The name M-Pesa is derived from the Swahili word pesa, meaning cash. M-PESA
allows users to make four basic types of transaction:
The M-Pesa service platform, developed in-house by Vodafone and the consulting
company Sagentia, integrates a mobile wallet with Safaricom’s rating, billing and
provisioning systems.
Subscribers of Safaricom can register for the M-Pesa service by filling up a simple
form and providing any identification proof. Once registered, Safaricom replaces their
SIM with the M-Pesa enabled SIM (if required, all new mobile subscribers now get
the M-Pesa enabled SIM). To load the money on the the wallet, the user needs to visit
the nearest agent and deposit cash there in exchange for “e-Float”. This e-Float is like
currency that can be used to make payments or transfer to any other person. The e-
Float is can be transferred to any person or merchant via encrypted SMS. The receiver
of the virtual currency can either use it for further transactions or can cash-out from
M-Pesa designated outlets. The figure along side depicts the M-Pesa transaction flow.
Safaricom has regularly been releasing the financials of M-Pesa service which have
been impressive by any standard:
• Pricing- Safaricom kept the pricing of the product very transparent and lower
than other alternatives. Free registration and no monthly fee helped the agents
in persuading the potential user to subscribe to the service. This helped in
building up the customer base initially that was important for agent and
merchant recruitment.
• Store Management -- Safaricom ensured consistent branding, training and
constant supervision of the stores to deliver the right user experience. It
worked tirelessly for proper liquidity management at the stores.
• Limited KYC -- M-Pesa was not positioned as a bank alternative and hence
the “Know Your Customer” requirements were quite relaxed. The users were
required to submit only the identity proof to get the service started. This
limited KYC helped many Kenyans especially in the rural areas where the
address proofs and other documents required by the banks are not available
with most of the Kenyans. People who were not able to fulfill the
documentation requirements of the bank saw M-Pesa a good alternative.
• Dedicated Customer Care Line - In Kenya, not everyone can read, so
sometimes people make mistakes and send money to the wrong person, so
Safaricom established back office support to assist people get the money back
where possible. M-PESA has its own dedicated call centre with its own
number. Safaricom ensures that a very high quality of customer care is
maintained. The strong back office support has helped the company in not
only building trust but also attracted the users who are afraid of technology.
Despite being touted as a financial inclusion service, M-Pesa user households are
twice more likely to have a bank account than non-user households. It is young, male,
urban migrants who are driving the uptake of services – customer adoption. Hence,
the adoption is not uniform across social strata.
Both agents and customers complain of cash float problems, especially in the rural
areas. Because the majority of transactions in the village are withdrawals, agents must
maintain their cash float. They do this by making frequent trips to the bank. This can
be problematic if the agent is not close to an urban centre, where most banks in Kenya
are located. This situation is frequent despite great efforts by Safaricom on the store
liquidity management.
All in all, M-Pesa is a great service which is brining in big benefits to the company
and the users. In my next post, I am going to talk about the economic benefits that this
services has brought to the people of Kenya.
In the meantime, please leave a comment on your take on M-Pesa service and what
you think are the reasons for its success?
References:
1. Three keys to M-PESA’s success: Branding, channel management and pricing (by
Ignacio Mas and Amolo Ng’weno, Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation)
If you liked this article, you may consider subscribing to Telecom Circle to get all
the articles in your mail box
Subscribe
Enter your email address:
Related Posts:
12 Comments
1.
Sachin Bhavsar
Hi
Having said that M Pesa can be really successful model in India, comparing
the mammoth number of Subscribers, but it is really a dampener in terms of
Regulatory compliance and acceptance of common platform between banks
and telcos.
I would state and this is my personal views that, M Pesa was succesful since
government in the region was lenient in the regulatory norms or in other words
since Regulatory was not a constraint hence it was more successful.
With 500 Million subscribers, there should be not be doubt of M Pesa getting
it own desi version soon.
Cheers
Sachin Bhavsar
Reply
2.
Robert Syputa
Reply
Robert Syputa
This subject is important: both of itself and also how this conspires
with business-social networking enablers and markets. I can think of
several worthwhile businesses that can be created.. that are also
socially responsible.
Robert Syputa
Reply
3.
Gaurav
Reply
4.
prashantn
This way the KYC is eliminated, at the same time, the transactions can be
traced through the UID numbers.
Reply
5.
Reply
o
Ian Bastow
Thanks Mohit for your very interesting articles – also Robert for the
link to Beam. The convergence between mobile and SaaS will create
an amazing social, economic and computing revolution over the next
decade, and m-commerce is at the top of the list.
Reply
6.
Jaco
good article
Reply
Trackbacks
Leave a Response
Name
Website
Submit Comment
The business models depend a lot on the regulatory freedom given by the
central banks. There are essentially three prevalent business models in the
field of MMT.
The business models in mobile money transfer are very similar to mobile
payments. For further details on these models, please refer to my earlier post
on mobile payments business models
Critical Success Factors
The process of mobile money transfer may look very simple and intuitive but
there are many factors that could derail the evolution of this exciting money
transfer mechanism. A few of the critical success factors are listed below:
The story of M-PESA that most of us know usually goes as follows. The two big
players, Vodafone and Safaricom, got together to develop and launch M-PESA. They
spent months testing, adjusting, and re-testing the system before it went live. The
result—an immensely popular service offering that has radically changed both the
financial and telecommunications sectors in developing countries and spawned a
lucrative industry for mobile money. This is not exactly how the story went, at least
not in the early days. Vodafone, led by a powerful duo of Nick Hughes and Susie
Lonie, was heavily involved from the beginning. While Nick was selling the service
idea to the executive staff at Vodafone, Susie was getting her hands dirty, so to speak,
and leading the pilot in Kenya.
Although Safaricom provided support throughout the pilot (access to desk space, a
small customer care and finance team, technical integration and support) they did not
dedicate a larger team to the project until commercial launch. This is not surprising.
The mobile network operator (MNO) was still focused on growing their customer
base. The introduction of a service that radically differed from their core service
offering was risky. Many also questioned whether M-PESA could beat out a form of
value transfer that was already in place—airtime.
So, if Safaricom was not heavily involved in the pilot then who was? There was also
a smaller player that had a vitally important role in the conceptualization and
development of the application. That is, Sagentia, a technology consultancy firm
based out of Cambridge. The firm not only wrote the software for M-PESA, they also
designed the business processes, and provided operational and technical support
during the pilot and after launch.
Recently, I was lucky to meet the initial development team of Sagentia (now they
have formed their own company called Iceni Mobile) at their offices just outside of
Cambridge. Several interesting findings came out of this discussion. Firstly, the firm
emphasized that a small and dedicated team is important, especially when two big
players are working together. M-PESA needed a significant amount of attention from
the beginning. The demand for such attention increased as M-PESA grew rapidly—
surpassing 2 million customers within their first year. Members of the team told
stories of being on-call 24/7, and resolving system issues in the middle of the night.
There is no doubt that it would have been difficult to get such attention from either of
the MNO giants. Usually, these companies lack the resources (human, time) that are
needed for the development of this type of system. This is especially the case if the
product has not yet gained the confidence of those at the very top.
Furthermore, the design of the application interface and entire system underwent
several iterations. It began as a tool for the repayment of MFI loans. It was launched
as a P2P transfer service. Such changes were made because the pilot team did their
research, and closely monitored usage patterns. Their findings in the field were then
fed back into the design of the application. The team explained that to react to these
changes, they focused on flexible design. This has paid off generously as M-PESA
moves across other contexts, which have very different needs and usage patterns.
I ended the discussion by asking the team what they planned to focus on next. How do
you, after all, beat a success like M-PESA? They assured me that M-PESA was just
the beginning. Using the mobile as a platform, they plan to create developmental
services that penetrate other spheres —m-health, agribusiness. They further predicted
that the mobile will soon begin to revolutionize these other spaces as well. This is a
very exciting proposition. If the mobile phone can penetrate and transform financial
sector, which is dominated by old and powerful players, imagine what it can do in
these other spaces.
Tomorrow's Phones Today: Extending Mobile
Applications into the Developing World
February 28, 2010 at 6:00pm
Do you remember when cellular phones were bulky, grayscale and used solely for
voice-based communication, less than a decade ago? Now fast forward ten years, and
cellular phones have radically transformed into miniature computer terminals; able to
access the Internet, download videos, transmit and store high quality pictures, and
serve as a repository for leisurely activities like games and cooking guides. Indeed,
we have witnessed a wide chasm form between mass-market phones and “smart
phones”, which offer much more interaction through graphical and video
interfaces. Although mass-market phones have been extremely useful tools in the
developing world, the latest hardware and software development trends have been
tailored for smart phones, which are mainly utilized in developed nations. In this
regard, the next decade of development efforts and infrastructural improvements in
the mobile world appear to be poised to correct this digital divide by providing smart
phones at low cost to developing countries.
As Google CEO Eric Schmidt put it at the recently-concluded Mobile Word Congress
in Barcelona:
"We understand that the new rule is mobile first… in everything. Mobile
first in terms of applications. Mobile first in terms of the way people use things. And it
means that we have a role now to inform, to educate through all these devices."1
Without a doubt, the most radical shift in the mobile industry enabling mass
marketing of smart phone applications has been the disaggregation of software
creation. The barriers to entry for new software solutions have been lowered
dramatically, exemplified by the launch of Apple’s Developer Kit and the open-
source Android platform. A shift from a previously oligopolistic industry structure to
a more competitive environment has taken place, where independent developers with
relatively little capital can leverage existing hardware platforms to produce their own
niche. Indeed, independent entrepreneurs in various parts of the world can readily
enhance the value of mobile hardware platforms by creating complementary
applications and systems suited to their local populations. Rather than seek to address
general consumer needs and the drive towards consolidation this brings, entrepreneurs
can instead carve out niches for themselves in addressing specific needs and demands,
ensuring product differentiation in a market where the barriers to entry are low and
will continue to get lower.
For example, mobile developers have recently deployed mobile banking systems in
Kenya and Malawi for populations that do not have access to bank branches. The
phone provider Safaricom lets users deposit, transfer and withdraw funds via simple
text messaging, bringing convenience to communities who lack the infrastructure and
know-how to access financial services and systems. The popularity of the M-PESA
system as a banking option has risen at an astonishing rate since its introduction in
2007; assistant professor Tavneet Suri at the MIT Sloan School of Management and
Georgetown University economist William Jack found that 38 percent of Kenyan
households have at least one M-PESA user in them2. In contrast, only 22 percent of
adults have bank accounts. According to Suri and Jack, groups as diverse as farmers
and children sending money back to their parents were utilizing M-PESA; a powerful
demonstration of how mobile technology can effect social and economic changes in
the developing world3.
Despite the favorable climate for deployment of mobile applications in the developing
world, several challenges still exist. First, smart phone innovations – which often do
not reach developing countries - make the headlines regularly, but they represent only
a small fraction of the mobile market. According to a research report by Gartner,
smart phones only comprise 12% of the mobile market, while the vast majority of
phones are still mass-market models4. The primary reason why smart phones have not
penetrated more of the world market (besides cost) is that the infrastructure required
to make full use of their capabilities (e.g., high-speed mobile Internet connections,
national-scale phone networks) are often non-existent or bare in the developing world.
As the UNCTAD Information Economy Report notes, the staggering increase in
mobile phone subscribers in the developing world has not been matched by
infrastructural development, leading to poor service quality and consumer
dissatisfaction5. In this regard, extending useful applications into the developing
world must be mediated through the pipeline of mass-market hardware. Yet the less
glamorous nature of the task should not hide its importance –simple applications can
go a long way in developing countries, as seen above in the case of mobile banking.
To address the fundamental challenge in the mobile phone divide, MIT is pursuing
new mobile telecommunications research programs for the developing world.
Entrepreneurial Programming and Research on Mobiles (EPROM) aims to foster
mobile phone-related research and entrepreneurship in developing countries to
address relevant social and political problems. In partnership with Nokia, this
program teaches computer science students from developing countries such as Kenya,
Ethiopia, Uganda and Rwanda the fundamentals of mobile application development,
hoping to provide them with the tools to develop mobile phone applications relevant
to local needs and cultures. EPROM also runs "SMS Boot Camps" at the University
of Nairobi, which couple education and entrepreneurship in an academic setting and
teaches teams of students to launch and market their own SMS services to the millions
of mobile phone users in Kenya. Thus by blending technological development and
entrepreneurial leanings, EPROM hopes to contribute to the development of the social
structure of the mobile market.
Moreover, MIT students and faculty have also contributed to advances in phone
software technology. In May 2008, four MIT undergraduates shared a $25,000 prize
as winners in Google's Android Developer Challenge with their project, Locale6.
Locale enables Android Users to efficiently manage settings on their mobile device.
At the MIT Media Lab, HealthMap's Outbreaks Near Me application is currently in
development, allowing users to track and inform others in the community about the
spread of infectious diseases. MIT’s NextLab class, with the tagline “Mobile
Innovation for Global Challenges”, guides students in partnership with Mexican
universities through the entire process of developing mobile phone software to tackle
social challenges, turning the whole classroom itself into a cutting-edge research lab
where ideas are generated and brought to market over the course of a semester.
At the cusp of the new decade, the mobile phone market has entered a period of
dynamic change, in which rapid innovations are reshaping and redefining the reach
and scope of both smart and mass-market phones. In this environment, potential
opportunities for entrepreneurs exist in both the hardware and software fields –
tomorrow’s phones are poised to be created by bold and decisive individuals today
who not only produce exciting tools and applications but also leverage improved
telecommunications infrastructures in order to reach under-served populations.
References