Analysis:
This past Monday, I met with seven sixth graders to hear their inputs on my original
work. Since my seminar targets middle school children, what better way to gauge their
interest in the program than to directly ask them. I half-expected them to groan and
complain about learning finance and budgeting, but surprisingly they were extremely
enthusiastic. As budding teenagers, they felt that learning how to handle expenses
made them feel older, more mature, and even like an adult.
I started by asking what they would like to learn about finance, which would
influence the content at the heart of the program. The main response I got was to
explain what types of expenses an adult has and how do to manage them. Taxes, loans,
and mortgages also fell into this category. Besides expenses and savings, the kids
wanted to know the government’s relationship with money. They are especially
curious as to what factors determine the value of a currency, since their world
geography class talks about current events and news like the 2008 Recession. The stock
market also piqued their interest as the kids believed that stocks were the easiest way
to make money. And they did not just stop there, in fact, these children wanted to learn
about predicting market trends, about inflation, and about tariffs in a global economy.
But I had to stop them there because I did not want to go too deep into finance as a
subject in the seminar. I stayed grounded by reminding myself that the goal of the
program was simply to teach middle school children the value of savings and
After what to learn, I asked the children how they want to learn. As a student
endless chapters in the textbook. I wanted to branch out and teach in an active and
engaging way, but I personally did not know how. The students suggested that I use
some PowerPoints to introduce the various concepts, but teach them through hands-on
games. For instance, I could create a life-size Monopoly that includes squares with
realistic expenses like insurance and retirement funds, which would then educate
players without boring them. In addition, I could give each student some fake money at
the beginning of the seminar and test how effectively they can budget throughout the
program to save for long-term financial success. I would give them opportunities to
invest in stocks and set aside money for their 401K, while charging them taxes and loan
payments. This would teach them how to budget and save money in a practical
manner.
The one thing the students told me not to do was to create a digital platform
teaching the content. They actually learn about finance in school through a online
software. But the kids find it boring since there is no human interaction, competitive
spirit, and active games to keep them engaged. This narrowed down the methods that I
can effectively convey my message, as the kids prefer small group, hands-on activities
Lastly, the middle schoolers gave me a brilliant suggestion for the final game
show. According to my original work proposal, I wanted to include a game at the end of
the seminar to ultimately test the effectiveness of the program. The students suggested
that I open fake accounts for each kid and give them money at the beginning of the
seminar with opportunities to invest it in stocks or funds. On the last day, I would have
five stations set up, each with ways to improve the student’s portfolio. The students
would have one hour to best budget their money to ensure long-term financial success.
For instance, one station would have a trivia about financial concepts covered in the
seminar, where right answers would earn the student money. In addition, there could
be a bank station with computers in which students can access their account and
transfer money between stocks, accounts, and funds. The kids wanted the
environment to be fast-paced and chaotic because it would demand both their mental
and physical alertness. This type of environment creates a healthy competition which
furthermore motivates the student. At the end, the student with the most balanced
portfolio that ensures the most success in the long-term would earn a prize.
Sitting down with middle schoolers unexpectedly solidified my ideas for the
seminar and also motivated me to pursue my cause. The students showed genuine
interest in learning about finance and budgeting, but are not given the proper tools to
further this interest. I hope to turn my seminar into a tool that prepares kids to handle
their financial health. In addition, their ideas were unique and reflected their needs as
students - they wanted smaller classes, less monotonous activities, and a more
practical approach, which gave me ideas of how I can teach the various concepts. With
this meeting, my brainstorming phase of the original work concluded as I need to start