Series eee eee
Community Police Hearing Board
Report for 2018
CHAIR
Attorney Emesto Castillo
MEMBERS
Robert C. Jackson
Albert Tranghese
Rev. Gail Hill
Paul A. Phaneuf
Linda Caron
Gary BerteTABLE OF CONTENTS,
INTRODUCTION
History and Purpose of Board
PHB Members - 20°8
‘The CPHB Case Review and Hearing Process
CPHB Activities ~ 2018
DATA SUMMARY OF COMPLAINTS REVIEWED,
41. Calls For Service, Arrests, Complaints, Reviews, Hearings
And Lawsuits Involving, Police Misconduct
‘Table A ~ Summary Data of Calls for Service
‘Table B- Summary Data of Arrosts
Table C-U.S. Census Data for Springfield
2. Data concerning Complaints Reviewed by CPHB 2010
Tables D through H
~ CPHB Data for 2018 (Summary)
3. Police Misconduct Litigation
Table | -Police Misconduct Lawsuits (Summary)
CPHB OBSERVATIONS
PHB RECOMMENDATIONS
Appendix 1 CPHE Data - 2018 Complaint Detail Data
Appendix 2 Data on Lawsuits alleging police misconduct (2006 to 2018)
Appendix 3 Executive Order (December 2017)
10
10
10
"
2
12
8
1“
48
16
8COMMUNITY POLICE HEARING BOARD
ANNUAL REPORT
2018
INTRODUCTION
This Annual Report describes the work to advance the mission of the Community Police
Hearing Board (CPHB) for 2018. The current report includes spreadsheets for the data
generated by the work of the CPHB during 2018 set forth in an Appendix. The
spreadsheets are summarized in tables provided in this report.
In addition, the report provides statistics with regard to lawsuits involving allegations of
police misconduct.
‘As a result of the Mayor's recent amendments in 2016 and 2017, and with the assistance
of the Police Department’s Crime Analysis Unit, gathering and reporting statistics on
behalf of the CPHB, 2018 Quarterly reports have been posted on the City’s website in
accord with the Executive Order providing for improved reporting and greater
‘transparency and mare public access to information about police misconduct complaints
in Springfet,
In addition, this report has included additional statistics which involve new procedures
requiring keeping track of *Calls for Service" (CFS). As such, a table has been included
to report and reference for the years 2013 through 2018 with greater accuracy and detail
Similarly, data on “Arrests” hes also been enhanced
‘The CPHB was created by en Executive Order of Mayor Samo in February 2010. The
CPHE was an evolution from the earlier Citizen Complaint Review Board (CCRB)
established by former Mayor Ryan. The CCRB was first created in response to a study
‘conducted by criminal justice experts Professor Jack McDevitt of Northeastern University
‘and his Associate, Dr. Amy Farrell. The study was conducted as part of a settlement of
the filing of a complaint by the Springfield Pastor's Council with the Massachusetts,
‘Commission Against Discrimination (MCAD).
Beginning in June of 2009, the former CORB, under the coordination and guidance of the
Mayor's Chief of Staff, Denise Jordan, began meeting to review the original Executive
Order governing its activities and began discussing options amongst its members and
legal counsel for improving the process and increasing the positive impact of the Board
fon the community, The former CCRB had issued a recommendation and report on
December 9, 2008 and had also held a public hearing on its draft suggestions on that
date.