2 HANUARY15, 1967
where betweenthe two extremes,• -- • and (r2 the materials tend to behave similarly under all
systems of loading under conditions favoring
The apparatusrequiredto measureaccurately nearly ideal plasticity.
the stressand strain in cylinderssubjectedto
STR•,ss•,s AT FA•LVRE
torsion and triaxial compressionat the same
time is necessarilycomplex.The chief disad- Convenient for purposesof comparisonis a
vantage,however,is that the stressesin twisted graphical representationof the state of stress
solidcylindersare not uniform; the shearstress at failure--fracture, faulting, or yielding. Let
developedunder the appliedtorque variesradi- us construct a Cartesian coordinate system in
ally from zero at the center to a maximum at which the x axis is parallel to the longitudinal
the periphery. Hence the data are not directly axis of the cylindrical specimenand the y and z
comparablewith those derived from tests in axes lie in the circular section. In general, the
which the stressfield is homogeneous. An alter- principalstresses at are [Jaeger,1962]
native is to twist thin-walled hollow cylinders
in which all stressesare nearly uniform. This - + + + +
leads to the difficult and time-consumingtask 2 2 T• )ffi
of preparinghollowcylindersof ordinary brittle 2 2
Type of Test
Uniaxial compression
•y --- •z -- Txy -- 0 0 •x/3
Uniax• tension
o o -•= -•:/3
•ax•l compression
p = •y = •z p +A•x/3
T•x• extension
a: = p -- A•: p -- A•z/3
Pure torsion
Tzy -- Txy 0
Torsion + confining pressure
p + •-•y P -- •'xy P
Torsion + t•xial •yx •
uompress•on
• -- 2 + •'xy2 P + A•/3
Braz•
variable p --•'•, variable
* p = confining pressure.
EXPERIMENTAL METHODS
PACKING
The nomenclature,theory, and techniqueof
experimental rock deformation have been
thoroughly discussedin previous publications
PRESSURE
[Handin, 1953, 1966; Handin and Hager, 1957, CONFININ
'•--UPPER
LOADING
PISTON
1958; Handin et al. 1960; Griggsand Handin., ,PRESSURE
K• '•--SPECIME
N
1960; Griggs et al., 1960; Heard, 1960, 1962;
Paterson,1964]. Here they are reviewedbriefly.
,••/••LOWER PISTON
FORCE.
GAGE
(CLUTC
Triaxial tests. In our so-called 'triaxial' ex-
periments, cylindrical specimensabout 0.5 to
1.0 cm in diameter and 1.0 to 2.0 cm in length
are sheathed in thin impermeable copper or
lead jackets,placedin a high-pressurechamber,
and surroundedby a fluid confiningmedium.
The state of stressis initially hydrostatic, a• --
(r2-- (rs-- p, wherep is confiningpressure.
The specimens are then loaded axially
:--•,
ll-:;•-DIFFE
Ill 6 TRANSFORMERS-•
an internal force gage similar to that shown yield stress,which is definedas the differential
in Figure 1 [Heard, 1963, 1965]. stressat somearbitrary small permanentstrain
The measurements of force,displacement,and and is usually of the order of 1-2% for rocks.
confining pressurehave a sensitivity of 0.1% The deformational behavior is described in
and an accuracy of 0.5%. For high-tempera- terms of relative ductility as previouslydefined
ture experiments,both internally and externally by Griggs and Handin [1960, Figure 1] and
heated test chambersare used; regulation is Heard [1960, p. 206]. The rock is regarded as
within ñ2øC for temperatures up to 500øC. brittle, transitional, or ductile when the total
In all tests the confining pressureis main- longitudinal strains before fracture or faulting
tained constant.When the axial pressureis in- are 1-3, 3-5, and 5% or more, respectively.The
creased(compressiontest), the specimenshort- correspondingmaximum shear strains would be
ens, and ax 2> a•. -- as -- p. When the axial 2-6, 6-10, and 10% or more.
pressure is decreased,the specimenelongates, Torsion tests. The apparatus,togetherwith
and a, <C a• -- a•. -- p. In any singletest the the theory, technique,and procedureof testing
rate of shortening or elongation is constant. rocks under torsion combined with triaxial
The ordinary strain rate is about 10-• per sec- compression, has already been describedin de-
ond. During the test we record the differential tail [Handin et al., 1960]. In brief, the appa-
force on the piston and the relative dis- ratus consistsof a double-actinghydraulic press
placement of the piston with respect to the coupledthrough a thrust bearingto a rotatable
chamber. From the predetermined initial triaxial test chamber,the fixed loading piston
cross-sectionalarea of the specimen and the of which bearsagainsta force-torquegage.This
displacementscorrected for apparatus distor- is a steel column to which two sets of four foil
tion, we can calculatethe new area at any given strain gages are bonded. For force measure-
strain by assumingthat volume is conserved ments these resistance elements are mounted
and that deformation is homogeneousalong parallel and perpendicular to the axis of the
the gage length. Dividing force by this area column, and for torque measurementsthey lie
then givestrue differentialstress,a• -- as.This at 45 ø to the axis. Each set forms a Wheat-
is plotted versus conventional longitudinal stone bridge, the output of which is fed to a
strain (shorteningor elongation) in the stress- strip-chart recorder. Also recorded are axial
strain curve, which reflects the deformational displacement of the press, rotation of the
behaviorof the specimen. . cylinder,and confiningpressure.All thesemeas-
Ultimate strength is definedas the maximum urementshave a sensitivityof 0.1% and an ac-
ordinate of the stress-strain curve. For brittle curacy of at least 0.5%. The chamber can be
materials which rupture after an essentially heated externally to 400øC with regulation of
elastic deformation, ultimate and breaking ñ2øC for high-temperaturetests.
strengthscoincide.For materials which deform Although piston friction is relatively low in
permanentlybeforerupturing, ultimate strength our controlled-clearance packing,externalmeas-
correspondsto the maximum ordinate of the urementsof axial force and torque are subject
stress-straincurve and is unambiguouswhen to some uncertainty, especiallyat small values
this curve is peaked. For ductile materials of these variables. We have therefore built an
which strain-harden,we prefer to specify the internal force-torquegagewhich eliminatesthe
problem of friction. This gage consistsof a
hollow steel column to which the base of the
TABLE 2. Full-Scale Readings
in Torsion Testing specimenis fixed, and it simply replacesthe
presentlower plug in the test vessel[seeHandin
Axial load, external 10•ødynes et al., 1960, Figure 6]. A rod extendsthrough
Axial load, internal 5 X 109dynes the columnfrom a fixed point near the end in
Torque, external 2 X 109dyne-cm contact with the specimento the outside of the
Torque, internal 109 dyne-cm vesselwhere the axial displacementand twist of
Axial displacement 2 cm
Rotation I radian the rod are measuredwith respectto the col-
Confiningpressure 4.5 kb umn by meansof two very sensitivedifferential
transformers(Figure 1). Thesetransducers give
EFFECTS OF INTERMEDIATE PRINCIPAL STRESS ON FAILURE 615
EPON 815
CEM *'NT STEp•.LLuGEND
OUTSIDE
COPPER
dACKET INSIDE
COPPER
LET STEEl
PLUGEND
I I
.50 INCH
crystallinespecimenin bulk is large relative to In a pure torsion test the specimenis twisted
the maximumsizeof the constituentgrains. (3) at a constantrate, ordinarily 0.1 rad/min under
Less torque is required to achieve the same constant confining pressure. The shear strain
shear stress,and this, of course,reducesthe rate is then about 10-' per second.In combined
sensitivity of the measurements. loading tests, an axial load below the yield
We have beenable to make uniform cylinders stressis first applied.Torqueis then applied,
with the following dimensions' outside diam-and the specimenis twisted at constant values
of • and of •, = 0'6= p = •.
eter, do -- 0.500 inch (1.270 cm); insidediam-
eter, d, -- 0.445 inch (1.130 cm); wall ratio,The stress distributions in permanently
d,/do -- 0.89. The wall thicknessof 0.028 inch
twisted solid specimensare unknown, but the
(0.070 cm) is more than 100 times greater stress-strainrelations for twisted cylindersare
than the grain size (5 X 10-• cm) of Solenhofen
easily computed when the deformation is
limestone. elastic.Thus the yield stressfor a ductile ma-
Developmentof a techniquefor effectively terial and the breaking stressfor a brittle ma-
616 HANDIN, HEARD, AND MAGOUIRK
terial can be determined with little error radius, its value at the inner wall will differ
(-----3%).The relationspreviouslywritten for a from the maximum value by 11%. The mean
solid cylindrical bar, damped at one end and deviation from the average r•, will be about
twisted by a eouple applied at the other end, 5%.
also apply to a hollow right-eircular eylinder If we had assumedthat r•, was uniform
[seeHandin. et al., 1960, pp. 246-248]. The as- acrossthe thin wall,
sumptionsare (1) that the material is uniform,
isotropic,and perfectly elastieand (2) that the
strain is homogeneous and constitutesa pure
M = 2•rr•
Jr
rø
r•'dr
i
• 2
where the limits of •tegration are the inner
and outer radii of the hollowcylinder.
Substitutionof (5) into (6) gives
(Txy)max
= 2M/•o3(1 -- ri4/Wo
4) (7) •'2 ---O'y
which reduces to
FRACTURE
= (8) OR
FACTj
for solid cylinderswhere r• -- 0. Our standard
diameter is 0.894 em; aeeordingly, the maxi-
mum value of r•, (in bars) is 7.14 X 10-6M
(in dyne-em) for solidcylinders.
For the hollow cylinderswith the dimensions
adopted (ro = 0.635 era, r• = 0.565 em), equa-
tion 7 gives the maximum r•, -- 6.70 X 10-øM.
Thus, for a given shear stress, the twisting Fig. 3. Angular relations of fractures or faults
moment required is about the same as before in torsion specimens. The angle a is measured
because ro is larger and becausemost of the from the circular section.The angle B is between
the x axis and the maximum principal stress •.
torque is taken up by the outer fibers of the The fault or fracture angle 0 is given with respect
cylinder. Since r,, varies directly with the to the • direction.
EFFECTS OF INTERMEDIATE PRINCIPAL STRESS ON FAILURE 617
144 0 3 47 3.47 0 0 I 16 I 63
28 0.76 4 75 5.51 0.76 0.76 2 34 2 25 25
24 1.03 4 85 5.88 1.03 1.03 2 65 2 28 30,32
116 1.03 4 63 5.66 1.03 1.03 2 57 2 18 3O
115 1.27 5 03 6.30 1.27 1.27 2 75 2 37 3O
27 1.53 5 O7 6.60 1.53 1.53 3 22 2 39
GT-117 0 3 98 3.98 0 0 I 33 I 97
GT-122 0 4 09 4.O9 0 0 I 36 I 93
GT-123 0 3 98 3.98 0 0 I 33 I 87
GT-116 0.20 4 73 4.93 0.20 0.20 I 78 2 23
GT-118 0.40 4 93 5.33 0.40 0.40 2 04 2 32 20
GT-119 0.60 4 85 5.45 0.60 0.60 2 22 2 29 22
GT-120 0.80 5 14 5.94 0.80 0.80 2.51 2 42
GT-121 1.00 5.35 6.35 1.00 1.00 2.78 2 52
COMPRESSION EXTENSION
o BLOCK 5 "BLOCK 5
ß BLOCK 1,2, 4 ß BLOCK 3 (HEARD, 1960)
- Z'oc,
=--.*/:5":53•
(o-i
-o-
$) ! Pm=
-'•'-
[$o-I-
pm=+[(o'l-o'3)+ (o-,
3 3]-o-$)]_
' EXTENSION
OFSOLENHOFEN
LIMESTONE
0 I 2 $ 4 5 6
PB(kb)
Fig. 4. Octahedral shear stressversus mean pressurefor failure of Solenhofen limestone in
compressionand extensionat room temperature and strain rate of 10-' per second.
tion 7) versus shear strain (7 = toro). For axis, which coincideswith •. In twisted cylin-
brittle materials the torque (or shear stress) ders, however,the principal axes do not coin-
at fracture is unambiguouslydetermined. For cide with the coordinate axes.
ductile materials the torque at failure is taken In a specimenunder combinedtorsion and
at the knee of the torque-twist curve. For rocks triaxial compression,the shear stress ß and
this occursat about 0.1 rad?cm, or 5% shear normal stress• on a plane inclinedat an angle
strain. fi with respect to the x axis are given by
Fractures and [aults. The operational defi- Handinet al. [1960,p. 251]:
nitions of Griggs aad Handin [1960, p. 348]
are adopted. Fracture implies separation into
two or more parts and total lossof cohesionand
•-= «(•r•
-- •r•)sin
2•q-•-•cos
2• (10)
resistanceto differential stress.Exteasion [rac-
= 1 o' + - -
ture involvesseparationacrossa surfacenormal cos 2• q- •'• sin 2•
to the direction of minimum principal stress.
There is no offset.parallel to this surface. A To find the angle for which the normal stress
[ault is a localized offset along a more or less is a maximum,we can differentiate(10) with
plane surface of nonvanishing shear stress. respect to fi and equate to zero; whence,for
O'max• O'1,
Total loss of cohesionmay or may not occur.
If it does,onecanproperly
speakof shea•[rac-
Gan2•S= q-2•x•/(•r• - •r•) (11)
ture as a special case. Uai[orm flow denotes
macroscopically homogeneouspermanent de- In torsionalone,•, - • = 0 andfi = 45ø. In
formation without fracturing or faulting. torsion and triaxial compression,
when •, --
The angle betweena fracture or fault and the • • 0, the maximumprincipalstressdirection
direction of maximum principal compression liesbetweenthe limits0 < fi < 45ø. For tri-
can be denotedby 6. In a compressed specimen axial extensionand torsion,the maximumprin-
this angle is measuredfrom the longitudinalx cipal stressdirection will lie betweenthe limits
EFFECTS OF INTERMEDIATE PRINCIPAL STRESS ON FAILURE 619
45ø < • < 90ø, althoughnoneof thesetests selected because its tensile strength is high
wasattempted duringthis study. relative to those of the rocks.
In twisted specimensthe orientationsa of
SOLENHOFEN LIMESTONE
fractures and faults are measuredwith respect
to the circular section. The relations between Triaxial compressiontests,room temperature.
a,/•, and 0 are shownin Figure3. The material used in our first 68 experiments
Selectiono• materials. If the resultsof many was cored from block 3, which was used by
different experimentsare to be validly com- Heard [1960]. When this material was ex-
pared, the test material must be homogeneous hausted, we made a cursory survey of the
within any singlespecimenand also from sam- properties of several different samples. The
ple to sample.The material must also be sta- available data of several investigators have
tistically isotropicif its deformationalbehavior been tabulated (Table 3) and plotted (Figure
is to be independentof the orientationsof prin- 4), along with our recent results (experiments
cipal stresses with respectto fabric. Becauseof GT-116 to 123). The octahedral shear stress-
the small sample size, especiallyof thin-walled mean pressure curve is drawn through the
hollowcylinders,the materialmustbe very fine- points for these latter experiments because
grained.The minimumdimensionshouldprob- most of our other tests, including all those on
ably be no lessthan 10 grain diameters.Finally, hollow cylinders,were done on specimenscored
the material should pass through the brittle- from block 5. The spread among the data de-
ductile transition at available mean pressures rived from seven different samplesof the rock
and temperatures. is evidently large. This is due in part to the
SoIenhofenlimestonemeets all these require- differencesin mechanicalpropertiesof the sev-
ments and has the additional advantage that eral blocks and in part to the different experi-
its behavior under triaxial loading has already mental techniquesof the severalworkers,but
beencarefullystudiedby Heard [1960]. Indeed, the reproducibility of tests on the same block
many of our specimenswere cored from the in the same apparatus is good (compare ex-
sameblock that providedthosetested by him. periments 24 and 116, block 3, and GT-117,
Blair dolomiteis also satisfactoryand is brittle 122, 123, block 5). The uniaxial compresslye
over a wider range of mean pressures.Brace strength is taken as 4.0 kb, the brittle-ductile
[1964] measuredthe propertiesof this block transition occurs at a mean pressureof about
under several states of stress. Pyrex glass was 2.7 kb [Heard, 1960, Figure 10], and the fault
* Indeterminate.
I Ductile, no faulting.
:[:Apparently an extensionfracture.
EFFECTS OF INTERMEDIATE PRINCIPAL STRESSON FAILURE 621
ß PURE TORSION
--ß TORSION + UNIAXIAL COMPRESSION
o TORSION + CONFINING PRESSURE
[3 TORSION+ TRIAXIAL COMPRESSION
• 00 0
TO.S,O.
so = - + ST.SS
V.SUS - +(•2-
//•
ß Pm =
•1+•2+•5
3
I
o I 2 $ 4 5 6
Pm(kb)
Fig. 5. Octahedralshearstressversusmean pressurefor failure of solid cylindersof Solen-
hofen limestonetwisted at room temperatureand shearstrain rate of 10-• per second.
anglesvary from 16ø to 30ø at mean pressures A(• must be negative to obtain a tensile stress,
in the range of 1.5 to 3 kb. The slopeof the A, < A•. For the ordinary ratio A•/A, = 2, a
short linear segmentof the curve is 0.75. Points 2% error in the differential force on the speci-
at highermeanpressures have not beenplotted men due to piston friction would lead to an
becausethe rock is strain-hardeningin the duc- error in --as of 0.2 kb at p = 5 kb. This is
tile state and the ultimate strength is not enormouswhen one is attempting to measure
unambiguously
specified. . a quantity of the same order of magnitude, a
Triaxial extension tests, room temperature. few tenths of a kilobar at most.
We first attemptedto measuretensilebreaking The previousresultsof Heard [1960] at high
stressesin Itandin's apparatus (experiments confiningpressures
are tabulated(Table 4) and
GT-20, 21, 25, 31, 46, and 47; block 3) at con- plotted (Figure 4) together with measurements
finingpressures of 2 to 5 kb. Thesetestsyielded on block 5 from Heard's apparatusequipped
unreasonably high (as muchas 0.8 kb) and sub- with an internalforcegage.The linear part of
sequently unconfirmedtensile strengths.They the octahedralshearstress-mean
pressurecurve
were done in an apparatus with a controlled- is describedby
clearancepiston packing in which friction is
relatively low. I-Iowever, an undeterminable 'ro•t = 0.17 4- 0.65p,•
variation of friction of only 2% during an ex- The brittle-ductile transition occurs at about
periment can result in a large error in meas- 5.4 kb, and the fractureanglesrangefrom zero
urement of tensile strength. In an extension (tensile fracture normal to as) at low mean
test the differentialforce AF on the piston can pressuresin the brittle state to 25 ø near the
be reduced to zero, but the piston cannot be transition. The tensile strength (--a• at rup-
pulledin tension.On a pistonof area A•, there- ture) is of the order of 0.15 kb and is inde-
fore, the maximumAF -- pA•, and in a speci- pendentof meanpressure.
men of area A, the differential stress Aa -- Torsiontests,solidcylinders,room tempera-
F/A, -- pA•/A,. Sincethe quantity •, -- p -- ture. Theseincludepuretorsion(o-,,-- (• -- 0,
622 HANDIN, HEARD, AND MAGOUIRK
rected for the contributions of the copper
jackets.Thesehave a wall thicknessof 0.02 cm
and the same diameter as the piston (1.3 cm).
The maximum specimendiameter is only 0.9
cm, however,sothat the jacket collapses around
the specimenwhen confining pressure is ap-
plied, and longitudinalribs developfrom buck-
ling of the thin shell (Figure 6). The strength
of the jacket cannotbe predictedfor this con-
figuration, but it has been measured inde-
pendently by identically jacketing very weak
lead of known strength and determining the
proportionsof axial load and torque borne by
the copper.
Three types of failure at ultimate stressare
observed. At low confining pressure, helical
tensilefracture occursas in specimensG-12 and
G-27. The fracture surface is everywhere in-
clined at nearly 45ø to a radius. At intermedi-
ate pressuresand axial loads, faulting with or
without total loss of cohesionoccursat angles
of less than 45ø with respect to (r,. :Figure 6
clearly showsthe offset along the fault in speci-
men G-14 (still in its copper jacket). At high
pressurescombined with high axial loads, the
specimens(G-16, 32, 33) are ductile and con-
tain no faults. The large permanent twist oc-
G14 G32 curs uniformly throughout the specimen (for
example, G-32, Figure 6). The brittle-ductile
Fig. 6. Photographsof twisted solid cylinders
of Solenhofen limestone. G-14 (still in its copper transition seemsto occur at a mean pressureof
jacket) is faulted. G-32 has floweduniformly. about 3.5 kb. Thus specimen G-211 is transi-
tional at 3, and G-241 is certainly ductile at 3.5
p -- 0), torsionplusuniaxialcompression (•, -- kb.
•, -7• 0, p -- 0), torsionplusconfining pressure Note the very high values of tensile stresses
(•, -- •, -- 0, p -7• 0), and torsionplustri- (--a3) attained in many of the tests in Table
axialcompression (•, -- •, -7• 0, p -7• 0). Table 5--for example, 1.33 kb in G-97. The calcula-
5 lists the axial differential stress (•, -- •,); tions, however,are basedon valuesof maximum
the confiningpressure(p); the maximumshear shear stressdevelopedat the periphery of the
stress (½.,) developedby the applied torque; specimens.Stressesin the central region must
the principalstresses;
the majorandminorob- be much lower. This anomalouslylarge tensile
served fracture or fault anglesmeasuredfrom strength and the heterogeneity of the stress
the circular sections (a); the angle between field in solid cylindersprompted the tests on
•, and •,(/•); the inclinationsof major and hollowspecimens.
minor faults or fractures with respectto •, (0 Torsion tests, hollow cylinders, room tem-
-- 90ø -- a -- /•); the mean pressure(p.,); perature. The same types of torsion tests have
and the octahedral shear stress (•o•,). From a been repeatedon hollow cylinders (Table 6).
plot of the last two parameters(Figure5) the The linear segment of the octahedral shear
linearsegmentof the curveis foundto be stress-meanpressurecurve in :Figure7 is given
by
foot - 0.52 -I- 0.90p.,
for torsion and torsion plus confiningpressure. •'oot= 0.12 + 0.70p,,,
The axial loads and torques have been cot- We first. tried to jacket the hollow specimens
EFFECTS OF INTERMEDIATE PRINCIPAL STRESSON FAILURE 621
ß PURE TORSION
--ß TORSION + UNIAXIAL COMPRESSION
o TORSION + CONFINING PRESSURE
n TORSION + TRIAXIAL COMPRESSION
E n O
o o.....• • -'-'-l:)----
o•E-'
ø
o o o
,
o o AL SHEARSTRESSVERSUSMEAN
PRESSURE FOR TORSION OF SOLID CYLINDERS
OF SOLENHOFEN LIMESTONE
//
•l
f Pm=
•1+•2+• - `3+(•i• +(•-
I ,
0 I 2 .3 4 5 6
Pm(kb)
Fig. 5. Octahedralshearstressversusmean pressurefor failure of solid cylindersof Solen-
hofen limestonetwistedat room temperatureand shearstrain rate of 10-' per second.
anglesvary from 16ø to 30ø at mean pressures A(r must be negative to obtain a tensile stress,
in the range of 1.5 to 3 kb. The slope of the A, < A•. For the ordinary ratio A•/A, = 2, a
short linear segmentof the curve is 0.75. Points 2% error in the differential force on the speci-
at highermeanpressures have not beenplotted men due to piston friction would lead to an
because the rock is strain-hardeningin the duc- error in --(rs of 0.2 kb at p -- 5 kb. This is
tile state and the ultimate strength is not enormouswhen one is attempting to measure
unambiguously specified. ß a quantity of the same order of magnitude, a
Triaxial extensiontests, room temperature. few tenths of a kilobar at most.
We first attemptedto measuretensilebreaking The previousresultsof Heard [1960] at high
stressesin Handin's apparatus (experiments confiningpressures are tabulated(Table 4) and
GT-20, 21, 25, 31, 46, and 47; block 3) at con- plotted (Figure 4) togetherwith measurements
finingpressures of 2 to 5 kb. Thesetestsyielded on block 5 from I-Ieard'sapparatusequipped
unreasonably high (as muchas 0.8 kb) and sub- with an internal force gage.The linear part of
sequentlyunconfirmedtensile strengths.They the octahedralshearstress-mean pressurecurve
were done in an apparatus with a controlled- is describedby
clearancepiston packing in which friction is
relatively low. However, an undeterminable •'o•t = 0.17 -{- 0.65pro
variation of friction of only 2% during an ex- The brittle-ductile transition occurs at about
periment can result in a large error in meas- 5.4 kb, and the fracture anglesrangefrom zero
urement of tensile strength. In an extension (tensile fracture normal to (rs) at low mean
test the differentialforce AF on the piston can pressures in the brittle state to 25 ø near the
be reducedto zero, but the piston cannot be transition.The tensilestrength (--(rs at rup-
pulledin tension.On a pistonof area A•, there- ture) is of the order of 0.15 kb and is inde-
fore, the maximumAF -- pA,, and in a speci- pendentof meanpressure.
men of area A, the differential stress A(r = Torsiontests,solidcylinders,roomtempera-
F/A, -- pA•/A,. Sincethe quantity •r, -- p -- ture. Theseincludepuretorsion((r, -- (r, = 0,
-.0;-::':4'
.....- ' '••i•:---'*---*""•:•-*"•.
:':--".-;.
",i':': .........
::i•c.../-
-.•s . •.--:?:
..
..
*.4: ::::i:.•
......
".'--:•::- ":.•
...•-
..
-* :-.-;'t.
':?:-..
:--.:::. ;.4
....................
½ s
P"!i!i*t•!}'½::.:.;.'"::':*
........
:':x'**:i:2?:*a2"
G75 G 76
Stage
1j Stage
2 Stage
3
Fig. 9. Ex•en•on œra½•urh•g
œoilo•eclb• œm•lfing
in •i•Lecl hollow ½•lh•der•oœSolenhoœen
•me•one unde• •x• lo•cl.
Although the copper sleevesare quite thin, no offsetparallelto the fracturesurfaceis evi-
the combined thickness of the external and dent. In the central sectors the surface is heli-
internal jackets (0.05 cm) is nearly as large as cal and is everywhereinclinedat 45ø ñ 1ø to
the wall thicknessof the specimen(0.07). The the radius--that is, normalto the least princi-
contribution of the jackets to the total axial pal stressa3as closelyas we can measure.Near
load and applied torque is therefore large, rang- the constrainedends of the specimensthese
ing from nearly 25% at low mean pressuresto fracture•tend to becomeparallelto the longi-
about 10% at the highest pressures.As noted tudinalaxisof twist (Figure9), whichno doubt
above, all reported data were corrected for reflectsa changein the imposedstressfield at
the strengthof the copperjackets.The strength the ends.
of annealed copper in torsion was determined Extensionfracturesof similar appearancealso
by twisting a hollow cylinder to a shear strain occurin axially loaded,twisted cylinders,as in
of about 0.2. The maximum shear stress-strain G-76, 77, 79, and 89 alone, or as in G-80, 90,
curve agreeswell with those measured previ- and 84 along with faults. The helical fracture
ously in compressionand extension [Handin surfacesare very nearly parallel to the pre-
and Hager, 1958,p. 2917]. dicted directionsof a• (0 -- 1ø to 4ø) in the
At axial differential stresses above 3 kb the central sectors (except.in G-80 where the dis-
hollow cylinders buckle before torque can be crepancyis not understood).Offset doesoccur
applied. To achieve higher mean pressures,we parallel to these extensionfractures.This hap-
elected to raise the confining pressure to 4.5 pensbecause,the instant the break occurs,the
kb. For tests above 3 kb the torsion test cham- torque but not the axial load vanishes,and the
ber was temporarily coupled to the pressure- average principal stressdirectionssuddenlyro-
generating and recording system of Handin's tate (Figure 9). In effect, the specimenenters
triaxial equipment. a state of triaxial compression,and shear oc-
At relatively low mean pressures(0 to about curs on the favorably oriented,already formed,
1.5 kb), the principal failure mechanismis ex- cohesionlessextension fracture. However, the
tension fracturing (for example, G-76, Figure surface is helical, not plane, and it affords in-
8). These fractures appear as open breaks, at terference to slip under axial compression.
least as observed after all constraints have been Crushing occurs, and minor, apparently con-
removed. The surfaces are smooth and undulat- jugate shear fractures may develop at high
ing on a smallscale.In pure torsionspecimens, anglesto the circularsection.
696 tIANDIN, tIEARD, AND MAGOUIRK
• •oo
i
Experiment
Confining
Pressure,
Minimum Principal
(Tensile) Stress •3,
•r 5 =p-
No. kb kb
- SS GB-3$ o -o .2o5
GB-35 o -o 195
GB-36 o -o 215
GB-37 2. oo -o 220
GB-38 2. oo -o 235
GB-39 5 oo -o 250
-t o
o
i
2
'1
8
GB-40
GB-4I
G B-42
GB-43
5
5
8
8
oo
oo
oo
oo
-o
-o
-o
-o
270
260
420
715
G B-44 8 oo -o 355
Fig. 11. Tensile strength of Solenhofenlime- 635
GB-45 8. oo -o
stone versus confining pressure as measured in
Brazil tests at room temperature.
EFFECTS OF INTERMEDIATE PRINCIPAL STRESS ON FAILURE 627
G-220 0.50 0.54 1.07 300 B 1.57 0.50 --0.57 42 45 3 0.50 0.88
G-208 0.50 0.39 1.14 400 B 1.64 0.50 --0.64 40 45 5 0.50 0.93
G-214 1.00 0.95 1.88 200 B 2.88 1.00 --0.88 •0' 45 •5 1.00 1.53
G-215 1.00 0.75 1.49 300 B 2.49 1.00 --0.49 8, 20 45 •7,25 1.00 1.22
G-207 1.00 0.83 1.65 400 T 2.65 1.00 --0.65 40 45 5 1.00 1.35
G-203 1.50 1.53 3.02 200 B 4.52 1.50 --1.52 • 45 • 1.50 2.47
G-221 1.50 1.10 2.18 300 B 3 68 1.50 --0.68 45, •5 45 0, •0 1.50 1.78
G-223 1.50 1.16 2.30 300 B 3 80 1.50 --0.80 45, • 45 0, • 1.50 1.88
G-206 1.50 0.75 1.49 400 B 2 99 1.50 0.01 40 45 5 1.50 1.22
G-222 1.50 1.06 2.09 400 B 3 59 1.50 --0 59 45, $5 45 0, $0 1.50 1.71
G-224 1.50 1.16 2.30 400 B 3 80 1.50 --0.80 48 45 --3 1.50 1.88
G-212 2.00 1.39 2.74 200 T 4.74 2.00 --0 74 • 45 • 2.00 2.24
G-233 2.00 1.34 2.65 300 B 4.65 2.00 -0.65 $0, (49) 45 $5, (-4) 2.00 2.16
G-226 2.00 1.30 2.57 400 T 4.57 2.00 -0.57 45, •3 45 0, • 2.00 2.10
G-213 2 50 1 60 3 16 100 T 5.66 2.50 --0.66 18 45 •? 2.50 2.58
G-200 2 50 1.64 3 25 200 D 5.75 2 50 --0.75 45 2.50 2.65
G-238 2.50 1.51 2.99 300 D 5.49 2.50 --0.49 $0 45 •5 2.50 2.44
G-236 2.50 1.01 1.99 400 I) 4.49 2.50 0.51 45 2.50 1.63
G-239 3.00 1.62 3.21 200 D 6.21 3.00 --0.21 45 3.00 2.62
G-237 3.00 1.80 3.57 300 D 6.57 3.00 --0.57 45 3.00 2.91
Exp. p = a•., a•, -- a,, Temp., Relative a,, as, 0, pro, •'oct,
No. kb kb øC Ductility kb kb deg kb kb
Compression*
GT-248 0 4.35 225 B 4.35 0 30 1.45 2.05
GT-247 0 3.85 300 D 3.85 0 1.28 1.81
GT-245 0.30 3.80 150 B 4.10 0.30 26 1.57 1.79
GT-246 0.30 4.50 300 D 4.80 0.30 1.80 2.12
GT-243 0.40 4.35 150 D 4.75 0.40 26 1.85 2.05
GT-244 0.40 4.00 300 D 4.40 0.40 2.06 1.88
GT-241 0.50 4.30 150 D 4.80 0.50 1.93 2.02
GT-242 0.50 4.05 300 D 4.55 0.50 1.85 1.91
GT-240 0.75 4.85 25 T 5.60 0.75 31 2.36 2.29
GT-237 0.75 4.85 150 D 5.60 0.75 2.36 2.29
GT-236 1.00 4.80 25 D 5.80 1.00 27 2.60 2.26
Extension
GT-288 2.00 1.26 450 B 2.00 0.74 0 1.58 0.59
GT-287 2.00 0.48 500 D 2.00 1.52 1.84 0.23
GT-283 2.50 2.06 400 B 2.50 0.44 0 1.81 0.97
GT-279 3.00 2.83 400 T 3.00 0.17 0 2.06 1.33
GT-281 3.00 2.67 400 B 3.00 0.33 0 2.11 1.26
GT-284 3.50 3.26 400 D 3.50 0.24 0 2.41 1.54
GT-285 4.00 3.92 300 B 4.00 0.08 0 2.69 1.85
GT-286 4.00 4.04 300 B 4.00 -0.04 0 2.65 1.91
GT-671 5.90 4.95 25 B 5.90 0.95 19 4.25 2.33
GT-670 6.40 5.45 25 T 6.40 0.95 22 4.58 3.01
Compression
GT-169 o 4.82 4.82 0 1 61 2.27
GT-171 o 5 66 5.66 0 1 88 2.67
GT-182 o 4.38 4.38 0 1 46 2.07
GT-189 o 6 O2 6.02 0 2 01 2.84
GT-191 0.50 4 99 5.49 0 5O 37 2 16 2.35
GT-195 0.75 8 93 9.68 0 75 32 3 72 4.21
GT-173 1.oo 9.10 10.10 1 00 26 4 03 4.29
GT-193 1 oo 9.91 10.91 1 00 24 4 31 4.67
GT-194 1 50 10.34 11.84 1 50 24 4 95 4 79
GT-175 2 oo 10.46 12.46 2 00 27 5 48 4 93
GT-190 2 oo 10.88 12.88 2.00 18 5 63 4 93
GT-192 2 oo 11.45 13.45 2.00 30 5 82 5 38
GT-178 3 oo 13.07 16.07 3.00 34 7.35 6 16
GT-181 3. oo 11.98 14.98 3.00 32 6.99 5 65
GT-184 4.00 13.24 17.24 4.00 38 8.41 6 24
GT-185 4.5o 13.67 18.17 4.5O 30 9.06 6.44
GT-240 4.5o 13.10 17.60 4.5O 31 8.87 5.35
Extension
GT-590 1.00 1.37 1.00 -0.37 0 0.55 0.65
GT-592 2.00 2.16 2.00 -0.16 0 1.28 1.02
GT-594 3.00 3.15 3.00 -0.15 0 1.95 1.49
GT-596 4.00 4.30 4.00 -0.30 0 2.57 2.03
mean pressureat 25øC and from about 2.0 to curve for compressionis linear over a much
1.5 kb at 400øC. The octahedral shear stresses wider range than that for limestone(Figure
at failure of 2.7 kb at a mean pressureof 2.5 12), and
kb and at a temperatureof 25øC and 2.1 kb' root = 1.20 q- 0.80p•
at 2.0 kb and 400øC do not differ greatly from
The extensioncurveis entirely linear, and
those measuredat 10-• per second(Tables 5
and 8). root = 0.30 + 0.67p•
B,,A•R DO,,O•IT•,
Solid
G-132 0 0.42 0.30 0.30 0 --0.30 42 45 3 0 0.25
G-144 0 0.52 0.37 0.37 0 --0.37 45 45 0 0 0.30
G-134 1.00 2.86 2.05 3.05 1.00 --1.05 45(30) 45 0(15) 1.00 1.67
G-136 2.00 4.39 3.14 5.14 2.00 --1.14 29, 36(20, 43) 45 16, 9(25, 2) 2.00 2.56
G-138 3.00 6.14 4.38 7.38 3.00 --1.38 20, 30(69) 45 25, 15(-24) 3.00 3.57
G-139 4.00 6.93 4.95 8.95 4.00 --0.95 25, 15(45) 45 20, 30(0) 4.00 4.04
G-165 4.00 7.15 5.10 9.10 4.00 --1.10 1/•, •6(35)* 45 $0, 19(10) 4.00 4.16
G-186 4.00 2.61 5.17 9.17 4.00 --1.17 6(30, 37) 45 $9(15,8) 4.00 4.17
G-159 4.50 7.14 5.10 9.60 4.50 --0.60 /•(26, 19, 33) 45 40(19,26, 12) 4.50 4.16
G-188 4.50 3.11 6.16 10.66 4.50 --1.66 •(21, 27) 45 •0(24, 18) 4.50 5 .O3
Hollow
G-142 0 0.29 0.18 0.18 0 -0.18 45 45 0 0 0.15
G-145 0 0.33 0.21 0.21 0 -0.21 43 45 2 0 0.17
G-162 0 0.37 0.23 0.23 0 --0.23 45 45 0 0 0.19
Go163 0 0.33 0.21 0.21 0 --0.21 45 45 0 0 0.17
G-146 1.00 2.17 1.36 2.36 1.00 --0.36 45 45 0 1.00 1.11
G-147 2.00 3.19 2.01 4.01 2.00 -0.01 42 45 3 2.00 1.64
Go153 2.00 3.33 2.10 4.10 2.00 -0.10 45, 26 45 0, 19 2.00 1.71
G-166 3.00 4.75 2.99 5.99 3.00 0.01 11, •(60) 45 $4, 23(-15) 3.00 2.44
G-152 4.00 5.72 3.60 7.60 4.00 0.40 •, 33(76, 16) 45 •$, 12(--31, 29) 4.00 2.94
I 3 4 3
G-219 2.00 1.61 3.19 400 B 5.19 2.00 --1.19 25 45 20 2.00 2.60
G-216 3.00 2.02 3.99 300 B 6.99 3.00 --0.99 27, •0' 45 18, •5 3.00 3.26
G-218 3.00 2.08 4.11 400 B 7.11 3.00 --1.11 22 45 23 3.00 3.35
G-201 4 •00 2.36 4.67 200 B 8.67 4.00 --0.67 •4(72) 45 •1(-27) 4.00 3.81
G-209 4.00 1.81 3.59 300 B 7.59 4.00 0.41 0 45 45 4.00 2.91
G-246 4.00 3.02 5.99 400 B 9.99 4.00 --1.99 17 45 •8 4.00 4.88
G-247 4.00 2.62 5.19 400 B 9.19 4.00 --1.19 lS 45 •7 4.00 4.24
G-258 4.00 2.42 4.80 400 B 8.80 4.00 --0.80 45 •$ 4.00 3.92
G-248 4.50 2.24 4.44 200 B 8.94 4.50 0.06 15, (35) 45 $0, (10) 4.50 3.62
Compression
GT-271 1.50 7.92 300 B 9.42 1 5O 27 4.14 3.73
GT-272 1.50 10.03 400 T 11.53 1 50 4.84 4.72
GT-275 2.00 8.89 300 T 10.89 2 00 32 4.96 4.19
GT-276 2.00 8.48 400 D 10.48 2 00 27 4.83 3.99
GT-277 2.50 9.53 100 B 12.03 2 50 34 5.68 4.49
GT-270 2.50 9.24 200 T 11.74 2 50 30 5 58 4.35
GT-273 3.00 8.02 25 B 11.02 3 00 21 5 67 3.78
GT-274 3.00 10.48 100 T 13.48 3 00 31 6 49 4.77
GT-282 3.00 8.88 200 D 11.88 3.00 •-•23 5 96 4.19
GT-278 3.50 8.94 25 B 12.44 3.50 22 6 48 4.21
G T-280 3.50 10.10 100 T 13.60 3.50 31 6 87 4.73
Extension
GT-672 8.90 7.35 300 B 8.90 1.55 0, •-•14 6.45 3.46
GT-673 10.00 7.65 300 B 10.00 2.35 0 7.45 3.51
GT-674 10.00 7.50 400 B 10.00 2.50 21 7.50 3.53
217, 228, 234 may not realistically reflect true 400øC, respectively (Tables 11, 13, and 15).
strength and ductility. Experiment GT-257 Ultimate strengthat the transitiondropsabout
was done with a hollow piston which allowed 30% at room temperature but remains about
any fluid phase to escapeto the atmosphere. constant at 400øC. In extension at 400øC and
This specimenis both ductileand strongand 10-7 per secondstrain rate, the mean pressure
seemsmore consistentwith the remainingdata. at the transitionis at least7.5 kb. At 10-' per
Torsion tests, high temperature. The brit- second,the meanpressureis expectedto be still
tle-ductile transition in torsion can be reached higher.
only at the highestpressure-temperature con- Torsion tests, low strain rate. Torsion tests
ditions in our apparatus, about 400øC and on solid cylindersat 10-• per seconddisclose
4 kb. Specimens G-246 and 247 barely show that the tenfold reduction in strain rate has
transitional behavior (Table 14). The octa- loweredthe transitionmean pressureat 400øC
hedral shearstressat the transition (about 4.5 from about4.4 to 3.8 kb. However,the rockis
kb) seemsto exceedthat (about4.2 kb) at the still brittle at 300øCand 4 kb (Table 16). The
samemeanpressureat 25øC (Table 12). octahedralshear stressat 400øC drops from
Triaxial tests,low strain rate. Compression about 4.2 to 3.5 kb at 4 kb mean pressure
tests at the thousandfold lower strain rate of (Tables12 and 16).
10-7 per secondreveal that the mean pressure
of the britfie-ductile transition is lowered from PYREX GLASS
about 8.7 to 7.0 and 6.0 to 4.2 kb at 25 and Triaxial compression
and extensiontests,
G260 3.50 2.21 4.37 400 B 7.87 3.50 --0.87 20 45 25 3.50 3.57
G263 4.00 3.18 5.33 300 B 9.33 4.00 --1.33 45 45 0 4.00 4.22
G259 4.00 2.20 4.36 400 T 8.36 4.00 --0.36 21 45 24 4.00 3.52
G262 4.00 2.23 4.41 400 T 8.41 4.00 --0.41 22 45 23 4.00 3.44
EFFECTS OF INTERMEDIATE PRINCIPAL STRESS ON FAILURE 633
No. kb kb kb kb deg kb kb
Compression
GT-168 0 11.41 11.41 0 3.80 5.38
GT-170 0 10.68 10.68 0 3.56 5.03
GT-172 1.00 19.34 20.34 1.00 7.44 9.12
GT-174 2.00 24.12 '26.12 2.00 10.03 11.37
GT-183 4.00 26.52 30.52 4.00 12.84 13.50
Extension
GT-591 1.00 1.29 1.00 -0.29 0 0.57 0.61
GT-593 2.00 2.26 2.00 -0.26 0 1.25 1.07
GT-595 3.00 3.17 3.00 -0.17 0 1.95 1.50
GT-597 4.00 4.32 4.00 -0.32 0 2.56 2.06
room temperature. In triaxial compressionthe 320 bars (Table 17). The linear relations for
glass is brittle at all confining pressures,and compressionand extension,respectively,are
it becomes enormously strong. The ultimate
strength is 26 kb at 4 kb pressure(Table 17). •'o• = 1.50 -]- 1.01pm
The octahedral shear stress-mean pressure •'o• = 0.20 -]- 0.72p,•
curve (Figure 14) is nearly linear to the highest
value of p• -- 12.8 kb. The shear fracture is Torsion tests, room temperature. Testing of
both solid and hollow cylinders involved pure
catastrophic; the specimensshatter, and no
torsion or torsion under confining pressure
fault anglescan be measured.
In triaxial extensionthe glass is also brittle
only; no axial loadswere applied. All specimens
at all pressures,and failure is due to tensile
fail at negative (tensile) values of a8 by tensile
fracture at uniaxial tensile stresses of 170 to fracturing at small total maximum shear strains
(Table 18). No faulting is observed;all speci-
mensare regardedas brittle. The deformedglass
typically shows closely spaced parallel helical
-- PYREX
GLA!S tensile fractures (Figure 13). The octahedral
shear stress-mean pressure curves are nearly
ICom
PR
ESSI•
/ linear (Figure 14), and for solid and hollow
cylinders,respectively,
.. ION {SOLIDI
6
•'o•t - 0.76 -]- 1.13p,,
•-o•t = 0.50 -]- 0.81p,,
The highest tensile stress measured (650
-- o bars) exceedsthat observedin extension (320
bars) by a factor of 2. The reason for this is
not understood.W. F. Brace (personal com-
munication,June 1966) has suggestedthe pos-
sible importance of stress gradients to the
• •,, I I ...... I I I
apparent tensfiestrengthsof very brittle ma-
00 2 ß 4 6 8 10 terials.
Pm{kb}
PrincipalStresses,
p =if2 = M, r=y kb Major Major
Exp. % -- •, dyne-cm max, (Minor) •, (Minor)
No. kb X l0 s kb • •. a8 a, deg deg 0,deg
Solid
G-131 0 0.85 0.61 0.61 0 -0.61 45 45 0 0 0.50
G-143 0 1.18 0.84 0.84 0 -0.84 45 45 0 0 O. 60
G-133 1.00 3.22 2.30 3.30 1.00 -1.30 45 45 0 1.00 1.87
G-135 2.00 5.21 3.72 5.72 2.00 -1.72 45 45 0 2. O0 3.04
G-137 3.00 6.77 4.84 7.84 3.00 -1.84 45 45 0 3. O0 3.95
G-164 4.00 9.27 6.62 10.62 4.00 -2.62 45 45 0 4. O0 5.41
G-151 4.50 10.09 7.20 11.70 4.50 -2.70 43 45 2 4.50 5.88
Hollow
G-160 0 0.99 0.62 0.62 0 -0.62 45 45 0 0 0.51
G-161 0 0.97 0.61 0.61 0 -0.61 45 45 0 0 0.50
G-154 1.00 2.62 1.65 2.65 1.00 -0.65 47 45 -2 1.00 1.35
G-155 2.00 4.19 2.64 4.64 2.00 -0.64 45 45 0 2.00 2.16
G-176 2.00 3.69 2.33 4.33 2.00 -0.33 43, 0 45 2, 45 2.00 1.90
G-157 3.00 5.50 3.47 6.47 3.00 -0.47 43 45 2 3.00 2.83
G-lB0 3.00 5.57 3.51 6.51 3.00 -0.51 45 45 0 3.00 2.87
G-196 3.00 5.69 3.59 6.59 3.00 -0.59 45 45 0 3.00 2.94
G-158 4.00 7.00 4.41 8.41 4.00 -0.41 44 45 1 4.00 3.60
G-167 4.00 7.19 4.54 8.54 4.00 -0.54 42 45 3 4.00 3.71
G-197 4.50 7.43 4.68 9.18 4.50 -0.18 45 45 0 4.50 3.84
pressiontest ((r• > (rs= (rs) or an extension under different states of stress and to account
test ((r8 < (rs = (r•) under otherwiseidentical for all three principalstresses, we can plot
conditions,we would like to assessthe influence oetahedralshearstressversusmean pressure
of •r•, the intermediateprincipalstress.This (equation 3). Thereare,of course,manyother
will
canbelie done
midway
by twisting
between athe
cylinder
extreme
in principal
which(r, waysto displaythesedata, but we are awareof
no scheme that hasa clearadvantage overthe
stresses(Table 1). To comparedeformations methodwe have adopted.Suchplots for ex-
tension,compression,and torsionof Solenhofen
SOLENhOFEN'
LIME'STONE limestonearecollected
in Figure15.
The curvefor hollowcylindersin whichthe
stresses
are nearly uniform can be compared
directly with those derived from triaxial tests.
3
TORSION
(SOLID).--.,•
/ It lies above the extensioncurve and below the
i compressioncurve.This is the tendencythat
COMPRESSlON-•
• -TORSION
(HOLLOW) wouldbe expected if the relativemagnitude
of
// /,,•//•-EXTENSION (rsis important.However,we wonderwhy it
doesnot lie midwaybetween.
/ // To meanpressures
of the orderof 3 kb, the
failure mechanismboth in hollowtorsionand
o
in extensionspecimens is tensilefracturing.In
o
I 2 Pm•kb) 4 5 6 extensionthe tensilebreakingstrength,--•r• --
0.15kb, is essentially
constantandindependent
Fig. 15. Summary of octahedral shear stress- of mean pressure(Table 4). In torsionthe
mean pressure relations for failure of Solenhofen
extension,and torsion maximum
limestonein compression, tensilestressachieved
at ruptureis
(solidand hollowcylinders)at 25øCand 10-• per aboutthe same(Table6), and Braziltestsalso
second. disclose
a constanttensilestrengthof the same
EFFECTS OF INTERMEDIATE PRINCIPAL STRESS ON FAILURE 635
SOLENHOFEN LIMESTONE
25øC, • =10'4/ sec
curve as lying a little above its observed
counterpart because•oet should be somewha•
larger at a given p,• (greater than zero). How-
ever, the conclusionswill not be significantly
modified.
O0 2 3 4
At mean pressuresin the linear range of the NORMALSTRESS,kb
compressioncurve (1 to 2 kb), failure which is
Fig. 17. Mohr envelopes for failure of Solen-
duetoshear
fracturing
orfaulting
isnotinde- hofenlimestone
underdifferent
loading
condi-
pendentof meanpressure,
and it depends
on tions.Heavylinesindicate
regions
of faluting.
636 HANDIN, HEARD, AND MAGOUIRK
TABLE 19. Coefficients
for the LinearOctahedral The angle 0 appears to approachabout 30ø
Shear Stress-Mean PressureRelations at the brittle-ductile transition for all states of
root= a q- bp,•. stressat roomtemperature.
The oetahedral shear stress-mean pressure
Solenhofen Blair Pyrex
Limestone
Dolomite Glass curves
forBlairdolomite
andPyrex
glass
under
the samethree statesof stress(Figures12 and
Experiment a b a b a b 14) are qualitativelysimilar to the limestone
curves. At room temperature, however, the
Compression
0.82 0.75 1.20 0.80 1.50 1.01 brittle-ductile
transitionin the dolomitecanbe
Extension 0.17 0.65 0.30 0.67 0.20 0.72 reachedonly in triaxial compression under
Torsion
(hollow) 0.12 0.70 0.18 0.80 0.50 0.81
available
mean
pressures,
andtheglass
isbrittle
Torsion in alltypesoftests.
(solid) 0.52 0.90 0.74 0.94 0.72 1.13 The linearoetahedralshearstress-mean
pres-
sure relations for all three materials are col-
lected in Table 19. The slopesb for extension
hedral shear stress-meanpressure curves are and for torsion of hollow cylinders all agree
concavedownward, and all seem to be ap- with the predicted values of 0.7 and 0.8, re-
proachingthe same limiting value of roet of speetively,for failure due to tensile fracture
about 2.5 to 3.0 kb. This is consistentwith the at constant tensile strength (Figure 16). The
fact that the yield stressfor flow in the due- compression coefficientsfor limestoneand dolo-
tile state is essentiallyindependentof mean mite are about the same (b = 0.8), but the
pressure;the curvesbecomehorizontalat about compressire strengthof glassis somewhatmore
the samevalue of root,which impliesthat yield- sensitive(b ----1.0).
ing is governedby the yon Mises condition,in- Comparisono/ solid and hollow cylinders.
dependentlyof the meanpressure. The torsion curves for solid cylindersevery-
The same mechanism,namely faulting, op- where lie abovethosefor hollowcylinders,pre-
crates in all three types of test only over a sumably becausethey representthe maxim'urn
narrow range of mean pressure,about 2 to 3 values of r•, at the periphery. Thus, for ex-
kb. Even here,however,no manipulationof the ample, in G-27 (Table 5), ,, -- --0.35 kb at
data reveals any stress-dependent failure eri- p• = 0, which is more than twice the highest
terion that successfullycorrelates the tests probable tensile strength; even higher values
under different loading conditions. The Cou- are recordedin other specimens.These impossi-
lomb-Mohr criterion dearly fails becausethe bly high apparent tensilestrengthsare ascribed
envelopesdiffer widely (Figure 17). Account- to the support of less highly stressedrock in
ing for the third stressinvariant doesnot help the centralregion.
[see, for example, Bresler and Pister, 1955]. One objective has been to find a consistent
Griftith'sfracturetheoryextended
to threedi- empiricalrelationship
betweentorsioncurves
mensionsis alsoinadequate[Jaeger,1966]. for solid cylinders in which the shear stress
At the same mean pressure,say 2.7 kb, the varies and hollow cylinders in which the
fault angle 0 is 10ø in extensionand 30ø in stressesare nearly uniform. This relationship
compression, so that 0 alsoseemsto dependon would eliminate the test limitation to very
the relative magnitudeof ,•. In torsion,fault- fine grain size and the costly sampleprepara-
ing first occurs (with extensionfracturing) at tion of hollow cylinders.Comparingthe linear
2.0 kb where the average 0 ----24ø. At 3.0 and curves showsthat for both limestone (Figure
4.0 kb the average angles are about 27ø and 15) and dolomite (Figure 12) the hollow-eyl-
28ø, respectively.Thus at the same pressures, inder curves can be predicted by dividing the
faulting in torsion occursat inclinationsthat intercept a of the solid-cylindercurvesby 4
are lower than thosein compression and higher and reducingthe slope b by a factor of 0.8
than thosein extension,
thoughnot midwaybe- (Table 19). For glassthe ratio of the slopesis
tween. To establisha full functional relation- slightly less,about 0.7, but the ratio of inter-
ship between0 and ,•, further tests would be eepts 0.72/0.50 is only 1.4. However, we are
required in torsion combinedwith extension. fairly confidentthat data from a solidcylinder
EFFECTS OF INTERMEDIATE PRINCIPAL STRESS ON FAILURE 637
I
BRITTLE-DUCTILE TRANSITION
ß
SOLENHOFEN LIMESTON E
ß DUCTILE
0 TRANSITIONAL
x BRITTLE
.x
I _© ßDUCTIL
o TRANSITIONAL
x BRITTLE
_
• DUCTILE
- x >•COMPRE
h ,
--ß BRITTLE
•DUCTILE
-- BRITTLE
- i xi
from 215 to 400øC. He has also found that the
transition confiningpressureover the range of
215to 1500øCdrops from 1 to 0 and from 7.15to
2.8 kb in compressionand extension,respec-
tively [Heard, 1960, Figure 7]. Torsional
' • BRIT•DUCTILE strengthis also reducedby heating (½f. Tables
O0 200 400 600 6 and 8), but, since high-temperature tests
TEMPERATURE, øC
were not doneon hollowcylinders,the stresses
Fig. 18. Confining pressureversus temperature developedin twistedspecimens
are not directly
of the brittle-ductile transition of solid cylinders
comparablewith those measuredby Heard.
of Solenhofen limestone in compressionand ex-
tension [after Heard, 1960] and torsion at 10-• per However, the brittle-ductile transitionsat 215øC
second. occur at about the same mean pressures(3.5
638 HANDIN, HEARD, AND MAGOUIRK
from 3.5 to 2.0 kb over the interval 25 to
--
I
BRITTLE-DUCTILE TRANSITION
400øC and to remain more or less midway be-
tween the higher extension and lower com-
pression curves. This effect strongly suggests
that relative ductility is a nearly linear function
of the relative magnitude of (r, over a wide
temperature interval.
Figure 19 showsa similar plot of compression
and torsion data for Blair dolomite from Tables
II
i\ DUCTILE
I
BRITTLE
•=10 /sec
•EXTEN•ION
.• y- \• ,o•,•ec
BRITTLE- DUCTILE TRANSITION
BLAIR DOLOMITE
ß DUCTILE
-
_ • ?DUCTIL
I
BRITTLE
I •,O'•/sec
200
• ,;"/secI 400 600
TEMPERATURE, øC
11, 12, 13, and 14. The compression transition brittle region as observed in compression,ex-
confiningpressuredecreaseslinearly from about tension,and torsion tests. However, we regard
4.5 kb at room temperature to about 2.5 kb the followingobservationsas significant.
at 400øC. In torsion the transition occurs at
1. Tensile breaking strengih is essentially
slightly greater than 4 kb at 400øC; it could
constant and equal to the value of --(r, at
not be traced to higher pressuresat lower tem- fracture.
peraturesbut certainly lies well abovethe com-
2. In the brittle state, the shearstrengthof
pressiontransitionas expected.
the material doesdependon the relative magni-
For all states of stress the fault angles 0
tude of the intermediate principal stress
tend to increasewith increasingtemperature--
Over the region of mean pressurein Solenhofen
that is, to approachpositionsof maximumshear
limestone where faulting occurs in all three
stressat 45øC to •.
tests (2 to 3 kb), the ultimate octahedralshear
Effects o• strain rate. Heard [1962] had al-
strength is greater in torsion than in extension
ready studied the influenceof a thousandfold
((r• = (r,) and lessthan in compression((r2 =
changeof strain rate on the triaxial compres-
sion of Solenhofen limestone. The variation
3. The fault angle measuredwith respectto
from 10-' to 10-7 per secondlowers the transi-
(r• also dependson (r•: about 30ø, 20ø, and 10ø
tion confiningpressurefrom 1.0 to 0.8 kb at
25øC and from 0.7 to 0 kb at 270øC. His com-
in compression, torsion, and extension,respec-
tively, in the limestone.
pressioncurvesand his extensioncurve at 10-•
4. The brittle-ductiletransition in limestone,
are reproducedin Figure 20. Shown are the
torsion curves at 10-' and 10-' from the data of
for example,also dependson (r•. At room tem-
Tables 8 and 10.
perature the mean transition pressureis about
2.7, 4.0, and 5.4 kb in compression, torsion,and
In extension,a drop of transition confining
extension,respectively.
pressurefrom about 7.4 to 6.6 kb at 25øC and
5. In the fully ductile region the octahedral
from 2.8 to 1.5 at 500øC accompanies the
shearstressfor yieldingis about the samein all
thousandfoldlowering of strain rate. In torsion
three testsand is independentof meanpressure
the effectsof only a tenfold rate reduction are
--that is, the von Mises yield conditionholdsat
significant.Transition pressuresare 15% lower
leastapproximately.
at 25øC and 25% at 400øC. Again, the torsion
6. At a given strain rate an increase in
transition remainsmore or lessmidway between
temperature or at a given temperature a de-
thosefor compressionand extensionat the same crease in strain rate lowers the transition con-
strain rate.
finingpressure(-- (r•) in all three tests.
Similar plots for Blair dolomite (Figure 21)
alsoreveallarge effects.The compression transi- Acknowledgments. Discussions with Professors
tion curve at 10-7 from data of Table 15 is about D. T. Griggs, W. F. Brace, and M. S. Paterson
have most helpful.
10% below the curve at 10-• at room tempera- This research was supported by the Air Force
ture and about 40% lower at 400øC. The tor- Cambridge Research Laboratories under contract
sion transition curve appearsto be appreciably AF19(628)-2784 in connection with project Vela-
loweredby the tenfold drop of shearstrain rate Uniform of the Advanced Research Project
Agency.
even though the data (Table 16) are sparse.In
extension at 10-7 and 400øC the transition must REFERENCES
occur a little above 10 kb confining pressure.
Thus the expectedpositionof the torsiontransi- Bresler, B., and K. S. PisSer,Failure of plane con-
crete under combined stresses,Proc. Am. Soc.
tion at the same conditions would certainly
Civil Engrs., 81, 1049-1059, 1955.
lie much closerto the compressionthan to the BSker, R., Die Mechanik der bleibenden Form-
extensioncurve and not about midway between anderungen in Kristallinisch aufgebauten KSr-
as is true of the limestone. pern, Vet. Deut. Ingr. M. H. Forschungsarbeiten,
175, 1-51, 1915.
CONCLUSIONS Brace, W. F., Bri•tle fracture of rocks, in Proc.
Intem. Con•. on Slate o• Stress in Earth's
We have found no adequatecriterion in terms C•st, pp. 111-174, Elsevier Publishing Com-
of stressalone for macroscopicfracture in the pany, Amsterdam and New York, 1964.
640 HANDIN, HEARD, AND MAGOUIRK
Frocht, M. M., Photoelasticity, John Wiley & Ph.D., thesis, University of California, Los
Sons, New York, 1941. Angeles,1962.
Griggs, D., and J. Handin, Observationson frac- Heard, H. C., Effect of large changesin strain
ture and a hypothesisof earthquakes,in Rock rate in the experimental deformation of Yule
Deiormation, Geol. Soc. Am. Mem. 79, 347-364, margle, J. Geol., 71, 162-195, 1963.
1960. Heard, H. C., Thermally activatedflow in quartz,
Griggs,D., F. J. Turner, and It. C. Heard, Defor- Trans. Am. Geophys. Union, 46, 698-699, 1965.
mation of rocks at 500ø-800øC, in Rock De- Jaeger,J. C., Elasticity, Fracture, and Flow, 212
formation, Geol. Soc. Am. Mem. 79, 39-104, pp., John Wiley & Sons,New York, 1962.
1960. Jaeger, J. C., The brittle failure of rocks, in
Handin, J., An application of high pressurein Symp. Rock Mechanics, 8th, University of
geophysics: Experimental rock deformation, Minnesota, in press,1967.
Trans. Am. Soc. Mech. Engrs., 75, 315-324, 1953. Jaeger, J. C., and E. R. Hoskins, Rock failure
Handin, J., Strength and ductility, in Handbook under the confined Brazilian test, J. Geophys.
o] Physical Constants,edited by S. P. Clark, R es.,71, 2651-2660, 1966.
Jr., section 11, Geol. Soc. Am. Mem., 97, 1966. Paterson, M. S., Triaxial testing of materials at
Handin, J., and R. V. Hager, Jr., Experimental pressuresup to 10,000 kg/cm' (150,000lb./sq.
deformation of sedimentary rocks under con- in.), J. Inst. Engrs., Australia, 23-30, Jan.-Feb.,
fining pressure: Tests at room temperature on 1964.
dry samples,Bull. Am. Assoc.Petrol. Geologists, Robertson, E. C., Experimental study of the
41, 1-50, 1957. strengthof rocks,Bull. Geol. Soc.Am., 66, 1275-
Handin, J., and R. V. Hager, Jr., Experimental 1314, 1955.
deformation of sedimentary rocks under con- Serdengecti,S., and G. D. Boozer, The effectsof
fining pressure:Tests at high temperature,Bull. strain rate and temperature on the behavior
Am. Assoc. Petrol. Geologists, 42, 2892-2934, of rocks subjected to triaxial compression,in
1958. Symp. Rock Mechanics,4th, PennsylvaniaState
Handin, J., D. V. Higgs,and J. K. O'Brien, Tor- State University, 83-97, 1961.
sion of Yule marble under confining pressure,in Timoshenko, S., Theory o/ Elasticity, 518 pp.,
Rock Deformation, Geol. Soc. Am. Mem., 79, McGraw-Hill Book Company, New York, 1934.
245-274, 1960. von K•rm•n, Th., Festigkeitsversuche unter all-
Heard, H. C., Transition from brittle fracture to seitigem Druck: Z. Vet. Deut. Ingr., 55, 1749-
ductile flow in Solenhofen limestone as a func- 1757, 1911.
tion of temperature,confiningpressure,and in-
terstitial fluid pressure,in Rock Deformation,
Geol. Soc. Am. Mem. 79, 193-226, 1960.
Heard, H. C•, The effectof largechanges
in strain
rate in the experimentaldeformation of rocks, (Received July 29, 1966.)