Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Learning outcomes
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Contents of element
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Contents of element
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Definitions of hazard and risk
Hazard
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Definitions of hazard and risk
Risk
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Objectives of risk assessment
General points
“An identification of what within your work or workplace, which may have the
potential to cause harm to people or workers, so that you can consider whether you
have provided sufficient precautions or need to do more to prevent harm”
Involves:
• Identification of the hazards at work
• Evaluation of the risks from the hazards
• Deciding how to control the risks
• Implementing a control strategy
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Outcomes of incidents
• Human harm
• Legal
• Economic
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Different types of incident
• Ill-health
• Injury accident
• Dangerous occurrence
• Near-miss
• Damage only
• The distinction between different incidents in summary
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Different types of incident
Ill-health
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Different types of incident
Injury accident
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Different types of incident
Dangerous occurrence
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Different types of incident
Near-miss
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Different types of incident
Damage-only
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Results of an accident
Equipment damage
Near Miss Minor Injury Death
Source: ACT
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Different types of incident
The distinction between different incidents in summary
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Different types of incident
The distinction between different incidents in summary
• Fatal accident
- If the person was working directly under the stone when it
fell there could have been a fatality
• The difference between a near-miss and a fatal accident in
terms of time and distance can be very small indeed
• An old adage says “Never waste an accident”
• A near miss is just as valuable as a serious injury/damage, in
fact even more valuable and an excellent opportunity not to
be missed
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Typical ratios of incident outcomes and their relevance
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Frank Bird’s accident ratio study
10 Minor injuries
30 Property damage
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Aims and objectives
Utility and limitations of accident ratios in accident
prevention
• For statistics derived to be of value their limitations have to
be understood
• Variables in work methods, hours of work, hazard controls
and management system
• Difficult to make comparisons outside the organisation
deriving the data
• Ratios are best suited to comparison of performance of the
same organisation over similar periods of time, for example
yearly
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Contents of element
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Identifying hazards
• Identifying hazards
• Accidents in terms of injury
• Health related hazards
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Identifying hazards
Identifying hazards
Sources and form of harm
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Identifying hazards
Identifying hazards
Roles of inspections
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Identifying hazards
Identifying hazards
Job / task safety analysis
• Job based
• Task based
• Intrinsic hazards
• Incidence of accidents
• Work organisation
• Tasks
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Identifying hazards
Identifying hazards
Example of a job/task analysis
Task Hazards Good Skills Influences on Learning Method
behaviour
1 Sharpening a knife Cuts to hand, arms Co-ordination of knife and Sharpness of knife Demonstration of
using a steel steel movement Condition of knife technique
Space limitations Repetitive practice
Other people present until speed increases
Condition of floor
2 Dispensing strong Burns to eyes, face and Correct position of drum Strength of chemicals Demonstration of
chemical compounds body cradle, drip tray and Type of fume techniques
from 200 litre container Inhalation of fumes container, use of tap Corrosive effects Practice using PPE
Correct protection Illumination Hazards of spillage,
clothing, fitting and Ventilation splashing and fumes
limitations
Source: ACT
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Identifying hazards
Identifying hazards
Legislation
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Identifying hazards
Identifying hazards
Manufacturers’ information
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Identifying hazards
Identifying hazards
Incident data
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Identifying hazards
Accidents in terms of injury
Hazard Associated risks
Slips/trips/falls Fall of a person on the same level
Falls from height; falling objects Fall of a person; object/material
Collision with objects Bumps and bruises. Striking head on low beams
Trapping/crushing under or Serious injury caused by loss of load from crane, collision with site
between object/s vehicles
Manual handling Back strains, cuts, injury to joints
Contact with machinery/hand Parts being ejected from the machine and trapping a person. Trapping
tools / crushing hands etc. Entanglement of clothing or hair.
Electricity Fire, shock, burns
Transport Collision with people and/or property
Contact with chemicals Dermatitis, burns, poisoning
Asphyxiation/drowning Drowning
Fire and explosion Static electrical sparks causing explosions in say, flammable or dusty
atmospheres
Animals Anthrax, psittacosis caused by coming into contact with animal hides
Violence Unhappy customers/clients, criminals, patients in hospitals
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Identifying hazards
Health related hazards
• Chemical hazards
• Biological hazards
• Physical hazards
• Psychological hazards
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Identifying hazards
Health related hazards
Chemical hazards
Acids and alkalis - dermatitis and burns
Metals - lead and mercury poisoning
Non metals - arsenic and phosphorus poisoning
Gases - carbon monoxide poisoning, arsine poisoning
Organic compounds - occupational cancers
Dust - silicosis, coal worker’s pneumoconiosis
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Identifying hazards
Health related hazards
Biological hazards
Animal-borne - anthrax, brucellosis, leptospirosis
Human-borne - viral hepatitis
Vegetable-borne - aspergillosis (farmer’s lung)
Others (water/land) - legionella
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Identifying hazards
Health related hazards
Physical hazards
Heat - heat cataract, heat stroke
Lighting - miner’s nystagmus
Noise - noise induced hearing loss
Vibration - vibration induced white finger
Radiation - radiation sickness, burns, arc eye
Pressure - decompression sickness
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Identifying hazards
Health related hazards
Psychological hazards
Work pressure, bullying - stress, alcohol / narcotic abuse
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Contents of element
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Identifying population at risk
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Identification of hazards
• Walk around
• Ask workers
• Trade association
• Check manufacturers’ instructions
• Accident and ill-health records
• Long-term hazards to health
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Evaluating risk and adequacy of current controls
• Likelihood of harm and probable severity
• Qualitative and semi-quantitative risk ranking
• Residual risk
• Acceptable / tolerable risk levels
• Use of guidance
• Sources and examples of legislation
• Applying controls to specified hazards
• General control hierarchy
• Prioritisation based on risk
• Distinction between priorities and time scales
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Evaluating risk and adequacy of current controls
Likelihood of harm and probable severity
• Consequence
• Likelihood
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Evaluating risk and adequacy of current controls
Likelihood of harm and probable severity
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Evaluating risk and adequacy of current controls
Qualitative and semi-quantitative risk ranking
• Qualitative
• Semi-quantitative
• Risk ranking
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Evaluating risk and adequacy of current controls
Consequence categories
5. Major Causing death to one or more people. Loss or damage is such that it could
cause serious business disruption (e.g. major fire, explosion or structural
damage). Loss/damage in excess of (£___________).
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Evaluating risk and adequacy of current controls
Likelihood categories
5. Almost Certain Absence of any management controls. If conditions remain unchanged
there is almost a 100% certainty that an accident will happen (e.g. broken
rung on a ladder, live exposed electrical conductor, and untrained
personnel).
4. High Serious failures in management controls. The effects of human
behaviour or other factors could cause an accident but is unlikely without
this additional factor (e.g. ladder not secured properly, oil spilled on floor,
poorly trained personnel).
3. Medium Insufficient or substandard controls in place. Loss is unlikely during
normal operation, however it may occur in emergencies or non-routine
conditions (e.g. keys left in forklift trucks; obstructed gangways; refresher
training required).
2. Low The situation is generally well managed, however occasional lapses
could occur. This also applies to situations where people are required to
behave safely in order to protect themselves but are well trained.
1. Improbable Loss, accident or illness could only occur under freak conditions. The
situation is well managed and all reasonable precautions have been
taken. Ideally, this should be the normal state of the workplace.
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Evaluating risk and adequacy of current controls
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Evaluating risk and adequacy of current controls
Residual risk
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Evaluating risk and adequacy of current controls
Acceptable/tolerable risk levels
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Evaluating risk and adequacy of current controls
Use of guidance
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Evaluating risk and adequacy of current controls
Sources and examples of legislation
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Evaluating risk and adequacy of current controls
Applying controls to specified hazards
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Evaluating risk and adequacy of current controls
General control hierarchy
• E liminate
• R educe
• I solation
• C ontrol
• P ersonal protective equipment
• D iscipline
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Evaluating risk and adequacy of current controls
Prioritisation based on risk
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Evaluating risk and adequacy of current controls
Distinction between priorities and time scales
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Recording significant findings
• Format
• Information to be recorded
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Recording significant findings
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Reasons for reviewing
Examples of circumstances
• When results of monitoring are adversely not as expected
• A change in process, work methods or materials
• Changes in the workforce
• Changes in legislation
• Introduction of new plant or technology
• New information becoming available
• As time passes by - the risk assessment should be periodically reviewed and updated
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Reviewing
Monitoring techniques
• Preventive maintenance inspections
• Safety representative / committee inspections
• Statutory and maintenance scheme inspections, tests and examinations
• Safety tours and inspections
• Occupational health surveys
• Air monitoring
• Safety audits
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Criteria for a ‘suitable and sufficient’ risk assessment
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Principles and practice of risk assessment
Special case applications of risk assessment
• Young persons
• Expectant and nursing mothers
• Disabled workers
• Lone workers
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT
Risk assessment
Contents of element
Copyright – MSRS Safety Health & Environment Training Services Inc. RISK ASSESSMENT