports?”
“linguistic” are a mouthful for many children. As • “How many of you enjoy making things
shown in Figure 4.1, I also accompany each term with your hands, like models or LEGO struc-
with a graphic symbol to spatially reinforce it. tures?”
Then I ask questions. “How many people here
can speak?” Usually, I’ll get a lot of hands with Musical Intelligence. Music Smart
this question! “Well, in order to speak you have • “How many here enjoy listening to music?”
to use words, so all of you are word smart!” • “How many have ever played a musical in-
“How many people here can write?” “You’re us- strument or sung a song?”
ing words here also, so again, you’re all word Interpersonal Intelligence. People Smart
smart.” Essentially, I ask questions that build in- • “How many people have at least one
clusion. I steer clear of questions that might ex- friend?”
clude lots of students, such as “How many of • “How many of you enjoy working in
you have read fifteen books in the past month?” groups at least part of the time here in school?”
This is a learning model not for deciding which
exclusive group one is a member of, but for cele- Intrapersonal Intelligence. Self Smart
brating all of one’s potentials for learning. Other- • “How many of you have a secret or special
wise, teachers might be preparing the way for place you go to when you want to get away from
students to say, “I don’t have to read this book, everybody and everything?”
because I’m really not word smart.” • “How many of you like to spend at least
Here are the simple terms for each of the in- part of the time working on your own here in
telligences and some questions that I use in my class?”
presentations: Naturalist Intelligence. Nature Smart
• “How many of you enjoy being out in na-
Linguistic Intelligence. Word Smart
ture?”
(see preceding questions)
• “How many of you have ever had a butter-
Logical-Mathematical Intelligence. Number fly collection, an insect collection, a collection of
Smart or Logic Smart leaves from trees in your neighborhood, a collec-
• “How many of you can do math?” tion of shells, or some other kind of collection of
• “How many people here have done a sci- natural things?”
ence experiment?” • “How many of you have pets, or enjoy
Spatial Intelligence. Picture Smart spending time with animals?”
• “How many of you draw?” You can develop your own questions to

32
Teaching Students About MI Theory

FIGURE 4.1
MI PIZZA

Nature Word
Smart Smart

Self Logic
Smart Smart

People Picture
Smart Smart

Music Body
Smart Smart

illustrate each intelligence. Just make sure they • People Smart. TV talk show hosts,
build in inclusion and give all children a chance politicians
to see themselves as intelligent. You can also give • Self Smart. Famous entrepreneurs (“self-
examples of what Howard Gardner calls the made” people)
“end-states” of each intelligence—that is, people • Nature Smart. Animal experts, nature
who have developed an intelligence to a high explorers
level of competence. These examples provide
students with models to be inspired by and to
aspire to. Pick famous figures and heroes from Activities for Teaching
each student’s own world. Examples might
include: MI Theory
Naturally, you’ll want to go beyond a simple ver-
• Word Smart. Authors of children’s literature bal explanation of the model, and you should
that the class has been reading strive to teach the model in all eight intelli-
• Number Smart or Logic Smart. Famous sci- gences. There are a number of ways of introduc-
entists students have studied in class ing the model or of following up your
• Picture Smart. Illustrators of children’s lit- five-minute introduction with reinforcing activi-
erature, famous cartoonists and filmmakers ties and supplementary experiences. Here are
• Body Smart. Famous sports heroes and some examples:
actors
• Music Smart. Famous rock stars, rappers, Career Day. If you regularly bring members
and other musicians of your community into the classroom to talk

33
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

about their jobs, begin to contextualize this ac- Luther King, Jr. (people smart), Sigmund Freud
tivity within a multiple-intelligence framework. (self smart), and Jane Goodall (nature smart).
Bring in an editor to talk about the kinds of Make sure the people studied are representative
“word smart” activities he uses, a tax accountant of your students’ cultural, racial, gender, and
to speak about how she uses her “number smart” ethnic backgrounds. See page 125 in Chapter 13
to help people, and an architect to explain the for more multicultural examples of famous peo-
usefulness of “picture smart” in her career. Other ple and page 106 in Chapter 11 for examples of
career-day guests might include an athlete (body famous people in each intelligence who over-
smart), a professional musician (music smart), a came specific disabilities and difficulties.
counselor (people smart), a person who has Lesson Plans. Teach an eight-way lesson on
started a business (self smart), or a veterinarian a particular subject or in a specific skill area (see
(nature smart). Keep in mind, though, that each Chapter 5 for guidelines on creating MI lessons).
career usually involves several intelligences, and Explain beforehand to students that you are go-
that you might want to discuss how each role ing to teach this material using each of the eight
brings together a combination of intelligences in intelligences and that they should pay particular
a unique way. These presentations are extremely attention to how each of the eight intelligences is
important in emphasizing to students that each covered. After the lesson, ask students to de-
of the intelligences plays a vital part in people’s scribe your use of each intelligence. This activity
success in the world. You may want to speak requires students to reflect on the kinds of pro-
beforehand with the guests about the model so cesses necessary for each intelligence and rein-
they can work it into their presentations. Or you forces their metacognitive awareness. You may
can simply follow up their appearances by relat- also want to ask them which particular method
ing what they said or did to one or more of the or methods they preferred. In this way, you help
eight intelligences. students begin to understand which strategies
Field Trips. Take students to places in the they prefer to use when learning something new.
community where each of the intelligences is Quick Experiential Activities. An experien-
particularly valued and practiced. Some destina- tial way of introducing MI theory is to have stu-
tions might include a library (word smart), a sci- dents complete eight activities, each of which
ence lab (logic smart), a crafts factory (picture draws primarily on the use of one intelligence.
and body smart), a radio station that plays music For instance, you might have students do some
(music smart), a public relations firm (people writing (“write a short poem”), math (“tell me
smart), a psychologist’s office (self smart), and a how long ago was a million seconds ago”), draw-
zoo (nature smart). Again, seeing these intelli- ing (“draw a picture of an animal”), running (“go
gences in context gives students a more accurate outside and run to the end of the block and
“real-life” picture of MI theory than could ever be back”), singing (“let’s all sing ‘Row, Row, Row
given in a classroom setting. Your Boat’ together”), sharing (“turn to a partner
Biographies. Have students study the lives of and share something nice that happened to you
well-known people proficient in one or more of this week”), self-reflecting (“close your eyes and
the intelligences (see Gardner, 1994). Subjects think about the happiest moment in your
for study might include Toni Morrison (word life—you won’t have to share it with anybody”),
smart), Marie Curie (logic smart), Vincent Van and observing nature (“look out the window and
Gogh (picture smart), Roberto Clemente (body notice all the living things and natural forma-
smart), George Gershwin (music smart), Martin tions you can see”). Adjust the activities to the

34
Teaching Students About MI Theory

ability level of your students, choosing open- each product is labeled with the intelligence or
ended activities that just about everyone can do, intelligences required to produce it.
and giving those who can’t do them modified Readings. For older students, you can assign
versions of the activities. You can use this ap- readings from any of the growing number of
proach either before or after explicitly describing books and articles on the theory of multiple in-
the “eight kinds of smart.” Make sure to ask stu- telligences (see Appendixes A and B), including
dents which activities they prefer, and remember chapters from Frames of Mind, 7 Kinds of Smart
to relate each activity to one (or more) of the (revised to include the naturalist intelligence), or
eight intelligences. In Their Own Way.
Wall Displays. Walk into a typical American MI Tables. Set up eight tables in the class-
classroom and you’ll often find a poster of Albert room, each clearly labeled with a sign referring
Einstein on the wall. Einstein is probably a good to one of the eight intelligences. On each table,
representative of multiple intelligences because place a task card indicating what students are to
he used several of them in his work, including do. At the word smart table, students can do a
spatial, bodily-kinesthetic, and logical- writing task; at the number smart table, a math
mathematical. Instead of displaying an Einstein or science task; at the picture smart table, a
poster, however, consider hanging eight posters drawing task; at the body smart table, a building
on the wall, each representing a person espe- task; at the music smart table, a musical task; at
cially proficient in one of the intelligences (see the people smart table, a cooperative task; at the
Gardner, 1994, and its “Biographies” section on self smart table, an individualized task; and at
pages 41–42 for suggested names). Or hang a the nature smart table, a task that involves ob-
banner reading “Eight Ways to Learn” or “This Is serving an animal or plant. Tell students to go to
How We Learn in School” and display photos of the table they believe represents their most de-
students in the school using each of the intelli- veloped intelligence (don’t tell them the tasks be-
gences. There are even commercially made post- forehand, or they will pick the table based on the
ers on the intelligences, available from Skylight/ activity). Have them work at the task for a desig-
IRI, 2626 South Clearbrook Drive, Arlington nated amount of time (perhaps five minutes),
Heights, IL 60005-6609 (1-800-348-4474), and and then use a musical signal (like a bell) to indi-
Zephyr Press, P.O. Box 66006-G1, Tucson, AZ cate that it’s time to move to the next table (move
85728-6006 (1-800-232-2187). clockwise). Continue until all students have ex-
Shelf Displays. Show products made by stu- perienced each task. Talk about students’ prefer-
dents in the school that required the use of each ences and relate each task to an intelligence.
of the eight intelligences. Examples might in- Chapter 7 deals more specifically with how to set
clude essays, stories, or poems (word smart); up activity centers that reflect a multiple-
computer programs (logic smart); drawings and intelligence perspective.
paintings (picture smart); musical scores (music Human Intelligence Hunt. If you are intro-
smart); three-dimensional projects (body smart); ducing MI theory at the beginning of the year,
cooperative projects (people smart); individual when students still don’t know each other very
projects (self smart); or simulations of ecosys- well, a “human intelligence hunt” is a useful way
tems (nature smart). The products could be dis- to teach students experientially about the eight
played on a shelf, in a glass case, or on a table, kinds of smarts while helping them get to know
and rotated regularly so all students have a one another better. It is based on the premise
chance to display their achievements. Make sure that each of us is a “treasure chest” filled with

35
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

special gifts. These gifts are our intelligences. working with very young students, you may
Sometimes, though, we’re unaware of other want to substitute the song “Old MacDonald
people’s gifts, so we have to go on a “treasure Had a Farm” for a Mozart tune. You can even
hunt”—in this case, an “intelligence hunt”—to create a hunt based entirely on pictures, which
discover one another’s special talents. Each stu- would involve students’ finding people in the
dent receives a list of tasks like those in Figure class who particularly enjoy doing the kinds of
4.2. On your signal, students take the task sheet activities depicted in each picture. After the ac-
along with a pen or pencil and find other stu- tivity, remember to link each task to a different
dents in the room who can do the tasks listed. intelligence and to talk about what students
There are three basic rules: learned about one another’s gifts or intelligences.
Board Games. You can create a homemade
1. Students must actually perform the tasks
board game based on the eight intelligences. Get
listed, not simply say they can do them.
a manila file folder and a magic marker and cre-
2. Once a student performs a task to the
ate the common board game format of a winding
“hunter’s” satisfaction, he or she should initial the
roadway divided into many small squares. Assign
blank space next to the appropriate task on the
each intelligence a color and then place an ap-
“hunter’s” task sheet.
propriately colored intelligence symbol on each
3. “Hunters” can ask a person to perform
square of the game board. You may use the sym-
only one task; therefore, to complete the hunt, a
bols in Figure 4.1 or make up your own. Then
student must have eight different sets of initials.
create eight sets of 2" x 3" game cards from eight
You can modify the activities listed in Figure 4.2 colors of paper that match the colored symbols
to include tasks geared to your students’ apti- on the game board. On each set of game cards,
tudes and abilities. For instance, if you’re type or write tasks that involve using a specific
intelligence. Here, for instance, are some tasks
for picture smart at the primary level:
FIGURE 4.2
HUMAN INTELLIGENCE HUNT • Draw a picture of a dog in less than thirty
seconds.
• Find an object in the shape of a circle in the
Find someone who can: class.
hum something by Mozart (Music Smart) • Tell us your favorite color.
do a simple dance step (Body Smart)
• Describe four blue things you see in the
room.
recite four lines from a poem
(Word Smart) • Close your eyes and describe the pictures
explain why the sky is blue (Logic Smart) in your mind.
briefly share a recent dream (Self Smart) Make sure most of the tasks are within the capa-
draw a picture of a horse (Picture Smart) bilities of your students. Then get a pair of dice
honestly say she is relaxed and comfort- and some miniature plastic figurines as game
able relating to other people during this pieces, and start playing!
exercise (People Smart)
MI Stories, Songs, or Plays. Be creative and
name five different types of birds (or trees)
that are found in the immediate area make up your own story, song, or play for teach-
(Nature Smart) ing the idea of multiple intelligences (your stu-
dents can help you). You might, for example,

36
Teaching Students About MI Theory

create a story about eight children, each an ex- There are undoubtedly many other activities
pert in a particular intelligence, who don’t get that would help teach students about the theory
along very well and who are forced into an ad- of multiple intelligences. The development of
venture that requires them to travel to distant such experiences should be an ongoing process
magical lands. In each land they encounter chal- throughout the year. After you have introduced a
lenges that require the unique intelligence of a few activities, it may be helpful to prominently
particular child. For example, the children come display a poster listing the eight intelligences,
to a land where, in order to be understood, peo- perhaps in the form of the MI Pizza shown in
ple have to communicate through singing, so the Figure 4.1. When something happens that seems
musical child guides them through this land. In to relate to one or more of the eight intelligences,
another land, they fall into a hole and get out you can then use the poster to help emphasize
through the body-smart child’s expertise. At the the relationship. For example, if several students
end of the story, they are able to accomplish their express a strong desire to work together on a
task (perhaps to retrieve a golden jewel) because project, you can point out that they want to use
they have drawn on the talents or intelligences of their “people smart.” For a student who has cre-
all eight children. ated a particularly apt visual illustration for an
This story can then be used as a metaphor for assignment, you can suggest that she really em-
classroom behavior: we need to respect and find ployed her “picture smart” in the work. By mod-
ways of celebrating the unique talents and gifts eling the practical use of MI theory frequently in
of each student. A story like this one could be the daily activities of the classroom, you will help
performed as a play, a puppet show, or a musical students internalize the theory, and you should
and performed for other students in the school. begin to see them use its vocabulary to make
sense out of their own learning lives.

FOR FURTHER STUDY


1. Drawing on the material in this chapter includes instruction in the theory of multiple
or activities of your own choosing, develop a intelligences. Include readings, exercises, ac-
way to introduce the theory of multiple intel- tivities, and strategies designed to help stu-
ligences to your students. Note their initial re- dents understand their thinking styles so that
actions. Follow this up with supplementary they can learn more effectively.
activities. How long does it take before stu- 3. Design a special wall display, bulletin
dents begin to use the terms themselves? board, or exhibit area where the eight
Note two or three examples of how students intelligences are honored and celebrated.
used the model to explain their learning Include posters of famous people, photos of
processes. students engaged in MI activities, examples of
2. Create a mini-unit or special course for products made by students in each of the
students on “learning about learning” that intelligences, or all these things.

37
MI and Curriculum Development
5
We do not see in our descriptions [of classroom activity] . . . much opportunity for students to
become engaged with knowledge so as to employ their full range of intellectual abilities. And
one wonders about the meaningfulness of whatever is acquired by students who sit listening
or performing relatively repetitive exercises, year after year. Part of the brain, known as Ma-
goun’s brain, is stimulated by novelty. It appears to me that students spending twelve years in
the schools we studied would be unlikely to experience much novelty. Does part of the brain
just sleep, then?
—John I. Goodlad (1984, p. 231)

MI theory makes its greatest contribution to broad range of stimulating curricula to “awaken”
education by suggesting that teachers need to ex- the slumbering brains that Goodlad fears popu-
pand their repertoire of techniques, tools, and late our schools.
strategies beyond the typical linguistic and logi-
cal ones predominantly used in U.S. classrooms.
According to John Goodlad’s pioneering “A The Historical Background of
Study of Schooling” project, which involved re- Multimodal Teaching
searchers in observing more than 1,000 class-
Multiple intelligences as a philosophy guiding
rooms nationwide, nearly 70 percent of
instruction is hardly a new concept. Even Plato,
classroom time was consumed by “teacher”
in a manner of speaking, seemed aware of the
talk—mainly teachers talking “at” students (giv- importance of multimodal teaching when he
ing instructions, lecturing). The next most wrote: “Do not use compulsion, but let early
widely observed activity was students doing education be a sort of amusement; you will then
written assignments; and according to Goodlad be better able to find out the natural bent” (Plato,
(1984, p. 230), “much of this work was in the 1952, p. 399). More recently, virtually all the
form of responding to directives in workbooks pioneers of modern education developed sys-
or on worksheets.” In this context, the theory of tems of teaching based on more than verbal
multiple intelligences functions not only as a pedagogy. The 18th century philosopher Jean
specific remedy to one-sidedness in teaching, but Jacques Rousseau declared in his classic treatise
also as a “metamodel” for organizing and synthe- on education, Emile, that the child must learn
sizing all the educational innovations that have not through words, but through experience; not
sought to break out of this narrowly confined ap- through books but through “the book of life.”
proach to learning. In doing so, it provides a The Swiss reformer Johann Heinrich Pestalozzi

38
MI and Curriculum Development

emphasized an integrated curriculum that re- fingers to teach multiplication, and imagery and
garded physical, moral, and intellectual training metaphor to clarify negative numbers (if one digs
based solidly on concrete experiences. And the a hole in the ground, the hole represents nega-
founder of the modern-day kindergarten, Frie- tive numbers, the pile of dirt next to it signifies
drich Froebel, developed a curriculum consisting positive numbers). John Keating (played by
of hands-on experiences with manipulatives Robin Williams), the prep school instructor in
(“gifts”), in addition to playing games, singing Dead Poets Society, has students reading literary
songs, gardening, and caring for animals. In the passages while kicking soccer balls and listening
20th century, innovators like Maria Montessori to classical music. MI theory provides a way for
and John Dewey evolved systems of instruction all teachers to reflect on their best teaching
based on multiple-intelligence-like techniques, methods and to understand why these methods
including Montessori’s tactile letters and other work (or why they work well for some students
self-paced materials, and Dewey’s vision of the but not for others). It also helps teachers expand
their current teaching repertoire to include a
classroom as a microcosm of society.
broader range of methods, materials, and tech-
By the same token, many current alternative
niques for reaching an ever wider and more di-
educational models essentially are multiple-
verse range of learners.
intelligence systems using different terminologies
(and with varying levels of emphasis on the dif-
ferent intelligences). Cooperative learning, for
example, seems to place its greatest emphasis on The MI Teacher
interpersonal intelligence, yet specific activities A teacher in an MI classroom contrasts sharply
can involve students in each of the other intelli- with a teacher in a traditional linguistic class-
gences as well. Similarly, whole language instruc- room. In the traditional classroom, the teacher
tion has at its core the cultivation of linguistic lectures while standing at the front of the class-
intelligence, yet it uses music, hands-on activi- room, writes on the blackboard, asks students
ties, introspection (through journal keeping), questions about the assigned reading or hand-
and group work to carry out its fundamental outs, and waits while students finish their writ-
goals. Suggestopedia, a pedagogical approach ten work. In the MI classroom, the teacher
developed by the Bulgarian psychiatrist Georgi continually shifts her method of presentation
Lozanov, uses drama and visual aids as keys to from linguistic to spatial to musical and so on,
unlocking a student’s learning potential, yet it often combining intelligences in creative ways.
seems that in this approach music plays the great- The MI teacher may spend part of the time
est role in facilitating learning, for students listen lecturing and writing on the blackboard at the
to music as an integral part of their instruction. front of the room. This, after all, is a legitimate
MI theory essentially encompasses what good teaching technique. Teachers have simply been
teachers have always done in their teaching: doing too much of it. The MI teacher, however,
reaching beyond the text and the blackboard to also draws pictures on the blackboard or shows a
awaken students’ minds. Two movies about great videotape to illustrate an idea. She often plays
teachers, Stand and Deliver (1987) and Dead Poets music at some time during the day, either to set
Society (1989), underline this point. In Stand and the stage for an objective, to make a point, or to
Deliver, Jaime Escalante (played by Edward James provide an environment for study. The MI
Olmos), a Hispanic high school mathematics teacher provides hands-on experiences, whether
teacher, uses apples to introduce fractions, this involves getting students up and moving

39
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

about, or passing an artifact around to bring to and materials that can be employed in teaching
life the material studied, or having students build through the multiple intelligences. Capitalized
something tangible to reveal their understanding. items in the list are discussed more fully in
The MI teacher also has students interacting with Chapter 6.
each other in different ways (e.g., in pairs, small
groups, or large groups); she plans time for stu- Linguistic Intelligence
dents to engage in self-reflection, undertake self- • lectures
paced work, or link their personal experiences • large- and small-group discussions
and feelings to the material being studied; and • books
where possible, she creates opportunities for • worksheets
learning to occur through living things or in the • manuals
midst of the natural world. • BRAINSTORMING
Such characterizations of what the MI teacher • writing activities
does and does not do, however, should not serve • word games
to immobilize the instructional dimensions of MI • sharing time
theory. The theory can be implemented in a wide • student speeches
range of instructional contexts, from highly tra- • STORYTELLING
ditional settings, where teachers spend much of • talking books and cassettes
their time directly teaching students, to open en- • extemporaneous speaking
vironments, where students regulate most of • debates
their own learning. Even traditional linguistic • JOURNAL KEEPING
teaching can take place in a variety of ways de- • choral reading
signed to stimulate the eight intelligences. The • individualized reading
teacher who lectures with rhythmic emphasis • reading to the class
(musical), draws pictures on the board to illus- • memorizing linguistic facts
trate points (spatial), makes dramatic gestures as • TAPE RECORDING ONE’S WORDS
she talks (bodily-kinesthetic), pauses to give stu- • using word processors
dents time to reflect (intrapersonal), asks ques- • PUBLISHING (e.g., creating class
tions that invite spirited interaction newspapers)
(interpersonal), and includes references to nature
in her lectures (naturalist), is using MI principles Logical-Mathematical Intelligence
within a traditional teacher-centered perspective. • mathematical problems on the board
• SOCRATIC QUESTIONING
• scientific demonstrations
• logical problem-solving exercises
Key Materials and Methods • CLASSIFICATIONS AND
of MI Teaching CATEGORIZATIONS
There are a number of teaching tools in MI the- • creating codes
ory, however, that go far beyond the traditional • logic puzzles and games
teacher-as-lecturer mode of instruction. Figure • QUANTIFICATIONS AND
5.1 provides a quick summary of MI teaching CALCULATIONS
methods. The following list provides a broader, • computer programming languages
but still incomplete, survey of the techniques • SCIENCE THINKING

40
MI and Curriculum Development

FIGURE 5.1
SUMMARY OF THE EIGHT WAYS OF TEACHING
Teaching Activities Teaching Materials Instructional
Intelligence (examples) (examples) Strategies

Linguistic lectures, discussions, word books, tape recorders, type- read about it, write about it,
games, storytelling, choral writers, stamp sets, books talk about it, listen to it
reading, journal writing on tape

Logical- brain teasers, problem solv- calculators, math manipula- quantify it, think critically
Mathematical ing, science experiments, tives, science equipment, about it, put it in a logical
mental calculation, number math games framework, experiment
games, critical thinking with it

Spatial visual presentations, art ac- graphs, maps, video, LEGO see it, draw it, visualize it,
tivities, imagination games, sets, art materials, optical il- color it, mind-map it
mind-mapping, metaphor, lusions, cameras, picture
visualization library

Bodily- hands-on learning, drama, building tools, clay, sports build it, act it out, touch it,
Kinesthetic dance, sports that teach, equipment, manipulatives, get a “gut feeling” of it,
tactile activities, relaxation tactile learning resources dance it
exercises

Musical rhythmic learnings, rapping, tape recorder, tape collec- sing it, rap it, listen to it
using songs that teach tion, musical instruments

Interpersonal cooperative learning, peer board games, party sup- teach it, collaborate on it, in-
tutoring, community involve- plies, props for role plays teract with respect to it
ment, social gatherings,
simulations

Intrapersonal individualized instruction, in- self-checking materials, connect it to your personal


dependent study, options in journals, materials for life, make choices with re-
course of study, self-esteem projects gard to it, reflect on it
building

Naturalist nature study, ecological plants, animals, naturalists’ connect it to living things
awareness, care of animals tools (e.g., binoculars), gar- and natural phenomena
dening tools

continued

41
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 5.1— continued


SUMMARY OF THE EIGHT WAYS OF TEACHING
Sample Educational
Movement Sample Teacher Sample Activity to
Intelligence (primary intelligence) Presentation Skill Begin a Lesson

Linguistic Whole Language teaching through storytelling long word on the blackboard

Logical- Critical Thinking Socratic questioning posing a logical paradox


Mathematical

Spatial Integrated Arts drawing/mind-mapping unusual picture on the


Instruction concepts overhead

Bodily- Hands-On Learning using gestures/dramatic mysterious artifact passed


Kinesthetic expressions around the class

Musical “Suggestopedia” using voice rhythmically piece of music played as


students come into class

Interpersonal Cooperative dynamically interacting with “Turn to a neighbor and


Learning students share . . . ”

Intrapersonal Individualized bringing feeling into “Close your eyes and think of
Instruction presentation a time in your life when . . . ”

Naturalist Ecological Studies linking subject matter to bring in an interesting plant


natural phenomena or animal to spark discus-
sion about topic

• logical-sequential presentation of subject • visual thinking exercises


matter • GRAPHIC SYMBOLS
• Piagetian cognitive stretching exercises • mind-maps and other visual organizers
• HEURISTICS • computer graphics software
• visual pattern seeking
Spatial Intelligence • optical illusions
• charts, graphs, diagrams, and maps • COLOR CUES
• VISUALIZATION • visual awareness activities
• photography • draw-and-paint/computer-assisted-design
• videos, slides, and movies software
• visual puzzles and mazes • picture literacy experiences
• 3-D construction kits
• art appreciation Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence
• imaginative storytelling • creative movement
• PICTURE METAPHORS • HANDS-ON THINKING
• creative daydreaming • field trips
• painting, collage, and other visual arts • mime
• IDEA SKETCHING • THE CLASSROOM THEATER

42
MI and Curriculum Development

• competitive and cooperative games • cross-age tutoring


• physical awareness exercises • group brainstorming sessions
• hands-on activities of all kinds • PEER SHARING
• crafts • community involvement
• BODY MAPS • apprenticeships
• use of kinesthetic imagery • SIMULATIONS
• cooking, gardening, and other “messy” • academic clubs
activities • interactive software
• manipulatives • parties or social gatherings as context for
• virtual reality software learning
• KINESTHETIC CONCEPTS • PEOPLE SCULPTING
• physical education activities
• using body language/hand signals to Intrapersonal Intelligence
communicate • independent study
• tactile materials and experiences • FEELING-TONED MOMENTS
• physical relaxation exercises • self-paced instruction
• BODY ANSWERS • individualized projects and games
• private spaces for study
Musical Intelligence • ONE-MINUTE REFLECTION PERIODS
• MUSICAL CONCEPTS • interest centers
• singing, humming, or whistling • PERSONAL CONNECTIONS
• playing recorded music • options for homework
• playing live music on piano, guitar, or • CHOICE TIME
other instruments • self-teaching programmed instruction
• group singing • exposure to inspirational/motivational
• MOOD MUSIC curricula
• music appreciation • self-esteem activities
• playing percussion instruments • journal keeping
• RHYTHMS, SONGS, RAPS, AND CHANTS • GOAL-SETTING SESSIONS
• using background music
• linking old tunes with concepts Naturalist Intelligence
• DISCOGRAPHIES • NATURE WALKS
• creating new melodies for concepts • aquariums, terrariums, and other portable
• listening to inner musical imagery ecosystems
• music software • gardening
• “SUPERMEMORY” MUSIC • PET-IN-THE-CLASSROOM
• nature videos, films, and movies
Interpersonal Intelligence • nature study tools (binoculars, telescope,
• COOPERATIVE GROUPS microscope)
• interpersonal interaction • ECOSTUDY
• conflict mediation • class weather station
• peer teaching • PLANTS AS PROPS
• BOARD GAMES • WINDOWS ONTO LEARNING

43
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

How to Create MI Lesson Plans 1. Focus on a Specific Objective or Topic. You


might want to develop curricula on a large scale
On one level, MI theory applied to the curricu- (e.g., for a year-long theme) or create a program
lum might best be represented by a loose and di- for reaching a specific instructional objective
verse collection of teaching strategies such as (e.g., for a student’s individualized education
those listed above. In this sense, MI theory repre- plan). Whether you have chosen “ecology” or
sents a model of instruction that has no distinct “the schwa sound” as a focus, however, make
rules other than the demands imposed by the sure you have clearly and concisely stated the
cognitive components of the intelligences them- objective. Place the objective or topic in the cen-
selves. Teachers can pick and choose from the ter of a sheet of paper, as shown in Figure 5.2.
previous activities, implementing the theory in 2. Ask Key MI Questions. Figure 5.2 shows the
ways suited to their own unique teaching style kinds of questions to ask when developing a cur-
and congruent with their educational philosophy riculum for a specific objective or topic. These
(as long as that philosophy does not declare that questions can help prime the creative pump for
all children learn in the exact same way). the next steps.
On a deeper level, however, MI theory sug- 3. Consider the Possibilities. Look over the
gests a set of parameters within which educators questions in Figure 5.2, the list of MI techniques
can create new curricula. In fact, the theory pro- and materials in Figure 5.1, and the descriptions
vides a context within which educators can ad- of specific strategies in Chapter 6. Which of the
dress any skill, content area, theme, or methods and materials seem most appropriate?
instructional objective, and develop at least eight Think of other possibilities not listed that might
ways to teach it. Essentially, MI theory offers a be appropriate.
means of building daily lesson plans, weekly 4. Brainstorm. Using an MI Planning Sheet
units, or monthly or year-long themes and pro- like the one shown in Figure 5.3 (p. 46), begin
grams in such a way that all students can have listing as many teaching approaches as possible
their strongest intelligences addressed at least for each intelligence. You should end up with
some of the time. something like the sheet shown in Figure 5.4 on
The best way to approach curriculum devel- page 47. When listing approaches, be specific
opment using the theory of multiple intelligences about the topic you want to address (e.g., “video-
is by thinking about how we can translate the tape of rain forest” rather than simply “video-
material to be taught from one intelligence to an- tape”). The rule of thumb for brainstorming is
other. In other words, how can we take a linguis- “list everything that comes to mind.” Aim for at
tic symbol system, such as the English language, least twenty or thirty ideas and at least one or
and translate it—not into other linguistic lan- two ideas for each intelligence. Brainstorming
guages, such as Spanish or French, but into the with colleagues may help stimulate your thinking.
languages of other intelligences, namely, pictures, 5. Select Appropriate Activities. From the ideas
physical or musical expression, logical symbols on your completed planning sheet, circle the ap-
or concepts, social interactions, and intraper- proaches that seem most workable in your edu-
sonal connections? cational setting.
The following seven-step procedure suggests 6. Set Up a Sequential Plan. Using the ap-
one way to create lesson plans or curriculum proaches you’ve selected, design a lesson plan or
units using MI theory as an organizing unit around the specific topic or objective cho-
framework: sen. Figure 5.5 (p. 48) shows what an eight-day

44
MI and Curriculum Development

FIGURE 5.2
MI PLANNING QUESTIONS

Logical-Mathematical
How can I bring in
numbers, calculations,
logic, classifications,
Linguistic or critical thinking skills? Spatial
How can I use How can I use
the spoken or visual aids, visualization,
written word? color, art, or metaphor?

Naturalist Musical
How can I incorporate OBJECTIVE: How can I bring in
living things, natural music or environmental
phenomena, or sounds, or set key
ecological awareness? points in a rhythmic or
melodic framework?

Intrapersonal Interpersonal Bodily-Kinesthetic


How can I evoke How can I engage How can I involve the
personal feelings students in peer whole body or use
or memories, sharing, cooperative hands-on experiences?
or give students learning, or large-
choices? group simulation?

lesson plan might look like when perhaps competencies or background information that
thirty-five to forty minutes of class time each day can prove useful to them in their further educa-
are allotted to the objective. tion, such instruction often fails to connect stu-
7. Implement the Plan. Gather the materials dents to the real world—a world that they will
needed, select an appropriate time frame, and have to function in as citizens a few years hence.
then carry out the lesson plan. Modify the lesson Consequently, educators are turning toward
as needed to incorporate changes that occur dur- models of instruction that more closely imitate
ing implementation. or mirror life in some significant way. Such in-
struction is frequently thematic in nature.
Appendix C contains additional examples of MI
Themes cut through traditional curricular
lessons and programs.
boundaries, weave together subjects and skills
that are found naturally in life, and provide stu-
dents with opportunities to use their multiple in-
MI and Thematic Instruction telligences in practical ways. As Susan Kovalik
More and more educators are recognizing the (1993, p. 5), developer of the Integrated The-
importance of teaching students from an inter- matic Instruction (ITI) model, puts it:
disciplinary point of view. Although academic
skill teaching or the teaching of isolated chunks A key feature of here and now curriculum is
of knowledge may provide students with that it is immediately recognized (by the

45
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

student) as being relevant and meaningful. tions.” It shows how activities can be structured
. . . Furthermore, it purports to teach our to address traditional academic subjects as well
young about their world and the skills nec- as each of the eight intelligences. This chart illus-
essary to act within and upon it, thus pre- trates how science activities needn’t focus only
paring themselves for living the fast-paced on logical-mathematical intelligence and how
changes of the [future]. language activities (reading and writing) needn’t
Kovalik’s ITI model is based on year-long themes focus only on linguistic intelligence; they can, in
(such as “What Makes It Tick?”) that are them- fact, span all eight intelligences.
selves made up of month-long components Keep in mind that MI theory can be applied
(such as clocks/time, electrical power, transpor- to the curriculum in a variety of ways. There are
tation) and weekly topics (such as seasonal no standard guidelines to follow. The ideas in
change and geologic time). Other curricular ap- this chapter are suggestions only; I invite you to
proaches focus on alternative time frames, such create other forms or formulas for lesson plan-
as semester units or three-month themes. Re- ning or thematic development (see p. 50), and I
gardless of the time element involved, MI theory encourage you to incorporate other formats, in-
provides a context for structuring thematic cur- cluding those developed by educators such as
ricula. It provides a way of making sure the ac- Kovalik (1993) and Hunter (see Gentile, 1988).
tivities selected for a theme will activate all eight Ultimately, you should be guided by your deep-
intelligences and therefore draw on every child’s est and sincerest attempts to reach beyond the
inner gifts. intelligences you may currently be teaching to,
Figure 5.6 (p. 49) outlines the kinds of activi- so that every child has the opportunity to suc-
ties that might be used for the theme “Inven- ceed in school.

FIGURE 5.3
MI PLANNING SHEET

Logical-Mathematical

Linguistic Spatial

Naturalist OBJECTIVE: Musical

Intrapersonal Bodily-Kinesthetic

Interpersonal

46
MI and Curriculum Development

FIGURE 5.4
COMPLETED MI PLANNING SHEET ON PUNCTUATION

dis
cu
ss
log
ic
of
pu p. r ks
nc m . ma
tua ar k
s e r s for p
tio b
nle num
ss e x p lanati
on Logical-Mathematical substitute
l
tex verba od
ing

so
ts rc
over lo

r tin
Linguistic head Spatial c o
on u

gt
ses ma
of p. kin

as
wr i
ting mark gi

k
the s nto

s
ir o pic
wn tur
sen
ten es
ces
m
Naturalist Musical u sic
OBJECTIVE:
al
s r k s m
a r k s a ne
. m ar k . m k s m
r p r p . m l p a r on
o o a m
n d sf m b ols f u sic u t p. ic
o u n t s y m b o fo
a l s p la y a rp
i m p l a .m
an s s ar
" rds cla ks
. a
Intrapersonal k .. s hc Bodily-Kinesthetic
a r fla
er s
.m pe ck coll
e ap n ba age
b Interpersonal o ma

act
ld k s teri
soc

ou a r als
c ass m for
out
u ign p. p. m
ial g

yo p. g ark
"I f ma i n
p. m
r ks ra c s
am

as t
cla ar k
e

ss
"rol s
es"

Note: “Punctuation marks” are abbreviated “p. marks.”

47
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 5.5
SAMPLE EIGHT-DAY MI LESSON PLAN

Level: 4th grade read sample sentences requiring the use of the
four marks.
Subject: Language arts
Friday (Logical-Mathematical Intelligence): Stu-
Objective: To understand the function of, and dif- dents form groups of four to six. Each group has a
ferences between, four punctuation marks: the box divided into four compartments, each of which
question mark, period, comma, and exclamation is assigned a punctuation mark. The groups sort
mark. sentence stubs with missing punctuation marks
(one per sentence stub) into the four compart-
Monday (Linguistic Intelligence): Students listen to ments according to the punctuation needed.
a verbal explanation of the function of punctuation
marks, read sentences having examples of each Monday (Interpersonal Intelligence): Students form
mark, and complete a worksheet requiring them to groups of four to six. Each student has four cards,
fill in their own marks. and each card has a different punctuation mark
written on it. The teacher places a sentence requir-
Tuesday (Spatial Intelligence): The teacher draws ing a given punctuation mark on the overhead pro-
on the board graphic images that correspond in jector. As soon as students see the sentence, they
meaning and form to each mark (Question mark = toss the relevant card in the center of their group’s
a hook, since questions “hook” us into requiring an circle. The first student in the group to throw in a
answer; exclamation point = a staff that you pound correct card gets five points, the second four, and
on the floor when you want to exclaim something; a so on.
period = a point, since you’ve just made your point,
plain and simple; and a comma = a brake pedal, Tuesday (Intrapersonal Intelligence): Students are
since it requires you to temporarily stop in the mid- asked to create their own sentences using each of
dle of a sentence. Students can make up their own the punctuation marks; the sentences should relate
images and then place them as pictures in sen- to their personal lives (e.g., a question they’d like
tences (with different colors assigned to different somebody to answer, a statement they feel strongly
marks). about, a fact they know that they’d like others to
know about).
Wednesday (Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence): The
teacher asks students to use their bodies to form Wednesday (Naturalist Intelligence): Students are
the shapes of the different punctuation marks as asked to assign an animal and its respective sound
she reads sentences requiring these marks (e.g., to each of the punctuation marks (e.g., a period
a curved body posture for question mark). might be a dog barking; a comma, a duck quack-
ing; a question mark, a cat meowing; and an excla-
Thursday (Musical Intelligence): Students make up mation mark, a lion roaring). As the teacher (or a
different sounds for the punctuation marks (as student) reads a passage, the students make the
Victor Borge did in his comedy routines), and then animal sounds corresponding to each punctuation
make these sounds in unison as different students mark encountered.

48
MI and Curriculum Development

FIGURE 5.6
MI AND THEMATIC INSTRUCTION
Sample Theme: Inventions
Intelligence Math Science Reading Writing Social Studies
Linguistic Read math prob- Talk about the Read a general Write about what Write about the
lems involving basic scientific book about you’d like to social conditions
inventions principles in- inventions invent that gave rise to
volved in specific certain
inventions inventions
Logical- Learn a math for- Create a hy- Read a book Write a word Create a time
Mathe- mula that served pothesis for the about the logic problem based line of famous
matical as the basis for development of a and math behind on a famous inventions
an invention new invention inventions invention
Spatial Sketch the ge- Draw a new or Read a book Label the individ- Paint a mural
ometry involved existing invention with lots of dia- ual components showing inven-
in specific showing all work- grams of the in- of your drawing tions in social/
inventions ing parts ner workings of of an invention historical context
inventions
Bodily- Create an inven- Build your own Read the instruc- Write instructions Put on a play
Kinesthetic tion to measure invention based tions for putting for building your about how a cer-
a specific physi- on sound scien- together an exist- own invention tain invention
cal activity tific principles ing invention from scrap came to be
materials
Musical Study the math Study the sci- Read about the Write the lyrics Listen to music
involved in the in- ence behind the background to in- for a song pro- about inventions
vention of musi- invention of elec- vention songs moting a new at different his-
cal instruments tronic music such as “John invention torical periods
Henry”
Inter- Be in a study Form a discus- Read about the Write a play Hold a discus-
personal group that looks sion group to cooperation nec- about inventions sion group about
at the mathemat- study the sci- essary for devel- that can be put how a certain in-
ics involved in ence behind oping an on by the class vention came to
specific inventions invention be
inventions
Intra- Create your own Develop a self- Read the biogra- Write your per- Think about this
personal word problems study program to phy of a famous sonal autobio- question: if you
based on examine the sci- inventor graphy as a could invent a
inventions entific basis for a “famous inventor” time machine,
specific invention where would you
go?
Naturalist Investigate in- Study the scien- Read about Write an essay Design an inven-
ventions used to tific principles be- “naturalist inven- on your opinion tion that would
measure posi- hind cloning, and tions” such as of the use of ani- contribute to the
tions of natural how a cloned hu- “wetware” (bio- mals in experi- ecological wel-
phenomena man being may logical software) ments to develop fare of the planet
(e.g., Astrolabe) someday repre- and genetically inventions
sent a biological altered foods
“invention”

49
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FOR FURTHER STUDY


1. Look over the list of teaching strategies your students using the activities you’ve
in this chapter. Circle the strategies you use developed.
or have used in your instruction. Place a yel- Afterward, reflect on the lesson. Which
low star next to the approaches that have parts were most successful? Which were least
worked best. Place a red flag next to the ac- successful? Ask students to reflect on the les-
tivities you think you use too much. Finally, son in the same way. What have you learned
place a blue arrow pointing upward next to from this experience that can help you regu-
new activities you would like to try. larly teach through multiple intelligences?
Over the next few weeks, eliminate or 3. Select a theme to serve as a basis for a
scale back your use of some of the red curriculum in your class. Use the seven-step
flagged/overused techniques, increase the lesson-planning process described in this
time you spend using the yellow-starred ap- chapter to generate a basic framework of ac-
proaches, and add to your teaching repertoire tivities that includes all eight intelligences and
some of the blue-arrowed techniques. each academic subject area. (Refer to Figure
2. Select a specific skill or instructional 5.6 for guidance in developing activities.)
objective that many of your students don’t 4. Focus on an intelligence that you usu-
seem to be effectively learning. Apply the ally don’t touch on in your teaching, create a
seven-step planning process described in this lesson plan that includes it, and teach the les-
chapter to generate a multiple-intelligence son to your students. (See Appendix B for in-
lesson or series of lessons, and then teach structional resources in each intelligence.)

50
MI and Teaching Strategies
6
If the only tool you have is a hammer,
Everything around you looks like a nail.
—Abraham Maslow

MI theory opens the door to a wide variety of emphasis from presentation to presentation,
teaching strategies that can be easily imple- there will always be a time during the period or
mented in the classroom. In many cases, they are day when a student has his or her own most
strategies that have been used for decades by highly developed intelligence(s) actively involved
good teachers. In other cases, the theory of mul- in learning.
tiple intelligences offers teachers an opportunity In this chapter, I present forty teaching strate-
to develop innovative teaching strategies that are gies, five for each of the eight intelligences. The
relatively new to the educational scene. In either strategies are designed to be general enough so
case, MI theory suggests that no one set of teach- you can apply them at any grade level, yet spe-
ing strategies will work best for all students at all cific enough so that little guesswork is required
times. All children have different proclivities in to implement them. Keep in mind that these are
the eight intelligences, so any particular strategy only a few samples of some of the better strate-
is likely to be highly successful with one group gies available (see Chapter 5 for a list of more
strategies). I encourage you to find additional
of students and less successful with other
strategies or to develop your own adaptations of
groups. For example, teachers who use Rhythms,
existing strategies.
Raps, and Chants (see below) as a pedagogical
tool will probably find that musically inclined
students respond enthusiastically to this strategy
while nonmusical students remain unmoved. Teaching Strategies for
Similarly, the use of pictures and images in Linguistic Intelligence
teaching will reach students who are more spa- Linguistic intelligence is perhaps the easiest in-
tially oriented but perhaps have a different effect telligence to develop strategies for, because so
on those who are more physically or verbally much attention has been given to its cultivation
inclined. in the schools. I do not include the traditional
Because of these individual differences among linguistic strategies involving textbooks, work-
students, teachers are best advised to use a broad sheets, and lectures among the five strategies dis-
range of teaching strategies with their students. cussed here, however, simply because they have
As long as instructors shift their intelligence been overused. This is not to say that textbooks,

51
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

worksheets, and lectures should never be used. be especially original or fabulous for children to
They serve as excellent channels for effectively benefit from them. Students are often impressed
imparting certain kinds of information. But they simply by a teacher’s willingness to be creative
are only one small part of a vast repertoire of and speak from the heart about a subject.
teaching strategies—and not necessarily the most Brainstorming. Lev Vygotsky once said that
important part. Though used extensively in a thought is like a cloud shedding a shower of
schools all over the United States, this trio of words. During brainstorming, students produce
teaching techniques most easily reaches only a a torrent of verbal thoughts that can be collected
segment of the learning population: the most and put on the board or an overhead transpar-
“book-oriented” and “lecture-gifted” students. ency. The brainstorming can be about anything:
The five strategies described here are accessible words for a class poem, ideas for developing a
to a broader range of learners because they em- group project, thoughts about material in a les-
phasize open-ended language activities that son being taught, suggestions for a class picnic,
bring out the linguistic intelligence in every and so forth. The general rules for brainstorming
learner. are: share whatever comes to mind that is rele-
Storytelling. Storytelling has traditionally vant, no put-downs or criticisms of any idea, and
been seen as entertainment for children in the li- every idea counts. You can place ideas at random
brary or during special enrichment times in the on the board, or use a special system (such as an
classroom. Storytelling should be viewed as a vi- outline, a mind-map, or a Venn diagram) for or-
tal teaching tool, for so it has been in cultures all ganizing them. After everyone has had a chance
over the world for thousands of years. When us- to share, look for patterns or groupings in the
ing storytelling in the classroom, you weave es- ideas, invite students to reflect on the ideas, or
sential concepts, ideas, and instructional goals use the ideas in a specific project (as in a group
into a story that you tell directly to students. poem). This strategy allows all students who
Although storytelling is usually thought of as a have an idea to be given special acknowledgment
means of conveying knowledge in the humani- for their original thoughts.
ties, it can be applied in mathematics and science Tape Recording. The tape recorder is proba-
as well. For example, to teach the idea of multi- bly one of the most valuable learning tools in any
plication, you can tell students the story of a classroom. This is because it offers students a
group of brothers and sisters who have magical medium through which to learn about their lin-
powers: whatever they touch multiplies (for the guistic powers and helps them employ verbal
first child, it doubles; for the second, it triples, skills to communicate, solve problems, and ex-
and so on). To convey the notion of centrifugal press inner feelings. Students can use a tape re-
force, you can take students on a mythical jour- corder to “talk out loud” about a problem they
ney to a land where everything spins around are attempting to solve or a project they are plan-
very rapidly. ning to do. In this way, they reflect on their own
Prepare for storytelling by listing the essential problem-solving processes or cognitive skills.
elements you’d like to include in the story. Then They can also use the tape recorder to prepare
use your imagination to create a special land, a for writing, helping to loosen the soil, so to
group of colorful characters, and a whimsical speak, of their topic. Students who are not good
plot to carry the message home. It may help to writers may also want to record their thoughts
visualize the story at first, and then practice tell- on tape as an alternative mode of expression.
ing it to a spouse or to a mirror. Stories needn’t Some students may use the tape recorder to send

52
MI and Teaching Strategies

“oral letters” to other students in the class, to writing as the dreary process of fulfilling an as-
share personal experiences, and to get feedback signment. Educators ought to be sending stu-
about how they are coming across to others in dents a different message: that writing is a
the classroom. powerful tool for communicating ideas and in-
The tape recorder can be used as a collector of fluencing people. By providing students with op-
information—in interviews, for example—and as portunities to publish and distribute their work,
a reporter of information—as in talking books. you can make this point in a strong way.
Tape recorders can also be used to provide infor- Publishing takes many forms. Students’
mation. For instance, one can be placed in each writings can be photocopied and distributed or
activity center so students can listen to informa- keyed into a word-processing program and
tion about the topic in that center. Every class- printed in multiple copies. Students can submit
room should have several tape recorders their writing to a class or school newspaper, a
available, and teachers should plan on using city newspaper, a children’s magazine, or some
them regularly to promote the growth of stu- other publishing source that accepts student
dents’ minds. work. Students’ writing can also be bound in
Journal Writing. Keeping a personal journal book form and made available in a special sec-
involves students in making ongoing written rec- tion of the class or school library, or published
ords related to a specific domain. The domain on a school Web site.
can be broad and open-ended (“Write about any- After publication, encourage interaction be-
thing you’re thinking about or feeling during the tween the authors and the readers. You might
class day”) or quite specific (“Use this journal to even have special student autographing parties
keep a simulated record of your life as a farmer and book circles to discuss students’ writings.
during the 1800s as part of our history course”). When children see that others care enough about
their writing to duplicate it, discuss it, and even
Journals can be kept in math (“Write about
argue about it, they become linguistically em-
problem-solving strategies you use”), science
powered and are motivated to continue develop-
(“Keep a record of the experiments you do, hy-
ing their writing craft.
potheses you’re testing, and new ideas that
emerge from your work”), literature (“Keep an
ongoing record of your responses to the books
you’re reading”), or other subjects. They can be Teaching Strategies for Logical-
kept entirely private, shared only between Mathematical Intelligence
teacher and student, or regularly read to the Typically, logical-mathematical thinking is re-
class. They can also incorporate multiple intelli- stricted to math and science courses. There are
gences by allowing drawings, sketches, photos, components of this intelligence, however, that
dialogues, and other nonverbal data. (Note that are applicable throughout the curriculum. The
this strategy also draws heavily on intrapersonal emergence of the critical-thinking movement
intelligence insofar as students work individually certainly suggests one broad way in which
and use the journal to reflect on their lives.) logical-mathematical intelligence has affected the
Publishing. In traditional classrooms, stu- social sciences and humanities. Similarly, the call
dents complete papers that are turned in, for “numeracy” (the logical-mathematical equiva-
graded, and then often thrown away. Many stu- lent of “literacy”) in our schools and, in particu-
dents exposed to this kind of routine begin to see lar, the recommendation that mathematics be

53
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

applied to an interdisciplinary curriculum point culture, students might brainstorm a random list
to the wide application of this form of thinking of geographic locations and then classify them by
to every part of the school day. The following are type of climate (e.g., desert, mountain, plains, or
five major strategies for developing logical- tropical). Or, in a science unit on states of matter,
mathematical intelligence that can be employed the instructor might put the names of three cate-
in all school subjects: gories—Gas, Liquid, Solid—at the top of col-
Calculations and Quantifications. In line umns on the blackboard and then ask students
with current reform efforts, teachers are being to list examples of things belonging to each cate-
encouraged to discover opportunities to talk gory. Other examples of logical-frameworks in-
about numbers both inside and outside the math clude: Venn diagrams, time lines, attribute webs
and science arena. In subjects such as history (listing the attributes of a person, place, or thing
and geography, you may focus regularly on im- as spokes around the subject), 5W organizers
portant statistics: lives lost in wars, populations (diagrams that answer who, what, when, where,
of countries, and so forth. But how do you ac- and why), and mind-maps. Most of these frame-
complish the same aim in literature? You works are also spatial in nature. The value of this
shouldn’t force connections that simply aren’t approach is that disparate fragments of informa-
there. It’s surprising, however, how many novels, tion can be organized around central ideas or
short stories, and other literary works make ref- themes, making them easier to remember, dis-
erence to numbers. In a novel by Virginia Woolf, cuss, and think about.
there is a mention of fifty pounds to fix a green- Socratic Questioning. The critical-thinking
house roof. How does that figure translate into movement has provided an important alternative
U.S. dollars? In a short story by Doris Lessing, a to the traditional image of the teacher as knowl-
boy must count to see how long he can stay un- edge dispenser. In Socratic questioning, the
derwater and then compare that to the amount teacher serves as a questioner of students’ points
of time it takes experienced divers to swim of view. The Greek sage Socrates is the model for
through a submerged tunnel. Each of these pas- this type of instruction. Instead of talking at stu-
sages provides the basis for some mathematical dents, the teacher participates in dialogues with
thinking. Of course, you shouldn’t feel com- them, aiming to uncover the rightness or wrong-
pelled to make word problems out of great ness of their beliefs. Students share their hy-
works of art—that would be stifling to say the potheses about how the world works, and the
least. It is a good idea, however, to keep alert for teacher guides the “testing” of these hypotheses
interesting numbers and intriguing math prob- for clarity, precision, accuracy, logical coherence,
lems wherever they may be found. By tuning or relevance through artful questioning. A his-
into the numbers in the midst of nonmathemati- tory student who declares that World War II
cal subjects, you can better engage highly logical never would have happened if soldiers had ac-
students, and other students can learn to see that tively resisted military service has his point of
math belongs not just in math class but in life. view subjected to rigorous scrutiny in this ap-
Classifications and Categorizations. The proach to teaching. A student defending the mo-
logical mind can be stimulated anytime informa- tives of a character in Huckleberry Finn is
tion (whether it be linguistic, logical- carefully questioned to see if her stand is sup-
mathematical, spatial, or other kinds of data) is ported by the facts in the novel. The purpose is
put into some kind of rational framework. For not to humiliate students or put them in the
example, in a unit on the effects of climate on wrong, but rather to help them sharpen their

54
MI and Teaching Strategies

own critical thinking skills so that they no longer influenced the outcome of World War II). They
form opinions simply out of strong emotion or can study science fiction with an eye toward dis-
the passion of the moment (see Paul, 1992). covering if the ideas described are feasible. They
Heuristics. The field of heuristics refers to a can learn about global issues—such as AIDS,
loose collection of strategies, rules of thumb, overpopulation, and the greenhouse effect—that
guidelines, and suggestions for logical problem require some science background to be well un-
solving. In terms of this book’s goals, however, derstood. In each part of the curriculum, science
heuristics can be regarded as a major teach- provides another point of view that can consid-
ing/learning strategy. Examples of heuristic prin- erably enrich students’ perspective.
ciples include: finding analogies to the problem
you wish to solve, separating the various parts of
the problem, proposing a possible solution to the Teaching Strategies for
problem and then working backwards, and find-
ing a problem related to yours and then solving Spatial Intelligence
it. While the most obvious applications of heu- The cave drawings of prehistoric man are evi-
ristics are in the math and science fields, heuris- dence that spatial learning has long been impor-
tic principles can also be used in subjects other tant to human beings. Unfortunately, in today’s
than logical-mathematical ones. In trying to en- schools the idea of presenting information to stu-
vision solutions to the problems of government dents through visual as well as auditory modes
waste, for example, a student might look for sometimes translates into simply writing on the
analogies by asking himself what other entities board, a practice that is linguistic in nature. Spa-
create waste. While looking for the main idea in tial intelligence responds to pictures, either the
a reading passage, a student might separate out images in one’s mind or the images in the exter-
each part of the passage (into sentences) and nal world: photos, slides, movies, drawings,
subject each part to qualifying “tests” of a key graphic symbols, ideographic languages, and so
point. Heuristics provides students with logical forth. Here are five teaching strategies designed
maps, so to speak, to help them find their way to activate students’ spatial intelligence:
around unfamiliar academic terrain (see Polya, Visualization. One of the easiest ways to
1957). help students translate book and lecture material
Science Thinking. Just as you should look into pictures and images is to have them close
for mathematics in every part of the curriculum, their eyes and picture whatever is being studied.
so too should you seek out scientific ideas in ar- One application of this strategy involves having
eas other than science. This strategy is especially students create their own “inner blackboard” (or
important given research showing that up to 95 movie or TV screen) in their mind’s eye. They
percent of adults lack a fundamental knowledge can then place on this mental blackboard any
of scientific vocabulary and demonstrate a poor material they need to remember: spelling words,
understanding of the impact of science on the math formulas, history facts, or other data.
world (“Poll Finds Americans Are Ignorant of When asked to recall a specific body of informa-
Science,” 1988). There are ways to spread sci- tion, students then need only call up their men-
ence thinking across the curriculum. For in- tal blackboard and “see” the data inscribed on it.
stance, students can study the influence A more open-ended application of this strat-
important scientific ideas have had on history egy involves having students close their eyes and
(e.g., how the development of the atomic bomb see pictures of what they’ve just read or studied

55
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

(e.g., a story or a chapter in a textbook). After- students master new material. The educational
ward, they can draw or talk about their experi- value of metaphor lies in establishing connec-
ences. Teachers can also lead students through tions between what a student already knows and
more formal “guided imagery” sessions as a way what is being presented. Think of the key point
of introducing them to new concepts or material or main concept you want students to master.
(e.g., leading them on a “guided tour” through Then link that idea to a visual image. Construct
the circulatory system to learn anatomy). Stu- the complete metaphor yourself (e.g., “How is
dents may experience nonspatial content as well the development of the colonies during early
during these activities (e.g., kinesthetic images, American history like the growth of an
verbal images, or musical images). amoeba?”) or have students develop their own
Color Cues. Highly spatial students are often (e.g., “If the major organs in the body were ani-
sensitive to color. Unfortunately, the school day mals, which ones would they be?”).
is usually filled with black-and-white texts, copy Idea Sketching. A review of some of the
books, worksheets, and chalkboards. There are, notebooks of eminent individuals in history, in-
however, many creative ways of putting color cluding Charles Darwin, Thomas Edison, and
into the classroom as a learning tool. Use a vari- Henry Ford, reveals that these people used sim-
ety of colors of chalk, markers, and transparen- ple drawings in developing many of their power-
cies when writing in front of the class. Provide ful ideas. Teachers should recognize the value
students with colored pencils and pens, and col- this kind of visual thinking can have in helping
ored paper on which to write assignments. Stu- students articulate their understanding of subject
dents can learn to use different colored markers matter. The Idea Sketching strategy involves ask-
to “color code” material they are studying (e.g., ing students to draw the key point, main idea,
mark all the key points in red, all the supporting central theme, or core concept being taught.
data in green, all the unclear passages in orange). Neatness and realism should be deemphasized in
Use color to emphasize patterns, rules, or classi- favor of a succession of quick sketches that help
fications during instruction (e.g., coloring all th’s articulate an idea.
red in a phonics lesson; using different colors to To prepare students for this kind of drawing,
write about distinct historical stages in Greek it may be helpful to play the game Pictionary or
history). Finally, students can use their favorite Win, Lose or Draw so students are used to the
colors as a stress reducer when coping with diffi- notion of making rapid drawings that convey
cult problems (e.g., “If you run into a word, central ideas. Then, begin to ask students to
problem, or idea you don’t understand, imagine draw the concept or idea you want to focus on in
your favorite color filling your head; this can a lesson. This strategy can be used to evaluate a
help you find the right answer or clarify things student’s understanding of an idea, to emphasize
for yourself”). a concept, or to give students ample opportunity
Picture Metaphors. A metaphor is using one to explore an idea in greater depth. Here are
idea to refer to another, and a picture metaphor some examples of subjects or concepts you
expresses an idea in a visual image. Developmen- might have students choose to illustrate: the
tal psychologists suggest that young children are Great Depression, gravity, probability (in math),
masters of metaphor (see Gardner, 1979). Sadly, fractions, democracy, pathos (in a literary work),
this capacity often diminishes as children grow ecosystem, and continental drift. Following up
older. However, educators can tap this under- the drawing activity with a discussion of the rela-
ground stream (to use a metaphor!) to help tionship between the drawings and the subject

56
MI and Teaching Strategies

matter is important. Do not evaluate the draw- Consequently, finding ways to help students in-
ings themselves; instead, seek to “draw out” stu- tegrate learning at a “gut” level can be very im-
dents’ understanding from the sketches (see portant to increasing their retention and
McKim, 1980). understanding. Traditionally, physical learning
Graphic Symbols. One of the most tradi- has been considered the province of P.E. and vo-
tional teaching strategies involves writing words cational education. The following strategies,
on a blackboard. Less common, especially after however, show how easy it is to integrate hands-
primary school, is drawing pictures on the board, on and kinesthetic learning activities into tradi-
even though pictures may be extremely impor- tional academic subjects like reading, math, and
tant to the understanding of the spatially in- science.
clined student. Consequently, teachers who can Body Answers. Ask students to respond to
support their teaching with drawings and instruction by using their bodies as a medium of
graphic symbols as well as words may be reach- expression. The simplest and most overused ex-
ing a wider range of learners. This strategy, then, ample of this strategy is asking students to raise
requires you to practice drawing at least some their hands to indicate understanding. This strat-
part of your lessons—for instance, by creating egy can be varied in any number of ways, how-
graphic symbols that depict the concepts to be ever. Instead of raising hands, students could
learned. Here are some examples: smile, blink one eye, hold up fingers (one finger
to indicate just a little understanding, five fingers
• Showing the three states of matter by draw-
to show complete understanding), make flying
ing a solid mass (heavy chalk marks), a liquid
motions with their arms, and so forth. Students
mass (lighter curvy marks), and a gaseous mass
can provide “body answers” during a lecture (“If
(little dots).
you understand what I’ve just said, put your fin-
• Indicating “root words” by putting little
ger on your temple; if you don’t understand,
roots at the base of those words on the board.
scratch your head”), while going through a text-
• Drawing a time line for a novel’s plot or his-
book (“Anytime you come to something in the
torical event and marking the line not only with
text that seems outdated, I want you to frown”),
dates and names but also with pictures that sym-
or in answering questions that have a limited
bolize events.
number of answers (“If you think this sentence
You do not need superior drawing skills to use has parallel construction, I want you to raise
this strategy; roughly drawn graphic symbols your two hands high like a referee indicating a
will suffice in most cases. Your willingness to touchdown; if you think it’s not parallel, put
model imperfect drawing can actually serve as an your hands together over your head like the
example for students who feel shy about sharing peak of a house”).
their own drawing with the class. The Classroom Theater. To bring out the
actor in each of your students, ask them to enact
the texts, problems, or other material to be
learned by dramatizing or role playing the con-
Teaching Strategies for tent. For example, students might dramatize a
Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence math problem involving three-step problem
Students may leave their textbooks and folders solving by putting on a three-act play. Classroom
behind when they leave school, but they take theater can be as informal as a one-minute im-
their bodies with them wherever they go. provisation of a reading passage during class or

57
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

as formal as a one-hour play at the end of the se- constructing adobe huts for a unit on Native
mester that sums up students’ understanding of American traditions or in building dioramas of
a broad learning theme. It can be done without the rain forest for an ecology theme. You can ex-
any materials or it may involve substantial use of tend this general strategy into many other cur-
props. Students may themselves act in plays and ricular areas as well. At a rote level, students can
skits, or they may produce puppet shows or study spelling words or new vocabulary words
dramatizations in miniature (e.g., showing how a by forming them in clay or with pipe cleaners. At
battle was fought by putting miniature soldiers a higher cognitive level, students can express
on a plywood battlefield and moving them complex concepts by creating clay or wood
around to show troop movements). To help sculptures, collages, or other assemblages. For
older students who may initially feel reluctant to example, students could convey an understand-
engage in dramatic activities, try some warm-up ing of the term “deficit” (in its economic sense)
exercises (see Spolin, 1986). using only clay (or some other available material)
Kinesthetic Concepts. The game of cha- and then share their productions during a class
rades has long been a favorite of party-goers be- discussion.
cause of the way it challenges participants to Body Maps. The human body provides a
express knowledge in unconventional ways. The convenient pedagogical tool when transformed
Kinesthetic Concepts strategy involves either in- into a reference point or “map” for specific
troducing students to concepts through physical knowledge domains. One of the most common
illustrations or asking students to pantomime examples of this approach is the use of fingers in
specific concepts or terms from the lesson. This counting and calculating (elaborate finger-
activity requires students to translate information counting systems such as “chisanbop” have been
from linguistic or logical symbol systems into adapted for classroom use). We can map out
purely bodily-kinesthetic expression. The range many other domains onto the body. In geogra-
of subjects is endless. Here are just a few exam- phy, for example, the body might represent the
ples of concepts that might be expressed through United States (if the head represents the North-
physical gestures or movements: soil erosion, cell ern United States, where is Florida located?). The
mitosis, political revolution, supply and demand, body can also be used to map out a problem-
subtraction (of numbers), the epiphany (of a solving strategy in math. For example, in multi-
novel), and biodiversity in an ecosystem. Simple plying a two-digit number by a one-digit number,
pantomimes can also be extended into more the feet could be the two-digit number, and the
elaborate creative movement experiences or right knee could be the one-digit number. Stu-
dances. dents could then perform the following actions
Hands-on Thinking. Students who show in “solving” the problem: tap the right knee and
signs of bodily-kinesthetic intelligence should the right foot to get the first product (indicated
have opportunities to learn by manipulating ob- by tapping the thighs); tap the right knee and the
jects or by making things with their hands. Many left foot to get the second product (indicated by
educators have already provided such opportu- tapping the stomach); tap the thighs and the
nities by incorporating manipulatives (e.g., stomach (to indicate adding the two products),
Cuisenaire rods, Dienes blocks) into math in- and tap the head (to indicate the final product).
struction and involving students in experiments By repeating physical movements that represent
or lab work in science. In thematic projects, too, a specific process or idea, students can gradually
students use hands-on thinking—for instance, in internalize the process or idea.

58
MI and Teaching Strategies

Teaching Strategies for including “When Johnny Comes Marching


Home Again,” “Tenting Tonight,” “The Battle
Musical Intelligence Hymn of the Republic,” and the more contempo-
For thousands of years, knowledge was imparted rary “The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down.”
from generation to generation through the me- After listening to the recordings, the class can
dium of singing or chanting. In the 20th century, discuss the content of the songs in relation to the
advertisers have discovered that musical jingles themes of the unit.
help people remember their client’s product. Additionally, you can find recorded musical
Educators, however, have been slower to recog- phrases, songs, or pieces that sum up in a com-
nize the importance of music in learning. As a pelling way the key point or main message of a
result, most of us have thousands of commercial lesson or unit. For example, to illustrate New-
musical jingles in our long-term memory but ton’s first law of motion (A body remains in its
relatively few school-related musical pieces. The state of rest unless it is compelled to change that
following strategies will help you begin to inte- state by a force impressed on it), you could play
grate music into the core curriculum: the first few lines of Sammy Davis Jr.’s version of
Rhythms, Songs, Raps, and Chants. Take “Something’s Gotta Give” (“When an irresistible
the essence of whatever you are teaching and put force such as you . . .”). Such “musical concepts”
it into a rhythmic format that can be either sung, are often effective openers (providing an antici-
rapped, or chanted. At a rote level, this can mean patory set) to a lesson.
spelling words to the rhythm of a metronome or Supermemory Music. Twenty-five years ago,
singing the times tables to a popular song. You educational researchers in eastern Europe dis-
can also identify the main point you want to em- covered that students could more easily commit
phasize in a lecture, the main idea of a story, or information to memory if they listened to the
the central theme of a concept, and then place it teacher’s instruction against a musical back-
in a rhythmic format. For example, to teach John ground. Baroque and classical musical selections
Locke’s concept of Natural Law, one half of the in 4/4 time were found to be particularly effec-
class can chant “natural law, natural law, natural tive (e.g., Pachelbel’s Canon in D and the Largo
law, natural law . . .” while the other half repeats: movements of concertos by Handel, Bach,
“life, li-ber-ty, happ-i-ness, life, li-ber-ty, happ-i- Telemann, and Corelli). Students should be in a
ness . . .” Inviting students themselves to create relaxed state (putting heads on the desk or lying
songs, raps, or chants that summarize, synthe- on the floor) while the teacher rhythmically gives
size, or apply meanings from subjects they are the information to be learned (e.g., spelling or
studying moves students to an even higher level vocabulary words, history facts, science terms)
of learning. This strategy can also be enhanced against the musical background (see Rose,
through the addition of percussion or other mu- 1987).
sical instruments. Musical Concepts. Musical tones can be
Discographies. Supplement your bibliogra- used as a creative tool for expressing concepts,
phies for the curriculum with lists of recorded patterns, or schemas in many subjects. For ex-
musical selections—tapes, compact discs, and ample, to convey musically the idea of a circle,
records—that illustrate, embody, or amplify the begin humming at a certain tone, drop the tone
content you want convey. For example, in devel- gradually (indicating the gradual slope of the cir-
oping a unit about the Civil War, you could col- cle) to a low note, and then gradually move up
lect songs related to that period in history, toward the original tone. You can use similar

59
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

techniques to express cosines, ellipses, and other to do is say to students, “Turn to a person near
mathematical shapes. And you can use rhythms you and share _______.” The blank space can be
to express ideas. For example, in a lesson on filled with virtually any topic. You might want
Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, you can pit students to process material just covered in class
rhythms against each other to suggest the two (“Share a question you have about what I just
families in conflict, while in the midst of those presented”). Or, you might want to begin a les-
rhythms, two quieter rhythms can be heard com- son or unit with peer sharing to unlock students’
ing into harmony with each other (the figures of existing knowledge about the topic under study
Romeo and Juliet). This strategy offers ample op- (“Share three things that you know about the
portunity for creative expression from both early settlers in America”). You may want to set
teachers and students. up a “buddy system” so each student shares with
Mood Music. Locate recorded music that the same person each time. Or you may want to
creates an appropriate mood or emotional at- encourage students to share with different mem-
mosphere for a particular lesson or unit. Such bers of the class so that by the end of the year,
music can even include sound effects (most non- each person has formed a sharing pair with every
verbal sounds are processed through the musical student in the classroom. Sharing periods can be
intellect), nature sounds, or classical or contem- short (thirty seconds) or extended (up to one
porary pieces that facilitate specific emotional hour or more). Peer sharing can also evolve into
states. For example, just before students are peer tutoring (one student coaching or teaching
about to read a story that takes place near the specific material to another student) or cross-age
sea, play a recording of sea sounds (waves crash- tutoring (an older student working with a
ing up against the shore, sea gulls crying), or La younger charge in a different class).
Mer (The Sea) by Claude Debussy. (See Bonny & People Sculptures. Anytime students are
Savary, 1990, for more information on music brought together to collectively represent in
and the mind.) physical form an idea, a concept, or some other
specific learning goal, a people sculpture exists. If
students are studying the skeletal system, they
Teaching Strategies for can build a people sculpture of a skeleton in
which each person represents a bone or group of
Interpersonal Intelligence bones. For a unit on inventions, students can
Some students need time to bounce their ideas create people sculptures of different inventions,
off other people if they are to function optimally complete with moving parts. In algebra class,
in the classroom. These social learners have they can create people sculptures of different
benefited most from the emergence of coopera- equations, each person representing either a
tive learning. But since all children have inter- number or a function in the equation. Similarly,
personal intelligence to one degree or another, in language arts, students can build people
every educator should be aware of teaching ap- sculptures to represent spelling words (each per-
proaches that incorporate interaction among son holds up a letter), sentences (each student is
people. The following strategies can help tap a word), or whole paragraphs (each person rep-
each student’s need for belonging and connec- resents a complete sentence). Assign a student to
tion to others. help “direct” the activity, or let the components
Peer Sharing. Sharing is perhaps the easiest of the sculpture organize themselves. The beauty
of the MI strategies to implement. All you need of this approach is in having people represent

60
MI and Teaching Strategies

things that were formerly represented only in successful functioning in real-life work
books, overheads, or lectures. People sculptures environments.
raise learning out of its remote theoretical con- Board Games. Board games are a fun way for
text and put it into an immediately accessible so- students to learn in the context of an informal
cial setting. social setting. On one level, students are chat-
Cooperative Groups. The use of small ting, discussing rules, throwing dice, and laugh-
groups working toward common instructional ing. On another level, however, they are engaged
goals is the core component of the cooperative in learning whatever skill or subject happens to
learning model. Such groups probably work be the focus of the game. Board games can be
most effectively when they have three to eight easily made using manila file folders, magic
members. Students in cooperative groups can markers (to create the typical winding road or
tackle a learning assignment in a variety of ways. path), a pair of dice, and miniature cars, people,
The group may work collectively on a written as- or colored cubes (available at toy stores or
signment, for example, with each member con- teacher supply stores) to serve as game pieces.
tributing ideas—much as screenwriters work Topics can include a wide range of subjects, from
when preparing a television episode. The group math facts and phonics skills to rain forest data
may also divide its responsibilities in a number and history questions. The information to be
of ways. In one case, the group may assign tasks learned can be placed on the individual squares
based on the structure of the assignment, with of the winding road (e.g., the math fact 5 x 7) or
one member doing the introduction, another on cards made from tag board or thick construc-
taking care of the middle section, and another tion paper. Answers can be provided in a
contributing the conclusion. Or groups may use number of ways: on a separate answer key, from
a “jigsaw” strategy and assign each student re- a specially designated “answer person,” or on the
sponsibility for a particular book or subtopic. Al- board squares or cards themselves (glue a tiny
ternatively, they may assign different roles among piece of folded paper to each square; on the top
group members, so that one person does the flap write the question or problem and on the
writing, a second reviews the writing for spelling bottom flap, the answer; players then simply
and punctuation errors, a third reads the report open the flap to read the answer).
to the class, and a fourth leads the ensuing You can also design board games that involve
discussion. quick open-ended or activity-oriented tasks.
Cooperative groups are particularly suitable Simply place the directions or tasks on each
for MI teaching because they can be structured square or card (e.g., “Explain what you would do
to include students representing the full spec- to control pollution if you were president of the
trum of intelligences. For instance, a group United States” or “Look up the word ‘threshold’
charged with the task of creating a videotaped in the dictionary”).
presentation might include a socially developed Simulations. A simulation involves a group
student to help organize the group, a linguisti- of people coming together to create an “as-if” en-
cally inclined member to do the writing, a spa- vironment. This temporary setting becomes the
tially oriented student to do the drawing, a context for getting into more immediate contact
bodily-kinesthetic student to create props or be with the material being learned. For example,
a leading actor, and so forth. Cooperative groups students studying a historical period might actu-
provide students with a chance to operate as a ally dress up in costumes of that time, turn the
social unit—an important prerequisite for classroom into a place that might have existed

61
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

then, and begin acting as if they were living in the information presented or to connect it to
that era. Similarly, in learning about geographical happenings in their own lives. They also provide
regions or ecosystems, students could turn the a refreshing change of pace that helps students
classroom into a simulated jungle or rain forest. stay alert and ready for the next activity.
Simulations can be quick and improvisational A one-minute reflection period can occur
in nature, with the teacher providing an instant anytime during the school day, but it may be
scenario to act out: “Okay, you’ve just got off the particularly useful after the presentation of infor-
boat on your trip to the New World and you’re mation that is especially challenging or central to
all standing around together. Begin the action!” the curriculum. During this one-minute period
Or they can be ongoing and require substantial (which can be extended or shortened to accom-
preparation, such as props, costumes, and other modate differing attention spans), there is to be
paraphernalia to support the illusion of a par- no talking, and students are to simply think
ticular era or region of the world. about what has been presented in any way they’d
Although this strategy involves several intelli- like. Silence is usually the best environment for
gences (including bodily-kinesthetic, linguistic, reflection, but you occasionally might want to
and spatial), it is included in the interpersonal use background “thinking” music. Also, students
section because the human interactions that take should not feel compelled to “share” what they
place help students develop a new level of un- thought about, but asking whether any students
derstanding. Through conversation and other in- wish to share their thoughts with the class can be
teractions, students begin to get an insider’s view useful.
of the topic they are studying. Personal Connections. The big question
that accompanies strongly intrapersonal students
through their school career is: “What does all
Teaching Strategies for this have to do with my life?” Most students have
probably asked this question in one way or an-
Intrapersonal Intelligence other during their time in school. It’s up to
Most students spend about six hours a day, five teachers to help answer this question by con-
days a week in a classroom with twenty-five to tinually making connections between what is be-
thirty-five other people. For individuals with ing taught and the lives of their students. This
strongly developed intrapersonal intelligence, strategy, then, asks you to weave students’ per-
this intensely social atmosphere can be some- sonal associations, feelings, and experiences into
what claustrophobic. Hence, teachers need to your instruction. You may do so through ques-
build in frequent opportunities during the day tions (“How many of you have ever . . . ?”), state-
for students to experience themselves as autono- ments (“You may wonder what this has to do
mous beings with unique life histories and a with your lives. Well, if you ever plan on . . .”),
deep sense of individuality. Each of the following or requests (“I’d like you to think back in your
strategies helps accomplish this aim in a slightly life to a time when . . .”). For instance, to intro-
different way: duce a lesson on the skeletal system, you might
One-Minute Reflection Periods. During lec- ask, “How many people here have ever broken a
tures, discussions, project work, or other activi- bone?” Students then share stories and experi-
ties, students should have frequent “time outs” ences before going on to the anatomy lesson it-
for introspection or deep thinking. One-minute self. Or, for a lesson on world geography, you
reflection periods offer students time to digest might ask, “Has anybody ever been to another

62
MI and Teaching Strategies

country? What country?” Students then identify creating moments in teaching where students
the countries they’ve visited and locate them on laugh, feel angry, express strong opinions, get ex-
the map. cited about a topic, or feel a wide range of other
Choice Time. Giving students choices is as emotions. You can help create feeling-toned mo-
much a fundamental principle of good teaching ments in a number of ways: first, by modeling
as it is a specific intrapersonal teaching strategy. those emotions yourself as you teach; second, by
Essentially, choice time consists of building in making it safe for students to have feelings in the
opportunities for students to make decisions classroom (giving permission, discouraging criti-
about their learning experiences. Making choices cism, and acknowledging feelings when they oc-
is like lifting weights. The more frequently stu- cur); and finally, by providing experiences (such
dents choose from a group of options, the as movies, books, and controversial ideas) that
thicker their “responsibility muscles” become. evoke feeling-toned reactions.
The choices may be small and limited (“You can Goal-Setting Sessions. One of the character-
choose to work on the problems on page 12 or istics of highly developed intrapersonal learners
14”) or they may be significant and open-ended is their capacity to set realistic goals for them-
(“Select the kind of project you’d like to do this selves. This ability certainly has to be among the
semester”). Choices may be related to content most important skills necessary for leading a suc-
(“Decide which topic you’d like to explore”) or cessful life. Consequently, educators help stu-
to process (“Choose from this list a method of
dents immeasurably in their preparation for life
presenting your final project”). Choices may be
when they provide opportunities for setting
informal and spur-of-the-moment (“Okay, would
goals. These goals may be short-term (“I want
you rather stop now or continue talking about
everybody to list three things they’d like to learn
this?”) or they may be carefully developed and
today”) or long-term (“Tell me what you see
highly structured (as in the use of a learning con-
tract for each student). How do you provide for yourself doing twenty-five years from now”). The
choice in your classroom? Think of ways to ex- goal-setting sessions may last only a few minutes
pand the choice-making experiences your stu- or they may involve in-depth planning over sev-
dents can have in school. eral months’ time. The goals themselves can re-
Feeling-Toned Moments. One of the sadder late to academic outcomes (“What grades are
findings of John Goodlad’s (1984) “A Study of you setting for yourself this term?”), wider learn-
Schooling” was that most of the 1,000 class- ing outcomes (“What do you want to know how
rooms observed had few experiences of true feel- to do by the time you graduate?”), or life goals
ing—that is, expressions of excitement, (“What kind of occupation do you see yourself
amazement, anger, joy, or caring. All too often, involved with after you leave school?”). Try to al-
teachers present information to students in an low time every day for students to set goals for
emotionally neutral way. Yet it’s known that hu- themselves. You may also want to show students
man beings possess an “emotional brain” consist- different ways of representing those goals
ing of several subcortical structures (see Holden, (through words, pictures, and so forth) and
1979). To feed that emotional brain, educators methods for charting their progress along the
need to teach with feeling. This strategy, then, way (through graphs, charts, journals, and time
suggests that educators are responsible for lines).

63
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

Teaching Strategies for the setting of the Battle of Hastings just before the
troops arrived on the scene”). Nature walks also
Naturalist Intelligence make a superb preparation for getting your class
Most classroom instruction takes place inside a ready to do some creative writing, drawing, or
school building. For children who learn best other art-oriented activities.
through nature, this arrangement cuts them off Windows onto Learning. One of the classic
from their most valued source of learning. There images of an “inattentive” student in the class-
are two primary solutions to this dilemma. First, room is of a child sitting at a desk looking wist-
more learning needs to take place for these kids fully out the window while, presumably,
outside in natural settings. Second, more of the fantasizing about what she’d rather be doing
natural world needs to be brought into the class- right now! Why do kids want to look out the
room and other areas of the school building, so window? All too often, it’s because what they see
that naturalistically inclined students might have out there is more interesting to them than what
greater access to developing their naturalist intel- is going on in the classroom. If this is true, then
ligence while inside the school building. Each of why not use this “off-task” tendency in students
the following strategies draws on one or both of as a positive classroom strategy? In other words,
these solutions: “looking out the window” is a technique that in-
Nature Walks. The Nobel-prize winning structors can use to further the curriculum.
physicist Richard Feynman once wrote that he What can be accomplished, pedagogically speak-
got his start along the path of science by taking ing, in looking out the window? Weather study
walks in nature with his father. It was from the (have a class weather station to make measure-
kind of questions that his father would ask him ments); bird watching (have binoculars handy);
as they walked along (e.g. “What animal do you understanding time (study the seasons’ effects on
think made that hole over there?”) that his own the trees, grass, and other plants); imagery (have
scientific questioning attitude was formed. In students create metaphors based on nature in
similar fashion, teachers might consider the their writing). In fact, looking out the window
benefit of “a walk in the woods” (or whatever can be used as a strategy for just about any sub-
other natural features are available within walk- ject. As with nature walks, looking out the win-
ing distance of your school) as a way of reinforc- dow can be used to set a scene for literature or
ing material being learned inside of the history, or for scientific observation. Other sub-
classroom. Virtually any subject lends itself to a jects, like geology and geography (“What natural
nature walk. Science and math, of course, can be features do you see in the earth or along the ho-
studied in the various principles at work in the rizon?”), economics (“Investigate the cost of
growth of plants, the weather above, the earth planting the trees just outside the window”), or
below, and the animals that scurry or fly about. social studies (“How well designed for human
If you’re teaching a piece of literature or a history use is the area just outside the window?”) can
lesson that involves a natural setting (and most take what’s beyond the window as a starting
do at least somewhere along the way), you might point, a place to briefly stop during a lesson, or a
use a nature walk as an opportunity to recon- final stopping point (“And as we finish this story,
struct a scene or two from the story or period of I want you to look out the window and imagine
history (“Imagine that this is the meadow where our protagonist walking between those trees into
the Pickwick Club had their ridiculous duel in the distance”).
Dickens’s Pickwick Papers” or “Picture this as the Of course, if you don’t have windows in your

64
MI and Teaching Strategies

classroom (a lamentably common practice of the plant and the students have grown during
nonnaturalist school designers and architects), or the year).
your windows look out onto other classrooms or Pet-in-the-Classroom. Many elementary
expanses of concrete, then it’s impossible to use school classrooms already have a “class pet” kept
this strategy. However, even then, you might use in a gerbil cage, a rabbit hutch, or some other
the “visualization” strategy from spatial intelli- species-relevant container. This strategy under-
gence to help your students imagine that they do lines how important this particular addition to
have windows that they can look out of to gain the classroom is in terms of sheer instructional
at least some semblance of connection to the value. First, having a pet in the classroom auto-
natural world. You might even design a “magic matically creates for many naturalistically in-
window” frame on a blank wall to use for look- clined students a safe place in the classroom
ing out at the imaginary “natural world.” where they can go to have a relationship to the
Plants as Props. If you can’t go out of the natural world and to feel a sense of caring for na-
classroom on nature walks and don’t have win- ture’s beings (some of these kids may be our fu-
dows in your classroom through which to look ture veterinarians). Second, having a pet in the
at nature, then the next viable solution is to classroom has many specific instructional uses.
bring nature into your classroom. Many teachers Kids can develop the scientific skill of observa-
have adorned their window sills or shelves with tion by keeping notes on a pet’s behavior (the
house plants simply to create a positive ambi- naturalist Jane Goodall traces her own love of
ance for learning. It is also useful, however, to animals back to an incident at five years old
consider the practical advantage of using plants where she stayed in a chicken coop for five
as learning tools. The fact that the petals of flow- hours just to see how chickens lay eggs). Kids
ers in bloom, for example, often come in multi- can keep math records on their pet’s food intake,
ples is an opportunity to examine the concept of weight, and other vital statistics. Finally, for high
multiplication in a natural setting. Plants can school classrooms, teachers can use a class pet as
make useful “props” as background scenery for a kind of “alter ego” for the classroom in posing
the “classroom theater” and “people sculpture” instructional questions (e.g. “How do you think
strategies described earlier in this chapter. In our rabbit Albert would feel about the problem
teaching about the branches of government, one of world hunger?”). Students who relate best to
can use a nearby branching plant as a naturalistic the world through their love of animals might
metaphor to illustrate the concept. In science well use Albert’s persona in giving voice to their
and math, students can measure the growth of own thinking on the matter. Having a pet in the
these plants. In history, students might consider classroom creates a sort of reality check for
the plants’ function or usefulness as herbal medi- teachers and students alike, reminding us of our
cines, foods, or even poisons. Assigning a par- own connection to the animal world, and our
ticularly difficult child with a naturalistic bent need sometimes to learn from the wisdom of our
the job of taking care of a plant in the classroom pets.
can be a useful way to redirect his energies. Fi- Ecostudy. Implied in the concluding state-
nally, I love the idea of using the image of plant ment of the last strategy is the importance of
growth as a metaphor for the learning that is go- having a sense of respect for the natural world.
ing on in the classroom (at the beginning of the This is the core idea behind ecostudy. This strat-
year, bring in a sprout of a plant and, at the end egy means that whatever we are teaching,
of the year, point out to the class how much both whether it be history, science, math, literature,

65
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

geography, social studies, art, music, or any other through Congress, students might consider an
subject, we keep in mind its relevance to the actual bill having an ecological focus that went
ecology of the earth. In essence, what I’m sug- through each stage of the process.
gesting here is that “ecology” shouldn’t just be a • If a teacher has the option of choosing lit-
“unit,” “course,” or “topic” isolated from the rest erature, then a dramatic work like Ibsen’s An En-
of the curriculum, but that it be integrated into emy of the People—an ecological play that was
every part of the school day. Here are some way ahead of its time—might be assigned or
examples: even acted out by the students.
• If the topic is fractions or percentages, the For students who are humanity’s “earth angels”
teacher asks students to investigate the fraction (those with a particular sensitivity to ecological
of a particular endangered species that exists to- issues), this sort of strategy can help draw them
day, as opposed to, say, fifty years ago, or the per- into the curriculum, and at the same time,
centage of rain forest left in Brazil compared to stimulate all students to take a deeper interest in
what was there in 1900. the welfare of our planet’s diminishing natural
• If the subject is how legislation goes resources.

FOR FURTHER STUDY


1. Select three strategies from this chapter here) to use in your teaching (consult the list
that intrigue you and that you haven’t already of strategies in Chapter 5 and the resources
used in your classroom. Do background read- list in Appendix B for more sources of ideas).
ing or consult with colleagues as needed, and 3. Develop a broad learning experience
develop specific lesson plans that describe ex- for your students that incorporates at least
actly how you will apply the strategies. Try one of the strategies for each intelligence in
out your lessons and then evaluate the re- this chapter. For instance, develop a unit that
sults. What worked and what didn’t work? involves body sculptures, mood music,
How would you modify each strategy in the feeling-toned moments, peer sharing, brain-
future to make it more successful? storming, color coding, and quantifications
2. Choose an intelligence that you usually and calculations. Work alone or as part of an
don’t address in your instruction, and re- interdisciplinary team.
search additional strategies (not mentioned

66
MI and the Classroom Environment
7
Nowhere else [but in schools] are large groups of individuals packed so closely together for so
many hours, yet expected to perform at peak efficiency on difficult learning tasks and to inter-
act harmoniously.
—Carol Weinstein (1979)

For most Americans, the word “classroom” Linguistic Intelligence


conjures up an image of students sitting in neat • How are spoken words used in the class-
rows of desks facing the front of the room, where room? Are the words used by the teacher too
a teacher either sits at a large desk correcting pa- complex or too simple for the students’ level of
pers or stands near a blackboard lecturing to stu- understanding, or is there a good match?
dents. This is certainly one way to organize a • How are students exposed to the written
classroom, but it is by no means the only way or word? Are words represented on the walls
the best way. The theory of multiple intelligences (through posters or quotations)? Are written
suggests that the classroom environment—or words presented through primary sources (e.g.,
classroom ecology, if you will—may need to be novels, newspapers, historical documents) or
fundamentally restructured to accommodate the through textbooks and workbooks written by
needs of different kinds of learners. committees?
• Is there too much “linguistic pollution” in
class (endless exposure to dittos and busy work),
MI and Ecological Factors or are students being empowered to develop
in Learning their own linguistic materials?
At a minimum, MI theory provides a template
through which educators can view some of the
Logical-Mathematical Intelligence
critical ecological factors in learning. Each intelli- • How is time structured in the classroom?
gence, in fact, provides a context for asking some Do students have opportunities to work on
searching questions about those factors in the long-term projects without being interrupted, or
classroom that promote or interfere with learn- must they continually break off their activities to
ing, and those elements absent from the room move on to a new topic?
that could be incorporated to facilitate student • Is the school day sequenced to make opti-
progress. A review of the eight intelligences re- mum use of students’ attention spans (morning
veals some of the following questions. best for focused academic work, afternoon best

67
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

for more open-ended activities), or do students well-designed breakfast or lunch during the day
have to perform under conditions that don’t to keep their bodies active and their minds alert,
match changes in their attention span? or do they eat junk food during recess and have
• Is there some consistency to students’ mediocre cafeteria meals?
school days (e.g., routines, rituals, rules, effective • Are there materials in the classroom that al-
transitions to new activities), or is there a sense low students to manipulate, build, be tactile, or
of chaos, of reinventing the wheel with the start in other ways gain hands-on experience, or does
of each new school day? a “don’t touch” ethos pervade the room?

Spatial Intelligence Musical Intelligence


• How is the classroom furniture arranged? • Does the auditory environment promote
Are there different spatial configurations to ac- learning (e.g., background music, white noise,
commodate different learning needs (e.g., desks pleasant environmental sounds, silence), or do
for written work, tables for discussion or hands- disturbing noises frequently interfere with learn-
on work, carrels for independent study), or is ing (e.g., loud buzzers or bells, aircraft overhead,
there only one arrangement (e.g., straight rows car and truck noises outside, industrial ma-
of desks)? chines)?
• Is the room attractive to the eye (e.g., art- • How does the teacher use her voice? Does
work on the walls), or is it visually boring or it vary in intensity, inflection, and emphasis, or
disturbing? does it have a dull monotone quality that puts
• Are students exposed to a variety of visual students to sleep?
experiences (e.g., optical illusions, cartoons, il-
lustrations, movies, great art), or does the class- Interpersonal Intelligence
room environment function as a visual desert?
• Do the colors of the room (walls, floors, • Does an atmosphere of belonging and trust
ceiling) stimulate or deaden students’ senses? permeate the classroom, or do students feel al-
• What kinds of illumination are used (fluo- ienated, distant, or mistrustful of one another?
rescent, incandescent, natural)? Do the sources • Are there established procedures for medi-
of light refresh students or leave them feeling ating conflict between class members, or must
distracted and drained? problems often be referred to a higher authority
• Is there a feeling of spaciousness in the (e.g., the principal) for resolution?
learning environment, or do students feel • Do students have frequent opportunities to
stressed in part due to overcrowding and lack of interact in positive ways (e.g., peer teaching, dis-
privacy? cussions, group projects, cooperative learning,
parties), or are students relatively isolated from
Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence one another?

• Do students spend most of their time sit-


Intrapersonal Intelligence
ting at their desks with little opportunity for
movement, or do they have frequent opportuni- • Do students have opportunities to work in-
ties to get up and move around (e.g., through ex- dependently, develop self-paced projects, and
ercise breaks and hands-on activities)? find time and space for privacy during the day,
• Do students receive healthy snacks and a or are they continually interacting?

68
MI and the Classroom Environment

• Are students exposed to experiences that students who enter the room with significant
heighten their self-concept (e.g., self-esteem ex- academic, emotional, or cognitive difficulties will
ercises, genuine praise and other positive rein- have an opportunity to feel stimulated toward
forcement, frequent success experiences in their making great strides in their learning.
school work), or are they subjected to put-
downs, failures, and other negative experiences?
• Do students have the opportunity to share MI Activity Centers
feelings in the classroom, or is the inner life of a In addition to the kinds of general ecological fac-
student considered off limits? tors described previously, there are more specific
• Are students with emotional difficulties re- applications of MI theory to the classroom envi-
ferred to professional counselors for support, or ronment. These focus on organizing the class-
are they simply left to fend for themselves? room in such a way that areas of the room are
• Are students given authentic choices in dedicated to specific intelligences. Although stu-
how they are to learn, or do they have only two dents can certainly engage in MI activities while
choices: “My way or the highway”? seated at their desks, the use of long periods of
seat time places significant limits on the kinds of
Naturalist Intelligence MI experiences they can have. Restructuring the
• Are students given an opportunity to do classroom to create “intelligence-friendly” areas
some of their learning outside of the school or activity centers can greatly expand the pa-
building in natural settings (e.g., field trips, gar- rameters for student exploration in each do-
dening, class on the lawn), or do they remain main.1 Activity centers can take a variety of
isolated from the natural world during most of forms, as illustrated in Figure 7.1. This figure
their in-school time? shows MI activity centers existing on two con-
• Does the classroom contain any living tinua, from permanent to temporary centers
things (e.g., pet visitors, aquarium, gerbil cage, (Axis A) and from open-ended to topic-specific
plants, terrarium), or is the occasional fly the centers (Axis B).
only nonhuman living thing to enter its portals?
• Does the classroom provide windows that Permanent Open-Ended Activity
look out onto the sky, clouds, trees, lawns, or Centers
other natural phenomena, or is it windowless Quadrant 1 of Figure 7.1 represents perma-
and shut in from any contact with the world of nent (usually year-long) centers designed to pro-
nature? vide students a wide range of open-ended
The answers to the preceding questions will pro- experiences in each intelligence. Here are some
vide a telling commentary on the quality of the
learning environment available to students. If an- *Write Project Zero (Harvard Graduate School of Edu-
swers consistently tilt toward the negative side of cation, 321 Longfellow Hall, 13 Appian Way, Cambridge,
the ecology ledger, then learning is apt to be sig- MA 02138; URL: http://www.pz.harvard.edu/; e-mail: info@
nificantly impaired, even if students come into pz.harvard.edu) for information about Project Spectrum’s
use of activity centers for preschool children; and visit the
the classroom as willing, able, and excited learn- New Horizons for Learning Web site (URL:
ers. On the other hand, answers that veer toward http://www.newhorizons.org/) for information about Bruce
the positive factors listed will enhance a class- Campbell’s use of MI activity centers at the elementary
room environment to the point where even school level (see also Campbell & Campbell, 2000).

69
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 7.1
TYPES OF ACTIVITY CENTERS

Open-Ended

Quadrant 1: Quadrant 2:

Permanent Open-Ended Temporary Open-Ended


Activity Center Activity Center

Permanent Temporary
Axis A
A
Quadrant 4: x Quadrant 3:
i
Permanent Topic-Specific s Temporary Topic-Specific
Activity Center B Activity Center

Topic-Specific

examples of such centers for each intelligence • Visual-thinking area (maps, graphs, visual
(with some suggested items for each center in- puzzles, picture library, three-dimensional build-
cluded in parentheses): ing materials)

Linguistic Centers Bodily-Kinesthetic Centers


• Book nook or library area (with comfort- • Open space for creative movement (mini-
able seating) trampoline, juggling equipment)
• Language lab (cassettes, earphones, talking • Hands-on center (clay, carpentry, blocks)
books) • Tactile-learning area (relief maps, samples
• Writing center (writing implements and of different textures, sandpaper letters)
paper, computers and printers) • Drama center (stage for performances, pup-
pet theater)
Logical-Mathematical Centers
• Math lab (calculators, manipulatives, math Musical Centers
software) • Music lab (cassettes, earphones, music
• Science center (experiments, recording ma- tapes)
terials, science software) • Music performance center (percussion in-
struments, tape recorder, metronome, music
Spatial Centers
software)
• Art area (paints, collage materials)
• Listening lab (“sound” bottles, stethoscope,
• Visual media center (videotapes, slides,
walkie-talkies)
graphics software)

70
MI and the Classroom Environment

Interpersonal Centers activities for the housing unit might include the
• Round table for group discussions following:
• Desks paired together for peer teaching
Linguistic Center. A “Reading Center” where
• Social area (board games, comfortable fur-
students read books on houses and write about
niture for informal social gatherings)
what they read.
Intrapersonal Centers Logical-Mathematical Center. A “Computing
• Study carrels for individual work Center” where students compare the costs,
• Loft (with nooks and crannies for individu- square footage, or other statistical measurements
als to “hide” in and get away from people) of different houses.
• Computer hutch (for self-paced study) Spatial Center. A “Drawing Center” where stu-
dents can design and draw a futuristic house.
Naturalist Centers Bodily-Kinesthetic Center. A “Building Center”
• A plant center with gardening tools and where students create a model of a house using
supplies balsa wood and glue.
• An animal center with a gerbil or rabbit Musical Center. A “Music Center” where stu-
cage, a terrarium, or an ant farm dents listen to songs about dwellings (e.g., “This
• An aquatic center with an aquarium and Old House” and “We All Live in a Yellow Subma-
tools for measuring and observing marine rine”) and make up their own songs.
habitats Interpersonal Center. An “Interaction Center”
where students “play house” (simulate a home
Clear labeling of each of these activity centers environment with peers).
with explicit MI nomenclature (e.g., “Linguistic Intrapersonal Center. An “Experience Center”
Intelligence Center,” “Picture Smart Center,” or where students think, write, draw, and act out
“Naturalists’ Corner”) will reinforce students’ un- their personal experiences with the homes
derstanding of MI theory. You may want to ex- they’ve lived in or with an image of their own
plain that the centers are named for the dream house.
intelligence that is used most in each center; in- Naturalist Center. A “Landscape Architecture
telligences are always interacting, so students Center” where students can design natural fea-
don’t have to switch activity centers if, for exam- tures to complement the house (e.g., lawn, bon-
ple, they want to add a picture to the writing sai garden, fountain, plants, aquarium).
they’re doing in the Word Smart Center.
Temporary Open-Ended
Temporary Topic-Specific Activity Centers
Activity Centers
Quadrant 2 of Figure 7.1 represents activity
In Quadrant 3 of Figure 7.1, diagonally centers for open-ended exploration that can be
across from Quadrant 1, are topic-specific activ- set up and taken down quickly by a classroom
ity centers that change frequently and are geared teacher. This type of center can be as simple as
toward a particular theme or subject. For exam- having eight tables scattered around the class-
ple, if students are studying a unit on housing, room, each clearly labeled with an intelligence
you may create eight different activity centers or and holding intelligence-specific materials that
“activity stations” that involve students in mean- invite students into open-ended activities. Games
ingful activities within each intelligence. The lend themselves particularly well to temporary

71
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

open-ended activity centers. Here are some Every center might have activity cards posted
examples: that tell students what kinds of things they can
work on either alone or cooperatively. For exam-
Linguistic Center. Scrabble
ple, the activity cards for the topic of “summer”
Logical-Mathematical Center. Monopoly
might read as follows:
Spatial Center. Pictionary
Bodily-Kinesthetic Center. Twister • Linguistic Center. “Write a poem about what
Musical Center. Simon you plan to do during the summer. If this is a co-
Interpersonal Center. Family Feud operative group activity, first choose a scribe to
Intrapersonal Center. The Ungame write down the poem. Then each person con-
Naturalist Center. The Bug Game (see http:// tribute a line to the poem. Finally, choose some-
www.weigl.com) one to read the poem to the class.”
Temporary open-ended activity centers are espe- • Logical-Mathematical Center. “First find out
cially useful for introducing students to the idea how many days there are in your summer vaca-
of multiple intelligences and for giving them tion. Then figure out how many minutes are in
quick experiences that illustrate the intelligences. that number of days. Finally, calculate the
number of seconds in your summer vacation. If
this is a group activity, collaborate with the other
Permanent Topic-Specific (Shifting)
members of your group on your answers.”
Activity Centers • Spatial Center. “Make a drawing of some of
Finally, Quadrant 4 of Figure 7.1 represents the things you plan to do during the summer. If
activity centers that are essentially a combination this is a group activity, do a group drawing on a
of Quadrant 1 (ongoing and permanent) and long sheet of mural paper.”
Quadrant 3 (topic-specific and temporary) activ- • Bodily-Kinesthetic Center. “Create your own
ity centers. Permanent topic-specific activity cen- representation of ‘summer’ out of a piece of clay.
ters are most appropriate for teachers working If this is a group activity, cooperate with the
with year-long themes along the lines of Susan other members of your group to create a clay
Kovalik’s (1993) Integrated Thematic Instruction sculpture or quickly improvise a short play that
(ITI) model. Each center exists year-round and includes the group’s favorite summer activities.”
has a number of materials and resources that • Musical Center. “Make up a rap or song
never change (e.g., art supplies in the Spatial about summer. If this is a group activity, collabo-
Center and hands-on materials in the Bodily- rate on a group song to sing to the class, or
Kinesthetic Center). Within each center, how- brainstorm all the songs you can think of that
ever, are revolving “explorations” that change have to do with summer and be prepared to sing
with every monthly component or weekly topic some of them to the class.”
of the year-long theme. So, for example, if the • Interpersonal Center. “Have a group discus-
year-long theme is “Change” (more appealingly sion about what you think makes for a great
titled “Does Everything Change?”), a month-long summer and select a spokesperson to summarize
component might deal with the seasons, and your conclusions in front of the class.”
weekly topics might focus on individual seasons. • Intrapersonal Center. “Make a list or a series
The activity centers, then, might focus on winter of sketches of all the things you like about sum-
for one week, then shift to spring the next week, mer.” Note: Students work alone in this center.
and to summer and fall in subsequent weeks. • Naturalist Center. “Close your eyes and

72
MI and the Classroom Environment

picture all the types of animals and plants you students choose the activity center they would
are likely to see this summer. Then open your like to start with but then have everyone rotate
eyes and either draw them or create a story (or center by center in a clockwise manner until eve-
list) where they are all mentioned.” ryone has had experience in all eight centers. Us-
ing this rotation system from time to time also
Student Choice and Activity Centers with Quadrant 1 and 2 activity centers will en-
sure that students have experiences across the
Should students be able to choose which ac- wide spectrum of intelligences.
tivity centers they work in? The answer to this Activity centers provide students with the op-
question may depend on the type of activity cen- portunity to engage in “active” learning. They
ter (i.e., which quadrant) and the purpose of serve as oases in the desert for many students
each center. Generally speaking, Quadrant 1 and who are thirsting for something other than dry
2 activity centers (those involving open-ended worksheets and individual work at their desks.
experiences) are best structured as “choice” ac- MI theory allows you to structure activity centers
tivities. In other words, you can make them in ways that activate a wide range of learning po-
available to students during break times, recess, tentials in students. Though the preceding de-
or special “choice times” after students have scriptions focus on centers based on individual
completed their other schoolwork. When used intelligences, there is no reason that you can’t
in this way, activity centers provide excellent as- structure centers to combine intelligences in dif-
sessment information about students’ proclivities ferent ways. In this sense, virtually any activity
in the eight intelligences. Students usually gravi- center that goes beyond simple reading, writing,
tate toward activity centers based on intelligences or calculation activities qualifies as an MI center.
in which they feel most competent. For example, A “Mechanic’s Corner” combining logical-
students who repeatedly go to the “Picture mathematical, spatial, and bodily-kinesthetic in-
Smart” area and engage in drawing activities are telligences or a “Composer’s Cabaret” combining
sending a strong message to the teacher about linguistic and musical intelligences are just two
the importance of spatial intelligence in their examples of MI centers that might combine
lives. intelligences.
Quadrant 3 and Quadrant 4 activity centers For other ways to create an intelligence-
emphasize directed study. Consequently, when friendly classroom environment, see the next
using these types of centers, you may want to let page.

73
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FOR FURTHER STUDY


1. Survey your classroom environment us- for activities related to the topic of “fast food”
ing the questions on pages 67–69 as a guide. include:
List the changes you would like to make in
the ecology of your classroom. Prioritize them • Linguistic Activity. “Create a poem about
(putting those items that you’d like to change, fast food.”
but can’t, on a separate list). Then set about • Logical-Mathematical Activity. “Using the
making those changes you can make, one at a nutritional charts provided by the fast-food
time. outlets you see here, develop a fast-food meal
2. Set up MI activity centers in your class- menu that is as low in fat as possible; then
room. First, decide which type of activity cen- put together a fast-food menu that is as high
ter you’d like to start out with (i.e., Quadrant in fat as possible.”
1, 2, 3, or 4). Then list the materials you need • Spatial Activity. “Create a mural that
and create a schedule for setting up the cen- deals with people’s fast-food eating habits.”
ters. Enlist the help of parent volunteers, stu- • Bodily-Kinesthetic Activity. “Rehearse a
dents, or colleagues as necessary. role play or commercial (with or without
If you have established permanent centers, words) about people’s fast-food eating habits
assess the project after two or three weeks of and then present it to the class.”
use. If you have established temporary cen- • Musical Activity. “Write a jingle or a rap
ters, assess their success immediately after stu- about people’s fast-food eating habits and
dents’ experience with them. Use your then sing it together.”
self-evaluation to guide the design of future • Interpersonal Activity. “Discuss among
centers. yourselves the fast-food eating habits of your
3. To introduce the idea of activity centers small group, and then go out and canvass the
to your class, select a topic that has an emo- rest of the class about their fast-food eating
tional charge and that everyone has had some habits. Select a scribe to record and report the
experience with—for instance, “fast food.” Put results.”
up eight signs at various points around the • Intrapersonal Activity. “Think about these
room, each bearing the symbol for an intelli- questions: If you could be any fast food,
gence. Under each sign, tape an activity card. which would you be? Why? Choose a method
Then signal students to move toward the in- for recording your thoughts (e.g., drawing,
telligence that they feel most comfortable with writing, or pantomime). You may work alone
(make sure they’ve been introduced to MI in or as a group.”
some way before this activity; see Chapters 3 • Naturalist Activity. “Make a list of all the
and 4). Or, alternatively, randomly hand out plants and animals used in creating the food
slips of paper on which have been inscribed at a fast food restaurant.” (Note: The follow-
symbols for each of the eight intelligences ing assignment might be more appropriate for
(one symbol per slip), and have students go to middle/high school students.) “Discuss the
the center that corresponds with their individ- potential impact of the consumption of these
ual slips of paper. (Students then read the ac- plants and animals on the world’s ecosystems
tivity for their area and cooperatively begin (e.g., oxygen-producing rain forests may be
working on it. Set a time to reconvene so the cleared for raising the cattle used for meat in
groups can present their findings. Suggestions hamburgers).”

74
MI and Classroom Management
8
Nature endows a child with a sensitiveness to order. It is a kind of inner sense that distin-
guishes the relationships between various objects rather than the objects themselves. It thus
makes a whole of an environment in which the several parts are mutually dependent. When
a person is oriented in such an environment, he can direct his activity to the attainment of
specific goals. Such an environment provides the foundation for an integrated life.
—Maria Montessori (1972, p. 55)

A classroom is a microsociety complete with her ineffectiveness, she finally screamed: “SHUT
student citizens, many of whom have competing UP!!!!” And the class became quiet. But then the
needs and interests. Consequently, rules, rou- talking started again, the noise began to grow,
tines, regulations, and procedures are a funda- and again she started the same sequence: “Class!
mental part of the classroom infrastructure. MI . . . Class!! . . . Class!!! . . . SHUT UP!!!!” And
theory, while not providing a classroom manage- once again quiet. The teacher repeated this pro-
ment scheme per se, offers beleaguered teachers cess several times until the ultimate futility of her
a new perspective on the many kinds of manage- attempts became painfully (and laughably)
ment strategies that they have used to “keep the obvious.
peace” and ensure a smoothly running learning Teachers can laugh at this situation because
environment. many have had the same experience. From a
multiple-intelligence perspective, however, the
use of mere words to quiet a class—a linguistic
Gaining Students’ Attention approach—might be seen as the least effective
Perhaps the best illustration of MI theory’s utility way to gain the class’s attention. Often, the teach-
in the area of classroom management can be seen er’s linguistic requests or commands (as “figure”)
in the ways in which teachers have sought to dissolve in the students’ linguistic utterances (as
gain their students’ attention at the beginning of “ground”). Students do not readily differentiate
a class or a new learning activity. A comedy rec- the teacher’s voice from the other voices sur-
ord some years ago humorously recounted one rounding them. As a result, they fail to attend to
teacher’s attempts to bring her class to order. directions. This phenomenon is particularly evi-
Against the loud hum of student noise, the dent among students who have been labeled “at-
teacher loudly said: “Class!” This not working, tention deficit disordered,” but it exists to a
she upped the voltage somewhat: “Class!!” And certain extent among most students.
once more, even more loudly: “Class!!!” Seeing A look at some of the more effective

75
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

techniques used by teachers to grab attention By looking at these “tricks of the trade” in terms
suggests the need to move to other intelligences. of the theory of multiple intelligences, we dis-
So, for example, the kindergarten teacher’s play- cover a fundamental methodology that can be
ing a piano chord to ask for silence (musical in- used in structuring other types of classroom rou-
telligence), the 4th grade teacher’s flicking the tines, such as preparing students for transitions,
lights on and off to call the class to attention initiating activities, giving instructions, and
(spatial intelligence), and the high school teach- forming small groups. Essentially, the underlying
er’s use of silence as an injunction to self- mechanism of each of these routines involves
responsibility (intrapersonal intelligence) all cueing students in such a way as to link symbols
demonstrate an understanding of the need to from one or more of the eight intelligences to
find a nonlinguistic way of gaining students’ at- specific commands and behaviors. In other
tention. Here are several other strategies for get- words, teachers need to discover ways of cueing
ting students’ attention in the classroom: students not simply through the spoken word,
but through pictures or graphic symbols (spa-
• Linguistic Strategy. Write the words “Silence, tial), gestures and physical movements (bodily-
please!” on the blackboard. kinesthetic), musical phrases (musical), logical
• Musical Strategy. Clap a short rhythmic patterns (logical-mathematical), social signals
phrase and have students clap it back. (interpersonal), feeling-toned stimuli (intraper-
• Bodily-Kinesthetic Strategy. Put your finger sonal), and living things (naturalist).
against your lips to suggest silence while holding
your other arm up. Have students mirror your
gestures. Preparing for Transitions
• Spatial Strategy. Put a picture of an attentive
To help prepare students for transitions, you can
classroom on the board and refer to it with a
teach the class specific cues and provide a differ-
pointer.
ent cue for each type of transition. When focus-
• Logical-Mathematical Strategy. Use a stop-
ing on musical intelligence, for example, you
watch to keep track of the time being wasted and
could explain that you will use different selec-
write on the blackboard the number of seconds
tions of music to cue different transitions:
lost at thirty-second intervals. Let students know
that this is time taken away from regular instruc- • Get-ready-for-recess music. Beethoven’s Pas-
tion that will need to be made up at a later date. toral Symphony (Symphony No. 6)
• Interpersonal Strategy. Whisper in the ear of • Get-ready-for-lunch music. “Food, Glorious
a student, “It’s time to start—pass it on,” and Food” from Oliver!
then wait while students pass the message • Get-ready-for-dismissal music. “Goin’ Home”
around the room. movement from Dvorák’s New World Symphony
• Intrapersonal Strategy. Start teaching the les- (Symphony No. 9)
son, and allow students to take charge of their
If spatial intelligence is your focus, you might
own behavior.
use graphic symbols or pictures to signal that it’s
• Naturalist Strategy. Play a recording of a
time to get ready for an event. You might even
shrill bird whistle or (even better) bring a live
use photographs or slides of students:
animal into the classroom. Generally speaking,
whenever there is an animal visitor in a class- • Get-ready-for-recess image. Picture of kids
room, that’s where the attention will be! playing

76
MI and Classroom Management

• Get-ready-for-lunch image. Kids eating in (e.g., “You just broke rule #4”).
cafeteria • Spatial Communication. Next to the written
• Get-ready-for-dismissal image. Students get- rules are graphic symbols of what to do and
ting on the school bus or walking home from what not do to.
school • Bodily-Kinesthetic Communication. Each rule
has a specific gesture; students show they know
For bodily-kinesthetic intelligence, you might the rules by going through the different gestures.
use specific gestures or body movements to sig- • Musical Communication. The rules are set to
nal the coming event. With this type of strategy, a song (either written by students or set to the
you begin the gesture; and students then make melody of an existing song), or each rule is asso-
the gesture, indicating that they have “received” ciated with a relevant song.
the message: • Interpersonal Communication. Each rule is
• Get-ready-for-recess gesture. Stretching and assigned to a small group of students who then
yawning (signifying “time for a break”) have responsibility for knowing its ins and outs,
• Get-ready-for-lunch gesture. Rubbing stom- interpreting it, and even enforcing it.
ach and licking lips • Intrapersonal Communication. Students are
• Get-ready-for-dismissal gesture. Putting hand responsible for creating the class rules at the be-
above eyes and peering outside of the classroom ginning of the year and developing their own
(signifying looking in a homeward direction) unique ways of communicating them to others.
• Naturalist Communication. An animal is as-
For logical-mathematical intelligence, you signed to each of the rules (e.g., “Respectful Rab-
could display a large digital “countdown” clock bit,” “Quiet Quail,” and “Cooperative
that students can see from anywhere in the class- Kangaroo”). Students learn the rules by imitating
room, set it for the time left until the transition, the movements of the animals.
and then let students keep track of the time left
until the transition occurs. For interpersonal in- Asking students to help create classroom
telligence, you could use a telephone-tree model; rules is a common way of gaining their support
simply give the cue to one student, who then of the rules. Similarly, asking students to help de-
tells two students, who themselves each tell two velop their own MI strategies or cues for class-
students, and so forth, until all students are per- room procedures is a useful way to establish
sonally informed. effective cues. Students may want to provide
their own music, create their own gestures, draw
their own graphic symbols, or come up with
their own animals to signal the class for different
Communicating Class Rules activities, transitions, rules, or procedures.
You can communicate the school or classroom
rules for proper conduct through a multiple-
intelligence approach. Some possibilities include:
Forming Groups
• Linguistic Communication. Rules are written Another application of MI theory to classroom
and posted in the classroom (this is the most management is in the forming of small groups.
typical approach). Although groups have often been formed on the
• Logical-Mathematical Communication. Rules basis of intrinsic factors (e.g., interest/ability
are numbered and later referred to by number groups), educators have increasingly seen the

77
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

value of heterogeneous groups working coopera- approach and using some of the other intelli-
tively. MI theory provides a wide range of tech- gences (two or three at a minimum), you will be
niques for creating heterogeneous groups based providing students with more opportunities for
on incidental features related to each intelli- internalizing classroom routines.
gence. Some of the following ideas have been
adapted from of the work of Joel Goodman and
Matt Weinstein (1980): Managing Individual Behaviors
• Linguistic Strategy. “Think of a vowel sound Regardless of how effectively you communicate
in your first name. Now make that vowel sound class rules, routines, and procedures, there will
out loud. Go around the room and find three or always be a few students who—because of bio-
four people who are making the same vowel logical, emotional, or cognitive differences or dif-
sound.” ficulties—fail to abide by them. These few
• Logical-Mathematical Strategy. “When I give students may well take up much of your class-
the signal, I want you to raise between one and room time as you remind them (through several
five fingers. . . . Go! Now keep those fingers intelligences!) to sit down, stop throwing things,
raised and find three or four people whose raised quit hitting, and start behaving. Although MI
fingers combined with yours makes an odd theory has no magical answer to their problems
number.” (no model does), it can provide a context for
• Spatial Strategy. “Find three or four people looking at a range of discipline systems that have
who are wearing the same color clothes you are proved effective with difficult behaviors. Natu-
wearing.” rally, MI theory suggests that no one discipline
• Bodily-Kinesthetic Strategy. “Start hopping on approach is best for all kids; in fact, the theory
one foot. . . . Now find three or four people who suggests that teachers need to match different
are hopping on the same foot.” discipline approaches to different kinds of learn-
• Musical Strategy. “What are some songs that ers. What follows is a broad range of discipline
everybody knows?” The teacher writes on the methods matched to the eight intelligences:
board four or five of them (e.g., “Row, Row, Row Linguistic Discipline Methods
Your Boat,” “Happy Birthday to You”). “Okay, I’d • Talk with the student.
like you to file past me while I whisper in your • Provide books for the student that refer to
ear one of these songs. Remember which one it the problem and point to solutions.
is, and when I give the signal, I’d like you to sing • Help the student use “self-talk” strategies
your song and find all the others in the class who for gaining control.
are singing the same song. . . . Go!”
• Naturalist Strategy. “Visualize a sheep, a pig, Logical-Mathematical Discipline Methods
and a cow in a pasture. Suddenly, there is a loud • Use Dreikurs’ logical-consequences ap-
noise and two of them run off. There is only one proach (Dreikurs & Soltz, 1964).
animal left. Start making the sound of that ani- • Have the student quantify and chart the oc-
mal out loud, and then find three or four people currence of negative and positive behaviors.
who are making the same animal sound!”
Spatial Discipline Methods
You need not address all intelligences when • Have the student draw or visualize appro-
developing a classroom management scheme. priate behaviors.
But by reaching beyond the traditional linguistic • Provide the student with a metaphor to use

78
MI and Classroom Management

in working with the difficulty (e.g., “If people say the student what sort of animal he feels like and
bad things to you, see the bad things as arrows how he can learn to “tame” it within him).
that you can dodge”). • Use “pet therapy” to teach responsibility
• Show the student slides or movies that deal skills.
with the issue or that model the appropriate
behaviors. Behavioral strategies can be further tailored to
the needs of students with specific kinds of diffi-
Bodily-Kinesthetic Discipline Methods culties. Figure 8.1 (p. 80) suggests what some of
• Have the student role play the inappropri- these interventions might look like.
ate and appropriate behaviors.
• Teach the student to use physical cues to
deal with stressful situations (e.g., taking a deep
breath, tightening and relaxing muscles). Taking a Broader Perspective
The strategies in this chapter, of course, are no
Musical Discipline Methods substitute for a comprehensive professional team
• Find musical selections that deal with the approach to a student’s emotional problems or
issue the student is facing. behavioral difficulties. MI theory is valuable,
• Provide music that reflects the appropriate however, because it provides teachers with the
behavior (e.g., calm music for an out-of-control means to sort through a broad range of behav-
child).
ioral strategies and discipline systems and offers
• Teach the student to “play” his favorite mu-
guidelines for selecting a limited number of in-
sic in his mind when he feels out of control.
terventions to try out, based on the student’s in-
Interpersonal Discipline Methods dividual differences.
• Provide peer group counseling. Sometimes the best strategy for a student
• Buddy up the student with a role model. may be one matched to a poorly developed intel-
• Have the student teach or look after a ligence. For example, if a student has behavior
younger child. problems because of an underdeveloped inter-
• Give the student other social outlets for his personal intelligence, then she may benefit most
energies (e.g., leading a group). from activities that seek to develop her social
skills. In other cases, however, the best strategies
Intrapersonal Discipline Methods
will be in a student’s areas of strength. For exam-
• Teach the student to voluntarily go to a
ple, you probably would not want to assign read-
nonpunitive “time-out” area to gain control.
ing to a student who has problems with both
• Provide one-to-one counseling.
reading and “acting out” his frustrations. This
• Develop a behavior contract.
strategy might only aggravate the situation. On
• Give the student the opportunity to work
the other hand, helping a student master a read-
on high-interest projects.
ing problem may be an important ingredient in
• Provide self-esteem activities.
improving her classroom behavior. For a student
Naturalist Discipline Methods who acquires knowledge easily through the
• Tell animal stories that teach about im- printed word, providing behavioral strategies
proper and proper behavior (e.g., “The Boy Who geared to this strength would, generally speak-
Cried Wolf,” for a persistent fibber). ing, be among the most appropriate choices.
• Use animal metaphors in working with dif- Ultimately, MI theory used in conjunction
ficult behavior (e.g., for an aggressive child, ask with classroom management goes far beyond the

79
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 8.1
MI STRATEGIES FOR MANAGING INDIVIDUAL BEHAVIORS
Intelligence Aggressive Student Withdrawn Student Hyperactive Student

Linguistic Bibliotherapy on theme of Taking up debate, oratory, Books on theme of hyperac-


anger control or storytelling tivity (e.g., The Boy Who
Burned Too Brightly)*

Logical- Dreikurs’ logical- Interactive computer net- Quantification of time-on-


Mathematical consequences system work, chess club task

Spatial Visualizing ways of manag- Movies on theme of with- Video games that help
ing conflict drawn child who meets a develop focus and control
friend

Bodily- Role play aggressive Pairing with trusted person Progressive relaxation,
Kinesthetic behavior and try out for walks, sports, games yoga, hands-on learning
alternatives

Musical Songs promoting social Discography encouraging Stimulating music


skills connection with others (“Musical Ritalin”)

Interpersonal Taking group class in Group counseling Leadership role in coopera-


martial arts tive learning group

Intrapersonal Time-out, contracting One-to-one counseling/ Quiet-time focusing


psychotherapy exercises

Naturalist Identifying with an animal Introspective book about Time to discharge energy in
that can then learn how to nature involving friendship nature
“tame itself” (e.g., The Secret Garden)

*See Welsh (1997).

provision of specific behavioral strategies and systems—which often are initiated only when
techniques. MI theory can greatly affect students’ the learning environment has broken down. As
behavior in the classroom simply by creating an Leslie Hart (1981) points out:
environment where individual needs are recog-
Classroom management, discipline, teacher
nized and attended to throughout the school day.
burn-out, student “failures”—these are all
Students are less likely to be confused, frus-
problems inherent in the teacher-does-
trated, or stressed out in such an environment.
everything approach. Permit and encourage
As a result, there is likely far less need for behav-
students to use their brains actively to learn,
ioral “tricks” or elaborate discipline
and the results can be astonishing (p. 40).

80
MI and Classroom Management

FOR FURTHER STUDY


1. Select a classroom routine that students Chapter 3). Then select behavioral strategies
are currently having trouble adapting to (e.g., that match the most-developed intelligences.
moving from one activity to another, learning Consider also strategies in less-developed in-
class rules) and experiment with different telligences that would help develop skills in
intelligence-specific cues for helping students areas of need. Evaluate the results.
master it. 4. Review the behavioral systems currently
2. Try out nonverbal ways of getting stu- used in your classroom or school. Identify
dents’ attention through musical, spatial, which specific intelligences are addressed and
bodily-kinesthetic, interpersonal, logical- how they match or do not match the learning
mathematical, naturalist, or intrapersonal in- strengths of your students.
telligences. Develop cues different from those 5. Identify classroom management issues
mentioned in this chapter. not specifically discussed in this chapter and
3. Choose a student who has been particu- relate MI theory to them in some tangible
larly disruptive in class or whose behavior in way. What are the advantages of using MI the-
some other way has proved difficult to handle. ory in handling classroom management prob-
Determine the student’s most-developed intel- lems? What are its limitations?
ligences (using identification strategies from

81
The MI School
9
The school we envision commits itself to fostering students’ deep understanding in several
core disciplines. It encourages students’ use of that knowledge to solve the problems and com-
plete the tasks that they may confront in the wider community. At the same time, the school
seeks to encourage the unique blend of intelligences in each of its students, assessing their
development regularly in intelligence-fair ways.
—Howard Gardner (1993b, p. 75)

The implications of MI theory extend far first to the reading and math programs for ways
beyond classroom instruction. At heart, the the- to save money. They begin by eliminating the
ory of multiple intelligences calls for nothing music program, the art program, and the physi-
short of a fundamental change in the way cal education program (see Viadero, 1991). Even
schools are structured. It delivers to educators when these programs are still operating, they of-
everywhere the strong message that students ten show the subtle influence of verbal and logi-
who show up for school at the beginning of each cal demands. John Goodlad, commenting on
day have the right to be provided with experi- observations of schools from his monumental
ences that activate and develop all of their intelli- “A Study of Schooling” report, writes: “I am dis-
gences. During the typical school day, all appointed with the degree to which arts classes
students should be exposed to courses, projects, appear to be dominated by the ambience of Eng-
or programs that focus on developing each of lish, mathematics, and other academic subjects. .
their intelligences, not just the standard verbal . . They did not convey the picture of individual
and logical skills that for decades have been ex- expression and artistic creativity toward which
alted above other domains in U.S. education. one is led by the rhetoric of forward-looking
practice in the field” (Goodlad, 1984,
p. 220). Goodlad found the physical education
MI and the Traditional School classes similarly flawed: “Anything that might be
In most schools today, programs that concentrate called a program was virtually nonexistent.
on the neglected intelligences (musical, spatial, Physical education appeared to be a teacher-
bodily-kinesthetic, naturalist, interpersonal, monitored recess” (p. 222).
intrapersonal) tend to be considered “frill” sub- Administrators and others who help structure
jects or at least subjects peripheral to the “core” programs in schools can use MI theory as a
academic courses. When a school district has a framework for making sure that each student has
budget crisis, fiscal managers usually don’t turn the opportunity every day to experience direct

82
The MI School

interaction with each of the eight intelligences. museums, art or science museums, or other
Figure 9.1 (p. 84) suggests some programmatic places where hands-on exploratory learning and
features that span the eight intelligences in play are encouraged and where interaction with
school, including traditional courses, supple- docents and other expert guides takes place.
mentary programs, and extracurricular offerings. Older students (past 3rd grade) could choose ap-
prenticeships based on an assessment of their in-
tellectual proclivities, interests, and available
The Components of an resources. They could then spend their after-
noons studying with experts in the community
MI School in specific arts, skills, crafts, physical activities,
Simply providing students with access to a di- or other real-life endeavors.
verse range of school subjects, however, does not Fundamental to Gardner’s vision of an MI
necessarily constitute a multiple-intelligence school are the activities of three key members of
school. In a recent book on MI theory, Gardner the school staff, representing functions that are
(1993b) sets up his vision of the ideal multiple- currently absent from most schools. In Gardner’s
intelligence school. In particular, Gardner draws model, every MI school would have staff in these
on two nonschool models in suggesting how MI roles:
schools might be structured. First, he sees MI
schools based in part on the example of contem- Assessment Specialist. This staff member is
porary children’s museums. According to responsible for developing an ongoing “picture”
Gardner, these environments provide a setting or record of each child’s strengths, limitations,
for learning that is hands-on, interdisciplinary, and interests in all eight intelligences. Using
based on real-life contexts, and set in an informal intelligence-fair assessments, the assessment spe-
atmosphere that promotes free inquiry into novel cialist documents each child’s school experience
materials and situations. Second, he looks to the in many ways (through observation, informal
age-old model of apprenticeships, where masters assessments, and multimedia documentation)
of a trade oversee ongoing projects undertaken and provides parents, teachers, administrators,
by their youthful protégés. and students themselves with an overview of
Gardner suggests that in an MI school, stu- their intellectual proclivities. (See Chapter 10 for
dents might spend their mornings working on an MI perspective on testing and assessment.)
traditional subjects in nontraditional ways. In Student-Curriculum Broker. This person
particular, Gardner recommends the use of serves as a bridge between the student’s gifts and
project-centered instruction. Students look in abilities in the eight intelligences and the avail-
depth at a particular area of inquiry (a historical able resources in the school. The student-
conflict, a scientific principle, a literary genre) curriculum broker matches students to specific
and develop a project (photo essay, experiment, courses and electives, and provides teachers with
journal) that reflects an ongoing process of com- information about how particular subjects might
ing to grips with the many dimensions of the best be presented to a student (e.g., through
topic. Students then go into the community dur- film, hands-on experiences, books, music). This
ing the second part of the day and further extend staff member is responsible for maximizing the
their understanding of the topics they are study- student’s learning potentials, given the particular
ing in school. Younger students, according to kinds of materials, methods, and human re-
Gardner, might regularly go to children’s sources available in the school.

83
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 9.1
MI IN TRADITIONAL SCHOOL PROGRAMS
Intelligence Subjects Supplementary Program Extracurricular Activities

Linguistic Reading Creative writing lab Debate


Language arts Communication skills School newspaper
Literature Yearbook
English Language clubs
Social sciences Honor society
History
Most foreign languages
Speech

Logical- Sciences Thinking skills Science clubs


Mathematical Mathematics Computer programming Honor society
Economics

Spatial Shop Visual-thinking lab Photography club


Drafting Architecture Audio-visual staff
Art Drawing on the right side of Chess club
the brain

Bodily- P.E. Theater games Sports teams


Kinesthetic Martial arts Drama
New games Cheerleading

Musical Music Orff-Schulwerk programs Band


Orchestra
Chorus

Interpersonal None (done at recess and Social skills Glee club


before and after school) AIDS/drugs/race awareness Student government
programs
Counseling

Intrapersonal None Self-esteem development Special-interest clubs


programs, counseling

Naturalist Biology Ecological awareness in Future Farmers of America,


Zoology other school subjects Future Homemakers of
Botany America, naturalist clubs
Ecology (e.g., gardening, bird
watching)

School-Community Broker. This staff per- geographic area. This person then attempts to
son is the link between the student’s intellectual match a student’s interests, skills, and abilities to
proclivities and the resources available in the appropriate experiences beyond the school walls
wider community. A school-community broker (e.g., finding an expert cellist to guide a student’s
should possess a wealth of information about the burgeoning interest in playing the cello).
kinds of apprenticeships, organizations, mentor-
ships, tutorials, community courses, and other Gardner suggests that the creation of such an
learning experiences available in the surrounding MI school is far from utopian. Instead, it

84
The MI School

depends on the confluence of several factors, in- geography, German), but also receive an equal
cluding assessment practices that engage stu- amount of instruction in physical education, art,
dents in the actual materials and symbols of each and music. Compared with schools nationally,
intelligence, curriculum development that re- students at Key receive double the exposure to
flects real-life skills and experiences, teacher art, music, and physical education than does the
training programs that reflect sound educational average student in the United States. Each child
principles and that have master teachers working learns to play a musical instrument, starting with
with students committed to the field, and finally, the violin in kindergarten.
a high level of community involvement from Schoolwide Themes. Each year, the school
parents, business leaders, museums, and other staff selects two themes, one each semester, to
learning institutions. help focus curricular activity. Themes used in
past years include: Connections, Animal Pat-
terns, Changes in Time and Space, Let’s Make a
Difference—Environmental Focus, Heritage, and
A Model MI School: Renaissance—Then and Now. During the devel-
The Key Learning Community opment of a theme, whole areas of the school
Efforts toward building an MI school have may reflect the learning that is going on. For ex-
already been underway for several years. One ample, during the environmental theme, part of
school in particular has been singled out by the the school was turned into a simulated tropical
media and other educators for recognition: the rain forest. Students select and develop projects
Key Learning Community in Indianapolis, Indi- for each theme, which they then present to their
ana. In 1984, a group of eight Indianapolis pub- teachers and peers during special sessions that
lic school teachers contacted Howard Gardner are videotaped.
for assistance in helping start a new school in the “Pods.” These are special learning groups
district. Out of their collaboration (as well as the that students individually select based on their
infusion of new educational ideas from the likes interests. Pods are formed around specific disci-
of Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, Elliot Eisner, Ernest plines (such as gardening, architecture, or acting)
Boyer, James MacDonald, and John Goodlad), or cognitive pursuits (such as mathematical
the Key School was officially born in September thinking, problem solving, and “the mind and
1987 (see Fiske, 1988; Olson, 1988). Since movement”). Students work with a teacher pos-
1994, the school has expanded from an elemen- sessing special competence in the selected area in
tary school to kindergarten through high school an apprenticeship-like context that emphasizes
(K–12) and has been renamed The Key Learning mastering real-world skills and knowledge. In
Community. the architecture pod, for example, students
The Key Learning Community combines sev- “adopted” nine houses in the surrounding area
eral different features of multiple-intelligence and studied the designs of the houses through
education to create a total learning experience, walking tours and other activities.
including the following: “The Flow Room.” Students visit the “flow
room” in the school several times each week to
Daily Instruction in All Eight Intelli- engage in activities designed to activate their
gences. Students at the Key Learning Commu- intelligences in open-ended and playful ways
nity middle school take classes in traditional (Cohen, 1991). Named after Mihaly Csikszent-
subjects (math, science, language arts, history, mihalyi’s (1990) concept of “flow” (referring to a

85
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

positive state of intense absorption in an activ- successful restructuring can be a grass-roots ef-
ity), the “flow room” is stocked with scores of fort. The Key Learning Community was not
board games, puzzles, computer software pro- mandated at an administrative level; it is a prod-
grams, and other learning materials. Students uct of the energy and commitment of eight pub-
can choose to participate in any activity available lic school teachers who had a dream about what
in the room (either alone or with others). A education could be for their students.
teacher helps facilitate their experience and also
observes how individual students interact with
the materials (each of which is keyed to a spe- MI Schools of the Future
cific intelligence; for instance, the game Otello is The Key School experience should by no means
linked to spatial intelligence, while Twister is be taken as the only way, or even the preferred
seen primarily as a bodily-kinesthetic activity. way, to develop a multiple-intelligence school.
Community Resource Committee. This There may be as many possible types of MI
group, consisting of community representatives schools as there are groups of educators, parents,
from business, the arts, cultural organizations, administrators, and community leaders commit-
government, and higher education, puts together ted to putting MI principles into action. Regard-
weekly programs or assemblies for the entire stu- less of how they are structured, MI schools of the
dent population that are based on interdiscipli- future will undoubtedly continue expanding the
nary themes. Frequently, the topics are tied into possibilities for unleashing children’s potentials
the schoolwide themes; for example, if the theme in all intelligences. Perhaps MI schools of the fu-
is the Environment, speakers might present in- ture will look less like schools and more like the
formation about sewage treatment, forestry, or real world, with traditional school buildings
lobbying for ecological causes. serving as temporary conduits through which
Heterogeneous Mixed-Aged Grouping. Stu- students move on their way to meaningful expe-
dents who attend the Key Learning Community riences in the community. Possibly, programs
are chosen randomly by a lottery system. Al- will arise that specialize in the development of
though some students had previously been la- one or more of the intelligences—although we
beled “learning disabled” and “gifted” and placed must be quick to guard against a “brave new
in special education programs, no such programs world” of multiple intelligences that could seek
are currently in place at the Key Learning Com- to identify a child’s strongest intelligences early in
munity. Students in any one class have a wide life so as to exploit them and channel them pre-
range of ability levels, a factor that is seen to maturely into a small niche that would serve a
enrich the program through diversity. (See Chap- narrowly segmented society.
ter 11 for a discussion of MI theory and special Ultimately, what will enrich the development
education.) of MI theory is its implementation in interdisci-
plinary ways that reflect the ever-changing de-
Although the Key Learning Community is mands of an increasingly complex society. As
only one of a number of schoolwide (and dis- society changes—and perhaps as we discover
trictwide) efforts to implement the theory of new intelligences to help us cope with these
multiple intelligences, it clearly provides evi- changes—MI schools of the future may reflect
dence that systemwide restructuring based on features that are right now beyond our wildest
MI theory can become reality—and that dreams.

86
The MI School

FOR FURTHER STUDY


1. Evaluate your school in terms of framework or philosophy, and compare and
multiple-intelligence theory. During the contrast their different ways of applying the
course of a school day, does each student have model (for information on schools applying
the opportunity to develop each of the eight MI theory, write Project Zero, Harvard
intelligences for its own sake? Specify pro- Graduate School of Education, 321 Longfel-
grams, courses, activities, and experiences that low Hall, 13 Appian Way, Cambridge, MA
develop the intelligences. How could the 02138; URL: http://www.pz.harvard.edu/su-
school’s programs be modified to incorporate mit/; e-mail: info@pz.harvard.edu). Which
a broader spectrum of intelligences? aspects of each program are applicable to
2. Assuming you had an unlimited your own school or classroom? Which com-
amount of money and resources available to ponents are not?
you, develop your version of the “ideal” MI 4. Discuss some of the problems that
school. What will the physical plant look like? schools might have in implementing MI
Draw a floor plan of the school to illustrate. theory as part of a broader reform move-
What kinds of courses will be offered? What ment. How can MI theory best fit into a
will the function of teachers be? What kinds school’s restructuring process? What ele-
of experiences will students have? If you wish, ments can be included in staff develop-
develop a scenario of an average student going ment to improve the chances for this model’s
through a typical day at such a school. success?
3. Contact schools that are now using
multiple-intelligence theory as an overall

87
MI and Assessment
10
I believe that we should get away altogether from tests and correlations among tests, and
look instead at more naturalistic sources of information about how peoples around the world
develop skills important to their way of life.
—Howard Gardner (1987)

The kinds of changes in instructional practice in recent years have argued that authentic meas-
described in the previous chapters require an ures of assessment probe students’ understand-
equivalent adjustment in the manner of assess- ing of material far more thoroughly than
ment used to evaluate learning progress. It multiple-choice or fill-in-the-blank tests (see
would certainly be the height of hypocrisy to ask Gardner, 1993b; Herman, Aschbacher, & Win-
students to participate in a wide range of multi- ters, 1992; Wolf, LeMahieu, & Eresh, 1992). In
spectrum experiences in all eight intelligences, particular, authentic measures allow students to
and then require them to show what they’ve show what they’ve learned in context—in other
learned through standardized tests that focus words, in a setting that closely matches the envi-
narrowly on verbal or logical domains. Educators ronment in which they would be expected to
would clearly be sending a double message to show that learning in real life. Standardized
students and to the wider community: “Learning measures, on the other hand, almost always as-
in eight ways is fun, but when it comes to our sess students in artificial settings far removed
from the real world. Figure 10.1 (pp. 90–91)
bottom line—evaluating students’ learning prog-
lists a number of other ways in which authentic
ress—we’ve got to get serious again and test the
measures prove superior to standardized testing
way we’ve always tested.” Thus, MI theory pro-
in promoting educational quality.
poses a fundamental restructuring of the way in
which educators assess their students’ learning
progress. It suggests a system that relies far less
on formal standardized or norm-referenced tests Varieties of
and much more on authentic measures that are Assessment Experience
criterion-referenced, benchmarked, or ipsative Authentic assessment covers a wide range of in-
(i.e., that compare a student to his own past struments, measures, and methods. The most
performances). important prerequisite to authentic assessment is
The multiple intelligence philosophy of observation. Howard Gardner (1983, 1993b) has
assessment is closely in line with the perspective pointed out that we can best assess students’
of a growing number of leading educators who multiple intelligences by observing students

88
MI and Assessment

manipulating the symbol systems of each intelli- tions, inventions, science and art projects).
gence. For instance, you might notice how stu- • Student Journals. Students can keep an
dents play a logical board game, how they ongoing journal of their experiences in school,
interact with a machine, how they dance, or how including writing entries, diagrams, doodles,
they cope with a dispute in a cooperative learn- and drawings.
ing group. Observing students solving problems • Student-Kept Charts. Students can keep their
or fashioning products in real-life contexts pro- own records of academic progress on charts and
vides the best picture of student competencies in graphs (e.g., number of books read, progress to-
the range of subjects taught in school. ward an educational objective).
The next most important component in im- • Sociograms. Keep a visual record of student
plementing authentic assessment is the documen- interactions in class, using symbols to indicate
tation of student products and problem-solving affiliation, negative interaction, and neutral con-
processes. You can document student perform- tact between class members.
ance in a variety of ways, including: • Informal Tests. Create nonstandardized tests
to elicit information about a child’s ability in a
• Anecdotal Records. Keep a journal with a specific area. Focus on building a qualitative pic-
section for each child, and record important aca- ture of the student’s understanding of the mate-
demic and nonacademic accomplishments, inter- rial rather than devising a method to expose the
actions with peers and learning materials, and student’s ignorance in a subject.
other relevant information about each child. • Informal Use of Standardized Tests. Give stan-
• Work Samples. Have a file for each child that dardized tests to individual students, but don’t
contains samples of the student’s work in lan- follow the strict administration guidelines. Relax
guage arts, math, art, or other areas you are re- time limits; read instructions to the student; ask
sponsible for. The samples can be photocopies if the student to clarify responses; and provide op-
the child wishes to keep the original. portunities to demonstrate answers in pictures,
• Audio Cassettes. Use cassettes to record three-dimensional constructions, music, or other
reading samples (have the student read into a ways. Find out what the student really knows;
recorder and also tell back the story at the end) probe errors to find out how the student is
and to record a child’s jokes, stories, riddles, thinking. Use the test as a stimulus to engage the
memories, opinions, and other samples of oral student in a dialogue about the material.
language; also use audio cassettes to document a • Student Interviews. Periodically meet with
child’s musical ability (singing, rapping, or play- students to discuss their school progress, their
ing an instrument). broader interests and goals, and other relevant is-
• Videotapes. Use videotapes to record a sues. Keep a record of each meeting in a student’s
child’s abilities in areas that are hard to docu- file.
ment in any other way (e.g., acting out a role in a • Criterion-Referenced Assessments. Use meas-
school play, catching a pass in a football game, ures that evaluate students not on the basis of a
demonstrating how she fixed a machine, intro- norm but with respect to a given set of
ducing an ecology project), and videotape stu- skills—that is, use assessments that tell in con-
dents presenting projects they’ve completed. crete terms what the student can and cannot do
• Photography. Have a camera on hand to snap (e.g., add two-digit numbers with regrouping,
pictures of things kids have made that might not write a three-page story on a subject that inter-
be preserved (e.g., three-dimensional construc- ests the student).

89
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 10.1
STANDARDIZED TESTING VERSUS AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT

Standardized Testing Authentic Assessment

• Reduces children’s rich and complex lives to a • Gives the teacher a “felt sense” of the child’s
collection of scores, percentiles, or grades. unique experience as a learner.

• Creates stresses that negatively affect a child’s • Provides interesting, active, lively, and exciting
performance. experiences.

• Creates a mythical standard or norm which re- • Establishes an environment where every child
quires that a certain percentage of children fail. has the opportunity to succeed.

• Pressures teachers to narrow their curriculum to • Allows teachers to develop meaningful curricula
only what is tested on an exam. and assess within the context of that program.

• Emphasizes one-shot exams that assess knowl- • Assesses on an ongoing basis in a way that
edge residing in a single mind at a single mo- provides a more accurate picture of a student’s
ment in time. achievement.

• Tends to place the focus of interpretation on er- • Puts the emphasis on a student’s strengths; tells
rors, mistakes, low scores, and other things that what they can do and what they’re trying to do.
children can’t do.
• Focuses too much importance on single sets of • Provides multiple sources of evaluation that give
data (i.e., test scores) in making educational a more accurate view of a student’s progress.
decisions.

• Treats all students in a uniform way. • Treats each student as a unique human being.
• Discriminates against some students because of • Provides a culture-fair assessment of a stu-
cultural background and learning style. dent’s performance; gives everyone an equal
chance to succeed.
• Judges the child without providing suggestions • Provides information that is useful to the learn-
for improvement. ing process.
• Regards testing and instruction as separate • Regards assessment and teaching as two sides
activities. of the same coin.
continued

• Checklists. Develop an informal criterion- copies of it. Each day indicate patterns of move-
referenced assessment system simply by keeping ment, activity, and interaction in different parts
a checklist of important skills or content areas of the room, writing on the map the names of
used in your classroom and then checking off the students involved.
competencies when students have achieved them • Calendar Records. Have students keep rec-
(as well as indicating progress toward each goal). ords of their activities during the day by record-
• Classroom Maps. Draw up a classroom map ing them on a monthly calendar. You can collect
(a bird’s-eye view of the classroom with all desks, the calendars at the end of every month.
tables, and activity areas indicated) and make

90
MI and Assessment

FIGURE 10.1— continued


STANDARDIZED TESTING VERSUS AUTHENTIC ASSESSMENT

Standardized Testing Authentic Assessment

• Answers are final; students rarely receive an op- • Engages the child in a continual process of
portunity to revise, reflect, or redo a testing self-reflection, mediated learning, and revision.
experience.

• Provides results that can be fully understood • Describes a child’s performance in common-
only by a trained professional. sense terms that can be easily understood by
parents, children, and other noneducators.

• Produces scoring materials that students often • Results in products that have value to students
never see again. and others.

• Focuses on “the right answer.” • Deals with processes as much as final products.

• Places students in artificial learning environ- • Examines students in unobtrusive ways within
ments that disturb the natural ecology of the context of their natural learning
learning. environments.

• Usually focuses on lower-order learning skills. • Includes higher-order thinking skills and
important subjective domains (e.g., insight and
integrity).

• Encourages extrinsic learning (e.g., learning to • Fosters learning for its own sake.
pass a test or to get a good score).
• Has time limits that constrain many pupils’ think- • Provides students with the time they need to
ing processes. work through a problem, project, or process.
• Is generally limited to reading, listening, and • Involves creating, interviewing, demonstrating,
marking on a piece of paper. solving problems, reflecting, sketching, discuss-
ing, and engaging in many other active learning
tasks.
• Generally forbids students to interact. • Encourages cooperative learning.

• Promotes unhelpful comparisons between • Compares students to their own past


children. performances.

MI Assessment Projects middle school, and high school levels


(see Gardner 1993b).*
Several projects that have attempted to create
models of assessment congruent with the funda-
mental philosophy of MI theory have been initi-
*For more information about these and other Harvard
ated nationwide, many of them under the
Project Zero projects, write for a materials list to: Project
direction of Howard Gardner and his colleagues Zero, Harvard Graduate School of Education, 321 Longfel-
at Harvard University’s Project Zero. These in- low Hall, 13 Appian Way, Cambridge, MA 02138 (URL:
clude projects at the preschool, elementary, http://www.pz.harvard.edu; e-mail: info@pz.harvard.edu).

91
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

Project Spectrum. This is a preschool pro- develop metacognitive skills and understandings
gram piloted at the Eliot Pearson Children’s in school-related activities; units include “Choos-
School at Tufts University in Medford, Massachu- ing a Project,” “Finding the Right Mathematical
setts. The program uses several assessment in- Tools,” “Notetaking,” and “Why Go to School.”
struments that are themselves rich and engaging Students were evaluated on these units through
activities forming an integral part of the Spec- contextually rich performance-based assess-
trum curriculum. They include creative move- ments. For the unit called “Choosing a Project,”
ment experiences (bodily-kinesthetic/musical); the assessment tasks included critiquing three
a dinosaur board game involving rolling dice, proposal plans and providing suggestions for im-
counting moves, and calculating strategies proving the least promising one. For the unit
(logical-mathematical); and a storyboard activity called “Mathematical Tools,” the assessment tasks
that requires students to create a miniature included solving a problem with limited re-
three-dimensional world and then tell a story sources and generating other options for devel-
about it (spatial/linguistic). The program also oping solutions (see Williams et al., 1996).
makes use of art portfolios and teachers’ observa- Arts PROPEL. This was a five-year high
tions of children engaged in activities in the dif- school arts project piloted in the Pittsburgh Pub-
ferent centers (e.g., the story-telling area, the lic Schools in Pennsylvania. The focus was on
building center, the naturalist’s corner). In addi- two elements: (1) domain projects, a series of ex-
tion to looking for “proclivities” in the eight in- ercises, activities, and productions in the visual
telligences, teachers assess each student’s arts, music, and creative writing designed to de-
characteristic “working styles,” looking at velop student sensitivity to compositional fea-
whether, for example, the child is either confi- tures; and (2) processfolios, ongoing collections of
dent or tentative, playful or serious, or reflective students’ artistic productions, such as drawings,
or impulsive in their way of approaching differ- paintings, musical compositions, and creative
ent learning settings. (For more information, see writing, from initial idea through rough drafts to
Gardner, Feldman, & Krechevsky, 1998a, 1998b, final product. Evaluation procedures included
1998c.) self-assessments (requiring student reflection)
Key Learning Community. This is a kinder- and teacher assessments that probed students’
garten to high school program that is part of the technical and imaginative skills and their ability
Indianapolis Public Schools in Indiana. In this to benefit from self-reflection and critique from
program, educators use videotape extensively in others. (Arts PROPEL handbooks based on the
their assessment of learning progress. Students project are available from Harvard Project Zero.)
are videotaped at two points during the year as
they are presenting their learning projects. These
video portfolios accompany a student through Assessment in Eight Ways
the grades, providing valuable assessment infor- MI theory provides its greatest contribution to
mation to parents, teachers, administrators, and assessment in suggesting multiple ways to evalu-
the students themselves. (See Chapter 9 for more ate students. The biggest shortcoming of stan-
information on the Key Learning Community.) dardized tests is that they require students to
PIFS (Practical Intelligence for School) show in a narrowly defined way what they’ve
Units. This program was a middle school infu- learned during the year. Standardized tests usu-
sion curriculum that sought to help students ally demand that students be seated at a desk,

92
MI and Assessment

that they complete the test within a specific On the other hand, MI theory suggests a vari-
amount of time, and that they speak to no one ety of ways in which students could demonstrate
during the test. The tests themselves usually con- their understanding:
tain largely linguistic questions or test items that
students must answer by filling in bubbles on • Linguistic Demonstration. “Describe Huck
computer-coded forms. Finn in your own words, either orally or in an
MI theory, on the other hand, supports the open-ended written format.”
belief that students should be able to show com- • Logical-Mathematical Demonstration. “If
petence in a specific skill, subject, content area, Huck Finn were a scientific principle, law, or
or domain in any one of a variety of ways. And theorem, which one would he be?”
just as the theory of multiple intelligences sug- • Spatial Demonstration. “Draw a quick sketch
gests that any instructional objective can be showing something you think Huck Finn would
taught in at least eight different ways, so too does enjoy doing that’s not indicated in the novel.”
it imply that any subject can be assessed in at • Bodily-Kinesthetic Demonstration. “Panto-
least eight different ways. mime how you think Huck Finn would act in a
If, for example, the objective is for students classroom.”
to demonstrate an understanding of the charac- • Musical Demonstration. “If Huck Finn were a
ter of Huck Finn in the Mark Twain novel The musical phrase, what would he sound like or
Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, a standardized what song would he be?”
test might require students to complete the fol- • Interpersonal Demonstration. “Who does
lowing task on a testing form: Huck Finn remind you of in your own life
(friends, family, other students, TV characters)?”
• Intrapersonal Demonstration. “Describe in a
Choose the word that best describes few words your personal feelings toward Huck
Huck Finn in the novel: Finn.”
(a) sensitive • Naturalist Demonstration. “If Huck Finn
(b) jealous were an animal, which one would he be? Why?”
(c) erudite
(d) fidgety By linking Huck Finn to pictures, physical
actions, musical phrases, scientific formulas, so-
cial connections, personal feelings, and animals,
Such an item demands that students know the students have more opportunities to use their
meanings of each of the four words and that multiple intelligences to help articulate their un-
every student’s interpretation of Huck Finn coin- derstanding. Implied here is the fundamental no-
cide with that of the test maker. For instance, al- tion that many students who have mastered the
though “fidgety” might be the answer the testers material taught in school may not have the means
are looking for, “sensitive” might actually be to show what they’ve learned if the only setting
closer to the truth, because it touches on Huck’s available for demonstrating competency is a nar-
openness to a wide range of social issues. But a rowly focused linguistic testing arena. See Figure
standardized test provides no opportunity to ex- 10.2 (p. 94) for examples of how students can
plore or discuss this interpretation. Students who show competence in specific academic subjects.
are not particularly word sensitive may know a Using the “eight ways” context of assessment,
great deal about Huck Finn, yet not be able to students might be assessed in any number of
show their knowledge on this test item. ways:

93
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 10.2
EXAMPLES OF THE EIGHT WAYS STUDENTS CAN SHOW THEIR KNOWLEDGE ABOUT SPECIFIC TOPICS

Factors Associated
with the South Losing Development of a Principles of Molecular
Intelligence the Civil War Character in a Novel Bonding

Linguistic Give an oral or written Do oral interpretation from Explain concept verbally or
report the novel with commentary in writing

Logical- Present statistics on dead, Present sequential cause- Write down chemical formu-
Mathematical wounded, supplies effect chart of character’s las and show how derived
development

Spatial Draw maps of important Develop flow chart or series Draw diagrams that show
battles of sketches showing rise/fall different bonding patterns
of character

Bodily- Create 3-D maps of impor- Pantomime the role from Build several molecular
Kinesthetic tant battles and act them out beginning of novel to end, structures with multicolored
with miniature soldiers showing changes pop-beads

Musical Assemble Civil War songs Present development of Orchestrate a dance show-
that point to causal factors character as a musical ing different bonding pat-
score terns (see below)

Interpersonal Design class simulation of Discuss underlying motives Demonstrate molecular


important battles and moods relating to bonding using classmates
development as atoms

Intrapersonal Develop their own unique Relate character’s develop- Create scrapbook demon-
way of demonstrating ment to one’s own life strating competency
competency history

Naturalist Examine how the geo- Compare development of Use animal analogies to ex-
graphical features of North character to the evolution of plain dynamics of bonding
and South contributed to a species or the history of (e.g., animals that attract
result an ecosystem and don’t attract, symbiotic
relationships in nature)

• Students could be exposed to all eight per- 10.3 contains a sample form that suggests how
formance tasks in an attempt to discover the students might “contract” to be assessed in a spe-
area(s) in which they were most successful. cific subject area.
• Students might be assigned a performance
task based on the teacher’s understanding of
their most developed intelligences. Assessment in Context
• Students themselves could choose the man- MI theory expands the assessment arena consid-
ner in which they’d like to be assessed. Figure erably to include a wide range of possible

94
MI and Assessment

FIGURE 10.3
“C ELEBRATION OF LEARNING” STUDENT SIGN-UP SHEET

To show that I know , I would like to:

write a report create a series of sketches/diagrams


do a photo essay set up an experiment
compile a scrapbook engage in a debate or discussion
build a model do a mind-map
put on a live demonstration produce a videotape segment
create a group project create an ecology project that incorporates
do a statistical chart the subject
develop an interactive computer develop a musical
presentation create a rap or song that encompasses
keep a journal the topic
record interviews teach it to someone else
design a mural choreograph a dance
create a discography based on the topic develop a project not listed above:
give a talk
develop a simulation other:

Brief description of what I intend to do:

Signature of Student Date

Signature of Teacher Date

contexts within which a student can express then he probably will not be able to externalize
competence in a specific area. It suggests that what he knows. Figure 10.4 (pp. 96–97) indi-
both the manner of presentation and the method cates some possible combinations between
of response will be important in determining a method of presentation and method of response
student’s competence. If a student learns primar- in structuring assessment contexts.
ily through pictures, yet is exposed only to the A look at Figure 10.4 shows that typical test-
printed word when learning new material, then ing settings for students in U.S. schools take in
she will probably not be able to show mastery of only one of the fifty-six contexts shown (the one
the subject. Similarly, if a student is physically in the upper left corner: “Read a book, then write
oriented (bodily-kinesthetic), yet has to demon- a response.” Yet even the contexts listed in the fig-
strate mastery through a paper-and-pencil test, ure are but a fraction of the potential settings

95
FIGURE 10.4
64 MI ASSESSMENT CONTEXTS

Logical- Bodily-
Activity/ Linguistic Mathematical Spatial Musical Kinesthetic Interpersonal Intrapersonal Naturalist
Assessment Activity Activity Activity Activity Activity Activity Activity Activity

Linguistic Read a book, Examine a Watch a Listen to a Go on a field Play a coop- Think about a Observe na-
Assessment then write a statistical movie, then piece of mu- trip, then write erative game, personal ex- ture, then
response. chart, then write a re- sic, then write a response. then write a perience, then write a re-
write a re- sponse. a response. response. write a re- sponse.
sponse. sponse.

Logical- Read a book, Examine a Watch a Listen to a Go on a field Play a coop- Think about a Observe na-
Math- then develop statistical movie, then piece of mu- trip, then de- erative game, personal ex- ture, then de-
ematical a hypothesis. chart, then develop a hy- sic, then de- velop a hy- then develop perience, then velop a
Assessment develop a hy- pothesis. velop a pothesis. a hypothesis. develop a hypothesis.
pothesis. hypothesis. hypothesis.

96
Spatial Read a book, Examine a Watch a Listen to a Go on a field Play a coop- Think about a Observe na-
Assessment then draw a statistical movie, then piece of mu- trip, then draw erative game, personal ex- ture, then
picture. chart, then draw a pic- sic, then draw a picture. then draw a perience, then draw a pic-
draw a pic- ture. a picture. picture. draw a ture.
ture. picture.
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

Bodily- Read a book, Examine a Watch a Listen to a Go on a field Play a coop- Think about a Observe na-
Kinesthetic then build a statistical movie, then piece of mu- trip, then build erative game, personal ex- ture, then
Assessment model. chart, then build a model. sic, then build a model. then build a perience, then build a model.
build a model. a model. model. build a model.

continued
FIGURE 10.4— continued
64 MI ASSESSMENT CONTEXTS

Logical- Bodily-
Activity/ Linguistic Mathematical Spatial Musical Kinesthetic Interpersonal Intrapersonal Naturalist
Assessment Activity Activity Activity Activity Activity Activity Activity Activity

Musical Read a book, Examine a Watch a Listen to a Go on a field Play a coop- Think about a Observe na-
Assessment then create a statistical movie, then piece of mu- trip, then cre- erative game, personal ex- ture, then cre-
song. chart, then create a song. sic, then cre- ate a song. then create a perience, then ate a song.
create a song. ate a song. song. create a song.

Interpersonal Read a book, Examine a Watch a Listen to a Go on a field Play a coop- Think about a Observe na-
Assessment then share statistical movie, then piece of mu- trip, then erative game, personal ex- ture, then
with a friend. chart, then share with sic, then share with a then share perience, then share with a
share with a a friend. share with a friend. with a friend. share with a friend.
friend. friend. friend.

97
Intrapersonal Read a book, Examine a Watch a Listen to a Go on a field Play a coop- Think about a Observe na-
Assessment then design statistical movie, then piece of mu- trip, then de- erative game, personal ex- ture, then de-
MI and Assessment

your own re- chart, then design your sic, then de- sign your own then design perience, then sign your own
sponse. design your own sign your own response. your own re- design your response.
own re- response. response. sponse. own
sponse. response.

Naturalist Read a book, Examine a Watch a Listen to a Go on a field Play a coop- Think about a Observe na-
Assessment then do an statistical movie, then piece of mu- trip, then do erative game, personal ex- ture, then do
ecology proj- chart, then do do an ecology sic, then do an ecology then do an perience, then an ecology
ect. an ecology project. an ecology project. ecology proj- do an ecology project.
project. project. ect. project.
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

that could be structured for assessment pur- document (the video) within which to assess a
poses. For example, “Listen to a talking book” student’s ecological competencies through a vari-
could be substituted for “Read a book,” and “Tell ety of intelligences.
a story” might replace “Write a response” to
structure several other assessment contexts.
There are also many opportunities for variety MI Portfolios
even within each of the combinations shown in
As students increasingly engage in multiple-
Figure 10.4. For example, the experience of a
intelligence projects and activities, the opportuni-
student who chooses to “go on a field trip, then
ties for documenting their learning process in MI
build a model” will vary depending on where the
portfolios expands considerably. In the past dec-
field trip was taken, what kind of mediating ex-
ade, portfolio development among reform-
periences were provided during the trip, and how
minded educators has often been limited to work
the model-building activity was structured.
requiring the linguistic and logical-mathematical
These factors would themselves give rise to a
intelligences (writing portfolios and math portfo-
multiplicity of contexts, some of which might be
lios). MI theory suggests, however, that portfolios
favorable to a student’s demonstration of compe-
ought to be expanded to include, when appropri-
tency (e.g., a field trip to a place the student is
ate, materials from all eight intelligences. Figure
interested in or has had prior experience with)
10.5 lists some kinds of documents that might be
and others that might handicap him (e.g., the
included in an MI Portfolio.
use of modeling materials the student didn’t like
Naturally, the kinds of materials placed in an
or had no familiarity with, or their use in a set-
MI portfolio will depend on the educational pur-
ting with peers he didn’t get along with).
poses and goals of each portfolio. There are at
Of course, you do not need to develop fifty-
least five basic uses for portfolios. I call them
six different assessment contexts for everything
“The Five C’s of Portfolio Development”:
you need to evaluate. Figure 10.4 suggests, how-
ever, the need to provide students with assess- 1. Celebration. To acknowledge and validate
ment experiences that include access to a variety students’ products and accomplishments during
of methods of presentation (inputs) and means the year.
of expression (outputs). The kinds of assessment 2. Cognition. To help students reflect on their
experiences that MI theory proposes—particu- own work.
larly those that are project-based and themati- 3. Communication. To let parents, administra-
cally oriented—offer students frequent tors, and other teachers know about students’
opportunities to be exposed to several of these learning progress.
contexts at one time (as in the Project Zero pro- 4. Cooperation. To provide a means for groups
grams described earlier). For example, if stu- of students to collectively produce and evaluate
dents are developing a videotape to show their their own work.
understanding of the effects of pollution on their 5. Competency. To establish criteria by which
local community, they may have to read books, a student’s work can be compared to that of
do field work, listen to environmental songs, and other students or to a standard or benchmark.
engage in cooperative activities (inputs) to create
a video that includes a montage of pictures, mu- The checklist in Figure 10.6 (p. 100) can help
sic, dialogue, and words (outputs). This complex you clarify some of the uses to which portfolios
project provides the teacher with a context-rich might be put in the classroom.

98
MI and Assessment

FIGURE 10.5
WHAT TO PUT IN AN MI PORTFOLIO

To document linguistic intelligence: To document musical intelligence:


• Prewriting notes • Audiotapes of musical performances,
• Preliminary drafts of writing projects compositions, collages
• Best samples of writing • Samples of written scores (performed or
• Written descriptions of investigations composed)
• Audiotapes of debates, discussions, • Lyrics of raps, songs, or rhymes written by
problem-solving processes student
• Final reports • Discographies compiled by student
• Dramatic interpretations
• Reading skills checklists To document interpersonal intelligence:
• Audiotapes of reading or storytelling • Letters to and from others (e.g., writing to obtain
• Samples of word puzzles solved information from someone)
• Group reports
To document logical-mathematical intelligence: • Written feedback from peers, teachers, and
• Math skills checklists experts
• Best samples of math papers • Teacher-student conference reports (summa-
• Rough notes from computations/problem-solving rized/transcribed)
processes • Parent-teacher-student conference reports
• Final write-ups of science lab experiments • Peer-group reports
• Photos of science fair projects • Photos, videos, or write-ups of cooperative
• Documentation of science fair projects (awards, learning projects
photos) • Documentation of community service projects
• Piagetian assessment materials (certificates, photos)
• Samples of logic puzzles or brainteasers solved
• Samples of computer programs created or To document intrapersonal intelligence:
learned • Journal entries
• Self-assessment essays, checklists, drawings,
To document spatial intelligence: activities
• Photos of projects • Samples of other self-reflection exercises
• Three-dimensional mockups • Questionnaires
• Diagrams, flow charts, sketches, or mind-maps of • Transcribed interviews on goals and plans
thinking • Interest inventories
• Samples or photos of collages, drawings, • Samples of outside hobbies or activities
paintings • Student-kept progress charts
• Videotapes of projects • Notes of self-reflection on own work
• Samples of visual-spatial puzzles solved
To document naturalist intelligence:
To document bodily-kinesthetic intelligence: • Field notes from nature studies
• Videotapes of projects and demonstrations • Records of 4H or similar club participation
• Samples of projects actually made • Photos of caring for animals or plants
• Videos or other records of the “acting out” of • Videotape of demonstration of naturalist project
thinking processes • Record of volunteer efforts in ecological activities
• Photos of hands-on projects • Writings about love of nature or pets
• Photos of nature collections (e.g., leaves, insects)

99
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 10.6
MI PORTFOLIO CHECKLIST

How will you use the portfolio? Manila folder


For student self-reflection (Cognition) Bound volume
As part of regular school evaluation/report CD-ROM
card (Competency) Internet Web site
At parent conferences (Communication, Other:
Competency)
In IEP/SST meetings (Communication, Who will evaluate the portfolio?
Competency) Teacher alone
In communicating to next year’s teacher(s) Teacher working in collaboration with other
(Communication, Competency) teachers
In curricular planning (Competency) Student self-evaluation
In acknowledging students’ Peer evaluation
accomplishments (Celebration) Other:
In creating cooperative learning activities
(Cooperation) How will the works in the portfolio be
Other: arranged?
Chronologically
How will it be organized? By student: from “crummy” to “great” (with
Only finished pieces from a variety of reasons given)
subjects By teacher: from poor to superior
Different expressions of a specific objective (with reasons given)
Charting of progress from first idea to final From birth of an idea to its fruition
realization By subject area
Representative samples of a week/month/ Other:
year’s work
Only “best” work What factors will go into evaluating the
Include “group” work portfolio?
Other: Number of entries
Range of entries
What procedures will you use in placing items Degree of self-reflection demonstrated
in the portfolio? Improvement from past performances
Select regular times for pulling student work Achievement of preset goals (student’s,
Train students to select (e.g., flagging with teacher’s, school’s)
stickers) Interplay of production, perception, and
Pull items that meet preset criteria reflection
Random approach Responsiveness to feedback/mediation
Other: Depth of revision
Group consensus (among teachers)
What will the portfolio look like? Willingness to take a risk
Two pieces of posterboard stapled or taped Development of themes
together Use of benchmarks or rubrics for
Box or other container comparison
Scrapbook Other:
Diary or journal

100
MI and Assessment

The process of evaluating MI portfolios and our attention in MI assessment on looking at in-
other MI performances presents the most chal- dividual students’ work in depth in terms of the
lenging aspect of their development. Current re- unfolding of each student’s uniqueness (for ap-
forms in assessment have emphasized the propriate assessment models of this kind, see
development of rubrics, holistic scoring, or other Carini, 1982; Engel, 1979; Armstrong, M.,
benchmarks by which complex performances 1980).
and works can be evaluated (see Herman et al., Ultimately, MI theory provides an assessment
1992). In my estimation, these devices are best framework within which students can have their
suited only for the competency dimension of port- rich and complex lives acknowledged, cele-
folio development. For the other four compo- brated, and nurtured. Because MI assessment
nents, emphasis should be placed less on and MI instruction represent flip sides of the
comparison and more on student self-evaluation same coin, MI approaches to assessment are not
and on ipsative measures (assessment that com- likely to take more time to implement, as long as
pares a student to his own past performances). they are seen as an integral part of the instruc-
Unfortunately, some teachers are using alter- tional process. As such, assessment experiences
native assessment techniques to reduce students’ and instructional experiences should begin to
rich and complex works to holistic scores or appear virtually indistinguishable. Moreover, stu-
rankings like these: Portfolio A is a 1, Portfolio B dents engaged in this process should begin to
a 3; Child C’s art project is at a “novice” level, regard the assessment experience not as a grue-
while Child D’s project is at a “mastery” level. some “judgment day” but rather as another
This reductionism ends up looking very much opportunity to learn.
like standardized testing in some of its worst mo- See the next page for further study of MI
ments. I suggest that we instead initially focus assessment.

101
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FOR FURTHER STUDY


1. Choose an educational outcome that (including photography, videotape, audio-
you are preparing students to reach, and then tape, or electronic duplication of student
develop an MI-sensitive assessment measure work) and begin documenting student work
that will allow students to demonstrate their using this medium.
competency in a number of ways (i.e., 5. Keep a daily or weekly diary in which
through two or more of the eight intelli- you record your observations of students
gences). demonstrating competency in each of the
2. Help students develop “celebration eight intelligences.
portfolios” that include elements from several 6. Experiment with the kinds of inputs
intelligences (see Figure 10.5 for examples of (methods of presentation) and outputs
what to put in a portfolio). Develop a set of (methods of expression) you use in con-
procedures for selecting material (see Figure structing assessments. Use Figure 10.4 as a
10.6), and a setting within which students can guide in developing a variety of assessment
reflect on their portfolios and present them to contexts.
others. 7. Develop an ipsative assessment
3. Put on a “Celebration of Learning” fair approach (i.e., one that compares a student
at which students can demonstrate competen- to her own past performance) and compare
cies and show products they’ve made that re- its usefulness to other methods of assess-
late to the eight intelligences. ment and evaluation (e.g., standardized
4. Focus on one method of documentation tests, benchmarked performances, holisti-
that you’d like to explore, develop, or refine cally scored portfolios).

102
MI and Special Education
11
Treat people as if they were what they ought to be, and you help them to become what they
are capable of being.
—Goethe

The theory of multiple intelligences has educators, we care only about competence
broad implications for special education. By fo- in its most traditional and bookish
cusing on a wide spectrum of abilities, MI theory sense—reading, writing, spelling, science,
places “disabilities” or “handicaps” in a broader social studies and math in basal texts and
context. Using MI theory as a backdrop, educa- worksheets (Poplin, 1984, p. 133).
tors can begin to perceive children with special Similar themes could also be identified in other
needs as whole persons possessing strengths in areas of special education, including speech pa-
many intelligence areas. Over the history of the thology, mental retardation, emotional disturbance,
special education movement in the United States, and attention deficit disorder, where the very
educators have had a disturbing tendency (gifted terms themselves strongly suggest the operation
educators excepted) to work from a deficit para- of a disease paradigm in each case (see Arm-
digm—focusing on what students can’t do—in an strong, T., 1987b, 1997, 1999a).
attempt to help students succeed in school. As an
example of this trend, Mary Poplin in her farewell
address to her readership as editor of the Learning
Disability Quarterly (LDQ) stated: MI Theory as a Growth
The horrifying truth is that in the four years Paradigm
I have been editor of LDQ, only one article We do not have to regard children with special
has been submitted that sought to elaborate needs primarily in terms of deficit, disorder, and
on the talents of the learning disabled. This disease. We can instead begin to work within the
is a devastating commentary on a field that parameters of a growth paradigm. Figure 11.1
is supposed to be dedicated to the education (p. 104) illustrates some key differences between
of students with average and above average these two paradigms. MI theory provides a
intelligence. . . . Why do we not know if our growth paradigm for assisting special-needs stu-
students are talented in art, music, dance, dents in school. It acknowledges difficulties or
athletics, mechanical repair, computer pro- disabilities, but does so within the context of
gramming, or are creative in other nontradi- regarding special-needs students as basically
tional ways? . . . It is because, like regular healthy individuals.

103
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

MI theory suggests that “learning disabilities,” naturalist difficulties (e.g., one who cannot relate
for example, may occur in all eight intelligences. to pets, or lacks a “green thumb”). These deficits,
That is, in addition to students with dyslexia (lin- however, often operate relatively autonomously
guistic deficit) and dyscalculia (logical-mathe- in the midst of other dimensions of the individu-
matical deficit), there are individuals who have al’s learning profile that are relatively intact and
prosopagnosia or specific difficulties recognizing healthy. MI theory thus provides a model for un-
faces (a spatial deficit), those with ideomotor dys- derstanding the autistic savant who cannot com-
praxias who cannot execute specific motor com- municate clearly with others but plays music at a
mands (bodily-kinesthetic deficit), individuals professional level, the dyslexic who possesses
who are dysmusic and have difficulty carrying a special drawing or designing gifts, the “retarded”
tune (musical deficit), as well as people with spe- student who can act extremely well on the stage,
cific personality disorders (intrapersonal deficit), or the student with cerebral palsy who has spe-
sociopathies (interpersonal deficit), and cial linguistic and logical-mathematical genius.

FIGURE 11.1
THE DEFICIT PARADIGM VERSUS THE GROWTH PARADIGM IN SPECIAL EDUCATION

Deficit Paradigm Growth Paradigm

• Labels the individual in terms of specific impair- • Avoids labels; views the individual as an intact
ment(s) (e.g., ADHD, ED, BD, EMR, LD). person who happens to have a special need.

• Diagnoses the specific impairment(s) using a • Assesses the needs of an individual using
battery of standardized tests; focuses on errors, authentic assessment approaches within a natu-
low scores, and weaknesses in general. ralistic context; focuses on strengths.

• Remediates the impairment(s) using a number • Assists the person in learning and growing
of specialized treatment strategies often re- through a rich and varied set of interactions with
moved from any real-life context. real-life activities and events.

• Separates the individual from the mainstream for • Maintains the individual’s connections with peers
specialized treatment in a segregated class, in pursuing as normal a life pattern as possible.
group, or program.
• Uses an esoteric collection of terms, tests, pro- • Uses materials, strategies, and activities that are
grams, kits, materials, and workbooks that are good for all kids.
different from those found in a regular
classroom.
• Segments the individual’s life into specific behav- • Maintains the individual’s integrity as a whole hu-
ioral/educational objectives that are regularly man being when assessing progress toward
monitored, measured, and modified. goals.
• Creates special education programs that run on • Establishes collaborative models that enable
a track parallel with regular education programs; specialists and regular classroom teachers to
teachers from the two tracks rarely meeting, ex- work hand in hand.
cept in IEP meetings.

104
MI and Special Education

Successful Disabled Individuals prophecy” or “Pygmalion effect” suggests that the


ways in which educators view a student can have
as Models for Growth a subtle but significant effect on the quality of
It may be instructive to study the lives of emi- teaching the student receives and may help to
nent individuals in history who struggled with determine the student’s ultimate success or fail-
disabilities of one kind or another. Such a study ure in school (see Rosenthal & Jacobsen, 1968).
reveals, in fact, the existence of people with all
types of special needs who are also exceptionally
gifted in one or more of the eight intelligences. Cognitive Bypassing
Figure 11.2 (p. 106) lists some creative individu-
als, along with the specific disability they strug- Teachers and administrators need to serve as “MI
gled with and the primary intelligence through strength detectives” in the lives of students facing
which they expressed much of their genius. difficulties in school. This kind of advocacy can
The people in Figure 11.2 are known primar- lead the way toward providing positive solutions
ily for their achievements in life. In some cases, to their special needs. In particular, MI theory
their disability was incidental to their accom- suggests that students who are not succeeding
plishments. In other cases, their disabilities because of limitations in specific intelligence ar-
probably helped spur them to develop their ex- eas can often bypass these obstacles by using an
ceptional abilities. MI theory provides a context alternative route, so to speak, that exploits their
for discussing these lives and for applying the more highly developed intelligences (see Gard-
understanding gained from such study to the ner, 1983, pp. 388–392).
lives of students who are struggling with similar In some cases, special-needs students can
problems. For example, a student labeled “dys- learn to use an alternative symbol system in an un-
lexic” can begin to understand that his difficulty impaired intelligence. It’s interesting to note that
may directly affect only a small part of one intel- braille, for example, has been used successfully
ligence area (the reading dimensions of linguistic with students identified as severe dyslexics who
intelligence), leaving unimpaired vast regions of possessed special strengths in tactile sensitivity
his learning potential. It’s instructive to note, for (see McCoy, 1975). Similarly, researchers have
instance, that many great writers, including reported more success in teaching a group of
Agatha Christie and Hans Christian Andersen, kids diagnosed as “reading-disabled” Chinese
have been considered to be dyslexic (see Fleming, characters than in teaching them English sight
1984; Illingworth & Illingworth, 1966). words (Rozin, Poritsky, & Sotsky, 1971). In this
By constructing a perspective of special-needs case, an ideographic symbol system (Chinese)
students as whole individuals, MI theory pro- worked more successfully with these spatially
vides a context for envisioning positive channels oriented youngsters than the linguistic (sound-
through which students can learn to deal with symbol) English code.
their disabilities. Educators who view disabilities In other cases, the empowering strategy may
against the background of the eight intelligences involve an alternative technology or special learn-
see that disabilities occur in only part of a stu- ing tool. For example, the Xerox/Kurzweil Per-
dent’s life; thus, they can begin to focus more at- sonal Reader provides individuals who cannot
tention on the strengths of special-needs students decode the printed word (due to special learning
as a prerequisite to developing appropriate reme- or perceptual difficulties) a means of electroni-
dial strategies. Research on the “self-fulfilling cally scanning a printed page and having those

105
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 11.2
HIGH-ACHIEVING PEOPLE FACING PERSONAL CHALLENGES
Intelligence LD CD ED PD HD SD

Linguistic Agatha Demosthenes Edgar Allan Alexander Samuel Rudyard


Christie Poe Pope Johnson Kipling

Logical- Albert Michael Charles Stephen Thomas Johannes


Mathematical Einstein Faraday Darwin Hawking Edison Kepler

Spatial Leonardo da Marc Chagall Vincent Van Henri de Granville Otto Litzel
Vinci Gogh Toulouse- Redmond
Lautrec

Bodily- Auguste Admiral Peary Vaslav Jim Abbott Marlee Matlin Tom Sullivan
Kinesthetic Rodin Nijinsky

Musical Sergei Maurice Robert Itzhak Ludwig van Joaquin


Rachmaninoff Ravel Schumann Perlman Beethoven Rodrigo

Interpersonal Nelson Winston Harry Stack Franklin King Jordan Harry Truman
Rockefeller Churchill Sullivan Roosevelt

Intrapersonal General Aristotle Friedrich Mohammed Helen Keller Aldous


George Nietzsche Huxley
Patton

Naturalist Linnaeus Erasmus Gregor Jean Jacques Johannes E. O. Wilson


Darwin Mendel Rousseau Kepler

Note: LD = learning difficulties; CD = communicative difficulties; ED = emotional difficulties; PD = physical difficulties; HD = hearing difficulties;
SD = sight difficulties

signals transformed into sound impulses that can The same approach used to empower special-
be heard and understood. Similarly, mathemati- needs students can also be employed in develop-
cal calculators have come to the rescue of people ing appropriate instructional strategies. The un-
identified as having severe dyscalculia and other derlying procedure involves translating informa-
math-processing difficulties. tion in the “intelligence language” that students
Sometimes, the empowering strategy wears a have trouble learning or understanding into an
human face, as in the case of a therapist (for “intelligence language” that students do under-
those struggling with difficulties in the personal stand. Figure 11.4 (p. 108) shows a few examples.
intelligences), a guide (for those with physical or Essentially, the approach to developing reme-
perceptual problems), or a tutor (for those with dial strategies is the same one used in creating
special learning difficulties). Figure 11.3 lists eight-way lesson plans and units for the regular
other important empowering strategies. It shows classroom (see Chapter 5). This confluence of
how a difficulty in one intelligence can often be regular and special education methodology rein-
successfully overcome by rerouting a task forces the fundamental growth-paradigm empha-
through a more highly developed intelligence. sis inherent in MI theory. In other words, the

106
FIGURE 11.3
STRATEGIES AND TOOLS FOR EMPOWERING INTELLIGENCES IN AREAS OF DIFFICULTY
Logical- Bodily-
Linguistic Mathematical Spatial Musical Kinesthetic Interpersonal Intrapersonal Naturalist
Area of Strategies Strategies Strategies Strategies Strategies Strategies Strategies Strategies
Difficulty and Tools and Tools and Tools and Tools and Tools and Tools and Tools and Tools
Linguistic tape recorder, computer ideographic song lyrics braille human readers open-ended reading based
Difficulty Kurzweil languages languages or person to journal on nature,
Reader take dictation plants, and
animals
Logical- calculators math arts, diagrams, explore music abacus and math tutor self-paced using scientific
Mathematical tutoring graphs and math other math or sci- instruments to
Difficulty software connections manipulatives ence programs observe nature
programs
Spatial talking books computer- magnifiers, walking stick relief maps, personal self-guided smell gardens/
Difficulty and tapes, assisted maps with tone Mowat sensor guide tours touching zoos
talking tours design (CAD) sensor
software

107
Bodily- “how-to” virtual choreography biofeedback mobility personal feedback canine
Kinesthetic books reality diagrams using tones devices/ companion from videotape companion
Difficulty software motorized
MI and Special Education

wheelchair
Musical rhythmic MIDI software machine that tapes, CDs, amplified music teacher self-paced recordings of
Difficulty poetry translates records vibrating music lessons the sounds of
music into a musical different kinds
sequence of instruments of ecosystems
colored lights
Interpersonal “talking cure” in cognitive movies on music groups Outward recovery/self- individual involvement in
Difficulty psychotherapy therapy interpersonal (e.g. choir) Bound help support psychotherapy Sierra Club
themes adventures groups activities
Intrapersonal self-help personality art therapy music therapy obstacle psycho- retreats, vision quest
Difficulty books self- courses therapist solitude in nature
assessment
software
Naturalist field guides, taxonomies Nature pro- recordings of extensive expert nature taking care of camping
Difficulty National and classifica- grams on PBS, bird songs and nature walks guide, a pet, planting and hiking
Geographic tion systems TLC, Discover other nature volunteer a garden, or experiences
TV network animal sounds for ecology other solo
organization nature project
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 11.4
EXAMPLES OF MI REMEDIAL STRATEGIES FOR SPECIFIC TOPICS

Topic

Letter Reversals: Understanding


Strategy “b” and “d” The 3 States of Matter Simple Fractions

Linguistic identify through context in give verbal descriptions, use storytelling, word
Remedial words or sentences assign reading matter problems
Strategy

Logical- play anagrams or other classify substances in the show math ratios on number
Mathematical word-pattern games classroom line
Remedial
Strategy

Spatial color code b’s and d’s; use draw pictures of different look at a diagram of “pies”;
Remedial stylistic features unique to states; look at pictures of draw pictures
Strategy each letter; create “pictures” molecules in different states
out of letters (e.g., “bed”
where the stems are the
posts)

Bodily- use kinesthetic mnemonic act out the 3 states in a put together manipulative
Kinesthetic (put fists together, thumbs dance; do hands-on lab ex- puzzles divided into
Remedial upraised, palms facing periments; build models of fractions
Strategy you—this makes a “bed” 3 states

Musical sing songs with lots of b’s play musical recording at 3 play a fraction of a song
Remedial and d’s in them to help different speeds (e.g., one note of a three-
Strategy differentiate note song)

Interpersonal give letter cards with b’s and create the 3 states as a divide the class into different
Remedial d’s randomly to students; class (each person as a fraction pies
Strategy have them find others with molecule)
their sound (auditorily) and
then check answers visually
with cards

Intrapersonal list favorite words that begin examine the 3 states in choose a favorite fraction
Remedial with b and d one’s body, home, and and collect specific in-
Strategy neighborhood stances of it

Naturalist list favorite animals and examine the 3 states as divide apples or other food
Remedial plants that begin with they exist in nature (e.g., items into segments
Strategy b and d clouds, rain, sand)

108
MI and Special Education

best learning activities for special-needs students that these examples accommodate the student’s
are those that are most successful with all stu- learning differences at both the instructional
dents. What may be different, however, is the level and the assessment level.
way in which lessons are specifically tailored to
the needs of individual students or small groups
of students. The Broad Implications of MI
Theory for Special Education
MI Theory in the The influence that MI theory can have on special
education goes far beyond the development of
Development of IEPs new remedial strategies and interventions. If MI
MI theory lends itself particularly well to the theory is implemented on a large scale in both
development of teaching strategies in individual- the regular and special education programs in a
ized educational programs (IEPs) developed as school district, it is likely to have some of the
part of a student’s special education placement. following effects:
In particular, MI theory can help teachers iden- Fewer Referrals to Special Education
tify a student’s strengths and preferred learning Classes. When the regular curriculum includes
style, and this information can serve as a basis the full spectrum of intelligences, referrals to
for deciding what kinds of interventions are special education classes will decline. Most
most appropriate for inclusion in the IEP. teachers now focus on the linguistic and mathe-
All too often a student having problems in a matical intelligences, neglecting the needs of stu-
specific area will be given an IEP that neglects his dents who learn best through the musical,
most developed intelligences while concentrating spatial, bodily-kinesthetic, interpersonal, intrap-
on his weaknesses. For instance, let’s say a stu- ersonal, or naturalist intelligences. It is these stu-
dent with well-developed bodily-kinesthetic and dents who most often fail in regular classrooms
spatial intelligences is having difficulty learning and are placed in special settings. Once regular
to read. In many schools today, he will be given classrooms themselves become more sensitive to
an IEP that fails to include physical and picture- the needs of different kinds of learners through
oriented activities as a means of achieving his MI learning programs, the need for special place-
educational objectives. Frequently, the interven- ment, especially for learning disabilities and be-
tions suggested for such a student will include havior problems, will diminish. This model thus
more linguistic tasks, such as reading programs supports the full inclusion movement in educa-
and auditory awareness activities—in other tion (see Stainback, Stainback, & Forest, 1989).
words, more concentrated and controlled doses A Changing Role for the Special
of the same sorts of tasks the student was failing Education Teacher. The special education
at in the regular classroom! teacher or learning specialist will begin to func-
MI theory suggests a fundamentally different tion less as a “pull-out” or special class teacher
approach: teaching through intelligences that and more as a special MI consultant to the regu-
have been previously neglected by educators lar classroom teacher. In this new role,
working with the child. Figure 11.5 (p. 110) MI consultants, perhaps operating like Gardner’s
shows IEPs that might be written for students student-curriculum brokers (see Chapter 9), can
who have had difficulty learning to read yet pos- assist regular classroom teachers in some of the
sess strengths in other intelligence areas. Note following tasks:

109
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

• Identifying students’ strongest intelligences begin to supplant standardized diagnostic meas-


• Focusing on the needs of specific students ures as a means of developing appropriate edu-
• Designing MI curriculums cational programs.
• Creating specific MI interventions Increased Self-Esteem. With more emphasis
• Working with groups using MI activities placed on the strengths and abilities of special-
needs children, students’ self-esteem and internal
All or most of a special-needs/MI teacher’s locus of control are likely to rise, thus helping to
time can be spent in the regular classroom focus- promote success among a broader community of
ing on the individual needs of students and the learners.
targeting of special MI activities to achieve edu- Increased Understanding and Apprecia-
cational outcomes. tion of Students. As students use MI theory to
A Greater Emphasis on Identifying make sense of their individual differences, their
Strengths. Teachers assessing special-needs stu- tolerance, understanding, and appreciation of
dents will likely put more emphasis on identify- those with special needs is likely to rise, making
ing the strengths of students. Qualitative and their full integration into the regular classroom
authentic measures (such as those described in more likely.
Chapters 3 and 10) are likely to have a larger Ultimately, the adoption of MI theory (or an
role in special education and may perhaps even MI-like philosophy) in education will move

FIGURE 11.5
SAMPLE MI PLANS FOR INDIVIDUALIZED EDUCATION PROGRAMS (IEPS)

Subject: Reading
Short-Term Instructional Goal: When presented with an unfamiliar piece of chil-
dren’s literature with a readability level of beginning 2nd grade, the student will be
able to effectively decode 80 percent of the words and answer four out of five compre-
hension questions based on its content.

Plan 1: For a Child with Strong Bodily- Plan 2: For a Child with Strong Musical and
Kinesthetic and Spatial Intelligences Interpersonal Intelligences
Some Possible Materials and Strategies: Some Possible Materials and Strategies:
• Student can act out (mime) new words and the • Student can make up songs using new words.
content of new stories. • Student can play board games or card games
• Student can make new words into pictures (e.g., that require learning new words.
hanging lights on the word “street”). • Student can use simple song books as reading
• Student can sculpt new words using clay. material (singing lyrics accompanied by music).
• Student can draw pictures expressing the con- • Student can read children’s literature to another
tent of books. child.
• Student can teach a younger child to read.

Assessment: Student is allowed to move his body Assessment: Student is allowed to sing while read-
while reading the book; student can answer content ing a book; student may demonstrate competency
questions by drawing answers rather than (or in ad- by reading a book to another child or answering
dition to) responding orally. content questions posed by a peer.

110
MI and Special Education

special education toward a growth paradigm and classrooms will then become the least restrictive
facilitate a greater level of cooperation between environment for all special-needs students ex-
special education and regular education. MI cept the most disruptive.

FOR FURTHER STUDY


1. Develop a curriculum unit for use in a difficulties because of limitations in one par-
regular or special-needs classroom that fo- ticular intelligence. Identify specific
cuses on famous individuals who overcame empowering tools (e.g., alternative symbol
disabilities. Include biographies, videos, systems, learning materials, software, human
slides, and other materials. Discuss with stu- resources) that can be used to help “reroute”
dents how a disability accounts for only one the problem into a highly developed intelli-
part of an individual’s life as a total person. gence. Choose one or two of the most ap-
Use MI theory as a model for regarding dis- propriate and available tools to apply to the
abilities as glitches in basically healthy human student’s particular need(s). Evaluate the
beings. results.
2. Identify a special-needs student who is 4. Write multiple-intelligence strategies
currently not succeeding in the school system. into a student’s IEP based on the student’s
Using some of the strategies suggested in strengths in one or more intelligences.
Chapter 3, identify the student’s strengths in 5. Meet with a regular classroom teacher
terms of the theory of multiple intelligences. (if you are a special education teacher) or a
Brainstorm as many strengths as possible, in- specialist (if you are a regular classroom
cluding strengths that combine several intelli- teacher) and discuss ways in which you can
gences. Then discuss with colleagues how this collaboratively use MI strategies to help
process of strengths assessment can affect special-needs kids succeed in the mainstream.
their overall view of the student and generate 6. Work individually with a special-needs
new solutions for helping her. child (or a small group of children) and help
3. Identify a special-needs student in your him (or them) become aware of their special
program who is having school-related strengths in terms of MI theory.

111
MI and Cognitive Skills
12
Though man a thinking being is defined,
Few use the grand prerogative of mind.
How few think justly of the thinking few!
How many never think, who think they do!
—Jane Taylor, children’s author, 1783–1824

With the advent of cognitive psychology as students retain what they learn appears to be one
the predominant paradigm in education, educa- of education’s most pressing and unresolved is-
tors have become increasingly interested in help- sues. MI theory provides a helpful perspective on
ing students develop thinking strategies. How this age-old educational problem. It suggests that
students think has become almost more impor- the notion of a “pure” memory is flawed. Mem-
tant than what they think about. MI theory pro- ory, according to Howard Gardner, is
vides an ideal context for making sense out of intelligence-specific. There is no such thing as a
students’ cognitive skills. The eight intelligences “good memory” or a “bad memory” unless and
in the model are themselves cognitive capacities. until an intelligence is specified. Thus, one may
Hence, to develop any or all of them in the ways have a good memory for faces (spatial/interper-
described in previous chapters is to facilitate the sonal intelligence) but a poor memory for names
cultivation of students’ ability to think. It may be and dates (linguistic/logical-mathematical intelli-
helpful, however, to look more specifically at gence). One may have a superior ability to recall
how MI theory applies to the areas most often a tune (musical intelligence) but not be able to
emphasized by educators espousing a cognitive remember the dance step that accompanies it
approach to learning: memory, problem solving (bodily-kinesthetic intelligence).
and other forms of higher-order thinking, and This new perspective on memory suggests
Bloom’s levels of cognitive complexity. that students with “poor memories” may have
poor memories in only one or two of the intelli-
gences. The problem, however, may be that their
Memory poor memories are in one or both of the intelli-
Classroom teachers have always seemed troubled gence areas most frequently emphasized in
by the problem of students’ memories. “They school: linguistic and logical-mathematical intel-
knew it yesterday, but today it’s gone” is a famil- ligence. The solution, then, lies in helping these
iar refrain. “It’s as if I never even taught it. What’s students gain access to their “good” memories in
the point?” many teachers lament. Helping other intelligences (e.g., musical, spatial, and

112
MI and Cognitive Skills

bodily-kinesthetic). Memory training, or work number to a letter depending on its placement in


involving memorization of material in any sub- the alphabet: a = 1, b = 2, etc.).
ject, should therefore be taught in such a way • Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence. Spelling words
that all eight “memories” are activated. can be translated into whole-body movements.
Spelling is an academic area that has typically Other bodily-kinesthetic approaches include
relied heavily on memory skills. Unfortunately, tracing spelling words in sand, molding spelling
most instructional approaches to studying spell- words in clay, and using body movements to
ing words have involved the use of linguistic show patterns in words (e.g., stand up on the
strategies only: Write the word five times, use the vowels, sit down on the consonants).
word in a sentence, spell the word out loud, and • Interpersonal Intelligence. Words can be
so forth. MI theory suggests that problem spell- spelled by a group of people. For example, each
ers may need to go beyond these auditory, oral, student has a letter and, when a word is called,
and written strategies (all linguistic) to find suc- students who have the letters in the word form
cess. Here are some examples of how the ortho- the word with the other students.
graphic structure of linguistic symbols (i.e., the • Intrapersonal Intelligence. Students spell
English alphabet) can be linked to other intelli- words developmentally (i.e., the way they think
gences to enhance the retention of spelling they’re spelled), or students learn to spell words
words: that have an emotional charge (organic spelling).
• Naturalist Intelligence. Students can spell
• Musical Intelligence. Spelling words can be words using natural materials (e.g., twigs, leaves,
sung. For example, any seven-letter word (or or stems), or code spelling words using animal
multiple of seven) can be sung to the tune of names (e.g., a = ant; b = bat; c = cat; d = dog).
“Twinkle, Twinkle Little Star,” and any six-letter
word can be sung to the tune of “Happy Birthday The task for the teacher, then, is to help students
to You.” associate the material to be learned with compo-
• Spatial Intelligence. Spelling words can be nents of the different intelligences: words, num-
visualized. Students can be introduced to an “in- bers, pictures, physical movements, musical
ner blackboard” or other mental screen in their phrases, social interactions, personal feelings and
mind’s eye. During study, students place words experiences, and natural phenomena. After stu-
on the mental screen; during test time, students dents have been exposed to memory strategies
simply refer to their “inner blackboard” for help. from all eight intelligences, they will be able to
Other spatial approaches include color cod- pick out those strategies that work best for them,
ing spelling patterns; drawing spelling words as and be able to use them independently during
pictures (e.g., the word “sun” can be drawn with personal study periods.
rays of light emanating from the word); and re-
ducing spelling words to “configurations” or
graphic outlines showing spatial placement of Problem Solving
stems. Although research studies suggest that over the
• Logical-Mathematical Intelligence. Spelling past few years students in the United States have
words can be “digitalized,” that is, reduced to a improved their performance on rote learning
series of 0s and 1s (consonants = 1; vowels = 0); tasks such as spelling and arithmetic, they place
spelling words can also be coded using other U.S. students far down the achievement ladder
sorts of number systems (e.g., assigning a in comparisons with other countries on

113
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

measures of higher-order cognitive processes Others have used problem-solving strategies that
(Fiske, 1987, 1988). In particular, U.S. students’ combine visual-spatial images with certain ki-
problem-solving abilities have been regarded as netic or bodily-kinesthetic features of the mind.
in need of significant improvement. Conse- For example, Albert Einstein frequently per-
quently, more and more educators are looking formed “thought-experiments” that helped him
for ways to help students think more effectively develop his relativity theory, including a fantasy
when confronted with academic problems. Un- that involved riding on the end of a beam of
fortunately, the bias in the recent critical- light. When asked by a French mathematician to
thinking movement has been in the direction of describe his thinking processes, Einstein said
logical-mathematical reasoning abilities and in they included elements that were of a visual and
the use of self-talk or other linguistic strategies. muscular type (see Ghiselin, 1955, p. 43). Simi-
MI theory suggests that thinking can and fre- larly, Henri Poincaré shares the story of how he
quently does go far beyond these two areas. To struggled for days with a vexing mathematical
illustrate what these other forms of problem- problem:
solving behavior “look” like, it may be helpful to For fifteen days I strove to prove that there
review the thinking processes of eminent indi- could not be any functions like those I have
viduals whose discoveries have helped shape the since called Fuchsian functions. I was then
world we live in (see Gardner, 1994; John- very ignorant; every day I seated myself at
Steiner, 1987). By studying the “end-states” of my work table, stayed an hour or two, tried
specific problem-solving processes in these great a great number of combinations and reached
people, educators can learn much that can help no results. One evening, contrary to my cus-
foster the same sort of processes in their tom, I drank black coffee and could not
students. sleep. Ideas rose in crowds; I felt them collide
Many thinkers have used imagery and picture until pairs interlocked [italics mine], so to
language (spatial intelligence) to help them in speak, making a stable combination. By the
their work. The physicist John Howarth de- next morning, I had established the exis-
scribed his problem-solving processes as follows: tence of a class of Fuchsian functions, those
which come from the hypergeometric series;
I make abstract pictures. I just realized that I had only to write out the results which
the process of abstraction in the pictures in took but a few hours (cited in Ghiselin,
my head is similar to the abstraction you en- 1955, p. 36).
gage in dealing with physical problems ana-
lytically. You reduce the number of variables, Musicians speak about a very different kind of
simplify and consider what you hope is the problem-solving capacity, one that involves ac-
essential part of the situation you are dealing cess to musical imagery. Mozart explained his
with; then you apply your analytical tech- own composing process this way: “Nor do I hear
niques. In making a visual picture it is possi- in my imagination the parts [of the composition]
ble to choose one which contains successively, but I hear them, as it were, all at
representations of only the essential ele- once. What a delight this is I cannot tell. All this
ments—a simplified picture, abstracted from inventing, this producing, takes place in a pleas-
a number of other pictures and containing ing lively dream” (cited in Ghiselin, 1955, p. 45).
their common elements (cited in John- Einstein acknowledged the operation of musical
Steiner, 1987, pp. 84–85). thought in a logical-mathematical/spatial domain

114
MI and Cognitive Skills

when, referring to Nils Bohr’s model of the atom solving strategies that could be used by students
with its orbiting electrons absorbing and releas- in academic settings:
ing energy, he wrote, “This is the highest form of
• Linguistic Intelligence. Self-talk or thinking
musicality in the sphere of thought” (cited in
out loud (see Perkins, 1981).
Clark, 1972, p. 292).
• Logical-Mathematical Intelligence. Logical
There are even processes unique to the per-
heuristics (see Polya, 1957).
sonal intelligences. For example, a commentator
• Spatial Intelligence. Visualization, idea
reflecting on the interpersonal intelligence of
sketching, mind-mapping (see Margulies, 1991;
Lyndon B. Johnson said, “Lots of guys can be
McKim, 1980).
smiling and deferential. He had something else.
• Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence. Kinesthetic
No matter what someone thought, Lyndon
imagery (see Gordon & Poze, 1966); also, ac-
would agree with him—would be there ahead of
cessing “gut feelings” or using one’s hands, fin-
him, in fact. He could follow someone’s mind
gers, or whole body to solve problems.
around—and figure out where it was going and
• Musical Intelligence. Sensing the “rhythm” or
beat it there” (Caro, 1990). In a more intraper-
“melody” of a problem (e.g., harmony vs. disso-
sonal fashion, Marcel Proust used simple sensa-
nance); using music to unlock problem-solving
tions like the taste of a pastry to evoke inner
capacities (see Ostrander & Schroeder, 1979).
feelings that swept him back into the days of his
• Interpersonal Intelligence. Bouncing ideas off
childhood—a context that provided the basis for
other people (see Johnson, Johnson, & Holubec,
his masterwork, Remembrances of Things Past (see
1994).
Proust, 1928, pp. 54–58). Finally, in the natural-
• Intrapersonal Intelligence. Identifying with
ist domain, a study of Charles Darwin’s note-
the problem; accessing dream imagery, personal
books reveals that he used the image of a tree to
feelings that relate to the problem; deep intro-
help him generate the theory of evolution: “Or-
spection (see Harman & Rheingold, 1984).
ganized beings represent a tree, irregularly
• Naturalist Intelligence. Using analogies from
branched, . . . as many terminal buds dying as
nature to envision problems and solutions (see
new ones generated” (Gruber, 1977, p. 126).
Gordon & Poze, 1966).
How these “end-state” cognitive processes
translate into classroom practice may seem at Once students have been introduced to strategies
first elusive. It is possible, however, to distill cer- like these, they can choose from a cognitive
tain basic elements from the problem-solving menu the approaches that are likely to be suc-
strategies of the geniuses of culture and create cessful for them in any given learning situation.
strategies that can be learned even by students in This kind of cognitive training can prove far
the primary grades. For example, students can richer than the traditional “thinking skills” pro-
learn to “visualize” their ideas in much the same gram, which all too often consists of worksheets
way Einstein performed his thought- containing games and puzzles or overhead sheets
experiments. They can learn to sketch meta- detailing the five-step sequence involved in solv-
phorical images that relate to problems they are ing a math word problem. In the future, when
working on much as Darwin worked with natu- students are urged by a teacher to “think harder,”
ral images in his own notebooks. The following students will have the luxury of asking, “In
list indicates the wide range of MI problem- which intelligence?”

115
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

Promoting Christopherian taking them “over the edge” into areas where
they must confront the contradictions and dis-
Encounters junctions in their own thinking. It’s possible to
In his book The Unschooled Mind, Howard Gard- apply this general approach to multiple intelli-
ner (1991) addresses the tendency of contempo- gences theory by suggesting examples in which
rary schooling to teach students surface-level students’ minds might be stretched in each of the
knowledge without ever affecting their deeper intelligences:
understanding of the world. As a result, students • Linguistic Intelligence. Moving students be-
are graduating from high school, college, and yond the literal interpretation of a piece of litera-
even graduate school still holding on to many of ture (e.g., the novel Moby Dick is more than a sea
the same naive beliefs they held as preschoolers. yarn about a whale).
In one example, 70 percent of college students • Logical-Mathematical Intelligence. Devising
who had completed a physics course in mechan- science experiments that force students to con-
ics said that a coin tossed up in the air has two front contradictions in their thinking about natu-
forces acting on it, the downward force of gravity ral phenomena (e.g., asking students to predict
and the upward force coming from the hand (the how a ball rolled straight from the center of a ro-
truth is, only gravity exerts a force) (Gardner, tating merry-go-round will move as it reaches
1991, p. 154). Supposedly well-educated stu- the edge and then discussing the outcome).
dents, who can spout algorithms, rules, laws, • Spatial Intelligence. Helping students con-
and principles in a variety of domains, still har- front tacit beliefs about art that might, for exam-
bor, according to Gardner, a mine field of mis- ple, include the prejudice that paintings should
conceptions, rigidly applied procedures, use pleasant colors and depict beautiful scenery
stereotypes, and simplifications. What is re- and attractive people (e.g., showing students
quired is an approach to education that chal- Picasso’s painting Guernica, which does not con-
lenges naive beliefs, provokes questions, invites tain those characteristics).
multiple perspectives, and ultimately stretches a • Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence. Moving stu-
student’s mind to the point where it can apply dents beyond stereotypical ways of using their
existing knowledge to new situations and novel bodies to express certain feelings or ideas in a
contexts. dance or play (e.g., helping students explore the
Gardner suggests that a student’s mind can be wide range of body postures and facial expres-
expanded through the use of “Christopherian en- sions for expressing Willy Loman’s sense of de-
counters.” Although Gardner uses the term spe- feat in Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman).
cifically in reference to exploding • Musical Intelligence. Assisting students in
misconceptions in the field of science, this undoing stereotypes that might suggest that
phrases can serve as a beautiful metaphor for the good music should be harmonious and have a
expansion in general of a child’s multiple intelli- regular beat (e.g., playing students Stravinsky’s
gences to higher levels of competence and un- Rite of Spring—a piece that caused a riot when
derstanding. Just as Christopher Columbus first played because it clashed with the listeners’
challenged the notion that the earth is flat by beliefs about what was good music).
sailing “beyond the edge” and thereby showing • Interpersonal Intelligence. Helping students
its curved shape, so, too, Gardner suggests that go beyond the imputation of simplistic motiva-
educators challenge students’ limited beliefs by tions in studying fictional or real characters in

116
MI and Cognitive Skills

literature, history, or other fields (e.g., helping • Knowledge. Rote memory skills (knowing
students understand that Holden Caulfield’s im- facts, terms, procedures, classification systems).
petus in Catcher in the Rye involved more than a • Comprehension. The ability to translate,
desire for a “night on the town,” or that Adolf paraphrase, interpret, or extrapolate material.
Hitler’s rise to power was motivated by more • Application. The capacity to transfer knowl-
than a “thirst for power”). edge from one setting to another.
• Intrapersonal Intelligence. Deepening stu- • Analysis. Discovering and differentiating the
dents’ understanding of themselves by relating component parts of a larger whole.
different parts of the curriculum to their own • Synthesis. Weaving together component
personal life experiences and backgrounds (e.g., parts into a coherent whole.
asking students to think of the “Huck Finn” or • Evaluation. Judging the value or utility of
“Laura Ingalls Wilder” part of themselves). information using a set of standards.
• Naturalist Intelligence. Challenging students
Bloom’s taxonomy provides a kind of quality-
to critically examine the scientific evidence sup-
control mechanism through which one can judge
porting the theory of evolution compared to the
how deeply students’ minds have been stirred by
theological idea that the earth was created 6,000
a multiple-intelligence curriculum. It would be
years ago.
easy to construct MI instructional methods that
Multiple-intelligence theory must be seen as appeared compelling—owing to the wide range
more than simply a process by which students of intelligences addressed—but that kept learn-
celebrate and begin to activate their many ways ing at the knowledge or rote level of cognitive
of knowing. Educators must assist students in complexity. MI activities for teaching spelling,
developing higher levels of understanding the times tables, or history facts are prime exam-
through their multiple intelligences. By making ples of MI theory in the service of lower-order
certain that “Christopherian encounters” are a cognitive skills. MI curriculums, however, can be
regular part of the school day—in each intelli- designed to incorporate all of Bloom’s levels of
gence—educators can help ensure that the un- cognitive complexity. The curriculum outline
schooled mind will truly develop into a powerful presented in Figure 12.1 (pp. 118–119) shows
and creative thinking force. how a teacher can articulate competencies that
address all eight intelligences, as well as Bloom’s
six levels of cognitive complexity.
You needn’t feel a compulsion to include all
MI Theory and Bloom’s Levels these tasks in one unit. In fact, you may at first
of Cognitive Complexity want to develop a thematic curriculum without
Almost forty years ago, University of Chicago reference to MI theory and Bloom’s taxonomy.
professor Benjamin S. Bloom (1956) unveiled his Then, use the instructional model displayed in
famous “taxonomy of educational objectives.” Figure 12.1 as a road map to help you stay on
This survey included a cognitive domain, and its course in your efforts to address a number of in-
six levels of complexity have been used over the telligences and cognitive levels. It may become
past four decades as a gauge by which educators apparent, for example, after laying the MI/Bloom
can ensure that instruction stimulates and devel- template over the curriculum, that some easily
ops students’ higher-order thinking capacities. incorporated musical experiences are missing
The six levels are as follows: from the unit, or that there are no opportunities

117
FIGURE 12.1
MI THEORY AND BLOOM’S TAXONOMY
Ecology Unit: Local environment—trees in your neighborhood

Bloom’s Six Levels of Educational Objectives

Intelligence Knowledge Comprehension Application Analysis Synthesis Evaluation

Linguistic memorize names explain how trees given description describe how each write a paper de- rate different
Intelligence of trees receive nutrients of tree diseases, part of a tree func- scribing the life cy- methods of con-
suggest cause of tions in relation to cle of a tree from trolling tree growth
each disease the whole pre-seed to post-
seed

Logical- remember number convert English to given height of analyze materials given weather, rate different kinds
Mathematical of points on spe- metric in calculat- smaller tree, esti- found in sap soil, and other in- of tree nutrients
Intelligence cific trees’ leaves ing height of tree mate height of residue formation, chart based on data
larger tree projected growth
of a tree

118
Spatial remember basic look at diagrams use geometric draw cellular create a landscap- evaluate practical-
Intelligence configurations of of trees and tell principles to deter- structure of tree ing plan using ity of different
specific trees what stage of mine height of tree root trees as central landscaping plans
growth they are in feature

Bodily- identify tree by the given array of tree given type of local create different gather all materi- evaluate the qual-
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

Kinesthetic feel of the bark fruits, identify tree, find an ideal parts of tree from als needed for ity of different
Intelligence seeds location for plant- clay planting a tree kinds of fruit
ing it

continued
FIGURE 12.1— continued
MI THEORY AND BLOOM’S TAXONOMY
Ecology Unit: Local environment—trees in your neighborhood

Bloom’s Six Levels of Educational Objectives

Intelligence Knowledge Comprehension Application Analysis Synthesis Evaluation

Musical remember songs explain how old change the lyrics classify songs by create your own rate the songs
Intelligence that deal with tree songs came of an old tree song issue and histori- tree song based from best to worst
trees into being to reflect current cal period on information in and give reasons
issues this unit for your choices

Interpersonal record responses determine the use survey results classify kids into arrange field trip to rank three meth-
Intelligence to the question most popular tree to pick location for groups according orchard by con- ods to ask others
“What is your fa- in class by inter- field trip to orchard to favorite tree tacting necessary about tree
vorite tree?” viewing others people preference

Intrapersonal remember a time share the primary develop “tree- divide up your ex- plan a tree- explain what you

119
Intelligence you climbed a tree feeling you had climbing rules” perience into “be- climbing expedi- liked “best” and
while up in the based on your ginning,” “middle,” tion based on your “least” about your
tree experience and “end” past experience experience
MI and Cognitive Skills

Naturalist learn to discrimi- describe how create a system analyze the func- develop an ap- evaluate which
Intelligence nate different tree other living beings for classifying dif- tion of a given tree proach for protect- trees in your
leaves by sight (e.g., humans, ani- ferent tree leaves in terms of the ing specific types neighborhood are
mals) benefit from larger ecosystem of trees in your most eco-valuable
trees in which it finds neighborhood to the surrounding
itself from damage or environment
disease
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

for students to evaluate experiences—something heavily linguistic, lower-order thinking activities


that can be easily remedied. MI theory represents (e.g., worksheets ) into a broad range of complex
a model that can enable you to move beyond cognitive tasks that prepare students for life.

FOR FURTHER STUDY


1. Write ten to fifteen random words on higher-order thinking processes. Allow stu-
the board (words that are at students’ level of dents ten to fifteen minutes to use whatever
decoding and comprehension). Give the class strategies they wish. Let them know they can
one minute to “memorize” them. Then cover work with other people, walk around, ask for
the words and ask students to write all the resources, and so on. Then have students
words from memory (in any order). Provide share their particular strategies or problem-
immediate feedback. Discuss the strategies solving processes, writing them on the board
that students used to remember the words. as they are given. After everyone has had a
Then teach them memory strategies using chance to share, go over the list of strategies
several intelligences: and note which intelligences have been
tapped. Ask students: Are some strategies
• Linguistic. String the words together in
more successful than others? Are certain
some kind of intelligible story.
strategies or problem-solving processes more
• Spatial. Visualize the story taking place.
fun than others?
• Musical. Sing the story to a set tune or a
Using other types of problems, repeat this
tune composed on the spot.
activity. Keep a list of problem-solving strate-
• Bodily-Kinesthetic/Interpersonal. Act out
gies organized by primary intelligence. Dis-
the story, emphasizing the body movements
play the list so students can refer to it
involved for each of the words.
throughout the year as a resource in guiding
• Intrapersonal. Associate personal experi-
their own study habits.
ences (and accompanying feelings) with each
3. Develop a thematic unit—or take a
word.
unit that you’ve already developed—and note
Practice these strategies using another list of which intelligences and levels of cognitive
words, and then have students write the list complexity are developed through the activi-
from memory. Discuss what was different this ties in the unit. List additional activities that
time (have students talk about which strate- might enhance the intellectual breadth and
gies seemed most successful to them). After cognitive depth of the unit.
using this procedure with two or three more 4. Create “Christopherian encounters” for
lists, have students use these memory strate- materials in your curriculum that will stretch
gies for curriculum-related material (e.g., his- students’ minds, challenge existing beliefs,
tory facts, spelling words, vocabulary). and bring students’ multiple intelligences to
2. Have students solve a brainteaser or higher levels of functioning.
other logical-mathematical problem involving

120
Other Applications of MI Theory
13
At present, the notion of schools devoted to multiple intelligences is still in its infancy, and
there are as many plausible recipes as there are educational chefs. I hope that in the next
twenty years, a number of efforts will be made to craft an education that takes multiple
intelligences seriously; should this be done, we will be in a position to know which of
these “thought” and “action experiments” make sense and which prove to be impractical
or ill-advised.
—Howard Gardner (1993b, p. 250)

In addition to the areas covered in previous them. And these software programs can be de-
chapters, there are many other potential applica- signed to interface with any or all of the eight in-
tions of MI theory to education. Three that de- telligences. Word processing software, for
serve mention before ending this book include example, calls forth from its users a certain level
computer technology, cultural diversity, and ca- of linguistic intelligence. Draw-and-paint soft-
reer counseling. In each case, MI theory provides ware, on the other hand, more often requires
a context through which existing understandings spatial intelligence. The list of program types in
and resources can be extended to include a Figure 13.1 on page 122 suggests the broad
broader perspective. This wider view, in turn, range of software available to activate the multi-
can allow educators to develop educational ma- ple intelligences; examples of specific products
terials and strategies that meet the needs of a are provided in parentheses.
more diverse student population. You can use MI theory as a basis for selecting
software for use in the classroom or in specially
designated computer labs in the school. Perhaps
Computer Technology the most exciting technology application involv-
Our first inclination may be to associate comput- ing multiple intelligences is emerging in the area
ers with logical-mathematical intelligence. This of multimedia. Using multimedia software, a
connection arises in large part because of the CD-ROM project incorporating word text (lin-
stereotypical images of “computer nerds” work- guistic), illustrations (spatial), sound score (mu-
ing on spreadsheets or toiling over highly ab- sical or linguistic), and video data (bodily-
stract computer programming languages. kinesthetic and other intelligences) can be devel-
Computers themselves, however, are oped. For example, a student could create a
intelligence-neutral mechanisms. What activates learning project on horticulture. The computer
computers are the software programs used to run program might begin with a written text

121
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

FIGURE 13.1
SOFTWARE THAT ACTIVATES THE MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES

Linguistic Intelligence • virtual-reality system software (Dactyl


• word processing programs (Corel WordPerfect) Nightmare)
• typing tutors (Mavis Beacon Teaches Typing!) • eye-hand coordination games (Shufflepuck Cafe)
• desktop publishing programs (Publish It!) • tools that plug into computers (Science Toolkit)
• electronic references (Encyclopedia Britannica • human anatomy and health reference guides
CD) (BodyWorks)
• interactive storybooks (Just Grandma and Me) • physical fitness software (Active Trainer)
• word games (Missing Links) • sports software (Golf Pro)
• foreign language instruction and translation soft-
ware (Easy Translator) Musical Intelligence
• Web site creation software (Front Page) • music literature tutors (Exploratorium)
• dictation software (Kurzweil Voice Pad) • singing software [transforms voice input into
synthesizer sounds] (Vocalizer)
Logical-Mathematical Intelligence • composition software (Music Studio)
• math skills tutorials (Math Blaster) • tone recognition and melody memory enhancers
• computer programming tutors (LOGO) (Arnold)
• logic games (King’s Rule) • musical instrument digital interfaces—i.e., MIDI
• science programs (Science Tool Kits) (Music Quest MIDI Starter System)
• critical thinking programs (HOTS—Higher • music instrument instruction software (Interactive
Order Thinking Skills) Guitar)
• database management (Lotus Organizer) • musical notation programs (Desktop Sheet
• financial management software (Quicken Music)
Deluxe)
• science reference guides (Encyclopedia of Interpersonal Intelligence
Science) • electronic bulletin boards (Kidsnet)
• spreadsheets (Lotus Spreadsheet) • simulation games (Sim City)
• mailing list programs (My Mail List and Address
Spatial Intelligence Book)
• animation programs (Art and Film Director) • genealogy programs (Generations)
• draw-and-paint (Dazzle Draw) • electronic phone books (Streets USA)
• electronic chess games (Chessmaster) • electronic board games (Chess)
• spatial problem-solving games (Tetris)
• electronic puzzle kits (Living Jigsaws) Intrapersonal Intelligence
• clip-art programs (The New Print Shop) • personal choice software (Oregon Trail)
• geometry programs (Sensei’s Geometry) • career counseling software (The Perfect Career)
• graphic presentations of knowledge (World • self-understanding software (Emotional IQ Test)
GeoGraph) • fantasy role play software (Myst)
• art history guides (History Through Art) • any self-paced program (e.g., many of the
• home and landscape design software preceding programs)
(Complete LandDesigner)
• maps and atlases (Eyewitness World Atlas) Naturalist Intelligence
• computer-aided design programs (Quick CAD) • naturalist reference guides (National
• photo-processing software (Adobe Photo Geographic)
Deluxe) • nature simulation programs (Amazon Trail)
• video-processing software (Video Wave) • animal games software (Amazing Animals
Activity Center)
Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence • ecology awareness programs (Magic School Bus
• hands-on construction kits that interface with Explores the World of Animals)
computers (LEGO to LOGO) • gardening programs (Complete LandDesigner)
• motion-simulation games (Flight Simulator)

122
Other Applications of MI Theory

describing local flowers (linguistic and naturalist) created a student population more racially, ethni-
accompanied by statistical charts listing the cally, and culturally diverse than ever before.
planting requirements of specific flowers Such diversity presents a great challenge for edu-
(logical-mathematical). By clicking the electronic cators in designing curriculums that are not only
mouse on specific nouns in the text—the word content-sensitive to cultural differences (e.g., ex-
“rose,” perhaps—an illustration of a rose might posing students to the beliefs, background, and
appear (spatial) along with a song mentioning foundations of individual cultures), but also pro-
the rose—for instance, “The Rose” sung by Bette cess-sensitive (e.g., helping students understand
Midler (musical). Clicking on specific verbs—for the many “ways of knowing” that different cul-
example, “to plant”—might activate a video pres- tures possess). MI theory provides a model that
entation of the student planting a flower is culturally sensitive to such differences. As
(bodily-kinesthetic). such, it provides educators with a valuable tool
The process of putting together such a multi- to help celebrate the ways in which different cul-
media project requires a great deal of intraper- tures think.
sonal intelligence. And if such a project is According to MI theory, an intelligence must
cooperative in nature (a class gardening project, be valued by a culture in order to be considered
perhaps), then interpersonal intelligence is called a true intelligence. This criterion automatically
into play as well. The completed CD-ROM discs disqualifies many of the tasks that have tradition-
themselves become valuable documents of a stu- ally been associated with intelligence testing in
dent’s learning progress. They can serve as “elec- the schools. For example, the ability to repeat
tronic portfolios” that can easily be passed from random digits backward and forward is a task
one teacher to the next as part of an authentic as- found on some intelligence tests, even though
sessment of the student’s accomplishments dur- this feat is not particularly valued by any culture.
ing the year (see Campbell, 1992). Nowhere in the world do a culture’s elders pass
Similarly, the use of the Internet provides op- on random digits to the next generation. What
portunities for the exploration and expansion of cultures do pass on to their younger members
a student’s multiple intelligences. One might, for are stories, myths, great art and music, scientific
example, “bookmark” Web pages related to each discoveries, social mores, political institutions,
of the intelligences, including math and science and number systems—among many other “end-
sites (logical-mathematical intelligence), sites for states” of accomplishment.
downloading music (musical intelligence) or for All cultures in the world possess and make
downloading images (spatial intelligence), sites use of the eight intelligences in MI theory; how-
that specialize in nature (naturalist intelligence), ever, the ways in which they do so, and the man-
sites that provide “chat rooms” and other ner in which individual intelligences are valued,
chances for interaction (interpersonal intelli- vary considerably. A person growing up among
gence), and sites that offer opportunities for the Puluwat culture in the South Sea Islands, for
self-development (intrapersonal intelligence). example, would discover that the spatial and
naturalist intelligences are highly prized because
of their use in navigating the seas (see Gladwin,
1970). Puluwat peoples live on several hundred
Cultural Diversity islands, and the ability to move easily from one
Over the past quarter-century, U.S. education has island to another has a high cultural value. They
seen tremendous demographic changes that have train their children from a very early age to

123
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

recognize the constellations, the various “bumps” theory into multicultural units. And you can also
(islands) on the horizon, and the different tex- introduce students to MI theory through great
tures on the surface of the water that point to figures in each culture who have achieved high
significant geographical information. The chief “end-state” performances in each of the eight in-
navigators in that society have more prestige telligences (see Figure 13.2 for some examples).
than even the political leaders.
In some cultures, musical intelligence is a ca-
pacity that is considered universal among all Career Counseling
members, rather than the province of an elite
Because it emphasizes the broad range of ways in
group of performers. Children growing up
which adults pursue their work in life, MI theory
among the Anang in Nigeria are expected to
provides an appropriate vehicle for helping
learn hundreds of dances and songs by the time
youngsters begin to develop vocational aspira-
they are five years old. In Hungary, because of
tions. If students are exposed from an early age
the pioneering influence of the composer Zoltán
to a variety of adults demonstrating real-life skills
Kodály on education, students are exposed to
in all eight intelligences, they will have a firm ba-
music every day and are expected to learn to
sis on which to launch a career once they leave
read musical notation. There are also cultures
school. In the early grades, students would bene-
that place a greater emphasis on connectedness
fit by having adults come into class to talk about
between peoples (interpersonal intelligence) than
their life’s work, and by going to visit adults at
on the individual going his own way (intraper-
their places of work. It is important that educa-
sonal intelligence) (see Gardner, 1983).
tors not attempt to match children’s proclivities
It’s important to repeat, however, that every
to specific careers too early in their development.
culture has and uses all eight intelligences. Edu-
By seeing the spectrum of occupations related to
cators would be making a great mistake if they
each of the eight intelligences through these
began to refer to specific racial, ethnic, or cultural
kinds of visits and field trips, children can begin
groups only in terms of one intelligence. The history
making their own decisions about what feels
of intelligence testing is filled with such bigotry
right and what doesn’t fit vocationally. Children
and narrow-mindedness (see, for example,
also benefit from periodic discussions about
Gould, 1981). Indiscriminate use of MI theory in
“what they’d like to be when they grow up.” Plan
discussions of cultural differences might well re-
on using the MI vocabulary in these discussions
vive old racist stereotypes (e.g., “blacks are musi- to help frame some of their aspirations.
cal” and “Asians are logical”). For a list of some At the middle and secondary school levels,
of the ways in which cultural groups value each students can participate in an ongoing process of
of the eight intelligences, see Figure 1.1, under self-assessment to determine what they are tem-
the heading “Ways That Cultures Value” (p. 5). peramentally and cognitively suited for in the job
Such a broad perspective on culture can pro- marketplace (the MI self-assessment tools may
vide a context for exploring in a school setting be useful in the process). Here is a list of occupa-
the tremendous diversity in the ways different tions categorized by primary intelligence:
cultures express themselves through each of the
eight intelligences. You might want to periodi- • Linguistic Intelligence. Librarian, archivist,
cally hold multicultural/multiple-intelligence curator, speech pathologist, writer, radio or TV
fairs in your school to celebrate such differences. announcer, journalist, legal assistant, lawyer, sec-
You could develop curriculums that integrate MI retary, typist, proofreader, English teacher

124
Other Applications of MI Theory

FIGURE 13.2
PROMINENT INDIVIDUALS FROM MINORITY CULTURES
Asian and
African Polynesian Hispanic Native
Intelligence American American American American

Linguistic Toni Morrison Amy Tan Isabel Allende Vine de Loria


Intelligence

Logical- Benjamin Banneker Yuan Lee Luis Alvarez Robert Whitman


Mathematical
Intelligence

Spatial Elizabeth Catlett I. M. Pei Frida Kahlo Oscar Howe


Intelligence Mora

Bodily- Jackie Joyner- Kristi Yamaguchi Juan Marichal Jim Thorpe


Kinesthetic Kersee
Intelligence

Musical Mahalia Jackson Midori Linda Ronstadt Buffy Saint Marie


Intelligence

Interpersonal Martin Luther King, Daniel K. Inouye Xavier L. Suarez Russell Means
Intelligence Jr.

Intrapersonal Malcolm X S. I. Hayakawa Cesar Chavez Black Elk


Intelligence

Naturalist George Washington Nainoa Thompson Severo Ochoa Wilfred Foster


Intelligence Carver Denetclaw, Jr.

• Logical-Mathematical Intelligence. Auditor, instrument salesperson, songwriter, studio engi-


accountant, purchasing agent, underwriter, neer, choral director, conductor, singer, music
mathematician, scientist, statistician, actuary, teacher, musical copyist
computer analyst, economist, technician, book- • Interpersonal Intelligence. Administrator,
keeper, science teacher manager, school principal, personnel worker, ar-
• Spatial Intelligence. Engineer, surveyor, ar- bitrator, sociologist, anthropologist, counselor,
chitect, urban planner, graphic artist, interior psychologist, nurse, public relations person,
decorator, photographer, art teacher, inventor, salesperson, travel agent, social director
cartographer, pilot, fine artist, sculptor • Intrapersonal Intelligence. Psychologist, cler-
• Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence. Physical thera- gyman, psychology teacher, therapist, counselor,
pist, recreational worker, dancer, actor, me- theologian, program planner, entrepreneur
chanic, carpenter, craftsperson, physical • Naturalist Intelligence. Forest ranger, zoolo-
education teacher, factory worker, choreogra- gist, naturalist, marine biologist, veterinarian,
pher, professional athlete, jeweler beekeeper, farmer, nature guide, ecologist, horti-
• Musical Intelligence. Disc jockey, musician, culturist, vintner, entomologist, tree surgeon.
instrument maker, piano tuner, music therapist,

125
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

Of course, virtually every job consists of a variety and grants or to communicate effectively with
of responsibilities touching on several intelli- others. They must also have good intrapersonal
gences. For example, school administrators must intelligence if they are to have enough confi-
possess interpersonal intelligence to facilitate dence in themselves to stick by their decisions.
their work with teachers, parents, students, and When discussing careers with secondary stu-
the community. But they must also have logical- dents, it may be helpful to discuss the multiplic-
mathematical capabilities to plan budgets and ity of intelligences required for each job.
schedules, and linguistic skills to write proposals

FOR FURTHER STUDY


1. Assess your classroom or school’s soft- community is diverse, focus on cultures rep-
ware collection. Note which specific intelli- resented by students in your classroom or
gences are activated through each program. school. In the unit, explore how different cul-
Identify intelligence areas that appear to have tures express themselves through the eight
few or no software programs represented. intelligences, examining oral and written tra-
Obtain catalogs of major educational software ditions; number systems or sciences, music,
companies and list software programs that art, dance, sports, political, and social sys-
could be purchased to expand the range of tems; religious and mythic traditions; and
intelligences covered in your school. Provide taxonomies for classifying nature.
your classroom or lab with at least one soft- 4. Develop a vocational curriculum unit
ware program for each intelligence. Then la- appropriate for your classroom (planning
bel software programs by intelligences field trips and parent visits at the elementary
developed, and encourage students to ex- level, self-assessments and specific study of
plore a range of programs during special careers at the middle school and high school
“choice” times. Similarly, create a list of val- levels).
ued Web sites that feature the eight 5. What are some educational applica-
intelligences. tions of MI theory that have not been men-
2. Develop expertise in the use of multi- tioned in this book? How might these
media software. Then use these resources to applications best be developed? Select one
help students develop special projects or unexplored area that has particular interest
“electronic portfolios” for assessment for you and design a unique expression of it
purposes. in your classroom or school.
3. Create a multicultural/multiple-
intelligence unit for your class. If your

126
MI and Existential Intelligence
14
Howard Gardner has recently written about room in this inclusive definition for explicitly re-
the possibility of a ninth intelligence—the exis- ligious or spiritual roles (theologians, pastors,
tential (Gardner, 1999b)—and so I would like to rabbis, shamans, ministers, priests, yogis, lamas,
conclude this book with a look at this candidate imams), as well as nonreligious or nonspiritual
intelligence and examine what some of the po- roles (philosophers, as well as writers, artists, sci-
tential applications of it might be in the curricu- entists, and others who are asking these deeper
lum. Gardner defines existential intelligence as “a questions as a part of their creative work).
concern with ultimate life issues.” He describes
the core ability of this intelligence as
the capacity to locate oneself with respect to How Does the Existential
the furthest reaches of the cosmos—the infi-
nite and the infinitesimal—and the related
Intelligence Fit the Criteria?
capacity to locate oneself with respect to Gardner has considered this intelligence for in-
such existential features of the human condi- clusion into MI theory because it appears to fit
tion as the significance of life, the meaning quite well with most of his criteria for an intelli-
of death, the ultimate fate of the physical gence. He’s humorously quipped that he cur-
and the psychological worlds, and such pro- rently has 8½ intelligences.
found experiences as love of another person
• Cultural Value. Virtually all cultures have
or total immersion in a work of art (Gardner,
belief systems, myths, dogmas, rituals, institu-
1999b, p. 60).
tions, or other structures that attempt to grapple
Gardner explicitly states that he is not proposing with ultimate life issues.
here a spiritual, religious, or moral intelligence • Developmental History. A look at the autobi-
based on any specific “truths” that have been ad- ographies of great philosophical, religious, spiri-
vanced by different individuals, groups, or insti- tual, scientific, or artistic individuals often shows
tutions (see Gardner, 1999b, pp. 53–77 for a an increasing progression from inklings of cos-
fuller discussion of why he has decided not to mic concerns in childhood through apprentice-
propose a spiritual or moral intelligence). In- ship stages, to advanced levels of understanding
stead, he is suggesting that any rendering of the or comprehension in adulthood.
spectrum of human intelligences should proba- • Symbol Systems. Most societies historically
bly address humanity’s long-standing efforts to have developed different kinds of symbols, im-
come to grips with the ultimate questions of life: ages, or “maps” with which to communicate to
“Who are we?” “What’s it all about?” “Why is their members about existential themes (witness,
there evil?” “Where is humanity heading?” “Is for example, key symbols used by the world’s
there meaning in life?” and so forth. There is major religions).

127
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

• Exceptional Individuals (Savants). In many their own consciences or belief systems or those
parts of the world, there are to be found indi- of their students with regard to these deeper life
viduals who are said by the local populace to issues. It is important to point out, however, that
possess a deeper wisdom or understanding, or this intelligence does not involve promoting re-
capacity to ask existential questions, while at the ligion, spirituality, or any specific belief system. It
same time having a low I.Q. or lacking substan- rather is dedicated to examining the broader ef-
tially in the capacities of the other intelligences forts of humanity to address existential concerns
(the movie figure Forrest Gump is perhaps the (both religious and nonreligious) in a diversity of
best known representation of this phenomenon ways. There are clear constitutional protections
in popular culture). for teaching about religion in public schools (ob-
• Psychometric Studies. Certain personality as- jectively and neutrally) and important pedagogi-
sessments purport to measure traits of “religios- cal reasons for doing this regularly across the
ity” or “spirituality,” although there are certain curriculum (Nord & Haynes, 1998).
problems inherent in obtaining quantitative Second, it appears to me that the potential
measures of experiences that are by definition applications of this intelligence to the curriculum
nonquantitative. will be more selective than it is for any of the
• Evolutionary Plausibility. There is evidence other intelligences. I don’t see any particular ad-
for an awareness of existential themes in the vantage in attempting to apply existential intelli-
hunting and burying rituals of prehistoric gence to every possible educational objective.
humans. Notice the absurdity, for example, in trying to
• Brain Research. Individuals who have teach multiplication, phonics, sentence structure,
temporal-lobe epilepsy sometimes show signs of the class rules, state government, or the different
“hyperreligiosity”; identical twins reared apart food groups through existential intelligence! I
show a strong link in terms of their religious atti- think that the existential intelligence—even if
tudes, suggesting the possibility of heritability. fully endorsed by Howard Gardner as an “offi-
There are problems involved, however, in sub- cial” intelligence someday—will always maintain
jecting existential concerns to bioreductionism. a somewhat special status within MI theory,
somewhere on the periphery of the day-to-day
Although the existential intelligence is not a workings of the model.
“perfect fit” in terms of Gardner’s criteria (this be- Finally, I feel that attempts to assess existen-
ing the reason why he has still not fully qualified tial intelligence in students—or to develop exis-
it for entry into MI theory), there are enough tential methods for assessing regular school
points of confluence to warrant educators to take topics—are not going to be at all productive or
this intelligence seriously as a “new kid on the useful in an educational context because they
block.” I would like to explore some potential will tend to force educators into creating criteria
applications of existential intelligence to the cur- that are far too limiting and artificial to be of any
riculum. Before I do so, I wish to make some pedagogical use (and, conversely, are likely only
preliminary comments. to incite controversy and confusion). I also be-
First, some educators may feel a certain re- lieve that attempts to create “existential strate-
luctance to address the existential intelligence for gies” to teach curriculum in specific areas (e.g.,
fear of running into controversy from the com- having students recreate a religious ritual during
munity, abridging constitutional protections on a multicultural unit, or telling them to do a
the separation of church and state, or violating closed-eyes meditation on the significance of

128
MI and Existential Intelligence

death in a biology class) are likely to violate the including Newton, Boyle, and Einstein have
consciences of some students, and possibly be been motivated in part (and sometimes in large
unconstitutional in a public school setting, as part) by religious, spiritual, or cosmic concerns
well. Consequently, I feel that the most appropri- (Einstein, for example, rejected the indetermi-
ate way to integrate existential intelligence into nacy of quantum physics because he did not be-
the classroom is by integrating content into the lieve that “God would play dice with the
curriculum that helps students think about the universe”).
existential dimensions of whatever they are Teachers can address science existentially in
studying, and that assists them in considering the classroom by highlighting those areas that in-
the ways in which scientists, artists, politicians, volve, as Gardner puts it, “the furthest reaches of
writers, and others have incorporated existential the cosmos—the infinite and the infinitesimal”
concerns into their own body of work. I strongly (e.g., theories about the origins of the universe,
suggest that educators read the book Taking Re- subatomic physics). An excellent book that viv-
ligion Seriously Across the Curriculum (Nord & idly demonstrates these extreme limits is The
Haynes, 1998) for a solidly grounded, legally Powers of Ten (Morrison & Morrison, 1994),
based, and pedagogically responsible approach where readers are taken from inside the atom to
to teaching about religious issues in the class- the edges of the universe by successive powers of
room. For a look at how children are natural ten. In the biological sciences, teachers can simi-
philosophers, I would suggest The Philosophy of larly approach the origins of life in an existential
Childhood (Matthews, 1996). What follows are way by helping students wonder about the dis-
some of my own suggestions for how existential tinctions between nonlife forms (rocks and min-
intelligence appears to intersect with different ar- erals) and life forms (plants and animals). Many
eas of the curriculum and how it can be inte- current controversies in science, from human
grated into the classroom in a way that does not cloning to nuclear weapons research, raise op-
violate the constitution or the belief systems of portunities for deep reflection on the nature and
individual students. destiny of humanity. One clear application of ex-
istential intelligence to science would entail com-
paring and making distinctions between Charles
How Can Teachers Integrate Darwin’s theory of evolution and metaphysical or
theological views of creation from Judaism,
Existential Intelligence in the Christianity, Hinduism, and other world relig-
Classroom? ions. Ultimately, questions that science poses
Several curricular areas lend themselves to explo- (e.g., “Where did we come from?” and “What are
rations of existential questions: we made of?”) are existential in nature. Wherever
science is working at its own frontiers with un-
Science. Although its external logical meth- answered questions, there is plenty of room for
odologies may seem to preclude the possibility of existential intelligence to be brought to the fore
entertaining existential issues, the inner core of in the curriculum.
science is alive to issues of ultimate concern in Mathematics. Like science, mathematics has
life. One should remember that modern science interacted for thousands of years with existential
emerged in the 17th century out of philosophy, issues. The first Western mathematician that we
religion, alchemy, and other existential fields. know about, the Greek thinker Pythagoras, was a
Many of the great scientists of the modern era, mathematician and a mystic who believed that

129
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

number patterns revealed the ultimate harmony in a way that can shake up our own personal be-
of the cosmos. Following Pythagoras, Plato be- lief system and cause us to think in new ways
lieved that mathematical reasoning was closer to about human existence. Finally, the very process
ultimate reality than the unreliable data gathered of interpreting history reveals existential issues.
by our mere human senses. The mystic compo- Some cultures view historical events as the un-
nents of Judaism, Islam, and other great religious folding of God’s divine plan, others as the work-
traditions saw numbers and mathematical rea- ing out of the law of karma, and still others as
soning as doorways into the secrets of the mys- moving toward apocalyptic “end times.” Under-
teries of the universe. standing the various meanings that are attached
In the classroom, teachers can bring together a to historical events can only serve to enrich each
multicultural emphasis with mathematics to ad- student’s understanding of history.
dress some of these historical connections. There Literature. The clearest connection in the
are also opportunities to touch on existential Western world between literature and existential
themes when discussing math concepts: zero or intelligence can be seen in the impact of the He-
infinity, very large or very small numbers, negative brew and Christian Bibles on subsequent writers
numbers, irrational numbers, imaginary numbers, in history. One can’t fully understand or appreci-
and concepts like probability and topology. ate many of the great books of our culture—in-
History. It is simply impossible to discuss cluding most of Shakespeare’s plays, Bunyan’s
much of human history in any “intelligent” fash- Pilgrim’s Progress, Melville’s Moby Dick, Faulkner’s
ion without bringing in factors related to existen- Absolom, Absolom, and many more—without see-
tial concerns, especially those involving religion. ing how Biblical or religious sources interpene-
Consider American history, for example. The trate them. I’m willing to make the claim that
motivation for many settlers to come to America virtually all great literature deals with issues of
in the 17th century was to seek freedom from re- ultimate life concern and cannot be understood
ligious oppression. Consequently, it’s important apart from them: from the existential crisis of
for history students to have a sense of what Puri- Gilgamesh after the death of his friend Enkidu in
tans believed, for example, and how their own the several-thousand-year-old Mesopotamian
beliefs differed from the Church of England (and classic, to the philosophical musings of Leopold
similarly how the Church of England came to Bloom and Stephen Daedelus in James Joyce’s
split off from Roman Catholicism). Many wars in twentieth century masterpiece Ulysses.
human history have come about at least partially In the classroom, teachers need to ascertain
as a result of religious differences, and so stu- in advance whether assigned literature contains
dents need to know something about the nature existential themes, and then provide opportuni-
of those religions to understand some of the ties for students to reflect on and discuss these
causes of those conflicts. ideas in relationship to other course objectives.
At the same time, students need to be famil- Geography. The constantly shifting pattern
iar with trends in philosophy or other existential on a world atlas of alliances, city-states, empires,
domains, to appreciate many world events (for confederations, and nations from the ancient
example, the impact of the French Enlighten- past to the current day, can be far better under-
ment on the French Revolution). And there are stood in a context that includes existential
events, such as the Holocaust, that transcend any themes. To make sense of the changing map of
particular religion or philosophy and cause us to the former Yugoslavia, for example, requires an
confront the nature of evil, suffering, and death understanding of the distinctions between

130
MI and Existential Intelligence

Roman Catholicism, Orthodox Christianity, and ponder ultimate questions of suffering and
Islam. Making sense of the division between In- mercy. Listening to Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony
dia, Pakistan, and Bangladesh requires familiarity or looking at American painter Thomas Cole’s
with differences between Islamic and Hindu series The Course of Empire can engender
thinking. thoughts about human destiny. Classroom
Teachers can help students better compre- teachers can help students appreciate these finer
hend how the landscape has been formed and dimensions of the arts and also provide the re-
reformed by spending some time discussing how sources and opportunities for students to express
differences in attitudes on issues of ultimate life their own existential concerns by creating their
concern can change geographical boundaries own works of art.
dramatically. In sum, there appear to be plenty of opportu-
The Arts. Gardner (1999b) has pointed out nities for the exercise of existential intelligence in
in his definition of existential intelligence that a classroom setting. The kind of connections and
“total immersion in a work of art” is one way in applications discussed in this chapter do not rep-
which individuals can experience and express resent a “side-trip” or “remote excursion” to a
themselves with respect to ultimate life concerns. new intelligence. Rather, they take students more
A look at the history of music, painting, sculp- deeply into the material being studied, by focus-
ture, dance, and drama reveals an ongoing con- ing on how existential concerns intertwine with
cern with the meaning of life, death, suffering, scientific, mathematical, historical, literary, artis-
and other existential issues. Seeing Michelange- tic, and other fields of study and by emphasizing
lo’s Pieta or attending a performance of Shake- how questions of ultimate concern in life are inte-
speare’s The Merchant of Venice can cause us to gral to a fuller understanding of human culture.

FOR FURTHER STUDY


1. Discuss the ways in which your school math, history, literature, social studies, eco-
is already tapping existential intelligence in nomics, psychology, sociology, or anthropol-
its courses and programs. ogy, and discuss how they can be incorpo-
2. Hold dialogues with members of your rated into the regular core curriculum.
learning community (parents, teachers, ad- 4. Develop an inservice training program
ministrators, students, board members) about for staff that will teach about religious and
integrating more of the existential intelligence philosophical traditions and help teachers to
into your school’s curriculum. Freely air all differentiate appropriate versus inappropriate
points of view, and then develop a constitu- ways to integrate existential issues into the
tionally sound framework that provides op- classroom.
portunities to teach about religious issues, 5. Offer a foundational course in ethics,
raise philosophical themes, and discuss other philosophy, or religions of the world for stu-
existential concerns as they relate to various dents to learn how existential questions have
parts of the curriculum. been raised by different peoples at different
3. Research the existential dimensions of times and places in history.
an academic discipline, such as science,

131
Appendix A
Resources on Multiple Intelligences

Books Carreiro, Paul. (1998). Tales of thinking: Multiple intelligences


in the classroom. York, ME: Stenhouse Publications.
Armstrong, Thomas. (2000). In their own way: Discovering Fogarty, Robin, & Bellanca, James. (1998). Multiple intelli-
and encouraging your child’s multiple intelligences. New gences: A collection. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
York: Tarcher/Putnam. Revised and updated version Fogarty, Robin, & Stoehr, Judy. (1995). Integrating the cur-
of the 1987 edition. A good introduction to multiple riculum with multiple intelligences. Palatine, IL:
intelligences for parents and teachers. Skylight.
Armstrong, Thomas. (1999). 7 kinds of smart: Identifying and Gardner, Howard. (1991). To open minds. New York: Basic
developing your multiple intelligences. Revised and up- Books. This book provides background information
dated with information on 2 new kinds of smart. New on the origins of multiple-intelligence theory.
York: Plume/Penguin. The first book on multiple in- Gardner, Howard. (1993). Frames of mind: The theory of mul-
telligences for the general public with self-help exer- tiple intelligences/tenth anniversary edition. New York:
cises and several checklists. Revised edition includes Basic Books. This is the bible of multiple intelli-
information on the naturalist and existential gences. For more information on Gardner’s research
intelligences. in MI Theory, write: Project Zero, Harvard Graduate
Bower, Bert, Lobdell, Jim, & Swensen, Lee. (1994). History School of Education, 321 Longfellow Hall, 13 Ap-
alive! Engaging all learners in the diverse classroom. pian Way, Cambridge, MA 02138 (URL:
Menlo Park, CA: Addison-Wesley. http://pz.harvard.edu; e-mail: info@pz.har-
Campbell, Bruce. (1994). The multiple intelligences handbook. vard.edu).
Tucson, AZ: Zephyr Press, 1994. Gardner, Howard. (1993). Multiple intelligences: The theory in
Campbell, Linda, Campbell, Bruce, & Dickinson, Dee. practice. New York: Basic Books. This book consists
(1995). Teaching and learning through multiple intelli- of a number of papers written by Gardner and his
gences. Boston: Allyn & Bacon. Excellent source of associates on MI theory updated to reflect his cur-
teaching strategies in the five neglected intelligences rent thinking. Includes the best overall bibliography
(musical, spatial, bodily-kinesthetic, interpersonal, available on MI theory, plus a list of consultants
and intrapersonal). working in the field.
Campbell, L., & Campbell, B. (2000) Multiple intelligences Gardner, Howard. (1994). Creating minds: An anatomy of
and student achievement: success stories from six creativity seen through the lives of Freud, Einstein,
schools. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision Picasso, Stravinsky, Eliot, Graham, and Gandhi. New
and Curriculum Development. York: Basic Books.

132
Appendix A

Gardner, Howard. (1998). Extraordinary minds. New York: intelligence profiles, processfolios, reflective journals
Basic Books. and logs, checklists, and multiperceptual formal
Gardner, Howard. (1999). The disciplined mind: What all stu- tests.
dents should understand. New York: Simon & Lazear, David. (1999). Eight ways of knowing: Teaching for
Schuster. multiple intelligences. Palatine, IL: Skylight. This is a
Gardner, Howard. (1999). Intelligence reframed: Multiple in- very teacher-friendly introduction to the theory of
telligences for the 21st century. New York: Basic multiple intelligences with many general activities
Books. for awakening and developing the intelligences.
Gardner, Howard, Feldman, David Henry, & Krechevsky, Lazear, David. (1999). Eight ways of teaching: The artistry of
Mara. (Eds.). (1998). Building on children’s strengths: teaching with multiple intelligences. Palatine, IL: Sky-
The experience of Project Spectrum (Project Zero light. A book containing eight detailed lesson plans;
Frameworks for Early Childhood Education, Vol. 1). each chapter focuses on teaching a school subject
New York: Teachers College Press. through one of the eight intelligences (e.g., teaching
Gardner, Howard, Feldman, David Henry, & Krechevsky, geometry through bodily-kinesthetic intelligence).
Mara. (Eds.). (1998). Project Spectrum: Early learning Lazear, David. (1999). The intelligence curriculum: Using MI
activities (Project Zero Frameworks for Early Childhood to develop your students’ full potential. Tucson, AZ:
Education, Vol. 2). New York: Teachers College Press. Zephyr Press.
Gardner, Howard, Feldman, David Henry, & Krechevsky, Nelson, Kristin. (1998). Developing students’ multiple intelli-
Mara. (Eds.). (1998). Project Spectrum: Preschool as- gences. New York: Scholastic. Includes sample lesson
sessment handbook (Project Zero Frameworks for Early plans, classroom activities, and background infor-
Childhood Education, Vol. 3). New York: Teachers mation on the theory.
College Press. New City School. (1994). Celebrating multiple intelligences.
Haggerty, Brian. (1994). Nurturing intelligences. Menlo Park, (Order from New City School, 5209 Waterman
CA: Addison-Wesley. Ave., St. Louis, MO 63108).
Hoerr, T.R. (2000). Becoming a multiple intelligences school. Shearer, Branton. (1996). The MIDAS: A guide to assessment
Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and and education for the multiple intelligences. Columbus,
Curriculum Development. OH: Greyden Press.
Kline, Peter. (1988). The everyday genius. Arlington, VA: Teaching for Multiple Intelligences. (1997, September).
Great Ocean. A book that is mainly about acceler- Educational Leadership, 55(1). Entire issue. (Available
ated learning strategies but includes MI theory as an through the Association for Supervision and Cur-
important component. riculum Development, 1703 N. Beauregard St., Al-
Kovalik, Susan. (1993). ITI: The model—integrated thematic exandria, VA 22311. Phone: 1-800-933-2723; URL:
instruction. Village of Oak Creek, AZ: Books for Edu- http://www.ascd.org; e-mail: member@ascd.org).
cators. (Available from: Books for Educators, 17051 Teele, Sue. (1991). Teaching and assessment strategies appro-
S.E. 277th St., Suite 18, Kent, WA 98032.) This priate for the multiple intelligences. Riverside: Univer-
book is primarily about integrated thematic instruc- sity of California Extension. (Available from
tion but includes a section on using MI theory in University of California Extension, H101 Bannock-
building thematic units. burn, University of California, Riverside, CA
Lazear, David. (1993). Seven pathways of learning: Teaching 92521-0112.) Sue Teele directs a Multiple Intelli-
students and parents about multiple intelligences. Tuc- gences Certificate Program at U.C. Riverside and has
son, AZ: Zephyr Press. Includes reproducible activi- authored an assessment device for MI theory called
ties and lesson extensions for teaching about the TIMI (Teele Inventory of Multiple Intelligences).
multiple intelligences. Write to her at: UCR Extension Center, 1200 Uni-
Lazear, David. (1994). Multiple intelligence approaches to as- versity Ave., Riverside, CA 92507-4596.
sessment: Solving the assessment conundrum. Tucson, Thornburg, David. (1989). The role of technology in teaching
AZ: Zephyr Press. Instruction on creating student to the whole child: Multiple intelligences in the

133
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

classroom. Los Altos, CA: Starsong Publications. Curriculum Development. (Address: 1703 N. Beau-
Thornburg applies here his substantial background regard St., Alexandria, VA 22311; Phone:
in computer technology (he helped develop the 1-800-933-2723; fax: 1-703-575-5400; URL:
Muppet Learning Keys and the Koala Pad) to MI http://www.ascd.org; e-mail: member@ascd.org).
theory. Consultant: Howard Gardner. Three videotapes, Facili-
Wahl, Mark. (1997). Math for humans: Teaching math through tator’s Guides, book (Armstrong, Multiple Intelligences in the
7 intelligences. Langley, WA: LivnLern Press. (416 Classroom), and audiotape by Howard Gardner. The videos
Fourth St., Langley, WA 98260). are:
Wass, Lane Longino. (1991). Imagine that: Getting smarter • Understanding multiple intelligences (38 minutes).
through imagery practice. Rolling Hills Estate, CA: Jal- • Classroom applications (35 minutes).
mar Press. MI theory applied to guided imagery. • Creating the school of the future (30 minutes).

National Professional Resources. (Address: 25 S. Regent St.,


CD-ROM Port Chester, NY 10573. Phone: 914-937-8879, fax:
D’Arcangelo, Marcia, & Checkley, Kathy. (1996). Exploring 914-937-9327, URL: http://www.nprinc.com). Five
our multiple intelligences. [cd-rom]. Alexandria, VA: videos:
Association for Supervision and Curriculum • Armstrong, Thomas. (1997). Multiple intelligences:
Development. Discovering the giftedness in ALL [videotape] (VHS, 44
Interactive media staff development tool; includes puzzles, minutes).
simulations, and activities for identifying one’s own intelli- • Gardner, Howard. (1995). How are kids smart? Multi-
gences. One CD-ROM with Windows version (486DX or ple intelligences in the classroom. [videotape] (VHS;
better with Windows 3.1 or later) and Macintosh version teacher’s version, 31 minutes; administrator’s version,
(68030 or better). For both versions: 8MB RAM, 2X CD 41 minutes).
ROM drive or faster, and 8-bit sound card are • Gardner, Howard, Goleman, Daniel, & Csikszentmi-
recommended. halyi, Mihaly. (1998). Optimizing intelligences: Thinking,
emotion & creativity. [videotape] (VHS; 40 minutes).
Videos • Gusman, Jo. (1998). Multiple intelligences and the sec-
ond language learner. [videotape] (VHS, 40 minutes).
Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. • Teele, Sue. (2000). Rainbows of intelligence: Raising
(1995). Multiple intelligences series [videotape]. Alex- student performance through multiple intelligences. [video-
andria, VA: Association for Supervision and tape] (VHS, 38 minutes).

134
Appendix B
Related Books on MI Teaching

Linguistic Intelligence Spatial Intelligence


Ashton-Warner, Sylvia. (1986). Teacher. New York: Simon DeMille, Richard. (1981). Put your mother on the ceiling: Chil-
& Schuster. dren’s imagination games. Santa Barbara, CA: Santa
Bissex, Glenda. (1980). Gnys at work: A child learns to write Barbara Press.
and read. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Edwards, Betty. (1979). Drawing on the right side of the brain.
Graves, Donald, & Stuart, Virginia. (1987). Write from the Los Angeles: Jeremy P. Tarcher.
start: Tapping your child’s natural writing ability. New McKim, Robert H. (1980). Experiences in visual thinking.
York: NAL. Monterey, CA: Brooks-Cole. High school level.
Rico, Gabrielle Lusser. (1983). Writing the natural way. Los Samples, Robert. (1976). The metaphoric mind. Reading,
Angeles: Jeremy P. Tarcher. MA: Addison-Wesley.
Trelease, Jim. (1982). The read-aloud handbook. Harmond- Warner, Sally. (1989). Encouraging the artist in your child.
sworth, England: Penguin. New York: St. Martin’s Press.

Logical-Mathematical Intelligence Bodily-Kinesthetic Intelligence


Allison, Linda. (1976). Blood and guts: A working guide to Benzwie, Teresa. (1988). A moving experience: Dance for lov-
your own insides. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. Grades ers of children and the child within. Tucson, AZ:
5–12. See also other books in Brown Paper School Zephyr Press.
Book series. Gilbert, Anne G. (1977). Teaching the 3 R’s through movement
Burns, Marilyn. (1975). The I hate mathematics! book. Bos- experiences. New York: Macmillan.
ton: Little, Brown & Co. Griss, S. (1998). Minds in motion: A kinesthetic approach to
Jacobs, Harold. (1982). Mathematics: A human endeavor. San teaching elementary curriculum. Portsmouth, NH:
Francisco: W. H. Freeman. Grades 9–12. Heinemann.
Lorton, Mary Baratta. (1976). Mathematics their way. Menlo Schneider, Tom. (1976). Everybody’s a winner: A kids’ guide to
Park, CA: Addison-Wesley. new sports and fitness. Boston: Little, Brown & Co.
Stein, Sara. (1980). The science book. New York: Workman. Spolin, Viola. (1986). Theater games for the classroom. Evan-
Grades 4–7. ston, IL: Northwestern University Press.

135
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

Musical Intelligence Intrapersonal Intelligence


Bonny, Helen, & Savary, Louis. (1990). Music and your mind. Armstrong, Thomas. (1985). The radiant child. Wheaton, IL:
Barrytown, NY: Station Hill Press. Quest.
Brewer, Chris Boyd, & Campbell, Don G. (1991). Rhythms Briggs, Dorothy Corkille. (1970). Your child’s self-esteem.
of learning. Tucson, AZ: Zephyr Press. Garden City, NY: Doubleday.
Halpern, Steven, & Savary, Louis. (1985). Sound health: Mu- Gibbons, Maurice. (1991). How to become an expert: Dis-
sic and sounds that make us whole. San Francisco: cover, research, and build a project in your chosen field.
Harper & Row. Tucson, AZ: Zephyr Press.
Judy, Stephanie. (1990). Making music for the joy of it. Los Oaklander, Violet. (1978). Windows to our children. Moab,
Angeles: Jeremy P. Tarcher. UT: Real People Press.
Merritt, Stephanie. (1990). Mind, music, and imagery: 40 ex-
ercises using music to stimulate creativity and self- Naturalist Intelligence
awareness. New York: NAL/Plume.
Wallace, Rosella R. (1992). Rappin’ and rhymin’: Raps, songs, Beame, Rona. (1989). Backyard explorer kit. New York:
cheers, and smartrope jingles for active learning. Tuc- Workman Publications.
son, AZ: Zephyr Press. Cornell, Joseph. (1998). Sharing nature with children. Nevada
City, CA: Dawn Publications.
Herman, Marina Lachecki, Schimpf, Ann, Passineau, Jo-
Interpersonal Intelligence seph, & Treuer, Paul. (1990). Teaching kids to love the
Johnson, David W., Johnson, Roger T., & Holubec, Edythe earth (Illus. by Carolyn Olson). Duluth, MN:
Johnson. (1994). The new circles of learning: Coopera- Pfeifer-Hamilton Publications.
tion in the classroom and school. Alexandria, VA.: Lingelbach, Jenepher R. (Ed.). (1989). Hands-on nature: In-
Association for Supervision and Curriculum formation and activities for exploring the environment
Development. with children. Woodstock: Vermont Institute of Natu-
Orlick, Terry. (1978). The cooperative sports and games book. ral Science.
New York: Pantheon. Roth, Karen. (1998). Naturalist intelligence: An introduction to
Sobel, Jeffrey. (1983). Everybody wins: 393 non-competitive Gardner’s eighth intelligence. Palatine, IL: Skylight
games for young children. New York: Walker & Publishers.
company The young naturalist kid kit. (1998). Tulsa, OK: Education
Wade, Rahima Carol. (1991). Joining hands: From personal to Development Corporation Publications; Usborne
planetary friendship in the primary classroom. Tucson, Publishing Limited.
AZ: Zephyr Press.
Weinstein, Matt, & Goodman, Joel. (1980). Playfair: Every-
body’s guide to noncompetitive play. San Luis Obispo,
CA: Impact.

136
Appendix C
Examples of MI Lessons and Programs

The following examples of lessons and programs [Intrapersonal, Bodily-Kinesthetic]


based on MI theory are designed for a variety of • Look for circles around the classroom.
grade levels. Note that in some cases, MI theory [Spatial]
provides the basis for the development of a pro- • Make circles in art projects. [Spatial, Bodily-
gram (e.g., a primary-level reading list); in other Kinesthetic]
• Sing “The Circle Game” and other circle
cases, MI theory is limited to the development of
songs
ideas that can be incorporated into existing cur- (including “rounds,” which are themselves musi-
ricular frameworks. In some cases, the educa- cally circular). [Musical]
tional focus is on the development of skills (e.g., • Make up stories about circles. [Linguistic]
learning how to multiply by 7); in other cases, • Compare sizes of circles (from small to
the emphasis is more on concepts (e.g., under- large). [Spatial, Logical-Mathematical]
standing Boyle’s law). In every lesson, however, • Find circular forms in nature [Naturalist]
activities spanning all eight intelligences have
been used to achieve the given instructional Example Two
objective.
Level: Kindergarten–1st grade
Example One Subject: Reading
Objective: To help develop a “book positive” at-
Level: Preschool titude in students.
Subject: Shapes Materials: Books that combine linguistic intelli-
Objective: To teach students to recognize circles. gence with one or more other intelligences.
Students will experience different types of A classroom library will be stocked with
circles in the following ways (the emphasized in- books of the following types (the emphasized in-
telligence appears in brackets): telligence appears in brackets):
• Make a group circle by joining hands. [In- • Books with read-along cassettes [Linguistic]
terpersonal, Bodily-Kinesthetic] • Three-dimensional pop-up books [Spatial]
• Make circles by using their bodies. • Wordless books (pictorial stories) [Spatial]

137
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

• Touch ‘n’ feel books [Bodily-Kinesthetic] section before passing the ball of yarn on. On
• Books with sing-along cassettes [Musical] reaching the count of 70, students will see that
• Books with computerized keyboards and the yarn creates a geometric design. [Spatial,
song lyrics [Musical] Bodily-Kinesthetic, Interpersonal]
• Science fun books [Logical-Mathematical] • Create their own geometric designs for the
• Counting books [Logical-Mathematical] 7’s on a Geoboard or in a drawing using the
• “This-is-me” type of books [Intrapersonal] strategy described above (e.g., use a circle num-
• Books on emotional themes, such as loss or bered 0 to 9 and then connect with string or a
anger [Intrapersonal] line every seventh number up to 70). [Spatial]
• Interactive books [Interpersonal] • Listen to a story about “The As Much
• Books with nature themes [Naturalist] Brothers” (who can touch things and see them
• Books that come with naturalist tools (e.g., multiply; for instance, when Seven Times As
book on insects with magnifying glass) Much touches 3 golden hens, 21 golden hens
[Naturalist] appear). [Linguistic]
• Create “before” and “after” drawings based
Example Three on “The As Much Brothers” story (for instance,
Seven Times As Much just before touching the
Level: 2nd–3rd grade 3 golden hens and just after touching them).
Subject: Math [Spatial]
Objectives: To help students master the multi- • Find natural forms that come in sevens
plication table facts for the 7’s; also, to reinforce (e.g., flowers) and explore math through nature’s
the concept of what it means to “multiply.” own multiples (e.g., six seven-petaled flowers
The class will do one of these activities each have how many petals?). Do this with living
day during math class (the emphasized intelli- forms in a natural setting (don’t destroy flowers
gence appears in brackets): to bring in for “dissection”).
• Count to 70, standing up and clapping on
every seventh number. [Bodily-Kinesthetic] Example Four
• Sing the “Multiplication Rock” song for the Level: Upper Elementary
7’s. [Musical]
Subject: History
• Chant the numbers 1 to 70, placing special
Objective: To assist students in understanding
emphasis on every seventh number. [Musical]
the conditions that led to the development of
• Complete a “hundreds chart,” coloring in
Rhode Island in early American history.
every seventh number. [Spatial]
Students will engage in one or more of the
• Form circles of ten students, each student
following activities each day during history pe-
wearing a number from 0 to 9. Starting with the
riod (the intelligences emphasized appear in
0, participants count off as they go around the
brackets):
circle (the second time around the circle, the 0
becomes a 10, the 1 an 11, and so on; the third • Read textbook passages that give reasons
time around, the 0 becomes a 20, the 1 a 21, and for the settling of Rhode Island and discuss their
so on). As they count, participants pass a ball of readings. [Linguistic]
yarn around the circle, unrolling it as they do so. • Create a time line of the events surrounding
The first person grasps the end of the yarn, and the development of Rhode Island. [Logical-
every seventh person after that also grasps a Mathematical, Spatial]

138
Appendix C

• Study maps of the United States during the the left, revealing x as 2. [Interpersonal; Bodily-
colonial era showing the progressive develop- Kinesthetic]
ment of Rhode Island. [Spatial] • Students perform algebraic equations using
• Compare the settling of Rhode Island with manipulatives (numbers and functions on a
the growth of an amoeba. [Naturalist] scale; sides must be kept in balance in order to
• Act out the events surrounding the settling solve). [Bodily-Kinesthetic]
of Rhode Island. [Bodily-Kinesthetic, • Students rhythmically repeat the following
Interpersonal] lyrics several times:
• Create a song that describes the circum-
x is a mystery
stances leading to the settling of Rhode Island.
you’ve gotta find a way
[Musical]
to get him all alone
• Divide into groups representing different
so he’s gotta say his name
colonies; groups then relate to the development
of another group of students as Rhode Island. Students can accompany their chanting with any
[Interpersonal, Bodily-Kinesthetic] available percussion instruments. [Musical]
• Relate the settling of Rhode Island to their • Students are asked, “What are the myster-
own need or desire to break away from authority ies—or x’s—in your own life?” Discuss how stu-
at times (e.g., conflicts with parents/teachers). dents “solve for x” in dealing with personal
[Intrapersonal] issues. [Intrapersonal]
• Students are told: “We go hunting for a lit-
Example Five tle animal whose name we don’t know, so we call
it x. When we bag our game we pounce on it
Level: Junior High School and give it its right name.” (Albert Einstein’s un-
Subject: Algebra cle Jakob Einstein used this particular strategy
Objective: To explain the function of x in an when teaching his nephew math! See Ronald W.
equation. Clark, Einstein: The Life and Times. New York:
• Students are provided with a verbal de- Avon, 1972, pp. 29–30). [Naturalist]
scription of x (“x is an unknown”). [Linguistic]
• Students are given an equation (e.g., 2x + 1 Example Six
= 5) and shown how to solve for x. [Logical-
Level: High School
Mathematical]
Subject: Chemistry
• Students are told that x is like a masked
Objective: To teach the concept of Boyle’s Law
outlaw that needs to be unmasked; students
draw their own version of x. [Spatial] • Students are provided with a verbal defini-
• Students act out an algebraic equation, tion of Boyle’s Law: “For a fixed mass and tem-
where a student wearing a mask plays x, and perature of gas, the pressure is inversely
other students represent numbers or functions; a proportional to the volume.” They discuss the
designated student then “solves” the equation by definition. [Linguistic]
removing students on both sides of the equation • Students are given a formula that describes
in a series of steps. For instance, in the equation Boyle’s Law: P x V = K. They solve specific prob-
2x + 1 = 5, one student is removed from the left lems connected to it. [Logical-Mathematical]
side, and one from the right, then half the stu- • Students are given a metaphor or visual im-
dents are removed from the right, and half from age for Boyle’s law: “Imagine that you have a boil

139
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

on your hand that you start to squeeze. As you yarn representing one side of the container start
squeeze it, the pressure builds. The more you moving it in on the “people molecules.” The
squeeze, the higher the pressure, until the boil fi- smaller the space, the more pressure (i.e., bump-
nally bursts and pus spurts out all over your ing into each other) is observed; the greater the
hand!” (or use a balloon metaphor). [Spatial] space, the less pressure. [Interpersonal, Bodily-
• Students do the following experiment: Kinesthetic]
They breathe air into their mouths so that their • Students do lab experiments that measure
cheeks puff up slightly. Then they put all the air air pressure in sealed containers and chart pres-
into one side of their mouth (less volume) and sure against volume. [Logical-Mathematical,
indicate whether pressure goes up or down (it Bodily-Kinesthetic]
goes up); then they’re asked to release the air • Students are asked about times in their
into both sides of their mouth (more volume) lives when they were “under pressure”: “Did you
and asked to indicate whether pressure has gone feel like you had a lot of space?” (Typical answer:
up or down (it goes down). [Bodily-Kinesthetic] lots of pressure/not much space.) Then students
• Students rhythmically repeat the following are asked about times when they felt little pres-
musical mnemonic: sure (little pressure/lots of space). Students’ ex-
periences are related to Boyle’s Law.
When the volume goes down
[Intrapersonal]
The pressure goes up
• Students are told about scuba diving guide-
The blood starts to boil
lines that caution divers never ever to dive down
And a scream erupts
deep with scuba equipment, take a deep breath,
“I need more space
hold it, and then go up to the surface. (In terms
Or I’m going to frown”
of Boyle’s law, diving down deep increases pres-
The volume goes up
sure, taking a deep breath increases volume, go-
And the pressure goes down
ing up to the surface decreases pressure, and,
[Musical]
according to Boyle’s law, this increases volume in
• Students become “molecules” of gas in a the lungs; however, lungs have already expanded
“container” (a clearly defined corner of the class- to maximum capacity. Students are asked to pre-
room). They move at a constant rate (tempera- dict what might happen. (Answer: possible life-
ture) and cannot leave the container (constant threatening condition, with air embolisms form-
mass). Gradually the size of the container is ing in bloodstream.) [Naturalist]
reduced as two volunteers holding a piece of

140
References

Armstrong, M. (1980). Closely observed children. London: and student achievement: Success stories from six
Writers & Readers. schools. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision
Armstrong, T. (1987a). Describing strengths in children and Curriculum Development.
identified as “learning disabled” using Howard Carini, P. (1982). The school lives of seven children. Grand
Gardner’s theory of multiple intelligences as an or- Forks: Center for Teaching and Learning, University
ganizing framework. Dissertation Abstracts Interna- of North Dakota.
tional, 48, 08A. (University Microfilms No. 87-25, Caro, R. (1990). Means of ascent. New York: Knopf.
844) Clark, R. W. (1972). Einstein: The life and times. New York:
Armstrong, T. (1987b). In their own way: Discovering and en- Avon.
couraging your child’s personal learning style. New Cohen, D. L. (1991, June 5). “Flow room,” testing psy-
York: Tarcher/Putnam. chologist’s concept, introduces “learning in disguise”
Armstrong, T. (1988). Learning differences not disabilities. at Key School. Education Week, pp. 6–7.
Principal, 68(1), 34–36. Collins, J. (1998, October 19). Seven kinds of smart. Time,
Armstrong, T. (1993). 7 Kinds of smart: Discovering and iden- 94–96.
tifying your many intelligences. New York: Plume. Csikszentmihalyi, M. (1990). Flow: The psychology of optimal
Armstrong, T. (1997). The myth of the A.D.D. child: 50 Ways experience. New York: Harper & Row.
to improve your child’s behavior and attention span Diaz-Lefebvre, R., & Finnegan, P. (1997). Coloring outside
without drugs, labels, or coercion. New York: Plume. the lines: Applying the theory of multiple intelli-
Armstrong, T. (1999a). ADD/ADHD alternatives in the class- gences to the community college setting. Community
room. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision College Journal, 68(2), 28–31.
and Curriculum Development. Dreikurs, R., & Soltz, V. (1964). Children: The challenge.
Armstrong, T. (1999b). 7 Kinds of smart: Discovering and New York: Hawthorn.
identifying your multiple intelligences/revised and up- Edwards, B. (1979). Drawing on the right side of the brain. Los
dated with information on 2 new kinds of smart. New Angeles: Jeremy P. Tarcher.
York: Plume. Engel, B. S. (1979). Informal evaluation. Grand Forks: North
Bloom, B. (1956). Taxonomy of educational objectives. New Dakota Study Group on Evaluation (Center for
York: David McKay. Teaching and Learning, University of North Dakota,
Bonny, H., & Savary, L. (1990). Music and your mind. Barry- Grand Forks, ND 58202).
town, NY: Station Hill Press. Feldman, D. H. (1980). Beyond universals in cognitive devel-
Campbell, J. (1992, May). Laser disk portfolios: Total child opment. Norwood, NJ: Ablex.
assessment. Educational Leadership, 49(8), 69–70. Fiske, E. B. (1987, January 11). U.S. pupils lag in math
Campbell, L., & Campbell, B. (2000). Multiple intelligences ability, 3 studies find. The New York Times, pp. A1,

141
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

A17–A18. Education, Vol. 2). New York: Teachers College Press.


Fiske, E. B. (1988, May 24). In Indiana, public school Gardner, H., Feldman, D. H., & Krechevsky, M. (Eds.).
makes “frills” standard. The New York Times, pp. (1998c). Project Spectrum: Preschool assessment hand-
A16–A17. book (Project Zero Frameworks for Early Childhood
Fiske, E. B. (1988, June). Schools’ “back-to-basics” drive Education, Vol. 3). New York: Teachers College Press.
found to be working in math. The New York Times, Gentile, J. R. (1988). Instructional improvement: Summary
pp. A1, A28. and analysis of Madeline Hunter’s essential elements of
Fleming, E. (1984). Believe the heart: Our dyslexic days. San instruction and supervision. Oxford, OH: National
Francisco: Strawberry Hill Press. Staff Development Council.
Gardner, H. (1979, March). The child is father to the meta- Ghiselin, B. (1955). The creative process. New York: Mentor.
phor. Psychology Today, 12(10), 81–91. Gladwin, T. (1970). East is a big bird: Navigation and logic on
Gardner, H. (1983). Frames of mind: The theory of multiple in- Puluwat Atoll. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University
telligences. New York: Basic Books. Press.
Gardner, H. (1987, May). Beyond IQ: Education and hu- Goodlad, J. I. (1984). A place called school: Prospects for the
man development. Harvard Educational Review, future. New York: McGraw-Hill.
57(2), 187–193. Goodman, J., & Weinstein, M. (1980). Playfair: Everybody’s
Gardner, H. (1989). To open minds: Chinese clues to the di- guide to noncompetitive play. San Luis Obispo, CA:
lemma of contemporary education. New York: Basic Impact.
Books. Gordon, W. J. J., & Poze, T. (1966). The metaphorical way of
Gardner, H. (1991). The unschooled mind. New York: Basic learning and knowing. Cambridge, MA: Porpoise.
Books. Gould, S. J. (1981). The mismeasure of man. New York: W.
Gardner, H. (1993a). Frames of mind: The theory of multiple W. Norton.
intelligences/tenth anniversary edition. New York: Basic Green, W. (1999, September). The bourgeois gentleman, mul-
Books. tiple intelligences theory, and public law courses. Paper
Gardner, H. (l993b). Multiple intelligences: The theory in prac- presented at the annual meeting of the American
tice. New York: Basic Books. Political Science Association, Atlanta, GA.
Gardner, H. (1994). Creating minds. New York: Basic Books. Gruber, H. (1977). Darwin’s “tree of nature” and other im-
Gardner, H. (1995, November). Reflections on multiple in- ages of wide scope. In J. Wechsler (Ed.), On aesthet-
telligences: Myths and messages, Phi Delta Kappan, ics in science. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
198–209. Harman, W., & Rheingold, H. (1984). Higher creativity: Lib-
Gardner, H. (1998, November 9). Letter to the editor in re- erating the unconscious for breakthrough insights. Los
ply to Collins’ “Seven Kinds of Smart” (Oct. 19, Angeles: Jeremy P. Tarcher.
1998). Time. Hart, L. (1981, March). Don’t teach them: Help them learn.
Gardner, H. (1999a, September). Howard Gardner debates Learning, 9(8), 39–40.
James Traub on multiple intelligences. Cerebrum: Herman, J. L., Aschbacher, P. R., & Winters, L. (1992). A
The Dana Forum on Brain Science, 1(2). practical guide to alternative assessment. Alexandria,
Gardner, H. (1999b). Intelligence reframed: Multiple intelli- VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum De-
gences for the 21st century. New York: Basic Books. velopment..
Gardner, H., Feldman, D. H., & Krechevsky, M. (Eds.). Hoerr, T. R. (2000). Becoming a multiple intelligences school.
(1998a). Building on children’s strengths: The experi- Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and
ence of project spectrum (Project Zero Frameworks for Curriculum Development.
Early Childhood Education, Vol. 1). New York: Teach- Holden, C. (1979, June 8). Paul MacLean and the triune
ers College Press. brain. Science, 20(4), 10–68.
Gardner, H., Feldman, D. H., & Krechevsky, M. (Eds.). Illingworth, R. S., & Illingworth, C. M. (1966). Lessons from
(1998b). Project Spectrum: Early learning activities childhood: Some aspects of the early life of unusual men
(Project Zero Frameworks for Early Childhood and women. London: Livingstone.

142
References

Johnson, D., Johnson, R., & Holubec, E. (1994). The new Perkins, D. N. (1981). The mind’s best work. Cambridge, MA:
circles of learning: Cooperation in the classroom and Harvard University Press.
school. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision Plato. (1952). The dialogues of Plato. Chicago: Encyclopedia
and Curriculum Development. Britannica.
John-Steiner, V. (1987). Notebooks of the mind: Explorations of Poll finds Americans are ignorant of science. (1988, Octo-
thinking. New York: Harper & Row. ber 25). New York Times, p. C10.
Kagan, S., & Kagan, M. (1998). Multiple intelligences. San Polya, G. (1957). How to solve it. New York: Anchor Books.
Clemente, CA: Kagan Cooperative Learning. Poplin, M. (1984, Spring). Summary rationalizations,
Kornhaber, M. (1999). Project Sumit: Outcomes. Available: apologies and farewell: What we don’t know about
URL: http://www.pz.harvard.edu./sumit/out- the learning disabled. Learning Disability Quarterly,
comes.html 7(2), 133.
Kovalik, S. (1993). ITI: The model—Integrated thematic in - Proust, M. (1928). Remembrances of things past, Vol. 1:
struction (2nd ed). Village of Oak Creek, AZ: Books Swann’s way. New York: Modern Library.
for Educators. Rose, C. (1987). Accelerated learning. New York: Dell.
Margulies, N. (1991). Mapping inner space: Learning and Rosenthal, R., & Jacobsen, L. (1968). Pygmalion in the class-
teaching mind mapping. Tucson, AZ: Zephyr Press. room. New York: Holt, Rinehart, & Winston.
Marzano, R. J., Brandt, R. S., Hughes, C. S., Jones, B. F., Rozin, P., Poritsky, S., & Sotsky, R. (1971, March 26).
Presseisen, B. Z., & Rankin, S. C. (1988). Dimen- American children with reading problems can easily
sions of thinking: A framework for curriculum and in- learn to read English represented by Chinese char-
struction. Alexandria, VA: Association for acters. Science, 17(1), 1264–1267.
Supervision and Curriculum Development. Sacks, O. (1985). The man who mistook his wife for a hat.
Matthews, G. B. (1996). The philosophy of childhood. Cam- New York: HarperCollins.
bridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Sacks, O. (1990). Seeing voices: A journey into the world of the
McCoy, L. E. (1975). Braille: A language for severe dyslex- deaf. New York: HarperCollins.
ics. Journal of learning disabilities, 8, 5–34. Sacks, O. (1993). A leg to stand on (rev. ed.). New York:
McKim, R. H. (1980). Experiences in visual thinking (2nd ed). HarperCollins.
Boston: PWS Engineering. Sacks, O. (1995). An anthropologist on Mars. New York:
Merrefield, G. E. (1997). Three Billy goats and Gardner. Vintage.
Educational Leadership, 55(1), 58–61. Silver, H., Strong, R., & Perini, M. (1997). Integrating
Miller, A. (1981). The drama of the gifted child. New York: learning styles and multiple intelligences, Educa-
Basic Books. tional Leadership, 55(1), 22–29.
Montessori, M. (1972). The secret of childhood. New York: Spolin, V. (1986). Theater games for the classroom. Evanston,
Ballantine. IL: Northwestern University Press.
Morrison, P., & Morrison, P. (1994). Powers of ten. New Stainback, S., Stainback, W., & Forest, M. (Eds.). (1989).
York/San Francisco: W. H. Freeman. Educating all students in the mainstream of regular edu-
Nord, W. A., & Haynes, C. C. (1998). Taking religion seri- cation. Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes.
ously across the curriculum. Alexandria, VA: Associa- Steiner, R. (1964). The kingdom of childhood. London: Rudolf
tion of Supervision and Curriculum Development. Steiner Press.
Olson, L. (1988, January 27). Children “flourish” here: Taylor-King, S. (1997, July 19). Using multiple intelligences
Eight teachers and a theory changed a school world. and multi-sensory reinforcement approaches to enhance
Education Week, 18(1),18–19. literacy skills among homeless adults. Paper presented
Ostrander, S., & Schroeder, L. (1979). Superlearning. New at the International Congress on Challenges to Edu-
York: Delta. cation, Kihei, HI. (ERIC ED417332.)
Paul, R. (1992). Critical thinking: What every person needs to Traub, J. (1998, October 26). Multiple intelligence disorder.
survive in a rapidly changing world. Santa Rosa, CA: The New Republic, 20–23.
Foundation for Critical Thinking. Viadero, D. (1991, March 13). Music and arts courses

143
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

disappearing from curriculum, commission warns. school: A review of the research. Review of Educa-
Education Week, p. 4. tional Research, 49(4), 585.
Walters, J., & Gardner, H. (1986). The crystallizing experi- Welsh, D. J. (1977). The boy who burned too brightly: A mod-
ence: Discovery of an intellectual gift. In R. Stern- ern allegory. Fort Worth, TX: Alison Press.
berg & J. Davidson (Eds.), Conceptions and giftedness. Williams, W. M., Blythe, T., White, N., Li, J., Sternberg, R.
New York: Cambridge University Press. J., & Gardner, H. (1996). Practical intelligence for
Weinreich-Haste, H. (1985). The varieties of intelligence: school. New York: Harper Collins College Publishers.
An interview with Howard Gardner. New Ideas in Wolf, D. P., LeMahieu, P. G., & Eresh, J. (1992, May). Good
Psychology, 3(4), 47–65. measure: Assessment as a tool for educational re-
Weinstein, C. (1979). The physical environment of the form. Educational Leadership, 49(8), 8–13.

144
Index

Abbott, Jim, 106f MI in other species) authentic assessment, 90f–91f


Absolom, Absolom (Faulkner), 130 animal stories, 79
activities apprenticeship, 83, 85 Black Elk, 125f
teaching to multiple intelligences, aquatic center, 71 Banneker, Benjamin, 125f
29, 42f Aristotle, 106f Beethoven, Ludwig van, 7, 106f, 131
trajectory of, 3–7 art area, 70 behavior problems, 79
activity centers, 70f arts, explorations of existential ques- benchmarks, 88, 101
multiple intelligences perspective, tions, 130–131 Bible, 130
35 arts classes, flawed in traditional Binet, Alfred, 1
permanent open-ended, 69–71 schooling, 82 biographies, 34
permanent topic-specific (shifting), Arts PROPEL, 92 biological endowment, 17–18
72–73 assessment Bloom, Benjamin S., 117
student choice and, 73 authentic, 88–90, 90f–91f levels of cognitive complexity, 112,
temporary open-ended, 71–72 context of, 94–98 117–120
temporary topic-specific, 71 eight ways, 92–94, 94f levels of educational objectives,
aggressive student, managing experience, varieties of, 88–90 118f–119f
behavior, 80f in individualized education board games, 36, 61, 86
algebra sample lesson, 139 programs (IEPs), 110f bodily-kinesthetic difficulty, 104, 107f
Allende, Isabel, 125f in special education, 104f bodily-kinesthetic intelligence, 2, 3,
alternative symbol system, 105 MI perspective on, 29 4f–6f (See multiple intelligences; see
alternative technologies, 105–106 practices, in MI school, 85 also body smart, hand smart, sports
Alvarez, Luis, 125f projects, 91–92 smart)
analysis, 117–119f specialist, 83 Einstein as example of, 35
Anang culture, 124 assessment models, 91–92 physical education teacher, source
Andersen, Hans Christian, 105 “at risk” students, identifying, 1 of information about, 28
anecdotal records, 22–23, 28, 30, 89 attachment (bonding), 5f teaching strategies for, 57–58
animal center, 71 attention span, matching work to body, used to express ideas, 2
animal intelligence (See presence of conditions, 67–68 body answers, 57
attribute webs, 54 body maps, 58
audio cassettes, as assessment tools, body smart, 32 (See also bodily-
Note: References to figures are fol- 89 kinesthetic intelligence)
lowed by “f.” auditory classroom environment, 68 biography subjects, 34

145
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

careers, 34 choice activities, 73 intelligences, 8


children identifying end states of, choice time, 63 The Course of Empire (Cole), 131
33 Chomsky, Noam, 7 crafts, 5f
experiential activities, 34 Christianity, 129 creative movement space, 70
field trips, 34 Christie, Agatha, 105, 106f criterion-referenced assessment meas-
in human intelligence hunt, 36f Christopherian encounters, 116–117 ures, 88, 89
MI tables, 35 Church of England, 130 critical-thinking movement, 53, 54,
shelf displays, 35 Churchill, Winston, 106f 114
Bohr, Nils, 115 classification, 2, 54 cross-age tutoring, 60
book nook, 70 classroom crystallizing experiences, 18
Boston Veterans Administration, 3 environment, 67–69 Csikszentmihalyi, Mihaly, 85
Boyer, Ernest, 85 management, 75 Cuisenaire rods, 58
braille, 105 maps, 90 cultural background, 17–18
brain damage, research on, 3, 5f organization, 69, 70f cultural diversity, 121, 123–124
brain research, existential intelligence theater, 57–58, 65 cultural value, 3–6, 5f, 127
and, 128 time, 38 Curie, Marie, 34
brainstorming, 44, 52 class rules, communicating, 77 curriculum
brain systems, autonomous nature of, Clemente, Roberto, 34 content-sensitive, 123
3, 5 cognition, 98 development in MI school, 85
Buddha, 4f cognitive bypassing, 105–109 expansion of, 38
The Bug Game, 72 cognitive functioning, 8 process-sensitive, 123
building center, 71, 92 cognitive psychology, 112 units using MI theory, 44–45
cognitive skills, 112
calculation, 2, 54 cognitive therapy, 107f Darwin, Charles, 4f, 7, 56, 106f, 115,
calendar records, 90 Cole, Thomas, 131 129
career counseling, 121, 124–126 color coding, 113 Darwin, Erasmus, 106f
career day, 33–34 color cues, 56 da Vinci, Leonardo, 106f
careers, categorized by primary intelli- Columbus, Christopher, 116 de Loria, Vine, 125f
gence, 124–125 communication, 98 Dead Poets Society, 39
Carver, George Washington, 125f community involvement in MI school, Demosthenes, 106f
Catcher in the Rye (Salinger), 117 84, 85, 86 Denetclaw, Wilfred Foster Jr., 125f
categorization, 2, 54 competency, 9, 98, 101 developmental factors, 5f, 7
Caulfield, Holden, 117 Composer’s Cabaret, 73 developmental history, existential in-
cave drawings, 7 comprehension, 117–119f telligence and, 127
celebrations, 95f, 98, 102 computer center, 71 Dewey, John, 39
Chagall, Marc, 106f computer software, 121, 122f, 123 dexterity, 2
challenging student’s beliefs, 116–117 conflict resolution, 68 dialogues, 54–55
chants, 59 connectedness, 124 Dienes blocks, 58
charades, 58 consistency of work, 68 disabled individuals, 105
Chavez, Cesar, 125f cooperation, 98 discographies, 59
Checklist for Assessing Students’ Mul- cooperative groups, 61 documentation, 22–23, 89
tiple Intelligences, 24f–27f cooperative learning, 39 domain projects, 92
checklists, 90 Coopersmith Self-Esteem Inventory, 8 drama center, 70
chemistry sample lesson, 139–140 coordination, 2 drama, as part of alternative education
children’s museums, 83 core components, 4f model, 39
chisanbop, 58 core operations, specific to dramatizations in miniature, 58

146
Index

drawing center, 71 different children, 30 formal testing, usefulness of, 21


drawings, 56–57 developing plan for cultivating Frames of Mind: The Theory of Multiple
dyscalculia, 104, 106 intelligences, 20 Intelligences/Tenth Edition (Gardner),
dyslexia, 104, 105 existential intelligence, 131 1, 11, 35
dysmusic, 104 identifying intelligences, 20 free time, 22
memory strategies, 120 French Revolution, 130
ecological factors in learning, 67–69 MI schools, 87 Freud, Sigmund, 4f, 34
ecology, integrated throughout school nurturing intelligences, 20 Froebel, Friedrich, 39
day, 66 problem-solving strategies, 120 full inclusion movement, 109
economics lesson, nature walk useful software, 126
in, 64 special education, 111 Gardner, Howard, 11, 21
ecostudy, 65–66 teaching strategies, 66 challenge of intelligence testing, 1
Edison, Thomas, 56, 106f existential intelligence, 9–10, Christopherian encounters, 116
educational movements, 42f 127–131 crystallizing experiences research,
educators, importance of understand- brain research, 128 18
ing multiple intelligences, 12–17 cultural value, 127 end states, 33
Einstein, Albert, 18, 35, 106f, developmental history, 127 Frames of Mind: The Theory of
114–115, 129 evolutionary plausibility, 128 Multiple Intelligences/Tenth Edition,
Eisner, Elliot, 85 exceptional individuals, 128 1, 11, 35
electronic portfolios, 123 integration of, 129–131 Intelligence Reframed: Multiple
Emile (Rousseau), 38 potential problems with as ninth Intelligences for the 21st Century, 11
empowering strategies, 105–106 intelligence, 128–129 memory as intelligence-specific,
end-state cognitive practices, psychometric studies, 128 112
114–115 symbol systems, 127 MI assessment projects, 91
Enemy of the People (An) (Ibsen), 66 experience center, 71 ninth intelligence, possibility of,
environment Experiences in Visual Thinking 127
classification of, 2 (McKim), 11 problem of teaching surface-level
recognition of, 2 experiential activities, 34–35 knowledge, 116
Erikson, Erik, map of personal intelli- explanation, 2 standardized testing of intelligence,
gence development, 7 7–8
evaluation, 117–119f familial factors, 19 study of end-states of intelligences,
evolution, intelligences’ roots in, 6f, 7 Family Feud, 72 7
evolutionary origins and plausibility, Faraday, Michael, 106f supporter of alternatives to formal
6f, 7, 128 feelings, sensitivity to, 2 testing, 7
exceptional individuals, existential in- feeling-toned moments, 63 The Unschooled Mind, 116
telligence and, 128 feeling-toned stimuli, 76 vision of ideal multiple-intelligence
exercises Feldman, David, 18 school, 83
activity centers, 74 Feynman, Richard, 64 Gauss, Karl Friedrich, 6
assessment, 102 field trips, 34 generalization, 2
Christopherian encounters, 120 fill-in-the-blank tests, 88 geographic factors, 19
classroom environment, 74 5W organizers, 54 geography
classroom management, 81 flexibility, 2 body maps useful in, 58
cross-cultural, 126 flow, 85–86 explorations of existential questions,
curriculum development, 50 “flow room,” in model MI school, 130–131
curriculum planning, 20 85–86 logical-mathematical intelligence
determining intelligences of Ford, Henry, 56 applied in, 53

147
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

nature walk useful in lesson, 64 simulations useful in, 61–62 core operation(s), 8
simulations useful in, 61–62 history lesson developmental history,
geology, nature walk useful in lesson, nature walk useful in, 64 distinctiveness of, 3–7
64 plants as props in, 65 end-state performances, 3–7
Gershwin, George, 34 sample, 138–139 evolutionary history, 7
gestures, 76 Hitler, Adolf, 117 evolutionary plausibility, 7
goal-setting sessions, 63 holistic scoring, 101 Gardner’s concept of capacity for,
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von, 8–9 Holocaust, 130 1
Goodall, Jane, 4f, 34, 65 Howarth, John, 114 grouped into eight categories, 1–2
Goodlad, John, 38, 63, 82, 85 Howe, Oscar, 125f objectification of, 1
Goodman, Joel, 78 human intelligence hunt, 35–36, 36f prodigies, 4
government lesson, plants as props in, humanities, logical-mathematical in- psychometric findings, 7–8
65 telligence influence on, 53 psychological tasks, 8
grades, 23 Hungary, importance of music in, 124 savants, 4, 11, 104, 128
Graham, Martha, 4f Huxley, Aldous, 106f symbol system, encoding in, 8
Grandma Moses, 7 hyperactive student, managing behav- testing, 1, 23, 124
graphic symbols, 57, 76 ior, 80f testing for in MI theory, 3–8
group discussion table, 68, 71 hyperlexics, 3 valued in a culture, 123
groups, forming, 77–78 hypothesis testing, 2 vs. style, 10
Guernica (Picasso), 116 vs. talents/aptitudes/skills, 3
Guilford’s Structure of the Intellect, 10 idea sketching, 56–57, 115 intelligence-friendly activity centers,
ideographic languages, 4f 69–73
hand smart, 32, 33 (See also bodily- ideomotor dyspraxias, 104 intelligence language, 106
kinesthetic intelligence) In Their Own Way (Armstrong), 35 Intelligence Reframed: Multiple Intelli-
hands-on center, 68, 70 independence, opportunities for, 68 gences for the 21st Century (Gardner),
hands-on experience, 39–40, 68 individual behavior, managing, 11
hands-on learning, 83 78–79, 80f intelligences
hands-on thinking, 58 individualized education programs, activators of, 18–19
haptic capacity, 2 109, 110f all present in everybody, 8–9
Hart, Leslie, 80 informal assessment tests, 89 combinations of, 34
Hawking, Stephen, 106f inner blackboard, 55–56, 113 deactivators of, 18–19
Hayakawa, S. I., 125f Inouye, Daniel K., 125f diversity within, 9
herbal lore, 5f instructional strategies, 41f, 51–66, empowering in areas of difficulty,
heterogeneous mixed-age grouping, 106–109 107f
86 integrated curriculum, 39 interaction of, 9
heuristics, 55 Integrated Thematic Instruction, introducing children to, 31–33
high end-states, 4f 45–46, 72 nontransferance from one to
Hinduism, 129, 131 intelligence (See multiple intelli- another, 8
historical background, 17–18 gences; see also bodily-kinesthetic other, 9–10
historical factors, 6f intelligence, interpersonal intelli- simple terms for, 32–33
history gence, intrapersonal intelligence, intentions, sensitivity to, 2
discographies useful in, 59 linguistic intelligence, logical- interaction center, 71
explorations of existential questions, mathematical intelligence, musical interaction of intelligences, 9
130 intelligence, naturalist intelligence, Internet, 123
logical-mathematical intelligence spatial intelligence) interpersonal difficulty, 104, 107f
applied in, 53 brain damage, isolation by, 3 interpersonal intelligence, 2, 4f–6f,

148
Index

124 (See multiple intelligences; see landscape architecture center, 71 logical-mathematical difficulty, 104,
also people smart) language, abilities surrounding, 2 107f
cooperative learning’s emphasis language arts, people sculptures use- logical-mathematical intelligence, 2,
on, 39 ful in, 60 4f–6f, 109 (See multiple intelli-
teaching style resulting from, 17 language lab, 70 gences; see also logic smart, number
sample individualized education learning smart)
program, 110f materials, associating with different Einstein as example of, 35
teaching strategies for, 60–62 intelligences, 113 heuristics used in, 55
intrapersonal difficulty, 104, 107f methods of, 22f teaching strategies for, 53–55
intrapersonal intelligence, 2, 4f–6f, “learning about learning” course, 37 transitions, 77
124 (See multiple intelligences; see Learning Disabled Quarterly, 103 logical patterns, 2, 76
also self smart) learning-style theories, 10 logic smart, 32 (See also logical-
journals drawing on, 53 lectures, 51–52 mathematical intelligence)
tape recordings of inner thoughts, Lee, Yuan, 125f biography subjects, 34
52 Lessing, Doris, 54 children identifying end states of,
teaching strategies for, 62–63 lesson plans, 34 33
introspection, as part of alternative to address all intelligences, 44–45 field trips, 34
education model, 39 creating for MI theory, 44–45 in human intelligence hunt, 36f
ipsative assessment, 88, 101, 102 eight-way, 106–109 shelf displays, 35
IQ scores, 1 sample, 48f Lozanov, Georgi, 39
Islam, 130, 131 linguistic difficulty, 104, 107f
ITI model, 45–46, 72 linguistic intelligence, 2, 4f–6f (See MacDonald, James, 85
multiple intelligences; see also word Madame Curie, 4f
Jackson, Mahalia, 125f smart) Malcolm X, 125f
Johnson, Lyndon B., 115 assessments, 92 Mandela, Nelson, 4f
Johnson, Samuel, 106f heuristics useful in, 55 manipulatives, 39, 58, 68
Jordan (King), 106f symbolization in, 8 Marichal, Juan, 125f
journal writing, 53 teaching strategies for, 51–53 mathematical expertise, 6–7
Joyner-Kersee, Jackie, 125f tests relating to, 23 mathematics
Judaism, 129, 130 whole language instruction’s applied to interdisciplinary
Jung, Carl, 10 emphasis on, 39 curriculum, 54
linguistic pollution, 67 body maps useful in, 58
Kahlo, Frida, 4f, 125f Linnaeus, 106f explorations of existential questions,
karma, 130 listening lab, 70 129–130
Keller, Helen, 106f literature heuristics used in, 55
Kepler, Johannes, 106f explorations of existential questions, journals used for, 53
Key Learning Community, 85–86, 92 130 manipulatives useful in, 58
kindergarten records, value of, 28 journals used for, 53 musical concepts useful in, 59–60
kinesthetic concepts, 58 logical-mathematical intelligence people sculptures useful in, 60
kinesthetic imagery, 115 applied in, 53 story telling used for, 52
King, Martin Luther Jr., 4f, 34, 125f nature walk useful in study of, 64 thematic instruction for, 49f
Kipling, Rudyard, 106f Litzel, Otto, 106f math lab, 70
knowledge, 117–119f living things, 76 math lesson
Kodály, Zoltán, 124 lofts, 71 nature walk useful in, 64
Kovalik, Susan, 45–46, 72 logical-consequences approach, 78 pets as props in, 65
logical heuristics, 115 sample, 138

149
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

math smart experiential activities, 34 MI stories, 36–37 through, 77


Matlin, Marlee, 106f MI tables, 35 core operations of, 8
McKim, Robert, 11 MI teacher, 39–40 demonstration of, 93, 94f
Means, Russell, 125f MI teaching, materials and methods determining one’s own, 12
Mechanic’s Corner, 73 of, 40–44 and discipline methods, 78–79
memory, 112–113 MI theory. See multiple intelligences documentation of, 22–23, 99f
memory training, activating intelli- theory emphasizing relationship among,
gences during, 113 mnemonics, 2 to students, 37
Mendel, Gregor, 106f Moby Dick (Melville), 116, 130 end-state of, 7
mentors, access to, 18 Mohammed, 106f fairs, 124
Menuhin, Yehudi, 18 Monopoly, 72 in forming groups, 78
The Merchant of Venice (Shakespeare), Montessori, Maria, 39 in free time, 22
131 mood, sensitivity to, 2 in high-achieving people facing
metacognitive activity, 31 mood music, 60 personal challenges, 106f
metalanguage, 2 Mora, Elizabeth Catlett, 125f honoring and celebrating in
metaphor, 78–79 Morrison, Toni, 34, 125f classroom, 37
children as masters of, 56 motivations, sensitivity to, 2 inventory for adults, 12, 13f–16f
plants as props in, 65 movies about great teachers, 39 learning disabilities in, 104
methods and materials of MI teaching, Mozart, Leopold, 17 map for, 7
40–43 Mozart, Wolfgang Amadeus, 6, method of learning through, 22f
MI assessment 17–18, 114 memory and, 112, 113
contexts, 96f–97f multimodal teaching, history of, minority culture, examples of, 125f
students’ reaction to, 101 38–39 neglect of individual intelligences,
Michelangelo, 7, 131 multiple-choice tests, 88 109
Midori, 4f, 125f multiple intelligences plan for addressing variety of,
MI Inventory for Adults, 13f–16f adult development of, 17–18 44–45
MI lessons activity centers, 70–74 problem solving and, 114–115
high school, chemistry, 139–140 anecdotal records, 22–23 remedial strategies, 108f
junior high school, algebra, 139 approach to gaining class’s attention, school records, 23–28
kindergarten/1st grade, reading, 75, 76 software to activate, 122
137–138 assessing in students, 21–29 strategies and tools, 40, 51–55,
preschool/shapes, 137 avoiding exploitation of, 86 64–66, 107f
2nd/3rd grade, math, 138 assessments, 92 tapping resources of, 12–17
upper elementary, history, 138–139 and behavior management, 21–22, teaching methods and materials,
mind-mapping, 115 80f 40–43
mind-maps, 52, 54 careers based on, 124–125 teaching to, 29, 51–66
MI Pizza, 29, 32, 33f, 37 challenging students’ beliefs tested in Wechsler Intelligence
MI planning questions, 45f through, 116–117 Scale for Children, 7
MI Planning Sheet, 44, 46f, 47f checklist for assessing, 24, 25f, 26f, tests relating to, 23, 24
MI plays, 36–37 27f thematic instruction and, 49f
MI portfolio checklist, 98–101, 99f, children identifying end states of, in traditional school programs, 84f
100f 33 and transitions, 76–77
misbehavior, clues provided by, classroom environment for, 67–69 multiple intelligences theory, 1 (See
21–22 combination of assessment and Gardner, Howard)
MI school, 83–86 activity in, 96f–97f activities for teaching, 33–37
MI songs, 36–37 communication of class rules application to educators and adult

150
Index

learners, 12 assessments, 92 in human intelligence hunt, 36f


avoiding stereotypes from, 124 core operations, 8 MI tables, 35
Bloom’s levels of cognitive sample individualized education shelf displays, 35
complexity, 117–120 program, 110f nature walks, 64
connections to different tapping resources for, 17 neurological systems, 5f
disciplines, 11 teaching strategies for, 59–60 Newton, Isaac, 129
core components, 4f valued at different times, 7 Nietzsche, Friedrich, 106f
cultural values, 5f valued in Anang culture, 124 Nijinsky, Vaslav, 106f
developmental factors, 5f musical phrases, 76 nonliving forms, discrimination
in development of individualized musical strategies and tools, 107f among, 2
educational programs, 109 music composition ability, 6 notational systems, 8
evolutionary origins, 6f, 7 music lab, 70 number smart, 32 (See also logical-
focused on contents, 10 music performance center, 70 mathematical intelligence)
as growth paradigm, 103–104 music smart, 32 (See also musical careers, 34
high end-states, 4f intelligence) children identifying end states of,
historical context, 7 biography subjects, 34 33
historical factors, 6f careers, 34 MI tables, 35
implemented in range of children identifying end states of, numbers, capacity to use, 2
instructional contexts, 40 33 numeracy, 53–54
implications of for special experiential activities, 34 nurture, 18
education, 103–105, 109–111 field trips, 34
introducing children to, 31–33 in human intelligence hunt, 36f observation, 21–23, 88–89
key points in, 8–9 MI tables, 35 Ochoa, Severo, 125
neurological systems, 5f shelf displays, 35 “off-task” tendency as positive
other applications, 121 Myers-Briggs model, 10, 31 strategy, 64
presence of MI in other species, 6f one-minute reflection periods, 62
relationship to other intelligence naturalist difficulties, 104, 107f Orthodox Christianity, 131
theories, 10 naturalist intelligence, 2, 4f–6f (See Otello, 86
summary chart, 4f–6f multiple intelligences; see also na- outline, 52
symbol systems, 4f ture smart)
theoretical basis for, 3–8 heuristics useful in, 55 pantomimes, 58
understandable by young possible premium on in future, 7 paralyzing experiences, 18
children, 31 teaching strategies for, 64–66 parents, sources of information about
Multiple Intelligences: The Theory in valued at different times, 7 different intelligences, 28–29, 30
Practice (Gardner), 11 valued in Puluwat culture, Pascal, Blaise, 4f, 6
music 123–124 Patton, George, 106f
as part of alternative education naturalist’s corner, 92 Pearson (Eliot) Children’s School, 92
models, 39 nature, 18 Peary (Admiral), 106f
sensitivity to, 2 nature smart, 32 (See also naturalist peer group counseling, 79
musical concepts, 59–60 intelligence) peer sharing, 60
musical difficulty, 104, 107f biography subjects, 34 peer teaching desks, 71
musical intelligence, 2, 3, 4f–6f (See careers, 34 peer tutoring, 60
multiple intelligences; see also music children identifying end states of, Pei, I. M., 4f, 125f
smart) 33 people sculpture, 60–61, 65
approach to gaining class’s experiential activities, 34 people smart, 32 (See also interper-
attention, 76 field trips, 34 sonal intelligence)

151
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

biography subjects, 34 picture smart, 32 (See also spatial psychometric studies, existential intel-
children identifying end states of, intelligence) ligence and, 128
33 biography subjects, 34 publishing, 53
experiential activities, 34 board games, 36 Puluwat culture, 123–124
field trips, 34 careers, 34 puppet shows, 58
in human intelligence hunt, 36f children identifying end states of, Puritans, 130
MI tables, 35 33 Pygmalion effect, 105
shelf displays, 35 experiential activities, 34 Pythagoras, 129–130
smart careers, 34 field trips, 34
performance-based assessments, 92 in human intelligence hunt, 36f quantifications, 54
Perlman, Itzhak, 106f MI tables, 35
permanent open-ended activity cen- shelf displays, 35 Rachmaninoff, Sergei, 106f
ters, 69–71 PIFS Units, 92 Rain Man, 3
permanent topic-specific (shifting) ac- Pilgrim’s Progress (Bunyan), 130 rapping, raps, 41, 59
tivity centers, 72–73 plant center, 71 Ravel, Maurice, 106f
personal challenges, high-achieving plants as props, 65 reading center, 71
people facing, 106f Plato, 38, 130 reading sample lesson, 137–138
personal connections, 62–63 pods, in model MI school, 85 reading, thematic instruction for, 49f
personal intelligence Poe, Edgar Allan, 106f readings on multiple intelligences, 35
map for, 7 Poincaré, Henri, 114 Redmond, Granville, 106f
problem solving and, 115 Pope, Alexander, 106f religion, 5f, 130
school counselor source of Poplin, Mary, 103 Remembrance of Things Past (Proust),
information about, 28 portfolio development, 98 (See also 115
standardized tests for, 8 MI portfolio checklist) resources, access to, 18
personality disorders, 104 positive interaction, opportunities, rhetoric, 2
personality theory, 10 for, 68 rhythms, 59, 60
personal life history, 17–18 Postman, Neil, 31–32 Rite of Spring (Stravinsky), 116
Pestalozzi, Johann Heinrich, 38–39 The Powers of Ten (Morrison & Morri- rites of passage, 5f
pet-in-the-classroom, 65 son), 129 Rockefeller, Nelson, 106f
pet therapy, 79 Practical Intelligence for School Units, Rodin, Auguste, 4f, 106f
philosophy, 130 92 Rodrigo, Joaquin, 106f
The Philosophy of Childhood presence of MI in other species, 6f Rogers, Carl, 4f
(Matthews), 129 presentation skills, 42f role play, 79
photographs, 23 problem solving, 1, 112, 113–115 Roman Catholicism, 130, 131
photography, as assessment tool, 89 processfolios, 92 Ronstadt, Linda, 125f
physical cues, 79 proclivities, 21–22 Roosevelt, Franklin, 106f
physical education classes, flawed in product creation, capacity for as intel- root words, 57
traditional schooling, 82 ligence indicator, 1 Rousseau, Jean Jacques, 38, 106f
physical learning, 57 project-centered instruction, 83 rubrics, 101
physical movements, 76 Project Spectrum, 92
physical skills, 2 Project Zero, 69fn, 87, 91 Sacks, Oliver, 11
Piaget, map for logical-mathematical proprioceptive capacity, 2 Saint Marie, Buffy, 125f
intelligence, 7 prosopagnosia, 104 savants, 4, 11, 104, 128
Picasso, Pablo, 116 Proust, Marcel, 115 school-community broker, 84
Pictionary, 56, 72 psychological studies, intelligences school records, 23–28
picture metaphors, 56 working in isolation, 8 schools of the future, 86

152
Index

schoolwide themes, in model MI simulations, 61–62 strengths of, 105


school, 85 situational factors, 19 speed, 2
Schumann, Robert, 106f “six-hour retarded child,” 28–29 sports smart, 32, 33 (See also bodily-
science Skylight/IRI, 35 kinesthetic intelligence)
explorations of existential questions, social area, 71 Stand and Deliver, 39
129 social sciences, logical-mathematical standardized tests, 88, 90f–91f,
heuristics used in, 55 intelligence influence on, 53 92–93
journals used for, 53 social signals, 76 in deficit paradigm, 104f
logical-mathematical intelligence social studies informal use of, 89
applied in, 53 nature walk useful in lesson, 64 insufficiency of, 12
manipulatives useful in, 58 thematic instruction for, 49f vs. authentic assessment, 90f–91f
nature walk useful in, 64 sociograms, 89 storytelling, 5f, 52
people sculptures useful in, 60 sociopathies, 104 storytelling area, 92
story telling used for, 52 Socrates, 54 Stravinsky, Igor, 116
thematic instruction for, 49f Socratic questioning, 54–55 strength, 2
thinking, 55 software, computer, 121, 122f, 123 strength profiles, 30
science center, 70 songs, 59 strengths, greater emphasis on identi-
science lesson, plants as props in, 65 spatial difficulty, 104, 107f fying, 110
Scrabble, 72 spatial frameworks, 54 Structure of the Intellect, 10
selective abilities, 8 spatial intelligence, 2, 3, 4f–6f (See student-curriculum broker, 83,
self-assessment, 92, 124 multiple intelligences; see also pic- 109–110
self-concept, heightening of, 69 ture smart) student interviews, 89
self-discipline, 2 art teacher, source of information student journals, 89
self-esteem, 2, 79, 110 about, 28 student-kept charts, 89
self-evaluation, 101 effect of limited development on students
self-fulfilling prophecy, 105 teachers, 12–17 contribution of intelligences to
self-knowledge, 2 Einstein as example of, 35 classroom, 17
self smart, 32 (See also intrapersonal grades as indicator of, 23 gaining attention of, 75–75
intelligence) possible premium on in future, 7 ranking of U.S. vs. others, 113–114
biography subjects, 34 sample individualized education sources of information about
careers, 34 program, 110f different intelligences, 29, 30
children identifying end states of, symbolization in, 8 study carrels, 68, 71
33 teaching strategies for, 55–57 “A Study of Schooling” (Goodlad), 38,
experiential activities, 34 valued at different times, 7 63, 82
field trips, 34 Spearman’s “g,” 10 Suarez, Xavier L., 125f
in human intelligence hunt, 36f special education, 103 Suggestopedia, 39
MI tables, 35 fewer referrals to classes, 109 Sullivan, Harry Stack, 106f
shelf displays, 35 focus on what students can’t do, Sullivan, Tom, 106f
self-talk, 78, 115 103 supermemory music, 59
self-understanding, 2 placement, 109 Suzuki Talent Education Program, 9,
sensory-channel model, 10 programs, in deficit and growth 18
7 Kinds of Smart (Armstrong), 20, 35 paradigms, 104f symbolizing, importance of, 8
Shakespeare, William, 130, 131 students, increased understanding symbol systems, 4f, 8, 11, 127
shapes sample lesson, 137 and appreciation of, 110–111 synthesis, 117–119f
shelf displays, 35 teacher, changing role for, 109–110
Simon, 72 special-needs students, focus on tactile capacity, 2

153
MULTIPLE INTELLIGENCES IN THE CLASSROOM

tactile-learning area, 70 textbooks, 51–52 warm-up exercises, 58


Taking Religion Seriously Across the Cur- thematic instruction, 45–46, 49f, 58 Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Chil-
riculum (Nord & Haynes), 129 Thompson, Nainoa, 125f dren, 7
Tan, Amy, 125f Thorpe, Jim, 125f Weinstein, Matt, 78
tape recordings, 52–53 time in the classroom, 67–68 Whitman, Robert, 125f
taxonomies, folk, 5f time lines, 54, 57 whole-body movements, 113
taxonomy of educational objectives time outs, 62 whole language and linguistic intelli-
(Bloom), 117 Toulouse-Lautrec, Henri de, 106f gence, 39
teachers topological thinking, 5f Wilson, E. O., 4f, 106f
in multiple intelligences approach, traditional school, 82–83, 84f Win, Lose or Draw, 56
39–40 transitions, 76–77 windows onto learning, 64–65
sources of information about translating among intelligences, 44 withdrawn student, managing behav-
different intelligences, 28, 30 Truman, Harry, 106f ior, 80f
in traditional linguistic classrooms, Tufts University, 92 Wonder, Stevie, 4f
39–40 tutoring, 60 Woolf, Virginia, 4f, 54
training programs, in MI school, 85 Twister, 72, 86 word smart, 32 (See also linguistic
voice of, 68 intelligence)
teaching Ulysses (Joyce), 130 biography subjects, 34
activities, 41f The Ungame, 72 careers, 34
materials, 41f The Unschooled Mind (Gardner), 116 experiential activities, 34
repertoire, expansion of, 38–39 field trips, 34
strategies, adapting to different Van Gogh, Vincent, 34, 106f in human intelligence hunt, 36f
children, 51 Venn diagram, 52, 54 MI tables, 35
strategies for multiple intelligences, videotapes, for assessment, 89, 92 shelf displays, 35
51–66 Vineland Society Maturity Scale, 8 working styles, 92
strengths, multiple intelligences visual aids, as part of alternative edu- work samples, 89
theory used to determine, 12–17 cation model, 39 worksheets, 51–52
summary of teaching through MI, Visual-Auditory-Kinesthetic model, writing, thematic instruction for, 49f
41f–42f 10 writing center, 70
through neglected intelligences, 109 visualization, 55–56, 65, 113, 115
team teaching, implications of MI the- visual media center, 70 Xerox/Kurzweil Personal Reader,
ory for, 17 visual-spatial perception, 2 105–106
technology, 17, 121–123 visual-thinking area, 70
temporary open-ended activity cen- vocational education, 57 Yamaguchi, Kristi, 125f
ters, 71–72 Vygotsky, Lev, 7, 52 year-long themes, 44, 46
temporary topic-specific activity cen-
ters, 71 wall displays, 35 Zephyr Press, 35

154
About the Author

Thomas Armstrong is the author of Your Child’s Natural Genius. For further
two other books by ASCD, Awakening Genius information about his work, visit his Web site
in the Classroom and ADD/ADHD Alternatives in (http://www.thomasarmstrong.com). To contact
the Classroom, as well as several trade books him, write: P.O. Box 548, Cloverdale, CA 95425;
including In Their Own Way, 7 Kinds of Smart, phone: 707-894-4646; fax: 707-894-4474; or
The Myth of the A.D.D. Child, and Awakening e-mail: thomas@thomasarmstrong.com.
Related ASCD Resources: Multiple Intelligences
Audiotapes
Authentic Assessment Using the Multiple Intelligences (stock no. 299191)
How Multiple Intelligences and Learning Style Fit: The Research and Practical Applications (stock no.
298137)
Multiple Assessments for Multiple Intelligences by Beth Swartz (stock no. 296267)
Multiple Intelligences—Putting a Theory into Practice by Helen Flamm, Connie Canter, Ernest Flamm, &
Carolyn Wheeler (stock no. 296117)
On Multiple Intelligences and Education by Howard Gardner (stock no. 295056)
Teaching for Understanding Through Multiple Intelligences by Geni Boyer (stock no. 297078)
Teaching Thinking to Multiple Intelligences and Diverse Student Populations by Richard Strong (stock no.
294022)

CD-ROM
Exploring Our Multiple Intelligences (stock no. 596276)

Online Course
Multiple Intelligences Professional Development Online course (http://www.ascd.org/pdi/pd.html)

Print Products
ASCD Topic Pack—Multiple Intelligences (stock no. 198220)
Becoming a Multiple Intelligences School by Thomas R. Hoerr (stock no. 100006) (see also Videotapes)
Multiple Intelligences and Student Achievement: Success Stories from Six Schools by Linda Campbell and
Bruce Campbell (stock no. 199274)

Videotapes
Becoming a Multiple Intelligences School, Books in Action Video Series (Video only: stock no. 400213;
10 copies of book plus video: stock no. 700218)
The Multiple Intelligences Series by Bruce and Linda Campbell (stock no. 495003)

For more information, visit us on the World Wide Web (http://www.ascd.org), send an e-mail mes-
sage to member@ascd.org, call the ASCD Service Center (1-800-933-ASCD or 703-578-9600, then
press 2), send a fax to 703-575-5400, or write to Information Services, ASCD, 1703 N. Beauregard St.,
Alexandria, VA 22311-1714 USA.
BookMmbrAd/7.875x9.875 7/8/02 12:10 PM Page 1

If you like this book,


you’ll LOVE the membership!
J O I N A S C D TO G E T O U R AWA R D - W I N N I N G R E S O U R C E S A L L Y E A R L O N G !

F
ounded in 1943, the Association for Supervision and Curriculum
Development (ASCD) is an international, nonpartisan, not-for-profit
education association dedicated to the success of all learners. ASCD
provides many services to educators—kindergarten through grade
12—as well as others in the education community, including administrators,
school board members, university professors, and parents.
ASCD membership is a convenient, low-cost way to stay current
on the best new ideas for K–College educators. ASCD member benefits
include the following:
◆ Educational Leadership magazine—Eight issues of our flagship
publication, read by over a quarter-million educators worldwide
◆ Education Update newsletter—Eight issues of the newsletter
that keeps you up-to-date on news and trends in education,
as well as ASCD activities and events
◆ Curriculum Update newsletter—Four issues of an award-
winning newsletter reporting education trends, research findings,
programs, and resources in specific grade levels and subjects
◆ Newly published Member Books on topics critical to K–College
educators, delivered to you throughout the year
◆ Low Member Prices on resources and meetings, saving you
a bundle throughout the year on your professional development
resources and activities
◆ Around-the-clock online access to major ASCD publications,
including searchable back issues of Educational Leadership
and Education Update and a vast archive of other educational
resources
◆ Access to ASCD Networks and Affiliates—special groups which
offer learning opportunities and networking with colleagues

JOIN TODAY!
BECOMING AN ASCD MEMBER IS QUICK AND EASY!
Check out our membership site on the Internet: www.ascd.org
or
Call (toll-free in the United States and Canada):
800-933-ASCD (2723) or 703-578-9600

® AS S O C I AT I O N F O R S U P E RV I S I O N A N D C U R R I C U L U M D E V E L O P M E N T
1703 North Beauregard Street Alexandria, VA 22311-1714 USA

Anda mungkin juga menyukai