ON
WITH REFERENCE TO
With great pleasure I would like to present my sincere gratitude to Mrs. Pooja rathi maam
our teacher for helping me throughout my project and providing her guidance to me. I would
also like to take this opportunity to thank our H.O.D Mr. T.G Madhusoodhanan, coordinator
of Mats School of Business Studies, for giving us this project which made us gain practical
I express my heartiest thanks to the faculties for giving me an opportunity to work under their
project.
I would like to extend my sincere thanks to all the respondents to whom I visited for giving
their support and valuable information which helps me in completing my project work. I
would also thank my institution and my faculty members without whom this project would
I would also like to thank my parents and friends who helped me to make this project and
MAHIMA TOPPO
B.Com Vth Semester
CERTIFICATE
in this project work has not been submitted earlier for award of any degree or diploma to the
T.G.MADHUSOODHANAN
Date:
APPROVAL CERTIFICATE
This is to approve that the work presented in the project titled “Comparative Analysis of
Private and Government Hospital” was carried out by Mahima Toppo and submitted for
the partial fulfillment of the requirement for the award of the degree of Bachelor of
Commerce in Mats University is the original work carried out under the guidance and
supervision of MRS. Pooja Rathi maam and that no part of this work has been submitted
T.G.MADHUSOODHANAN
I Mahima Toppo hereby declare that this project is record of authentic work carried out by
me during the academic year 2016-2017 Submitted in partial fulfillment of the degree of
bachelor of commerce to Mats University has not been submitted to any other university or
institute towards the award of any degree to the best of my knowledge and belief.
The entire data, figure and information belong to selected hospitals, based on collected by
myself.
Signature of student
Mahima Toppo
CONTENTS
PAGE
CHAPTER TITLE
NO.
INTRODUCTION
Introduction 1-2
THEORATICAL FRAMEWORK
Feedback 51-53
Limitations 57
III DATA ANALYSIS AND 59-65
INTERPRETATIONS
IV SUGGESSIONS 67-70
BIBILIOGRAPHY 72
CHAPTER
ONE
INTRODUCTION
Introduction
Each child born in a country is human resource who will add to the productivity and
prosperity of the nation. However, the responsibility of converting this latent resource in to an
active workforce lies with the Government, private sector and NGOs. They should be made
responsible for health care development in the country. A child suffering from poor health
lacks attendance in the school. Workers who suffer from childhood malnutrition are less
productive than healthy workers. India has one of the youngest populations in the world.
India is experiencing high growth since a decade. The sustainability of this high economic
growth rate requires huge investment in education and health care of the population
Government hospitals, some of which are among the best hospitals in India, provide
treatment at taxpayers’ expense. Before economic reforms in 1991, most essential drugs were
provided free of charge to all patients in these hospitals. Government hospitals provide
treatment either free or at minimal charges. For example, an outpatient card at AIIMS (one of
the best hospitals in India) costs a onetime fee of rupees 10 (around 20 cents US) and
thereafter outpatient medical advice is free. In-hospital treatment costs in these hospitals
depend on financial condition of the patient and facilities utilised by him but are usually
much less than the private sector. For instance, a patient is waived full treatment costs if
he/she is below poverty line. Another patient may seek for an air-conditioned room, if he is
willing to pay extra for it. The charges for basic in-hospital treatment and investigations are
much less in public hospitals as compared to the private hospitals. The cost for these
subsidies comes from annual financial allocations from the Central and State Governments.
In addition to the network of public and private hospitals, there are charitable dispensaries
and hospitals, many of which provide treatment and facilities parallel to those provided by
private hospitals at highly concessional rates or in some cases free of costs to the needy
population.
Primary health care is provided by city and district hospitals and rural primary health centres
(PHCs). These hospitals provide treatment free of cost. Primary health care is focused on
immunization, prevention of malnutrition, care during pregnancy, child birth, postnatal care,
and treatment of common illnesses. Patients who receive specialised care or have
complicated illnesses are referred to secondary care centres (often located in district and
taluka headquarters) and tertiary care hospitals (located in district and state headquarters or
In post-independence period, India has eradicated mass famines, however the country still
suffers from high levels of malnutrition and disease especially in rural areas. Water supply
and sanitation in India are also major issues and many Indians in rural areas lack access to
proper sanitation facilities and safe drinking water. However, at the same time, India's health
care system also includes facilities that meet or exceed international quality standards. The
medical tourism business in India has been growing in the recent years and as such India is a
popular destination for medical tourists who receive effective medical treatment at lower
Conceptual Background:
The health care industry, or medical industry, is an aggregation of sectors within the
economic system that provides goods and services to treat patients with curative, preventive,
rehabilitative, and palliative care. The modern health care industry is divided into many
sectors and depends on interdisciplinary teams of trained professionals and paraprofessionals
The health care industry is one of the world's largest and fastest-growing industries.
Consuming over 10 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) of most developed nations,
health care can form an enormous part of a country's economy. For purpose of finance and
management, the health care industry is typically divided into several areas. As a basic
framework for defining the sector, the United Nations International Standard Industrial
Classification (ISIC) categorizes the health care industry as generally consisting of:
1. hospital activities;
As this is comparative study on government and private hospital in Raipur . We have seen lot
of differences in both private and public in many terms no doubt with the data collected has
shown more response towards private hospitals then public hospitals. Private sector seems to
be much more effective in influencing policy making, satisfying the public at the local or
Health:
physical, mental and social well being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity”.
Necessarily, health has to be defined from a practical point of view and therefore, it has been
defined according to life expectancy, infant mortality, and crude death rate, etc.
measuring well-being, especially child welfare. India ranked 134th among 187 countries
Health Expenditure Per Capita is the sum of public and private health expenditure (in PPP,
International $) divided by total population. The health expenditure per capita stood at 45 $ in
the year 2009 in India, which lies much below the international standards.
Health Economics:
Health economics is the study of how scarce resources are allocated among alternative uses
for the care of sickness and the promotion, maintenance and improvement of health,
including the study of how health care and health-related services, their costs and benefits,
and health itself are distributed among individuals and groups in society.
Out-of- Pocket Expenditure on Health is the direct outlays of households, including gratuities
and in- kind payments made to health practitioners and to suppliers of pharmaceuticals,
therapeutic appliances and other goods and services. The out-of-pocket expenditure on health
Equity in health implies providing equal access to health facilities, equal use of services and
equal health status for all by distributing health services on the basis of need regardless of
income. There exist widespread disparities in India in providing health care services –
disparities in health care infrastructure in rural and urban areas, disparities in access to health
care services by men and women and also by rich and poor, disparities in health care
expenditure by public and private sector and also be various state governments.
Morbidity rate shows the departure from the ideal condition of health, i.e. a state of complete
physical, mental and social well being. Morbidity rate is high in slum areas than non-slum
areas. One of the obvious explanations for this high morbidity in slums is the degradation of
Nutrition:
Nutrition refers to food substances required to keep the body in good working condition, and
to supply fuel for energy. Good nutrition can help prevent disease and promote health. On an
average, per capita per day calorie intake is 2,496 and the per capita per day consumption of
protein is 59 grams. So far as the people below the poverty line are concerned, their average
per day calorie intake is not even 1,500 and many of them do not get even 30 grams of
Illness:
Webster’s International Dictionary defines illness as a state of being ill or sick, bodily
indisposition disease. It refers to anything affecting the total well-being of the patient.
Communicable diseases, maternal, peri-natal and nutritional disorders constitute 38 per cent
of deaths in India while non-communicable diseases account for 42 per cent of all deaths.
The concept of Primary Health Centre was introduced by Bhore Committee in 1946 as basic
health unit to provide health services to people as close to people as possible. Primary health
care means essential health care based on practical, scientifically sound and socially
acceptable methods and technology which is made universally accessible. Primary health care
in India is provided through a network of over 147,069 health sub-centres, 23,673 Public
Morbidity among women is the major issue in recent health policies. Women are more prone
to sickness due to neglect during puberty and at the reproductive age. Due to poor financial
condition women consume inferior quality and inadequate food which leads to anaemia. In
the allocation of food women always neglect themselves. The work burden is always more.
Expanding healthcare access is a critical priority for the Government of India and the private
sector. Efforts to date have addressed numerous issues and much progress can be reported.
Yet the gap between the aspiration - of providing quality healthcare on an equitable,
accessible and affordable basis across all regions and communities of the country - and
today’s reality is all too apparent. The extent of change and improvement in India’s
healthcare system over the past decade is remarkable. The Government of India’s initiatives,
as well as private sector actions and public-private-partnership programs, have all contributed
to this progress. Yet much more remains to be done. Understanding the current state of
healthcare access is one important and foundational element for determining priorities,
THE STUDY
The literature available, clearly indicates that much work has been done on various aspects of
Majority of the hospitals in India follow the western system of medicine and public hospitals
today are exclusively run in the administrative framework designed by the Britishers in the
increase in population and inadequate availability of facilities. Both the central and state
Governments have multiplied their investments on health sector since the First Five Year
Plan. Even though government spends crores of rupees in this area, patient satisfaction levels
are very low and hospitals continue to deteriorate. The private hospitals exploit the patients
without providing adequate facilities to the needy. These traditional and rigid organizations
At present, most of the hospitals are run by the Superintendent who is the senior-most
physician, with a small number of administrative staff. The administrative body generally
tends to rely on rules, procedures and techniques which have not changed over the years. A
good doctor may not be a good administrator. He himself is a doctor and has to attend to
many administrative matters. It is very difficult to attend to both kinds of duties effectively.
Time has changed and specialization has become the order of the day. In view of the
tremendous expansion in health services, it has become essential to have specialists or experts
not only in their fields but also in other fields of hospital administration so that maximum
services have thrown the administrative machinery completely out of gear. It is therefore,
imperative to have separate specialists for general administrative and personnel functions in
the hospitals. Moreover, earlier the patients used to favour a good doctor. In the recent years
the patient shifted his interest to availability of facilities in a hospital. Now the patient trusts a
hospital with well-reputed doctors. In this context, it is necessary to have a separate cadre of
administrators who combine some knowledge of medical system with sound management
principles.
In the present changed scenario, the public shows interest on corporate hospitals which run
their organizations on scientific principles. Some of the distinct features of these corporate
availability of all diagnostic facilities under one roof and (c) availability of different
specialists without any delay or inconvenience. Corporate hospitals make these facilities
hospitals also have some drawbacks. Basically, an average Indian citizen is not in a position
income group are not in a position to use this facility because if a patient wants to have a
kidney transplantation, he has to spend Rs.1 50,000 to Rs.2, 00,000 as package amount. For
coronary bypass surgery (CABG), one has to spend nearly Rs.1, 50,000. In this context, the
question arises as to how many patients can utilize these services. The answer is clear. Only
higher income group can afford, leaving all the other groups out of the reach.
The scope of the present study extends to analyze financial status of both the selected
government and private hospitals and comparison between both the hospitals and how far the
management functions are carried out effectively to satisfy their Out and In-patients in
sample units. The study however includes the comparative details of paramedical staff,
finance related aspects , Bed capacity, size, in- patients and out-patients super specialties
offered are taken as basis for sample selection of both the hospitals.
In the next step, an attempt has been made to elicit the opinions from patients about both
government and private health care because every human being carries a particular set of
thoughts, feelings and needs. It gives new ideas and suggestions. One must admit that there
are lots of things which could be altered. Moreover, the concept, scope and philosophy of the
hospital of today are far different from those of the past. Once upon a time, the hospitals were
regarded as curative institutions and today these hospitals are being recognized more and
To draw attention of policy makers of healthcare system and make suggestions for the
RESEARCH DESIGN
This study is mostly exploratory in nature and it aims at comparing the hospitalss. In this part,
an attempt has been made to explain the research design, the procedure of sample selection,
Cost of treatment at a public healthcare facility is more affordable than that available at a
private healthcare facility, and is dependent on the nature of treatment. The economic burden
of a treatment is significant for both poor and affording class of people , However, due to
lack of physical reach, availability of quality treatment, and other practices, people are forced
Quality of Services:
The standard of something as measured against other things of a similar kind; the degree of
excellence of something.
Patient Satisfaction:
The study shows that the first important factor that influences the overall service quality as
perceived by people is satisfaction. Hospitals need to focus on patient giving them personal
attention, providing in correct help and suggestion easy in and out service, doctor availability,
behaviour of doctors and staff emergency service and ensuring the accuracy of billing system
etc as per the study and the feedback taken this was effectively practices in private then the
public hospitals.
Timeliness:
Importance of understanding the high need for discipline professionalism empathy towards
individual is very important this is high requirement both in private and public hospitals.
METHODOLOGY-
The present study is an attempt to explore both public and private healthcare hospitals in
Raipur, and examine the performance of each sector. For this study a private hospital and a
government hospitals comparative feedback has been taken. Private, in this study refers to the
corporate sector in health care and government sector are used interchangeably. The scope is
so vast that the effort in this study is limited to private and Government hospitals. This study
answers many structured problems that the public faces. This study has been done through
TWO
THEORITICAL
FRAMEWORK
Selection of Sample Hospitals
There are more than 70 hospitals in Raipur alone. It is difficult for a researcher to take up all
the hospitals and study the existing financial analysis. For this reason a detailed study of two
hospitals that run on different lines were taken up for study.( i.e private hospital and public
hospital.)
Private hospital
A private hospital is one which is owned and governed by a person or many people who are
managing the whole finances on their own. Not just finances, even the whole funds process
and the administration, staff, all the doctors, everything is under control of that private body.
It has been seen that most of the people go for private hospitals and they prefer them over any
other option. This might be due to the facilities provided and the perception that all the
equipment used are reliable, of good quality, and better. However, the fact of private
hospitals being much more expensive and costly can also not be denied. The number of
facilities and the kind of individual care and attention given to the patient in a private hospital
is undeniable. These little yet highly paying services provided in a private hospital makes it
the first choice for any patient who can afford the price. Since no one wants to risk their lives
and get into more trouble caused by even the slightest of negligence on the part of treatment,
It is the largest government health care facility in Chhattisgarh. Located in the heart of
Public Hospital-
A public hospital, on the other hand, is completely and entirely run by the government
funding and money. Everything from the construction to the fees of the doctors to the
equipment, medicines are based on the government budget. Hence, each and every single
thing is being taken care of by the local government body. A public hospital is considered to
be a preferable option for the not-so-rich lot of people who, despite acute illness, cannot
afford the heavy fees of a private hospital. It is very ironical to see that a hospital that is
governed by the government, which has obviously more funds than a group of people or one
person alone, does not offer that level of service that can be counted on in most of the times.
However, this can be due to the fact that a government has a limited budget allocation to
health care as it has many things in its hands such as defense, education, economy, etc.
Dhamtari Road Raipur. It provides various facilities to the patients. Hospital aims to grow
the business while maintaining various levels of profitability, providing a basis for
INTRODUCTION
Dr. Bhimrao Ambedkar Memorial Hospital, Raipur is the largest government health care
facility in Chhattisgarh. Located in the heart of the city and within one kilometer from
railway station & bus stand, Dr. Bhimrao Ambedkar Hospital is commonly known as
Dr. Bhimrao Ambedkar Memorial hospital has medical facilities in all specialties and in
surgery. A highly developed radiotherapy & cancer department is the largest medical care
Besides OPD & general wards, hospital also has Medical ICU, Cardiac Care Unit, Post
Operative Ward, well equipped Operation Theatres for routine and emergency surgeries,
Critical Care Unit, Neonatal ICU, Labour Room, and Nephrology Unit with dialysis facilities.
A 24 hour casualty & trauma unit is supported by round the clock laboratory & radiological
services.
The hospital has state of the art equipments like latest 3 Tesla MRI, 128 Slice CT scan,
Linear Accelerator, Cobalt Machine, Digital Subtraction Angiography (DSA) &Cath lab. A
model blood bank insures adequate supply of tested blood & blood components to the
The Hospital also provides services under Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojna (RSBY), Mukhya
Hospital has other patients care facilities like ambulances, help counter, canteen, generic
medicine shop, pharmacy & injection room, mortuary and a separate OPD for senior citizens.
The hospital has facilities for mechanized central sterilization, lift & generator. MRD
(Medical Records Departments) has been established for registration and data recording of
the patients.
The Dr. Bhimrao Ambedkar Memorial Hospital is committed to provide excellent medical
care facilities and continuously growing opportunities for medical education, research &
training in Chhattisgarh.
Objective-
providing comprehensive health care under one roof, the hospital is equipped with all
Hospital provides high quality and cost effective medical services to all sections of the
society.
Will give Personal Attention to all our patients, treating them as our friends and
family members. We shall provide a good environment for our Healthcare Team.
Special provisions are also available to those who are unable to afford cost of medical
treatment.
SUPPORT SERVICE
The storage and description of medicines and the other medical equipments of Central
1. Storage-
The medicines and other medical equipments are purchased by the purchase
department of the hospital; the related firm supplies the medicines as per requirement.
employees maintain the daily expenditure register, the batch expiry no., details of bill,
stock and the other required information is maintained in it. At the time of supply,
firm provide 3 bill copy to us. This is sent to Dispatch department to record received
We keep one copy of bill and the other 2 is sent to the purchase officer for
medicine/article in our computer software regularly. The medicines, injection and the
other medical equipment are placed in rack according to alphabetical order and by
2. Description:
During this procedure the computer software is placed central medicine store
which demand is online, which is also known as indent. According to the stock this indent
ismade, the Central Medicine store generate an issue voucher which is kept by store. The 2
copy is released in which one is distributed to the related wards, and the other to sore for
stock entry. The pharmacist matches the drugs volume through the medicine voucher. The
related calculations are matched by the departmental nurse, officers and doctors.
3. Stock Management:
expenditure register. And by the end of month, the stock register is maintained as the
consumption of medicines is done. The expenditure and stock register of all materials like
tablets, disposable, dressing material suture, soap cancer medicine, x-ray material and
permanent artier are maintained separately. The expenditure of articles is daily the end of the
For the purchase of medicines as required by the central medicine store based on
consumption of pharmaceuticals for 3month, a demand letter is given to Joint Director cum
Superintendent, and as the demand letter is given by the wards, according to that from time to
Pharmacy-
Hospital pharmacies are within the premises of a hospital which provides a huge quantity of
medications per day which is allocated to the main entrance, wards and to intensive care unit
pharmaceutical activities such as dispensing and manufacturing. Then, the increasing range
and sophistication of medicines available, awareness of medication errors and the widespread
use of ward-based prescription charts brought pharmacists out of the dispensary and on to the
wards in increasing numbers. Pharmacist and trained pharmacy technicians compound sterile
products for patients including total parenteral nutrition (TPN), and other medications given
intravenously e.g. Neonatal antibiotics and chemotherapy this is a complex process that
requires adequate training of personnel, quality assurance of products, and adequate facilities.
Hospital pharmacies typically provide medications for the hospitalized patients only, and are
not retail establishments. They typically do not provide prescription service to the public.
Kitchen-
Kitchen of the hospital takes care of diet of the patients admitted in different wards. Every
day breakfast, lunch & dinner of about 700 patients is prepared under hygienic conditions and
under supervision of dietician. Fruits and milk are also included as per the requirement.
Special diets like Liquid Diet, Hyper Tension diet, Diabetic diet etc are provided as per the
patient's requirement. Special diet is also provided to pregnant women and lactating mothers
Laundry-
Hospital laundry is enticed with the reponsiblity of provided clean and hygenic linen to
various wards, OTs and other pateint care area of the hospital. Laundry of Dr. Bhim Rao
The laundry service has been outsourced to an outside agency which ensure collections of
dirty linen, washing, ironing and distribution of linen within different area of the hospital.
The central sterile services department (CSSD) is an integrated place in hospital that
performs sterilization and other actions on medical devices, equipment and consumables for
subsequent use by health workers in the operating theatre of the hospital and also for other
The operations usually consist of cleaning of previously used devices, like stainless steel
tools, with a sterilizing liquid. After drying the device on a stand (not by hand or cloth) it gets
wrapped in a specialized paper bag (called an aseptor bag), tape-sealed and then sterilized by
to the end-user as a sterile product. If along the supply route, the sealed package got damaged
A sterile processing technician is someone who cleans and sterilizes used surgical
instruments and other [medical supplies] so that they can be safely redistributed and reused
on additional patients. This work is usually centralized in a special department of the medical
facility.
Ambulance-
1. Hours Ambulance-
with the necessary facilities, like monitors, defibrillators, ventilators and continuous oxygen
supply. Ambulance services are available in the hospital for 7x24x365 days. Free Ambulance
service is provided trauma patients as and when required. Our fleet of 4 ambulances. Have
young, skilled emergency medical technicians who are trained in basic life support and
advanced cardiac life support. They accompany the patient during transportation.
The services of doctors trained in emergency medicine are always available to accompany the
2. sanjeevni 108-
The Sanjeevani Express is well equipped with basic and state of art instruments to
handle the emergency cases on its way to hospitals - oxygen, suction machine, medicines, BP
operator and delivery kits besides other high end equipments make these ambulances efficient
to handle emergency cases. Along with the vehicle come four types of stretchers which help
in carrying patients in difficult cases like – rough roads, fire cases, commuting in hilly
terrains and water bound regions. Previously, after a road accident or in other emergency
cases there used to be a substantial delay in accessing the treatment. This used to be the
But since the advent of Sanjeevani it takes only 15 minutes in towns and 30 – 35 minutes in
villages for an emergency ambulance to reach the patient. Toll free number 108 connects
directly to Raipur located control room which carries out a conference call between the caller
and the Sanjeevani ambulance which is already in a standby mode in the closest proximity
and runs for the help of the caller after noting down the details of the location/accident spot.
In a frantic bid to coincide the launch of the 'Mahtari' Express service with the chief
minister's Vikas Yatra, the Chhattisgarh health department on providing free transportation to
pregnant women and children below the age of one year without the mandatory telephone
institutional deliveries, under the centrally sponsored National Rural Health Mission
(NRHM), is available in almost all other states across the country on phone number 102.
5. Muktanjali 1099-
The service christened as ‘Muktanjali’ would be offered in all the district hospitals
and the vans could be summoned by dialling toll free number ‘1099’. The ‘Muktanjali’ van
would bring home the mortal remains of the person on account of his or her sudden death
from the government hospital free of cost. The service launched by the Health and Family
Welfare Department would provide great relief especially to the financial weaker families.
The use of information and communication technologies has become widespread in the
hospital. Technology has taken over the daily schedules of hospitals, and has allowed nurses
and doctors to work more efficiently with patients and each other. In clinical implication IT is
Patient Monitoring
Documentation
Telemedicine
Patient Registration
IPD/OPD Registration
Indent
E-Tender
Data gathering
The use of IT in assessment helps in gathering and storing data about the patient. IT is used in
settings such as emergency, intensive care, ICCU, and the NICU for vital sign monitoring,
calculations of cardiac output, and even pulmonary artery pressure. This allows the focus to
be solely on the patient and helps in the comparison of a patient's present condition to earlier
conditions. Computers are also useful in documenting nurses' observations. Right now we are
having our new software Hospital Management System. This software was launched on 23rd
July 2014. This software has been designed and developed by a programmer hired from a
private company. This software targets to provide basic solution for Hospital services.
information for consultation, examinations, and even some small medical procedures. In
Medical Record Department digitalization has increased the efficiency of hospital by making
patient information readily available and saving office space for the storage of records. It has
connects related records. Through means of security, only authorized individuals have access
to medical records. The computer even keeps track of the history of those who have visited
certain records. Most significantly, IT has dramatically reduced the need for paper and
storage services. Programs such as Excel and QuickBooks allow hospitals to calculate the
total cost of the services they are providing. These programs would also help with the
comparison of the net values of money coming in and going out, and ensuring balance
between the two. Computers help in the calculating of pay checks, the respective salaries of
all workers, and the respective taxes to be taken out of each salary. This same financial
system also keeps track of the bills the hospital needs to have paid. All of these items above
would assist in the administrators making sure that the medical care they are giving their
patients is as cost effective and efficient as possible. A local area network (LAN) is a
computer network that interconnects computers within a limited area. LAN was installed in
the year of 2008. Cat-5 category cable is used in it. There are 18 Switches installed. Switch is
made 2622655652of HCL Model, HL524 Port - 10/100 Ethernet 24 port is used.
Currently server is located in MRD (Medical Record Department). Server was installed by
Hp Company on June 2013. Server AMC is being done by HP for 1 year. The manpower for
In addition to costs, computers evaluate quality assurance programs. These programs ensure
that all the methods and procedures of the hospital are in proper installation. Computers
additionally help to justify new roles for nursing in the health care system. This essentially
means that the job of a nurse is enhanced through duties on the computer in addition to their
medical duties. So, computers are facilitating the nursing process. A job that used to be
Advanced systems are bringing more advanced minds to our hospitals, which in turn,
advances our medical treatments. The picture I see is mighty bleak. Thank you, IT, for
transforming our medical system to the best that it can be in saving our citizens.
Security-
Hospitals are one of the most active public places, When it comes to hospital security we
have the expertise and experience required to address your most challenging problems.
are places with high-valued equipment, accessibility to drugs, and many entrances. A hospital
needs common precautions against fire, attacks, and vandalism as any other large facility. At
the same time, heightened security requires special electronic protection solutions such as
control against abduction of infants from maternity wards or threats against patients or staff,
Hospital is having extremely complex building that needs the strongest security solution. We
are having a highly skilled team, experienced with evaluating a Hospital’s infrastructure and
identifying threats and vulnerabilities. We focus on its specific weaknesses and offer the
necessary hospital security solution to protect the institution’s people, property, and
reputation.
Having a fire alarms, access control, and CCTV security systems. 24*7 hours guards are
always there in each and every gate and doors. Security guard view people entering and
leaving the area. They are in entrance, lobbies, operating rooms, labs and pharmacies, wards,
OPDs, OTs etc. Cameras are programmed to count the number of people moving through an
area or identifying and reporting that an object has been removed or left behind.
In some specific areas of a hospital there is restricting access also a high priority for hospital
security. A busy hospital is full of doctors, nursing and service staff, patients, relatives,
friends and other visitors. Any of which may have a reason to access specific areas. The
Hospital administration needs to assure that this access is restricted. Only authorized people
can then access controlled areas (pharmacy/drug storage, ICUs, surgical areas, e.g.). If
unauthorized personnel attempts entry to a restricted area, the security staff control the
situation immediately.
The engineering department performs a wide image of functions which may be assigning
to various unit of department. It is responsible for the operation of all equipment, machinery
Routine maintenance
Breakdown maintenance
Clinical services
Educational services
Acceptance testing
Maintenance planning
Risk analysis
Repairs
medical devices, diagnostic devices and imaging equipment such as MRIs and EEGs, and
pharmaceutical drugs.
Introduction-
Trauma/ Emergency Care at Dr. B.R.A.M. Hospital facility is a selective focus that offers
quick treatment in any emergency with the most abnormal amount of consideration, round-
the-clock. All our emergency medicine specialists, trauma surgeons, nursing staff, caretakers
pertaining to road side traffic accidents and mass casualties are exceedingly prepared to
manage cases from minor wounds to cutting edge injury administer to patients needing brief
consideration. Our emergency medicine specialists address the patient at the best time
conceivable with the right care. The doctor's facility offers 24*7 service with every minute of
every day access to present day operation theatres, imaging & demonstrative instruments and
completely supplied 24-hour pharmacy stores for prompt and exact conclusion of the
superior and more successful patient experience. The authorities from different controls, for
FACILITIES-
We have devoted groups arranged to start quick and propelled look after:
Sepsis Emergency
Vascular Emergency
Stroke Emergency
disappointments.
Paediatric Emergency
Cardiac Emergency
Facilities available:
Fully equipped 24/7 blood bank, laboratory, diagnostics and ventilator management
22 beds in old trauma & with 12 ICU beds, and 2 aseptic major OT and 21 beds in
new trauma.
Mobile Ultra Sound, X-ray, 2D echo, etc for critically sick & emergency patients
Medical Officer-
CARDIOLOGY 2
NEPHROPLOGY 1
OPTHAMOLOGY (231) 3
PSYCHIATRIC(205) 2
Total 40
Casulity Medical Officer-
DEAN
Medical Superintendent
Assistant Medical
Superintendent Office
Superintendent
Public
information
OPD Registration-
The out patient department (OPD) in Dr. Bhim Rao Ambedkar Memorial Hospital provides out
patient services to the patient coming to the hospital from Raipur Chhattisgarh. On an average 1500-
(1) OPHTHALMOLOGY:-
RATE
orbital cellulites)
cystostemy)
Fistula)
Specialist Surgery:
Endoscopy – Upper GIT 300/-
Laparoscopy 1500/-+
E.S.R. 5/-
C.T./B.T. 10/-
E.C.G. 20/-
Phototherapy 55/-
Steroid Infiltration
Ganglion/cyst Excision
BIOPSY
Removal of Pins/Fixator
Under GA
Ganglion/Cyst Excision
BIOPSY
Removal of Pins/Fixator
Minor Surgeries :
External fixator GA
Jess/Wire Fixation
Shoulder Amputation/Disarticulation
Arm/Forearm Amputation/Disarticulation
Wrist Amputation/Disarticulation
Hip Amputation/Disarticulation
Above/below knee
Amputation/Disarticulation
Patella
Excisional Arthroplasty
Arthroscopy (Diagnostic)
Fixator 500/-
Neurolysis/Neuroraphy
Skin grafting
350/-
Sequesterectomy
Major Surgeries:
Hindquarter amputation
graft
Ring Fixator
Reconstruction
CTEV correction
Pseudoarthroses
slab/cast
Hybrid fixation
Spine laminectomy/Fenestration
(Spine/Hip/Knee/Ankle/Shoulder/elbow
wrist)
Therapeutic Aspiration)
seating
(4 films)
Ramkrishna Care Hospital
Dr. Sandeep Dave's dream had ever been to build a hospital with dedicated posture,
meticulously designed , futuristically styled with an eco-friendly and patient-friendly bearing,
unparalleled in skill and specialization, exemplary in nursing care, and affordable to all
classes of society of this region.
Inaugurated on 17 October 2004 in a new building in a different and versatile habitat and in a
new grab of Private Company at Pachpedi Naka, Raipur, with 20 upgradable and sustainable
super-specialties commanding absolute faith of patients, Ramkrishna Surgical Nursing Home
never compromised while rendering quality health service, with state of the art equipment,
dexterity and technology.
Infused with kindled and stirring rationality, reasonability, solidity, judgment and profundity
each and every molecule of this hospital was in perfect harmony while inviting the searching
glances of Care Group of Hospitals, Hyderabad, which ultimately culminated in a wedlock
and interlacing of Ramkrishna and Care on 10th may 2007 being renamed as Ramkrishna
Care Medical Sciences Pvt. Ltd.
This confluence of these two entities pursuing the same goal of preparing a crucible for
amalgamization of new ideas and research for human care, concern and benevolence has
made Ramkrishna Care a Hospital of advantages and opportunities, a friend for life, that
touches and lifts, a companion in solitude that caresses and fondles, a team partner that
supports and upholds and blows a new meaning into life which never betrays.
The visible contours of our venture and transformation forecast that Ramkrishna Care is
going to serve as a growth island and catalyst for the development of Chhattisgarh.
Our Hospitals
Ramkrishna Care Specialty Hospitals, India, provide world class services for all medical
super specialties.
Unit-I
Raigarh Metro CARE Hospitals, Near Pahad Mandir, Chakradhar Nagar Raigarh – 496001
Phones: +91-7762-220222/220666
Fax: +91-7762-220222
Email: info@carehospitals.com
For Emergency Call: +917762-220222
For Appointments Call : +917762-220222
Timings: 6AM to 10PM
Patient Facilities
Emergency Care
Critical Care
Fully-equipped 5 Intensive Care Units (MICU, ICCU, NICU, SICU, Cardiothoracic ICU)
Cardiology
Laparoscopy
Gastroenterology
Pulmonology
Orthopaedics
Complicated fractures, total hip and knee replacement, arthroscopic surgery, foot and ankle
surgery, spine surgery, ligament injuries and bone grafting
Neurology
Urology
Uroflowmetry, Urodynamics
Nephrology
Dialysis, chronic kidney diseases, acute renal failure, renal biopsy, plasmapherisis, CAPD,
perm cath SLED, peritoneal dialysis
Laboratory services
ECG, Echo, EEG, TMT, Spiral CT scan, digital X-ray and ultrasonography
Other Facilities
Laboratory Medicine
Ambulance
The emergency department has a fully equipped ACLS ambulance, which works round-the-
clock and is managed by a team comprising a doctor, nurse and paramedical staff.
Emergency Care
The Trauma & Emergency Unit works round-the-clock. There are 5 beds with all life-saving
equipment. The department also deals with medico-legal cases, medical emergencies and
minor surgical work.
Pharmacy
The hospital runs a 24*7 pharmacy with qualified and trained pharmacists who help patients
to comply with the prescription instructions.
Charges Of Health Check-up
Download Brochure
Haemogram, Urine study, Blood Sugar (Fasting & PP), Serum Potassium, Serum Sodium,
Serum Urea Serum Creatinine, Serum Total Protein & Albumin, Serum Phosphorus, Uric
Acid, Sodium Bi Carbonate, Nephrologist Consultation
Gynaecology Check-up
Haemogram, Urine study, Blood Sugar (Fasting & PP), T3, T4, TSH, Ultra Sound (Whole
Abdomen), PAP Smear
Haemogram, Haemoglobin, Lipid Profile, Liver Function Test, Kidney Assessment, Serum
Urea, Serum Creatinine, Complete urine study, Blood Sugar (Fasting & PP,) , X-ray(Chest),
ECG , Ultrasound Screening (Whole Abdomen), Stool Test, Blood Group & RH, Doctor
Consultation
Haemogram, Haemoglobin, Lipid Profile, Liver Function Test, Kidney Assessment, Serum
Urea, Serum Creatinine, Blood Sugar (Fasting & PP), X-ray (Chest) ECG, 2D Echo ,
Ultrasound Screening (Whole, Abdomen), Stool Test, Complete Urine Study, Blood Group &
RH, Physician Consultation
Haemogram, Haemoglobin , Lipid Profile , Liver Function Test, Kidney Assessment, Serum
Urea Serum Creatinine, Serum Uric Acid, Blood Sugar (Fasting & PP) ,X-ray (Chest), ECG ,
2D Echo, TMT, Ultrasound Screening (Whole Abdomen), Stool Test, Complete Urine Study,
Blood Group & RH, Physician Consultation ,Cardiologist Consultation
Haemogram, Haemoglobin ,Lipid Profile , Liver Function Test, Kidney Assessment, Serum
Urea , Serum Creatinine, Serum Uric Acid, Blood Sugar (Fasting & PP) , X-ray (Chest), ECG
, 2D Echo or TMT, Ultrasound Screening (Whole Abdomen), Stool Test, Complete Urine
Study, Blood Group & RH, PSA (For Men), PAP Smear (For Women), PFT, Physician
Consultation, Cardiologist Consultation
Haemogram, Urine study, Urea, Serum Creatinine Ultrasound of KUB, PSA for Men,
Urologist Consultation.
Gastro Check-up
Haemogram, L FT, Urea, Serum Creatinine, Uric Acid, Stool Test, UGI Endoscopy,
Gastroentrologist Consultation
Haemogram, L FT, Urea, Serum Creatinine, Uric Acid Stool test, UGI Endoscopy,Fibro
Scan, Gastroentrologist Consultation
1. Improve the services provided by the association for the members through improving the
3. To elicit the feelings and problems of the doctors, nursing staff, paramedical staff and
SERVICES-
Mesh-
Kitchen of the hospital takes care of diet of the patients admitted in different wards. Every
day breakfast, lunch & dinner as per patients requirement, prepared under hygienic
conditions and under supervision of dietician. Fruits and milk are also included as per the
Medical Store-
Medical store is available in the hospital for patients to purchase medicines.
Bed-
Staffs-
Doctors-
PATIENTS-
Hospital has aprox. 115 in-patients and 55 out-patients, with having OPD charges 300Rs.
INCOME-
FACILITIES-
24 hours facility
24 hours ambulance
24 hour Medical store
6 operation theatre
The above table indicates the comparison of average time taken to access healthcare services
of private hospitals and government hospitals. It can be seen in the above table that the
average time taken to access healthcare services of private hospital is only 50 minutes on an
average while it is around 80 minutes in the case of government hospitals. Thus, the time
Thus, it can be concluded on the basis of above analysis that it is time consuming to access
(A)Sample:
A sample of 50 respondents has been selected randomly from areas in to seek responses on
healthcare services provided by the government hospitals vis-à-vis private in their areas.
The government hospitals and private hospitals which are generally visited by people for
Government Hospital:
Mekahara hospital
Private Hospital:
Samarpan hospital
The researcher found it difficult to collect information from illiterate and some aged
respondents. Some respondents refused to part with information due to their severe and
prolonged illness. Thus, wherever respondents refused to part with information or where the
researcher found it difficult to extract information, such respondents were substituted with
other respondents. The technique used to collect sample for the present research was random
sampling technique
hospital in the area was interviewed to have in-depth investigation and analysis of the
(B). Feedback
(1) Feedback on Testing and Evaluation facilities in Government Hospitals:
Although 63% of the respondents reported that they could get hospitalisation on emergency
basis in government hospitals, 72% of them reported that government hospitals lacked
adequate infrastructure and evaluation and testing facilities. Many advanced testing facilities
are not available in these hospitals and therefore, poor patients have to shell out huge money
on getting these tests done from private hospitals and clinics. When inquired reason for such
breakdowns, the hospital staff reported that there is heavy pressure of patients on these
machines and therefore, they are used round the clock. They also reported that most of these
machines are purchased through government rate contracts who generally supply substandard
machines and instruments and there is no maintenance contract for these machines. For
efficient functioning, these machines need regular up keeping and maintenance. Under these
circumstances, they have to recommend their patients to private hospitals and clinics for
Government Hospitals:
On an average, most of the respondents found the standards of cleanliness, food, sanitation
and hygiene in Government hospitals to be satisfactory but not at par with the hygiene and
charitable institutions and in many cases refrain from adopting “scientific cleaning practices”
as it comes at a price, the private set ups claim a handsome price for both treatment and the
clean factors. But on the whole respondents were found to be satisfied with the standards of
quality of services of doctors and their approach towards patients to be above average with
17% of the respondents rating it to be excellent and 40% rating it to be good. Empirical
evidences show that patients are generally satisfied with the quality of services of
government doctors and in many cases people have complaints against other staff and
absence of infrastructural facilities in hospitals. 15% of the respondents who were dissatisfied
doctor is a vital factor, especially in case of emergency. But, according to these respondents,
who personally or their family members utilised government hospital for treating their major
illnesses, revealed that doctors were not accessible during emergency, although many of them
were inmates.
On a whole, services of nurses and administrative staff in Government hospitals are found to
be satisfactory which is supported by the responses of 70% of the respondents. But when
compared to satisfaction with the quality of doctors in government hospital, the satisfaction
with quality of the services of nurses and administrative staff was found to be poor. 22% of
the respondents who rated the quality of services of nurses and administrative staff to be
poor reported that the nurses and administrative staff in government hospitals behave
Experience evidences through various researches have been suggestive of failure of public
sector as one of the prime reasons for growth of the private sector in India. In the present
study, majority of the respondents have rated the services provided by public hospitals vis-à-
long waiting time, long distance, inadequate infrastructure, irresponsible behaviour of staff
(sometimes), comparatively poor standards of cleanliness and hygiene are some of the factors
The present study is constrained by the limitation of time and cost. The study is restricted to
the public and private Hospital in the city of Raipur. Due to the size of the problem, the
study is limited to patient satisfaction only. It has become difficult for the researcher to
collect data from different hospitals. Another basic limitation of behavioural sciences is that
they would deal with attitudes. These attitudes differ from individual to individual. Even
though utmost care has been taken in selecting the sample, the results derived from a study
may not be exactly equal to the true value of the population. Hence results of the study are
considered to be true, and relationships hold good, only for this study.
questionnaire and schedules. It became very difficult to meet and elicit opinion of
Majority of administrators are under the impression that research on analysis of hospital
means probing into their internal affairs especially in healthcare Sector. With this opinion
they hesitated in providing required data. However, administrators of different hospitals did
co-operate. This research project would not have been possible without the help received
from them.
CHAPTER
THREE
INTERPRETATIONS
ANALYSIS OF THE STUDY
The data was analyzed by simple statistical way to present the study in a meaningful way.
The analysis reveals that there is more positive feedback from the public on private working
hospitals then the government. Based on the study some suggestion has been outlined on the
Hospitals
50
40
Series 1
30
Series 2
20 Series 3
Series 4
10
0
GOVT PRIVATE
60
50
40
EXCELLENT
VERY GOOD
30
GOOD
ADEQUATE
20
10
0
GOVT PRIVATE
hospital in Raipur:
50
45
40
35
30 EXCELLENT
25
VERY GOOD
20
GOOD
15
10 ADEQUATE
5 POOR
0
GOVT
PRIVATE
60
50
40
VERY GOOD
30 GOOD
POOR
20
10
0
GOVT PRIVATE
Chart 6: How would you rate the quality of the food and canteen facility in
50
40 VERY GOOD
30 GOOD
20 POOR
10
0
GOVT PRIVATE
50
40
30 Series 1
20 Series 2
10
0
GOVT PRIVATE
Collection of Data:
primary data
secondary data.
For collection of data from primary sources, efforts were made to elicit the opinions of almost
questionnaires and schedules. The researcher spent months together in sample hospital offices
observing the management process in the selected hospitals. In depth interview technique was
used here for collecting primary data. This was collected through personal observation and
also from the hospital documents, Annual Reports & Budgets. The researcher visited and
collected information from the two hospitals i.e., MEKAHARA Hospital and Ramkrishna
care Hospital. The data for the study was collected by administering the questionnaire
schedules and through observation method. Observation method is one of the most important
and extensively used methods in social sciences research. It is one of the primary research
methods. All the time it is not possible to use quantitative techniques, in such circumstances,
observation method bridges the gap. On the other hand Questionnaires are widely used for
data collection in social sciences research particularly in surveys. It is a fairly reliable tool for
gathering data from large, diverse, varied and scattered social groups. It is used in obtaining
treated as the heart of the survey operation. The data for the study was collected by
administering a two part questionnaire to administrative staff, doctors, and nursing staff and
contained the data, regarding working and performance of office, different functions of
management and different organizational patterns and structures. The instrument was tested
for its reliability and validity. A Three point scale was used. It contained the column of
Satisfied, Partially Satisfied and Not Satisfied Three point scale was used which contained
Satisfied, Partially Satisfied and Not Satisfied. Relating to their satisfaction on services
FOUR
SUGGESTIONS
SPECIFIC SUGGESTIONS
1. Staff Behaviour:
Employees are the important asset of the organization. Small but Significant number of
health-care workers show disrespect for colleagues, dole out verbal abuse and engage in other
unacceptable behaviour. Now a new report suggests this kind of poor workplace
communication can also contribute to medical errors, even if other preventive steps are being
taken.
Quality is one of the main ingredients of all successful organization it includes everything in
the organization work environment as. Especially for hospitals as 10 % of GDP comes from
3. Hospital Hygiene:
As hygiene is one of the fundamental rights of every human being. That’s why the World
Health Organization (WHO) has chosen May 5 as Save Lives: Clean Your Hands Day, its
annual campaign to get health workers to practice better hygiene. The WHO has a simple
five-step framework for getting health care workers to ensure they keep their hands clean, but
it won’t worker until hospitals get serious about pushing hand washing, before and after a
There are various factors which influence customer’s expectations of services. They include
efficiency, confidence, helpfulness, personal interest reliability. The dietary units stand as the
second major department of a hospital from the point of view of expenditure. Except the
well-established hospitals, patients are not happy with the quality of food supplied to them.
That is why most of them get food from their houses or from relatives. There is a problem of
excess diet consumption when compared to the number of in-patients in the hospital resulting
huge expenditure.
5. Personnel:
Delegating the responsibility with authority to the personnel and establishing interpersonal
relationship for the purpose of co-ordination of work, so as to get the work done together
There are both excellent and poor performing hospitals worldwide. To promote greater use of
practices and policies that enhance quality in hospitals, this study identifies and describes the
key ingredients that have contributed to the success of hospitals that are sets as an example of
many high-performing hospitals to those who do not have or practice the policies.
The key elements of a successful strategy can be organized into the following categories:
Efforts should be made to reduce the patients load at the higher level facilities that doctors
8. Hospital Infrastructure:
9. Medicine Availability:
Patients in are suffering due to non-availability of emergency drugs/ life saving drugs. The
administration within minutes post or during a medical emergency. These medicines have the
potential to sustain life and/or prevent further complications and are prescribed for both out-
patients and in-patients. The non-availability of these drugs in government hospitals has
posed serious problems forcing patients to buy these drugs from outside.
Data need to be collected within or at the end of a visit, usually with a very brief written or
even verbal question. It is used to find out patients’ experience when it is fresh in the mind,
and usually focuses either on a specific area of interest to the team, or on the general
experience of the patient during the visit. In our example of visit preparation, the medical
assistant might give the patient a form asking their preferences when they begin the visit. It is
helpful if the form is introduced by a team member. It is very important to set realistic
expectations for the amount of time and effort needed to see results in this work once feed
Many public hospitals have reimbursed more suppliers then the private.
SUGGESTIONS
The present study indicates that there has been an extensive development in health care
services in public and private hospital. However still there are many changes need to be
acquired to reach the services to the public from government hospital. The cost of treatment
at a public healthcare facility is much more affordable than at a private centre. However, due
to lack of physical reach, availability of quality treatment and other practices, patients are
forced to use more expensive private facilities, thus exacerbating affordability challenges.
The majority of out of pocket expenses are due to medicines, though they have not increased
Private hospitals are making better efforts as compared to the public hospitals. As the private
hospitals have to depend on customers in order to meet the financial constraints and gain
profitability. As results of this study shows that private hospitals like the other service
organizations are focusing on their patients demands and developing themselves in order to
provide maximum healthcare facilities to their patients. All these efforts led these hospitals
towards continuous improvement in the processes, system and provide continuously quality
of healthcare service to their patients. It can be concluded from the analysis and the responses
of data collected that in private hospitals where compare to the government hospital are very
satisfactory. Public health care system is very good in terms of space and operational
equipment however services towards patient are inadequate in providing the good services,
government hospitals must select a strategy that gives highest “healthcare access” benefit to
the people Quality services need to be provided to the patient in order for quick recovery.
Whereas the poor quality of healthcare services delivered to patients by public hospitals as
compare to the private hospitals are due to the many factor. These factors include:
and overburdened public hospitals due to rapid growth in population and Comparison of
Websites:
http://drbramhraipur.in
http://wikimapia.org
http://infohind.com
www.zaubacorp.com
Reports: