(/)

Bi-Wiring A Loudspeaker: Does it Make a Difference?

9 9 Share

by Jim Lesurf — March 19, 2007

(https://www.audioholics.com/audio-video-
cables/bi-wiring-from-amplifier-to-
loudspeaker/image)
Biwire Waveform

Originally published at: University of St. Andrews, St Andrews, Fife KY16 9SS, Scotland.

“Bi-wiring” is a controversial topic. Some people are quite certain it makes an audible
difference. Some others are convinced that it can’t actually make any difference at all. The
purpose of this analysis is to try and decide whether it is at least theoretically feasible that bi-
wiring can make any difference.

To define what is meant by “bi-wiring”, and understand what effects it may (or may not) have,
we can start by considering the situation illustrated in Figure 1.

(fig1.png/image)
This shows an amplifier connected to a loudspeaker by a standard cable made from a pair of
connecting wires. For clarity, only one channel of a stereo pair is shown. The loudspeaker
consists of two drive units. – a high-frequency (HF) unit often called a “tweeter”, and a low
frequency (LF) unit often called a “woofer”. Loudspeakers generally employ a “cross-over
network” to direct low signal frequencies to the woofer, and high frequencies to the tweeter.
In the example shown here this network is split into distinct HF and LF sections. This split
permits the loudspeaker to be bi-wired. (Not all loudspeaker cross-over arrangements will
permit this without modification.) In practice, as shown here, loudspeakers designed to permit
bi-wiring have extra sets of input terminals which may be joined together when bi-wiring is
not employed.

In the conventional wiring arrangement shown in Figure 1, the HF and LF input terminals are
wired together in parallel at the speaker, and just one pair of connecting wires are employed
to link both speaker units to the amplifier. In most cases “bi-wiring” means using an extra pair
of connecting wires (i.e. another cable) so that the signals for the tweeter and woofer are
sent from the amplifier to the speaker by separate routes. This bi-wiring arrangement is
illustrated in Figure 2. In this new arrangement, Cable 1 carries the signals destined for the
tweeter, and Cable 2 carries the signals destined for the woofer.

(Fig2.gif/image)

Various arguments have been presented for this bi-wiring arrangement by adherents who feel
it alters the sound. For example, it may be claimed that each of the two cables may now be
optimised in some way for the limited range of signal frequencies it now carries, and hence
act more effectively. Alternatively, it is sometimes claimed that separating the signals for the
tweeter and woofer means they do not now ‘interfere’ in some manner which may arise when
they share the same cable. Unfortunately, these claims are generally unclear in technical
terms, and there is a general lack of any reliable analysis or measured data to support the
claims. This makes it questionable whether the claims are justified. It is also unclear whether
the alternative arrangement in Figure 3 might also be “better” than the conventional
arrangement. The arrangement in Figure 3 is also bi-wired, but the pairs of wires are now
joined at both ends of the signal connection from amplifier to loudspeaker.
 (Fig3.gif/image)

In the modified arrangement shown in Figure 3 both cables are used “in parallel” to connect
signals to both speaker units. The question now becomes, “Are the arrangements shown in
Figures 1, 2, and 3, all going to produce exactly the same results in use?”

Detailed analysis of the three arrangements is made difficult by two factors. Firstly, the
electrical properties of the items involved can be quite complicated. The networks used in
loudspeaker crossovers may contain a number of components and have a complex
behaviour. Similarly for the actual speaker units. As we have seen on the webpages on
cables, even the behaviour of simple twin-feed connecting cable can be more complicated
that we might expect.

The second problem for a precise analysis is that the actual details of the loudspeaker
crossover, etc, will vary a great deal from one model of loudspeaker to another. Hence we
can expect any results to depend upon the choice of loudspeaker, cable, etc.

To make understanding these questions easier we can address a simpler question – i.e. we
can ask, “Is is possible for the changes between the arrangements in Figures 1 - 3 to make
any difference, or not?” To answer this question we need only look at a simplified example. If,
in that example, a difference can be show to be possible, then it implies that a difference may
appear even in more complicated arrangements. If no such difference is shown, this does not
necessarily resolve the real issue, but at least we have progressed part of the way to a better
understanding. With the above in mind we can now form a electronic models of the above
arrangements, simplify them as far as seems reasonable, then compare their computed
behaviours.

Confused about what AV Gear to buy or how to set it up? Join our Exclusive
Audioholics E-Book Membership Program (/combo-pack-ebooks)!

Jump to: Bi-Wiring A Simple Model Go

Next Page (/audio-video-cables/bi-wiring-from-amplifier-to-loudspeaker/bi)

By Jim Lesurf — March 19, 2007
Recent Forum Posts:

Read the Complete Thread

(http://forums.audioholics.com/forums/threads/mythread.30527)
Post Reply (http://forums.audioholics.com/forums/threads/replythread.30527/reply)

Subscribe to our newsletter

(https://audioholics.us6.list-
manage.com/subscribe/post?
u=e5450cdd4a74ce0dc3f066818&id=1d94c9d718)

Subscribe to Our Channel

(https://www.youtube.com/user/audioholicslive?
sub_confirmation=1)

Sitemap

Loudspeaker Reviews
Surround Sound Systems (/surround-sound-reviews)
Bookshelf Speakers (/bookshelf-speaker-reviews)
Tower Speakers (/tower-speaker-reviews)
Wireless Speakers (/computer-speaker-reviews)
Sound Bar & Satellite (/soundbar-and-satellite-speaker-reviews)
Subwoofers (/subwoofer-reviews)
Headphones (/headphone-reviews)
Outdoor & In-Wall (/outdoor-speaker-reviews)

Amplification Reviews
Audio Amplifiers (/amplifier-reviews)
AV Preamp & Processors (/av-preamp-processor-reviews)
AV Receivers (/av-receiver-reviews)
Display Reviews
Home Theater Projectors (/projector-reviews)
Projector Screens (/projector-screen-reviews)
HDTVs (/hdtv-reviews)

AV Accessory Reviews
Acoustical Products (/acoustic-reviews)
Universal Remotes (/universal-remote-reviews)
Home Theater Furniture (/home-theater-furniture-reviews)

Source & Gadget Reviews

Blu-ray & DVD Players (/blu-ray-and-dvd-player-reviews)
Gadgets & Cables (/gadget-reviews)
Power Conditioners (/power-conditioner-reviews)

Music & Movie Reviews

DVD-A, SACD & CD Music (/music-reviews)
Blu-ray Movies (/blu-ray-movie-reviews)

AV News
Editorials (/editorials)
News & Press Releases (/news)
Trade Show Coverage (/trade-shows)

E-Books (/combo-pack-ebooks)
Super Combo Pack (/super-combo-pack-ebooks)
Combo Pack (/combo-pack-ebooks)
Set Up Guides (/setup-guides-ebooks)
Buying Guides (/buying-guides-ebooks)

AV Research
Audio Video Cables (/audio-video-cables)
Audio Technologies (/audio-technologies)
Room Acoustics (/room-acoustics)
Audio Amplifiers (/audio-amplifier)
HDTV Display Formats (/hdtv-formats)
Frequently Asked Questions (/frequent-questions)
Loudspeaker Design (/loudspeaker-design)

Buying Guidelines
Recommended Systems (/recommended-systems)
How to Shop (/how-to-shop)
Product Awards & Gift Guides (/product-awards)
 Home Theater Setup
Subwoofer Setup (/subwoofer-setup)
Home Theater Calibration (/home-theater-calibration)
Home Theater Connection Help (/home-theater-connection)
DIY Audio & Wiring (/diy-audio)

Top

About Audioholics (/siteinfo) Advertising (/groups/admin/advertise)

Author Pages (/siteinfo/staff-biographies) Legal (/groups/admin/legal)

Reprints, Terms & Conditions (/groups/admin/reprints) Privacy Policy (/groups/admin/privacy)

Maintenance by Rivmedia (https://www.rivmedia.co.uk)
Contact (/contact)

Copyright © 1998–2018 Audioholics, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Audioholics.com is NOT affiliated with Audiogurus.com